@@Iggyslime8910 I mean that wen you change a character (like he did) and make him so different from the original it’s no longer that character Imagine you change Thomas to an E2 to a saddle tank it’s no longer Thomas
0:30 I can't help but imagine that, at the end of your SR adaptation concept when Henry and Bear are heading to the works, Henry compliments him for refusing to give up and Bear responds"It's just like I said: anything steam engines can do, diesels can do!' with a warm smile. That would be such a sweet moment
I mean you chance so much with these characters that you might as well make brand new ones. Not to be rude i just dont understand the deal with chance a characters bases instead of making a new one.
I'd like to see how you'd approach Daisy next; her low bufferbeams on her model are very distracting. Also, if you ever get to Barry at some point, since he was revealed to be an LMS 2MT like Arthur, will the two characters end up being combined or be separate characters entirely? And since Bear is No. 16 in your headcanon, does that mean Barry/Arthur becomes No. 14 or 15, or will those two numbers go to other characters (i.e. Derek, Rosie or Rebecca)?
@Iggyslime8910 I think them not doing Bear is for the best, they didn't have the resources to make him and I'm fine with them not using any other RWS engines.
It’s funny how people are complaining how “this isn’t even bear” when the books did little to nothing with this character and the show outright didn’t include him, ironically this persons given bear more story then the books ever did.
Rolling stock characters ie. Annie, Clarabelle, and Rolly (or whatever your version of the special coach). but I can also see your version of Henrietta, S.C. Ruffy, Toad, and the other rolling stock characters.
If I’m going to be honest, I don’t think I mind bear as a br 22. The br 22 is still a hydraulic diesel like the hymexs which keeps the variation of diesels the nwr has. I still prefer the 35 over the 22 but it’s a cool headcannon
I just discovered this channel and the edits. I think some of them are really cool. My only issue with them is why do you have to make the face the same color as the body or a different color. It’s so bizarre and does not work in the same style as Thomas. I completely understand if you like that. I understand if you like it but it does not feel like Thomas. No offense but it feels more like Chuggington. Other than that I kind of like the different classes that you picked for the engines. Good work overall.
I’m curious. What information exactly inspired you to change Bear’s basis? Did you find a story or a detail about the Class 22s in that book which inspired you to make bear into that engine? You were a bit vague as to what specific info influenced your decision. Btw I like this edit.
Pretty much. This happens all the time. I crack open a book looking for anecdotes and nuggets of information that can help me avoid mistakes, but some morsel I come across makes me think "Okay, wait... I guess I'm gonna Homeward Bound a character."
Frankly, I like this interpretation of Bear. Its super different and honestly pretty banger. People don't understand what an AU or interpretation IS lmao
The fact of the matter is that this simply isn't Bear anymore. Not only does he not look like him but has also scrapped his personality and original story as well.
Nice one. I enjoy this little series. I honestly want to see Cranky the crane. Not sure if anyone’s done a different take on him yet. Unless you count the Golden Bear Cranky.
In my opinion I think having faces not covering the whole front just works just so the crew could place lamps and head codes onto them without their face in the way.
You changed so much of Bear, that it's no longer Bear at all.
Yea your right I would not change anything about bear
A new diesel
Word
I mean bear didn't really have much but I do understand what your getting at
@@Iggyslime8910 I mean that wen you change a character (like he did) and make him so different from the original it’s no longer that character
Imagine you change Thomas to an E2 to a saddle tank it’s no longer Thomas
“Trying to Do Things Better” works oddly well as Bear’s theme.
Yeah that’s very odd
I think the faces of the horrid lorries have a much closer shape than stanley's face does though, but stanley's face works well too
The thing is... I'd retain the Lorries.
And Max and Monty, too.
that’s not bear.
That’s salmon
bro this is lion 💀💀
This is panda
nahhhh that's elephant @@Sudriantank743
Naaaaah that's Will smith fish
That’s an OC
Interesting take on Bear. Next character: Maybe a post season 5 character you like.
Whats wrong with bear being a class 35? He doesn't need to be a warship
He’s not even bear anymore.
He’s now an entirely different character
That's not bear, thats deer
(get it, cuz like.. a bear is a animal and a deer is also a animal)
I can't wait for you to make Mavis a BR standard 9F and renamed Douglas into Denise
Well this comment didn't age well
**LOUD INCORRECT BUZZER**
0:30 I can't help but imagine that, at the end of your SR adaptation concept when Henry and Bear are heading to the works, Henry compliments him for refusing to give up and Bear responds"It's just like I said: anything steam engines can do, diesels can do!' with a warm smile. That would be such a sweet moment
I mean you chance so much with these characters that you might as well make brand new ones. Not to be rude i just dont understand the deal with chance a characters bases instead of making a new one.
While I think most of them are interesting this one seems to different
now that we’ve seen BoCo and Bear, I’d love to see your take on Daisy
I'd like to see how you'd approach Daisy next; her low bufferbeams on her model are very distracting.
Also, if you ever get to Barry at some point, since he was revealed to be an LMS 2MT like Arthur, will the two characters end up being combined or be separate characters entirely? And since Bear is No. 16 in your headcanon, does that mean Barry/Arthur becomes No. 14 or 15, or will those two numbers go to other characters (i.e. Derek, Rosie or Rebecca)?
There is not another tank type for Arthur to not be any of the ones he's already done
I think
Thats not bear
That's a cringe fanfic of him
Well I think it's better than what the show did with him, witch is nothing, just my opinion
@Iggyslime8910 I think them not doing Bear is for the best, they didn't have the resources to make him and I'm fine with them not using any other RWS engines.
I'd love to see your take on Murdoch
I hate to say it, but this ain’t Bear anymore. You’ve basically created an OC..
I mean, almost everyone got a new basis
True
It’s funny how people are complaining how “this isn’t even bear” when the books did little to nothing with this character and the show outright didn’t include him, ironically this persons given bear more story then the books ever did.
Since your still shying away from Douglas I’d say do either Daisy or even The Works Diesel next. Perhaps even the narrow gauge engines
Rolling stock characters ie. Annie, Clarabelle, and Rolly (or whatever your version of the special coach). but I can also see your version of Henrietta, S.C. Ruffy, Toad, and the other rolling stock characters.
Well, since you've covered Diesel and BoCo, and now Bear, how about Mavis or Daisy?
How about you do a TVS only character like Arthur, or Molly!
Yesyesyesyyeysyeysyyeysyeysye
If I’m going to be honest, I don’t think I mind bear as a br 22. The br 22 is still a hydraulic diesel like the hymexs which keeps the variation of diesels the nwr has. I still prefer the 35 over the 22 but it’s a cool headcannon
If bear still has communication doors
Then does that mean his face just splits apart?
*oh god*
Fnaf sister location be like:
@@the_birb23 five nights at Thomas' diesel location
your ideal hector please thank you "__"
Maybe ideal daisy next?
That not Bear, that Panda
0:59 “When boco was rebuilt with his power bogeys switched around his communication doors were removed as well” How?
With craftsmanship.
If not the doors themselves, then the telescoping gangways were removed.
*by removing the face*
@@johnathonmcjohn3 Bear: say what now
That's not bear, you made a new character.
Ideal daisy would be insane
Pretty nice Ideal Bear. Since we're on a 2 streak of Diesel Engines, I would love to see your Ideal Daisy next.
Murdoch please
Do your favourite Post-S5 character!
Just say it’s an OC 😂
Can you make Murdoch? It would be so cool to see your take on the character
That's not Bear
That's Bfire
I just discovered this channel and the edits. I think some of them are really cool. My only issue with them is why do you have to make the face the same color as the body or a different color. It’s so bizarre and does not work in the same style as Thomas. I completely understand if you like that. I understand if you like it but it does not feel like Thomas. No offense but it feels more like Chuggington. Other than that I kind of like the different classes that you picked for the engines. Good work overall.
When the video starting it thought you were rapping
Question if Oliver is number 13 and bear is 16 who's 14 and 15 I'm guessing mildred and eunice
Im interested in seeing Daisy next, or if you make a tvs character, maybe Derek or Arthur
I’m curious. What information exactly inspired you to change Bear’s basis? Did you find a story or a detail about the Class 22s in that book which inspired you to make bear into that engine? You were a bit vague as to what specific info influenced your decision. Btw I like this edit.
Pretty much. This happens all the time. I crack open a book looking for anecdotes and nuggets of information that can help me avoid mistakes, but some morsel I come across makes me think "Okay, wait... I guess I'm gonna Homeward Bound a character."
Daisy next!
Frankly, I like this interpretation of Bear. Its super different and honestly pretty banger. People don't understand what an AU or interpretation IS lmao
The fact of the matter is that this simply isn't Bear anymore. Not only does he not look like him but has also scrapped his personality and original story as well.
After you do Douglas pllllssss do emily 🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺🥺
How about bill and Ben?
I would love to see mavis.
Ah yes, my ideal grizzly
Cuz this ain’t no bear
Maybe Bill and Ben could be wing tank locomotives
do emily next
Very Interesting Take.
What Would Your Version Of Derek Be?
How about Arthur?
Honestly don’t listen to this people this is sweet!
I have an idea, what if you explain your ideal timeline, like, if Boco is number 12 and Oliver is number 13 then who is Number 11, 14 and 15
Daisy is n.o 11. I don't know about 14 and 15
Can you do Arthur
💀I like this series but THAT AIN'T BEAR!
not too sure about u but that is not bear.
Can you do an ideal Class 40
Please do douglas next!!!
you killed him 😭
Be different and do Billy
Nice one. I enjoy this little series. I honestly want to see Cranky the crane. Not sure if anyone’s done a different take on him yet. Unless you count the Golden Bear Cranky.
You did Bear dirty.....
Arthur or even one of the background engines like 98462 or 87546 would be nice to see
id turn bear to a br class 52
Bill and ben
Ehh... a bit of a stretch, but I can see it. I can also see we're getting more NWR engines. Barry perhaps?
Arthur
make Emily, Arry/Bert, Arthur or D O U G L A S
OK, I kinda want to see who's number 14 on your roster. 15 too.
Can You Do Arthur And Barry Together In Your Next Ideal Video By Merging The Two In One Character
In my opinion I think having faces not covering the whole front just works just so the crew could place lamps and head codes onto them without their face in the way.
I lowkey think that Boco with a Co Co wheel configuration would be good but since he’s a Co Bo with Un mismatched power bogies
That’s not bear
I wonder who's the Number 14 and 15. Mavis? Bill And Ben? Derek? An Original Character? I guess I'll just have to wait and see... Great Job as always!
Daisy.
What music is this? I mean the name not the creator of the music i already knew it
This is an instrumental of "Trying to Do Things Better", composed by Ed Welch.
@@williamb.298 thanks
I think daisy, salty or Emily whould work
Roly
Yo on my Birthday too. This is perfect. I love this version of Bear not bad.
Jinty and pug! They’d be neat to see.
Nice video. What diesel are you planning on doing next?
Ideal Emily if not diesle ten
I’d like to see diesel 10
I wonder how his ideal of Diesel 10 is going to be like
His claw would probably be the first thing to go
How about your ideal Daisy?
How about Daisy? or Emily?
Is that an AI voice?
No
Do smugger
Murdoch please!
Can You do skaloy
Could u send me a link to ur second channel it’s seems I can’t find it anymore
Look in the description.
So at this point, is it still even Bear?
How would Cranky look like?
Ideal Billy please
I'd like to see Murdoch
Do class 40 next
Do Douglas next
Salty
Bar