Undertale is a horribly made game
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ก.ค. 2024
- Undertale is a game that revolutionized the RPG genre.. but what spaghetti is lurking behind the source code?!
Download GameMaker FOR FREE: gamemaker.io/en/download
I make content on indie games and game development!
Join the Discord: / discord
I stream every weekend over at / juniperdev
Contact → juniper.owo.biz@gmail.com
0:00 Undertale
8:15 GameMaker
9:45 Undertale
#undertale #tobyfox #gamedev #indiegame #pixelarts #aseprite #indiegames #gaming #pixelart #pcgaming #gamedesign #videogames #gamemaker undertale toby fox yellow - เกม
![[SUB] 베몬이 교관님 멘탈을 탕탕 후루후루~٩(๑❛ᴗ❛๑)۶ FOREVER 웃게 되는 갓기들의 수련회 | 돌들의침묵 | BABYMONSTER(베이비몬스터) 'FOREVER'](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FISAO7BwIxE/mqdefault.jpg)
Download GameMaker over at gamemaker.io/en or else
I already have 😈😈
I expected some kind of a referral link, but it's actually clean??? That's a miracle :3
OR ELSE?! WHY IS THERE AN OR ELSE?!
This is the most fitting sponsor i have ever seen. I literal unskipped on SponsorBlock to watch it. Swag.
I love gameMaker 💖
if i remember correctly Toby actually got the genocide game delete to work. but he removed it since windows detected it as a virus 💀
@@ACoffiend LOL even better
Well, that sucks. That would've been better. But noooo. Windows has to be a crybaby and complain about everything. "Oh my god! A game is uninstalling itself? I gotta fucking remove this virus!" @JuniperDev
@@jarielwilliams9856 That's intended behavior, and should never ever change. A program uninstalling itself without the control of a user is malware behavior, regardless of the source and intention. If Microsoft ever allowed this, it would create a ton of security vulnerabilities. I agree, it would've been funny and scary, but there's a limit you have to not pass if you want your game to still be considered a game in front of the OS's eyes.
@@Tenandrobilgi Yeah. Fair. That is true.
@@Tenandrobilgi why can an uninstaller be allowed to uninstall a part of the pc itself then?
thats a double standard there.
the WRITING is genius
the code on the other hand is held together by sticks, duct tape and a prayer.
so basically a normal computer program.
well we gotta remembner this guy was basically one man with $50k
correction: and hopes and dreams :)
that was one EPIC prayer.
@@Thatmoosejimenez he spend 50k more wisely than a certain other guy recently
Toby Fox made his game in a cave WITH A BOX OF SCRAPS
GameMaker Studio: am I a joke to you?
I'm sorry...I'm not Toby Fox
he only had 2 sticks and a rock, and he HAD TO SHARE THE ROCK (with temmie)
And on hussie basement, the creator from homestuck, no wonder the game is called UNDERtale
Tony Fox?
this is just how people code. if its not held together with spaghetti and tape, are you really even a developer?
Hahah! I laughed too hard at this. I diligently start every project with absolute star level folder and consistency. A week into the code base. I realize star level means you can pick a star in the sky and I’ve probably put a bit of glue, duct tape and code in it. 😂😂
It's called "modular design"
By which I mean I grabbed a bunch of hastily-coded, self-contained functions and stitched them together as needed.
And plagiarized as much open source as I could get away with.
@@NotAGoodUsername360 Haha! The three of us are on our way to becoming a AAA Studio! Heh heh heh!
literally running on Hopes and Dreams
Honestly, the fact that Undertale is a poorly coded game makes Undertale even more of an inspiration. If even a rookie developer can make such a fantastic game, then you can too!
That’s kinda why I use it as inspiration too. Kinda what made me ever consider if I want to learn to make video games. I probably won’t ever be able to make a full project, but I can dream!
not in my case, because i know i can do worse than toby fox in 2013 with 50k
@@ssg-eggunner if you feel you can't do what Toby did, just try a smaller scope! Find something that you feel you can do by yourself and just do it! Even if it never sees the light of day, you'll have a blast!
@@AnimatingBeats you don't have to start with a full proejct!! Toby started with ROM hacks, UniqueGeese started with a Garten of Banban remake, you can start with a small scope, like a 10-minute to 1 hour-long game. Once you feel comfortable doing stuff like that, you can dream bigger! It's better to have a complete small project than an incomplete big one!
@@Wince_Media i could do a ripoff of pong and i still can imagine it crashing
"If you like quirky characters and inconsistent pixel lengths, Undertale is for you." - Toby Fox, 2015
@@mrwilsonisofflinegape577 true insanity IRL 🦕🦕🦕
@@mrwilsonisofflinegape577 Buddy, Metal Gear Rising is almost 11 years old and it still gets talked about today. If we go even older than that we have Ocarina of Time or Doom, or Minecraft.
Hello pfp twin
I HATE inconsistent pixel lengths with a burning passion... but I still somehow managed to get through Undertale without rupturing a hernia. Who knows how.
@@rocks4brainzz No way......
There are two routes of spaghetti:
Toby Fox
YandereDev
Nuff said
At least Toby bothered using switch statements
@@squid_cake haha yes
chaotic good and chaotic neutral
And Papyrus
@@Hyperboidneutral???
"Undertale is poorly programmed" Canonically it was made by a dog barking into a text to speech converter, so that checks out
_Reads title._
_Gets pitchfork._
_Watches video._
_Lowers pitchfork._ "Good point."
REAL
_Reads title._
_Reads the first two sentences of the description._
_Lowers pitchfork._
So relatable.
Accurate. Except I wasn’t gonna bring a pitchfork. I was gonna bring a machine gun. Get Ralsei to wield it. Stuff like that
im lowering my pitchfork but im not happy about it
Yeahhhhh Undertale is held together by a bunch of sticks and glue 😅it's honestly kind of miraculous that it not only works, but also that most playthroughs really don't see many glaring bugs at all
MYSTIC! You have been all over my feed while I've been making this video haha. Seriously, creators like you are a big reason the community behind this game is still thriving and videos like mine are still interesting to people. Kudos!!
You forgot determination, loot and loots of determination.
Not as bad as tf2
That spaghetti code is barely tied together there
It's like old Pokémon games
This is how most coding projects work, or at least mine.
Two very important things:
- Undertale is graphically good. The vast majority of visual assets seen in the game were cleaned up considerably by Temmie, produced from scratch by her, or done by another artist Toby hired. The entirety of Home, Snowdin, and many other areas were not only drawn and sprited entirely by Temmie, but even conceived in concept art by her first via fairly vague instructions from Toby. It is not an exaggeration to say Temmie is more important to Undertale's identity at many points in the game than Toby is.
There was a strong effort to keep the look simple and reminiscent enough of what Toby himself would doodle, but most of the final product is by no means not a professional quality finish, nor something he could produce anything that feels remotely similar to.
This confuses a lot of aspiring gamedevs into thinking they can still achieve what Undertale did with lower standards/ability. They cannot.
-Toby's lack of ability to code his way out of a "Hello world" assignment is one of the many factors delaying Deltarune to year infinity. It is very much an issue and, much like the point above, should not be something that encourages aspiring game devs to skip over learning their fundies.
Toby has been notably trying to use Temmie less on Deltarune also, and development and the product itself is suffering for that as well.
I didn't know these facts, and I'm glad I now do. Thank you for making this comment ^^
really nice points.
Wait, why isn't he working with her as much anymore?
@@annagolikova5167 I'm honestly not sure. He mentioned in the 2022 commentary stream that he wants to be able to do as much of the visuals himself as he possibly can, but then he started simply giving more work to Gigi that would have gone to Temmie in Undertale.
It's hard to figure out how he is thinking.
Had he given Temmie the same role and freedom she had on Undertale, getting everything done for the game on the visual asset and design side would be done practically overnight with how good Temmie is these days. Maybe she simply charges too much now.
Question: I can see how the development would be suffering due to the lack of involvement of Tem. But why the product, too? Is there something from the already-released Deltarune chapters that bothered you and that you think clearly shows a downgrade from Undertale? Just to be clear, I'm not trying to criticize you, I am legitimately curious.
The "Fun Value" thing should be in more games. It adds variety to different playthroughs with minimal effort from the developer
Awesome video btw
Can any coders tell us if this would be hard to add to games?
@@rakesiar not really just create a random value on new game and check if the value is below or above something and then do the thing u actually want to happen which is the hardest part
@@rakesiarSoftware engineer / game dev here: It’s actually pretty easy, the only hard part would be coding all the unique events (and that’s more of a content creation task).
It’s as simple as doing something like:
int funValue = Math.Rand(1,100)
if (funValue > 57)
{
//add code for an event that will only happen if the fun value is greater than 57
}
I think a lot of games tend to avoid this because they don’t like players to have a very randomized experience. It only works for certain types of games where it doesn’t harm the gameplay, otherwise it can be kinda annoying.
@@rakesiar Not particularly, just adding the feature would be extremely easy, the hard part would be adding the various possible events, and that would scale linearly with how many there are.
3:01 fun fact: I saw on a yt video about unused undertale content that this flowey sprite was gonna be used if you manage to oneshot Asgore by hacking the game
@@FireCo0kie-0fficial Oooh that's super interesting lol!!
100 yard stare lookin flowey
"..."
"..."
"...uhh, you win?"
That would’ve been hella funny
"Jeez..."
"...And i thought I'M the bad guy here."
One of my favorite things about Undertale is how, with Toby's limited skills and technical crap, it's still one of the best games I've ever played
I actually like how it's "badly coded"
Old games had bad code too and Undertale is meant to replicate those games
similar to Minecraft in a way, at least for redstone. Fun fact: turning off a 3 block long redstone wire causes over 1700 block updates.
@@vibaj16no wonder why my world is lagging like heck lol
@@SMCwasTaken at the same time though a lot of those games were sort of ingenious if you think about how much memory and space they took up like literal MBs of info which to me I think is awesome, like we laugh at how janky they are but a lot of those were written with basically assembly which is definitely pretty awesome
@@SMCwasTaken tbf, none of those games intended to have bad code, including Undertale. 😂
5:00 For your knowledge: Computers are really fast at everything. Going through thousands of statements does not require a lot of computing power, however if that is done every frame (which it isn't here) it could take away crucial computing power from other tasks.
So, Toby's approach is dubious, but ultimately fine.
Interestingly, the switch statement would theoretically be the best solution if you could design it in a jump table statement, where every single condition gets assigned a number and the code is spread out in a massive array, the number corresponding to the array position of the code. This would make it O(1).
But yeah, sometimes you want to keep it simple, it is not an area where performance matters at all.
@@briannormant3622 in a compiled language yeah, but I think gamemaker has its own interpreted language or something. It's a mystery to me how it handles switch statements.
really, i think the only reason that such an approach is frowned upon is that it makes localization harder, since if the dialogue is stored externally, localizing the text to another language is just a matter of replacing it, whereas baking the dialogue into the executable like that means that translating the game's text to another language requires you to recompile the game entirely
@@briannormant3622 _technically_, the default way to make a jump table - as the name implies - requires an extra layer of indirection from an array. as the array/table that's built gets you "the direction to jump to to run the code there", not "the dialogue data itself". as long as dialogue data is always the same (and there isn't some extra preparation code for some special dialogues) an actual array would be faster. unless the compiler realizes the data is the same and makes a genuine array as a second optimization
that being said i doubt GML even makes a jump table in the first place
You must never have used the laptop I did A level computer science on
"Undertale is a horribly coded game" could have gotten the point across better, but what do I know? I still clicked on the video 💀
Yeahh but honestly that title made me avoid this video for a while bc it was so glaringly obvious that it was a clickbait. Im only here because TH-cam kept shoving this video into my recommended and I got tired of it
Title's meant to be clickbait for angry UT fans looking for a fight.
Hence the issue. It's a clickbait title mostly just saying stuff we already knew.
@@Enuocale Opinion moment, most people think the games is amazing, you dont lol. But to be fair there is no game that is for everyone.
@@scizorscyther694 i don't think they meant to diss the game, they (maybe) thought that undertale having funi coding practices is common knowledge :P (especially thanks to the piratesoftware short that got quite popular recently)
oh hey, i'm in this!! thanks for the shoutout
@@ShayyTV Yooo!! Neat seeing you here! That makes a lot of sense bahahah, I was debating between showing a couple areas that seemed to have the gag surrounding conveyer belts. I appreciate the clarification!
i literally called it that shayy was going to be in the comments lmao
ah yes the room with the really quiet easter egg
Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing
Hi Shay I love your content
You should change the "Written" in the title to "Programmed", "Coded", "Developed" or "Designed", it'd still be plenty eyecatching for the youtube algorithm and wouldn't send people to just dislike and then click off which would tank the video and stop TH-cam from recommending it. But yeah I agree it's interesting how a game as great as undertale looks like it was just programmed on a napkin by a drunkard with a crayon behind the scenes.
Perhaps something more creative and eye-catching than even that, like "Undertale's code is spaghetti" with Papyrus' shocked face as the thumbnail.
where's u pfp from?
The point is that she may have done it on purpose to get more views
@@SamBateman Leave the title but have foreshadowing with just Papyrus pogging at a plate of speghetti with no words.
@@SamBateman Honestly could work, messy code is often called "spaghetti code" so there'd be plenty of space for some Papyrus jokes.
Undertale is a roomba with a razor taped to it.
Good enough.
Yeah, Undertale is a cheap game. But it’s not cheap in its heart, literally. So much will and emotion is put into every corner of it. Honestly, it being so simple in its controls helps it’s worth blossom MORE, because the game is about subversive storytelling. It’s saying that beauty can be found in anything, and in anyone. And it’s up to you to give it that chance, and you do that so many times in the game that it eventually feels instinctual to the player. It gives someone good values without them even knowing it.
"Undertale" (and by extension, what it says about Fox) is the _Ratatouille_ of indie games.
"A great artist can come from anywhere."
THE UNDERTALE DIALOGUE "IF" STATEMENT
Oh god no
Lord o me may code Jesus (so basically brackeys before he quit) save me
terrifying
still better yandere sim game spaghetti code
Switch is not an if statement
So THAT’S why Deltarune Ch.3 is taking so long
Well, actually the opposite, cause toby now has other people working on the game so he has to make it more readable
I can’t wait for the Woody fight
Deltarune is a pretty large step up from Undertale, so that means that the code has to be written cleaner so the game can actually work. Also he has a team now so the code has to be readable if they want to work on the game.
@@soapgaming4903 yes I know this is sarcasm
@@illegalmemedealer3549 whoops. Looks like I need to work on my literary skills lol.
This video is kinda neat, though the statements made about the switch statement being "slow" or "unoptimized" are incorrect.
It's still wrong to do dialogue this way because it makes the code difficult to read and add onto, but it doesn't make it "slow". A switch statement has a constant speed no matter how many cases are in the statement, this is why it's preferred to use a switch statement over a long string of elseif statements.
In fact, depending on how the code is written, it would likely be *faster* than accessing a JSON file. (Since in order to access a JSON file you need to make a read request to the storage device as opposed to ram, though you could just store the JSON file in an array, but even then, that's unlikely to be faster than a switch statement.)
Again, it's still wrong to do that massive switch statement, but it certainly isn't wrong because it's slow.
a switch statement isn't inefficient memory-wise, it may be even faster than a file you read whenever you need data.
that's what i was thinking, the I/O solution sounds like it would take way longer
@@BlueBoyTech yeah, for it to be faster one needs to load the file into memory and then map every entry to an array, which would be the same as a switch statement (maybe a little more organized). However, when it comes to Undertale.. it doesn't really matter
Games nowadays don't have enough dogs you can pet.
@@bananaman9869 So true
Minecraft legend does
Or just animals to pet in general
ugh
That is a huge pet peve of mine
I know you are going for a rage bait title but I strongly recommend you to change it. You don't want to meet a certain side of the fandom
Exactly. Why rage bait? Doesn’t end well usually.
and this one's especially too strong that even people outside the fandom to get startled ngl
@@THGMR-ox7sdit gets views, let’s be honest we all clicked because of the title
The game is like 10 years old I don't think those kinda people are around anymore
@@Kosta991 i love how that age's a year away from not being a hyperbole
I want to point out a few things:
1. Game optimization does matter. However, it's importance depends on what kind of a game you are making.
2. Switch statement are not inefficient. Inefficient is what's called an if ladder, because it will check conditions one by one. Switch statement are designed to determine what code should be executed in almost constant time. That's why it only accepts constant values as cases. So it's not that bad.
This very much reminds me of Thee Sims 2. It’s in my (and many other people’s) opinion the best Sims game to date, yet the code is so awful, that you have to jump through hoops _not_ to completely break the game beyond repair. Like, certain buttons in the game that you’re supposed to use will just break. Say you try to export a lot that Sims have lived in, the whole game has a chance of breaking because now there’s missing data and it’s just a beautiful mess of a game.
Yeah, I remember the heartbound dev saying that you "don't need to be a good game dev to make a great game" in a shorts and using Undertale as example, so I actually didn't get clickbaited (Also, there is a code behind sans so...)
read the title. grabbed my pitchfork. then watched for a few seconds and realized: "yeah the code is just papyrus' spaghetti" and then put my pitchfork away
Papyrus'S
@@animainmilol *Papyrus'
@@stuckatthevalley both are valid
@@vibaj16no. if you have a name that ends with S, you don’t put another S when referring to something that belongs to the person with the name ending with S, so it’s just papyrus’
Papyru's
4:00 to be fair, Toby used to be an Earthbound rom hacker, and Earthbound is pretty much infamous for how overtly complicated it's text system was
extraordinarily rare oneshot mention in a random video
the 2016 remake of oneshot doesn't do anything as extreme as deleting the entire game though, but it does do something similar by restricting your access to the rest of the game until your delete your save file or solving the puzzle related to it
though OneShot becomes literal in the 2014 version as mentioned. however, there are versions where you get more than one attempt at the game
the thing holding it all together is some tape and DETERMINATION
And Papyrus‘ spaghetti of course
-It works?
-yes...
-so?
programmer philosophy 101.
Watch it bite your ass one year later@@MarcosAlexandre-no3qx
Look at Yandere Dev and say that again
@@ee-zae unlike the 5k polygon toothbrush game, Undertale works just fine
@@ee-zae 2 words
"it works?"
Robtop is hiding under his desk begging not to be found after this video came out...
The twd video essay:
Wow your channel is awesome! How did youtube not recommend this to me earlier? Keep it up!
Dude thank you so much!! (:
@@JuniperDev Your channel is truly awesome! But I wish the title of this video didn't make a bad first impression of it. :P
I disagree about the illusion of choice. When done correctly, it's a very useful tool that gives the player some sense of agency without spiraling off exponentially with every decision made. Plus having multiple paths to the same outcome is just realistic.
Plus all you need to do is throw in some real choices, and then now the player doesn't know if the choice will matter or not.
You do want a common experience between players. Not exactly the same experience, but they need to feel like they're playing the same game. And, for completionists, it needs to achievable to see all the content.
I think that's what Toby wants to do with Deltarune, since, you know, your choices don't matter. The last chapter will probably happen during the roaring, since I can't imagine any possible outcome of snowgrave
I actually really like when this is done in a way where the choices lead to very different dialog/scenes that eventually lead to the same outcome. Even if the overall story is the same, it feels unique enough to have a new experience
The main problem with illusion of choice is when there's literally zero depth to it. Instead of adding flavor it just brings extra attention to the fact that you have no agency.
At least give *some* detour before joining back to the main route instead of "yes/no" ">no" "haha you don't mean that" "yes/no"
More accurate, and less clickbaity to say "Undertale is a horribly coded game" because everyone either knows that's true or would be interested to learn more about. (As a modder, it _is_ questionably programmed... Well, at least I was able to make plenty of progress on my Bug Fables mod of Undertale!)
Bug fables mentioned 🗣️🗣️🔥🔥🔥🔥
My experience messing around Undertale's code is when me and another guy working on technical stuff for an Undertale localization project, the other dude noticed me about a problem that when a player walk through Alphys's lab, they sometime got lag and even game crash. The reason for that is because of the screen displayer (that display Frisk's face) works by deleting and generating a sprite from the main surface (that draw everything inside the room) every single step, using function sprite_create_from_screen_x, which is sprite_create_from_surface but with application_surface. We have to modified the code to use surface_copy_part and the result is like day and night. There are more funny stuff we found inside the code but this one is the one I remembered the most.
this is the same guy who wrote and sang a song about a 13 year old boy giving birth to his best friend. and it's an amazing song.
I saw "Dev" in your name and immediately knew it was going to be about the code lol
If you think Undertale's dialogue being one giant switch statement is bad, look at VVVVVV. %90 of THE GAME (yes, the ENTIRE game) is one giant switch case statement
WHAT
@@minestar2247I've been seeing you a lot recently.
You're now one of the commenters. I see frequently.
It's interesting how you keep reading you to comment sections and you keep finding familiar faces.
ong
why are the best games so horribly coded
im crying what
1:17 Thankfully this only happens in an old version, the steam version just has niko confused when you relog into the game
4:47 Minor correction: Unlike a list of if statements, where you run the dialogue ID through X amount of statements one after the other. Switch statements, on the other hand, use a hashlist that tells the game what part of the program to jump to in order to execute the right code.
Like it's a messy blob function that could be written in a more coherent way, but coming from a background of backend development, I've sort of just accepted that there are some situations where you will just have blobby code, and game design is one of those cases.
So it's less "slow", and more "a visual affront to god"
"Undertale is a horribly coded game" wouldn't hit as hard as written
YEAH that's what I'm sayiiiin man but hey, I do feel bad for possibly clickbaiting people D:
@@JuniperDev you clickbaited me
i legit thought you were gonna hate on Undertale as a whole
@@JuniperDevyou should change the title if you feel bad :/.
@@JuniperDev I was already loading my dislike shotgun
@@1th_to_comment. NOT THE DISLIKE SHOTGUN-
I feel the need to clarify that larger switch statements do NOT impact performance. No matter how large the switch statement is, it will always take the same amount of time for the game to figure out which set of instructions need to be referred to -- effectively, they are the O(1) alternative to having a bunch of separate if statements.
I will agree, Toby's method of handling dialogue events may seem kind of odd, but ultimately it looks more like a preferential thing to me. It seems like he was more fond of keeping everything in one place so that he could refer to different in-game events easier, instead of having to look in multiple different places around the game. That's just what I personally believe, though.
@@dracobot1223 My understanding is that the operating time depends on the compiler; you are correct that many languages do port those statements into a jump table automatically, making it o(1), but not all do. So without optimization generally o(n). And if it's thousands of cases, that optimization may be a binary search, so logn.
I could definitely do some more thinking about that one and you definitely got me double checking. I appreciate your comment! 🍃
@@JuniperDev I think the main problem is even worse case scenario the switch statement is still faster than loading and processing a csv file.
On a good compiler, you would be correct, but gamemaker studio uses an interpreted language. It's proprietary, so you can't know for certain but it probably does not do many optimisations, so it will still be O(n). In the end, it doesn't matter since computers are fast enough that you can do thousands of comparisons per second. I just checked in python, known for being slow, and it does 1,000,000 comparisons in 43 ms.
@@santania4719 Worst case scenario you need to write your own jump table and an interpreter so you can read the instructions that you're jumping to.
Whoops! I meant to reply to someone else, still should show for everybody I think, but sorry that it looks like I'm replying to your entirely different comment.
@@JuniperDev Interestingly, I've just learned that switch statements in GameMaker may have not always compiled the same way. I remember getting an error when attempting to supply a non-constant in the case argument field, which led me to believe that switch statements were compiled as jump tables. It seems that this is no longer the case..?
I'm not fully certain what this means in the context of the version of GameMaker that Toby used, either.
For now I will say that I may have been the one spreading misinformation here, LOL.
Remember kids, you dont have to be good, just good enough
This doesn't make any sense
This doesn't make any sense
True that
When I read the title, I knew exactly what you were talking about
Toby even added a reference to this in Deltarune with the Spaghetti Code item
I think the spaghetti code item is a more broad reference to jank programming, spaghetti code is a common term.
I think I remember Toby hinting multiple times that coding is a slog for him.
She actually has a point, PUT DOWN THE PITCHFORKS
No
@@MichaelJohn-hy6utwhy?
Nope! That woman will suffer the CONSEQUENCES.
wait why
I won‘t put down my pitchfork, but I‘ll put down my Meowmere
While I agree with the overall message of this video, it contains A LOT of misinformation. Here are some critiques:
1:00
This code technically works, but it's blocked due to limitations with Game Maker and Windows. While a work-around could be done, it's not really a "coding" issue as much as a computer security one.
4:56
This would not slow anything down. In fact, it's the opposite: this is the most performant method possible way you could add dialogue to your game. Parsing an external .csv file or other data structure would take waaaay longer. Having the text embedded directly in the code allows for instant access. It also wouldn't take more memory. I'm guessing you said this under the assumption the hard-coded strings are loaded at runtime, but compiled code stores hardcoded strings directly on the .exe file and only loads them when they are used.
In addition, we actually don't know how Toby created the switch statement. As far as we know, Toby used a tool like Excel to write all the dialogue, then used a script to convert the data into a GML switch statement. This would actually be the best system by far in terms of writing the dialogue and loading it in game. Which is why I hate how this potentially genius system is treated as some "Toby bad coder" evidence.
5:10
Not much to say here other than this tweet seems to imply "if statements" are inherently evil... but they serve a specific function and are required to do most things. A lot of the "if statements" run at the start of the level's creation to set things up, which would not impact the game's performance at all. Once again, this is actually the fastest and most logical way to handle things, not bad at all?
5:30
This is a somewhat deceptive critique of Undertale. While technically correct, this could be optimized a tiny bit by moving the Game Maker object instead of recreating it, internally this would make no difference for the renderer. All the font glyphs are preloaded, and the data is re-sent to the GPU even if it's the same Game Maker object. You need to rebuild the text to animate it in other ways due to Game Maker limitations, so this choice probably made the most sense for working with the existing system Toby already had.
THISS!! Also the part about the snowballs having vertices is weird because they aren't 3d models. They are sprites and should render like everything else
Thanks for saving me a watchthrough! I was wondering where the flawed arguments would come into play.
@@santania4719 not sure about how gamemaker studio works, but it could be due to something with the graphics engine - for something like opengl you process vertices first, and it'd be where you apply transformations regarding position, perspective etc. though, that is mainly for 3D graphics and i cant imagine he actually used a proper graphics API to scoot around some snowballs lmao
Couldn't the dialogue just be directly in the code that uses it, instead of all being put in that separate file?
@@vibaj16 itd be much better for translation and code structure to have dialogue be loaded in fron files. much easier for the translators to change text files and load the appropriate language, and the dialogue could be update more easily (just add a line of text to the file for the dialogue and any conditions etc that happen during the scene).
4:51 As far as I know, using switch is faster than using if, yes, the code reads worse, but internally the compiler makes optimizations that make it much faster, using a CSV you first have to read the file and I suppose you will load it in a map, which I think is a little slower than a defined switch, although they are small things that practically do not affect the performance of the game.
The look of horror on my face when I heard that all the dialogue in the game was in a single if statement...
In other words, OP has a _point._
Was he trying to delete the game from the game's own code or something? That's not a great way to do it. Spawn and use a separate process. Write an EXE to temp that kills the game and then deletes it. Or, if you want no traces of the game left, launch the game uninstaller in silent mode, and close out the game before it starts.
Sure, you can possibly figure out a way to delete the actual files out from under you, if you know how to keep the game in memory while the files are removed. (Or if you're using Linux, which automatically handle this). But it's so easy for things to go wrong. Far better to separate things out.
Of course, maybe the tool he used can't spawn new processes?
Nice, I was disappointed that there was no explanation for how to be could have done it in the video
Thank you for this
GameMaker by default won't let you spawn any process you wish to. You can make extensions that let you do that, though
@@Mizu2023 I didn't know that
For the code to be running, wouldn't it already be in RAM? So it wouldn't need to worry about that?
Also, another comment said that he did actually get it to work, but Windows detected it as a virus.
@@vibaj16 Like I said, it's not impossible to delete something while it's running. But it can be tricky. Running programs are often locked, to prevent other programs from messing with them while running.
That idea that it was detected as a virus makes sense. It was trying to delete itself while it was still running. That's something viruses often do, to try and hide themselves.
I'm not at all saying it can't be done. Just that it's attempting to do it in hard mode.
I remember that instead of figuring out any type of real pathing system or fixing several boundary issues, there's several Out of Bounds areas in Undertale that have "magic glass" (his words) that appears when you or Undyne walk on it. It's like instead of being able to get rid of a bug, he put a clown nose on it instead and said, "See, now it's a funny joke and not irritating at all!" and went to do something else.
I sometimes wonder how the game would look if he knew beforehand just how popular Undertale would become.
Oh thank god
I saw the title and I was getting worried I would have to summon Franklin again
whos franklin😨
IT'S A SWITCH CASE!? THAT'S HOW THE DIALOGUE WORKS!? WHAT THE FUCK!?
Bait used to be believable
why did you still comment
"bait used to be believable" used to be believable
Undertale has spaghetti code... boom. the title doesn't trigger my fight or flight response
i feel liek a better title would be "undertale is a horrible coded game" before people start jumping you??
Gotta get people to click somehow
@@the_seer_0421 fr lmao i personally think it's genius
4:30 Excuse me, but isn't switch statement very efficient so it will jump into a certain place in a constant time no matter how many cases there are?
From what I have seen in this video, I guess dialogs in the game work in a way that when an event that causes a dialog happens, the event asks a global switch statement to handle a number the event was given in advance. For example, the player hits an object, so the object requests the global switch statement to handle the object's pre-made number.
In such a way the dialog shouldn't be inefficient, am I wrong?
The title almost gave me an heart attack lol
Understanding how really, really big games has a lot of kludge and are made in a not-so-professsional way encourages me to keep programming
Real. You ain't gotta code good to make a 10/10 all-timer. Make games!
I was honestly hoping this was actually about the story because I wanted to see what unique standpoints would be given for a criticism of the game.
I agree with Mr. Fox on the last bit. Hades is only good because you can pet Cerberus.
Is this what all this "Hopes And Dreams" is all about?
10:22 - Toby Fox’s 2 favorite words…
*P E T D O G S*
Everything from its programming to the music to the dialogue was unorthodox, that’s what makes undertale so great. Toby went and did everything you aren’t supposed to do with a game, especially something like RPGs and made it into a game and IT WORKED.
6:56 omori does that wich is why I wondered why I saw Mari once and not again in a different play through
"Not yet ferb!"
7:38 deltarune chapter 1: 😰
All these commentators are like "thank god you didn't talk shit about the dialogue or characters!" and here I am disappointed that this video is only about code.
@@Bluehawk2008 HAHA I bet you can find critiques out there. I did enjoy the game but I also see some flaws as well. Thinking of making a "Everything I'd change about xyz" for various games
Can i be honest with you... The game is kinda eh... I preffer deltarune
5:30
Ah, the classic "I could program this object to be able to move with another object and spend hours debugging that, or I can fake the same thing through weaponized code jank because this is literally the only time I need it to move like this".
This honestly makes me wanna go back and learn more about the backstory to Earthbound and see if there were any similarities in that process as well
Toby Fox make Undertale with DETERMINATION
So clickbait-y title aside, this video really isn't great because I think you can totally improve and do better. The whole topic of "toby fox = bad programmer" is very disingenuous when you're supposed to be talking about the source code and why its bad / how to do better yet you've only brought up one proper example about its dialogue system. Everything else is just cut content, secrets and features that did not make it in (and some random talk about its art for a minute? why is this relevant?) You've only covered one valid example that goes on for 2 minutes in a 10 minute video, is that not a problem?
5:45 as far as I know, Toby isn't responsible for most of the website's content as in he most likely never had a hand in its development and couldn't have added that comment there. The website is all done by Fangamer who are also in on Toby's den of secrets, so its a little something they added themselves
this is honestly extremely encouraging. i want to get into game design but have found it challenging to approach and this video honestly made it seem better. just jump into it, doesnt matter if youre perfect. an unprofessional random guy did it pretty inefficiently and now its one of the most beloved games ever
I mean he isn't exactly a professional game dev. It's really not a bug deal if the code sucks since the game is so simple it probably doesn't really affect the game anyway. It's sort of how like TBOI was, Edmund was an artist, so the flash code had a lot of weird issues modders had to overcome... even to this day the documentation for TBOI code sucks and requires a ton of time to get used too.
The dialogue system... wow! You just know Toby must have been feeling really passionate about making the game because it would have been a gargantuan task setting up those match statements and calling them reliably with all the little things that are affected through the game.
Making a metroidvania right now and writing all of my dialogue in a single array because I'm too lazy to set up a json. So I can sympathize with Toby Fox.
This is the equivalent to some stickman carrying a Statue of Liberty.
I realized this when I started developing in Game Maker and noticed Undertale had a walking glitch that took me like thirty seconds to fix.
I'm so glad they changed that for the oneshot for steam so people could actually see the story they don't give any information that closing the game kills the kid
Came here to see this vid get clowned on. Stayed when it was actually ballin.
1:29 this is how I learnt Niko straight up dies in older versions 😭
4:45 - I'm going to have to disagree with you here.
Huge switch statements are bad because they are hard to maintain and work with. They are not bad for performance, at least in any halfway decent language. A competently-designed compiler will transform a large switch statement (or lengthy else-if chain) into a lookup table, because that's much more efficient and has the same overall effect. It does probably make performance a little worse, because it increases the size of the binary and might cause paging or cache misses, but that is way cheaper than manually iterating through every case as you suggest it's doing. Also, fetching dialogue from JSON or CSV files will hit the disk, which is quite slow compared to a computed indirect jump.
i gasped at the dialogue being one if statement, oh my god
Thing is, it's not even true
This video is not what I thought it was. I thought it was about Toby being a bad NARRATIVE writer. The video itself is fine, but you might want to change the title to “Undertale is poorly coded” instead. Cool video though.
Poorly _-made,_ not poorly _-written._
2:13 This Steam Thread was surprisingly tame. Why use this as an example of them being horrible? Lord knows you have PLENTY of choices in that regard.
using a switch statement is literally faster than using a csv. the switch statement is going to be compiled to a vector table and instantly branch to the desired code. A csv has to be loaded and parsed, then do the lookup. Its cleaner, but it is not more efficient.
If TF2 taught us anything, is that revolutionary pieces are held together by duct tape behind the curtain.
I've heard that Toby was inspired by the Shin Megami Tensei series, it's where he got the idea for the talking to enemies especially, and that series is also has a good amount of code fuckery like accidentally making a boss a debug enemy with only 2 attacks, having a stat that does almost nothing, having magic damage thst decreases as you level, forgetting to compress layouts and having an underflow glitch where you can't increase your agility past like 27
Toby's other major gamedev experience before Undertale was the Halloween Hack, which is made on Earthbound, a game infamous for its horrific code. I can't include links in youtube comments, but if you're interested, look if you can find Mato's article about how the dialog system works in Earthbound, it's absolutely bonkers.
Toby made Undertale by himself. Oneshot, dokidoki has a team, from what I know.
It's also his first main game. He improved himself with Deltarune. That's why I prefer Deltarune over Undertale. Better art, party members, complex fights, music still great, storytelling still great too.
One of the few examples to show "don't judge a book by its cover".
8:18 Calling game maker free nowadays is like calling mushrooms a fruit.
You can make web based games but that's it. They removed free Windows game development. That's paywall content unless you have the old version unlocked and installed before the switch.
Hold down the pitchforks she's got a point
Why on earth do people think switch for dialogue is slow?
It's literally supposed to be faster than loading text from a disk and using a hashmap for dispatch.
Because most coders don't think about what the processor does to do to make their program happen. It's ugly so it's bad, and because it's bad it must be slow.
Being fair to Tony, he had a little time to work on Undertale, but with Deltarune, he had since 2012 to plan out the game and what it’s about, how it works, etc., not to mention having more people to work on it at least for chapter 2
Fun fact about fun values: when the game initially released, they were bugged and every play through had the same fun value. Everyone got the wrong number song, no matter what. Imagine the state of the fan base if fun values work from the start?