@@cookiesontoast9981they want the game to be childishly easy to play and no real difficulty at all Such as if you accidentally changed to set; they don’t trust kids not to fool around in the settings
They had a golden opportunity to help Bug types by making them super-effective against Fairys like how Poison and Steel were helped offensively...and they blew it
Plus, considering that Dragon and Fairy Type are primarily based on folklore, I doubt that anyone would have complained about a Bug weakness. Depnding on the specific fantasy world in question, fairies could be so tiny, pacifist ect. that they fill the niche of several bugs' prey within an ecosystem.
@@dansattahDragonflies have the highest rate of successful hunts out of ANY animal. Period. They’re little grim reapers. If we’re talking traditional small Disney-style fairies, or even gnomes, they would definitely be prime dragonfly food.
The worst part about removing the basic attack from the Pokemon Mystery Dungeon series is that that basic attack still exists in the game, it's just you can't do it but all the enemy Pokemon can
Slightly worse, imo, is that they didn't actually remove it, they just changed it to always do a static 5hp of damage, so it's basically useless. Why even bother? (Not sure if the remakes still have it or not, I didn't play those.)
@spectralumbra1568 Maybe the idea is that it's suppose to just be a turn waste? Like for positioning purposes? But there are other ways to do that. Honestly they need to revert it back to how it was in PMD 1 and 2
On the bright side, if you pick Meowscarada, the Quauquaval has a secondary type advantage at least (Fighting is strong against Dark). Would’ve been cool if they’d made the secondary types for all matchups work like that.
I mean I kinda get it. Your starter learns its first elemental move, you use it against rival’s starter, you feel good about big damage. Compare it to say Johto where Chikorita is just tackling things most of the time, not the same sort of satisfaction you know?
Tbf I kind of see it as we’re the rivals to the “rival” characters, which makes sense in the case with Hop and Hau since they want to prove they’re going to be the best, but the idea doesn’t work with with Nemona or Shauna who are supposed to be better than us, they feel Ike they’re taking it easy on the player despite them being our rival :/ But by the end, I still agree the idea of current rivals choosing the weaker starter apart from ours is still disappointing
Shauna I get but I think the whole gimmick with Nemona is that she’s actually intentionally going easy on us or otherwise limiting herself because she’s canonically so strong that if she brought her usual team, she’d stomp the player into the dirt, so she goes with a new team and makes sure to pick the starter weak to yours so you give her a more challenging fight. She’s a battle loving adrenaline junkie after all, and the whole game she’s basically playing a challenge run to try to get you to be the one person who can make her sweat in a Pokémon battle.
@@spiderssssssssssss no yeah, that was I was thinking after realizing it and forgot to add that Yeah, Nemona does makes sense to take it easy on us since she's already a champion and trying to push us to get to her level eventually by the end I feel that is a creative choice than what they tried to pull for Shauna IMO, or idk
Nobody is gonna call them "first partner pokemon" cause "starters" or "starter pokemon" has been cemented in the community for ages now, and is a way better term off the tongue.
@@Obsidian8RI’d like that, tbh. Take gigantamax Pikachu’s model, replace the tail with the usual design, and maybe also give it a paler belly like in some of the old art.
Agree!! Everyone compares them to Ash and most haven't even watched Pokemon Horizons yet, when so far the anime is super great. Wish Liko and Roy were given a more fair chance :/
"We need better jerk rivals" Not every rival needs to be an asshole or have this sympathetic/empathetic story. Like Nemona, i think she's a great rival because she's fun and expressive. She didnt have to be a jerk to be cool
Yeah. Besides, the only jerk rivals are only 3. Blue, Silver and Bede and everyone keep taking the Kalos gang into this discussion, which is really annoying. It's been 10 years since X and Y. And they weren't even the first friendly rivals. That was Brendan/May
There's always Hugh from Black & White 2, and hell, even Wally (in ORAS, at least) was a well-developed rival despite not being an asshole (and kinda getting shafted from most of the story).
I gotta say, one thing that keeps gen 3 from being perfect for me is the rival. Flat out doesn't even compare to the first 2 or the one after thank god
Blue wasn't really a jerk though. More like condescending and competitive. Silver was the only jerk. Even the fairy weirdo in SWSH doesn't really count because he acted like a baby lol.
I'll give you 1 major downgrade you somehow skipped. Going from gen 3's battle system speed to gen 4's. It was on newer and more powerful hardware and yet the battles were still in 2D and runs slower than previously.
Honestly, the PLG graphics is the best the games ever looked, in my opinion. I skipped the games when they were initially released, but got them gifted some years later, and was really surprised by their graphics. If it weren't for the missing PvE fights and the GO style catching, they would be almost perfect remakes of Gen 1.
I feel like it was a mistake to call PLA mainline, because fans reasonably expect that gameplay and a lot of its elements to appear in future mainline games. But I'm glad a lot of them didn't reappear fully in SV. PLA is more of a 3rd-person shooter than a turn-based RPG. It's far less about battling and gaining experience through training. It's just an option in PLA to battle for experience, and frankly, it's a far harder option. The game encourages you to play it like an action game most of the time. But SV is an open-world turn-based RPG. It's not an action game even after incorporating light action elements. They added the ability to sneak behind a Pokémon to make it a little easier to catch from PLA, and I think that's appropriate. What I did want to see though was the frostbite and drowsy mechanics return. Those made more sense in a more active game like PLA, but it would have still worked in SV. And Freeze was never a good status since it's very hard to inflict and remove. And Sleep is so broken that there are multiple rules in multiple formats restricting its use. I do hope that returns.
7:10 Geetas biggest problem was her ace. its best used as the first Pokemon to use Hazards Plus the terra type Stone change almost nothing, that thing had a fairy moves who got wasted. The fight would definitely be better if she started with it(with terra or not) and made the Kingambit her final one, which get stronger the more pokemon are defeated.
I always thought they could do more with the "Cut grass" mechanic that they ditched after Gen III. Why not have Pokemon or items that can only appear after cutting the grass away?
Emboar has grown on me a lot ever since I used it in BW2 recently. It learns Scald, which is neat, but having to grind PWT for a Brick Break TM was admittedly a bit of a pain.
Brother don’t waste time on the PWT. You get more BP from the battle subway and it’s much much easier to get the TMs there. Plus the BP counts if you take it to PWT.
Still salty that ash greninja was retconned. I remember being so excited using battle bond greninja in the sun and moon games, transferred it to scarlet and violet, and was immediately disappointed. I get that gamefreak wanted to distance itself from both ash and mega evolution, but they really violated my entire experience with battle bond.
For some of mine 1. Reducing the number of double battles. Colosseum and XD are the poster children but emerald had a fair few too 2. Transferring Pokémon between generations. It was annoying but at least it was free. 3. Pokémon following you. Need I say more?
The remake of the Gen that is most associated with double battles has barely any. Why even make mechanics for doubles only for the player to not use any of them in the game itself.
The remake of the Gen that is most associated with double battles has barely any. Why even make mechanics for doubles only for the player to be unable to use any of them in the game itself.
I think you're being a bit unfair towards Liko and Roy. They need more time to be fleshed out as characters. Edit: Also I don't think Starter Pokemon being humanoid is an objective downgrade. I can't speak for everyone, but I actually don't mind the majority of them.
I feel like removing the Battle Frontier is the biggest downgrade for me. The fact that they teased it in ORAS but never gave it to us is just adding salt to the wound.....
So crazy that the last time it was in a game was HGSS. OVER HALF of the series so far doesn't have the Battle Frontier! It's been FIVE generations since it was there!
Making that Battle Frontier tease even worse is the fact that Hoenn's Battle Frontier was confirmed to be destroyed in Emerald's timeline during SM's postgame story. Because THAT'S not a HUGE MIDDLE FINGER to the people who thought it'd return!
4:27 Liko and Roy are actually super entertaining and well-written protagonists so far in Pokemon Horizons! I like them a lot (especially Liko!) and I feel like most people aren't giving them a fair chance just because of Ash nostalgia :(((
I haven't watched the anime since I was never a huge fan of it, but TBH I'm glad we got new protagonists, hell thats entirely one of the major points people give to the digimon anime, it got new characters and new stories.
I'm way too old for the anime now, however I'm pretty glad Ash was discontinued. I got sick of him getting bonked with the stupidity hammer every new generation.
I can't speak on them because I stopped watching the anime a long time ago. One reason is that it's very clearly a children's anime. But I stopped watching it when I was young enough to still be in the target audience because I always found Ash annoying, so calling a change from Ash to ANYONE a downgrade rubbed me the wrong way here.
I have to disagree what u Said about liko and Roy Pokemon horizons is such a huge upgrade from the dumpster fire that was Pokemon journeys Liko isn't supposed to be ash shes has a different personallity and goal
I think horizons needs a chance to get their footing, ash had over 1,000 episodes to grow while Liko and Roy aren’t even 30 episodes in, not a fair comparison honestly
Someone who gets it, it's so annoying seeing people comparing Liko and Roy to Ash. His dumbass had 25 years and 1000 episodes worth of anime, whereas Liko and Roy barely had 30 or so
The worst part about removing the PLA catching method is that this method never inherently took away the original system. You can choose to battle a Pokemon, weaken it, and then throw a Pokeball in the actual fight. That, or you could choose to skip the fight and actually interact with them in the overworld.
@@imprincesswolfy2565 Many things started with gen 3 lmao the friendly rival, All starters being Bipedal & humanoid, and like the linear Aka to much water 😂
That is not true, they removed the phrase from box arts, but the phrase "Gotta catch em all" was used all the way up to and including gen 6 with the advertisements for each new games such as posters, and the announcement commercials such as in Diamond and Pearl, and X and Y.@@imprincesswolfy2565
Maybe its because i spent so many years trying to get certain shinies but finally getting them now actually makes me really happy bc I can finally have them... it still feels like a payoff to me
Same, shinies were only for people who was willing to waste hours upon hours in a game, people who dont want to waste their life getting legit cool colored pokemon i think will be more memorable, but even so, they should not be THIS common. I got 5 in my first playthrough of violet and that was when I was not even trying
I wanted them to make it a little bit easier then pre-gen 8. But they went to far.😂 Make me feel an idiot looking back at having spent so many days and hours soft resetting for my shiny legends in gen 7, and all the time spent with dexnav, s.o.s battles and masuda method breeding... Felt so proud of my 30+ shinies but now Shinies are not that valuable anymore...😐
Well, i Will say, in my First game of Scarlet, i didnt got even a Shiny, not even How much i Hunted, until end game, that a cutie Lion club walked to me, all white, and i used to defeito everyone in the final part of the game with a Shiny Female Pyroar, but nowdays, i have now 4 Boxes of Shiny pokemon, but only because i Hunt for they
One of the biggest reasons why I still consider Pokemon X&Y my underrated gem is because, at the time, the 3D graphics were so different and amazing! "Oh, Nintendo used the models again? Well Pokemon Platinum and Heartgold weren't too different in style so maybe they'll change it up a bi--- oh... oh......... oh............. :("
They did add the Arceus event in bdsp but you do have to play Legends to completion in order to get it I guess they did that for the lore...which is a little silly but hey it's there
I feel like beta girafarig it could have worked pretty well as an evolution perhaps even a middle stage - as if the tail is slowly taking over the body turning girafarig a psychic dark type
I don't understand how people complain about shiny hunting being refined into a "easier process". Sure the hunt itself maybe shorter, but it's not as if you don't have to put effort into getting the hunt set up. It's extremely time consuming to complete the pokedex to get the shiny charm and quite tedious to farm tera raids for herba. It's not like you're just given these things at the start of the game, you have to go and earn them. Furthermore, no one is making you earn these items, so if you want the hunt itself to feel longer, just don't use them...
Making it so you can't turn off battle animations in Scarlet and Violet. It's even worse in Tera Raids. I once got timer-stalled by a Greedent spamming Bullet Seed.
I think it's saying something that Pokemon is in such a dire state that the people who aren't blindly worshipping the franchise are only looking forward to a finished product now. That's an inexcusable low that no other Nintendo IP committed.
Strongly disagree that XY didnt have much in the way of post game, the looker cases were so incredibly fun, a better comparison would have been Scarlet and Violet which after completing Area 0 (which isnt post game, it's the final major story plot) theres NOTHING to do
you can do the academy ace tournament, take classes. catch the four ruin legendaries by finding the stakes, farm herba mystica by doing tera raids. i wouldn’t say there’s nothing to do
Fans: “why Ash is still around give us a new main character!” Pokemon anime finished Ash anime and replaced with new main characters,Liko and Riyo Fans:”Boo ! I don’t want these new characters! I want Ash!” For real I think the only ones who are complaining never gave the new anime a chance
Another downgrade is that well I can't pick so let me list them down below *clears throat as i get my papers in order* 1- removing the option to put stickers on our pokeballs (my adhd creative brain loved it) 2- contests or whatever gen 5 (aka unova) had cause I loved doing them more than the gyms 3- customization getting worse (gen 6/7/8 were good but gen 9 screwed it up) 4- good online features and stuff that didn't require a online subscription (I hate Nintendo online for their expensive prices)
Gen 9 have more limiting outfits due to you being a student. And besides hairstyles are no longer locked between genders which already makes it (imo) superior to prior gens
A Massive Downgrade not mentioned in the video is Evolutions getting way to tedious and obscure. Galarian Farfetch to Sirfetch is so annoying and also needing Pokémon to walk a certain amount of steps and the step count can reset.
Iv'e pretty much had it with people's beef about "Bipedal mons are bad" thing, last time we had quadrapeds (Meganium and Samourott) people still didn't like them.. I also hate the term "furries/people in Fursuits" Everytime we do get a Bipedal mon..
I like meganium, though I did find samurott disappointing. I think I mostly just wanted it to stay looking like an otter though. I very much agree that the complaints about humanoid mons is super subjective and kind of silly.
@@mastermarkus5307 I think what annoys alot of people (me included) is that Samurott could've either leaned more into being an otter OR go hard on the "Swordmaster"-thing, but Gamefreak decided to do a weird hybrid of the two that REALLY didn't turn out right. It looks SO weird wielding a sword, when it has the body-type of a table.
The problem with BDSP is that it stuck too close to the originals. There were plenty of bugs in the originals they could have fixed in the originals, but didn't for the sake of "consistency".
I really wish triple and rotation battle makes their comeback. People who are not in the competitive world would appreciate it. Only having TWO battle options are very limited. Since 2002 that we are having the same battle systems in the games. At least Gen 5 and 6 were the exception, but in Gen 7 we lost them. So, since 2014 we are missing a new battle way in the games.
Same I really loved the addition of triple & rotation battles and I still don’t think they were utilized enough. I’d love a game where during the course of the game you battled both a gym a antagonist and rival using triple/rotation.. hey we had a double battle in gen 3 with Tate & Liza in RSE..
3:27 Wait, so what are these new shiny odds he's talking about? Also, there's no way it actually involves making sandwiches... I did that once, laughed at how bad of a feature it was, then never again.
Base odd are 1/4096, using a level three sandwich can get it to 1/1024.38 but using a lv.3 sandwich, the shiny charm, and using outbreak method hunting you can shave it down to 1/512.44 odds. Not to mention outbreak hunting kinda guarantees the shiny Pokémon as long as you don't mess it up, shinies are pretty easy to get.
If you download like the two pictures of the lv 3 shiny sandwich recipes for every type you can get most stuff easily. one for increasing spawn rates for a type so you don’t always have to wait for the outbreaks, and one for increasing size in the overworld -useful to my blind 31yo ass squinting at the microscopic dreepies you can easily pick up a few even as a very casual hunter. I have maybe five or six shinies I hunted and a couple I don’t care about just from getting same type mons walk into my specific hunt location or whatever. the adhd is severe so I’ve never bothered for more than an hour or so. Most annoying part is the sandwich eating animation and the “let’s go” knock out chains needed to maximise rates without a shiny charm
Oh also I didn’t know until embarrassingly late 1) that the herba mystica were in the condiments page of my sandwich ingredients when I was in creative mode and 2) you don’t gotta place that top bun if you don’t want to, throw it into the void if it’s about to knock the important ingredients off
I feel like GF Meetings are: "Okay we have the upcoming remakes, what do fans want and expect? Okay we are not gonna do any of it and remove what they like".
I feel like catching pokemon in Legends Arceus seriously lowered the attachment I had to my pokemon. I felt nothing with a capture. It was like, oh my 36th Bidoof. hurray guess. I feel like the only way it could work in a normal pokemon title, is having you battle the pokemon if you fail to catch it.
Contrarily, IDC about any pokemon I catch in main series apart from the main 6 I use in a normal playthrough, any other one is just pokedex fodder. It's also a lot slower having to engage in battles and catch them the traditional way. But legends ALSO made both catching styles optional. Nothing stopped you from battling to catch a mon apart from it being the slower method. Scar/vio doesn't give you the choice, you either do it the slow traditional way, or you don't catch pokemon.
@@darcidious99 Unlike Legends Arceus, you're not supposed to catch heaps and mountains of pokemon in Scarlet and Violet, just the ones you're intrested in, or if you want to complete the dex, 1 of each. I get that the mechanic makes sense gameplay wise in that game, you don't want to need to battle every mon and watch a cutscene to catch it, if catching a lot of pokemon is the goal. But as I said, that's not the point of S&V, slowness may be annoying, but it's 10x better than feeling nothing for me.
@@shinysilverstardust which is why again, there's no point in it not being optional, which legends did do. I never cared about it making sense in the context of the game's story/atmosphere, what I cared about is that it was fun to just chuck balls and items around and stealth up on pokemon. I feel nothing catching pokemon the traditional way apart from "cool, one more in the pokedex", I'm not saying that the legends way is the best thing since sliced bread, but it's quick and has a tactile feel to aiming/throwing that battling doesn't do for me. Especially in the context of the game being a massive open world, why do i have to be restricted into a turn based battle to catch/interact with a pokemon? Why can't I bait an area with berries to draw in pokemon, or set like a trap or something to lock fast ones like varoom into place? You're still tasked with completing the pokedex, even if you only catch 1 of each species that's still 400 catches minimum, why not make it something that's fun to do? I don't think the traditional way should ever be deserted, but they definitely need to give us something else to do cause I hate it. At the very least baiting an area or something to that effect immerses me into seeing them as wild creatures, even if i have to do a turn based battle to catch the thing. Here you just walk into them... I hate it😂. At least you can throw your pokemon out manually though im glad that made it over at least, it sorta barely transfers that feeling from legends.
Number 42, Kanto was a downgrade even in GSC, let alone HGSS. The trainers were weak, the Wild Pokémon even weaker and no big story event besides challenging Gym Leaders to battle Red. The Rocket Sidequest in Cerulean doesn’t count. Post Game Content has never been THAT good. Don’t kid yourself.
I genuinely had no clue who the angel chick dressed in white was when you were talking about the Champions, so I had to look up all the Champions in the core games... turns out it's Diantha from X & Y. How is it that I've played through Pokemon Y more than 10 times and I still forgot who she was... seems like you've proved your point about them not being near as memorable as they used to be haha
diantha is also easy as f*ck to beat so that’s also probably why she’s forgettable, it’s been 10 years since the games came out, and also when you beat her it’s not worth rematching her because she will have the exact team at the exact same levels as her first battle (maybe grinding for money is worth rematching) but other than that she’s the worst champion imo aside from geeta
7:29 I NEVER want ILCA to touch Unova. I haven’t played either original Unova Game yet (Even though I have a 2DS to play them on) so I don’t want my first Unova Experience to be like my first Sinnoh Experience (Which was BDSP… AKA PAIN)
Pokemon fans have been BEGGING for over a decade to replace Ash in the anime. And now youre complaining that theyre not good enough??? Jesus christ I hate this fandom.
No one is going to talk about the Vs Recorder? That's a massive downgrade, I remember watching a lot of Indiv and VGC matches in USUM, and then in SwSh it was like bruh
I will agree with you on Hyper Beam(3:42). The low PP is enough to balance the move from being spammed. Hyper Beam not being effective against Rock, Steel, and Ghosts helps as well.
7:00 there were always human like pokémon. Machoke is just a buff guy. I would like to see a quad pedal meowscarada but the design could start to be repetitive with all the other Cats/dogs in the game. Plus I think making it an Magician was a cool idea.
I agree. It's a very "genwunner" sort of opinion where someone doesn't look back on what was actually in gen 1. Like, so many people hate on Klefki for being "just keys" but Voltorb and Electrode are absolutely more boring (I think Klefki is really cute and has a good inspiration). I understand some people kind of wanting the sprigatito evolutions to be quadrupedal because it seems like a lot of STARTER final evos specifically are bipedal, but I very much agree that meowscarada ended up being a cooler idea than just "plant cat".
Well they were specifically talking about the Starters which I'd say is easy to see by classifying them with a "Job" that could fit a real person which doesnt help with majority of them also being anthro Starting from Gen 6: Paladin, Ninja, Mage, Archer, Singer, Wrestler, Drummer, Spy, Soccer player, Magician, Dancer, they keep designing starters with a profession instead of just...making a creature.
@@AnzuInfinity it doesn't matter if starter or not when it has a cool design. they try to give a similar design origin for the starter with dnd classes, good vs evil+damsel in distress(even thou dicedueye keeps most of his owl look) , things that are popular in England and final artists (same for the Gen 1-5 ones just don't have all in mind), they mostly try to keep all choices in that theme and human like starters were a thing since Gen 3 with Blaiziken. Plus for the drummer part, it's hard to make a monkey less human looking
8:23 Female Pikachu and Raichu are so cuuuuute !! I've never seen this until now, why ?! p.s. I was about to say that I remembered Female Wobbuffet to have lipstick, but in this beta she actually had a longer "hair" too ! That's actually fun (I'm totally onboard Pokémons having minor differences such as this, doesn't need to be associated to gender btw...)
51. Going from TCG online to TCG Live 52. Pikachu’s cry going from the cute “pika!” to the static computer noises from Gen 1 in legends arceus forward.
Biggest Downgrade of all time in Pokémon: Pokémon Fans. They get worse and worse as time passes by… I can sense the darkness inside their heart… At this point on… their heart will fall into darkness… and become corrupted for good…
Kingdom Hearts speech aside, I'm definitely inclined to agree. I remember back when the biggest issue in the fanbase were genwunners, which aside from their very harsh opinions, were just opinionated people but not necessarily toxic. Nowadays it seems everyone is as opinionated as them, and the truly rabid fans are unbelievable.
Eh, mixed feelings on that. Sometimes the fans are toxic, but the games have had some serious, objective problems recently (Scarlet and Violet visuals and performance) and Pokémon as a whole has kind of languished in not making interesting changes to the main gameplay loop, at least not battling.
Oh, indeed. This fanbase is corrupt and rude and I am sick of it. I see way too many insults spat in the faces of people who like the newer games, myself included.
#19. I'm so glad I'm not the only one that thinks they should reintroduce no cooldown when fainting a pokemon. Like, just say that they recharged while the opponent was sending out another pokemon or something.
@@josh_jacobbwho? Ghost is one of the best types in the meta, steels are basically everywhere, porygon-z is basically the only one that can pull it off and you wouldn’t waste your tera on that. We have a broken normal move already in boomburst it just has small distribution and even with tera normal it’s not broken. Besides, with modern power creep we can definitely handle it.
I for one am glad the Fairy type is around! Also, I am liking Pokémon Horizons so far and I already vastly prefer Liko over Holden Caulfield. Battle Frontier and single use TMs? Agreed. You also missed that following Pokémon were done better in Heartgold/Soulsilver and Let’s Go. Also, Giovanni’s highest level Gym Pokémon should have been a Rhydon rather than Rhyhorn; It’s the last Gym, it’s level 50, make it a Rhydon!
Im happy that i only played gen 1-5 and just replayed them instead of buying the new ones since I have never heard anyone say they prefer gen 6-10 over the older games and most reviews on them are mostly about whats wrong and what they removed instead of whats good.
5:45 I LOVE that shiny jingle, I trained my ears to that sound only because I have rare chances for a shiny, and I made it my text ringtone when my girlfriend texts me. 🥰
I think pretty much everyone is mad that the jingle is gone. A while ago I ran into a Sunflora because I thought the colour was off and it actually was a shiny. Barely any difference and I would have walked past it if not feeling like something was off. #Bringbacktheshinyjingle
The biggest downgrade is the artstyle going from amazing in SWSH and LA to whatever the bad word SV gave us (the kids in that game just look like creepy dolls I actually hate looking at it)
Should N be counted as the gen 5 champion, I mean you fight him right after the elite four, and he beat Alder, so if he does count he was the last super good champion.
Aura Guardian i respect your opinions, but honestly the fight with either N Ghetsis or Iris is feels better than Cynthia. Blondy is kinda overrated at this point
The only thing I explicitly disagree with is the ash downgrade. Riko and Roy are better than Ash, imo. And Horizons is actually interesting, a lot more than most of Ash's journeys.
Anthro Pokemon have a genuine presence in the world of Pokemon, but when you get something like an anthro green cat masquerade or a lizard with gloves, you need to step back a bit and remember these are Pokemon. Amidst my criticism, anthro green cat is a sick design, but it would fit better in a game like Digimon.
The biggest downgrade of all time is the rival like we have blue and silver who actually have personalities and story but then we have tierno Shauna and nemona
As someone who started with Platinum and awaited the gen IV remakes with massive anticipation...I was so insanely disappointed it's not funny. They're the worst Pokémon games, not even close.
Added some to make 60. (MY OPINION) 51: Adding overworld shinies in LGPE and not having them in SWSH. (Probably addressed in the video) 52: Scrapping Friendship based moves like Return, teasing them in BDSP only for them to get cut again. 53: Nerfing the already terrible PokeRadar in BDSP, at least it was fixed. 54: Nerfing the Shiny Charm in BDSP. At least it was fixed in PLA and Sc/Vi. 55: Making Outbreaks behave differently between PLA and Sc/Vi. 56: Nerfing critical captures in Gen 8 so they have a moderate chance of failing, at least it was finally fixed in Sc/Vi. 57: Going from an abundance of region forms in Gen 7 & 8 to only two in Sc/Vi. (Convergent forms don't count) 58: Classifying The "Loyal Three" as Legendary Pokemon but only having BST's of 555. (The same as Arcanine, Banette and Ursaluna) 59: Not making Fezandipiti our first Poison/Flying type since GEN 1. 60: Adding an item that basically removed trade evolutions, only for them to return in Sc/Vi. (R.I.P Linking Cord)
I really don't agree on the Starters becoming more humanoid being bad. I personally actually prefer it that way, as it gives them more personality. Also, I'd say Infernape is pretty humanoid lol.
I have to disagree that it gives them more personality. Swampert and Serperior have a ton of personality, and they aren’t humanoid at all. And Chesnaught is kind of a mess personality-wise, at least imo, and it is fully bipedal with humanoid arms. Being humanoid could make it _easier_ to give them personality from a designer’s perspective, but it doesn’t give them a leg up in showing personality.
@@christiancinnabars1402 Oh, I didn't mean it as in "Humanoid = Always better", I just tend to prefer the more humanoid designs. I personally don't think ANY starter is bad design-wise.
@VioletLunaChan I really don't mind humanoid starters at all. I especially dislike when people say Pokémon like empoleon, are humanoid because they stand on 2 legs. Not all animals are quadrupeds, animals like birds are bipedal, bears and apes often take bipedal stances.
Shiny odds being lowered is not an issue cause that exclusivity was always dumb, especially since shiny system is so threadbare. Oh you only get one shiny variant for a Pokemon and not several, freaking lame.
Another downgrade is not being able to switch between the “Set” battling style and the “Switch” battling style.
Wait, you *can't* do that anymore?!
@@blackcat_064 No, not anymore, unfortunately!!
THANK YOU
Although I've never actually bothered to try out set battle style, that's just really weird that they would remove it?!
@@cookiesontoast9981they want the game to be childishly easy to play and no real difficulty at all
Such as if you accidentally changed to set; they don’t trust kids not to fool around in the settings
They had a golden opportunity to help Bug types by making them super-effective against Fairys like how Poison and Steel were helped offensively...and they blew it
U-Turn spam
Have you seen this move’s distribution
@@goGothitaLOLyeah let’s just keep bug useless bcuz U-turn exists…
As if they couldn’t lower its power etc. so funny 😂
@@goGothitaLOL Just...don't give it to as many Pokémon? There, problem solved
Plus, considering that Dragon and Fairy Type are primarily based on folklore, I doubt that anyone would have complained about a Bug weakness.
Depnding on the specific fantasy world in question, fairies could be so tiny, pacifist ect. that they fill the niche of several bugs' prey within an ecosystem.
@@dansattahDragonflies have the highest rate of successful hunts out of ANY animal. Period. They’re little grim reapers.
If we’re talking traditional small Disney-style fairies, or even gnomes, they would definitely be prime dragonfly food.
The worst part about removing the basic attack from the Pokemon Mystery Dungeon series is that that basic attack still exists in the game, it's just you can't do it but all the enemy Pokemon can
Lmao
Slightly worse, imo, is that they didn't actually remove it, they just changed it to always do a static 5hp of damage, so it's basically useless. Why even bother? (Not sure if the remakes still have it or not, I didn't play those.)
@spectralumbra1568 Maybe the idea is that it's suppose to just be a turn waste? Like for positioning purposes? But there are other ways to do that. Honestly they need to revert it back to how it was in PMD 1 and 2
That's crazy. I'd use the basic attack a lot when I played Explorers of Sky. Sometimes you want to save some PP.
@justanotherweirdo11 it was in super too, but they nerfed it and capped its damage which I hated, but atleast it was still there
Pokemon:you remember that feature that everyone loves and we promoted?
Players:yeah it was great.
Pokemon: me neither
Ball seals :(
@@darcidious99YES
legit my favorite addition ever, and now the only other game to have them is BDSP... makes me so sad@@KoniXyz
True
Not exactly loved or promoted but I think sky battles were great
Of course not as good as triple and rotation battles but still
You forgot making it so the rival chooses the Pokémon weak to your starter now. Removing basic strategy.
On the bright side, if you pick Meowscarada, the Quauquaval has a secondary type advantage at least (Fighting is strong against Dark). Would’ve been cool if they’d made the secondary types for all matchups work like that.
I mean I kinda get it. Your starter learns its first elemental move, you use it against rival’s starter, you feel good about big damage. Compare it to say Johto where Chikorita is just tackling things most of the time, not the same sort of satisfaction you know?
Tbf I kind of see it as we’re the rivals to the “rival” characters, which makes sense in the case with Hop and Hau since they want to prove they’re going to be the best, but the idea doesn’t work with with Nemona or Shauna who are supposed to be better than us, they feel Ike they’re taking it easy on the player despite them being our rival :/
But by the end, I still agree the idea of current rivals choosing the weaker starter apart from ours is still disappointing
Shauna I get but I think the whole gimmick with Nemona is that she’s actually intentionally going easy on us or otherwise limiting herself because she’s canonically so strong that if she brought her usual team, she’d stomp the player into the dirt, so she goes with a new team and makes sure to pick the starter weak to yours so you give her a more challenging fight. She’s a battle loving adrenaline junkie after all, and the whole game she’s basically playing a challenge run to try to get you to be the one person who can make her sweat in a Pokémon battle.
@@spiderssssssssssss no yeah, that was I was thinking after realizing it and forgot to add that
Yeah, Nemona does makes sense to take it easy on us since she's already a champion and trying to push us to get to her level eventually by the end
I feel that is a creative choice than what they tried to pull for Shauna IMO, or idk
Nobody is gonna call them "first partner pokemon" cause "starters" or "starter pokemon" has been cemented in the community for ages now, and is a way better term off the tongue.
Leave it to gamefreak to finds a way to make pokemon lamer and lamer each generation 😂
Lol in japan one of the fan term for starters is "The Big Three"
The same thing can be said about Arceus's pronunciation
@@aztecelotl You better be joking. Ain't no one pronouncing it ar-see-us.
Ar-kæy-us is only way to pronounce his name.
@@olivercharles2930 Don’t believe me? Watch some poketubers, and tell me how many of them pronounce the name with the “s”?
3:53 can’t say “gotta catch ‘em all” when they literally no longer let you
To be fair they never let you... I think.
@@olivercharles2930 even if you didn’t catch em all in one game, you could transfer them over
@@NasuPrimeYou could catch 'em all...
across both versions.
You know the “Upgrade” “Go Back” “I said Go F*cking back” Meme Template? That’s this video in a nutshell
Yeah lol 😂
Me when xy dropped
No, it is not. It is full of either nitpicks or things that simply aren't realistic.
I mean we also have of the most major upgrades in those game
You mean Pokemon for years
Fat Pikachu looks more like an adorable pet.
Modern Pikachu looks more believably agile and strong, to me.
I like both designs.
Fat pikachu looks outdated and acoustic
It would have been funny if there was a parodox version of pikachu that was basically just fat pikachu
@@Obsidian8RI’d like that, tbh. Take gigantamax Pikachu’s model, replace the tail with the usual design, and maybe also give it a paler belly like in some of the old art.
@@OneClick2goboo
I think Liko and Roy need time to flesh out before we start comparing them to Ash, who’s had 25+ years of content behind him.
Agree!! Everyone compares them to Ash and most haven't even watched Pokemon Horizons yet, when so far the anime is super great. Wish Liko and Roy were given a more fair chance :/
@@ScribbleSpirit yeah. I even think if you put Liko and Roy next to Ash at the start of his journey, people would probably like Liko and Roy more.
I thought her name was spelt "Rico"
Liko and Roy have so much charisma and are so fun to watch compares to the repetitive one sided minded Ash. He was good but lets move on.
yeah. I don't want 10 year old ash back. Let him rest! And only return if aged!
"We need better jerk rivals" Not every rival needs to be an asshole or have this sympathetic/empathetic story. Like Nemona, i think she's a great rival because she's fun and expressive. She didnt have to be a jerk to be cool
Yeah. Besides, the only jerk rivals are only 3. Blue, Silver and Bede and everyone keep taking the Kalos gang into this discussion, which is really annoying. It's been 10 years since X and Y. And they weren't even the first friendly rivals. That was Brendan/May
There's always Hugh from Black & White 2, and hell, even Wally (in ORAS, at least) was a well-developed rival despite not being an asshole (and kinda getting shafted from most of the story).
I gotta say, one thing that keeps gen 3 from being perfect for me is the rival. Flat out doesn't even compare to the first 2 or the one after thank god
Blue wasn't really a jerk though. More like condescending and competitive.
Silver was the only jerk. Even the fairy weirdo in SWSH doesn't really count because he acted like a baby lol.
Sure but name one guy who had no crush on Nemona.
I'll give you 1 major downgrade you somehow skipped. Going from gen 3's battle system speed to gen 4's. It was on newer and more powerful hardware and yet the battles were still in 2D and runs slower than previously.
Worth dealing with all of it for the physical/special split.
@@ViewtifulBeau Modern gen III rom hacks: Am I a joke to you?
@@GalCon99 I don't play rom hacks
Honestly, the PLG graphics is the best the games ever looked, in my opinion. I skipped the games when they were initially released, but got them gifted some years later, and was really surprised by their graphics. If it weren't for the missing PvE fights and the GO style catching, they would be almost perfect remakes of Gen 1.
I still think battle revolution is the best we got visually, but for main series lets go is definitely the highest quality visuals we got.
In my opinion, PLG isn't the best Pokemon ever looked but it's certainly the best looking pokemon game on Switch.
And the missing cross-gen evolutions
What do you mean by PLG?
@@flyingchairguy2221Pokemon Let's Go (Pikachu and Eevee)
Legends Arceus really made a bunch of good steps forward. To me, its the biggest upgrade ever.
If abilties were in legends arceus/regigigas did not have slow start even without abilities being in the game it would be the best pokemon game
I agree but but i hate the star system
Yes like getting rid of freeze and making frostbite like an ice type burn but lowered special attack instead of attack
I agree
I feel like it was a mistake to call PLA mainline, because fans reasonably expect that gameplay and a lot of its elements to appear in future mainline games.
But I'm glad a lot of them didn't reappear fully in SV.
PLA is more of a 3rd-person shooter than a turn-based RPG. It's far less about battling and gaining experience through training. It's just an option in PLA to battle for experience, and frankly, it's a far harder option. The game encourages you to play it like an action game most of the time.
But SV is an open-world turn-based RPG. It's not an action game even after incorporating light action elements.
They added the ability to sneak behind a Pokémon to make it a little easier to catch from PLA, and I think that's appropriate.
What I did want to see though was the frostbite and drowsy mechanics return. Those made more sense in a more active game like PLA, but it would have still worked in SV. And Freeze was never a good status since it's very hard to inflict and remove. And Sleep is so broken that there are multiple rules in multiple formats restricting its use. I do hope that returns.
7:10 Geetas biggest problem was her ace.
its best used as the first Pokemon to use Hazards
Plus the terra type Stone change almost nothing, that thing had a fairy moves who got wasted.
The fight would definitely be better if she started with it(with terra or not) and made the Kingambit her final one, which get stronger the more pokemon are defeated.
I always thought they could do more with the "Cut grass" mechanic that they ditched after Gen III.
Why not have Pokemon or items that can only appear after cutting the grass away?
Emboar has grown on me a lot ever since I used it in BW2 recently. It learns Scald, which is neat, but having to grind PWT for a Brick Break TM was admittedly a bit of a pain.
Brother don’t waste time on the PWT. You get more BP from the battle subway and it’s much much easier to get the TMs there. Plus the BP counts if you take it to PWT.
Still salty that ash greninja was retconned. I remember being so excited using battle bond greninja in the sun and moon games, transferred it to scarlet and violet, and was immediately disappointed. I get that gamefreak wanted to distance itself from both ash and mega evolution, but they really violated my entire experience with battle bond.
are you ash?
Downgrades are the biggest reoccurring flaw of the series. It’s a shame they don’t take a longer break between games
For some of mine
1. Reducing the number of double battles. Colosseum and XD are the poster children but emerald had a fair few too
2. Transferring Pokémon between generations. It was annoying but at least it was free.
3. Pokémon following you. Need I say more?
Yup, gotta wave Nintendo my credit card every year to keep my virtual friends off death row.
Pokemon following was cool in HGSS but honestly, there should've been a toggle for doing it.
@@jeremiahgreen5632 I agree and tbh I think let's go did it better overall.
The remake of the Gen that is most associated with double battles has barely any. Why even make mechanics for doubles only for the player to not use any of them in the game itself.
The remake of the Gen that is most associated with double battles has barely any. Why even make mechanics for doubles only for the player to be unable to use any of them in the game itself.
Only having 4 clothing sets in sv was disappointing enough to be on this list imo
I think you're being a bit unfair towards Liko and Roy. They need more time to be fleshed out as characters.
Edit: Also I don't think Starter Pokemon being humanoid is an objective downgrade. I can't speak for everyone, but I actually don't mind the majority of them.
yea those were weird takes, especially the Liko/Roy one
@@NovaDog-gz4ye It is an objective downgrade,
@@NovaDog-gz4ye Clearly done to target furries
I feel like removing the Battle Frontier is the biggest downgrade for me.
The fact that they teased it in ORAS but never gave it to us is just adding salt to the wound.....
So crazy that the last time it was in a game was HGSS. OVER HALF of the series so far doesn't have the Battle Frontier! It's been FIVE generations since it was there!
Making that Battle Frontier tease even worse is the fact that Hoenn's Battle Frontier was confirmed to be destroyed in Emerald's timeline during SM's postgame story. Because THAT'S not a HUGE MIDDLE FINGER to the people who thought it'd return!
4:27 Liko and Roy are actually super entertaining and well-written protagonists so far in Pokemon Horizons! I like them a lot (especially Liko!) and I feel like most people aren't giving them a fair chance just because of Ash nostalgia :(((
I haven't watched the anime since I was never a huge fan of it, but TBH I'm glad we got new protagonists, hell thats entirely one of the major points people give to the digimon anime, it got new characters and new stories.
I'm way too old for the anime now, however I'm pretty glad Ash was discontinued. I got sick of him getting bonked with the stupidity hammer every new generation.
@@scrittle that only happened in Gen 5 anime
I can't speak on them because I stopped watching the anime a long time ago. One reason is that it's very clearly a children's anime. But I stopped watching it when I was young enough to still be in the target audience because I always found Ash annoying, so calling a change from Ash to ANYONE a downgrade rubbed me the wrong way here.
@@scrittlethat only ever happens in gen 5. Every other gen he keeps his smarts
Triple Battles and Rotation Battles were the best in my opinion as they were fun to play
I have fond memories of playing X as a kid. EV training my playthrough team the moment I caught them so they could destroy the battle maison.
@@NintendoMeister2260 Cool
More variations of the usual battle style is not a bad thing.
@@ct2xperience749 I never said it was
@@rainbowdragon168 my apologies I misread the comments
I have to disagree what u Said about liko and Roy
Pokemon horizons is such a huge upgrade from the dumpster fire that was Pokemon journeys
Liko isn't supposed to be ash shes has a different personallity and goal
I think horizons needs a chance to get their footing, ash had over 1,000 episodes to grow while Liko and Roy aren’t even 30 episodes in, not a fair comparison honestly
Someone who gets it, it's so annoying seeing people comparing Liko and Roy to Ash. His dumbass had 25 years and 1000 episodes worth of anime, whereas Liko and Roy barely had 30 or so
The worst part about removing the PLA catching method is that this method never inherently took away the original system. You can choose to battle a Pokemon, weaken it, and then throw a Pokeball in the actual fight. That, or you could choose to skip the fight and actually interact with them in the overworld.
i want inverse battles to return, i always set the battle style, in my oras secret base, to inverse battles
I wouldn't be surprised to see triple & rotation battles be scrapped in the Generation 5 remakes.
they realized we no longer can "catch em' all" anymore so they changed it to "train on" lol
They removed “catch ‘em all” all the way back in gen 3
@@imprincesswolfy2565 Really? I didn't know it was removed at all. It's still the slogan to me.
@@imprincesswolfy2565 Many things started with gen 3 lmao the friendly rival, All starters being Bipedal & humanoid, and like the linear Aka to much water 😂
That is not true, they removed the phrase from box arts, but the phrase "Gotta catch em all" was used all the way up to and including gen 6 with the advertisements for each new games such as posters, and the announcement commercials such as in Diamond and Pearl, and X and Y.@@imprincesswolfy2565
Also it was still in the TV shows up to and including X and Y.
Maybe its because i spent so many years trying to get certain shinies but finally getting them now actually makes me really happy bc I can finally have them... it still feels like a payoff to me
Same, shinies were only for people who was willing to waste hours upon hours in a game, people who dont want to waste their life getting legit cool colored pokemon i think will be more memorable, but even so, they should not be THIS common. I got 5 in my first playthrough of violet and that was when I was not even trying
@@uncreativename775 I think some people are just lucky... since release Ive gotten one
I wanted them to make it a little bit easier then pre-gen 8. But they went to far.😂 Make me feel an idiot looking back at having spent so many days and hours soft resetting for my shiny legends in gen 7, and all the time spent with dexnav, s.o.s battles and masuda method breeding... Felt so proud of my 30+ shinies but now Shinies are not that valuable anymore...😐
Well, i Will say, in my First game of Scarlet, i didnt got even a Shiny, not even How much i Hunted, until end game, that a cutie Lion club walked to me, all white, and i used to defeito everyone in the final part of the game with a Shiny Female Pyroar, but nowdays, i have now 4 Boxes of Shiny pokemon, but only because i Hunt for they
One of the biggest reasons why I still consider Pokemon X&Y my underrated gem is because, at the time, the 3D graphics were so different and amazing!
"Oh, Nintendo used the models again? Well Pokemon Platinum and Heartgold weren't too different in style so maybe they'll change it up a bi--- oh... oh......... oh............. :("
Am I really the only one who's happy with the new anime protags?
I like them too. I think it’s a bit unfair to be comparing them to Ash already.
Nah I love them!! Wish so many people wouldn't slander them without having even watched Pokemon Horizons
Nah your not I love them too even though I haven't watched much of Horizons lol
Man i love triple and rotation battles lets hope gen 5 remake/ what ever else they are planning adds them back.
I love triple battles I really miss em..but doing em multiplayer reall strained the system.
They did add the Arceus event in bdsp but you do have to play Legends to completion in order to get it
I guess they did that for the lore...which is a little silly but hey it's there
Remember when our biggest complaint was whether or not Fennekin would evolve into another Fire/Fighting type?
I feel like beta girafarig it could have worked pretty well as an evolution perhaps even a middle stage - as if the tail is slowly taking over the body turning girafarig a psychic dark type
I don't understand how people complain about shiny hunting being refined into a "easier process". Sure the hunt itself maybe shorter, but it's not as if you don't have to put effort into getting the hunt set up. It's extremely time consuming to complete the pokedex to get the shiny charm and quite tedious to farm tera raids for herba. It's not like you're just given these things at the start of the game, you have to go and earn them. Furthermore, no one is making you earn these items, so if you want the hunt itself to feel longer, just don't use them...
Making it so you can't turn off battle animations in Scarlet and Violet.
It's even worse in Tera Raids. I once got timer-stalled by a Greedent spamming Bullet Seed.
I think it's saying something that Pokemon is in such a dire state that the people who aren't blindly worshipping the franchise are only looking forward to a finished product now. That's an inexcusable low that no other Nintendo IP committed.
Strongly disagree that XY didnt have much in the way of post game, the looker cases were so incredibly fun, a better comparison would have been Scarlet and Violet which after completing Area 0 (which isnt post game, it's the final major story plot) theres NOTHING to do
you can do the academy ace tournament, take classes. catch the four ruin legendaries by finding the stakes, farm herba mystica by doing tera raids. i wouldn’t say there’s nothing to do
Fans: “why Ash is still around give us a new main character!”
Pokemon anime finished Ash anime and replaced with new main characters,Liko and Riyo
Fans:”Boo ! I don’t want these new characters! I want Ash!”
For real I think the only ones who are complaining never gave the new anime a chance
Fr 😂 everyone clowns on ash till he left now suddenly he was never annoying
clowning on him for being dumb or whatever but when he becomes the master ppl praise him. my main downgrade would be the community.
Literally no one said that lmao
He never was annoying, just incompetent @@Phoenix_Blader_93
@@olivercharles2930 youd be suprised
Honestly the constant downgrades on the switch games led me to snap. I think Scarlet and Violet are easily the worst pokemon games in the series.
Another downgrade is that well I can't pick so let me list them down below
*clears throat as i get my papers in order*
1- removing the option to put stickers on our pokeballs (my adhd creative brain loved it)
2- contests or whatever gen 5 (aka unova) had cause I loved doing them more than the gyms
3- customization getting worse (gen 6/7/8 were good but gen 9 screwed it up)
4- good online features and stuff that didn't require a online subscription (I hate Nintendo online for their expensive prices)
though for #4 there is more to it than just online though I agree it can be high for some to afford
Gen 9 have more limiting outfits due to you being a student. And besides hairstyles are no longer locked between genders which already makes it (imo) superior to prior gens
online is a bit bad, but at least it’s not $70 a month, right?
@@giganticmoon 1 system has online for $70?
@@pkmnlover3812 Xbox is going to raise it to $90 and PS is $70.
A Massive Downgrade not mentioned in the video is Evolutions getting way to tedious and obscure. Galarian Farfetch to Sirfetch is so annoying and also needing Pokémon to walk a certain amount of steps and the step count can reset.
Iv'e pretty much had it with people's beef about "Bipedal mons are bad" thing, last time we had quadrapeds (Meganium and Samourott) people still didn't like them..
I also hate the term "furries/people in Fursuits" Everytime we do get a Bipedal mon..
I like meganium, though I did find samurott disappointing. I think I mostly just wanted it to stay looking like an otter though.
I very much agree that the complaints about humanoid mons is super subjective and kind of silly.
@@mastermarkus5307 I think what annoys alot of people (me included) is that Samurott could've either leaned more into being an otter OR go hard on the "Swordmaster"-thing, but Gamefreak decided to do a weird hybrid of the two that REALLY didn't turn out right. It looks SO weird wielding a sword, when it has the body-type of a table.
Thank you for putting Lanturn in the video, i was so dissapointed when i transfered my shiny to pokemon X back in the day.
I like to call mini changes for the worse for no reason “quality of death” changes
The problem with BDSP is that it stuck too close to the originals. There were plenty of bugs in the originals they could have fixed in the originals, but didn't for the sake of "consistency".
I really wish triple and rotation battle makes their comeback. People who are not in the competitive world would appreciate it. Only having TWO battle options are very limited. Since 2002 that we are having the same battle systems in the games. At least Gen 5 and 6 were the exception, but in Gen 7 we lost them. So, since 2014 we are missing a new battle way in the games.
Same I really loved the addition of triple & rotation battles and I still don’t think they were utilized enough. I’d love a game where during the course of the game you battled both a gym a antagonist and rival using triple/rotation.. hey we had a double battle in gen 3 with Tate & Liza in RSE..
@@JayClearman411 I hope from the Gen 5 remakes, they make a comeback. They were part of the story and had some sort of presence in the post game.
@@didy3615 I’d love a triple or rotation battle featuring chill cilian and cress
With passage pansear an panpour.
@@JayClearman411 tbh I thought that’d be the triple battle/rotation battle introduction in BW1.. it was a wasted potential
3:27 Wait, so what are these new shiny odds he's talking about? Also, there's no way it actually involves making sandwiches... I did that once, laughed at how bad of a feature it was, then never again.
Base odd are 1/4096, using a level three sandwich can get it to 1/1024.38 but using a lv.3 sandwich, the shiny charm, and using outbreak method hunting you can shave it down to 1/512.44 odds. Not to mention outbreak hunting kinda guarantees the shiny Pokémon as long as you don't mess it up, shinies are pretty easy to get.
If you download like the two pictures of the lv 3 shiny sandwich recipes for every type you can get most stuff easily.
one for increasing spawn rates for a type so you don’t always have to wait for the outbreaks, and one for increasing size in the overworld -useful to my blind 31yo ass squinting at the microscopic dreepies you can easily pick up a few even as a very casual hunter. I have maybe five or six shinies I hunted and a couple I don’t care about just from getting same type mons walk into my specific hunt location or whatever. the adhd is severe so I’ve never bothered for more than an hour or so.
Most annoying part is the sandwich eating animation and the “let’s go” knock out chains needed to maximise rates without a shiny charm
Oh also I didn’t know until embarrassingly late 1) that the herba mystica were in the condiments page of my sandwich ingredients when I was in creative mode and 2) you don’t gotta place that top bun if you don’t want to, throw it into the void if it’s about to knock the important ingredients off
I feel like GF Meetings are: "Okay we have the upcoming remakes, what do fans want and expect? Okay we are not gonna do any of it and remove what they like".
another one is that getting rid of gengar’s ability levitate. changing it in gen 7 to cursed body giving it another weakness.
That'a a well deserved nerf
gengar is still to powerfull. Deserved that nerf. And cursed body is a great and annoying ability on it anyways.
Undeserved @@lacuevadelosrpg4070
I feel like catching pokemon in Legends Arceus seriously lowered the attachment I had to my pokemon.
I felt nothing with a capture. It was like, oh my 36th Bidoof. hurray guess.
I feel like the only way it could work in a normal pokemon title, is having you battle the pokemon if you fail to catch it.
It's the PoGo effect. I throw out hundreds of pokemon a week that I give zero shats about any of them.
Contrarily, IDC about any pokemon I catch in main series apart from the main 6 I use in a normal playthrough, any other one is just pokedex fodder. It's also a lot slower having to engage in battles and catch them the traditional way.
But legends ALSO made both catching styles optional. Nothing stopped you from battling to catch a mon apart from it being the slower method. Scar/vio doesn't give you the choice, you either do it the slow traditional way, or you don't catch pokemon.
@@darcidious99 Unlike Legends Arceus, you're not supposed to catch heaps and mountains of pokemon in Scarlet and Violet, just the ones you're intrested in, or if you want to complete the dex, 1 of each.
I get that the mechanic makes sense gameplay wise in that game, you don't want to need to battle every mon and watch a cutscene to catch it, if catching a lot of pokemon is the goal.
But as I said, that's not the point of S&V, slowness may be annoying, but it's 10x better than feeling nothing for me.
@@shinysilverstardust which is why again, there's no point in it not being optional, which legends did do. I never cared about it making sense in the context of the game's story/atmosphere, what I cared about is that it was fun to just chuck balls and items around and stealth up on pokemon. I feel nothing catching pokemon the traditional way apart from "cool, one more in the pokedex", I'm not saying that the legends way is the best thing since sliced bread, but it's quick and has a tactile feel to aiming/throwing that battling doesn't do for me.
Especially in the context of the game being a massive open world, why do i have to be restricted into a turn based battle to catch/interact with a pokemon? Why can't I bait an area with berries to draw in pokemon, or set like a trap or something to lock fast ones like varoom into place? You're still tasked with completing the pokedex, even if you only catch 1 of each species that's still 400 catches minimum, why not make it something that's fun to do? I don't think the traditional way should ever be deserted, but they definitely need to give us something else to do cause I hate it. At the very least baiting an area or something to that effect immerses me into seeing them as wild creatures, even if i have to do a turn based battle to catch the thing. Here you just walk into them... I hate it😂. At least you can throw your pokemon out manually though im glad that made it over at least, it sorta barely transfers that feeling from legends.
same
Number 42, Kanto was a downgrade even in GSC, let alone HGSS. The trainers were weak, the Wild Pokémon even weaker and no big story event besides challenging Gym Leaders to battle Red. The Rocket Sidequest in Cerulean doesn’t count.
Post Game Content has never been THAT good. Don’t kid yourself.
Looking back, even the postgame of FireRed and LeafGreen was better, cause while shorter, feels like a lot more happened.
@@TheReaperofHades agree
I genuinely had no clue who the angel chick dressed in white was when you were talking about the Champions, so I had to look up all the Champions in the core games... turns out it's Diantha from X & Y. How is it that I've played through Pokemon Y more than 10 times and I still forgot who she was... seems like you've proved your point about them not being near as memorable as they used to be haha
diantha is also easy as f*ck to beat so that’s also probably why she’s forgettable, it’s been 10 years since the games came out, and also when you beat her it’s not worth rematching her because she will have the exact team at the exact same levels as her first battle (maybe grinding for money is worth rematching) but other than that she’s the worst champion imo aside from geeta
The images used for downgrade 44 are actually f***ing legendary, lmfao.
I liked BDSP, but the fact that it’s missing the Platinum content is baffling.
7:29 I NEVER want ILCA to touch Unova. I haven’t played either original Unova Game yet (Even though I have a 2DS to play them on) so I don’t want my first Unova Experience to be like my first Sinnoh Experience (Which was BDSP… AKA PAIN)
Pokemon fans have been BEGGING for over a decade to replace Ash in the anime. And now youre complaining that theyre not good enough??? Jesus christ I hate this fandom.
No one is going to talk about the Vs Recorder? That's a massive downgrade, I remember watching a lot of Indiv and VGC matches in USUM, and then in SwSh it was like bruh
Number 18, that’s a lie or I’m the unluckiest guy who ever used a Sparkling Power Level 3 Sandwich… TWICE!!
Didn’t see ONE shiny Pokémon, either time!
I will agree with you on Hyper Beam(3:42). The low PP is enough to balance the move from being spammed. Hyper Beam not being effective against Rock, Steel, and Ghosts helps as well.
7:00 there were always human like pokémon. Machoke is just a buff guy.
I would like to see a quad pedal meowscarada but the design could start to be repetitive with all the other Cats/dogs in the game.
Plus I think making it an Magician was a cool idea.
I agree. It's a very "genwunner" sort of opinion where someone doesn't look back on what was actually in gen 1. Like, so many people hate on Klefki for being "just keys" but Voltorb and Electrode are absolutely more boring (I think Klefki is really cute and has a good inspiration).
I understand some people kind of wanting the sprigatito evolutions to be quadrupedal because it seems like a lot of STARTER final evos specifically are bipedal, but I very much agree that meowscarada ended up being a cooler idea than just "plant cat".
@@mastermarkus5307 I like Klefki too and I'm sure most who complain about it don't have a better design for a "Key stealing fairy"
Not to mention Jynx is literally categorized as the "Human Shape Pokémon"
Well they were specifically talking about the Starters which I'd say is easy to see by classifying them with a "Job" that could fit a real person which doesnt help with majority of them also being anthro
Starting from Gen 6:
Paladin, Ninja, Mage, Archer, Singer, Wrestler, Drummer, Spy, Soccer player, Magician, Dancer, they keep designing starters with a profession instead of just...making a creature.
@@AnzuInfinity it doesn't matter if starter or not when it has a cool design. they try to give a similar design origin for the starter with dnd classes, good vs evil+damsel in distress(even thou dicedueye keeps most of his owl look) , things that are popular in England and final artists (same for the Gen 1-5 ones just don't have all in mind), they mostly try to keep all choices in that theme and human like starters were a thing since Gen 3 with Blaiziken.
Plus for the drummer part, it's hard to make a monkey less human looking
"No champion as good as Cynthia since Gen 4"
Iris on Gen 5: "Am I a joke to you?"
I do think Cynthia is still the best, especially relative to it's time, but I also agree on Iris, Steven and Leon being actually pretty strong.
yeah she is a joke
@@mysticmisc4585not if you play black2 on challenge mode she’s NOT!
@@JayClearman411 no, even then shes still a joke. Gen 5 as a whole is easily the worst gen.
@@mysticmisc4585 if you’ve play sword/shield, brilliant diamond, scarlet etc your clearly misinformed.
I like how all of the cartridges shown at 6:17 are bootlegs
8:23 Female Pikachu and Raichu are so cuuuuute !! I've never seen this until now, why ?!
p.s. I was about to say that I remembered Female Wobbuffet to have lipstick, but in this beta she actually had a longer "hair" too ! That's actually fun (I'm totally onboard Pokémons having minor differences such as this, doesn't need to be associated to gender btw...)
Pokken was one of coolest thing that happened to Pokemon company
51. Going from TCG online to TCG Live
52. Pikachu’s cry going from the cute “pika!” to the static computer noises from Gen 1 in legends arceus forward.
I'm not sure how many people know this, but Gamefreak didn't actually make Brilliant Diamond and Shining Pearl
The company they hired is shrouded in mystery, Nintendo themselves endorsed the product so therefore they're complicit in the trash that was BD/SP.
@@scrittle Thing is that BD/SP wasn't "trash".
Correct, it was a dumpster fire
@@scrittle You are describing Platinum there.
That's bait
Biggest Downgrade of all time in Pokémon: Pokémon Fans.
They get worse and worse as time passes by… I can sense the darkness inside their heart… At this point on… their heart will fall into darkness… and become corrupted for good…
Kingdom Hearts speech aside, I'm definitely inclined to agree. I remember back when the biggest issue in the fanbase were genwunners, which aside from their very harsh opinions, were just opinionated people but not necessarily toxic. Nowadays it seems everyone is as opinionated as them, and the truly rabid fans are unbelievable.
True. You are speaking facts.
Also nice guess on Kingdom Hearts speech, but it’s more of a speech on backstory of Lord Shen from Kung Fu Panda 2.
Eh, mixed feelings on that. Sometimes the fans are toxic, but the games have had some serious, objective problems recently (Scarlet and Violet visuals and performance) and Pokémon as a whole has kind of languished in not making interesting changes to the main gameplay loop, at least not battling.
I felt like the Pokemon fandom started to become a fucking warzone since the Kalos sequels were cancelled
Oh, indeed. This fanbase is corrupt and rude and I am sick of it. I see way too many insults spat in the faces of people who like the newer games, myself included.
I am really getting sick of people complaining about the graphics and Megas being gone, like seriously get over it.
I agree with you. Megas were the worst for VGC.
Same soon as megas were added postgame content took a nosedive.
Triple Battles, yes please!
I'll even take them with a side of Inverse Battles and Battle Royals.
#19. I'm so glad I'm not the only one that thinks they should reintroduce no cooldown when fainting a pokemon. Like, just say that they recharged while the opponent was sending out another pokemon or something.
Problem is fast enough special sweepers would use choice specs to utterly destroy teams
Might as well just play gen 1 ou if you want the feature back
@@josh_jacobbwho? Ghost is one of the best types in the meta, steels are basically everywhere, porygon-z is basically the only one that can pull it off and you wouldn’t waste your tera on that. We have a broken normal move already in boomburst it just has small distribution and even with tera normal it’s not broken. Besides, with modern power creep we can definitely handle it.
I for one am glad the Fairy type is around! Also, I am liking Pokémon Horizons so far and I already vastly prefer Liko over Holden Caulfield.
Battle Frontier and single use TMs? Agreed. You also missed that following Pokémon were done better in Heartgold/Soulsilver and Let’s Go. Also, Giovanni’s highest level Gym Pokémon should have been a Rhydon rather than Rhyhorn; It’s the last Gym, it’s level 50, make it a Rhydon!
mandjtv reference i see at the end there 🤭
I like emboar, don't defame emboar or I will show up at your HOUSE
Im happy that i only played gen 1-5 and just replayed them instead of buying the new ones since I have never heard anyone say they prefer gen 6-10 over the older games and most reviews on them are mostly about whats wrong and what they removed instead of whats good.
5:45 I LOVE that shiny jingle, I trained my ears to that sound only because I have rare chances for a shiny, and I made it my text ringtone when my girlfriend texts me. 🥰
I only got a shiny one time since I played the pokémon for years
@byronrush9802 it's not just visually seeing them, but training your ears is highly important.
I think pretty much everyone is mad that the jingle is gone. A while ago I ran into a Sunflora because I thought the colour was off and it actually was a shiny. Barely any difference and I would have walked past it if not feeling like something was off. #Bringbacktheshinyjingle
They can't use "Gotta catch 'em all" anymore, because you straight up can't. Hell, since Gen 1, you haven't be able to without a glitch
Don't sleep on Emboar, its surprisingly fun to play with.
Cut content is some of the most frustrating stuff ever; why oh why? That and the over-the-top hand-holding.
Every game has its cut content, Pokemon is not the exception there.
As for hand-holding? That's done for the sake of new players.
The biggest downgrade is the artstyle going from amazing in SWSH and LA to whatever the bad word SV gave us (the kids in that game just look like creepy dolls I actually hate looking at it)
More westernized artstyle to appeal to Americans and Europeans. Ironicially, the majority of US and EU highly prefers the more anime-style lol.
What's hilarious is that most of these come from the last 5-10 years and in that same time the company has made more money than ever
In my opinion 95% of pokemon and their shinies looked better in sprites.
Should N be counted as the gen 5 champion, I mean you fight him right after the elite four, and he beat Alder, so if he does count he was the last super good champion.
Aura Guardian i respect your opinions, but honestly the fight with either N Ghetsis or Iris is feels better than Cynthia. Blondy is kinda overrated at this point
You're wrong.
@@olivercharles2930you’ve obviously haven’t fought again iris in black2 challenge mode.
The fact that there is 50 down grades is just depressing
The only thing I explicitly disagree with is the ash downgrade.
Riko and Roy are better than Ash, imo. And Horizons is actually interesting, a lot more than most of Ash's journeys.
This!!!
Ur mentally ill
Am I the only person who likes the humanoid pokemon?
Nah I’m right here as well
Anthro Pokemon have a genuine presence in the world of Pokemon, but when you get something like an anthro green cat masquerade or a lizard with gloves, you need to step back a bit and remember these are Pokemon.
Amidst my criticism, anthro green cat is a sick design, but it would fit better in a game like Digimon.
Nope, I also like them.
@@scrittle I ain’t wanting to… you know… do that to ‘em
@@GrimoireIsGrimm I'm about to order my Inteleon to give you an anoplasty
The biggest downgrade of all time is the rival like we have blue and silver who actually have personalities and story but then we have tierno Shauna and nemona
Are you seriously saying that Nemona doesn't have a personality?!
@@miikaroos3809 yes
Biggest Downgrade of all time in Pokemon: Pokémon Fans
As someone who started with Platinum and awaited the gen IV remakes with massive anticipation...I was so insanely disappointed it's not funny.
They're the worst Pokémon games, not even close.
Facts the letdown was drastic
I’m sorry but Liko and Roy are infinitely better than Ash (I don’t hate Ash btw)
Added some to make 60. (MY OPINION)
51: Adding overworld shinies in LGPE and not having them in SWSH. (Probably addressed in the video)
52: Scrapping Friendship based moves like Return, teasing them in BDSP only for them to get cut again.
53: Nerfing the already terrible PokeRadar in BDSP, at least it was fixed.
54: Nerfing the Shiny Charm in BDSP. At least it was fixed in PLA and Sc/Vi.
55: Making Outbreaks behave differently between PLA and Sc/Vi.
56: Nerfing critical captures in Gen 8 so they have a moderate chance of failing, at least it was finally fixed in Sc/Vi.
57: Going from an abundance of region forms in Gen 7 & 8 to only two in Sc/Vi. (Convergent forms don't count)
58: Classifying The "Loyal Three" as Legendary Pokemon but only having BST's of 555. (The same as Arcanine, Banette and Ursaluna)
59: Not making Fezandipiti our first Poison/Flying type since GEN 1.
60: Adding an item that basically removed trade evolutions, only for them to return in Sc/Vi. (R.I.P Linking Cord)
I really don't agree on the Starters becoming more humanoid being bad. I personally actually prefer it that way, as it gives them more personality. Also, I'd say Infernape is pretty humanoid lol.
Apes are humanoid by default, though. Out of all animals, they resemble humans the most and share the most DNA with us
I have to disagree that it gives them more personality. Swampert and Serperior have a ton of personality, and they aren’t humanoid at all. And Chesnaught is kind of a mess personality-wise, at least imo, and it is fully bipedal with humanoid arms.
Being humanoid could make it _easier_ to give them personality from a designer’s perspective, but it doesn’t give them a leg up in showing personality.
@@TrueDokkanGod That is true. Howerver, doesn't change the fact that it inheritly makes Infernape humanoid.
@@christiancinnabars1402 Oh, I didn't mean it as in "Humanoid = Always better", I just tend to prefer the more humanoid designs. I personally don't think ANY starter is bad design-wise.
@VioletLunaChan I really don't mind humanoid starters at all. I especially dislike when people say Pokémon like empoleon, are humanoid because they stand on 2 legs. Not all animals are quadrupeds, animals like birds are bipedal, bears and apes often take bipedal stances.
2:53 Wait! When did that happen? I haven’t been keeping up with the TCG that much.
How about not being able to turn off battle animations? Or Pikachu and Eevee losing their signature cries?
i disagree with the let's go thing. i see the let's go and legends catching mechanic to be an upgrade to the normal catching.
What about the villain team?
Went from "world domination" to "we got bullied at school"
At least they have interesting development and not "I wanna expand the land/sea because... Why not?"
@@naganut9718 exactly
@@theamazingspooderman2697 expanding the sea for is still 10x cooler than whatever the hell Gen 9 was on
Shiny odds being lowered is not an issue cause that exclusivity was always dumb, especially since shiny system is so threadbare. Oh you only get one shiny variant for a Pokemon and not several, freaking lame.