@@Chuck_ELI don't really agree at all. My suspension of disbelief is not challenged by aliens looking like they're related in the same way that humans are
Yeah I'm an Irish boy with black cousins, even from a human perspective there'd be no reason to give a shit if someone's cousin doesn't look like them. I know black and white siblings with different parents even, it's not insane for family to look different. Much more important is that they can make us feel as though they're family with their performances. @@drainstorM11
Agree 100%, plus she has a fan base that will go see a movie with her in it regardless of genre. I don't know if the other two can pull people in who are not comic book fans.
I love how comic accurate James goes with his casting. I still can’t get over how perfect his Jimmy Olsen casting is. (also knowing that Meg voiced Supergirl…they should pull Jensen Ackles Batman from that same universe)
considering they've stated that they will be keeping the actors the same across live action and animated, it seems extra relevant for meg since she's already proven she can do voice work.
@@ProjektTaku no since they’ll be largely recasting for voice actors when they cast live action. supergirl would just already have both bases covered. also i’m down with jensen as batman could be fun
Not to mention, James gunn said most actors in both live action and animated will be the same because its in the same dc universe. I want to believe that this audition was to check if meg can play Kara in live action because the animated story is tied up to the dcu then go to other candidates if she cant do live action well.
@@TheStormbringer8751 idk I can't hear it see I'm not a dog but race swapping is lame and character assassination not all characters need to be changed for no reason at all
@@DavidRogers-t7h But no one has talked about changing ALL characters. And so far nothing has changed at all. You're celebrating nothing so far. And if you get your way, you'll be celebrating a "Whites Only" sign in the year 2025....
@@TheStormbringer8751 no Im Mexican so your wrong white characters that are White in the source material should be played by white actors black characters should be played by black actors why change the characters race that's what you are changing the characters race character assassination black washing race changing in The Hunger Games Rue is black so she was played by a black actress no let's just change her race she is played by a white girl now do you like any of that? No I don't think so
I cannot believe you did not being up Meg Donnelly’s most iconic roll in Z-O-M-B-I-E-S (2018) and Z-O-M-B-I-E-S 2 (2020) and Z-O-M-B-I-E-S 3 (2022) where she literally plays an Alien. Perfect connection right there and you missed it.
Emilia Jones has played characters with simmering angst/pain/discontent. She's pretty, and then there's this turmoil underneath the surface. In Locke and Key it's her grief and trauma. In CODA it's her isolation and resentment. It looks like Cat People will be about unease and discomfort. Anyway, she's really good with layers.
Emilia Jones had always given me huge Barbra Gordon vibes, that fiercely intelligent and really mature for her age feel. I'd say Alcock for Kara and jones for Babs!
Recently James Gunn has said that most of the stuff we''ve been hearing in the rumour mill is not true, except for one thing, it might be one of these actors for Supergirl.
@@smashallpots1428 Paired with the right gordon i think it would work yeah (Upright her other tv show she played a daughter-figured to an older male co-star and it was totally believable).
I'm not a DC fan whatsoever. But even I have to admit the Supergirl comic that Gunn is adapting is spectacular. It's a shame we have a small but loud minority of people who think Supergirl is a character that's not relevant because she's a woman and because of other absurd reasons.
A casting I thought of, who, from what I've heard would be interesting is Euphoria's Hunter Schafer, from what I've heard about Euphoria her character gives a similar energy to Kara in Woman of Tomorrow, just thought that would be interesting. Not to mention adding a dash of diversity into the cast with a trans woman would be pretty cool
I think Kiernan would be great to sell Kara’s smartness and wit (if you watched CAOS, you know what I mean) but I don’t know about the physical aspect of it. Maybe they can work on the suit department to make her look more intimidating ??
Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow is my most anticipated movie from the new DCU, and while i really wanted Kiernan Shipka as Kara too, i'm okay with either of the actresses that screen tested for the role. I agree that Meg Donnelly makes the most sense to be chosen. Also, while the Supergirl show was mostly ok, Melissa Benoist was amazing as Kara, so i'm hoping the new actress will bring the same energy. Also, i really want to get the comic to read it but it's constantly out of stock. People are buying it like crazy. Now i'm patiently waiting to come back so i can get a copy too.
I read it. It's not great. It basically has Supergirl as a side character in her own comic. It's basically True Grit in sci-fantasy space with a teen girl named Ruthie wanting to avenge the death of her father and goading Kara into helping her (which is reluctant about at first, but gets serious about it after the bad guy shoots her dog and steals her spaceship).
Milly Alcockk is my top pick. That actress has so much incredible range that its not even funny, and her two biggest roles feel exactly how I feel Supergirl should feel and be like. I absolutely love her and I hope she gets the role of Kara.
alcock = most well known donnelly = looks like supergirl the most jones = best actress my choice is jones as just dye her hair blonde and i believe she'd kill the role of supergirl in gunn's dcu
I mean the comic premise kinda calls for it, milly has definitely shown up for an awards show wasted more than once she was clearly method acting for this role haha.
In watching the scene with Rhaenyra walking back to camp during the great hunt. I can totally see Milly in the role. Slap an S on her chest in that scene and that's the jaded Supergirl Gunn is going for.
I’m late to this, it will get buried, but I gotta say, after the “how to replace Kang” video, I was like, “do we use the crossing and just reset the MCU that way?
Of these 3 I'd go with Donnelly easily. But I agree that Kiernan Shipka would be an interesting choice, she definitely has some edge to her as we saw especially in Totally Killer.
I have seen Meg Donnelly in both the Winchesters and in HSMTMTS… and I’ll be honest, I haven’t seen from her enough to make me think she can be the lead of this blockbuster movie. That doesn’t mean that she couldn’t! It just means that I haven’t seen it yet, whereas I know Alcock, Shipka, and Jones could.
I think Milly has the most potential to give a really cool performance that contrasts against a more wholesome, traditional Superman. That said, Donnelly has a great look, some bonafides with the character, and some of that same quality from the days of the early MCU where these lesser known actors were being plucked from off the Hollywood bench to become superstars. I’d also be very interested to see someone with her stature as the smallest of the bunch in a powerhouse role. The rest I’m sure could give competent performances but just don’t seem to bring anything special to the table for this character.
I know the number that is out there is 5' 5 for Milly but she's definitely 5' 2 at most which makes her my least favorite out of the three. Supergirl needs to have some sort of stature. Sasha is 5' 7 and Melissa 5' 8, would be a drastic decline in terms of height. Acting wise, Emilia is the best followed by Milly
Hey Nando, what do you think of Alan Ritchson batman? He's expressed interest and I personally think It'd be great so long as he can lose a little muscle and dye the hair.
he's 41 right now and the if dcu batman movie doesn't happen until 2027 or 2028, he'll be in his mid 40s and way too old to be first introduced as a batman in this new film universe ... corenswet is comparison is 30 right now and i think gunn said his superman and batman will be around the same age so i expect any actor who gets the role of the dcu batman to be in his early to mid 30s at the oldest
I haven't seen anything Amelia has been in so I can't say much about her, Millie was good in House of the Dragon, but Meg I think is my favorite of the 3 I'm a massive Supernatural fan (currently on my 13th rewatch) and she was great in The Winchesters she does have that Supergirl edge, plus she's already played her
I like her over Megan. Meg traditionally looks the part but Milly legitimately feels alien, and I mean that in the best way. She stands alone. Which i think will lend itself to the character
The only reason I don't want Mily Alcok as Super Girl is because some time ago, I saw a fan casting of her as live action Spider Gwen and I really want that to come true
While I've not seen anything any of them have done aside from Meg's animated Supergirl thing, I agree that all 3 of them would be awesome Supergirls. That said, I've sort of already fancast Milly as the MCU Gwen Stacy, I'm the least familiar with Emilia, and I'm not quite sure Meg has the right sort of vibes for this version of the character, but again, I still think any of them would still be awesome in the role. Also, I agree, we do need the Fantastic Four casting ASAP, especially with them setting filming for it in just a few months.
I've just read Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow on Nando's recommendation and it's amazing! I think Gillian Jacobs would be perfect but she might be a bit too old now
Man, imagine them making a Fantastic Four movie without actually deciding who to cast. We just never see faces lmao. Vin Diesel, for how not amazing he seems as a normal actor, is shockingly great at voicing characters so that's probably my Ben Grimm lol. Let's pretend he's not already in the MCU.
Sight unseen I would pick Milly but whoever has the best audition process should supercede obviously, may the best gal win. (and not *that* Gal) (when this movie was first announced my first thought and tweet was "you know who'd crush this, milly alcock" if it happens you're welcome haha)
I hope it's someone new. Someone who truly looks like Supergirl. So far, I think all the people talked about don't really look the part. As in, they would be nobody's first choice.
Meg Donelly would be perfect. Emilia Jones would be ok. And Milly Alcock would be a perfect choice for a character I would love to see in the DCU but probably wont be which is Artemis Crock.
My picks: Melissa Benoist = Supergirl Charlie Hunnam = Aquaman David Corenswet /Henry Cavill (preferred) = Superman Aldis Hodge= Green Lantern (John Stewart)...I also think he could play T'Challa, but Black Twitter wouldnt allow that lol Alexandra Daddario = Wonder Woman Brenton Thwaites = Nightwing Richard Madden = Batman Finn Wittrock= The Atom Taron Egerton = The Flash Stephen Amell = Arrow
The right choice is Milly Alcock... she would give all the necessary tone to the character no one else wants the character with a landscape face without personality and crying in the corners like the CW one.... the fable that the voice actor plays well should have guaranteed Class an Oscar, right? I don't remember any aliases... in short, dubbing is not acting!
I like Meg but the version they are going for it’ll be milly which I’m fine with because I been reading woman of tomorrow on dc infinite it’s really good
Isn’t she also going to be Abby in season 2 of the last of us, so clearly Hollywood thinks she can play vengeful, and she’s already been supergirl so she’s the pick for a vengeful supergirl
Molly Alcock can literally play anyone. She’s a very young and gifted actress, but I have to say, what a miss, if Sony hasn’t already contracted her for a live action Gwen Stacy. I do think she would do good with Warner Bros as well, although that is her original family, so I’m sure they’ll treat her right too. Then she’s the perfect age already for Supergirl, so in the end it’s a win-win for Molly.
I feel like if you had watched The Winchesters you might feel differently. I just never felt like she never quite got in the groove doing that show and I didn't believe her performance. Might not have been the actress; could've been the writing... It's hard to say.
That doesn't to me cause while Meg is the current voice of the character none of the Creature Commandos actors previously had that type of role at least not for the most part
@@veggiewillymass What I mean is that knowing she’s capable of voicing the character gives her such a huge advantage here. From what I understand about voice acting, just because you can act in live action doesn’t mean you can do adequate voice work. But, I could be wrong here
Obviously not Nando, but it could go either way. It really depends on how they want to do the Multiversal stuff for DC when they get around to it since Power Girl is a Multiversal Supergirl. Do they want to do it more like having most or all of a characters Variants be the same actor, or do they want to go more in the direction of each Variant is played by someone different. Basically, it's too soon to tell, but potentially yes and potentially no.
Don't get me wrong but why do you say that race-swaping and gender-swaping a character or as some people call it "checking the boxes" is being creative?? I personally think finding actors that look like and resemble the characters as they are in the comics is even harder.
Plus you created "why ?" questions , if you want to represent communities ( which is not a problem ) use the characters that are already in that community or create new ones, that way you have a character that you can do whatever the f you want , that way everybody wins (well majority but that's normal) the community is represented the left group is happy and the right group will be " well we have a new character for the left group , but they didn't change a character just for politics , that's win " .
There was a black Batman and I thought that was a great comic ... he's the son of Lucius Fox and takes the mantle after he dies and Bruce takes him under his wing
I hope it's not gonna be a girl boss feminist movie. We've seen how Marvel and Star Wars crashed and burned. Just make a good story. Have her have flaws and learn to overcome them in a hero's journey.
Milly has some incredible range and definitely has more of an edge to her I can see her bringing to the version of Supergirl from the inspired comic.
I agree. Shame about her giant mouth though
Plus she looks like she can be related to David's Superman which is a huge deal
@@Chuck_ELI don't really agree at all. My suspension of disbelief is not challenged by aliens looking like they're related in the same way that humans are
Yeah I'm an Irish boy with black cousins, even from a human perspective there'd be no reason to give a shit if someone's cousin doesn't look like them. I know black and white siblings with different parents even, it's not insane for family to look different. Much more important is that they can make us feel as though they're family with their performances. @@drainstorM11
Agree 100%, plus she has a fan base that will go see a movie with her in it regardless of genre. I don't know if the other two can pull people in who are not comic book fans.
I love how comic accurate James goes with his casting.
I still can’t get over how perfect his Jimmy Olsen casting is.
(also knowing that Meg voiced Supergirl…they should pull Jensen Ackles Batman from that same universe)
jensen did a bad job voicing batman
@@womanfan5328 your lying to yourself if you legitimately think that.
@@grbhighlights9401he has no emotion in his voice at all. reddit tier casting.
@@womanfan5328 someone never watched Batman: Under the Red Hood lmao
The Jensen casting seems odd even tho he voiced the role. It seems uninspired tbh.
I hope for Meg Donnelly. Woman of Tomorrow is my second most anticipated DCU movie now.
considering they've stated that they will be keeping the actors the same across live action and animated, it seems extra relevant for meg since she's already proven she can do voice work.
If so, wouldn't that mean Jensen Ackles is the new Batman? But also, Darren Chris isn't the Superman for Superman Legacy.
@@ProjektTaku no since they’ll be largely recasting for voice actors when they cast live action. supergirl would just already have both bases covered. also i’m down with jensen as batman could be fun
@@ProjektTaku Corenswet will voice superman in animated things now as well as long as it’s all in the new Gunnverse
@@dingus2k when was this confirmed?
@@ProjektTaku way back when they announced james gunn as the head of DC
Meg Donnelly would be a fun Supergirl, she could toe that line of sweet and bubbly, and badass and tough… that would be dope
Especially at 9:26 that's Kara Zor El to a T
And she already voiced her
Not to mention, James gunn said most actors in both live action and animated will be the same because its in the same dc universe.
I want to believe that this audition was to check if meg can play Kara in live action because the animated story is tied up to the dcu then go to other candidates if she cant do live action well.
She already plays that with Addison so it would have been perfect
I know it’s only the first month but I’m loving 2024 so far.
Nando extremely common W with the predictions. Milly is amazing and I can't wait to see her perform.
Casting actors that look like the characters they are playing from the comics this man is so dope at running DC
Dog whistle....
@@TheStormbringer8751 idk I can't hear it see I'm not a dog but race swapping is lame and character assassination not all characters need to be changed for no reason at all
@@DavidRogers-t7h But no one has talked about changing ALL characters. And so far nothing has changed at all. You're celebrating nothing so far. And if you get your way, you'll be celebrating a "Whites Only" sign in the year 2025....
@@TheStormbringer8751 no Im Mexican so your wrong white characters that are White in the source material should be played by white actors black characters should be played by black actors why change the characters race that's what you are changing the characters race character assassination black washing race changing in The Hunger Games Rue is black so she was played by a black actress no let's just change her race she is played by a white girl now do you like any of that? No I don't think so
I cannot believe you did not being up Meg Donnelly’s most iconic roll in Z-O-M-B-I-E-S (2018) and Z-O-M-B-I-E-S 2 (2020) and Z-O-M-B-I-E-S 3 (2022) where she literally plays an Alien. Perfect connection right there and you missed it.
Facts
Emilia Jones has played characters with simmering angst/pain/discontent. She's pretty, and then there's this turmoil underneath the surface. In Locke and Key it's her grief and trauma. In CODA it's her isolation and resentment. It looks like Cat People will be about unease and discomfort. Anyway, she's really good with layers.
Her story arc in Locke and Key is a reason why I think she’d be a good pick for the Supergirl they’re doing
it would be wild to see addison from zombies cast as super girl
Not really tbh
Emilia Jones had always given me huge Barbra Gordon vibes, that fiercely intelligent and really mature for her age feel. I'd say Alcock for Kara and jones for Babs!
Recently James Gunn has said that most of the stuff we''ve been hearing in the rumour mill is not true, except for one thing, it might be one of these actors for Supergirl.
I picked up Woman of Tomorrow solely based on your rec. Not normally a comic reader aside from some niche things. Thanks!
Milly Alcock is my Barbra Gordon
hmm, not bad actually
@@Aussie27Legend i like her a lot for the new 52/rebirth design which is easily my favorite batgirl design
@@smashallpots1428 Paired with the right gordon i think it would work yeah (Upright her other tv show she played a daughter-figured to an older male co-star and it was totally believable).
I'm not a DC fan whatsoever. But even I have to admit the Supergirl comic that Gunn is adapting is spectacular. It's a shame we have a small but loud minority of people who think Supergirl is a character that's not relevant because she's a woman and because of other absurd reasons.
She's my top 3 favorite female superhero she's awesome
I'm not marvel fan
No one thinks that bcuz she’s a woman
You should become one, great characters and stories.
How can you not be a DC fan?
They have the best characters
A casting I thought of, who, from what I've heard would be interesting is Euphoria's Hunter Schafer, from what I've heard about Euphoria her character gives a similar energy to Kara in Woman of Tomorrow, just thought that would be interesting. Not to mention adding a dash of diversity into the cast with a trans woman would be pretty cool
Her smile is very reminiscent of Melissa Benoist.
I wish. (still pulling for her to be zelda)
@@Aussie27Legend never thought of that but yeah she looks just like Zelda wow
@@LiableFilm She herself pitched it! (unlikely to happen sadly, for reasons, but it would be perfect)
@@Aussie27Legend that sounds awesome but yeah I do doubt it'll happen, but I've been surprised before
I think Kiernan would be great to sell Kara’s smartness and wit (if you watched CAOS, you know what I mean) but I don’t know about the physical aspect of it. Maybe they can work on the suit department to make her look more intimidating ??
Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow is my most anticipated movie from the new DCU, and while i really wanted Kiernan Shipka as Kara too, i'm okay with either of the actresses that screen tested for the role. I agree that Meg Donnelly makes the most sense to be chosen. Also, while the Supergirl show was mostly ok, Melissa Benoist was amazing as Kara, so i'm hoping the new actress will bring the same energy.
Also, i really want to get the comic to read it but it's constantly out of stock. People are buying it like crazy. Now i'm patiently waiting to come back so i can get a copy too.
I read it. It's not great. It basically has Supergirl as a side character in her own comic. It's basically True Grit in sci-fantasy space with a teen girl named Ruthie wanting to avenge the death of her father and goading Kara into helping her (which is reluctant about at first, but gets serious about it after the bad guy shoots her dog and steals her spaceship).
Milly Alcockk is my top pick. That actress has so much incredible range that its not even funny, and her two biggest roles feel exactly how I feel Supergirl should feel and be like. I absolutely love her and I hope she gets the role of Kara.
Congratulations! 🎊 . Milly has been officially casted as supergirl
@@matthewlee4697 I know. I'm so happy right now.
@@HerbCoswellBornAgain I'm happy too! 😊👍
alcock = most well known
donnelly = looks like supergirl the most
jones = best actress
my choice is jones as just dye her hair blonde and i believe she'd kill the role of supergirl in gunn's dcu
jones doesn't have blue eyes
Milly Alcock Supergirl would cuss you out. I think that would be good
I mean the comic premise kinda calls for it, milly has definitely shown up for an awards show wasted more than once she was clearly method acting for this role haha.
It's called swearing not cussing.
What are you like 50?
3 great choices honestly
Congratulations to Milly Alcock. Looking forward to seeing what she does with the role.
I'm all in on Meg. Rooting for her
In watching the scene with Rhaenyra walking back to camp during the great hunt. I can totally see Milly in the role. Slap an S on her chest in that scene and that's the jaded Supergirl Gunn is going for.
Milly Alcock is now confirmed
I was hoping Halston Sage would be casted as Kara Zor-El/Supergirl
Out of all the choices ,Milly has the edge, range and substance to pull it off!
I’m late to this, it will get buried, but I gotta say, after the “how to replace Kang” video, I was like, “do we use the crossing and just reset the MCU that way?
You and that Fantastic Four cast 😂.
Oh man Kieran Shipka would be great!
Of these 3 I'd go with Donnelly easily. But I agree that Kiernan Shipka would be an interesting choice, she definitely has some edge to her as we saw especially in Totally Killer.
The F4 shade at the end 😂
We might get two separate Supergirl live actions castings before an MCU Fantastic 4 cast
I have seen Meg Donnelly in both the Winchesters and in HSMTMTS… and I’ll be honest, I haven’t seen from her enough to make me think she can be the lead of this blockbuster movie. That doesn’t mean that she couldn’t! It just means that I haven’t seen it yet, whereas I know Alcock, Shipka, and Jones could.
I think Milly has the most potential to give a really cool performance that contrasts against a more wholesome, traditional Superman. That said, Donnelly has a great look, some bonafides with the character, and some of that same quality from the days of the early MCU where these lesser known actors were being plucked from off the Hollywood bench to become superstars. I’d also be very interested to see someone with her stature as the smallest of the bunch in a powerhouse role. The rest I’m sure could give competent performances but just don’t seem to bring anything special to the table for this character.
I would’ve liked to have seen Lili Reinhart as Supergirl. She’s a very talented actress and looks the part.
Meg is just perfect
I just think Milly has the more interesting look.
I know the number that is out there is 5' 5 for Milly but she's definitely 5' 2 at most which makes her my least favorite out of the three. Supergirl needs to have some sort of stature. Sasha is 5' 7 and Melissa 5' 8, would be a drastic decline in terms of height. Acting wise, Emilia is the best followed by Milly
Hey Nando, what do you think of Alan Ritchson batman? He's expressed interest and I personally think It'd be great so long as he can lose a little muscle and dye the hair.
Hahaha he'd be the first Batman that would have to lose muscle for it
@@jonbonjour4 Or just stay as he is and be a physically scary Batman.
@@jaegerwhatifs4679 I mean that works too! Although I wonder how believable he would be gliding around Gotham in full Reacher Mode
he's 41 right now and the if dcu batman movie doesn't happen until 2027 or 2028, he'll be in his mid 40s and way too old to be first introduced as a batman in this new film universe ... corenswet is comparison is 30 right now and i think gunn said his superman and batman will be around the same age so i expect any actor who gets the role of the dcu batman to be in his early to mid 30s at the oldest
I can see it if theyre going for TAS like Batman, he was a machine
I don't think I've ever seen a actor or actress has gotten a live action role because they voiced a character. I may be wrong. Milly is my choice.
Katee Sackhoff as Bo-Katan
@@jamesboston Touche
Milly Alcock looks like the perfect Ruth to me.
I really want milly as Supergirl ngl
I’m still in the camp that they cast my pick for Supergirl: Henry Cavill
Isn't this supergirl from the comics suppose to be older and more mature which is why shes in space on this quest.
I mean, I'll be fine with whoever they cast. So far, I have liked all the casting for the DC.
I haven't seen anything Amelia has been in so I can't say much about her, Millie was good in House of the Dragon, but Meg I think is my favorite of the 3 I'm a massive Supernatural fan (currently on my 13th rewatch) and she was great in The Winchesters she does have that Supergirl edge, plus she's already played her
I like her over Megan. Meg traditionally looks the part but Milly legitimately feels alien, and I mean that in the best way. She stands alone. Which i think will lend itself to the character
The only reason I don't want Mily Alcok as Super Girl is because some time ago, I saw a fan casting of her as live action Spider Gwen and I really want that to come true
I think a female booster gold would be awesome! Keep the personality and all!
I have little faith Marvel knows how to save the MCU without a complete reboot. It is wild that they let it go to shit so quick after End Game.
Milly would be a great Supergirl. Beautiful and definitely has edge.
Meg Donnelly is the best pick of the three. Like you said, since she's the safest pick, Gunn will probably pick her.
Nando, where is ur pc wallpaper from?
While I've not seen anything any of them have done aside from Meg's animated Supergirl thing, I agree that all 3 of them would be awesome Supergirls.
That said, I've sort of already fancast Milly as the MCU Gwen Stacy, I'm the least familiar with Emilia, and I'm not quite sure Meg has the right sort of vibes for this version of the character, but again, I still think any of them would still be awesome in the role.
Also, I agree, we do need the Fantastic Four casting ASAP, especially with them setting filming for it in just a few months.
Milly.
Why is no one talking about the actress who played Ciri from The Witcher series, Freya Allan? She is my best bet to play Supergirl.
This video made me excited for Meg Donnelly but I'm still team Shipka
I've just read Supergirl Woman of Tomorrow on Nando's recommendation and it's amazing! I think Gillian Jacobs would be perfect but she might be a bit too old now
When they cast Zantanna, I think Gillian would kill it
As a huge Zantanna fan, I can't wait til she makes her big screen debut
Give me Milly
Man, imagine them making a Fantastic Four movie without actually deciding who to cast. We just never see faces lmao. Vin Diesel, for how not amazing he seems as a normal actor, is shockingly great at voicing characters so that's probably my Ben Grimm lol. Let's pretend he's not already in the MCU.
Sight unseen I would pick Milly but whoever has the best audition process should supercede obviously, may the best gal win. (and not *that* Gal)
(when this movie was first announced my first thought and tweet was "you know who'd crush this, milly alcock" if it happens you're welcome haha)
I hope it's someone new. Someone who truly looks like Supergirl.
So far, I think all the people talked about don't really look the part. As in, they would be nobody's first choice.
I think Milly is perfect for the role tbh
I think Meg is probably the front runner, but I feel like her Supergirl isn't really the Supergirl from Woman of Tomorrow.
It's definitely Milly Alcock for me.
Meg was also in Disney’s zombies which is her biggest and most notable role that she’s still playing idk how u skipped that
Also American housewife
Meg Donelly would be perfect. Emilia Jones would be ok. And Milly Alcock would be a perfect choice for a character I would love to see in the DCU but probably wont be which is Artemis Crock.
Sydney Sweeney could make a pretty great power girl
For two obvious reasons lol
@@tehronmoment1367She's blonde and what else?
@@TheStormbringer8751 her tits bro
@@TheStormbringer8751Balloons.
If nando had it his way , hed cast seth Rogen as supergirl ...
Yes, that's probably true. Somewhere in your head.
My picks:
Melissa Benoist = Supergirl
Charlie Hunnam = Aquaman
David Corenswet /Henry Cavill (preferred) = Superman
Aldis Hodge= Green Lantern (John Stewart)...I also think he could play T'Challa, but Black Twitter wouldnt allow that lol
Alexandra Daddario = Wonder Woman
Brenton Thwaites = Nightwing
Richard Madden = Batman
Finn Wittrock= The Atom
Taron Egerton = The Flash
Stephen Amell = Arrow
The right choice is Milly Alcock... she would give all the necessary tone to the character no one else wants the character with a landscape face without personality and crying in the corners like the CW one.... the fable that the voice actor plays well should have guaranteed Class an Oscar, right? I don't remember any aliases... in short, dubbing is not acting!
I like Meg but the version they are going for it’ll be milly which I’m fine with because I been reading woman of tomorrow on dc infinite it’s really good
im starting to get weirdly early
I think Milly would make a great Ruthye
When are we getting Batman and robin actors that is the one I am most curious for
someone asked james gunn that on twiter a while ago and he responded "not any time soon"
We'd have till at least next year if the movie coming out 2026/27
@@_N4T hopefully it comes out 2026. But if I’m being honest. Probably 2027 cause the Batman part 2 comes out 2025.
Isn’t she also going to be Abby in season 2 of the last of us, so clearly Hollywood thinks she can play vengeful, and she’s already been supergirl so she’s the pick for a vengeful supergirl
Molly Alcock can literally play anyone. She’s a very young and gifted actress, but I have to say, what a miss, if Sony hasn’t already contracted her for a live action Gwen Stacy. I do think she would do good with Warner Bros as well, although that is her original family, so I’m sure they’ll treat her right too. Then she’s the perfect age already for Supergirl, so in the end it’s a win-win for Molly.
Maybe Sony did contact her to play Gwen Stacy. And she said 'No'. Like a sane person would.
I never understood the whole need to do race swapping. It's SO disrespectful to the original character
Thank the lord this man nando has no casting power in hollywood 🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌
I feel like if you had watched The Winchesters you might feel differently. I just never felt like she never quite got in the groove doing that show and I didn't believe her performance. Might not have been the actress; could've been the writing... It's hard to say.
I’d prefer Milly from HOD
Didn’t James Gun also say he wants the same actor to do live action and voice in the animated projects? To me, that almost guarantees Meg will win
That doesn't to me cause while Meg is the current voice of the character none of the Creature Commandos actors previously had that type of role at least not for the most part
But it's a different universe right? Maybe he will think twice about mixing all that
@@veggiewillymass What I mean is that knowing she’s capable of voicing the character gives her such a huge advantage here. From what I understand about voice acting, just because you can act in live action doesn’t mean you can do adequate voice work. But, I could be wrong here
@@alexcgarciag See my most recent comment
Hey Nando, do you think when casting Super Girl, we need to consider we're also casting a potential Power Girl at the same time?
Obviously not Nando, but it could go either way. It really depends on how they want to do the Multiversal stuff for DC when they get around to it since Power Girl is a Multiversal Supergirl. Do they want to do it more like having most or all of a characters Variants be the same actor, or do they want to go more in the direction of each Variant is played by someone different.
Basically, it's too soon to tell, but potentially yes and potentially no.
Posted 3 minutes ago
Okay, look this is gonna sound leftist af, but his casting is the most white I've ever seen one of these universes
i’m a huge fan of , if it doesn’t add to the character , why keep default white
Don't get me wrong but why do you say that race-swaping and gender-swaping a character or as some people call it "checking the boxes" is being creative??
I personally think finding actors that look like and resemble the characters as they are in the comics is even harder.
Plus you created "why ?" questions , if you want to represent communities ( which is not a problem ) use the characters that are already in that community or create new ones, that way you have a character that you can do whatever the f you want , that way everybody wins (well majority but that's normal) the community is represented the left group is happy and the right group will be " well we have a new character for the left group , but they didn't change a character just for politics , that's win " .
Meg mypick or house of dragon 2 pick
is pedro pascal really mr fantastic and eddie munson really johnny:(
We have no idea. Those are the rumors going around, but we don't have any definitive yes or no on those.
Unrelated but on the race swap topic. I keep getting an itch for an Asian American Batman…idk why. Just something my brain thinks is cool
There was a black Batman and I thought that was a great comic ... he's the son of Lucius Fox and takes the mantle after he dies and Bruce takes him under his wing
Charles Melton would be great for that
I hope it's not gonna be a girl boss feminist movie. We've seen how Marvel and Star Wars crashed and burned. Just make a good story. Have her have flaws and learn to overcome them in a hero's journey.
But people will still call it woke.
Book looks bland af, story and dialog is probably boring to reading the summary is probably more exciting and straight to the point.