I am an Indonesian citizen. Indeed, I have never been to Taiwan, but I know that there are so many workers from my country who live in Taiwan. but after I read a lot of sweet comments in this youtube comments column, I was touched too. thank you people of Taiwan. sorry if my english so bad
Thank you for the interview. I’ve been to Taiwan a couple of times, I love the country and the friendly people. As an Indonesian, I’ve also been asked “You’re Indonesian, why are you white?” despite my skin being not as fair as the girls you have in your interview, but I wasn’t as surprised because I’ve been asked the same thing in Hong Kong/Macau. I was honestly offended but I didn’t know how to react because I kind of understand that they meant it as a compliment. It shouldn’t be, but we have to admit that Asia as a whole is still behind on the matter of colorism 😢 Indonesia is a multicultural country with more than 300 ethnic groups, some of us look like we belong to Polynesia, Melanesia, while others might look East Asian. All skin colors are beautiful, but getting that kind of “compliment” about being more fair-skinned than the stereotype makes me want to go out and get myself some good tanning to show them how beautiful sun-kissed skin is 🌞 Cheers to all Southeast Asian, embrace our tropical blessings and flaunt your cinnamon tan! 😎
tbf we actually born white though but because we are living in the equator that have a lot of uv light that make our skin darker. espially for western indonesia (im sundanese btw)
thank you for delivering on your promise to interview SE Asians, and non-Euro, non-whites in Taiwan, as their voices are such valuable additions to our understanding of Taiwan! good job!!
Huge respect for Rema, that is so admirable what she’s doing(for all of your interviewees from SW Asia as well)! Jay, your interviews are always so informative!
很感動能看到這樣的主題，很多受訪者的經歷我自己也親眼看過。教授對白人跟黑人學生不會說中文給予很大的包容跟幫助，對於華裔印尼學生卻視若無睹。跟泰國朋友吃飯遇到老闆詢問為什麼他皮膚那麼白，當然我非常肯定是沒有惡意的。 I probably should not said this, but I’m pretty disappointed to see those comments defending Taiwanese, using ignorance as an excuse of being racist. I understand that not every people have the chance or ability to be access to these kinds of information, but the fact that we’re now living in a society with multiple cultures, however treating a group of people with prejudice. We should accept the fact and try our best to be better.
Hi Jay! I was so touched by this video. These people are so kind and their appreciation of Taiwan is clear. I am grateful for the honest response about the difficulty of being South East Asian here as well. I would love to talk to them sometime!
I’m a Malaysian living and working in Taiwan. Actually a lot of Chinese looking people in Malaysia or Singapore don’t speak Mandarin either. That is because they were mainly educated in English since they were born. In Taiwan, you don’t get to speak English often because of the environment. So it doesn’t make sense for someone to be educated in English here.
5:10 its perfectly fine if you do not speak chinese fluently like a taiwanese. Even me a chinese native speaker from Malaysia, may face playful teasing from them. It is important to understand that these remarks are meant in jest and should not be taken seriously. We are all valued and unique individuals in their eyes. Stay positive ⭐
Totally agree with Nicole that not all Asian/Chinese look can speak Chinese. Well, Most of Thai-Chinese don't speak Chinese as mother tongue in Thailand like Chinese Malaysian or Singaporean. When I travel to Taiwan, I get the questions from Taiwanese that "You're lookalike Chinese, why I can't speak Chinese?"
Lighter skinned 'Asian' people are not necessarily Chinese, They just live there. People who are so hung up on the concept of being 'Chinese' need a reality check quick.
I think it’s necessary for Taiwanese to understand that there are a lot of Chinese Diaspora in South East Asia. Many are unable to speak mandarin due to geopolitical issues, mainly due to anti Chinese hatred in the past.
Glad foreigners are like this place, truly. For the ladies and young girls had been interviewed in this video Most Taiwanese are friendly and kind (I can't say "all") also, most people have no racism (no matter skin color/race/gender/body shape). If a bad experience in any part you had(if), i/we/many many Taiwanese will feel sorry and will try to help/correct it. Hope you like this place and enjoy every day here.😅
I've lived in Korea for 3 years and I see similar things happening here too. Generally, Korean people don't seem to know the difference between Taiwan and Thailand. There was a Taiwanese exchange student in my school and he was being asked if he rides an elephant when he went to school in Taiwan or if he ever knew muay thai. I saw him explaining that he is not from Thailand over and over. I think it is because Koreans don't know much about Taiwan but know couple things about Thailand. Both Taiwan and Thailand spells almost identical in Korean letters too, so when they hear the word 'Taiwan', the image of 'Thailand' pops up in their heads. I don't think Koreans weren't trying to be rude to those Taiwanese people, they were just curious about the country.
Just look, Indonesia is now one of the centers of the world economy, and is also a member of the G20 (20 richest countries in the world). Indonesia is now also a leader in Southeast Asia, both in terms of economy, technology and military. A country that is vast and has unlimited natural resources makes developed countries eager to collaborate with it.
Indonesia itu sangat luas, beragam suku. Factor cuaca juga mempengaruhi, yang tinggal didaerah yang lebih dingin biasanya kulitnya lebih putih. Gak mesti keturunan tionghoa saja yang mesti putih, gue asli sunda juga kadang dikira Chindo.
ya krn mayoritas melihat para pekerja pabrik atau asisten rt yg kebetulan nggak putih kulitnya padahal ya ada internet super canggih yg langsung bisa kasih info indonesia tuh kayak apa kalo perlu liburan ke asean deh pasti akan menemukan bahwa yg punya kulit terang itu banyak apa warga taiwan itu sgt sibuk dan lupa piknik? atau hanya mau liburan ke tempat yg nyaman scr infrastruktur?
Please, do not get angry while Taiwanese ask you about your skin color, because most of Taiwanese do not know or haven't been in Indonesia, They didn't mean to be rude to you, they were just curious that all!
I am a Vietnam born Chinese. I left Vietnam when i was 5 years old and went to the USA where i lived for the next 40 years. I've been living in Taiwan for 4 years now and teach English to children. Every now and then, Taiwanese would make comments about me not covering up while out in the sun. Their intentions for the most part is well because the sun can damage your skin, but the other part is about staying 'fair/light', and i dont say 'white' because Asians are not and will never be 'white', we are 'yellow skin tone'. I dont have a problem with what skin color people prefer but to tell other people to do the same is stepping over the line. Also, with English teachers here, there is a pay difference depending on your race. In general, they would pay Filipinos or anyone they perceived as 'Asian' a lower salary. While i understand Taiwanese just wants an authentic experience for their child, it may not be healthy to have that shadow lingering in one's consciousness saying: I'm Asian and i'll never speak perfect English.
@@fredcheng2736 belum tentu, bisa jadi mereka orang Nias, orang Dayak atau dari suku lain yg secara fisik memang 100% menyerupai orang Asia timur, meskipun di Indonesia ada 20 juta orang Tionghoa. Namun karena nenek moyang orang Indonesia berasal dari Yunan, China Daratan maka banyak suku lainnya yang menyerupai orang China 😅, jangan terlalu cepat menyimpulkan di Indonesia ada 350 suku dan 700 lebih bahasa 😊
Ah i relate her (the Indonesian). I don't know maybe they see us (Indonesian) are black or dark skin something like that. Because i have a light skin color, and i think that's normal for people who don't know much about Indonesia. Yeah we have many ethnicity here, u can find any race here. There are people with very light skin color, also there are people with very dark skin color. But majority was yellow to brown i would say because you know the weather was sooo hot here.
Jay, I personally not blaming the Taiwanese having a "negative mind set" against southeast asian, It is a matter of how the teachers, parents educate their children. Chinese and Indian ethnic are spread out in the entire world, I believe you will find them from northern southern hemisphere. My opinion they are not racist, just lack of knowledge. 😁😁😁
Hey KV Sulinom, Thanks for your message. When I heard Nicole saying about skin things towards Southeast Asian.Yes, I was shocked! I maybe used a bit strong word " Racist" to descirbe it. However, I think you are right -> "lack of knowledge"
I don't think most people ask about why your skin is so white is out of racism, for older generation (or just all generations in Taiwan) to give this comment, it is normally a compliment. And southeast asian tend to have darker skin, that's the impression worldwide not just exclusive in Taiwan. I hope friends from Southeast Asia understand that people don't mean to be rude or ill-willed.
im sorry but that what we call "Racist". in fact Southeast Asian is not darker skin, its almost same tone with your skin even more white than Taiwanese itself. especially in Singapore, Vietnam and Thailand. but almost every SEA Country have white skin like taiwan and its not mix anymore its 100% native.
@@mobagenieI am Vietnamese & I must say our Viet girls have whiter skin than Taiwanese. Even more beautiful, I swear. People there they've never go to bar, club in Vietnam to see our girls.
@@kikiwonwon29 yes That right.. im feel so angry and crazy knowing that Country like Taiwan still have super low knowldege about their neighborhood country :/
印尼人大部分很可愛又善良，有時候看到他們被差別對待真的蠻難過，在異鄉生活很辛苦，如果從事看護工作更是累。
而且真的在台灣過不好的也不太可能接受採訪或說太多真話..
總之謝謝Jay致力於話題性相對不高的主題，希望台灣越來越進步！
謝謝你的支持 持續的努力 💪
這抽那抽多方抽幾乎有 一年半在還債 薪資最低9700NT（當地牛頭仲介流行不借不幫妳辦還帶利息）再轉賣台灣仲介 政府再抽安定費 健康檢查1000也是抽他們的 ，當自己老婆曾經是看護我才知道水很深
@@風來助野 在香港都是僱主付的
很多在台灣歧視東南亞人的人也同樣歧視在國外打工的台灣人😂 所以並不是種族問題哈哈哈
@@belindal.7194 不是，台灣也是雇主付費，但是來台灣的外勞沒有語言能力限制，所以很多不會中文的來台灣找仲介就會被迫簽署很多服務費，所以台灣有很多逃逸外勞，寧願薪水少一點也不要給仲介剝削。
幫 7:25 的姐姐翻譯～
：在菲律賓的各位們還好嗎 你們要常常記得我在台灣工作 是為了這個家庭 是為了老公、孩子們祝你們有美好的一天～
-
我媽媽也是菲律賓人 來台灣工作真的會犧牲很多跟原本家庭相處的時光 大家要好好珍惜能跟家人相處的時間(;´༎ຶД༎ຶ`)
太感謝了🙏
之前職場上有遇到非常優秀的印尼人，本身會多國語言，像英文、韓語、中文、西班牙，甚至馬來話也能回覆~
在台灣也拿到博士，他本人表達說論文很簡單，完全可以應付~
而且待人親切又真誠，作事也是蠻努力勤勞，完全不會覺得工作很辛苦，
最重要的是他真的很喜歡留在台灣工作和氛圍，
可惜後來他還是決定要回鄉繼承家業和陪伴家人~
是我遇過最棒最有趣的外籍同事。
身為一個為了更好的薪水到美國念書的台灣學生，特別能理解東南亞朋友來到台灣的心境。而她們所面對的又是更辛苦的工作環境跟歧視，希望台灣社會可以更加進步、多元，更尊重不同的族群。
I bully Asian people here in USA
身為一個小留學生 我懂你的感受啊... 去別的國家被歧視很想大家都會遇到
I am an Indonesian citizen. Indeed, I have never been to Taiwan, but I know that there are so many workers from my country who live in Taiwan. but after I read a lot of sweet comments in this youtube comments column, I was touched too. thank you people of Taiwan. sorry if my english so bad
Hey my friend ! Welcome to Taiwan anytime 😎
Welcome my friends
你知道評論是甜蜜的
但是我仍然有聽到有人不尊重東南亞人
除非我不再聽到他們再講，雖然這些都是年紀比較老的長輩
你們有人願意來台灣工作
卻很少有人去讚揚你們的貢獻
大家都是人，在地球村都是優秀的民族
i hink Southeast have many cute 🐒
每一位東南亞朋友都是懷抱夢想來到台灣的，為台灣各行各業努力打拚，真的要好好感謝人家。
但我覺得很多人覺得印尼朋友為什麼不是皮膚黝黑，我個人認為應該不是種族歧視，而是對熱帶國家或是他們所見過的，做出這樣的既定印象，就像我也覺得原住民皮膚比較黑、臉部輪廓比較深邃，但這不是歧視，而是我見過的原住民朋友都有這樣的特徵，所以我覺得應該不是種族歧視啦！個人見解
感謝你的留言. 當天我是被 Nicole 的回答嚇到, 才用了比較重的字眼.我覺得台灣人是在"刻板印象"跟"偏見"之間遊走. 因為其實如果不認識對方,盡可能不要先入為主的,把對方放到框框裡面, 這才是最正確的, 因為每個人都是獨特的存在
@@JayChenTaiwan 比如日韓港的人在台灣..有些會被問到薪水.在哪工作.結婚沒..他們也是三條線..問的人只是當聊天也沒惡意..不過也有很大一部分的人知道不會去聊這種話題..所以說印尼那個皮膚比較白..比較是台灣人聊天特性或刻板印象..而不是歧視用語..
僅以我個人看到的，台灣人對東南亞人多半帶有偏見，
面對西方人時又顯得沒自信。
這僅僅是個人的觀察沒有對錯，我比較好奇其中的原因，目前僅能想到台灣人的審美觀偏好白皮膚
"你那麼黑"不是歧視
但"你好白喔 好漂亮喔" 就是赤裸裸對黑皮膚歧視
就好像我印象中的小美人魚
主角，是紅髮白人來演
算是刻板印象，以前認為非洲
就是瘦瘦黑黑像勵蘇那樣
我堂哥家幾年前雇了一位外籍看護幫忙照顧小孩長輩之類的，她是我見過最善良且努力工作生活的人之一，長輩喜愛他，小孩也把她當作另一個媽媽了，他在台灣工作了好幾年之後，被家鄉長輩催促著要回去結婚，我們全部人都一直挽留，她也一直捨不得離開，最後是我長輩過世了，所以她的簽證就到期了，最後還因為疫情再拖了一陣子．據他們說離開時，堂哥全家依依不捨幫她送行，小孩子哭抱著她求她不要離開😭
人性的溫暖以及美麗
is she from Indonesia ?
台灣人真的非常感謝他們 ， 犧牲與家人相處的時間 來台灣， 感謝還是感謝
善良的雇主遇到認真的員工，祝她回國結婚後也能幸福快樂
Taiwan ou tr toooooooooo
Thank you for the interview. I’ve been to Taiwan a couple of times, I love the country and the friendly people. As an Indonesian, I’ve also been asked “You’re Indonesian, why are you white?” despite my skin being not as fair as the girls you have in your interview, but I wasn’t as surprised because I’ve been asked the same thing in Hong Kong/Macau. I was honestly offended but I didn’t know how to react because I kind of understand that they meant it as a compliment. It shouldn’t be, but we have to admit that Asia as a whole is still behind on the matter of colorism 😢
Indonesia is a multicultural country with more than 300 ethnic groups, some of us look like we belong to Polynesia, Melanesia, while others might look East Asian. All skin colors are beautiful, but getting that kind of “compliment” about being more fair-skinned than the stereotype makes me want to go out and get myself some good tanning to show them how beautiful sun-kissed skin is 🌞
Cheers to all Southeast Asian, embrace our tropical blessings and flaunt your cinnamon tan! 😎
My pleasure 😉
As a Malaysian, I feel jealous of Indonesia, because many Malaysian Chinese cannot speak Malay
tbf we actually born white though but because we are living in the equator that have a lot of uv light that make our skin darker. espially for western indonesia (im sundanese btw)
非常感謝之前照顧我阿嬤10多年的印尼看護 真的是無休無息 盡心盡力的付出 如果能再次見到她 我一定要給她一個大大的紅包 可惜當年我還沒工作 不然我一定包紅包給她了!
不管是在台灣在澳洲遇到的東南亞朋友都是善良又樂觀 很喜歡和他們當朋友❤️
我對東南亞的看護非常尊敬，因為這是份非常辛苦的工作，他們分擔無數家庭的重擔，希望大家多珍惜(人也非常善良👍👍👍)
其實我對所有看護都很尊敬，醫護也是，在我知道他們背後的工作量後，完全可以接受他們兇巴巴的樣子。
@@LesserPand 台灣的護士不做看護的工作
@@belindal.7194 因為護士跟看護不一樣啊
@@媽咪-q4j 一樣，護士不做看護難道做醫生？因為台灣護士不肯做，病人只能自聘看護
@@belindal.7194 痾..哪一樣..護士跟看護就是不一樣的工作啊,護士會幫忙照顧但那不是主要的工作內容阿,合理範圍內多做多幫忙的護士很多,但是那不是理所當然的好嗎?
你需要人一直幫你看著就是得找專門的人來顧,護士不可能24小時幫你盯著人,有別的工作要做,照你話說,不然看護是幹嘛用的?
終於有人願意拍這種主題，不是整天看歐美或日韓吹台灣，但必須得說，這些能出來買東西的東南亞人都是相對幸福的，剛來的移工很多是不給出門的，怕他們學壞或是跑掉，我們如果去歐美打工大概也是被這樣看待。
沒錯沒錯！終於有人願意拍東南亞
thank you for delivering on your promise to interview SE Asians, and non-Euro, non-whites in Taiwan, as their voices are such valuable additions to our understanding of Taiwan! good job!!
My pleasure
我在兩三間工廠待過，裡面外籍朋友碰過菲律賓、越南、泰國等等的。工廠裡面有些有粉塵、噪音、粗重、化學氣味重的工作內容通常都他們在做。真的要感謝他們。
很棒耶！ 跳脫都訪問西方人 ， 反而東南亞的朋友是佔最大多數的在台外籍人士 ， 台灣的年輕人 應該不會這麼 racist, 可能都是老一輩的才會這麼問😅，不過應該也沒有惡意啦
謝謝你的支持 😎
年輕人也有歧視別人的哦，要看成績段，雖然不想用成績貼標籤，但我自己就在低段學校，我們班一半以上會歧視外勞和黑人
我們感到很抱歉，讓您們有這種感受，或許要有多一點的資訊，讓台灣的人更了解東南亞其他國家，或許會越來越好，因為台灣人的旅遊習慣，通常比較少去這些國家，也很謝謝您讓其他國家的人，說出真正的感受，我們相信台灣人會檢討與改進。
東南亞朋友在台灣的人口遠高於歐美以及日韓 , 台灣人太愛去日本了 😅
真的有部份臺灣人對東南亞人士非常歧視，臉書上很多.
@@JayChenTaiwan 到印尼與菲律賓旅遊的吸引資訊不多
每次遇到印尼移工都會點頭微笑向我問候 他們其實很善良
他們身為我們國家的一份子
應該多關心他們一下
東南亞國家的朋友
為我們付出很多時間在我們國家
台灣人❤熱情好客
Huge respect for Rema, that is so admirable what she’s doing(for all of your interviewees from SW Asia as well)! Jay, your interviews are always so informative!
Yes, Huge respect for Rema ! Thank you for your supporting
台灣目前還是對東南亞人民有刻板印象。移工及外籍新娘(相親)那都是過去20年以來的印象。現在真的有越來越多的留學生或白領在台灣念書及工作的。 能出國念書及工作的....家庭環境肯定不會差。 希望對東南亞人民的刻板印象能夠慢慢減少!
他們現在很多優秀的人才, 台灣人自己要努力 !
改變從自我開始。我們一起來😀
真的 越南妹現在越來越正了 那身材根本屌打台女
真的，尤其現在會中文的東南亞人那麼多，被看到台灣網民的不友善，該如何是好？
@@vinsiontan只有南部台灣人跟東南亞人關係比較差。
中部北部比較少聽到那些鳥事，南部人真的比較會坳人家
我是蘇門答臘女婿 也是個雲林鄉村長大的，我跟老婆是戀愛結婚的，但台灣傳統觀念非常的歧視身邊許多人也常充斥著酸言酸語，也希望我們台灣人可以打開腦袋，他們資源豐富國土巨大只是開發比較慢而已，當地文化及語言也融入很多閩南客家華人文化 我也有去當地媽祖廟 觀音寺 及各種不同宗教寺廟教堂 ，希望大家能理解以及互相尊重。 那邊白皙正妹真的超多的不要再刻板印象了😂 🇹🇼❤🇮🇩 追了3800公里的人
感謝您的留言 台灣加油
這種人應該受譴責
看到你訪問東南亞人真的感到很暖心
似乎想起十多年前高中時，聽到親友叫外勞也不自覺貼了標籤
我們平常遇到東南亞人也沒有打招呼
確實是能夠做得更好，地球村時代是必定到來的這時候全世界人的人權意識都會進步
不再分你我
謝謝支持
是的，雖說我是土生土長的台灣人，但常覺得，台灣人的種族岐視、並不輸給西方人。
我們對於膚色比我們白、跟比我們黑的，看待的眼光差很多。
很喜歡這次的採訪，謝謝Jay👍
謝謝你的支持😎
我在泰國工作常常被誤會是泰國人，每次澄清我是台灣人的時候他們都會一臉懷疑，會有類似“你比泰國人黑欸（泰國其實膚色白的很多）”或是“你泰文比我還標準你跟我說你台灣人（我就沒有方言的腔調啊）？”這種反應，但到後來就放棄辯解了，能被認同是當地人也算一種稱讚啊。🤣🤣🤣
Jay i like your interviewing style and friendly attitude. Would love to visit TW one day. Much love from Australia.
I appreciate it. Welcome to Taiwan anytime
很感動能看到這樣的主題，很多受訪者的經歷我自己也親眼看過。教授對白人跟黑人學生不會說中文給予很大的包容跟幫助，對於華裔印尼學生卻視若無睹。跟泰國朋友吃飯遇到老闆詢問為什麼他皮膚那麼白，當然我非常肯定是沒有惡意的。
I probably should not said this, but I’m pretty disappointed to see those comments defending Taiwanese, using ignorance as an excuse of being racist. I understand that not every people have the chance or ability to be access to these kinds of information, but the fact that we’re now living in a society with multiple cultures, however treating a group of people with prejudice. We should accept the fact and try our best to be better.
感謝你的支持
It's interesting that the Indonesians mostly speaking English with a fairly decent American accent.
真的要好好感謝東南亞的朋友，從事許多辛苦的工作，也希望臺灣社會給予更多善意和尊重
Jay加油，請繼續拍更多好影片👍
謝謝支持
Hi Jay! I was so touched by this video. These people are so kind and their appreciation of Taiwan is clear. I am grateful for the honest response about the difficulty of being South East Asian here as well. I would love to talk to them sometime!
Thank you Naeem 😎
每個人都值得被尊重 都是為了生活而努力 致敬那些來台灣的國外工作者 你們都是台灣人的家人
在國外工作之後對移工只能更佩服
我一年回台一次
要離台時都是在機場哭到無法看路
難以想像有些移工三五年甚至十年才能回家一趟
東南亞人和白人所看到的台灣友善程度差很多
社會聲量也是
希望台灣的歧視漸漸好轉
當阿公阿嬤面對東南亞的文化差異
用外勞這詞貶損人的時候
我會說說在國外遇到的不友善
笑說自己也是外勞
老人家就漸漸可以將心比心了
感謝你的分享.我覺得你提到的"社會聲量"很重要,東南亞朋友在台灣的比例遠高於歐美白人 (並不是說白人不好,是一種現象)
我們知道刻板印象是不好的習慣，提醒自己修正觀念有其必要，要努力讓每個在這土地上的人都能受到平等的對待，感謝你的訪談，能對台灣產生正面影響
I’m a Malaysian living and working in Taiwan. Actually a lot of Chinese looking people in Malaysia or Singapore don’t speak Mandarin either. That is because they were mainly educated in English since they were born. In Taiwan, you don’t get to speak English often because of the environment. So it doesn’t make sense for someone to be educated in English here.
真的很感謝Jay做這樣的採訪，很多台灣人真的對東南亞帶有很大的刻板印象，難聽點就是歧視，
我當初做工廠，知道他們的薪水時，才知道他們真的很辛苦，時數跟我一樣(含加班)，薪水卻差了兩倍多(我當時是4.7左右，他們卻不到2)，
我是不清楚到底是他們中介所在抽還是資方在抽，因為我英文也不好，也沒辦法深聊，只是覺得很震驚
他們其實在台灣工作是很辛苦的，真的不要歧視他們，就像亞洲人去西方國家也是，說實在的人都是人，沒什麼好比的，希望能將心比心
感謝支持🙏
按照你這個想法，
假設政府開放100萬對岸的中國人你的城市工作，你的生活被壓縮了，你的環境被壓縮了，你還能講這種話？
你說的情況，應該是剛來的時候，仲介會抽比較兇，但過幾年的%數會調低，不過確實是挺辛苦的
@@Min.C人家做的是你不願意做的工作 不然你去當24小時看護啊？？整天憤世嫉俗的可憐蟲
@@Min.C 笑死,你會去做有粉塵的工廠,去做粗工,去照顧阿公阿嬤,現在他們的薪水上來了我發現很多有像你一樣言論的鍵盤俠不斷的罵引進這麼外勞壓縮到我們的新水我們的生活,其實並沒有好嗎?他們新水能到三四萬很多都是加了加班費工作12小時(8+4)做的都是台灣人不要做的事
I have a lot of SEA customers and I love Filipino the most. They are always happy and up beat, sometimes their energy even made my day.
比較少看到採訪在台 東南亞朋友的影片，很高興能透過你的影片多了解他們一些，希望還能多訪問他們一些不同的話題，以前老闆有請菲律賓的大姊幫忙打掃，應該是她會說一點點中文所以很樂於跟我們交流，是一個很活潑很熱心俏皮的人，也是為了賺錢給家裡蓋房子，她說老公都在耍廢😂
感謝支持! 關於什麼樣的話題你會想要了解 ? 我可以延續東南亞朋友的主題去採訪 😎
5:10 its perfectly fine if you do not speak chinese fluently like a taiwanese. Even me a chinese native speaker from Malaysia, may face playful teasing from them. It is important to understand that these remarks are meant in jest and should not be taken seriously. We are all valued and unique individuals in their eyes. Stay positive ⭐
台灣人看到東南亞臉孔和西方臉孔外國人的差別。
看到西方人臉孔時：你是來旅遊嗎？還是來留學的？你的中文說得很好耶
看到東南亞臉孔時：你是來照顧阿公阿嬤的嗎？
雖然是在諷刺但卻很寫實😂
你形容的很貼切 有股淡淡的哀傷
Bravo Jay! great work giving these women the mic. and as a blue-eyed former occasional blonde in taiwan, it is a SOLID YES a SOLID YES.
Thanks Jason ! It's my pleasure.
Totally agree with Nicole that not all Asian/Chinese look can speak Chinese. Well, Most of Thai-Chinese don't speak Chinese as mother tongue in Thailand like Chinese Malaysian or Singaporean. When I travel to Taiwan, I get the questions from Taiwanese that "You're lookalike Chinese, why I can't speak Chinese?"
Lighter skinned 'Asian' people are not necessarily Chinese, They just live there. People who are so hung up on the concept of being 'Chinese' need a reality check quick.
I think it’s necessary for Taiwanese to understand that there are a lot of Chinese Diaspora in South East Asia. Many are unable to speak mandarin due to geopolitical issues, mainly due to anti Chinese hatred in the past.
真的覺得這集很棒 我當初就是投東南亞朋友🤣。人都有刻板印象。透過這 可以了解更多 有時候真的是無心。但是傷人於無形啊～
謝謝參加投票😎 大家的意見也很重要
東南亞的人真的好可愛又好親切🥺
有時候還覺得他們比台灣人還好😭
該檢討冷漠的自己😂
前几天看了一个越南学生在韩国的评论，很多东南亚人在韩国遭受到很大的歧视和漠视。对比起来，台湾人真的很友善。发达不仅仅意味着有富裕的生活，人们也应该友善文明。台湾还是很好的。
請問，有影片連結嗎？
我的越南朋友也說，嫁去韓國的越南女生常常遭到家暴，但嫁到台灣被家暴的很少。
別太單純，還有很多糟糕的台灣雇主。你沒聽過而已。
毕竟韩国
對海外當勞工的，遇到好的雇主待遇就好，遇到很苛的也有。相對的，要請到好的工人也很難。而且好於不好因人而異。因此法律上的健全，社會的文化就顯得非常重要，最起碼要保護雙方不至於受到肢體傷害，利益不被剝削，能夠真正做到就很好了。
我想要謝謝所有海外來到台灣工作的朋友，謝謝你們幫助照顧我們台灣人，幫助我們台灣的經濟！感恩！
絕大多數移工來台辛苦工作都是想要存錢回去蓋房或做生意。但是桃園以南的一些工廠移工許多買了電動車更花很多錢在改裝車上。不知道是否有機會採訪到這類移工，看看他們的想法。
工廠移工我會單獨做一集出來
電動痛車改到比市面台灣機車還貴，當然是為了把妹啊
現在政府都在抓非法改裝電動車，現在改裝的應該會來越少，我聽過改好一台都要破十萬塊
我們鄉下地方還是有騎腳踏車的...
難道是被扣死當的關係？
反過來想，台灣人自己工作三年能蓋房嗎？
Glad foreigners are like this place, truly.
For the ladies and young girls had been interviewed in this video
Most Taiwanese are friendly and kind (I can't say "all") also, most people have no racism (no matter skin color/race/gender/body shape). If a bad experience in any part you had(if), i/we/many many Taiwanese will feel sorry and will try to help/correct it.
Hope you like this place and enjoy every day here.😅
I've lived in Korea for 3 years and I see similar things happening here too.
Generally, Korean people don't seem to know the difference between Taiwan and Thailand.
There was a Taiwanese exchange student in my school and he was being asked if he rides an elephant when he went to school in Taiwan or if he ever knew muay thai. I saw him explaining that he is not from Thailand over and over. I think it is because Koreans don't know much about Taiwan but know couple things about Thailand. Both Taiwan and Thailand spells almost identical in Korean letters too, so when they hear the word 'Taiwan', the image of 'Thailand' pops up in their heads. I don't think Koreans weren't trying to be rude to those Taiwanese people, they were just curious about the country.
Taiwan = Thailand --> This is very classic 😂
Just look, Indonesia is now one of the centers of the world economy, and is also a member of the G20 (20 richest countries in the world). Indonesia is now also a leader in Southeast Asia, both in terms of economy, technology and military. A country that is vast and has unlimited natural resources makes developed countries eager to collaborate with it.
Taiwanese people don't see that. They only see Indonesians as workers.
We love all people in Taiwan!!❤❤
Thanks for all people come from other country to Taiwan! thanks for your hard working!
Thanks to the people of Taiwan. A nice people ever I know
歧視的部份真的很鳥...希望那些歧視他人的混蛋趕快覺醒, 改過自新.
也希望不管是哪裡來的在我們國家居住的外國人都可以覺得自由自在, 快樂生活.
我相信啦～「部分人」有時候人們只是驚訝他們的皮膚白皙或美麗超過他們的刻板印象所以感到驚訝，甚至有一點稱讚的意味～當然不是全部😅
我覺得那些人其實都只是刻板印象而已
驚訝大於預期 心理完全沒有惡意
講成歧視有點太過了......
我工作環境就是會接觸很多移工
他們一開始也會覺得我們會排外
後面才會了解其實不是歧視 就是只是不了解而已 會歧視的只有那些老闆......很多老闆對移工待遇真的只有越省越好而已....
摳門計較與無理要求 容易被其他間公司的朋友慫恿 會使得移工想要逃逸
印尼國土長又廣跨三個時區的樣子，其實他們國家人民本來就有不同的膚色，但不管是什麼膚色都不能作為人種好壞之分😮
謝謝移工朋友來台灣幫忙👍
只能說有些台灣人眼界還太小，去過東南亞才知道這個世界不是只有華人才是亞洲人。
印度人、西亞人、俄羅斯人也都是亞洲人
只是有些人不這麼認為而已🤣
不需要去過也知道，只是單純無知。
@@g8manxdla 對還有蒙古人
還好啦，有的國家還到處逼人當中國人。
我從小到大都是信奉人人平等的觀念，但是看了很多影片才知道原來某些說法會讓別人覺得歧視或不舒服，即便自己完全沒有那個意思，所以也在慢慢學習中。
Indonesia itu sangat luas, beragam suku. Factor cuaca juga mempengaruhi, yang tinggal didaerah yang lebih dingin biasanya kulitnya lebih putih. Gak mesti keturunan tionghoa saja yang mesti putih, gue asli sunda juga kadang dikira Chindo.
ya krn mayoritas melihat para pekerja pabrik atau asisten rt yg kebetulan nggak putih kulitnya
padahal ya ada internet super canggih yg langsung bisa kasih info indonesia tuh kayak apa
kalo perlu liburan ke asean deh
pasti akan menemukan bahwa yg punya kulit terang itu banyak
apa warga taiwan itu sgt sibuk dan lupa piknik?
atau hanya mau liburan ke tempat yg nyaman scr infrastruktur?
Kurang piknik 🤣😂🤣
天呀，為何每個英文都那麼好。謝謝，大家願意照顧外籍看護，外籍看護真的很辛苦，一定要好好照顧它們，謝謝他們。會問那些怪問題的，都老一輩。我很愛所有的外籍人士，我們健身房超多泰國人，它們生活條件都很好，很扯的是，都長得很帥，然後使用器材都會清潔，反而很多台灣人，使用器材都不擦，丟臉喔
印尼菲律賓 英文好是很正常的XD
泰國混血在這🙋😂
@@GE845634215632 印尼英文好的就當地比例來說也不多吧，出來的大多都是挑過的
印尼饒舌網紅英語很好
台灣人其實不是用膚色來歧視外國人，台灣人講話比較直接，也有可能是開玩笑，台灣看護的雇主真的都很照顧她們，我們工廠也有印尼員工他的妹妹跟他視訊聊天，房間一大堆瓶瓶罐罐的零食開心果，瓜子，還有水果，台灣人會買吃的都會買一些給她們吃
本来就是歧视人，说成只是讲话直接😢😢
Please, do not get angry while Taiwanese ask you about your skin color, because most of Taiwanese do not know or haven't been in Indonesia, They didn't mean to be rude to you, they were just curious that all!
台灣的社會真的要學習如何尊重每一個人，世界上的每一個人
支持這類型的企劃，讓更多背景不同的人有發聲的管道和機會👍
謝謝支持 我會多推出東南亞朋友系列的訪問
真的很多人覺得印尼很窮😂他們現在已經在發展了，越來越少印尼人願意來台灣工作或嫁到台灣
還有很多人不知道，很多是印尼華裔，他們講客家話，所以長得白也是正常
純印尼的五官跟皮膚比較好認
現在在台灣的不一定就是移工或者嫁來的，也有不少是留學生或有錢人😂
說實在不論是什麼原因來到台灣，他們還是很強，就論抗壓性跟外語還是適應力，真心佩服
台灣人會覺得東南亞貧窮不是刻板印象
台灣人均GDP：$35513
印尼人均GDP：$4691
@@chunyuchennn 作為台灣人我覺得沒什麼好驕傲的，一山還有一山高。他們在乎的是態度
而且我說他們正在發展中，很多人停留在他們過去，是刻板印象。你肯定沒看過老一輩的人是怎麼跟他們說話的吧？很多人無知的可笑
你只要在你社區附近多走動就知道了
@@瑜-b8d 我在跟你陳述事實而已，如果不包含華僑的話人均會更低，對一般台灣人理解印尼就是貧困的國家
真的很佩服他們+1！這些工作都是吃力不討好、語言不相通，台灣還是有很多歧視東南亞移工的觀點、政策、作法，只是平常不被重視罷了！有時候看到這些部分，真的覺得台灣遠遠落後西方國家。
@@chunyuchennn 對啊， 正如我新加坡出身現移居美國， 這2個國家很多人民也覺得台灣貧窮到不行。
美國人均GDP ：7萬多
新加坡人均GDP ： 7萬多
台灣人均GDP ： 3萬多
WHAT？居然連一半都沒有，看來覺得台灣窮也不是刻板印象。
我對這些離開自己國家，遠渡重洋的來台灣做很多低階辛苦工作的移工們，都是比大姆指看待，他們都很偉大很棒👍👍👍
其實就是國際觀的問題，看得太少了，就跟之前還有中國人問馬來西亞人怎麼會講中文一樣，以前台灣沒有那麼多外國人，才會自己都沒意識到問了那麼失禮的問題，現在年輕人已經好很多了，以後會越來越好
台湾还会每天把我们归类中国人因为用简体😢😢
@@Ssss-zm1gs 畢竟翻牆來吵架的小粉紅也不少，所以多少影響到台灣人看到簡體字的觀感，但通常沒有跟台灣人吵架的前提下，你講你是大馬華人，台灣人通常就會閉嘴了，或回喔！表示知道😅
@@fishswiminwaterfish 台湾人也影响到我对繁体字观感
@@Ssss-zm1gs 不過使用繁體字的也不是只有台灣人就是了
@@fishswiminwaterfish 大多数台湾人，剩下的就香港人和一部分喜欢繁体的人罢了
Lack of flavor in food is definitely the most difficult thing about being a foreigner in Taiwan. Not much variety
這影片提醒了我們，雖然我對膚色沒有刻板印象，但在台灣人自己覺得不帶惡意的把膚色當作聊天話題時，請注意其實對方多數是會在意的！
你說的很客觀👍
Those are 49ner
The three young fair skin ladies are Chinese indonesians. Thats why they have fair skin.
我屏東人，來台南工作，很多台南人也常驚訝問我，怎麼你屏東人皮膚那麼白，其實他們真意應該不是歧視而是羨慕～可能是台灣大部分人都很喜歡皮膚白白的。
只是真的要注意，這樣不經意的刻板印象言語，真的很容易讓人感到是一種歧視
是的 重點是對方的感受
屏東喔！好懷念的地方，
當年我龍泉待幾個月，黑的跟什麼似！
I am a Vietnam born Chinese. I left Vietnam when i was 5 years old and went to the USA where i lived for the next 40 years. I've been living in Taiwan for 4 years now and teach English to children. Every now and then, Taiwanese would make comments about me not covering up while out in the sun. Their intentions for the most part is well because the sun can damage your skin, but the other part is about staying 'fair/light', and i dont say 'white' because Asians are not and will never be 'white', we are 'yellow skin tone'. I dont have a problem with what skin color people prefer but to tell other people to do the same is stepping over the line.
Also, with English teachers here, there is a pay difference depending on your race. In general, they would pay Filipinos or anyone they perceived as 'Asian' a lower salary. While i understand Taiwanese just wants an authentic experience for their child, it may not be healthy to have that shadow lingering in one's consciousness saying: I'm Asian and i'll never speak perfect English.
Thank you for sharing. ❤❤❤
Thank you for watching ☺
Indeed, so many Indonesian living in Taiwan for working and studying, at least around 375K!
遇到好雇主也是要靠運氣呢，總之移工們也是為了臺灣社會做了很多的貢獻
First time come to ur channel love it ,good job for interview ❤
Thank you 🙏
4.45那位女生的言談不就在歧視自己同胞? 意思就是{台灣人覺得印尼人黑黑的是因為他們是移工 像我這種留學生就不是}
至於刻板印象我是很認同要用更圓融的方式表達，但我相信台灣人沒有惡意。身邊很多人都很謝謝他們辛苦來到台灣
工作，協助我們社會~
那個女生明顯是印尼華人，印尼華人經濟條件比本地人要高不少，在台灣做看護的幾乎都是印尼本地人，沒有華人，印尼農村華人男子有可能去台灣做外勞，但是也不多。印尼稅率低，人口多，市場大，街邊開個小吃店，一月賺幾萬人民幣是常事。
@@fredcheng2736 belum tentu, bisa jadi mereka orang Nias, orang Dayak atau dari suku lain yg secara fisik memang 100% menyerupai orang Asia timur, meskipun di Indonesia ada 20 juta orang Tionghoa. Namun karena nenek moyang orang Indonesia berasal dari Yunan, China Daratan maka banyak suku lainnya yang menyerupai orang China 😅, jangan terlalu cepat menyimpulkan di Indonesia ada 350 suku dan 700 lebih bahasa 😊
她只是在陳述區別而已。 對於刻板印象的不舒服。
而且她的意思是大部分台灣人知道的是移工，不是黑黑的就是移工也不是移工就是黑黑的
（可能她被問很多次了吧
身為台灣人，我真為我們的人文教育感到丟臉😔
台灣加油
我覺得台灣人有時候是
說者無意；聽者有心～
菲律賓人都充滿歡樂❤
我覺得也不是歧視 很多人有時候聊天會抓不準那個距離 會常常問一些白目問題
尤其是年紀大的 像我同事就常常會問客人一些白目問題 對象不止外國人 大部分都是台灣人
有時候我在旁邊聽了也很想阻止他
但他覺得自己是在跟客人打好關係 他覺得他問這些沒什麼問題⋯⋯
希望東南亞的朋友不要想太多 台灣有些人真的白目 但沒有惡意啦
good to hear the first goal is house ,, love from india
我覺得絕大多數的台灣人對待來自任何國家的人都是很友善的，希望不管外國朋友是來自哪裡都能享受在台灣的一切
非常棒的街訪，外國人來台灣的活動已漸漸不同，但主流媒體卻沒好好討論這議題。
特別是東南亞現在經濟正在大幅成長，未來天秤會越來越傾斜。
感謝支持 🙏
有在關注國外同類型的節目 很開心台灣也有這類優質的頻道 期待之後的更新!!
感謝你的支持 繼續努力💪
Taiwan is technically counted as a southeast asian country as well
Ah i relate her (the Indonesian). I don't know maybe they see us (Indonesian) are black or dark skin something like that.
Because i have a light skin color, and i think that's normal for people who don't know much about Indonesia. Yeah we have many ethnicity here, u can find any race here. There are people with very light skin color, also there are people with very dark skin color. But majority was yellow to brown i would say because you know the weather was sooo hot here.
The dark skin Taiwanese di Taiwan😅
th-cam.com/video/nxDI-JmZeLc/w-d-xo.htmlsi=SS-YHky_PpzEb6p8
也許我們對印尼人的刻版印像是皮膚比較黑,，我是出國後才知道印尼有好多不同民族,，說真的皮膚白大概率是有華人血統～長的跟我們一般台灣人蠻像的, 白白的！她們如果被台灣人說怎麽比較白或比較黑也可以回說因為她們有什麼血統所以如此．讓台灣人知道。過去也比較少東南亞人來台旅游所以ㄧ般接觸不多，很難分辯印尼人 馬來西亞人 菲律賓人。
所有的智人祖先都在非洲, 簡單的說所有的人類本來都是純黑.
全世界有兩個地方特化出白皮膚基因, 一個是歐洲, 一個是東北亞, 因為這些地方極端缺乏太陽光, 白皮膚可以盡可能地吸收陽光以在陽光不足的情況下製造足夠的維他命D.
歐洲就不用多說, 基本上在歐洲這詞本身就等於白人.(Europe是希臘文的"大眼") (海南島和英國在同個歐亞大陸板塊, 所以歐洲和亞洲是人文的分割, 不是地理的分割, 這是大陸歸類法的一個大異類, 因為所有其他的大陸都是用板塊分界. 所以光是"歐洲"這詞本身就是帶著種族意識, 只是現代人大多數已經內化了這個事實, 很少注意到這一點)
但東北亞的白皮膚基因是比較近代才開始擴散, 這隻人種本來被地理阻隔在一個小區域, 因為小冰河時期到來, 氣溫驟降無法支撐現有人口所以被迫大逃荒, 一部分經由白令橋東移進入美洲大陸, 成為依努特(愛斯基摩)和美洲原住民.
一部分則是南移, 穿越華人神話中的天堂接口:崑崙山進入中原和當地原住民(藏人分支)經過"文化整合" (黃帝與蚩尤對抗), 演變成今天一大部分的東亞人 (華人, 韓國人, 蒙古人, 日本人, 清人). 因為是白皮膚和黑皮膚混和, 所以東亞人膚色光譜廣.
所以在大航海時代到來前全世界有有白皮膚基因的大致上有歐洲人, 東亞人, 東北亞人和美洲原住民這四支而已.
所謂的"白皮膚基因"只有兩種, 一種是西歐基因, 一種是東北亞基因.
Good respectfully devised questions 🎉
I appreciate it 😎
台灣普遍對東南亞地區還是有些歧視，畢竟他們較落後發展較慢要改變這種觀感並非一朝一夕，但跟10、20年前比起來能感受到有在改善了
在雲林的親戚，他們自己栽種溫室番茄，每次收成只有他們夫妻超級辛苦
幸虧有外籍移工幫忙，才讓他們不致於兩個人忙到翻掉
就像台灣人去西方國家打工存錢一樣，我們若在那遭受歧視也會忿忿不平
除去一小部分素質不好的人還有過重的香水味，真的很感謝外籍移工願意做這些活
真的, 台灣人去歐美打工=亞洲移工, 對他們來說我們看起來都一樣
有次在產業道路上車子陷進泥坑，剛好有三個要去抓魚的菲律賓移工經過，他們很快幫我把車子救出來，還跟我分享他們帶的自釀米酒，那喝起來很像養樂多。後來我也跑去附近手搖店買了不錯的珍奶回敬，也順便表示謝意。
之後才知道常有移工開台直播，或錄製他們在台灣放假抓魚的短片，或許他們比很多台灣人都知道台灣的大自然和內陸水域呢！
你分享的經驗很酷 感受到人性的美
@@JayChenTaiwan 那是最真摯的人性之美，單純地伸出援手並且分享所有
👍
釣魚真的很常遇到😂
他們都還會讓我小孩看他們釣到的魚，有次有位大哥還送我們一隻帶回家。
@@er26562002 他們真的很會，譬如這個印尼移工 Ulum Zaenal，不只會抓魚，影片點閱數也很高
拉到你的影片 很適合我的口味 本人很喜歡這種街頭訪問 訂閱你了 也祝福你訂閱量更多 加油唷
感謝支持😎
Jay, I personally not blaming the Taiwanese having a "negative mind set" against southeast asian, It is a matter of how the teachers, parents educate their children. Chinese and Indian ethnic are spread out in the entire world, I believe you will find them from northern southern hemisphere. My opinion they are not racist, just lack of knowledge. 😁😁😁
Hey KV Sulinom, Thanks for your message. When I heard Nicole saying about skin things towards Southeast Asian.Yes, I was shocked! I maybe used a bit strong word " Racist" to descirbe it. However, I think you are right -> "lack of knowledge"
他們都好可愛 感覺都好善良
I don't think most people ask about why your skin is so white is out of racism, for older generation (or just all generations in Taiwan) to give this comment, it is normally a compliment. And southeast asian tend to have darker skin, that's the impression worldwide not just exclusive in Taiwan. I hope friends from Southeast Asia understand that people don't mean to be rude or ill-willed.
im sorry but that what we call "Racist". in fact Southeast Asian is not darker skin, its almost same tone with your skin even more white than Taiwanese itself. especially in Singapore, Vietnam and Thailand. but almost every SEA Country have white skin like taiwan and its not mix anymore its 100% native.
@@mobagenieI am Vietnamese & I must say our Viet girls have whiter skin than Taiwanese. Even more beautiful, I swear. People there they've never go to bar, club in Vietnam to see our girls.
@@kikiwonwon29 yes That right.. im feel so angry and crazy knowing that Country like Taiwan still have super low knowldege about their neighborhood country :/
Nicole 一定在美加待過好一陣子，英文口音太標準了
蠻特別的一集，讓我們知道東南亞朋友的想法
謝謝你
台灣人對於東南亞的移工或移民有非常大的歧視問題 一部分來自他們對於台灣社會常模的不了解導致行為使台灣人反感 另一部分來自台灣人對他們的不了解 多一點這種訪問是很棒的
感謝支持
推！內容很有意思！
謝謝🙏
今天偶然遇到這頻道，真的很好看😍
希望有機會看到更多
謝謝你的讚美 繼續努力 😎
Their English is very good.其實很羨慕他們花三年就可以買房子。台灣一般人要花20-30年。
現在一般人工作一輩子都買不起了 隨便就是千萬起跳
大家英文都好棒，加油！🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉祝大家都有美好的未來