Barry talks about them practicing singing with cans and their mom noticed how good they harmonized. Just think of what the world would have never known if they were all sitting in their rooms playing video games or on their cell phones instead of interacting with each other in real time.
C est sur . Nos jeunes maintenant ne savent que jouer et parler sur écran. Je me souviens que chez nous enfants on chantait aussi pas de TV on s en portait bien . On se recevait entre famille tantes oncles. On a
Vous dites de la merde. Mes amis et moi jouions à des jeux vidéos dans nos chambres. Et puis on a créé une chorale. Nous chantons les musiques des jeux que nous aimons et nous sommes très bien accueillis en concert. Les jeunes et le monde se portent bien sans votre acrimonie, merci.
Yea they could have become Elon musk, Steve jobs or bill gate's. Or if they'd been born in the 19th century they may have discovered penicillin or invented the motor car
I had the pleasure of seeing these 3 sqeaky voice kids perform live in a tent at the Sydney Royal Easter Show about 1960 .. They amoung other entertainers were performing in the Australian version of Bandstand . Who would of thought they would go on to achieve the fame they did.. RIP Maurice and Robyn
Barry was 17 and the twins, 13. Andy was five and probably not quite ready yet. Barry's voice changed very little if any thru the years. This is just incredible ! Hugh and Barbara were obviously very proud of their boys.
The younger ones singing the harmony is amazing! Usually the younger one has the melody as they are the “cute one”… or are not developed enough to do harmony! Exceptional!!
Wonder how many in that live audience - back then, in that place - understood that they were witnessing history. The most talented set of siblings ever born. The Bee Gees got a terrible raw deal in the early 80s when talentless hacks who would appear in the deep background - making stupid noises about the BGs - and then disappear forever. And people would take those a-holes seriously. RIP Robin and Maurice. RIP to Andy, as well. Gone but will never be forgotten. May big bro Barry hang tough and live long.
At 76 now, the Bee Gees remain the best male vocalists to have ever harmonized in my ears. Carry on Barry, your brothers and you will never be forgotten.
Where did the years go that two of them are gone? We will never see the talent that era brought us ever again. Love to you Barry..Rest in peace Maurice and Robin our love goes with you as you fly free 🕊️🕊️
Even at their young age, they were so talented & went on to become extraordinary world famous.You don't get that way from staying on social media 24/7.Its sad this young generation has missed out on a lot of things that us older baby boomers experienced and got to see.
Never had seen this. Incredible ! I bought their first album way before their Disco craze. Their harmonies were always stunning. Hard to believe only one is left.
Just incredible!! They had no lessons in singing, reading music or performing!! They started so very young and they loved what they were doing!! I respect for these guys and their families! They are undoubtedly the best group ever!! And never will there be any other group like them!!❤️❤️❤️
Robin was a real comedian and Moe is very gentle while big brother Barry was trying to keep cool as the leader of his 2 little brothers. Love them so much!
From childhood, in the 60’s, I remember watching on tv and listening to, on radio and an album, Peter, Paul, and Mary singing this, “Lemon Tree”, and so many more…
Each one a gifted star. That little Robin is it? may be on the back bench, but his energy and charisma is huge. This is how a group stays together and never breaks. Thank you BeeGees for sharing your talent with the world.
The Best Harmonies in the Music Business, so beautiful & they are just children here, & they got better & better as they became Adults. They were the most talented Song Writers writing hits not only for themselves but hits for other artists in the Music Business with hits from the 60’s thru 2003 upon Maurice’s death followed by Robin in 2012, Barry has carried on their legacy & also continued to write & record. He is still a talented Singer with his beautiful voice & has received Life Time Achievement Awards for Himself & His Brothers. Also Andy is not to be forgotten, he was also very talented like his brothers & had several hits & also cowrote some of them with his Brothers. There were plans for him to join the group as the fourth Bee Gee when he suddenly died from a heart condition just following his 30th birthday. Most talented group of Brothers ever. The Bee Gees will always be #1 and I doubt anyone ever topping them.👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️💙👍🏼😊
Barry Gibb is the only one still alive. 20 years older than me. Watching this I feel a kind of fatherly love for him though. I wish I could give him a hug.
What a great journey these lads have had. Becoming international stars was their destiny. When you stop and think about it, all of their songs were great.
The Bee Gees are not my favorite band but in this early live version of Blowing In The Wind they knocked me out, i have to say. Not only their voices already sound mature but we can recognize their unmistakable and beautiful harmonies.
@@tom-id1nz I've never understood why such a big deal has been made over Bob Dylan. He can't carry a tune in a bucket. When one of his songs comes on on the radio, I always have to change the channel. Can't stand the whiny voice.
Beautiful version of the song. A good way to start their career with a Bob Dylan song. Meanwhile, their little brother, Andy, was just 5 years old when this came out.
The blending of their voice at their very young age. They obviously steal the show but there's something about Robin which outshines his brothers on this performance. His confidence, charm & charisma. I can't take my eyes off of him.♥️ The way he looks at the camera.♥️💞 It's Priceless.💖 They deserve to be given the break they were given. They made the most out of it. Well deserved.♥️💖♥️💖♥️💞💞
Agreed! I came to read comments because I felt the same way about Robin in this song. At times you can hear his voice rise and carry a tone above his brothers that just makes the song wonderful.
This is the first song I learned in 1985 when I was just starting to learn English in high school. She had struck me at the time by the simplicity of the words, and at the same time by the very strong message conveyed
since youth they had a perfec voices performance. Later they will be one of the best singers group in the world., and Barry Gibb also one of the best song compositors
It is fascinating that these young lads (having been inspired by such groups as the Everlys and the Beatles) went on to develop their harmonic and melodic (song writing) skills to such a high degree.
Robin makes the greatest eye contact with the camera/audience...his movements add such a special pizzazz and tis like he is singing/speaking directly to U. How many years for us boomers has it been, that it seems like last week.
The twins are adorable 🥺 rip Maurice and Robin
" Twins "? But they don't even look alike.
@@reynaldoflores4522they are fraternal twins, not identical twins. Edit: were.
Can't believe I didn't know that Robin and Maurice were twins
Barry talks about them practicing singing with cans and their mom noticed how good they harmonized. Just think of what the world would have never known if they were all sitting in their rooms playing video games or on their cell phones instead of interacting with each other in real time.
ESSA GERAÇÃO , INFELIZMENTE NÃO PENSA
ASSIM 😢
C est sur . Nos jeunes maintenant ne savent que jouer et parler sur écran. Je me souviens que chez nous enfants on chantait aussi pas de TV on s en portait bien . On se recevait entre famille tantes oncles. On a
Vous dites de la merde. Mes amis et moi jouions à des jeux vidéos dans nos chambres. Et puis on a créé une chorale. Nous chantons les musiques des jeux que nous aimons et nous sommes très bien accueillis en concert. Les jeunes et le monde se portent bien sans votre acrimonie, merci.
Yea they could have become Elon musk, Steve jobs or bill gate's.
Or if they'd been born in the 19th century they may have discovered penicillin or invented the motor car
You might have a point.
I had the pleasure of seeing these 3 sqeaky voice kids perform live in a tent at the Sydney Royal Easter Show about 1960 .. They amoung other entertainers were performing in the Australian version of Bandstand . Who would of thought they would go on to achieve the fame they did.. RIP Maurice and Robyn
I saw them in Manchester in a cinema interval in about 1962 They were brilliant
@@yorkshirerootsAt some point their family lived on Kepel Road in Chorlton.
I saw them after Saturday Night Fever…in Philadelphia. I was in the very first row right next to the stage!! Wonderful performance!
RAP rithym and poetry
Cada qual no seu cada qual
*would HAVE
Can you imagine three sons of your own doing this at such an early age? If your kids love it let them to it!
Barry was 17 and the twins, 13. Andy was five and probably not quite ready yet.
Barry's voice changed very little if any thru the years.
This is just incredible ! Hugh and Barbara were obviously very proud of their boys.
Until he started doing the grease yodeling.
Wrong. This is a month before Barry's 17th birthday. August 8th 1963.
Barry is three years older than his twin brothers. They are all super talented singers,song writers, and musicians.❤
@@brcfan9I
The younger ones singing the harmony is amazing! Usually the younger one has the melody as they are the “cute one”… or are not developed enough to do harmony! Exceptional!!
This version of the old folk song brought me to tears! Bless you, Barry! RIP Robin and Maurice! We will always love you!
This is not an old folk song. It was written by Bob Dylan and released in 1963 and sung by the Bee Gees in the same year.
😵💫
And Andy, of course!!!
Scary. Bob Dylan wrote this and been covered by a lot of artists and Dylan's outlived them...
@longus4 it's considered folk now
Wonder how many in that live audience - back then, in that place - understood that they were witnessing history. The most talented set of siblings ever born.
The Bee Gees got a terrible raw deal in the early 80s when talentless hacks who would appear in the deep background - making stupid noises about the BGs - and then disappear forever. And people would take those a-holes seriously.
RIP Robin and Maurice. RIP to Andy, as well. Gone but will never be forgotten.
May big bro Barry hang tough and live long.
they were so good from such an early age!!!!
OMG... This is good? I was in a high school folk group. We were just as good. Pretty corny. Not bad but sort of grating.
True
It's sad that barry is the only one that made it to an old age
Sweet💙💜💚🇺🇸✨💃😊
They have always been great!!!! Some of the best harmonies in the music industry!! Thanks for sharing
❤👍👍🇹🇭🙏
I never saw the BeeGees so young. I was always a fan 🎼🎶🎵 👍🏼
I wonder how old they were then !
Ще є на ютубі їх виступ 1960 рік😊❤
This was 1963, so they were about 14 & 17 here. Check out their first tv appearance in 1960, singing one of Barry's songs Time is Passing By!♥️
The Bee Gees were the best ole school and new school. 💓
Born in England...
At 76 now, the Bee Gees remain the best male vocalists to have ever harmonized in my ears. Carry on Barry, your brothers and you will never be forgotten.
Where did the years go that two of them are gone? We will never see the talent that era brought us ever again. Love to you Barry..Rest in peace Maurice and Robin our love goes with you as you fly free 🕊️🕊️
Hello how are you doing today hope you're having a wonderful day that the Lord has made 😊
Quanta doçura ; e , muita saudade ! ..❤❤❤
Even at their young age, they were so talented & went on to become extraordinary world famous.You don't get that way from staying on social media 24/7.Its sad this young generation has missed out on a lot of things that us older baby boomers experienced and got to see.
Agreed.
Some kids create their own music on social media. The ones who persist and become really great at it have my respect.
This is what is great about the internet.
Music still saves lifes!🇵🇷
Those clean baby faces about to turn into rock gorgeous men😍And I wasn't even born yet,but I found them🥰🥰🥰
Early 60's Australian Bandstand my wife lived next door to their mother in 1965 and went to school with Andy
Robin your beautiful harmony is rising above all else....RIP sweet baby....
They had to perform like a grown-up man at an early age...
The older I’ve become, the better my ears have listened to greatness.
Robin’s appearance hasn’t changed throughout his entire life.🙏🏻
I agree. Only his hairstyles changed thru the decades.
Barry's emotional facial expressions before up to now did not not change. really commited to the songs he sings
I agree. Robin's facial expressions are also unchanged over time. 💚
Excelent observation
Love this! Robin looked like he was a little troublemaker when he was a kid, LOL!
Barry said he was the most happiest kid ever ☺
A
Soooo cute.
So cute and wonderful 💕
he was the most enthusiastic of the three, how cute is robin!
Never had seen this. Incredible ! I bought their first album way before their Disco craze. Their harmonies were always stunning. Hard to believe only one is left.
I like the pre-disco BeeGees best!
Wait what? There's only one Bee Gee left?
@@finni-h2x Yup. Barry Gibb the oldest of the Gibb brothers
Yep...only one .🙄
Yes, only one.. 😢😢
How wonderful they were. We're so lucky they had parents who encouraged them & let them grow their amazing talent.
Just incredible!! They had no lessons in singing, reading music or performing!! They started so very young and they loved what they were doing!! I respect for these guys and their families! They are undoubtedly the best group ever!! And never will there be any other group like them!!❤️❤️❤️
Yes! I'm thinking they were good but never on the Osmond's level ...
Are you serious they were way better
Sus padres eran músicos.
Hopefully.
@@fonografo6008 Sí, no creo que no tuvieran estudios en música. Hasta sabían tocar instrumentos.
Robin was a real comedian and Moe is very gentle while big brother Barry was trying to keep cool as the leader of his 2 little brothers. Love them so much!
To read all of that from them, you are either a parent or a detective.
... Or both. Lol
You hit the nail right on the head love.
❤🎉love
From childhood, in the 60’s, I remember watching on tv and listening to, on radio and an album, Peter, Paul, and Mary singing this, “Lemon Tree”, and so many more…
Good boys. They're voices haven't even changed yet!
Each one a gifted star. That little Robin is it? may be on the back bench, but his energy and charisma is huge. This is how a group stays together and never breaks. Thank you BeeGees for sharing your talent with the world.
Yes so right, he was bursting with charisma and talent.
They are teens and their voices are professional- what a treat to see them. Barry is thankfully still with us making music . ❤❤
your mother must be proud of you. 🤩
If I were there, I really want to hug the twins with my heart.
The Best Harmonies in the Music Business, so beautiful & they are just children here, & they got better & better as they became Adults. They were the most talented Song Writers writing hits not only for themselves but hits for other artists in the Music Business with hits from the 60’s thru 2003 upon Maurice’s death followed by Robin in 2012, Barry has carried on their legacy & also continued to write & record. He is still a talented Singer with his beautiful voice & has received Life Time Achievement Awards for Himself & His Brothers. Also Andy is not to be forgotten, he was also very talented like his brothers & had several hits & also cowrote some of them with his Brothers. There were plans for him to join the group as the fourth Bee Gee when he suddenly died from a heart condition just following his 30th birthday. Most talented group of Brothers ever. The Bee Gees will always be #1 and I doubt anyone ever topping them.👏👏👏❤️❤️❤️💙👍🏼😊
Where are the harmonic voices we use to hear....the Carpenters, Elvis, the Bee Gees, etc. Where are they???
La felicidad y el humor en Robin es genial...parece que von los añis se puso serio....
Das ist ja unglaublich!! So jung sah ich die Bee Gees noch nie!!! Danke fuer's Teilen ❤❤❤
Ich auch! 🤯
Love the way Robin couldn't sit still
Jenny Lonton - Noticed that too. Barry said he was the funniest kid he ever knew.
He would have fit right into the movie
Stand by me.
Adorable su carita y su sonrisa
Yes, he never could sit still ever - just a very special and unique human being ❤
Their early performances are just wonderful and because of TH-cam we can enjoy them as much as we desire.
Yes it is nice to go back and hear the Bee Gees sing anytime we can on Utube
It's a shame that a lot of people don't check copyright laws before they post videos.
@@Flynn1982x You might want to look over TH-cam's Terms of Service regarding copyright.
Who knew they would turn out to be one of the greatest bands of the 70's❤❤❤ why did this song bring tears to my eyes? ....
Only you can answer that "question"
Por los recuerdos de otras épocas, que no volverán. Tengo 62 años y me llevó a mi juventud. 🇻🇪💖
They've been already one of the best bands in the 60s, at least in Europe. Personally I prefer the 60s Bee Gees much over the 70s ones.
Because it is about answers to urgent questions of how to hold peace?
@@ankelenze5696the Harmony is always there. For example in nights on broadway
Einfach. Wunderbar. 💖💖💖👏👏👍👍🎶🎶🎶🎶✌️✌️🌟🌟
What a great version of this song. The harmonies are spot on.
MY FAVORITE BAND , I LOVE ALL THEIR SONGS
THEY ARE NOT A BAND
I loved this guys in 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s, 2000s, 2010s, 2020s, and more. They are wonderful singers.
Beautiful .... and so very young... !!!
Great, I've never seen the three of them that young 👏👏👏
Sad that Robin and Mo was not here anymore' but their memories stays forever.. Love the beegees so much
Robin williams
So beautiful and great at a young age🙏🏻❤️☮️✝️🌹🎉🎈
Barry Gibb is the only one still alive. 20 years older than me. Watching this I feel a kind of fatherly love for him though. I wish I could give him a hug.
What a great journey these lads have had. Becoming international stars was their destiny. When you stop and think about it, all of their songs were great.
How lovely!!! I've never seen them singing this one before!!!🤗❤️❤️❤️👍👏👏👏👏👏👏🙏🌹🙏🌹
Me neither.. 🧡🧡🤗
Robin moved his head and swayed his body as he sang. This really showed how much he enjoyed singing
I really like Robin Gibb. So adorable
How cute must Andy have been at age 5 when this was shot? Wonder if he was backstage or in the audience with Mum or Dad in tow.
This was my favorite Bob Dylan song. Barry was handsome even back then!
The Bee Gees are not my favorite band but in this early live version of Blowing In The Wind they knocked me out, i have to say. Not only their voices already sound mature but we can recognize their unmistakable and beautiful harmonies.
No where near Dylan or Mrrianne Faithfuls cover
Robin sang the high part here I believe. He was awesome!!! Please forgive me for being hung up on Robin, but he will always be my favorite Bee Gee.
@@amd64alan Maybe not, I don't think they even hit puberty here. Dylan couldn't sing worth crap.
And they didn't know what lay before them. The rest was rock & roll history.
@@tom-id1nz I've never understood why such a big deal has been made over Bob Dylan. He can't carry a tune in a bucket. When one of his songs comes on on the radio, I always have to change the channel. Can't stand the whiny voice.
I agree. We have been blessed with their harmonies. Such gifted song writers too
Oh my goodness! They're sooo cute 🥰
Hello 👋 how are you doing hope you're having a wonderful day that the Lord has made
I think this version is my favorite. I loved seeing the Bee Gees as kids singing so beautifully
Como não amar B. G ❤❤❤❤
One of the greatest songs written by Bob Dylan and sang by one of the best groups ever
The Bee Gees
Robin and Maurice are clearly in the period when their voices are breaking...and yet they sing THAT beautiful! It’s unbelievable
Legends...absolute legends....The Bee Gees will live on for many many decades to come!!!
Gosh, they were so young here!
God bless these beautiful people The Bee Gees 🙏
Beautiful version of the song. A good way to start their career with a Bob Dylan song. Meanwhile, their little brother, Andy, was just 5 years old when this came out.
Mensch, was waren die da noch jung!!! 😮😮😮
Вы родились стариком? 😮
This has brought me back nice and happy memories . Thanks Bee Gees forever!!
Me too❤
Tears
Each of them had wonderful voices, but Robin was blessed with a fantastic tone to his voice. Born talented 🌈
Maurice
It's wonderful they continued with their nice harmonizing to give us some of the best music ever.
Amazing voice of Robin and Maurice.
Rapaz, que afinação, que harmonia das vozes e instrumentos, em uma época tão remota! Esse grupo é demais!
Tal e qual The Beatles, o cuidado com cada detalhe era lei!
i like this version, it's so innocent.
Super talented even as kids!
Wow three beautiful sons
The blending of their voice at their very young age. They obviously steal the show but there's something about Robin which outshines his brothers on this performance. His confidence, charm & charisma. I can't take my eyes off of him.♥️ The way he looks at the camera.♥️💞 It's Priceless.💖 They deserve to be given the break they were given. They made the most out of it. Well deserved.♥️💖♥️💖♥️💞💞
Agree re Robin, he's living the music and can't take my eyes off him
Agreed! I came to read comments because I felt the same way about Robin in this song. At times you can hear his voice rise and carry a tone above his brothers that just makes the song wonderful.
Fantastic poise and confidence in their youth.
The Bee Gee's are my absolute favorite!! I miss them all, Andy too.
This is the first song I learned in 1985 when I was just starting to learn English in high school. She had struck me at the time by the simplicity of the words, and at the same time by the very strong message conveyed
since youth they had a perfec voices performance. Later they will be one of the best singers group in the world., and Barry Gibb also one of the best song compositors
Que relíquia! Fantásticos desde sempre!
So precious. RIP Maurice and Robin. You are missed.
So cute gifted singers. They can harmonize those high pitched young voices.
First time seeing this one. Wouldn't have recognised them. The two brothers in the back have the harmony down pat as usual.
Barry was 17, Robin and Maurice was only 14 by that time~
precious video💖
Diese. DREI. SIND. SUPER🎶🎶🎶💖💖💖👏👏👏😃😃
Incredible harmony
Beautiful version of this song by Bee Gees!
What an extraordinary voice Robin was blessed with. Such an unusual sound. Lovely 🌈
NO EXISTIRA NUNCA UNAS VOCES TAN PERFECTAS...BEE GEES FUE LO MEJOR COMO GRUPO QUE PASO PIR ESTE MUNDO 👏👏👏👏👏👏
Absolutamente. Voces unicas. Es una lastima que solo Barry esté. Mucha nostalgia😢❤❤❤❤
It is fascinating that these young lads (having been inspired by such groups as the Everlys and the Beatles) went on to develop their harmonic and melodic (song writing) skills to such a high degree.
Hören sich genau so synchron an wie die Everly Brothers, einfach nur Klasse
Never knew this existed. Interesting to see the Bee Gees this young.
Heartbreakingly beautiful.
Barry is the only living brother now unless he has died. The BeeGees were great.
Not one of my favorite songs, but it’s cool to see them performing at such a young age.
So sad most of them are gone. What great song writers they were!
They didn't write this song!
Robin makes the greatest eye contact with the camera/audience...his movements add such a special pizzazz and tis like he is singing/speaking directly to U. How many years for us boomers has it been, that it seems like last week.
Brilliant!... Amazing voices so intune with each other.
Are they as close as brothers?🤔