Classical Musicians React: BTS Short Stories 'First Love' & 'Reflection'
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.ย. 2024
- For the 59th video of this series, classical music majors react to BTS’s ‘First Love’ & ‘Reflection’ short story videos!
To enter the YNWA giveaway: gleam.io/TqstY...
The 2 winners will be chosen and notified June 13th! If they do not respond 24 hours after contact, a different winner will be chosen.
Shop online on Mandu Apparel's website (manduapparel.com/) and get a discount from our channel!
For official goods, type in the code 'Mahler 5' to get 5% off
For unofficial goods, type in 'Mozart 10' to get 10% off
*used short story videos/eng sub credit goes to (twitter) yoongified93!
We filmed these reactions in 2017; the weekend before BTS Spring Day was released. I recently organized the CMR schedule so that the WINGS solo reactions will be posted in 2018 and I cannot/will not move them up any sooner.
However!!!! I have recorded Yunyi and Kevin's reactions to them already! If you want to watch their COMPLETE reactions to ALL 7 solos, you can watch them right now by becoming a patron on patreon: / reacttothek
FOLLOW MY TWITTER FOR UPDATES & SNEAK PEEKS OF FUTURE REACTIONS: @_emcha_
Full Reaction Schedule:
docs.google.co...
THE FULL LIST OF MVs TO-BE REACTED TO: • Playlist
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Thumbnail credit goes to Nozomi Murayama (insta: @nonchanyuzuru)
Eng subs done by Ash (@ashhfong) and Umu (@_emcha_)
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(PD) Umu:
Instagram and twitter: @_emcha_
TH-cam (Kpop covers): EMCHA
Tumblrs: / kpop-instrumental-covers
/ omg-horns
/ bangtan-fanart
/ funny-vixx
(kpop, mamamoo, bts, vixx) Amino app: Umu @ ReacttotheK
(channel manager) Eric:
Twitter: @ricekangaroo
(Assist. filmer) Ash:
Instagram: @ashhfong
Snapchat: @ashleyfong457
Henry:
instagram: @zappa_yes_floyd_genesis
Twitter: @henry_carpender
Yunyi:
Tumblrs: / classic-jenny
/ beijingboi
Facebook: / classicjennycomics
Peyton:
Instagram and Twitter: @pjohnzzz
Jarod:
Instagram: @JVLPhotographic
and @Jarod_lau
Davis:
Instagram: @davisherndon9664
Kevin:
Twitter: @nerdymusicks
TH-cam: nerdymusicks
Gwen:
Instagram and Twitter: @gwenpakerr
TH-cam: Gwen Paker
Hugo:
Instagram: @hugohumbility
Shimon:
Instagram: @shimonohi
Ben:
Instagram: @ben.j.l.kronk
Naoki:
Instagram: @naokitoyomura
Lindsey:
Instagram and twitter: @lamusicstudio
tumblrs: / punk-popsicle
/ double-horn
Fiona:
twitter: @fiona_stout
Insta: @fionaastout
Emiel:
Fb: Emiel De Jaegher
Insta: @trumpetoats
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
*DISCLAIMER: I do not own any of the songs or videos being reacted to in this video. All credits to the companies that own them.
Also, none of us are PROFESSIONAL musicians. So if you come here for a strict breakdown/analysis of the music, you won’t be getting that.This is strictly my conservatory musician friends taking time in their schedule to watch kpop for fun, and throw in any musical comments that come into their mind! Also please do not complain about any "boring" reactions...some of the musicians have blank faces since they are concentrating so deeply on analyzing the music.
"Is piano his first love?"
"I wonder if his love is music"
Holy shit how did they know
Bey3030 When Ive just became ARMY
I didnt even think about first love, like love, I thought about his love to music, and I dont know why :D
I feel like the answer to this is "Because they're musicians."
Jarod literally admitted that his first love is a trumpet before watching Suga's short. XD
omg IKR ive seen so many theories lol
They should react to First Love lyrics. Please~
Saseko yeah they should listen to the full version one
"He combined with Tub Boy~"
"Ooo... that's gaaay."
I CIDNDKSNFKA LAUGHED SO HARD AT THIS
YOONMINYOONMINYOONMIN
LOL.... I like her 😂😂😂after saying it's gay😳😂
Yoonmin
YOONMIN!!!
I laughed so hard to that too 😂😂
living for yunyi with blonde hair
chanyeol's side hoe Same!
chanyeol's side hoe SAME
chanyeol's side hoe saaaaammeee
omg yes
Please react to FT ISLAND - WIND it's just came out 13 hours ago , its very musical the piano is so beautiful , classical reactor will be like it ,
"They're all one person!" He literally solved the whole thing with one sentence I'm donee
.......Wait what?
That moment when you have never got the theories behind it,*Shakes head*..... My life
+ICE97 _98 i know right. But each theories were different and I had no idea which is right of wrong. The theories were interesting though, it made sense in some way but not at the same time. Again, I still have no idea what the hell is the actual the story behind it
+ηνεяγll 乙•0427• I hate mobile devices because TH-cam doesn't have an edit button here but there's alot of mistakes on the text so... i'm just gonna let you figure out the actual spellings
In the wings tour VCR it kept saying 'one boy with seven hearts' 'seven hearts in one boy' and stuff like that so basically it means that they are all one person experiencing different things. There's probably a video of it somewhere on TH-cam. Based on that I think the theory by bangtanwordpress is most accurate, you can go through their theories here: thebangtantheory.wordpress.com/
i love how they refer to yoongi as 'the fire guy' and jimin as 'the tub boy' 😂
Yeah we marathoned HYYH stuff 1 weekend and WINGS the next, so on top of names, I called each member by the thing they were associated with in HYYH (tub, fire, lollipop, pills, youngest getting beat up, stab/jump off water, oldest/petals)to help the reactors recognize faces X'D
hahaha... yes. so cute
fire boy and water girl amiright
ReacttotheK omg the one for kookie 😂😂
they figured out how First Love was about piano faster than we did, i'm out 😂😂
when youre studying for finals but clasical musicians react are your number one priority
main rapper jin why is this so relatable...
ok but same I have 2 exams tomorrow as well lol
i'm so happy because this is my last day of school yaaay
main rapper jin THIS IS ACTUALLT ME IM CRYING
fucking same, tomorrow i have two, but here i am LOL
10:50 " just break the glass, u always break the glass just break it"
my thought: if only u know this RapMon guy broke the chain with his bare hand when he was filming this. 😂😂
And the phone box lol
🤣
The lord of distruction 😘😘❤
I CLICKED FOR BANGTAN BUT I GOT ATTACKED BY BLONDE YUNYI INSTEAD
Nur Arina IKR
Nose piercing and choker?? Fck me up 😭😭
S A M E 😍
YES
B
Awwww no one realised that the ringing phone that RapMon couldn't pick up was from Taehyung calling him >
Ray4URay yeah
I just realized. I feel stupid 😂😂🤣🤣
Omg 😱 thank you
Omfg your right 😂😂
I DID!!! omg I like screamed "TAE!!"
I'm so sorry Rap Mon but every time I see your short film, I keep on remembering the moment you actually broke the set when filming it lol
RIP King of Distruction
한지민 😂😂😂 me too
한지민 lol I'm glad I'm not the only one!
한지민 IKR BAHAHAHA LMAO
HAHAH WE'RE SORRY RM BUT WE'RE ALL THINKING THE SAME
Same
10:50 "Just break the glass, you always break the glass!"
UHHHHH ABOUT THAT...
😂😂😂😂😂😂
RAVE He breaks EvErYtHiNg!
Shreya Ganti actually during the filming of RM's phone part in one of the bloopers have him accidentally knocking the phone off and then he broke the chain too!!!😂😂😂😂
RAVE *flashbacks to the behind the scenes when he broke the chains and made the phone fall*
Yeah ikr 😂 RM god of Destruction
"woooo... that's gayyy... " 😂😂😂
Yaoiste Dumonde your username is so appropriate😂😂
Tentastic ARMY-L to the world I knowww 😂😂😂😂
Yaoiste Dumonde YOONMIN IS LIFE BOI HAHA
hmm..
Yaoiste Dumonde terserah yunyi deh 😂😂😂
Aw it sucks that no one noticed that the phone booth from reflection was the same as stigmas. I thought that was a really clever storyline in that tae is asking for one phone call and because namjoon can't pick up it says liar on the box (because in another MV namjoon said he'd always be there for tae or something and he wasn't there for him in the time he needed him most at the police station)
RIGHT MY HEARTU
FJFOSODJIWHDKSNEJFKS
Yes exactly! Would've been cool if they'd noticed that
eVERYDAY i get these new theories from everyone! AND WINGS STILL REMAINS A MYSTERY!
I am only this fast for 3 channels
-ibighit
-BANGTANTV
-ReacttotheK
Jimin's rosy cheeks what about bangtan subs?
Entisar Hashim Oh yea bangtan subs is my lifeu too but I am not this fast LOL
Jimin's rosy cheeks Same. they even just dropped dance practice
kpopiskillingme literally! Yes I head staright to this video after watching their dance practice😂
Jimin's rosy cheeks Same here
I'm gonna start calling Jimin
'The bathtub guy' 😂😂
"I wonder if his first love was music" HAHSALDJSBSKSHDDKKA
I'm waiting
marte me their analysis is so on point like poooofff!!!! Gaaahhhh
IM CRYING
"that's the longest t-shirt i've ever seen in my life." OMFG I'M DONE
"its like my question are answered by more questions"
yup that's the army life
the teasers are connected
jungkook - yoongi
jimin - hoseok
taehyung - namjoon
and jin with himself, he's actually simbolized "a god"
If you remember in V's short film when he's talking to the police he asks for his one phone call, then it flashes to the chained up phone booth. Then in RapMon's short film, he runs to the same phone booth as its ringing but he can't answer it because it's chained......dun dun duuuuh dun. lol
Vera Huddleston wow,captain obvious
Well thanks Sparky. Your compliment just made my day, keep up the good work.
Vera Huddleston Aww,thanks :)
Vera Huddleston and the phone booth had the writting "Liar" so Rapmon must've promised to always be there for him,but since Rapmon didn't answer the call,V got locked up.
Vera Huddleston doNT FUCK WITH ME LIKE THAT
the one who called rapmon is probably tae , bcs at the police station tae asks if he can make one last call.
This was the last straw, BTS wings era officially broke my brain. I am typing with my last two brain cells 😤
"It's ok it wasn't that great of a piano"
I SNORTED
Ana ikr😂
Ana why?
5:21 "ooOOOHhhh, thats gayyy..."
me: *lmao*
"It's like just give me a little bit more to work with! It's like "oh what's happe- ooh it's-its over" I feel like my questions are just answered with more questions. You're like "oh!" And then.. "o-oh?" I swear I don't think I've ever heard a better or more accurate description of what it's like to watch this series! Also who else would love to see them react to Agust D (Suga)? Epescially his song "The Last" or "So Far Away"? Suga's short film kinda had me thinking about that
THE LAST PLEASE
I think they have it scheduled already
Now makes sense that "Lie" combined with "First Love" and in their new album is "Fake Love"
It's Suga Time
Holy shit! How did I not notice that!? Oof 😂😂😂 good job with finding that 👍
You just blew my mind
There's something about musicians talking using music jargon which I understand nothing about... that I love.
OooooOOooo that's gay. Yoonmin confirmed by Yunyi
Jin YES OMG HAHAHHA
It's funny that those two, yoongi and Jimin are a ship 😂😂
yes my frind yoonmin is real
Yas
Yoongi's vid shows exactly what his song meant how the piano or music was his first love, then he took a break then he went back to music through bangtan which is symbolized by the whistling
Neel Monte
(just gotta add a little more to this)
..but he thought he couldn't come back (piano already burnt in the trailer) but he still hears someone whistling and still tried to find it.
Min Shubay Yaaas. on another note, i loved how they correlated the lyrics of road/path to his vid
'wooo... that's gay' OKAY I WANT YUNYI TO REACT TO THE GAY SHIPS IN BTSSS
when you get real excited for the giveaway then remember you live in europe
Mia Mäkelä ...or in Africa
Or South America...
Mia Mäkelä or Asia.
Mia Mäkelä relatable
Mia Mäkelä
Yup same...
5:20 " thats gay" im telling yall this amazing humam knows what up with yoonmin
"It combined with tub boy."
"Uuuuuuh...that's ...gaay"
LOL
june XDDDDD
yoonmin
"the lollipop guy"
"that's gay"
tru tbh
YOONMIN IS MY RELIGION
wow.. hugo and gwen got the whole freaking story.. from just that!! how!?
Asian PrincesS_Amy I got the whole freakin story when I was at the CONCERT, HOW!? They got it from only 5 videos!?
ikr!!!... i mean they dint even listen to sugas song.. and they found the entire story for that...
and i had to read the lyrics to understand what the song was about..
i feel so dumb compared to them actually..ahaha
tbh i still am fucking confused, bts is going to be the death of me.
I SOO AGREE WITH YOU !!
'That is the longest T-shirt I have ever seen in my life'-Peyton
I love this video so much:)
"i think like my answer just being answered by more question"
*armys every bts comeback*
"just break the glass, you always break the glass" the power of rm accidentally crack his things HAHAHAHA
this is literally the worst bloody cliff hanger ever. They're reacting to the full song IN 2018. ONE YEAR LATER. I CAN'T WAIT THAT LONG
I'm like a bird not a turkey 2018
Ahahahaha
I WANT DEATH
Chimchimchimichangas
Don't worry it's dec alrdy
I am readyyy
a bit less than a month left!
my favourite parts about these reactions is when they speak classical music (aka alien) and it's just something that's so unknown to me but I can't help being addicted to it because it's so mesmerizing
The piano symbolizes Jungkook. Jungkook was the first member to play the piano in the MVs. In Danger era, Jungkook played the piano and he was angry and destroyed it. But during I Need U he was playing it with Yoongi.
In First Love MV the piano burnt after getting hit by a car.
reina nique you're onto something there. Didn't Kookie get hit by a car. That car accident probably represented Kookie and the 🎹
also the whistles were the beginning of #1 Begin
reina nique OH CRAP... NO WAYYY
if you read the bts album notes you'll see the piano represents his mother as his mother dies in a fire and what was left of the fire was a burnt piano. Yoongi from there refuses to play piano from there however it's jungkook who encourages him too. You should really read them they're really helpful :)
I think the HYYH stories date back even to the Danger era, not only because of the piano, but V's haircut scene in 'Stigma' is the exact one from the end of the Danger MV.
Goes to show just how much planning there was.
Now I can't hear Rapmon singing 'I wish I could love myself' without saying WE LOVE YOU.
Thank you ARMYs
the longest t shirt i havent seen in my life ahahahaha
Aleyna Bianca C. Nario I burst into uncontrollable laughter bc I didn't expect him to say that
I'm so glad they Stan namjoon 😄
did no one notice the phone booth in stigma cuz in wingstour when rap Mon finishes his solo he goes into the phone booth and tae comes out which to me means that it was tae calling since he asked for a call he asked rapmons help
yes i noticed that tooo
+chimchimislife!
im confused about that too.
coz in HYYH, the groupings were suga-kookie, rapmon-v, jhope-jimin and jin.
and in Wings, according to the clues in the solos films, its still the same groups.
(suga playing kookies theme on the piano, rapmon's phonebooth ringing with probably call from v, who was seen dialing someone in his film, jhope seeing the blue scenery in jimin's film, and jimin who also sees the circle with EVA which is Jhopes logo, and then jin. )
But according to the logos fusing together, its kookie-rapmon, suga-jimin, jhope-v, and jin.
like, what in the bultoureune hell, bighit.
Angelina Jolson girll I dont know what's happening no more I hope they'd gives us answers
Did you notice that the parings that arised when the logos combined were hints to pairings in the BS&T video? HYYH was Sugakookie, Jihope and Vmon but in BS&T it was Kookiemonster, Yoonmin and Vhope like the logos that combined.
omg yunyi still getting mad at henry because he stepped on piano really made my day xD
*sigh* I will miss Yunyi and Kevin arguing bout the music.
"It combined with *tub* boy".
Lmao, Kevin called Jimin Tub boy so cute!😂😂
That's actually something to talk about. BTS is amazing with this new concept that they did and everything, but we never talk about the production team and honestly they did such a fantastic fucking job and it would most definitely have not been the same if it wasn't filmed, storyboarded and carried out the way it was.
"I feel like my questions are answered with more questions"
eVERY ARMY EVER
Yunyi - "oooo that's gay" I died hahaha 😂😂😂😂
"I feel like my questions were answered by questions"
"Oh, oh?" 😂😂
'I feel like my questions are just answered with more questions.'
That's exactly how i describe being an army feels like.
I never request things or even comment but I have to do this seeing his short film again. I'm pretty sure it's not on your react list so please react to Agust D(Suga) So Far Away. I know you guys usually don't react to songs with no mvs but everything about it is so just beautiful. I was just listening to So Far Away and looking at the lyrics, I started crying it really hit me how much emotion was put into the song. Yoongi(Suga) really deserves to get the praise for how talented he is. Please react to So Far Away or any song from his mixtape would make me happy🙏😭
Also if you read this whole entire thing thank you. Please like to make this comment more noticeable if you agree😊
So this reminded me of a poem I wrote for humanities last semester. We had to write a simplified "Shakespearean sonnet," with a certain rhyme scheme and ten syllables per line, and we had to have a sort of artistic reference, and my uncreative ass decided to write mine based on the BTS short films XD I was proud of it, my teacher liked it, so here it is in case you wanna see
I’ve found that I am caught in my own lie
My hope is gone yet he was never here
Empty space surrounds me so I can’t fly
I can see my stigma in the mirror
Reflection to me is like a monster
I wish I could love myself every day
My past actions try to pull me closer
I really wish that I could fly away
I can never fly and I know this well
I cannot pretend it never happened
I can’t touch the sky and this I can tell
I must find a way to make this guilt end
I cannot pretend that my past is fake
I must move on and jolt myself awake
LightishRedGummi so... BTS are literally art 💜 Your muses 💜 I loved your poem 😍
Park Jimin is my light aw thank you! ^~^
Yo i wish i was smart enough to think of this tbh 😂😂😂
Jimin Panda I'm not even sure how I do it XD apparently in elementary school I wrote a pretty good poem about not being able to think of anything to write about XD
Wow, I'm impressed
I like the way you used the references, it's a lovely poem
Casually knowing what Suga's is about; his parents doubted him being able to make music, they didn't think he should. The store and the piano represents his love for music. His life distracts him and he leaves the store, or his "first love" which is in fact music. The car represents his parents, the car crashes into the store and ruins everything. Suga also had a hard time with depression, and doubted himself. His solo song Agust D talks about him dealing with that depression and everyone/thing that caused it. If you couldn't tell already, I'm a Suga stan 😃❤️
Now its the hyung line to confuse them......ha.ha.ahh
And yunyi went super saiyan in the beginning
I read the reaction schedule so you don't have to react to these but both of the song I mention the reactors would find interesting and the musical elements really stand out:
1. Bts rap monster and V - 4 O'Clock - soft with distinct piano and guitar
2. G-Dragon - (untitled,2014)
- uses only piano in background
Yunyis hair is giving me life
"Just break the glass! You always broke the glass."
YOU HAVE NO IDEA… HE DID BROKE IT… LOOOOOLLL😂😂😂
that moment when kevin starts playing the piano like a maestro out of nowhere...
and i start questioning my worthless existence...
the first tub theory tho.. hahaha
"Obviously the piano symbolizes a girl"
"no"
I laughed at that monotone 'no' 😂 cause same lol
"it combined with the tub boy"
YOONMIN RISE!!!
"Ooohhhhhh~~ that's gayyyy" lmao 😂😂
I watched this video a million times and idk why they don't realize that the whistle at the short storie first love is the same whistle at the short stories begin
IT'S SO FUCKING OBVIOUS, GUYS!!!!!!
It's not complete without Kevin and Yunyi's debate about music
"i know that the piano has something to do with the fire dude, it made so much sense"
IT MADE SO MUCH SENSE? I JUST REALIZED THAT NOWWW
I just really need them to react to "first love" lyrics
shoutout to hugo for noticing how cool the camerawork was when suga broke into the store! that was my first impression as well!
My words cannot express how much I love this channel.
I love how these people haven't even read theories or done research but they're nailing the story and even saying things that I haven't thought of before XD geniuses, all of them
The phonebooth is the one thing Namjoon can't break~~
But he broke it many times if you watch the behind the scenes. lol... Don't worry, he can break anything.
You Do You I stand corrected 😂😂 our Namjoon can break anything
"I feel like my questions are just answered with more questions."
Oh, I feel you, Jarod.
the phone call is by Taehyung
from Run era i think Rap monster promise to Tae that he will always be here for him
and in Tae short film we can see the same telephone
so i think Tae called rapmon because he needed him ( bcs he killed someone ) but rapmon didn't answer
this is why we can see the word ''LIAR" on the telephone
( sorry for my bad english x) )
yes tae did ask the police officer to make a phonecall
Amazed at the fact that they got so much info on just 4 video, while I STILL have trouble understanding everything. 😂🤦🏻♀️ They are geniuses! 👏🏻👏🏻
Why am i so happy to watch you guys react to these BTS Shorts?
If you wanna find out whats the meaning behind these vids, just search it up on youtube. Hahah most of the theories makes sense tbh. Armies are crazily smart HAHAHA
Fawwaz Ndhyl
their reactions gave me goosebumps especially when they pointed out that the symbols merged~
I am From Korea and I enjoy these videos so much! You are all so funny! I love you guys!
정서현 let's not even try to talk about where I'm from 😒
Zanele Mnguni I'm curious ...
kana kono hello!
Zanele Mnguni what's wrong?
정서현 안녕하세요!!
I love how deep they get in the music and trying to figure out the meanings.
are the wings solo songs going to be a studio version or are they going to be reacting to them live?
i would love to see them react to both sides. studio for a more clear version but live, they can also appreciate the stage and performance
anyone else agree? :)
ps. great videos and reactions ♡
Shirley Chen: The video she posted on patreon has the studio "lyric" versions. They talk briefly about live versus studio etc... You can see a clip on her twitter account.
omg. In reflection, I noticed something and started crying. On one of the mirrors, it said "you have to live." I remembered it was either Rapmon or Jin I think, who wrote those words in 'prologue' on a MIRROR. My mind is blowing itself up rn.
"Oooooo that's gay"
So that summarises the whole album.
In a good way, I love BTS and I'm not homophobic lol
i love these reactions. its nice seeing people really appreciating these short films and taking time to dissect them both visually and musically. i cant wait to see everyone react to the actual songs too!
"ooh~ that's gay"
me: tries not to laugh really loud at 1am
"that is the longest tshirt i have seen in my life" i died
*Cries in European*
"He combine with tub boy." I understand the yoonmin we gotta have that.
Yunyi looks FIRE with blonde hair!
I'll be so happy when I can recognize chords and schemes and stuff like they can
YUNYIIIIIII DON'T LEAVE AND PLEASR CONTINUE APPEARING IN THIS CHANNEL
WATCH RED VELVET'S ROOKIE what??? isn't she gonna appear in this channel anymore?????
I just realized I can't believe we have to wait till next year to see their reactions to the actual songs!
that moment when you live in canada and canada gets included for once for kpop......😢😢😢
I've just realised the significance of which portraits combine! In the MVs it's Sugakookie, Jihope and VMon as the main pairings. Jin is alone trying to save them.
The portraits in these teasers match up with the official notes. In the other timelines Jungkook and RM are a pairing, as RM teaches Jungkook how to be adult (this is backed up by the Japanese BS&T MV). J-hope stops V from killing his dad so they're also paired. And Suga tries to protect Jimin from his past at the Arboretum, and tries to save him in Japanese BS&T. Jin is still alone.
I WAS JUST ABOUT TO SLEEP
BUT THANKS THO I CANT WAIT I SRSLY LOVE THIS AND YOU GUYS
the one time an ad in a video is actually bearable to watch
yunyi looks so good!!!!!
Also, if they get a chance to listen, I think her and Kevin would love First Love.
Not even a reaction, I just want them to listen to it!
The story continued to Tear. So many of these elements reappear in fake love MV. I hope we can get the answer from Answer.
5:24-5:34 is me trying to decipher the theories. Saying stuff very seriously but basically saying nothing
Regarding the burning piano! Suga was in an accident irl and broke his arm. His first love was the piano and he set his on fire when he thought he wouldn't be able to play again. You should react to the lyric video when you get to the full songs so you get the full story cuz they really are crazy deep ❤️ love your reactions and your appreciation/focus of the music and it's production is fantastic!
BLONDE YUNYI YAASSS
"I feel like my questions are answered with more questions"
basically what it's like ever since 2015 when they started this concept ughhh