MG ASTOR vs VOLKSWAGEN TAIGUN - SUV Shootout! | Comparison Review | PowerDrift
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 มี.ค. 2022
- It's the battle of the new kids on the block - the MG Astor and the Volkswagen Taigun. A step away from the usual suspects like the Hyundai Creta, Kia Seltos or the Skoda Kushaq. Both of them are good cars. Period. But it all boils down to what ticks the most boxes. So here's Cyrus Dhabhar's comparison review of the Astor and the Taigun!
#PowerDrift
Join the 2 Million strong #PDArmy : bit.ly/PDARMY
Stay updated with News, Behind the Scenes here : / powerdrift
Find us on Facebook: / powerdriftofficial
Follow us on Twitter for Launch updates & more : / powerdrift - ยานยนต์และพาหนะ
Hey #PDArmy, which one of these two will you pick? Comment below, and give the video a Thumbs up if you want us to make more comparison reviews!
I guess if petrol is the only option under 20 lakh. Then jeep compass sport petrol is also a good option
@@bhuwanchandra2066 a 🍓 : n. A
.0= , .,. , A. .,. , 00.
@@bhuwanchandra2066 ,,. ,. .
,,,,. V.
VW Taigun .
Its a non-nonsense car , its basically still a CAR . Its easy & fun to drive , also navigation is easy through its infotainment system. Just a better value at the price point . Moreover it atleast looks a crossover/Mid Size SUV , Astor doesn't even come into a category of crossovers, looks more like a botched up hatchback ...
P
Cars like Astor pushes other cars to have more features & creature comfort at a value for money price point. And for people who are swayed by the build quality of Volkswagen, do check out Astor because you are in for a surprise, do not make perceptions based on China’s investment in MG. Do take a test drive, it might change your views about Astor.
Took. Test drive still taigun and kushaq build quality is super. Back seat tight support is best in vw cars. Compared to mg. Interior is so luxurious in MG. Driving is fun comfort and uncomparable in vw cars. Booked kushaq
You r right!!!
It certainly changed my view of evaluating MG!!!
Astor is a fantastic car 👍
@@kapadiagk11 Indeed, it’s a great car and very solidly built
everyone said that.. I took TD and didn't find its build any special but I do remember a lot of reviewer pointing that out .. my XUV3OO doors felt at least twice as heavy
If you hide the MG logo, and that AI bot, that car from the inside looks very much like a VW. All the parts like the AC vents and all looks very much like a VW.
Going to be a proud owner of Virtus 1.5 GT white❤️
Onroad price?
Congratulations in advance 🎉 Please give it some respectable stance and do us all a favour ❤️😛
@@TheSiddhantp 21.7 L
@@reyonk6603 sure 💥
@@cbegamingorg dont you find that way too much ? at that price i would prefer getting a petrol 700
The Taigun is a panoramic sunroof and 360' camera away from being a perfect offering.
As for the Astor, the only thing British about it is that it's name is written in English.
Haha well said
They don't have guts to say that it is Chinese...
😂
Same case with volvo too
@@kevindevgan Nope. A lot of Volvo's R&D is done in europe. Can't say the same for MG
I've bought an Astor CVT with ADAS and like the host says, for me, it's a complete package. My kids just love the panaromic sunroof and playing with the AI Bot. The parents and wife love the interiors and the comfort. I personally enjoy ADAS and feel confident while driving. Also get an avg mileage of 14 to 15 kpl which i feel is a great mileage. Looks wise and build wise as well, its a solid car. Yes it's not a driver's car, fun to drive etc. but me and my family are totally satisfied with it!
internet inside chinese all side
9
You get 14-15 in city? The sellers in india say you only get 10 kmph in manual variant...can you please clarify?
I did a tank to tank test last week where i checked the mileage exclusively in city conditions. I got a mileage of 12.5 kmpl with ac. On highways i get 16 to 17. The figure that i quoted was the average when you look at both city + highway
@@PforPREM what would you suggest? Manual Astor or the CVT one?
Both my heart and head preferred brand VW to brand MG, so I bought a Taigun !
Mee too same bro …
Taigun without any doubt..
I will definitely go with VW taigun, its power , engine are the phenomenal mainly german engineering ♥️
U will be suprsied with fit N finish. Totally disappointed
@@rahulcajetandcosta5430 Downgrade of Fit and finish in Taigun is just too much exaggerated. Just stop it seriously ....
@@raunakbhagwane1259 True, with all the downgrade from a German CBU car, it is still levels above the competition. And one thing which very less people know, you keep these current German and Korean cSUVs in sun for few days and you will notice the plastics will start smelling in the Korean cars. The quality is not visually low, but they are very low, and everyone just thinks, ahh its a 4 year old car, what do you expect. Check any 10 year old polo and vento and you will know what quality actually means.
@@Eren-da-Jaeger but still...the old Volkswagen built quality was a different breed...now it's just like the Koreans...even mat Watson if you know who he is...complains about the built quality of the newer Volkswagen's
@@raunakbhagwane1259 nah man just see the car...the old Volkswagen's were much better...it isn't what it used to be
Astor 1.5 CVT is super laggy and has a very progressive pickup. Taigun 1.0 AT has a very clean pickup with minimum lag and feels much more powerful. However, interior and exterior are better in the Astor in my personal opinion. I’m unable to decide on which one to buy unfortunately.
which one you bought then, I am facing the same dilemma rn
@@user-cc4pq9cd3r took me a year finally. Was going to buy Hyryder but didn’t feel worth it. Bought the SELTOS facelift 1.5 IVT this month.
Well, the comparison was to decide which one is from Heart and which one from Head.
Obviously, the winner is which you buy making a mindful (Head) decision.
If you make decision based on where your Heart goes, you would've bought already before seeing this vid :).
Want comforable ride ? go for Astor ,Taigun suspension does Thud ,Thud noise on speed breaker.
Poor comfort.
If don't belive me ,test drive both on rough road.
Taigun GT is the SUV for enthusiasts and petrol-heads! The rest can pick whatever they want!
Well i think your video gave me answer. If it stops accident even once thats worth the money. I prefer family safety over doing drag races so Head it is
Install taigun 1.5 DSG engine in Astor.. it will solve the problem.. 😜
Well they should give such options to lego out a car 🤣 modular cars 🤣
oio
Astor's driver door has been repainted i guess !
Anyways Taigun is ❤️
Honestly for the Indian climate, the cloth seats are better. Less back burning 😂😂
1:55 I appreciate the edit but this split screen setup is kind of confusing and failing to highlight a lot of details that you're trying to show. If you could've cut the cloning effect and showed/explained each car individually it would've been more breathable if it makes sense? Anyway, it's always nice to see Cyrus ❤️☺️ Great video as always
true, and felt like too much talk with very few details
Amazing Editing of your 2 Avatars debating features.
Location of shoot for off road?
Nice review, both car are great in their respective way but Astor is little better IMO, as it is slight better in terms of build quality and preimmunises of the car.
Middle seat in Astor (Rear ) is like Hard wood, Its worse than uncomfortable.
Its more or like luxury vs pure driving experience.
Seriously no one drives like a nascar racer in the city, besides performance astor is the clear pick for who loves to enjoy luxury and technology..both are best if you are a hardcore driver just blindly go with VW if not MG is there for you😉
Love the way Cyrus carries the video !
Cyrus!!! I absolutely loved watching this new format with your clone brother! keep it coming... #PD
Mg Astors suspension is overly soft it feels plush at low speeds but feels like it will literally tip over and roll in corners
Love n enjoy power drifting rides in every video but "sometimes" music is overdone which is the uniqueness of this channel, keep it up
Follow your mind to earn. Follow your heart to spend.
Choice is simple 😊
9:21
See where equality bought us
Can’t even say an age old phrase with freedom.
However, everything in, Hearts, brains, bank balance I’ll pick the Taigun
Taigun any day if u r a enthusiastic..
Cyrus acting skills... 😂 Thought there were two people arguing
MG Astor is pure luxury, particularly the top end Savvy Turbo AT trim. No other car in its segment compares to its build quality, luxurious interiors, tech and safety. It's an international model quite popular in UK and Europe too. Its ADAS too works perfect and far better than the competition. Great job by MG!
Please make video comparison of Nissan Kicks & MG Astor
One thing to note is peoples fancy of panaramic roof . People don’t understand what happens when the car turn turtle even at a speed of 30 k mph and as most of the rare seat passengers don’t wear seat belts.. it sure is a tough situation.Not to mention the heat it brings and a burglars delight . Will u sleep peacefully in a tough neighbourhood. Total fancy.
all people understand....its just that you are too narrow minded to realise that not everyone wants sheer driving pleasure from a car....
I took the test drive of both cars. The Astor interior feels very classy and luxurious, and also, the outlook is too awesome. I feel VW should concentrate on appropriate pricing and high volumes. Breaking was also of the same calibre in terms of performance. If you are a techie, then this car is for you.
You should have bring mg 1.5 NA to Scross
Polo is already #powerdrift ki i20 vs polo video is no where to be seen😂😂 I am not even surprised at this point 😂
I just flipped a coin moment before watching this.. confused as hell between Astor (head) and Virtus (heart)
Once upon a time Astor is British Queen's family car ❤️❤️❤️❤️
Heart, whenever it comes to cars.
Taigun.. Best looking?? Not for me..
Astor ❤️ value for money 👍
For our country fabric seats make more sense
Good reading ❤️
Practical and honest comparison review i think 👍
But though if you mentioned the attention to details thing it will be good
Like cost cutting is full on VW and nothing or less in ASTOR
Some small but premium things are there too in astor which is missing in taigun a that's why ASTOR feels more EUROPEAN than TAIGUN
I have went through the test drive of both vehicles on same day. If you drive Volkswagen you cannot like any other. The driving comfort and we feel the German car. VW build quality, first we have to consider safety. If you want superb driving experience , safety and build quality go for taigun. If you need features more astor. Even seat comfort also vw taigun I felt best.
A car that drives like a german vs a car that has quality levels of german
Comparing two extremes
Piwerdrift known for its high technical values, still posts videos in 1080p which looks very average in a good quality 4K TV!!.. Please upload videos in 2160p anymore..
Astor will be limited to usage in city confines due to soft ride but Taigun will be absorbent at low speeds and will have great high speed manners and handling and as an added plus you can power through the biggest potholes you can find.
❤️❤️❤️ PowerDrift
Taigun is compared with Seltos segment. But in real world it looks very small and narrow. Feels like it is as small as sub 4 meter segment. With so many reliability issues and Unreliable DSG, the VW customers are going to suffer in long term.
It just feels that way. But it isnt! Sit inside the car you will know what Im talking about! The legroom on offer is better than Creta and Seltos. And about the reliability issues. There is nothing of a deal breaker! DSG has come a long way, there is no point in cribbing about the past issues it had. It is still the better automatic we have in the country today at this price point.
Heart ki bhi Sunni chahiye.
Sabkuch dhara rah jata hai engine main hota hai features vo bhi itne kon use karta hai built achchi honi chahiye jo taigun me hai
Will the soft touch parts last on the astor
No
I had the same thoughts. Good quality hard plastics will last for a lifetime. Moderate or substandard quality soft touch materials will wear off in 5 years time.
why isn't anybody making video on astor 1.5l
Why are so many (4) ads in this video....?
Good morning sir Cyrus
Awesome work Team PD 👌
Astor base variant
Nice content vidio
Cyrus won in the test.!
Meanwhile Skoda Kushaq 🤭
kushaq is rubbish in front of taigun
@@Cyrax210 in what way brother..?
Where's the original powerdrift guys
Astor ka punch xuv 700 ka sab ka comparo karega re tera Cyrus
Taigun clearly shines out! The driving dynamics offered are galaxies away from the competition. An absolute delight 💖
Does Taigun has ADAS? If not, what driving dynamics does it have? Oh, a stiff suspension which feels bone rattling on Indian roads. Corner carving isn’t the only way to judge a car brother. And looking at the overall package it is actually Astor which is galaxies away from Taigun
@@vipin365 Oh yeah absolutely! What sort of a rubbish explanation! That Chinese junk ain’t no way near to this German. Get your facts right and then start blabbering then at least you would make some sense.
“Does Taigun has ADAS?” Seriously that’s the best you could come up with?! How old are you again?
@@shrijitnair3957 Driving since 2000. I don’t know if it is a qualifier. Why not ADAS? Does it sound irrelevant to you? Do you only judge a car by one or two of its virtues or you see cars as a complete package?
@@vipin365 Sir, I’m gonna put this to rest. You’ve your opinion and I’ve mine. I respect both.
🙏🏼
Taigun
Just pull the door of taigun and astor. You will understand the difference
This guy beats around the bush too much..
Astor anytime 😀
anytime i will buy mg astor instead of taigun
Nam mane yuvarani
I don’t know why all the auto journalists fail to address the cabin ambiance ie. smell & engine heat insolation .. you all will agree to me if one will drive a polo Gt tsi Dsg (2016) & a Honda city petrol . The instance difference will be notable and then all this comparison will become more fair . The Germans build nice cars but trust me when I say that those cars are not the best place except the drivers seat just becz of a suspicious foul smell that it constantly throws into the cabin.... it’s unbearable even after putting ac on .
MG is just a smartphone company that is trying to make car
Proudly own a VW Taigun 1 litre TSI AT, absolute delight!
Do you feel any lag when there are 5 people onboard?
@@TheSiddhantp have driven it with 4 passengers on a long 4 day trip, hardly felt anything. I think your doubt about it being underpowered won’t be an issue, it’s adequately powered and more.
@@karannkshah thanks man.. I am planning to buy 1.0 manual. What was the onroad price for 1.0 AT?
Definitely a no brainer…we also have the 1 liter at and it’s just pull and revs so nicely even engine noise is not evident once u begin driving
@@TheSiddhantp go for AT, i got mid variant for 15.75lac on road
I am waiting for a car that gets a shit pot with a screen to put our ass on. Yes more features only please as we do not want to see the road also no engine power/drive dynamics will be great. Yes peeps like that
MG Astor ❤ great
tho le de ke koi decision ni le paye
S out we should I buy for 20 lakh rupees I want just say something that everybody
Dude please.. These are neither suvs nor is this a shootout . Pleez mwonu
Mahindra XUV700 wins ICOTY 2022 (Indian Car of the Year) Award,
along with all nominations Award.
Kudos to Mahindra for this type of Blockbuster SUV.🤘❤️🤘
Astor is better.
A S T O R
views vs likes
Is astor looks like Maserati Levante
It looks but it isnt 😅 .
Just bcoz your coat looks like that of Ambani's doesn't make you Ambani ...
@@raunakbhagwane1259 Elite boomer uncle spotted
MG sucks dont go for it…. Choose the Taigun 1.0 MT which gives 25 milage on highways…
VW definitely, this MG looks like Bulky Hatch not an SUV !
taigun ksuhaq creat nothing looks like an suv all are cossovers
Why would you compare a German car brand with China's?
Not cool man.🧐
Umm why not?
Still your so called chinese car looks far better and the quality of materials is supreme there....i guess you have gone through that roof lining of vw and skoda??? Looks like a curtain above your head!!
China mai bani todhi hai, aise toh iss logic se toh Jaguar and Landrower Swadesi gaadi hai 🤣. Kuch bhi comment kar raha hai
@@RED_58 Do you really want to put that much amount of money on a chinese car which is pretending to be British?
@@AbidKhan-ro1rc hey boomer uncle who thinks astor is a British brand. You know Maserati Levante. Watch that design
The Chinese crap is already a hit and those are thinking to buy taigun has already turned blind to the same
Taigun is a baby SUV 😂😂
In murkho ko kon smjaye ki mg main 30,000 km chlne pr hi bhut kuch change krvana pdta hn. Sabse pehle toh tyres😂😂
No comparison. MG's are shit. VW's good quality.
Powerdrift tries to be genuine.
But seriously, a half cooked chinese car is what your head told you Cyrus?
I'll give MG on the interior for the usage of colors and That's where it ends.
Which interior would last longer?
I know VW tests its products for lasting atleast 15 years.
I would like to see how well MG's Astor would hold up.
Head or heart Taigun is the one to go for in this shootout.
Though both interior and exterior copied from Maserati Levante
cloth is better. leather is cows skin 😢
Never heard of synthetic leather or what??
Rs. 50 kato iske overacting ke ..
Your stale comedy does not help. Just review the car
Looking For Luxury?
Choose Astor.
Looking For A Rocket?
Choose Taigun GT.
FAKE SUVs
Taigun best looking? Well it's a personal choice. But wait wait taigun comfortable? Kidding right? 3 log bhet ke dekho bhai, 10mins mai uncomfortable lagta hai. Adas and sunroof kaafi hai taigun reject karne ko. But of if u are in 20-25 age bracket and want just pickup and race then maybe taigun is for u, other than that in every , i repeat every scenario, Astor is definitely a better choice.
The rear seats in the Taigun are more comfortable than the Astor in general ... perhaps not for 3 but undeniably so for 2.
I think people have not actually sit in Taigun after checking out Astor ....
Its fabric seats are just more comfy and the space is a step ahead than Astors , 3 Slim adults can very well sit in the real, but two is the best with more space & roomie feel than that of Astors .
@@sosid23 bhai rear seat ki baat kar raha hu, taigun mai 3 adults bhete the hum for test drive, 10min mai mann kar raha tha ki bhai break le lete hai. Trust me, Astor ki bhi bohot jyada Full size suv jitni comfortable toh nahi hai, but definitely much better than taigun, also uski width jyada hai, toh woh naturally hi todhi jyada spacious hai
Depends on person to person and how is their physique I also own taigu and have traveled with 3 people not at all a problem
@@aavirbhavsingh5914 bhai aise determine nahi hota hai kabhi bhi, 3 avg full size adults piche bhete the. Humesha toh ekdum patle patle log nahi bhetege na. And same 3 log dono gaadiyo mai bhete the, and Astor was much better than Taigun, much much better, plus leather upholstery ki toh baat hi alag hai, ekdum rich feel hoti hai toh impression bhi aata hai. Ha, hector/xuv 700 jitni nahi thi but taigun se toh much better thi.
MG is a Chinese auto maker. Please do not buy it.
For 20 lacs buy a XUV700 ax3 , the best is class spacious and it also comes with the fun of diesel engine
Not everyone likes the bullish looks of xuv as it caters mostly to politicians, rogues, young bloods trying to show off. ..power is good , size is huge, practicality will be great for 6-7 passengers but a small 4 member sophisticated family might go for small so called pseudo suv. That's ok....
If I have 20 lakhs i ll never opt for Mahindra rather put my money on Germans 1.5 or tata if needed a bigger space..if could shell out more then there is a real big boss that's Jeep compass...