Cinderella’s dress has so far been the only dress that had traveled from the realm of animation to live action and not only stayed beautiful but became stunning. All the other princesses iconic dresses did not fair so well on the journey from animation
Literal ...a Ariel la castración, no tuvo ningún momento icónico de vestimenta , jamas Lucio principesca ...yo dije bueno ya lo del vestido rosado no saldrá, pero espero con ansias el momento magico cuando sale de agua con un vestido marino de la mano de tritón ...quedé como payasa
Seeing it side by side makes the blue coloring look like someone just ran a brush tool over the footage, details be damned. The blue eats up the butterflies along the neckline, and a lot of the layering of the skirt blends together in a lump. Almost makes you wonder what else they fiddled with in post that wasn't originally planned.
@@TommyRoss Yeah, because the blue they decided to use is almost like a party costume from a knock off store. Don't get me started on that Snow White leak...
I love the deep blue chosen for the movie. The saturated blue matched the set design and prince’s costume better than the “real” color. In life though, the real color is gorgeous.
Agree that the original color in the animated story was silver, not blue! But sorry, I think the original color of the dress was too light and too subtle to compete with the bright colors of the other ladies at the ball in the live action movie. I do agree that the blue chosen was maybe too strong, you can still see something of the differing colors in the layers of the petticoats and those would have made a stronger impact if the top layer wasn't such an overpowering shade of blue.
I agree. That's the same thing that I thought. The dress was absolutely stunning prior to the digital change. The detail that the designer placed into it became almost completely lost. There were other ways to make the dress stand out from the others in the film take. Now as far as the snow white...YIKES!
oh my god, i had no idea the dress was such a different colour irl. i still love the dress but ugh i wish theyd kept it silver like in the cartoon. it just feels so magical
I don't know if I had a mandela effect but I remember watching the real color dress on the movie, now I went to disneyplus and it is totally blue as you said! That's a sabotage for the designer fr, I even have a cinderella live action doll who respect more the color than the movie itself lol
I feel like I at one point heard that the reason why Disney keeps making Cinderella's dress more blue rather than trying to return to the more silver roots of the dress, is that the silver version looks a lot like a wedding dress. And modern day Disney isn't really trying to have their princess line scream Bride, even if a number of the Disney Princesses end their stories as brides. Along with the fact that they want to sell dress up dresses, and the vast majority of parents aren't going to buy their little girls silvery white dresses that they'll inevitably horribly stain in like three days at most, with no innate color of it's own to hide/disguise the staining. More colorful dresses hide grass stains better than silver/white ones, and they only make fabrics so stain resistant while also being comfortable to wear.
They should've reverted this bad decision when they re-released the movie in 4K. It's the only thing that really bothers me about this movie. As for Snow White, everything in that movie seems to be a disaster...
My issue with this extends to it even being a story problem. It made sooo much more sense for Ella to have the original lavender-pink duochrome dress before they edited it, because Ella made it clear she did not want her mother's dress changed too much. Fairy Godmother said, "I understand...but you wouldn't mind if I cheer it up a bit? Wouldn't mind a nice blue?" And the resulting dress ends up giving a very sophisticated and ethereal vibe, simultaneously showing forth pastel pink and bluish/lavender tones, which is something you would feel as though Ella and her mother would approve of. To do this cheap color correction in post-production could actually be seen as disrespectful to the characters. Especially since they play her mother's lullaby when she's walking into the ballroom for the first time. I hate to speak negatively in any way regarding this movie, because it's one of my favorites of all time and always will be. But this is definitely one thing I would change. I really do want to know who was responsible. 😅
Did they change edit it for the home video and disney plus version? I could have sworn it was the lighter periwinkle in theaters and its so much prettier that way
I don't know what version of the live action I watched, but her gown doesn't look as saturated of a blue as the one on the video. I mean I enjoyed her gown because of the colors in it. It's still blue but you can see the other colors. Did they release multiple versions of this? 😮
In India, a lot of housholds use a product known as "Ujala," which is used to "whiten" white shirts and pants of School going children. It's actually a blue coloured dye and only a few drops are added to to the water used for the last rinse. The original dress' colour looks like what would have happened if a few extra drops were added, and the second dress looks like the colour those white shirts and pants would have have turned out if an overzealous parent used an entire bottle of "Ujala."
i prefer the bright blue cause you can see that she lights up and everyone is wearing darker dress and color so they did a great job to make her like THE main character
I’m sorry but I love the blue that they changed the dress to, it makes it feel more magical, it also helps her stand out rather than blend in, if I had to choose between the two I would choose the deep bright blue that they went with.
Thank you! It didn't keep me up at night but I always wondered what happened there ;-) I just love the costumes from the movie so I had to get all the dolls. But when I put the normal Cinderella Film Collection doll next to the bigger 17" Limited Edition doll, it just hit me. The limited one's dress is designed in the color of the photos from the making of the film and the smaller one's is darker blue like in the final movie. Normally, I like both colors but as I can see in your video, so many details get lost with the darker color. I really wonder why someone thought it would be a good idea to make it as blue as it is now.
I agree with the person about the dress. It was so much better before they changed it in the movie. I don't like what Disney is doing with some of their live action movies.
The vibrant cerulean blue matches the blue on the prince's outfit, and helps Cinderella stand out against the palace walls and the ball guests. It's colorful and magical, appropriate for a dress made with magic. There are scenes in which the dress does show different colors, like aqua, cornflower-blue, and lilac, so the watercolor effect is still there. The original dress is great to look at in real life, but the original color doesn't work in the film. It'll be the equivalent of the light pink flowers that Cinderella's turquoise maid dress is covered with. They blend in with the color, preventing it from looking like a polka doted mess, and only the bigger flowers near the hem of the skirt are visible.
It is all for marketing. Disney can't sell millions of costumes with a huge petticoat and 10 different shade of blue tulle. What they can do is take a blue dress, add some butterflies and maybe a layer of tulle and watch the money roll in.
Edit: The reason they changed the original cinderella's dress from silver to blue is they can't sell white dresses to little kids without it looking like awedding dress.
@@flea10x6 While the original color looks good in isolation, it the film, it would have made Cinderella look washed out, and not stand out as easily against the gold of the palace or among the ball guests.
I love the vibrant blue but you're right... And once you see them compared it is just too blue. The silver-periwinkle definitely evokes the animated gown...it's perfection. They need to release a cut with that version. It's a shame that Disney took the classy Cinderellas from both films and tried to turn them into Barbie.
I wasn't fond of the live action dress and never could pint point why. Seeing the real color side by side with the blue dress is an eye opener. I absolute love the real color, and I love how much more similar it is to the animated one. The butterflies that initially didn't like now compliment the dress perfectly. The blue dress is ok but it's just look so saturated it feels like a visual sore thumb. I understand why they make it blue but I would love to see the original one, much more on the silver side, like the original animated silver dress. Anyways, I'll take saturated blue over whatever Emma Watson was wearing in the Beauty and The Beast.
If you look at color analysis you'll see that the real deep cerulean blue doesn't fit the actress, it takes attention away from her. The lighter blue in the trailer or the periwinkle blue does.
Technically Cinderellas dress was never blue, it was silver. They later added a bluish tint to allow the sparkling effect to stand out. I would have loved to see this dress in silver with gold butterflies. It would have been stunning with that colorful iridescent layer of the gown
I would swear I saw the dress in theaters and was enchanted by the shifting colors in the dress, which I don't see in the hyperlink-blue version. I wonder if the original color (or at least the trailer version) was shown in cinema and then ruined it before DVD/Streaming release.
Lavenders blue, Lavenders green.... if you listen to the song it sounds like the original dress was trying to emulate the color described in that song. th-cam.com/video/zsuCMiy0h60/w-d-xo.html
I absolutely think Cinderella is the best of the live action movies. While I will still like the movie, the bright blue was kind of cringe worthy (but still beautiful), and then when I checked further I see that is not what the designer had intended. I think they should redo the movie with the original color of silvery blue. I would buy a new copy for my home. (The too Blue dress was the only thing that mars a perfect, excellently done movie.
In the animated film, Cinderella's dress and hair style were actually a ball outfit. In the live action movie, she looks like a girl going to prom night, except for all the petticoats. That's what makes it look cheap. Apart from that: historically speaking, a girl of that time would never have worn her hair open in public.
Unpopular opinion: I love the costumes, they’re gorgeous and creative and really well made. BUT I don’t feel the essence of the 1950 animated movie. The 1950 movie has more of a mid 19th century setting and you can clearly see that in the architecture and dresses and fashion. The live action adaptation as it’s own Cinderella movie is really good (both visually and storytellingwise) but as a adaptation of 1950 movie it’s just okay (again both visually and storytelling wise). It’s in my opinion TOO colourful, at least for being an adaptation based on the 1950 movie which was more ethereal and decent
I prefer the saturated blue. As for the original dress, I'd have preferred they went full silvery-white rather than a pale blue, and omit the butterflies, given how they clash with the color.
I think as a Cinderella adaptation itself the movie itself is really really good (and in general the movie itself is really good) but yes (at least visually) the movie is kind of disappointing for being an 1950 live action adaptation
Cinderella’s dress has so far been the only dress that had traveled from the realm of animation to live action and not only stayed beautiful but became stunning.
All the other princesses iconic dresses did not fair so well on the journey from animation
Literal ...a Ariel la castración, no tuvo ningún momento icónico de vestimenta , jamas Lucio principesca ...yo dije bueno ya lo del vestido rosado no saldrá, pero espero con ansias el momento magico cuando sale de agua con un vestido marino de la mano de tritón ...quedé como payasa
That blue blocking the color shift of the layers and layers of opalescent fabric makes me wanna fist fight whoever edited that footage
the crime of the century tbh
Seeing it side by side makes the blue coloring look like someone just ran a brush tool over the footage, details be damned. The blue eats up the butterflies along the neckline, and a lot of the layering of the skirt blends together in a lump.
Almost makes you wonder what else they fiddled with in post that wasn't originally planned.
It's so insane. Even if they wanted to amp up the vibrancy, they could've approached it in a much less sloppy way.
@@TommyRoss Yeah, because the blue they decided to use is almost like a party costume from a knock off store.
Don't get me started on that Snow White leak...
I love the deep blue chosen for the movie. The saturated blue matched the set design and prince’s costume better than the “real” color. In life though, the real color is gorgeous.
Agree that the original color in the animated story was silver, not blue! But sorry, I think the original color of the dress was too light and too subtle to compete with the bright colors of the other ladies at the ball in the live action movie. I do agree that the blue chosen was maybe too strong, you can still see something of the differing colors in the layers of the petticoats and those would have made a stronger impact if the top layer wasn't such an overpowering shade of blue.
I agree. That's the same thing that I thought. The dress was absolutely stunning prior to the digital change. The detail that the designer placed into it became almost completely lost. There were other ways to make the dress stand out from the others in the film take. Now as far as the snow white...YIKES!
oh my god, i had no idea the dress was such a different colour irl. i still love the dress but ugh i wish theyd kept it silver like in the cartoon. it just feels so magical
I don't know if I had a mandela effect but I remember watching the real color dress on the movie, now I went to disneyplus and it is totally blue as you said! That's a sabotage for the designer fr, I even have a cinderella live action doll who respect more the color than the movie itself lol
I feel like I at one point heard that the reason why Disney keeps making Cinderella's dress more blue rather than trying to return to the more silver roots of the dress, is that the silver version looks a lot like a wedding dress. And modern day Disney isn't really trying to have their princess line scream Bride, even if a number of the Disney Princesses end their stories as brides.
Along with the fact that they want to sell dress up dresses, and the vast majority of parents aren't going to buy their little girls silvery white dresses that they'll inevitably horribly stain in like three days at most, with no innate color of it's own to hide/disguise the staining.
More colorful dresses hide grass stains better than silver/white ones, and they only make fabrics so stain resistant while also being comfortable to wear.
They should've reverted this bad decision when they re-released the movie in 4K. It's the only thing that really bothers me about this movie.
As for Snow White, everything in that movie seems to be a disaster...
My issue with this extends to it even being a story problem.
It made sooo much more sense for Ella to have the original lavender-pink duochrome dress before they edited it, because Ella made it clear she did not want her mother's dress changed too much. Fairy Godmother said, "I understand...but you wouldn't mind if I cheer it up a bit? Wouldn't mind a nice blue?"
And the resulting dress ends up giving a very sophisticated and ethereal vibe, simultaneously showing forth pastel pink and bluish/lavender tones, which is something you would feel as though Ella and her mother would approve of.
To do this cheap color correction in post-production could actually be seen as disrespectful to the characters. Especially since they play her mother's lullaby when she's walking into the ballroom for the first time.
I hate to speak negatively in any way regarding this movie, because it's one of my favorites of all time and always will be. But this is definitely one thing I would change. I really do want to know who was responsible. 😅
This is best comment on this video! Its like you are Cinderella's friend and have empathy for her as a person. Shouldn't we all?
Did they change edit it for the home video and disney plus version? I could have sworn it was the lighter periwinkle in theaters and its so much prettier that way
I think the Snow White costume might be a trick and it's not the one we end up with hopefully
I don't know what version of the live action I watched, but her gown doesn't look as saturated of a blue as the one on the video. I mean I enjoyed her gown because of the colors in it. It's still blue but you can see the other colors. Did they release multiple versions of this? 😮
No, the dress is not this saturated in the movie. This video isn’t accurate.
In India, a lot of housholds use a product known as "Ujala," which is used to "whiten" white shirts and pants of School going children.
It's actually a blue coloured dye and only a few drops are added to to the water used for the last rinse.
The original dress' colour looks like what would have happened if a few extra drops were added, and the second dress looks like the colour those white shirts and pants would have have turned out if an overzealous parent used an entire bottle of "Ujala."
i prefer the bright blue cause you can see that she lights up and everyone is wearing darker dress and color so they did a great job to make her like THE main character
I’m sorry but I love the blue that they changed the dress to, it makes it feel more magical, it also helps her stand out rather than blend in, if I had to choose between the two I would choose the deep bright blue that they went with.
👍
Thank you! It didn't keep me up at night but I always wondered what happened there ;-) I just love the costumes from the movie so I had to get all the dolls. But when I put the normal Cinderella Film Collection doll next to the bigger 17" Limited Edition doll, it just hit me. The limited one's dress is designed in the color of the photos from the making of the film and the smaller one's is darker blue like in the final movie. Normally, I like both colors but as I can see in your video, so many details get lost with the darker color. I really wonder why someone thought it would be a good idea to make it as blue as it is now.
I agree with the person about the dress. It was so much better before they changed it in the movie. I don't like what Disney is doing with some of their live action movies.
The vibrant cerulean blue matches the blue on the prince's outfit, and helps Cinderella stand out against the palace walls and the ball guests. It's colorful and magical, appropriate for a dress made with magic. There are scenes in which the dress does show different colors, like aqua, cornflower-blue, and lilac, so the watercolor effect is still there.
The original dress is great to look at in real life, but the original color doesn't work in the film. It'll be the equivalent of the light pink flowers that Cinderella's turquoise maid dress is covered with. They blend in with the color, preventing it from looking like a polka doted mess, and only the bigger flowers near the hem of the skirt are visible.
In one way or another it is dressing amazing...
Oh my gosh! I said the same thing about Snow White’s dress as well! It looks like a Party City dress 😂
It looks like a circus big top.
I honestly loved both color variations the real color was stunning but so was the movie color
Well dang, I absolutely loved that color and it looked stunning to me!
I enjoy original design of her dress and the editing to the blue they both simply IMMACULATE
It is all for marketing. Disney can't sell millions of costumes with a huge petticoat and 10 different shade of blue tulle. What they can do is take a blue dress, add some butterflies and maybe a layer of tulle and watch the money roll in.
Edit: The reason they changed the original cinderella's dress from silver to blue is they can't sell white dresses to little kids without it looking like awedding dress.
@@kadenbarrett6776that's just not true.
@@TheStOne1it is dress would look to Much like a wedding gown
The original also pays homage to the Theme: “Lavender’s Blue Dilly, Dilly…”
Cinderella does not wear purple.
The actual dress is like a Al grayish lavender with the iridescent fabric and reflection. They describe it as “watercolor” effect.
@@flea10x6 While the original color looks good in isolation, it the film, it would have made Cinderella look washed out, and not stand out as easily against the gold of the palace or among the ball guests.
I love the vibrant blue but you're right...
And once you see them compared it is just too blue. The silver-periwinkle definitely evokes the animated gown...it's perfection. They need to release a cut with that version.
It's a shame that Disney took the classy Cinderellas from both films and tried to turn them into Barbie.
She designed this beautiful gown, AND the dress that looks like it came from Party City??
can we just wait for the final Snow White costume before giving our final thoughts?
Ah.. that's why.. dress was looking unreal.. now I UNDERSTAND SIGHHH
Her wedding dress was my favorite dress in the movie.
I totally disagree with you! The blue is exquisite! You need to get your eyes checked! Or stop commenting!
THE WEDDING DRESS....AAAHHHHH
Jeez I had no idea this was the case 😢 Sad they couldn’t just leave the colour alone.
Magnifique film 📽 et magnifique robe ❤
The dress is gorgeous but I like the blue dress 👗
Blue looks way better
I wasn't fond of the live action dress and never could pint point why. Seeing the real color side by side with the blue dress is an eye opener. I absolute love the real color, and I love how much more similar it is to the animated one. The butterflies that initially didn't like now compliment the dress perfectly. The blue dress is ok but it's just look so saturated it feels like a visual sore thumb. I understand why they make it blue but I would love to see the original one, much more on the silver side, like the original animated silver dress.
Anyways, I'll take saturated blue over whatever Emma Watson was wearing in the Beauty and The Beast.
Oh come on, the blue was super elegant. We should accept things as they are rather than wanting to change everything. 😍
6:09 That made me lose it 🤣
CINDERELLA I LOVE DIFFERENT VERSIONS..💙💙💙💙
If you look at color analysis you'll see that the real deep cerulean blue doesn't fit the actress, it takes attention away from her. The lighter blue in the trailer or the periwinkle blue does.
I wonder if it's due to merchandising? Anyway I actually like the garish blue, hehe
I agree that the lavender fits better in every way, even with Cinderella's song.
for me, much better the movie color, deep blue is much better.
I saw this on opening day and was shocked, it was so dark
Ive always wondered about this
I love the blue dress in the movie. The original dress looks grey. That’s just me.
Technically Cinderellas dress was never blue, it was silver. They later added a bluish tint to allow the sparkling effect to stand out. I would have loved to see this dress in silver with gold butterflies. It would have been stunning with that colorful iridescent layer of the gown
You are so right
I would swear I saw the dress in theaters and was enchanted by the shifting colors in the dress, which I don't see in the hyperlink-blue version. I wonder if the original color (or at least the trailer version) was shown in cinema and then ruined it before DVD/Streaming release.
No, I saw it opening day in NY and it was very dark blue like that in the beginning, so weird
Agree with the blue dress - didn't like that deep blue - the original lavender blue is absolutely gorgeous
Lavenders blue, Lavenders green....
if you listen to the song it sounds like the original dress was trying to emulate the color described in that song.
th-cam.com/video/zsuCMiy0h60/w-d-xo.html
I absolutely think Cinderella is the best of the live action movies. While I will still like the movie, the bright blue was kind of cringe worthy (but still beautiful), and then when I checked further I see that is not what the designer had intended. I think they should redo the movie with the original color of silvery blue. I would buy a new copy for my home. (The too Blue dress was the only thing that mars a perfect, excellently done movie.
In the animated film, Cinderella's dress and hair style were actually a ball outfit. In the live action movie, she looks like a girl going to prom night, except for all the petticoats. That's what makes it look cheap. Apart from that: historically speaking, a girl of that time would never have worn her hair open in public.
Unpopular opinion: I love the costumes, they’re gorgeous and creative and really well made. BUT I don’t feel the essence of the 1950 animated movie. The 1950 movie has more of a mid 19th century setting and you can clearly see that in the architecture and dresses and fashion. The live action adaptation as it’s own Cinderella movie is really good (both visually and storytellingwise) but as a adaptation of 1950 movie it’s just okay (again both visually and storytelling wise). It’s in my opinion TOO colourful, at least for being an adaptation based on the 1950 movie which was more ethereal and decent
I prefer the saturated blue. As for the original dress, I'd have preferred they went full silvery-white rather than a pale blue, and omit the butterflies, given how they clash with the color.
Im mad.
❤
Its Beautiful but yhe blue kakes it pop. The original colour git washed out by the surrounding
They could have brightened it 🤷♂️
That dark blue is just absolutely HIDEOUS!
It truly haunts me.
I loved it!
In my opinion, Lily looked great in the blue!
The original color made her look too pale!
Original dress has big colour difference between top and skirt which throws me out of the illusion.
The made it look same shade in postproduction.
I loved Belle’s dress in the live action Beauty and The Beast. I thought it was very ethereal
I agree and the whole movie was a flop and i hated it...they butchered 1950's Cinderella..😢
No they didn’t, Lily James was a beautiful and gentle Cinderella 💖
I think as a Cinderella adaptation itself the movie itself is really really good (and in general the movie itself is really good) but yes (at least visually) the movie is kind of disappointing for being an 1950 live action adaptation
The animated dress was WHITE folks! Not blue.
It was SILVER, silvery-white.
lol chill u won't even know they edited it if u never saw those behind the scenes