Ranking the BEST 35mm and 120 Film | Tier List
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 7 ต.ค. 2019
- Every 35mm and 120 film I think is worth shooting, ranked.
Thank you to Squarespace for sponsoring this video, if you'd like to try out their service you can do so here: squarespace.com/negativefeedback
Make your own version of the Tier List: tiermaker.com/create/film-190...
Support us on Patreon: / negativefeedback
Video recorded on Sony A6500
Music from Bensound: www.bensound.com/royalty-free...
Social Media:
/ negativefb
/ negativefb
George:
/ gmuncey
/ g_muncey
/ gmunchiez
www.georgemuncey.com/
Not only is this 30+ minutes of rambling - There's an additional video going up TOMORROW
NegativeFeedback we dont deserve you
yes!
You got the ColorPlus and Gold cut aways the wrong way. I'm assuming it wasn't intentional
What about Kodak Pro Image 100 !!!!
i made it! also yeah pro image 100 is a film ive never seen reviewed and was considering doing reviewing myself so surely do a video covering that.
Me: *Sees my photo on the Velvia slideshow*
George “No for me”
Me *cries inside*
420 likes - *nice*
“Some people think u can shoot portraits with it **silent pause that rings into the abyss** but they’re wrong”
A green screen? Damn, the budgets really been going up around here
Just you wait for my next hollywood future classic "Shooting film ON THE MOON?!"
NegativeFeedback oh I’m ready
it's pink screen duh
It's the formula in action :)
"maybe i should've done more research but here we are"
- me with any workload
11/10 relatable vid
"however" Count = 3287
However
@@NegativeFeedback 3288
the suit was a great choice.
dressing for the occasion is important
I must admit, it made me sit up and pay more attention.
Needs a slim abstract tie. I will buy you one. Viva la tie. Or Viva le tie ?.
He's really evolved to a top tier memester, god bless you.
This isn't even my final form
@@NegativeFeedback oh dear
What a time to be alive
Meme well gergo
waiting, watching, cheering this meme career.
Wow! George's top film selections are the same films I used to photographed with. And that was nearly 20 years ago. Thank you George and to the rest of you youngsters who are keeping the art of film photography alive. Never let it die!
You mixed up Gold and Colorplus when showing those instagram hashtags.
are you surprised hes a youtube photographer.
my film tier list:
1. Kodak Colorplus 200
2.
3.
reason: i'm a cheapskate.
This guy gets me.
Same but I would also put ultramax as no:2 because for me it is $5 for a pack of 3
100ISO Foma though
Same, but replace it with Kodak gold 200, because I can buy it cheap locally, heh
I understand your point very well ... but if you are a real "cheapskate", you should try the Kodak Vision 3 250D in ECN-2 process (at home). Buy in large quantities and start bulkloading. You save big money - even compared to Kodak Colorplus 200. Then you have more than one option...
Calling something BTEC is one of the most british things of all time. You made me smile 😅
#notallBTECs (I did mine at Bournemouth Arts Institute. We got to do Sinar workshops at the Swiss HQ. Sooooo amazing)
edshotsdotcodotuk can't polish a turd
Memes and film... really the bridge between past and present lol thanks george
Ektar 100, fuji acros and fuji xtra 400 are underrated, but thats only my opinion
Becksi agreed, really enjoyed my own results w these films
fuji xtra 400 is the GOD
Ektar 100 Ektachrome E100 and Velvai 50 were all way too underrated and Portra was way over rated
Superia X-tra 400 is literally nectar from the God’s
Acros II is god tier. Incredibly sharp and not expired
i've never heard the term "poor man's portra" and i love that
Really cool that you put this together - the ending killed me by the way. Thanks for the videos!
It's only just occurred to me that the reason it's called XP2 is because it's Cross Processed (XPRO)...
its always been good when somebody tried it all and get the review done :D thanks mate!
George u went ham on this one and it’s amazing. You really did it to us with the editing. Thumbnails have been amazing lately too lol.
Kodak Gold is like 8€ for a 3-pack in Germany
where?
Francis Bombus DM and Rossmann
found www.dm.de/kodak-200-color-negativ-film-135-36-3-filme-a-36-bilder-p41771880804.html
@@tobim3447 Danke
Kodak Gold 👍🏻 instagram.com/p/B3NnvhvF0Dq/
31 MINUTES OF NF? Thank you!
Easily the best Squarespace plug I've seen, I can't argue with that tier list either
Stopped watching after you rated Color plus as a god tier. I just wanted to make sure you placed it in its proper spot
Acros 100 is above God tier due to its reciprocity characteristics for long exposure photography. Also, when developed in Rodinal it shows no grain.
Agreed. Acros was definitely God tier. I'm really hoping the new Acros will be as good as the old.
The Science of Photography would rodinal be better for acros than ID11 stock? Have you tried it?
@@girmonsproductions I personally think that Rodinal (sometimes branded as Adonal or R09) is the best developer for Acros 100. I develop semi stand for 60min with 1:100 dilution (semi stand = 3 initial inversions, let sit for 30 min, invert 3 times, let sit for last 30min)
The reason is that rodinal does not contain solvents that cause a smoother grain, but make you lose sharpness. It is a high acutance developer so it normally would increase grain size, but doesn't impact slow films that much (Acros 100, Delta 100, Pan F 50). Don't use Rodinal for films faster than 100 ISO.
I have never tried the ID-11 with Acros, but I do know that ID-11 behaves in a similar way to Kodak D-76. It's a good all around developer, but i feel that it does not produce the finest grain on these fine grain films.
Rodinal only comes as a liquid so if you are in a part of the world that has difficulty with liquid chemical shipping then I think XTOL (which is available as a powder) would be a better choice than ID-11.
Hope that helps.
Provia is the same, i use it for all night star trails not even a colour cast and if it does its a nice blue look.
@@TheScienceofPhotography oh I see, I used to use R09 stand dev for 400 speed films and I did not like that at all. so I switched back to 1:50 / 25 but now recently been using ID11 ( 1:1) and I sort of liked it, but I got 5L of ID11 so Im gonna try to use just the stock because I like the results from that. Once I will run out of ID11 I will try Xtol or DDX
Loved the video ! Always enjoy your perspective on film
Dude. Thanks for the video. You explained films better than anyone I know! Great one!
I go back and watch this again once inn a while. It is just so incredibly useful! Thanks.
Excellent and very helpful overview, George. Totally agree with much of that.
“Dressed for the occasion” LMAO
Brilliant insight into films, can't comment on a lot of the films you have rated but can say I 100% agree with the Velvia Provia decision. Thanks for posting.
This was hilarious, thank you. (I made it to the end, listening to you for the most part)
Very informative. Great video to watch like all the ones you make.
Loved it mate. Very insightful and saved me a lot of time
Where my Pro Image 100 madlads at?
Not widely available in the USA, only imports. So if it doesn't exist in the States then It's not considered. Proimage 100 is available only for third world countries, (like my country Mexico :P) cuz does not need low temp
renewii it’s widely available in europe and the us now. I just got a pro pack in the US
@@renewii Damn this man really be dissing my country New Zealand
@@jkerman5113 we all buying at bhphoto anyway dude--I love my local but I'm not paying $25NZD for a roll of tri-x
@@robinsonick Yeah - do you buy in bulk? Because the 20nze shipping fee isnt that kind for small amounts (or that portra with free shipping i guess)
Adox CMS 20 II is my favourite black and white landscape film, but I never hear anyone talk about it, would be nice to see it given some credit.
Pro 160 NS is not discontinued, it's just only sold in Japan and Oceania. This summer I shot my first rolls of it and I found out it is favourite colour negative film. In Australia it cost around €33 for a 5-pack 120 which is pretty affordable. Shipping is pretty expensive, fortunately I know some people that go there on holiday and will take me some.
Pretty much agree on everything except I think you’re having a mad one on Velvia, I’m guessing it’s just not your style. People like Charlie Waite and David Ward have made incredible work on Velvia
Blown away by this quality content. I'm here for it. I completely agree with you in regard to Portra, though I use Portra160 since I live in the desert.
Just the thumbnail killed me 😂 Great info and fun setup!
This is so amazing because it's so useful. Thank you!
such a fun comparison George…never got my hands on a clean well stored portra nc, but the search never stops :)
Made it to the end ! Wow ! Thanks for this and I know much is personal preference for sure . Like the TriX vs HP . Myself I’ve been shooting hp , I like how it handles shadows better. Also been shooting Portra 400 . Did shoot portra 800 a while back but haven’t developed it yet .
Thanks, it was interesting to see your point of view about all those films.
Recently started shooting film and my jaw almost hit the floor when you said Colour plus was £2.75 a roll 3 years ago. It's about £14 a roll around here. I pretty much just shoot portra and hardly experiment with others as they all seem similarly extortionate.
not even a mention for agfa vista. shame on you
As far as we're aware (in the UK) it has been discontinued 😔
@tyvek05 yeah, not fresh though!
@@matchat86 It's been discontinued for well over a year now, from what I understand. Still worthy of being ranked imo!
its fuji c200
also agfa apx
Really enjoyed the video, great to see what you rate these films. I've always enjoyed shooting ultraMax over gold.
The new formula of Lomochrome Purple is actually fantastic. I have a video comparing it with real Aerochrome if you want to check it out.
Kodak Gold is actually my favourite colour neg and over exposed Portra 800 is my favourite Portra film!
Velvia 100 (not 50) is also underrated. Fuji 160ns is still available in Japan and Australia! Acros is goodtier!
Rollei Retro 400s is great too!
Most B&W film is panchromatic. Orthochromatic film is the other type and can be developed with a red light on without ruining the film.
This is quality content thanks george 😀
This was highly entertaining. I stopped counting the amounts of time I laughed out loud. Your comedic timing is starting to show.
So glad you put lomography 800 in god tier. That’s my go-to.
For film you’ve missed, I shot a roll of ‘film never die IRO400’ the other day and was pretty happy with the results
I've got to thank you again for this one, George. I don't shoot film that often, and when I'm about to order some, I find myself coming back to this video as a reference. The only thing I might disagree with you about is 400TX. Our labs are very consistent, and back when I used to process that film myself I found I could get very consistent results. I had no such issues as you mentioned. If I wanted really strong grain and that striking contrast, it was Tri-X every time. But... Now my top two are the same as your top two. Basically, because since I don't shoot that often, and 36 exposures per roll means that quite different situations might arise from the start to the end of one roll in my camera, just how awesome those two films do at shooting nearly anything makes them my go-to choices.
Love this vid and the fresh ‘do. Funnily enough I have half a roll of Ektar in my K1000 that is killing me rn as I’ve avoided shooting with it until I’m next in a field or something. I largely agree with you although recently Fuji Superia 400 in my Yashica t5 has been one of my favorite combos (for the exact ‘disposable’ feel you mention) and would have ranked higher for me. Keep it up George!
I just discovered your channel and I'm already in love 30 seconds in.
I have ascended I reached the end
Axel Gerber welcome to heaven
@@NegativeFeedback Welcome to The Good Place
NegativeFeedback thank you based george
Very helpful video. Thanks!
George, was sorely disappointed at a lack of party in the back growth update
24:10 that is nice to hear since I just ordered a bulk roll of it yesterday.
amazing editing!!!!!!!! do more of these
£2.75 for colorplus 200 just 3 years ago? Damn I picked the wrong time to start shooting film... 😵
I honestly really enjoyed this and I really agree with most of the ranks
Personally I think shooting portraits with ektar 100 can be really cool, when you have a hard and saturated light situation for example at sundown. The pictures I took were absolutely gorgeous and the colors were super vibrant. Of course it's up to the photographer's style and preference but I would totally use ektar 100 again for portraits.
Thank you very much George!
Great video. I watched it while scanning negs. Very enjoyable
lowkey got hype when you were looking through the ekachrome hashtag and i saw my photo haha.
Totally with you on the Lomo 800. It's amazeballs.
I would put CineStill 800T in "amazing". It's probably my favourite daylight film with a warming filter. Super wide latitude and gorgeous colours. Crazy expensive, though. I also love the Fuji Industrial 400, but that's hard to get a hold of in Europe.
Also already loving the mullet.
very nice and informative! thx mate!
I was hoping to see Agfa Vista but then i realized that you didn't included the "ultra god" tier... :(
this was awesome - thx!
I watched everything till the end. I don't shoot film yet but i am gonna save this thing for later. VEry informative. Thanks for putting this together.
@Dominik I am sure I will have a better grasp after starting shooting film but I don’t think this was a waste of time.
favorite video so far !
My 3 favourite films are Colorplus, portra 400 and HP5! Glad they made the God tier! Haven't used lomo 800 so will defintely check it out!
Made it to the end, I dig 🤘🏻
Thanks for this, I don't shoot much colour so it is interesting to hear from someone who uses it frequently. FWIW my first couple of rolls of Ektar 100 came back really muddy and grim, bit of a gamble.
In terms of what is not on your list but I would include:
Ilford Delta 100 is my current favourite film, just beautiful and I have some gorgeous prints from it;
Kodak P3200 beats the socks off Delta 3200;
Kodak Pro Image 100 is my favourite colour stock;
Rollei IR 400 is all kinds of R72 fun and I love an infrared landscape;
Ilford SFX 200 for those lovely black skies and more sharpness than the Rollei;
and I have had fun with novelty films like Revolog and Yodica, which tend to use Kodak stock I believe.
I was so not ready for that mid video Squarespace Feat. haha
Thanks! Great, well done
Made it till the end and enjoyed it!
Kodak P3200??? (It’s a no for me btw)
LOVED this video. I watched the whole thing from beginning to end. Loved how your list absolutely reflected your shooting style as all the films that you put in God and Amazing were color films, aside from HP5.
I’d be curious to see other photographer on TH-cam do a list like this one.
Great video!!!!
here to the end! thank you!
I want to see videos about expired films!
Very helpful, thank you! :)
Great video! In Japan we can get other film you didn’t mention. btw you can still buy Fuji NS160 in 120rolls here in Japan. You can ask big camera they may ship it to England!? Great job with the video.
I wanted to post this yesterday before you made it private : You said color plus but you were showing images hashtag Kodak gold and when you were talking about Kodak gold, you showed color plus.
Perry I was just gonna say this, it’s good I read your comment before I did!
This video is a work of art
I made it to the end and I was ironing since you were wondering. Good video, thanks!
Georgie-boy you've achieved comedy
I’m just glad colorplus is a god, also this video is in god tier when it comes to 30 min long videos
No Kodak Pro-Image 100?? Super underrated film in my opinion! Great nostalgic feel
Also, Ultramax is better than OK for sure.
My two favorite films I'd say!
Darn! This is a cool video on film. I have some expired film rolls of Fuji Reala, Fuji Astia, Fuji X-TRA 800 and Portra (160, 400 & 800) sitting in my fridge and I don't know what to do with it since I have sold my Voigtlander Bessa R3A + CV 40mm f/1.4 M-Mount years ago.
Hey George. You might have forgotten Kodak Pro Image 100. Here in Brazil we use it a lot. Nice nice video btw
I've never used it myself, not many stockists in the UK carry it. I might pick up a roll and give it a go soon though
@@NegativeFeedback oh, I see it. I recommend you to search results of Pro Image 100 pushed to 1600 iso. The colors look pretty good
Watched this video waiting for my car to be serviced. Thank you for helping me pass the time!
“It’s in purgatory”- George
Aye, poor lomo purple - seemed like such a fun idea at the time. Maybe a sun drenched summer on a fabulous coast would've created more pleasing results (all round lol), but a cool damp season in the UK really didn't do it any favours. Can safely say won't be using it again, maybe gift the remaining rolls to someone I hate lol. Saying all that much more excited by the metropolis (?) stock there bringing out next - pledged for 10 rolls of that...
Memester style? yes please. Other than that I can agree on most parts. Maybe put ektar100 into good? Other than that godlike content again, bigup!
Fujifilm Acros 100II both 135 and 120 is selling here in Japan, have not tried it yet as I still have a load of the original I bought just before it went away. I always push Acros to 400, that is the look I enjoy the most. I only hope the new version looks the same
This is such a good video I love your content! It’s helped me so much with film photography! Thank you so so much!
Awesome video! Only thing I might change is bumping Fuji Acros 100 up to Amazing. I think it's a really underrated film and have a good stash of it in my fridge still :D It's super flexible and I've had plenty of success shooting at ISO400 when needed and even some decent results at 800.
Great, fun video. Largely agree, and am pleased you were brave with your HP5 / TriX decision. My key changes would be Pan F 50 up to Amazing or God. Niche for top quality b&w studio portraits. Also you need to try Agfa APX 100, a poor mans Acros IMHO.
I was looking for a comment on the Pan F 50 ;) It's my favourite
I miss Delta 100, Rollei Retro 80s and 400 in your list (all of them great films). Mostly agree with all of your thoughts, but I think Acros should be considered higher due to the lack of reciprocity failure and contrast rendition. Fun video :)
The thumbnail is amazing 😂😂😂
Hi George, I'd love to know how these scans were achieved!
What I assume are 6x6 medium format shots on Ektar 100 seem to have unreal detail in them, better than I see out of my medium format negs.
I think you did lomochrome purple dirty.. tsk tsk
Not sure I'd put Velvia in "no" but it definitely has some drawbacks, one being its pretty expensive, and two, its hard as heck to shoot. Way less forgiving than Portra or pretty much any color negative film and if you underexpose it has a sort of blueish overcast look to it. But tbh totally agree with the rest of these thoughts!