Question is what your definition of the ideal best player - Judge is the prolific ringer / power hitter. Ohtani is the more versatile, all around, EVER.
@@GeorgeKuan-o8m judge is the best hitter when it comes to average, homers, ops...but ohtani is the most complete player ever...when it comes to offense & defense...ohtani can hit for power & run like a deer...while pitching with a 2.5 ERA
Best player, Ohtani, hands down! Never seen Judge punchout the side. Judge has 6 steals. Ohtani hits a single and then steals bases to get into scoring position. Yankees fans, imagine Gerrit Cole hitting 40+ home runs and 40+ stolen bases to go along with a Cy Young caliber pitching performance. That's Ohtani. Ohtani, with pratice, could easily become as good if not a better outfielder than Judge. Ohtani is much faster, and has a cannon for an arm with pin point precision.
Shohei played outfield in Japan. He played it for a minute or two when he was with the Angels. I think he'll be a full time outfielder when he gives up pitching.
That bottom left guy is a literal term of a hater . His explanation has to be so bias and so weak . Even Ohtani without pitching had a better season than judge . Matter of fact dude won a World Series too.
Judge is a super star player. Shohei is an international super star player. There's no comparison to how big Shohei is to Judge. When fans stops traffics and wait 8 hours before the game starts to get a bobble head. Or when Judge's bobble head is worth thousands of dollars on Ebay, then he would be bigger.
on the popularity scale not many people even know what the hell is judge anywhere shohei is so big in asian counties let alone the other parts of the world its not even close i think its just some american fans are ignorant and doesn't watch the seoul series or wbc the whole there is a reason that the most watched baseball game ever the japan vs usa one
Check the attendance at your ball park when Shohei comes to town. You compare half an Ohtani to a complete Judge. Ohtani can hit, pitch, and now we surprise to see he steals bases too. Judge might be a better hitter this year, but Ohtani is a lot more fun to watch.
Truth! I like that you said half an Ohtani. Most if not all pitchers that are recovering from TJ have a team contribution of 0. That fact that Ohtani is setting records in his first year with a Major market I think speaks volumes. I honestly think theres a camp of people that have Ohtani fatigue, but as a sports fan, greatness should be recognized! The same went for MJ, Bron, and TB12. Minus the championships, Ohtani belongs in that company in terms of talent especially considering that baseball is much harder than basketball and football to single handedly take over and win on your own.
Only thing bottom left dude got right is that he's biased. Cause facts isn't his strong points. Nobody forgot acuna. Shohei is the first 43/43 (now 44/44) and he's achieved this faster than anybody ever has. He's on pace for over 50/50 which blows everything out of the history of the game. Also it sounds like he really hoping to see Ohtani never pitch again. All while probably being the type who says someone who could do both aint nothing special. And Shohei is the face of baseball. TH-cam view counts don't lie.
Your comment reminds me of a commenter a couple years ago. In reference to Shohei Ohtani he was saying there was nothing special about pitching and that anybody could pitch. The hate (or should I say the stupidity) is very real.
Someone's gotta be the "bad cop" for the sake of a supposed debate. There is none. Judge is a fantastic hitter, no doubt about it. But Shohei is in a league of his own.
This should not even be a comparison. One guy is great at hitting. The other guy is great at hitting, pitching, and is equipped with speed. And he has a high baseball IQ.
Judge only hits, has a couple more HRs than Ohtani, can't steal bases can't pitch it's not even a comparison. With Ohtani's arm, speed and power he can probably plan any position.
Ohtani brings more to the table than Judge. Dude can hit, run, pitch, sell tickets, draws casual fans & add global sponsorships. He alone made 120mil this year for the Dodgers. To the yankees fans who were calling Ohtani names & laughing when he got hurt. Ohtani is a WS Champion while Judge dropped the ball on the biggest stage 😂
Judge is much better than all time this year Ohtani. Steals are the least valuable their equivalent to a walk. Aaron Judge has 50 more walks than Shohei Ohtani. You can’t use the argument that you’ve never seen it before so it’s more impressive because the reality is the top players are focused on the things that matter the most, and the things that matter the most valuable in production will always be batting average RBIs home runs average with RSPOPS. And judge is better than Ohtani in all six categories. Not to mention these playing defense and stealing players of home runs.
Ohtani is the best ever. And second biggest name? Lol. Dodgers have more instagram followers and bigger than Yankees. Get some facts. Dodgers have battled injuries. Ohtani has carried them. Judge probably won’t get to 60 this year.
judge is the best slugger...but ohtani is the best overall player to have ever played baseball in history
EXACTLY!!!!
Question is what your definition of the ideal best player - Judge is the prolific ringer / power hitter. Ohtani is the more versatile, all around, EVER.
Agree
@@GeorgeKuan-o8m judge is the best hitter when it comes to average, homers, ops...but ohtani is the most complete player ever...when it comes to offense & defense...ohtani can hit for power & run like a deer...while pitching with a 2.5 ERA
Absolutely right.
Shohei, he can hit, he can steal, he can pitch. Enough said.
He hasn’t pitched this year
@@fabianavalos1386 doesn’t matter cause no one else has
People that knows baseball, loves baseball, and appreciate baseball knows Ohtani is the global🐐 ENOUGH SAID
Agree
Best player, Ohtani, hands down! Never seen Judge punchout the side. Judge has 6 steals. Ohtani hits a single and then steals bases to get into scoring position. Yankees fans, imagine Gerrit Cole hitting 40+ home runs and 40+ stolen bases to go along with a Cy Young caliber pitching performance. That's Ohtani. Ohtani, with pratice, could easily become as good if not a better outfielder than Judge. Ohtani is much faster, and has a cannon for an arm with pin point precision.
Good take!
Shohei played outfield in Japan. He played it for a minute or two when he was with the Angels. I think he'll be a full time outfielder when he gives up pitching.
Trust me I would recognized Othani faster than Judge. Lol😂
That bottom left guy is a literal term of a hater . His explanation has to be so bias and so weak . Even Ohtani without pitching had a better season than judge . Matter of fact dude won a World Series too.
Judge is a super star player. Shohei is an international super star player. There's no comparison to how big Shohei is to Judge. When fans stops traffics and wait 8 hours before the game starts to get a bobble head. Or when Judge's bobble head is worth thousands of dollars on Ebay, then he would be bigger.
on the popularity scale not many people even know what the hell is judge anywhere shohei is so big in asian counties let alone the other parts of the world its not even close i think its just some american fans are ignorant and doesn't watch the seoul series or wbc the whole there is a reason that the most watched baseball game ever the japan vs usa one
No one can compare against Ohtani.
Check the attendance at your ball park when Shohei comes to town. You compare half an Ohtani to a complete Judge. Ohtani can hit, pitch, and now we surprise to see he steals bases too. Judge might be a better hitter this year, but Ohtani is a lot more fun to watch.
Truth! I like that you said half an Ohtani. Most if not all pitchers that are recovering from TJ have a team contribution of 0. That fact that Ohtani is setting records in his first year with a Major market I think speaks volumes. I honestly think theres a camp of people that have Ohtani fatigue, but as a sports fan, greatness should be recognized! The same went for MJ, Bron, and TB12. Minus the championships, Ohtani belongs in that company in terms of talent especially considering that baseball is much harder than basketball and football to single handedly take over and win on your own.
@@stevenn6410, well said. Respect
Only thing bottom left dude got right is that he's biased. Cause facts isn't his strong points.
Nobody forgot acuna. Shohei is the first 43/43 (now 44/44) and he's achieved this faster than anybody ever has. He's on pace for over 50/50 which blows everything out of the history of the game.
Also it sounds like he really hoping to see Ohtani never pitch again. All while probably being the type who says someone who could do both aint nothing special.
And Shohei is the face of baseball. TH-cam view counts don't lie.
Your comment reminds me of a commenter a couple years ago. In reference to Shohei Ohtani he was saying there was nothing special about pitching and that anybody could pitch.
The hate (or should I say the stupidity) is very real.
@@Kotaro1326I’ll take a CY young level pitcher over any hitter
I like Judge but Sho hands down probably the best player of all times
All time already?👀
@@bmepod i guess we will see, but maybe some people dont like him but i do!
@@bmepodOhtani is versatile. Bat, run (stolen base), pitch. No one can do all 3 at a high level as Ohtani.
Who else is stealing 46 bases right now? I'll wait.
52
Bottom left dude is just a hater, got picked on too much as a kid
Someone's gotta be the "bad cop" for the sake of a supposed debate. There is none. Judge is a fantastic hitter, no doubt about it. But Shohei is in a league of his own.
Bottom left guy is new to baseball? Seems like it.
Clearly, non-facts bro miles is racist too.
@darylmorales4838 cap
I sincerely regret listening to the guy on bottom left for the 5 min
😂😂 why is that
@benchmobentpod I know you guys know why lmao
This should not even be a comparison. One guy is great at hitting. The other guy is great at hitting, pitching, and is equipped with speed. And he has a high baseball IQ.
MA BOY IS SUCH A MET BIAS AHAHA, THATS OKAY THO.. WE CAN'T HELP IT SOMETIMES, BUT LINDOR NOT GETTING THE MVP.
True he having a great season though
Mets fan did pick Shohei though btw
Judge only hits, has a couple more HRs than Ohtani, can't steal bases can't pitch it's not even a comparison. With Ohtani's arm, speed and power he can probably plan any position.
Othanie the GOAT
Greg is such well spoken man
Mets fan needs to realize Lindor is not going to win MVP this year.
The Mets fan in fairness chose Shohei
Ohtani brings more to the table than Judge. Dude can hit, run, pitch, sell tickets, draws casual fans & add global sponsorships. He alone made 120mil this year for the Dodgers.
To the yankees fans who were calling Ohtani names & laughing when he got hurt. Ohtani is a WS Champion while Judge dropped the ball on the biggest stage 😂
Judge been stuck at 51 home runs for awhile, why so confident he going to make it to 60 this year?
Yeah it's six days later and he hasn't hit one. Doesn't matter, 51 was great in 1955-1985, and now.
Dude said look at the stats
But Ohtani stats literally make judge look average .
Bonds never failed a drug test. GOAT hitter. Judge is ordinary next to Bonds.
Judge can hit. But Ohtani is way more popular.
Judge is much better than all time this year Ohtani. Steals are the least valuable their equivalent to a walk. Aaron Judge has 50 more walks than Shohei Ohtani. You can’t use the argument that you’ve never seen it before so it’s more impressive because the reality is the top players are focused on the things that matter the most, and the things that matter the most valuable in production will always be batting average RBIs home runs average with RSPOPS. And judge is better than Ohtani in all six categories. Not to mention these playing defense and stealing players of home runs.
He’s going to pitch next season
Tell judge to get couple strike outs and then we can start talking.
Ohtani is the best ever. And second biggest name? Lol. Dodgers have more instagram followers and bigger than Yankees. Get some facts. Dodgers have battled injuries. Ohtani has carried them. Judge probably won’t get to 60 this year.
Get that bottom left guy out of this pod
judge cheats together with his coach
Judge, it's not close
This year yes. Other years absolutely not. I like judge alot ... but ohtani is better when healthy
Keep telling yourself that 😂
@@Adam-mj5hl I will because it's the truth, fanboy
@@sumandsubstance7881 Is that why Ohtani’s making double of what Judge is being paid?
lol the “not even close,” part tells me you don’t know anything about baseball. Argue with the wall, goofy!
Shohei Ohtani is The GOAT MAN! 👍