Bye dear Peter can i give you a generational talent? Morissette Amon. listen to her sing, on an FM radio Wish 107.5 LIVE. Rise up (removed from the WIsh channel because it had more views than the original), Never Enough 44 million views, Akin kana Lang (original song)151 million views, Secret Love Song 190 million views. her voice cannot be explained, you have to listen to her to understand.🤷♂ all live, without cunning, auto tuning or lip syncing. you won't believe your ears.😊
The gap in the songs, that you will find out later, is because these guys are brilliant dancers. So the songs are composed with that in mind. That should be something new for you 🤣🤣 Eventually it would be amazing if you reacted to a live. Their ability to have stable voices while dancing it one of the things that makes them who they are. 😘💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
Jimin (orange microphone) is a contratenor. Jungkook (purple microphone) is a first tenor Jin (pink or sometimes white microphone) is a second tenor, but he can get just as high as Jimin or Jungkook but also hit lower notes like he does in their song Dionysus. V (green microphone) is a baritone, but has a solid falsetto which allows him to also sing tenor in many of their songs. He tends to use the baritone a lot more in his solo songs. J-Hope (red microphone) is a rapper but also considered a Sub-vocalist as they tend to use his baritone for harmonies in a lot of songs. Suga (black microphone) and RM (Blue Microphone) both mostly rap, but do sing baritone in a few songs. Suga sometimes likes to sing to harmonize with his own raps, putting it farther back in the mix so it’s more subtle and enhances, rather than distracts from his rapping. (Since he produces most of his own songs) All 7 members write songs for the group, and Suga, RM, J-Hope, and sometimes Jungkook produce them. Although I should note that their three all English songs were written by outside song writers.
Hey friend I'm still holding out for a Mike Patton analyses. He is Home free and Voice Play all by himself. His range,versatility and talent is unmatched. He sings all genres of music and does voice overs for horror movies and creatures for video games. He is a true free range vocalist. He's fronted six bands and numerous solo projects From Jazz, disco standards,pop ,opera to rock ,R&B All metal genres ,hip hop,rap,punk classical and others. One of my faves is his Mondo Cane concert in 2011 singing in Italian.An absolutely beautiful show to witness. There are many singing compilations showing his amazing talent. His rabbit hole goes deep and travels many different tunnels. Its a 100% real rollercoaster ride. You will be astonished. You might have to get a friend to pick a good video of his singing compilations. There are so many its hard to choose one because they are all great. Thanks.
@@kinetic4475 Perhaps Jimin is not a true counter tenor, but your information is incorrect. Contra Tenor is, in fact, the correct original term. Encyclopedia Brittanica says: "Countertenor, also spelled Contra Tenor, in music, adult male alto voice, either natural or falsetto. In England the word generally refers to a falsetto alto rather than a high tenor. Some writers reserve the term countertenor for a naturally produced voice, terming the falsetto voice a male alto." (And your comments about Jimin seem a bit shady. None of the bts members are classically trained singers, but that doesn't mean they aren't well trained - just because he didn't receive voice lessons before debut doesn't mean he hasn't received any since then.)
Trust me, we don't mind the long reactions. We can sit through hours of reactions because we love hearing about the Tannies. You might not like their songs, but be respectful about it.
First of all, loooove your analysis + reaction! And yes bts debuted in 2013, but they didn't get famous immediately and it took them lots of hard work to get where they are now because they had to face numerous hardships...They actually first blew up in america around 2017!
i guess debuting in 2013 and being at the level they are now in 2022 can be named fast, but also just wanted to mention to you, that it wasn't easy. bts was in creation since 2010, the label was looking for the right members for the group for 3 years. those years were filled with serious training, 10-16 hours a day (and their work ethic never changed since). once they debuted, they faced strong oppression, being under a small label, trying to survive in a local music industry dominated by huge companies that don't play fair. there were a lot of hardships of their path, enormous amount of criticism and hate. all that being thrown at them just to bring them down, because people liked them and gravitated to them due to bts' message and values. there wasn't any breakthrough song for them, they didn't became stars in one day. fandom was growing gradually, but as it was happening, bts were treated as a threat by other big and rich labels that manage their own groups. every public persona gets hate, but double it in this case. this hate is organized and dedicated. boys been through a lot, but despite that never gave up on what inspired them to make music: the desire to help people, to make the world a better and kinder place. they stay polite even if they are mad, they help others even when they are hurt. to the hate and disrespect they answer with music, never stepped down to those unworthy people. to love they answer with even more and better music: there are soo many songs dedicated to us, army. they never shy away from expressing how genuinely they love us and how they are thankful for our support. you will understand this relationship after spending some time with us, bts and their music "I always wanted to become the best, so I was impatient and anxious. To compare myself against others became my daily life, and my greed, which used to be my weapon, became a leash that chokes me. But then, looking back, actually, I feel like it’s not that I wanted to become the best. I wanted to comfort and move your heart. I want to take away your sorrow and pain" Magic Shop by BTS
@@erume5776 yeah right...I think he/she just only here to introduce the group he/she like which is I don't know them,lol. But take note he/she watch your video huh 😂
😭😭😭😭😭😭hiiii there..im a baby army i just know bts..5 months ago...I always cry and get hurt every time I hear their hardship stories from the past until now....
The singer with the blue hair, RM, is the leader of the group and the main rapper. He is the one who is most fluent in English. He taught himself to speak English by watching DVDs of the TV show Friends. He watched it first with Korean subtitles, and then with English subtitles and eventually taught himself English from the dvds.
I will suggest you to check their "Film Out" live too. That song is beautiful and V is the baritone while Jimin naturally have high pitch voice. They all have beautiful and unique voice.
I use "Bass Singer" because "Vocal Coach/Opera Singer/Music Producer/Bass Singer" would be too long for the title 😂Glad you appreciate my explanations!
@@PeterBarber now i know & heard what is key change ☺️. All this while im watching other vocal coach reactions & they screamed for the key change but i don't get it. Im not a vocal student or singer but i love listening to all of this and it added to my knowledge.
That short instrumental part is in the original song 😄 They'll usually do a dance break there on a live performance. They actually have choreographies for each of these songs, this Tiny Desk Concert is an exception in that they're not dancing. I'm sure you'd enjoy seeing them perform on a stage 🤩
This is the performance that made me fall in love with BTS and started my Army journey.. I remember thinking "Oh sh*t these guys are actually super talented!"...I must have watched it about 50 times and it's still one of my favorite performance of theirs! It really showcases their talent and uniqueness...as well as how frickin adorable they all are 🥰🥰🥰 P.S. I know "Bass singer" is in the title but I still got a shock when he started talking...so low 😂😂😂
You should really watch the parts when they talk as well. I feel like it’ll actually help when you’re trying to analyze their voices. You’ll also learn more ab them if you’re interested. We also like watching it. As much as ARMY loves watching people react to them for their craft, we also love watching their personalities as well
The instrumental breakdown is present also in the original track. However, keep in mind that this is a live "stripped-down" version, very different vibe from their concerts and also a way to keep it different from studio versions of their songs and therefore interesting. In the original track the producer was playing more with the EDM feeling, making the beat drop more of a dance break (as a lot of their song have really high energy choreography) while for this version they decided to render it a bit more groovy and let the instruments shine through a bit more. The band that is playing with them in the background is called Ghost. I'm not sure about the recent concerts, but for large sections of their tours they would be the go-to band to play at BTS' live shows. They are amazing musicians and completely changed my mind about some songs I wasn't a massive fan of, after hearing the live rendition. I think they complement BTS' energy on stage really well and again, make sure to switch things up just enough so that you feel like the concert is a different experience rather than just sit in your room and listen to the album tracks.
Thank you for reacting to BTS again. Tiny desk concert showcases their vocal ability and the dynamics of the band better. When you said there was a break, it’s usually bc they dance during that time. Your analysis and knowledge are always a breath of fresh air and I love to hear you dissect the artists’ vocals and the instruments playing. With you operatic background, you may like the Korean quartet Forestella. You could start with Bohemian Rhapsody or Nella Fantasia… just like Dimash, they are bringing a more operatic experience to the world of entertainment. If you want to hear more asian artists, you could check out Hua Chenyu’s “Nunchucks”, performed on the show The Singer where Dimash found international recognition. I can’t wait for your part 2 of BTS’s Tiny Desk concert!
Yay! Glad you are reviewing the tiny desk concert. Their live performances are what made me ARMY! For Save Me, there are dance breaks in the song for their choreo, which is a bit unexpected in a live band setting when they aren't dancing. The arrangement with the band has a distinct feel from the synth-EDM original
Loved the lengthy analysis, the insights are really appreciated. People really over-stigmatized autotuning to the point where discussing it is a much bigger deal than it actually is.
18:39 theres no tuning in that video ...thats genuinely their real voices. Jimin which is the one on the screen rn paused, he has the most unique, beautiful voice ive heard and i just love him so much.
As an interesting note, BTS are the only artists ever to have three songs charting simultaneously in three different languages: an English song, a Korean song, and a Japanese song. :) If you want to hear a single song with three languages in it, you should check out JHope's collab with Becky G for Chicken Noodle Soup, lol. That song has segments in English, Korean, and Spanish. I love the diversity.
You might react to "LIE" is a solo from JIMIN a BTS member. I think you might find interesting the combination of melody and vocal elements that he uses. The song is his composition, production and all the vocal elements used within made by him.
Hahaha the original version of save me is an EDM song with some wild dance breaks so they've converted the drops into those instrumental sections. Really enjoyed this! Looking forward to part 2 :)
I’m a year late to this reaction. I’ve watched your Pentatonix ones, but didn’t realize you also reacted to BTS until I saw your reaction to Jimin’s Like Crazy. I always enjoy your reactions, it’s always fascinating to hear from the perspective of a professional singer. What you mentioned about going back and forth between Korean and English - check out J-Hope’s Chicken Noodle Soup. It combines Korean, English and Spanish!
Thank you for this amazing reaction! Very interesting to not only see your reaction to the song and BTS' vocal abilities, but also have you break down so many of their choices. I love the fact that your reactions can have me learn something new about songs and performances I've seen a hundred times before. Really excited to follow your journey in getting to know BTS and can't wait to see the rest of your reactions to this Tiny Desk Concert!
One of the aspects of a typical BTS performance that you're (kind of) missing here is their dancing. K-pop emphasizes a full-package performance, and BTS goes HARD on that, so where you were expecting rap line to come in on "Save Me," there's a dance break. (And yes, they can also sing and dance at the same time. Their vocal stamina is INSANE.)
They are just perfect in vocals, Jungkook sings excellent for me, now on June 10th there will be BTS comeback, new era, new album and song for you to support views!!💜💜
One thing about ARMY, is that we don't mind long videos, like we also have multiples reactors who spend a good 2 to 3 hours doing livestreams on BTS. Also, I hope if there are rude comments, please don't take it to heart, some people do have tendencies to take everything wrong when it comes to BTS, while you are clearly explaining things respectfully and nicely. About their voice, what's most impressive is that they improve - their voices - over time. At the beginning of their careers (and first concerts), they were a bit scattered everywhere and despite everything they were already very good. V's voice (green mic), for example, he worked a lot - especially for Dynamite as you see, in 2020 - to reach high notes, and he succeeded. V possesses a low, deep baritone voice. His voice is not just deep. It's soft and has a warmth, bringing depth to any pop song he sings. He makes excellent use of his deep chest voice, head voice, mixed voice and falsetto, drawing on his sweet baritone voice, resulting in transitions so smooth you won't notice how wide his range is from a casual listen. Jin (pink mic) is called "Silvery Vibrato" or "Silver Voice" by the Grammys because the Grammy panel stated that although BTS Jin's voice may not be the fanciest, he has stable breathing and the ability to switch between singing techniques freely. Hence, they described Jin’s voice as “silvery”. He only started singing (for the first time) at the age of 20, and he not only changed his voice, but he totally transformed it, he can easily switch between head voice and true voice. Jimin (orange mic) struggled with his vocals especially during their tour for the "Wings" album, he struggled to know how to use his vocal chords at the time. Yet, with continued work, today he has a falsetto and head voice that have a unique tone that could only be produced by him. Above all, Jimin's high notes were assessed as naturally of a higher range for any adult male, like for their song "Let me know", where he can go as high as an A5 which is three notes higher than Jungkook's F5 in "ON" which is already a high note. The only one who we can say found it easier to use his voice naturally was Jungkook (purple mic), that's why he's the main vocalist, but also the most stable to sing and dance at the same time. He is often referred to as one of the best singers in the world. His voice is pure, with a perfect pitch and a crazy range. Jungkook has been ranked as one of the best singers and all-rounders in the industry since he has solid abilities and is able to express his vocal in performances that require high technical skills. Really, I have to say that the vocalists of BTS always amaze me, and those since their debut despite their struggles, it didn't come naturally but from continuous hard work and dedication. Special mention to J-Hope, the rapper with the red mic, who is also a sub-vocalist, we get to hear his voice singing nicelyfrom time to time. So there's "Let me know" which I mentioned above for Jimin's high note absolutely to see (it's a song that includes the whole group, so also the rappers), know that there is a live for that performance. For songs coming only from the vocal line, there are "House of Cards", "Butterfly", "Dimple" and "The Truth Untold", they are also performances live available for all of theses. Thank you so much for being that professionnal and respectful. Can't wait for the next parts and future reactions. 💜
I know you are focusing on the vocals, but I am excited for you to see a live performance where they are dancing and singing live! They usually have backing tracks because of all the movement but still sing live and it's amazing to see :)
Every vocal coach reacted to them couldn't believe their perfect singing and had doubts. They practiced for many hours. It's ingrained in their soul. As you get to know them you will understand that. They never take anything for granted. You can see their dedication through their works.💜 Also check out Indian singers' live performance(A.R.RAHMAN,SHREYA GOSHAL,SONU NIGAM,LATA MANGESHKAR),they will also surprise you. Solid vocals and different from western music. You will gain more music knowledge.
BTS DOESN'T USE AUTOTUNE OR LIP SING IT'S THEIR ACTUAL VOICE, THAT YOU ARE HEARING. IF I AM WRONG PLEASE ARMY CORRECT ME. THANKS. I'M AN ARMY SINCE MAY 2, 2018, I WAS 66 YEARS OLD NOW I'M 72 YEARS OLD AND TOTALLY LOVE BTS.
I really loved this video! When you finish resting to their tiny desk performance I think you’d like their 2021 Festa Room Live where they sing some extracts from their older and their newer songs!
That was wonderful! They were a bit better than my choir in high school. 😁 But that experience did give me a better appreciation of what Voctave did today! 💜💜💜
I was enjoying your reaction so much the end of the video surprised me 😭. This was fun to watch. Looking forward to the next part. Also, what you're seeing here and what I love about BTS is their voices are so distinct. Each member can sing the same thing and it's completely different.
First off, CONGRATS on the sponsors! Secondly, Yay to 2 parts! Now to song lol. Very funky, I like it very much. They have a great mixture of voices and sounds.
‘Film out’ live would be a great next reaction, or ‘your eyes tell’ because both really showcase their vocals. Also, I’m sure it’s been mentioned but the instrumentals in their songs (the gaps with no singing) is because they dance on stage so it’s used for dance and performance when sang live
Jhope (rapper) & Jungkook (singer) harmonies are always sound epic. These 7 guys are actually really amazing performers that they even sound this good even when doing very complex choreo.
Yeah in my opinion, the vocals sound slightly different for dynamite and the other two songs, so there might be some kind of little effect on the voices. I feel like that's kinda been the stylistic vibe for dynamite.
Ya it's confirmed that there is some tuning on just Dynamite. This is the version without if you're interested in the difference: th-cam.com/video/qqN4UWnfcQA/w-d-xo.html
I love your reaction and attention to detail. Glad a other singer gets to know BTS and some unique approach to music creation fresh for the Western world
I was so happy to see this pop up in my feed today. I loved the last analysis. One of the first thing I thought of last video was how I wished you would do the Tiny Desk Concert so I could learn more about their vocals as a non-singer. When you say we don’t need to be told they are good singer, the truth is that I did need to hear that. It is good to hear from a professional opera singer that they are good. Just because I like a singer does not always mean they are good singers. I think they are, but I have an untrained ear. I just went to check out your Dimash breakdown and will do a few others. Glad I found you. I am going to guess you will have many requests for FESTA live, so I will add my vote for that one as well.
If you want to hear more harmonies I suggest you to listen to "Life goes on" (MTV unplugged version). I also recommend "The truth untold" live (performed only by the vocal line) and "Blue & Grey (MTV unplugged version). Finally I suggest "BTS room live FESTA 2021" to get a taste of various songs. You won't regret it!😉 p.s. I think it's very interesting to listen to the rap line's songs too beacuse they have very unique voices and styles. maybe it's not your field but you should give it a try. Bye
jin has a solid chest voice (pink mic). first time listening to bts, i picked him as my bias cos it hits me different when people sing on chest voice. but yeah, great catch on everything. they're all wonderful vocalists and i can't wait to hear more bts from you. 💜
thank you so much for your analysis! bts are my favorite artists and even though i don't know music in a professional way i learned a lot with this video!! keep it up :)
If you react to their huge concert, you will realize they don't do auto-tunes or live editing. There are fan-cams of live concerts where instrument sounds are removed and you can tell that they dont make auto tunes. Their mic are, however, costumized and made of gold. Their polished performance are result of hours and days of practice and rehearsals. They don't stop until they perfect their performance. They are all hard working perfectionist artists.
@@priiifrg why the rudeness? What i mean is live tone editing. If am wrong in uding the term autotunes, why the rudeness? You could hsve been heloed uf yiu educate me instead. I may not be tech-savy but i know tenor, bass and baritone. I know notes and pitches. I know what this reactor is talking about and i like his reactions because i watch opera, orchestra concerts and ballet. I guess you're right, we are of different wavelength. Take care and love yourself, ✌️
I love how detailed your reaction i think now you should check thier Japanese songs live wich are one's of my favorite and you will see other quality in thier voices my top 3 : film out, your eyes tell and let go
They can sing the same well while dancing crazy choreos btw. Also they debuted in 2013 so it's been almost 10 years before they've been actually started to treat seriously by the industry. Their popularity was growing in a very organic way to the point they finally couldn't be ignored. But it for sure wasn't fast : )
Glad you noticed the Ghost band. This is the first time they performed Dynamite with a live band. You appreciate them more when you find out how much training they had to go through to get them to this point. They each had a speciality when they were trainees but had to learn other skills throughout their journey (e.g, the rappers needed to learn to sing, several never danced before, etc.) Welcome to the BTS journey. Look forward to more of your critique...
Thanks for doing this video. What a cliffhanger! 😂 Never be afraid to do long videos with ARMY, we will watch lol. I literally just watched a 4 hour video of someone reacting to every one of their music videos. I really enjoyed your breakdown and cannot wait to see more. After the rest of Tiny Desk I recommend perhaps the live performances for House of Cards or Magic Shop and the 2021 Festa Room Live. Thanks!
Hi, I'm a new viewer from Indonesia. I'm a fan of BTS and also Voiceplay, since my son loves them so I use to hear them daily played in my house. And guess what, my son loves the bass voice, so his person of idol is more to Geoff and he practices his type of singing like Geoff does. Btw, I write a comment here to let you know I can't wait for the next part. And like any other army, yes, I don't mind if you upload more than an hour video, we'll still keep watching it, without any complaint. It's also valid with a lot of pauses happen in between. Thank you...
Hi Peter...a new subscriber here! Glad you're reacting to more BTS. They may not be the perfect artiste (no one is btw) but they are truly inspiring, positive young men that has bonded multi facet of people around the world through their artistry. You'll soon discover... and welcome to BTS World 💜
Hi Peter, it’s really nice to see some vocal analysis from an opera singer! I’m an opera student currently whos also a big kpop fan :) wondering if in your future analysis you can do a bit more in terms of variety of analysis? The analysis of chest vs mix vs head and things like chord closure is very insightful but I would also love to hear your thoughts on other musical aspects like how they use their diction or contrasting between different amounts of legato to express emotions and things like that!
I agree with you! There could be a little tuning in Dynamite, the first song in tiny desk. Probably because it's disco pop and there's some in the studio version as well. However, in the other 2 songs they sing later, it's not quite there.
Thank you for such detailed explanations and examples! If you do want to learn their names, go back and watch the speaking parts of Tiny Desk because their names are listed in the subs every time they speak. This is also a great vid for learning their names because they stay in the same formation the whole time (well, except when they get up cuz they're too excited lol.) Names left to right: j-hope (rapper) Suga (rapper) Jungkook/JK (vocalist) V (vocalist) Jin (vocalist) RM (rapper, group leader) Jimin (vocalist)
PART 2 NOW AVAILABLE: th-cam.com/video/YXmvetMv2CM/w-d-xo.html
great, ty
Bye dear Peter
can i give you a generational talent?
Morissette Amon.
listen to her sing, on an FM radio Wish 107.5 LIVE.
Rise up (removed from the WIsh channel because it had more views than the original), Never Enough 44 million views, Akin kana Lang (original song)151 million views, Secret Love Song 190 million views.
her voice cannot be explained, you have to listen to her to understand.🤷♂
all live, without cunning, auto tuning or lip syncing.
you won't believe your ears.😊
The gap in the songs, that you will find out later, is because these guys are brilliant dancers. So the songs are composed with that in mind. That should be something new for you 🤣🤣 Eventually it would be amazing if you reacted to a live. Their ability to have stable voices while dancing it one of the things that makes them who they are. 😘💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
@@sariel8406 who’s that? I’m interested to watch?
@@eamillie me too, which vocal coach, please? 🤣
@@sariel8406 are you talking about William Hostutler’s reactions? I’ve enjoyed his reactions also
@@sariel8406 same here wanna know who's that
@@eamillie William Houstler I think
Jimin (orange microphone) is a contratenor. Jungkook (purple microphone) is a first tenor Jin (pink or sometimes white microphone) is a second tenor, but he can get just as high as Jimin or Jungkook but also hit lower notes like he does in their song Dionysus. V (green microphone) is a baritone, but has a solid falsetto which allows him to also sing tenor in many of their songs. He tends to use the baritone a lot more in his solo songs. J-Hope (red microphone) is a rapper but also considered a Sub-vocalist as they tend to use his baritone for harmonies in a lot of songs. Suga (black microphone) and RM (Blue Microphone) both mostly rap, but do sing baritone in a few songs. Suga sometimes likes to sing to harmonize with his own raps, putting it farther back in the mix so it’s more subtle and enhances, rather than distracts from his rapping. (Since he produces most of his own songs) All 7 members write songs for the group, and Suga, RM, J-Hope, and sometimes Jungkook produce them. Although I should note that their three all English songs were written by outside song writers.
This! 👏🏽💜
RM co-wrote Butter too.
@@moonchild2556 RM co-wrote the lyrics for butter, but the actual song was written by someone else.
Hey friend I'm still holding out for a Mike Patton analyses. He is Home free and Voice Play all by himself. His range,versatility and talent is unmatched. He sings all genres of music and does voice overs for horror movies and creatures for video games. He is a true free range vocalist. He's fronted six bands and numerous solo projects From Jazz, disco standards,pop ,opera to rock ,R&B All metal genres ,hip hop,rap,punk classical and others. One of my faves is his Mondo Cane concert in 2011 singing in Italian.An absolutely beautiful show to witness. There are many singing compilations showing his amazing talent. His rabbit hole goes deep and travels many different tunnels. Its a 100% real rollercoaster ride. You will be astonished. You might have to get a friend to pick a good video of his singing compilations. There are so many its hard to choose one because they are all great. Thanks.
@@kinetic4475 Perhaps Jimin is not a true counter tenor, but your information is incorrect. Contra Tenor is, in fact, the correct original term. Encyclopedia Brittanica says: "Countertenor, also spelled Contra Tenor, in music, adult male alto voice, either natural or falsetto. In England the word generally refers to a falsetto alto rather than a high tenor. Some writers reserve the term countertenor for a naturally produced voice, terming the falsetto voice a male alto." (And your comments about Jimin seem a bit shady. None of the bts members are classically trained singers, but that doesn't mean they aren't well trained - just because he didn't receive voice lessons before debut doesn't mean he hasn't received any since then.)
Trust me, we don't mind the long reactions. We can sit through hours of reactions because we love hearing about the Tannies. You might not like their songs, but be respectful about it.
We love it
he is respectful
@@christinecrafts1578 general statement
@@christinecrafts1578 also he is professional and does great analysis
but he was respectful wdym
First of all, loooove your analysis + reaction! And yes bts debuted in 2013, but they didn't get famous immediately and it took them lots of hard work to get where they are now because they had to face numerous hardships...They actually first blew up in america around 2017!
i guess debuting in 2013 and being at the level they are now in 2022 can be named fast, but also just wanted to mention to you, that it wasn't easy. bts was in creation since 2010, the label was looking for the right members for the group for 3 years. those years were filled with serious training, 10-16 hours a day (and their work ethic never changed since). once they debuted, they faced strong oppression, being under a small label, trying to survive in a local music industry dominated by huge companies that don't play fair. there were a lot of hardships of their path, enormous amount of criticism and hate. all that being thrown at them just to bring them down, because people liked them and gravitated to them due to bts' message and values. there wasn't any breakthrough song for them, they didn't became stars in one day. fandom was growing gradually, but as it was happening, bts were treated as a threat by other big and rich labels that manage their own groups. every public persona gets hate, but double it in this case. this hate is organized and dedicated. boys been through a lot, but despite that never gave up on what inspired them to make music: the desire to help people, to make the world a better and kinder place. they stay polite even if they are mad, they help others even when they are hurt. to the hate and disrespect they answer with music, never stepped down to those unworthy people. to love they answer with even more and better music: there are soo many songs dedicated to us, army. they never shy away from expressing how genuinely they love us and how they are thankful for our support. you will understand this relationship after spending some time with us, bts and their music
"I always wanted to become the best, so I was impatient and anxious. To compare myself against others became my daily life, and my greed, which used to be my weapon, became a leash that chokes me. But then, looking back, actually, I feel like it’s not that I wanted to become the best. I wanted to comfort and move your heart. I want to take away your sorrow and pain" Magic Shop by BTS
Exo Better
@@exokings7849...and where is ur exo now?
@@exokings7849 probably not if you are here under bts video instead of watching exo content lol
@@erume5776 yeah right...I think he/she just only here to introduce the group he/she like which is I don't know them,lol. But take note he/she watch your video huh 😂
😭😭😭😭😭😭hiiii there..im a baby army i just know bts..5 months ago...I always cry and get hurt every time I hear their hardship stories from the past until now....
The singer with the blue hair, RM, is the leader of the group and the main rapper. He is the one who is most fluent in English. He taught himself to speak English by watching DVDs of the TV show Friends. He watched it first with Korean subtitles, and then with English subtitles and eventually taught himself English from the dvds.
I will suggest you to check their "Film Out" live too. That song is beautiful and V is the baritone while Jimin naturally have high pitch voice. They all have beautiful and unique voice.
Omg yes! This one's beautiful
Agreed. Film Out really shows off their vocals.
yes! film out live is top notch
Why you explain everything way better than "vocal coach" youtuber and you putting a lot of effort 👍💜💜💜💜💜💜💜
He is a real professional and very respectful
I use "Bass Singer" because "Vocal Coach/Opera Singer/Music Producer/Bass Singer" would be too long for the title 😂Glad you appreciate my explanations!
@@PeterBarber now i know & heard what is key change ☺️. All this while im watching other vocal coach reactions & they screamed for the key change but i don't get it. Im not a vocal student or singer but i love listening to all of this and it added to my knowledge.
A lot of vocal coach reactors on TH-cam don’t know what they’re talking about
@@bii-like-bee Truer words have never been spoken
The one who goes with a full chest voice,his name is KIM SEOKJIN(Jin) his voice is so powerful he is the belter of the group
Let's not forget Dionysus
True
And the only member praise by GP..😍
That short instrumental part is in the original song 😄 They'll usually do a dance break there on a live performance. They actually have choreographies for each of these songs, this Tiny Desk Concert is an exception in that they're not dancing. I'm sure you'd enjoy seeing them perform on a stage 🤩
when Save Me is performed on stage there's a dance section in that 'break' you didn't expect
This is the performance that made me fall in love with BTS and started my Army journey.. I remember thinking "Oh sh*t these guys are actually super talented!"...I must have watched it about 50 times and it's still one of my favorite performance of theirs! It really showcases their talent and uniqueness...as well as how frickin adorable they all are 🥰🥰🥰 P.S. I know "Bass singer" is in the title but I still got a shock when he started talking...so low 😂😂😂
Thank you for your lovely breakdown, and I'm awfully excited for Part 2 this upcoming week! 😊💜
You should really watch the parts when they talk as well. I feel like it’ll actually help when you’re trying to analyze their voices. You’ll also learn more ab them if you’re interested. We also like watching it. As much as ARMY loves watching people react to them for their craft, we also love watching their personalities as well
BTS have changed many people’s lives for the better, i am glad you’re reacting to them.
The instrumental breakdown is present also in the original track. However, keep in mind that this is a live "stripped-down" version, very different vibe from their concerts and also a way to keep it different from studio versions of their songs and therefore interesting. In the original track the producer was playing more with the EDM feeling, making the beat drop more of a dance break (as a lot of their song have really high energy choreography) while for this version they decided to render it a bit more groovy and let the instruments shine through a bit more.
The band that is playing with them in the background is called Ghost. I'm not sure about the recent concerts, but for large sections of their tours they would be the go-to band to play at BTS' live shows. They are amazing musicians and completely changed my mind about some songs I wasn't a massive fan of, after hearing the live rendition. I think they complement BTS' energy on stage really well and again, make sure to switch things up just enough so that you feel like the concert is a different experience rather than just sit in your room and listen to the album tracks.
Thank you for reacting to BTS again.
Tiny desk concert showcases their vocal ability and the dynamics of the band better.
When you said there was a break, it’s usually bc they dance during that time.
Your analysis and knowledge are always a breath of fresh air and I love to hear you dissect the artists’ vocals and the instruments playing.
With you operatic background, you may like the Korean quartet Forestella. You could start with Bohemian Rhapsody or Nella Fantasia… just like Dimash, they are bringing a more operatic experience to the world of entertainment. If you want to hear more asian artists, you could check out Hua Chenyu’s “Nunchucks”, performed on the show The Singer where Dimash found international recognition.
I can’t wait for your part 2 of BTS’s Tiny Desk concert!
Yay! Glad you are reviewing the tiny desk concert. Their live performances are what made me ARMY! For Save Me, there are dance breaks in the song for their choreo, which is a bit unexpected in a live band setting when they aren't dancing. The arrangement with the band has a distinct feel from the synth-EDM original
Loved the lengthy analysis, the insights are really appreciated. People really over-stigmatized autotuning to the point where discussing it is a much bigger deal than it actually is.
18:39 theres no tuning in that video ...thats genuinely their real voices. Jimin which is the one on the screen rn paused, he has the most unique, beautiful voice ive heard and i just love him so much.
there is tuning, there is no point saying there isn't their voices are amazing but there is clearly some tuning happening especially during dynamite
As an interesting note, BTS are the only artists ever to have three songs charting simultaneously in three different languages: an English song, a Korean song, and a Japanese song. :)
If you want to hear a single song with three languages in it, you should check out JHope's collab with Becky G for Chicken Noodle Soup, lol. That song has segments in English, Korean, and Spanish. I love the diversity.
The members from left to right J-Hope, Suga, Jungkook, V, Jin, RM, Jimin
You might react to "LIE" is a solo from JIMIN a BTS member. I think you might find interesting the combination of melody and vocal elements that he uses.
The song is his composition, production and all the vocal elements used within made by him.
th-cam.com/video/-ThId6ZWqsE/w-d-xo.html
In case you are interested
Correction, Docskim is the producer of Lie. Jimin composed it along with Docskim, Bang PD, Pdogg and SUMIN
Thank you for your honest reactions.
Festa BTS room live is good too and yes I know I’m spelling it wrong
Hahaha the original version of save me is an EDM song with some wild dance breaks so they've converted the drops into those instrumental sections. Really enjoyed this! Looking forward to part 2 :)
Muchas gracias 🥰👌💜
They really have this crisp voice that makes like very high notes. But they are really good singers.
I’m a year late to this reaction. I’ve watched your Pentatonix ones, but didn’t realize you also reacted to BTS until I saw your reaction to Jimin’s Like Crazy. I always enjoy your reactions, it’s always fascinating to hear from the perspective of a professional singer. What you mentioned about going back and forth between Korean and English - check out J-Hope’s Chicken Noodle Soup. It combines Korean, English and Spanish!
Thank you for this amazing reaction! Very interesting to not only see your reaction to the song and BTS' vocal abilities, but also have you break down so many of their choices. I love the fact that your reactions can have me learn something new about songs and performances I've seen a hundred times before.
Really excited to follow your journey in getting to know BTS and can't wait to see the rest of your reactions to this Tiny Desk Concert!
One of the aspects of a typical BTS performance that you're (kind of) missing here is their dancing. K-pop emphasizes a full-package performance, and BTS goes HARD on that, so where you were expecting rap line to come in on "Save Me," there's a dance break. (And yes, they can also sing and dance at the same time. Their vocal stamina is INSANE.)
They are just perfect in vocals, Jungkook sings excellent for me, now on June 10th there will be BTS comeback, new era, new album and song for you to support views!!💜💜
Jimin voice ❤
It's cute when u'r smiling n having fun mimicking the instruments
I love your professional analysis and reaction. Thank you so much for appreciating the boys.
Check out Jimin’s video of his “High Notes”❣️ I think you’ll be blown away….💜
One thing about ARMY, is that we don't mind long videos, like we also have multiples reactors who spend a good 2 to 3 hours doing livestreams on BTS.
Also, I hope if there are rude comments, please don't take it to heart, some people do have tendencies to take everything wrong when it comes to BTS, while you are clearly explaining things respectfully and nicely.
About their voice, what's most impressive is that they improve - their voices - over time.
At the beginning of their careers (and first concerts), they were a bit scattered everywhere and despite everything they were already very good.
V's voice (green mic), for example, he worked a lot - especially for Dynamite as you see, in 2020 - to reach high notes, and he succeeded.
V possesses a low, deep baritone voice. His voice is not just deep. It's soft and has a warmth, bringing depth to any pop song he sings. He makes excellent use of his deep chest voice, head voice, mixed voice and falsetto, drawing on his sweet baritone voice, resulting in transitions so smooth you won't notice how wide his range is from a casual listen.
Jin (pink mic) is called "Silvery Vibrato" or "Silver Voice" by the Grammys because the Grammy panel stated that although BTS Jin's voice may not be the fanciest, he has stable breathing and the ability to switch between singing techniques freely. Hence, they described Jin’s voice as “silvery”.
He only started singing (for the first time) at the age of 20, and he not only changed his voice, but he totally transformed it, he can easily switch between head voice and true voice.
Jimin (orange mic) struggled with his vocals especially during their tour for the "Wings" album, he struggled to know how to use his vocal chords at the time. Yet, with continued work, today he has a falsetto and head voice that have a unique tone that could only be produced by him. Above all, Jimin's high notes were assessed as naturally of a higher range for any adult male, like for their song "Let me know", where he can go as high as an A5 which is three notes higher than Jungkook's F5 in "ON" which is already a high note.
The only one who we can say found it easier to use his voice naturally was Jungkook (purple mic), that's why he's the main vocalist, but also the most stable to sing and dance at the same time. He is often referred to as one of the best singers in the world. His voice is pure, with a perfect pitch and a crazy range.
Jungkook has been ranked as one of the best singers and all-rounders in the industry since he has solid abilities and is able to express his vocal in performances that require high technical skills.
Really, I have to say that the vocalists of BTS always amaze me, and those since their debut despite their struggles, it didn't come naturally but from continuous hard work and dedication.
Special mention to J-Hope, the rapper with the red mic, who is also a sub-vocalist, we get to hear his voice singing nicelyfrom time to time.
So there's "Let me know" which I mentioned above for Jimin's high note absolutely to see (it's a song that includes the whole group, so also the rappers), know that there is a live for that performance.
For songs coming only from the vocal line, there are "House of Cards", "Butterfly", "Dimple" and "The Truth Untold", they are also performances live available for all of theses.
Thank you so much for being that professionnal and respectful.
Can't wait for the next parts and future reactions. 💜
I know you are focusing on the vocals, but I am excited for you to see a live performance where they are dancing and singing live! They usually have backing tracks because of all the movement but still sing live and it's amazing to see :)
Love the reaction and look forward to the next part!
Every vocal coach reacted to them couldn't believe their perfect singing and had doubts. They practiced for many hours. It's ingrained in their soul. As you get to know them you will understand that. They never take anything for granted. You can see their dedication through their works.💜
Also check out Indian singers' live performance(A.R.RAHMAN,SHREYA GOSHAL,SONU NIGAM,LATA MANGESHKAR),they will also surprise you. Solid vocals and different from western music. You will gain more music knowledge.
I hope you get to know their names by now. Borahae💜
BTS DOESN'T USE AUTOTUNE OR LIP SING IT'S THEIR ACTUAL VOICE, THAT YOU ARE HEARING. IF I AM WRONG PLEASE ARMY CORRECT ME. THANKS. I'M AN ARMY SINCE MAY 2, 2018, I WAS 66 YEARS OLD NOW I'M 72 YEARS OLD AND TOTALLY LOVE BTS.
Dynamite had autotune. But it was more of an artistic choice
Thank you so much for reacting to the BTS tiny desk home concert. This is one of my favorite performances of theirs.
They always sings live,that's how good they are cause they've worked hard for that 💜 💜 💜
I really loved this video! When you finish resting to their tiny desk performance I think you’d like their 2021 Festa Room Live where they sing some extracts from their older and their newer songs!
th-cam.com/video/RRhjdYsNwAk/w-d-xo.html this is the link if you feel like checking it out :)
That was wonderful! They were a bit better than my choir in high school. 😁 But that experience did give me a better appreciation of what Voctave did today! 💜💜💜
Ok, First off, Damn brother I like your voice.
Yeesss!!
Sameee
I was enjoying your reaction so much the end of the video surprised me 😭. This was fun to watch. Looking forward to the next part.
Also, what you're seeing here and what I love about BTS is their voices are so distinct. Each member can sing the same thing and it's completely different.
First off, CONGRATS on the sponsors!
Secondly, Yay to 2 parts!
Now to song lol.
Very funky, I like it very much. They have a great mixture of voices and sounds.
Bro you’ve developed that low register so much that you’re voice became a bass 🔥🔥 love it man
Merci beaucoup ! 🇫🇷 Thank you so much for this clever and technique analysis ! Just the kind of video I was looking for ! 💜
Thank you for the reaction! We like longer videos if they are informative, don't worry 😁
Some effects on Dynamite are a stylistic choice 😉
Thanks for the really interesting reaction, Peter! I learned plenty 😄☺️
ithank you so much for your reaction. so very informative, respectful and open minded. Can't wait for part 2!
loved your reaction! so insightful
‘Film out’ live would be a great next reaction, or ‘your eyes tell’ because both really showcase their vocals. Also, I’m sure it’s been mentioned but the instrumentals in their songs (the gaps with no singing) is because they dance on stage so it’s used for dance and performance when sang live
Lought The Bomb reaction!!🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣🗣
Jhope (rapper) & Jungkook (singer) harmonies are always sound epic. These 7 guys are actually really amazing performers that they even sound this good even when doing very complex choreo.
One of the best breakdowns I've watched. I can't wait for part 2 😭
room live reaction pleaase its just so good and im sure ull like it 🥺🙏💜💜
I cannot wait for 2nd part 🤩
Thank u so for your reaction I really enjoyed it
Yeah in my opinion, the vocals sound slightly different for dynamite and the other two songs, so there might be some kind of little effect on the voices. I feel like that's kinda been the stylistic vibe for dynamite.
Ya it's confirmed that there is some tuning on just Dynamite. This is the version without if you're interested in the difference: th-cam.com/video/qqN4UWnfcQA/w-d-xo.html
I love your reaction and attention to detail. Glad a other singer gets to know BTS and some unique approach to music creation fresh for the Western world
Omg I love your voice. I can listen to u talk all day.
woah your voice is so deep.... im super shookt... i didnt saw that coming
and i find it soothing/relaxing to hear
I'm so excited for the next part of this reaction! Thank you for reacting to this!
Felicitări BTS cei mai talentați frumoși perfecți tare dor de ei ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I was so happy to see this pop up in my feed today. I loved the last analysis. One of the first thing I thought of last video was how I wished you would do the Tiny Desk Concert so I could learn more about their vocals as a non-singer.
When you say we don’t need to be told they are good singer, the truth is that I did need to hear that. It is good to hear from a professional opera singer that they are good. Just because I like a singer does not always mean they are good singers. I think they are, but I have an untrained ear.
I just went to check out your Dimash breakdown and will do a few others. Glad I found you.
I am going to guess you will have many requests for FESTA live, so I will add my vote for that one as well.
If you want to hear more harmonies I suggest you to listen to "Life goes on" (MTV unplugged version). I also recommend "The truth untold" live (performed only by the vocal line) and "Blue & Grey (MTV unplugged version). Finally I suggest "BTS room live FESTA 2021" to get a taste of various songs. You won't regret it!😉
p.s. I think it's very interesting to listen to the rap line's songs too beacuse they have very unique voices and styles. maybe it's not your field but you should give it a try. Bye
"BTS room live FESTA 2021" yes this please~!
Excited for Part 2!❤️
I don't know why but your voice makes me feel calm
love your reaction
I loved this breakdown and your reaction so much! Can't wait for the next one!!! So happy I discovered this channel.
they are crazy good dancers too!!
jin has a solid chest voice (pink mic). first time listening to bts, i picked him as my bias cos it hits me different when people sing on chest voice. but yeah, great catch on everything. they're all wonderful vocalists and i can't wait to hear more bts from you. 💜
Love your appreciation for our WWH Jin. He is my favorite too
I miss him already 😭
Jin 💎
@@annwane_jinmoon6420 and i love your username! hahaha 2seok. uwu 💜
@@tunaman5712 always! can't get enough of him. 💜
Peter loved loved loved loved loved loved loved loved the whole breakdown analysis ❤️ Looking forward from more ~ India
Just btw the gap in Save Me is there bc of the dance break!! They are spectacular dancers/performers
I neeed the second part. Love your reaction. Keep them coming
thank you so much for your analysis! bts are my favorite artists and even though i don't know music in a professional way i learned a lot with this video!! keep it up :)
I'm gonna waiting for part 2 for sure, thanks so much
If you react to their huge concert, you will realize they don't do auto-tunes or live editing. There are fan-cams of live concerts where instrument sounds are removed and you can tell that they dont make auto tunes. Their mic are, however, costumized and made of gold. Their polished performance are result of hours and days of practice and rehearsals. They don't stop until they perfect their performance. They are all hard working perfectionist artists.
you don’t know what auto-tune is so it’s not even worth it to discuss it with you. but yes, in Dynamite they use auto-tune.
@@priiifrg why the rudeness? What i mean is live tone editing. If am wrong in uding the term autotunes, why the rudeness? You could hsve been heloed uf yiu educate me instead. I may not be tech-savy but i know tenor, bass and baritone. I know notes and pitches. I know what this reactor is talking about and i like his reactions because i watch opera, orchestra concerts and ballet. I guess you're right, we are of different wavelength. Take care and love yourself, ✌️
Oh my God, i can't even concentrate on your reaction because i fall in love with your voice 😅😅💕💕
The live of their song Film Out blow my mind, i really recommend it for your next reaction.
Oh, you'll love all of their songs esp when you get to check out their individual songs.
I love how detailed your reaction i think now you should check thier Japanese songs live wich are one's of my favorite and you will see other quality in thier voices my top 3 : film out, your eyes tell and let go
I'm sooo happy to see he turned on the cc :)))))
They can sing the same well while dancing crazy choreos btw. Also they debuted in 2013 so it's been almost 10 years before they've been actually started to treat seriously by the industry. Their popularity was growing in a very organic way to the point they finally couldn't be ignored. But it for sure wasn't fast : )
Glad you noticed the Ghost band. This is the first time they performed Dynamite with a live band. You appreciate them more when you find out how much training they had to go through to get them to this point. They each had a speciality when they were trainees but had to learn other skills throughout their journey (e.g, the rappers needed to learn to sing, several never danced before, etc.) Welcome to the BTS journey. Look forward to more of your critique...
They have a very inspiring story "BTS From Nobodies to Legends 2019"
Thanks for doing this video. What a cliffhanger! 😂 Never be afraid to do long videos with ARMY, we will watch lol. I literally just watched a 4 hour video of someone reacting to every one of their music videos. I really enjoyed your breakdown and cannot wait to see more. After the rest of Tiny Desk I recommend perhaps the live performances for House of Cards or Magic Shop and the 2021 Festa Room Live. Thanks!
What was that long video?
@@nadinehoogenboezem4798 here is a link to it: th-cam.com/video/jONxmqa7sow/w-d-xo.html
Hi, I'm a new viewer from Indonesia. I'm a fan of BTS and also Voiceplay, since my son loves them so I use to hear them daily played in my house. And guess what, my son loves the bass voice, so his person of idol is more to Geoff and he practices his type of singing like Geoff does. Btw, I write a comment here to let you know I can't wait for the next part. And like any other army, yes, I don't mind if you upload more than an hour video, we'll still keep watching it, without any complaint. It's also valid with a lot of pauses happen in between. Thank you...
Hi Peter...a new subscriber here! Glad you're reacting to more BTS. They may not be the perfect artiste (no one is btw) but they are truly inspiring, positive young men that has bonded multi facet of people around the world through their artistry. You'll soon discover... and welcome to BTS World 💜
Check out some behind the scenes of their singing. You can hear their raw vocals without any mic.
Hi Peter, it’s really nice to see some vocal analysis from an opera singer! I’m an opera student currently whos also a big kpop fan :) wondering if in your future analysis you can do a bit more in terms of variety of analysis? The analysis of chest vs mix vs head and things like chord closure is very insightful but I would also love to hear your thoughts on other musical aspects like how they use their diction or contrasting between different amounts of legato to express emotions and things like that!
I agree with you! There could be a little tuning in Dynamite, the first song in tiny desk. Probably because it's disco pop and there's some in the studio version as well.
However, in the other 2 songs they sing later, it's not quite there.
The music video for Save Me is definitely worth checking out! It was filmed in one take!
Hobi jumping up was his main dancer blood telling him to get up and Dance! Lol even if they weren’t dancing this time. 😂
Thank you for such detailed explanations and examples! If you do want to learn their names, go back and watch the speaking parts of Tiny Desk because their names are listed in the subs every time they speak. This is also a great vid for learning their names because they stay in the same formation the whole time (well, except when they get up cuz they're too excited lol.) Names left to right:
j-hope (rapper)
Suga (rapper)
Jungkook/JK (vocalist)
V (vocalist)
Jin (vocalist)
RM (rapper, group leader)
Jimin (vocalist)