He was baiting 100% he was just sitting by his laptop, stroking his mustache and waiting for someone to respond with something around the lines of “then you do it then!”
@williammarchand253 that is irrelevant though. To his skill level. The original video piano player was really was A Mediocre to him. Age never was the focus of the argument. It was about skill.
@@timexyemerald6290 Yeah the person got what they asked for, they couldn't fathom what mediocre is because they were a non-player. Had to sting because it also reveals that their musical taste and ear was atrocious. Glad they got pwned LMAO
@@noobboss0 he was a legendary pianist back then and he retired until he got in an argument on youtube and decided to go back to the pianist life he once forsakened
In his video’s description, Fanchen said that he didn’t mean it in a bad way and that he just meant there was some room for improvement, and later he got in good terms with the original commenter and i think later he also made a collab with the original video’s creator, so it actually ended up being the *good ending*
WAIT! FANCHEN ISN’T MEAN! On the channel that posted the so-called “mediocre” Rush E, Fanchen supported him on his newest video. He is a supporter of their channel.
@@Squeekysquidnahhh I mean technically. He didnt want to kill off half the universe because it was funny. He truly believed it would fix the universe's problem of poverty/hunger. He was right, it did fix it, but that doesn't mean it was a good thing to do
@@Firerr16bruh the entire universe is so big like what are the chances earth people are exactly half wiped out, why not the entirety of some other planet, and none of ours, or all of ours, or just kill all the microbes, so many plot holes in this fr fr
Being considered or rated as "mediocre" from that dude actually is almost a compliment. His statement is based on his expertise and in comparision to his actually almost savant skill level. Maybe his statement hurt the creator of the video, or he felt criticized but the guy rated his performance on HIS very own scale. In his reaction video is mentioned that he even didn't want to upload that video, because his performance didn't meet his standards. "Niveau only looks like arrogance if viewed from below."🤷🏻♂️
The video is definition of being mediocre, the quality was there but it couls get much better as shown. Some people didnt like it some did thats why its "ok". Of course he rated it on HIS OWN SCALE, and in HIS EYES it was mediocre. Who elses scale are you using when youre trying to judge whether something is good or bad XDXD People like you get offended for someone calling your efforts as OK and then you get mad about it because someone can have higher expectations for something :O Guess what ur comment was mediocre too, pussy boi.
@Dylan Ogega Yes it is. Arrogance is arrogance, regardless of whether you’re actually capable or talented. Two people can both be superb at something, one can be arrogant about it and the other can be humble.
Off the bat in the video reply, the fact Fanchen has a K. Kawai Piano AT HOME should instantly raise your eyebrow hinting at his skill level if you know the price of these pianos
fr this ties into the jus because u spent days n days on something that’s extremely difficult n complete it dosent mean ur subjected to only positive feedback makes me mad cause a lotta ppl r like this irl too totally disregard on any non positive comments even if ur tryin to be respectful
JaGWLH kinda baited with the over-praise, but I cant fully side with Fenchen's approach. I have SEVERE doubts that if I went to an art museum or concerts and said "No offense, this is mediocre" to everything with no elaboration people would just nod and "appreciate my honesty". Personally people "can be jerks" about their opinion, but small comments like that come off as snooty unhelpful jerks looking for trouble. Have an INFORMED opinion and convince me, at least. Any d-bag can just say "I dont like it therefore its mediocre!" ike a brat.
As another musician, not only is hearing and pointing out flaws in others performances completely involuntary, but sometimes I wish people would tell me that I got things wrong while playing to give me motivation to keep practicing rather than feeding my procrastination with delusions lol
not a musician, but an artist. this sentiment can be shared with literally ANYTHING! you cannot improve if nobody gives you feedback, and while some people see feedback as rude, it is absolutely a necessity. ive gone as far as to tell someone that i want them to insult my art just to get some critique out of them, because the most they weere willing to do was call my art ‘nice.’
@wrightcember have you ever just walked by some painting or piece and just been disgusted by how bad the techniques were. Clear brush strokes, bad mixing of thinner, terrible composition, etc. One of my memories was someone asking me how a piece was on their phone and I just went off involuntarily. They deleted their post after and I felt bad ( the person who showed me their art was a younger cousin). I've been trained for this and it makes me sad.
@@aaronmontgomery2055 ive done the same, but you should tone it down. ive had to teach this to myself and a LOT of people do not appreciate criticism without explicit permission. if they dont wanna learn, they dont wanna be taught :(
@wrightcember I know how to hold it but when a parents ask if their kids art is good and I can only bite my tongue to uh-huh. If they press me I have to sound so dishonest since I have obvious tells when I'm lying.
@A Z Did your parents love you enough? I ask only because I can’t think of any other reason you would be here talking shit. It’s also weird since your pfp is something a 12 year old would have. O and btw I’m great at piano.
@A Z Aw. I’m REALLY sorry I got to you. I guess someone hasn’t encountered enough trolls to know that’s what I was doing. In case it wasn’t clear by my claim of piano playing, I was joking. Maybe I should have expected you to take it to heart *since* you took the time to correct the usage of the word “troll” in another online joke… And I’m not sure what you think the word “since” means, but I’m using it as a conjunction.
I think it’s worse to have someone who gets told “Do it better than, jerk” and then decides to dedicate 5 years of their life to learning an entire trade just to do it better.
@@1404kevinmicik Yeah, but that implies he was already good at piano. That’s not as terrifying to me as “Someone said I couldn’t do it, let me take a college course and master the trade so that I can prove them wrong”
Lets be honest #1: Everyone NEEDS a friend that will tell you the truth. #2: Criticism isnt a bad thing just because there is not "positive" part. #3: If the guy saying you suck can do it better than you, then he is justified in haaving his opinion and speaking it.
Also, mediocre is average. I bet a mediocre millionaire doesn't take offense to that term. Rush E is hardz and takes a lot of talent to play and upload. So even mediocre of the best, is still good. Plus, he even said No Offense.
His comment wasn't even mean. He knew what he was talking about, and it was mediocre to him. It is fantastic to us plebs that cannot play at all, but to someone that has the ear for this kind of stuff, it was probably less than mediocre and his comment was holding back.
I mean if youve watched the original even someone with no musical talent/knowledge could tell it was a bit sloppy. They just missed notes and it just wasnt clean. That doesnt mean it wasnt impressive, id be more than happy if i had that level of skill, it just was a bit mediocre if youre 100% honest
Yeah. Like that one time I got pissed at someone calling sharks murderous beasts so I spent over an hour looking for credible sources. They never replied, I wonder why?
My phone somehow just glitched and I gave you four likes? I opened the replies, gave ur comment a like, left and saw that the total went up but the button wasn't blue, and hit it 3 more times, seeing the counter go up each time, until it turned blue. Weirdest youtube glitch I've ever seen personally.
He wasn't being an asshole he was just being honest. This is like when you watch a fight and the guy next to you is like "I could kick both their asses".. only this time the guy next to you was Jon Jones, so he sounded like an A hole but he was honest, just like this kid.
If that "bad guy" was actually musical professional, it's quite normal for him to share his honest opinion. Why should he lie? He's not your friend or mother nor your girlfriend. Yeah, he's being harsh, but that's mainly in response to incompetent (in his opinion) praises. Also, harsh criticism is important for anyone struggling to improve. All that blind overpraising makes people too stop trying to improve. Of course, the criticism might eventually break your will to engage in that field (because it seems that you don't improve at all). But there are 2 important points: 1) Don't engage in such open and competitive fields if your psyche is that weak because you'll face harsh (and sometimes unreasonable) criticism anyway, 2) One instance of critical response won't do much harm, only systemic harsh treatment would really affect any normal person.
I like to imagine that Fanchen actually knew nothing about piano before this, and his piano abilities were fuelled by nothing other than pure spite and hubris.
As a guitarists I can guarantee you that type of trash talking will get him verbally assaulted and if said to the wrong guitarist, punched. In short, talent means nothing if you can't defend yourself
He apparently has a piano video from five years ago. Still, not impressed that he decided to be an arrogant piece of shit just because he knows how to play the piece better than an aspiring musician.
clearly his comments had the mosts likes so he did get the satisfaction he wants and charlie is in the wrong here for desperetly trying to make him look bad when the majority was liking the "asshole" comments. stop putting your fragility into work he didnt even insult the artist itself but the work he put on social media. if his opinion didnt suit you clearly it did for others or else he wouldnt of gotten so many likes
@@jameshakai1662 The thing is, a lot of pianists, especially the good ones, are classically-trained musicians. My personal experience with classically-trained musicians is that they tend to be, how do I put this in a non-offensive way, proud perhaps? They are proud that they're good at what they do, so much so that if you're inferior to them they'll be sure to let you know. In contrast, a lot of contemporary musicians (most guitarists, bassists, drummers, etc) are really chill. This is just anecdotal of course, so take it with a grain of salt.
People have different ways of elaborating their argument. Fanchen's way of elaboration is more effective in backing up his argument than just spouting out some musical theories that will fly over most people's heads.
WAIT! FANCHEN ISN’T MEAN! On the channel that posted the so-called “mediocre” Rush E, Fanchen supported him on his newest video. He is a supporter of their channel.
"I see you have promise. I will let you live for now and let you return to me when your stronger. Farewell" *Fucking goes straight through a mountain and destroys 7 villages just by trying to retreat back to his homebase*
Wouldve been so funny if the hentai dude commented “mediocre performance, no offense”. And then just uploads his version of the song which is 50x better
In the end they work together to put play the third pianist who played better then both of them but when the three unite the play the impossible version and grab a pizza together
Being a classical musician for around 20 years I can tell you that this is how a lot of classical musicians treat eachother from what I’ve experienced - especially in professional settings
The funniest part is it’s a custom arrangement and people don’t even appreciate that. You can’t just go online and find simplified versions of Rush E. Well, you can, but they’ll all be the same one or two versions. This is HIS arrangement, adding even more skill to this feat.
Fr, people don't get that half of the difficulty, and honestly most of the brainwork (for me anyway) goes into arranging/transcribing the music rather than learning the piece itself.
I FUCKING LOVE HOW TH-cam RECOMMENDS OLD VIDEOS SO REDDITORS LIKE YOU CAN MAKE THE EXTREMELY OBVIOUS OBSERVATIONS! Jokes aside, there is literally no creativity or originality in this comment section, and if there is, it’s just a different way to say the same thing.
@@sunium5814 Not sure if you wanna trigger me with that , but no matter what i will take it as you wrote it, have a nice day! EDIT: Just for clearing up he edited his comment, it ended with and , instead of .
This is like when a guy claimed to be more ripped than you and better at guitar and you say prove it and he comes over a claps your mom and becomes step dad.
Hentai guy deserves to be shamed. It's always a cop out for losers like him to say that people can't criticise if they can't do it in the first place. Hope he goes off himself
i can understand franchen.the way the hentai dude said "i don't see anyone else actually playing it" seems pretty annoying knowing there is probably someone like franchen who's better.
As someone who played piano for a few years I can totally understand why he said it was mediocre. It's pretty easy to spot mistakes for a trained ear but for an average person it still sounds insane.
@@BlakouttheMM See, that is a very good point, however, you can argue that Charlie’s lexicon consists of all 27 ways you can say butthole in polite conversation. The lexicon of buttholes.
This is going to sound super lame but, honestly helping someone and actually seeing them improve is a way better feeling than dissing anyone. Unless maybe the person you were dissing was being an asshole first.
He was baiting 100% he was just sitting by his laptop, stroking his mustache and waiting for someone to respond with something around the lines of “then you do it then!”
He didn't wait he looked and found
Chad
He was.. dare i say it.. trolling
@@eeveesmusic1938 He was just being an asshole
@@disliked1390 In Ireland we say,
Jaaaysus Yer man can feckin play
If you're an asshole but can back it up, you're not an asshole, you're just Tony Stark.
Here before it blows up
He’s the 1% David Goggins mentioned
Holy shit hes iron man
.
Underrated comment right here
Fun fact: This dude needed 2 weeks for it, 1 for preparation and 1 week for learning it. This guy has a lot of talent.
He also has an insanely good WORK ETHIC.
This comes from practicing and hard work throughout time, no other way.
Did you think this was funny? Corny boy 🤡
Yea but didn’t he have like a lifetime of playing piano under his belt tho lol
@williammarchand253 that is irrelevant though. To his skill level. The original video piano player was really was A Mediocre to him.
Age never was the focus of the argument. It was about skill.
@@timexyemerald6290 Yeah the person got what they asked for, they couldn't fathom what mediocre is because they were a non-player. Had to sting because it also reveals that their musical taste and ear was atrocious.
Glad they got pwned LMAO
Fanchen: Oh, you're a villain alright, just not a *super* one!
JaGWLH: Oh yeah? What's the difference?
Fanchen: *PRESENTATION!!*
Comments you can hear
who is JaGWLH
@@rafsanstudent3792 acronym for the user who was arguing with Fanchen: Just a guy who loves hentai
You must have absolutely awesome book/tv series/movie recommendations. Share a few?
@@TrekStar11accurate
Plot twist: Fanchen wasn’t good at piano when he made the first comment. He became a pianist out of pure spite.
A legend was born through a youtube argument lmao
😂😂😂
Ik this is a joke but fanchen has a piano video from 5 years ago
this is my favorite theory
@@noobboss0 he was a legendary pianist back then and he retired until he got in an argument on youtube and decided to go back to the pianist life he once forsakened
"Man who likes hentai challenges pianist, lives to regret his decision"
Dharr man moment
Someone please narrate something obvious!
Was bout to say sum bout Dhar Mann but other beat me to it.
Babylon Bee, The Onion, and The Hard Times better be covering this
So you see
crazy thing is, he only said it was "mediocre" lol, they created a monster when he just meant the rendition needed work.
I don't even play piano and could tell it was mediocre lmao.
I know its an impossible piece to play, but i agree with the comment above me, it didnt sound all that good
"If you speak the truth, have a foot in the stirrup."
He worded it pretty badly, something he himself admitted in the description of the video
@@happylad7765 it WAS mediocre tho
In his video’s description, Fanchen said that he didn’t mean it in a bad way and that he just meant there was some room for improvement, and later he got in good terms with the original commenter and i think later he also made a collab with the original video’s creator, so it actually ended up being the *good ending*
Lol guy who loves hentai asf after that : 🤡😭
Man fuck that. Why's everybody always on some peacemaker bullshit.
@@thayerfletcher731 seems like you want people to be angry at other people for uh, what reason?
@@rob_epic Nah man fuck it shit's too boring. People too soft. And everybody happy n shit. Fuck all that love. Where's a bit of vitriolic hatred?
@@thayerfletcher731 bro wants to start another year-long argument 😭🙏
“Then do it. Stop talking and DO IT.” Doom music kicks in.
*Doom music played in piano kicks in*
WAIT! FANCHEN ISN’T MEAN! On the channel that posted the so-called “mediocre” Rush E, Fanchen supported him on his newest video. He is a supporter of their channel.
Regret incoming in 10
All caps
Rush E starts playing
"unfortunately, it fucking slaps."
not a sentence you see every day.
hear*
@@DaveLambertITA taste*
@@desensitized smell*
@@callmezombie6323 feel*
@@libersia7302 We’re out of senses
I wouldn’t even say he was being an asshole, he was just extremely talented so his perspective is warped.
Franchen wasn’t the antagonist. He was simply here to remind us we aren’t the protagonist.
Like Thanos, people didn’t like him but he was right.
pianotagonist
@@Scooter227bait
@@Squeekysquidnahhh I mean technically. He didnt want to kill off half the universe because it was funny. He truly believed it would fix the universe's problem of poverty/hunger. He was right, it did fix it, but that doesn't mean it was a good thing to do
@@Firerr16bruh the entire universe is so big like what are the chances earth people are exactly half wiped out, why not the entirety of some other planet, and none of ours, or all of ours, or just kill all the microbes, so many plot holes in this fr fr
“Why are you booing me? I'm right." - Fanchen, probably.
And he is.
And he actually is
People will always have a bad attitude, not caring about how the first guy feels. Hentai Guy did all the talking so they have no right to piss on him
He was right though
Idk get why people are against him the hentai guy was just kinda cringe imo
“If youre an asshole noone will respect your skill”
*every fine artist in history laughing*
cough cough stanley kubrick
*choke cough cough* Gordon Ramsay *cough*
*physically dying* every comedian ever
_literally already dead_ Wagner says YEET
cough cough *hitler*
Being considered or rated as "mediocre" from that dude actually is almost a compliment.
His statement is based on his expertise and in comparision to his actually almost savant skill level.
Maybe his statement hurt the creator of the video, or he felt criticized but the guy rated his performance on HIS very own scale.
In his reaction video is mentioned that he even didn't want to upload that video, because his performance didn't meet his standards.
"Niveau only looks like arrogance if viewed from below."🤷🏻♂️
The video is definition of being mediocre, the quality was there but it couls get much better as shown. Some people didnt like it some did thats why its "ok".
Of course he rated it on HIS OWN SCALE, and in HIS EYES it was mediocre. Who elses scale are you using when youre trying to judge whether something is good or bad XDXD
People like you get offended for someone calling your efforts as OK and then you get mad about it because someone can have higher expectations for something :O Guess what ur comment was mediocre too, pussy boi.
And yet fanchen's îs pretty mediocre as well. He îs below
@@MihaiLupascu-kg9ssBelow 😂😂 Why lie?
@@MihaiLupascu-kg9ssdude tryna be him lmao
@@MihaiLupascu-kg9ss Fanchens is better though
He hit us with a "You got it twisted, I'm not the one who needs a new attitude"
Hypothetically, bro MIGHT be the backbone of the Vees.
Yuh
@@logans_left_toe maybe he’s mad that he acted respectless?
I think it’s cause no one could respect this
@@TheSpikestaralmost like sorry group attending but since when are pianists too scared to fight
@@Kindofboredhe knows the guy who likes hentai is long past trending. Sorry babe, but he ain’t swiping right.
This is what actually happens when the villain that trained for his entire life doesn't get a$$-plowed by the power of friendship.
😂
I really want some watchmojo typo video with title "top 10 villains that actually didn't fucking lost cuz of some stupid power of friendship"
lmfao this is one of the most relatable comments I’ve ever fucking read
@@ujjwal7297 kumo desu
yes brother
He has the skill to back up his arrogance, a true anti-hero.
That’s actually a pretty smart statement
The classic heel
@Dylan Ogega Yes it is. Arrogance is arrogance, regardless of whether you’re actually capable or talented. Two people can both be superb at something, one can be arrogant about it and the other can be humble.
@Dylan Ogega of course it is
@@criert135 yeah the man was obnoxiously arrogant with his abilities and kinda looked down on the poor rush e dude
Off the bat in the video reply, the fact Fanchen has a K. Kawai Piano AT HOME should instantly raise your eyebrow hinting at his skill level if you know the price of these pianos
Probably not at home I'd guess
could be at a family's house. @@_shadownotes_
@@_shadownotes_ still, not everyone has the opportunity to play a piano of that quality
@@_shadownotes_you would guess that 😂XD
@Buy-oz5fm yes I would?
Fanchen was not at all a bully, he gave an honest opinion and didn’t say “oh you fucking suck kid you should be embarrassed”
fr this ties into the jus because u spent days n days on something that’s extremely difficult n complete it dosent mean ur subjected to only positive feedback makes me mad cause a lotta ppl r like this irl too totally disregard on any non positive comments even if ur tryin to be respectful
JaGWLH kinda baited with the over-praise, but I cant fully side with Fenchen's approach.
I have SEVERE doubts that if I went to an art museum or concerts and said "No offense, this is mediocre" to everything with no elaboration people would just nod and "appreciate my honesty".
Personally people "can be jerks" about their opinion, but small comments like that come off as snooty unhelpful jerks looking for trouble.
Have an INFORMED opinion and convince me, at least.
Any d-bag can just say "I dont like it therefore its mediocre!" ike a brat.
@@DeepEye1994 People would just nod.
You taking it personal is the problem.
@@slimluka2947 so true, people's mentality nowadays are too weak. They don't want to hear the truth but only sweet words.
@@DeepEye1994 The comment he was responding to was literally asking for criticism.
This is proof that there is no stronger motivator than pure spite.
true
Sony and nintendo
this. Hate makes you stronger
Pretty unhealthy way of motivating urself tho
That's how murder happens
“Unfortunately, it fucking slaps.”
Best Charles quote.
🤨🤨🤨ayo??
WOOOOOOOOOOO!! YEAH BABY thatswhatsivebeenwaitingfor
thatswhatitsabout
wHOOOOOO
fanchen got the most likes to lol
I'm rewatching this video after finding it with "unfortunately it slaps"
not even close to the iconic "MY COCK IS THROBBING, THROBBING"
As another musician, not only is hearing and pointing out flaws in others performances completely involuntary, but sometimes I wish people would tell me that I got things wrong while playing to give me motivation to keep practicing rather than feeding my procrastination with delusions lol
Yes dude. Been playing for 15 years and this is exactly how i feel
not a musician, but an artist. this sentiment can be shared with literally ANYTHING! you cannot improve if nobody gives you feedback, and while some people see feedback as rude, it is absolutely a necessity. ive gone as far as to tell someone that i want them to insult my art just to get some critique out of them, because the most they weere willing to do was call my art ‘nice.’
@wrightcember have you ever just walked by some painting or piece and just been disgusted by how bad the techniques were. Clear brush strokes, bad mixing of thinner, terrible composition, etc. One of my memories was someone asking me how a piece was on their phone and I just went off involuntarily. They deleted their post after and I felt bad ( the person who showed me their art was a younger cousin). I've been trained for this and it makes me sad.
@@aaronmontgomery2055 ive done the same, but you should tone it down. ive had to teach this to myself and a LOT of people do not appreciate criticism without explicit permission. if they dont wanna learn, they dont wanna be taught :(
@wrightcember I know how to hold it but when a parents ask if their kids art is good and I can only bite my tongue to uh-huh. If they press me I have to sound so dishonest since I have obvious tells when I'm lying.
They actually eventually teamed up , good guys and "bad", to play it with 8 hands. I love it, what a story! 😍
Literally sounds like an Onion article.
“Worst troll on internet backs up claim of piano mastery.”
Hahaha 😂🤣
spot on. Nice.
There's a clickhole article to the same effect. Heartbreaking: The Worst Person You Know Just Made A Great Point
@A Z Did your parents love you enough? I ask only because I can’t think of any other reason you would be here talking shit. It’s also weird since your pfp is something a 12 year old would have.
O and btw I’m great at piano.
@A Z Aw. I’m REALLY sorry I got to you. I guess someone hasn’t encountered enough trolls to know that’s what I was doing.
In case it wasn’t clear by my claim of piano playing, I was joking. Maybe I should have expected you to take it to heart *since* you took the time to correct the usage of the word “troll” in another online joke…
And I’m not sure what you think the word “since” means, but I’m using it as a conjunction.
The Bravo is better, Alpha ain't shit
"Unfortunately, it fucking slaps"
Lol... That performance was good as hell.
An add came right after he said that for me
@@nanotron6491 Same
@Bold Coward still higher than her
It was mediocre, no offense
Probably because it was mediocre, no offence
"That wasn't supposed to happen."
I come back to this video randomly. It just feels good when the villan wins sometimes.
"unfortunately, it fucking slaps" sadder words have never been pronounced
Famous last words
“Unfortunately, it fucking slaps” FIN.
Brother
@@loognabet1753 brother...
@J IMAKREWITATL son?
Jesus Christ.
This guy is the worst fear of anyone who says "Do it better then, jerk" to tackle criticism.
I think it’s worse to have someone who gets told “Do it better than, jerk” and then decides to dedicate 5 years of their life to learning an entire trade just to do it better.
@@JacobNintendoNerd99 yes but if you look at the comments, he did it in about a week
@@1404kevinmicik Yeah, but that implies he was already good at piano. That’s not as terrifying to me as “Someone said I couldn’t do it, let me take a college course and master the trade so that I can prove them wrong”
@@JacobNintendoNerd99 the dedication lol
@@JacobNintendoNerd99 has that ever happened
Bro got a k kawai grand piano of course he’s good 😭
you know what's even better ? The two of them + another piano playing couple collabed and played Rush E. Iconic.
Plot Twist : Fanchen & Just A Guy Who Likes Hentai are the same person with different accounts, hustling for marketing their stuff.
*Takes notes*
@@StormsandSaugeye ✍✍✍
well if that's really the case then that's genius
Interesting
Ngl probably true I've seen it before
"So I said 'Hit me. Hit me!'"
"And what happened?"
"He hit me."
Ur pfp though..
@Fred Brayan no one feed the troll
WHAT HAPPENED TO YOUR HAND
Are you patched up now?
@@jblazerndrowzy Oh…. 🍳(｡_｡)🍲
This is one of those things where, by winning, he instantly went from the bad guy to the good guy
Winner writes history but this man's origin wasn't trampled with
Fanchen: every breath I take without your permission fuels myself esteem
Fenchen: "You are not that guy pal, you are not that guy"
Other guy: "Are you?"
Fenchen: "Absolutely"
Is this from something?
@@brucewayne2184 tough guy tik tok
@@ericchoi1515 college tutor to catch a predator Chris Hansen as well
Sigma guy
@@brucewayne2184 watch it in this channel
"This sucks"
"Sure, then I'd like to see you do better"
"Ok"
*Proceeds to do better*
@yes is that Candice?
Carl the Pooh is the perfect pfp for this comment's tone
@@w_ldan what's ligma?
@@TomasM30 who is joe
@@lolbosss deez what?
Lets be honest #1: Everyone NEEDS a friend that will tell you the truth. #2: Criticism isnt a bad thing just because there is not "positive" part. #3: If the guy saying you suck can do it better than you, then he is justified in haaving his opinion and speaking it.
Also, mediocre is average. I bet a mediocre millionaire doesn't take offense to that term. Rush E is hardz and takes a lot of talent to play and upload. So even mediocre of the best, is still good. Plus, he even said No Offense.
Just saying something is bad isn't criticism
@@Fish_tennisYou’re right. It’s not criticism, it’s just a fact.
@@joao34386 There is no objective metric for music. It's opinion. Even if it could be objective franchen didn't say why it's bad he just said it's bad
@@Fish_tennisdid everyone else who said its good explain exactly why it was good?
His comment wasn't even mean. He knew what he was talking about, and it was mediocre to him. It is fantastic to us plebs that cannot play at all, but to someone that has the ear for this kind of stuff, it was probably less than mediocre and his comment was holding back.
I mean if youve watched the original even someone with no musical talent/knowledge could tell it was a bit sloppy. They just missed notes and it just wasnt clean. That doesnt mean it wasnt impressive, id be more than happy if i had that level of skill, it just was a bit mediocre if youre 100% honest
The most dangerous troll is a troll that can back up his own trolling
Damn right
Yeah. Like that one time I got pissed at someone calling sharks murderous beasts so I spent over an hour looking for credible sources. They never replied, I wonder why?
True
wasn't a troll, dude was really packin
Those are the most important trolls
That's a hard "I'm not even mad, I'm impressed" moment.
Like a good wheel of cheese.
@@Abi-ki1rc very epic indeed
@@repentoryouwilllikewiseper8741 what
@@crazyboi6654 repent
Dude straight up got served
I love your channel, commentary and dry sarcasm, sir. Finally subscribed (long overdue)
I’ve been waiting for these types of videos from charlie
"He gives his rendition of this piece, and unfortunately, it fucking slaps.."
The disappointment in his voice just made it that much more funny lmao
Yeah keep talking mate
@@ThatsWhtasUp what
My phone somehow just glitched and I gave you four likes? I opened the replies, gave ur comment a like, left and saw that the total went up but the button wasn't blue, and hit it 3 more times, seeing the counter go up each time, until it turned blue.
Weirdest youtube glitch I've ever seen personally.
timestamp
@@xcels 6:23
I honestly wish more internet arguments were like this
Want to start one?
@@chaddy8565 Jeffrey eipstein didn't kill himself, prove me wrong
Why? Lonely?
No
@@Noah-lj2sg* finds and kills jeffrey epstein to prove my point*
He did, in fact, give us an awe-inspiring performance.
He wasn't being an asshole he was just being honest. This is like when you watch a fight and the guy next to you is like "I could kick both their asses".. only this time the guy next to you was Jon Jones, so he sounded like an A hole but he was honest, just like this kid.
Everyone: "Can you do something to fix your superiority complex?"
Fanchen: "My superiority works just fine."
Fanchen: "But I *am* superior."
It's not a complex. It's JUST superiority.
@@raeishimura hence they say that Fanchen Superiority works just fine
It's not complex. It's just simple.
"Superiority complex? I find it quite simple."
Dhar Mann wouldn’t be happy hearing about this story
This needs more likes LOL
DHAR MANNS TAKE ON THIS WOULD BE SO INSIGHTFUL
Guy makes fun of pianist instantly regrets it
Mean bully on TH-cam shows haters what he can really do!
@@federalbureauofinvestigati5549 What happens next is shocking
A truly wholesome outcome would be them playing together to get all the keys and smash that challenge.
Pretty sure they did.
Man hopefully that happens 😏
They did. Like, 2 years ago
If that "bad guy" was actually musical professional, it's quite normal for him to share his honest opinion. Why should he lie? He's not your friend or mother nor your girlfriend. Yeah, he's being harsh, but that's mainly in response to incompetent (in his opinion) praises.
Also, harsh criticism is important for anyone struggling to improve. All that blind overpraising makes people too stop trying to improve.
Of course, the criticism might eventually break your will to engage in that field (because it seems that you don't improve at all). But there are 2 important points:
1) Don't engage in such open and competitive fields if your psyche is that weak because you'll face harsh (and sometimes unreasonable) criticism anyway,
2) One instance of critical response won't do much harm, only systemic harsh treatment would really affect any normal person.
I like to imagine that Fanchen actually knew nothing about piano before this, and his piano abilities were fuelled by nothing other than pure spite and hubris.
As a guitarists I can guarantee you that type of trash talking will get him verbally assaulted and if said to the wrong guitarist, punched. In short, talent means nothing if you can't defend yourself
Unless you’re talented AT defending yourself
@@Birtheater4545 "Haha, daaamn bro, I'd totally *punch* that dude! I'm a guitarist brooo!" Stfu
He apparently has a piano video from five years ago. Still, not impressed that he decided to be an arrogant piece of shit just because he knows how to play the piece better than an aspiring musician.
@@Birtheater4545 real edgy
“Because when you're an asshole, it doesn't matter how right you are, nobody wants to give you the satisfaction.” -Rick and Morty.
Which episode is that from?
@@yanikt.8918 Vindicators 3, s3 e4, I think.
Being an asshole is when you don't pretend everything is perfect, even when its clearly shit
@@lambsauce8172 wat
clearly his comments had the mosts likes so he did get the satisfaction he wants and charlie is in the wrong here for desperetly trying to make him look bad when the majority was liking the "asshole" comments. stop putting your fragility into work he didnt even insult the artist itself but the work he put on social media. if his opinion didnt suit you clearly it did for others or else he wouldnt of gotten so many likes
You listen to a professor if he tells you that you're wrong
This is the kind of stuff I want to be able to do eventually as a new pianist
This is why playing the piano is concentrated mental torture. There’s always someone better than you around and they’ll make sure you know
Not relevant, because that applies to literally any kind of skill
@@jameshakai1662 Yeah theres always gonna be some snobby asshole to remind you they're better
@@pugbro2297 Then get so better so they can't say shit.
@@jameshakai1662 The thing is, a lot of pianists, especially the good ones, are classically-trained musicians. My personal experience with classically-trained musicians is that they tend to be, how do I put this in a non-offensive way, proud perhaps? They are proud that they're good at what they do, so much so that if you're inferior to them they'll be sure to let you know.
In contrast, a lot of contemporary musicians (most guitarists, bassists, drummers, etc) are really chill.
This is just anecdotal of course, so take it with a grain of salt.
@@jameshakai1662 not really
*Enters Comment Section*
"Pretty mediocre, no offense."
*Refuses to elaborate*
*Plays better version*
Fking bradd
That's what giga chads do.....
He elaborated plenty lol
@@justkidding3390 sorry i thought bradd is mean chad
People have different ways of elaborating their argument. Fanchen's way of elaboration is more effective in backing up his argument than just spouting out some musical theories that will fly over most people's heads.
First performance: 0:29 Fanchen’s performance: 6:30
Man imagine how the "mediocre guy" feels. He's like the child in the middle.
WAIT! FANCHEN ISN’T MEAN! On the channel that posted the so-called “mediocre” Rush E, Fanchen supported him on his newest video. He is a supporter of their channel.
@@KFP_Fanboy yeah, he literally said no offence, and later even gave criticism like why everyone hating on him, he seems like a socially awkward guy
@@de1isa That wasnt really constructive, also no offence but your opinion sucks. See, it changes nothing.
@@loglogic7846 no offense but let me quickly say something offensive
@@HercadosP tbf that isn't a racist statement
He's not just a bad guy, he's a well written anime antagonist
And the protagonist never came
"I see you have promise. I will let you live for now and let you return to me when your stronger. Farewell"
*Fucking goes straight through a mountain and destroys 7 villages just by trying to retreat back to his homebase*
A broken hero
He was misunderstood.
Literally the arc halfway through where the writer subverts expectations and the villain wins in order to make the triumphant ending more satisfying.
Fanchen simply talked the talk and walked the walk.
Blind people reading sheets for rush E: 💀
Plot twist: This was just an elaborate way to promote both their covers
Woahh big brain time, that would have been sick
It all make sense now...
@Low Tier God what are you going on about?
@@Minecraftguns It's the type of person you just scroll past, I think they're crazy
@@boomboom2644 understable
The Devil Went Down to Georgia, but this time he actually won.
He took his soul and kept that fucking golden fiddle
HA
But he didnt stick around cuz this is Gods country
The bad ending
Guitar Hero 3
No way i only just discovered this
"Real life isn't like anime, where the good guys always win"
tell that to me after I watched edgerunners
Wouldve been so funny if the hentai dude commented “mediocre performance, no offense”. And then just uploads his version of the song which is 50x better
that would've sparked such an epic rivalry
@lord z00mer and its just a repeat until they perfect the impossible version
In the end they work together to put play the third pianist who played better then both of them but when the three unite the play the impossible version and grab a pizza together
@@prodbykaji they would eventually combine forces like a megazord to master the song.
This is basically every episode of Dragonball Z
Man called his bluff. Apparently he wasn’t bluffing.
Beluga
@@beluga8956 O ma god. It’s the cat
@@beluga8956 yo, is that Beluga?
@@beluga8956 not verified
@@beluga8956 beluga
If friendship does not exist in anime, demon lords would be exactly like this guy
Motivating people through harsh words means nothing if no one is interested anymore in learning the craft you mastered.
Being a classical musician for around 20 years I can tell you that this is how a lot of classical musicians treat eachother from what I’ve experienced - especially in professional settings
@ik ur cool Shut.
Which doesn’t justify it lmao
Man that sucks. Why can't people just encourage each other instead of shitting on them?
@@MrFusion Because not everyone is a big suck up 🐱
@@devilliar3786 being a suck up and not being an asshole are two different things
“Man Calls Out Commenter, Lives To Regret His Decision” - Dhar Mann
hahaha exactly
@Low Tier God eat dn?
@Low Tier God are you just going around posting ltg copy pastas? if so its awesome
This is a god tier comment
so you see ...
Idk man, at a certain point when Michael Jordan says your jump shot sucks, you kinda just have to say “yes Michael “
This guy is Squilliam. "Oh no, he's HAWT! 😭"
The funniest part is it’s a custom arrangement and people don’t even appreciate that. You can’t just go online and find simplified versions of Rush E. Well, you can, but they’ll all be the same one or two versions. This is HIS arrangement, adding even more skill to this feat.
And he did it all in a week. Menace
😧
Fr, people don't get that half of the difficulty, and honestly most of the brainwork (for me anyway) goes into arranging/transcribing the music rather than learning the piece itself.
Man transposed a piece and perfected it in one week over an argument
I FUCKING LOVE HOW TH-cam RECOMMENDS OLD VIDEOS SO REDDITORS LIKE YOU CAN MAKE THE EXTREMELY OBVIOUS OBSERVATIONS!
Jokes aside, there is literally no creativity or originality in this comment section, and if there is, it’s just a different way to say the same thing.
It’s over when a pianist says a performance is mediocre.
Laughs in tinnitus
It's over when somone actually uses advanced grammar.
@@sunium5814 grammar is just away of making speech more regulated and understandable. If you understood what he said than every thing should be fine.
@@IshIKoara Yeah you are right.
@@sunium5814 Not sure if you wanna trigger me with that , but no matter what i will take it as you wrote it, have a nice day!
EDIT:
Just for clearing up he edited his comment, it ended with and , instead of .
The dude set his trap card and was just waiting for someone to call him out.
Just watching the demonstration made my epilepsy trigger
This is like when a guy claimed to be more ripped than you and better at guitar and you say prove it and he comes over a claps your mom and becomes step dad.
LMAO WHY DOES THAT ACTUALLY WORK HAHA
He claps your mom AND your dad who left you
Biggest plot twist ever
Oddly specific
oddly specific
He even ended up going on to collaborate with the guy who initially uploaded the video, and squashed the beef with hentai guy. Dude won on all sides.
Do you have a link?
link
Dude had a whole redemption arc
or just search Ultimate Rush E! (8-hands with @Fanchen and @litening5826!)
Hentai guy deserves to be shamed. It's always a cop out for losers like him to say that people can't criticise if they can't do it in the first place. Hope he goes off himself
Spite is one hell of a motivator
i can understand franchen.the way the hentai dude said "i don't see anyone else actually playing it" seems pretty annoying knowing there is probably someone like franchen who's better.
Fanchen: You're not that guy
Hentai guy: Are you that guy?
Fanchen: Absolutely!
He is not just that guy, he is *THE* guy.
@@sunium5814 fr
Best meme for this
Underrated comment
@@sunium5814 spy kids tier
He's like a rich anime character who humiliated the main character and he's actually very powerful
To the score of Rush E
seto kaiba irl
dio
No he's like when the Mc becomes even richer and humiliates the rich guy who humiliated him
Just like _Seto Kaiba_
literally CID KAGENO vibes
Peek anime
As i always say
"If someone says they can do something stupid, and then they do it, you should be scared of that person"
The chances on someone on the internet actually responding to a “I’d like to see you try” is slim…. But never Zero
But... but I've been saying "I'd like to see you try and walk" to disabled people all this time
"I'd like to see you try"
- some blind dude
Me beating the world record of minecraft potatos to back up my trolling:
@@cana0 Careful Techno doesn't hear you
@@friend4596 beyblade
As someone who played piano for a few years I can totally understand why he said it was mediocre. It's pretty easy to spot mistakes for a trained ear but for an average person it still sounds insane.
oh shit, here we go again...
Ughhhh
@@mtnentertainment3454 tf do you mean here we go again? Just because I understand why he said it doesn't mean I approve of it.
@@finesseandstyle i think they might've been talking about the bot and not what you said
@@50milesmiles didn't even notice it
You can tell he was just waiting for someone to say “you try it then!”
He probably played so well because the song was fueled by the purest, distilled spite and dougbag-ery ever.
Charlie has such a diverse lexicon but he doesn’t know the word rhetorical
true
No, but he does know how to say "butthole" 27 different ways.
I would say expansive vocabulary, not lexicon. Lexicon refers to all the words in a language.
I prefer the analogy though, I hate it when I forget words even though I know them
@@BlakouttheMM
See, that is a very good point, however, you can argue that Charlie’s lexicon consists of all 27 ways you can say butthole in polite conversation.
The lexicon of buttholes.
“Guys think I can’t play Rush E and calls me a liar” this sounds like 2008
Oh god it does
Those kinds of titles are still around.
indeed
Thats why its so good
That what makes it so good
I love how the video TH-cam is recommending me to watch next is the "Guy thinks I can't play Rush E and calls me a liar" one.
He uploaded the diss track on my birthday. I feel honored to have something so historic take place on my birthday
Honestly, being able to diss people and then absolutely destroy them should be the greatest feeling of power.
When you drop a "here's why you suck" essay, and then can also cite more than 50 sources on their ass.
I'd imagine it feels pretty fuckin' sick actually :^]
This is going to sound super lame but, honestly helping someone and actually seeing them improve is a way better feeling than dissing anyone. Unless maybe the person you were dissing was being an asshole first.
@@dominicsaavedra5113 Oh yeah, then the feeling of saving someone´s life would beat the shit out of that feeling.
Some of us like him because we vicariously live through the feeling of shutting people down with high skills. Polarizing but can’t deny those skills
Fanchen wasn't an asshole. He's just a well written supervillain.
underrated
Copied the top comment and replaced “anime antagonist” with “supervillain” lmao
@@grandre3464 what can you do about that? Report me?
@@dy7296 I can’t (and won’t) do anything about it, especially because I didn’t have a problem with it in the first place lol
@@dy7296 oooo lets start a war
How about go touch some grass?
Or play on your tricycle instead of copying someone?
got recommended this after 2 years in bro is still one of the biggest Villian i seen
"It's not bragging if you can back it up." - Muhammed Ali
this guy is like the villain that is loved by the fandom more than the protagonist is for no reason
@Camping Comrade fatherless
@Camping Comrade deez nuts
YES
@UC-iXS7dbJA2qfyFKqRY4NRg why are there- I don't think there is a single person who would fall for this bot, if so, I feel sorry for them
@Camping Comrade Max PFP.