I have been watching your channel for so many years now, from the moment i found your smokey eye tutorial I new you were going to be huge in the makeup world(most likely already were at the time) i always look forward to your videos, i think its amazing how far you have grown , i think i have been watching your channel since i was about 16 or 17 and i am 21 and you have achieved so much, it is obvious how grateful you are i am so glad i can still find the time to sit down and enjoy your videos knowing your 100% you. you're so kind. also your home is so pretty, wish Australia had homes like that haha
Your palette is my favorite! I use it everyday since I got it and have bought it as gifts. Great colors, great texture and quality! Most importantly it's cruelty-free. You did a wonderful job 💚💚
Intithar Alfadhili At Ulta! It was since last October, though. They only had a few left at that time and I bought two. It's the only palette that I've been using since then :)
Just wanted to let you know how much I freakin loved "boyfriend does voiceover" I've watched it numerous times and I laugh more each time. Hands down my favorite TH-cam video of 2016! 🙌🏻👌🏻 He is definitely a keeper wish you both the best 😊
Carli don't think you didn't do enough on TH-cam this year! I just joined you this past year and I've loved every second of it! You've taught me to just enjoy everything I have and work on how I can be a better person. Thank you for everything. I love you (and your palette) so much ❤
Of all the palettes I own, yours is still my favorite! I hope this new year is a better experience for you and your family! In regards to your giveaway a new laptop would be amazing because I know many of us could really use it! So many students, professionals, aspiring youtubers, and creators; We are all here! 💜💜💜
lolliecandy I really want this sweater badd..I work at forever 21 and we never got one in...do u know where I can get this same exact color and sweater from?? and is it a blueish color like a blue grey?
That turquoise color is so pretty! I would love to see some artistic makeup looks from you like a look inspired by one of your cats, household items, chip bag, phone case, etc. I think that'd be awesome! :)
Can you do more looks using your carli palette. i love it, its for sure my favorite. thats the palette that made me love makeup because it looks AMAZING with my brown eyes. The top row is my favorite love mauve in my creases and shimmer on the lid. your my favorite youtuber love u ❤︎✾♡♥︎❀
This is such a fun tutorial! makes me want to try the look with my blue eyes. LOVE turquoise and your necklace! Thanks for sharing. Hope you have a blessed New year!
Hi Carli, I just want to thank you for brightening my day. I don't even watch you for the makeup anymore (though your looks are always gorgeous!) but instead because you're always so positive and genuine. I love how you said you want to remember where you came from. I think many youtubers forget about that and they get too sucked into TH-cam as it is now and projecting a certain image. Thank you for always being you!
I literally love you! this is my first time ever commenting but just know that I've watched all your videos from the start. Youre such a stunning girl naturally and know how to enhance your beauty perfectly. NEVER stop making videos because there's people like me who admire watching your work. keep it up Carli!❤
Carli, remembering what I saw of your family after you had a member pass away has really helped me get through my dad passing before NYE. You all buckled through a vacation he was meant to go on and I'm doing my best to help my mom and sisters get through losing someone so important to the family. Thank you for sharing your life.
lol you're such a cutie patootie...and did you just put that mauve eyeshadow under your nose with that blending brush in between blending your creases at 14:28? lol
and btw I am scrolling thru the comments and I see you comment back a lot! I love that. you have over 5 mil subs and you still reply!! that's amazing. I've seen YTers with waaayyyy less who NEVER reply.
elizabeth greer many people also put blush on their nose! Blush tones can blend a contour more and pull a look together better. She may have seen she needed to blend something so she quickly did it with the brush she had not even realizing she did it.
absolutely gorgeous makeup look. ill definitely be trying this out soon. thank you Carli. Makeup lovers are blessed to have someone as talented as you to guide us.
the last bit of that quote in the intro is in a messy font i can't see what it says... and maybe you should use revitalash or something to repair your lashes? beautiful look nonetheless! love the pop of colour
Idea for your holiday giveaway: someone can win a lunch date with you! I think that would be such a fun idea, but if not... the iPad or laptop would be an awesome idea like you said!!
Another idea for the big gift: you can fill a box with a bunch of your favorite products that you use in your videos (graftobian palette, L' oreal telescopic mascara, etc) and give it away to someone!
I missed this so much I feel like the last two years we haven't gotten much of classic Carli which is these get ready with me s... the bohemian lunch date look was my fav from the year she was super active.. before she went missing almost lol love you anyway you're the best
Carli you're one of the most humble persons I've seen on TH-cam you really inspire me. I hope what ever downs you've had in 2016 get better this year and for you to have a happy wonderful year. Thank-you for all your amazing videos. Also, you should totally recreate the 1920s look and do your hair with it. :)❤
I think another great giveaway prize could be a youtuber "starter kit" with all the essentials to start a beauty channel! Or a shoutout to or collab with a smaller beauty youtuber!
Got your eyeshadow palette for Christmas & im obsessed with it, seriously can't put it down. Can't wait to see what other makeup products you come out with.
Carli, it's not a bad habit! It's something called Trichotillomania, and is a "disorder" where you pull your hair out. It can be your lashes, eyebrows or the hair from your head. I have the same thing myself, and did the exact same thing as you when I first tried out lash extensions.. I've gone to psychiatrists and doctors, but there's not much research on it:/
andrinesr I'm eyed as I type this message 😂, my right eye always gets it the most. I sit up and pluck them out one by one, it's soothing to me then I regret it because I end up looking crazy.
I don't think she has trichotillomania! I used to pick off my mascara, too - it doesn't actually rip your eyelashes out. Then when I got my lash extensions, I would try to pick the extension off my natural lash because I used to do it with my mascara, but it would pull out my natural lash so I learned to stop. Trichotillomania is when you actually want to pull the hair out.
OMG I kept thinking ...her sweater is going to fall any minute lol😂😂😂
Ivonne Carmona I kno lol...bit too low can almost see armpits
Ivonne Carmona boobies!!!👀
Ivonne Carmona same😂😂😂😂
Ivonne Carmona Same. It was distracting.
I found it very distracting also. She looked so awkward whenever she moved. I don't think it was supposed to be worn that way. Very unflattering
Shes legit the only person ill watch her videos beginning to end
That necklace is so stunning I could stop glancing at it 😻
The pops of blue really brought out your eyes, so lovely!!
Sub for sub? :)
thank you my love!
Carli Bybel your my favorite youtuber luv ya 😘😘😘😘
Please recreate the 1920s look would love to see that!
Dana C Yesssssss
I have been watching your channel for so many years now, from the moment i found your smokey eye tutorial I new you were going to be huge in the makeup world(most likely already were at the time) i always look forward to your videos, i think its amazing how far you have grown , i think i have been watching your channel since i was about 16 or 17 and i am 21 and you have achieved so much, it is obvious how grateful you are i am so glad i can still find the time to sit down and enjoy your videos knowing your 100% you. you're so kind. also your home is so pretty, wish Australia had homes like that haha
Your palette is my favorite! I use it everyday since I got it and have bought it as gifts. Great colors, great texture and quality! Most importantly it's cruelty-free. You did a wonderful job 💚💚
I love it too. I use it almost everyday 😍
DreamingTata VeganMama me toooooo. I love her palette editing a video with it now!!
DreamingTata VeganMama how do u purchase her palette
Intithar Alfadhili At Ulta! It was since last October, though. They only had a few left at that time and I bought two. It's the only palette that I've been using since then :)
the feeling when your favourite youtuber upload a video on your birthday😘
Happy Birthday!!!!
happy birthday girl! 💞
Emmy Sundström happy birthday ! 🎉
Emmy Sundström Happy Birthday!!! 🎁🎂🎉
Happy Birthday!! // ❤
Cheers to the New Year, Carli! We are so proud of your accomplishments!
Torquoise eyes look soo amazing on her. Her skin tone is just poppin' 😍
She is the first youtuber I've ever watched , my fav since then ❤️
Carli and I both use ABH brow products in ebony. We're obviously twins.
lilian makori Obvs. 😂
TWINSIES
Carli Bybel love ❤️ you
Carli, if you want your real lashes to grow strong and fast, you should try applying castor oil on them every night ❤️❤️Hope this helps
Carli your positivity inspires me so much! Whenever you upload it brightens up my day!
Just wanted to let you know how much I freakin loved "boyfriend does voiceover" I've watched it numerous times and I laugh more each time. Hands down my favorite TH-cam video of 2016! 🙌🏻👌🏻 He is definitely a keeper wish you both the best 😊
Shu80 Shu meanwhile my bf is tripping about doing mine ugh
Carli don't think you didn't do enough on TH-cam this year! I just joined you this past year and I've loved every second of it! You've taught me to just enjoy everything I have and work on how I can be a better person. Thank you for everything. I love you (and your palette) so much ❤
One of my favorite tutorials in awhile. Like not just from Carli, one of my faves period!
Of all the palettes I own, yours is still my favorite! I hope this new year is a better experience for you and your family! In regards to your giveaway a new laptop would be amazing because I know many of us could really use it! So many students, professionals, aspiring youtubers, and creators; We are all here! 💜💜💜
Jamie H. totally agree with you! I love the color combination and those highlights🦄🐧⚡⚡
Jamie H. & staying home Moms! 💪🏼
Jamie H. How do u enter for the giveaway? I can't find a vid bout it anywhere. I've been wanting a laptop/iPad for years
And is it international??
Peta Innes I don't think she has announced it yet plus she wants to add more prizes! 💜💜💜
ugh I love these long talk through/life update videos 💗
alexisbreana me toooo. I never want her videos to end
Finally! So glad it's uploaded been stalking your snap chat to see if it worked lol. That eye color is everything. 💙
When you said you used the side of your Starbucks drink I died 🤣😂🤣😂🤣😂🤣
The outfit is oddly perfection, the longer I look at it the more I like it! Such amazing style Carli!
Im obsessed with this look and your technique!! I also love love love your necklace, watch and ring!!
That sweater is so gorgeous! Grey suits you like crazy! Happy new year everyone!! 😚🔥
Legend says, the longer a youtuber goes without uploading a video, the more dramatic their sickness stories get.
yes please do a 1920s makeup look because i want to have a great gasby themed birthday
got waay too excited about the fact we have the same sweater lmao love u carli!!
lolliecandy I really want this sweater badd..I work at forever 21 and we never got one in...do u know where I can get this same exact color and sweater from?? and is it a blueish color like a blue grey?
Kimberleigh Carol i got mine at the forever21 online uk store! and i got mine in white and it's a bright white, really pretty x
lolliecandy am I able to shop the UK store even tho I live in the us?
I feel like any color just suits you! Gorgeous
Got your palette for Xmas and I love it! Happy New Year ❤❤
Parveen isn't the absolute bestest???
Aladdin vibes in this video love it!
When you drop everything you are doing just to watch Carli 😭❤
always ❤
I LOVE U X
Carli Bybel me too 😭❤
That turquoise color is so pretty! I would love to see some artistic makeup looks from you like a look inspired by one of your cats, household items, chip bag, phone case, etc. I think that'd be awesome! :)
Elisa G Music this is such a good idea!
You're seriously such a genuinely good person! I love when you upload and when you snap!! Definitely my favorite TH-camr :)
Can you do more looks using your carli palette. i love it, its for sure my favorite. thats the palette that made me love makeup because it looks AMAZING with my brown eyes. The top row is my favorite love mauve in my creases and shimmer on the lid. your my favorite youtuber love u ❤︎✾♡♥︎❀
yali segura Same. I use that palette literally everyday. Love the highlighters too. Every. Day. Lol
yeas please!!!
Please do the 20's inspired hair and makeup😍😍
I would love to get some of your make up for a give away! I've never tried it and that palette is gorgeous!
Kawii Cookie it's sold at ULTA
Happy Puppy it's sold out! 😢
Ryan Kilgore it's the bombbbbb
Ryan Kilgore did you try ulta . com?
Ryl
This is such a fun tutorial! makes me want to try the look with my blue eyes. LOVE turquoise and your necklace! Thanks for sharing. Hope you have a blessed New year!
I love your GRWM videos! You're so natural talking and doing your makeup. Love! xoxo
Omg i have that same nervous habit of picking my mascara!
ShineBrightStars Me too but it's not a nervous habit. I just always do it at the end of the night. my eyelashes really suffer
you're such an inspiration in my life. i love you and your channel! xoxo
Your sweater looks so comfy 🔥
I love you so god damn much & I admire how positive you're all the time, even though life is so tragic at times
I want to thank you for being so inspiring, every time I watch one of your videos I feel so happy with my life! thankyou!!!
You are so incredibly beautiful inside and out. Thank you for being so inspiring 💜 I hope to be half as amazing as you are.
You look so gorgeous, I really love watching your videos as you seem so sweet and you're obviously so talented!
Omg ur gorgeous I love u!!!!!
YOU'RE GORGEOUS & I LOVE UUU :D
Carli Bybel thank you so much for replying it means so much!!!!!
Carli Bybel I love you and your cats
Isn't she. Carli is freakin stunning.
I agree// like jaw dropping!!! its incredible how shes 100% natural!!!
I absolutely love how you do your makeup!! Long time subscriber and you never cease to amaze me!
A makeup brush set with all your eyeshadow favs would be great. Im glad your back making videos
"I'm just trynna like remember my life" lmao
hahaha
Try putting Vaseline on your lashes before you go to bed! It helped mine grow so much !!! ☺
Tiffany Grande Hey! Can I ask, how long did it take?
Tiffany Grande and castor oil
Xx N.girl0303 xX I saw results within just a few weeks :)
Tiffany Grande Hi! Which Vaseline did you use? Just the normal one?
Vaseline isn't Vegan so she might not use it. But castor oil & rosemary oil mixed with Almond oil, is all time holy grail!
pleaseeee can you do a video on what camera you use and how you edit your videos? thank you xxxx
Hi Carli, I just want to thank you for brightening my day. I don't even watch you for the makeup anymore (though your looks are always gorgeous!) but instead because you're always so positive and genuine. I love how you said you want to remember where you came from. I think many youtubers forget about that and they get too sucked into TH-cam as it is now and projecting a certain image. Thank you for always being you!
I literally love you! this is my first time ever commenting but just know that I've watched all your videos from the start. Youre such a stunning girl naturally and know how to enhance your beauty perfectly. NEVER stop making videos because there's people like me who admire watching your work. keep it up Carli!❤
Thank you for being so positive it gives me hope! Did you get the rings from itsy as well?
Not the opal ring btw...the cute gold ones
Arey Macklin I love her motivation
Free people!
i know it's early but Valentine's looks would be awesome!
Shani Ramento right!!! I'm getting ready tooo
I had bald spots too with my eyelash curler! I felt the same way 😭💖
When carli asks "let me know if you wanna see a video about such and such" Like girl, we wanna see any video of yours!
Carli, remembering what I saw of your family after you had a member pass away has really helped me get through my dad passing before NYE. You all buckled through a vacation he was meant to go on and I'm doing my best to help my mom and sisters get through losing someone so important to the family. Thank you for sharing your life.
lol you're such a cutie patootie...and did you just put that mauve eyeshadow under your nose with that blending brush in between blending your creases at 14:28? lol
Ellen O hahaha I saw that too 😂😂
lmao!!! yes!! I always do with the mauve shades! they are similar to shadow colors so its ok ;) XOXO
Lol I do that too when my nose is itchy but don't want to rub my foundation off hahahah
wait girl why did you put that mauve eye shadow on your nose at about 14:28?? you're silly but I love you and this blue is beautiful!
and btw I am scrolling thru the comments and I see you comment back a lot! I love that. you have over 5 mil subs and you still reply!! that's amazing. I've seen YTers with waaayyyy less who NEVER reply.
elizabeth greer many people also put blush on their nose! Blush tones can blend a contour more and pull a look together better. She may have seen she needed to blend something so she quickly did it with the brush she had not even realizing she did it.
Haley Perry thank you!
Haha I saw that too and thought maybe her nose itched 😂
Elizabeth I would love you to come check out my recent emerald green smokey eye tutorial
Listened to every single word. And love love your looks, every time. Glad you're feeling better doll!
absolutely gorgeous makeup look. ill definitely be trying this out soon. thank you Carli. Makeup lovers are blessed to have someone as talented as you to guide us.
the last bit of that quote in the intro is in a messy font i can't see what it says... and maybe you should use revitalash or something to repair your lashes? beautiful look nonetheless! love the pop of colour
SH The cursive script reads, 'To criticize others'.
Revitalash is great! 😍😍
SH omg! so glad to know I'm not the only one lol. I always want to read the quote but I can never read the last line lol
haha lol, you're not the only one.
Idea for your holiday giveaway: someone can win a lunch date with you! I think that would be such a fun idea, but if not... the iPad or laptop would be an awesome idea like you said!!
Another idea for the big gift: you can fill a box with a bunch of your favorite products that you use in your videos (graftobian palette, L' oreal telescopic mascara, etc) and give it away to someone!
LOVED the turquoise watch, pendant, and eyes!!! Loved your sweater too, but it didn't "match" your theme!!! HAPPY 2017!
Roxie Eyeleers I need this sweater
carli you're so adorable! totally digging the turquoise blue look 😉💕 honestly your makeup videos are life!!
What you do is such a beautiful art! I love watching you do your eyes! A true beauty you are! 💜
Carliiii, could you do a video on your workout routine and some vegan meals since a lot of people's resolutions for 2017 is to lose weight? Thanks!
Anyone notice that opal ring is on her engagement finger 😳😍
I didn't mean to !! I wear it on my right normally 😇
Please do the 1920s makeup/hair look ❤❤
I missed this so much I feel like the last two years we haven't gotten much of classic Carli which is these get ready with me s... the bohemian lunch date look was my fav from the year she was super active.. before she went missing almost lol
love you anyway you're the best
Carli you're one of the most humble persons I've seen on TH-cam you really inspire me. I hope what ever downs you've had in 2016 get better this year and for you to have a happy wonderful year. Thank-you for all your amazing videos. Also, you should totally recreate the 1920s look and do your hair with it. :)❤
for some reason my eyes kept focusing on all the school buses passing out the window lol. anyone else?
Yasss! I'd love to see your 1920's look. 😍
How cool would a recreate your first TH-cam video be? I think that's a great idea!
The elf cream eyeliner !! It's sooo pigmented and it doesn't budge !
The Stila all-day wateproof felt tip eyeliner is the BEST!!! Super jet black and doesn't budge one bit!! 10/10 recommend ✨
the link for the necklace doesn't work :(
I fixed it so sorry!!
Carli Bybel thank you! 😊
Carli Bybel the links don't work for etsy for the other necklaces from the last last video!
"I looked like a thumb" 😂😂
A 1920's look sounds awesome!!!!!!!!
Michelle Ramos just like her xmas party 💙💙💙
I remember watching you when you first started! You have grown so much! Love you Carli!
Love this makeup look!!! The blue/turquoise is sooo gorgeous! Loved it!
Turquoise is your colour. It is a pretty on you!
I think another great giveaway prize could be a youtuber "starter kit" with all the essentials to start a beauty channel! Or a shoutout to or collab with a smaller beauty youtuber!
I'm so jealous of how beautiful you are! 😭❤
Got your eyeshadow palette for Christmas & im obsessed with it, seriously can't put it down. Can't wait to see what other makeup products you come out with.
Happy New year , Doll ! Thanks for supporting Etsy shops & using cruelty free products !
How do you use your iPad as a monitor?
with a system called Camranger!
Yes pls do the 20s look :)
A updated skin care video would be great
I literally just found you yesterday and your already my favorite TH-camr 😍😍😍 your makeup tutorials are amazing 👍🏻👍🏻
Omg the suspense for the upload of this video was REALLL girl!! haha so worth the wait.. excited for more videos!! can't get enough
yesterday I said, "Carly isn't uploaded video this week" and I watched like 4 videos and said again " I hope she upload tomorrow" and here I am
awwww :D
paodoc c I was thinking the same and then a few hours later she uploaded 😊😆 made me really happy 🤗
Carli, it's not a bad habit! It's something called Trichotillomania, and is a "disorder" where you pull your hair out. It can be your lashes, eyebrows or the hair from your head. I have the same thing myself, and did the exact same thing as you when I first tried out lash extensions.. I've gone to psychiatrists and doctors, but there's not much research on it:/
andrinesr I'm eyed as I type this message 😂, my right eye always gets it the most. I sit up and pluck them out one by one, it's soothing to me then I regret it because I end up looking crazy.
I don't think she has trichotillomania! I used to pick off my mascara, too - it doesn't actually rip your eyelashes out. Then when I got my lash extensions, I would try to pick the extension off my natural lash because I used to do it with my mascara, but it would pull out my natural lash so I learned to stop. Trichotillomania is when you actually want to pull the hair out.
don’t thank us, it was all you girl.
OMG Carly I missed you so much!! I'm so glad that you came back❤️ you look so great!! And I would like if you include your plate!!
I love your palette, especially the highlighters. All the shades are so gorgeous and pigmented!
I feel like everytime you make a new video you say the same thing in the beginning.. which is telling your viewers why you've been so absent :(
Please don't continue with the lash extensions it is so Bad for your own lashes they will tell you it isn't but believe me..i've been through it
What i also wanted to say you are beyond gorgeous carli
Definitely agree on that! 😩 I'll never do lash extensions again
jana dobrev, use a lash and eyebrow serum. They really work and work amazing! Just make sure you apply every night before bed. 😊
Beautyful like Cleopatra!!
agree! ❤
OMG you are sooo stunning !!!!! Love your tutorials 😍😍 and that opal ring is absolutely gorgeous !!!
Are you kidding me with this look?! Im obsessed! Ugh glad you're back ☺
does she not prime her eyelids first?