Recorded live at Expo Studiotheater on Friday, March 13th, 2009. Vocals: Elmar Ferner Guitar: Niklas Turmann Keyboards: Jochen Pietsch Bass: Michael Schugardt Drums: Momme Boe
Unbelievable that they guys were essentially a “one off” project. They are arguably one of the best Genesis cover bands EVER. They make this song look effortless. And the ACTUAL band struggled playing this
Very, very good 👍. Seen one I think is a little better, by Crucible-- you can search it here on YT. This still is "A" for the video. I'm impressed with any band that will even attempt this song. Genesis stayed away from it, as it was too difficult live.
I’ve searched for good live versions of this song. This is hands down the best. What I would give to have been able to watch Phil play this. I can only hope there is Genesis vault footage from the studio somewhere someday.
Nice live versions by Genesis themselves do exist. They dropped it early during the 1978 tour. Perhaps because it's very straining on the voice. Phil clearly struggles. Good versions: Bloomington, Dallas rehearsal. O.K. version: Malmö, Sweden. Just search it here on YT.
Listened to it again, 2 weeks later. Before I start, I'd like to say I am a Genesis nerd and have trawled TH-cam well after being in the bootleg scene many years ago. Not that I am the best judge in the world, but i've seen many covers as well as the original band many times. This is easily the best cover I have seen of this song. You don't see Down and Out covered much, because it's not the for casual listener or player - a tough song and IMO perhaps the most underrated of all the harder Genesis songs, it's an overlooked classic by even many hardened Genesis fans because of the period the song was released and the production of the album in general. Anyway, this is easily the best cover version I have heard over the last 20 years and is up there with the real thing (I personally think it's as good as they did on the tour, musically and production wise) - everything is great, keyboards especially. You guys did a fantastic job, well done!!!
I watch every Genesis tribute and they're all good (not for beginners) but I've got say The Farm are my favourite. First, their singer is the best imo and secondly they love the band's music in the transitional phase post-Hackett and even Phil's solo stuff. Whilst the Hackett era is my favourite, there's so much guts and energy on the post ATTWT/Duke material.
The beauty of Genesis is how they felt themselves at every step. They had Anthony Phillips at first and went along with him, Gabriel always present. After that, they added Collins and Hackett and did an amazing body of work for the RRHOF to induct them. After that, Collins, Rutherford and Banks went on producing Genesis in their own magnificent sound. What a pleasure it is to listen to musical talent like that!
Amazing on all regards. The live performance you love to see exist. The vocals are so similar to Phil, and they're too good to become a parody. The difficult high notes are belted just right. And then there were the drums of course, perfect, as are all the instruments. Yes, you did a great song a great service. Thank you.
Nailed it! Every part, every sound of every instrument was spot on. Special shout out to the drummer. This is one of the toughest Genesis drum parts in a long line of tough parts.
My freaking lord!!! 😮 You executed flawlessly a song from a band you are covering that struggled to perform this on the ATTW3 Tour. And they gave up on it. You guys made this look like a walk in the park. All of you are insanely talented and gifted!! Such an unbelievable performance! 👏🏻
@@themusicofgenesis Nearest version of Phil Collins voice I have ever heard. With Phil's voice gone it's great to hear this new version. Come to the US! (specifically Detroit)
I discovered your band a few weeks ago because I found your cover of , don’t lose my number, loved ‘ second home by the sea ‘ and you cover this song so well. I am a huge fan of PhIl Collins. Is this band still active? 😊
Amazing! I love to see young guys carrying on this music for a new generation. I doubt these gents were even born when the original album was released. I saw Genesis twice on that tour and twice on the Lamb tour. Lucky bastard!
How am I just now discovering this? “Down and Out” is one of my favorite Genesis tracks, and this performance is nothing short of brilliant. 5/4 is tricky, but you guys made it look effortless.
Best COver of this on the net... * * * * * Even better than Genesis' live recordings from 1978. Great job guys and keep rocking. -Your friend from the USA.
How wonderful is this! Wow what an amazing sound. It’s very rare for a tribute band to be this good. Every one of you are bang on the money. I would love to see you.
I closed my eyes while this brilliant track played. What cover band. I'd swear it was Genesis! Heavenly ear porn. Best memories are made on 'The Farm'.
It's good to be here! How've you been? Check my bags, boy! Where's my room? I sit on the phone, that's my game, Keep up the pressure all the way! I don't want to beat about the bush but none of us are getting any younger. There's people out there who could take your place. A more commercial view! A fresher face! I need a shower, take a nap I'll meet you in the bar, we must have a rap. There's a lot on the line, a lot to say. There's something I must tell you today. You and I both know the score, you can't go on like this forever. So it's with regret that I tell you now that from this moment on, you're on your own! I don't talk round corners, it's right between the eyes If you're slow they'll run past you, Stand tall, see them falling over. I walk a straight line, it's right between the eyes. Well show me the door, show me someone who'll do it better. The drinks are on me, be my guest. Smoke a cigar? Take the best. Don't hedge your bets, we can make a deal,you got it in your pocket, how do you feel? So glad that's over, now you know, but I'm only acting under orders. And looking down on you from way up here. You've got to sink or swim, get off the floor! I don't talk round corners, it's right between the eyes If you're slow they'll run past you, Stand tall, see them falling over, I walk a straight line, right between the eyes. Well show me the door, show me someone who'll do it better.
La mejor banda haciendo Génesis sin lugar a dudas. Muy buenos músicos y la mejor voz honrando a Phil Collins. No como las aburridas versiones sin gracia alguna de Steve Hackket y los bobos de los que se ha rodeado últimamente. Ésta banda es lo que siempre quise escuchar y hasta hoy jamás había encontrado.
MUY BUEN TRABAJO muchachos !!! Excelente...no tengo palabras!!! La tarea musical, la voz del muchacho que interpreta a PHIL COLLINS...!!! Me alegraron el día!!! Encima, que de esta canción GÉNESIS no dejó videos...😞, así que...ustedes me lo compensaron en buena medida !!!
@@melbman43 They did. But not for long. Chester Thompson (the greatest drummer EVER in my never-humble opinion) struggled with the incredible complex meters and Phil Collins struggled reaching the high notes. High-quality boots are sadly lacking from this tour - the Dijon Soundboard is a spectacular exception, but sadly: No Down and Out. However, there is a reasonably good version from rehearsals in Dallas TX.
Fucking awesome, boys. Superbly done. Heresy, I know, but I've seen live versions of this fantastic song with less energy and passion played by the original Genesis himself. And the vocals.. oh My! I close my eyes and see Phil's voice! Amazing.
![[UNCUT] The Loyal Pin ปิ่นภักดิ์ EP.4 (4/4)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/d3l5rxl5CVo/mqdefault.jpg)
Unbelievable that they guys were essentially a “one off” project. They are arguably one of the best Genesis cover bands EVER. They make this song look effortless. And the ACTUAL band struggled playing this
Tony Banks has even said that there are lots of musicians that play his keyboard parts better than he ever could.
Best cover I've seen so far.......great
Very, very good 👍. Seen one I think is a little better, by Crucible-- you can search it here on YT. This still is "A" for the video. I'm impressed with any band that will even attempt this song. Genesis stayed away from it, as it was too difficult live.
It is an excellent cover indeed.
cttgaegoaktd
Check out David Hale - Genesis - Down and Out (Full Cover)
@@Tjoppy David Hale's version is most excellent - kudos to him and Chris O’Connell. But this is LIVE. One take. No fixing.
I’ve searched for good live versions of this song. This is hands down the best. What I would give to have been able to watch Phil play this. I can only hope there is Genesis vault footage from the studio somewhere someday.
Nice live versions by Genesis themselves do exist. They dropped it early during the 1978 tour. Perhaps because it's very straining on the voice. Phil clearly struggles. Good versions: Bloomington, Dallas rehearsal. O.K. version: Malmö, Sweden. Just search it here on YT.
The balls on you all to play this live and then to pull it off! Fucking hell!!!!
Listened to it again, 2 weeks later. Before I start, I'd like to say I am a Genesis nerd and have trawled TH-cam well after being in the bootleg scene many years ago. Not that I am the best judge in the world, but i've seen many covers as well as the original band many times. This is easily the best cover I have seen of this song. You don't see Down and Out covered much, because it's not the for casual listener or player - a tough song and IMO perhaps the most underrated of all the harder Genesis songs, it's an overlooked classic by even many hardened Genesis fans because of the period the song was released and the production of the album in general. Anyway, this is easily the best cover version I have heard over the last 20 years and is up there with the real thing (I personally think it's as good as they did on the tour, musically and production wise) - everything is great, keyboards especially. You guys did a fantastic job, well done!!!
Thanks for writing the Gettysburg Address.
@@larrylanberg3552 Sorry Larry, I didn't realise you had a word limit. If I had only known.....
@@larrylanberg3552 The Gettysburg Address is, of course, famously short.
Superb cover. Great sound.
This is live? Good heavens, what a stunning performance. Seriously.
Wish these guys would tour the US
I watch every Genesis tribute and they're all good (not for beginners) but I've got say The Farm are my favourite. First, their singer is the best imo and secondly they love the band's music in the transitional phase post-Hackett and even Phil's solo stuff. Whilst the Hackett era is my favourite, there's so much guts and energy on the post ATTWT/Duke material.
The beauty of Genesis is how they felt themselves at every step. They had Anthony Phillips at first and went along with him, Gabriel always present. After that, they added Collins and Hackett and did an amazing body of work for the RRHOF to induct them. After that, Collins, Rutherford and Banks went on producing Genesis in their own magnificent sound. What a pleasure it is to listen to musical talent like that!
For the love of all things sacred, this KILLS! Almost effortless for such a tricky song. Amazing!
Amazing on all regards. The live performance you love to see exist. The vocals are so similar to Phil, and they're too good to become a parody. The difficult high notes are belted just right. And then there were the drums of course, perfect, as are all the instruments. Yes, you did a great song a great service. Thank you.
They are by far the best Genesis tribute band ive ever heard . Please come to the uk .
Amazing. 'Deep in the motherlode' please. 😊
...in progress 😬🙏
Amazing musicians, and one of the most beautiful voices I've ever heard!
I love And then there Were Three, and this is a great song, and a truly superb rendition by the Farm.
cttgaegoaktd
That was great!!!!!! I wish I could see the band live!
That is a great performance, they nailed it completely.
This makes the material off this album seem way more powerful. Credit to these performers.
Brilliant ,period.
I am blown away by their sure accuracy!
Honestly, this is the best version of this song I've heard, well done guys!!
Awesome drummer
Its a complicated song!
Best cover I've heard. Keep up the good work guys!
Best live version of this song i have ever heard! Brilliant!
Nailed it! Every part, every sound of every instrument was spot on. Special shout out to the drummer. This is one of the toughest Genesis drum parts in a long line of tough parts.
My freaking lord!!! 😮 You executed flawlessly a song from a band you are covering that struggled to perform this on the ATTW3 Tour. And they gave up on it. You guys made this look like a walk in the park. All of you are insanely talented and gifted!! Such an unbelievable performance! 👏🏻
Cracking band and brilliant performance. My favourite track from And Then There Were Three.
So good...... Wish this band would tour.
Never say never... 😉
@@themusicofgenesis Nearest version of Phil Collins voice I have ever heard. With Phil's voice gone it's great to hear this new version. Come to the US! (specifically Detroit)
I discovered your band a few weeks ago because I found your cover of , don’t lose my number, loved ‘ second home by the sea ‘ and you cover this song so well. I am a huge fan of PhIl Collins. Is this band still active? 😊
I keep returning to this. So, so good.
Amazing! I love to see young guys carrying on this music for a new generation. I doubt these gents were even born when the original album was released. I saw Genesis twice on that tour and twice on the Lamb tour. Lucky bastard!
My very favorite post-Hackett tune of Genesis.
Fabulous! Especially given the fact this was live. Only very good musicians could pull this off - bravo!
My favourite genesis track. So intense & those drums ❤️❤️❤️
It is a great song alright.
cttgaegosktd
Fantastic version, one of early faves
As a genesis expert and studio drummer you guys nailed it
thanks bro! 🙏
thanks bro! 🙏
Awesome! Incredible!
This is (to me) a complex song, but you guys look so relaxed!
What a talented bunch you all are.
Fantastic! Very faithful to the original! Great musicians & great vocals! My favorite Genesis Song!
E X C E L L E N T !
Formidable !
Bravo !
Phil from Dunkirk
Never heard that live - great!
First time I have heard a cover for this song. Really well done. Thanks you for keeping this song alive!
Great job. The drumming is phenomenal.
Wow just wow!!!!!
great band , great singer. He has a boddy language of a Rapper / guy of hip hop ATTWT is one of my fave albuns
WTFFFFFF EXCELENTE MUCHACHOS..... LOS FELICITO, aplausos mil!!!
OMFG - this is out of this world.
One of THE best Genesis covers of.all.time.
Just awesome guys, well done!!!!!!!!!!
My god, that was amazing.
They will com back in September '24 in Husum/ northern Germany. Google!
superb!
This is incredible. Amazing song and playing !!
They are the best Genesis trbute band I've heard . Great stuff . Please come to the UK
How am I just now discovering this? “Down and Out” is one of my favorite Genesis tracks, and this performance is nothing short of brilliant. 5/4 is tricky, but you guys made it look effortless.
Boy you guys were fantastic. Super fantastic.
What a performance!! Epic! A masterpiece of a song. Highly underrated in my opinion.
Amazing version.!!!!!!
wow that was great!!---and the best song on the album but rarely played except for when the album came out
Best COver of this on the net... * * * * * Even better than Genesis' live recordings from 1978. Great job guys and keep rocking. -Your friend from the USA.
Agree!
How wonderful is this! Wow what an amazing sound. It’s very rare for a tribute band to be this good. Every one of you are bang on the money. I would love to see you.
Fantastic!!!
superb!!!!!
Great cover! The Song is very difficult ti play👏👏👏👏👏
Wow amazing playing GENESIS
Stupid Covid. These guys need to tour!
amazing version. finally a band that also performs less famous songs... I'm eagerly awaiting HEATHAZE from DUKE.
Fine performance 👍👏👏👏👏
I closed my eyes while this brilliant track played. What cover band. I'd swear it was Genesis! Heavenly ear porn. Best memories are made on 'The Farm'.
This is fantasic...such a hard song to play live...genesis gave up on TTWT tour...so total respect for playing it...great sound
What an incredible cover
he's even doing the phil hand gestures while singing
Close your eyes and see Genesis
Owww!!! So great!!!!
guys this is pretty amazing and you are great. Keep on.
It's good to be here! How've you been? Check my bags, boy! Where's my room? I sit on the phone, that's my game, Keep up the pressure all the way! I don't want to beat about the bush but none of us are getting any younger. There's people out there who could take your place. A more commercial view! A fresher face! I need a shower, take a nap I'll meet you in the bar, we must have a rap. There's a lot on the line, a lot to say. There's something I must tell you today. You and I both know the score, you can't go on like this forever. So it's with regret that I tell you now that from this moment on, you're on your own! I don't talk round corners, it's right between the eyes If you're slow they'll run past you, Stand tall, see them falling over. I walk a straight line, it's right between the eyes. Well show me the door, show me someone who'll do it better. The drinks are on me, be my guest. Smoke a cigar? Take the best. Don't hedge your bets, we can make a deal,you got it in your pocket, how do you feel? So glad that's over, now you know, but I'm only acting under orders. And looking down on you from way up here. You've got to sink or swim, get off the floor! I don't talk round corners, it's right between the eyes If you're slow they'll run past you, Stand tall, see them falling over, I walk a straight line, right between the eyes. Well show me the door, show me someone who'll do it better.
Such a great cover of an underrated song! It sounds very near to the original, which is not an easy job (I think).
Incredible musicianship once again.
Excellent
THE BEST GENESIS BAND!!! THE BEST ONE!!!
excellent!
Nice job guys… you can tell they did this for the love of the music
GOOD JOB!!!
Phil's gestures is over there :D
La mejor banda haciendo Génesis sin lugar a dudas. Muy buenos músicos y la mejor voz honrando a Phil Collins. No como las aburridas versiones sin gracia alguna de Steve Hackket y los bobos de los que se ha rodeado últimamente. Ésta banda es lo que siempre quise escuchar y hasta hoy jamás había encontrado.
MUY BUEN TRABAJO muchachos !!! Excelente...no tengo palabras!!! La tarea musical, la voz del muchacho que interpreta a PHIL COLLINS...!!! Me alegraron el día!!! Encima, que de esta canción GÉNESIS no dejó videos...😞, así que...ustedes me lo compensaron en buena medida !!!
Thank you for performing and sharing this classic. Bravo to this very talented group!
The closest to "Collins sound",excellent band!!
A parte l'indiscutibile bravura dei singoli è incredibile la somiglianza dei suoni, degli stacchi e della voce. Bravissimi!
Whoa, that kicked ass...
Probably the best video recording on youtube even better than Genesis's 1978 live recording. Das Gut!
Such a difficult song to play .Genesis themselves gave up after a few "and then there were three" tour dates . So congratulations guys
So they actually DID play it live?
melbman43 yeah they played it quite a few times apparently until giving up. Such a shame! Amazing song ❤️🧡❤️
@@melbman43 they gave up because of the vocals. Phil couldn't reach the higher notes every night
@@acex90 I never knew that, infact I've never herd the band talk about it at all.
@@melbman43 They did. But not for long. Chester Thompson (the greatest drummer EVER in my never-humble opinion) struggled with the incredible complex meters and Phil Collins struggled reaching the high notes. High-quality boots are sadly lacking from this tour - the Dijon Soundboard is a spectacular exception, but sadly: No Down and Out. However, there is a reasonably good version from rehearsals in Dallas TX.
The keyboards sounds almost like 1992 tour, so it's a well imagination of what would this song sound like in the WCD Tour.
its perfect, thank you so much! chapeau!
Todos excelentes músicos! Congratulations! Venham ao Brasil please!
wow! outstanding job!
Excellent guys
Excellent.
Somebody just shared this in a Genesis group. All I can say is HOLY SHIT!
Fucking awesome, boys. Superbly done.
Heresy, I know, but I've seen live versions of this fantastic song with less energy and passion played by the original Genesis himself. And the vocals.. oh My! I close my eyes and see Phil's voice! Amazing.
Очень сложная партия для барабанщика. Спасибо парни, очень мощно сыграно.
Epic. Spot on.