...e ancora una volta hai fatto centro con questo bellissimo testo...grazie per aver postato questa ballata che non ascoltavo da tempo..un tuffo nel passato quando,superato il timore della guerra fredda e la minaccia di un conflitto nucleare e caduti vari regimi autoritari, la pace sembrava a portata di mano... ma come dice Cardarelli "il mio destino è vivere balenando in burrasca "...ciao
To say it's not about the Berlin Wall ( in part ) is foolish .. The fall of the Berlin Wall meant so much to so many people in the UK.. Family members that Hundreds of thousands of people hadn't been allowed to see for what must have seemed an eternity finally came to an end.. Brothers sisters , lovers , Kids and parents peeking through cracks in the wall to get a glimpse of their loved ones. Know your band , know your history.
The building and the fall of Berlin Wall is a hell of a fact, indeed, there shall not be discussion about that. Earlier works of the band discussed issues related to that, we're all aware. What I meant was that the walls he talks about in this particular song are the ones within ourselves, from my point of view. The Division Bell constitues a conceitual work, and the current theme present on the other songs is isolation, individual and psycolhogic isolation.
I don't believe any of the members of the band touched on that when they were interviewed.. Interesting individualistic point of view of what the song means to you though based off of the band members etc I just don't think it fits.. Now if you had hinted at a hidden message being present having to do with a fallen band member , I'ld bite ..... I could see it , just don't think it's as cryptic as you're letting on ..
Again, NOT trying to troll you in any way.. You chose the word ABSOLUTE .... By definition , what exactly would that mean in the context of your statement ? Wouldn't that mean you had irrefutable proof and evidence that all other theories including the band members OWN ACCOUNTS and INTERVIEWS were just plain bollocks ?
Mike Cig Ok, maybe I was too hyperbolic in the sentence. I do not have that kind of proof in that sense. It was a statement that sounded appropriate at the moment, in the light of personal conclusions that came out of the research I was doing about the Enigma Publius thing at the time, which I believe it might be a substancial matter, related to the concept/theme of the album. We all know it was a REAL thing, and we also know that David, or Richard or anyone involved in the album composition or recording spoke openly about it in any situations. This is similar to some Beatles songs that appeared to talk about superficial things (soft concepts that were confirmed in interviews with the band members as well, though a lot of people knew it was not it at all) when actually they traversed exceptional or even transcendental themes. But, who knows... maybe I'm just too non-sceptic. Oh, and I know you're not trying to troll me here.
David Gilmour does so many fantastic songs,I have never been able to pick one as a favorite.
Great and beautiful song .. very underrated
David Gilmour os a genious.Is playing is just great!!! Carlos
This song brings me to tears for some reason!
me, too
Followed him for many years..there is nothing better then Gilmour!!
It's nice to know he appreciates the people he's working with.
Eu amo Rock!
Eu amo o Pink Floyd!
Eu amo David Gilmour!
Agnaldo eu te amo não é o q o nome do seu perfil diz. Quem é Agnaldo ? Ele é melhor q Gilmour ?
Magic music
😍💗 Wow!! The chills! Magnificent song love the achello touch intensifies the feeling if this awesome song💗
You've made this song mean in my life.. I love you..🤗
thanks for sharing
...e ancora una volta hai fatto centro con questo bellissimo testo...grazie per aver postato questa ballata che non ascoltavo da tempo..un tuffo nel passato quando,superato il timore della guerra fredda e la minaccia di un conflitto nucleare e caduti vari regimi autoritari, la pace sembrava a portata di mano... ma come dice Cardarelli "il mio destino è vivere balenando in burrasca "...ciao
grazie... anche a te...ciao
todo un arte auditivo
Moltó bellio
This is like a sunrise
estremece el cuerpo... sana el alma
"Disillusione successiva".....mai parole furono così appropriate! :-(
Something from "Animals" please? :)
Saddly we'll never see him playing it....
What is said when he drinks the water?
"... Could we get something from Animals, please?"
That Weird Otaku Thank you
and what does David answer with?
What I can hear is: "we'd still be here after 'third half time' (or something like that) if we do that"
haha :D okay i understand. yes that's true. the animals songs are just so long, but the greatest
whats the name of the song at the end?
Great live version, although this song it's absolutely not about "real" walls.
To say it's not about the Berlin Wall ( in part ) is foolish .. The fall of the Berlin Wall meant so much to so many people in the UK.. Family members that Hundreds of thousands of people hadn't been allowed to see for what must have seemed an eternity finally came to an end.. Brothers sisters , lovers , Kids and parents peeking through cracks in the wall to get a glimpse of their loved ones. Know your band , know your history.
The building and the fall of Berlin Wall is a hell of a fact, indeed, there shall not be discussion about that. Earlier works of the band discussed issues related to that, we're all aware. What I meant was that the walls he talks about in this particular song are the ones within ourselves, from my point of view. The Division Bell constitues a conceitual work, and the current theme present on the other songs is isolation, individual and psycolhogic isolation.
I don't believe any of the members of the band touched on that when they were interviewed..
Interesting individualistic point of view of what the song means to you though based off of the band members etc I just don't think it fits..
Now if you had hinted at a hidden message being present having to do with a fallen band member , I'ld bite ..... I could see it , just don't think it's as cryptic as you're letting on ..
Again, NOT trying to troll you in any way.. You chose the word ABSOLUTE .... By definition , what exactly would that mean in the context of your statement ? Wouldn't that mean you had irrefutable proof and evidence that all other theories including the band members OWN ACCOUNTS and INTERVIEWS were just plain bollocks ?
Mike Cig Ok, maybe I was too hyperbolic in the sentence. I do not have that kind of proof in that sense. It was a statement that sounded appropriate at the moment, in the light of personal conclusions that came out of the research I was doing about the Enigma Publius thing at the time, which I believe it might be a substancial matter, related to the concept/theme of the album. We all know it was a REAL thing, and we also know that David, or Richard or anyone involved in the album composition or recording spoke openly about it in any situations. This is similar to some Beatles songs that appeared to talk about superficial things (soft concepts that were confirmed in interviews with the band members as well, though a lot of people knew it was not it at all) when actually they traversed exceptional or even transcendental themes. But, who knows... maybe I'm just too non-sceptic. Oh, and I know you're not trying to troll me here.