Rakhighari DNA study - हड़प्पा के लोग कौन थे आर्य या द्रविड़ ? - Debate on Aryan Invasion Theory (2)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 13 มิ.ย. 2021
- In this video have discussed the DNA study of a female skeleton found in Rakhighari site of Indus valley civilization. in this video we also continue our debate associated with the Aryan invasion theory which is also a important aspect of this DNA analysis.
To watch previous video on Debate on Aryan invasion theory click on the link below :
• A brief Debate on the ...
World History playlist :
• World History Series -...
This is very informative video for all of those who want to know our history & those who are Preparing for various competition exams Like #UPSC , #SSC , #Railways , #State_PSCs & many more.
Follow us on Telegram to download pdf of the lesson and ask your Queries :-
Telegram - t.me/successplusacademy
Follow us on Facebook :-
m. Success-Plus-A...
I appreciate your categorical assertion ,that while explaining ,the theory of A.I.T.,
You are totally impartial.
he is not impartial, he just does not know
क्या इसका reverse संभव नहीं है कि भारत के मूलनिवासियों का ही एक धड़ा steppes इसकी तरफ migrate हो गया क्योंकि उस समय के हिसाब से भी भारतीय प्राकृतिक climate ही human population sustain करने के लिए ज्यादा मुफीद था इसीलिए सभ्यता का विकास पहले यहां हुआ होगा और यहां से लोग अन्य स्थानों को गए होंगे। जबकि steppes आज भी रहने लायक उतना अच्छा स्थान नहीं है . Climatic conditions harsh हैं . संस्कृत अगर indo-european लैंग्वेज थी और स्टेपीज से पनपी तो वहां आज भी संस्कृत बोली जानी चाहिए । कम से कम वहां लिपि का तो कोई प्रमाण मिलना चाहिए
You are absolutely right
Bilkul sahi kaha aapne ye to angrejo ka propoganda hai esliye Britannia ne Jurmanny ke scoler max Muller ko bhartiyon ke khilaf. utara tha sabse pahle Aryan invesion ka Galat kissa usi ne failaya tha rigved me Arya ka matalab kushal byakti hota hai na ki ayra usi tarah daravid ka matalab threevid hai matalab wo ilaka jo pani se teen taraf se ghira ho yani jo South Indian hai ye sari chhijen ko galat bataya hai ...jay hind jay bharat
Congratulations sir on 30k subscribers. The kind of hard work you are putting in, soon 1 million will also be completed.
Please keep enlightening us 🙏🙏
Thank you so much for your kind words .😊
There are lots of similarities between Iranian Avesta (Parsi book) and vedas..
Zoroastrianism/Parsi *Asəm Vohu* prayer in
*Avestan language* : _asəm vohu vahištəm asti. Ušta asti ušta ahmai hyat ašāi vahištai ašəm_ ->
*Vedic Sanskrit language* : _ṛtam vasu vasiṣṭham asti. Uṣṭa asti uṣṭa asmai syat rtai vasiṣṭhai ṛtam_
*Translation* : Truth/Righteousness is the best good and it is the happiness. Happiness is to him who is righteous for the sake of truth/righteousness.
सत्य सबसे अच्छा है और यही खुशी है। सुख उसी को मिलता है जो सत्य के निमित्त धर्मी है।
What if migration is from India to Iran
@@vishaltiwari6466 please provide historical and archeological evidences which supports your view.
Sir there is no concrete evidence of so called Aryan invasion and migration
There is no evidence to Aryan invasion theory either
Wo jo bhi the hamare purwaj the hamare hi the.wo Arya ho ya Dravid bas hamare the.hame unka samman karna chahiye.Jai Hind.
welcome back on such a interesting debate. Thanks sir
Bht sahi baat, history sirf knowledge k liye honi chahiye usse hamare present pe koi asar nahi padna chahiye
*As a Biomedical Engineer I can guarantee DNA doesn't prove language the human being is carrying.If anyone is trying to draw conclusion that certain DNA carried certain language then he/she is studying in some university which has no relation with science.DNA doesnt have any marker of language family*
*We can call it as steppe movement or steppe migration but cannot call it Aryan Migration.We know (from Rig vedas) there were many tribes in vedic period like Anu , pakhtas, bhalanas, who lived at the north eastern fringes of Afghanistan , kazhakh plane who had hostile relations with puru tribes (Bharata clan of Haryanas and western UP) ,In later vedic age we see migration of shakas,parthavas migrating to India from central asia.The steppe gene in Indian subcontinent is mostly due to the contribution of shakas,parthavas, yavans, gurjara, kushanas,Hunas,turks and some other tribes whose names are not documented by oral history*
What will we call them while debating then, science had told irula tribe is the oldest peoples in this soil …
@@cheltooktribefreethinker1028 Till you get any concrete prove you can't call them by giving names that you want to listen. Science is there not to make everyone happy. According to protocol just name the genes and can only call steppe migration simple. I have already mentioned names of tribes those who have migrated to India and whose names are documented in literary history....Something which is not documented you cant speculate and simply thrust it on others.
So true.. And aryan is a linguistics group.. aryan koi jati nhi hai.. or Sanskrit me v aryan means noble person..ye point bhttt jbrdst hai steppe migration bol v skte hai pr aryan migration nhi.. aur shakas, hunas , pahlav-pratihars, achamenid rulers ye sab v toh migration huwa hai.. r1a1 gene iska v parinam ho skta hai..bhtt shi kaha aapne
@@pujadas4566 If you are a bengali , tumi kore bolchi "arya" kothar ortho " noble" eta thiki bolecho. Buddhist scripture eo Buddha has mentioned about "Ariya Ashtamarga" [Eight noble truth] ,South India te Ayya/Iyer also stands for noble.Arya was just an adjective used by vedic Bharata puru groups.Just like English ,sanskrit became wheel of communication through out Indian Subcontinent and influenced around 80% languages in India.
For details you can listen to srikant talageri , DR. Neeraj Rai on Charvaka podcast channel and mrugendra vinod on sangam talks channel
R1A1 gene ka origin actually India me hua tha...Dr Neeraj Rai me prove kardia uska new paper me
@@adwaitvedant3297 Dhonnobad 😊 .. apka ye point v mujhe bht accha laga south India me Ayya/ Iyer ka jo similarities bataya apne.. ye mujhe kuch naya study karne ka feild mila, interesting hai.. aur kheeladi site jo south me invent huwa wo ivc se similar aur ivc se purana hai.. toh aysa nhi k ivc people ko kisine vagaya.. ivc se purana aur ivc se similar site already south me hai.. aur puru tribe, bharata clan, suda jo the jo battle of 10 kings jita toh ye v toh ho skta hai k sabhi tribe bharat ka hi native tha jo ki das raja yudh k baad jo hara wo Sindhu elaka chorke aaspas chale gye.. ariyan ho ya Dravidian, sabhi native toh India ki hi hai..
Fantastic. I have also watched your earlier video. Great 👍
Very informative topic and sir makes it so easy. Thanks sir 👍🥰🥰🥰
सच्चाई तो यह है कि अमेरिका और आस्ट्रेलिया में भी वहाँ के मूल निवासी आज अल्पसंख्यक हैं। अच्छी बात ये है कि भारत में आज भी द्रविड़ों की संख्या बहुत अधिक है!
Tu bhi Australian hai jaa waha reh🤣🤣🤣
@@mehulkapoor1412 हे आर्यपुत्र, द्रविड़ों के लिए अपमानजनक भाषा का प्रयोग न कर।
@@realvisionforever हे अफ़्रीकन मैं भारत का मूलनिवासी आर्य आपसे माफ़ी मांगता हु की आप अफ्रीकी को ऑस्ट्रेलिया जाने कह दिया कृपया आप अपने देश अफ्रिका चले जाए |
@@mehulkapoor1412arey Bhai agar Aryan invasion theory sahi bhi hai toh yeh mulk mein inhe bhi nahin rahna chaiye asli natices centinnels hain Jo andman nicobar mein rehte Hain. Unka gene proper african. Yeh Desh dravidians ka bhi nahin hai phir
Very nicely explained. Well researched and made easy. Thanks 🙏
Dr Ambedkar after his in-depth Study of Vedic Scripturas , completely discarded Aryan Invasion Theory , In his book " Who were the Shudra". He even went on saying people of all CASTES are Racially similar which is what Genetic proves also.
Dr Ambedkar after his in-depth Study of Vedic Scripturas , completely discarded Aryan Invasion Theory , In his book " Who were the Shudra". He even went on saying people of all CASTES are Racially similar which is what Genetic proves also.
I Have Heard Some Where He Can't Read Sanskrit
@@greatkaafir9316
1. Yes our Top Historian like Romila Thapar can not read Sanskrit but she is TOP historian for Indian Vedic history ... SHOCKED??
2. Our Middle age historian like Irfan Habib can not read Arabic or Persian ... SHOCKED???
3. Dr Ambedkar read Vedic Scriptures in English.
@@DilipSadh these all historian are bc 😁😄😆😆 all historian make them chutiya
Aryan Re-entry Theory:
If you find european genome Y-chromosome DNA haplogroup R1a1 or highest phenotype resemblance in some of indians, it not mean it happened because of aryan invasion it simply interbreeding, prostitution, child adoption or child abduction.
The Aryans are the native inhabitants of indian plain and they are not came from other plain. The Aryan are the first migrant gypsies to europe from north india before the present day Roma gypsy but aryan gypsies are usuccessful and they returned to homeland India after few hundred years because during the migration they been looted, raped, slaved and murdered. It's become difficult for aryan gypsy to protect their minority community without permanent settlement so they decide to return India. But before they re-entered india their genetic, language and culture changed. Finally they settle in gangetic Plain and called themself as Brahmins and they speak mixed language called Sanskrit. Brahmins are still living as nomads as they practice religion professionally.
@@satheeshbabu7724 ye acha hai isme dono side waale khush 😂😂
Skeleton of a female is examined.You can examine a male skeleton also.See if R1A1 is also missing in male skeleton.
Perfectly explained please make videos on more sites in haryana and nearby
Bro people will fight for their political agendas but you are doing a fantastic job as a teacher. Don't worry about these stupids , you are not here to make everyone happy . 👍👍
Exactly
Sir you are doing great
Thank you ❤️
You are doing fantastic job sir
What a great explanation sir
So basically, the studies still don't give any certain clarity, and the balance hangs on *deciphering the IVC script*, right?
Till the time we decipher the IVC script, and ascertain whether it's more closely related to Sanskrit, or to other non-Sanskrit Indo-European languages, or is a completely different language, we can't say which culture is the most ancient. Am i right?
Sir any report/material about Kandar dweep of Hind Mahasagar or south India or south historical or religious old text for indian/south Indian civilizations exist bank of Narmada,Godawari or Krishna rivers ?
Very informative.👍🏼👍🏼👍🏼
बहुत बढ़िया समझाते हैं सर जी
1 -1 बात 1-1 शब्द इंटरेस्टिंग था
You are really a great narrator 👍👍🙏
Sir, I believe in Aryan invasion or migration theory . Keezhadi civilization in Tamil Nadu also proves this. Can you make one video on Keezhadi of Tamil Nadu....?
Soon
Dr Ambedkar after his in-depth Study of Vedic Scripturas , completely discarded Aryan Invasion Theory , In his book " Who were the Shudra". He even went on saying people of all CASTES are Racially similar which is what Genetic proves also.
डाक्टर अम्बेडकर के वचन
1) अम्बेडकर कहते हैं शूद्र राजाओ और ब्राह्मणों में हमेशा झगड़ा रहा जिस करना ब्राह्मणों पर अत्याचार हुआ, शूद्र राजाओ के अत्याचार के करना ब्राह्मण उनसे घृणा करने लगे उनका उपनयन संस्कार बंद कर दिया जिस करना शुद्रो का पतन होता चला गया
( डाक्टर अम्बेडकर राइटिंग अण्ड स्पीचेज खण्ड 13, पृष्ठ 50 )
2) आर्यो का मूल स्थान ( भारत के बाहर ) वैदिक साहित्य से मेल नहीं खाता | वेदों में गंगा, यमुना, सरस्वती के प्रति आत्मीय भाव हैं कोई विदेशी ईस तरह भारत की नदियों के प्रति आत्मीय भाव नहीं दिखा सकता
( डॉ अम्बेडकर राइटिंग अण्ड स्पीचेस, खण्ड 7, पृष्ठ 70 )
3) हिन्दू अपनी मानवतावादी भगवानवो के लिए प्रसिद्ध हैं और प्राणी, जीवन के प्रति उनकी आस्था अद्भुत हैं, वो विषैले साँपो को भी नहीं मारते, हिन्दू दर्शन सर्वव्यापी आत्मा का सिद्धांत सिखाता हैं और श्रीं गीता उपदेश देती हैं की ब्राह्मण चांडाल में भेद ना करो
प्रश्न उठता हैं की जिन हिन्दुओं में उतना कुछ अच्छा हैं दर्शन इतने अच्छे हैं वो ऐसा निर्दयी व्यवहार क्यों करते हैं ( Material edition B. G Kunte Vol 1 page 14 - 15 )
4) डाक्टर अम्बेडकर का मत था की प्रत्येक हिन्दू वैदिक रीती से यज्ञयोपवित धारण करने का अधिकार रखता हैं, इसके लिए अम्बेडकर जी ने बम्बई में " समाज समता संघ " की स्थापना की जिसका मुख्य कार्य अछूते के नागरिक अधिकारों के लिए संघर्ष करना था इस संघ बड़ा सक्रिय था
इसी समाज के तत्वाधान में 500 महारों को जनेऊ धारण करवाया, यस सभा बम्बई में मार्च 1928 में संपन्न हुई डॉ अम्बेडकर की मौवजूदगी में
( डॉ बी आर अम्बेडकर - व्याक्तित्व एवं कृतित्व पृष्ठ 116 - 117 )
5) तरुणो की धर्मविरोधी प्रवृति देखकर मुझे दुख होता हैं कुछ लोग कहते हैं की " धर्म अफीम की गोली हैं " परन्तु यस सही नहीं हैं मेरे अंदर जो भी गुड़ हैं अथवा मेरी शिक्छा के कारण मैं जो समाज हित के कार्य मैंने किये हैं वो मुझमे विद्यमान सनातन धार्मिक भावना के कारण ही मुझे धर्म चाहिए ना की धर्म के नाम पर चलने वाला पाखंड चाहिए
( हमारे डाक्टर अम्बेडकर जी, पृष्ठ 9 )
जय श्रीं राम
🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
@@greatkaafir9316 plz do not befool us with distorted & fake stuff.
मुसलामानों ने invasion किया या migration.
Invasion
Invasion 😂😂 , their is not even a question on This.
Jaise aryo be Invision kiya waise hi
@@fekumodiya2691 sale sinauli kya kahta hai?
Decoding shuru h sir ji
Last time news me aaya tha
Why stepies aryan people choose to stay in indian subcontinent traveling so long distance rather than other nearby places ?
Sir., trible language ka research karo, indus script samaj me aa jayga.
Thats a good idea actually
In 2016 archaeologist find that gond trible have similar writings as Indus valley you can search on internet
And gond muriya tribes traditional dress is very similar to the dress that the man where in Indus valley civilization seals 😇
Indus Valley People Weren't Tribalistic! They Were City Folks!
You're Saying That People Who Built Such A Vast Civilisation Moved To Forests & Started Living As Hunter- Gathering Tribals?🙄 Illogical!
Apart From That, Most Of Tribals In India Are Austo Asiatic! They Came Around 4000 BC From South East Asia Not From West!(Also, Indus Valley Is Older Than 4000 BC) Only Bhils & Gonds Are The Ones Who Came From West! But That Was Too Long Ago Around 20,000 Yrs Ago!
@@DeependraSingh11 bro see 😇 thiswww.thehindu.com/news/national/telangana/gonds-may-have-migrated-from-indus-valley/article6698419.ece
@@DeependraSingh11 see the similarities between gonds and Indus valley civilization 😇www.heritageonline.in/shiva-as-bada-dev-gond-symbolisms-on-indus-seals-part-1/
❤ very usefull information sir ji.Thank you ❤
आप सचमुच सच्चे आर्कोलॉजिकल बाते कर रहे हैं
डाउट यह है सर कि... किसी प्रथम पूजनीय भगवान गणेश या किसी ब्रम्हा, विष्णु, शंकर जी की मूर्ति खुदाई में अब तक मिली है क्या? अगर नहीं तो कौन से भगवान की मिली है? और उससे क्या प्रूफ हो सकता है?
Not found any of these statues.
हड़प्पा सभ्यता में शिवलिंग मिला था संग्रहालय में रखा है पता कर लो और भारत में तो कहीं ना कहीं कुछ ना कुछ मूर्ति मिलती रहती है हाल ही में तमिलनाडु में विष्णु की प्रतिमा मिली
In the script of indus valley i have found some symbals which r still in use in hindu culture like swastika in perticular so what if that language is neither sanskritik nor tamilianik but a language which have both and honestly i think aryans came to india but not from steppes but from tibit and settled in ganges cause now we r finding a civilization which is as old as indus along ganges and samw is true for brahmaputra and Kaveri what if india is not a land of 1 but more than 3 civilization existing together and later became 1, each having its own nature i think govt. Should sponcer this kind of searches, i am saying this cause i read about a civilization in south maybe on the banks of kaveri where they have found a settlement which is atleast 3000+ yrs old and maybe its age could go aw back as 6000+years sirauli is almost there too and i heard there was a civilization in assam along brahmaputra which is also claimed to be atleast 3000+yeara old and according to me maybe it could be older cause that river got everything to make or form a developed agrigariam civilization. Just a question.
The Saraswati alßo dried up around 1900bc. The inhabitation seen on maps refered to as Saraswati settlements should actually be the pre- Harappan sites.
Great information
Conclusion is steppes r out sider who brought sanskrit with them.
अच्छी जानकारी
It is not only site in hisar jind and fatebad kaithal ..lot of villages have mound at remains parts of lost rivers ...which called daab mean a half moon shape natural tank..and also found many places deffective pottery remains.....
Very informative video....❤👍🏻
Great explanation
मोहन जोदड़ो हड़प्पा सभ्यता में कोई भी देवी, देवता का मूर्ति और मंदिर नहीं मिला । जबकि आर्य , वैदिक संस्कृति में मंदिर और मूर्ति का बहुत महत्व है ।यह दविड़ सभ्यता ही है उदाहरण-जैसे गोंड (आदिवासी बस्तर ) सिर में मौर ,दो सिंगों वाला पहनते हैं। वही हड़प्पा सभ्यता में मिले सिक्के में दिखाई देता है। लाश को दफनाना , प्रकृति की पूजा , मातृसत्तात्मक समाज , नारी पुरुष में बराबरी का दर्जा आदि।
vedic me mandir or murti ka mhetav nahi hai , vo nirakar brhama jal vayu per hi jor deta hai, apni jaankari durrust kijie vedo ko lekar , वर्तमान मे प्रचलित हिंदू धर्म व वेद अलग है। स्वामी दयानंद सरस्वती को पढीए , उन्होंने कहा था वेदो की ओर चलो. और धार्मिक कर्मकांडो को छोड़ो, वो आर्य समाज के संस्थापक थे। जब अंग्रेजो का राज था भारत में
Bhai shivling mila hai achhese pdh lo...
Murtiya aur shivling dono mile hai
True
Ye naya scientists paida ho gaya..... Saala zutth he bol raha hai........ Prabhaker ji u r true
Sanskrit is still used in India. It is not used in places from where it is claimed to have come. Any language,culture in the place of its origin remains forever but not in places where it was borrowed. This clearly proves that Sanskrit was the native language and not that of migrants
But we only have our old ancient literature written in Sanskrit otherwise no one here in this Indian subcontinent also use to speak Sanskrit in their daily routine life.
संस्कृत भाषा, प्राकृत भाषा पर संस्कार करकर बनाई हुई है!
Sanskrit is not Indian native language.
@@rdsc.455 Are baba even during the british times there were sanskrit newspapers. Its just that the the british stooges(post colonial govt barring janta dal and bjp) didn't promote sanskrit.
@@stella-theretriever2208 sanskrit is an Indian native language but not tamil
👌🙏We Nayakas of karnataka, andra, odissa, kerala, tamila nadu, part of maharastra and srilanka are still believes that we are Aryas and we have come here thousands of years back. We were called as Paika Nayakas -Hale Paikas, at present we are Arya Namadharis, Arya Idigas..... Like that..... Hale Paikas means ancient brave soldiers. My father always says that we brought peddy from north to south. That peddy is called kariarya means black aryan peddy.... Still this is called different names which start from black..........,
As per my beliefs and knowledge our ancientors were from the bank of sindhu and ofyamuna ganga. We had come here for rule and cultivate with our cattle. Agriculture and animal husbandary is our main occupation. Our ancientors rulled many kingdoms and served as brave soldiers.The kadambas, pallavas, pandyas, gangas, chalukyas, hoysalas, vijaya nagara nayakas made the land with wealth and prosperous.
Hale (olden or ancient )Paika, is the ward came from the word "Pouka".... Means gentleman, nobleman.... Arya means gentleman, nobleman
As per your debate regarding DNA R1H1 genes people are in south India also. Many thanks to you. 👌👌🙏🙏.
Ok
One who has gone through Indian scriptures knows it well that it is original, indigenous and unparalleled in respect of other parts of the world.
बहुत अच्छा
Problem lies in the political and economical power....imbalance in these things among North and South of India,,,that makes all the difference
Sir l have mailed you some informations relating this, hoping that you may also check that
Dr David Reich ( Head of Genetic at Harvard university ) was leading Rakhigarhi ( Harrapan site ) genetic study and he said all South Asians ( Indians, Pakistanis, BD etc.) are descendent form Indus Valley people.
This all divide of North / South , India / Pakistan is not right.
Yes at base everyone has harrapan dna but upper castes have higher r1a1 which is not found in rakhigharhi dna
@@nvspraneeth901
1. Jat's also have high R1A1 and they are OBC (backward caste)
2. This Aryan Propaganda serve ONLY 2 purposes now
a) Certain corrupt & dynastic political parties uses it for VOTE Bank Politics.
b ) Foreign religions uses it as tool to do Conversion of vulnerable Hindus.
@@nvspraneeth901 that Only Proves That North Indians intermixed With Scythians, Shakas, Greeks, Hunas & Persians! Who Came Much Later! While South Indians Mixed With Tribals!
Origin Is Same! We All Were Harappans! We Just Intermixed With Different People Due To Geographic Isolation!
Example! Turks In turkey have Mixed With Greeks So they Have Good European looks! While Turks In Central Asia Mixed With Mongols! That Gives Them Mongoloid looks! But Originaallly Both Are Same Turks! Its just geographic Rift!
@@nvspraneeth901 Skelton was found of female and they are not associated with paternal R haplogroup.
Pakistan Mohana 70% r1a
Khatris 66%
Ahirs 63
Sahratia tribe 50%
WB Bengal 72
Lohana 60+
Bhanushali 60+
Only WB Brahmins have high r1a
@@nvspraneeth901 ok Once I believe Brahmins are Foreigners So Who Teach Other People?
Without Education How Harapa Can Be So Advance WITHOUT EDUCATION?
Others Caste also Have R1a1..
So AIT/AMT is False..
i don't know why people gets emotional.In 3 to 5 years you can get citizenship of any country and we are talking here from 3 to 4 thousand years. of course we are all Indians.
Sir haryana ke pataudi side bhi bhot poorani chije mili hai jo ab sarkar ke pass hai....ab uski koi survey hui hai ye mujhe nahi pta.....ek mere hee gaav me ek badi tasvir mili jisme bhot jyada bhagwano kee tasvir hai...lekin vo log usse dene se mna kare hai😊
Good one
खुप छान
Thnx
Dr. S. L. Bhardwaj or bharat or bhar vansi.
Anchor, please study ancient literature of history, you will know about of bharata or bhar tribe.
Dr Ambedkar after his in-depth Study of Vedic Scripturas , completely discarded Aryan Invasion Theory , In his book " Who were the Shudra". He even went on saying people of all CASTES are Racially similar which is what Genetic proves also.
Great
Please may kindly be inform about lashy tribe I from karachi
Bhai sahab 31 March 2018 ko yahi report 92 scientists ne published ki thi us me aaane ka time bhi diya hai ...jara obhi bataye....
कौन सी रिपोर्ट भाई
Nice excellent
2 questions still unanswered-
1) why burial sites at Indus Valley ?
2) why scripts on the seals were right to left
Before any conclusion can be drawn
In my view if we don't consider the timming based on carbon dating meathod our mythological theory is absolutely correct which says there was a large flood in ancient time called as Jal pralay and a large area of this subcontinent was merged in water. This flood destroyed the present civilisation.I think this was Indus valley civilization. And when the flood dried the new civilization which devloped along the time was Aryan civilization migrated slowly from anywhere in subcontinent in different groups. It may be possible that some areas were unaffected by flood and there were Haddapan peoples reside. And over the time we see many fights between two civilization in our mythological stories. So in this way the both theories beacome true.
Sir , mera manana hai ki harapaa key log drabir they , aur aaryans Himalayas key aas pass key area sey aaye honge. .
Kya New DNA match kra skte h Aryan ka aur angrejo ka kyu ki india me kuch log aise h jinka rawaiyyaa angrejo se milta hai ?
हड़प्पा और मोहनजोदड़ो में रहने वाले लोग Munda, संताल,और गोण्ड।थे( कयोंकि ये नाम उनकी भाषा से मिलती जुलती है)।
ऐसा कुछ नहीं है
Astro-asiatic nahi the Indus valley mei.
Bahooooot sunder hai
Excellent sirji🥰🥰🥰🥰🥰
There is no debate. Not only does it destroy AI Theory. The dna also proves that farming indigenous or transferred through idea and not invasions or migration.
@@ex009adityarajsingh2 proved no dna from Iran. Admixture was later.
@@colorguppies you really didn't read the David Reich report the indigenous part was from mitochondrial dna hich meant that the female dna which passes as it is says it indigenous but the y chromosome of ancestral north and ancestral south dna etc are different in ancestral south the mix of South Asian hunter hunter gatherers and Iranian steppe both was there where as in ancestral north Iranian steppe south asian hunter gatherer plus a new one from Eurasia European country also generally known as Aryan was found this accumalation was largely found in Brahmins in up with sirname Tiwari and other well either the iranian steppe got out and mated with the others because there are proofs or else eurasians came only some part and mixed here
@@ex009adityarajsingh2 maybe you need to read!! 😂😂😂😂. 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂.
@@ex009adityarajsingh2 But Steppe pastoralist DNA is absent in the ancient Indus Valley individual, suggesting similarities between these nomadic herders and modern populations arose from migrations after the IVC’s decline. 😂😂😂😂😂
Again, the admixture came later!! That is the point.
इजिप्ट, चीनी, फोनेशियाई, आर्मेनिक तथा सुमेरियाई और मेसोपोटामियाई सभ्यताओं की लिपियां जब पढ़ ली गई हैं, तब सिन्धु सभ्यता के अवशेषों को आखिर अब तक क्यों नहीं पढ़ा जा सका है? जबकि, जेनेटिक साइंस एवं कम्प्यूटर टेक्नोलॉजी से प्राचीन लिपियों का पढ़ा जाना पहले की तुलना में अब ज्यादा आसान हो गया है। भारत के इतिहास को सही दिशा में सुव्यवस्थित करने के निमित्त इसका पढ़ा जाना आवश्यक है
पूर्वजों की आत्मा को बुलाकर उनसे पढ़वा लो। 🙏🙏
उस लिपी का अर्थ गोंडी के शब्दो मे छुपा है
Apne sahi samjhaaya
Get updated..get informed by genetic scientist Mr.Neeraj Rai
Now a days harhappa and mohanzodaho are in pakistan mulniwasio ko pakistan par claim karna chahiye
🤣🤣
Sir mesopotamia ki civilization k bare me b vedio bnae
What argument supports AIT ?
Jab aryans migrate karke north india aye unhone indus valley walon ko request kia aur wo south india chale gaye.
हां और आर्यन लोग शहर के पक्के मकान को छोड़कर गांव के झोपड़ियों में रहने लगा। आर्यन लोग बड़ा नेक बंदा था, हड़प्पा के लोगों को मारकर भी उनके घर पर कब्जा नहीं किया 😂
@@arjun4143 aur unke pass saare modern hathiyaar, aur rath aur ved likh rahe the, lekin unhe ghar banana nahi aata tha 😂😂😂😂😂
Aryan had nuclear weopan alos ha ha
@@arjun4143 भाई इनके बातों से तो यही लगता है। , , 😂😂 , , कोए लड़ाई नहीं कुछ नहीं।
वो लोग खुद कुछ नहीं सीखा , शहर बनाना इधर सिखाने आ गए , मुझे लगता है पहले तो इन अंग्रेजों के आर्यन वाला चीज का ही जाँच करना चाहिए , के ये खुद वहां कितने ठिक है। अंग्रेज जब भारत आए तब ये कहते थे हम भारत वालों को civilized कर रहे है। लेकिन जब सिंधु वैली जैसी सभ्यता मिली तो और कुछ जवाब तो मिला नहीं अपनी ईज्जत बचाने को बोल दिए की , , आर्यन बाहर से आए थे। और उसका कोई तगड़ा प्रुफ भी नहीं दे पाए। भारतीय सभ्यता और संस्कृति सच में बहुत महान थी जो इतने मुस्लिम आक्रमण और अंग्रेजों के 200 साल के शासन के बाद भी survive करती रही। शर्म तो मुझे उन गँवार लोगो पर आती है। जो अपनी सभ्यता संस्कृति को स्वीकार नहीं कर सकते क्योंकि यहाँ के कुछ लोगो से वे जलते है। लेकिन मुस्लिम या अंग्रेज कहलाने मे उनको ज्यादा मजा आता है। या खुद को और अन्य लोगो को अलग मानते है। मुल निवासी बोलते है। बल्कि वो मुल निवासी आज भी आदिवासी जीवन जी रहे है। बल्कि उसी हिंदू धर्म वाले सारे कर्म कांड भी करते है। जो वेदों के आगे की कहानी है। वो ना तो हिंदू बन पा रहे , ना और कोई existence को अपना पा रहे। बस कारण एक की विशेष वर्ग का विरोध करना । ,उनमें अपना इतिहास या पुर्वजों के बारे में जानने की बजाए इर्ष्या के भाव ज्यादा है। बाहर वाले बस हमें लड़ने के रास्ते दिखा सकते है। लेकिन वास्तव में DNA या किसी तरह से लगाओ , 1500 साल B.C , और 2000 साल A.d 3000 साल में हम घुल मिल चुके है dna भी घुला मिला है , अब बस हम भारतीय है. । और रही बाहर से आने की बात तो सब साऊथ अफ्रीका से आए है। 🤣🤣 ,
1. ऋग्वेद में श्लोक 10 में लिखा है कि हम (वैदिक ब्राह्मण ) उत्तर ध्रुव से आये हुए लोग है। जब आर्य व् अनार्यो का युद्ध हुआ ।
2. The Arctic Home At The Vedas बालगंगाधर तिलक (ब्राह्मण) के द्वारा लिखी पुस्तक में मानते है कि हम बाहर आए हुए लोग है ।
3. जवाहर लाल नेहरु ने (बाबर के वंशज फिर कश्मीरी पंडित बने) उनकी किताब Discovery of India में लिखा है कि हम मध्य एशिया से आये हुए लोग है। यह बात कभी भूलना नही चाहिए। ऐसे 30 पत्र इंदिरा जी को लिखे जब वो होस्टल में पढ़ रही थी।
4. वोल्गा टू गंगा में “राहुल सांस्कृतयान” (केदारनाथ के पाण्डेय ब्राहम्ण) ने लिखा है कि हम बाहर से आये हुए लोग है और यह भी बताया की वोल्गा से गंगा तट (भारत) कैसे आए।
5. विनायक सावरकर ने (ब्राम्हण) सहा सोनरी पाने “इस मराठी किताब में लिखा की हम भारत के बाहर से आये लोग है।
6. इक़बाल “काश्मीरी पंडित ” ने भी जिसने “सारे जहा से अच्छा” गीत लिखा था कि हम बाहर से आए हुए लोग है।
7. राजा राम मोहन राय ने इग्लेंड में जाकर अपने भाषणों में बोला था कि आज मै मेरी पितृ भूमि यानि अपने घर वापस आया हूँ।
8. मोहन दास करम चन्द गांधी (वेश्य) ने 1894 में दक्षिणी अफ्रीका के विधान सभा में लिखे एक पत्र के अनुसार हम भारतीय होने के साथ साथ युरोशियन है हमारी नस्ल एक ही है इसलिए अग्रेज शासक से अच्छे बर्ताव की अपेक्षा रखते है।
9. ब्रह्म समाज के नेता सुब चन्द्र सेन ने 1877 में कलकत्ता की एक सभा में कहा था कि अंग्रेजो के आने से हम सदियों से बिछड़े चचेरे भाइयों का (आर्य ब्रह्मण और अंग्रेज ) पुनर्मिलन हुआ है।
kuch nahi..angrejo ki bato k adhar pe ye sb bol gaye..baki bharatiye yehi k h..jb bharityo ki pracheen mahanta angrejo ko pata chala to unhone ye natak racha..us time pe bhart k logo me garibi thi..or apna itihas b bhul gaye the muslim atyacharo se..fir angrej padhare
Fake
ये सब उस टाईम का बात है जब , सिंधु घाटी सभ्यता की इतनी विस्तृत जानकारी नहीं थी। ये सब एक ही समय के लोगो के विचार है. जो भारत की आजादी के समय या अंग्रेजों के शासन समय अंग्रेजों के बताए इतिहास से प्रभावित थे। अब जबकि बहुत सारी खोजे हो रही है। नई sistes मिल रही है। scientific चीजों और नई थ्योरी को मानेगे या .. उस समय के लोगो के कथन से प्राचीन सभ्यताओं का निर्धारण होगा। क्या ये कोई पुरातत्ववेदा , dna test करने वाले या इतिहासकार है। ये सब नेता और सामाजिक लोग थे। और सब एक ही तरह के इतिहास जो अंग्रेजो द्वारा गढ़ा गया या बताया गया था उस से प्रभावित थे। अब जब हम सक्षम है तो हमें अपने प्राचीन सभ्यता की जाँच व निर्धारण करना हमें ही करने का अधिकार है। ना की उन अंग्रेजों को जिन्होंने हमारे जगह पर खोजे गई चीजो और ग्रंथों को अपनी देन बता रहे है। उनका कोई भी एक ऐसा तगड़ा प्रुफ उनकी थ्योरी को साबित नहीं कर पा रहा है। अब तक।
बेटा सबूत दे अौर जिनका नाम अौर वर्णन तूने किया हैं उन्होंने वेदों की रचना नहीं की अौर न ही वे वैदिक सभ्यता के मुख्य प्रवर्तक थे जिस प्रकार से मैक्समूलर आर्य आक्रमण थ्योरी का मुख्य प्रवर्तक था। अौर जो बाद में उसने खुद स्वीकार भी कर लिया था कि इस थ्योरी में कोई सच्चाई नहीं हैं। अौर उसके पास इसके कोई प्रमाण भी नहीं थे।
Brahmno ne teri maa behn ki Li ...fir tum paida hue...saala
Sir, bhtttt easy kar diya aapne.. ye lecture study iq lecture se v accha hai 💮
Dr Ambedkar after his in-depth Study of Vedic Scripturas , completely discarded Aryan Invasion Theory , In his book " Who were the Shudra". He even went on saying people of all CASTES are Racially similar which is what Genetic proves also.
@@DilipSadh i
This report published on 5 September 219 in cell and science magazine by 117 scientists ...
@@deepakarya4208
Yes i am aware of it.
1. Dr David Reich head of this study has said all South Asians are descendants of Harappan people. He said he does not know any thing called " Aryan"
2. DNA is not equivalent of Civilization.
3. Vedic / Hindu civilization is native to India due to all Linguistics and archeological evidences.
4. Across all developed civilizations like India, China etc , people come to them due to their wealth etc.
economictimes.indiatimes.com/news/politics-and-nation/indus-valley-civilisation-is-largest-source-of-ancestry-for-south-asians/articleshow/71042072.cms?from=mdr
To iska mtlb ye hua ki indus civilization south mein thi?
Katappa ayppa name ke peeche lagne wala pa aj bhi darvid logo dwara south main use Kiya jata hai jo ki ye darsata hai ki darvid established harappa civilization
😊😊😊
सर, वेदांत काल से पुराना मोहोनजोदडो हड्डपा संस्कृती है न? ईश्वरी तत्व तो सभी काल मे होता है,ये बात अलग है,ये श्रद्धा हमारी अभंग है, धन्यवाद 🙏🌹
इस्वर नहीं है।सर।
@@ladumunda5991 (आहे ही!) It is there and not there also, like that it is ब्रह्म तत्व , one has to take his own experience (आणि नाही ही, असे नाहीत्वाने नटलेले तत्व आहे ते साहेब),नीजी, खुद का अनुभव की बात होती है,unknown को 'X' factor assume करते है विज्ञान, गणित शास्त्र मे,वैसे ही ईश्वरी तत्व को समज लेना ठीक है,अपनी अपनी श्रद्धा की बात है साहब,कहा जोर जबरदस्ती है जी,🙏
हड़प्पा में शिव लीग मिले थे |
@@greatkaafir9316 wo shiv ling hadapa k samay ka nahi nikla
Sir make a video on shamnik religion and animisim religion
Already made watch in playlist of religions.
Jara ye bhi batao ki report log khud bhe study kare jo ki cell and science magazine me report 5 September 2019
Please make a video on Sanuli excavation of UP...
That was included in the previous video but will make a saparate video soon.
@@SuccessPlusAcademy also requesting you to go through the genetic discursion by Dr. Ganashwar Chuby...
That is also included in the last video.
Good
Indus valley mein r1 nhi mila.. Iska matlab steppe ka migration after indus vally hua.
सर जब कंकाल मिला है तो उसके सिर किस दिशा में थे, क्या उसके आसपास कोई पत्थर मिला था ?
You have not mentioned about irular community.
Bro agar ho sake to language research ke baare me ek video banao ..
Ek news esa bhi suna gya hai ki Indus valley civilization ki language ek central india ki gondi language me read kiya jaa skata hai to thoda dekh lo.. or agar ye comment pdh rahe ho to ek like/reply de dena taki pta chal jaaye ki aapne dekh liya hai
Language decode ki koi authentic information ni h abhi jb asa hua toh surely video bnayenge . 👍👍
Fake news hai .sindhu ghati sabhyta ki language ko aaj tak padh nahi paye hai.kuch gondi log ye afhwah faila rahe hai jatiwad kar rahe hai.
Kuch log ye bhi bolte hai ki gondi bhasha se hi south ki sab bhasa bani hai.ye bhi galat hai
Were the Indus valley civilization not Mongolio?
That means ,
1. Indian original population were independent
2. Steppes migration is right but people understand these migration as invasion because R1A1 gene of aryan from Steppes crescent( have white colour skin, long statured , etc ) oppressed south indian people or original indian people and divide them into 4324 caste ( under sc, st category ) to rule them while they itself divide themselves in some few castes ( brahmin, rajput, vaisay , etc) for ruling in a united way and maintain unity between themselves.
3. Farming is also not done by original people of India but by iranian farmers who migrate or invade India so basically farming were not came to india with aryans but came from outside india which is basically AIT wants to tell us that farming is not characteristics of original moolniwasi of india.
But, finally we all are united now and no one can divide us now...
ek sawal ans pls sanskrit ka archeological proven h jiski carbon dating hui ho 900 ad ke pehle ka ?
Refer to "Junagarh Rock Inscription" of Rudradaman dated back to 150 CE.
@@kshitizsinghias brahmi lipi hai bhai bo devnagri ni but tq u
@@Yunishkhan Aapne sanskrit language ki baat ki thi script ki nahin. Isliye... ek aur evidence aapko delhi ke qutub complex mein milega jahan ek iron pillar hai jisme sanskrit text likhe hue hain jo approximately 4th century CE ke hain.
@@kshitizsinghias that's great
@@Yunishkhan ..sanskrit was written in Devanagari,Tibetan,Siddham,Gupta Brahmi,Pallava,Tamil Grantha,Khmer,Javanese,Kawi nd many others
Ye Thory vidosiyo ki di huyi ha iske ap aak gaon ke kuch logo re dna le kar pura Thory bannayi gayi isme hindu dharm ko todne k liye barhamana ko videshi bol kar st sc ko darbid bana dia taki ye Christian ban sake gurukul ko katham karke convat school bana diye gaye or aaj be wahi ho raha desh me videshi takatoo ka pola pala ... sàvdhan me angreji kannuna ko badal kar fir se bharta ko mahan banaya jaa sakta desh aazad hone par be desh Kannun wahi puraña bàla raha 8 August ko chalo jantar mantar angarajo k Kannun ki holi jalne
Bhai..Ramayan Aur Mahabharat to 5000 varsha pahily hu tha....kindly explain
Tumhare pass is bat ka koi praman hai😂
जिसे सच्चाई जानना है वह यह दोनों वीडियो को पूरा देखें।
डॉ आचार्य कंगाली जी ने सबसे पहले पढ़ा
th-cam.com/video/EpHJtc0n6Fs/w-d-xo.html
सिंधु लिपि मोहनजोदड़ो हड़प्पा पढ़ना सीखें
th-cam.com/video/xrRp-XlME50/w-d-xo.html
Sanstit bhasha sirf arya bolte the.. Kyu ki woh bhasha leke woh indus valley mein aaye the
ARORAS OF WEST PUNJAB WHO MOSTLY LIVED ON BANKS OF RIVER SINDH WERE ORIGIN INHABITANTS OF MOHAN JO DARHU FROM USA
Sir ji garm ilaka ka manav kala ho jata hai & thanda ilaka ka manav white ,,toh Africa se khiska land india,joki garm ilaka ka hai ,,aap khud samjhdar ki yaha pahle kala tha ya white ,
आर्यावर्त क्षेत्र कहां तक था?फिर उसके निकट के क्षेत्र कौन कौन थे?
During mahabharath war , it was said that kings from Persia in the east to Cambodia in the east almost all participated.
I wonder what is the common language they all would have got connected with because during war it’s very necessary to discuss plans .
Also seeing the culture where Arjun and lord krishna get married to their own bua’s daughters which is a very prevalent culture of Tamil people . Also Lord krishna was dark skinned which is an important feature of majority of people living in south of India .
According to Ex I A S officer Balakrishnan sir ‘s many many years of research in that site he has said the following things :
Sindhu valley civilisation signs and those got from Tamilnadu Keeladi are similar . Two cock symbol from Indus is a very prominent proof because two cock fighting is still an important culture in Tamilnadu .
The keeladi excavations antiques 3000 years old had potteries similar to that of Indus and names were written on the pots which shows that it was a very educated civilisation. There are poems written in Tamil comparing a beauty of a girl’s face with wide lanes , well built roads and architectures which shows that how obsessed they were with the urban culture . Tamil sangam had more than 48 female poets and all the maha kavyam are story of women centric which shows how prominent the role of women in Tamil civilisation . And we all know Sindhu valley civilisation was women centric .
कुंती कृष्णा की सगी बुआ नहीं थी
SO you mean to say that it was Ramayna & Mahabharta people who migrated from Harrapa- Mohanjodaro civilisation site i.e all around Sindh river to Tamilnadu ?? But why there are no signs of Sanskrit language there at Harrapa ?? Why they have different languages that of signes ? Why no havan kund found there ?? Why most of the paintings and statues show most of MAHABHARAT people as fair complexion and sharp features people ? Who were Rakhshas always shown as people with dark skinned and with somewhat fat physique ? Why these fair complexion sharp featured Devi Devtas had fought with those Dark skinned fat people ??
tamil sangam has very old books and culture they have been debating with brahmins also and yes sangam was very free and many things is influenced by sangam
Old Persian nd Sanskrit were sister languages nd were very similar
@@rtam7097 Persian or Greek avestan
Mujhase BN Jaan lo R1A1 hai DNA aur atiyadhik gahrai se janne ke liye science jurny aur rational world authentic you tube chainal me aaye debate karle vo bhi bhartiya purtatva shakchhiya sahit prachin Bharat me vanshavaad vayvashtha thi jishaka bhartiya purtatva shakchhiya milta hai jai bharat
R1 A1 gene jise aryan gene kahkar European khud ko superior sabit karna chahte the jisse wo ham Indians ko bargala sake ,asal mein ye gene aryan ka nhi balki European ka hi hoga
Santhal ST ka DNA?