48th place was from Kill Em All, the rest up to 126 were after And Justice For All, speaks voumes about their stuff after that album. Top 14 were all from the first 4 albums.
I like some songs from the Load and even Reload, because I really like country music. On the other hand, my favorite song ever is Fade to Black, it's beautiful, strong and simply amazing, for me should be the first place; but I can understand that many people consider One as the best, cause it is absolutelly incredible too, even the video, the best of Metallica. Excellent ranking!!!
It really depends on your criteria of evaluation. The three albums with Cliff should make up most of the top 40 for any metal head or hard rocker. If you don't fall into said demographic then this list might as well be upside down.
Yikes, I realize that a lot of people were sour over the "wug wug clang clang" sound on St. Anger, but to put half of the album's songs all down at the very bottom? Ridiculous.
The album is poorly mixed and the vocals are cringe worthy, there are no solos and some of the songs sound like bad ripoffs of bands that were popular at the time. It's not just the drums, the whole album is garbage. They should've kept going with the album they were working on until they cancelled it in 2001, it would've had a similar sound to No Leaf Clover, Minus Human and I Disappear.
I love the whole St. Anger album. It's heavy, you know what's worst? Load and reload. Sounds like alternative rock not heavy metal. with a fuckn mama said hat.
plenty of songs worse than the anger ones. Jump In the Fire,Prince Charming, Unforgiven 2,Screaming Suicide, Now That We're Dead and Lux Aeterna are TERRIBLE. In general, Kill Em All is WAY too high up this list. The album is a 6/10 at best, and that includes my nostalgia for it. It didn't age well at all and almost all Metallica albums are superior imho
St. Anger is the worst metal album since the human race discovered iron. For this list to be fair, St. Anger's songs would have to be below 200th place after several positions with nothing listed or with demos from when Kirk was 5 years old. It's unfair to see St. Anger's songs next to Load and ReLoad's songs. Load and ReLoad sound like Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning compared to St. Anger.
I love St. Anger, it kinda sounds like a mix between punk and nu-metal, its the exact kind of beat i search for when at the gym
lmao i didnt realize it was out of 5 not 10, i was so confused
She lux on my aeterna til i m72
😟😟
Broooo st anger AINT that badddd
Ikr
@@jacksteroni007 real
For some reason, everyone hates the St. Anger album.
🙉🥁🙉🥁🙉🥁🙉
You are right. There is always Lulu.
@@RobertJohnson-bj5lkbecause it's awful as hell
As far as I love the first four albums, I gotta say that St. Anger and Load aren't THAT bad. They just sound different.
Load is good at anger is bad
@@JacobD42811 different means shit??????
The people who put Don't Tread On Me in 71 were probably not American smh.
HWTSD and 72s are overhated, and most of the "real" fans, didnt even give them a chance
Having St Anger down there while St Anger is now one of my favorite albums, outrageous
Bullshit rating
👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻👆🏻
The Day That Never Comes at #42 is criminal
Black album and some songs of load are so underrated in rym
Load is the greatest album
a testament to how GOOD the first 4 albums are, is out of 126 songs, you don't see one from those 4 until the top 50
I just realized my likings are all the worst rated ones 😭
48th place was from Kill Em All, the rest up to 126 were after And Justice For All, speaks voumes about their stuff after that album. Top 14 were all from the first 4 albums.
I like some songs from the Load and even Reload, because I really like country music. On the other hand, my favorite song ever is Fade to Black, it's beautiful, strong and simply amazing, for me should be the first place; but I can understand that many people consider One as the best, cause it is absolutelly incredible too, even the video, the best of Metallica. Excellent ranking!!!
Invisible kid is great? Or am I stupid for thinking that? The lyrics are soo good and reletable
let's be honest with ourselves here
St Anger would be a legendary Nu Metal album if it were mixed properly
Almost any other band could've been given this album to release unedited, and it'd be heralded as one of the greatest metal albums.
One is the number one
room of mirrors and too far gone are 3/5?!?
It really depends on your criteria of evaluation. The three albums with Cliff should make up most of the top 40 for any metal head or hard rocker. If you don't fall into said demographic then this list might as well be upside down.
Suprising rank 36 for eye of the beholder, my favourite song but i fully expected it to be on pair with St.Anger
BAD SEED 117 IS CRAZY
You must Burn is the Best Metallica Song they have made since the unforgiven 3
Yikes, I realize that a lot of people were sour over the "wug wug clang clang" sound on St. Anger, but to put half of the album's songs all down at the very bottom? Ridiculous.
The album is poorly mixed and the vocals are cringe worthy, there are no solos and some of the songs sound like bad ripoffs of bands that were popular at the time. It's not just the drums, the whole album is garbage. They should've kept going with the album they were working on until they cancelled it in 2001, it would've had a similar sound to No Leaf Clover, Minus Human and I Disappear.
Slither sounds...
...
...
Familiar...
I literally Lux Æterna on my Apple Music playlist
Master of puppets is NOT the best song on the album and is overrated as hell but is still a great song
You hated on new Metallica WAY too much. I can’t agree with One being your favorite also, it’s good but it’s really not the best.
not his list
NO WAY they put crown of barbed wire after you must burn
St anger is a goated album
It's no surprise for anyone that One is their best song.
1:22 Worst take ever
why would they make someone who doesnt like thrash rank metallica songs
I know it’s not an actual song but Pulling Teeth is literally one of the best bass solos of all time
if darkness had a son is TOO far down
no Lulu?
@@cheburek9197 That's not really a Metallica album.
Thorn Within, a lot to like, the chorus is a little weak, good song… I think the average listener only listens to the hook or chorus
Master of puppets in my opinion is better than one
Ok, Load isn’t that bad of an album 😭 it’s really overhated
Inamorata at #79??? Nah this list is bs
how is straw the lowest rated on the album💀
Was this ranked by a middle schooler full of teen angst? 😅
Room of Mirrors does not deserve to be that low
I agree
I love the whole St. Anger album. It's heavy, you know what's worst? Load and reload. Sounds like alternative rock not heavy metal. with a fuckn mama said hat.
lulu is so bad it ain't even on the list
Ironic
plenty of songs worse than the anger ones. Jump In the Fire,Prince Charming, Unforgiven 2,Screaming Suicide, Now That We're Dead and Lux Aeterna are TERRIBLE. In general, Kill Em All is WAY too high up this list. The album is a 6/10 at best, and that includes my nostalgia for it. It didn't age well at all and almost all Metallica albums are superior imho
Bruh wdym screaming suicide sucks that’s a banger, same with unforgiven 2
L opinion
Is the worst rating i have never see
St anger,hardwired,magnetic,reload,load are so so bad istg how can someone prefer those over the original albums
And facts One is 1
St. Anger is the worst metal album since the human race discovered iron. For this list to be fair, St. Anger's songs would have to be below 200th place after several positions with nothing listed or with demos from when Kirk was 5 years old. It's unfair to see St. Anger's songs next to Load and ReLoad's songs. Load and ReLoad sound like Master of Puppets and Ride the Lightning compared to St. Anger.
You are a stupid man
Nah bro, have you ever heard lulu?
Lulu is worse
Poser rating
Im surprised sandman isn't in the top 3
AJFA overrated as fuck.
Nah its peak but st anger overhated
@MuckSoulfly I prefer St. Anger.
The most unbased ranking ever 🤢 I could have never guessed what songs are in the top 10 🤮