@@mebrahtomgebremeskel5307 yeah indeed . I remember him because we took matriculation exam at same room and he was on college of arts and social science Mai nefhi but I was on college of business and economics any way he was ginues from the beginning.
Samuel was so decent and considerate to Yosef. First, I would like to salut you (Samuel) for your well manners, calmness and composure. Second, your debate skills and Eritrean history knowledge is unmatched on the show. One more thing, Yosef has published neither a peer-reviewed article nor a thesis. Hence, he ain’t up to your level! Looking forward to part II.
Yosief caught in Red hand, in previous monologues he was going without challenge, now he is in complete denial & deceptive. Thanks Dr. Samuel for debunking this fraud
Yosief got undressed today. I have dreamed for this for a long time, thank you Shishay for hosting this and Samuel is exceptional. I don’t think Yosief will have the balls to face any Eritrean in an argument from now on. He can go to TMH and speak BS to himself. We are watching Mr self proclaimed ፋላስፋ
A country cannot developed with people like you! You just want to see or hear what you like or people who agrees with your point of views. If there is tolerances of other people views a country can be built and develop!
እዚ ሰብአይ(ዮሴፍ) ባዶ ገረወኛ እዩ። please take time and read 📖 the books 📚 behind you which are on the shelf. He is on fire please give him a glass of water. Dr, Samuel much respect bro.
Yoseph's shallow and biased knowledge of Eritrean History starts with Shabia and ends with Shabia. His intellectual capacity is limited to criticising Shabia and Gedli as a whole.If he doesn't know that there were various newspapers and discussions in Eritrea in the 40th and 50th, what else does he know then? This young historiean has walked on him in every aspect of history and intellect. He had the upper hand.
Thank you shishay for organising wonderful discussion. I hope to see more debate like this one for coming months. Regarding the result of the debate, it is 10 -1. Yossef is very weak when he duscussed his argument because he has nothing to bring to the table.Of cource he is probability best for tigrians as they have none,that can present and discuss his ideas with valid points. Viva Eritrea.
Samuel was so polite, respectful and patient. He is very analytic. I do also admire Yosef's analytic skill and capacity. He was sometimes lacking patience though.
Good job on teaching us all Sami, I appreciate your patience and confidence and not trying to convince by being loud which was esp. noticed when you told him about how Senegal elites were given similar previlege by French. Thanks also Shishay for helping those who may be confused by loud noises and fail when asked to materialize
Few points to note: 1. Revolution starts with questions/demands, then evolves to demonstration -> Protests-> armed struggle 2. If the rulers are homegrown/domestic, it is called dictatorship 3. If the rulering party is an external force, it is colonialism 4. BTW. Eritreans were OK with the Federal arrangement. What caused the armed struggle was the forced annexation
How can you say that the Eritreans were okay with the federation. Even the federation was forced upon them by the UN. The Eritreans only accepted it only because self determination was also ruled to follw after a limited time of 10 years. That is why the armed struggle was said to be for self determination and came to rest only after that.
Good points but Eritreans weren't even ok with the 1952 federation's but initially they were searching for a peaceful method of independence nd that federation was forced federation for the preparation of annexation
This is what will happen when you are confronted with a well informed intellectual. One of them is highly charged and emotional and the other one is well-informed, measured and prudent to clarify the points with tangible examples. Most uninformed people like to shout and talk loud and incessantly interrupt the conversation. Although the questions were insightful, the moderator failed to curb one of the speakers to stick on the subject. Note: tautology does not mean "anything goes". It means saying the same thing using different words.
Questions to Mr Yesef 1) When did you leave Eritrea? 2) Does you believes Eritrea is an independent country or it is part of the Un-great Tigray or Ethiopia? 3) Did you participate or any member of your close family members in the Eritrean independent army struggle in person? 4) If the history is not recorded, how do you know with absolute authority what the wishes of majority Eritrean people were? 5) You speak about Eritrean people leaving their countries, what role are you playing in that and do you assist/help people when they come to where you live?
Anyone who has no idea just talks a lot and doesn't give the others a chance to say anything, so please don't get into the media with a person like that Eritrea 🇪🇷 hagerey 💪🏾
Yesief Ethiopian go to what you love. Eritrea is fully independent. Dem teqereTs. The next phase of our struggle will be achieved on our scarification.
ዮሴፍ ዕርቃኑ ዝወጸሉ ኣጋጣሚ! ቅድሚ ሕጂ ስቅ ኢሎም ዝሰምዕዎ ሰባት እንተረኸበ ምሁር ኮይኑ ዝስምዖ ዝነበረ ምስ ዓቕሚ ዘለዎም ሰባት ምግጣም ኣሽርጊርዎ ጥራይ ዘይኮነ፡ናብ ቁጥዐን ዘይምሁራዊ ኣገባብን ከምዝኸይድ ገይርዎ።ከቕርቦ ዝፈተነ ምጉት ፡ንኣንድነታዊ ኣተሓሳስብኡ ዘንጸባርቕ ድኣ እምበር ፈጺሙ ካብ ክውንነት ዝወጸን፡ ንዝንቡዕ ኣተሓሳስብኡን ጥማዕ ፍልጠዩን ዘርኣየ ክትዕ!
ዶር ሳሚኤል ትምህርቲ ዝጸገበ፡ኣብ ፍልጠትን ርትዕን ዝተበገሰ፡ካብ ስምዒት ዝረሓቐን ኣዝዩ ብሱል፡ምቅሉልን ርእሰ ተኣማንነት ዘለዎን ኮይኑ ረኺበዮ።ዮሴፍ ኣብ ስምዒትን ጸርጸር ምባልን ዝዓብለሎ፡ብኣካዳሚክ ክትዓት ዘይተሰነየ ዘየእምን መርትዖታት ከቅርብ ተዓዚበዮ።ብሓፈሻ ከምዚ ዓይነት ምጉት ጽቡቕ'ዩ።
Well described.
በቃ ክትንእዱ ጥራሕ
ባዓል እዚ ቦቕሳስ ሳሙኤል ዘዳልዉዎ ዝነበሩ መጻሕፍቲ ትፈልጦ ዲኻ?
ኣበይ ኣሎ ታሪኽ ነጋውሳትናን ራእስታትናን
ብራቮ ሳሚኤል። ከማኻስ 1000 ይኹኑ
ብትሕትና ዶር ሳሚኤል እመሃ ማራ ተገሪመ።ብጣዕሚ ብቍዕን ርእሰ ተኣማንነትን ናይ ሰብ ኣኽብሮት ዘለዎ ወረጃ መንእሰይ።ብሱል ምሁር ብምቅላለኡ'ዩ ዝልለ።
Yegerem sami hawey tedenike ey eti abey sebay kea rikayo eka resi tanika
እቲ ዝገርም እቲ ዓቢ ክዛረቦ ዝግበኦ እቲ ንእሽተይ ሳሚ ብሱል ሙኻኑ እዩ ዘርእየና።
በልዎ ጨፍጭፍዎ ደቂ ኤረይ እዚ ክልቢ ህውሓት😂😂😂😂 proud of you deki erey 🇪🇷❤️🇪🇷❤️🇪🇷❤️🇪🇷❤️🇪🇷❤️🇪🇷❤️🇪🇷❤️🇪🇷
ዮሴፍ ገብረ-ህወሓት በይኑ ኣብ መዳ TMH ምጽዋት ዝለመደ ሎሚ ምጽዋር ስኢንዎ ነዚ ብሱል ወዲ። ዮሴፍ ፋንዲያ
Kkkk ፋንድያ 🤣🤣🤣
@@begooddogood8334 ፋንድያ ከም fertilizer ትጥቀመሉ ኢኻ። ንዮሴፍ ግን አብ ትጉሕፎ እዩ ዝጨንቀካ።
I'm Eritrean but my grandmother is Tigrayan.
Exactly. I felt the same way
Karaoke 🎤 ( one man band) እንድዩ ለሚዱ፡ ወላ ስነ ምግባር ዘብሉ። ናይ ምዝራብ ኪእለት ኪህልዎ ይኪእል እምበር ናይ በሓቂ ንሓደ ታሪክ ብዝተወሰነ ይፈልጥ ንዝብል ከደናግሮ ኣይክእልን እዩ።
Proud of you Dr.Samuel 🇪🇷 wedi zurey mearey . I CAN see Mr yosief is burning 🔥he can't tolerate the truth.
Mine too 😅😉
@@amanuel-. 18 round
@@samitihabte34 is he?i am 18 as well. Where he got earned his political education?? He looks very calm and full of wisdom.
@@mebrahtomgebremeskel5307 yeah indeed . I remember him because we took matriculation exam at same room and he was on college of arts and social science Mai nefhi but I was on college of business and economics any way he was ginues from the beginning.
@@amanuel-. 18 😉
ጠራዕ ጠራዕ ስለዝበልካስ ፈላጥ መሲሉ ክርኤ ዝፍትን ቁጡዕ ሓሳዊ ዮሴፍ ተዋስኣይ!
እዚ ዮሴፍ ገብረዕንወትስ ክዱንቁር ድዩ ዝማሃር ነይሩ ወይስ ባህርያት ናይ ዕሱብ ምኻን ከም ከልቢ ምንባሕ እዩ ጻምኡ።
🇪🇷💚❤️💛💙🇪🇷
ባህርያት ዕሱብን ጽልእን እዩ:: ዕራቆቱ ግን ወጺኡ ሎሚ::
@@mr.hrealpeople2135 ብጣዕሚ ርካሽ ዝኾነ ፍጥረት እዩ
መጀመርያ ኢሰያስ ከዳዕ ቆልዑ ኣብ ኪናት የእትዩ ዘጽንት ዝርሎ ንኣምሓሩ ከድሕን ::
@@Azeb1782 ንህወሐት ካብ መሬት ምሕካኽ ምጽራግ ንድሕነት ኤርትራ እንበር ኤርትራውያን ንባዕዳውያን ንኽንሕጉስ ኢሊና ንገብሮ የለን ንወያነ ምጥፋእ ምስ ኣምሐሩ ከይ ኮነስ ዋላ ውን ምስ ሸይጣን ምስራሕ ውን ይካአል'ዩ 😜
@@LYE4EVER denkoro ንህወሓት ክተጥፍእ በየናይ ሕጊ እዩ ዝፍቀደካ ? ልዕላውነት ትግራይ ጥሒስካ እትገብሮ ጉዳይ ፅባህ ንጉሆ ኣብ ዓድኻ ከምዝመፀካ ክትፈልጥ ኣለካ።ግዜ ስለዝረኸብካ ምስ ዝኸድዐና ፡ስልጣኑ እምበር ልዕላውነት ሃገርን ህዝብን ዘይፈልጥ ተለዋዋጢ ባህርይ ዘለዎ ኣብይ ኣሕመድ ኮይንኩም ነቲ እንኮ ደጋፊ ናፅነትን ልዕላውነትን ኤርትራውያን ዝኣምን ህዝቢ ክተጥፍኡዎ ተላዒልኩም።ህዝቢ ትግራይን ህወሓትን እቲ ቀንዲ ብኢ/ያውን ብፍላይ ብኣምሓሩ እኮ ንናይ ኤርትራ ናፅነት ዝደገፍኩምን ዝፈምኩን ንስኻትኩም ኢኹም ዝብል እዩ።ብዙሕ ምበልኩ ግን ኣይርድኣካን እዩ።ብፅልኢ ኣእምሮኡ ዝዓወረ ሰብ ነቲ ሓቂ ንኽርዳእ የፀግመሉ እዩ።
ድንቈርናካ ሎሚ ብወግዒ ደገ ወጺኡ ቁሩብ ከማን ትሕትና ኣዘውትር ጸርጸር ኣይትበል ጒኑፍ
ዮሴፍ ገ/ህይወት፡ ፍጹም ከዳዕን ዕሉል ዕሱብን ምዃኑ ዕርቃኑ ወጺኡ። ርእሲ ሓምሓም!
ኣቶ ዮሴፍ ጌታቸውን ገብረጼንን ይድዉሉልካ ኣለዉ ተቀበሎም በጊዕ።
Yesef
Kenwze ezi jebjeb melhasu
🤣😂🤣😂🤣 በጊዕ ጥራይ ኢልካ !
@@Wedieritrea323 ሪኢኻዮ ዶ ሳሚኤል ቀስ ኣቢሉ ሚሳይል ኣብ ጁቡኡ ምስ ፈንጀረሉ ብ ኣፉ ዓፍራ ን ዓፍራ ኮይኑ ዓቅሉ ጸቢቡዎ
ኢሰያስናኻትኩም ደገፍቲ ጽባሕ ንግሆ ትሓተቲ ኢኹም ቆልዑ ናብ ኢትዮጵያ ኣሰሊፍኩም ህጻናት ተጥፍኡ ኣለኹም ::
@@Azeb1782 ክክክክክክክክ ክላ ሕልኩስ ንነብስኻ ብ ኸምዚ ኣጸናናዓያ ምዉት ወዲ ምዉት። ኪድ ህዝብኻ ብ ዓጸቦን ብ ደብዳብ ነፈርትን ይጠፍእ ኣሎ ቀብሪ ኣርክብ ካንሰር ናይ ቀርኒ ኣፍሪቃ
ዶክተር ሳሚኤል ብጣዕሚ ብሱልን ዓሚቊ ታሪኻዊ ፍልጠትን ዝተላበሰ በሊሕ ምሁር ምዃኑ ጎሊሑ ይረኤ።
Samuel was so decent and considerate to Yosef. First, I would like to salut you (Samuel) for your well manners, calmness and composure. Second, your debate skills and Eritrean history knowledge is unmatched on the show. One more thing, Yosef has published neither a peer-reviewed article nor a thesis. Hence, he ain’t up to your level!
Looking forward to part II.
አቶ ዮሴፍ: ምስ ጸላእቲ ኤሪትራ ኮንካ ምጭዳር ስለዝለመድካ: ሕጂ ምስ ሐደ ምሁር ኮፍ ኢልካ ክትሙጉት ዓቅሚ የለን:: ዓቅልኻ ጸቢቡካ: እዚ ናይ ምሁር ጠባይ አይኮነን:: ፈንጨርጨር ኢልካ ናይ ብሐቂ መልክዕካ አርኢኻ::
ዓቕምን ሓቅነትን ዘይብሉ ሰብ ከምዚ ናይ የሴፍ ኢዩ ዝገብር ።
It is true 😄😄😄
ሓው ዮሴፍ ዉሪብ ስሚዒታዊ ትኽውን ኣሎኻ ፡እቲ ጽልኣት ናይዚ ስርዓት ነቲ ዝነበረሓቂ ታሪኽ ክትነግ ጌርካ ኣሎ።
ናይ ብሓቂ ዲኩም ምሁር አልኩም ኣምጺኩሞ መንእሰይ ካብዚ ዝመሃሮ የለን ዮሴፍ ደንቅሮ ወለድካስ ናኣካ ካብ ምውላድ 2 ደርሆ ናይሆላዲ ምፍራይ ምሃሾም እንቃቁሖ ከማን ምበልዑ ጋሓፍ ሸይቲ ዓዱ ይሁዳ
Yosief caught in Red hand, in previous monologues he was going without challenge, now he is in complete denial & deceptive. Thanks Dr. Samuel for debunking this fraud
ኣምሰሉ ወይ ቁጡዕ ሓሳዊ ዮሴፍ ገብሪሂወት ጠቀነ ወሰን የብሉን!
ዮሴፍ ገብረዕንወት ከመይ ዓይነት ድሁል ከዛብ ሰብ ኢኻ ኮነ ኢልኩም እዛ ሃገር ክትከፋፍሉ እንድዩ ሕልምኹም 🙏🙏🙏🇪🇷🇪🇷🇪🇷😍😍😍 ERITREA FOR EVER
Bravo Samuel, calm and collected, the sign of a competent and confident man.
ኣቶ ዮሴፍ ንነብስኻ ከተታልሎ ዝኽልክለካ ሰብ የለን። ን ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ከተታልል ግን ይትረፍ ዶ ንስኻ ሓደ ሂወትካ ዘይትመርሕ ሙሽሙሽ ሰብ እቶም ኣብ መቀለ ኮይኖም ዘማሓድሩኻ ኣዛብእ ቀትሪ ከማን መዋእሎም ፈቲኖም ቀቢርናዮም ኢና ሞ ዕጫ እቶም ጎይተትካ ዩ ክበጽሓካ።
ገዛ ኤርትራዊን ይብዛሕ 🇪🇷. 🐅
Yosif started with anger, he ended up with shame
እዋይ ኣታ እዚ ዮስየፍ ዝብሃልሲ መሕፈር ዘይምቅራቡ ምሓሸ ግን ከኣ ዕሽነቱ ዘጉልሔ ቃለ ማሕተት ።ካብ ቅርሕንቲ ተበጊሱ ሓቅታት ክሽፍን ሃላው መጉርዒ።
Yosief got undressed today. I have dreamed for this for a long time, thank you Shishay for hosting this and Samuel is exceptional. I don’t think Yosief will have the balls to face any Eritrean in an argument from now on. He can go to TMH and speak BS to himself. We are watching Mr self proclaimed ፋላስፋ
Sami ; u did good job. Wonderful
Bravo Dr. Samuel !!!!
ሳሚ ሳሚ ጹቡቅ ሓሳባት እዩ እቲ ኣብ ኣርባዓታት ዝጀመረ ሓሳባት እዩ ኣብ ሱሳታት ሓዊ ተቀይሩ
በጃኹም እባ ነዚ ዮሴፍ ድሕሪ ሕጂ ኣብዚ ሜድያ ኣይተምጹልና
Yosief has only mouse no ears lol. Kzareb ember kisemie zeykiel seb yosief denkoro
A country cannot developed with people like you! You just want to see or hear what you like or people who agrees with your point of views. If there is tolerances of other people views a country can be built and develop!
ዮስይፍ ሎሚ ኢድ ፍንጂ ተታሕዙ
ምስ ሳሚ ኢንቃዓ ኣቅርብካዮ ጁፉጁፉ
ብይኑ ክዛርብ ዝጽነሕ ዮስይፍ ምስ ሓድ ምሁር ታሪኽ ሙስ ቅርበ ክመ ኣዝለ ቆልዓ ምንርጻር ክክክክ
ከመ ኣብ ዉዑይ ማይ ዝጣሓለት ዶሮሆ ቆሮብቱ ቅልጦሞ
ኣታ ረሳሕ ኣስላማይ መጀመርያ ስማዕ ብጽብጽ ኣፍ ከልቢ
Yosief Ghebrehiwet eko intelligentsia Educated Nay eastAfrica eiu handasi Nay Hasab eiu tmhrti temahar pls kab Yosief Ghebrehiwet
Ata bexbex entadika kigaber amharay ab meryat eritrra naytu endher megzati zaynberu guhaf agame
@@muradnejib4666 ወዲ መክኑድ ጓሓፍ እንታዲኻ ይምልከተካ ስደተኛ ዋሒድ
@@Ayla-Gundet neska endika ab amet zayakel fah elka fokodo maskerat sudan tilmn zelka komal chenawi sensrat enta zaygerkin kab sudan wn kitguhfa ekin chemalk hilaf kondom
እዋይ ንእሽቶ ፍልጠት ሓደገኛ እዩ ዝበሃል ሲ ሓቂ እዩ። ኣይተ ዮሴፍ ዓሙይቕ ፍልጠት ዘይብሎም ኣምሰሉ ንዘይፈልጡ ደኣ ከዳናግሩ ይኽእሉ እምበር። ነቲ ዝፈልጥስ ዘይቅቡልን ንጹግን ምጉት ሒዞም ኣብ ማሕበራዊ ሜድያ ዝቐርቡ ፍንፉንን ብቕዓት ዘይብሎምን ንሑሉፍ ታሪኽ ኤርትራ ሰኒዖም ናይ ኣሸቀልቶም ወያነን ጎይቶቶምን ዕላማ ክወቕዑ ኣብ መጥቃዕቲ ኤርትራዊ መንነትን ልእላውነትን ዝተዓጥቁ ምዃኖም ይፈልጥ እዩ። እዞም ዝጠፈሹ ሰብኣይ ኮነ ኢሎም ንኹቡር ታሪኽ ኤርትራ ጸሎሎ ዝቐብኡ ዕሉል ከዳዕ ምዃኖም ብፍላይ ኤርትራዊ መንእሰይ ክፈልጦ ይግባእ።እቲ ርቡጽን ህዉኽን ባህሪ ኣይተ ዮሰፍ ንማንነቶም ዘቓልዕ እውን እዩ።
ፈሊጥናዮም ሕጂ ድኣ ጽልኢ ህዝቢ ኤርትራን ታሪኽ ህዝቢ ኤርትራን ከም ዘለዎም
ኣቶ ዮሴፍ ብዙሕ ዓፍራ ስለ ዘውጻእካስ ታሪኽ ትዛረብ ዘለካ ይመስለካ ይኸውን። ንነብስኻ ከተታሊል ሕቡእ መርዛም ድሌታትካ ከተዕግብ ኢልካ ነዊሕ እንተ ተዛረብካ ወይ እንተ ዓፈርካ ንስኻን ሕልምታትካን ኢኩም ክትቅበሩ። ቀዳሞት ጎይተትካ ቀቢርናዮም 2ይ ዝመጸ ጎይተትካ ውን ናብ ገደል ኣጽዲፍናዮ። 3ጎይተትካ እቲ ኣብ መቀለ ኮይኑ ዘማሓድረካ ውን እንተ ኮነ ኣብ ኣፍ ደገ ሞት ኣእቲናዮ ኢና። ምስኦም ክትቅበር ኢካ። ምጅሉሕ ኣረጊት።
አዚ ዮስየፍ ገብርሂወት ዝብሎ አየረድእ አይርዳእ ትርጉም የብሉን ብካ ንቶም ስድራኡ ትምህርቲ ገዲፋ ንቶም ስድራኡ ጥሪት ሐለይሎም
እዚ ሰብአይ(ዮሴፍ) ባዶ ገረወኛ እዩ። please take time and read 📖 the books 📚 behind you which are on the shelf. He is on fire please give him a glass of water.
Dr, Samuel much respect bro.
ደኩተር ሳሚኤል የቀንየልና ትዕግስተኛ፡አብነገራት ዘለካ ርድኢት፡ትሕትናኻ፡አርአያ ናይ በሓቂ።
Yoseph's shallow and biased knowledge of Eritrean History starts with Shabia and ends with Shabia.
His intellectual capacity is limited to criticising Shabia and Gedli as a whole.If he doesn't know that there were various newspapers and discussions in Eritrea in the 40th and 50th, what else does he know then? This young historiean has walked on him in every aspect of history and intellect. He had the upper hand.
ሎሚ እባ ተረኺቡ እዚ ዓንጃል። በይኑ ስለ ዝተዛረበ ፈላጥ ይመስሎ ኒሩ።
ዮሴፍ ጠራጢ ይበኪ ኣሎ በይንኻ ምዝራብ ለሚድካ ሎሚ ኣብዘይ ዓቕምኻ ኣቲኻ
Yosief Ghebrehiwet intelligentsia Educated eiu
@@tesfitkubrom8730 ስገደሉ እንዶሞ እምበር ዮሴፍ ሒዝዎ ዘሎ ጫሌዳን ዉስልትናን አዩ
@@tesfitkubrom8730 ዮሴፍ ንፉዕ ካድር ወያነ እዩ። ካብኣ ኣይሓልፍን እዩ። ብጥቕጣቕ ዛንታታት ለጋጊቡ ከደናግር ዝፍትን ናይ ወያነ ሜላ ከምዘላታ ተሓንጊጡ እዩ ዝቐርብ።
yesof dyom zblouka eti txihfo ab enda Gahaf ena kinetwo resah
@@EmmanuelAngosom Entay eiu Nay yosief Ghebrehiwet gega ? Eske Ms respect hasabka xahafeley
የሴፍ ነቲ ድሩት ኣፍልጦካስ ብሳሓቅ ከተህጥሮ ትፍትን ውዱቅ
Woow! Very nice discussion. Part 2 please.
ደቂ ኤረይ ፡ ነዞም ጎሓላሉ ጸረ ኤርትራውያንን ኤርትራን ከም በዓል ዮሴፍ ንፍለጦምን ነጋልጾምን
ብሓይሊ ኣነ ዝብሎ ጥራይ ስምዑ ኣየ የሴፍ ጊባቦ
ዮሴፍ ድኣ በይኑ ምጉያይ እዩ ለሚዱ። ቅኑዕ ሓሳብ ከፍልቅስ ይትረፍ ፡ ፉቱንን ቁቡልን ሓሳብ ዉን ብግቡእ ክስዕብ ዘይክእል ባእታ እዩ። እዛ ናይ ሎሚ ክትዕ መርኣያ እያ። ዮሴፍ ኣብታ ናይ ትግራይ ሚድያ ጥራይ ድኣ🤣😂🤣😂
ዮሴፍ ገ/ሂወት ጥራሕካ ወጺእካ። ለካስ ካብቲ ዝግምተካ ዝነበርኩ ንታሕቲ ሑሱር ኢኻ። ካብ ሙሁር የ ባሃሊ ደንቆሮ፤ የድሕነና ዝበሉ ኣቦታተና ከምዚ መሰጋጠሞም ኢዩ። ዮሴፍ 0, ሳሙኤል 2 ነጥቢ ብምጭባጥ ቀዳማይ ዙርያ ተወዲኡ ኣሎ፣ ኣብ ካላኣይ ዙርያ ብሰላም የራኽበና።
ዮሴፍ ዕንክላሎ.. ዋላ ሓንት ብቕዓት የብልካን.... ቦታኻ ኣብ tmh እዩ ዝካተኣካ ዘይብልካ ኣደንቁር ከተብሎም.... ዓጁስ ዋሕድ
Thank you shishay for organising wonderful discussion. I hope to see more debate like this one for coming months. Regarding the result of the debate, it is 10 -1. Yossef is very weak when he duscussed his argument because he has nothing to bring to the table.Of
cource he is probability best for tigrians as they have none,that can present and discuss his ideas with valid points. Viva Eritrea.
ነቲ ኣብ'ቲ እዋን እንግሊዝን ምፍራስ ፈደረሽንን ዝነበረ ኵነታት ዝተፈላለየ ሰነዳት መንግስቲ እንግሊዝ ብምውካስ፡ ኣብቲ ግዜ'ቲ ተዋሳእቲ ዝነበሩ ሰባት ብምዝርራብ፡ ዝሕተሙ ዝነበሩ ጋዜጣታት ብምውካስ ዝተጻሕፈት 'ኣይንፋላለ' ዘርእስታ ብተጋዳላይ ኣለምሰገድ ተስፋይ ዝተጻሕፈት መጽሓፍ ኩሉ ኣብቲ እዋን'ቲ ዝነበረ ሃዋህውን ስታተስቲካዊ ሓበሬታን ከይተረፈ እርይ ቍጽር ኣቢላ ኣቕሪባቶ እያ። እዚ ዮሴፍ ዘቕርቦ ዘሎ ቆሎ ጥጥቖ ዘረባ ከም ወትሩ ኣካል እቲ ንፍትሓውነት ቃልስን ናጽነትን ኤርትራ ንምንእኣስ ዝገብሮ፡ ሕሱር ፈንጠርጠር እዩ። ካብ'ቲ ተጋሩ ብመልክዕ ወፈራ ዝፈትልዎ ዛንታታት ኣይፍለን።
I like the debate...I really appreciate Samuel
can please invite Samuel again and pick some other point for great future 🇪🇷. Thanks
እዋይ ዘረባ
ዩሴፋ።።
ሙሁር ድንቆሮ ብጽልኢ ተማዕጢጥካ እምብር እምብር ንበዓል ተላ ባይሮ እንደዘከርካስ ንቶም ካልኡት ሃገራዊያን ምርኣይ ሲእንካ።
ኣየ ኣቶ ዮሴፍ ሃላይ በላዒ መፍለስ። ግዳ ናብራኻ ምራሕ ሙዉት።
Samuel was so polite, respectful and patient. He is very analytic. I do also admire Yosef's analytic skill and capacity. He was sometimes lacking patience though.
Rip yosef Gebrehiwet
ምፍራስ ፈደረሽን እኹል መግዛእታዊ ሕቶ ዩ period
ኣንታ ከመይ ዓይነት ሰብ ኢኹም ኣምጺእኩም ነዚ የስየፍ ገብሪሂወት ዝበሃል ብስለት የብሉ ኣፍልጦ የብሉ ዝሓተትካዮ ኣይምልስን ኢዩ ዘሎ እዋይ ዘይሓፍር ብምልእታ ኤርትራ ጎቢጦም ሒዞማስ ኣብ ኤርትራ መግዛእቲ ኣይነበረን ይብል እዋይ ኣንድነታውያን ኣርቶፊሻል ተጋሩ ከመይ ዝበለ ኣተሓሳስባን ርእሲ ኢዩ ዘለዎም
ትግራይ ሚድያ ሃውስ መሲልዎ ዮሰፍ ከምድላዩ ክሕሱ በይኑ ፈላጥ ኮይኑ ክቀርብ። አሞ የለን ሕጂ ጸርጸር ኣይኮነን
ዮሴፍ ከዳዕ ብዓንብቀራ ተታሒዛ ሎሚ አብ ገዛ ደደቢት መሲሉዋ ተሃንዲዳ መጺአ ተነፅያ
ሳሚኤል እማሃ ሙሁር ዩ ዮሴፍ ዓቢ ዓርግን ግን ብ ስምዒት ዩ ዝዛረብ ኩሉ ግዜ ኣብ TMH ዝለመድካዮ ኣብዚ ሓፍ ኪፍ ኣይትበል ኣይሕሉፉካን ኢዮም ን መንእሰይ ሳሚኤል ኮ ምዝራብ ከሊእዎ ዮሴፍ ኮ ቅድሚ 3 ዓመት ኣንድነት ትብል ዝነበርካ ን ሰውራ ኤርትራ ድም ዝተከፍሎ ባርነት ዝበልካ ክዳዕ ኢካ
እዛ ቪድዮ ዓባይ ዶኩመንት እያ። ናብ ኩሉ ከተታሓላልፉዋን ከተቐምጥዋን አለኩም። ን20 ዓመት ዝአክል ንኤርትራን ንገድሊ ኤርትራን ከናሹን፥ ከባሳብስን ዝነበረ ገበነኛ ሎሚ ብግሁድ ጥርሑ ዝወጸላ፥ ድንቁርንኡን ሕማሙን ዝተጋለጸላ፥ ሓሳውን መታለልን ምኳኑ ዝተጋለጸላ፥ ስዕረትን ውድቀትን ናይ ጸላኢ ኤርትራ ዝተመስከረላ ቪድዮ እያ።
አብ ትግራይ ሜዲያን ቴዲፕረስን ዑቕባ ይሕተት።
Bravo sami ezi yousef sakit felasifa eye ena bele berara ena bele xubuq geberkayo .
In all societies there are naturaly negative persons like Yosef, but we must always fight them , otherwise they can spoil many.
ዮሴፍ ዕሉል ከዳዕ
ገልጣም እዚ ሕጅስ ታሪኽ ይፈልጥየ ድዩ ክብል ።ኤሬትራዊ ከምዘይኮነ ግልጲ እዮ ዳሐር ድማ ብስነ ስርዓት ደይዛረብ. ሐደ ውቁዕ ሰብ እዮ ።ፈላጥየ ኢልካ ድማ ምጅሃር
ኣቶ ሳሚኤል እንጀራ ብላዕ ።እዚ ደንቅሮ ዑሱብ የሴፍ ኣይርድኦን ኢዩ ግዜኻ ክበልዓልካ ኢዩ ።
Good job on teaching us all Sami, I appreciate your patience and confidence and not trying to convince by being loud which was esp. noticed when you told him about how Senegal elites were given similar previlege by French. Thanks also Shishay for helping those who may be confused by loud noises and fail when asked to materialize
ልኡላውነት ትግራይ ጥሒሱ ዝኣተወ ኤርትራዊ የለን ። ባድመና ክንመልስ ፡ ሃገርና ካብቶም ከጽንቱና ዝተበገሱ ክንከላኸል ግን ፡ ግድን ኣቲና ንጭፍጭፎም
Bravo Dr. Samuel.....entekone mis elfi guhafat sebat... dereja zeyblom aytizareb...
Yosef malet nay husurat husur!!
Yosef got a good lesson against his text book _linear_ thinking. I doubt, however, he is able to accept the hard truth.
ኣቶ ዮሶየፍ እኮ ካብ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ሲ ክንደይ ሰብ ኢካ ትፈልጥ ብቁጽሪ እንተ ዝበሃል ሲ እንታይ ኮን ምበል ኣሕ። ሓመድ ብላዕ ኤርትራ ሲ ንባዓል ዮሴፍ ኣዕብያ በላዕቲ 2 ስጋ
ዬሴፍ ገብረህወት ንበይኑ እዮ ክዛረብ ዝደልይ ጸርጸር አብዚሑ ።
ኣታማ ኡዙይ ዮሱዮፍ ድዓ እንታኣሙ ዩ ዝብል እእእእእእእእእእዋዋዋዋፋፋፋፋፋፌኣኣኣኣኣኣ ዳሕና ድዮም ዋይዋይይይይይ። ኣብዮት በስመኣብ ወልደፍደፍ TMH የላይ ድያ ህ እንደበልዎ ዋ ህ ዩ ለሚዱ ሃሃሃሃሃ 🇪🇷🇪🇷🇪🇷🇪🇷። ኤረትራዊነት ኩቡር መንነት
I love this type of interview regardless of the difference!
Few points to note:
1. Revolution starts with questions/demands, then evolves to demonstration -> Protests-> armed struggle
2. If the rulers are homegrown/domestic, it is called dictatorship
3. If the rulering party is an external force, it is colonialism
4. BTW. Eritreans were OK with the Federal arrangement. What caused the armed struggle was the forced annexation
How can you say that the Eritreans were okay with the federation. Even the federation was forced upon them by the UN. The Eritreans only accepted it only because self determination was also ruled to follw after a limited time of 10 years. That is why the armed struggle was said to be for self determination and came to rest only after that.
Good points but Eritreans weren't even ok with the 1952 federation's but initially they were searching for a peaceful method of independence nd that federation was forced federation for the preparation of annexation
This is what will happen when you are confronted with a well informed intellectual.
One of them is highly charged and emotional and the other one is well-informed, measured and prudent to clarify the points with tangible examples.
Most uninformed people like to shout and talk loud and incessantly interrupt the conversation.
Although the questions were insightful, the moderator failed to curb one of the speakers to stick on the subject.
Note: tautology does not mean "anything goes". It means saying the same thing using different words.
Questions to Mr Yesef
1) When did you leave Eritrea?
2) Does you believes Eritrea is an independent country or it is part of the Un-great Tigray or Ethiopia?
3) Did you participate or any member of your close family members in the Eritrean independent army struggle in person?
4) If the history is not recorded, how do you know with absolute authority
what the wishes of majority Eritrean people were?
5) You speak about Eritrean people leaving their countries, what role are you playing in that and do you assist/help people when they come to where you live?
ዮሴፍ ርቡሽ ድርቡሽ ፡
ልቡ ብ ኣፉ ነጢራ ክትወጽእ ደልያ።
እዋይ ሃለፍታ ጌርሉ
Thank you so much, very interested discussion political & historical Eritrea peoples
We proud sami b/c you are very intelligent keep it up♥♥♥🇪🇷🇪🇷🇪🇷🇪🇷🇪🇷
ዶር ሳም ዓቅልኻን ቃላትካን ምርግጽ ምልክት ወይ ውጺኢት ትምህርትካ እዩ፡ናይ ብሓቂ ኣድኒቐካ።ኣቶ ዮሴፍ ድማ ብዙሕ ሓቅታት ኣለኩም ግና ቅሩብ ትህወኩ ወይ ትኮልፍዎ ነርኩም።ብሓፈሻ ግን ደስ ዘብል ትምህርትን እዩ ኔሩ ነመስግነኩም።
Anyone who has no idea just talks a lot and doesn't give the others a chance to say anything, so please don't get into the media with a person like that
Eritrea 🇪🇷 hagerey 💪🏾
ሳሚኤል respectful 💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼💪🏼
Well done Historian Sami!!! ናይ ዮሴፍ ዘረባ ሲ እና ሰምዐ ዘስቀጠ፡ ........ ትብል ጥቅሲ እዩ እዘኪሩኒ?!
ኣንታ እንታይ ዳኣሉ ኣዛርቡኒ እምበር ተዛረቡ ዘይብል እቲ ፍልጠቱስ ካባይ ዘይሓይሽ ዬሴፍናብ እንዳ ተጋሩ ኪድ እሶም እዬም ዓቅምካ
ዮሴፍ ዘርባዕባዕ ዶ ኣብሎሙኻ ኣታ ባኮ ሓንቲ ፍልጠት የብልካን ወረግ ጡዑይ ሓታታይ እንተረክብካ ሲ ካብዚ ናይ ሎሚ ዝኸፈአ ረሃጽ ንረሃጽ ክትከውን ኢኻ ሳምኤል ግን ብፍልጠት እዩ ዝካትዓካ ኔሩ.. እቲ ጸገም እቲ ሶሻል መድያ ብኸም በዓል ዮሴፍ ገብርሂወት ብኣፍልጦ ዘይኮነ ብስምዒት ዝማጎቱ ተዓብሊሉ ጸኒሑ እዚ ከኣ ወያነ ኮነ አሉ ብገንዘብ ዓሲቡ ዘሸቅሎ ዘሎ ባርያ እዩ ኣይተሓዞን እዩ.
ብሓፈሻ ጽቡቕ ምብህሃል ነይሩ።ዝተፈላለየ ኣመለኻኽታ ዘሎዎም ሰባት ብሃናጺ ኣገባብ ክዘራረቡ ባይታ ምፍጣር ኣገዳስን ሓጋዝን እዩ።ገይጋ ትዕዝብቲ እንየዘይኮይኑ እዞም ብዕድመ ቅድም ዝበሉ (ኣቦታትና) ዝያዳ ከረድኡ ብማለት ይመስለኒ ነቲ ዕድል ዝያዳ ክጥቀምሉ ናይ ምድላይ ኩነት የስተብህል እየ፡ኣብዚ'ውን ከም'ኡ ዝተዓዘብኩ ይመስለኒ። ምክብባር ዝመልኦ ምንባሩ ግን ክተባባዕ ዝግበኦ እዩ።
ሓታቲ ንተሓተቲ ኣብ ዝተፈላለዩ እዋናት ዝበልዎ ከም ቀንዲ ሕቶታትካ ገርካ ምቕራብ ብፍላይ ድማ ንሓዲኦም ጥራይ ምስ ዝኸውን ምዛናውነት ስለ ዘጥፍእ ተመራጺ ኮይኑ ኣይተሰማዓንን።ምናልባት ከም ሰዓቢ ሕቶ ወይ ድማ ሓፈሻዊ ከምዚ ንዝብል ኣበሃህላ ከመይ ትርእዩዎ ወይ ትገልጹዎ ኢልካ ንኽልቲኦም ብማዕረ ምዕዳል ዝበለጸ ኮይኑ ይስማዓኒ።ብዝተርፈ ጽቡቕ ስራሕ ቀጽሎ።
ሸንኮለል
ዮሴፍ ወያናይ ሰብ ቆጺርኩሞ ማለት ድዩ?
ዮሴፍ ሎሚ ተረኺብካ ፡ ደንቆሮ ። በይንኻ ምህዳድ ለሚድካ ። game over
Bravo Samuel 👍👍👍👍👍
ዮሴፍ ኣበየናይ ናይ ታሪኽ መጽሓፍ ተመርኩስካ "ናይ ኣምሓራ መሳፍንቲ ንደቡብ ገፊዖም" ኢልካ፣ ? ቃልሲ ሓደ ሰብ እውን ክጅምሮ ይኽእል፣ ንኣብነት ምሃትማን ጋንዲ::
እዚ ደኣሞ ፍሉጥ እንድዩ ሚኒሊክ ካብ ደቡብ ሰባት ንባርነት ይሸይጥ ኔሩ።
ኣየ ምሁር እየ በሃሊ፣ ዮሴፍ ገብረሂወት። ኣቦታት ክምስሉስ " ኣይትብከ እንዲዩ ዘብክየኒ " ይብሉ። ንሕና ኤርትራዊያን ድማ፣ እዚ እስኻ ትብሎ ዘሎኻ መምዘኒታት ከተማልእ እትኽእል ሃገር እንትትገዝኣና ብዙሕ ኣይመጉሃየንን፣ ናትና ኣደራዕ ግን እዘን ሓያላት ዝባሃላ ሃገራት መሰልና ጓዕጺጸን በታ ንነብሳ ብዴሞክራሲያዊ መገዲ ከተማሓድር ዘይትኽእል ሃጸያዊት ኢትዮጵያ ከምንጉበጥ ጌረናና። ስለዚ መግዛእቲ ጥራይ ዘይኮነ፣ ዘይንቡር መግዛእቲ እዩ።
እዚ ሰብዚ ዮሴፍ ዝበሃል ጽልኢ ኤርትራውያን ዶ ኣልዎዩ ንምንታይ የንጸርጽር ኣሎ፣ኣቲ ኣነ ዝበልኩም ንሱዩ ልኽዕ ይብለናሎ።ምሰረት ዘይብሉ ዘረባ ይዛረብ ንዓይ ስምዑኒ ዲታቶሪያዊ ጸቕጢ ንምንታይ? ፍኹስ ኢሉ ሓሳቡ ክዛረብ ንምንታይ ዘይክእል ዓቢ ይመስል ?ህዝቢ ኤርትራን ንፖለቲካዊ ያን ኤርትራውያን ምፍልላይ ድክመት ጥራሕዩ። ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ጣልያን ወጺኡ እንግሊዝ ክ ኣቱ ከሎ ብጣቒት ክቕበሎ ከሎ ፈትዩ ዘይኮነ ሓሊ ስለዘይነበሮ ጥራሕዩ። እንግሊዝ ወጺኡ ኢትዮጵያ ክኣቱ ከአሎውን ሓይሊ ስለዘይነበሮ ውሽጡ ሕሩር ኮይኑ ቁሒምዎ ስቕ ምስበለ ነዚ ውሽጣዊ መረረ ዘስተብሃለ ውላድ ኩሉ ምስቶም ንቑሓት ፖለቲካውያን ብምሕባር ነቲ ብውሽጡ ዝሓረረ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ሓይሊ ዘይነበሮ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ኣሎኻ ኣለናልካ ኢሎም ካብ መታሕት ደሓር ካብ ከበሳ እናተኣኻኸቡ ንውሽጡ ሕሩር ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ናጽነት ክወግኡ ኣንጻርቲ ኩሉ ሸርሕታት ሃይለስላሰን ኣሜሪካን ብሓይልን ፖለቲካን እናሰወደ ከይዱ ን ኢትዮጵያ ካብ ምድሪ ኤርትራ ሓኺኹ ኣውጺ ኡዎም። ናይ ዘይተወደበ ህዝቢ ሓሳብ ሕቶ ፣ድሌት ንምፍላጥ ኣጸጋሚዩ ፣ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ኣብትህቲ ኢታዮጵያ ኣብዝወደቐሉ ጊዜ ግን ኣይጎሃየን ፣ውሽጡ ኣይሓረረን ፣እኳ ድ ኣ ብሓጎስዩ ተቐቢልዎ ኢልካ ምዝራብካ ግን ናይቶ ኣንድነታውያን ሓሳብ ሎሚውን ስለዘሎ ንዑዑ ተንበድብድ ኢኻ ዘለኻ ።እቲ ሕርቃንካ የነጽር ኣሎ። ዲና ሙፍቲውን ነዚ ትብሎ ዘለኻዩ ኢሉ፣ንሱ ግን ቀልጢፉ ነቲ ዝነፍሕዕ ስሚ ይቕሬታ ሓቲቱሉዩ። ሎሚውን እቶም ኣንድነታውያን ፈልኽ ፈለኽ ትብሉ ከምዘለኹም ብጎንደር፣ብገል ብነገራ፣ብገለገለ ምሁራት በሃልቲ ከምዝስማዕዩ።
እዚ ዮሴፍ ዝብልዎ ሓደ ማዳ ሃገር ዑቡድ ሰብኣይእዩ ስቅ እይሉ እዩ ዓጀውጀው ዝብል ንሳሙኤል ውን ምዝራብ ይከልአ ኣሎ
ዶር ሳሚኤል እምሃ ርትዓውን ካብ ዝኾነ ወገናዊ ጸግዒ ተኣልዩ ንሓቂ ንምግላጽ ብህዱእን ርጉዕ መንፈስን ብሓቂ ንታሪኻዊ ኣፍልጥኡ ዝበቅዕ ቅኑዕ ሓሳብ ኢዩ ድዛረብ ደሎ። ብሓቂ ድማ ሚዛናዊ ንዓቅሉን ርግኣቱን ድማ የመስግን ጽባሕ ኤርትራ ኣለውኒ ካብ እትብሎም ፖተንሻል ዘጋታት ሓደ ኢዩ።
ኣቶ ዮሴፍ ካብ ነዊሕ እዋን ንጻዕዳ ጸሊም ክብል ኣብ ጽሑፍን ሚዳያታትን ክኾልል ዝጸንሐ ጸረ ኤርትራውነት ምዃኑ ካብ ኣንደበቱ ኩሉ ኤርትራዊ ክርድኦ ኪኢሉ ኢዩ።
ሕጂ ኣብዛ ቃለ መሕትት ውን ቃልሲ ህዝቢ ኤርትራ ምኽንያታዊ ኣይኮነን ኤርትራ ሃገር ኣይኮነትን ይብል ኣሎ። ካብዚ ዝዓቢ ረሳሕ ሓሳብ ክሕደት ንህዝቢ ኤርትራ ድማ የለን።
ዮሴፍ ገ/ሂወት ስነ ልቦና ናይ ኤርትራዊ ዘይብሉ ብገንዘብ ናይ ወያነ ተታሊሉ ንቃልሲ ኤርትራ ጸለሎ ክለኪ ዝውዕል. ሓደ ጡዑይ ሂወት ዘይመርሕ ሰብ ዋርድያ /Security guard/ ዝሰርሕ ጉዙእ ናይ መስተ ኣብ ሓንቲ ጸባብ ገዛ ዝቅመጥ እዩ ጉዙእ ናይ መስተ ከኣ ገንዘብ ዝኣኸለ ኣይኣኽሎን እዩ ወያነ ነዚኣ ፈሊጦም ኣብትሕቲ ቁጹጽሮም ይአትዮም እዮም. ስለዚ ካብዚ ዑሱብ ናይ ወያነ ዋላሓንቲ ክትመሃር ዋላ ክትፈልጥ ኣይትኽእልን ኢኻ.
Betami adnikeya aza media erirea nekedmet .2kefal alewa di u aza interviev tanks kea nezi medebat zekrebkumna
TMH ሚድያ ንዮሴፍ በይኑ ተጋለብዎ ንነብሱ ፈላጥ ጌርዋ ጸርጸር ኢሉ በኽዩ፡ ሳሙኤል ቀጽለሉ ንፉዕን ፈላጥን ርጉእን ሰብ ኢኻ።
Samuel Amaha jegna😎
It is interesting in my opinion if you do part 2 very good.
ኩሉ ኤርትራዊ ከምዚ ኸምኡ፡ ንዝርገት፡ ንኽድዓት፡ ንዕግርግር፡ ንምእንቲ ኸብዱ ምሻጥ፡ ቀረባ እዩ ዝመስሎ። ኣለዉና ኣለዋና!
Yesief Ethiopian go to what you love. Eritrea is fully independent. Dem teqereTs. The next phase of our struggle will be achieved on our scarification.