Afghanistan: a Chinese Colony? - VisualPolitik EN
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.ย. 2021
- This video is sponsored by Newsreels. Download Newsreels for free:
get.newsreels.app/xU9P/visual...
Welcome to the future of news!
Join the VisualPolitik community and support us on Patreon: / visualpolitik
On 7 October 2001, the United States launched Operation Enduring Freedom, a campaign that began the invasion of Afghanistan. That day marked the start of a war that did not come to an end until 31 August 2021, almost 20 years later, with the Taliban regaining power.
Many questions are now on the table: Why was the United States unable to build a strong state with an effective political apparatus for 20 years? What does the future now hold for the country? Who do the Taliban trust? And perhaps the most important question for many of all:
What on earth is going on with China? What role will it play in the construction of this new Afghanistan?
In this video, the third part of our special trilogy on Afghanistan, we answer all these questions.
And don't forget to visit our friend’s podcast, Reconsider Media:
www.reconsidermedia.com/
📌 Download Newsreels for free:
get.newsreels.app/xU9P/visualpolitik
Welcome to the future of news!
you should add the afghan govt was elected by only 5% of the population on a 25% turnout. it never had popular support to begin with, hence the corruption because every faction positioned to benefit themselves most.
however authoritarian they may be, the taliban is the best bet to uniting the country (by force). for afghans to have a future, a general amnesty must be demonstrated to stem the brain drain. the centuries of wars resulted in millions of afghans abroad, many of them educated. however westernised they are, their presence along with western ideology are something that must be tolerated in order to contribute skills for their home country.
these are vital times of the beginning and the taliban need smart minds, western-educated minds to navigate the intricacies of business in order not to get screwed by investors in the long run.
nice balanced reporting as always, neutrality is rare these days.
Wheres Grant?
China and the Taliban, are the most unlikely couple ever.
@@thomasridley8675 why? because xinjiang proves china has an axe to grind with islam? if thats the case, it's best that you stick to cnn because this channel explores both sides of the story.
@@pepelepew1227
I don't 'stick' to any news channel.
A super religious ideology and a atheistic theocratic dictatorship. This should be interesting. Sort of like the Vatican and the Satanic Temple linking up.
interesting how US militarily occupied Afghan for 2 decades and it wasn't colonialism but suddenly China, never sent one soldier afoot Afghan, became a colonial power?
This channels is dripping in bias. It's a shame it has so many followers. One should not come here to get informed.
Informative video, but I think the use of the word "colony" to describe China's increasing influence in Afghanistan is very biased on your part. You did not use the term "colony" in describing the relationship between the previous Afghan government with the US, despite the fact the the the US had an obviously more controlling influence on the previous Afghan administration than China will likely ever have on the Taliban.
Well, Pakistan is a puppet- Imran shuts about the Muslim concentration camps in SingKiang (oops XingJiang) and he shuts up about the export of Pakistani women to China. He shuts up when his country has to hand over territory. When China sends its Police to investigate crimes in Pakistan. So When a puppet supports an invasion, isn't the outcome another colony? Sounds about right
@@krishnam1 no... it just makes him a bit of a hypocrite who looks the other way when his current favourite ally commits human rights abuses when it suits his purposes which is regretfully nothing new in politics.
♦️ SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
You do know this is a western neoliberal propaganda channel right?
There's a 6 year old documentary by Australian John Pilger called "The coming war on China" I'd highly recommend it. Please check it out
Media: The Afghanistan withdraw was humiliating
NATO & US: it’s China’s fault.
Media:…
NATO & US: It’s their colony after all.
China: what’s happening? What colony? Where?
What are you talking about?
@@JasonTubeOfficalexactly
@@JasonTubeOffical He's talking about the hypocrisy of calling the country a Chinese colony just cos they're working with its govt., when it wasn't called a colony when it was literally invaded and occupied by the US for 20 years. This is just blame shifting, coupled with using the country to further feed the anti-China narrative.
What news are you watching? Yeah China is likely to play a big role post ISAF backed government but no one is blaming them for the Taliban victory.
Pakistan on the other hand...
@@JasonTubeOffical I'd say he's building a strawman.
USA occupied Afghanistan for 20 years, thousands murdered: Freedom and Democracy
China started talking to Afghan govt: Afghan is a new chinese colony
It's a new phenomenon that should be known as Australian rationalism. Which is basically China fear porn.
@@rdm3373 yes China doesn’t believe in “freedom and democracy” that america brings which means death and bombs
@@rdm3373 I am being sarcastic: Afghan people didnt enjoy freedom and democracy when their lives are under constant threat.
@@Ducksonqrack Australians arr more scared of chinese invasion than taiwan,that should tell you something
Don't forget the Soviet Russians before the Americans, killing 2 million civilians
funny thing is the westerner always compare china to the history they can understand for instance colony, geocide, concentrate camp, slavery.
This is true but doesn't change anything. Because he has a colony doesn't mean she doesn't
"Colony, genocide, concentration camps, and slavery."
Sounds like you are talking about Xinjiang.
@@badluck5647 According to the media propaganda.
@@zsarimaxim692 According to the Uyghurs who escaped the country. President Pooh has armed border guards to prevent journalists from entering the country. Why have a cover up if there is nothing to hide?
@@badluck5647 You mean terrorist and their sympathizer paid for by NED?
One wonders why US had failed in Afghanistan and Iraq? The reliance on exiles to paint the completely false picture against the reality on the ground which led to wrong assessment and actions, and ultimately defeat.
Afghani on CNN: we will fight the Taliban to our last man.
Reality: lay down their arms and join the Taliban.
And idiots still trust everything shown on Western media.
So in thelast two decades of occupation, did you ever call Afghanistan a US colony? You wouldn't need a question mark, because it is obvious.
Too much propaganda from this channel
@@jkigtehuioropsdfjoaw since Simon left
@@c.o.o.4633 Nah, Simon never determined the content of this channel. They're just repeating the stuff from their Spanish channel - even Simon was just the English language presenter, nothing more.
The military industrial complex loves these channels lol
So much anti China propaganda from this channel. US literally sets up a government for itself which fails meaning they can't control Afghanistan but China makes investments and it's turning into a colony?? Colonialism is western thing!!
Gotta love how NATO wanted to emphasize their shared sacrifice and involvement until it went sideways, at which point its discussed as a solely-US project
Was gonna say this as well
I mean... can you blame them, when they got dragged in a useless war by us?
@@no_name4796 yes, because it's cowardly and dishonest
Considering Afghanistan was sanctioned by the UN, very dishonest
@@ace448
USA was the one who influenced UN at the time and bullied others to see the world as it sees it basically she is the Sole Power
US: Occupies Afghanistan for 20 years
VisualPolitik: Is It A ChInEsE CoLoNy ThOuGh
Yeah...this channel is a western propaganda channel. Most of what they say aren't even 10% accurate.
Selective amnesia is a powerful tool. It's built in the system.
Rusia & USA: good luck
Decade later
China: f this... adios afgan
🔵 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
@Christopher Meisner Help a US puppet?
I give China 5 years before they Nope out of Afghanistan.
"building *autonomous* Afghan Government"
American propaganda at its best
Depends on how you define autonomy. For example if the Afghan government were not autonomous they would have acquiesced to American requests. Which, of course, they didn't do. America wanted an end to political corruption...they knew it was a huge problem. Afghans didn't do that. End to opium production....not going to happen. Women's rights...no. End to the rape of male children...not going to happen. On and on. America had very little influence on the government they were bankrolling. That's why Biden saw it as a write off and left. Good call.
There's a 6 year old documentary by Australian John Pilger called "The coming war on China" I'd highly recommend it. Please check it out.
@@cabreram.4734 Yeah I have seen it
China MUST increase its Nukes to 7K to protect herself
@@shinchan-F-urmom *The CCP must increase its nukes to protect themselves. China would be vastly better off without the corrupt and morally bankrupt party
@@AeneasGemini China has far outpaced the West easily!! Why would they get rid of the CCP party?... They have more people living middle and upper class than the entire West. They have the most advanced and largest cities in the world.
Maybe visual politics should study the word "colonialism"
China taking over the world invite clicks...
@@johnniewalker7628 Bro, you should see the amount of channels pushing propaganda against china and how many views they get... Its insane
How did I could to know am I living in a calony or Country? Both of them gonna to has museums, institutes… Banks, police, military (or not militiarized)…. Special currency and so on.
@@xila-man8249 america just loves war bro
They know what it means and they also know they're misusing the word. This channel is neoliberal propaganda.
FIY Afghanistan was never colonised. They were ruled by others but people always lived by their traditional customs. They are very proud people. Don’t belittle their sense of pride by calling it a Chinese colony. How absurd and childish. I used this channel for educational purposes but no more.
NB: Doing bi lateral economic deals won’t make a country a colony.
The only ruled them was Mongolia.
A Afghani is Muslim first and anything else later, US try to impose Democratic ideology without uprooting Islamist mindset
Not all muslims are afghans. Not all afghans are muslims. What I'd like to know is the strength of the links between the talibans and the crown prince of Saudi Arabia.
@@The0ldg0at Technically yes, but almost 97-98% of Afgan population is muslim and noboby is claiming all muslim are afgans, as of your intetest MSD will sitting somewhere in lavish palace and sobbing because he want "the Unma" to leave their "Kuranic" ways and modernize as the oil money is slowly evaporating
Uprooting Islamic mindset will cause more extreme Islamic mindset, if you push the spring to it's end, it'll backfire like a idk
@@havi5570 In the good old days some tried to uproot the judeo-christian mindset that a country is created by the will of their abrahamic god. They wrote down in their constitution that their country was created by the will of the People. Two century later that judeo-christian mindset that their country was created by their abrahamic god's will is still alive and kicking. It's hard to uproot religious mindsets that have been alive for centuries.
How ironic that they tried to set up a hardcore centralized state government instead of using the US separate but equal states model for the various ethnic/tribal regions.
Yeah it's a real mystery. It's almost as if they didn't give a shit about the afghan people and just wanted to wield their puppet state effectively as a weapon in the wider region...
@@Kevin-cm5kc Even if they wanted that, they actually could have succeeded in doing that using a decentralized US model over a centralized model.
Instead they got nothing.
@@gungan5822 nah because then there's due process and questions when you want to wield them as a blunt object. If they have actual democracy and a degree of regional autonomy etc then Afghanistan has the chance to question if its really in their own best interests if America wants to use them as a pawn in X geopolitical power play. They might even decide its in their best interests to play American influence off of other powers in the region to get the most utility for Afghanistan. They might even, god forbid, decide they don't want to be an American ally of any kind at all because just maybe the americans invading their country causing untold collateral damage is at the VERY LEAST controversial.
Much better to have one loyal stooge bribed with fabulous wealth and centralise power in his hands
The Taliban is kind of a broad umbrella. If the US had of divided the country into States, a large number of those States would have just voted for their previously held Taliban rulers. That was Politically impossible to tolerate for the US & any 'Coalition' partners. Only now that we're facing the grim reality that nothing was achieved for the last 20 years can we be objective & kind of admit they're going to be ruled by whoever they want, not who the West imposes.
Until they piss the Chinese off, & find out what hardship REALLY is...
Actually what is more ironic is Taliban is more decentralized than the US imposed Government
Taliban have a system of Tribal democracy where the tribes decide their Representative/Governor and the Religious Elders elect the Overall Emir.. Thereby uniting the religious and Tribal Elders..
It was impossible for Us to let Taliban back in power because Afghans would choose Taliban over a Puppet without blinking
It was a US, UK and Aust colony for 20 years until two months ago
@Teramisu I'd rather prefer my country to be colonized by Loans and investments for development than to be colonized by Wars and destruction
@Teramisu of course I have, on the internet, like you did... And I know about the propaganda about it too🙃...
Britin : in the 1800s u can rent Afghanistan loyality but not buy it
Its truly the grave yard of empires
The US lost the war as they did in Vietnam and got out.
Chinese are moving in with a different strategy and making friends with the Afghans including the Taliban.
Actually if you want to bring Vietnam into this, the United States won the war in Vietnam and then simply walked away because it was politically unpopular to stay. We essentially did the same thing in Afghanistan.
We'll see what happens when ISIS-K kills a few dozen Chinese mining engineers.
You dont know what china did in Vietnam after US left? 😂 it's simply a disaster, dude
@@Matt-yg8ub 😂😂 america lost the war ,don't sugercoat it
@@Matt-yg8ub US has a history of not winning a single war. Because they don't have a reason or strategy!!!! They didn't just leave, they were beaten badly and forced to leave. Obviously US wouldn't want the world to know that. Iraq wasn't a victory either, civilians were targeted to get the military to walk away. USA only kills civilians wherever it goes. Don't believe what your government tell you, find out the truth
Simply Afghanistan was running on US money and international aid. now that the US left, Afghanistan is begging for food and aid.
And it's the Afghanistan govt. to blame for gobbling all the funds/state money into their personal pockets. instead of putting that into security, and public welfare.
Most non-cash money in Afghanistan was held outside the country, so when the government collapsed the banks froze the money.
I hope they get it together but now they have what they asked we'll see , its highly unlikely ...they will be asking what was it all for?
🛑 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
Afghan money is still frozen by the USA.
Tired of propaganda channels.
Well at least he made it obvious with his tone and word choice.
Do you think Taliban will deal with USA or Russia? lol
None
🤪the title- some kind ofJOKE🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🥳🐒🍌
Would we have gotten this video if afganistan was an American colony?
Nope cuz US and Russia never did control Afghanistan 100% they just messed up everything for 40 years.
@@smileyface2915 Nor has China and yet here we are ...
Rather than colony, I think it'd be more appropriate to call it china's new cashcow.
Love the comment section on the video. Usually this channel attracts a plethora of pro west commentators. But even those guys can't justify this propaganda 🤣🤣🤣
You just lost a subscriber
VisualPolitik should rename to "American Daily Propaganda"
🔸 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
lol
What made you think putting unberable music between the segments it's a good idea ? It's super annoying and out of context
Will China really gonna go on with it? They are closing off now compared to how they've been recently
He failed to mention that China and Afghanistan share a border...A stable, peaceful and reliable neighboring borders is in China's best interest as much as it is for Afghanistan.
@@archangel7052 Do you know that armed Uighur separatist groups has built up near the border. You think something like that would've happened without approval from Taliban high command?
Taliban are smarter than we give them credit for. They'll use the Uighur like a bargaining chip to secure Chinese cooperation.
@@rafimuhammadzakaria482 Well I know that the US removed them from the terrorist list for obvious reasons and like I said a peaceful, secure and stable Afghanistan is in China's interest. This will re-assure not just China but other potential investors in Afghanistan. Uighur separatists and activists are also funded by the NED a CIA tool.
@@archangel7052 meaning that if China invests there it will invest in their terrorism
That presenter's brain is getting smoother and smoother with every video.
It is based on the spanish videos. This video is very similar to one of them.
This presenter's brain is getting closer and closer to official US propaganda.
Well that was quick
I didn't realize the colonization begins AFTER the men with guns have left
The economy hardship, recession, unemployment and loss of job caused by covid pandemic is enough to push people into financial ventures.
Love this comment ❤️and the information given always learning and growing is the only way we can hone our skills and build ourselves. Most interesting thing is that the rich gets Richer because the poor thinks that every opportunity is a scam especially investment like bitcoin, dogecoin, safemoon, gold, silver, crude oil, ethereum, litecoin, bitcoin cash, cardano, polkadot, stellar, chainlink, binance coin, (BNB) etc has been able to represents legion of adventures and entrepreneur most especially risk taking, investors and problems solver.
Rich people plays the money game to win while the poor people plays the money game not to lose. The goal of a true rich people is to have massive wealth and the poor sees surplus as an opportunity for consumption instead of investing it change your mindset and do what the rich does, which is investing a motivational speaker ones told me this.
I have secured financial freedom by investing in bonds, equities, EFT's and some digital currencies
I wanted to invest more on digital Digital currency (crypto) but the fluctuations in crypto value discouraged me into dumping.
Mrs Mitchell is obviously the best broker. I invested $4,500 with her and she made me profit $48,100 in 2 weeks and 3 days. It was mind blowing.
China, Pakistan and Afghanistan could forge a powerful alliance.
To be honest, what could Pakistan and Afghanistan bring to the table besides geographycal position? I mean, probably just Russia by itself would make a stronger alliance with China.
@@LuisRomeroLopez Only time will tell if such an alliance will happen or if it is feasible.
@@LuisRomeroLopez Huge actually. First of all, Pakistan gives access to the o whole of Western China via Gwadar port. This is imperative to China who is trying to revamp the global trade routes. Also China has border disputes with India, in fact the largest border dispute in the world. Pakistan traditionally has had had to spread out it's military forces towards India and Afghanistan. The former due to its dispute in Kashmir and latter due to the baloch who want to be a part of Afghanistan backed by Ashraf Ghani. However, now that the taliban have come to power, Pakistan who are friendly to them can allocate more forces towards Kashmir thus further pressing India whose forces will be quite stretched. This is important because India is already a poverty stricken country and any more budget allocated to the military will not be accepted by the people.
@@makkialqaosain8872 LOL What the hell are you talking about? Indians have lifted more people from the poverty since 2010 that's more than the population of Pakistan & Afghanistan combined. Why would India hesitate from Investing money in Millitary when the approval rating of Army in the Country is highest even more than any other Institution. Not to mention that Gwadar & the CPEC is a failed project to begin with. How can you match the per capita cost of transportation of goods via land to sea? I mean it's basic maths. As far as you think that Taliban are your friends, Who the hell do you think is supporting TTP now? And we all know Your Handsome PM loves blaming India for it using the territory of Afganistan but please explain how more than 250 Servicemen of the World's finest army have been slain in FATA & Balochistan? If you think Afghanistan is your friend, Wait before the Durand Line comes up in one of these meetings. Also, What do you really think ISIS K will just sit there and let Taliban marinate there ass on the Kabul Presidential Palace. And you think China is like Americans that throw free money everywhere they go. They will take there pound of the flesh just like they have taken your airports , Even I heard you guys leased them a Park for 99 Years LOL. Having said that if you think Chinese are not streched out in South China Sea , You got another thing coming. Having said that I wish the best for the Afgan People & for the people of Pakistan sans Its army. There are just so many ifs & buts in your arguments that it is crumbling on its own over its weight.
@@makkialqaosain8872 🤣🤣🤣funny comment I ever see ,in India, people laugh at Indian government because they spent 1billion USD to buy 114 Arjun mk1 tank just because we have money .Buy the way tank is rejected by Indian army twice but we buy any way because we have money .The poverty is higher because our population is higher .But we are richer than Pakistan .Then predator B in coming home Afghanistan air space is no man land , our base in tajikitan help us to keep busy Pak air force and Pak army in West .Besides u training of terrorist is obsolete so train well , now they are dead even before they are entering valley
In the eyes of robbers, everyone is a robber
China has invested in CPEC project in Pakistan. The taliban who were fighting the US & NATO were based, armed & trained by pakistan. The taliban are welcoming the chinese with open arms to invest in Road & communication related infrastructure related projects in afghanistan. It's a win win situation for both the parties.
Pakistan has many "seminaries" where they train these fighters. The US withdrawal gave Pakistan a huge strategic and military advantage. Pakistan has seven nuclear warheads, which is said to be the reason why PM Khan and his rule have been given so much leeway, in spite of training militant groups and harboring Bin Laden. The worry on the horizon is that Pakistan and its training seminaries, along with nuclear warheads, could become a terrorist threat. Everything's happening at warp speed, but Afghanistan may become a terrorist haven, and the talks will be between it, China and Pakistan. It's also no secret China's Belt & Silk Road Initiative has recently come up against roadblocks, with some countries pulling out and China running low on Belt cash and domestic problems, like Evergrande real estate mess. There's no telling where all this will end up, but the losers may be the people of Afghanistan and the fight to protect US from further terrorist attacks, whether here or elsewhere in the world.
Omg I thought this channel couldn't get any more ridiculous, but with this video and title you outdone the limit of it
It seems like someone is getting paid by the Military Industrial Complex
More fake news = more war = more profit
@@Cheesecake99YearsAgo which war? in Afghanistan?
Or are you talking about the US making war again?
We all know US is more likely to make conflict in South america or something.
Not with china.
China spreading influence into Afghanistan is not even disputable at all, fhey are already there.
Good Wumao , here’s your 50 cents
@@bigmedge hell yeah 50 cent gang here. I love my boy Xi Drip Ping dropping social credits in my ass.
So. 12,0000 NATO soldiers with boots on ground in Afghanistan nobody bothered that it was a US colony but now it is "Is Afghanistan is a Chinese colony" because they said they'll try to cooperate.
Shallow analysis as always.
In the great game a British agent said u can't buy Afghan loyalty only rent it
Why you do not say Canada , Australia and New Zerland is Great Britain Colony also?? Because the fact until tidak this country still England Colony until now
Maybe the Chinese can sell them some empty condos that they have on hand the lying around?
They're more likely to use the empty buildings for "re-education" camps
American Propaganda Much. Tired of these "exceptionalism" filled westerners. If what this narrator is saying is true then Afghanistan was the real forcefully occupied and made an American colony for 20 years is it?
Don't be surprised if Kandahar starts to produce batteries for EVs in a few years and becomes global battery supplier. China can turn mud into gold.
and thats bye for me , how you talk about it being a chinese colony when the us left just the other day, mybe you should have talk about how it is an american colony for over 20 years and whats next.
as a US tax payer this is where my wasted tax money went. a lot of US tax payers lost and the US defense industry gained a lot from this
Kudos to you finally someone who actually see what happened.
America is covertly ruled by those companies ... You didnt have to win the War you just had to go on fight so they could make more and more money.
🏐 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
10:23 is when the answer the titles question.
I saved you 10 minutes of useless waffling.
I saw your comment after watching the whole video 😂
thank you, you saved me 10 mins 😊
Always enjoy your well produced vids.
China still has not able to operate their mines in Afghanistan yet because of security reasons. I don't think they are planning to invest more until they got their initial investment back first.
China might offer impossible lones with the belt and road initiative and thereby take over Afghanistan (but in disguise).
If the Taliban wants to further humiliate the Globalist American Empire, they should lease Bagram to the Chinese.
@@Justwantahover Are you high? how would China take over them if US can't do it. Taliban are not scare of bombs, you think they scare of loans collection?
Did he just refer to the Taliban and the so-called ISIS-K as "sweet and sour"?!
This is a leftist channel masquerading as objective socio-political discourse channel. They even once said the Belt and Road initiative is a good thing for Africa and is developing the continent.
@@orboakin8074 They're definitely not left-wing. Their only side is the Globalist American Empire. Whatever narrative the GAE wants to push, this channel among others on TH-cam will shill their position.
I saw the title and immediately thought, "The graveyard of empires". The P.R.C. has grown enough to join the World Power club. Their turn starts now and who is going to be arming the non-Taliban "interest groups".
I sell gun to everyone...
For the right price even to those nutjobs
The fact you didn't think that the Afghans will just allow themselves to be colonised despite the past 20 years showing otherwise, or that China is stupid enough to colonise Afghanistan shows that just how much you lack in intelligence.
@@cecaloather8701 they are not stupid... They are capable enough to colonise Afghanistan
@@steephanroy8461 I think you should go back and check the dictionary definition of colonisation. And are you admitting that mighty Murica is not capable of colonising Afghanistan? Thought it is Numba Wan.
@@cecaloather8701 china will Colonise.. or vassilise Afghanistan..
America is a dying power.. they don't have the capability to do it.
But why? It's a scorpion
You forgot the part most of the trillions with T went to US contractors, in other words they moved the money from one pocket to another
Where is Genghis Khan when you need.....?😅😅😅
Does Genghis Khan have billions of dollars?
Ha...Exactly what I.ve been saying! TEMUJIN...ALEXANDER OF MACEDON...& TIMUR THE LAME BROUGHT THEM TO HEEL!😠SPOKE TO EM IN A LANGUAGE THEY COULD UNDERSTAND!🔥💥😡
You've earned yourself an unsub with this transparently biased propaganda.
bye bye commie, don't let the door hit you on the way out.
Bye! Don't come back!
I enjoy the videos on this channel for the infomation but for the love of God please stop with the DJ stop sound effect. I hear it like 5 times a video. It's so annoying
Did you mean cheese factory?
World propogandas Championship 2021
1st US
2nd US
3rd US
NO 1st Should Be Us
2nd Should Be China
AND last 3rd Should Be Russia
@@WarcrimesEnthusiast haha no
The lesson here is Corruption will destroy everything. Why Taliban is winning in Afghanistan because Taliban is not corrupt compare to Afghanistan Politicians
You are right, this is a brilliant example of effect of corruption, part of the explanation in the derailing of a project for a country.
That's too idealistic my friend. You forget the Taliban are humans after all.
@@waldo8158 yes taliban is human. but many people forget. taliban never care about money. taliban only care about implement sharia law. lets say you are thief, then you want to escape punishment so you plan to give bribe to taliban. Believe me, taliban will not accept your money and they will continue punish you because they believe in sharia law
Taliban will be very corrupted once they have tasted the taste of money！When huge lump sum of money came in their hands, corruption begins!
Nobody is exception to resist "Money"!
Well they didn't have the opportunity to be corrupted untill now since they didn't make a government. It will be another story now. We shall see.
You made fun of "Dear Leader"! Apologize. Lol.
China would maintain their previous investments and see if Taliban can stabilize the country or not to worth new investments.
I’m unsubscribing from this channel. It had some decent videos a long time ago. But now has become just another part of the propaganda machine. I’m gone for good.
you are looking back
"what you see is with all possible nuances"
I've never lost so must trust in an informative yt channel in so little time
No, the channel said is distilled facts
stupid title,tell me how many Chinese people stay in Afghanistan right now and how many American murders live in Afghanistan last year
Was USA Colony for 2 Decades.
Colonies are supposed to make the Imperial power wealthier, while Afghanistan was nothing but a money pit for American taxpayers.
@@badluck5647
USA wanted to remake Middle East..
And Colonies sometimes are costly lol
@@badluck5647 You ever play RTS games? After invading a city, there's always a deficit to your treasury during the rebuilding process. In fact, even in 4X space games, building a new colony also cost a fortune to support.
@@acevaver5425 Have you ever played Call of Duty where they just shoot the bad guy and the conflict is resolved?
Wait. That isn't how real life works.
Maybe comparing the Afghan war with a video game is stupid.
Has Afghanistan been a US colony for the past 20 years?
Yes and no.
Nope, nothing there was done with the intention of remaining there forever. Every piece of investment was created with the desire to improve the country so that in the long term the US could leave.
China, on the other hand, is working enslave the country with debt. They want the corrupt Taliban to be in their pocket forever and rule the country indirectly.
They could of helped Afghanistan but they chose not to. All the Taliban have to do was to march in the city and most people welcomed them. That tell you nobody is benefitting from the Afghan gov't.
No, but CCP is going to experience a rude awakening that it deserves.
Nice clickbait.
The new Afghanistan government is not yet finish to form and there are no one single Chinese walking around Afghanistan and you suddenly asking is Afghanistan is a new Chinese colony...?
In the late 80s when the Soviets left you dont want to make a headline like 'Is Afghanistan a new US colony...? ' right...?
When you put words about Chinese or China with antagonist tone on every TH-cam videos sure it will get many views.
Did someone hurt the feelings of your favourite genocidal, warmongering communist regime?
@@snuscaboose1942 last time I checked the US hang out in Iraq for 8 years and Afghanistan for 20 years.
If you get the number for how many lives has lost in both countries during the occupation please let me know.
After defeat in Afghanistan which country American Empire is invading now?
A crazy situation.
China might have an easier time controlling Afghanistan, the two countries do share a common border, although a small one. Still, Afghanistan is very unstable at the moment, so this could be a migraine for China down the road.
It might be, but the PRC has manpower to spare. The headache will come if they get too involved in influencing (read: puppeteering) the government. That’s what doomed the British Empire and the Soviets.
It might have been a consideration of leaving Afghanistan for China to take... right when China's productivity has begun stalling and creditors have begun calling.
@@CAP198462 It'd be funny if they also end up wasting resources in Afghanistan like the other world powers. Then I'd truly believe Afghanistan is the graveyard of empires.
🏮 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
The only problem is that china must also give a slice of the pie to Pakistan, Iran and Russia to ensure the security, otherwise guerilla warfare in mountains will begin once more...
What is the name of the song which starts at 10:28 ?
🟤 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
Did this nigga just have 2 sponsored spots for the same company? Newsreels must be paying some good money.
For the colonial group, of course the mindset is to colonize. Just because you are colonizers, don't think other countries are invaders. That's a petty thought. The world is not just about invasions and wars. The world can be better if everything is done peacefully. War is not the answer.
I can't imagine the Uighur situation is going to sit well with them...
Makes you think. But maybe Taliban is Pashtun first. Sunni second. Islamic third.
Fake news
I am sure Afghans will blindly follow US propaganda like you do.
the Uyghur situation is part of why China wants to have some level of political influence in Afghanistan - it is in the interest of China to prevent any sort of link between Muslims in China and various Islamic militant groups in the Afghanistan.
@Gordon Brown
They do care about Uyghurs.. Islamic Feelings is too strong in Afghanistan never underestimate that at all
Jealousy is a disease 🥴🤣😂🤣😂
it was a colony for 20 years , so it destroyed and in mess
I usually can always watch topics like this with no problem but this video just isn’t holding my attention. And I dunno why cus I can tell you put a lot of effort into the editing.
Bruh he literally repeated a line verbatim in the middle of the video. They put very little effort into proofing their vids. You'll frequently see people pointing out errors in the editing, such as the narration not matching the stuff on screen or stock footage of the wrong thing (often even completely different countries than the one being discussed!).
Chinese are not idiot, will not repeat Russia or USA ill fated adventures. There is no point in trying to "control"the country.
Soviet thinked the same way about VIetnam war. US thinked the same way about Europeans empires.
The more Chinese involve in those matter, the more necessary it is for China to go into some sort of adventure to protect its interest or again rely on US on that matter. That is how business work..
China didn't have any problem putting Tibet down.
Do u think there are still muslim in that area if it became china's province
Where the hell was the CIA when all this bribery and corruption was taking place?
I know, they had all those guys flying cash into the country in black helicopters, surely they must have seen some corruption going on !😁
One would imagine the CIA were front & centre, as usual...
MIA
Americans suddenly became very sensitive in terms of " human rights" and some nonsenses they invented to cover their imperialism. I recommend americans to get some knowlegde on nuclear attacks on japan and napalm attacks on Vietnam. They directly targeted civilans
💯
And agent orange and "regime" changes throughout the world.
Ask non-Japanese Asians how they feel about the atomic bombs dropped on Japan.
Did you make any video during 20 years military occupied Afghanistan: USA colony ??? No, but china Afghanistan friendship and cooperation is colony??? Wtf whom you making fool ???
🟢 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
1980's map of NATO member nations in blue and Warsaw Pact nations in red.
Killing Afghans: omg so democratic
Helping Afghans: colonization
That's how America said China is colonizing Africa,when China is actually helping Africa.
@@darkcyborgsuperman9521 Helps which African countries are refusing because of financial colonisation.
@@amolkhobaragade my country hasn't refused any help. Speak for yourself
@@mrcapybara3579 yea now there in tremendous debt they they won’t be able to pay off an the communist party is gonna squeeze all they can outta ur country once tht happens😂happend to Sri Lanka and a lot more ,China doesn’t wanna help they wanna use my guy do sum research...
@@mrcapybara3579 that*
Colony: a country or area under the full or partial political control of another country and occupied by settlers from that country.
er no
r japan n korea is us colony?
After decades of US army involvement in Afghanistan, suddenly it became Chinese colony?? LOL
So, when exactly are you guys going to create a Biden animated opener? Or are you too biased in his favor to acknowledge his own screw ups, especially with Afghanistan?!
Afghanistan is known as the Graveyard of Empires tho...
China: Fuck... Jajajaja
@Superior than everyone different technology and the eastern countries would do things that the west would not do due to ethics and morals.
If the Roman empire had reached Afghanistan back in The day. They would have done to them what they did the Jews in Jerusalem or the Carthaginians.
This is not a statement of support for this type of occupation, but a sad observation that wiping out the native population completely is a sure fire way of removing any resistance in those lands.
I’m sure the Chinese and the afghani’s will get along fine! lol 😂
Ok so Afghan is a Chinese/Pakistani Colony? Is that what you wanna say?
◽ SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
I always thought that colonizing other countries was the patent of whites.. I'm proud that we can colonize other countries, too
Best comment ever
It is time for the next generation
U know, there is a saying that only the ones with evils in mind can see evils
Mongol empire
Calling colonization is something We expect from Westren Colonization after their Shamefull failure..
Yeah if Western could colonise Afganistan they would say its for human rights (!) And democracy(!) Not because of natural sources of Afganistan...
🟨 SERCH ADITYA RATHORE-HE ALSO MAKES INFORMATIVE CONTENT LIKE VISUAL POLITIK
How to spot propaganda
The USA did fight in Afghanistan for 20 years and can't win.
Taliban lost 50,000 soldiers. The Afghanistan government army which backed by the USA lost 70,000 soldiers, the West lost 3000 soldiers.
At the end, 8000 American soldiers only can defend an airport in Afghanistan. In American movie, 8000 American soldiers should conquer a country.
Also the West fights with 3000 Mali militias for 10 years, and cant win the war.
I absolutely love the upbeat, rom-com music as interludes in between describing the failures of the US government, total collapse of a country, and its pending future uncertainty
🤣🤣
Ah yes, Japan and South Korea are certainly not American colonies...
Afgan government itself are US colony before collapse by taliban
man, no one cares about your sponsors, can you talk about them at the end of the videos? thanks
People never said anything about « Afghanistan, American’s colony for the last 20 years ». Now just because Taliban said something nice to attract Chinese investment, suddenly, China is an imperialist force, it’s the Chinese neo-colonialism in Africa, blah blah blah , said the biggest colonial power in the world, namely the US, France, etc.