Getting China Wrong: The U.S Would Lose the War with China
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ส.ค. 2024
- In recent years, tensions between the United States and China have escalated. Today, we are honored to have Ben Becker, chief-editor of BreakThrough News, to talk about his view on US-China relations.
Join our Telegram discussion group by link:
t.me/+w8w-J6nn...
For more trending stories and tech news in China, please subscribe:
chinaacademy.s...
For more latest Chinese tech news Podcasts, please subscribe:
chinaacademy.s...
How many native Indians now living in US? Uyghurs in Xinjiang now has 11 millions. There are about 22k mosques in China. You can find Uyghur language on China currency notes. Uyghurs in Xinjiang speak Uyghur and Mandarin. The tourism, agriculture, new energy production, etc are booming in Xinjiang. Just visit Xinjiang see it yourself.
The problem is, those that always, I mean ALWAYS bring up Xinjiang in any argument and they are either too stupid to do some easy research about the place or they are just too stupid.
In China, one of the most famous actresses is Uyghur Dilraba. Uyghurs can get extra points in China's national college entrance examination. The Chinese government's policies towards Uyghurs and other ethnic minorities are better than those of the Han people, who make up the majority of the population. One of the most powerful countries in the world and its allies have killed many Muslims in the Middle East and Afghanistan, but they are extremely concerned about the Uyghur Muslims in China. Ugly double standards, ugly politics.😂
@@jacklee3663 when you hear that you really need to start ask questions....Ugly politics indeed
@@jacklee3663She is gorgeous meanwhile her acting hasn't improved for ages. Still in idol dramas😂😂😂
@@jacklee3663 well said
Guantanamo is example of human rights violations.
Guantanamo Bay, Abu Ghraib, Bagram, and USA prisons.
A piece of land stoled by the u.s.
...And I forgot to mention, NO ONE is in jail for torturing prisoners in Guantanamo until today, because the US IS ABOVE AND BEYOND ANY LAW, and are simply a bunch of untouchable crooks. Like Bush Jr...
and all the dark sites that we dont know off
@@tonypeterson5316how can kidnap people willy nilly and hold indefinitely
Hypocrisy is the US greatest export.
UK is probably the biggest importer
Using TH-cam
and chinese are the worst export from china
microplastics and coal pollution from china
@@LHVMleodragonlamb The United States has also polluted the earth in this way. Likewise, Chinese people have the right to develop.
Can't agree more. I'm a Chinese living in the US for 20+ years. I will summarize the US in two words: Hypocrisy and Short-sightness
Well, Mr. @Philoreason, after living in the US for 20+ years, if you think the US is so bad
there is still time the move back to Mainland China. My blessings and good luck.
China steal and copy , whats new ?
@@pathomthavaradhara that is not for you to decide , he will do that in his own time but truth must be told
@@pathomthavaradhara He needs to earn dollars in the US before the debt collapses🤣
Then why you runaway from your country and lived in U.S.? WUMAO
US is HYPOCRITICAL........... FULLY IN AGREEMENT with you.
TRUTH! Thank you for speaking the truth. The way China is building infrastructure in Africa made me change my position on them. They are making a real difference on the global scene.
In the name of humanity and world peace.
说实话，我们给你们建基础设施，和你们做生意，你们可以提供金属资源，这很公平，不要把我们想的太无私，我们不像西方人一样掠夺其他国家，我们只是想安安静静，和平做生意。
Go to war with Chine? America lost their mind. You even couldn't win in Afghanistan.
They won't 😂, lesson learned during korea war.
Well, Taiwanese doesn’t think so. They trust US will fight with China for them with no doubts 😂
Neither could the soviets
I'm not even Chinese but the Americans are kidding themselves if they believe their single forward-deployed Carrier Strike Group in Japan comprising a grand total of 7 ships can make a difference if war does break out over Taiwan, like right now for example.
China also has 3 Carriers.and actually doesn't even need them @@aero.l
You are one of the limited US citizens that tell the truth about China. Only taking a very close look at China before having an unbiased view of this country with hardworking people.
Hit the bull's eye! I particularly applaud the part "whatever the US accuses others it do it more at home". That is a fact so bring it out is truly sublime!
Honest and clear thinking👍👍👍
China has been deeply involved in Africa for more than 50 years, Africa trusts China more than Asia, which is why China has shared development with its neighbors for nearly 20 years.
They need infrastructure. The Chinese have an overcapacity in infrastructure, and a willingness to build for better prices than anyone.
They need capital. The Chinese have enormous capital
They have raw materials and food. The Chinese need both.
Africa will learn that China is taking advantage of them and put them into debt traps. India is much better partner than China at least India is not predatory when it comes to making deals.
@@howcc6973 China is the world's largest food importer. (Although for livestock and strategic reserves)
What you mean about Asia here but no Western like US?
@@fenglihei evidence, please
Truth speaker.❤
"whatever the US accuses others it do it more at home" that is so true I personally experienced it yrs back, the slogan " hit hard look out for #1" zero sum game, massive government corruption, deteriorated basic education, half of the populion is sick beyond repair from top to bottom all mess up, 'salability is the only reality in America' Hopelessly doom! PEACE
The US can't even win a war against Afghanistan, Iraq, Syria, etc. and has lost every war since WW2. Give that some thought.
And now it fights Russia, a much larger power.
The main purpose of US wars is to siphon tax payers money into private arm dealers' pocket. It has every mean of prolonging or even perpetuate wars.... so winning or losing is not the main concern. This narrow thinking exactly the cause of the empire's decline.
because in the end justice will win, evil not.
@@automatism4790 interesting statement unfortunately evil wins most of the time, but sometime justice do win; when justice win, civilization moves forward a little bit.
Sadly the last time the US stood as the good guy was in WW2. 😂
The danger of war is that the media in the US talks about war as if it costs nothing. If something costs nothing, why not?
It will cost their lives and economy
One thing for sure. These hypocrites will try their best to not get their children drafted, and if they ever do,, they make sure their kids don't get sent to the frontlines.
Excellent presentation❤❤
How can I click 10 likes? Anything less doesn’t do justice to the video.
The algorithm certainly won't allow justice to be done
make 10 YT account 😂😂
@@aredtomato8957 That would be cheating. what do you think I am? The US?
@@Hermit-Crab 👍🏻
bravery man standing upright and tell the truth, let more people know what is truly
Shory and to the point. It covered all aspects of world history and geopolitics in 5 minutes. Great 👍
In the face of US bluster, China quietly prepares...
because theyre in a digital prison and cannot even speak openly about weakened exonomy in China
LOL very apt description. Do more, Talk less vs Talk a lot but does nothing constructive. The World wants to Develop Peacefully but the US Only want that to happen in US n its vassal states while the Rest of the World their slave.
U$ is like a dog barking up some passing caravans
regrettable, I agree@@monipenny408
They don’t ask the USA citizens. Our government is so disconnected from the American people. I wonder if any of our Congress or Senate people know anything about America
With all the homelessness in America do you think they really cares about Americans? We are just tax donkeys and the elites are the owners of this country
Mike pence : it's not my job to take care of America
USA is becoming war state
The rich is the one’s they listen to not the regular Americans.
They all do American dollars.
Bravo China
Great interview!!!
China doesn't want war but trade and help build poor countries without discriminate them. That what countries should do for world good. Not constraint or control them. Stop corruption and do good to your country people first before you are capable of do good to other countries.
that's a lie china wants control just as much as the us I mean look at tibet or Hong Kong there an authoritarian dictatorship with only one party ppl think that China is out to help anyone but themselves is crazy
But your pres. Xi does not agree. He wants not only trade but to steal too.
by bullying other country?
@@dontknowyYou mean America?
@@dontknowy怎么欺负的？给别的国家修铁路修学校算侵略吗？那美国在中东干的那些事是不是大屠杀啊？
I totally agree with the view presented in this program. I think before it comes to the point of no return, that is when the war becomes inevitable, the US financial and economic condition will become so deteriorated, that it is inevitable to halt its offensive and subversive activities around the globe. It becomes inevitable to have a change in the whole fundamental of the US political system, as indicated in this program. Hegemony will be seen as futile, and the US must follow the global trend of cooperation with a win-win strategy as a dominating feature. The zero-sum, which is based on a colonial economy, is already becoming an out-of-date modus operandi. The EU will have to review its toxic leadership first. They will have to do it for their survival. Even now, you can see it becoming urgent, but they are still in limbo. Then after that, the US, being left alone in the Western camp, will have no choice but to go to the awakening phase. A whole new society with new foreign policies will have to ensue. I'm not sure how easy it is to do, seeing that the US has been so proud of itself for so long, that it has to "humiliate" itself for survival. But there is hope, given that there is a significant number of intellectuals with the right attitude and objectivity, that a new league of eligible community leaders could start a chain reaction for the change. We'll have a very interesting phase of modern civilization appearing in front of us.
really couldnt agree more 👍
Lies again? FNB Money Higher Chinese
Check out the history; the US was the enabler to both Nazi Germany and Militarism Japan because both Germany and Japan are resources poor countries. Just look at Germany now, the winter is coming for Germans. So, only with the US's support could Germany and Japan launch a war, never mind a world war. So, the US beating the Germans and Japs in WW2 was the enabler beats the starving kids.
Afer WW2, the Chinese communists started to run China. Then, China was extremely weak and poor, China and the US fought in Korea and Vietnam.
Rightly said! 👍
The question of how much Fiat Currency can a Nation spend to Bluff their way through a Conflict,
does appear to affect how well a Colonial Empire can exert influence on other Nations?
The US ran into financial difficulties in 1967,
that appeared to limit how much was enough on the Debt Bill.
LBJ was informed by Mike Mansfield about the War on Poverty that Johnson wanted to win,
could promote no Appropriations.
Without Cash, who pays the Workers in a Tank Factory in Lima Ohio?
If Banks that handle Payroll Accounts for several Employers are unable to find liquid assets to cover Checks,
what amount of fit will hit a shan?
Medium Banks were made aware of Capital limitations by Silicon Valley Bank.
They appear to be prepared to unload Treasury Paper to obtain cash.
So with a limited number of buyers for Treasury Notes,
who is buying the Treasury Paper that is supposed to insure the value of the Federal Reserve Note?
Germans faced a similar situation in between Wars.
But now we have Fiat Dollars that could lose value faster than a Wiemar Deutschmark
The European Union was Broke in 2018, they apparently will not be buying Bonds.
"Could be Bad." ...............Troy Tschudi
A real patriot can directly face the problems of his country.
Unfortunately most of us don’t get it.
Every word he says is true.
Amen to that. Younger and rational American like you should run the country,
Once in power, he will have no choice but to serve the JJJ elites who are the one who run this country
He is one of the few conscientious and wise people in the Western world! 👍
I saw a documentary that finally figure it out about the outcome from an hypothetical conflict is the South China Sea. The key defining factor is LOGISTICS. The reason why the US got five new military bases in Phillippines is because it needs a Weapons & Equipment Hub for the West Pacific. Guam is way too distant from the US operational bases in Okinawa (JP), Daegu City and Kunsan (SK) to serve as an effective re-supply spot. Should the conflict take longer than one month and China managed to hold bridgeheads near taipei, the U.S. air force would need multiple runways in the nearby area: F-35 are the strategic asset in that conflict. The two or three carriers deployed to South China Sea would need jet fuel re-supply as soon as the third week of conflict began. That's why the Phillippines -where ammo and fuel deposits will rest- should be a target from Day One.
Philippine sign up to be the target board.
To help the Marcos in keeping the family wealth.
That's why the Philippines leadership is so stupid (no other more charitable word to use). I am pretty sure that China has already locked in the coordinates for each of the bases in Philippines. The minute war is declared, missiles will be on their way to each of the bases. And most definitely, they will reach their targets faster than the Americans can even scramble.
The last time the USA had bases in the Philippines they left 50k half half babies and dumped their toxic waste into the bay
The Filipinos were thank you sir come again sir
@@DW-op7ly1M Filipinos were killed when US invaded in 1890s. I'm sure no Filipinos know this history . But yeah, "thank u sir" to the US. They will also provide prostitutes for their masters sailors😂
same no us media shout “free julian assange”
They always conveniently ignores Julian Assange
U put it so correctly men thanks atleast people are seeing
One of the most intelligent man I ever see.
Wow, well said and totally true!
I vouch this man is correct about all that has been said by him。
You also forgot proxy war which is what the US wants with Taiwan but everything else is 100% correct.
exactly.
"but does that mean that people in the US (Utterly Shameless) actually are willing to go to have a war with China?"
Well yes, as long as they are not involved directly. Look at how shameless those people in the US (Utterly Shameless) that screamed "we stand with ukraine" (but from thousands of miles away).
That's why they are manufacturing consent, by demonizing China and to instigate neighbouring countries of China to act against China.
US's gamble on a proxy war will be a lost, and they will lose big. China has said many times that they are not and will not fight a proxy war. If there is a war, they will target US military bases and they will hit US land in the pacific and Atlantic ie Hawaii and Alaska. If US wants to provoke, they'll get dragged into a war they are going to lose big.
Don’t forget the Philippines too.
Rarely seen good article! Dare to face reality, be thoughtful, and keep paying attention!
Fully agree 👍 with all he said
Clash of two different mindsets.
Realist Scarcity mindset: Fear of losing something, anxiety about not having enough, insecurity about lacking security, and greed for more. It always strives for a win-lose outcome, where one's gain is someone else's loss. Obama's Pivot to Asia: "If over a billion Chinese citizens have the same living patterns as Australians and Americans do right now, then all of us are in for a very miserable time. The planet just can't sustain it." Destined for war.
Continuation of US Foreign Policy to keep Asia poor and chaotic.
February 24, 1948, Declassified U.S. Foreign Policy:
Furthermore, we have about 50% of the world’s wealth but only 6.3% of its population. This disparity is particularly great as between ourselves and the peoples of Asia. In this situation, we cannot fail to be the object of envy and resentment. Our real task in the coming period is to devise a pattern of relationships which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security. ... that Japan and the Philippines will be found to be the corner-stones of such a Pacific security system and that if we can contrive to retain effective control over these areas there can be no serious threat to our security from the East within our time.
Since WWII, the United States has started 201 wars, overthrew 36 foreign leaders, killed or attempted to kill 50, dropped bombs in 30 countries, interfered in 86 foreign elections, and established a staggering 800 overseas military bases. To make the world safe for democracy, the US has caused the deaths of tens of millions of people in its conflicts in Korea, Vietnam, Yugoslavia, Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, and Syria. The CIA was involved in covert operations that resulted in mass killings of communists in over 22 countries. 500,000 to 2,000,000 Indonesian civilians disappeared in 1965-1966.
Here are the benefits of democracy for the world's richest and most powerful country: Economic inequality, inflation, stagnant real wages for the last forty years, costly healthcare, an expensive education system, student loan debt totaling $1.7 trillion with an average balance of $38,000, racial inequality, mass incarceration, the militarization of police, deteriorating infrastructure, housing affordability, homelessness, the opioid epidemic, and gun violence.
The form of democracy practiced in the U.S. results in social and economic policies that may not be as beneficial for the poorer eighty-eight percent of the population. Politics determines how wealth is distributed within a country.
Idealist Abundance mindset: Cooperation, resource-sharing, and win-win outcomes. War is avoidable.
The Chinese military has not been involved in any war or used its weapons to kill a single person outside its territory in the last forty-four years.
In 2011, Obama proposed the "Pivot to Asia" strategy, which shifted the focus of US foreign policy from the Middle East to Asia. This, along with the wargaming of a sea blockade of Chinese commercial ships on a global scale, the formation of the Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP), which deliberately excluded China, the establishment of a 2500-strong US marine air-ground task force in Darwin, and an increase in the rotation of both US Air Force planes and US Navy vessels through Australian bases, alarmed the Chinese leadership.
Unable to remain passive, hide their strength, and bide their time, Xi Jinping was selected as the leader of China in 2013 to make China more secure. These included the establishment of the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, the Belt and Road initiative, and the building of artificial islands in the South China Sea. These policies were a direct response to the perceived threat posed by the "Pivot to Asia" strategy. No country is excluded from joining the AIIB or the Belt and Road Initiative. Obama's intentions were clarified when he responded to Xi Jinping's proposal on September 25, 2015, to make the South China Sea (SCS) a non-militarized zone by initiating freedom of navigation operations in the SCS on October 27, 2015.
well said...
I hope more Americans can see this video. What did China do to America to owe this hostility? America would fall off grace only because of their own failures and issues.
China dared become the second leading economy and will be the leading economy by the end of the decade, that is its sin to the US.
General American even don’t know where is Africa or Asia. Your hope is only a dream.
"America will never be destroyed from the outside. If we lose our freedoms it will be because we have destroyed ourselves from within" - Abraham Lincoln.
America and Europe export, by value, 70% of all weapons. China could impose an arms export embargo on them to prevent more wars.
Not only will lose but will lose badly.
Well said!
so much truth i cried 😢
Candid, honest, truthful and smart guy
Agreed 100%.
Man power is running out in America, and the quality of manpower is weakening. The degree of thinking, physical fitness, family stability, and mental well-being are dramatically diminishing?
Agree You may say it Again & Again. HYPOCRISY 😂
Thanks for your point of view and honesty opinions
I am not willing to go to war for Taiwan.
Would you send your child to next door to stop a domestic dispute ?
美国挑起纠纷并且从中获利，如果划算全家上场
Definitely not, but I will send my wife!😁😁
It would lose quickly the conventional war. Then it would go nuclear and nobody would win. Not even the bystanders.
Very true Sir , thank you ❤
Totally agree
you have lots of good points there where a lot of people don't even think about👍
The PLA would be the strongest military the US has faced at least since Vietnam, probably longer. I doubt Americans have the kind of mass casualty tolerance war would mean.
U.S. military regime wil be underestimating China just like it's doing it to Russia.
And not to forget that the patriotic spirit of an average PLA soldier is 100 times that of an average american soldier. Faith is a formidable weapon. One is fighting for his homeland, the other is fighting for a salary.
I would wager the Americans would have better soldiers because American has spent so much of its existence at war
With that said America can’t supply the Ukrainians with weapons fast enough these days
Where China is still an industrial powerhouse
@@jivvyjack7723 And China has fought 8 long years against the Japanese invasion, and survived. And China has chase the US led coalition against N Korea when that coalition has 100 times more firing power and yet still ran away with tails between their collective legs. If US fight China this time around, they will have no legs or tails.
US has never fought an enemy of equal strength.
Trains derailing and bridges collapsing in America? Wow I didn’t know about this! 🤣
Can’t agree more with you
Well said 👏👍. Thanks for sharing and surfacing the truth. 👏👍
Completely agree with you!
Everything has its own consequences
Well presented
EXACTLY. Can’t be any more accurate. Salute you Sir for stating pure facts. 🫡
Thank you, i learned something new.
Well said Ben Becker comparing China, US and the West.
給台灣人的話：美國支持台獨的唯一原因是因為它想永遠維持美國的帝國主義地位。如果美國真的相信一個國家有自決的權利，為什麼美國不支持波多黎各的獨立呢？相反，美國125年前軍事入侵波多黎各，將其變成了殖民地。美國拒絕遵守42項聯合國決議，要求立即將波多黎各的主權歸還給波多黎各人。美國由幾百年前到現在都不斷犯下違反仁義道德的底線。如今，美國無條件扶植所謂以色列的「國家」，不斷供應武器，企圖讓以色列對巴勒斯坦人在他們自己的家園-巴勒斯坦實施種族滅絕。真正的民主國家會種族滅絕嗎？美國曾對美洲土著人民犯下種族滅絕，以建立自己的人為殖民地國家。這樣還沒算美國在夏威夷做的各種分裂、違反人道德觀念的行為；還有讓烏克蘭變成代理人，企圖挑撥一個民族之間的內部矛盾。如果美國是一個民主國家，為什麼現在有3800萬美國人生活在貧困中，而全球最富有的10人中有8人是美國公民？而中國則已經清除了大部分貧困，儘管人口是美國的4倍！（有眼的人都能看出來吧）如果美國是一個民主國家，為什麼只有40%的公民對美國的政府感到滿意，而90%的中國人對他們的政府感到滿意？不要投票讓台灣變成烏克蘭的樣子！
Let me ask amerikaans: are you certain you have got the right political persons(thus far, I have seen no leaders)through astronomically expensive 'elections'?
A very valid argument about a non war situation. A word of caution, China is no pushover. So go repair your bridges etc etc, but first get the necessary skills.good luck
It is definitely not easy for an American to make such comments. I love you bro.
Every government needs someone to speak out loudly about its shortcomings, which is the way to solve the problem or prevent it from expanding.
True
Excellent video!
This is so true
A man who just told the truth.
Loved your video. The US regime has lost its way. As I see it, the hegemony is broken.
The question now is how many Western countries does the US want to devalue.
Germany is in recession and in trouble.
The IMF needs overhauling, the UN needs overhauling and based outside the US.
How many US retired service men and women realized after serving that they were lied to and abandoned by their own government?
USA must be mad to imagine it could stop china progress. Just by population size alone, china has many more geniuses, scientists, researchers, engineers etc, invest more in R&D, has better government support, bigger market and a culture of diligence/discipline entirely lacking in the USA. Plus China has reached a critical mass to power its own rapid progress. Cheers.
Great analysis. Really. You hit it on the dot. Thank you for your insightful analysis of this intricate geopolitical matter and for presenting your vision with clarity. The opposition will challenge your perspective and, hopefully, you can expose their false superego defenses.
Bravo, well said! ✊🏼😎
👍👍👍I wish more people could hear this!
No question,they loose with China.
US: We are the beacon of humanity!
Me: Okay, I am officially lost the faith in humanity.
Fire keeper: Are you alright, ashen one?
I think the best is win-win! win-lose situation/zero sum game is also not really a win
But Americans won't accept a win-win situation
Thank you, Ben Becker, BreakThrough New and Thinkers Forum, for this presentation.
It’s time for USA to take care of their problems at home ‘ before it’s too late
The US is a paper eagle
More people need to watch this
An excellent analysis of the US-China situation. Factual, Unbiased and logically articulated. I just wish that those American-Chinese TH-camrs who are so anti-China could listen to this and give some serious and soul searching thoughts about their own words and actions. 🙏🙏
Think on the image of the lone man stopping a whole platoon of tanks in the china tiananmen incident. That is a symbol of power of the people.
Do you think a lone man can stop a platoon of tanks in the usa?
Think on it.
That’s also a sign of self restraint by the Chinese government. Even the western world keeps labeling China as the “bad guy”. The “tank man” would not have lived another day if he were to be in the U.S.A. I don’t even think he could even have a chance to cry out “I can’t breathe”.
Never thought about it that way. Thanks for changing my perspective.😊
@gl7252 it took me years and seeing that shaman gent on the capitol and how his story got so twisted. Courtesy of Tucker for opening my eye, it made me reflect on that man stopping the tanks.
@@gl7252 美国有麦克阿瑟的坦克，结局却是与中国不一样
No, that's result of Photoshop, you can thank Adobe for that.
Great assessment of the western society .
wow so you mean 300 mill people will beat 1.4 billion chinese😂😂😂😂 how legit is this bruh😂😂😂😂. You gotta be kidding
Why is war such a common topic in the USA? Is it a cultural obsession to constantly be looking for wars to get involved in? Or is it, as I believe, that the military industrial complex promotes this in the USA for profits?
well said
Lucid account, and a great set. Thanks!
It seems safe to predict that China would win, but also we have the dynamic that the Chinese economy is ascending, while the United States economy is descending, if not collapsing.
Sift through the history, which Western empire is still alive and hegemonic still 😂
logistics, short of a nuclear exchange,
Chongqing mountain city of 30 millions pop is an example how people living in disadvantageous geography can survive and prosper without conquering and stealing land in other continents