When you cheat at business and your customers and competitors get over it this is what happens!! My suggestion is for China to get back to the trade table and fly right and be honest because last agreements they failed to live by!!
China became predominantly an export orientated country. From low to high end accessories, parts or whole products. When people from other countries have no money to spend on their products due to the need to first feed themselves and their families then, we don’t buy, even when those Chinese products are discounted at ridiculous prices and sometimes with free shipping. We are all suffering the high cost of living.
Every country exports, that’s how they value each one’s currency. China is suffering because of the decoupling from the west. This isn’t really hard to understand.
No one talks about the roughly 100k chinese men who have crossed the southern us border in the last 2 years or the chinese camps in the durian gap in south America.
China had a decision to make: stop trying to build a military aggression against the west, or continue with its economic growth. They chose the earlier and now their citizens are paying for it. Was it worth it? is it still worth it trying to build military to take an aggressive foothold in the world vs benefitting its own economic growth and welfare of its citizens'? Was the anti-foreign policy effective (it led to foreign companies leaving China to other markets)? It was all working great...
Propping up foreign leaders who then fail their country has ramifications. A healthy customer with spending money is vital to anyone selling. A healthy economy is vital to anyone buying. Weakening "adversaries" is just weakening demand. Weak demand, unchecked, is catastrophic.
Much of China's boom was between 1990 to 2020. Money was much easier to be made. Many of those who made theie money have now cut back spending. College graduates found it easier. Real estate was over built with unfinished projects. The CCP pandemic lockdown hurt the average workers which they never recoveted. Companies are leaving China and the jobs with it.
Every boom is followed by a downturn where the fat gets trimmed and China was overdue. However, China is even more complicated due to the cult of personality and mandates from Heaven (ie central control by idiots - same story in the West) given by Xi AND the the draconian Covid lockdowns that accelerated business failures. Shanghai storefronts look a bit like NYC but judging economic healthy by retail is shallow. The two things to watch in China are the real estate crisis and factory closures. Xi is scaring off foreign money and business at the worst possible time. Another thing to watch is local government tax revenues........ those are declining rapidly in many parts of China and that is unprecedented in the past few decades. FWIW - I wish for the Chinese people to do well and do NOT equate them with the CCP. Prosperity brings peace.
So, these individuals that kept claiming that only they would be happy to be under the Chinese government control that they would prosper when under British rule they were one of the wealthiest territories on Earth. Be careful what you wish for…
All they know how to do is drop the bag. Look at what CN did to Hong Kong. Now their major cities are going to crumble under the financial pressure they created. lol.
The US built and abetted those very practices with its agreementa & massive outsourcing to take advantage of the low labor costs & efficient infrastucture.
Lol at the bots complaining about this being propaganda when it's just showing videos that they took and translating what they say. Next they'll be saying these are all CGI lol
People will claim that its propaganda because it only shows China in a bad light (which it does). I don't recall seeing anything positive mentioned, yet there are positives. "Shanghai's truly done this time" ...
Chineese are hard working, disciplined, family oriented people. There may be ups and downs but they will prosper. The greed and expansionism of leadership are detrimental to the growth of China.
Stop using filters on your SM Posts. Your eyes look like they're going to pop right out. We stopped our hundreds of million in direct investment and moved them to Mexico. And we are not alone. Enjoy your XI.
Champaign lifestyles on beer budgets. Chinese people have grown accustomed to rich living, not practicing frugality and wise spending/saving habits. Reminds me of the womens' lifestyles here in US actually 🤔
Hey, do you think you could get some Chinese people talking American? That way I know what they’re saying instead of relying on translation that could be not right
There is no such language as American. It's called English. I speak Chinese and I can assure you, the translation is correct. If not, many people proficient in Chinese would point out. On the contrary, many Chinese do not speak English. If you force them to speak in broken English, there is a higher risk of misunderstanding and error...
I was watching the military games between Russia and China unfortunately for China their temu tank fell apart during the games. I even heard Pakistan bought many tofu tanks from the ccp but, had to send the temu tanks back to China for repair even the Prime Minister of Pakistan stated it was a piece of junk unfortunately for the Pakistanis, the temu tanks broke down again so the Prime Minister of Pakistan r tv told the Chinese not to build the damn temu tanks for them just dsend the parts and they would build the tanks themselves unfortunately for the Chinese it was a huge embarrassment, even their allies like Russia made fun of the Chinese but just my opinion it’s a design flaw😂😂😂😂😂 just like there, Temu soldiers unfortunately China couldn’t get a break with Saudi Arabia and UAE they had to return the so-called Fire Dragon air defense junk worth $6 billion I bet they kicking themselves in the head even Peru wouldn’t touch Chinese military hardware even though the CCP offered the Peruvian government half-price on Chinese military junk but lucky for them they passed on the deal which was the smartest move they ever made especially after hearing about Brazil and Bolivia having problems with their equipment but did you about hear the situation in Bolivia? Supposedly one of the generals tried to overthrow the government recently, but the military hardware they bought from China fell apart on the way to the palace unfortunately for the general he was apprehended and thrown in prison I bet he’s probably thinking to himself the damn Chinese got me good they straight up sold me a lemon🥲🥲🥲
In everyday Russian language term "low-quality" is often represented by the word "Chinese", i.e. "this Chinese train stop is falling apart". We find their stuff malfunctioning just as funny and expected as others. Fear not, most Russia's own tanks (that were not shot in Ukraine yet) are probably too rusted to even start, if not sold for scrap by some corrupt colonels years ago.. I hope both Russia and China will see reason and stop the horrible violence that they cannot sustain and most damaging to Russians and Chinese
😄🤦♂️….The owner of the channel changed the thumbnail video photo of the girl 3 times in lest then a few hours. It went from just a concerned face to the stereotypical OVERUSED crying Asian face….😫😄🤦♂️…..like I said, the programming can’t be broken. The crying face and the peace symbol will be till the end of time. If Asian from multiple generations spanning million of years ever reunited in the after life they would all at least have those two things in common.
I have no idea what you are talking about my dad grew up in Shanghai since 1950s I've visited Shanghai since 2000 every 4-5 years and I've seen it transform from a third world city to probably the most cleanist and futuristic cities in these past 2 decades, came back from Shanghai last week and with the majority switch to electric vehicles the city has became very quiet and peaceful from the noise pollution and smog it once was full of.
Checked your channel and every video is basically China bashing. It's fine to be critical in a balanced manner, but it's obvious you're heavily biased towards a particular narrative.
How to be "balanced" when there's nothing good to say about China? That there are no good news for China? Should they make something positive up just to cater to your sensitive, little, pink wumao soul?
It's called delivering the truth. Are you so naive that you do not realize that official Chinese state media is a 100% propaganda. Pull your head out of a dark place and enjoy the light of information and truth.
Toronto, Vancouver, Sydney, LA. I m an Aussie but lived in Canada before. Problem is, most of them are Westernised, and indoctrinated by feminism and cultural Marxism, just like all other Western gals
I watch a lot of China stuff because I like geopolitics and like to know what’s happening in important parts of the world. Lately, TH-cam started recommending this Channel to me and every single video I have seen on China from here is extremely negative. I know some foreigners and expats in China and even if some of the things this Channel talks about are facts, the consistency of the negativity and the exaggeration has got me scratching my head a little bit. I think someone is clearly pushing a narrative here 😂😂. It’s so obvious. Btw, it’s statistically and objectively impossible for a country of 1.4 billion people not to have some social issues and certain people to struggle economically, especially more so given the dynamics of the world economy and geopolitical environment. My verdict is this channel makes their agenda too obvious. Balance is key otherwise discerning people will not take you serious 😂.
Yah. It's not just this channel saying it. When Israel goes after Iranian oil, China will go down harder because they need Iranian oil. Now you know why the US is reluctant to punish Iran until the US de-risks from China further
You do realize that just because the great 'firewall of China' keeps the average person in China from seeing the rest of the world doesn't keep us from seeing them?
If Shanghai, China’s best city is done, then China is done.
At one point in time it was Hong Kong.
Unwilling to fight the dictator, the people suffer in silence!
Not only that but that typhoon probably did a lot more damage then reported buisness that stuck around now have a very convient reason to leave.
It's pretty bad when state media propagandists get laid-off.
This is all xi jinping and ccp’s fault. Thanks for sharing.
This is propaganda channel😂😂
Thanks, Wolf Warrior Diplomacy! Thanks, anti spying laws!
Don't worry Chinese shop owners, Winnie the Xi has told me to expect 5% growth this year! Everyone is prospering.
Do you believe that number?
@@iancheng6527 I believe my bald head will regrow 5% more follicles this year. That is how much I believe the number.
🐷 can 💸
@@LEV1ATHYN you are reactionary, everyone already has "prospered", not "prospering", Winnie will put you in jail.🤣
From what I see, if you're over 35 you're toast in any business.
Please don't discount slightly older folks!!!
Especially busineses requiring trained skill and expertese like engineering
Shanghai lost 2 Chicagos worth of people. If you've never been to Asia from the states, its hard to understand how big these cities are.
It is apparent that the Chinese economic woes have spiraled into a looming crisis which plagues all industries.
When you cheat at business and your customers and competitors get over it this is what happens!! My suggestion is for China to get back to the trade table and fly right and be honest because last agreements they failed to live by!!
Go back to rice farming 🇨🇳
The results of more money in the hands of a few, and the monopoly of everything we need.
Yep. This is happening in The West also, China are just ahead.
Are you really Black?
superficiality obviously isnt just an American thing
The west can maketh. The west can breaketh. Don't bite the hands that feed u. 😂😂🎉
True
And "Xi JinPing" have been chomping on *"That Hand"* BiG TiME ❗️
AND, they jst did 😂
West is a third world country that asks China for loans...😆
China became predominantly an export orientated country. From low to high end accessories, parts or whole products.
When people from other countries have no money to spend on their products due to the need to first feed themselves and their families then, we don’t buy, even when those Chinese products are discounted at ridiculous prices and sometimes with free shipping.
We are all suffering the high cost of living.
Every country exports, that’s how they value each one’s currency. China is suffering because of the decoupling from the west. This isn’t really hard to understand.
A lot of little pinks are mad on this channel.
They need to move to the belt and road countries because that's where their money is at
A lot of jobs in Chinise army.
Soon they will be busy
No wonder the capital flight is enormous there.
This is what happens when you have one dictator surrounded by “yes” “men”.
Rise up People of China
They did... for a little bit. Otherwise, they'd still be under lockdown.
Thank you, God
No one talks about the roughly 100k chinese men who have crossed the southern us border in the last 2 years or the chinese camps in the durian gap in south America.
They steal intellectual properties without consequences
China is not doing so well right now.
Flee for the rice fields 🇨🇳
At least there is food there
How many people have left china for the west in the last 5 years?
the same number that will get offed in the future, I suppose?
China had a decision to make: stop trying to build a military aggression against the west, or continue with its economic growth. They chose the earlier and now their citizens are paying for it. Was it worth it? is it still worth it trying to build military to take an aggressive foothold in the world vs benefitting its own economic growth and welfare of its citizens'? Was the anti-foreign policy effective (it led to foreign companies leaving China to other markets)? It was all working great...
Propping up foreign leaders who then fail their country has ramifications. A healthy customer with spending money is vital to anyone selling. A healthy economy is vital to anyone buying. Weakening "adversaries" is just weakening demand. Weak demand, unchecked, is catastrophic.
Much of China's boom was between 1990 to 2020. Money was much easier to be made. Many of those who made theie money have now cut back spending. College graduates found it easier. Real estate was over built with unfinished projects. The CCP pandemic lockdown hurt the average workers which they never recoveted. Companies are leaving China and the jobs with it.
“Shanghai population has dropped from 30->24 million”
So still 20 million too many.
The paper money system is loosing affecting many lives. We need to reboot our money system.
How many times does it have to be finished until it gets reeeeallly finished?
So no more chinese tourists?
fewer legal tourists... probably a lot more "just off the boat" types though
Every boom is followed by a downturn where the fat gets trimmed and China was overdue. However, China is even more complicated due to the cult of personality and mandates from Heaven (ie central control by idiots - same story in the West) given by Xi AND the the draconian Covid lockdowns that accelerated business failures. Shanghai storefronts look a bit like NYC but judging economic healthy by retail is shallow. The two things to watch in China are the real estate crisis and factory closures. Xi is scaring off foreign money and business at the worst possible time. Another thing to watch is local government tax revenues........ those are declining rapidly in many parts of China and that is unprecedented in the past few decades.
FWIW - I wish for the Chinese people to do well and do NOT equate them with the CCP. Prosperity brings peace.
And they say chinas economy is growing.
5% every year, nobody out China believes that
@@aldopalomino9156 Even the Chinese people in China don't believe it.
There is actually negative growth there.
So, these individuals that kept claiming that only they would be happy to be under the Chinese government control that they would prosper when under British rule they were one of the wealthiest territories on Earth. Be careful what you wish for…
I love the comment-people are not inclined to spend when they don't have money- Genius
Dictatorships don’t work!
Money coming out, no money coming in
This happens in America too. No one watches tv anymore. Just streaming services.
Fiasco economy is outcome of blunder by XI.
Thank you buddy
Shanghai didnt get shanghai'd it got see see peed
All they know how to do is drop the bag. Look at what CN did to Hong Kong. Now their major cities are going to crumble under the financial pressure they created. lol.
Eh their management skills are not that great. I mean look at Hong Kong. lol.
The worlds a mess. I hope things simmer down soon.
I don't watch TV Hate the TV..over 5 years now ..
Good job. That's why they call it the boob tube.
This is like that south park episode. Those celebrities needs their millions of dollars to pay their Mansion.
Good news if this is true 😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮😮
Price of gold Jan 20 2020 = 1575.00
Price of gold Oct. 1 2024 = 2,660.00
The USA dollar is worth = 41% LESS
A lot of Chinese who had jobs teaching on their own lost their jobs because of new laws the central government passed.
Maybe if China had played fair by international business and trade practices for the past 30 years I'd feel more sympathy.
The US built and abetted those very practices with its agreementa & massive outsourcing to take advantage of the low labor costs & efficient infrastucture.
theres no such word as "fair" in CCP rules
@@netizencapet
Thanks Kissinger
@@netizencapet The US does not engage in dumping, unlike China
Good!
Lol at the bots complaining about this being propaganda when it's just showing videos that they took and translating what they say. Next they'll be saying these are all CGI lol
People will claim that its propaganda because it only shows China in a bad light (which it does). I don't recall seeing anything positive mentioned, yet there are positives.
"Shanghai's truly done this time" ...
China has censored TH-cam but is itself sending bots onto TH-cam)))
Chineese are hard working, disciplined, family oriented people. There may be ups and downs but they will prosper. The greed and expansionism of leadership are detrimental to the growth of China.
Drive a couple of hours west of Shangai and you're back in the third world.
Martin Andanar in CGTN was also laid off...
source?
How did China record a 4.7% growth rate in 2024 if the businesses are really leaving China?
Cooking the books, obviously.
Or these vids are carefully orchestrated by the CCP to win sympathy and make foreign companies to stay 😂
Fake numbers. There's no growth in China atm.
Just accept the fact that all big companies are leaving your country
All their numbers are fake
Shanghai back to Mao time, a hell hole.
It will sound bad but whatever happening is good for climate
Thank you God
good
Let's find out how they will contend with having to be useful to make a living.
Most of Shanghai is either under water or torn apart from the typhoons right now.
What a disaster..
Is this true
No, there are alot of work but low to no pay. One for example is russian frontlines or african construction front.
Stop using filters on your SM Posts. Your eyes look like they're going to pop right out. We stopped our hundreds of million in direct investment and moved them to Mexico. And we are not alone. Enjoy your XI.
The mandate of heaven, the fall of a dynasty has come.
And I wonder how would Mihoyo would do
5million/1.4 billion is not a bad percentage even if it is bad in comparison between countries.
CCP is doing fine, they got 800 Billion of US treasury and surely is receiving that interest payment every year.
I’m turned on my the cover. I’m sick. I need help.😢
Champaign lifestyles on beer budgets. Chinese people have grown accustomed to rich living, not practicing frugality and wise spending/saving habits. Reminds me of the womens' lifestyles here in US actually 🤔
Imagine how P Diddy Coombes is feeling right now 😂
With all these terrible reports coming out of China, I’m starting to get worried that it will get invaded by Taiwan.
The Nationalists!
I like this channel but its so doomer. Every other video is how china is done.
Not the fault of the channel, mate.
Just reporting what's happening
well, it is the modus operandi of the channel, it exists to expose everything that communist China tries to sugarcoat.
It's going to get way worse mate, within four years you are going to see real doom.
Hey, do you think you could get some Chinese people talking American? That way I know what they’re saying instead of relying on translation that could be not right
There is no such language as American. It's called English. I speak Chinese and I can assure you, the translation is correct. If not, many people proficient in Chinese would point out. On the contrary, many Chinese do not speak English. If you force them to speak in broken English, there is a higher risk of misunderstanding and error...
Bro, what? 😂
@@DanielDeBenoitmost of the translation also has a English accent to boot.
I clicked expecting 12,000 over a number of years. I gotta do some research, I can't except this bomb shell from a single source.
Agreed, and I can’t see any sources confirming such a statement.
Yes you can you just don’t want to see.
@@Inkslinger123 I do want to see lmao, I legitimately searched, I would love to see the sources you found.
@@Inkslinger123 Life tip, don't go taking spectacular claims at face value without checking. A claim like this is source material checking big.
@@Onyx-Rose150 exactly what in the world was he trying to prove by saying that💀💀
Chinese government must force tge People living in Shanghai to live outside Shanghai. Yes force tgem out just like the Cultural revolution
Me no love long time ago a propagandist
I was watching the military games between Russia and China unfortunately for China their temu tank fell apart during the games. I even heard Pakistan bought many tofu tanks from the ccp but, had to send the temu tanks back to China for repair even the Prime Minister of Pakistan stated it was a piece of junk unfortunately for the Pakistanis, the temu tanks broke down again so the Prime Minister of Pakistan r tv told the Chinese not to build the damn temu tanks for them just dsend the parts and they would build the tanks themselves unfortunately for the Chinese it was a huge embarrassment, even their allies like Russia made fun of the Chinese but just my opinion it’s a design flaw😂😂😂😂😂 just like there, Temu soldiers unfortunately China couldn’t get a break with Saudi Arabia and UAE they had to return the so-called Fire Dragon air defense junk worth $6 billion I bet they kicking themselves in the head even Peru wouldn’t touch Chinese military hardware even though the CCP offered the Peruvian government half-price on Chinese military junk but lucky for them they passed on the deal which was the smartest move they ever made especially after hearing about Brazil and Bolivia having problems with their equipment but did you about hear the situation in Bolivia? Supposedly one of the generals tried to overthrow the government recently, but the military hardware they bought from China fell apart on the way to the palace unfortunately for the general he was apprehended and thrown in prison I bet he’s probably thinking to himself the damn Chinese got me good they straight up sold me a lemon🥲🥲🥲
In everyday Russian language term "low-quality" is often represented by the word "Chinese", i.e. "this Chinese train stop is falling apart". We find their stuff malfunctioning just as funny and expected as others.
Fear not, most Russia's own tanks (that were not shot in Ukraine yet) are probably too rusted to even start, if not sold for scrap by some corrupt colonels years ago..
I hope both Russia and China will see reason and stop the horrible violence that they cannot sustain and most damaging to Russians and Chinese
Hehe
😄🤦♂️….The owner of the channel changed the thumbnail video photo of the girl 3 times in lest then a few hours. It went from just a concerned face to the stereotypical OVERUSED crying Asian face….😫😄🤦♂️…..like I said, the programming can’t be broken. The crying face and the peace symbol will be till the end of time. If Asian from multiple generations spanning million of years ever reunited in the after life they would all at least have those two things in common.
Oh, that's AWFUL. Make sure to point your acerb observations out in your report for the CCP.
5millions out billions is just a small drop..?! 🤔
Trump 2024
China is just fascinating in so many ways...
Shanghai is already dead since the 1990s when they started to demolish beautiful buildings, trees and parks and built ugliness in their places
I have no idea what you are talking about my dad grew up in Shanghai since 1950s I've visited Shanghai since 2000 every 4-5 years and I've seen it transform from a third world city to probably the most cleanist and futuristic cities in these past 2 decades, came back from Shanghai last week and with the majority switch to electric vehicles the city has became very quiet and peaceful from the noise pollution and smog it once was full of.
If u.s economie is back then china will pay the price
This year, not this "jear."
This jeer?
🎉
Not the only Nation 100%
But it's the only one single thought nation It's a dictatorship.
AND yet another heading your way from the same direction
Checked your channel and every video is basically China bashing. It's fine to be critical in a balanced manner, but it's obvious you're heavily biased towards a particular narrative.
How to be "balanced" when there's nothing good to say about China? That there are no good news for China? Should they make something positive up just to cater to your sensitive, little, pink wumao soul?
"critical in a balanced manner" think before typing.
It's a propaganda channel, most likely being funded by the West
Yeah as much as I hate the CPP and all communists this seems like American funded propaganda channel 😂
It's called delivering the truth. Are you so naive that you do not realize that official Chinese state media is a 100% propaganda. Pull your head out of a dark place and enjoy the light of information and truth.
Where can u meet a Chinese girl?
In China.
In China, genius.
@etiletsatsi5130 ahahha. Maybe close than China? 🤣🤣
Vancouver Canada
Toronto, Vancouver, Sydney, LA. I m an Aussie but lived in Canada before. Problem is, most of them are Westernised, and indoctrinated by feminism and cultural Marxism, just like all other Western gals
Rats are endangered in China 😂
Its finally done? For reals this time? I better not still see this city in the map then
Just give the Chinese a break! Give them a reasonable leader and replace their dictatorship!
That’s up to them not us.
pass
I watch a lot of China stuff because I like geopolitics and like to know what’s happening in important parts of the world. Lately, TH-cam started recommending this Channel to me and every single video I have seen on China from here is extremely negative.
I know some foreigners and expats in China and even if some of the things this Channel talks about are facts, the consistency of the negativity and the exaggeration has got me scratching my head a little bit. I think someone is clearly pushing a narrative here 😂😂. It’s so obvious.
Btw, it’s statistically and objectively impossible for a country of 1.4 billion people not to have some social issues and certain people to struggle economically, especially more so given the dynamics of the world economy and geopolitical environment.
My verdict is this channel makes their agenda too obvious. Balance is key otherwise discerning people will not take you serious 😂.
Yah. It's not just this channel saying it. When Israel goes after Iranian oil, China will go down harder because they need Iranian oil. Now you know why the US is reluctant to punish Iran until the US de-risks from China further
Its balanced when inside the great firewall is severely biased toward downplaying issues and glorifying CCP XD
I saw from another source that Chinese riches queued up to buy an expensive Huawei phone which was foldable. What a different world!
dun gaslight internet viewers pls. Shanghai and china and as a whole is as properorus if not better than before. this observer channel is fake as hell
I hope the 50¢ was worthwhile to lie on the Internet wumao
Ok monkey
You do realize that just because the great 'firewall of China' keeps the average person in China from seeing the rest of the world doesn't keep us from seeing them?
Ok wumao
Hope you enjoy your fake moon cakes
Enjoy your life in Guangdong! Enjoy the gray skies, even in sunlight, the public shamings, the low pay, job insecurity, etc.
situation of china today china people must thanks to chief accelerator🤣
Nah, China’s fine. On the other hand, America….