Yasir Qadhi: Problems with the Preservation of the Quran (Copyright Appeal Won!)
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ย. 2024
- Yasir Qadhi shows the knowledge of the problematic transmission of the Quran is now trickling down to the mainstream Muslim world. Update: on October 7th, 2020, Qadhi false flagged this video for copyright because he’s trying to erase all traces of his embarrassing interview. I won the appeal. See here: • Yasir Qadhi's Copyrigh...
What will happen in the Muslim world as the problematic transmission of the Quran becomes common knowledge? For anyone not familiar with "ahruf" and "qira'at" that Qadhi is discussing, see here: th-cam.com/video/lH6M-iLVcKM/w-d-xo.html; Shabir Ally on ahruf: th-cam.com/video/c0Z7_MAZX5g/w-d-xo.html. In this edit, I focus on western vs. eastern scholars, the holes in the traditional narrative, and ahruf and qira'at. Original video here: th-cam.com/video/8Dc1HJ8Uif4/w-d-xo.html.
Thanks to "Islamic Clarity" for alerting me to this video.
I'll find out when I show my family members
islamic scholars are slowly agreeing the quran is corrupted. what more do we need. islam is on the downhill.
I think Dr. Shabir Ally popularized it? Hmmm... I guess they will listen to their own apologist.
Thank you for pointing me to the explanation video. Now, I know exactly what "ahruf" means 😅
Basically he's saying if it make Islam look bad we try to hide it.
Go see the full original video.
@@user-is7no9kb5e
Does watching the whole video take away the problems of the preservation of the Qur'an?
Or is it more empty rhetoric?
Don't you see the problem?
Muslims have been lied to for years and years.
And now they try to cover up again?
@@SaintOtter
Firstly, he is talking about the 7 styles in which the Quran was revealed in. You could write or recite the Quran to these 7 styles. This teacher cannot reject prophet Muhammad s.a.w so he cannot make one superior to another. All of these 7 styles of the Quran goes back to the prophet s.a.w. we have authentic narattions. The Quran is perfectly preserved from prophet Muhammad s.a.w to us.
Millions have been memorizing the Qur'an sense the time of prophet Muhammad s.a.w until now. Its impossible for it to be corrupted.
Unlike your gospels and bible.
1 they are not in original language.
2 Gospels contradict each other in many points.
3 they are stories rather than narrations
4 nothing goes back to jesus.
5 gospels written by unknown people.
Research from your own sources.
@@relevantinfor6682 That is incorrect. Biblical Manuscript data is a vast field.
@@relevantinfor6682 The problem is not one of recitation or of style. It is of meaning that differences from Quran to Quran. Hatun Tash and Jay smith h ave identified about 37 different Qurans now in circulation in Islamic societies and identified over one hundred thousand differences between them... and counting. noun becomes verb, verb becomes noun, inflections change, meanings change to opposites etc. Just check out Jay smith or Hatoun Tash's videos you will see how gravely faulted the so called holy book of God is ( written in his own hand and in Arabic, since the poor god knows only Arabic and would not let anyone read except in Arabic!
''In a muslim environment, we press a little bit and then say khalas''- Yasir Qadhi
They need to say khalas to the whole quran forever and try something else. 🙄
Exactly man! Can I be your friend? 😂
@@jacob_varghese Khalas
@@alvinjohn2540 😂😂
😂😂😂😂
"I don't want to be explicit" i.e. I don't want to advertise the problems more than I have to.
This type of thing shouldn't be talked about openly...
Islam Critiqued 😜😜😜😜🤔😋😋😨😨😨😨 oh boy like CP says !! Yessir is in trouble!!!
@@IslamCritiqued Do you think his life could be in danger if he talked about them openly?
@Jon Doe 🤣🤣🤣
Exclusivist Claims of Islam Challenged Logically
th-cam.com/video/pSz64rIb6sE/w-d-xo.html
Also watch Internal Logic of Religous Fanaticism
th-cam.com/video/_5aqIqgigIw/w-d-xo.html
he just pointed out calamity is coming to Islam.
@森林雪 I'm afraid that is not something that is going to be peaceful.
Vaticancatholic.com for the truth
@@bernieburns3404 Cheers bro, interesting site :)
actually it's also showing his fair side, he's smart enough to understand that lying can't be prolonged. And remember, this isn't yet the era of blockchain. If open ledger exist all together as internet, there'll no chance to do censorship. blockchain will attain its peak using 5G. Islam, your wall is closing in.
@Serve mabunda read the verses that follow this.
David wood looks different in the video, probably has to do with his new glasses
His book shelf looks bigger too
They both have same lvl of stupidity XD
Best comment EVER! 😆😂🤣
@@MRVENM-rz2ng idk man, Phd in Philosophy isn't a stupid person
Way too far akhi
What he really means is that their lying days are numbered .
Are done! Finished!
And, as we all know, without lies…
@@slamwall9057 christianity dies
@@slamwall9057Islam dies
Slowly the shaky bastian of Islamic apologetics is crumbling , Shabbir Ally out, Yassir Qadhi out, cannot defend the preservation of quran any longer.
They should of never spouted that nonsense to begin with.
@@lizicadumitru9683 why out? "And ye shall know the truth, and the truth shall make you free."
@@MU-we8hz you right Yasir is helping muslims to see Quoran for what it is in reality,so now people start thinking, not acepting blindly everything what they are fed with by scholars
A
Do you think islam is dependent on some scholars in the US. They are merely known in the west. They are insignificant in the whole islamic world.
@rajesh vengat yes Indian live in the west insignificant
If Yasir Qadhi continues like this, then he is in danger of leaving Islam 😊
NO he's not leaving. He already said he battled with it and has decided to just OBEY
The Eastern world is not like the Western world. People stay behind in Islam even after knowing the truth because of the tremendous loss that is ahead of them - most important family. Second, fear of losing their own life. Third, stigma in the society. Daily taunts. Its a different world out there in the Eastern side.
@@DennyEapen I disagree. "End of the world" cults exist in the west and when the end doesn't come they come up with an excuse or the followers just move on to another similar cult. the Jehovas witnessess made four or five predictions in the last century which were bogus but the retained members
@@DennyEapen This is so true. But they shall fear the real God. Not those impediments.
Sorry @Bart Connolly - I didn’t understand what you were trying to convey.
Translation: "every student of knowledge" knows the Quran is highly corrupted and learns to simply regurgitate nonsense instead of admitting it, or better yet keep his mouth shut. How sad.
@Serve mabunda Yes, after ~2 years of daily conversations with Muslims, I would say that 90% of the time the Muslim simply tries to distract/keep changing the subject instead of answering anything. It is like they know they have no actual answers to offer and is quite sad.
@@ReasonedAnswers
Qadhi should start reading Bible. He should also read "Book of Jasher" to see the truth.
Qadhi's name is in "Book of Jasher".
@Serve mabunda Absolutely. Even if 90% of Muslim ears/minds are closed, that is still 10% that can be reached, which is a LOT of souls to save.
@@ReasonedAnswers
Listen to what? Do you have something to offer other than 'Jesus loves you'?
@@ahm512 _"Find out what ahruf and qirat are before you say the Quran has been corrupted looool"_ Considering Muslim scholars don't even know what they are, it seems you have asked the impossible. Maybe try actually thinking and moving beyond that "we hear and obey" phase of knowledge?
First muslims said, "You must know arabic." Then they denied their own texts incl sahih. Now this. What's next?
_"What's next?"_ An avalanche of apostasy.
@buymebluepills _"the true Quran is in heaven"_ The "true" Quran doesn't exist - they are all equally false.
Islam=Contradiction Paradox
Roosje Keizer unfortunately they cannot abolish the apostate law as it is the word of Al-Lah, this law is another example of the peaceful and merciful command that Al-Lah has offered to the world...
What’s next is Muslims will claim Islam is not easy to follow because you don’t speak Arabic so therefore the 1.3 billion Muslims are not actual Muslims
So what he's really saying to the Muslim students is "Don't ask questions, just regurgitate whatever your Imans tell you!"
like what church told you to believe in 3 partners to God and break the commandments? hahahaha
@@fidelcatsro6948 why is ur first reaction to bring up other religions to excuse ur own. Such childish and immature behaviour, it’s how children behave.
@@Normaldude10174 dont blame us.. you thwarted teachings of jesus into a teaching about jesus 1900yrs ago!
He's not recommending that, he's sayjng it's what people do
@@fidelcatsro6948 quite the opposite! we were encouraged to speak about the trinity and understand what it means!
I watched ali dawah speak many times about the perfect preservation of the quran. Now his nurse hijab is offering excuses for the lack of preservation.
@Romeo Romeo “When the missionaries came to Africa they had the Bible and we had the land. They said "Let us pray." We closed our eyes. When we opened them we had the Bible and they had the land.” Said by Tutu
A honest black man telling the truth generations ago
So what he's saying is that there's a problem, but not really, but it's a big problem, but we shouldn't talk about it because it's a problem, but the Christians are talking about this problem, and we know it's a problem, but we don't or rather can't answer the problem....
Haha that's it. We have a problem which is a very very difficult problem which is a problem which is a complex problem and very problematic and is complicated and complex.
Halo! What's the problem? And what are you trying to do about it?
It’s perfect.... but it has holes in it.
Beginning of the end I say.
...perfected with holes. :-)
The new mantra for marketing, it is perfect..... but has holes in it.
🛑 CLARIFICATIONS BY DR YASIR QADHI🛑. After a recent interview with Br. Muhammad Hijab, some missionaries and anti-Muslim propagandists have read their own prejudices into our very brief discussion. Some of them have twisted my words to suit their agenda. While Muslim scholarship has pioneered Quranic studies for centuries and continues to do so, the fact remains that we all agree on the demonstrably proven fact that the Quran has been preserved in its entirety, word for word, and that we believe that all of the ten recitations (qira'āt) of the Quran are revealed from Allah. To see such Islamophobes try to read in an argument that no one amongst us ever made in order to prove their incorrect narrative is only demonstrating the unethical tactics they resort to.
Here is a beautiful example of this from a post from a few years ago: The recent carbon dating of an ancient Quranic manuscript at the University of Birmingham has now added even more proof regarding the unparalleled degree of certainty with which the Quran has been preserved. These folios have been Carbon 14 dated to within the same time frame, or perhaps shortly after, our Prophet (salla Allahu alayhi wa sallam). In other words, if this parchment wasn't written for/by a Companion, then it was written by/for a student of one of the Companions.
In this image, prepared by Prof Godlas, you can see the original manuscript, written in the ancient Hijazi manuscript, and compare it with its modern, typed equivalent.
This collection, called the 'Mingana collection' (after the researcher Alphonse Mingana, d. 1937) was purchased by Mingana in either Iraq or Syria, almost a hundred years ago. Edward Cadbury, the founder of the famous chocolate company, sponsored Mingana's trips to the Middle East. His collection, which includes hundreds of manuscripts, is primarily housed at the University of Birmingham, in the UK.
Many Muslims ask me, 'How come so many Islamic documents and manuscripts ended up in non-Muslim lands and libraries?' The response, in a nutshell is: colonialism, and the power of money. Some manuscripts were simply 'acquired'; but most were sold by private owners, or on the black market, to travelers from Europe who could pay what would have been considered astronomical prices for the time.
And frankly, that is a good thing. The Muslim world simply did not have (nor does it have!) the latest technology or the scientific means to take care of these manuscripts the way that the Western world is now doing. It is my belief that Divine Will is allowing these manuscripts to be preserved in the best manner possible, even if that is occurring at the hands of those who do not believe in them in the first place.
"Truly, we have sent down this Remembrance, and We shall, for sure, preserve it" [Quran]
@Harrie Nak
The fact is that every anciant manuscript we find, confirm the quran we have today... it does not matter How many the birmingham manuscript is... the paris manuscript is 1/3 of the quran and i confirms the one we have today. Same with the one in Germany....
@Harrie Nak
I have no time to waste with bigots.
Grow up a little bit and we can discuss...
I'll add a small dictionary:
Uloom al-Qur'an - Sciences of the Quran
Ahruf - "letters", Muhammad said in a hadith that "The Quran was revealed in 7 ahruf" and nobody knows what it means.
Qira'aat - "readings" - versions of the Quran that are available today
Uthmanic Mushaf - Quran written by Uthman after he burned all other copies
Qari - reciter
fa dakhala fee nafsee shakk- so doubt entered into me
shakk - doubt
khalaas, sami'na wa-ata'ana - that's enough, we hear and we obey
riwayat - narrations
athar - literally "remnants". hadiths from early Muslims, not from Muhammad directly
makhtutat - manuscripts
ulema - "scientists". Islamic scholars call themselves scientists.
Jazakhallah khayran!
Thank you...else it would have been hard for most of us to understand....
"versions of the Quran" no, there is no multiple versions as you said.
@@amine5761 I think he meant different recitations
@@amine5761 there are multiple versions with different readings
So what he was saying is, in essence, if you don't want to be ex muslim, do not dig deeper into Quran literary criticism. Because even the most expert scholar of Qur'an have no answer for these question.
We live in a very interesting time indeed. To be able to witness a very well kept deception that reign supreme for 1400 years began to crack and exposed. In Christian Prince word, "Abdul! You are busted~~~~!"
@Jon Doe I do not think it's only oil money. But also the trauma that the west have endure from Nazi germany. They fear the label of racist. And also the success of Islamic propaganda regarding "Islamophobe" label. To avoid these label, and also death threats, many scholar and scientist in the world become dishonest. Like Bart Ehrman said "I will talk about Qur'an only when i do not value my life."
Bless you to brother
Whats the problem with what YQ briefly articulated? - "'Umar bin Al-Khattab said:
I heard Hisham bin Al-Hakim reciting Surat Al-Furqan during the lifetime of Allah's Messenger (ﷺ). I listened to his recitation and noticed that he recited it in several different ways which Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) had not taught me. So I was about to jump over him during his Salat (prayer) but I waited till he finished his Salat (prayer) whereupon I put, either his upper garment or my upper garment around his neck and seized him by it and asked him, "Who has taught you this Surah?" He replied: "Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) has taught it to me." I said (to him), "You have told a lie! By Allah, Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) has taught me this Surah which I have heard you reciting." So I dragged him to the Allah's Messenger (ﷺ). I said: "O Allah's Messenger I have heard this man reciting Surat Al-Furqan in a way in which you have not taught me, and you did teach me Surah Al-Furqan." On that Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "O 'Umar, release him! Recite, O Hisham". So Hisham recited before him in the way as I heard him reciting. Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "It has been revealed like this." Then Allah's Messenger (ﷺ) said, "Recite, O 'Umar" So recited it. The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "It has been revealed like this." And then he added, "This Qur'an has been revealed to be recited in seven different ways, so recite it whichever way is easier for you." Sahih al-Bukhari 6936
I'm here after the copyright appeal was won😂😂🤭
What do you mean?
Me too 😂
@@faza4023 yq made a copyright claim (he reported this video to youtube) he didnt want it to be spread all over the internet, because this is the famous video where he, as an academic muslim scholar, claims that there are "holes in the narrative". of course, he lost the case, as you can see - youtube did not deleted the video
@@kubura762 hahah thanks got it
Yep. Me too :)))
I love how this past month we are now seeing the Muslims argument of the perfect preservation of the Quran is crumbling.
The next step is to talk about historical errors like the crucifixions of pharoahs magicians thousands of years before crucifixions were ever recorded
@Jonathan Soko They will find some spin
@Roosje Keizer Now we need honest Arabic speaker to show that is either correct or incorrect
@buymebluepills yes, but it gives us the ability to point to the lies and deceptions they spread, so our children have proof that the Muslims are lying heathens.
@Roosje Keizer Thanks!
Allah has preserved this video for us despite the Abduls' efforts 🙏🙏🙏
Hamdullah
this video is perfectly preserved!
@@martinvanburen4578
"Word for word"
@FearlessMovement down to the letter to the dot😂😂
Actually as an Arabic speaking Christian I don't see ahruf and kiraat as a problem of preservation. Muslims always claimed that quran was un-doted. And it was later doted. The problem is did they dot it correctly. That's the question. The even bigger problem that the dotting creates is the large amount of possibilities the original text could have meant.
Tae this for example, which I highly doubt you'll find in any of the readings.
The part in the quran that speaks of the crucifixion of Jesus says it the last part that those who disagreed about him ( Jesus) are in doubt , which refers mostly to disciples not knowing what happened. But if you add one dot to the word إختلفوا on the ف to have two dots instead of one it would become إختلقوا the meaning would change from those who disagreed/ argued to those who created stories about Jesus which would mean in this context the Jewish leaders that fabricated the story of disciples stealing the body. Just one example of a whole array of infinite possibilities.
You touch on the the whole array of difficulty involved with having a "scripta defectiva" in a language in its development stage and using a primitive script and then presenting this as "clear and uncomplicated and perfectly preservable". It simply can't be.
We need more of you guys. Native Arabic speakers who are not Muslims. You guys will destroy radical Islam.
tigerarmyrule I am talking about the whole array of possibilities that could come out of such scripta, that even the current variants of the quran wouldn't have, because the people who dotted this scripta never wanted it to be that way!
Keyur Patel I don't want to destroy radical Islam ( actually some Muslims are now trying to do that). All I want to do is for people to know they are loved. I am just here out of curiosity 😂😂😂
@@keyurpatel1982 While you keep searching for this in Disney Land, keep enjoying cow's piss and dung
Who’s here after the video got restored ;)
Meeeee
naaaaaah i came here to warn Trinitarians not to make partners to the Creator!
Still wondering how Qadhi is still a Muslim. He points out the fatal problems in Islamic tradition so clearly, yet provides no answers. The closest he gets is at 1:36 when he says only a select few should discuss these problems. Suspicious to say the least.
He specifically said that, at Yale, he set limits to things he would and would not look into critically.
@@IslamCritiqued Yeah, that's also suspect, yet incredibly honest. A rare combination.
He seems like a sincere and intelligent person, honestly, on this topic. When it comes to things like Aisha, he tosses his brain out the window.
@@IslamCritiqued or he's ok with it..😔
Qadhi decided the Quran is beyond question, that the "proper" way to think is start with the "fact" (assumption) that the Quran is true and go from there.
Umar ibn al-Khattab reported: The Messenger of Allah, peace and blessings be upon him, said, “Verily, among what I fear most for my nation is every hypocrite with a knowledgeable tongue.”
baraka Allah oufik
@The Apostate Murrah former disciple please enlighten us with your findings, facts and evidence:
BRO, UNTIL PROVEN OTHERWISE, YOU'RE NO WHERE NEAR YASIR IN KNOWLEDGE ABOUT ISLAM
He is not speaking about quran preservation. But the style of recitation
I like how he dichotomized 'eastern' vs. 'western' takes on what scholarship should be like. In the western tradition you start with the 'thing' which is going to be studied and you apply a methodology which should be replicable, understandable and falsifiable and then you go all Socratic on it till either you have to acknowledge that the thing cannot be taken apart any further (i.e.- arriving at base facts or the 'truth' of the matter) or you have to acknowledge that you can't at this time take it any further then you already have. Whereas here Yasir indirectly claims to have a crisis of personhood while at Yale over the fact that if you go more than a few layers deep on the Quran the things which he now claims everyone knows are there (which is him basically flirting with apostasy over the multiple translations of the Quran). And in order to save himself from the crisis he falls back on a tradition which states you can as 'some' questions but there is a hard line you aren't supposed to cross. A had line, mind you, which he doesn't define, but which might kinda of rhyme with 'perfect preservation' but not quite.
If this keeps up then Islam is well on its way out.
naaaah Islam is going to be Great again!! Restoring the lies they made about Prophet Jesus with whom we are pleased!
Lies or truth about Jesus? 😅
I hear a rattling sound, of the foundations of Islam breaking!
Lol i get here to see atheists just having orgasms about something that they dont even understand what it is. Qiraat you should google it. It is just a recitation variants. Nothing exposed. Every muslim knows about them. And still billions still choose to believe in Islam. So bad news for you and your wishes buddy.
Go read the quran and study these qiraars and make a video about what you discovered yourself. Maybe you should read more instead of watching youtube videos that you dont understand.
@@fortnajt yes i should read more, then i can definitely know more and stay away from islam. Mo was the most heinous person in history
those rattle were coming from rattlesnakes in your mind..
Snakes who bit mohammed
You know the famous story of the emperor with no clothes 🤣🤣😂
Yasir Qadhi knows that Islam is a hoax.
Yah, what a weird thing to say. He just called Islam a scam by making that analogy.
@@ReasonedAnswers Yes indeed he just did.
Reasoned Answers apologetics videos I think you should see the whole video lol to understand the context.dishonest Christians again doing clip and paste videos.
@@ayy9536 Clip and paste? Did you not hear the man.. islam has holes.. BIG HOLES!.. and they don't know how to fill them.. they'll never be able to cover it up because they brought it HERE.. of all places! To the west, where it will get taken apart, inspected, reviewed, and weighed, we found it to be both lacking AND wanting! There is no damage control now.. it's too late.. It's a sinking ship! Oh, and just so we have an understanding, I'm a curious human who doesn't like being told what to do, where to go, or what to say. I have an opinion and I'm allowed to express that opinion. I form that opinion by looking at all sides.. didn't take long to figure this one out.. which is: islam is a cult and momo the child (expletive) needs to be thrown to the curb. And that's after reading what I have in the CONTEXT in which it was written. The only dishonesty I see here are your words, the words written in the quaran, and those uttered by other 'believers'.. well.. Yasir Qadhi not so much.. now.. he did publicly point out they're up sh!t creek..
@@ayy9536 Quote: "see the whole video lol to understand the context." Therefore, Mimi Hijab cut out 30 minutes. 😂
Yasir Qadhi. Which ahruf and qira'at is written on the eternal tablet (lawh e mahfuz) in heaven?.
@tigerarmyrule exactly! if Muslims claim the quran is uncreated, eternal and there is only 1 Quran, then surely Allah hu snackbar should have known there would be this issue and why did Uthman have a quranic barbecue also.
@@Tai91827 The father of Arabic grammar Abu Amr ibn al-Ala
was died 770 CE/154 AH . That is 150 years after the Hijra. It was he who inserted vowels into the Quran.
All the 7.
No, I mean all the 10 qiraats
As Pagan Mohammad said, Islam will end...? its waste of time investing spiritualy on something that will end..
If Muhammad pbuh was Pagan i will die tonight, but if he is not i hope you will tonight
Yasir admitted Islam didn't spread peacefully, now he's admitting the Qur'an may not be perfectly preserved.
Nelsin-Nagant Kimber-g He also admitted Aisha was 6
Muslims often bring this up about the Bible's reliability. Now that the Quran is being deeply scrutinized too, you've scholars like Qadhi who "admit!" that there are Quranic difficulties that cant be answered in a traditional way. IDK much about him but it seems Qadhi might be transitioning into "Reformed Islam". I find it ironic that Hijab was the interviewer lol... I wonder how he's processing all that info.
Bye, Bye, Mr. Arabic Pie, Drove my Chevy to the Kaaba but the Kaaba was dry
And them good ole boys were drinking from the Well of Zamzam. The day the Music DIED!
"You must know Arabic to understand the Quran." RIP
Hah! Music is haram. Especially that tune!
RIP??? Islam has brought so much misery to the world, it should suffer ALL the punishments of the grave.
At first I thought he was clearing his throat when speaking those arabic terms.
@The Great Bodhisattva Hachiman Oh, I see. It's not really bad tho.
Yasir Qadi is "smart enough" to continue the lie/deception on unquestioning Muslims (for now) but sly enough to avoid doing a Shabir Ally (deer caught in the headlights impression) ... that line of deception won't last for long as Shabir has now opened the Quran to textual criticism.
Shabir ally????? What's that? Oh it is someone.
Shabbir ally is a liar himself, yasir Qadhi is absolutely right
So, non Muslims are studying Islamic texts more deeply and thoroughly than Muslim Scholars! Gee...ya THINK? hahahahaha!
He dug and found the truth that islam is fake. But for fear of his life, he refuses to speak about it publicly. He can't hide for ever. One day, if he doesn't leave, the muslims will force him out of the cult.
"The truth will set you free", says the Bible. But this man is prisoner of the truth. Very strange.
The more he talks the more he lies the deeper he dives the harder he finds the appropriate lie .. What a lier... His body language itself is a give away... Poor man
Can you point out even one lie in the clip?
i dont understand the other understood that he is finally telling the truth. but you call him a liar?
Tell us then, O scholar, how he is wrong and you are right?
@@abdullarashid9383 coz you are blind and will never see the truth .. When the devil has his grip over you nothing seems right what defeats the devil and that's the trap people like you are in.
@@saintburnsy2468 try listening to Christian Prince, Robert Spencer, Al Fadi, David Wood, Daniel Brubaker, Ramin Parsa, Daniel Shayesteh, Jay Smith, Apostate prophet, Nab eel Qureshi, Nasser Al Qahtani . These are just a few and you will know why this guy is lying ..coz the truth will never be told from withing, so try listening to these folks.
I fear for his life. God protect him from harm as he continues to trend toward the truth, because I know if he turns from his faith, people like the Hijab interviewing him will turn on him overnight, because they are not interested in the truth
Kamron Anderson I feel like Yasir Qadhi left Islam. He continuously is against Muslims in his speeches
@Kamron Anderson Qadhi knew if he went public with his knowledge, and what is common knowledge in the scholarly community, the people he had brought to Islam would all become apostates, and the ones who didn't would ridicule him sooner than lose the traditions they cling to without evidence. Islam can't tolerate the truth about his origins.
@@molight9832 I'm not an arabic scholar, but the issue is Yasir Qadhi claiming to one crowd of muslims that the quran hasn't been changed even one dot, perfectly preserved, whereas on the other hand he admits to people who know better like Hijab that scholars themselves know of many different readings and qurans, which are admitted to exist in the hadith, some having missing surahs and some having surahs added, and he says to them after much pressure to answer the question that he cannot say for sure which if written down would be the quran of Allah, given to Muhammad. A variant form of the verbs or nouns may have a similar meaning but is not the same.
Also that "quran" in the UK is not a good answer for early material. For one if you research, it predates Muhammad and has material that is not even in the Hafs quran. I encourage you to look more closely. Personally I'm not opposed to having found quranic materials as early as you could imagine, by the way. I just don't think anyone will find it after the various rescensions burning all the evidence that reigning caliphs were manipulating the text in the time they ruled. When have governments ever been a force of righteousness and virtue in the land?
"THE STANDARD NARRATIVES HAVE HOLES IN IT".
Yasir Qadhi
AkA BS 😂lol
Imagine not taking knowledge from big islamic scholars but some western muslims like Asir qadhi! 😂
He took back that statement and apologised for what is understood, rather he was talking about the Ahruf and Qiraat
Right, Right! In a muslim environment, we press a little bit and then say khalas, thats it. End of discussion. But in western acedemia, they push on relentlessly and hence the Quran is in danger of being exposed from all its lies..
@@meerarfatali5469 Too late, buddy, here he was honest, of course now, he wants to save his butt and apologized. 🤣🤣🤣
I actually believe that the Qur'an has been perfectly preserved. It has preserved the tradition of teaching it's followers to be on their worst possible behavior even 1,400 years later. That is a true Islamic miracle! 🤣
Which qirat did Muhammad get? He had 7 ahruf but there are 10+ qirat
@@OrdoMallius who knows, there’s over 30 different Qur’an
Wow! I think should build a security around Yasir Qadhi and Shabir Ally. Their fellows will kill them if we don't protect them.
"I don't wanna be explicit" 😂😂😂
khalaaaaaaaaaas
You lost me within the first two sentences after naming some Arabic terms without even trying to explain their meaning to non-Muslim listeners. Sorry, your credibility is lost by not even thinking how to facilitate understanding. Bad teachers do this all the time.
I don’t review the basics for every video, that would be absurd. Some videos assume background knowledge. Nothing to do with credibility.
Facts 101:
- Jesus is God.
- Christianity is true.
- Mohammad was a sinful human being.
- Allah was Mohammad's alter ego and a figment of his sinful imagination.
God bless you.
Love the message. Whoever is reading this and has waited for so long for a miracle. God is going to rescue you. Trust in Him and victory is yours
Amen
Which God did you have in mind?
Gods of the Roman Greko Henotheism that you assimilated into the teaching of the Bible?
Do you mean theos in Greek bible??
You cannot lie and love at the same time! Darkness cannot mix with light!
"Nobody expects the (christian) spanish inquisition!"
@@yuriyu123 Spanish Inquisition was from politics not from Christianity.
@@fitzburg63Christianity is the Religion of Contradiction and Teh Bible is very much Corrupted
how rich, i wonder what were the religious backgrounds of the people who started world wars@@fitzburg63
Hatun destroy them by bringing 37 different quran
Suddenly, they must all admit to the 'problem' they never had for 1400 years??
Yes we admit as Muslims and apologise , that we forgot to tell you all about this important message earlier!!
*JESUS TOLD YOU BE MUSLIMS 2000YRS AGO AMIGO!!*
The disciple is not above his master: but every one that is perfect shall be as his master.(Luke 6:40)
Sounded from aramaic : "Ein talmeed na'leh 'al rabbo; shekken kal adam she'MUSHLAM yihyeh k'rabbo."(from Aramaic : The perfection here means a spiritual one. What the verse is saying is that knowledge is not what matters! The teacher or master is higher in knowledge than his student. But the student can be as high as his teacher, or even higher, by being a true 'MUSHLAM' or Muslim, a spiritually perfect and well-disciplined person!)
The fact that he is refraining himself to invoke example of what he is talking about tells you all you need to know.
Islam survivability depends on concealing to deceive.
The man is beating around the bush, throwing up lots of words without being specific about what e the problem is. Just talking blarney!
@Gaz Gandalf Why are they leaving? For a number of reasons. The first : they have started learning what the religion actually teaches. Second: They see the unprecedented eruptions of violence from inside this religion for allah's sake. They themselves are victims of it. yet another reason is that atheists, intellectuals of all hues, christian scholars and even ordinary people have access to their books in vernacular languages and accessible online. The internet in one word. Historic lies have now started surfacing mainstream. There is no going back.
naaaaaahh youre wrong stick to medicine amigo... Islam is the fastest growing religion.
@@fidelcatsro6948 High birth rate.
@@RGRaj_1977 you mean like india?? toilets cannot accomodate birth rates there
@@fidelcatsro6948 No, like Indonesia, Arabia & north African countries. And also in countries where they've migrated to. When it comes to birth rate, they obliterate the opposition.
If the word of Allah is unchangeable, yet the Qur'an HAS been changed, the Qur'an is not the word of Allah
What are u talking about? It hasn't been changed. You go to any corner of the earth you will find the same text.
@@lilacblue783 you're wrong. The Qur'an has been changed many times.
Even Aisha mentioned a goat eating part of the Qur'an.
These are facts. Please check them on Google for proof.
I'm not lying
@@lilacblue783 God's holy word through the prophets is never changing. No one may ever change the world's of Allah, spoken through Moses, Isaiah, Jesus and all the prophets.
If anyone ever lies about the world of Allah in the Bible. If anyone ever accuses Allah of allowing humans to mistreat his holy word in the Bible, they must have weak faith, because Allah always protects his word spoken through his prophets in the Bible
Tiiiiiiimbeeeeer!
My Nigeria Muslim do you hear this some of you lie to me that Quran drop from heaven and there is another one in heaven call umul,see how your secret is opening gradually come to lord Jesus Christ he loves you all with evalasting love that only God can give
Amen oooo my nigerian people.
Muslims are lied too
Pls don't blame them
When I asked my friend about Muhammed marrying a nine year old girl
She said it's a lie
Only if she knew he did even more despicable things
Then she'll be out of Islam in no time
Another Nigerian here.
Let's pray that the Lord will open their eyes to the truth.
@Jon Doe what if she hates me
I'm scared
You know the way things work in Nigeria
I don't criticise them. I doesn't work that way. Preach to them the "Ray Comfort Style" . They are seeing sense in what I tell them
WE GOT EM!!!!! LETS KEEP CHIPPING AWAY AT THEIR HISTORY!!!
My god help you to chip away at peoples history you truly have strayed away from god
im sorry Jesus was not a White man with Blue eyes and Blonde hair in Levi jeans wearing a cowboy hat with a 16th century King James Bible in his hand as you perceive
We need to REMEMBER to pray for all the muslim apologists, scholars and muslim community in general for them to come to know the truth : JESUS AS LORD AND SAVIOR
😂😂😂
That Jesus was a middle eastern Jew?
People living in glass houses, shouldn't throw stones at others
Inshaallah we will pray for you to become muslim💯brother
@@sudmohamud7444 GOD bless you..I must tell you islam is a lie Qalanjo..
muhammed was 54 Aisha was 9...
Aisha was immature in this hadith...
Sahih al-Bukhari: Vol. 6, Book 60, Hadith 274: “I have never seen anything regarding Aisha which I would blame her for except that she is a girl of immature age...” sunnah.com/urn/44290
In Bukhari 2637 Aisha is a young girl who sleeps a lot: sunnah.com/bukhari/52
Narrated `Aishah: I used to wash the semen off the clothes of the Prophet (ﷺ) and even then I used to notice one or more spots on them. -Sahih al-Bukhari 232; sunnah.com/bukhari/4/99
Aisha was playing on a swing set when they came to get her: sunnah.com/abudawud/43/163
LORD Jesus is calling you to himself..You must be born again Qalanjo
@@sidzy79 JESUS CAN BE THE OWNER OF YOUR HOUSE...Repent and Live or Refuse and when you DIE you will end in HELL..You must be born again Siddy
@@mpmh3 bruh islam is the truth the Bible has been chnaged like how many times 100s?
Amazing at 2:35 he says believing in Islam is like the story of the emperor's New clothes and the outside non believing academics are the ones pointing out how it doesn't make any sense and the emperor is naked! What an admission
Yes. That particular phrase is a massive blow to Islam itself. Especially coming from a scholar itself.
@@keyurpatel1982 He is not a scholar though. Just a student of the deen like all other muslims.
His only difference to majority of muslims is he studied in Yale and has a big following in social media.
So basically you can read the same material as him and give your interpretation and it is as official.
@@makishimashogo2164 Muhamamd himself is not a scholar. How can an illiterate person dictate an entire book !!!! Every time some Muslim says so and so is not a scholar, I immediately remind him that Muhamamd himself was illiterate so this scholar thing is really irrelevant.
Lol 😂🤣 if you don't believe a Christian saying Islam is wrong, than hear it from Yasir Qadih himself. Lol 🤣😆
The real reason why people watch this clip is that it's the first time we've ever heard a muslim apologist speak the truth. THAT'S THE REAL SHOCKER!
"Problems becoming mainstream" Our mission encapsulated in one statement.
@@joefilter2923 peeling back the scabs of an ideology that festers with the puss of death, slavery, murder, rape, and so many more lies, then exposing that darkness to light is a good mission. Jesus had a different mission, which was to die for our salvation. 600 years later after Jesus brought us the "Way, the Truth and the Life" there comes a warlord on the scene saying he's the cat's meow and some god's favorite. I don't mind being part of exposing that "Problem" and taking it MAINSTREAM.
islams true
@@AC-mp7cx "true lies" was a great movie too
@@tripperdan bible is full of incest, mathematical errors and mass genocide of men, women and children. look at your own scriptures before shitting on something that you have no knowledge of.
@@AC-mp7cx
Wdum "islams true"?
Nice job uploading this piece of the discussion. Short, direct and to the point.
Why did you cut the video at this interval. Dr Qadhi answer was longer than this why don't you tell us what he said at 1:37:30. Is his how low Christians are!
See pinned comment.
even - mohamed - golden shower - hijab did not object to the narratve of Yassir, what are you hypocrite complaining about?
oh I see, you are just defending your dying cult.
he said i wouldn't be explicitly mentioning the problems. that is how scared they are
"He is who he is" giving Muhammed the status of God
What are the issues mentioned at 2:45 so I can research myself?
I think we should all be allowed to give this another thumbs-up, because the restoration of this vid is also victory over a big hole in Qadhi's copyright claim! Hurrah for the good guys who defeated the lie of Qadhi!!!!!!!!!
Hamdullah it is plan of Allah😂😂
It is now beyond repair. Cats are out of hats.
Moneyxl00 you can keep copying and pasting this man. But Yasir even admits “our most advanced scholars don’t even know how to go about these issues “ “this isn’t a game brothers and sisters”
Oh and let’s not forget that Hijab cut out the last 30 minutes of his discussion with Yasir. It’s your own scholars saying this man , not even Christians anymore
But I’ve come to learn thay Muslims are the most hard headed people in the world, which isn’t all bad I would say. But it takes ALLOT for you to admit something . Maybe due to threats or something , depending on the country you live in
So what he's really saying is "Dang, if only we could keep Muslims in blissful ignorance, then they wouldn't know that the Quran has not been perfectly preserved."
100 times better preserved than Paul's Corinthinans... eating and drinking the body and blood of the Messiah?..yuck!!
Abomination abhored by Islam as well as Judaism and even the early disciples of Jesus
@@fidelcatsro6948 I am so sorry that you are truly ignorant of what the Trinity is. One God. We worship one God, not 3. He doesn't have partners. Mohammed told you that Mary is a part of the Trinity, thus proving what a false prophet he was. No Christian EVER believed Mary was a part of the Trinity. Also you appear to be ignorant of the Eucharist. Please do some research before you embarrass yourself further. The purpose of God coming to this earth was to redeem people for Himself. To take away the sin and evil that separated us from Him. Our God is a just, righteous, holy and loving God who loves you. He brings peace and reconciliation to sinful people like me and you through Jesus his son. There is no other name under heaven by which we must be saved.
@@IlovetheTruth Im sorry theres no saying in scripture saying redemption is through Jesus,...you are in idolatry!
REPENT TO ALLAH THE GOD ABARAHAM ISAAC ISHMAEL JACOB MOSES JESUS AND MUHAMMAD!!
@@fidelcatsro6948 Nah, I will bow my knee to the one who raised Jesus from the dead. Not to a 6th century demon possessed caravan robber, who broke everyone of the 10 commandments God gave Moses. Read Exodus 20. Mohammed was so awful he even lusted over his adopted son's wife. His son divorced his wife so Muhammad could have her. Leviticus 18:15 says Do not have sexual relations with your daughter-in-law. She is your son’s wife; do not have relations with her." JESUS said "It has been said, ‘Anyone who divorces his wife must give her a certificate of divorce.’ But I tell you that anyone who divorces his wife, except for sexual immorality, makes her the victim of adultery, and anyone who marries a divorced woman commits adultery."
@@fidelcatsro6948 May Yahweh, the God of Abraham, Issac, Jacob, Moses, David & Jesus grant that your eyes be opened. That you will experience the love of God and see Jesus as your savior. He will abundantly pardon all who come to God through Him. Please listen to me, Muhammad even mixed up Mary the mother of Jesus and the sister of Moses. They lived thousands of years apart, but he thought they were the same person. He thought at times he himself was demon possessed. He tried to kill himself numerous times when the revelations stopped. He broke the oaths he made to his wives and all of the commands of God.
I will follow the One who healed the sick, raised the dead, cast out demons, walked on water, calmed the storm, was transfigured and talked with Moses and Elijah, died and rose again, and ever lives as the Lord and judge of the world, Jesus!!
@Islam Critiqued ❤️ Ps you look different in this vid
Kay Soco Films lol
hahahah, I like your videos kay. God bless you
@Jonathan Hatfield I only missed one week at Easter 😎
😂
YEP, this muslim Yasir Qadri proves again that islam is just one big fat lie !
Hi brothers and sisters please pray for my wife and my baby she needs to get in to manual labor tomorrow. thank you!
initiated into what?
@@worshippers3590 right...yikes...
@@worshippers3590 i mean they need to start the labor manualy not naturaly idk how to call it other wise )not native english
@Trinit Productions. Okay. Please go to oxytocinmeasures.com and download the chart for LICENSED dilution and dosage range of synthetic oxytocin, and do not consent to any other dosage range on offer. Ideally accept only licensed dilution too.
Prostaglandins may be enough to get labour started, but use of iv synthetic oxytocin should be limited to the licensed directions, for the most natural labour and outcome possible. Do not expect to have the same midwife all the way to the end. What matters is the best chance of a normal birth. God is with your wfe.
@@LogosDefenders oh sorry to hear that dear brother. I'll keep you in my prayer. You mean caesarian section?
They always gotta use Arabic words, which most muslims don't understand.
He said ·" سَمِعْنَا وَأَطَعْنَا “. Which means we hear and we obey I'm Somali knows arabic.
Call me ignorant. But why is Yasir Qadhi exposing his religion?
Tom Burnett thank you for your reply.
Yasir Qadhi is too honest to be muslim
He wasnt.
This was an internal discussion among them which was later leaked by the least brightest one among them.
Farid from the youtube channel Farid Responds.
If you watch the full video you can see YQ repeatedly asserting our scripture and hadiths have major issues that cannot be explained away and it is being taken apart by the western academics.
At one point YQ even gets irritated when Mo Hijab keeps pressing him for details and repeatedly tells him not to push the matter further after saying these are well known issues among our scholars and it should only be discussed among circles of muslim academics who are of an advanced level.
Its a 1 hour video available on youtube with the original being about 1 and half hours. Mo Hijab edited the juciest part before sharing it with his inner group that includes apologist like Farid and Ali Dawah.
The leak and the source of the leak was confirmed by YQ in another video where he politely called out Farid as an idiot.
YQ reminds me of the Jahmiyya, Mu’tazila who tried to change Quraan/Hadith to please the Philosophers.. to keep loyal to Aristotles 10 origins of bodies..
He learnt from the Eastern scholars and today he dismisses them.. they aware of the Western world than he is while living in it!!
We should pray for this investigative scholarship that is digging in the root of islam. Truth will raise its head.
there is answer givenby one and only scholar javed ahmed ghamdi and his answer is on the spot
'their level of knowledge is now leaps and bound of what it used to be....' 😂
Apparently before.. most of them are fools…
The title is decieving and misrepresenting . Sheikh Yasir didn't say anything in the video about problems with the preservation of the Qur'an. He was talking about what scholars say about " Ahruf " and " Qira'at " . I thought you were better than this. Scholars have different opinions about the difference between the two . That is what Sheikh Yasir was talking about . Also, he was referring to the time when he was a student not now. He had no problem with the Qur'an being preserved. See the last 10 minutes of the original video to hear him say this.
I hope you can see it. His name Qadhi is so well preserved in the Bible. Bible is written more than 2000 years ago. That is amazing. Bible is so well preserved. His name is used so many times. In the Bible it is written as "Qatsin" it means "chief". His name means "Judge", "Ruler", "Commander" in the Bible. His name has same meaning in Arabic
@@mrome3634 sorry but I don't get it.
@@user-is7no9kb5e
People say Bible is not well preserved.
Qadhi is Biblical name it is well preserve.
@@user-is7no9kb5e
"His name Yasir is also well preserved in the Bible. "Jasher
The is a Book of Bible call Book of Jasher
So it is Book of Yasir.
Shalom
@@mrome3634 lol
"I had crisis in yale university" you have crises, you have shak, you have problems differentiating philosophy from islamic fiqh. We dont have any problems with ulumul Quran period. As a beginner or advanced student
Every thing is cristal clear with the science of ulumul Quran. And please enough with every one on youtube saying our scholars dont understand this or that, just because you have iPhone in your pocket.
that is a very cheap blow. Finally in Islam we dont make vague statements to address things if there is a certain thing you have crises with be specific and you will be answered. The prophet (may peace be upon him) left us with sound proof « تَرَكْتُكُمْ عَلَى المَحجّةُ الْبَيْضَاءِ ، لَيْلُهَا كَنَهَارِهَا لا يَزِيغُ عَنْهَا إِلاَّ هَالِكٌ"
May Allah protect us from the shak of modern day philosophy.
we all know islam is FALSE... I am happay Yassir is acknowledging that.
"And, just like that, Islam crumbled. "
Cit. The Internet
Only 10 likes, but like Mount Rushmore or Hollywood words that need to be edificed.
Cit. The Internet.
naaaaah theres 50,000 errors in the Bible..Quran still wins hands down
I'm curious to know why would allah create Jewish people if he hated them so much?! The GOD of the Bible loves all of HIS creation, even the unbelievers!
@Emperor AMEN brother! 🙏
He didnt hate the jews. He chose them above all nations. But they still chose something else over God.
"I don't wanna be explicit" why Sir? what are you trying to hide?
I find it very odd to claim copyright for a video that he kept up on his own channel for weeks and that had already been shared many times
Thanks for posting the video Colin. I was hoping you would narrate the video at points where we might not have the deep knowledge to understand some of the terms and/or implications of what Qadhi said. Critical analysis (asking unbounded questions) is an important aspect of the worldview vetting process if we honestly want people to adopt what we think is true, whatever that might be. As a follower of Christ, I appreciate that Christian scholars that have been doing this for some time and engaging with those in academia and other religions' scholars who may have differing presuppositions. Having faith from the Christian perspective entails that we trust which assumes that we're asking tough questions and analyzing the material and artifacts, making that analysis accessible to all who want to know. Otherwise, you have a lot of folks under a cloud of lies and in denial who close off conversation when presented with information that brushes up against what they've always been told. Grace and peace all.
Yasir Qadhi can be shockingly honest at times
Can you be little honest? Can you tell Islamic Critiqued that Abdeel is one of the title of Jesus (PBUH). Abdeel is Hebrew name for "Abdullah".
M Rome, your comments are consistently below my ignorance limit. Do better or I'll ban you. I'm tired of seeing your childish banter. Only warning.
@@IslamCritiqued With all due respect as someone whose not even Muslim and has no bone in this fight either way it seems very childish and even hypocritical of you to call someone a troll and threaten to ban them over a claim you disagree with. Especially ironic given your channel's purported aim to air controversial opinions to better arrive at a more reasonable truth.
Hypocrite
@@mrome3634yes... So?
@@Chandler4Mandler.🤡 🤡 🤡
So is this about translation or preservation ? Ubai was a reader not a revelator or translator . He read what he was given .
The oldest Quran muslim's have today was written in 1924. I know people older than that!
ByGrace ThroughFaith: the real sad part is Saudi Arabia issued their koran in 1984!
Five things that Muslims cannot and will never answer:
1. The word "al-Masih" means "the anointed" and it always meant "the savior" in Jewish history. If Jesus is al-Masih, whom Jesus saved from what by how?
2. "I challenge you to show me one verse from the Bible that clearly states he was God." Challenge accepted.
Isaiah 44:6 (God says) "Thus says the Lord, the King of Israel and his Redeemer, the Lord of hosts: I am the first and I am the last, And there is no God besides Me."
Revelation 22:13 (Jesus says) "I am the Alpha and the Omega, the first and the last, the beginning and the end."
3. Quran was not preserved perfectly.
3-1. You do not have the original Quran which is a compile of barks, leaves, leathers, and stones that Zayd ibn Thabit collected under the order of Uthman.
3-2. Many people who memorized the Quran died during the war.
3-3. People fought and even killed each other because of different recitation.
3-4. When Zayd compiled the Quran, there were two verses that only one man remembered. But Quran teaches you need at least two men for valid testimony.
3-5. ibn Masud didn't like the Quran that Zayd compiled and even said "it is deceitful." That's the Quran you have today.
3-6. Besides of 7 Qiraat, there are even more "versions" of Quran which reads and means differently.
3-7. Aysha reported that there were more than 200 verses in Surah 33 but now you have only 73 verses.
3-8. Zayd and Uthman completed "one" version but you now have at least "seven" Qiraats.
If the Quran is preserved by recitation, shouldn't Zayd, or ibn Masud, or Uthman remember the whole Quran correctly? Why did they need to collect all remaining materials and ask to all reciters? This historical fact shows that even the closest companions of Muhammad didn't memorize the Quran perfectly.
4. Is the Kabaah the house of God? If infinite(limitless) God goes into that limited structure, does he cease to be limitless God? If God enters into that building, does God stop being everywhere(omnipresence)? Who is the God inside the building and who is the God outside of the building?
5. If the Bible is corrupt, where in the Quran says that? If the Bible is corrupt, why do you find evidence of Muhammad from the corrupt book? If the Bible is corrupt, why Allah in the Quran gives same authority as the Quran, and orders Muhammad to "go to the people of the scripture and ask about what I told you"?
@@betos-08 Yeah that's the problem I'm talking about.
Yasir Qadhi: The standard narratives has holes bit I won't say it.
"I don't even wanna be explicit here" = "I don't want to want to tell you what these holes are to Muslims as this will lead them to critical thinking and potentially leave the fold of Islam".
It is so difficult to be a Muslim scholar. With the fear of being threatened with death, one has to choose between truth and death.
There is no free will in Islam. For example: Narrated Abu Huraira:
The Prophet (ﷺ) said, "Adam and Moses argued with each other. Moses said to Adam. 'O Adam! You are our father who disappointed us and turned us out of Paradise.' Then Adam said to him, 'O Moses! Allah favored you with His talk (talked to you directly) and He wrote (the Torah) for you with His Own Hand. Do you blame me for action which Allah had written in my fate forty years before my creation?' So Adam confuted Moses, Adam confuted Moses," the Prophet (ﷺ) added, repeating the Statement three times.
A just God will not write the destiny of a person to commit evil and then punish him for the same thing he made him do it.
Hijab had to pishab(pee) after hearing this.
Hijab is a guy who can win a debate by increasing his voice or stressing a immanent contradiction in the quran.
Eg. allah prays furrrrrrrrrr mohamad not 'Tooooooooo' mohamad.
Haha either ways allah PRAYS which means he is not the God.
Islam is a divine thing. It is not dependent on any mere mortals. Having doubts is that particular person's shortcomings. No matter what no humans can belittle it. People trying to harm, spread doubt or corrupt it will only hasten their own destruction. May the Creator curse these people and save mankind from their evil intentions.
stop that nonsense: allah did not even protect his kaaba against the Qarmatians, who destroyed it, took the stone away, peeded on it for 20 years and sold it back in the 8 pieces it is today...
allah is just as impotent as his prophet who could not even get a son to adulthood (9 years?)
Yasir Qadhi, at least he is genuinely honest about it. Even though he was holding back, I remember him saying he does not like to sugar coat things.
Imagine if people were allowed to criticize Islam... It would've died before it even got famous.
He doesn't want to be explicit in identifying what these pressing issues about the holes in the standard narrative are. Why don't Muslim leadership want to be transparent? Are they trying to maintain the grasp they have on their sheep? That's evil.
That is because he's just trying to parade himself as a scholar of the Qur'an when he's not. He can speak of defects all he likes, but fails in presenting a single one. Just blowing hot air. You'd have seen this if his message was not so much music to your ears... you just want to believe it's true.
The internet is number one enemy of islam. Takebeer