There is a judgment that is agreed upon by all the scholars of Usool: Leaving out a matter does not prove its forbiddance. If the Prophet left out a matter, peace be upon him, that is not in itself evidence to deem something forbidden. And of course using the fact that it was not done by the Salaf, is not sufficient evidence to deem it forbidden.
If the 1st Three Generations didn't Practice nor acknowledge it, only for a couple of Hundreds of Years later The Fatimids from Egypt Began to practice it is Substantial Evidence enough for you to stay away from it and not practice it.
Alhamdulillah.. sooo happy sooo happy to see these comments from brothers who are sincere to Allah and not follow these random sufi videos. Let's follow the Sunnah and the Salaf in their actions. Allahumma barik.
@razakhan1054 I am surprised that such arguments are still used.. in the 90s we used to hear such statements like "Don't use cars because it's a bid’ah (innovation)" etc. So if I go in a car to a place to give dawah it's not acceptable and is a bidah. One of our Imaam said: "I never won a debate with a jahil."
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
How can we stay muslim if we are jot feeling happy on that day when our beloved prophet Muhammad PBUH born? If you're not feeling glad, think about this that who are not happy with this...
Salafi or wahabis are the one who always tried their best to ignore the muqam and honour of hazrat Mohammad sallallahu alaihi wa sallim as they have bughz ( jealousy) inthier hearts for the prophet pbuh . They celebrate the national day very happily.
So it is a Bidah. You basically said it yourself. And you are taking the qiyas of Ibn Hajar and As-suyuti (may ﷲ ﷻ have mercy on them) rather than taking the strongest opinion and that the salaf did not practice this. Don’t confuse the people. The mawlid was started by the fatimids (Shia) and that is a tradition that is not from us😊
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
@@SherazH1how can it be a Bidah Hasanah when birthdays themselves are haram? Birthdays comes from ancient pagan Egyptians, by celebrating it, you do shirk.
____Reading quran on on your mobile is bidah hasanah, there are many bidah hasanah is our lives today, take the good and leave the bad, but don't criticise if you havent researched in depth and understood
Liar. Salafiees are the only one who are praising him salallahu aleihi ua sallam , correctly and rightful !!!! As Allah told us in Quran, how prophet salallahu aleihi ua sallam told, and how the sahaba used to praise him salallahu aleihi ua sallam!!
Narrated `Umar: I heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "Do not exaggerate in praising me as the Christians praised the son of Mary, for I am only a Slave. So, call me the Slave of Allah and His Apostle." Sahih al-Bukhari 3445
Repent to Allah before it's too late this is a shubuhat that eventually leads many to misguidance may Allah protectt us from this kind of misguidance and may Allah gave us & him hidayah upon tawhid and the sunnah of the prophet ﷺ
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 That is a pathetic argument brother. Celebrating Mawlid annually is considered an act of worship. Nobody says the same for social media. Dawah to Islam is integral part of the Deen. Social media is just one of the tools we have at our disposal.
Nobody ever said you have to celebrate the mawlid as if it was obligatory. It's a perfect analogy. Just like da'wah online is not obligatory and the salaf did not practice this specific form of da'wah yet you still do it, celebrating the mawlid is also not obligatory but we can still do it
The first three generations did not practice it. You mean we live the prophet PBUH MORE THAN US? Let’s teach this beautiful deen as it was revealed. There’s is no good or bad bidaa. KULLU BIDAA FI DHWALALA.
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
@@Yasser-2does every innovation only means worship? If it's so then mawlid isn't worship of Rasoolallah ﷺ (I know the defination of bidah just giving response to the persons statement)
After reading the comments, it is evident that those who hate Mawlud, don't actually know what is Mawlud, or what happens at functions. They've clearly been told funny things.
If you’ve gone to these “mawlid” conventions you see people practicing other than Islam, sisters and brothers mixing, dances and songs, “dhikr and nasheed” that are no different than concerts and placing the messenger ﷺ beyond what ﷲ ﷻ placed him. Do not overpraise or exaggerate the status Muhammad ﷺ as the Christians did to Jesus alayhiasalam. His ﷺ status is already determined by ﷲ ﷻ so why do these people do that which would have displeased him if he ﷺ was alive? He disliked people standing for him. He disliked being over-praised. And he disallowed the people from taking the graves of prophets as places of worship and feared that for his ummah.
@@Moose-wj8sc I have attended them for years and I don't know what dancing and singing you're speaking of. Programmes have always started off with Salah, followed by Surah Yaaseen, Qiraat, Naat-E-Rasool, a Lecture, Du'aa, and Salaat O Salaam - all of which have been approved by valid scholars throughout the centuries. How is his status being exaggerated by commemorating him on the day that he was born? He is literally 2nd in ranking after Allaah(swt). It's not a birthday celebration like the world thinks with cakes and candles. It's an actual Islamic gathering in honor of Nabi (saw). What do they do that displeased him when he was alive? Nobody is worshipping graves buddy. Again my conclusion is the same as before. Dr. Shadee has mentioned in his quote from Allaamaa Hajar that you can take the good from it and discard the bad about it. And what you guys are doing is, you see 1 sect of people doing the wrong things in the name of this act and then you'd determine the entire act as wrong, instead of determining the bad of it as wrong, and keeping the good. The Wahabis on our area do the exact same thing the Sunnis do. They've slowly incorporated it over the years but they do it under "different intention" and that "makes it right". True Sunni Islam has been prevalent for so long and then you get Ulama who's chain of existence is a mere century old, dictating any and every bidah to be wrong. It was all the plan of the British when they took down the Ottoman Empire (by working with the Saudis). They knew without Khilafah, the Muslims would just fall into disarray.
@@1p_edits nah we haven’t been told funny things, we just don’t follow Shia innovations mate. The first 3 generations never ‘knew what mawlid is’ or celebrated it, do you reckon you are more pious than them?? No exactly 👍🏼
@@theemperor477 So it's wrong to have a gathering where Qur'aan, Poetry, & Talks are done in commemoration of our prophet (saw)? Shias are something else, we're referring to Sunni Muslims. And for the "do you reckon you're more pious than them?". Do you reckon you know the Qur'aan, Haddeth, and Sunnah better than the Awliyaah Ikraam, or the Scholars that have dedicated their lives to studying it? Bid'ah is something that has been painted as 1 color. Qur'aan in book form, is a Bid'ah. Diacritical Marks on the Arabic letters of the Qur'aan, is a Bid'ah. New poetry and praises of the Prophet & Sahaabah, are Bid'ah. Qir'aat programs, are a Bid'ah. But are any of these wrong? No. Same goes with spreading Dawah on social media/devices (which actually do have drawbacks tbh), the use of Mics and Speakers in Mosques, or the use of modern transportation. The ruling for any Bid'ah, is that if there's good to it, it's permissible. And if it's wrong, the one who calls it wrong, needs to refute it and prove that it is wrong. Because there will never be a time where no scholars are able to refute something which is wrong. We fear what we do not understand. Courtesy of the Wahaabis and Western world - to keep our knowledge away from us. The lack of actions in the first 3 generations, is not evidence to suggest that such actions cannot be permitted. Even the Sahaabah acknowledged this when the Qur'aan was compiled into book form. Everybody was against the idea until Allaah gave them the guidance to go ahead with it. And no Sahaabah ever used the argument of "Nabi (saw) didn't do this, so we don't do it". Sayyidina Umar (RA) himself told Sayiddina Abu Baker (RA) that they should not look as to whether Nabi (SAW) did the act or not. Instead they should look as to whether a new act has good to it or not before implementing it or discarding it. But you'll never be taught this. You know why? Because under the modern Islamic system and Ulama, they're taught to not "tell the average person too much." That's why.
@@1p_edits Brother what I understand is that on the birth of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam every true muslim feels happy. Ok some may do extra things on that day to express their happiness like majaalis of zikr/durood, sadqah etc. But it should not contain any acts which are against islam or not part of it.And it should be upto a person to do such things or not. One shouldn't be marginalized or mistreated for not doing such things. THESE ARE NOT NECESSARY. BUT what I have seen, people do completely opposite of it. They miss their Salah, for attending such programmes, and there is mixing, dancing, hate slogans against other sects of muslims happening in many of these programmes. And it is celebrated as EID. If you declare and celebrate mawlid as Eid just like the 2 eids provided by the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam, then it is Biddah.
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
@@hassanbacus995 brother brother ..plx learn definition of biddah ....bidah means innovation in religion...even a 5 yr old kid would know this after reading the ahadith related to it .....this platform has nothing to do with islam..i dont know who ppl are feeding u all this stuff ..fear allah
@@ApatheticKhan1054use common sense here. Methods of communication have changed. But no celebrations at all were done by any sahaba. Clear biddah there is no defense of it.
read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
With respect to the speaker, Ibn Hajar or Suyuti or the "4 imams" or anybody is at the end of the day a "follower" of the last prophet (pbuh). What the followers say from themselves is just their opinion. What the last prophet (pbuh) said, became Deen. Stop trying to impress people by naming scholars. We only love & respect these scholars because they taught us Qur'an and Sunnah.
So the people leaving it, the reason is explained by hafiz ibn hajr, and people doing it dont have any proof from the khair al quroon!! and will you stop me if I start celeberating , the day when prophethood was given, when the hijrah was done, when each battle of Islam was won, when Makkah was conquered, when the khilafah started and so on??
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
It was PROPHET (saw) who decided to fast 2 days instead of one on the day of Ashura, so whatever prophet (saw) does in Islam is not biddah “period” what we introduce after him is Biddah so trying to justify a biddah afterwards less than lame!
The Tarawee prayer was introduced after the blessed prophet SAW. Is this a bad innovation? The quraan, in written format was introduced after the blessed prophet SAW time. Is this a bidah? Yes both the above are but are good innovations in deen. May Allah azwj guide us all. Aameen.
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl you are mistaken, Taraweeh was prayed by prophet (saw) and Umer (ra) only gathered people on it to be prayed throughout Ramadan. Even if are to believe that as a biddah then prophet(saw) said follow me and khulafa e Rashidoon so it still directly or indirectly is Sunnah. Who told you that Quran was not written during prophet’s time?
@@arshadmohammed5534 You didn't mention the Rashidoon in your above comment. Also, if you listen to the above clip, the works and status of the above pious people are not disputed by any groups!!!
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl umar (ra) is from khulafa e rashidoon, and if you agree with that status of that scholar is not disputed, then I can quote scholars with similar statures who has called in a biddah that is invalid would you then agree with them? No you will not because you want to pick and choose where you aqeedah fits in
@@arshadmohammed5534 There is good biddah, biddah e hasana. This is what clip is saying. Each to their own brother if you are not happy with Celebrating Mawluud, that is your choice.
It shows how ignorant people are about their deen that the moment the word Bid3a is said they jump to the conclusion that it is the completely abhorred Bid3a they forget or they dont know that the Salaf had always understood Bid3a to be of two types the good and and the not good. As Imam Shafiee concluded from his vast knowledge, expertise, and experience and codified it in his works. This should be understood by the reader in the words of Ibn Hajar as he is speaking based on that distinction that should be in the very basic knowledge of a student of knowledge ! But it seems the level of quite a few of the responders is shameful. Their attention span is so short... they just run with the first thing that resonates with their ignorance and propagate the misappropriated understanding. Like those taking that God Woes the Worshippers not the sinners from (Woe to the worshippers ويل للمصلين) or justifies taking alcohol (ولا تقربوا الصلاة وأنتم سكارى ) that its fine just not when or while your praying ! Things that have been introduced IN the Deen , is like the introduction of 2nd Friday Athan by Sayidna Uthman and FOR the Deen are, like, the appointing of a successor, the gathering of the Quran, the gathering of people in one place to perform Taraweeh, expanding the Masjid of Prophet Muhammad 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam Whether In the deen or for the deen so long as they follow with the UsulelFiqh then it is accepted. As is understood by Ibn Hajar that the act of Mawlid HAS a Islamic legislative fundamental basis in the way the Prophet legislated Ashura Fasting. To commemorate every day every week month year whether separate or by oneself or together with your family or in a public gathering arranged in the month of Rabi the month where he was born made hijra until he returned to his Aloft Companion on the most probable MONDAY 12th or 8th or 2nd that coincided with his birth in that month is just means for arrangement enploying the best authorized authentic judgment to meet the sweet end is part and parcel of our faith to revive our spirit hearts and awaken ourselves reviving it with the wakeful mind and loving heart and encouraging us to refinment of ourselves in the commeration of the Prophet to put his shariah fully in our lives and to do so with hearts filled with love and an awakened mind in our hearty and mindful association with the Prophet 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam to endure to refine all To express Thankfulness to Allah for sending us the manifestation of His Mercy in the creation and in the Birth of Prophet Muhammad ... the Prophet was asked when were you a Prophet He responded: I was when Adam was being created with Allah written as the Seal of Prophets... عن العرباض بن سارية رضي الله عنه عن النبي صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم قال : إني عند الله مكتوب خاتم النبيين وإن آدم لمنجدل في طينته ... اخرجه الإمام أحمد والخاكم وابن حبان وصححه قال الحافظ أبو الفرج بن رجب الحنبلي في اللطائف : المقصود أن نبوة النبي كانت مذكورة معروفة من قبل أن يخلقه الله تعالى ويخرجه الى دار الدنيا حيا (إني عند الله في أم الكتاب ) ...وللحديث تكملة ( وسأخبركم أول أمري : دعوة ابراهيم وبشارة عيسى ورؤيا أمي التي رأت حين وضعتني وقد خرج لها نور أضاءت لها منه قصور الشام) وعن ميسرة الفجر رضي الله عنه قال يا رسول الله متى كنت نبيا ؟ قال وآدم بين الروح والجسد رواه البخاري في تاريخه والإمام أحمد والحاكم وصححه وفي رواية كتبت اي متى كُتبتَ نبيا ..كُتبتُ نبيا وآدم بين الروح والجسد ) May Allah guide us and benefit us and teach us what is beneficial to us and make us enlightened and use it in the most beneficial way ameen.
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
They (SWS & RA) also did not have the Quran divided into 30 Juz. Books of Ahadith compiled. Or a microphone for Salah. These are all Bidat e Hasanah. So is the Mawlid with the purpose being to increase the Ummahs love for Nabi (SWS).
This is a bidah. This is a bidah, this is a bidah! Anyone that stray away by bring something new to Islam is in innovation. The shahabahs didn't practice the mawlid because it has no proof in deed or actions. If Ibn hajar goes against the sunnah, then he or anybody else is not a proof in Islam ( regarding that matter).
@@ladon2162 sahaba kiram not practicing blood donate cigarettes 🚬 dance - school - madarasa jeens shirt, mobail laptop airplane air conditioner ect but you want you are also innovative by ur parents it’s mean you are biddat
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
@@hassanbacus995 there are two types of innovation one is linguistic and the other one is in religion. This is the first thing they teach you in basic aqeedah classes. To put an air conditioner in the mosque is a good innovation but it falls under linguistic. To look to the sky when calling for prayer based on someone's own understanding when the companions never did it is a clear and blatant innovation in religion.
Seems you are more knowledgeable and logical then Sheikh ul Islam imam hajar al asqalani r.a. is it? Really? 😂 For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
@@invisible_assassin the three generations (peace be upon them) never read and listen Qur'an on mobile So according to your stupid and jahil logic, that would too be considered as Bidah and Haram today If Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam himself has given permission to do Bidah e Hasana (innovation within the limits of Sharia) and all the Reputed and renowned scholars of Ahle sunnah labelled MAWLID as Bidah e Hasana Then who the hell are you to say it's haram or un permissible? ( Muslim 6800, Messenger of Allâh sallallahu alaihi wasallam said: Whoever STARTS A GOOD PRACTICE IN ISLAM that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.)
@@invisible_assassin Taraweeh in jamaat (gathering) is also a Bidah in Islam by Umar r.a. as Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam didn't do that nor he instructed or wished to do that in future nor he told his followers Sahih bukhari 2010, ... So, 'Umar said, 'In my opinion I would better collect these (people) under the leadership of one Qari (Reciter) (i.e. let them pray in congregation!)'. So, he made up his mind to congregate them behind Ubai bin Ka'b. Then on another night I went again in his company and the people were praying behind their reciter. On that, 'Umar remarked, 'What an excellent Bid'a (i.e. innovation in religion) this is; ... If Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam completed the religion of Islam then who gave Umar r.a. the right of introducing a Bidah in Islam ???
Bro I happy that the prophet was Bron saw but not gonna celebrate bc that's bidah and the sahabah never did that, so I don't care what ever comes after the three generations, what ever they did we do
Prophet sallallahu alai wasallam fasted on Mondays citing that he was born on that day. That's enough to follow his sunnah and fast on Mondays, if you want to follow him, and Thursdays. No need for any other celebration, or fast any other day to give shukr for his birth. Period.
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl that's not what I think or anybody else thinks matters. Prophet Muhammad SAW practiced that. Period. You have to realize who you are questioning. That's not my practice. And islam is sent down in perfect form through the divine revelation and the practices of our Nabi. And if you think that's not enough and you can make it better then go ahead.
@@new1passion It says in the quraan that the birthday of Eisa pbuh is a blessed day. So is it not then true that the birthday of the greatest of all of the prophets is a blessed day and one to celebrate?
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl so what? now you want to celebrate Christmas too since it's the birth of eesa alaihisalaam. You can have differences on the dates. Stop going back into the loop with same kind of questions.
Thr Muslim jurists should have stopped at “the first 3 generations didn’t practice it”… It would have been better then to see the ummah playing songs, making cake and hanging lights like non-Muslim birthday parties….
I had seen a video some years back where people from South Asia(if I'm not wrong,the people were from Pakistan) were cutting cake on mawlid day singing something which goes like Happy birthday Muhammad nabi. Something like that! Allahul musta'an. May Allah guide us all @@MB-mh4cz
First three generations didn’t need Madhabs. But our generation certainly does. Don’t put your logic ahead of generations of scholars who dedicated their lives to Deen.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 such an ignorant thing to say brother. Social media is a tool - it’s not a ritual like prayers etc. Are the the type of person who says “cars are an innovation, so we need to go back to camels”? Also, not sure of you you know this or not, but this concept was taken form the Nusayri ismali sect in Egypt who were influenced by the Egyptian coptics. I don’t know about you but I certainly wouldnt take my Islam from the Alawites.
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
I don't understand how people can tolerate this fake guy dr shadee. He is misleading misguiding many Muslims with his false interpretations. This guy is an extreme sufi who is very good in hiding his aqeedah
mr wahabi ur heart eyes ears have been sealed by Allah . ur wahabi akeeda is fake false without love respect. son of saudi ,jews christian and you are best friend forever
The problem with wahabis is that whoever doesn't agree with the cult is a kaafir. There is no space for disagreement like there is within ahle sunnah wal jammah. You only prove yourselves to be a cult.
Let's be fair they should proud that ibn hajar asqalani😂 is better than sahabah and 4 major imams and he should entitiled a prophet too😂 for his opinion that so differ than the best acknowledged generation. Hence we all know the fact pharaoh was the first men ever to be recorded celebrated birthday party in bible scripture and they should thanks him to following his hasanah step 😂🎉🎉🎉
Wonderful akhlaq, brother. Keep it, as this will whey heavy. The Salaf as-Salih would probably talk exactly like the way you wrote your comment, which we like to refer to even though it does not fit the matter, right? This is a good example why people first need to learn how to behave (Adaab) before they go seek 3ilm. May Allah (swt) guide us all, ameen.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 🤣🤣🤣 the way u comment show u r now in totally emotional damaged😝. The fact Happy birthday origin major key ritual is to make a wish that in islam we call dua as ibadah that's why the teaching of prophet is already completed and bcoz 5days prayer were more greater and already includes so many dua and total submission to Allah swt the only God and Absolute Creator than the pharao way of life that u proud of🤣🤣. The Prophet,sahabah and 5 major imams teaching distinguish the daily basis need and tools such as car and social media not ibadah but a tools to make sure someone like u to be corrected in social media before more muslim that lack of knowledge deceive by urs mislead information though u try hard to justified your proudness to copied pharao act🤣🤣. Did u know a interesting fact, pharao was already live before prophet muhammad saw and he never ever have a need to copy kafir way like u do😎.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 🤣🤣🤣 the way ur comment show u r now in totally emotional damaged. The fact Happy birthday origin major key ritual is to make a wish that in islam we call dua as ibadah that's why the teaching of prophet is already completed and bcoz 5days prayer were more greater and already includes so many dua and total submission to Allah swt the only God and Absolute Creator than the pharao way of life that u proud of🤣🤣. The Prophet,sahabah and 4 major imams teaching distinguish the daily basis need and tools such as car and social media not ibadah but a tools to make sure someone like u to be corrected in social media before more muslim that lack of knowledge deceive by urs mislead information though u try hard to justified your proudness to copied pharao act🤣🤣. Did u know a interesting fact, pharao was already live before prophet muhammad saw and he never ever have a need to copy kafir way like u do😎.
@razakhan1054 🤣🤣🤣 the way how u comment show u r in totally emotional damaged. The fact Happy birthday origin major key ritual is to make a wish and that in islam we call it dua as ibadah that's why the teaching of prophet was already completed and bcoz 5days prayer were more greater and already includes so many dua and total submission to Allah swt the only God and Absolute Creator than the pharao way of life that u proud of🤣🤣. The Prophet,sahabah and 4 major imams teaching distinguish the daily basis need and tools such as car and social media not categorize as ibadah but a tools to make sure someone like u to be corrected in social media before more muslim that lack of knowledge deceive by urs mislead information though u try hard to justified your proudness to copied pharao hasanah act🤣🤣. Did u know a interesting fact, pharao was already live before prophet muhammad saw and he never ever have a need to copy kafir way like u do😎.
The Mawlid is a Bid’ah with NO BASIS in the Sunnah of the Prophet peace be upon him or that of the Salaf. DO NOT play foolish games like the deviant Sufis. May Allah guide you to understand this.
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis read Sahih Muslim 6800 ...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest. Also -Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162) So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
![[Live] : ONE 168 วันนี้!! "โจนาธาน vs ซุปเปอร์เล็ก"](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/0jIN65KgJsI/mqdefault.jpg)
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA Finals D2 | Fall | ต้องรักษาฟอร์ม อย่ายอมให้ใครแซง](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/x38QsGn7A3M/mqdefault.jpg)
It’s not really celebrating his birthday it’s thanking allah for sending Muhammad there is a Hadith on it as well
Ofc ❤ and every companion did it
True
There is a judgment that is agreed upon by all the scholars of Usool: Leaving out a matter does not prove its forbiddance. If the Prophet left out a matter, peace be upon him, that is not in itself evidence to deem something forbidden. And of course using the fact that it was not done by the Salaf, is not sufficient evidence to deem it forbidden.
If the 1st Three Generations didn't Practice nor acknowledge it, only for a couple of Hundreds of Years later The Fatimids from Egypt Began to practice it is Substantial Evidence enough for you to stay away from it and not practice it.
📗یا رسول اللہ ✍️
Alhamdulilah from New Jersey!
Alhamdulillah.. sooo happy sooo happy to see these comments from brothers who are sincere to Allah and not follow these random sufi videos.
Let's follow the Sunnah and the Salaf in their actions.
Allahumma barik.
Indeed! May Allah guide us all
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@razakhan1054 I am surprised that such arguments are still used.. in the 90s we used to hear such statements like "Don't use cars because it's a bid’ah (innovation)" etc.
So if I go in a car to a place to give dawah it's not acceptable and is a bidah.
One of our Imaam said: "I never won a debate with a jahil."
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
One can never will an argument with jahil
How can we stay muslim if we are jot feeling happy on that day when our beloved prophet Muhammad PBUH born? If you're not feeling glad, think about this that who are not happy with this...
Salafi or wahabis are the one who always tried their best to ignore the muqam and honour of hazrat Mohammad sallallahu alaihi wa sallim as they have bughz ( jealousy) inthier hearts for the prophet pbuh . They celebrate the national day very happily.
So it is a Bidah. You basically said it yourself. And you are taking the qiyas of Ibn Hajar and As-suyuti (may ﷲ ﷻ have mercy on them) rather than taking the strongest opinion and that the salaf did not practice this. Don’t confuse the people. The mawlid was started by the fatimids (Shia) and that is a tradition that is not from us😊
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
Well the posed arguement is that its a bid'ah hasanah...did you not get that?
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
@@ApatheticKhan1054Has nothing to do with Islam Jaahil, theire is bidah in religion and then there is bidah (innovation) om general
@@SherazH1how can it be a Bidah Hasanah when birthdays themselves are haram? Birthdays comes from ancient pagan Egyptians, by celebrating it, you do shirk.
Milad is sunnah❤❤
____Reading quran on on your mobile is bidah hasanah, there are many bidah hasanah is our lives today, take the good and leave the bad, but don't criticise if you havent researched in depth and understood
Labbaik haqqq labbaik yaa Rasool Allah SAW
shubhan Allah
Salafis don’t like too much praising the Prophet ﷺ
Liar.
Salafiees are the only one who are praising him salallahu aleihi ua sallam , correctly and rightful !!!!
As Allah told us in Quran, how prophet salallahu aleihi ua sallam told, and how the sahaba used to praise him salallahu aleihi ua sallam!!
Narrated `Umar:
I heard the Prophet (ﷺ) saying, "Do not exaggerate in praising me as the Christians praised the son of Mary, for I am only a Slave. So, call me the Slave of Allah and His Apostle."
Sahih al-Bukhari 3445
Love from Pakistan ❤
Repent to Allah before it's too late this is a shubuhat that eventually leads many to misguidance may Allah protectt us from this kind of misguidance and may Allah gave us & him hidayah upon tawhid and the sunnah of the prophet ﷺ
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 😂😂
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
🤦🏿♂️IMO imagine the dangerous😈 precedence it would set if we started adapting traditions from the kufaar😈 ourselves & made them biddah hasanah.🤷🏿♂️
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
No. it is not a valid opinion. Allegiance is to Quran and Sunnah not any scholar!
Poor argument, lost all respect for this guy.
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@@ApatheticKhan1054
That is a pathetic argument brother.
Celebrating Mawlid annually is considered an act of worship. Nobody says the same for social media.
Dawah to Islam is integral part of the Deen. Social media is just one of the tools we have at our disposal.
Nobody ever said you have to celebrate the mawlid as if it was obligatory. It's a perfect analogy. Just like da'wah online is not obligatory and the salaf did not practice this specific form of da'wah yet you still do it, celebrating the mawlid is also not obligatory but we can still do it
The first three generations did not practice it. You mean we live the prophet PBUH MORE THAN US? Let’s teach this beautiful deen as it was revealed. There’s is no good or bad bidaa. KULLU BIDAA FI DHWALALA.
"Every bid'ah is misguidance "
🎉
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
@@hassanbacus995 bid’ah relates to the worship my bro.
@@Yasser-2does every innovation only means worship? If it's so then mawlid isn't worship of Rasoolallah ﷺ
(I know the defination of bidah just giving response to the persons statement)
Ovcourse we celebrate mawlid evreyday we thank Allah for sending the most beloved there would be no earth if it wasnt for our beloved
Didn’t even finish the video but I can answer after 10 seconds that NO you cannot celebrate it. It’s bid3a
Lovings from Kerala,malaibari india ❤❤❤
After reading the comments, it is evident that those who hate Mawlud, don't actually know what is Mawlud, or what happens at functions.
They've clearly been told funny things.
If you’ve gone to these “mawlid” conventions you see people practicing other than Islam, sisters and brothers mixing, dances and songs, “dhikr and nasheed” that are no different than concerts and placing the messenger ﷺ beyond what ﷲ ﷻ placed him. Do not overpraise or exaggerate the status Muhammad ﷺ as the Christians did to Jesus alayhiasalam. His ﷺ status is already determined by ﷲ ﷻ so why do these people do that which would have displeased him if he ﷺ was alive? He disliked people standing for him. He disliked being over-praised. And he disallowed the people from taking the graves of prophets as places of worship and feared that for his ummah.
@@Moose-wj8sc I have attended them for years and I don't know what dancing and singing you're speaking of.
Programmes have always started off with Salah, followed by Surah Yaaseen, Qiraat, Naat-E-Rasool, a Lecture, Du'aa, and Salaat O Salaam - all of which have been approved by valid scholars throughout the centuries.
How is his status being exaggerated by commemorating him on the day that he was born? He is literally 2nd in ranking after Allaah(swt). It's not a birthday celebration like the world thinks with cakes and candles. It's an actual Islamic gathering in honor of Nabi (saw).
What do they do that displeased him when he was alive?
Nobody is worshipping graves buddy.
Again my conclusion is the same as before. Dr. Shadee has mentioned in his quote from Allaamaa Hajar that you can take the good from it and discard the bad about it.
And what you guys are doing is, you see 1 sect of people doing the wrong things in the name of this act and then you'd determine the entire act as wrong, instead of determining the bad of it as wrong, and keeping the good.
The Wahabis on our area do the exact same thing the Sunnis do. They've slowly incorporated it over the years but they do it under "different intention" and that "makes it right".
True Sunni Islam has been prevalent for so long and then you get Ulama who's chain of existence is a mere century old, dictating any and every bidah to be wrong.
It was all the plan of the British when they took down the Ottoman Empire (by working with the Saudis). They knew without Khilafah, the Muslims would just fall into disarray.
@@1p_edits nah we haven’t been told funny things, we just don’t follow Shia innovations mate.
The first 3 generations never ‘knew what mawlid is’ or celebrated it, do you reckon you are more pious than them?? No exactly 👍🏼
@@theemperor477 So it's wrong to have a gathering where Qur'aan, Poetry, & Talks are done in commemoration of our prophet (saw)?
Shias are something else, we're referring to Sunni Muslims.
And for the "do you reckon you're more pious than them?". Do you reckon you know the Qur'aan, Haddeth, and Sunnah better than the Awliyaah Ikraam, or the Scholars that have dedicated their lives to studying it?
Bid'ah is something that has been painted as 1 color.
Qur'aan in book form, is a Bid'ah. Diacritical Marks on the Arabic letters of the Qur'aan, is a Bid'ah. New poetry and praises of the Prophet & Sahaabah, are Bid'ah. Qir'aat programs, are a Bid'ah. But are any of these wrong? No.
Same goes with spreading Dawah on social media/devices (which actually do have drawbacks tbh), the use of Mics and Speakers in Mosques, or the use of modern transportation.
The ruling for any Bid'ah, is that if there's good to it, it's permissible. And if it's wrong, the one who calls it wrong, needs to refute it and prove that it is wrong. Because there will never be a time where no scholars are able to refute something which is wrong.
We fear what we do not understand. Courtesy of the Wahaabis and Western world - to keep our knowledge away from us.
The lack of actions in the first 3 generations, is not evidence to suggest that such actions cannot be permitted.
Even the Sahaabah acknowledged this when the Qur'aan was compiled into book form. Everybody was against the idea until Allaah gave them the guidance to go ahead with it. And no Sahaabah ever used the argument of "Nabi (saw) didn't do this, so we don't do it".
Sayyidina Umar (RA) himself told Sayiddina Abu Baker (RA) that they should not look as to whether Nabi (SAW) did the act or not. Instead they should look as to whether a new act has good to it or not before implementing it or discarding it.
But you'll never be taught this. You know why? Because under the modern Islamic system and Ulama, they're taught to not "tell the average person too much." That's why.
@@1p_edits Brother what I understand is that on the birth of the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam every true muslim feels happy. Ok some may do extra things on that day to express their happiness like majaalis of zikr/durood, sadqah etc. But it should not contain any acts which are against islam or not part of it.And it should be upto a person to do such things or not. One shouldn't be marginalized or mistreated for not doing such things. THESE ARE NOT NECESSARY.
BUT what I have seen, people do completely opposite of it. They miss their Salah, for attending such programmes, and there is mixing, dancing, hate slogans against other sects of muslims happening in many of these programmes.
And it is celebrated as EID. If you declare and celebrate mawlid as Eid just like the 2 eids provided by the prophet sallallahu alaihi wasallam, then it is Biddah.
it is a biddah as simple as that ...why complicate things
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
@@hassanbacus995 brother brother ..plx learn definition of biddah ....bidah means innovation in religion...even a 5 yr old kid would know this after reading the ahadith related to it .....this platform has nothing to do with islam..i dont know who ppl are feeding u all this stuff ..fear allah
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@@ApatheticKhan1054use common sense here. Methods of communication have changed. But no celebrations at all were done by any sahaba. Clear biddah there is no defense of it.
The Madrasah establishment is from where you take your knowledge is also such.
I don't have a problem with the mawlid. Doesn't the Qur'an praise the birth of Issa and Yahyah?
To praise and to celebrate are 2 different things
Follow the Messenger if you truly love him
Follow the sunnah and learn the sunnah
According to your logic bukhari and Muslim are also biddah and siha e sitta also because they are compiled after the deaths of imams
@@MB-mh4cz are you a Shiite? May Allah guide you
yeah when i did my study on this then i got to know bout it
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
With respect to the speaker, Ibn Hajar or Suyuti or the "4 imams" or anybody is at the end of the day a "follower" of the last prophet (pbuh). What the followers say from themselves is just their opinion. What the last prophet (pbuh) said, became Deen.
Stop trying to impress people by naming scholars.
We only love & respect these scholars because they taught us Qur'an and Sunnah.
So the people leaving it, the reason is explained by hafiz ibn hajr, and people doing it dont have any proof from the khair al quroon!! and will you stop me if I start celeberating , the day when prophethood was given, when the hijrah was done, when each battle of Islam was won, when Makkah was conquered, when the khilafah started and so on??
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
It was PROPHET (saw) who decided to fast 2 days instead of one on the day of Ashura, so whatever prophet (saw) does in Islam is not biddah “period” what we introduce after him is Biddah so trying to justify a biddah afterwards less than lame!
The Tarawee prayer was introduced after the blessed prophet SAW. Is this a bad innovation?
The quraan, in written format was introduced after the blessed prophet SAW time. Is this a bidah?
Yes both the above are but are good innovations in deen.
May Allah azwj guide us all. Aameen.
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl you are mistaken, Taraweeh was prayed by prophet (saw) and Umer (ra) only gathered people on it to be prayed throughout Ramadan. Even if are to believe that as a biddah then prophet(saw) said follow me and khulafa e Rashidoon so it still directly or indirectly is Sunnah. Who told you that Quran was not written during prophet’s time?
@@arshadmohammed5534
You didn't mention the Rashidoon in your above comment. Also, if you listen to the above clip, the works and status of the above pious people are not disputed by any groups!!!
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl umar (ra) is from khulafa e rashidoon, and if you agree with that status of that scholar is not disputed, then I can quote scholars with similar statures who has called in a biddah that is invalid would you then agree with them? No you will not because you want to pick and choose where you aqeedah fits in
@@arshadmohammed5534
There is good biddah, biddah e hasana.
This is what clip is saying.
Each to their own brother if you are not happy with Celebrating
Mawluud, that is your choice.
It shows how ignorant people are about their deen that the moment the word Bid3a is said they jump to the conclusion that it is the completely abhorred Bid3a they forget or they dont know that the Salaf had always understood Bid3a to be of two types the good and and the not good.
As Imam Shafiee concluded from his vast knowledge, expertise, and experience and codified it in his works.
This should be understood by the reader in the words of Ibn Hajar as he is speaking based on that distinction that should be in the very basic knowledge of a student of knowledge ! But it seems the level of quite a few of the responders is shameful. Their attention span is so short... they just run with the first thing that resonates with their ignorance and propagate the misappropriated understanding. Like those taking that God Woes the Worshippers not the sinners from (Woe to the worshippers ويل للمصلين) or justifies taking alcohol
(ولا تقربوا الصلاة وأنتم سكارى )
that its fine just not when or while your praying !
Things that have been introduced IN the Deen , is like the introduction of 2nd Friday Athan by Sayidna Uthman and FOR the Deen are, like, the appointing of a successor, the gathering of the Quran, the gathering of people in one place to perform Taraweeh, expanding the Masjid of Prophet Muhammad 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam
Whether In the deen or for the deen so long as they follow with the UsulelFiqh then it is accepted.
As is understood by Ibn Hajar that the act of Mawlid HAS a Islamic legislative fundamental basis in the way the Prophet legislated Ashura Fasting. To commemorate every day every week month year whether separate or by oneself or together with your family or in a public gathering arranged in the month of Rabi the month where he was born made hijra until he returned to his Aloft Companion on the most probable MONDAY 12th or 8th or 2nd that coincided with his birth in that month is just means for arrangement enploying the best authorized authentic judgment to meet the sweet end is part and parcel of our faith to revive our spirit hearts and awaken ourselves reviving it with the wakeful mind and loving heart and encouraging us to refinment of ourselves in the commeration of the Prophet to put his shariah fully in our lives and to do so with hearts filled with love and an awakened mind in our hearty and mindful association with the Prophet 3lyhisSalaatwasSalaam to endure to refine all
To express Thankfulness to Allah for sending us the manifestation of His Mercy in the creation and in the Birth of Prophet Muhammad ... the Prophet was asked when were you a Prophet He responded: I was when Adam was being created with Allah written as the Seal of Prophets...
عن العرباض بن سارية رضي الله عنه عن النبي صلى الله عليه وآله وسلم قال : إني عند الله مكتوب خاتم النبيين وإن آدم لمنجدل في طينته ... اخرجه الإمام أحمد والخاكم وابن حبان وصححه
قال الحافظ أبو الفرج بن رجب الحنبلي في اللطائف : المقصود أن نبوة النبي كانت مذكورة معروفة من قبل أن يخلقه الله تعالى ويخرجه الى دار الدنيا حيا (إني عند الله في أم الكتاب ) ...وللحديث تكملة ( وسأخبركم أول أمري : دعوة ابراهيم وبشارة عيسى ورؤيا أمي التي رأت حين وضعتني وقد خرج لها نور أضاءت لها منه قصور الشام)
وعن ميسرة الفجر رضي الله عنه قال يا رسول الله متى كنت نبيا ؟ قال وآدم بين الروح والجسد رواه البخاري في تاريخه والإمام أحمد والحاكم وصححه وفي رواية كتبت اي متى كُتبتَ نبيا ..كُتبتُ نبيا وآدم بين الروح والجسد )
May Allah guide us and benefit us and teach us what is beneficial to us and make us enlightened and use it in the most beneficial way ameen.
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
If Messenger and his Sahabah did not do it then Asqalani or 4 imams endorsement has value of NULL
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
@@hassanbacus995 we’re not talking about the meterial life we’re talking about the deen that perfected in the life of the prophet SAW.
Exactly!
@@hassanbacus995this platform is not a part of deen 🤷♂️... innovating something in deen is bida'h
They (SWS & RA) also did not have the Quran divided into 30 Juz. Books of Ahadith compiled. Or a microphone for Salah. These are all Bidat e Hasanah. So is the Mawlid with the purpose being to increase the Ummahs love for Nabi (SWS).
This is a bidah. This is a bidah, this is a bidah!
Anyone that stray away by bring something new to Islam is in innovation.
The shahabahs didn't practice the mawlid because it has no proof in deed or actions. If Ibn hajar goes against the sunnah, then he or anybody else is not a proof in Islam ( regarding that matter).
@@ladon2162
sahaba kiram not practicing blood donate cigarettes 🚬 dance - school - madarasa
jeens shirt, mobail laptop airplane air conditioner ect but you want
you are also innovative by ur parents
it’s mean you are biddat
the fact that you and i are chatting on this platform is an innovation (bidah). Now Why dont you be critical ? Or Are are you selective of what is in reality a good bidah ?
@@hassanbacus995
yes good biddat is best help guide to walking ahdenas siratal mustakim.
wahhabism is bad biddat
@@hassanbacus995 there are two types of innovation one is linguistic and the other one is in religion. This is the first thing they teach you in basic aqeedah classes.
To put an air conditioner in the mosque is a good innovation but it falls under linguistic. To look to the sky when calling for prayer based on someone's own understanding when the companions never did it is a clear and blatant innovation in religion.
@@ladon2162 preach my brother. These people don't know the difference between innovations in religion and innovation in worldly affairs!
Even if imam hajar al asqalani said it did the three generations celebrate mawlid...no they didn't
Seems you are more knowledgeable and logical then Sheikh ul Islam imam hajar al asqalani r.a. is it? Really? 😂
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
@@Kl45458vfw and is imam asqalani better than the three generations, no hes not. If they never did it why would we idiot😂😂
@@invisible_assassin the three generations (peace be upon them) never read and listen Qur'an on mobile
So according to your stupid and jahil logic, that would too be considered as Bidah and Haram today
If Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam himself has given permission to do Bidah e Hasana (innovation within the limits of Sharia) and all the Reputed and renowned scholars of Ahle sunnah labelled MAWLID as Bidah e Hasana
Then who the hell are you to say it's haram or un permissible?
( Muslim 6800, Messenger of Allâh sallallahu alaihi wasallam said: Whoever STARTS A GOOD PRACTICE IN ISLAM that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.)
@@invisible_assassin Taraweeh in jamaat (gathering) is also a Bidah in Islam by Umar r.a. as Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam didn't do that nor he instructed or wished to do that in future nor he told his followers
Sahih bukhari 2010,
... So, 'Umar said, 'In my opinion I would better collect these (people) under the leadership of one Qari (Reciter) (i.e. let them pray in congregation!)'. So, he made up his mind to congregate them behind Ubai bin Ka'b. Then on another night I went again in his company and the people were praying behind their reciter. On that, 'Umar remarked, 'What an excellent Bid'a (i.e. innovation in religion) this is; ...
If Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam completed the religion of Islam then who gave Umar r.a. the right of introducing a Bidah in Islam ???
@@Kl45458vfw the thing with your kind of people is u just don't learn. Its a waste of my time even talking to you
Bro I happy that the prophet was Bron saw but not gonna celebrate bc that's bidah and the sahabah never did that, so I don't care what ever comes after the three generations, what ever they did we do
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@razakhan1054 the sahabah also spread the dawah so plus social media does have anything to do with ibadah so u can have it, like what do u think I am
Prophet sallallahu alai wasallam fasted on Mondays citing that he was born on that day. That's enough to follow his sunnah and fast on Mondays, if you want to follow him, and Thursdays. No need for any other celebration, or fast any other day to give shukr for his birth. Period.
Do you think that thanking Allah azwj for just 2 days for his biggest blessing is enough?
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl that's not what I think or anybody else thinks matters. Prophet Muhammad SAW practiced that. Period.
You have to realize who you are questioning. That's not my practice.
And islam is sent down in perfect form through the divine revelation and the practices of our Nabi. And if you think that's not enough and you can make it better then go ahead.
@@new1passion
It says in the quraan that the birthday of Eisa pbuh is a blessed day. So is it not then true that the birthday of the greatest of all of the prophets is a blessed day and one to celebrate?
@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl so what? now you want to celebrate Christmas too since it's the birth of eesa alaihisalaam. You can have differences on the dates.
Stop going back into the loop with same kind of questions.
Assalamualaikum! Do write his with capital H!@@MohammedShafi-ou8bl
Thr Muslim jurists should have stopped at “the first 3 generations didn’t practice it”…
It would have been better then to see the ummah playing songs, making cake and hanging lights like non-Muslim birthday parties….
I had seen a video some years back where people from South Asia(if I'm not wrong,the people were from Pakistan) were cutting cake on mawlid day singing something which goes like Happy birthday Muhammad nabi. Something like that! Allahul musta'an. May Allah guide us all @@MB-mh4cz
Brother who are we to criticize the great Fuqahah of our religion who have been recognized by the whole Ummah and whose great impact can still be felt
First three generations didn’t need Madhabs. But our generation certainly does. Don’t put your logic ahead of generations of scholars who dedicated their lives to Deen.
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 such an ignorant thing to say brother.
Social media is a tool - it’s not a ritual like prayers etc.
Are the the type of person who says “cars are an innovation, so we need to go back to camels”?
Also, not sure of you you know this or not, but this concept was taken form the Nusayri ismali sect in Egypt who were influenced by the Egyptian coptics.
I don’t know about you but I certainly wouldnt take my Islam from the Alawites.
STAY AWAY FROM THIS TYPE OF DEVIANTS.
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis like you
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.
❤
This guy is the new Santa Claus of the ahle Sunna.
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 I'm not doing dawah.
I don't understand how people can tolerate this fake guy dr shadee. He is misleading misguiding many Muslims with his false interpretations. This guy is an extreme sufi who is very good in hiding his aqeedah
mr wahabi
ur heart eyes ears have been sealed by Allah .
ur wahabi akeeda is fake false without love respect.
son of saudi ,jews christian and you are best friend forever
No he doesn't misguide. Just say you disagree with some of his opinions and move on, period.
When has Dr shadee elmasry EVER hid his creed?
@@Rancli
but Allah knows best everyone everything even ur heart .
don’t blame
The problem with wahabis is that whoever doesn't agree with the cult is a kaafir. There is no space for disagreement like there is within ahle sunnah wal jammah. You only prove yourselves to be a cult.
Let's be fair they should proud that ibn hajar asqalani😂 is better than sahabah and 4 major imams and he should entitiled a prophet too😂 for his opinion that so differ than the best acknowledged generation. Hence we all know the fact pharaoh was the first men ever to be recorded celebrated birthday party in bible scripture and they should thanks him to following his hasanah step 😂🎉🎉🎉
Wonderful akhlaq, brother. Keep it, as this will whey heavy. The Salaf as-Salih would probably talk exactly like the way you wrote your comment, which we like to refer to even though it does not fit the matter, right? This is a good example why people first need to learn how to behave (Adaab) before they go seek 3ilm. May Allah (swt) guide us all, ameen.
Social media and online dawah is also bidah,
immediately delete all your accounts.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 🤣🤣🤣 the way u comment show u r now in totally emotional damaged😝. The fact Happy birthday origin major key ritual is to make a wish that in islam we call dua as ibadah that's why the teaching of prophet is already completed and bcoz 5days prayer were more greater and already includes so many dua and total submission to Allah swt the only God and Absolute Creator than the pharao way of life that u proud of🤣🤣. The Prophet,sahabah and 5 major imams teaching distinguish the daily basis need and tools such as car and social media not ibadah but a tools to make sure someone like u to be corrected in social media before more muslim that lack of knowledge deceive by urs mislead information though u try hard to justified your proudness to copied pharao act🤣🤣. Did u know a interesting fact, pharao was already live before prophet muhammad saw and he never ever have a need to copy kafir way like u do😎.
@@ApatheticKhan1054 🤣🤣🤣 the way ur comment show u r now in totally emotional damaged. The fact Happy birthday origin major key ritual is to make a wish that in islam we call dua as ibadah that's why the teaching of prophet is already completed and bcoz 5days prayer were more greater and already includes so many dua and total submission to Allah swt the only God and Absolute Creator than the pharao way of life that u proud of🤣🤣. The Prophet,sahabah and 4 major imams teaching distinguish the daily basis need and tools such as car and social media not ibadah but a tools to make sure someone like u to be corrected in social media before more muslim that lack of knowledge deceive by urs mislead information though u try hard to justified your proudness to copied pharao act🤣🤣. Did u know a interesting fact, pharao was already live before prophet muhammad saw and he never ever have a need to copy kafir way like u do😎.
@razakhan1054 🤣🤣🤣 the way how u comment show u r in totally emotional damaged. The fact Happy birthday origin major key ritual is to make a wish and that in islam we call it dua as ibadah that's why the teaching of prophet was already completed and bcoz 5days prayer were more greater and already includes so many dua and total submission to Allah swt the only God and Absolute Creator than the pharao way of life that u proud of🤣🤣. The Prophet,sahabah and 4 major imams teaching distinguish the daily basis need and tools such as car and social media not categorize as ibadah but a tools to make sure someone like u to be corrected in social media before more muslim that lack of knowledge deceive by urs mislead information though u try hard to justified your proudness to copied pharao hasanah act🤣🤣. Did u know a interesting fact, pharao was already live before prophet muhammad saw and he never ever have a need to copy kafir way like u do😎.
It is bidaah.
The Mawlid is a Bid’ah with NO BASIS in the Sunnah of the Prophet peace be upon him or that of the Salaf. DO NOT play foolish games like the deviant Sufis. May Allah guide you to understand this.
For ignorants and Google graduated muftis
read Sahih Muslim 6800
...... Messenger of Allâh (s.a.w) said: Whoever starts a good practice (Bidah e Hasana) in Islam that is followed after he is gone, there will be written for him a reward like that of those who do it, without that detracting from their reward in the slightest.
Also
-Abu Qatadah al-Ansari narrated that the Messenger of Allah (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) was asked about fasting on Mondays. He said: “On that day I was born, and on it the Revelation came to me.” (Narrated by Muslim, 1162)
So Every Monday is auspicious as well as the date on which He (s.a.w.) was born.