First off, there is absolutely no need to make UPSC a 5 years plan - it is DEVASTATING. If you are eligible to write the exam in 2025 and can dedicate around 6-10 hours per day to your preparations, please do not postpone your plans. Please do not make UPSC a 5-year plan. There is no need for it. The more time your spend in the exam cycle, the harder it will get to get out of it. Here’s your game plan should look like : 1. Phase 1 : Take a Break and Recharge. 30th October (today) till 14th November : Please unwind for the next two weeks. Spend time with family, travel, and spoil yourself with gratifiations. Sounds counter-intuitive, but this is also needed. Half Hearted Mechanical way to studies yields no results. Take a break, and binge-watch that movie or TV series you have been delaying. Consider this period to be your mini vacation before the marathon begins from 15th November onwards. 2. Phase 2 : Structured Study Hours (15th November onwards). Starting November 15th, commit to a schedule. All of this is self-paced learning - so you can pick your favorite slot of the day. a) For working professionals: Around 4-6 hours a day (ideally before your office : 5 AM to 9 AM) b) For students: 6-10 hours a day (Divide the day into 3 parts). This commitment is vital; the next steps build on it, so stay consistent. 3. Phase 3 : The Four Wheel Drive Approach (15th November - February). Starting November 15th, engage in a focused, four-day learning cycle - Each day will have a set theme, and the cycle repeats every four days, allowing you to build momentum and dive deeply into each area without the traditional weekly structure Day 1 - History Drive: Watch 2 episodes focused on historical foundations. Day 2 - Economy Drive: Watch 2 episodes exploring economic fundamentals. Day 3 - Polity, Society, and Governance Drive: Watch 2 episodes covering governance and societal structures. Day 4 - Geography Drive: Watch 2 episodes that map out the physical and human geography basics. Repeat this four-day cycle continuously, completing a full "Four-Wheel Drive" loop every four days. Each cycle keeps your learning well-rounded and dynamic, ensuring you cover the essentials efficiently and consistently. This will ensure that gaps between subjects do not exceed by more than 4 days. This will help you cover 4 crucial subjects that will form the core foundations for your Prelims - in the next 3 months 4. Phase 4 : Environment, Science & Tech, and Revision (February - March). With the core subjects well in hand, turn your focus to Environment and Science & Technology, along with thorough revision of everything covered so far. This month will bridge gaps and deepen your grasp. 5. Phase 5 : Practice and Test-Taking Strategy (15th March onwards) From 15th March, the focus shifts to Prelims testing. You should aim to solve at least 3,000 questions from a test series, plus 10 years of past UPSC papers, revising thoroughly. In the self-paced module Video - you will find dedicated videos on how to efficiently attempt these tests-no unnecessary grind. By 25th May, you’ll be primed to crack the Prelims. After Prelims, don’t take a full week off-rest for two days, then dive back into the Ethics and Essay Module within 10 days. 6. Phase 6 : UPSC Mains Prep, Answer Writing and Optional Subject Following Prelims, we’ll hold live sessions on answer writing and building structured responses. These would be around 10-20 Live Sessions - around Security Issues, Disaster Management, and a few other aspects covered in Mains (For GS Mains). During this phase - focus more on your Optional Subject, Essay, and these 10-20 Live Sessions that we will design. If you’re taking PSIR as an optional, rely entirely on MisFits Episodes and the 8 Seasons. There are 8 seasons of episodes that you can revisit-just make sure you’ve watched them once before Prelims. Post-Prelims, we’ll strengthen your answer writing and critical analysis. In every season - we have covered all topics - with innumerable answer building sessions. 7. Phase 7 : After Mains. Well, I will schedule a few one on ones - to analyze the next steps individually. Enrollment Link for GS Foundational Module (Self-Paced + Hybrid): Starting on 15th November : www.misfits.bet/
Brother is there any example of a country where the middle class have provided the best foundation for a mixed government or the middle class has a significant role for a stable government! I recently started watching videos and now follow you, you make great videos. Also if you answer my first question my second question is can you tell me which form of political government is best for country Democracy, monarchy, republic, communism, dictatorship, theocracy, oligarchy, anarchy, federalism, autocracy, capitalism, Socialism and also suggest some great and important books which will help me understand the politics and neo politics
@@soumalyasoutam4003 many poor people don't have home if u visit villages they live in the one they made with bricks and wood and with other materials, and other question which you raise how can poor don't get affected by the collapse of the country yes the poor and middle class are the one will get affected the rich will stay in other countries
Dearest friend/Sir ji Y didn't I encounter you during my prep phase aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhh I missed it tooo badly BTW LAST BUT NOT LEAST ANY PLANS ON APPSC SIR?
@@sarveshsinha1530I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class. For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys. Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction. But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
Leaving India soon.. what I am getting in return of paying so high taxes? Nothing. I am happy to give 40% tax in any European country and get free health, education for kids, clean air and water.
@@PK-xv4bg Many foreign countries have inclusive societies so that is just false fear mongering...even though India is not fully developed look how open and inclusive we are ..we allow people from other countries to settle and grow....and nowadays people say the world is a global village...and at the end of the day people appreciate hardworking people no matter where they are...
@@PK-xv4bg one should not put too much emphasis on white black colour, sex (gender) or religion it erodes your mind and locks you mentally at one point of view, I don't give a damn about white people one should look after one's own interest and profit....and if it helps other people that's even better....
Income tax killing middle class. No benefits to 2% who are paying income tax and 98% enjoying life not paying taxes. Middle class is really frustrated.
We are in a freebees cycle. Where every gov(center or opp) is given more freebies to win the election. Ask for road infra, hospital education became a crime. In this process many gov became bankrupt just look the debt amount state-wise. Who is the main criminal? We are. yes. We want free electricity not solar. We want a farmer loan weaver, not a rice-cutting machine. We don't vote for productivity. Someone asked for the net to catch fish and became self-employed. Someone always looking for 2kg of fish from gov every month just to survive. In a democracy, people are the main criminals. Logo ko chori pe dukh nahi hay. Chori ka mal use q nahi mila ispe dukh hay.
No point in blaming FM. She delivering what the party & Govt is expecting. Present BJP govt is just another east India company, Only focusing on revenues. Don't Think congress will reverse this, they will continue the same and lure more freebies to win elections. Rich have no issues, either they will evade tax or leave the country. Instead if uplifting Poor will be offered some freebies. But it is the working middle class getting sandwiched. Apologies for grammar mistakes.
BJP messed up big time, but congress is even more incompetent, not even a question. Maybe if the opposition was strong in the first place, BJP would've been kept in check.@@Mysterious-Universe001
We are in a freebees cycle. Where every gov(center or opp) is given more freebies to win the election. Ask for road infra, hospital education became a crime. In this process many gov became bankrupt just look the debt amount state-wise. Who is the main criminal? We are. yes. We want free electricity not solar. We want a farmer loan weaver, not a rice-cutting machine. We don't vote for productivity. Someone asked for the net to catch fish and became self-employed. Someone always looking for 2kg of fish from gov every month just to survive. In a democracy, people are the main criminals. Logo ko chori pe dukh nahi hay. Chori ka mal use q nahi mila ispe dukh hay.
What a beautiful work sir! I agree with you completely. Whats happening now is our dearest fm is taxing crazy on middle class & now middle class is now thinking to leave their good jobs and stay under the tax bracket so that they dont participate any more in nation building!! This is the truth thats happening now. Now India has only rich and poor MARK MY WORDS NO MORE MIDDLE CLASS!!!
@@yudhistirs It has nothing to do with maths exam.. Maybe you mentioned this because most look down if someone makes an error in maths.. Maths complex is real. But if he is wrong with the numbers.. It's a news issue.. Info issue rather than maths...
Bro it is for the artificial diamond Y bcz to get more product and supply it to other countries Bcz of massive demand in market hear if v supply more our export becomes more
I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class. For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys. Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction. But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
Not all FMs have been criticised this badly. She is useless. Most of the time she doesn't have answers to genuine questions. Let her try and fight once from any constituency. She will fail miserably. She cant be mocking and ridiculing people
Middle class rarely bothers. Just passed through Haryana elections lately, and everyone here cared whether the Chief Minister will be from their preferred caste group or not. Democracy won't yield desired result if the electorate is not in the desired mindset.
Although I agree.I have a slightly different take on this matter. Which I would like to add. Most of these ministers don't have an opinion of their own. They have secretaries and bureaucrats working for them, who plan and suggest these policies. These are mostly IAS officers. They don''t care about middle-class. Their life is all set and they are in cahoot with the rich class. They prioritise policies that are good for Poor class over middle-class only when it benefits their career record. Middle class gets left out everytime.
The tax slabs are not inflation-adjusted. That means that we are being forced to pay higher and higher taxes every year. In exchange of every lack of basic facilities like good roads, air, and health services.
My Managerial Economics lecturer taught us This country is trying hard to remove #MiddleClass from the society and turning them into Poor with their policies.
Modi is main culprit here, she is the just face.. Modi loves towards businessmen is not hidden and hate towards common people is clearly visible. Modi is sin for India's middle class dream
These talks are really fascinating to think but the truth of the new India is that I ( a middle class worker) is paying to run a country which is more concerned regarding religious dominance over growth
@@sarveshsinha1530 any household with income of 4-6 lakhs per annum is considered middle class. Just having a tv,fridge,washing machine and a two wheeler puts you at top 10% of Indians list.
@@sarveshsinha1530 I think in india even upto 15 lakh income of a household is considered middle class ( upper middle class). But that's my personal bias so it's better to google about the data.
Bhai idhar ye baat kisiko samajh nhi ayegi. Sabko socialism se pyar hai. Koi bhi limited government nhi chata hai kyuki phir responsibility individual par ajegi aur usse hame daar lagta hai. Sab chate hai ki sari responsibility government par dal do. Isliye to itne taxes hai. Recommendation - listen to 'Milton Friedman' TH-cam videos
And than the economy will collapse. People often elect the people with good personalities, not the person with appropriate qualifications. FM should be always be appointed by the PM.
@@hemishshah6666 PM in this country is also elected solely by "PERSONALITY" not by qualities or qualifications.....as long as finance minister is associated with a party it's a lose-lose situation
Don't ever forget that India had a FM named Manmohan singh and they call him accidental prime minister😂, what a life we are living witnessing all this shit😢
India is one of the greatest man powers in the world.. Instead of utilizing it, and develop the country, govt chose to loot the people to core.. Taxes are the base of the finance of the country.. But what we got in return.. Even corporates have lot of tax exemptions, favoritism.. People are suffering.. Riches are having their families settled in best countries possible.. But normal citizens like us, suffer, suffer, we suffer forever
The judiciary system and all other institutions. Media’s, CBI, ED all have fallen because of this government now they are only puppet of Bjp and do their dirty bidding 😢
Naman, you said that we must make sure our ministers are accountable . For that we must ask questions. But now my question is what should we do if people holding responsible position didn't even answer our questions. They just ignore us. They didn't have to sit for election because from rajya sabha, they can become ministers.
my opinion : weekly public briefing should be made compulsory for ministers where they should be held accountable for their actions and the questions should be asked by decentralized media so that they can't control or fabricate the conference
We say that a woman is an avatar of goddess laxmi who brings fortune and happiness with her. She is not laxmi but Kuber. Who is sucking everything from 1 category of people😢
@sarveshsinha1530 we classify people based on there income then everyone has different slabs. My slabs are as follows. Poor->0 to 3lpa Middle->3-10lpa Upper middle->10-15lpa Rich->15lpa+++ This only counts in hand salary anyally and does not include other components. Genuine Reports also have same slabs that reflect ground reality. Note:-a 10 to 15% fluctuations in the slab limits can be observed as well
Just because some of us glorify english so much that we are suffering now with such tax scam our FM will just speak in english abd get away with the counter questions and majority of Indians would just let it go, so just used local language so that everyone can soeak up 4:23
For someone as young as you are, hats off for your insights, analysis etc. As someone who is of the strangled middle class, i thank you for bringing this wealth of knowledge to the young people who are the future of this country. I belong to an age which saw honest politicians with vision, with heart and who felt for tbe poor and marginalized and what i see today scares me. Not for myself as i have almost come to the end of the line, but for the young starry eyed citizens who despite having earned certificates after years and years of toil will be brushed aside by people who, because of their ancestry will take away their jobs, scarcely care if they lived died or even had enough to put food on their tables. God help india. Her people are wonderful but if they stay silent, years from now they will be silent watchers of theur own destruction. We did not even see a century of freedom and already we can see the ominous writing on the wall. God bless india! My india! Thank you Mr. Naman Shrivastava for your great work. God bless you, you will be remembered in years to come.
i hate such ministers that cant answers questions (i cant see energy in there answers really !!! or any other solutions )but when its about party reputation i don't get how they have to much energy to talk
See states like Karnataka, Himachal, Telangana going into debt crisis don't have even money to pay to civil servants what do you tell about opposition it is even worse
We are in a freebees cycle. Where every gov(center or opp) is given more freebies to win the election. Ask for road infra, hospital education became a crime. In this process many gov became bankrupt just look the debt amount state-wise. Who is the main criminal? We are. yes. We want free electricity not solar. We want a farmer loan weaver, not a rice-cutting machine. We don't vote for productivity. Someone asked for the net to catch fish and became self-employed. Someone always looking for 2kg of fish from gov every month just to survive. In a democracy, people are the main criminals. Logo ko chori pe dukh nahi hay. Chori ka mal use q nahi mila ispe dukh hay.
She will be our FM for a long long time. It does not matter if you post such videos. She is doing what was assigned to her perfectly. She should start a coaching center for FMs across the world, let citizen of every other country pay the tax.
Answer is simple : we have already given waive off and write off of loans worth 25 lakhs of crores. And to them given away some public sectors, which was giving us minimum income to the country. Mostly Gujaratis one caste are benefited. Banks went weak, so a huge sum of money was released from RBI to avoid banks getting closed, plus we have combined and changed many banks to avoid closure. Collected minimum balance fine, to elevated service charges, elevated minimum balance. And finally to fill the financial deficit, started collecting more tax from the people.
naman sir please make a video on how indian manufacturing failed. i saw a recent article where it said that after 10 years of make in india the manufacturing is back like 2014 and our fdi is at an all time low. please enlighten us sir and what us citizens can do?
@@mayureshrasam1708I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class. For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys. Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction. But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
C'mon Make in India has been extremely successful our FDI was rising pretty well and our exports in many sectors is all time high. Recently, there are some conflicts with Five eyes, which is having some impact. But we can't do anything if they want to worsen the relationship we are handling it well.
@@GondTribeyeh sab comment karne ke kitne paise milein. Commented same illogical shit on every other comment. I truly admire your stupendous stupidity.
I never thought about this and wow! this is actually a solution .. has any country ever has this kind of govermental arrangement before where the middle class are the government ? ...
Untill and unless middle class systematically organises itself and gives a pushback they wont take it seriously. Electorally middle class doesnt have the numbers to influence the policy but financially they can create major dent. All FMCG & Car companies are worried that there is less consumption, becuase middle class doesn't have money to splurge. Now let's make it even more apparent. Lets start reducing our spending by 2 to 5 percent every months. Let the government coffers feel the pinch.
Well said, I have dropped my expenses to bare necessities (roughly 10k per month) living in Mumbai, after this year's budget came out. Band karado sabke business, if the Government doesn't care about middle class who effectively run this country.
she isn't accidental though, deliberation on part of cronies, she taxes middle income businesses to make sure a few expand in exchange for political reasons.
I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class. For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys. Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction. But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
"Vande Mataram! You are focused on the issues, but what is the solution? We want a solution-please express it in a single word, without any ambiguity."
You asked a really good question but to the wrong person. He is giving you areas where you need to focus but for change & solution you need to ask it to Government.
@@rkc342 its not about Modi and congress ...its more about India's political administrative structure. reason you are going to be a political stooge and guys like u deserve this system.
Sir as middle class how can we buy property flat, land. Cost is in crore beyond our reach. We land in taking loan and end up life long EMI with high interest rate. What will happen to next generation. How will they survive? 😢
Next generation of rich will live in or leave India. Middle and lower class will become poorer and will live a harsher life than we lived while breathing toxic air in a toxic society. Sadly this is the reality.
Already left n never coming back. Fresh air, unadulterated food, fresh water, rule of law, community support, lower taxes n interest rates, affordable health care and education cost are enough for me to ensure a safer n prospering environment for my family. Even if i have to change my religion for the upliftment of my family i will not even think for a second. This vande matram, bharat mata ki jai all that are of no use but a political tool. These leaders dont care abt us and the only thing we should care are our parents cuz without them you would have been begging on streets while trashing your patriotism in a garbage bin.
@spikenraul nobody wants to meddle in your puny little matters that are not even worth of an autorikshaw driver’s time. Stay in your polluted corrupt hell hole bubble and as a free global citizen I am free to express my views on global matters. You can take your advice, roll it tight and shove it up in your chaiwala leader.
True nobody knows her am from south thalapathy Vijay is the right person he is kind everyone knows him he can win anywer in tamilnadu with just his aura. I demand the govt to look for ministers who has good following to occupy the post of fm.
@@peddintilokesh4616 a person who is from middle class never done any politics and has just a motive to develop country is a right person like me but I'm 17 but preparing how i would do things when i will become PM
Itbwill destroy the farming sector by corporates they are waiting for the farmers to sell land, presently govt is tring to reverse the problem created by earler govt, I believe govt trying to bring native seed for sustainable farming and fertilizers and scrapping green revolution, Now depopulation by economic pressure
Very enlighten to watch your intelligence on subjects of national importance with facts. Keep the good work.. we hope to see the light at end of tunnel.
Yeah the line "the best political community is the one where the middle class holds a significant influence".... We need to know how we can live a better life?.. As naman sir said the rich will leave, poor hv nothing and middle-class is the one who suffers. Why the hell on the planet earth in India we need to buy health insurance paying 18% gst, that too when we are saving it from the salaries that they deduct tax from?.... This is a serious issue... Today's system is just so bristle
Hey make video on Karnatka. I am from Karnataka,and they said there will be no development because funds are not sufficient and used up issuing freebies. Please help people knie about this .
@@English-cp5hs fulfilled my responsibilities by paying a lot of tax. Now I am where I deserve to be. You enjoy the tax I paid. What changes have you made till now??🤣🤣
Naman sir, I do pray for revolution, our country should be ruled by independent local familiar person who is humble and corruption free who can make India proud, instead of these corrupt politicians who loot taxpayers money fully selfish in nature. There are so many in the list and you are one in the list.
But we Indians know best and have experienced best, the success and peace in middle Eastern monarchies. UAE, Qatar, Bahrain, Oman, Saudi. They have peace, they have harmony, economically sustainable and constant new opportunities. Someone should do a study on why it works even though ppl keep talking about how bad it is to have a monarchy anymore.
@venaist Do you know that Dubai doesn't have any oil anymore and hasn't had for the last 15 years or so?? It still remains a prime destination for every nationality on the planet. Tourism and trade. that's Dubai's main economy. India has far greater potential to tap those 2 sectors. I remain convinced that Indians are better off being ruled by a family of kings who know to manage like the Middle Eastern States... we are a bunch of unruly misfits who need to be disciplined and not given choices. It's gone far enough.
@@rohitrevankar7674do u know dubai still owns oil and produces enough for her and do u kbow dubai have investments and land owned in africa, there is mining and industrial material governed by abudubi majority of african gold goes to arab countries especially dubai, and agricultural produces also, they dont have standing army and they relies on US for that😂 bad logic of yours , do u think non tax country and tourism is what abudhabi exist u r wrong
@veerar8203 Dude Abu Dhabi and Dubai economies are independent. UAE doesn't operate as one nation when it comes to their own financial system. They have one currency but each Emirate operates independently. Dubai is mostly a tourism and trade economy. I am speaking facts not making up theories. You think I'll talk about it if I haven't been there myself? My family has been there since the 90s. Don't bother mentioning Agricultural produce, it's mostly for the local market not exports. All of UAE's foreign investment comes from Abu Dhabi not Dubai.
Naman ji, you have told the every middle class worker story who is crushed by tax, tax, tax.. This Nirmala Sitaraman is height of arrogance. Everything is taxed including basic necessities food, clothing, house, health education. I voted for BJP thinking that they do good, they did good by increasing taxes.. God save middle class, God save India.
Is there a way to impeach any minister ? I mean is there a legal way to impeach a minister by the public ? There should be something like that in a “democratic” country right ??
Sorry it's a long comment but it's worth a read! Aristotle's emphasis on the middle class as a stabilizing force in society remains profoundly relevant in contemporary India, particularly amidst widespread dissatisfaction with the finance minister and economic policies. In India, the middle class has historically been the engine of economic growth, consumer spending, and innovation. It aspires for upward mobility and demands accountability from policymakers. However, in recent years, rising income inequality, inflation, and perceptions of elitist policies have alienated this demographic. A diminished or disillusioned middle class risks destabilizing democratic institutions, fueling populist movements, and exacerbating social divides. For India's progress, it is crucial to realign fiscal and economic policies to address middle-class concerns, ensuring inclusive growth that revitalizes Aristotle’s vision of a balanced and harmonious society.
These Ministers are always supported by those citizens who are heavily worried about Hindutva than India. Those citizens who want infra, economy, stability and scientific temperament are minority unfortunately. Leaving the country is the best thing one can do for themselves without spending their life for this society. Sorry
yeah, you are wrong, do you want your house to be taken by WAQF board overnight, I have just lost my wife's ancestral property to WAQF. You will only understand the pain if it happens to you
@@sathishkumar-dt4zc as a human I deeply apologize on behalf of a section of Humanity which have done wrong to you, but As A tax payer of India, I must worry about my family's material welfare as well in terms of Infra, services, security, justice and income here. I am not wrong. I can't compromise on economic prosperity for hindu sentiments. Sorry.
@@fireStorm070 toh fir hindutva ka RR q Kiya tu😂😂jaise tujhe apni family ki padi hai..humko hindutva ki padi hai smja..aacha hua chala gya desh chord kar..tere jaise napunsako ki jarurat b nahi yaha pe
I don’t even care about the burden! If a staff engineer from uber who has 90lpa base pays 25-33 lakhs of direct tax is killed by a rich MLA, nobody gives a shit not even the media whereas someone whose sleeping on footpath dies it’s a national issue! Life value should be subjective rather than objective
Dude, those who were sleeping on footpath, were killed. Only ravindra Patil til his last breath keep saying that it is the salman khan who was driving car while being drunk heavily. Despite getting threats from underworld he never changed his bayaan.
You talked about agitations and toppling government is Bangladesh but very cleverly suppressed the starting reason of this ''movement''. And the reason was introduction of Quota in Jobs, depriving the merit. In India, most of the middle class private job holders are being deprived from govt. jobs and higher education due to SC, ST, OBC, EW, Sports Quotas. Did you see any agitation/protest? So, not only high taxes but raise your voice against reservation (quota) which deprives most of the middle class merits. Many meritorious middle class students are compelled to leave India because of this injustice....
Nice deflection.yet what he said was true.this fm is clueless and keeps taxing middle class and favours buissness class. Imagine taxing medicines more than diamonds.is it the fault of sc/st reservations that such kind if bizzare tax slabs are imposed on middle class.stop digressing and accept that the present government is inept
Which category do you fall in ? K2a? Pappuparty? Problem with people like you is very simple, no earnings so no taxes, no respect towards other religions so call everyone bhakts who don't support your party, all in all - no work but muah se hag do bas.. bhaak MC
high tax in India destroying middle Class that's true but giving that logic she is a Rajya Sabha MP that's why not accountable to the people of India that so stupid opinion. because if this is true then we will only call them real Indian citizens who paid taxes and those who don't pay taxes they are not Indians or care about this country. Aristotle choose middle class , but he also advocate Slavery, gender discrimination etc. don't use selective statements give them full picture.
I am sorry to say this, and I do agree with pretty much everything on this video, this is a monologue about the problems we have. The problem with this video is that it doesn’t really talk about any solutions. How are we supposed to fix all of this? Governance by the middle class. Full stop. But how do you get a government run by the middle class? That is the problem with this channel. It seems more like scathing commentary on the issues, like any other contemporary media outlet, without any discussions on how to improve.
@@sumitalwarI think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class. For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys. Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction. But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
Bhai. Switzerland doesn't get anything done. If india follows that model you will not even see cleaning people working and you'll have to go and throw your own garbage outside the city.
Given that running for political office in India often demands a budget exceeding 1 crore for campaign expenses, how can a middle-class candidate realistically compete in elections?
Agreed with the quote. In today’s context, the Center govt is for the riches and my state govt (West Bengal) is for the poor. The middle class is being slow-poisoned to eventual death.
Yes but to solve India's problem and to develop India...Division of India is necessary. India should be divided into 10-12 small independent countries then only they all can develop. All those countries should be divided politically...not on religious or caste lines.
Rajya sabha MP never bhi given ministers which are linked with middle and poor class because they never faced those problems and they never answerable to people because they never selected by people
Arguing about the complexity of tax policy is important. I'm not saying the BJP government is perfect, but reducing the tax burden on the middle class is a challenging issue. If taxes are lowered, who will make up the difference? If we target millionaires and billionaires too aggressively, they might choose to leave India, which would be a significant loss. While they do find ways to minimize their tax bills, it's essential to recognize that they also create many jobs and contribute significantly to the economy. Simply reducing the tax burden on the middle class or cutting GST won't address the economic challenges of a large country like India. It’s overly simplistic to assume that lowering taxes alone will improve the economy. I don't see any point on this discussion. When it comes to the facilities we receive from the government, it's important to acknowledge that the quality of service often falls short. This is not a new issue; it's rooted in a corrupt political system. No party can win elections without substantial funding, which complicates the situation. If the BJP were to avoid engaging in controversial political tactics, it would be challenging for them to maintain their position. What we often see is just a high-level overview, but the reality at the ground level is much more complex.
Recently i brought car and i found average suvs has around 55% taxes (28% gst and rest cess) The car which costs only 10 lakhs people are paying 15 lakhs. Additionally you have to pay RTO registration also
First off, there is absolutely no need to make UPSC a 5 years plan - it is DEVASTATING.
If you are eligible to write the exam in 2025 and can dedicate around 6-10 hours per day to your preparations, please do not postpone your plans. Please do not make UPSC a 5-year plan. There is no need for it. The more time your spend in the exam cycle, the harder it will get to get out of it.
Here’s your game plan should look like :
1. Phase 1 : Take a Break and Recharge. 30th October (today) till 14th November : Please unwind for the next two weeks. Spend time with family, travel, and spoil yourself with gratifiations. Sounds counter-intuitive, but this is also needed.
Half Hearted Mechanical way to studies yields no results. Take a break, and binge-watch that movie or TV series you have been delaying. Consider this period to be your mini vacation before the marathon begins from 15th November onwards.
2. Phase 2 : Structured Study Hours (15th November onwards).
Starting November 15th, commit to a schedule. All of this is self-paced learning - so you can pick your favorite slot of the day.
a) For working professionals: Around 4-6 hours a day (ideally before your office : 5 AM to 9 AM)
b) For students: 6-10 hours a day (Divide the day into 3 parts).
This commitment is vital; the next steps build on it, so stay consistent.
3. Phase 3 : The Four Wheel Drive Approach (15th November - February).
Starting November 15th, engage in a focused, four-day learning cycle -
Each day will have a set theme, and the cycle repeats every four days, allowing you to build momentum and dive deeply into each area without the traditional weekly structure
Day 1 - History Drive: Watch 2 episodes focused on historical foundations.
Day 2 - Economy Drive: Watch 2 episodes exploring economic fundamentals.
Day 3 - Polity, Society, and Governance Drive: Watch 2 episodes covering governance and societal structures.
Day 4 - Geography Drive: Watch 2 episodes that map out the physical and human geography basics.
Repeat this four-day cycle continuously, completing a full "Four-Wheel Drive" loop every four days. Each cycle keeps your learning well-rounded and dynamic, ensuring you cover the essentials efficiently and consistently.
This will ensure that gaps between subjects do not exceed by more than 4 days. This will help you cover 4 crucial subjects that will form the core foundations for your Prelims - in the next 3 months
4. Phase 4 : Environment, Science & Tech, and Revision (February - March).
With the core subjects well in hand, turn your focus to Environment and Science & Technology, along with thorough revision of everything covered so far. This month will bridge gaps and deepen your grasp.
5. Phase 5 : Practice and Test-Taking Strategy (15th March onwards)
From 15th March, the focus shifts to Prelims testing. You should aim to solve at least 3,000 questions from a test series, plus 10 years of past UPSC papers, revising thoroughly. In the self-paced module Video - you will find dedicated videos on how to efficiently attempt these tests-no unnecessary grind.
By 25th May, you’ll be primed to crack the Prelims. After Prelims, don’t take a full week off-rest for two days, then dive back into the Ethics and Essay Module within 10 days.
6. Phase 6 : UPSC Mains Prep, Answer Writing and Optional Subject
Following Prelims, we’ll hold live sessions on answer writing and building structured responses. These would be around 10-20 Live Sessions - around Security Issues, Disaster Management, and a few other aspects covered in Mains (For GS Mains).
During this phase - focus more on your Optional Subject, Essay, and these 10-20 Live Sessions that we will design.
If you’re taking PSIR as an optional, rely entirely on MisFits Episodes and the 8 Seasons. There are 8 seasons of episodes that you can revisit-just make sure you’ve watched them once before Prelims. Post-Prelims, we’ll strengthen your answer writing and critical analysis. In every season - we have covered all topics - with innumerable answer building sessions.
7. Phase 7 : After Mains. Well, I will schedule a few one on ones - to analyze the next steps individually.
Enrollment Link for GS Foundational Module (Self-Paced + Hybrid): Starting on 15th November : www.misfits.bet/
Brother is there any example of a country where the middle class have provided the best foundation for a mixed government or the middle class has a significant role for a stable government! I recently started watching videos and now follow you, you make great videos. Also if you answer my first question my second question is can you tell me which form of political government is best for country Democracy, monarchy, republic, communism, dictatorship, theocracy, oligarchy, anarchy, federalism, autocracy, capitalism, Socialism and also suggest some great and important books which will help me understand the politics and neo politics
@@soumalyasoutam4003 many poor people don't have home if u visit villages they live in the one they made with bricks and wood and with other materials, and other question which you raise how can poor don't get affected by the collapse of the country yes the poor and middle class are the one will get affected the rich will stay in other countries
@@soumalyasoutam4003 we need more educated people like Dr Manmohan Singh these people will save the country like he saved.
Election Commission and IAS officers are the reasons why India is still a poor country. Even Singapore has developed far more than India.
Dearest friend/Sir ji
Y didn't I encounter you during my prep phase aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaahhhhhhhhhhhh
I missed it tooo badly
BTW LAST BUT NOT LEAST
ANY PLANS ON APPSC SIR?
We live in a country where leaving the country is the biggest achievement .
Sorry not sorry .
I feel the same way…
I am already waiting for my visa.
@@SonuSharma-ys3jrfor which country? And what qualifications?
I left last year 🇦🇺😊
you are not wrong.
She will be remembered always how she looting poor middle class
Election Commission and IAS officers are the reasons why India is still a poor country. Even Singapore has developed far more than India.
you are not even above poverty line
upto how much income is consider as middle class?
@@yudhistirs landvhakt apne 2rs comment lele
@@sarveshsinha1530I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class.
For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys.
Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction.
But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
Leaving India soon.. what I am getting in return of paying so high taxes? Nothing.
I am happy to give 40% tax in any European country and get free health, education for kids, clean air and water.
Bro how to go EU countries
Bro which country are you thinking about and are you going to do job or business there....
India should pose 50% tax on all assets of people leaving india like us
@@PK-xv4bg Many foreign countries have inclusive societies so that is just false fear mongering...even though India is not fully developed look how open and inclusive we are ..we allow people from other countries to settle and grow....and nowadays people say the world is a global village...and at the end of the day people appreciate hardworking people no matter where they are...
@@PK-xv4bg one should not put too much emphasis on white black colour, sex (gender) or religion it erodes your mind and locks you mentally at one point of view, I don't give a damn about white people one should look after one's own interest and profit....and if it helps other people that's even better....
Income tax killing middle class. No benefits to 2% who are paying income tax and 98% enjoying life not paying taxes. Middle class is really frustrated.
90% Indian population is under privileged, they can't afford their basic essentials, they are not enjoying themselves,
2% are paying both direct & indirect taxes but everyone is paying indirect taxes. be it upper, middle or lower class
95%*
We are in a freebees cycle. Where every gov(center or opp) is given more freebies to win the election. Ask for road infra, hospital education became a crime. In this process many gov became bankrupt just look the debt amount state-wise. Who is the main criminal? We are. yes. We want free electricity not solar. We want a farmer loan weaver, not a rice-cutting machine. We don't vote for productivity. Someone asked for the net to catch fish and became self-employed. Someone always looking for 2kg of fish from gov every month just to survive. In a democracy, people are the main criminals. Logo ko chori pe dukh nahi hay. Chori ka mal use q nahi mila ispe dukh hay.
Tax is a legal scam in India taxes like Sweden and service like Africa
No point in blaming FM. She delivering what the party & Govt is expecting. Present BJP govt is just another east India company, Only focusing on revenues. Don't Think congress will reverse this, they will continue the same and lure more freebies to win elections. Rich have no issues, either they will evade tax or leave the country. Instead if uplifting Poor will be offered some freebies. But it is the working middle class getting sandwiched. Apologies for grammar mistakes.
A rare saner view.
Why not blame her , she can very clearly say that she is incompetent to play the role of fm
Sure but you got no idea what congress will do, isn’t that just a bias?
BJP messed up big time, but congress is even more incompetent, not even a question. Maybe if the opposition was strong in the first place, BJP would've been kept in check.@@Mysterious-Universe001
We are in a freebees cycle. Where every gov(center or opp) is given more freebies to win the election. Ask for road infra, hospital education became a crime. In this process many gov became bankrupt just look the debt amount state-wise. Who is the main criminal? We are. yes. We want free electricity not solar. We want a farmer loan weaver, not a rice-cutting machine. We don't vote for productivity. Someone asked for the net to catch fish and became self-employed. Someone always looking for 2kg of fish from gov every month just to survive. In a democracy, people are the main criminals. Logo ko chori pe dukh nahi hay. Chori ka mal use q nahi mila ispe dukh hay.
The worst FM in India's history...
Na bro, we have had so many bad finance ministers. She is up there but not the worst.
India once had 98% tax rate. You still think she is the worst FM?
She is Tax minister not fm
Election Commission and IAS officers are the reasons why India is still a poor country. Even Singapore has developed far more than India.
@@User-mncbjlfjrebxkl98% tax? 😂
We didn’t even voted for her, still she is FM
Shame on our parliamentary rules & regulations 😂
See what caste privilege can buy you ….
You don't vote for the Finance Minister, id iot.
@@yudhistirs she was not a candidate in the election id iot.
She was later nominated as MP
@@yudhistirswe too know that ministeries are given by PM and don't throw a word on other person. Knowledge should make you kind not rude
Modi decides the cabinet. Be more focused in ur criticism
She is the worst minister ever
Yeah but what can we do
She is a puppet of Modi.
Choosen by worst mass ever.
Worst people of decade
Face to face bolna chahiye nirmala tai you are worst
😢😢😢 because she does not eat garlic 😮😮😮
This should be distributed on all social media platforms. Quality and logically sound content.
What a beautiful work sir! I agree with you completely. Whats happening now is our dearest fm is taxing crazy on middle class & now middle class is now thinking to leave their good jobs and stay under the tax bracket so that they dont participate any more in nation building!! This is the truth thats happening now. Now India has only rich and poor MARK MY WORDS NO MORE MIDDLE CLASS!!!
18% Tax on medicines and Air purifiers and On Diamonds 0.25% tax.
This is 56 inch ka Modinomics.
All hail supreme leader 😂
Did you give your mathematics exam? who said there is 0.25% tax on diamonds? your pappa?
@@yudhistirs It has nothing to do with maths exam.. Maybe you mentioned this because most look down if someone makes an error in maths.. Maths complex is real.
But if he is wrong with the numbers.. It's a news issue.. Info issue rather than maths...
Bro it is for the artificial diamond
Y bcz to get more product and supply it to other countries
Bcz of massive demand in market hear if v supply more our export becomes more
Why they are not changing her? Or even Biren singh
@@multifocalshortz3360 biren singh did not killed people. Christians kuki terrorist killed people in Manipur. Why change biren singh?
A minister should not have this level of anger.
Ya but here we are😂
I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class.
For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys.
Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction.
But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
The minister is also human. Besides, she is trolled badly so there will be some reaction.
Not all FMs have been criticised this badly. She is useless. Most of the time she doesn't have answers to genuine questions. Let her try and fight once from any constituency. She will fail miserably. She cant be mocking and ridiculing people
😮😮😮😮😮worst fm
But better than tughlak😅😅😅😅😅
Middle class rarely bothers. Just passed through Haryana elections lately, and everyone here cared whether the Chief Minister will be from their preferred caste group or not.
Democracy won't yield desired result if the electorate is not in the desired mindset.
Educating the electorate is what the video is trying to do.
Although I agree.I have a slightly different take on this matter. Which I would like to add. Most of these ministers don't have an opinion of their own. They have secretaries and bureaucrats working for them, who plan and suggest these policies. These are mostly IAS officers. They don''t care about middle-class. Their life is all set and they are in cahoot with the rich class. They prioritise policies that are good for Poor class over middle-class only when it benefits their career record. Middle class gets left out everytime.
A mean faced and a mean hearted person. Does not even care for the people. Power to the head
The tax slabs are not inflation-adjusted. That means that we are being forced to pay higher and higher taxes every year. In exchange of every lack of basic facilities like good roads, air, and health services.
My Managerial Economics lecturer taught us This country is trying hard to remove #MiddleClass from the society and turning them into Poor with their policies.
Modi is main culprit here, she is the just face.. Modi loves towards businessmen is not hidden and hate towards common people is clearly visible. Modi is sin for India's middle class dream
Do you know how many expenses and compliances a businessman has to deal with?
@@yudhistirsshut up man. Check how many airports were allowed for one entity to hold and what Modi government did to help adani
I guess he's talking about industrialists and businessmen with good political connections. Compliances are easy for them
True
Businesses and servicemen are running country not you communist
These talks are really fascinating to think but the truth of the new India is that I ( a middle class worker) is paying to run a country which is more concerned regarding religious dominance over growth
how much income is considered middle class?
@@sarveshsinha1530 any household with income of 4-6 lakhs per annum is considered middle class.
Just having a tv,fridge,washing machine and a two wheeler puts you at top 10% of Indians list.
@@narendrameena684 so the person wo doesn't come in income tax bracket is considered middle class.
So, up to 7.75L is middle class.
@@sarveshsinha1530 I think in india even upto 15 lakh income of a household is considered middle class ( upper middle class). But that's my personal bias so it's better to google about the data.
@@sarveshsinha1530if you can go for movies once a month and eat popcorn and later eat at a restaurant is middle class bracket 😅😅😅😅
Its sad that as an indian, i now don't want have anything to do with India
Only Solution: Limit the state.
1. Bring US 1st Amendment.
2. Politicians shouldn't have power. People should have power.
What about Gun culture
@@suneely3122 However we dont need gun rights here.
in US people control politician and in india politician control people. ngl india is going down.
Bhai idhar ye baat kisiko samajh nhi ayegi. Sabko socialism se pyar hai. Koi bhi limited government nhi chata hai kyuki phir responsibility individual par ajegi aur usse hame daar lagta hai. Sab chate hai ki sari responsibility government par dal do. Isliye to itne taxes hai.
Recommendation - listen to 'Milton Friedman' TH-cam videos
@@suneely3122 it is second amendment.
FM should be a elected leader not selected politician😢
Today 99 percent of elected ministers are corrupt
And than the economy will collapse.
People often elect the people with good personalities, not the person with appropriate qualifications.
FM should be always be appointed by the PM.
@@hemishshah6666 PM in this country is also elected solely by "PERSONALITY" not by qualities or qualifications.....as long as finance minister is associated with a party it's a lose-lose situation
@@hashiramasenju2248 Gujarat model was personality and not work? Are you guys brainwashed against the govt already?
@@hemishshah6666he is just taking up his agendas against govt.
,She must Resign
No she will not resign because vo lasan pyaaz nai khaati😏
No no she must be PUNISHED in such a way she shouldn't think for becoming finance minister again.
U mean RS or Minister post , She couldn't even win a LS seat
Nehru resign karo. dhokebaaz gandhi..
Modify must resign
Don't ever forget that India had a FM named Manmohan singh and they call him accidental prime minister😂, what a life we are living witnessing all this shit😢
India is one of the greatest man powers in the world.. Instead of utilizing it, and develop the country, govt chose to loot the people to core.. Taxes are the base of the finance of the country.. But what we got in return.. Even corporates have lot of tax exemptions, favoritism.. People are suffering.. Riches are having their families settled in best countries possible.. But normal citizens like us, suffer, suffer, we suffer forever
No Justice in India...#Justiceisdead
The judiciary system and all other institutions. Media’s, CBI, ED all have fallen because of this government now they are only puppet of Bjp and do their dirty bidding 😢
Naman, you said that we must make sure our ministers are accountable . For that we must ask questions.
But now my question is what should we do if people holding responsible position didn't even answer our questions.
They just ignore us.
They didn't have to sit for election because from rajya sabha, they can become ministers.
my opinion : weekly public briefing should be made compulsory for ministers where they should be held accountable for their actions and the questions should be asked by decentralized media so that they can't control or fabricate the conference
Jokes =justice=media ,all are same brother
Dictatorship under the garb of democracy
Apart from that they have created million of andhbhakt. They will start trolling you if you ask questions to the government.
@@ganjameowisn't that what Parliament was once supposed be?....
We say that a woman is an avatar of goddess laxmi who brings fortune and happiness with her.
She is not laxmi but Kuber. Who is sucking everything from 1 category of people😢
upto how much income one is considered middle class?
@sarveshsinha1530 we classify people based on there income then everyone has different slabs.
My slabs are as follows.
Poor->0 to 3lpa
Middle->3-10lpa
Upper middle->10-15lpa
Rich->15lpa+++
This only counts in hand salary anyally and does not include other components.
Genuine Reports also have same slabs that reflect ground reality.
Note:-a 10 to 15% fluctuations in the slab limits can be observed as well
@@priyangshu2743it depends where you live😢
In Bengaluru 5 laks for a bachelor is peanuts 🥜
No girl wants to even date you😢😢😢😢
@xaviercolaco same in allahabad
Just because some of us glorify english so much that we are suffering now with such tax scam our FM will just speak in english abd get away with the counter questions and majority of Indians would just let it go, so just used local language so that everyone can soeak up 4:23
For someone as young as you are, hats off for your insights, analysis etc. As someone who is of the strangled middle class, i thank you for bringing this wealth of knowledge to the young people who are the future of this country. I belong to an age which saw honest politicians with vision, with heart and who felt for tbe poor and marginalized and what i see today scares me. Not for myself as i have almost come to the end of the line, but for the young starry eyed citizens who despite having earned certificates after years and years of toil will be brushed aside by people who, because of their ancestry will take away their jobs, scarcely care if they lived died or even had enough to put food on their tables. God help india. Her people are wonderful but if they stay silent, years from now they will be silent watchers of theur own destruction. We did not even see a century of freedom and already we can see the ominous writing on the wall. God bless india! My india! Thank you Mr. Naman Shrivastava for your great work. God bless you, you will be remembered in years to come.
i hate such ministers that cant answers questions (i cant see energy in there answers really !!! or any other solutions )but when its about party reputation i don't get how they have to much energy to talk
See states like Karnataka, Himachal, Telangana going into debt crisis don't have even money to pay to civil servants what do you tell about opposition it is even worse
@@lakshmikrishna5660 then stop taking money from Karnataka and give to bimaru States
The way they are putting pressure on bank employees is beyond the bearable pain...!!
Suit-boot ki sarkar
Just don't work man. They can't fire you
If shamelessness has a face : tai
😂
😂😂😂
We are in a freebees cycle. Where every gov(center or opp) is given more freebies to win the election. Ask for road infra, hospital education became a crime. In this process many gov became bankrupt just look the debt amount state-wise. Who is the main criminal? We are. yes. We want free electricity not solar. We want a farmer loan weaver, not a rice-cutting machine. We don't vote for productivity. Someone asked for the net to catch fish and became self-employed. Someone always looking for 2kg of fish from gov every month just to survive. In a democracy, people are the main criminals. Logo ko chori pe dukh nahi hay. Chori ka mal use q nahi mila ispe dukh hay.
She will be our FM for a long long time. It does not matter if you post such videos. She is doing what was assigned to her perfectly. She should start a coaching center for FMs across the world, let citizen of every other country pay the tax.
It's the Govt..not the FM who is merely a pawn to follow the leader in every possible way.. whether arrogance or attitude or anything
Answer is simple : we have already given waive off and write off of loans worth 25 lakhs of crores.
And to them given away some public sectors, which was giving us minimum income to the country.
Mostly Gujaratis one caste are benefited. Banks went weak, so a huge sum of money was released from RBI to avoid banks getting closed, plus we have combined and changed many banks to avoid closure.
Collected minimum balance fine, to elevated service charges, elevated minimum balance.
And finally to fill the financial deficit, started collecting more tax from the people.
Then why the FM isn't saying something like this instead of shutting down questions.
absolutely none of what you said is correct. Not that I like the FM but it's because of idiots like you that politics goes on with public money.
Entire political science post graduate 🤪 is making a good job of running the 3rd largest economy of the world and we are vikshit very soon😅😅😅😅
Why she is always in quarrel mode......😂😂
Frustration. You know what kind😅😅😅
When people don't have answers they do.
Because she is not able to handle the pressure
Women 😂
Sexual frustration
naman sir please make a video on how indian manufacturing failed. i saw a recent article where it said that after 10 years of make in india the manufacturing is back like 2014 and our fdi is at an all time low. please enlighten us sir and what us citizens can do?
Can do nothing, no scope for progress under this govt
@@Koshabhh I can't say it is complete failure but it is not a moderate success either.
@@mayureshrasam1708I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class.
For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys.
Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction.
But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
C'mon Make in India has been extremely successful our FDI was rising pretty well and our exports in many sectors is all time high.
Recently, there are some conflicts with Five eyes, which is having some impact. But we can't do anything if they want to worsen the relationship we are handling it well.
@@GondTribeyeh sab comment karne ke kitne paise milein. Commented same illogical shit on every other comment. I truly admire your stupendous stupidity.
This is my first video of yours. I am impressed by the facts and knowledge you are sharing. Thank you so much.
I never thought about this and wow! this is actually a solution .. has any country ever has this kind of govermental arrangement before where the middle class are the government ? ...
Untill and unless middle class systematically organises itself and gives a pushback they wont take it seriously. Electorally middle class doesnt have the numbers to influence the policy but financially they can create major dent. All FMCG & Car companies are worried that there is less consumption, becuase middle class doesn't have money to splurge. Now let's make it even more apparent. Lets start reducing our spending by 2 to 5 percent every months. Let the government coffers feel the pinch.
Well said, I have dropped my expenses to bare necessities (roughly 10k per month) living in Mumbai, after this year's budget came out. Band karado sabke business, if the Government doesn't care about middle class who effectively run this country.
She is an accidental FM...
Election Commission and IAS officers are the reasons why India is still a poor country. Even Singapore has developed far more than India.
she isn't accidental though, deliberation on part of cronies, she taxes middle income businesses to make sure a few expand in exchange for political reasons.
I think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class.
For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys.
Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction.
But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
But why did p.m select her if she was that bad. ??
@@Shabbir1277her husband is more sensible and intelligent 😢😢😢
"Vande Mataram! You are focused on the issues, but what is the solution? We want a solution-please express it in a single word, without any ambiguity."
Simple Don't vote Godi 😂
@@rkc342and then what vote khangress? We don't have capable ministers.
You asked a really good question but to the wrong person. He is giving you areas where you need to focus but for change & solution you need to ask it to Government.
@@anmolgupta3203We can't question accountability of a simple clerk in any government office! Forget about ministers or bureaucrats.
@@rkc342 its not about Modi and congress ...its more about India's political administrative structure. reason you are going to be a political stooge and guys like u deserve this system.
Sir as middle class how can we buy property flat, land. Cost is in crore beyond our reach. We land in taking loan and end up life long EMI with high interest rate. What will happen to next generation. How will they survive? 😢
Next generation of rich will live in or leave India. Middle and lower class will become poorer and will live a harsher life than we lived while breathing toxic air in a toxic society. Sadly this is the reality.
Already left n never coming back. Fresh air, unadulterated food, fresh water, rule of law, community support, lower taxes n interest rates, affordable health care and education cost are enough for me to ensure a safer n prospering environment for my family. Even if i have to change my religion for the upliftment of my family i will not even think for a second. This vande matram, bharat mata ki jai all that are of no use but a political tool. These leaders dont care abt us and the only thing we should care are our parents cuz without them you would have been begging on streets while trashing your patriotism in a garbage bin.
which country did you go to ?
Thank you for leaving.And please don't interfere in our internal matters
@spikenraul nobody wants to meddle in your puny little matters that are not even worth of an autorikshaw driver’s time. Stay in your polluted corrupt hell hole bubble and as a free global citizen I am free to express my views on global matters. You can take your advice, roll it tight and shove it up in your chaiwala leader.
Congratulations brother 🎉🎉🎉
@@spikenraul Your internal issues are not even worth interfering. It's a mess.
Worst FM ..We should campaign in social media about her immediate resignation...A worthless minister who's been afraid of contesting..Bogus!
True nobody knows her am from south thalapathy Vijay is the right person he is kind everyone knows him he can win anywer in tamilnadu with just his aura. I demand the govt to look for ministers who has good following to occupy the post of fm.
@@peddintilokesh4616 a person who is from middle class never done any politics and has just a motive to develop country is a right person like me but I'm 17 but preparing how i would do things when i will become PM
You are absolutely correct. Our country has been pushed to that level, which may be very bad for our democracy.
High time bring agriculture into taxation and give freebies to only deserved. Lot of black money with people in rural sector.
Itbwill destroy the farming sector by corporates they are waiting for the farmers to sell land, presently govt is tring to reverse the problem created by earler govt,
I believe govt trying to bring native seed for sustainable farming and fertilizers and scrapping green revolution,
Now depopulation by economic pressure
Naman has rightly dwelled into types of Governance as written by Aristotle and all the shortcoming was given as well
Taxes on Health Insurance
Taxes on Severance Package
Taxes on Trading
Taxes on Fantasy Games
Taxes on online education and courses
Worst country worst govt worst religion
Very enlighten to watch your intelligence on subjects of national importance with facts. Keep the good work.. we hope to see the light at end of tunnel.
Yeah the line "the best political community is the one where the middle class holds a significant influence".... We need to know how we can live a better life?.. As naman sir said the rich will leave, poor hv nothing and middle-class is the one who suffers. Why the hell on the planet earth in India we need to buy health insurance paying 18% gst, that too when we are saving it from the salaries that they deduct tax from?.... This is a serious issue... Today's system is just so bristle
True taxes on health insurance is unjust, the middle class in India does not ve any influence per se. We dnt fight we dnt ask qustns, we jst pay taxes
Hey make video on Karnatka.
I am from Karnataka,and they said there will be no development because funds are not sufficient and used up issuing freebies.
Please help people knie about this .
I left India, and now i think it was the best decision of my life 😅
Good
How did u do it? Please help me leave
Yes
Same here
@@English-cp5hs fulfilled my responsibilities by paying a lot of tax. Now I am where I deserve to be. You enjoy the tax I paid. What changes have you made till now??🤣🤣
You deserve more than 1 crore subscribers.
Worst FM Ever
But then, who gave her this important ministry? How did she become F.M.? Please ask this question yourself; hopefully, you will get the answer.
Naman sir, I do pray for revolution, our country should be ruled by independent local familiar person who is humble and corruption free who can make India proud, instead of these corrupt politicians who loot taxpayers money fully selfish in nature.
There are so many in the list and you are one in the list.
This is a peice of marvelous lecture. Plz give the way forward to these problems ...
But we Indians know best and have experienced best, the success and peace in middle Eastern monarchies. UAE, Qatar, Bahrain, Oman, Saudi. They have peace, they have harmony, economically sustainable and constant new opportunities. Someone should do a study on why it works even though ppl keep talking about how bad it is to have a monarchy anymore.
You are forgetting oil in the equation.
@venaist Do you know that Dubai doesn't have any oil anymore and hasn't had for the last 15 years or so?? It still remains a prime destination for every nationality on the planet. Tourism and trade. that's Dubai's main economy. India has far greater potential to tap those 2 sectors. I remain convinced that Indians are better off being ruled by a family of kings who know to manage like the Middle Eastern States... we are a bunch of unruly misfits who need to be disciplined and not given choices. It's gone far enough.
@@rohitrevankar7674do u know dubai still owns oil and produces enough for her and do u kbow dubai have investments and land owned in africa, there is mining and industrial material governed by abudubi majority of african gold goes to arab countries especially dubai, and agricultural produces also, they dont have standing army and they relies on US for that😂 bad logic of yours , do u think non tax country and tourism is what abudhabi exist u r wrong
@veerar8203 Dude Abu Dhabi and Dubai economies are independent. UAE doesn't operate as one nation when it comes to their own financial system. They have one currency but each Emirate operates independently. Dubai is mostly a tourism and trade economy. I am speaking facts not making up theories. You think I'll talk about it if I haven't been there myself? My family has been there since the 90s. Don't bother mentioning Agricultural produce, it's mostly for the local market not exports. All of UAE's foreign investment comes from Abu Dhabi not Dubai.
Naman ji, you have told the every middle class worker story who is crushed by tax, tax, tax.. This Nirmala Sitaraman is height of arrogance. Everything is taxed including basic necessities food, clothing, house, health education. I voted for BJP thinking that they do good, they did good by increasing taxes.. God save middle class, God save India.
so according to you how much earning is considered a middle class?
Amma is the best in the world 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉
One of the most thought provoking videos made. Keep it up.
Is there a way to impeach any minister ? I mean is there a legal way to impeach a minister by the public ? There should be something like that in a “democratic” country right ??
From last 10 years no increase in tax slabs.. just playing the number game between old and new regime
You can read her, she is egoistic, she doesn't care , cares about sangh. No wonder her husband is against her.
It shows how much we are intelectual.. In 5 hour only 10000 views for showing the actual truth without being biased..
Wealth Distribution in China worked brilliantly, it depends on government, administration and policy makers how to execute it
What an amazing video!!! Much appreciated.
Sorry it's a long comment but it's worth a read!
Aristotle's emphasis on the middle class as a stabilizing force in society remains profoundly relevant in contemporary India, particularly amidst widespread dissatisfaction with the finance minister and economic policies.
In India, the middle class has historically been the engine of economic growth, consumer spending, and innovation. It aspires for upward mobility and demands accountability from policymakers. However, in recent years, rising income inequality, inflation, and perceptions of elitist policies have alienated this demographic. A diminished or disillusioned middle class risks destabilizing democratic institutions, fueling populist movements, and exacerbating social divides. For India's progress, it is crucial to realign fiscal and economic policies to address middle-class concerns, ensuring inclusive growth that revitalizes Aristotle’s vision of a balanced and harmonious society.
These Ministers are always supported by those citizens who are heavily worried about Hindutva than India. Those citizens who want infra, economy, stability and scientific temperament are minority unfortunately.
Leaving the country is the best thing one can do for themselves without spending their life for this society.
Sorry
yeah, you are wrong, do you want your house to be taken by WAQF board overnight, I have just lost my wife's ancestral property to WAQF. You will only understand the pain if it happens to you
True ppl with scientific temperament are a minority we should ban religion in India .
@@sathishkumar-dt4zc as a human I deeply apologize on behalf of a section of Humanity which have done wrong to you, but As A tax payer of India, I must worry about my family's material welfare as well in terms of Infra, services, security, justice and income here. I am not wrong. I can't compromise on economic prosperity for hindu sentiments. Sorry.
@@fireStorm070 toh fir hindutva ka RR q Kiya tu😂😂jaise tujhe apni family ki padi hai..humko hindutva ki padi hai smja..aacha hua chala gya desh chord kar..tere jaise napunsako ki jarurat b nahi yaha pe
Naman Sir, this was one of my favorite episodes in the PSIR module - the whole episode was a true masterclass in understanding aristotle. thanks!
I don’t even care about the burden! If a staff engineer from uber who has 90lpa base pays 25-33 lakhs of direct tax is killed by a rich MLA, nobody gives a shit not even the media whereas someone whose sleeping on footpath dies it’s a national issue! Life value should be subjective rather than objective
Dude, those who were sleeping on footpath, were killed. Only ravindra Patil til his last breath keep saying that it is the salman khan who was driving car while being drunk heavily. Despite getting threats from underworld he never changed his bayaan.
You are giving words to my thoughts, Thanks for doing so.
Please talk about some actions by middle class. We should promote to realise the Govt.
A very pinpointed analysis from poliyical as well as economical perspective👌👌👌👍👍👍
You talked about agitations and toppling government is Bangladesh but very cleverly suppressed the starting reason of this ''movement''. And the reason was introduction of Quota in Jobs, depriving the merit. In India, most of the middle class private job holders are being deprived from govt. jobs and higher education due to SC, ST, OBC, EW, Sports Quotas. Did you see any agitation/protest? So, not only high taxes but raise your voice against reservation (quota) which deprives most of the middle class merits. Many meritorious middle class students are compelled to leave India because of this injustice....
Nice deflection.yet what he said was true.this fm is clueless and keeps taxing middle class and favours buissness class.
Imagine taxing medicines more than diamonds.is it the fault of sc/st reservations that such kind if bizzare tax slabs are imposed on middle class.stop digressing and accept that the present government is inept
Well in that middle class we find pure bhakts. Poor are paid to vote, rich votes dont affect the result.
Which category do you fall in ? K2a? Pappuparty?
Problem with people like you is very simple, no earnings so no taxes, no respect towards other religions so call everyone bhakts who don't support your party, all in all - no work but muah se hag do bas.. bhaak MC
high tax in India destroying middle Class that's true but giving that logic she is a Rajya Sabha MP that's why not accountable to the people of India that so stupid opinion. because if this is true then we will only call them real Indian citizens who paid taxes and those who don't pay taxes they are not Indians or care about this country. Aristotle choose middle class , but he also advocate Slavery, gender discrimination etc. don't use selective statements give them full picture.
She'll be remembered as one of the best finance ministers from the bottom🙂
That is how we have reached to the level of improvement which we see around ourselves now.
The only limit to our realization of tomorrow will be our doubts of today." - Franklin D. Roosevelt
I am sorry to say this, and I do agree with pretty much everything on this video, this is a monologue about the problems we have. The problem with this video is that it doesn’t really talk about any solutions. How are we supposed to fix all of this? Governance by the middle class. Full stop. But how do you get a government run by the middle class? That is the problem with this channel. It seems more like scathing commentary on the issues, like any other contemporary media outlet, without any discussions on how to improve.
It would be participatory democracy. Read about Switzerland .
Also there could be right to accountability which can be brought.
@ wouldn’t it be nice if the monologue was replaced by these suggestions and possible solutions?
@@sumitalwarI think anyone who take place of FM will be criticised heavily 😅.. Many people criticize taxes and all that but doesn't provide a constructive criticism with proper solution which takes care of major concern of govt. which actually drives them to put tax on Middle class.
For e.g:- we have to give incentives to corporates so that they can come here, establish well and expand well, keep generating jobs which mostly Middle class enjoys.
Every developed or highly developing countries has done exactly that including China, problem is we doing late and thanks to internet these things along with heavy criticism spread fast causing panic & dissatisfaction.
But there is no alternative, this will happen irrespective of FM & govt because the country is in that stage of development.
Bhai. Switzerland doesn't get anything done. If india follows that model you will not even see cleaning people working and you'll have to go and throw your own garbage outside the city.
Stress ho jaata h bc iska video dekh k....I mean this as a compliment.
Given that running for political office in India often demands a budget exceeding 1 crore for campaign expenses, how can a middle-class candidate realistically compete in elections?
Wow! What a presentation!
Taxes like England services like Somalia
@8:29 : Well Said
History will remember NirmalaTai as the WORST FM under the WORST PM of INDIA.
Agreed with the quote. In today’s context, the Center govt is for the riches and my state govt (West Bengal) is for the poor.
The middle class is being slow-poisoned to eventual death.
Great work bro. Respect for you. One humble request, reduce or cut off the background music.
She is truly truly incompetent.
Yes but to solve India's problem and to develop India...Division of India is necessary. India should be divided into 10-12 small independent countries then only they all can develop. All those countries should be divided politically...not on religious or caste lines.
Impotent
@@IronMan-nu3rbJust what we would expect from Islamists, talking casually about Dividing the country. Jihadis are doing their work online.
She will succumb to her ego and incompetence.
Worst minister ever
Salute to you sir for awakening us.
soja beta. varna gabbar ajayega
Rajya sabha MP never bhi given ministers which are linked with middle and poor class because they never faced those problems and they never answerable to people because they never selected by people
Arguing about the complexity of tax policy is important. I'm not saying the BJP government is perfect, but reducing the tax burden on the middle class is a challenging issue. If taxes are lowered, who will make up the difference? If we target millionaires and billionaires too aggressively, they might choose to leave India, which would be a significant loss. While they do find ways to minimize their tax bills, it's essential to recognize that they also create many jobs and contribute significantly to the economy.
Simply reducing the tax burden on the middle class or cutting GST won't address the economic challenges of a large country like India. It’s overly simplistic to assume that lowering taxes alone will improve the economy.
I don't see any point on this discussion.
When it comes to the facilities we receive from the government, it's important to acknowledge that the quality of service often falls short. This is not a new issue; it's rooted in a corrupt political system. No party can win elections without substantial funding, which complicates the situation.
If the BJP were to avoid engaging in controversial political tactics, it would be challenging for them to maintain their position. What we often see is just a high-level overview, but the reality at the ground level is much more complex.
agree
6500 top high value rich Indians have left the shores this year😢😢😢😢
@@xaviercolaco 🙂
@@xaviercolaco 😌
FANTASTIC JOURNALISM.....EXCELLENT
Recently i brought car and i found average suvs has around 55% taxes (28% gst and rest cess)
The car which costs only 10 lakhs people are paying 15 lakhs.
Additionally you have to pay RTO registration also
You doing very well bro 👍
India must watch this video and feel what is being done
My Creata 2024 tax details
Car price- ₹758552/-
CGST 14%- ₹106197/-
SGST 14%- ₹106197/-
CESS 17%- ₹128954/-
TCS 1%- ₹10999/-
My Vehicle TAX imposed by state(RTO)- ₹109990/-
Total Tax ₹462337/-
More than half tax 😭💀