Baseus Gan5 Slim USB Power Adapter and others Review and Test
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 3 ก.ค. 2024
- Baseus Gan5 Slim USB Power Adapter and others Review and Test
Subscribe to the channel: / @allthingsoneplace
Support this channel via Patreon: / allthingsoneplace
In this video I am looking at seven different power adapters!
Baseus 65W Gan5 Pro Ultra-Slim Fast Charger with model CCGAN65S5-OE
Okray 20W USB C Power Adapter with model BHPD-01
Trebleet Ultra-Thin 25W USB-C PD Super Fast Charger with model TRE-2USBA
Yilon 18W Ultrathin-Slim Fast Plug/USB c Fast Charger with model YLTC-355
Tebleet Ultra Thin 65W GaN PD Fast Charger with model TRE-65
Budi 65W Travel Adapter USB A C with adapters with model AC336
Sankton 65W 2 Port Foldable USB C Slim Wall Charger with model S-TR-261
Paid affiliate links to help the channel
Anker Prime A2343 100W Power Adapter: amzn.to/3s45wbE
ZMI PowerPack No. 20, QB826G 25k mAh, 210W: amzn.to/3KNM9dc
Anker 737 PowerCore 24K Power Bank: amzn.to/3S9nSQL
165W Satechi USB Adapter ST-UC165GM: amzn.to/3YAgpNV
100W Desktop Adapter: amzn.to/3a4Pfuy
Baseus Slim 65W Adapter: amzn.to/3tHhMzz
Sankton Slim 65W Adapter: amzn.to/46IQiYU
Video on USB Cables: • USB Cables Part III Th...
Video on Power Quality: • Does Small Power Suppl...
Equipment:
Video Editing Software: DaVinci Resolve 18
Video Camera / Still Camera: Sony ZV1
Lights: Three VILTROX VL-200T
Microphone: Blue encore300 / MOTU / Reaper
GW Instek GPM-8310 Power Analyzer amzn.to/3PiabfR
Power Z USB 3.1 Decoy (PD 3.1 Emulator) eBay
Siglent SDL1020X-E Programmable DC Electronic Load amzn.to/3PkL2Ba
AC Power Supply: GW Instek APC-5050A amzn.to/3uk5p9V
Website: www.allthingsoneplace.com/
Other Website: pqs.app/
00:00 Intro
01:08 Okray
02:20 Trebleet 25W
03:36 Yilan
04:18 Trebleet 65W
05:06 Budi
06:08 Baseus
07:09 Sankton
08:06 Other Data
09:28 Quick Teardowns
11:21 More data
13:24 Conclusion - วิทยาศาสตร์และเทคโนโลยี
Unboxing of first few look like opening up cheap hotel soaps lmao
haha
periodic buyer's guides (quarterly/semi-annual)
are a great idea for your channel and consumers.
i wonder if any consumer oriented channels
might like to do their own videos covering your guide.
Thanks yeah, I guess it comes down to if anything new or noteworthy has arrived. I believe it's fair use for a news organization to use a piece of my work within theirs.
I really appreciate that you're now including DC output ripple in these reviews; I know it's extra work to capture, but I think it gives good insight to the amount of effort the designers went into the device's quality and high ripple can absolutely cause hard to diagnose problems depending on the downstream device.
Yeah, slowly adding more things in time.
Yes! I've been patiently waiting for this. Thank you so much for getting around to these.
No problem! Yeah, they don't seem of overly bad quality at least but it does appear in general that performance is sacrificed for form factor.
@@AllThingsOnePlace I think you're correct. Hopefully they put a bit more effort into newer models.
I really hope that the 100W GaN5 Pro version from Baseus can perform better, at least on par with previous generations.
Keep up the good work!
Thanks for the support! Yeah, I have been trying to get that one.
Wow 1st time I see so in depth review. Excellent love it. This is my style
Well, plenty to choose from then on the channel.
Thanks a lot..I didn’t know how much I needed this info
Glad it was helpful!
That caliper is a thing of beauty!
It's something alright.
Looking forward to both buying guide videos 👍👍
Okay, I better get them going.
I was just about to ask about your calipers when you said they would be the topic next week. 🎉
Yeah, should be a fun one. I should design a PCB and make it look nicer but also, it isn't broken.
Thanks for this! 👍
Edit: based on your reply a couple weeks ago about these I instead went with a flat APC surge protector and UGREEN 20W chargers (no longer making them???), and Anker 30W and the Amuzone 33W base on your rec and having zero issues. Thanks for the great reviews!
Glad to hear that! UGREEN has newer models out. I have to test them still.
@@AllThingsOnePlace Yeah, I needed two more and they only had the 30W now and I saw you hadn't reviewed them so got the two you had reviewed that you like.
I love that you did a video on these! I travel alot and love the Sankton 65w as my travel adapter. I wish it was more efficient, but I'm not paying the bill at airpots, shops and hotels. I also travel with an Anker 543 65W slim charger with 4 ports. 2 Laptops fully charged plus I can juice up my phone, mouse, keyboard, toothbrush...whatever. I wonder if I'm hurting my devices? I bought the Satechi for home use because of your videos and want the efficiency.
I don't think you are causing any harm to the devices themselves. But yeah, it does seem true that in general the slim adapters sacrifice a bit of performance for thinness.
@@AllThingsOnePlace I don't think you fully grasp how necessary these adapters are. All my laptop accessories are nice and thin and fit in my laptop sleeve. The exception is the power supply. Most people buying these are using them as travel adapters, not something that fits behind a desk (although honestly who cares if they're a little warm so long they don't catch fire). I really don't understand this striving for poverty meme. 300mw isn't the end of the world. A clean power supply that is slim and lightweight is all that travelers give a damn about.
Just wanted to leave my thanks for stellar content. You got me hooked on USB PD tech and I've picked up several of your recommendations. Stellar content all around - keep up the great work! I would love to see a video on "best power banks / adapters for projects", focusing on only ones which can function as a UPS and/or don't interrupt other devices when renegotiating. Sometimes that functionality alone would make or break me buying a product. I'm probably demonstrating my ignorance, but I wonder if there may be a market for some kind of supercap-based "renegotiation fixer" product you could throw inline for devices that are sensitive to it.
Yeah, I have a prototype of that, it isn't very good but technically does work. I have some video of it in action but it isn't posted anywhere. To make it cheap makes it terrible, to make it functional is expensive and time consuming. I have a whole video on UPS functionality planned. They make specific devices for that. I have a bunch of them.
@@AllThingsOnePlace I look forward to it! Thanks for the reply :)
Curious to know of this series will continue. I'd love to see the POANES and Nomad models tested in this way.
Yeah, I have a bunch of suggestions piled up. Nomad was on the list already.
Thank you for your video!
Would like to suggest, if possible, to test out Razer 130W Gan Charger. It has been on the market for a couple of years now, but still no one has done a thorough testing of it. Would be great to see your review :)
I know, when I got into this I was very turned off by the price to watt ratio of the adapter. I wonder if it is cheaper now. I'd also worry about general compatibility at this point. It'll make it eventually, maybe I can find a used one.
I use the baseus but got it on sale. I got it for the form factor and it suits my use case as I use when I travel or go to a coffee shop. If it wasn't on sale I would've passed on it and bought a better performing anker adapter
Yeah, these things on sale for not full time use make more sense.
I'm with you. I don't quite see the appeal of these. My one thought for a use case would be maybe for use with an outlet blocked by a piece of furniture, such as behind a nightstand or a couch or something, where having an adapter which lays flat against the wall and the ports point down may be an advantage.
Yep, one person said they use it since it fits in a thin tablet case and for occasional use is good on the go.
The slim adapter I use is the Realme 50W Mini SuperDart Charger.
Edit: I remember where I found this one. MKBHD mentions this adapter in his Everyday Tech for 2022 video.
Yeah, that is a good one to check out. I haven't yet so no idea how it will do. Thanks for the suggestion.
Just a heads up, Creative, the company that used to be known for its sound cards, has launched GaN chargers in the US.
Thanks!
One thing that's missed is these almost all certainly kick down power during load. I have the Trebleet and it will swing down to 45W after about 10 minutes at high load. That said, I'm fine with that... it's less than 3 ounces and the form factor is everything as a digital nomad. It slips into a slim pocket on my MBP's sleeve and cuts at least 2-3 ounces over more conventional 65w gan chargers. It can easily fit it in areas with little extra space (ie. behind a couch). As the cord points up/down it tends to work better in areas like cafes.
Yeah, form is the main idea for sure.
hmm i have a aolion 65w flat one that i like but usually carry around my voltme 65w usb-c one since its so small. the reason i like the 65w Aolion one is because its flat front face lends itself well to taking aluminum or copper foil tape and creating a sort of improvised external heatsink/rf shield on the outside of it by folding the tape back on itself about 20 times on the front face with about 50-70mm of length. kinda janky but i think it will make it last a lot longer since i charge my laptop with it.
It's something to try at least. Thanks!
I don’t see myself buying a skinny adapter that has only NEMA prongs. An adapter for travel but not international travel seems pretty niche to me.
I think I’d rather travel with a C7 input and the right mains cables.
I agree!
I think you have to factor in that they are travel adapters, so efficiency is lower on the list of priorities. I opted for the Baseus.
Maybe, I do get from a lot of people, I'm looking for something that fits behind furniture that I never have to touch again.
Maybe I suggest another video idea?
What about all those USB wallplugs with LCD displays that show the power consumption etc.?
How good are they, is the display even accurate on those models, such things.
I did one a couple weeks ago. The Essager 33W model. They're a novelty but fun to see roughly what's going on.
Would be cool to add the Nomad 65W slim adaptor to your results… at that premium price would be helpful
Thanks for the suggestion. Yeah, I am sure there will be a slim round 2.
I’d love if you could test the nomad offerings. They look like they should be a well executed version of this concept.
Thanks for the suggestion!
@@AllThingsOnePlace also I just bought the “belkin boost charge 3 port”. My unscientific method says that it’s working for me at the moment
I would like to recommend Cuktech 65w ultra slim for review
Thanks!
Reminds me of the OG, the Mu One, and its successor the Mu Two.
Sounds like they were early to the party.
The budi appears to use the same type of clip-on adapters as Aukey.
I didn't try them on that one, I was looking for adapters they fit on.
Can you test the Nomad 65W Slim Power Adapter? It's very compact and has 2 USB C outputs. There is also a 35W with one port. They look great for travel if they perform decently well
Yeah, that is on the list now. Hopefully can find a bunch more to make enough for a round 2 slim adapters.
@@AllThingsOnePlace not specifically about slim adapters but, I tried 5, 30W anker nano 7 series adapters and 1, 511 adapter to power a macbook air, and after a while of charging they stop charging and restart again after a second and cause the charge sound to play on the mac. maybe they are overheating after a while and do this as protection. Is this some thing you can test for?
Have u review the LDnio 100w charger.. I saw ya take on the roceren 100w charger.. and that help me alot..
I haven’t yet but I do have that one on the list.
You can try realme,oppo and Huawei silm chargers
Yeah, or just any charges from them... I have no way to test them though.
Are the stock chargers of Google, Samsung, Xiaomi etc any good?
They aren't bad. Samsung's 45W charges are quite good, the Google 30W charger is a favorite of mine for lower power charging. The Xiaomi lacks any safety marks but the one I looked at seemed okay performance wise.
Hi
Kindly tell the two best 3.3ft type c to type c cables.3ft and 4ft also acceptable.
Thank you
The all things web site has a list of cables, pick one with the features you need and the lowest resistance for the length. www.allthingsoneplace.com/usb-cables-1
I would buy the one for $6 and call it good. It’s a USB port right?
Oh. One thing. You said you don’t understand the point. I do. I travel for work. One of the hotels is light on plugs. So I have to move furniture out of the way to plug in a normal USB port. Huge pain in the ass. A slim one like this would be perfect. That said. I ain’t spending $40 a usb plug to charge my phone overnight!
Love your channel.
haha, thanks for some perspective! You watch electroboom's video on power in Mexico? That's a good one for finding outlets in a hotel room.
Can you do the Ruifei 65w? It only has one USB C port, so perhaps that will fix any USB negotiation issues.
True on negotiation. I added it to the list.
@@AllThingsOnePlace the voltme 65w ultra slim charger is a more premium option that's very similar to the Ruifei, which would be a good comparison. The XSUFR 65w flat seems to be exactly the same as the Ruifei but under a different brand name.
Good day sir. May i ask which power adapter for macbook pro 16 you would recommend? I want to pick maybe from 120-140 watts , to charge my phone and the laptop simultaneously. Was thinking to pick the ugreen one.... but maybe youll suggest better option? I don't like apple one cause it enormous)) and also would like it to have safety features to be relaxed when i have it on a plug all day) also i can order directly from China i need eu plug so that is more convenient for me. Thanks would appreciate if you help
My choice is the 165W Satechi. Safety listed, universal input voltage, replaceable line cord so it can be powered from any socket type. If you want something with earthing though, which you might with a macbook, your options shrink considerably. Basically, desktop adapters with three pin. There's not a lot out there in the sub 200 watt category, I'm actually not coming up with any. At 140W, the UGREEN or any of the clones (Rocoren, etc.) adapters all perform okay.
@@AllThingsOnePlace thanks sir! Appreciate your response very highly! I guess ill pick 14watt ugreen one. Hope that will be safe to use at keep it on plug all the time😏
the Bseus GAN5 65W travel charger gets really hot and after about 15 mins lowers the output to 45W on the USBC port. I only have it for travel, but this makes it clearly not usable for anything else!
Yeah, it's less efficient so more heat makes sense.
I was thinking that my unit was defective... So, "is a feature,not a bug"
That is ridiculous with this unit a 65w charger can't even sustain 65w continuously. Garbage. I really like my anker 543 4 port pd/pps 65w total charger, perfect for all my smaller devices, I could even charge my laptop if I needed to with 45w on 1 port, perfect Slim desktop multi device charger. Love the channel AllThingsOnePlace thanks for all you do 🤘🏽👍🏽☝🏽🇨🇦⚡️🔋🔌⚡️
you missed asomotech :( was expecting for one kekw
There's always round 2.
First! Love your videos
Thanks!
Hi! im looking for 100w charger for my laptop and smartphone now, and in my country there is some option like Baseus Gan5 100w, Ugreen Nexode 100w, Anker 736 Nano II 100W, and Mcdodo CH 8101 GAN 100w. Do you have any recomendation throung these brands for 100w charger? Thanks!
I haven't tried the Gan5 one yet, the Anker wasn't great, Mcdodo I haven't looked at for 100W, the UGREEN may win just from not having looked at the others, opinion of course. I need to get some of these other chargers in.
Unbox and Testrun Sungzu 100W Power bank 🎉
Thanks for the suggestion.
Hey ... Can you make the videos about electric leakage? Most of my own charging adapter is light on my testpen while i put it to USB C. Its save ? Or not? And can u explain about electric shock in mobile phone ?.
Model I've:
- Ugreen 65w
- Xiaomi 67w
- Vooc 33w
Thanks before.. 😊
Yeah, I do need to get into some of the leakage and isolation tests. They're often destructive though.
Just by the looks of these Adapters, one would assume it's a Power bank because of their sleek design. Great product Though.
Yeah, they do have that appearance.
will you please review Mcdodo 100w 3 port charger i'm dying for your review????? please please please from India
🙏🙏🙏🙏
Replied on the other comment.
can you test Baseus Charging Station 100W, 7-Port GaN USB C Charger Power Strip Surge Protector 1200J with 5ft Extension Cord? I measured 2w idle power consumption, I can't believe it has .99 power factor 100% load, but 2w idle power draw
Yeah, that's awful. I did look at one Baseus power strip thing, it was okay. Idle was high at 0.4 watts. 2w sounds like an apple cable may still have been plugged in during measurement.
I got the baseus during a sale, so I paid a lot less (~38$). Unfortunately, your review didn't exist at the time! :P Ultimately, I got it because the size/shape allows it to fit inside my tablet case without pressing on the screen. A shame it's such a poor performer.
Yeah, as a once in a while use it's fine, the energy loss won't have much impact, especially if it doesn't sit plugged in doing nothing. It does have a lot of stuff in the box so it looks like they really tried to make a good adapter. It just doesn't quite hit the mark on efficiency. There is certainly opportunity and demand for a good thin adapter.
Same here. For the price and form factor I'll keep it for now since it's just used occasionally to top of my phone when I'm on the road.
Boy, it's a good thing I don't give a flip about efficiency
haha.
Grandpa stop pronounce every single product ID that out loud it’s hilarious 😂
Totally do that on purpose.
@@AllThingsOnePlace Project Farm? Please keep doing this on purpose, it's entertaining.
What is the difference with a similar charger ? Or it is just a difference in name only ?
Watch the video
@@sjoerd104Watched it can't find a reason why i should choose this product over a similar gan charger. The pps and charge modes are similar so why choose something that takes more space ?
@@lolidasterner414 well if you watched the video then you would've heard him talk about efficiency, ripple and idle power usage too.
At the end of the day you shouldn't really get a slim charger, get normal shaped ones, they're better.
@@sjoerd104 So the only difference is the shape which affects the performance. I suspected it when sometimes he had a slip in the tongue calling the adapters chargers etc . Well i still cant find a reason for such a product to exist since any 65w charger is smaller than the adapters but in the end how much my opinion counts ? Ty btw.
Yeah, I also mix up power adapters and power bank constantly when working on those videos. But yeah, essentially they squeeze the adapter into a slim case and lose a bit of performance along the way.
I do notice You don't normally Test Over Current or over Voltage input on Power bank while Doing Unboxing test
Secondly; You don't do Teardown to see the battery Used on the Project 😪😪😪
Yeah only so much I can cram into a short youtube video.
these look like that Oppo charger they bragged about last year "OPPO 50W MINI SUPER VOOC CHARGER"
Yep. Looks similar.