Omar Delhi Visit “Hasty”, He’ll Be "Embarrassed" if Statehood Not Granted Soon;Bad Relations With LG
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 8 ก.พ. 2025
- "Not a good relationship" between LG and CM in J&K; Omar's visit to Delhi was "hasty" and he'll be "embarrassed" if statehood isn't quickly granted: Amarjit Singh Dulat
..........................................
In an interview to talk both about the new Jammu and Kashmir Chief Minister Omar Abdullah and his demand for the early grant of statehood as well as the recent spike in terror in the union territory, a former Head of R&AW and one of India’s renowned experts on Kashmir has said the relationship between the Lieutenant Governor and Chief Minister is “not a good relationship”. Amarjit Singh Dulat has also said that Omar Abdullah’s coming to Delhi within days of taking over was “hasty”, adding he will “look embarrassed” if Delhi doesn’t restore statehood quickly.
In a 30-minute interview to Karan Thapar for The Wire, Amarjit Singh Dulat also said that “terror has never gone away in J&K”. He identified three broad causes for the present prolonged spike in terror. They are, first, a deliberate effort by Pakistan to tell the Kashmiri people that Pakistan is with them and supports them, second, a deliberate attempt by terrorists to disprove the Lieutenant Governor’s narrative that everything is normal and, third, the continuing impact of abrogation of Article 370 in 2019 which, Mr. Dulat said, “still disturbs Kashmiris … it’s not done and dusted, it’s not out of the minds of Kashmiris.”
Speaking about the relationship between the new Chief Minister and Lieutenant Governor, Mr. Dulat said “a message is being sent by the Governor that he is still in control”. Mr. Dulat said every time the Chief Minister calls a meeting of bureaucrats the Governor does the same thing. He said the relationship between the LG and the CM is not working well.
Mr. Dulat said if Farooq Abdullah had been Chief Minister he would not have come to Delhi so quickly after taking over. Mr. Dulat said the Kashmiri people are closely watching and scrutinizing everything, including the fact Omar Abdullah gifted expensive shawls to the Prime Minister, Home Minister and other top ministers. However, Mr. Dulat did not think this was an error on the new Chief Minister’s part.
Speaking about the recent prolonged spike in terror, Mr. Dulat spoke about areas where the jurisdiction of the Northern Command of the army and the Western Command meet and suggested that there could be “gaps” or “misunderstandings” which are allowing the terror to happen.
Mr. Dulat said the right response to the spike in terror is for the Modi government “to engage with Kashmiris”. He said: “Delhi needs to figure out if its muscular policy will sort out Kashmir or if it should go back to the Vajpayee and Manmohan Singh approach.”
Mr. Dulat said Delhi needs to take “a more empathetic approach”. One important step would be the immediate restoration of statehood.
I will stop there and leave you to see the interview to hear everything else Mr. Dulat has said. There’s a lot else that he has said.
Here is the link to the interview:
Join The Wire's TH-cam Membership and get exclusive content, member-only emojis, live interaction with The Wire's founders, editors and reporters and much more. Memberships to The Wire Crew start at Rs 89/month. / @thewirenews
Free and frank discussion on the recrudescence of militancy in the J&K state between Ex-RaW Chief Mr Dulat and MrThappar.Mr Dulat speaks with caution for reasons of his own.Mr Dulat is in favour of granting statehood to the state which may minister 27:46 some relief to the people.
It has been 34 years of unrest in j&k, some time it escalates and sometimes it seems to be normal, where does the solution lies, that is to be ascertained sincerely, this unrest of 34 years changed so many faces but problem seems to be their today, common people faced everything good, bad, ugly and sustained in those very difficult phases, wherever the politic is used in this problem that proved fatle, common people are concerned about unrest as far as business and future of their lives are concern, when nothing lies in the hands of common people for resolution of this long standing problem
Dulat's pacific approach to national security is history now and will never return for good.
You know what is the biggest problem? The government creating a hype is the biggest problem. The hype that everything got solved in Kashmir is the biggest problem. Unless the ground reality note gets revealed, the problem wouldn't be solved at all.
If hype would not be there then there would not be a problem in kashmir? Those people always find some reason to do violence. Now they are repeatedly claiming that abrogation of article 370 is the reason for violence in kashmir as if before it kashmir was peaceful. The battle to reach a peaceful resolution in kashmir is a continuous process until Kashmiris understand this point that their fate lies with this nation.
@@AMITKUMAR-bv7qmKashmir was peaceful until BJP and pdp came in government that is were stone pelting started as people were Against dictator mehbooba and BJP. You need to know what happened from a kashmiri not godi media.
@@affanzaman6683 Right. No business, no celebration…maybe you are also puppet of Pakistan who talks about maintaining relation with Pakistan.
@@palashroy6 Are you insane, no one is talking about Pakistan
@@AMITKUMAR-bv7qm When the hype is created, people start to think that the problem has been actually solved. Ignoring the ground reality, I am not telling that is the only problem, though there are many problems, but the main problem is creating hype. Why always Pakistan have to interfere in our matters? That is because we are irrelevant, right? If we seriously focus on autonomy and equal rights to the people of Jammu and Kashmir that problem will be solved to some extent. Right? Now, there is no use of speaking about abrogation of 370. Now we can focus on statehood, at least that would bring some impact, but the problem is government is delaying that to happen.
Very murky. Musclar handling may get votes for the bjp but will put the kashmir solution so far away that it will always rob india of resources. One needs a statesman at the helm not a hit and run tactician. Jai shnkar should be the home minister and Amit should sit at home now that the usa and canada are slowly but surely tightning the noose. Crores of tax payer money is beeing bled away due to the inept handling besides the loss of lives in kashmir.
U got that tight
No other option but to vacate Kashmir
@@TH-camrKashmir-m3tYou wanna go to jail ?
Omar was the youngest Union minister in the history of India at the age of 29 and the youngest Chief Minister in the history of Jammu and Kashmir at the age of 38.Hence, he has more administrative and political experience than A.S. Dulat or Modi and Amit Shah.
Loved the Interview 😊
Very impressive
Great interview about Jamu and Kashmir
Dulat has problem with Alcohol...you can see he is always hungover from night before.
Please also bring some other expert on J&K issues. This is not to undermine Mr Dulat's experience and expertise but to have a different view and aspect.
He's the only one who will entertain Karan's insidious ANTI-modi wolf in sheep's clothing. Mr. Dulat is too tired to correct Karan's placing of words in his mouth ... vintage Thapar😂
Mr.Thaper is always the best
A. S. Dulat is wrong. We never wanted elections though were left with no choice but to vote against BJP which would have been benefited by our boycott. Hope A. S. Dulat understands the differentiation between ''Wanted elections'' and ''Were forced to vote'' to keep BJP out.
Dulat was an incompetent RAW chief. Never had clarity on what the real issues in Kashmir were.
What's your demands?
@@haribhanujan8575As a kashmiri i think he knows problem of Kashmir better than ajit doval. He has lived here worked here he has a lot of experience. Moral of the story us majority of people in Kashmir are anti india
😂😂😂 Don't worry your son's will join toitelt cleaning jobs in rest of india 😂😂😂
A s dulat is the master of deep business in kashmir politics, giving reality of the sentiments on ground.
Governors are working as a government agents.
Every governor is a government agent
Guy doesn't let his guest speak, does he? Guest didn't get to complete even one sentence without thappar jumping in to interrupt him.
Good evening sir. Nice analysis on the very subject to say abrogation of 370 alone is not sufficient to normalise the ongoing terror situation. To restore statehood is also important keeping the view of public as not to instigate the common people by the machinery of Pakistan.
Why are you linking 370 with peace or terror it was just a article that know one knew about except politicians and lawyers...
Hi Karan, your interviews are really a pleasure to watch and real unbiased media work. It should not stop with you, please consider mentoring some new comers 🫡
Mr.K.Thaper is always the best and good courageous in all over India Jurnaliest Right ✅ angel.
How national security and Human security issues will be solved by state and non state actors. How non state actors will be accomodated in mainstream.
Beyond pinpointing and dissecting the problems, would that the wise ones had also advised the Prince as to what should be the next steps, one, two, three...
Earlier Lg was king... Now he has gun on CMs shoulder so that the blame comes on CMs face, and now a POWER tussle between the LG & CM.
Mr Dulat has a very good opinion about Dr Abdullah.The hoourable guest avoids answering some questions.
It seems things are not at all normal in Kashmir. Government abrogated Article 370, and the state was downgraded to Union Terrritory. Since abrogration of Article 370, there was the President's rule till the present elections. What has gone wrong now?
The victory of Omar Abdullah shows that the majority of Kashmiri Muslims wants to be with India. As far as Pakistani intrueders are concerned they were coming ing in the past, during six months black out and now. After Elections giving more powes to LG and makin the state run under him has cofused the people.
What are you saying voting for omar means we want to live with india. Lol.We don't want to live with india. Clear your thought
Lolz..
kashmiri lost everything in last 35 years now kashmiri people want peace in kashmir & peace of mind also...
Don't blame Pakistan, Mr Thapar. This will strengthen Modi.
Omar needs to clean up his act & grow out of the "JK nepo-pappu" mindset. For every misbehavior act, statehood should be delayed by 6 months. Even with a lower population, Jammu pays more taxes than Kashmir - benefits should be given accordingly. There should not be wealth transfer from Jammu to Kashmir.
Jagmohan then mow sinha aching like Birtish GOVERNOR GENERAL deepen the crisis , kashmir a good issue to win election
the wire good media not godi media
Real godi media .every one knows it. 😅
Karan..in Todays world of Long Podcasts with meaningful conversations....This style of Arnab Journalism is old and outdated. People want to listen to good conversations without interruptions.
What did vajpayee's policy and talks with separatists achieve ever in kashmi, except for brutal & continuous bloodshed & violence along with complete shutdowns in kashmir. It is only after 2019 & abrogation of 370 that peace & calm had come to kashmir,
I feel like I have more knowledge than this RAW guy. He is absolutely clueless and helpless
Lg is considered bad man in Kashmir. Not respected at all
Shall we ever hear the last of militancy in the J&K state?I think Pakistan wants to keep the pot boiling in J&K state.The terrain that Pakistan is using now is difficult and inaccessible from the defence of view.This is what our defence experts have been repeatedly speaking.
It shud be clear that Omar is CM of a UT and not of a full fledged State. He and his family supporters like Dulat must reign in their ambitions and help him to run the UT successfully. The Kashmiri politicians earlier have shown no competence to run the state well landing us in a 30 yr long turmoil. It is only the last 5 yrs since 2019 that we have seen some peace.
The same bunch of incompetents can’t be given back all the powers of a state only to return to full blown terrorism of the past.
This so called expert is a joke !! He is past his expiry date
Kashmir resistance forever ❤️
It’s funny Pakistan dictates Kashmir policy
Karan is a pain sometimes Dulat speaks clearly and there no need for Karen to repeatedly seek clarification. He is insulting the intelligence of his audience
Karan, you do not allow the guest to complete and jump in. Also pls tone down a bit. You are very loud. Louder than your guest.
Both in isi goodbooks
We dont support anti Nationals.
I am a regular viewer of the show including previous interviews with Mr Dullat, but sorry that i didn't find it insightful this time.
Yah to tab se tushtikaran rupi dharmnirpekshta Ka Godi media hai Jab hinduon ne sangathit hokar Bharat per Lage kalank Babri masjid ko giraya tha yah pakka godi patrakaar hai tushtikaran rupi dharmnirpekshta ki yah pakka Godi patrakaar hai
Omar Abdullah is incapable of being "embarassed". If you don't know that about him you probably are speaking out of your ass.
Interviews technique very old school and intimidating
The whole episode is a BBJP's Political gimmics. They divided Kashmir into three states to have a majority in Jammu where it had to execute some developping plans which requires Assembly permission
Jammu Hindus will always vote bjp
Muhammad was 54,
Aysha was 6
A S Dullat,karan's favourite punching bag...
😂😅
J & k ki govt ko bhi modi k hisab se hi chalna hoga.. Otherwise operation lotus.. It may be governor rule or something else. 🩳🩳🐊🐊🚜🚜🦉🦉
We are kashmiris we don't care about modi. Impose presidents rule again we don't give a F.
Fighting for freedom equality justice people land and sovereignty is not terrorism at all free illegally Indian oppressed occupied kashmir Pakistan ❤
The Wire is best Pakistani Godi Media..
6:20 ,,true Dullat saab but these days it is well defined barbed border & doesn't seem to be porous but is plausible, you never know from where they are entering. It used to be a top smuggling route across the border back in the 80's. I suspect more on Kathua/Poonch end ...we're from RS Pura (for other viewers, it's adjoining Sialkot across the International Border - just as Lahore is adjoining Amritsar)
Never support you 😢
Would it not be correct to say
Occassionally laureates, rather than occasional laureate 1:45
Karan thaperji
Simple questions hindus has any fundamental rights.
When injustice become law so resistance become the duty free illegally Indian occupied kashmir Pakistan ✌️ 🇵🇰 ❤ 🔥
Is both kashmiri to me not so canot feel.our pulse. Mere speculations have they Cristal ball with them.locals know far more than these and others donot beat about the bush enough is enough.
Hindi me bhi de
Two traitors chatting
TRUTH Hurts
@sreenivasmittapalli7759 i can see, they look hurted to their core
You interviewed Modi too. He taught you a lesson.
Really?
u both are jock...adding no value but speculations and nonsense...
Sir i am a kashmiri and i have voted in both LS2024, assembly elections...the recent attacks especially on non-locals were not done by pak backed terrorists.. we people of Kashmir think thy might be done by some agencies who want to delay or divert something which their(agency) leaders in high command dont want to give...btw after watching this interview it seems Dulat sir dont knw ABC of jk especially Kashmir....#jaiHind
Long live illegally Indian occupied kashmir Pakistan ✌️ 🇵🇰 ♥️ forever integral part of Pakistan ✌️ 🇵🇰 ♥️ 🔥
MEER JAFAR and JAYCHAND together 😂😂😂😂😂
Cryyyyy
Renember, it will be LG rule after some time because omer abdallah is incapable, inefficient, duffer abd moreover flambyont , inept, feeble and Wreck, flirt guy.
Muslims in a Mumbai society stop Hindus from celebrating Diwali
th-cam.com/video/1bEZFIgpe9Y/w-d-xo.htmlsi=l5fTIH4kFNjIp6PD
Jaha Peaceful community waha Bawal aur Ashanti