#MediaRumble
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 6 ส.ค. 2019
- In this session of The Media Rumble, Abhinandan Sekhri is joined by Shekhar Gupta, editor-in-chief of The Print, founding editor of The Wire Siddharth Varadarajan, Swarajya’s editorial director R Jagannathan, and Sevanti Ninan, media commentator, columnist and founder of The Hoot. They discuss whether the media's criticism of other media houses is a healthy practice for improvement or an exercise in discrediting news.
To watch this and many more videos, click on www.newslaundry.com/
Let's admit Shekhar Gupta has brains.
So Shekhar got visibly and strongly admonished by Abhinandan at 28:35 which was correct to my opinion.
But only a very well read and smart journalist like Shekhar can give it back with such grace, wit and aplomb at 43:18
45 minutes spent well for a viewer.
Abhishek Toshniwal shekhar exposed the arnab in abhinandan
@Shashi Deshmukh Totally agree with you, this is problem with most of the so-called experts, that they think they know it all. They don't want to give audience an option to make their own opinion and decide, they just want to influence and manipulate. Shekhar, was trying to make it like stupid main stream media.
@@kshitijraaj8374 hey asshole, even if you spent a millennia studying journalism, you wouldnt have an iota of the knowledge that SG has.
Stfu
No excuse for bad behaviour. We have been taught to behave/speak properly with our seniors. Even if we do not agree with their point of view. Showcases that Sekhri (I really like his newslaundry) has a long way to go....
Ahahahahaha shekhars retort was brilliant!
interesting friction between two people i respect very much SG and Anandhan , SG with classic master class on facts over emotions . Anandhan with moral high ground and fire works .
I do admire and follow Shekhar Gupta, but this time he totally and rightly succumbed to completely logical idea which this debate was called for.
Sekri 1(won) : Gupta 0(Null).
And media can and must question anything and anyone.
High five at end was screenshot of debate.
Keep going NL
Keep going ThePrint, wire, swaraj..etc
Let's change the status quo.
Public sab janati hai...ye public hai...
I knew something of this sort would happen. Shekhar Gupta and Abhinandan Sekhri together.
Shekhar Gupta might be interrupting and rude, but he's making the most sense.
He was the only one who spoke
We didn't get to hear much from others
28:34 best part. He was asking for this beat down
I like shekhar's articles, but loved Sekhri today !
This is one of the best panel discussions I have seen in a long long time. I just realized I had completely given up on watching these since the last 2-3 years.
and this is why i have a love-hate relationship with shekhar 😁 very valid points on facebook
Shekhar Gupta worked really hard to make a point that this whole thing is irrelevant, but the fact he is here proves the point, it could be irrelevant but he knows it's important.
Ohhh damn
Bhai bhai bhai bhai bhai
Just tooo good
Always love to hear you speak.
Loved your show I agree.
And the way you always find a way to bring people of different ideologies or narrative together for a cause is quite adorable actually. And I often get confused whether you are speaking your mind or just being sarcastic on fews things.
Keep up the good work bro.
You are a complete different man out of this rat race.
Overacting 😎
Shekhar Gupta, big fan!
Shekhar Gupta seized the opportunity....and he was most knowledgeable also.....
News is OK. Opinion is contentious. There comes left & right and all the rubbish comes out then.
First time I have seen Siddharth laughing.
He's a psychopath man! A real psychopath!
Shekhar Gupta was out of character and defensive and aggressive.
Abhinandan is courageous, experience of Shekhar doesn't allow him to experiment which should be the character of media in today's sold out industry...
Viewers please stop being snowflakes. It was a good discussion, that's all matters. Minor incidents in between don't matter. Stop emphasizing on trivial things of the discussion. Thank you.
Little hypocritical of Abhinandan to expect Shekhar to not interrupt him when he has done the some to his guests and Manisha in one of his podcasts
Shekhar was agitated at times, but didn't lose his cool. All the panelists were great in the way they put forth their points.
P.S. It was cool to see Abhinandan feel threatened by Shekhar.
Omg 😳 never seen Shekhar so worked up
SG was unusually 'Off the Cuff'...
😂
Jaggi summed up the ugly reality of media-politicis-corporate beautifuly.
Full marks to Shekhar Gupta for not ending on a sour note. Nice discussion.
Awesome Shekhar Gupta
Shekhar Gupta looks so annoyed, so unlike him he is usually very measured
sheldon pereira correct Abhi is a sub standard journalist in every conversation will do chest thumping the hafta podcast is like 99 percent anti government except Anand Vardhan.
He seldomly faces smart people, not very used of handling smart young people.
@@kshitijraaj8374 I know I am late here and this is just nitpicking, but Abhinandan is not a 'young' dude, he is in his mid 40s, so basically he is a middle aged dude, Ravish Kumar is a year younger than Abhinandan.
He is annoyed of the pretense in new laundry and Abhinandan
Abhinandan probably doesn't understand the difference between moderating, interviewing and investigating
👌👌👌👌👌brilliant, no words to express
When would you be posting the video of panel moderated by Jyoti Nisha?
Shekhar had all the right points.
We the Youth of India along with some domain expert people need to gather and form India's leading political party and fights election with an economic development-based manifesto and fight elections against the ruling party.
Why is Shekhar Gupta behaving like such a boor? He's been on a high ever since j&k.
i know u are pissed becaz u cant taste gandhi dynasty piss anymore
yeah. boor is the right word.
Send this guy with Sai Baba hairs to Journalism school, he has a lot to learn
why Shekhar Gupta is annoyed to me
Guyz.............SG: was trying to make a point on GAFA sponsoring a lot of media events; at the same time he was trying to have a dig at NL with the same stone. AS: knew where SG is going so tried to cut him short, (rivalry at its best). RJ: as usual is a soft spoken rightest brahmin-like, so would not go far to annoy anyone, but would make a self-serving point. SN: was most objective and to the point, although delivery was not upto mark; Finally SV: made the most sense, we need more 'defector's' like him to correct the course of Indian Godhi media. But greed has to play in full and get stretched until then journalism will, regretably, ride piggy back on corporate money and interests . An ex-journalist.
Absolutely loved this !!!!!
"offcoure we are all compromised " 🤓
@PS whole media has been leftist
Awesome discussion
Good calling out by Abhinandan
Only to listen to shekhar sir
Same
Takla Makan pays the price of ignoring all the complaints and criticism by us viewers on ThePrint of him being so slow.
Abhay Bhatt but still we love sekhar Gupta
@@kundankumar9100
U mean Snaker Couptha?
Shekhar is in good direction 👍👍
I toh loved it 💜
By looking at Siddharth face one cant say this person have 24 years of journalism experience. He still looks younger, one of the persons who defy age.
SG called out that Newslaundry does not have the skills to criticize news media. 😀
I always felt AS is a pretentious lazy poser of a journalist. He has a very classist attitude, that too by just being born into a privileged class.
Personal attack…… nothing on material, scope, limitations of the discussion. The real problem with social media experts with opinions 😂
Lol seriously? Abhinandan talking about being courteous?
Abhinandan is the moderator..who wants to debate on "calling out our own - is it good or bad" and then when he doesnt allow shekhar to talk, he says I am not Arnab'.. is he fit for being a moderator, who should be neutral????
No. And he's just another charsi elite pretentious leftist. Not a journalist. Not a comedian.....just a joke.
I think he wanted others to talk too, Shekhar has this tendency to keep talking without listening, making it one-sided
, not debate.
Shashi Deshmukh the question is not on abhinandans behavior but on abhinandans neutrality. As a moderator he should be neutral on the topic being debated. He says “I am not Arnab” while the topic being debated is “calling out our own “. Very ironic. Before you write comment which is totally unrelated to what is being discussed in the comments section, I would recommend you to first read and understand what is written here and respond appropriately. Cheers
@@mraghul Before Abhinandan interrupted Shekhar, Shekhar spoke for more than 11 minutes out of 28 minutes. In a debate, every one should be given equal opportunity, I don't understand where is the issue. To me Shekhar misbehave Abhinandan interrupted. Don't make this debate about, who should say what?
did not allow shekar to talk...OMG...shekar was the only one doing all the talking i think it was proper on the part of the host to "call him out"
Where was this held? Bangalore?
Where's Manu joseph?
Self importance in pointless roles of media representatives - especially in the indian-english area makes these people utterly insignificant. Gupta praises people in Murdoch's employment as those who do extensive research - there he is right. Indian media is full of people who work at a very superficial level. They write using templates and create very boring, insipid copy - and the main reason is that english just does not sit pretty on our faces. On the other hand the national language media imitate the english language media's every move... so that renders them even less important... and then i heard one of these guys say Radia...and switched off. These people are corrupt in addition to being inefficient and ineffective.
28:36 Don't do No No No😂😂😂😂
Jaggi sir 👍
This guy is as young as Shekhar guptas own child, he sits like a CEO and called by his name
Oh so was it a case of child marriage then?
SedLyf Shekhar😱
*06:00**, IN VERY INCEPTION OF DISCUSSION, WE CAN SEE THE IRRATIONALE AND UNCIVILIZED ACTIONS AND APPROACHES OF RIGHT WING OPEN SUPPORTERS, THEY CAN'T CALL THEMSELVES JOURNALIST PER SE AND THAT'S MAJOR CHALLENGE FOR RIGHT WING AS A WHOLE AND **29:00** WAS A DAMN GOOD SITUATION AND I REALLY APPRECIATE THIS VIEW OF ANCHOR, WHICH SHOULD COME IN MAINSTREAM MEDIA WHICH IS ALMOST INVISIBLE!*
Abhinandan road rolling SG ... Epic*
I am just here to listen to Jaggi
He is a sellout
@@vimalshahi9299 absolutely. He's an outright propagandist, peddles fake news day in day out.
@@tgsaravind yeah just like that chubbish thug
For Sevanti not to have had the last word felt dismissive.
Great job by the moderator.
Only Jaggi makes sense.
Shekhar ji 🙏🙏🙏🙏
Shekhar Gupta was always in Godee of powerful and rich people. He always danced, tiptapped and spinned on behalf of ruling elite.
Great work Abhinandan!!!
LoL
“People took 500 bucks from their pockets and said KUCH KARO...”. That is crowdfunding. Looks like Indians understood this concept even before the term was invented”
People who are ashamed of m talking their national language
Talking about nation 🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔🤔
Such a hypocrites
National Language? What's that?
Abey chutiye, India ki koi National Language nahi hai. Anpadh kaheen ka, le kardi Official language mein baat.
Gupta is wiseman
Agree or disagree, jaggi is most neutral and balanced author, doesnt sugarcoat anything.
Eah sajjan jo pile kapde baithe hai inhone to ek jhoothi khabar chalai
Thi ki military ke bare mein yad kar
Lo.
nice
That was good Shekhar sir! You screwed up this person from NewsLawndry...he is an arrogant person less of a journalist
इस शो को सिर्फ जग्गी जी की वजह से देखा नही तो कौन अपना समय खराब करेगा
Body language gives thinking away... Shekhar wasn't going to back down. Abhinandan, good try!
Shekhar uncle "OP" 😆
"Swaraj and the wire have the same sponsors". Ofc that's an amazing marketting strategy or business model cause then you have got folks from both sides of the ile as your potential consumers. Common sense?
In india now medi is tied with chain
Even mathematical theorems are not written in stone.
You all had hay days when there was no social media.🤣
Liked the way in which Sekhri politely, humbly and strongly told Shekhar to shut up. Wonder where is Rajdeep in all these debates.
Here only for Jaggi.
#sekhargupta is only journalist makes sense . Other' s are just #left journalist.
LoL Gupta us extreme leftist shit.
He want to play both sides
How is Jaggi left? He runs Swarajya.
answer to their criticism point by point instead of crying and seminars.
Such a witty discussion. 😂
The word is apoplectic.
Gupta did not even acknowledge the lady correcting him when he made such an idiotic choice of word... of course cant expect high vocab from people like him...cant expect humble acceptance of error as well...
The corona event is nearly apocalyptic... wreaking damage on a catastrophic scale. Hope Gupta realizes the difference between the words Apocalypse and apoplexy at least now...
How can anyone bring themselves to listening to anything he says when he has such problems with the english vocabulary... and not just that he is so unwilling to correct himself... he insists that he is right... how can such people be acceptable as senior editors in english language media... too bad...
sorry old man.
you brought it all on yourself.
its so simple to solve the financial aspect of media independence. A public funded media house should be there like BBC and a percent of our income tax 5 % goes to that sector. Done and Dusted !!
How terrible Shekhar Gupta is. So intolerant. This is how his show Walk the Talk was!! He asked a question and answered it himself on behalf of his guests.
Hindi kyo nai Bolte ye log
who are these people ??????
🤞I wish this was me
Nice one Abhinandan!!
Shekhar needs to calm down.
Well spoke Abhinandan 👍
Both belong to same shit
What Sekhri pretends really well is that it's all hunky dory. He's prick who's pretending.
Shekhar Gupta ne Sekhri ko expose kar diya. Badi judgement paas karta hus dusron par.
People like Sekhri will continue to face these powerful humiliations.
Yaar baki sab chodo. Ye anchor kaise sukhda se hai. Ghazab. Mera to dhyan hi nahi gaya debate pe. Lagta hai isko heavy lunch nahi mila
What kind of sick low IQ person you are???
Ye saale har jagah chillate hai
Everything fine beside this childish moderator
Listening to this video it appears Abhinandan has become too big for his shoes...
Fake newslaundry..
Shekhar Gupta.. doesn't make the cut!
The host is highly rude and lack of knowledge