@@siddhartsharma9872 bro if It's true if I forgot all the negative side effects and trust your word , then would you guarantee farmers that they wil not become a slave of a corporate that Their land will not become barren that they can pay their debts. And communism is not agenda you can create by a single video, it's a collective prosses . If you can't watch facts at least don't deny them
@@siddhartsharma9872 but they will use all of their resources for their agenda which is profit, not to help the farmers. If corporates get the total control, they will manipulate prices at will and exploit farmers at will. And is just tip of the ice berg.
@@siddhartsharma9872 you seem like a kid who just passed out of high school and hardly ever read a book. A country like which has at least 30% of it's population around poverty line we can't straight forwardly implement either capitalism or communist template. That's why India joined the non-aligned movement. We need a balance of both to control all extremes. And farmers which have been exploited since independence they need something like government or judiciary to protect their rights, putting them in front of corporates is like putting them in front of vultures.
@@siddhartsharma9872 bro, you really need to read something about communism before arguing about it, there is hardly ever been communism in India, those parties who claim to be communist they are closer to socialism ; they are not really communists. I don't think you clearly understand the distinction between the two.
@@siddhartsharma9872 judiciary is not qualified to protect anybody right ? You know na the Judiciary means the legal system ? If they won't protect rights of citizens then who would. And it was Nehru who got us into non aligned movement, Indira kaha se was gayi ! Kid please read some books, you don't seem like a getting a job in corporate sector too !
Answers most of the questions for a person like me who is born and brought up in a city like Chennai.. Awesome documentary guys.. kudos to your efforts...
An foreign punjabi scientist was worried about punjab land....he told that if we don't shift towards organic farming then punjab will soon become like Rajasthan...he also provide the way how to can do it ...But indian government and specially punjab government ignored him plus when that scientist visited india ,,government started creating problems for him through police ...... After that he left country..... Only villain here is our own corrupt politicians....... And today punjab water level is decreasing day by day
@@abhijeetsingh3722 bhaiya perfect nhi h farm laws, of course amendment chahiye unme.. But they are by far most comprehensive solutions to the farming issues atleast from economical and environmental prospect. MSP aur DM ko authority bnana is an agreeable issue but nothing else
Growing up, I've always been taught that the Green Revolution was the best thing to happen for agriculture in India.. We have been told it helps the farmers the most and also boosts the economy. But I never knew there was this other side of the story, where the green revolution has led to malnutrition (especially in the Farmers!), Water pollution and air pollution on such a large scale...
it has led to this but everythign has pros and cons, so does green rev, being from west up, i can say without green revolution west up would have been as poor as east up, adn this affects million of people, today food security is only possible due to green rev,
@@oksowhat brother sirf financially stable ho jaana hi sabb kuch nai hota...uske peeche hamne kya kuch gva diya...pani gya..shudh hva gyi... environment gya.. acha khana peena gya...organic cheeze gyi...khane k sare ache positive tatt, vitamin, minerals gye...hzaro laakho logo ki jaane gyi...chaaye woh khudkushi k karan ho ja fr bimariyo k karan...cancer ek normal si cheez bann gyi harr ghar mein hai kisi na kisi ko... breast cancer hua pda hai aurto ko...unke dhood mein woh sabb chemical paye gye hai..to hisaab lga lo whi dhood pekar bacha pehalwan to banne se rha... obvious si baat hai woh b kisi na kisi bimari ka shikaar hoga...ja fir uski body mein koi defect aaye ga...abhi to bss 5-10 saal rukk jao tum dekhna yha paani k bgair kya manzar hoga..jbb ek b boond na mili peene ko ...aur pta nai kya kya gva liya yr hamne...yeh sabb gvaana worth nai hai bhai sirf ek financial stability k liye...baki tum khud samajdaar ho... 🙏
@@crimescene5153 bhai bhot saari cheez over exagratted h is video me, mere par dada mummy ke side ke 95 ke h, unse maine poori baat kar rakkhi h, log bhook se mar rahe the phale, aur jitnama janta hu bhook se marne se accha ha ke thode pradushit vatavaran me reh le, aur aaj gau me jaoge to sudh hawa, sudh pani, sab kuch sudh h, bas barish ka mausam hota h to us time jo ruka hu apni hota h jaise talab, waha ka pani kharab ho jata h, par aaj kal sabke pas handpump h, jo bilkul sudh paani deta h aur sal me ek bar sarkar sabke ghar ka handpump ke pani check karwati h, meerut aur baghpat ke yhaa zameen ka pani RO ke pani se sudh aata h, agar aaj bharat jo bhi h na bas islea h ke us time green revolution aur indra ji ke commitment se hum kudh apne logo ko khana khila pay the, western nation blackmail kare the ke food aid band kar dege agar kuch unki pasand ka nahi kiya to, india puppet state tha, jo desh apne logo ko khana nahi de sakta uski internation stage pe koi izzat nahi karta, aur bhukmari me sepratist movements bhi badh jati, aur us time to bharat ka har hisse ko alag country banani thi, fir chye tamil nadu ho ya maharastra, ya punjab, aaj kisan kudh kushi karta h kyuki fasal se kamai kam hoti h, aur isme green rev ke galti nahi h, balki land fragmentation ke galti h, mere pad dad ke pas 300biga zameen thi, isme se 150biga unhone dalit samaj me de di thi, laghbagh 50 privar me, itne me itna aanaj ug jata tha ke parivar bhuka na rahe, har parivar ke pas 3 bigha zameen thi, 2 genration bad yani aaj vo 3biga zameen 6hisso me bat gai h, aadha biga me kuch nahi hota, aur rahi baat humari, mere par dada ke 7ladke the, laghbagh 21biga sabko mili zameen, itni zameen middle class ke liye sahi h, sal me aarma se 4lakh ke kamai ho jati h, ab fir mere dada ke 2 ladke h, mere papa aur chacha ko 10biga zameen mili, itni zameen pe bhai kuch kahs nahi uga sakte, aaj ke mehangai me to gareebi me he reh sakte ho, aur ye main reason h sucide ka, na ke green rev,
@@oksowhat ye sab leftist foreign funded NGO wale hain , inko coverage di ja rahi hai iska matlab jaroor kuch agenda hai , Vandana Shiva ko scientist kai baar debunk kar chuke hain
Scoopwhoop is like the Vice of India. This was eye-opening and should serve as a mode to spread awareness for change. Please share this video as much as possible for people to become aware of the dire situation of agriculture in our northern states.
I cried.......I know that pain ...I came from a farmer's family....I studied hard to get a job but there is no job....I worked with my family into our fields..we work hard...but still we can't get msp..or fair prices for our crops.... Most of times.... my parents feel helpless...so I am.....if you are from a farmer's family...then you can relate
Thank you Scoopwhoop for taking an initiative to give an overview of the soo called laws to the highly egoistic educated population of our great country. Who are not willing to accept that a simple farmer can well understand the economics and benefits of farming which they can’t 👏🏻👏🏻
@@harpreetsidhu0130 it's useless to hope from govt. Most govt does only what fits in their political interests. Farmers, intellectuals and youths should unite to find a solution without govt. Intervention . Perhaps like a cooperative society works for farmers and general population and not for industrialist and goverments
@Time Machine यही तो दुर्भाग्य है देश का किसान को देश का दुश्मन समझा जाता है। बात करते हो तुम Free electricity की लेकीन सच बात ये है कि तुम्हें घंटा नही पता उसके बारे में।किसान को पूरे साल में 1600 घंटे जो सिर्फ 66 दिन होते हैं। लेकिन वो बिजली का कनैक्शन लेने के लिए किसान ने अगर आज फार्म भरा तो ये भी हो सकता है कि क्या पता वो कनैक्शन आज से 10 साल बाद मिले।हमने खुद आवेदन किया हुआ है 2013 का लेकिन कनैक्शन नही मिला आज तक।फिर उसके बाद चलो मिल गया समझ लो कनैक्शन।तो ऐसा नहीं है कि बस 3 से 4 हजार में किसानों को कनैक्शन मिल जाता है। जो दूर किसी के खेत में 11केवीए की तार होगी वहां से लेकर अपने खेत तक जितनी भी तार खंबे लगते हैं वो किसान को खरीदने पड़ते हैं,यहां तक की एक एक बोल्ट किसान को खुद खरीदना पड़ता है फिर उसके बाद ट्रांसफार्मर भी किसान को खरीदना पड़ता है।हमने estimate लगवाया था 3.80 लाख खर्च बना। फिर उसके बाद एक पूरा कमरा बनवाना पड़ेगा तब जाकर कनेक्शन मिलता है एक लाख रुपए उसका भी खर्च।यानी एक मोटर के कनैक्शन के लिए 5 लाख का खर्च। 5 लाख अगर व्याज पर लिया हो तो कम से कम 10% ब्याज तो देना ही पड़ता है।मतलब हर साल 50 हज़ार ब्याज।66 दिन मतलब तकरीबन 2 महीने जिसमे से भी किसान सिर्फ 40 दिन के जितना टाइम मोटर चलाता है। डेढ़ महीना बिजली चलाई और 50 हजार उसका ब्याज। इतना तो हमें बिल न आता सारे साल में। 5 हजार में हमें कनैक्शन दे दे सरकार हमें हम बिल देने को भी तैयार हैं।।अभी रुको और अगला कॉमेंट भी पढ़ लेना
@Time Machine 24 घंटे बिजली दे दे सरकार। अभी पता है कैसे आती है बिजली?? 10 महीने सिर्फ 4 घंटे बिजली आती है। 15 दिन दिन में और 15 दिन रात को।ऐसा भी नहीं कि एक निश्चित समय आती है कभी रात को 12 बजे आती है कभी 3 बजे तो कभी 11 बजे। दिन में भी ऐसा ही है। 24 घंटे बिजली कर दे सरकार,ट्रांसफार्मर तक का सारा खर्च बिजली बोर्ड खुद करे।जब आवेदन किया तभी कनेक्शन मिल जाए और जितने पैसे तुम लोगों से लेती है एक घर का कनेक्शन लगाने को उतना हमसे ले लें तो बिल भी दे देंगे।वो काम तो हमें सस्ता पड़ेगा। अभी और पढ़ो अगला कॉमेंट
Thanks for this! I've been studying ag-econ for some years now..and these are things I so wanted people in general to be talking about. Your ground work, research and presentation are superb. Keep going.
@Debajyoti Patra tab agar punjab wale dhaarne pe baith jaye humare khilaf ved vao ho rha hai..dhan pe MSP nhi mil rha hai...bengal wale dharne pe baith jaye ki humhe wheat pe MSP mil nhi rha hai. Solution bahut asan hota hai..lekin democracy me lagu karna bahut muskil hota hai. Naya firm bill bhi isiliye laya gaya tha ki farmers open market pe exposed ho..taki demand ke anusar fasal ugaye. nhi to jindegi dhar rice aur wheat hi ugate rah jayenge ..lekin parinam to dikh gaya..ek saal road block karke baith gaya.
Wow…This video is indisputably the best of Indian journalism that I have encountered. It is a journalist’s job to tell the people what they need to know, and you guys have splendidly outperformed your duty. Thank you for shedding light on the issues that are indeed more important to us than we perceive. Also, I absolutely adore the presentation, I was firmly fixated to the screen for the entire duration of the video. Keep up the Great work Guys👍🏼 Kudos
Hats off to this channel ..... 🙏🏻🙏🏻 Keep going ..... The problem is that majority of population even don’t know about what actually the farmers protest is ?? Thats why population (other than farmers ) are not standing with these protesters.....
100 percent right .I am from Punjab and most people are worried about this but very few are now shifting toward organic farming. Hope government should do something.
One of the most knowledgeable channel in whole TH-cam A huge respect to all unscripted team❤️😍😊 beautiful presentation speaking about all facts Hatts off ✌️
Amazing compilation of data reports, analysis, expert opinion and detailing.. Hats off you guys. One thing I clearly understand that if we don't focus on these farmers' issues, there will be big trouble coming up to our society. Infact we already late..
Raunaq & team, You raised the bar! Watched the video completely in a single go without skipping any part/bit of it. Well researched and aptly presented, and also Data Visuals are commendable. Hope, there will be a video in this series briefing the way-outs.
For a ignorant person like me, who always thought farmers should be held accountable for stubble burning and their loans being written away, I now understand that I literally know nothing. I felt just scared on watching this.
Don't know what to say. Thanks to this channel for enlightening me. Procuring weapons may be important for a country like India but, this is a way more serious problem for the country. But as it is not a direct problem for urban people and the cultural and social gap that our society is nurturing between urban and rural societies, will only increase the problem. Farmers will suffer and Govt will ignore and urban class will not question... And then some Multinational will see this problem and will try to make profit from manipulating the situation, and we will be fooled again by these companies and so on and forth. I know my depressing words do not help, this has been going on... When I have no power to do anything, at least my negativity can serve not to forget what our governments, leaders, MNCs and 'First World Countries' have been doing to us. Thank you once again.
Absolutely But they actually don't have any option... Even after growing so much (using chemicals) majority are just at lines of poverty and depend more on their children and familes in neighbor countries They cant go for a method where they will get comparatively less crop and hence lesser money
Not really. sri Lanka recently did. Announced all farming to be done through organic means, 4 months later(recently) asked India for food grain. The issue is extreme laws. What should be done is assimilation of organic farming practices gradually.
Easier said than done, Haryana trails show day , 60% productivity in 1st year, 40% productivity in 2nd year, 30% productivity in 3rd year without fertilizers
Organic sounds good only on paper. In reality it's impossible for entire agriculture industry to become organic. Our citizens would starve due to food shortages.
before watching this: "green revolution saved the country from starvation after: " green revolution is the main cause of today's agricultural crisis Thank you for clearing everyone's doubt keep it up....
@@schrodinger8605 at that time india needed that kind of agriculture but now its became a.bad habit which and no other support for innovative farming from the government
Very detailed analysis covering all aspects. Govt really need to think hard and implement more inclusive & alternatives at ground level irrespective of politics. Jai Jawan Jai Kisan 🙏
The fact that this media outlet is trying to bring this discussion to the mainstream in India is relieving to say the least. It's high time people start talking about the Green Revolution.
Very illuminating and unbiased explanation of a burning issue. You guys have done a great job. Would like to see another episode exploring the possible alternatives to the present model , instead of just handing over the entire agriculture to corporates. This video needs to be seen by more and more people.
Cowdung has 2% Nitrogen against 46% available in urea. The reason to shift to urea was not to feed soil with more nutrients? The natural replenishment of the soil would have suffered, but what was the option if the target was to increase production mani-fold
The detailed and in-depth research along with the knowledgeable scholars have truly helped me realize just how lacking our education and awareness is towards the ordeals of our farmers, who are the most important organ.
Topic to be discussed. Thank u 🙏 I am an agriculturist.. I feel very sad watching farmers spraying lots of chemicals and fertilizers juz to increase the yield. Now everyone is exposed to hazardous chemicals. When a chemical is sprayed on the plant, the plant absorbs it and transports to every corner top to bottom. And then, the produce obtained is eaten by us. This is so disheartening. I sometimes feel green revolution has pissed humans lives. It is not farmers fault... It is our two faced government , that says stop using chemicals and gives permission to chemical industries. I wish depending on green revolution ends.
Even the panelist ladies in the video were so good and nicely explained everything in a simple manner... ❤️ I wish modi ji could have put some of these solution in their farm laws instead of selling their crops to ambani and adani..
@@karanpreetsingh5059 just speaking about kishan ekta will not be enough. We need newer system fpr sustainable agro production, balancing and reduce dependence on pesticide and fertiliser.
@@karanpreetsingh5059 oh mr KisanEkta, ਪਹਿਲਾਂ ਸਮਝੋ ਕਿ ਵੀਡੀਓ ਵਿੱਚ ਕੀ ਕਿਹਾ ਜਾ ਰਿਹਾ ਹੈ. Farmers are growing poisons from many years. Famers are growing crops by following American farming way rather than following the Indian traditional farming way. I am not blaming farmers, Govt is responsible for this.
You guys are completely wrong... Modern agriculture has sustained the high population we have today. Without it, we would not be able to feed this population and everyone would be back to subsistence farming.
But the farmers are getting nothing out of it. They're incurring debt, getting malnourished, consuming toxic products, while we keep talking about the laws and technicalities
This is documentary of Global Standards! Just Awesome 🙌🙌🔥 You guys have done such a awesome work, it's more easy to understand even it's better than Vox and other Infotainment content! 🙌🙌 Kudos to you guys!
Green Revolution happened in the 1960s was the dichotomy of success and failures in the life of farmers. India at that time was deficit in food grain production & was relying on other nations like the USA to meet the domestic demand. So these solutions were focused on short production rise, disregarding its long-term socio-economic impact in society. Since the 1960s, the political turbulence has had a really adverse impact on the Indian economy overall. We need a new holistic approach for the agriculture sector in India. Modernization, Organic Farming, Fewer People employed, Maximum Yield YoY, etc.
@@jasssingh20 Government gives MSP for 24 crops fir bhi sab rice and wheat hi ugate hain. why? That too in an ARID region like Punjab and Haryana. This SCAM of MSP has to go for diversification to take place.
hats off @scoopwoop superb series, research, content and presentation on such an important subject is far higher level than what we can expect from our so called mainstream news media.
This is the best video I've ever seen in ScoopWhoop Unscripted. I feel like I'm watching Vox. The editing of this video is excellent.
@@siddhartsharma9872 bro if It's true if I forgot all the negative side effects and trust your word , then would you guarantee farmers that they wil not become a slave of a corporate that Their land will not become barren that
they can pay their debts. And communism is not agenda you can create by a single video, it's a collective prosses . If you can't watch facts at least don't deny them
@@siddhartsharma9872 but they will use all of their resources for their agenda which is profit, not to help the farmers. If corporates get the total control, they will manipulate prices at will and exploit farmers at will. And is just tip of the ice berg.
@@siddhartsharma9872 you seem like a kid who just passed out of high school and hardly ever read a book. A country like which has at least 30% of it's population around poverty line we can't straight forwardly implement either capitalism or communist template. That's why India joined the non-aligned movement. We need a balance of both to control all extremes. And farmers which have been exploited since independence they need something like government or judiciary to protect their rights, putting them in front of corporates is like putting them in front of vultures.
@@siddhartsharma9872 bro, you really need to read something about communism before arguing about it, there is hardly ever been communism in India, those parties who claim to be communist they are closer to socialism ; they are not really communists. I don't think you clearly understand the distinction between the two.
@@siddhartsharma9872 judiciary is not qualified to protect anybody right ? You know na the Judiciary means the legal system ? If they won't protect rights of citizens then who would. And it was Nehru who got us into non aligned movement, Indira kaha se was gayi ! Kid please read some books, you don't seem like a getting a job in corporate sector too !
Answers most of the questions for a person like me who is born and brought up in a city like Chennai.. Awesome documentary guys.. kudos to your efforts...
An foreign punjabi scientist was worried about punjab land....he told that if we don't shift towards organic farming then punjab will soon become like Rajasthan...he also provide the way how to can do it ...But indian government and specially punjab government ignored him plus when that scientist visited india ,,government started creating problems for him through police ...... After that he left country..... Only villain here is our own corrupt politicians....... And today punjab water level is decreasing day by day
Can you tell his name please
When was this?
But still you won't accept the farm laws
Are bhaiya farm laws are nowhere close to the solutions our farmers need
@@abhijeetsingh3722 bhaiya perfect nhi h farm laws, of course amendment chahiye unme.. But they are by far most comprehensive solutions to the farming issues atleast from economical and environmental prospect. MSP aur DM ko authority bnana is an agreeable issue but nothing else
Growing up, I've always been taught that the Green Revolution was the best thing to happen for agriculture in India..
We have been told it helps the farmers the most and also boosts the economy.
But I never knew there was this other side of the story, where the green revolution has led to malnutrition (especially in the Farmers!), Water pollution and air pollution on such a large scale...
it has led to this but everythign has pros and cons, so does green rev, being from west up, i can say without green revolution west up would have been as poor as east up, adn this affects million of people, today food security is only possible due to green rev,
@@oksowhat brother sirf financially stable ho jaana hi sabb kuch nai hota...uske peeche hamne kya kuch gva diya...pani gya..shudh hva gyi... environment gya.. acha khana peena gya...organic cheeze gyi...khane k sare ache positive tatt, vitamin, minerals gye...hzaro laakho logo ki jaane gyi...chaaye woh khudkushi k karan ho ja fr bimariyo k karan...cancer ek normal si cheez bann gyi harr ghar mein hai kisi na kisi ko... breast cancer hua pda hai aurto ko...unke dhood mein woh sabb chemical paye gye hai..to hisaab lga lo whi dhood pekar bacha pehalwan to banne se rha... obvious si baat hai woh b kisi na kisi bimari ka shikaar hoga...ja fir uski body mein koi defect aaye ga...abhi to bss 5-10 saal rukk jao tum dekhna yha paani k bgair kya manzar hoga..jbb ek b boond na mili peene ko ...aur pta nai kya kya gva liya yr hamne...yeh sabb gvaana worth nai hai bhai sirf ek financial stability k liye...baki tum khud samajdaar ho... 🙏
@@crimescene5153 bhai bhot saari cheez over exagratted h is video me, mere par dada mummy ke side ke 95 ke h, unse maine poori baat kar rakkhi h, log bhook se mar rahe the phale, aur jitnama janta hu bhook se marne se accha ha ke thode pradushit vatavaran me reh le, aur aaj gau me jaoge to sudh hawa, sudh pani, sab kuch sudh h, bas barish ka mausam hota h to us time jo ruka hu apni hota h jaise talab, waha ka pani kharab ho jata h, par aaj kal sabke pas handpump h, jo bilkul sudh paani deta h aur sal me ek bar sarkar sabke ghar ka handpump ke pani check karwati h, meerut aur baghpat ke yhaa zameen ka pani RO ke pani se sudh aata h, agar aaj bharat jo bhi h na bas islea h ke us time green revolution aur indra ji ke commitment se hum kudh apne logo ko khana khila pay the, western nation blackmail kare the ke food aid band kar dege agar kuch unki pasand ka nahi kiya to, india puppet state tha, jo desh apne logo ko khana nahi de sakta uski internation stage pe koi izzat nahi karta, aur bhukmari me sepratist movements bhi badh jati, aur us time to bharat ka har hisse ko alag country banani thi, fir chye tamil nadu ho ya maharastra, ya punjab, aaj kisan kudh kushi karta h kyuki fasal se kamai kam hoti h, aur isme green rev ke galti nahi h, balki land fragmentation ke galti h, mere pad dad ke pas 300biga zameen thi, isme se 150biga unhone dalit samaj me de di thi, laghbagh 50 privar me, itne me itna aanaj ug jata tha ke parivar bhuka na rahe, har parivar ke pas 3 bigha zameen thi, 2 genration bad yani aaj vo 3biga zameen 6hisso me bat gai h, aadha biga me kuch nahi hota, aur rahi baat humari, mere par dada ke 7ladke the, laghbagh 21biga sabko mili zameen, itni zameen middle class ke liye sahi h, sal me aarma se 4lakh ke kamai ho jati h, ab fir mere dada ke 2 ladke h, mere papa aur chacha ko 10biga zameen mili, itni zameen pe bhai kuch kahs nahi uga sakte, aaj ke mehangai me to gareebi me he reh sakte ho, aur ye main reason h sucide ka, na ke green rev,
@@oksowhat ye sab leftist foreign funded NGO wale hain , inko coverage di ja rahi hai iska matlab jaroor kuch agenda hai , Vandana Shiva ko scientist kai baar debunk kar chuke hain
That is propaganda and indoctrination 101 for you.
Scoopwhoop is like the Vice of India. This was eye-opening and should serve as a mode to spread awareness for change. Please share this video as much as possible for people to become aware of the dire situation of agriculture in our northern states.
Ha ha biased channel😂
@@ALOKKUMAR-sg5nb ha ha zee news sabse acha aur unbiased channel hai na?🤣🤣🤣
Unscripted is just a little biased while vice is biased .
@@sumantabisoi7800 unbiased kaun hai fir? Zee News waale?🤣🤣
@@crimescene5153 they are completely biased 😑😑 . And wtf fuck is so funny ?
I cried.......I know that pain ...I came from a farmer's family....I studied hard to get a job but there is no job....I worked with my family into our fields..we work hard...but still we can't get msp..or fair prices for our crops.... Most of times.... my parents feel helpless...so I am.....if you are from a farmer's family...then you can relate
The brokers traders moneylender are rich at cost oF farmers
Yes I know
Johnny Harris will be proud of this edit
yehhh, for a sec i thought its frn vox
Thank you Scoopwhoop for taking an initiative to give an overview of the soo called laws to the highly egoistic educated population of our great country. Who are not willing to accept that a simple farmer can well understand the economics and benefits of farming which they can’t 👏🏻👏🏻
Yes, because they don't strive in farms like our farmers it's easy to say about something untill someone is in their shoes.
Ironically farmers stuck in endless loop that will end either by farmer death or by Thanos's Snap.
@@harpreetsidhu0130 it's useless to hope from govt. Most govt does only what fits in their political interests. Farmers, intellectuals and youths should unite to find a solution without govt. Intervention . Perhaps like a cooperative society works for farmers and general population and not for industrialist and goverments
@Time Machine यही तो दुर्भाग्य है देश का किसान को देश का दुश्मन समझा जाता है। बात करते हो तुम Free electricity की लेकीन सच बात ये है कि तुम्हें घंटा नही पता उसके बारे में।किसान को पूरे साल में 1600 घंटे जो सिर्फ 66 दिन होते हैं। लेकिन वो बिजली का कनैक्शन लेने के लिए किसान ने अगर आज फार्म भरा तो ये भी हो सकता है कि क्या पता वो कनैक्शन आज से 10 साल बाद मिले।हमने खुद आवेदन किया हुआ है 2013 का लेकिन कनैक्शन नही मिला आज तक।फिर उसके बाद चलो मिल गया समझ लो कनैक्शन।तो ऐसा नहीं है कि बस 3 से 4 हजार में किसानों को कनैक्शन मिल जाता है। जो दूर किसी के खेत में 11केवीए की तार होगी वहां से लेकर अपने खेत तक जितनी भी तार खंबे लगते हैं वो किसान को खरीदने पड़ते हैं,यहां तक की एक एक बोल्ट किसान को खुद खरीदना पड़ता है फिर उसके बाद ट्रांसफार्मर भी किसान को खरीदना पड़ता है।हमने estimate लगवाया था 3.80 लाख खर्च बना। फिर उसके बाद एक पूरा कमरा बनवाना पड़ेगा तब जाकर कनेक्शन मिलता है एक लाख रुपए उसका भी खर्च।यानी एक मोटर के कनैक्शन के लिए 5 लाख का खर्च। 5 लाख अगर व्याज पर लिया हो तो कम से कम 10% ब्याज तो देना ही पड़ता है।मतलब हर साल 50 हज़ार ब्याज।66 दिन मतलब तकरीबन 2 महीने जिसमे से भी किसान सिर्फ 40 दिन के जितना टाइम मोटर चलाता है। डेढ़ महीना बिजली चलाई और 50 हजार उसका ब्याज। इतना तो हमें बिल न आता सारे साल में।
5 हजार में हमें कनैक्शन दे दे सरकार हमें हम बिल देने को भी तैयार हैं।।अभी रुको और अगला कॉमेंट भी पढ़ लेना
@Time Machine 24 घंटे बिजली दे दे सरकार। अभी पता है कैसे आती है बिजली?? 10 महीने सिर्फ 4 घंटे बिजली आती है। 15 दिन दिन में और 15 दिन रात को।ऐसा भी नहीं कि एक निश्चित समय आती है कभी रात को 12 बजे आती है कभी 3 बजे तो कभी 11 बजे। दिन में भी ऐसा ही है।
24 घंटे बिजली कर दे सरकार,ट्रांसफार्मर तक का सारा खर्च बिजली बोर्ड खुद करे।जब आवेदन किया तभी कनेक्शन मिल जाए और जितने पैसे तुम लोगों से लेती है एक घर का कनेक्शन लगाने को उतना हमसे ले लें तो बिल भी दे देंगे।वो काम तो हमें सस्ता पड़ेगा।
अभी और पढ़ो अगला कॉमेंट
Thank u soo much for again covering Farmers issue ❤️
that's why the new laws are important
@@abhijeetkumar9483 no they are not. We do not need corporate fuckers to ruin it for us.
@@OkarinHououinKyouma may I ask how.
@@octs609 What happened to equality? If all Indians are equal, anybody should be able to buy a piece of land and farm.
@@r.ssumedh7626 with that logic give monopolistic practices more rights and let them hoard?
जब तक जनसंख्या कम नहीं होगी तब तक ये समस्या रहेगी ही
Bekar ki baat hai ye
You are doing phenomenal job. Very well presented, something should have been brought to light.
Ese kahte hai journalism ❤️
One of the best deep Analysis Reports!
Always will get a deep report whatever the issue is presented.
One of the greatest journalistic series. Hope it brings some change.
This video is Gold! Thank you for such a tremendously educative and in depth video. Please continue with your efforts.
Thanks for this! I've been studying ag-econ for some years now..and these are things I so wanted people in general to be talking about. Your ground work, research and presentation are superb. Keep going.
Farmers ki demands maani chaiye and side mei organic agriculture pe focus dena chaiye ab chemicals se door jaana hoga
ek baat batao bhaiya..agar dhan aur gehu pe MSP badhta rahe to koi kisan kiyon dusra kheti pe shift honge?
@Debajyoti Patra tab agar punjab wale dhaarne pe baith jaye humare khilaf ved vao ho rha hai..dhan pe MSP nhi mil rha hai...bengal wale dharne pe baith jaye ki humhe wheat pe MSP mil nhi rha hai. Solution bahut asan hota hai..lekin democracy me lagu karna bahut muskil hota hai. Naya firm bill bhi isiliye laya gaya tha ki farmers open market pe exposed ho..taki demand ke anusar fasal ugaye. nhi to jindegi dhar rice aur wheat hi ugate rah jayenge ..lekin parinam to dikh gaya..ek saal road block karke baith gaya.
Wow…This video is indisputably the best of Indian journalism that I have encountered.
It is a journalist’s job to tell the people what they need to know, and you guys have splendidly outperformed your duty.
Thank you for shedding light on the issues that are indeed more important to us than we perceive.
Also, I absolutely adore the presentation, I was firmly fixated to the screen for the entire duration of the video.
Keep up the Great work Guys👍🏼
Kudos
Good work, one of the best documentaries ever made towards explaining the agriculture and farmers issues in India
This is such an eye opener video!! Thank you for making and sharing. 🙏
This video should be a mandatory lesson in schools. I have learned more in this video than in high/secondary school. Great research !
Hats off to this channel ..... 🙏🏻🙏🏻
Keep going .....
The problem is that majority of population even don’t know about what actually the farmers protest is ??
Thats why population (other than farmers ) are not standing with these protesters.....
both videos should be part of school curriculum, both are truly gem
I am happy to see that this channel is growing consistently
100 percent right .I am from Punjab and most people are worried about this but very few are now shifting toward organic farming. Hope government should do something.
One of the most knowledgeable channel in whole TH-cam A huge respect to all unscripted team❤️😍😊 beautiful presentation speaking about all facts Hatts off ✌️
Such a great video, guys! Somebody had to say this. We really need discussion about this in India.
Amazing compilation of data reports, analysis, expert opinion and detailing.. Hats off you guys. One thing I clearly understand that if we don't focus on these farmers' issues, there will be big trouble coming up to our society. Infact we already late..
Raunaq & team, You raised the bar!
Watched the video completely in a single go without skipping any part/bit of it.
Well researched and aptly presented, and also Data Visuals are commendable.
Hope, there will be a video in this series briefing the way-outs.
Amazing work. Please keep up what you are doing, it’s extremely important to bring this to peoples attention!
For a ignorant person like me, who always thought farmers should be held accountable for stubble burning and their loans being written away, I now understand that I literally know nothing. I felt just scared on watching this.
I know, right. I am in a state of shock to be honest.
same
Amazing Journalism! Thanks a million!
What a commendable series man. GOD BLESS YOU GUYS.
@Time Machine Jali😂kyuu tere pupe. Bhalwe mudi papa ko di gali hurt krege tuje
राजीव दीक्षित जी का बहुत धन्यवाद जो उन्होंने हमे इसे बारे मे बिल्कुल सच बताया 🙏🙏🙏
This is just a masterpiece of knowledge.. thanks a lot team whoopschoop☺️
15:21 this is the reason why farmers are demanding MSP
Because of msp farmers are only growing rice and wheat , because they have higher msp
@@Papa-ur3ju exactly why they demand MSP on all the crops and rather more on those traditionally grown in Punjab like til, pulses, bajra, etc
@@rajdeepsingh6308 country is not that rich to give msp on all crops even usa don't do thatv
@@narendranarendra5143 do you know how much money the USA gives as subsidy?
@@siddhartsharma9872 farm laws will make situation from worse to worst.
Thank you for providing the full episode👏👏
Aside from Copying Vox everything about this series is good.... Nice research... Pehli baar ScoopWhoop ka video dekh ke itna accha laga!
And they support this farmers protest led by by Punjab whose rice will cause you cancer if you eat it
Kya kaam kiya hai Team SoopWhoop ne.... Dil se Salute ❤️🇮🇳🙏
Raunaq Singh Chopra and team ScoopWhoop....BRILLIANT. You made such a complex subject so easy to understand for the layperson. Excellent job guys.👏👏
This is such an enlightening informatic video🙏🙏
Keep up the good work scoopwhoop.
The level of journalism 🚀
Keep up the good work guys.
So glad I've subscribed to you guys for the year ahead.
Outstanding video. Well researched. Highly informative and equally important.
Don't know what to say. Thanks to this channel for enlightening me. Procuring weapons may be important for a country like India but, this is a way more serious problem for the country. But as it is not a direct problem for urban people and the cultural and social gap that our society is nurturing between urban and rural societies, will only increase the problem. Farmers will suffer and Govt will ignore and urban class will not question... And then some Multinational will see this problem and will try to make profit from manipulating the situation, and we will be fooled again by these companies and so on and forth.
I know my depressing words do not help, this has been going on... When I have no power to do anything, at least my negativity can serve not to forget what our governments, leaders, MNCs and 'First World Countries' have been doing to us.
Thank you once again.
This is what news should be informative, balanced and above all no screaming and shouting.
very well researched and articulated!! proud of u guys!
शुक्रिया |
Wow.. Keep up doing the great work of awareness, information anf ground reality👍🏻
Punjab and Haryana needs an agriculture plan to become organic.
Absolutely
But they actually don't have any option... Even after growing so much (using chemicals) majority are just at lines of poverty and depend more on their children and familes in neighbor countries
They cant go for a method where they will get comparatively less crop and hence lesser money
Not really. sri Lanka recently did. Announced all farming to be done through organic means, 4 months later(recently) asked India for food grain. The issue is extreme laws. What should be done is assimilation of organic farming practices gradually.
Easier said than done, Haryana trails show day , 60% productivity in 1st year, 40% productivity in 2nd year, 30% productivity in 3rd year without fertilizers
Organic sounds good only on paper. In reality it's impossible for entire agriculture industry to become organic. Our citizens would starve due to food shortages.
@@RamandeepSingh-sz2fn Srilanka is already facing food shortages due to this abrupt change.
What an amazing video. Journalistic research done for this video is commendable.
This video needs to be shared with maximum population. Thankyou for the information.
Special mention for #Raunaq for the awesome editing - Facts & figures are so well represented. Keep up the great work 👍
Thank you for making this detailed video. It helped me understand the nuances.
This is missing in mainstream media....this is real reporting well done.....schoopwoop
A very illuminating video. Props to the editor, great illustration. Keep up the good work!
This is one of the best videos unscripted has ever made
before watching this: "green revolution saved the country from starvation
after: " green revolution is the main cause of today's agricultural crisis
Thank you for clearing everyone's doubt keep it up....
It actually saved the country but now it is becoming a curse for our fertile land
@@schrodinger8605 at that time india needed that kind of agriculture but now its became a.bad habit which and no other support for innovative farming from the government
Very very informative 👌
Thankful for this video as a agriculturist 🌾🙏
I can't believe I've come across this so late. Brilliant video, all 3 of them!
Very detailed analysis covering all aspects. Govt really need to think hard and implement more inclusive & alternatives at ground level irrespective of politics. Jai Jawan Jai Kisan 🙏
The fact that this media outlet is trying to bring this discussion to the mainstream in India is relieving to say the least. It's high time people start talking about the Green Revolution.
Great episode from scoopwhoop unscripted👍👍.Thanks for all those who have worked for bringing up the episodes.
Great job scoopwhoop unscripted great job👏thank you
Depicted the real image of farmers!! Well done!!
Very illuminating and unbiased explanation of a burning issue. You guys have done a great job. Would like to see another episode exploring the possible alternatives to the present model , instead of just handing over the entire agriculture to corporates. This video needs to be seen by more and more people.
She explained it amazingly well.
best,time was now, at farmers protest, we could educate many farmers at a time
💯 Insightful as always!
Cowdung has 2% Nitrogen against 46% available in urea. The reason to shift to urea was not to feed soil with more nutrients? The natural replenishment of the soil would have suffered, but what was the option if the target was to increase production mani-fold
In an ideal world U need to keep testing the soil and adjust the ratio and type of fertilizers added
One must find a balance between chemical and organic fertilizer.
The detailed and in-depth research along with the knowledgeable scholars have truly helped me realize just how lacking our education and awareness is towards the ordeals of our farmers, who are the most important organ.
Great video! keep it up .👍
this has helped me preparing upsc cse notes on agriculture.this case study is very productive.
thanks
Topic to be discussed. Thank u 🙏
I am an agriculturist.. I feel very sad watching farmers spraying lots of chemicals and fertilizers juz to increase the yield. Now everyone is exposed to hazardous chemicals.
When a chemical is sprayed on the plant, the plant absorbs it and transports to every corner top to bottom. And then, the produce obtained is eaten by us. This is so disheartening. I sometimes feel green revolution has pissed humans lives.
It is not farmers fault... It is our two faced government , that says stop using chemicals and gives permission to chemical industries.
I wish depending on green revolution ends.
It's gold . We need this type of journalism not the Rotten debates and useless news
Even the panelist ladies in the video were so good and nicely explained everything in a simple manner... ❤️
I wish modi ji could have put some of these solution in their farm laws instead of selling their crops to ambani and adani..
Kuch bhi bakte kya bhai
08:07 amit shah ji explains bad effects of human intervention. 🤯🤯
KisanEktaZindabad
@@karanpreetsingh5059 just speaking about kishan ekta will not be enough. We need newer system fpr sustainable agro production, balancing and reduce dependence on pesticide and fertiliser.
@@karanpreetsingh5059 oh mr KisanEkta, ਪਹਿਲਾਂ ਸਮਝੋ ਕਿ ਵੀਡੀਓ ਵਿੱਚ ਕੀ ਕਿਹਾ ਜਾ ਰਿਹਾ ਹੈ. Farmers are growing poisons from many years. Famers are growing crops by following American farming way rather than following the Indian traditional farming way.
I am not blaming farmers, Govt is responsible for this.
@@prateeknarang9849 bilkul bai, ehi samjn di lod aa, je farm laws cancel krake v apa ohi kheti krni aa fer ta koi faida ni
@@Lovejassar cancel kra k new bnwane ne te duji crops te v msp di demand chlri jis nal rice to khaida chuttu pnjb hryana da.
Vandana Shiva is legendary! Keep up the legendary work ma'am.
very well presented.kudos to the tEAM OF UNSCRIPTED.
Amazing work!
To sum up
Tradition way of living was the best
The more you become (so called) developed, more you are towards extinction.
Exactly our ancestors weren't some fools as modern people think
You guys are completely wrong... Modern agriculture has sustained the high population we have today. Without it, we would not be able to feed this population and everyone would be back to subsistence farming.
But the farmers are getting nothing out of it. They're incurring debt, getting malnourished, consuming toxic products, while we keep talking about the laws and technicalities
@@orange7536 Your comment makes no sense at all. Please make your point more coherently.
@@orange7536 Lol! Coherence is not an "effect". You have proved my point that you lack coherence. You clearly don't know how to use it in a sentence.
This is documentary of Global Standards! Just Awesome 🙌🙌🔥
You guys have done such a awesome work, it's more easy to understand even it's better than Vox and other Infotainment content! 🙌🙌
Kudos to you guys!
Best video exposing the failures of green revolution 👌, eternally grateful to unscripted 🙏
Great content ...good data analysis ...hats off to the unbiased journalism
Green Revolution happened in the 1960s was the dichotomy of success and failures in the life of farmers. India at that time was deficit in food grain production & was relying on other nations like the USA to meet the domestic demand.
So these solutions were focused on short production rise, disregarding its long-term socio-economic impact in society. Since the 1960s, the political turbulence has had a really adverse impact on the Indian economy overall.
We need a new holistic approach for the agriculture sector in India. Modernization, Organic Farming, Fewer People employed, Maximum Yield YoY, etc.
Thank you for making it in Hindi, atleast i can send it to my father.
underrated comment ...
I appreciate this . really very detailed and true story or system of agriculture in India.
Thumbnails and editting is looking more and more like Vox styles.
To kya, tereko information chahiye, ya style chahiye ?
You have done a fabulous job man. So informative .with good graphics.
But did you ask the farmers, why do they keep growing rice and wheat every year?(Hint: MSP)
Hint MSP, Answer Low/No MSP on other crops for diversification & transformation.
Best reply....no MSP for other crops
@@jasssingh20 Government gives MSP for 24 crops fir bhi sab rice and wheat hi ugate hain. why? That too in an ARID region like Punjab and Haryana. This SCAM of MSP has to go for diversification to take place.
hats off @scoopwoop superb series, research, content and presentation on such an important subject is far higher level than what we can expect from our so called mainstream news media.
Raunaq Singh Chopra matlab pura concept, animation, style, music sab Vox se churaa liya!!! Waah Desi Johnny Harris!!
I wish such presentation is on prime television but unfortunately we have mandir masjid Ali bajarang bali Pakistan Afghanistan 🙏🏻🙏🏻🙏🏻
I have not seen such an informative video since a very longtime..... Great job guys
Very informative.
Now I see Norman Barloug and the green Revolution from a very different perspective.
Thanks for this information.
Thanks to team 💖🙏
Salute to the two ladies here...🙏
Very informative video .Phenomenal work Mr. Raunaq Singh Chopra ..
Excellent report - In depth analysis with great narration and editing. Kudos to the unscripted team. (Y)