What if Someone Rejects Hadith? | Ask Shaykh YQ #20
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 5 ต.ค. 2019
- It is something that is indeed popular nowadays. Some people decide to follow the Qur'an only and reject every else including Hadith.
Please LIKE, COMMENT, & SHARE!
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Credits
Intro Quran Recitation: سورة النحل هزاع البلوشي
Link: www.youtube.com/watch?v=GSDLl...
Outro Nasheed: 'The Good is Still Alive'
Link: • The Good Is Still Aliv...
Timelapse Footage
From: Timestorm Films
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official Social Media Pages
Facebook: yasirqadhi
Instagram: yasir.qadhi
Twitter: yasirQadhi
Snapchat: snapchat.com/add/yasir.qadhi
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
© Shaykh Dr. Yasir Qadhi - Official TH-cam Channel
What I've learned from these Q&A sessions are more than what I've learnt from diploma .may Allah bless Sheikh Yasir Qadhi, may Allah protects you
You once again wasted your time. Read Quran.
@Iron Man Your name tells me who you are.
@@adilrasheedonline OF COURSE I DO READ QURAN. WHAT DO YOU WANT FROM THE PAGE OF SOMEONE YOU HATE ?
@@adilrasheedonline i see those who rejects hadith in its entirety are with the smallest thinking ability
Brother do not get angry. If your statement that you learned from the video more than what you learned in your diploma, then you should be very careful in accepting things too quickly without reasoning it our. Remember you already wasted your time doing diploma according to your own admission.
Amazing value in these Q&As, please keep them going! Jazakallah Khair
th-cam.com/video/EloWrUEzapA/w-d-xo.html this will clear your confusion, thank me later.
May Allah blessed you for such an explanation.
Amin. JazakaLLahu Khairan.
I don't understand.. where is the deviation when a muslim wants to recheck and revalidate the books of hadith... To be honest I have some issues with the criteria followed to hadith classifications. Also I'm really surprised that Hadith testing based on the Qur'an is not a criteria within the filtration process? I'm looking into the science of the hadith and I still can't find this, maybe I didn't go deep enough?
I wish this session was a bit longer so you would explain where does the deviation lie in all of this? I hope one day you can open a special session to explain to us the science of Hadith in a nutshell :)
Jazakallahu khairan
No you are right! The focus of traditional scholars on hadith authentication has been on isnad (transmission) and ilm al rijal (biographies of transmitters), matn (content) was, by and large, ignored. That is why we have hadiths in the sahih collections that contradict the Quran, contradict each other, contradict reason and show the Prophet in a negative light!
May Allah swt bless you abundantly my dear brother. So many people have critised you and yet you never retaliate or criticise anyone else. This is why I do listen to your lectures. Ma shaa Allah tabarak Allah I have benefited from your knowledge. Please pray for this sister of yours my dear brother
MaashaAllah a great lecture. May ALLAH BLESS YOU.
Very respectable answer.
We have a lot to learn from here.
he is totally talking on point.
Jajak Allah khairan.
th-cam.com/video/EloWrUEzapA/w-d-xo.html this will clear your confusion, thank me later.
Wow he speaks very articulate. Mashallah.
Iron Man so the Quran itself is also eloquent. So what does that mean for you?
MaShaAllah.... Wise and detailed answer.
Dr Yasir jazakallah Khairan for this well thought explanation.
All your lectures need to be seen by the world. Your teaching skills are hard to find.. MashAllah... why don’t you do an ilm fest in Dearborn Mi again. Come live in Dearborn mi. Forget Texas, we need you here.
Jazak Allah ya sheikh🤲🏼
Yasir Habib galby , you are by far the best western scholar in human history. May Allah continue to bless you with knowledge MashAllah. Woow such a pure intellectual human your like an angel among us. May Allah shower you with blessings here and in the after life. Grant you haven with prophet Muhammad pbuh. I love how you explain deep in depth You explain it from top to bottom. Keep the content going. I will tell you one thing that will make your lectures perfect. Have a little more humor. I think you will go viral. InshAllah. Love you man!
And he is honest in his Talks..
Classical knowledge Living in our Time..
Get so much benefit from him
MashaALLAH you make my heart joyful ......I like you so much ...love from Pakistan
Mashaallah
Shiekh this is the biggest problem of today, people make judgements without knowing the whole thing, or they are just eager to find out a statement so that they can make a big noise about it, there are plenty of such people now a days who take things out of context n then go to scholars so n so said this n then begins a "war", May Allah SWT protect us Ameen 🤲🏻
salam to all, does rejecting man made hadiths attributed to the messenger prevent me
from following and understanding the quran ?
yes or no ?
Yes
No.
If some lives in a far land and he found The Quran, Doe he need to read Books of Sahih totally to understand.
@@doot2359 no, Quran explains itself. Don't listen to hadith mushriks
I'd say no, if it sounds like it's written for the benefit of man only then its definitely been written by man
but if u say sunnah has been 100% preserved, there are literally things such as "weak hadiths", and there is absolutely NOTHING like a "weak verse"
I wish i was like you.
💚💚💚💚
Laila Wardak 😂 you can never be like him but u can be a better person than you are today. Listen to the lectures of reputable Shaikhs and you will learn a lot in shaa Allah. Make it a point to learn something good everyday. I have learned so much from this Shaikhs. May Allah help us all
@@zeezeebo
Jazak Allaho khair for taking time and gave me advice. 😊🐝
My point to be is his knowledge and his character as a Muslim. I don't wish to be Lady Gaga.
Laila Wardak I’m proud of your intention. All you need to study and listen to beneficial lectures and implement it in your life .
Stay away from the negativity and be an example for your community.
Much respect ✊.
MusMud Jazak Allaho khair for your advices, may Allah bless you and your family for making my heart feel happy. 😊🐝
most people are already are like him. DEVOTED PAGAN MUSLIM. A MUSLIM BUT ASLO A PAGAN.
I've got Q ، what is the verdict upon s1 who committed haram bcoz of superstitions , magic , or bewitchment etc ?
th-cam.com/video/EloWrUEzapA/w-d-xo.html this will clear your confusion, thank me later.
Who is person before the talk?
12:55 the scariest part of this video but also true without a doubt.
technically speaking, if someone accepts Quran, then he totally accepts that this Quran was delivered to the prophet Muhammad. So the Quranist who only accepts Quran doesn't mean he rejects the prophet. It doesn't make sense.
The Sunnah isn't in vain. Hadiths are a crucial part of Islam. How would you know how to pray if not for the Prophet (ﷺ)?
@@muslim94727 you don't need hadith to pray, except if there was a time, 100 years muslims in the world don't pray, so they lost the knowledge how to pray. So then, there was a man, find a book and in that book it was written how to pray... That would be the time we need hadith.
Salam Mashallah Believe Quran Only Completely Be Little Patient If You Have Trouble
Ok we have to follow the Hadith and Sunna. But what is authentic? So many of them were "discovered" hundreds of years after the dead of the Prophet? Some hadiths have no logical sense and explanation. I am a convert and find it very difficult. For example how unaware fart (at home) makes my wudu invalid. I don't have time to repeat my wudu every time. It often stops me from praying. Logically thinking my niyah is more important right? I WANT to pray.
Salam, Allah asks us in the Quran to purify ourselves before prayer. Remember you are taking the time to pray to your creator who asks you to make wudu before the prayer.
I wonder which Dr. He is talking aboutb
@roven 08 no idea but ohh well
@Hamza Khan he doesn't reject hadiths
@@TALHA43289914 only those that go against the Quran but even in general he doesnt see them in a very high light
One cannot accept hadith blindly
Quran will be the criterion to judge wat is true in hadith
When can I call myself your student ya Shaykh!
It is duty of hadith scholar to always study and investigate the truth of hadith shahih whether there is contradiction in hadith to Quran. Do not doubt to remove if it is proven false. Ummah will follow. I think hadith as writing document is nessecary not only as source of fikh but also as controlled document to preserve sunnah from distortion either it is done purposedly or unpurposedly because of lack of memory by who teach students. Most of Islamic practice in daily basis were taught by example and oral or in other hand by sunnah.
We know that the Torah and the Bible were distorted and we know that Allah guaranteed only the authenticity of the Quran. Why do we assume that Hadiths have not been distorted, no matter what the scholars say? In any case scholars bear most of the responsibility for the distortions of the Torah and Bible. As Allah says, "Rabbis and monks determined what was lawful and what was not instead of God." (The Quran, 9:31). Why do we assume Muslims scholars to be different from the Jewish and Christian scholars?
So if someone denies that the sunnah has been preserved he is only doing a bid'ah? 18:15 And if he denies sahih al bukhari and picks and chooses which authentic hadith to accept, you think this is within islam? Also someone in this video forget a lot ob salawat when mentioning our prophet saws. Can you explain why someome would allow >5% haram in investments?
YTSince2006
You think being sunni is correct?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39:28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Don’t listen to people, read Quran and follow Allah instructions.
@@lolyou6676 educate yourself allah guide you
mista Haych
How can someone be educated first then Allah to guide them? You first need help in being educated then Allah to guide you? If you don’t get help how do you get educated?
Sheikh do you know that particular women who leaded the jumma in Kerala is not a Muslim now. She is now in atheism. Now she always speaking against Quran.
@de Her name is jamida. Jamida teacher. She is a ex Arabic teacher.
@the truth You can't understand bcoz it's in my mother tongue i.e.malayalam
She left Islam because sunni people were calling her a nonbeliever so she then decided to follow the sunnah! And now she is a nonbeliever, are you happy now sunni people?
Do you think being sunni is following Allah?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39.28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Stop listening to fabricated stories and start reading Quran, then you will understand what Islam is about!
Both did wrong, the people who shouted at her, made her feel bad. And she also on focussing what the people will say. If you are true to God like Mary A.S was then you'll not care of the people, and those people will indeed be wrong. Here, both were wrong.
@@lolyou6676 oh you are saying women leading salah is correct. It is against Islamic tradition. Prophet didn't teach this. We also cannot find the evidence for this from the doings of sahaba. We are following Quran and authentic ahadith upon understanding of salaf as saliheen. Not fabricated hadith.
Amazing is the wisdom that is present in the Quran. All 21 minutes of this person talking can be objected using just one verse from the Quran.
Those are the Revelations of God that We recite to you (through Gabriel) with truth. In what hadith, if not in God and His Revelations, will they, then, believe? Quran 45:6
What about verses: 49:1, 3:31, 3:32, 4:59, 5:92, 8:46, 9:71, 24:54, 24:56, 47:32, 47:33, 64:12
What about the 3rd category, who only rejects Hadiths that are contradictory to the Quran and do not make common sense?
Thats the whole point. The person being spoken about denies hadith that are against the Quran and common sense. And to be frank, i agree with him. The hadith need to be revaluated
@@Hamza00011 What is the name of 'Dr. X?'
@@littlecouchpotato Dr Shabir Ally
Major problem in sub continent.
I love Yasir Qadi. May Allah bless him and always keep him on haqq. There are times when I disagree with his views, but even when that happens, I still love and respect him immensely. On this specific issue, I disagree with him. If let's say you view Bukhari not as a perfect source of Sunnay preservation , this does not fit the definition of Bidah that Dr. Yasir Qadi layed layer out in previous lectures. If you say there are elements of Bukharis work that have not been properly preserved, and can articulate your reasonings, this doesn't make you part of another sect. Sahih Bukhari is not the Sunnah. No man is without error. Your reasonings behind the rejection of Bukhari determine whether you are a Kafir, An innovator, or someone having good intention and trying to establish what the Authentic Sunnah is. Most people who have problems with Sahih Bukhari reject specific hadiths, rather than the whole book. I am one such person. I don't reject Bukhari. Far from it. But the man was not perfect. And there are certain problematic hadith that, from the opinion I follow, dishonor the holy prophet. May Allah bless Yasir Qadi and keep him safe. Regardless of the differences, he remains one of my favorite teachers in Islam and someone I hope to meet personally one day.
Shaikh, why did you leave Memphis and moved to Dallas. What about the so many ppl you left behind?
zeezeebo
It’s all about the money, who cares about people! That’s how the world works.
This is a question for Dr Yasir
There is a new Doctor called Dr Hany
I want to know your attention on His channel
Please answer Sheikh
They are talking about you a lot
I am new in Islam
And I am learning
How should I know if should listen to you or any one else
I really love your lecture
Can any one tell me more about m I in right place
Welcome may Allah bless you! Yes this is a very trustworthy teacher mashallah
Yes yasir qadhi is a very good teacher
Not radical or extremist
He tries his best to explain quran and sunnah
In my opinion its a trustworthy source
Yasir qadhi is quite balanced. Also I'd recommend Dr Jonathan Brown who is a friend of Yasir Qadhi and Hamza Yusuf.
Dr Yasir Qadhi is a presentation of true Islam. You are in the right place.
Do you think being sunni is following Allah?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39.28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Stop listening to fabricated stories and start reading Quran, then you will understand what Islam is about!
Hmm, not sure if you'll get this message but even though Parwez is gone, misrepresenting his words is still very unscholarly and makes you appear unresearched and biased. There is no "group" that he led called Parwezi nor did he reject the Sunnah or say that there's no such thing as Sunnah. His claim was that any Sunnah that are against the pure Quranic message should be rejected.
His claim was that hadith and Sunnah are not sources of law in Islam, and instead only Quran should be used. Basically he denies that the Prophet (SAW) is a source of divine knowledge. He thinks Allah only gave the Quran as our source for knowledge.
So, even though people might say he didn't "reject" the Sunnah because he didn't say all hadith are false, he rejected the basic philosophy of Islam that the Sunnah is a source of legal knowledge.
@@zaidmujtaba1062 The point of this is simply that Be Yaser laid out his own criteria of how he classifies these groups and he misclassified the Parwez position pretty significantly. If you note in the video, he says that those who deny Hadith because they do not feel it is preserved accurately fall into the still within Islam group. And Parwez laid it out quite clearly that his reason for not utilizing Hadith for divine guidance is that he does not believe it was preserved accurately
Zaid Mujtaba
Do you think being sunni is following Allah?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39.28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Stop listening to fabricated stories and start reading Quran, then you will understand what Islam is about!
@@lolyou6676 I obey Allah and his messenger. 24:54
Anyone who turns away from the messenger's commands is misguided. Allah's commands are in the Quran. Where are the messenger's?
@@zaidmujtaba1062 There are more than 300 verses in the Quran where Allah instead of answering the queries of the people, instructed messengers to say something. These verses start with the work "Qul" and is preserved in the Quran. When Allah commands us to obey the messengers (moosa, isa, muhammad), He is talking about these verses because these are the only ones preserved.
He doesn't realise that he's critical of hadith himself. He said 'how do I know what you've said is true, its your version or interpretation'.
Thats true
do not put words in his mouth... you are comparing apples and the pathogen theorem...
Rejecting individual or groups of certain hadiths isn’t the same as rejecting the Sunna. Bukhari himself didn’t include over 99% of hadiths which he had access to in his book.
That doesn't mean Imam Bukhari never followed those rest of the hadiths or respected them. He just didn't add them in his book because his book was the best of them all in terms of narrations and they're all authentic without a shadow of the doubt. Doesn't mean other hadiths are ruled out or Bukhari never followed them in his personal life.
@@ammarahmed6432 Your argument makes no sense! why would Bukhari follow or respect hadiths that he considered to be forgeries? How can you even say that Bukhari's hadiths are "authentic without a shadow of doubt?" The only Book that is authentic without a shadow of doubt is the Quran! Allah says,"Shall I then seek a judge other than Allah ? When it is He who has revealed the Book to you fully detailed?" (The Quran, :114). To attribute infallibility to anyone other than Allah is shirk!
@@ahmedakhan1 my brother what is Quran if not the collection of hadiths. Men collected those hadiths when they heard it from Prophet Muhammad (S.A.W). It is evidently your Iman that makes you believe in the infallibility of the Quran. Otherwise Quran was preserved the same way Hadiths are. The only difference is Quran was learned by thousands of people by heart and hadiths by hundreds only.
@@ammarahmed6432 You seem to suggest that there is not much difference between the Quran and hadith, but I suggest the following: 1. The Quran was compiled into its present form within a few years after the Prophet's death under the authority of Khalifa Uthman (the third of the rightly guided khalifa) and under the surpervision of Zayd bin Thabit, the Prophet's scribe. At that time most of the people, closest to the Prophet and very familiar with the Quran, such as Ayesha and Ali and others were still alive. The first sahih collection of hadiths were compiled by Imam Bukhari, some 200 years after the Prophet's death, when over 600,000 hadiths were in existence of which he rejected 99 percent as inauthentic. 2. Recent scientific evidence exists to show that fragments of the Quran from late 7th century CE, are similar to the current Quran.No such evidence exists for hadiths. 3. Allah has guaranteed the authenticity of the Quran. No such guarantee exists for hadiths. Finally the essence of the Islamic faith is belief in one God, that Muhammed is His messenger and that the Quran is the Word of God. No such belief is required for hadiths!
@@ahmedakhan1 bro...
I agreed with the fact that there are plenty of fabrications inside hadith books. But that doesn't mean all hadiths are fabricated.
Even without hadith we can do Salah, do Hajj, and Give Zakah.
As it was non stop Daily activity it was continually preserved from time of our prophet from generation to generation.
Even if these things was not written in hadiths . it will not be lost in any generation.becoz it was follow up by all ummah one after other generations.
I am not rejector of any hadiths. Offcourse there are some fabrications in hadith books. But don't reject whole hadiths. if any hadith contradict with Quran throw that to garbage bin.
First Go to Quran for Knowledge, then to hadith to gain more knowledge. If there blatant illogical thing , Contradictory with quran or mocking our Rasool throw that hadith to garbage bin.
I advice you to See lectures of Sheik imran Hosein, Shabir Ally, Sheik Baloch, Yasir Qadhi, etc to gain knowledge.
There is one Channel called believer. Go through it . Many of your doubts regarding hadith will be cleared.
Do your research and don't accept any scholars word until you convinced.
And I googled Dr.X
Didn’t your Hadith writers reject Hadith when they were burning and erasing them ?
Who thinks That scholar is Shabir ally
I think so, but im very inclined to shabir ally’s views. Hes an absolute forward thinking legend with a sea of knowledge
Does anybody has any idea who is Dc.X
Edip Yuksel i think
@@lilbaigs5003 oh he is a great guy
Redefine the sunnah in his own way. What does that even mean?
Wauw someone who is critical of a man made construct like the preservation of Hadith is now an innovator?
He moves around very much.
Who is he talking about?
People who believe only in the Holy Qur'an and not in the rulings of our prophet Muhammad piece be upon him. While Allah commanded us in the Holy Qur'an to obey the commands of our prophet.
billu barber 420
Yes he is talking about me, I’m a Quran only Muslim and I’m very proud to follow Allah and not those fabricated Hadiths written by humans 200 years after the prophets death, they still haven’t found any original Hadiths written by the prophets companions but people have found pages from the Quran dating back to the prophets time www.aljazeera.com/news/2015/07/world-oldest-quran-manuscripts-uk-150722110034399.html, so you go figure it out? Quran always wins!
Kamal AL-Hinai
Do you think being sunni is following Allah?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39.28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Stop listening to fabricated stories and start reading Quran, then you will understand what Islam is about!
@@lolyou6676
you follow the Holy-Qur'an yes?
Then follow this verse:
{وَمَا آتَاكُمُ الرَّسُولُ فَخُذُوهُ وَمَا نَهَاكُمْ عَنْهُ فَانتَهُوا ۚ وَاتَّقُوا اللَّهَ ۖ إِنَّ اللَّهَ شَدِيدُ الْعِقَابِ}
And whatever the Messenger has given you - take; and what he has forbidden you - refrain from. And fear Allah ; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty.
59:7 part of the 7th verse of surat Al-Hashr
@@Kamal_AL-Hinai read the context of the verse, it is explicitly talking about material things.
Well, the 19 thing is weird I give you that but why do they have to accept Buhari or Muslim? Shia's don't. I heard some Quranist and the only thing they say is that they don't find hadith books reliable. At least, they don't make up their own hadiths like Shia. How is this worse than Shia? So they do certain things differently. It's their problem. What's the big deal?
Since when are shia (twelver for example) muslim?
chuck
Do you think being sunni is following Allah?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39.28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Stop listening to fabricated stories and start reading Quran, then you will understand what Islam is about!
YTSince2006
Do you think being sunni is following Allah?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39.28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Stop listening to fabricated stories and start reading Quran, then you will understand what Islam is about!
Moneyxl00
Do you think being sunni is following Allah?
Quran is clear 12:1
Easy to understand 44:58
No ambiguity 39.28
No sects in Islam 6:159
Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
Stop listening to fabricated stories and start reading Quran, then you will understand what Islam is about!
@Moneyxl00 According to you! So now you have given yourself the authority to judge who is a Muslim and who is not! I believe Allah is the only true judge and to put yourself in that position is shirk!
Sunnah has not been preserved so why does it fall under bidah? Who decides this
During his life, Did prophet Muhammad PBUH act as a political leader? A prophet? A messenger? A combination of them? How to distinguish between the source of his actions?
When he made a political decision on a crime incident, was the punishment he implemented timeless? Or it was valid only given the time and geographical parameters?
“people will reject hadit at the end time”
kindly give me thr reference. i need the reference
Aslam al-Qibti reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Let me not find one of you reclining on his couch, when a command or prohibition of mine comes to him and he says: I do not know, we only follow what we find in the Book of Allah.”
Source: Sunan al-Tirmidhī 2663
Grade: Sahih (authentic) according to Al-Albani
Narrated Al-Miqdam bin Ma'dikarib:
that the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) said: "Lo! Soon a Hadith from me will be conveyed to a man, while he is reclining on his couch, and he says: 'Between us and you is Allah's Book. So whatever we find in it that is lawful, we consider lawful, and whatever we find in it that is unlawful, we consider it unlawful.' Indeed whatever the Messenger of Allah (ﷺ) made unlawful, it is the same as what Allah made unlawful."
Jami` at-Tirmidhi 2664
Grade : Hasan (Darussalam)
@@ahmedc3227 Al-Albani was human and subject to making errors!
@@ahmedc3227 I paraphrase Abubaker who said upon the death of the Prophet: "Those who worship Mohammed, Mohammed is dead. Those who worship Allah, Allah lives!" Much as we respect and love Mohammed, Mohammed was a Prophet, he cannot be compared to Allah. That would indeed be shirk! Allah says, "Shall I then seek a judge other than Allah? When it is He who has revealed the Book to you fully detailed?" (The Quran, 6:114). So is the Book of Hadiths to have the same authority as the Quran? In another place Allah says, "These are Allah's revelations (Quran) that we recite to you truthfully. In which Hadith other than Allah and His revelations do they beleve?" (The Quran, 45:6).
@@ahmedakhan1 Please just ask Allah for guidance. It will solve everything in sha Allah.
Dr X after watching this video
So why your beard not so long as sahi hadis.... u follow sunnah?
Is Dr X Ghamidi?
Dr. Shabir Ally
@@sheriefelsayad5578 Dr. Shabir Aly is not a Hadeeth rejector
@@mdrasid007 he rejects many authentic ahadith
@@sheriefelsayad5578 i never heard about
so questions are why people are rejecting hadith? we know that the prophet spoke , it is because of our scholar , lots of them used to give fatwa , invent hadith and add a chain of sahih chain and throw it to the public , at the time of Banu Umayyah , our Scholar propagated the wring throughout centuries , now people believe more in hadith that the Quran , some shcolar even take hadith and aborgate Quranic verses , on the day of judgement we shall see them.
The female who lead prayer in Kerala has later became an atheist and announced explicitly. At present, she is trying to get popular by abusing Allah and his messenger.
I come from the place which shares border with Kerala. I haven't heard about this lady. When did this happen?
@@secondary317 better not to hear about her. It's useless
@@jumbojet5496 Ok brother.
@@secondary317 ok 😊
It is important to know a few basic things about hadith before claiming these hearsays to be the word of prophet and branding their rejection as biddah. The sunni scholars reject shiit hadith and viceversa. Bukhari himself rejected 99% of the hadith he collected and retained only 1%. Now the scholars misguide us by making us believe that these hadith are the undoubted words of the prophet. Here is what Allah tells us in unambiguous words:
[Quran 45:6] These are God's revelations that we recite to you truthfully. In which hadith other than God and His revelations do they believe?
In response to the above verse our sunni ulema present six hadith books and the shiits ulema present 4 authentic hadith books. Haven´t they made a mockery of Islam ?
Hadith are mere hearsay. It is something like A heard from B who heard from C who heard from D....who heard from G who claimed that the prophet said / did so and so. In modern terminology this is called Chinese Whisper, which has no credibility in preserving information. Try circulating a paragraph of text through a chain of 10 narrators and verify for yourself.
A hadith shouldn't be confused with the statements or actions of the prophet. Those who claim hadith to be the words or actions of the prophet run high risk of attributing falsehood to the prophet no matter how nice they sound or appear.
Any hadith is actually an alleged saying attributed to the prophet and propagated through a chain of 7- 8 narrators over 200 years or more. What we have (for eg. in Bukhari
collection) are 7000+ hadith categorized by Bukhari (not by Allah or the prophet) as authentic from a total collection of 700,000 hadith circulating at his time.
The methodology that was used to authenticate hadith is called "Sound chain of narration". In this, the character, sincerity and mental health etc. of narrators in a particular chain was evaluated by hadith compilers several decades / centuries after the narrators had died. This act of character evaluation involved backbiting and slandering which is considered a sin in Islam according to the Quran. The organized slandering and backbiting was conducted at an unprecedented scale in human history. In Quran, Allah tells us that there were hypocrites among the sahaba and the prophet had no idea about them. Ironically, in one hadith prophet is alleged to have said that on the day of judgment some of his companions will be take away from him and Allah will inform about their bad deeds. It is interesting how hadith collectors could evaluate the characters of those narrators who were dead long back and even prophet himself was not aware of their character.
The most authentic collections of Bukhari and Muslim do not match 100% because of personal biases and judgment. These two major collections are rejected by the Shiits sect of Islam as unreliable. Thus is can be said that belief in a certain set of hadith automatically divides the Muslim ummah into at least two distinct sects: Sunni and Shiits. Such sectarian divide is strictly prohibited by Allah.
There is a consensus that there is not a single hadith in the entire collection which can be considered a verbatim quotation from the prophet.
Just like majority of Jewish, Christian, Hindu scholars can be wrong about the basic of religious beliefs it should not come as a surprise that the majority of Muslim scholars are also wrong. In fact, Quran criticizes those people who follow scholars, ulema blindly and take them as Gods.
One can find story tales, blasphemy of the highest order, contradictions, unscientic and illogical stus attributed to the prophet. In fact one can use hadith to project the prophet with diametrically extreme and opposite personality characterwise. Most of the abuse that the enemies of Islam hurl upon our prophet has some basis in these hadith collections.
Although, the clergymen and hadith followers claim that they let Quran superseded hadith, there are numerous occasions where the verse from the Quran are abrogated by hadith despite a command from Allah that none (including the prophets) can abrogate his verses.
The true reason of your hadith rejection lies in the last paragraph. " the abuses hurled at islam from non muslims" You are tired of being apologetic about our prophet's polygamy, the way muslims dress, the salah and the general differences of a muslim lifestyle that come only from hadith and sunnah. So you created a whole lifestyle of an apologist to conform better in a western society. Accept this apologist approach that you have created to placate your conscience and cherry pick your deen. Do not go around trying to propagate this as the right way.
@@samster6502 Dear Sameeya, I havec ompiled the verses from QUran taht asks for a categorical rejection of hadith. YOu can also find many blasphemous hadeeth abusing prophets, their wives and even Allah. YOu can download the document from the link. Be honest in your evaluation.
www.dropbox.com/s/ns37vysfjg1q20i/main.pdf?dl=0
It is only your interpretation of the ayah that uses the word in the quran to mean what the prophet saw said. I do not see it that way. I wonder how much better a human being you are by rejecting the prohet's way. May your "enlightenment" serve you well in this duniya and hereafter. Salaam
Dear Sister,
Use your own wisdom to understand Quran.
Ask these questions:
1. Do you become a better human being by beleiving in the hadith of the prophet considered authentic by the sunni sect or also by the shiit sect ? Let me know then I will show you blasphemies in your chosen books.
2. Why can not you become a good human being by following Allah's word ? Do you doubt Allah when He says only He will guide you when you seek guidance.
2. Have you read all the 35000 of the "authentic" hadith of the sunnis ? I just read Bukhari and Muslim and found highly blasphemous, contradictory, illogical and proven unscientific stuffs. If you have not read them then I wonder how you claim to be beliving in these hadith. Only an ignorant can believe in things he has not even read. Allah prohibits us from believing in things we have no sure knowledge of.
I accept only those saying of the prophets which are approved by Allah and therefore 100% authentic. These sayings / hadith of the prophets are in the Quran itself. Do you know that Bukhari never took any narrations from 600 of the narrators considered authentic by Muslim. And Muslim rejected 400 of the narrators of Sahih Bukhari. These hadith collectors had contradicting methodologies. It is insulting Allah to say that you use their flawed collections to explain Allah's word.
Quran 45:6 These are the verses of Allah which We recite to you in truth. Then in what HADITH after Allah and His verses will they believe?
And here is an authentic hadith of the prophet narrated in the Qurna by Allah
Quran 25:30 ’And the Messenger will say: “O my Lord! Verily, my people deserted this Qur’an.”
Notice that the prophet is not going to complain about his ummah deserting Bukhari and Muslim hadith. The above two verses are in perfect agreement. I think you did not get the link that I posted here. If you send me an email then I can send you a document that I prepared for my own reflection on Quran. I can share it with you and we will see how you deal with the irrefutable arguments.
@@samster6502 it is not about being apologetic. But about seeking the truth. Sometimes westerners are pointing on things that are false in sunni islam and they are correct in it. For example, can you explain how come that according to hadith our prophet commanded to stone someone to death for adultery when Quran clearly states that punishment for adultery is 100 lashes.
REPLY TO SHAMSI
Typical Indian / Pakistani ulema blame Javed Ghamidi. He wants to look for authenticity before passing on or following.
Enmass rejection of all the sahih hadith amounts to disobeying the prophet pbuh because all the sahih hadith can't be wrong or even of suspicious authenticity.
Accepting hadith you are disobeying Allah because Allah told you in Qur'an that it is CLEAR, COMPLETE AND PERFECTED and a guidance to all.
@@t1000v20quran also says " He is the One Who raised for the illiterate ˹people˺ a messenger from among themselves-reciting to them His revelations, purifying them, and teaching them the Book and wisdom, for indeed they had previously been clearly astray"
KEYWORD *TEACHING* them the book and wisdom. Which can be found nowhere else apart from the teachings of the prophet s.a.w.
too bad the brothers who are refuting your Judgement day signs series wont take your advice.
th-cam.com/video/EloWrUEzapA/w-d-xo.html this will clear your confusion, thank me later.
With all due respect u have taken half of the time to just justify urself that u didn’t taken the name its too much
That was also a message to be conveyed
There's no a Quran alone follower
Which denies the sunnah, wake up,
We just deny your Ahadith & mullas,
While sunnah is in Quran we follow.
The strawman of "sunnah rejection"
Comes from the sunnis themselves,
As we define sunnah by Quran alone
While sunnis follow corrupted Arabic,
So some may say "I reject the sunnah"
Which may mean their sunni Hadiths,
The context of speech matters here,
But no Quraniy meant the Prophet.
I'm not here defending Rashad Kh.
Or others like him who deviated,
And instead followed Ahadith,
They're not the true Quranis.
I follow the first Quraniy
Our Prophet Muhammad,
He's the first Quran aloner,
And his companions also
Forbade writing Ahadith
In Rashidun Khaliphate.
So by your own definition,
We're not the disbelievers,
And rather you're the ones
Who're the disbelievers here,
Denying Quran having sunnah
Which just means other Hadiths
Are useless & abrogated by Quran,
And following sunnah of other books
Makes them abandon Quranic sunnah,
Which means sunnis are Quran rejectors
And Sunnah and best Hadith rejectors
As Quran itself is the best Hadith.
The problem with Hadiths and the Sunnah is that it is full of contradictions, even after Bukhari discarded 99% of Hadiths. In essence we are relying on his judgement as to what is correct and what is not and even what is left so full of inaccuracies.
Saif - you are wrong. The earlier generations of imam clearly mentioned which are weak fabricated and daef . Now in today’s world people have started to hear their own molvis and try to follow their own fiqh and forgotten the salafs . If you are from Ind or Pak then you are in this problem . There are many modern XYZ people who give the interpretation by thier own desires . So you need to stick to the people who follow salafs . Not the books which are written a 100 yr ago without any chain of narration .
You can look up references for the fact that Bukhari rejected 99% plus of Hadiths. Just on matter of namaz, there are so many glaring contradictions among “SAHIH”.
@@NA-nm9ce medium.com/uncorrupted-islam/problematic-hadith-29bff645812c
@@saiflalani6431 - and have you Checked the reason for rejection . ?? This is what is called the science of hadeeth . brother even if 1% of hadeeth are authentic and if you have to adhere to those 1% you would perhaps need a whole lifetime. So try to follow the ones that are authenticated by the imams and scholars of old and follow them .Insha Allah you would not be holding any burden on yourself and Allah knows best
@@NA-nm9ce @NA I think you could spend your entire lifetime in this maze and not have a clear answer. The Quran stands as the clear word of Allah. 100% accurate. After discarding 99% of hadiths, you can still find contradictions galore in the remaining 1%. Even among the few that we may find ok, we do not know how many were appropriate for that time and how many would apply today. Would you learn anything from any source that has 99% inaccurate stuff? I would not.
Muslims reject the Old and New testaments because theya re not 100% accurate word of God, and then we go into a system that we know has so much incorrect stuff.
Very good explanation but did not the hadith collector did character assassination of thousands of narrators, prophets and their wives in his what is referred to as the "authentic collection" ?
[Quran 45:6] These are God's revelations that we recite to you truthfully. In which hadith OTHER THAN God and His revelations do they believe?
Aren´t the sectarian hadith of sunni and shiits "other than God and His revealation" ?
First RESPECT.
I'm working on video and I will add you in Facebook to clarify my evidence why I don't believe Hadith's. But my question is what is real Sunnah or System, call it how do you like. And I believe you will be to the first who will get the video.
And I ask for Understanding.
Respect for all Muslim's doesn't matter background from where they are coming.
Thank you.
Logo Shop some hadiths May not be authentic but how do you live Islam without it. How do you explain the Quran?
Logo Shop Mohammed pbuh recited the Qur'an to his companion and the Hadiths, if you are refusing the Hadiths you are refusing also the Qur'an because both knowledge came from the same person. 😊💚
@@zeezeebo Very Easy.
Respect Qur'an and Love God.
The Qur'an describes Life with 2 words.
Game and happiness.
Peace.
@@lailawardak2395 First Respect.
Because you are Female I believe, I will tell you 2 Hadith's now about Women's.
Sahih Bukhari 76/53 "Bad OMEN is in the Woman, the Horse and the Home.
Again Sahih Bukhari; Abu Bakara said messenger of God said; " Any community whose Leader is a Woman will never SUCCED ".
Can you believe this because I simply can't.
But I will tell you one more just to understand what I wanna say better.
Narated by Omran Ibn Hussein said Prophet said; " I looked at Heaven and found that majority of its dwellers are poor, and looked at Hell and found the majority of its dwellers are WOMEN ".
Once more Respect.
Thank you.
@@logoshop3580 even if you reject these narrations, it does not mean that you reject all of them. Now there is always a story for those two narrations. Did you research?
Sahih Bukhari has aided in destroying Islam
I reject hadis
May Allah guide you
*The whole argument of Hadith rejectors can be simply destroyed reason why Hadith is revelation can be proven by prophecies which even they cannot deny nice try!*
Iron Man *wait wait wait the verse doesn’t say Quran is the only wahi so nice try ha! You fool like I said your argument can be easily destroyed because of the prophecies that even you cannot deny which prove Hadith is revelation there’s many prophecies you fools pick and choose unclear verses I never mentioned setting up partners with Allah so nice try!!!!*
Iron Man *um none of those verses oppose sunnah being revelation can u try a little harder I’ll show you many prophecies that even disbelievers don’t deny they may not accept but don’t deny you have no legs to stand on!!!*
You say the majority are correct in Islam and the minority are lost? What happened to the people of Lut? the majority didn’t listen and the minority wins!. We are in a situation where you are Goliath (sunni) and we are David (Quran only Muslim) and i wonder who will win? Is it Sunni’s with their fabricated stories about the prophet or Quran only Muslim’s with their Authentic Quran from Allah?
There’s nothing wrong in being a Quran only Muslim, we follow the book of Allah because it’s the only authentic book on this planet, all other books are problematic. How can you read Hadiths and trust them after so many people have rewritten Hadiths over time and changed the story? Hadiths have been added and changed and it’s a fact!, so many scholars are saying that yes there is problematic Hadiths and they need to be filtered out. Sorry but I’m not convinced into following Hadiths narrated by ordinary people saying things about the prophet that are not true. The only way I’ll believe you is if you find me one verse from the Quran that says we have to read Hadiths narrated by people/scholars? Because Quran comes first in everything you need to prove it from the Quran! And with out Quran there’s no Islam and that’s a fact.
1. Quran is clear 12:1
2. Quran is easy to understand 44:58
3. No ambiguity 39:28
4. No sects in Islam 6:159
5. Sects = mushrikeen 30:31-32
You sunni people really need to focus more on the Quran and less on fabricated Hadiths!
Because soon you will say Hadiths come first not the Quran.
I agree with you fully.
All praise belongs to God, The Most-High
Iron Man Agreed
Good point. The are following the Quran only on words in reality 90 % of their beliefs, rituals and agenda comes from hadith book. They don’t need Quran and they are deaf to its message.
@@ruslanali928
Are you a Quran alone believer?
@@lolyou6676 yes , I am
Mr Yasir Qadhi… Anyone one states that I do not follow Hadith does not make them out of the fold of Islam. The Quran states follow the messenger to obey God. So you follow the Messenger with Qurans message not the 250 years old handwritten quotes made up on behalf of the Prophet - where one even mentions on Behalf of the Prophet of saying 'do not write any Hadiths from me'. Hadith is A BIG PROBLEM IN ISLAM and its a Misrepresentation of the Religion - Anyone who Cannot understands what Salah means or what are forbidden and not allowed need to Learn Qurans Arabic Language and not go to Intrepretation on Hadith Literature.
Did you even listen to the video?
Your great imams bukhari, abu dawood ibnu hanbal etc NEVER MET the Prophet their WHOLE LIVES!! The Prophet was UNAWARE of books you are upholding today! Such horrible lies against him.
Hadith made 99% of Muslims lost
With due respect he is wrong Islam is passed on to us by prophet sunnah not hadith by scholars who came way long after 80 years
Plus imam bukhari too rejected thousands of hadith as to say he collected most reliable as per his understanding
I'm confused. Are you suggesting hadith doesn't represent sunnah?
@@PaperGlazed
Yes sunnah is different and hadith Is different thing if I want can explain in 2 mins so you will never make a mistake inbox your no and country you from
@@PaperGlazed
th-cam.com/video/vSfQzRQOFQs/w-d-xo.html
You are all confused lol. When in confusion, consult Qur'an. Qur'an brings clarity, hadith brings ambiguity, sectarianism, hate within the umnah, the only hadith brought to the people was the Qur'an through the prophet. There are no grounds for hadiths to exist alongside the Qur'an. Those who believe it to be from the prophet are wrong and in serious error.
12:111 There was certainly in their stories a lesson for those of understanding. Never was the Qur'an a narration invented, but a confirmation of what was before it and a DETAILED EXPLANATION OF ALL THINGS AND GUIDANCE AND MERCY FOR A PEOPLE WHO BELIEVE
16:89 And [mention] the Day when We will resurrect among every nation a witness over them from themselves. And We will bring you, [O Muhammad], as a witness over your nation. And We have sent down to you the Book as clarification for ALL THINGS and as GUIDANCE and mercy and good tidings for the Muslims.
6:114 [Say], "Then is it other than Allah I should seek as judge while it is He who has revealed to you the Book EXPLAINED IN DETAIL?" And those to whom We [previously] gave the Scripture know that it is sent down from your Lord in truth, so never be among the doubters.
12:1 Alif, Lam, Ra. These are the verses of the CLEAR BOOK
11:1 Alif, Lam, Ra. [This is] a Book whose verses are PERFECTED and then presented in DETAIL from [one who is] Wise and Acquainted.
6:115 And the word of your Lord has been fulfilled in truth and in justice. None can alter His words, and He is the Hearing, the Knowing.
In conclusion the Qur'an stands alone, why? Because Allah has told us such through the prophet, the only hadith is Qur'an, the only Sunnah is the Sunnah of Allah. The Prophet had no grounds to teach anything other than what was revealed to him and what was revealed to him is COMPLETELY, TRUTHFULLY, and CLEARLY in Qur'an. The Prophet was even warned not to teach anything outside of revelation.
69:43 [It is] a revelation from the Lord of the worlds
69:44 And if Muhammad had made up about Us some [false] sayings
69:45 We would have seized him by the right hand;
69:46 Then We would have cut from him the aorta.
69:47 And there is no one of you who could prevent [Us] from him.
69:48 And indeed, the Qur'an is a reminder for the righteous.
69:49 And indeed, We know that among you are deniers.
69:50 And indeed, it will be [a cause of] regret upon the disbelievers.
69:51 And indeed, it is the TRUTH OF CERTAINTY.
69:52 So exalt the name of your Lord, the Most Great.
So when Hadithists claim the prophet received revelation that is outside of Qur'an, that is a massive contradiction of these verses because if we go back to the previous verses I have put up, Allah is telling us the Qur'an is COMPLETE, FULLY DETAILED and CLEAR. The prophet cannot bring anything other than what was revealed to him. If you disagree with these verses in order to claim the hadith is needed, then you are in error.
Here is the conundrum for Hadith followers, if you accept the Qur'an is fully detailed, complete and clear like Allah says it is, then there is ZERO validation for Hadith to exist as a source of Islamic law and guidance. If you don't accept these verses and what Allah has told you (Through the prophet) then you are calling Allah a liar and incompetent because he says the book is complete yet left things out. So to the hadith advocates, what is your position?
@@t1000v20 Subhanallah. Sadly the Quran has been relegated to a book below Hadith. How can Man explain Allahs words? One ray of hope is here www.reuters.com/article/us-saudi-islam/saudi-arabia-to-vet-use-of-prophets-sayings-to-counter-extremism-idUSKBN1CN1SZ