I purchased my first and last chainsaw in 1995, a Husqvarna 55 (Rancher). I have burned through about a dozen bars and umpteen chains and it is still going strong. I replace the plug, drain the fuel and clean oil and debris from the cowlings between seasons. I have also had to replace the recoil spring once and the pull cord 3-4 times. I cut 6-8 cords or live oak and blackjack oak each year, not to mention brush cutting, Texas Cedar (juniper). Like I said my last saw. I better start thinking about my will and who will inherit this chainsaw.
Where the Stihl shines is hardwood, most European and American trees are soft pine and juniper like one bloke commented on here, hardwood in Australia is Blackbutt, ironbark and some real hard gumtree, most people in Australia use a Stihl Saw to ger threw hardwood, it might rev slower but has more torque
@@dack4545 Most European and American trees are softwood? Don't tell the maples, oaks, beeches, birches or ironwoods that. I had a Husky for over 30 yrs with very little issues, bought a Stihl 3 yrs ago and have had to get a major repair already, not impressed.
Not to give you a hard time, but why are you burning through bars like that? I cut about 20 cords a year, and have a Husqvarna that's 22 years old. It's got the original bar on it, and it's in better shape than most people who have saw that's only four or five years old. Why? Because I always keep my chain sharp. I touch it up with every tank of gas! Every four or five tankfuls, I pull the bar off, and clean everything up, including the slot in the bar. I also make sure the little oil hole in the bar is clear. If your bar isn't getting enough oil, and your chain isn't sharp, your bar takes a beating. This includes also taking your rakers down. I've seen people who I thought were pro chainsaw users fight with their saws to get them to cut, only because they never file their rakers!!! That's another thing I do every four or five times I sharpen the chain. Otherwise you'll find yourself pushing down hard, and that creates a lot of friction between your chain and your bar. You might want to think of what you're doing, where you're burning through so many bars. Also chains. I get about 3 to 4 years out of a chain, probably cutting 60 to 80 cord of wood in sometimes bad conditions. I noticed I don't beat on my chains as much, if I don't drag my wood through the mud, and if one side is dirty, try to brush it off, and cut from the clean side out, when you can. Also flipping your wood and not cutting it right down to the dirt. Keep your bar / chain out of the dirt, because that's the worst thing you can do. Anyways, good luck, and be safe!
I own a little 14 inch Husqvarna saw that's about 10 years old now and I've used it very little, always leave old gas in it, haven't ever changed the filter, plug, etc. But it still starts right up and cuts whatever I need. It's been super reliable with virtually zero maintenance.
I can say that about my MS171 except I have used it a lot, about 30 new chains with them being sharpened also on the second bar, didn't like the 16" on it so next day went with 14" bar.
@@makattak3550 not using something can be just as hard on it as using it; mechanical things don't like sitting around for long periods without prepping them
I’ll go husky for sheer power, but weight, control and the new easy start tech, for my carving, Stihl. But I have a problem and collect chainsaws. I’ve got all kinds, makes, models. Just get as many as you can, and treat them like your best friends. Remember, The Saw Is Family.
I have a Husky 460 Rancher and a little baby Stihl MS170, both top saws. I use the little one any time I can because it's lighter, apart from that no preference. If you own either brand you're on to a winner.
I have the 455 Rancher, 3 years old now, starts everytime and CUTS FAST ! My brother in law has a sawmill and clears lands for logs. He has the Sthils. We had a storm go through and it took 7 trees down, BOTH performed equally. ZERO problems. HE said Sthil used to be made better, have gone downhill lately. Was surprised and highly impressed by my Husky, told me to buy an older Sthil if I ever go to buy one. He has been operating the mill for like 30 years and also competes with his saw. He gave the Husky a thumbs up. Just sayin.
455 and 460 rancher do not cut fast. They’re good homeowner/ranch saws, but they’re not anywhere near fast. The same CC saw in a professional saw will have nearly double the power. More expensive sure and not for everyone but theyre the gold standard for cutting speed, and none of the ranchers cut very fast
Agreed. I loved my echo but I never could find parts for it. I picked up a Stihl from the local tractor dealership and I know any day of the week I can get bars, chain, filters, whatever. Also price for replacement parts would be good to look into. The echo was going to cost over $100 in parts to fix. Brand new the saw was only $200.
One plus for Stihl is that almost every small town or village has a Stihl shop owned by a factory trained Stihl technician. They take pride in having parts and accessories for your Stihl and can repair it quickly and get you back on the job quickly. This is one reason that most of the Professionals around the world prefer Stihl to any other brand. I personally own both Stihl and Husky and various other brands. The Husky is easier starting and runs faster. The Stihl has more torque for pulling big bars. I have a 56inch bar on the Biggest Husky made and a 42 inch Bar on the Stihl 090. I also have an 80 cc Solo. And an 83 cc Efco and a 33 cc Makita (also made by solo) Love that little guy. I have a few others as well.
A side note, I used a Homelite in the woods in the early 70's for falling, didn't last long though. By the end of the 3rd or 4th day the crew was about ready to kill me after I asked the lead man for advice on falling a widowmaker and he slid about 300 ft down the mountain and was badly injured. He had told me not to attempt it but the boss insisted. Oh well! We tried.
Had a Husky, it served me well and I ran the crap out of that saw. While I was working out of state, my wife (Broke the Cardinal rule) loaned it to someone who put straight gas in it. The local saw shop had changed to all Stihl sales talked her into a comparable Stihl saw. I hated that saw, it was harder to start and less power than my Husky. While moving, someone broke into the horse trailer and stole the Stihl. I was mad and relieved at the same time. I'm back to running a Husky and am will never go back to Stihl again.
I am a Professional Arborist with 18 years experience and have run for the most part of my carrier Stihl Chainsaws simply because of their longer service life. However!!! I love my Husky's for there On the Ground performance and I tend to go to them once I am out the tree. Husqvarnas are a lot more user friendly and will save your hands and elbows over long term use. This is just my opinion on what I think personally. I do not get paid by selling you saws. I simply get paid by making wood hit the ground.
Yes in the end let's talk about longer service life. Back in the early 70's I thinned out a mixed woodlot useing two Stihl Farm Boss saws. Cut 100 cords of stove length wood in 30 days and removed it to later be split. Only issue was a worn out oiler(my own fault) for useing strained old crankcase oil for bar oil. Fix was a new oiler(local dealer)$15. Replaced it myself in 10 minutes. Since then I must have run 20-25 Stihl, currentlyMS 462 I will not run any other brand.
lol.....according to some folks lol......too funny...I bought this hard had...it's about worn out...but folks accused me of skewing the video because of the hat ...bhahhaha...it was just cheaper than the Stihl and served the same purpose...hahhaha
I sold both for years and one feature all professional loggers liked about the Husky was the path for air intake. The husky is designed to have airflow take a sharp bend causing the solid particles to centrifically bypass the air intake where the competitive saws would choke the air filter much more quickly. For the commercial cutters time is money.
I've been in the small engine industry my whole life, grew up in it, my dad's been working in it for over 30 years. I've had years of experience with both brands and actual maintenance and mechanical experience, so I've seen the worst of each. Generally Stihl is more expensive to maintain over here in South Africa and most of their products are now made in Brazil and China , where Husqvarna is still Swedish and has factories all over including the states everywhere. But I can say this, both are very good products and it depends and what you are looking for, but I feel that Husqvarna has advanced faster than Stihl and catters more to the user for modern day. In the old days the equipment was heavy and difficult to use and that's where husky has improved on more. If a machine is maintained and run properly, both will give almost the same life and reliability but husky will be easier on you as the user in the long run and there's a reason that they are the biggest outdoor product supplier in the world with their variety of products. We have some of the worst operating conditions and operators in the world, and I can say I trust husky just as much here to get the job done as anywhere else. Really liked your review. This was my 2 cents.
For what it's worth, I've had a Husqvarna 55 Rancher since I bought it new 32 years ago. I live in the Welsh countryside and cut my own firewood, nothing professional I keep 2 wood burning stoves. The Husky has given me almost no trouble over that time, 1 new clutch and 1 new exhaust, a few chains of course and I think 3 bars. 32 years from a machine that I think cost me £250 back then and it's still running. I doubt if a new one would last as long or if a new Stihl would but it just proves that you should always buy the very best tools you can possibly afford. Enjoyed your vid.
Yep It doesn't 😂which one you use If it's not 100% maintained It's not 100% cutting. That's the point . I've used echo 44cc 1980 saw . And it's just as good as today's saw Start easy ..1 Idle just like it should .. 2 Cuts if chain is sharp .. 3 Paid 80 $ 😂 25 cords a year 4 years of experience with that saw Compare to husqvarna 58cc Yes it's smaller but Way lighter 😊. Keep them sharp
I've had a Stihl 291 for 20 years. It's a great saw! I've also got a top handle Echo with a 14 inch, narrower gauge bar and chain. Works well up to 12 inch trees and is half the weight of the Stihl or Husky. Great video!
I’ve been using the 460 rancher for approx 8 years. I mostly use it with a 20” bar. Zero complaints. Those spikes just under the chain are there to help you create a fulcrum, you stab them into the wood and then work the saw like a lever. Edit-I have been cutting approx 5-6 cords of wood each year in the 8 year period. I’m not a professional but my husky gets plenty of use. Some other comments claiming that husky isn’t an all day saw are fos. After I drop the trees and lop the tops with a pruner I’ll run the saw all day, gas/oil and go from sun up til sunset with zero issues.
I've been a full time logger for over 20 years and used both brands often. Both have problem models / years and it seems over the past few years Husky has taken Stihl a bit but both good brands. If possible find a pre 2008 / pre- emissions saw at a pawn shop and always mix 1:40 (1:50 listing is just for emissions). All the best!
My dad got a husq 340 used on local CL years ago. The owner had also bought it used, and this thing was well-worn when we got it. I’ve used that saw more than I can describe over the years, have cut big trees & have cut out many stumps well into the dirt with it, and the engine still feels just as strong as when we got it. I’ve replaced wear items as needed, but haven’t even had to mess with the carb or the fuel system. Still even has the original clutch. This 40cc saw can punch way above its weight class. My eventual upgrades will convert the engine into the equivalent of the 346xp.
I've had my Husky 450 for ten years now, and with proper cleaning, maintenance and sharpening it hasn't once been in the shop! That's cutting 20 truckloads of firewood per year, not to mention clearing and thinning around my cabin. Husqvarna all the way!
My husqvarna 440 is the same bought semi used for 200 bucks from a dealer the guy bought it ....used it once then he died....yes he dropped a tree on himself! His wife brought the saw back....best 200 bucks I ever spent! That saw has never been in the shop and has only been taken apart for routine maintenance on my tailgate and its pushing 10 years old!
Been cutting fire wood since the mid /70's, I have had many saws, right now my 2 small saws are a Stihl 025 and Husky 445. Both great saws for there intended job. I have bad hands, they can go numb do to damage from 40 yrs of auto repairs. Recently using the Stihl my hands were getting numb but had lots of clearing to do so switched over to the Husky, My hands started to go back to normal and were ok for the rest of the day. Both saws are better than my old Homie but the Husky i can run all day and my hands are usually fine. Having troubles with my old Stihl 064 and if i have to replace it it will most likely be with a Husky.
Once you get comfortable with a tool you like, these things become second nature anyway. that can also lead to bias preferences between brands/models amoungst professional and general user of the brand. There’s no real problem with that unless we become completely blind to quality and longevity of the tool in order to stay devoted to our preferred brand 👍🏻
Been using chainsaws with downward kill switch like the Husqy for 40 years and never accidentally hit it. Thumb is usually wrapped around the handle unless a person has a physical defect that keeps them from bending their thumb.
I have both brands as well. I tend to drift towards my husky as well. My father inlaw who is a stihl owner got ahold of one of my huskies and has been holding it hostage for the past year. Less vibration he says. .
I've used a lot of different brands over about 45 years of cutting wood. My observation is that the size and shape of the cutting teeth makes more of a difference in how well a saw cuts, more than anything else. When tuned good, with sharpened chain, and lubed properly, any saw will eventually cut, but having the power to pull a chain with large cutting teeth through the wood will have the greatest impact on speed of the cut. Just like having the proper tires on your car. Wearing racing slicks on your 4WD in the mud won't get you very far. I've had some low priced saws, like Poulan, that run very well, good acceleration, good power. Jonsered was a very good, and very lightweight saw, but more expensive. I bought that for my dad, as he got older, the lighter weight was better for him. I currently use a Husqvarna 455, and I don't know if it's because I know better how to maintain and tune saws now, or if it's simply a better saw than I've used in the past, but it starts very easy, runs hard and fast, and cuts incredibly fast. I've had it for about 12 years, and only had to replace the factory oil tubes, as they leaked from day one, now much better. I've cut 3 to 4 foot diameter trees with it without any problems. Don't forget to lube the clutch needle bearing on the Husqvarna. It can be lubed with the same plunger greaser that lubes the end of your chain bar, through the hole on the end of the shaft that sticks out through the clutch. I've never bought the expensive bar and chain oil. The cheapest 30 weight oil I can find has always worked just fine for me. I've used bar and chain oil when someone gave it to me, and I see no difference in how it lubes the saw. I also have a Husqvarna string trimmer and backpack blower, and, after tuning the string trimmer from the poor factory settings, it runs better and has more power than any other string trimmer that I have ever used, by far. It never bogs down in heavy grass, is light and comfortable. Probably the best thing I can say about the Husqvarna products is that they all start very easily. With the string trimmer and my backpack blower, after working all day, and you are very tired, and you find you have one patch of something you missed, it's a good feeling to pull the string and it starts right up, when you are dog tired. None of the other manufacturers come close to this easy starting, every time. Even after sitting over winter, they crank right up in the spring. Forty years ago, as a young kid, you could crank on these tools until your arm went limp (and that's a strong, teenager arm, not my current model of old, boomer arm) before they would start, so it's an amazing change from many years ago. Use what you like, take care of it, and it will do the job it was designed to do.
I have a Stihl fs91r I’ve had for 1 year so far and it starts up first pull everytime and has amazing power! Wont bog even in the thickest grass and I don’t have any complaints besides I’m not a fan of the head design for reloading the string…I also have a Stihl bg 56 blower and it’s also great!
@@gonewronggarage4565 I have a FS90R that's just over 10 years old, and still running well. I've used a brush knife on it to cut through small trees that are much larger than the knife was meant to cut through. I normally use line on it, but the first time I used that brush knife, I was laughing like a supervillain. The only reason I want to replace it is the vibration.
When one of my two Stihl's run like yours does it needs the carb adjusted which only happens about every 50 hrs. That being said the Husky did very well.
I agree, if your saw bogs or hesitates when you throttle up, the carb is not properly adjusted. My Stihl had no hesitation. Same thing if the saw cuts slower, the high speed screw is misadjusted.
Great video. Thanxx for not being another guy who likes to hear himself talk. Straight and to the point! I want to like the Stihl’s better. But I bought the 460 Husky. Even though it doesn’t feel or look like it, I believe it’s a better saw when in use.
I just bought a 450 Rancher with a 20" bar. I've been using Husqvarna for years and I notice all these well engineered design choices, like the power button layout, the fuel caps, and the choke, to name a few. Unless I needed a top handle, I would go with Husqvarna.
I'm have used a Husqvarna 365 for 10 years, sold and thereafter bought a new Husqvarna 365 which I am using now for 9 years. I love it. Being 65, the saw is getting rather heavy! ( I don't know why) Would appreciate a lighter model, but it is working like a charm, every time! I added a Husqvarna Generator G 5500P to my Husqvarna tools. Then I don't even mention my Husqvarna mincer that my parents used!
Awesome review!!! good to show how both work and how there are some things that people miss when choosing a new saw. For me I bought my Husqvarna 359 back in 2004 and have fell probably over 200 White oak, Red oak, sweetgum, and pines. bucked up I don't know how many cords of wood. other than bars, chains and plugs, that all I have had to replace on this thing. It still starts on first or second pull. I have run Stihls others owned but was never rich enough to buy a stihl.
I've been running Husqvarnas for 50 years. My 380 and 44 Rancher run like the day I bought them! I recently bought a 450 and 562 XP. Best SAWS on earth!
Love my Husqvarna had it for years. Had a Echo trimmer since 1987 replaced primer bulb , gas filter twice, gas lines, 3plugs air filters and trim head. Runs like a new one, after storing 3 total pulls.
I've owned them both for many years. A 460 Rancher and a 036 PRO. When both saws are tuned correctly, I think the Husky is actually smoother and better balanced. BUT..... after these saws started to get some hours on them, the Stihl is by far more reliable and easier/cheaper to do maintenance on. Slight edge to Stihl. Just my opinion. Both are great saws.
You obviously have ran both. I had the exact same thoughts. The Husqvarna ran smooth until it lost compression after 2 years of light use. The cheap chinese parts in the 455 failed. The stihl I replaced it with has been going strong ever since.
I love German-made stuff so I have always been biased toward Stihl - but in the end I bought the Husky. Warranty and ease of service were the deal breaker. Oh, and I love the saw - very happy with the decision.
I know you are trying to compair them on how they operate out of box and with what they come with out of the box but you should have slapped bars on them that are both the same length so we could watch them play ball in the same statium. Nice review bro.
This would be true if the losing saw (stihl) had the 24” bar and the husqvarna had the 20”. But the longer bar was on the winning saw, so putting a 24” on the stihl would have just made it lose even more to the husky. If you threw a 20” on the husky it would smoke that 311. IMO stihl makes great pro saws but their home owner models are cheap plastic junk. They sell based off their name, not quality. All husqvarna saws home owner or pro are built very well.
It was a good test of overall performance for both saws. I have used the Husqvarna saw more than other chainsaws, and my personal favorite saw is the 372. It is great for topping, and delimbing trees. Other Husqvarna saws that were good were the 281s, and the 288s.
I have run saws in the woods as a pro logger for years, hands down Husky is where it’s at, but I would get a prosas, Husky 372,or 562, consumer grade saws don’t impress me much. My all time favorite saws are McCulloch 10 series saws..
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer ,My Dad had a 1970's vintage Mac 1010 my whole childhood cutting California Oak,when He gave it to me I lived in Montana,the only thing that could stop that saw was Montana winters :D I retired that and got a Stihl 028 that is still cutting strong and I use more than my MS460. Thanks for your videos!
I think both Stihl and Husqvarna make great saws. We own both Stihl and Husky even though I've always preferred Stihl I think that both brands are fantastic and make some great saws.
I love my 460 . I have a 201T Stihl for a climbing saw . I have a Husqvarna ported 390 for taking the big ones down each saw has there different uses . The 460 I use for fire wood all around good ground saw
Have owned both brands but always felt the Huskys had more power and felt more natural in the hands during use. Have been cutting firewood all my life 55years old now so no amateur. Have a 365 special and an old 61 I inherited from my GRANDFATHER who ran it in the bush with me since I was in my early 20's!! Never had any major work other than bars & chains. One of my sons uses it now and cuts 5 or 6 cords every year with it. The Stihls I've owned were good saws but the Huskys are tops!
I've got a Husky 61 that I've been using since I was a teenager (It still has the gold Husky 1689 - 1989 300 year anniversary sticker on it) with a 24" TSUMURA solid bar.. The saw's been underwater 6 or 7 times. Some years it gets heavy use.. other years it's a shelf queen. Regardless... fresh gas and oil rocks out like it's brand new.
Good to hear! Husqvarna is far better in every way. Have been working on both brands and the husky’s is great and simple. The Stihl is a pain when it comes to dismantle for service etc. Had saws coming with all sorts of broken parts too. The best one i have done trees with is the 550 Xpg with heater handle in cold winter.
I use husqarna, and have no complain, my dad has stihl. I pick husky because price (3/4 of stihl price). Both stihl and husqarna are quality product, have decent service coverage. Keep them sharp, oiled and corect fuel mix, you will not have any issues for years. Dont buy cheep chinese saw, or you will regret in long run, get frustrated and start hate working with chainsaws.
I have an 018, MS 310, and MS 390. The 310 would out cut the 390 until I had run 10 to 15 tanks of fuel through the 390. The 310 is much older. You can hear that the rpm of the 310 is much higher. The 311 in the video sounds like it could use a carb adjustment oh the high rpm. Great videos!
I’m a lover of Stihl saws but they are temperamental to start and flood easy. I bit the bullet though and bought an MS261 C-M with M-Tronic and am blown away with how good it is and how easily it starts. I’ve used a bunch of saws over the years and it’s easily my favourite. One thing I will recommend when buying a Stihl is to ask the dealer to change out the stock safety chain for a full chisel. That one change alone makes a huge difference and the 261 has more than enough grunt (4 hp) to power it through anything even with the optional 20” bar rather than the stock 16” it comes with.
totally agree. I have Husrqvarna 359 and then I decided to by also Stihl MS261, Stihl has more power and is like 1,5 lighter - needless to say this is the difference you can notice. I still believe both are great saws and I'm keeping both.
This I learned many years ago. Steel makes a good saw but could keep them together they would vibrate there self apart just got tired of putting them together all the time plus the wait
I timed the last cut with each saw. There is roughly a 1-second difference in the final cuts. Husqvarna: 7.30 seconds. Stihl: 8:38 seconds. Your video is excellent and well-made. I just wanted to give an accurate timing of the cuts. I appreciate your video. I'm trying to decide between the two.
Yeah, just because they were sharpened by the same guy doesn't mean they were sharpened the same way . Also did you notice that when the Stihl took two pulls to start . That it slipped out of his hand the first pull. He obviously had his mind made up long before the video. A very biased review.
I have been very happy with my Husqvarna. I've had for around 5 years, and it is still easy to start. I will say I don't do heavy cutting. If you're like me and only need a chainsaw, occasionally buy which of the 2 you can get the better deal on. Both are great, and unless you're cutting every day, then it just isn't worth worrying about, which is better.
12 hours out of the box....you saw the results...this ain't no trickery brotha...just 2 saws competitively built and priced...head to head...I was surprised to be honest with you
I work in a Husqvarna repair shop.The Stihl ships with a .325 - 63 gauge chain and the Husqvarna ships with a 3/8 - 50 gauge chain. The Husqvarna chain is thinner and more aggressive than the Stihl chain. However, the Stihl .325 chain is a very good chain but slightly slower. Both are excellent saws. I own a Stihl and a Husqvarna and like them both. I do not like the Stihl fuel and oil tank caps because they break too easily.
Loved the video until the end!! It isn’t just men who use chainsaws!! I was looking for the comparison for myself. Appreciate you sharing the differences and know which one I’d like for Mother’s Day. Thank you
I've owned both and both are good saws. I replaced them with a MS261 with a 20 inch bar. the 261 is a beast for it's size and light enough to work with all day
10-4! For what was done in this vidja, a MS261, Huskie 550XP, or Echo 501P would all be perfect and a guy could do it literally all day and not wear out. My arms would be lead weights after just a few gas tanks working up high like that and limbing. For me there's something special about a sub 11 lb. saw with 3.6 to 4 bhp!
@@lucfournier3939 yes. it's supposed to be good in very low temp's. I cut wood last year when we had a two week cold snap avg. 0-5 degrees during the day. I had no problems. I use still pre mix fuel and their synthetic bar oil. I had the husky rancher and liked it to but it is built like a home owner saw. I think you need to go to their pro series to get a tougher saw.
I bought a 20” bar husky about 6 months ago. It’s been great. If I’ve had one gripe: it’s a full pound plus heavier then the Stihl competitor. It doesn’t sound like much but makes a big difference.
Im leaning towards the Husq. Im small work, Echo C-310 14" But after a few years of winter side jobs Im ready to do some bigger projects. Great video, thanks for making it. I prefer the switch to push up to cut off. A lot of times, I will pull the chord to start and my finger brushes the switch accidentally and I dont notice for 2 or 3 pulls.
I agree totally. I learned this when I worked the woods back fifty years ago when my boss went from STIHL to Husqvarna. We had a John Deere skidder and we'd say "Nothing runs like a Deere and nothing bites like a Husky"
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer im just joking man... its all good... im stihl-hearted thru and thru but the 311 is an awful saw... I actually agree with your assessment... the husky gear tho lol
Husqvarna dealer here in Avon Park Florida, tested the spark voltage on the Stihl and Husqvarna chain saws. He said the Husk puts out far more voltage the Stihl, He theorized that that is one of the reasons the Stihl is harder to start. Any chainsaw or small engine should have a tankful or 2 of fuel run through them at a dead idle or only slightly faster. This helps to break the engine in so that the parts which have been freshly machined will rub together and smooth the roughness down a bit inside the engine. After that readjust the idle and high and low-speed carb screws with the engine warmed up to suit the altitude and temperature and fuel mix.. The older fellas also sometimes run a 24-1 fuel mix for the first couple of tanks of fuel. After the initial break-in involving some lighter duty cutting so that you don't overheat the engine, you will probably want to readjust the idle screw and the high and low-speed screws for the 40-1 fuel mix or whatever mix you prefer. If you travel up into the different altitudes in the mountains for firewood cutting you will also have to readjust the carb settings again. On some of the old saws, they were usually adjusted to burble quite a bit until in a very heavy cut at which time they would lean out and speed up and change to a higher-pitched sound. The Stihl as he mentioned was not running correctly and that is probably the problem. A saw is usually not considered fully broken in until it has probably 15 0r 20 tans of fuel run through it. If you lean out the mixture too much it will seize the engine. If you run it too rich, it will run too slow and generally not achieve full power. There are some great videos on youtube for chainsaw tuning. Enjoy yourselves.
It has actually been proven that breaking in gently leads to faster wear because the crisshatch goes away before the rings seat! Break in hard and fast
Interesting you mentioned the Stihl fuel blowing out the gas cap when opening. Just experienced fuel geysering on my MS310. Recovering from some severe burns.
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer I had been cutting for about an hour. Saw was running fine. After cutting through my second tank of fuel, the saw started stalling in and out. I thought it was out of fuel again. Not thinking anything about it, I turned it off and as soon as I opened the cap the fuel that was in the tank came spraying out. It took a few seconds but must have hit the saw just right and lit up along with the fuel that hit me. I've been cutting for nearly 30 years and have respect for this tool. Never heard of this problem. I've been finding a lot of information on this since then. There are no warnings in the owner's manual regarding vapor lock or fuel geysering. Look up some TH-cam videos. Stihl has recalls on four models and their flip caps. Numerous injuries out west with the fire fighters. Stihl now has a new design fuel adapter using the Sotor system. They knew they have problems
It's all very trivial. Who cares if a certain saw will cut a 10" log 3 seconds faster than the other. Both are great saws and you can't go wrong with either. I have an old Stihl MS 180 and a newer MS 362 pro series and love them both dearly. Would never consider trading for Husky. But that's just me because I'm a Stihl guy. You'll hear the same from any of the Husky guys on here. It's just a matter of what you like and what you know.
I also timed the cuts with my phone stopwatch. He's full of shit. The last cuts were Husky 6.98 secs and the Stihl was 8.5. That's about 1.5 sec's ...Not 5 or 6. This comparison is bullshit. On Stihls Website the 311 weighs 13.67 not 14.1 on the Husky site it shows 13.2 not 12.8. Not sure where he's getting his info but Stihl must have pissed him off somehow.
I’ve been a Husky fan for a very long time. I own an original Pro fallers saw, highly desirable from the late 80’s, the 266SE. It’s still in excellent shape and it’s been used commercially. Husky always has built some incredible saws. I want to get a newer rancher. I just bought my first Stihl Small limbing saw used and it’s decent, but I’ll be buying huskys from here on out. The newer ranchers are amazing
Buy a Pro series Stihl off craigslist and don't look back. I like Huskies for lighter stuff, but when there is a downed walnut tree or oak or willow, my ms 461 is my best friend.
I have an older Husqvarna 372xp with a 24 and 28 inch bar. I wouldn't trade it for any other saw. It's reliable and cuts big trees fast. The biggest that I have cut was a maple tree that was 58 inches across.
Stihl vs husky Chevy vs Ford JD vs NH or Kubota or... Mayo vs miracle whip Boxers vs briefs All good. It’s the user that is the real variable Have a good day guys. Stay safe
Thanks man! I have ran a Stihl for years and thought it was great. Then I went out with a buddy who had a Husqvarna. His saw outdid my saw in every way. Looks like I'm gonna buy a Husqvarna. Great review!! Thanks!!
Great video, no I'm not a professional but do get to cut a lot of firewood for our place in N. Ga. I have both a Stihl my wife bought me one year and a Husky... I use both and both are good saws but I tend to use the Husky as my main saw and Stigh as a backup. I have just found the Husky easier to work with for my personal preference and starts up a lot easier than the Stihl .. the Stihl floods real easy if you are not careful with the choke .... my 2 cents
If the saw is reliable and gets the job done without any trouble, who cares about the brand. Husqvarna or Stihl? Why not both? I like both companies and they both have really nice models to offer. Here in Québec though when winter arrives I think the Huskies start and run better so they're my favorites. My 572 is one hell of a saw!
My 1st good saw was a Sthil 026 - and I loved that saw! - it did all I needed for 17 yrs - than when it finally died I bought a husky 455 rancher ,because i didn't want to spend the extra 100. to get a comparable sthil ,i have wavered on whether that was a good choice or not. the Husky seems a bit more powerful (and louder) but the sthil lasted for so many yrs . & after a few yrs the husky is having carb problems - which even though i run clear( good gas ) in it - it seems to be needing a new carb now , (welcome to the new world of crappy gas)
i had two 575 xps but found that i like my 372 xp better . less goes wrong with it than the 575s .. my saw shop guy hated the 575s and says the 372s are much superior. Try one.
It's just a helmet.. My safety equipment are both Husqvarna and Stihl, best price on highest series is the winner. Besides, even if one were Stihl bias one would have to admit that the Husqvarna won this test.
I have both of these, I like both of them, but I will tell you the Stihl after 10 years still starts in 5 pulls or less and runs great. The Husqvarna starts in 5 pulls or more and I have to run it with a smaller bar because it has lost a lot of power.
Have a 30 year old Husky 351. Still starts right up , only issue I've had was a mouse ate the coil wire so had to replace the coil about two years ago. Also have a Stihl 181. No issues , takes longer to start , has the ez start which I don't really like . The only issue I've had with this saw is I'm a big guy 6'6" , big hands . When I'm cutting I've had the saw shut off several times because my hand hit the shutoff switch , never had a issue like that with the Husky
Great video. I have been using an ECHO recently with great results. Always had Husky until now. I am looking for a saw inch bar capability and the 460 Rancher is st the top of my list. The only question I have is does the 24 inch bar in your comparison have any impact on cut speed? More chain in the same RPMs.
I had a Husqvqrna 50 a few years ago. That thing was a great saw. I sold it and bought a Stihl 038 magII. That was a great saw also. Both cut lots of wood. I think both of my saws were bigger than those "ranch size" saws. Now that I am older, the professional saws I had are a little to heavy for me.
Yeah, my old Stihl Pro sounds like it's effortlessly slicing through any log... and it starts and runs better than his... Don't buy a HF 'Portland' electric... mine fell apart 5 times during it's first cut through a 10" softwood limb... chain/bar dangerously comes loose and swings up... cuts into the saw... only one stud holds it on... nut won't stay tight... (Not to be confused with a Poulan)
Ive done a bit of wood chopping.. and i started with a stihl 251got a ms 391now.. mates used huskys but they kept blowing up.. is that just a faulty saw or are they known for blowing up?
Had one stihl, 460, the quick caps pop loose working in the brush, heavy trimming and climbing, constant vapor lock issues, no dealer could figure it out.. never again... never had husky issues, also have a few newer echo's. Exact copy of a husky at half the price. That's my experience anyways... Oh and echo's a 5yr warranty. Lol
Thank you for the tip! We had an Echo 20 years ago and it worked great.
5 ปีที่แล้ว +6
Things to consider, scooter: you used a longer bar husky, which will have the chain heating up slower and its dulling diminished by the minimised thermal expansion of the chain and cutting edge is not expanded while cutting, as opposed to the hotter chain on the Stihl will have a hotter and consequently larger and duller cutting edge. Plus, you used different sawing motions with the two saws, rocking the husky saw, but cutting without doing the same to the stihl. you seem like a nice guy and your video quality was good, but its plain to see you had the cards unevenly stacked and a dampened bias for the husky. both are great tools but they were unequally yoked
If you were to put the same length bar on the Stihl it should slow it down even more. Rocking the Husky could be the fact that it's 2 lbs lighter but he should use the same identical technique when comparing saws. For a really fare comparison , set up both saw with a tachometer to the factory specs. The Stihl has a shorter bar and is claiming to have more horsepower. It's 2lbs heavier so it should easily take the trophy. Not certain but It looked to me like the Husky had more chain speed.
Having 1/6 more cutting teeth than the Stihl (24" chain versus 20" chain) of course the Husqvarna cuts faster. You should have used a 24" bar&chain Stihl to make it perfectly even. What do you think of the Baumr 24" chainsaw with a 75cc motor?
Think of it this way stihl runs over 11,000 rpms on the run . Husqvarna runs 9,000 rpms so given that you say bar size is the difference. I see the difference in rpms being the factor moreover .
The Stihl saws are made like that so your saw doesn’t turn off during cutting if you have an emergency your chain break is your best option it’s right there
or as i said above in an emergency choke will stop the motor but the chain break on the Stihl can be easily popped forward with my left hand on Huskies i have to move my hands to engage the chain brake
Husqvarna is the way to go, dependable work horses, and the 460 is the one to have all around, toss a skip tooth chain on it and reduce your cutting time considerably.
Texas Treehouse Tree Service & Stump Grinding has been using Echo for over 25 yr. we are a very fast pace tree removal service in Dallas,Tx AND dont have time to be working on saws every day.!! Big trees we do in a few hours. take a craw of man all day to do!!. a good saw save time and money.!!
I personally own McCullough saws but they're dinosaurs that are really heavy, really loud, and scream through the fuel. When it comes to the two tested, the Husky is at least half the price of the Sthil, where I live anyway. Ran em both professionally for a year, up and down mountain sides in all weather conditions. If the price were the same, I would pick the Husky based solely on my experience with durability between the two. That fuel cap on the Sthil is terrible, they break way to easily, that Sthil ain't runnin if it don't have fuel in it.
I like both brands I have owned both, but I do favor the Husqvarna saws a little bit more for the ease of starting them you did a good review of both these fine saws anyone would be happy with either one of these
Even if Husky is better, what i have from it when first service is 50km away while Stihl i can walk to service. I think both are awesome saws just depends of service
For what it's worth, I have a Stihl MS250 and have had to replace the oil filler cap and the fuel filler cap as they have both failed and leaked. I'm not a fan of that cap system. I'm carrying an extra one of each in my kit.
My stihl 441(non m-tronic) starts as easy as that husky. One pull with the choke from cold and it barks one pull after that and it runs. My m-tronic 362's are fairly easy to start also. Stihl does use the primer bubble on the 500i though. The primer button bypasses impulse so you are manually pushing fule to the carb, you don't have to pull it over a few times to pump fule you already did by pushing the primer bulb. Thanks for the video!!
Folks don't forget! For daily livestreams come join us on the livestream channel here: th-cam.com/users/StoneyRidgeFarmerLIVESTREAMS
Remember the husqvarnas run a higher rpm. My 460 is on order be here next week. Can't wait!!! My 450 is getting tired.
I purchased my first and last chainsaw in 1995, a Husqvarna 55 (Rancher). I have burned through about a dozen bars and umpteen chains and it is still going strong. I replace the plug, drain the fuel and clean oil and debris from the cowlings between seasons. I have also had to replace the recoil spring once and the pull cord 3-4 times. I cut 6-8 cords or live oak and blackjack oak each year, not to mention brush cutting, Texas Cedar (juniper). Like I said my last saw. I better start thinking about my will and who will inherit this chainsaw.
richranchernot wow i change my plugs every two to 3 yrs once it starts misbehaving on pull start
Lol
Where the Stihl shines is hardwood, most European and American trees are soft pine and juniper like one bloke commented on here, hardwood in Australia is Blackbutt, ironbark and some real hard gumtree, most people in Australia use a Stihl Saw to ger threw hardwood, it might rev slower but has more torque
@@dack4545 Most European and American trees are softwood? Don't tell the maples, oaks, beeches, birches or ironwoods that. I had a Husky for over 30 yrs with very little issues, bought a Stihl 3 yrs ago and have had to get a major repair already, not impressed.
Not to give you a hard time, but why are you burning through bars like that? I cut about 20 cords a year, and have a Husqvarna that's 22 years old. It's got the original bar on it, and it's in better shape than most people who have saw that's only four or five years old. Why? Because I always keep my chain sharp. I touch it up with every tank of gas! Every four or five tankfuls, I pull the bar off, and clean everything up, including the slot in the bar. I also make sure the little oil hole in the bar is clear. If your bar isn't getting enough oil, and your chain isn't sharp, your bar takes a beating. This includes also taking your rakers down. I've seen people who I thought were pro chainsaw users fight with their saws to get them to cut, only because they never file their rakers!!! That's another thing I do every four or five times I sharpen the chain. Otherwise you'll find yourself pushing down hard, and that creates a lot of friction between your chain and your bar. You might want to think of what you're doing, where you're burning through so many bars. Also chains. I get about 3 to 4 years out of a chain, probably cutting 60 to 80 cord of wood in sometimes bad conditions. I noticed I don't beat on my chains as much, if I don't drag my wood through the mud, and if one side is dirty, try to brush it off, and cut from the clean side out, when you can. Also flipping your wood and not cutting it right down to the dirt. Keep your bar / chain out of the dirt, because that's the worst thing you can do. Anyways, good luck, and be safe!
I own a little 14 inch Husqvarna saw that's about 10 years old now and I've used it very little, always leave old gas in it, haven't ever changed the filter, plug, etc. But it still starts right up and cuts whatever I need. It's been super reliable with virtually zero maintenance.
You said you have used it very little. You cannot talk reliability.
You must have stabilizer in it. The gas will clog the carb
@makattak3550 he is simply saying he has treated it poorly, and it still functions properly
I can say that about my MS171 except I have used it a lot, about 30 new chains with them being sharpened also on the second bar, didn't like the 16" on it so next day went with 14" bar.
@@makattak3550 not using something can be just as hard on it as using it; mechanical things don't like sitting around for long periods without prepping them
Stihl and Husqvarna both great saws ! Buy both a man can never have to many chainsaws !
I have Sithl and Husquarna and i cannot say one is better than another. When sharpened properly they both work great.
@@Dr.Sciatica true!!!
I’ll go husky for sheer power, but weight, control and the new easy start tech, for my carving, Stihl. But I have a problem and collect chainsaws. I’ve got all kinds, makes, models.
Just get as many as you can, and treat them like your best friends. Remember, The Saw Is Family.
I have a Husky 460 Rancher and a little baby Stihl MS170, both top saws. I use the little one any time I can because it's lighter, apart from that no preference. If you own either brand you're on to a winner.
Can gay people own more than one saw?😂
I have the 455 Rancher, 3 years old now, starts everytime and CUTS FAST ! My brother in law has a sawmill and clears lands for logs. He has the Sthils. We had a storm go through and it took 7 trees down, BOTH performed equally. ZERO problems. HE said Sthil used to be made better, have gone downhill lately. Was surprised and highly impressed by my Husky, told me to buy an older Sthil if I ever go to buy one. He has been operating the mill for like 30 years and also competes with his saw. He gave the Husky a thumbs up.
Just sayin.
I quote you on that the new Stihl's are plastic Husqvarna is old reliable construction nearly 40 years old and is easy and cheap to repair.
Echo timber Wolf is better than both
@@tony18662Husqvarna switched in the past couple years to using plastic wheels for the pull start and they’ve been breaking like crazy.
455 and 460 rancher do not cut fast. They’re good homeowner/ranch saws, but they’re not anywhere near fast. The same CC saw in a professional saw will have nearly double the power. More expensive sure and not for everyone but theyre the gold standard for cutting speed, and none of the ranchers cut very fast
Tell him he has been lackin for 30 years using a stihl
It's probably best to go with the brand that your local dealer sells for parts and maintenance.
Agreed. I loved my echo but I never could find parts for it. I picked up a Stihl from the local tractor dealership and I know any day of the week I can get bars, chain, filters, whatever. Also price for replacement parts would be good to look into. The echo was going to cost over $100 in parts to fix. Brand new the saw was only $200.
That's why I gave up homelite and McCullough. Parts are always weeks away or not available anymore.
One plus for Stihl is that almost every small town or village has a Stihl shop owned by a factory trained Stihl technician. They take pride in having parts and accessories for your Stihl and can repair it quickly and get you back on the job quickly. This is one reason that most of the Professionals around the world prefer Stihl to any other brand. I personally own both Stihl and Husky and various other brands. The Husky is easier starting and runs faster. The Stihl has more torque for pulling big bars. I have a 56inch bar on the Biggest Husky made and a 42 inch Bar on the Stihl 090. I also have an 80 cc Solo. And an 83 cc Efco and a 33 cc Makita (also made by solo) Love that little guy. I have a few others as well.
A side note, I used a Homelite in the woods in the early 70's for falling, didn't last long though. By the end of the 3rd or 4th day the crew was about ready to kill me after I asked the lead man for advice on falling a widowmaker and he slid about 300 ft down the mountain and was badly injured. He had told me not to attempt it but the boss insisted. Oh well! We tried.
Had a Husky, it served me well and I ran the crap out of that saw. While I was working out of state, my wife (Broke the Cardinal rule) loaned it to someone who put straight gas in it. The local saw shop had changed to all Stihl sales talked her into a comparable Stihl saw. I hated that saw, it was harder to start and less power than my Husky. While moving, someone broke into the horse trailer and stole the Stihl. I was mad and relieved at the same time. I'm back to running a Husky and am will never go back to Stihl again.
I am a Professional Arborist with 18 years experience and have run for the most part of my carrier Stihl Chainsaws simply because of their longer service life. However!!! I love my Husky's for there On the Ground performance and I tend to go to them once I am out the tree. Husqvarnas are a lot more user friendly and will save your hands and elbows over long term use. This is just my opinion on what I think personally. I do not get paid by selling you saws. I simply get paid by making wood hit the ground.
yep...I ain't selling you a saw either...just showing ya the difference
Witch is good for to buy sthil 250 or husqvarna 51 both are in good condition ! Plis tell me
Yes in the end let's talk about longer service life. Back in the early 70's I thinned out a mixed woodlot useing two Stihl Farm Boss saws. Cut 100 cords of stove length wood in 30 days and removed it to later be split. Only issue was a worn out oiler(my own fault) for useing strained old crankcase oil for bar oil. Fix was a new oiler(local dealer)$15. Replaced it myself in 10 minutes. Since then I must have run 20-25 Stihl, currentlyMS 462
I will not run any other brand.
the stihl cuts faster if your wearing a stihl hard hat and ear muffins.
lol.....according to some folks lol......too funny...I bought this hard had...it's about worn out...but folks accused me of skewing the video because of the hat ...bhahhaha...it was just cheaper than the Stihl and served the same purpose...hahhaha
*BRILLIANT* 👍
😭
I notice that too.I prefer a Husky but you point is well taken.
Not true
I sold both for years and one feature all professional loggers liked about the Husky was the path for air intake. The husky is designed to have airflow take a sharp bend causing the solid particles to centrifically bypass the air intake where the competitive saws would choke the air filter much more quickly. For the commercial cutters time is money.
I've been a logger for over 20 year years and I absolutely agree. As a professional I'll take the husky.
Yep...agreed...
I've been in the small engine industry my whole life, grew up in it, my dad's been working in it for over 30 years. I've had years of experience with both brands and actual maintenance and mechanical experience, so I've seen the worst of each. Generally Stihl is more expensive to maintain over here in South Africa and most of their products are now made in Brazil and China , where Husqvarna is still Swedish and has factories all over including the states everywhere. But I can say this, both are very good products and it depends and what you are looking for, but I feel that Husqvarna has advanced faster than Stihl and catters more to the user for modern day. In the old days the equipment was heavy and difficult to use and that's where husky has improved on more. If a machine is maintained and run properly, both will give almost the same life and reliability but husky will be easier on you as the user in the long run and there's a reason that they are the biggest outdoor product supplier in the world with their variety of products. We have some of the worst operating conditions and operators in the world, and I can say I trust husky just as much here to get the job done as anywhere else. Really liked your review. This was my 2 cents.
Your review makes a lot of sense. I particularly like this " we have some of the worst operating conditions and operators...". LOL
@Nellis
Stihl pro saws come straight out of Germany.
Husky its better
These are not pro saws, farmer saws. Weak plastic parts on both.
Pro saws, husqvarna is king. Stihl has tried to hard to be a step ahead of the EPA.
Husqvarna wins everytime!!
I fitted a 4 inch stainless steel exhaust system, a Winger Supercharger and ceramic piston cap. My stihl now cuts faster than my wife’s tongue.
Yeah but ya missus changes her oil once a month 😜
Bwahahahahahaha!!!!
LMFAO
Mah GAWD this is FKN Funny! 🤣🤣🤣
For what it's worth, I've had a Husqvarna 55 Rancher since I bought it new 32 years ago. I live in the Welsh countryside and cut my own firewood, nothing professional I keep 2 wood burning stoves. The Husky has given me almost no trouble over that time, 1 new clutch and 1 new exhaust, a few chains of course and I think 3 bars. 32 years from a machine that I think cost me £250 back then and it's still running. I doubt if a new one would last as long or if a new Stihl would but it just proves that you should always buy the very best tools you can possibly afford. Enjoyed your vid.
Whatever you own, just take care of it and keep your chain sharp.
Guessing your in your early 90s
Yep
It doesn't 😂which one you use
If it's not 100% maintained
It's not 100% cutting.
That's the point .
I've used echo 44cc
1980 saw . And it's just as good as today's saw
Start easy ..1
Idle just like it should .. 2
Cuts if chain is sharp .. 3
Paid 80 $ 😂
25 cords a year
4 years of experience with that saw
Compare to husqvarna 58cc
Yes it's smaller but
Way lighter 😊. Keep them sharp
I've had a Stihl 291 for 20 years. It's a great saw! I've also got a top handle Echo with a 14 inch, narrower gauge bar and chain. Works well up to 12 inch trees and is half the weight of the Stihl or Husky. Great video!
Stihl didn’t start manufacturing the MS291 until March of 2011. Are you sure you didn’t mean the higher quality MS290 that Stihl made from 2000-2012?
I’ve been using the 460 rancher for approx 8 years. I mostly use it with a 20” bar. Zero complaints.
Those spikes just under the chain are there to help you create a fulcrum, you stab them into the wood and then work the saw like a lever.
Edit-I have been cutting approx 5-6 cords of wood each year in the 8 year period. I’m not a professional but my husky gets plenty of use. Some other comments claiming that husky isn’t an all day saw are fos. After I drop the trees and lop the tops with a pruner I’ll run the saw all day, gas/oil and go from sun up til sunset with zero issues.
Me to the only reason I don't use it today is cause some lazy ads jerk couldn't work for his own saw and stole mine arrrrr!
No Shit!
I've been a full time logger for over 20 years and used both brands often. Both have problem models / years and it seems over the past few years Husky has taken Stihl a bit but both good brands. If possible find a pre 2008 / pre- emissions saw at a pawn shop and always mix 1:40 (1:50 listing is just for emissions). All the best!
That sounds like good advice..I drive semi, and those emissions have ruined the engines, i always rather a pre emmision Detroit 60 vs the newer DD15..
Same for tractors. A pre-emissions one will have fewer problems.
Agreed totaly...
My dad got a husq 340 used on local CL years ago.
The owner had also bought it used, and this thing was well-worn when we got it.
I’ve used that saw more than I can describe over the years, have cut big trees & have cut out many stumps well into the dirt with it, and the engine still feels just as strong as when we got it. I’ve replaced wear items as needed, but haven’t even had to mess with the carb or the fuel system. Still even has the original clutch.
This 40cc saw can punch way above its weight class.
My eventual upgrades will convert the engine into the equivalent of the 346xp.
I’m still using my Husqvarna 340 that is almost 23 years old. I purchased it in 2001.
I've had my Husky 450 for ten years now, and with proper cleaning, maintenance and sharpening it hasn't once been in the shop! That's cutting 20 truckloads of firewood per year, not to mention clearing and thinning around my cabin. Husqvarna all the way!
My husqvarna 440 is the same bought semi used for 200 bucks from a dealer the guy bought it ....used it once then he died....yes he dropped a tree on himself! His wife brought the saw back....best 200 bucks I ever spent! That saw has never been in the shop and has only been taken apart for routine maintenance on my tailgate and its pushing 10 years old!
Been cutting fire wood since the mid /70's, I have had many saws, right now my 2 small saws are a Stihl 025 and Husky 445. Both great saws for there intended job. I have bad hands, they can go numb do to damage from 40 yrs of auto repairs. Recently using the Stihl my hands were getting numb but had lots of clearing to do so switched over to the Husky, My hands started to go back to normal and were ok for the rest of the day. Both saws are better than my old Homie but the Husky i can run all day and my hands are usually fine. Having troubles with my old Stihl 064 and if i have to replace it it will most likely be with a Husky.
I think the kill switch on the stihl is opposite direction so you don’t accidentally kill it
i think its just a shitty design lol i have 2 husky and a stihl and iv never once accidentally turned off my husky.
Callam Littlefair .....Agreed.
nothing wrong with being accidentally safe than not being able to shut down your saw in time
Once you get comfortable with a tool you like, these things become second nature anyway. that can also lead to bias preferences between brands/models amoungst professional and general user of the brand. There’s no real problem with that unless we become completely blind to quality and longevity of the tool in order to stay devoted to our preferred brand 👍🏻
Been using chainsaws with downward kill switch like the Husqy for 40 years and never accidentally hit it. Thumb is usually wrapped around the handle unless a person has a physical defect that keeps them from bending their thumb.
I have both brands as well. I tend to drift towards my husky as well. My father inlaw who is a stihl owner got ahold of one of my huskies and has been holding it hostage for the past year. Less vibration he says.
.
I help logger friends sometimes, they use husky, like em better and also claim they're tougher.
Kurt,
Do we need to make a night time run to rescue that Husky?
I've used a lot of different brands over about 45 years of cutting wood. My observation is that the size and shape of the cutting teeth makes more of a difference in how well a saw cuts, more than anything else. When tuned good, with sharpened chain, and lubed properly, any saw will eventually cut, but having the power to pull a chain with large cutting teeth through the wood will have the greatest impact on speed of the cut. Just like having the proper tires on your car. Wearing racing slicks on your 4WD in the mud won't get you very far.
I've had some low priced saws, like Poulan, that run very well, good acceleration, good power. Jonsered was a very good, and very lightweight saw, but more expensive. I bought that for my dad, as he got older, the lighter weight was better for him.
I currently use a Husqvarna 455, and I don't know if it's because I know better how to maintain and tune saws now, or if it's simply a better saw than I've used in the past, but it starts very easy, runs hard and fast, and cuts incredibly fast. I've had it for about 12 years, and only had to replace the factory oil tubes, as they leaked from day one, now much better. I've cut 3 to 4 foot diameter trees with it without any problems. Don't forget to lube the clutch needle bearing on the Husqvarna. It can be lubed with the same plunger greaser that lubes the end of your chain bar, through the hole on the end of the shaft that sticks out through the clutch. I've never bought the expensive bar and chain oil. The cheapest 30 weight oil I can find has always worked just fine for me. I've used bar and chain oil when someone gave it to me, and I see no difference in how it lubes the saw.
I also have a Husqvarna string trimmer and backpack blower, and, after tuning the string trimmer from the poor factory settings, it runs better and has more power than any other string trimmer that I have ever used, by far. It never bogs down in heavy grass, is light and comfortable.
Probably the best thing I can say about the Husqvarna products is that they all start very easily. With the string trimmer and my backpack blower, after working all day, and you are very tired, and you find you have one patch of something you missed, it's a good feeling to pull the string and it starts right up, when you are dog tired. None of the other manufacturers come close to this easy starting, every time. Even after sitting over winter, they crank right up in the spring. Forty years ago, as a young kid, you could crank on these tools until your arm went limp (and that's a strong, teenager arm, not my current model of old, boomer arm) before they would start, so it's an amazing change from many years ago.
Use what you like, take care of it, and it will do the job it was designed to do.
I have a Stihl fs91r I’ve had for 1 year so far and it starts up first pull everytime and has amazing power! Wont bog even in the thickest grass and I don’t have any complaints besides I’m not a fan of the head design for reloading the string…I also have a Stihl bg 56 blower and it’s also great!
Nice article.
I agree.
@@gonewronggarage4565 I have a FS90R that's just over 10 years old, and still running well. I've used a brush knife on it to cut through small trees that are much larger than the knife was meant to cut through. I normally use line on it, but the first time I used that brush knife, I was laughing like a supervillain. The only reason I want to replace it is the vibration.
@@ChipLinck mine was very smooth but for some reason it developed a vibration and I think it’s the string head.
When one of my two Stihl's run like yours does it needs the carb adjusted which only happens about every 50 hrs. That being said the Husky did very well.
I agree, if your saw bogs or hesitates when you throttle up, the carb is not properly adjusted. My Stihl had no hesitation. Same thing if the saw cuts slower, the high speed screw is misadjusted.
I just purchased the Rancher 460, I hadn't put it threw its paces yet, I have 2 globe willows that need a heavy cut back
Would appreciate a video on the best chainsaw for home and self defense.
How 'bout a battery powered Tonka? Lol.
Ash Williams used a Homelite XL. 🤣
This
🤪😂😂
Kind of like the chainsaw fight scene in the horror movie "Phantasm 2".
Great video. Thanxx for not being another guy who likes to hear himself talk. Straight and to the point! I want to like the Stihl’s better. But I bought the 460 Husky. Even though it doesn’t feel or look like it, I believe it’s a better saw when in use.
I just bought a 450 Rancher with a 20" bar.
I've been using Husqvarna for years and I notice all these well engineered design choices, like the power button layout, the fuel caps, and the choke, to name a few.
Unless I needed a top handle, I would go with Husqvarna.
Отличная пила, я тоже недавно купил такую для Дома, сбалансированная и приятная в дизайне 450.
I'm have used a Husqvarna 365 for 10 years, sold and thereafter bought a new Husqvarna 365 which I am using now for 9 years. I love it.
Being 65, the saw is getting rather heavy! ( I don't know why) Would appreciate a lighter model, but it is working like a charm, every time!
I added a Husqvarna Generator G 5500P to my Husqvarna tools. Then I don't even mention my Husqvarna mincer that my parents used!
Awesome review!!! good to show how both work and how there are some things that people miss when choosing a new saw. For me I bought my Husqvarna 359 back in 2004 and have fell probably over 200 White oak, Red oak, sweetgum, and pines. bucked up I don't know how many cords of wood. other than bars, chains and plugs, that all I have had to replace on this thing. It still starts on first or second pull. I have run Stihls others owned but was never rich enough to buy a stihl.
I own Stihl products, but I was very impressed with the Husky.
Hey I just got a new MS 362 stihl it's amazing. But I did have the biggest husky made back around 1980 it had 110 CCs
The one thing I don't like about huskies is the cheap chain brake and cheap feeling throttle.
I've been running Husqvarnas for 50 years. My 380 and 44 Rancher run like the day I bought them! I recently bought a 450 and 562 XP. Best SAWS on earth!
Love my Husqvarna had it for years. Had a Echo trimmer since 1987 replaced primer bulb , gas filter twice, gas lines, 3plugs air filters and trim head. Runs like a new one, after storing 3 total pulls.
I've owned them both for many years. A 460 Rancher and a 036 PRO. When both saws are tuned correctly, I think the Husky is actually smoother and better balanced. BUT..... after these saws started to get some hours on them, the Stihl is by far more reliable and easier/cheaper to do maintenance on. Slight edge to Stihl. Just my opinion. Both are great saws.
You obviously have ran both. I had the exact same thoughts. The Husqvarna ran smooth until it lost compression after 2 years of light use. The cheap chinese parts in the 455 failed. The stihl I replaced it with has been going strong ever since.
I love German-made stuff so I have always been biased toward Stihl - but in the end I bought the Husky. Warranty and ease of service were the deal breaker. Oh, and I love the saw - very happy with the decision.
Husky is reliable. Stihl got into that bigger market with the bigger retailers like Ace. Their quality is slipping a bit.
I know you are trying to compair them on how they operate out of box and with what they come with out of the box but you should have slapped bars on them that are both the same length so we could watch them play ball in the same statium. Nice review bro.
This would be true if the losing saw (stihl) had the 24” bar and the husqvarna had the 20”. But the longer bar was on the winning saw, so putting a 24” on the stihl would have just made it lose even more to the husky. If you threw a 20” on the husky it would smoke that 311. IMO stihl makes great pro saws but their home owner models are cheap plastic junk. They sell based off their name, not quality. All husqvarna saws home owner or pro are built very well.
Husky had a smoother running sound. Thanks ! I've been looking at them both.... now to find the best deal !
It was a good test of overall performance for both saws. I have used the Husqvarna saw more than other chainsaws, and my personal favorite saw is the 372. It is great for topping, and delimbing trees. Other Husqvarna saws that were good were the 281s, and the 288s.
My fav was the 254 cut alot of pulp with it.
Agreed I have the 372xp and the 395 xp best heavy saw investments I ever made
I have run saws in the woods as a pro logger for years, hands down Husky is where it’s at, but I would get a prosas, Husky 372,or 562, consumer grade saws don’t impress me much. My all time favorite saws are McCulloch 10 series saws..
Good ol pro mac ...dad still has a couple nice ones...back when saws were built to last a lifetime
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer ,My Dad had a 1970's vintage Mac 1010 my whole childhood cutting California Oak,when He gave it to me I lived in Montana,the only thing that could stop that saw was Montana winters :D I retired that and got a Stihl 028 that is still cutting strong and I use more than my MS460. Thanks for your videos!
I think both Stihl and Husqvarna make great saws. We own both Stihl and Husky even though I've always preferred Stihl I think that both brands are fantastic and make some great saws.
A good honest comparison Husqvarna all the way . Thanks for sharing.
I love my 460 . I have a 201T Stihl for a climbing saw . I have a Husqvarna ported 390 for taking the big ones down each saw has there different uses . The 460 I use for fire wood all around good ground saw
Have owned both brands but always felt the Huskys had more power and felt more natural in the hands during use. Have been cutting firewood all my life 55years old now so no amateur. Have a 365 special and an old 61 I inherited from my GRANDFATHER who ran it in the bush with me since I was in my early 20's!! Never had any major work other than bars & chains. One of my sons uses it now and cuts 5 or 6 cords every year with it. The Stihls I've owned were good saws but the Huskys are tops!
I've got a Husky 61 that I've been using since I was a teenager (It still has the gold Husky 1689 - 1989 300 year anniversary sticker on it) with a 24" TSUMURA solid bar.. The saw's been underwater 6 or 7 times. Some years it gets heavy use.. other years it's a shelf queen. Regardless... fresh gas and oil rocks out like it's brand new.
Good to hear!
Husqvarna is far better in every way. Have been working on both brands and the husky’s is great and simple.
The Stihl is a pain when it comes to dismantle for service etc.
Had saws coming with all sorts of broken parts too.
The best one i have done trees with is the 550 Xpg with heater handle in cold winter.
@@Skyisnotalimit Stihl is better quality overall. Other than that, it's all personal preference.
I use husqarna, and have no complain, my dad has stihl. I pick husky because price (3/4 of stihl price). Both stihl and husqarna are quality product, have decent service coverage. Keep them sharp, oiled and corect fuel mix, you will not have any issues for years. Dont buy cheep chinese saw, or you will regret in long run, get frustrated and start hate working with chainsaws.
Just did a video comparing the Chinese clone of the Stihl...quite impressive I must say
Husqvarna rancher 460 is the winner. I have Husqvarna and I love the way is handled and starts.
I have an 018, MS 310, and MS 390. The 310 would out cut the 390 until I had run 10 to 15 tanks of fuel through the 390. The 310 is much older. You can hear that the rpm of the 310 is much higher. The 311 in the video sounds like it could use a carb adjustment oh the high rpm. Great videos!
Yep that is just what I heard the rpm’s seemed low compared to what I hear when my 311 Is wide open
I’m a lover of Stihl saws but they are temperamental to start and flood easy. I bit the bullet though and bought an MS261 C-M with M-Tronic and am blown away with how good it is and how easily it starts. I’ve used a bunch of saws over the years and it’s easily my favourite. One thing I will recommend when buying a Stihl is to ask the dealer to change out the stock safety chain for a full chisel. That one change alone makes a huge difference and the 261 has more than enough grunt (4 hp) to power it through anything even with the optional 20” bar rather than the stock 16” it comes with.
totally agree. I have Husrqvarna 359 and then I decided to by also Stihl MS261, Stihl has more power and is like 1,5 lighter - needless to say this is the difference you can notice. I still believe both are great saws and I'm keeping both.
This I learned many years ago. Steel makes a good saw but could keep them together they would vibrate there self apart just got tired of putting them together all the time plus the wait
I've got a little husky 142 I've had since new 20 years ago, does pretty much anything I ask of it still runs like new.
Own both. Cut a lot of wood in the last 35 years. Husky 455 never quits. About 20 yrs old. Stihl is good too.
I timed the last cut with each saw. There is roughly a 1-second difference in the final cuts. Husqvarna: 7.30 seconds. Stihl: 8:38 seconds. Your video is excellent and well-made. I just wanted to give an accurate timing of the cuts. I appreciate your video. I'm trying to decide between the two.
iT....thanks. I was thinking about doing the same thing.
@@gregblackburn4280 and he said 6 seconds longer.
@@makattak3550 in total. Not per cut
Go for the Husky!
Damn right!@@efarmer233
The Stihl seems to make smaller flakes. Maybe check the guide tooth depth and count sprocket drive teeth for a more fair comparison
Excellent comment 👍🏼
Yeah, just because they were sharpened by the same guy doesn't mean they were sharpened the same way . Also did you notice that when the Stihl took two pulls to start . That it slipped out of his hand the first pull. He obviously had his mind made up long before the video. A very biased review.
I have been very happy with my Husqvarna. I've had for around 5 years, and it is still easy to start. I will say I don't do heavy cutting. If you're like me and only need a chainsaw, occasionally buy which of the 2 you can get the better deal on. Both are great, and unless you're cutting every day, then it just isn't worth worrying about, which is better.
Any competent tuner can make either of those saws out perform the other, just by tweaking the mixture a tiny bit.
12 hours out of the box....you saw the results...this ain't no trickery brotha...just 2 saws competitively built and priced...head to head...I was surprised to be honest with you
SmoothBore ::
I work in a Husqvarna repair shop.The Stihl ships with a .325 - 63 gauge chain and the Husqvarna ships with a 3/8 - 50 gauge chain. The Husqvarna chain is thinner and more aggressive than the Stihl chain. However, the Stihl .325 chain is a very good chain but slightly slower. Both are excellent saws. I own a Stihl and a Husqvarna and like them both. I do not like the Stihl fuel and oil tank caps because they break too easily.
Cool thanks for the info Mark...makes sense why the Stihl was cutting so slow
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer .325 is 3/8 ... the gauge is the groove size of the guide in the bar.. just saying... (edited spelt groove incorrectly first time)
Loved the video until the end!! It isn’t just men who use chainsaws!! I was looking for the comparison for myself. Appreciate you sharing the differences and know which one I’d like for Mother’s Day. Thank you
Cool...you most certainly aren't the typical woman ...would ya agree
Now that's my kind of woman.
Just purchased a Husqvarna 450 Rancher, but haven’t used it yet. I hope it works good too…
460 is where it's at...I had the 450 and I think the 455 and had to upgrade
That and what's the price deference on them also
I've owned both and both are good saws. I replaced them with a MS261 with a 20 inch bar. the 261 is a beast for it's size and light enough to work with all day
Is your 261 à (cm)
10-4! For what was done in this vidja, a MS261, Huskie 550XP, or Echo 501P would all be perfect and a guy could do it literally all day and not wear out. My arms would be lead weights after just a few gas tanks working up high like that and limbing. For me there's something special about a sub 11 lb. saw with 3.6 to 4 bhp!
@@lucfournier3939 yes. it's supposed to be good in very low temp's. I cut wood last year when we had a two week cold snap avg. 0-5 degrees during the day. I had no problems. I use still pre mix fuel and their synthetic bar oil. I had the husky rancher and liked it to but it is built like a home owner saw. I think you need to go to their pro series to get a tougher saw.
@@ggarden8432 I am having engine behaviour of all kind. I have 33 hrs running time with this saw And I wanna sell it .
I have 260 N love it. Always starts right away. My experience has been that husqvarna is harder to start and overall just feels cheaper
Good stuff, (own 2 Huskavarna saws) however it was very clear, Husky all the way.
I bought a 20” bar husky about 6 months ago. It’s been great. If I’ve had one gripe: it’s a full pound plus heavier then the Stihl competitor. It doesn’t sound like much but makes a big difference.
@@Gregoman89 depends what your doing. Stihl for up the tree and brush cutting. Husky for big round buckin and tree chopping.
Wow, thanks for the detailed review. Clear victory goes to the Rancher. Time to go shopping!
Great honest comparison. Will be getting a husky . Yes I’ve owned three stihls
Im leaning towards the Husq. Im small work, Echo C-310 14" But after a few years of winter side jobs Im ready to do some bigger projects. Great video, thanks for making it. I prefer the switch to push up to cut off. A lot of times, I will pull the chord to start and my finger brushes the switch accidentally and I dont notice for 2 or 3 pulls.
I have an Echo C310.Great little saw.
I agree totally. I learned this when I worked the woods back fifty years ago when my boss went from STIHL to Husqvarna. We had a John Deere skidder and we'd say "Nothing runs like a Deere and nothing bites like a Husky"
Truth! I still miss our 448. It was a great machine.
Totally unbiased... with the husky hard hat 😉
husky protective gear was 1/3 cheaper my friend....unbiased or smart?
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer im just joking man... its all good... im stihl-hearted thru and thru but the 311 is an awful saw... I actually agree with your assessment... the husky gear tho lol
Huskavarna is my favorite. Great video
The husky out performed the sthil. I've used both saws myself and i prefer the husky over the sthil. BUT they are both GREAT chainsaws.
I feel like the chains are thicker on sthil
Husky just sounds better too
Husqvarna dealer here in Avon Park Florida, tested the spark voltage on the Stihl and Husqvarna chain saws. He said the Husk puts out far more voltage the Stihl, He theorized that that is one of the reasons the Stihl is harder to start. Any chainsaw or small engine should have a tankful or 2 of fuel run through them at a dead idle or only slightly faster. This helps to break the engine in so that the parts which have been freshly machined will rub together and smooth the roughness down a bit inside the engine. After that readjust the idle and high and low-speed carb screws with the engine warmed up to suit the altitude and temperature and fuel mix.. The older fellas also sometimes run a 24-1 fuel mix for the first couple of tanks of fuel. After the initial break-in involving some lighter duty cutting so that you don't overheat the engine, you will probably want to readjust the idle screw and the high and low-speed screws for the 40-1 fuel mix or whatever mix you prefer. If you travel up into the different altitudes in the mountains for firewood cutting you will also have to readjust the carb settings again. On some of the old saws, they were usually adjusted to burble quite a bit until in a very heavy cut at which time they would lean out and speed up and change to a higher-pitched sound. The Stihl as he mentioned was not running correctly and that is probably the problem. A saw is usually not considered fully broken in until it has probably 15 0r 20 tans of fuel run through it. If you lean out the mixture too much it will seize the engine. If you run it too rich, it will run too slow and generally not achieve full power. There are some great videos on youtube for chainsaw tuning. Enjoy yourselves.
It has actually been proven that breaking in gently leads to faster wear because the crisshatch goes away before the rings seat! Break in hard and fast
@@willbutcher9095 - do you have a link to that study? I'm curious.
Interesting you mentioned the Stihl fuel blowing out the gas cap when opening. Just experienced fuel geysering on my MS310. Recovering from some severe burns.
why would you get burned from this? Unless you're opening the fuel tank over a heat source. Not sure I understand how you'd get burned
@@StoneyRidgeFarmer I had been cutting for about an hour. Saw was running fine. After cutting through my second tank of fuel, the saw started stalling in and out. I thought it was out of fuel again. Not thinking anything about it, I turned it off and as soon as I opened the cap the fuel that was in the tank came spraying out. It took a few seconds but must have hit the saw just right and lit up along with the fuel that hit me. I've been cutting for nearly 30 years and have respect for this tool. Never heard of this problem. I've been finding a lot of information on this since then. There are no warnings in the owner's manual regarding vapor lock or fuel geysering. Look up some TH-cam videos. Stihl has recalls on four models and their flip caps. Numerous injuries out west with the fire fighters. Stihl now has a new design fuel adapter using the Sotor system. They knew they have problems
It's all very trivial. Who cares if a certain saw will cut a 10" log 3 seconds faster than the other. Both are great saws and you can't go wrong with either. I have an old Stihl MS 180 and a newer MS 362 pro series and love them both dearly. Would never consider trading for Husky. But that's just me because I'm a Stihl guy. You'll hear the same from any of the Husky guys on here. It's just a matter of what you like and what you know.
Who cares if a saw cuts faster than the other saw it seems like a ridiculous question maybe a guy who uses a saw a lot .
@@goodguy5595 Exactly. It's a mute point.
I also timed the cuts with my phone stopwatch. He's full of shit. The last cuts were Husky 6.98 secs and the Stihl was 8.5. That's about 1.5 sec's ...Not 5 or 6. This comparison is bullshit. On Stihls Website the 311 weighs 13.67 not 14.1 on the Husky site it shows 13.2 not 12.8. Not sure where he's getting his info but Stihl must have pissed him off somehow.
Lol I have the same combo ms180 and ms362 mines a m tronoic model. I love the saw.
luvs2race370 yea, and if you watch the starting procedure he put the stihl to idle NOT high idle like he said so it would start harder.
I’ve been a Husky fan for a very long time.
I own an original Pro fallers saw, highly desirable from the late 80’s, the 266SE. It’s still in excellent shape and it’s been used commercially.
Husky always has built some incredible saws.
I want to get a newer rancher.
I just bought my first Stihl Small limbing saw used and it’s decent, but I’ll be buying huskys from here on out. The newer ranchers are amazing
Chris I still use a 61SE and a 66xp
Buy a Pro series Stihl off craigslist and don't look back. I like Huskies for lighter stuff, but when there is a downed walnut tree or oak or willow, my ms 461 is my best friend.
scbane yes huskies have a higher rev better for falling because they are lighter to put it on your back but stihl is better for what you said
Buy a pro series and throw it in the trash sthil sucks any model
I have an older Husqvarna 372xp with a 24 and 28 inch bar. I wouldn't trade it for any other saw. It's reliable and cuts big trees fast. The biggest that I have cut was a maple tree that was 58 inches across.
Stihl vs husky
Chevy vs Ford
JD vs NH or Kubota or...
Mayo vs miracle whip
Boxers vs briefs
All good. It’s the user that is the real variable
Have a good day guys. Stay safe
Whoa, mayo everytime!
@@freetolook3727 ok, Chipotle Mayo vs Smokey Bacon Mayo
@@davidoakley3256 Oh, definitely Smokey Bacon Mayo
No No No No Miracle Whip!
Thanks man! I have ran a Stihl for years and thought it was great. Then I went out with a buddy who had a Husqvarna. His saw outdid my saw in every way. Looks like I'm gonna buy a Husqvarna. Great review!! Thanks!!
Both qualitie name brands
Great video, no I'm not a professional but do get to cut a lot of firewood for our place in N. Ga. I have both a Stihl my wife bought me one year and a Husky... I use both and both are good saws but I tend to use the Husky as my main saw and Stigh as a backup. I have just found the Husky easier to work with for my personal preference and starts up a lot easier than the Stihl .. the Stihl floods real easy if you are not careful with the choke .... my 2 cents
Me too
I have both, but use the husky, more problem with flooding
I have a stihl 66 for big logs and ripping lumber with 32 inch bar. My firewood saws are a smaller stihl and a husquvarna.
Wife got me the 562xp for Christmas best woman ever!!!
If the saw is reliable and gets the job done without any trouble, who cares about the brand. Husqvarna or Stihl? Why not both? I like both companies and they both have really nice models to offer. Here in Québec though when winter arrives I think the Huskies start and run better so they're my favorites. My 572 is one hell of a saw!
My Stihl suffered a drop in starting ease/performance during the winter. Then I read the User's Manual. There is an easy adjustment for cold weather.
@@gatoryak7332 exactly 👍🏼
They’re both the best two brands. How about that. It’s just preference.
My 1st good saw was a Sthil 026 - and I loved that saw! - it did all I needed for 17 yrs - than when it finally died I bought a husky 455 rancher ,because i didn't want to spend the extra 100. to get a comparable sthil ,i have wavered on whether that was a good choice or not.
the Husky seems a bit more powerful (and louder) but the sthil lasted for so many yrs . & after a few yrs the husky is having carb problems - which even though i run clear( good gas ) in it - it seems to be needing a new carb now , (welcome to the new world of crappy gas)
I had a 455...not nearly the saw that the 460 is....455 was a pig
Since everyone is saying what saws they have, I have a 455 rancher and 575 xp and they’re great
Stihl ms271 farm boss. I love it.
i had two 575 xps but found that i like my 372 xp better . less goes wrong with it than the 575s .. my saw shop guy hated the 575s and says the 372s are much superior. Try one.
You’re not biased at all with Husky helmet are you.
It's just a helmet..
My safety equipment are both Husqvarna and Stihl, best price on highest series is the winner.
Besides, even if one were Stihl bias one would have to admit that the Husqvarna won this test.
I have both of these, I like both of them, but I will tell you the Stihl after 10 years still starts in 5 pulls or less and runs great. The Husqvarna starts in 5 pulls or more and I have to run it with a smaller bar because it has lost a lot of power.
Have a 30 year old Husky 351. Still starts right up , only issue I've had was a mouse ate the coil wire so had to replace the coil about two years ago. Also have a Stihl 181. No issues , takes longer to start , has the ez start which I don't really like . The only issue I've had with this saw is I'm a big guy 6'6" , big hands . When I'm cutting I've had the saw shut off several times because my hand hit the shutoff switch , never had a issue like that with the Husky
Great video. I have been using an ECHO recently with great results. Always had Husky until now. I am looking for a saw inch bar capability and the 460 Rancher is st the top of my list. The only question I have is does the 24 inch bar in your comparison have any impact on cut speed? More chain in the same RPMs.
I have 3 echo saws on my shelf Can't get parts for any just looking at them makes me sick
I had a Husqvqrna 50 a few years ago. That thing was a great saw. I sold it and bought a Stihl 038 magII. That was a great saw also. Both cut lots of wood. I think both of my saws were bigger than those "ranch size" saws. Now that I am older, the professional saws I had are a little to heavy for me.
Thanks for the great comment Dave....check out the little MS141 ...pretty light STIHL saw...I have one...love it for a "running and gunning" saw
I like both lol. I will say something about the way a Stihl sounds, they just sound right.
Yeah, my old Stihl Pro sounds like it's effortlessly slicing through any log... and it starts and runs better than his...
Don't buy a HF 'Portland' electric... mine fell apart 5 times during it's first cut through a 10" softwood limb... chain/bar dangerously comes loose and swings up... cuts into the saw... only one stud holds it on... nut won't stay tight...
(Not to be confused with a Poulan)
Ive done a bit of wood chopping.. and i started with a stihl 251got a ms 391now.. mates used huskys but they kept blowing up.. is that just a faulty saw or are they known for blowing up?
I have both saws, similar size with similar bar lengths. The husqvarna always outperformed the stihl whether limbing, bucking, or falling trees.
I agree but stihl makes a better climbing saw
Had one stihl, 460, the quick caps pop loose working in the brush, heavy trimming and climbing, constant vapor lock issues, no dealer could figure it out.. never again... never had husky issues, also have a few newer echo's. Exact copy of a husky at half the price.
That's my experience anyways...
Oh and echo's a 5yr warranty. Lol
interesting brotha...very interesting
Thank you for the tip! We had an Echo 20 years ago and it worked great.
Things to consider, scooter: you used a longer bar husky, which will have the chain heating up slower and its dulling diminished by the minimised thermal expansion of the chain and cutting edge is not expanded while cutting, as opposed to the hotter chain on the Stihl will have a hotter and consequently larger and duller cutting edge. Plus, you used different sawing motions with the two saws, rocking the husky saw, but cutting without doing the same to the stihl. you seem like a nice guy and your video quality was good, but its plain to see you had the cards unevenly stacked and a dampened bias for the husky. both are great tools but they were unequally yoked
Jon West Sr i noticed the same Not same -rocking of the Husky
He used the max bar length on both who’s fault is it that the stihl can’t handle a bigger bar
If you were to put the same length bar on the Stihl it should slow it down even more.
Rocking the Husky could be the fact that it's 2 lbs lighter but he should use the same identical technique when comparing saws.
For a really fare comparison , set up both saw with a tachometer to the factory specs.
The Stihl has a shorter bar and is claiming to have more horsepower. It's 2lbs heavier so it should easily take the trophy.
Not certain but It looked to me like the Husky had more chain speed.
Had a 460 for several years until I burnt it out, nice saw. I replaced with a 550 Mark 2, wow power difference! Nice upgrade choice, Husqvarna rules!
Having 1/6 more cutting teeth than the Stihl (24" chain versus 20" chain) of course the Husqvarna cuts faster. You should have used a 24" bar&chain Stihl to make it perfectly even. What do you think of the Baumr 24" chainsaw with a 75cc motor?
Think of it this way stihl runs over 11,000 rpms on the run . Husqvarna runs 9,000 rpms so given that you say bar size is the difference. I see the difference in rpms being the factor moreover .
If they had used a24 inchbar on the Stihl that would made it slower
The Stihl saws are made like that so your saw doesn’t turn off during cutting if you have an emergency your chain break is your best option it’s right there
I prefer the husky switch
or as i said above in an emergency choke will stop the motor but the chain break on the Stihl can be easily popped forward with my left hand on Huskies i have to move my hands to engage the chain brake
Husqvarna is the way to go, dependable work horses, and the 460 is the one to have all around, toss a skip tooth chain on it and reduce your cutting time considerably.
Texas Treehouse Tree Service & Stump Grinding has been using Echo for over 25 yr. we are a very fast pace tree removal service in Dallas,Tx AND dont have time to be working on saws every day.!! Big trees we do in a few hours. take a craw of man all day to do!!. a good saw save time and money.!!
that's great...now go advertise your business on Google brotha lol
I have not had good luck with Stihl. In my opinion, the Husky is far superior. I have one and love it.
I love my husky for sure...both are great saws...but we saw the results...I think I need to upgrade to the MS391
I personally own McCullough saws but they're dinosaurs that are really heavy, really loud, and scream through the fuel. When it comes to the two tested, the Husky is at least half the price of the Sthil, where I live anyway. Ran em both professionally for a year, up and down mountain sides in all weather conditions. If the price were the same, I would pick the Husky based solely on my experience with durability between the two. That fuel cap on the Sthil is terrible, they break way to easily, that Sthil ain't runnin if it don't have fuel in it.
I like both brands I have owned both, but I do favor the Husqvarna saws a little bit more for the ease of starting them you did a good review of both these fine saws anyone would be happy with either one of these
Even if Husky is better, what i have from it when first service is 50km away while Stihl i can walk to service. I think both are awesome saws just depends of service
For what it's worth, I have a Stihl MS250 and have had to replace the oil filler cap and the fuel filler cap as they have both failed and leaked. I'm not a fan of that cap system. I'm carrying an extra one of each in my kit.
interesting ...thanks for the input for sure!
My stihl 441(non m-tronic) starts as easy as that husky. One pull with the choke from cold and it barks one pull after that and it runs. My m-tronic 362's are fairly easy to start also. Stihl does use the primer bubble on the 500i though. The primer button bypasses impulse so you are manually pushing fule to the carb, you don't have to pull it over a few times to pump fule you already did by pushing the primer bulb. Thanks for the video!!