I feel bad for him he was probably nervous and getting even more so by the crowd’s jeering…. He probably would’ve had a better time talking in person one on one
But that comment contradicts the idea that the average American would refer to Kaitlynn Jenner and Blaire White as, "Woman." What a society is able to do (even if doing so is morally unsound) is have an etymological paradigm that is based not on true but on mental gymnastics. And the leftist definition is not the most widely used definition but I would argue that specifically it is: "someone who wants the NORMALCY OF the way that they look, dress and act to be judged by the standards that the society that they live in has set for people with XX chromosomes." So someone could be a woman by leftist standards and have physical features and a personality that is usually found in people with XY chromosomes if: that leftist wants the people around him/her to think it's weird that he/she expresses him/herself that way. And someone could be a woman by leftist standards and have physical features and a personality that is usually found in people with XX chromosomes if: that leftist wants the people around him/her to think it's NORMAL that he/she expresses him/herself that way.
To be a man you have to be a male (XY) To be a woman you have to be a female (XX) As society, we do associate some traits with men or women, and that of course may be slightly wrong, but that's what we are, humans, and make mistakes. That does not mean that the term "man" and "woman" are wrong, from which their main traits are described above.
A feminine man would still be conceived as a mam, the vast majority of trans women you wouldn't even know that they're not born as a women, the vast majority of social issues and interactions that they would have would be that of a cis women (female ) So there's a pretty good reason to separate sex from gender and not have them mean the same thing.a
Funny story. This film was supposed to be shown in northern Colorado (I lived there at the time), I can't remember if it was a film festival by Colorado State University or if it was by an independent group in the town.... it was removed from the list for being transphobic. This was a couple of years ago. It must have been because of your quote lmao.
@@spikemurphy5054Utter rubbish, these idiots are disrespecting all women. Russia, China, North Korea etc are laughing at this insanity.... And we will pay a heavy price in the future for being so weak...
@@ratsrude of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of female gametes (ova) that can be fertilized by male gametes. There are females who aren’t able to bare children, but this only further affirms their womanhood. Why? Because a doctor can run tests on a female to find out exactly why she cannot bare children, whereas not a single doctor on earth is going to run a test on a male if he were to report that he cannot have children. In other words, there are *distinguishable biological attributes* between both sexes (not just on the basis of sexual function either). 👍
@@leahmay1506 problem is, you can’t tell these crazies this. In their fantasy world the impossible, is possible. The saddest part of all of this is, as a society, we are allowing this to become normal, instead of standing up and saying “ No!! What you are saying is not possible. Unfortunately, it’s vulnerable children that are getting this shoved down their throats and made to believe it and normalising it. Society won’t stand up and say something all because they don’t want to hurt some poor irrational snowflakes feelings. We are doing more harm than good by allowing this to continue. The same goes for this “ pronoun “ rubbish. If they don’t know what they are, how is anyone else ? I saw a video by some irrational moron, they said “ if I have a blue scrunchie on my wrist , my pronouns are he /him, if I have a red one , then it’s them/they … this went on for a bit. How is anyone meant to know what colour is what pronoun ?? Then they get their panties in a twist if we get it wrong. The world has gone to shit
I disagree with the kid’s model, but I wouldn’t call it ‘word salad’. His idea is that ‘woman’ is a ‘gender’, and gender is which of the traditional ‘gender roles’ you act out/typify. I think his model is bad, but it is not nonsensical like ‘whoever identifies as one’.
@@kabir93sardar If you haven't noticed, they don't care about facts. Informing people who willingly disregard facts because they have already made the choice to hold their position is a waste of breath. No one, including "transgender" advocates, believe men can become women and vice versa. It's simply nonsense and they know it.
Ask him to define those “stereotypical female traits” and take a shot for every openly misogynistic thing that comes out his mouth. Be careful, don’t get blood poisoning.
I was thinking the same. "Stereotypical female traits"? Doesn't that reject their ideology? They have probably had meetings to try and prove Matt's definition wrong. Since nothing even somewhat coherent comes out I would say the meetings didn't go well.
@@NewYorkCityGritty5 He couldn’t even answer the kids question on religion. They cut it out because Walsh had no comeback. And why does it bother you how people identify themselves? It’s so creepy honestly 😂
Then ask him what feminine is . The definition is “having qualities that are like women or girls “ He would have to define women to claim a thing is feminine.
@@kangaroo3708 "Why does it bother you how people identify?" Because I don't want a man in a dress in the ladies' room with my mum, my sister, or my nieces.
I give him credit for giving the best, most objective and complete answer possible given the worldview he has, and saying it very respectfully without name-calling, with the single exception of the insinuation that "I hope you understand that." Some wouldn't interpret it this way, but it could be interpreted as a passive dig at him rather than a plea for understanding and common ground. I wanted this response to include Matt asking, what constitutes traditional feminine traits, then? What degree, type, or number of feminine traits does someone have to have to be considered a woman? At some point the subjectivity breaks down into either total subjectivity, at which point woman cannot be defined at all, or some attempted objective standard besides "an adult human female." And one can't get more objective than that, regardless of whether one believes that definition is accurate.
I like Piers Morgan’s statement. He said “ if a person is able to identify as to what they are, with no need to explain, then i identify as a black lesbian “. Perfect response.
I saw that and there was a beautiful black woman on the panel and when Piers Morgan said that she absolutely lost it it was hilarious and the white chick was incredulous that what Piers Morgan said was absurd. Oh the irony of it all
And there's only 1 woman. One born as one. And the argument that some are born with both is irrelevant. Less than .005% of people are born with both, and when they are they still have an obvious indication of the sex that they were meant to be, whether that's physically, hormonally or both
@@noahb.3279 Ps Annette doesn't need you to tell her to apologize to a pastor when God will forgive her. You are not righteous & stop being a simp, riding with this Woke garbage. If you are a man, grow a pair & do some manual labor instead of playing keyboard 🖥 warrior. You probably was raised by a single mom who celebrates both mother's & father's day, you'll probably never understand women or truly become a man.
A woman is an adult female human.[a][1][2] Prior to adulthood, a female human is referred to as a girl (a female child or adolescent).[3] A woman in Selangor, Malaysia Typically, women inherit a pair of X chromosomes, one from each parent, and are capable of pregnancy and giving birth from puberty until menopause. More generally, sex differentiation of the female fetus is governed by the lack of a present, or functioning, SRY-gene on either one of the respective sex chromosomes.[4] Female anatomy is distinguished from male anatomy by the female reproductive system, which includes the ovaries, fallopian tubes, uterus, vagina, and vulva. An adult woman generally has a wider pelvis, broader hips, and larger breasts than an adult man. Women typically have less facial and other body hair, have a higher body fat composition, and are on average shorter and less muscular than men. A Wikipedia definition ladies and gentlemen ___
Ask your teacher how people could differentiate between men and women before the XX century then. He will be surprised they could. Spoiler alert: they didn't have to touch each other genitals either
@@don_goku They would see men that looked like men and women that looked like women. By defining characteristics. That’s what’s new. Visually, you can tell between the genders because men and women wore certain outfits and fit their gender identities. Now, you can’t tell what a teen is, and your yelled at like a child for assuming. Good try though.
As a soccer playing woman that used to wrestle her brother when she was little, I am 100% a woman and not a man in any way. His answer is just hurtful and will f*ck up a lot of girls that don't know that being a tomboy is OK and that they will allways be female, no matter their traits.
My Mom worked at a factory full time, drove a forklift, repaired machinery. She also worked as a cocktail waitress part time, dressed in dress and high heels. She raised 3 daughters on her own. She was a woman. I love and miss her.
That's awesome! She obviously played the role of a father in a way too but still in all respects is a woman. What an amazing woman to juggle all that at once, you my friend are a lucky individual ❤️
@@sterlingfallsproductions3930 look them up in the dictionary to see the definition. I’m not your teacher. You’re talking about a drug or slang for cool, then a flying rat or something used to hit a baseball with, then someone people worship or look up to. Troll elsewhere bub.
And he said basically nothing. If the definition of "everything" changes over time, how are we going to communicate about anything? Opinions can change over time, but "definitions?" Half the reason for the existence of a dictionary is to standardize the meaning of words for the sake of clear communication. Does the term "empty - headed" still mean what it used to - this guy?
More precisely, this is what happens when your child is never expected or required to think for themselves, and is rewarded for regurgitating naive beliefs that are rooted in contempt for life’s realities.
@@ArctecGemini You must have never used a single word in the English vocabulary, or any vocabulary for that matter, if you think definitions never change. The word “girl” was once gender-neutral, but that is undoubtedly no longer the case.
@@devoid-of-life I didn’t say words don’t change. I said what gives him the right to change it. Imo for words to change, all, if not an overwhelming majority of society has to agree to go by the new definition. I doubt that much of society will agree to address a woman as anything other than an adult human female. I certainly won’t.
They would just say birthing person. Which would be incredibly offensive to my mother who is a woman. But that's their right to say it and believe it. Doesn't make them right. But being offended is strictly on the person offended. If any of this offends someone they are wholly too attached to politics.
We don't pay more tax here in Sweden, yet our schools are free... Imagine that! On the other hand; we don't give our taxes to a private cooperation, and we don't let our politicians get fat and rich on our tax money, so you might have a problem with "holes" that steals the tax dollars... 🤷🏻♂️
@@SgtMclupus you do pay more tax though. Your income tax rate is 52% and you pay 25% sales tax 😂😂😂😂 imagine giving 75% of your money to the government 😂😂😂😂
@@davidgraham8739 You're trying to educate me on how much I pay in tax??! Okey; if we're gonna see it the way you see it, a waitress in Sweden earn the equivalent of $35/ hour before taxes, plus tips.. The thing is; 25% of what you pay in tax of your salery you never see; it's not in your contract that states your monthly income before taxes! You clearly don't have a clue what you're talking about! Try educating yourself before you open your mouth
Imagine 10 years ago your biology teacher asks you „define a woman.“ and you say „the definition changes over time so I can’t answer that.“ 😂 would def get an F and get checked if I’m mentally good or not
@ILL LOGIK thats epic because genz has more people working several jobs at once than any generation before, most will probably work harder than you or anyone you know and still never make enough to get by
So sad, its like saying some one who swims alot is a fish or if i wear a superman costume i can fly Grow up people if i stand on a garage it doesnt make me a car
@@SIEGESLAYER69whatever the case, a woman is a human Adult female of the nature to get pregnant and has never been, of the nature to impregnate. If a "trans person" could impregnate at some point in the person's life before the "change", the person is not a woman . He is a man. Not any other option! (Because there are only two options. If not we would be born in all shapes and forms) I don't need to explain this. I know, you know and they know as well.
@@crystallogan4675No, not directly. Feminine can refer to anything that is generally associated with girls or women, but it doesn't need to be directly related to women. We consider things like pink, baby dolls, long hair, dresses, heels, etc as typically feminine because they are more often used/displayed by girls and women, but there is no direct relationship between those things and women. For example someone can be a feminine man, or a pattern can be considered feminine because it is pink, but that is different than something directly linked to female biology.
@rachelmarie2228 you said it yourself. Feminine relates to a woman. A feminine man is womanly. Pink is feminine because it's a "womanly" color. So, I stand by my statement and you only reinforced it.
Don't take offense to this, but this kid actually shows very good critical thinking skills. I see very few people who are thoughtful enough to realize this is a question of language NOT science, and as a language teacher, this makes me very happy, and actually gives me hope for our future!
@@bigguy7353 true. But I don’t think the “traditional traits associated with femininity” are what make women women. There are women who lean more masculine or androgynous but are still biologically women, and they are no less so. Women are mothers; mothers nurture. I think being nurturing is the most feminine thing you can be.
i was just thinking "wow that was an incredibly sexist response". me choosing to wear pants instead of a skirt or cutting my hair shorter makes me a man i guess😂
This kid’s parents have to know they grew a nut job, maybe they have a nut farm and the kid identifies as a nut plant, anyway why does he get time on this discussion
Nah because most of them still can admit that sex is biological and that "gender is a social construct". So they will admit that females produce the egg (or ova) and carry and birth children and have xx chromosomes.... whereas the male produces sperm (or gamies) and has XY chromosomes.
As someone who has consistently found myself aligning with the Matt Walsh’s on all this… I don’t hate this student’s answer. At least he tried to offer a legitimate response that he feels keeps his ideology within the boundaries of the question. Per the click-baity title I was expecting someone more ridiculous, and as a result I’m kinda bummed the crowd reacted over his comments.
To be quite honest, that's not even open mindedness. That's allowing your mind to get programmed to a point where the room for common sense is completely depleted and replaced with garbage.
Almost like the people Walsh speaks to are either very carefully hand-selected or massively edited. Why bother having a decent argument when you can rig the venue.
@@Capybarrrraaaa you’re free to tell us what a woman is here in this chat since this venue was rigged. Now’s your chance to share the most compelling answer you have or even an answer you heard from someone else. I haven’t heard anything yet, so I’m genuinely curious.
@@elmergloo3259 Why do we have to define a concept that we don't use? We reject the gender-binary, 'woman' is not our word to define because we're not the ones proposing it as a concept.
@@moaidalmutairi3188 Yeah, you could sex a person based on their sex-traits, and that's useful in many different contexts. The issue is that 1. society doesn't do that, generally because 2. those definitions don't hold any utility in most usages. Like, how do you discuss 'women's clothes' or 'makeup' or 'masculine jobs' or 'the bread-earning gender' or 'sexism' using biology? You just don't, biology tells you jack about those things. Sure, you could get *an* answer, but you'd have to do tonnes of digging to discuss even simple concepts. Hence why nobody uses gender in the same way they do sex-traits.
Sir. This is the thought IRS. Now since you identify as a billionaire. We’re going to have to tax you as such. Though you may not physically have the funds, we support your thoughts equally. The following amount needs to be paid by the end of June. $12,147,947.03. Thank you
You, as well?! I, myself "identify as" a millionaire! I tried explaining this to the bank teller, but she tried to say that I was just a "thousandaire" (or a hundredaire on a rough week), but she refused to accept my "pronouns," which are "millionaire" and "his wealthyness!" I'm suing them for "miswealthasizing" me! Just because I only have a few Gs in the bank doesn't give them the right to "assume my savings account." Obviously, I'm being facetious, but in 2023, I feel the need to clarify this -not to *you,* personally, but to random people who may read my comment and not catch the satirical nature of what I'm saying. Cheers and kind regards.
He’s wishing his professor was there to help him. Unfortunately they’re all hiding behind their degrees in campus classrooms waiting to predate the next generation.
Oh boy if u think thats not true ive got a real shit sandwich for ya.. the word "literally" now also means "not literally" Weve been redefining words to their exact opposite meaning for some time now, even outside of weird trans stuff. Were actively ruining our own language
@@Ch1lton_A a man is a person who was born with masculine features, a greater mass for muscle than women. a man is also born with a penis, and a man is not a woman. a man can't get pregnant and a man does not have a uterus. men are different than women, and instead of transitioning, it's better if we accept the great that we can do with our bodies instead of quitting and switching - both men and women are unique and that should be what's accepted.
Def mental. This kid will get worse. "The definition of everything changes over time"? Um.. no it doesn't. If it did, then you wouldn't be standing in a theater room in a university. We would still be breaking rocks with other rocks and dying of our teeth.
@@caesarstrings “Everything changes over time.” NO. Not everything. A WOMAN IS AN ADULT BIOLOGICALLY BORN FEMALE, PERIOD. I’m so damn tired of this crap, and the way so many are feeding the delusional thinking of the obviously mentally ill.
I like how he was respectful and didn’t react to the crowd and start cursing at him like we’ve seen so many other people do. One thing I do sort of agree with him on is that the definition of a word and or concept can change over time but there are also words and concepts that will never change, for example what a man or a women is
@Naosch He does. It doesn't change the fact that he spewed an illogical word salad attempting to dance around what he knows is the truth. He's a respectful, and clueless, young man.
Did you watch the documentary "what is a woman ?" Let live and let live, just don't push the ideology on others especially children. I realize many don't want anyone to disagree with them.
@@pennylan6466 no I didn’t and I’ll admit I didn’t. They constantly push ‘it’s for the kids’, while guns are allowed that kill more kids than a trans person would. But because it falls into their religious beliefs they think the government should step in there instead but not with guns. As the student said in the actual full video they don’t care about science when it comes to religion but when it comes the gender it’s some big issue
I think the foundation that "everything changes over time . . ." simply needs to be destroyed. Death is Death. Food is Food. Breathing is Breathing. The most obvious essential realities need to be hammered into the morons who want to live in Meta's Un-verse.
@@Texas75023 no, he said definitions change over time… which they do. Words are tools that describe ideas. It would be silly if we were using the same words we started with for everything instead of changing them to suit our needs. You could make the argument that the inclusion of trans women in the “woman” category is not useful, but that’s not the same as saying it’s ontologically incorrect.
@@phillapple8260 Go listen again. He said *EVERYTHING.* Change for the sake of change, or worse, deception and destruction, is evil. But then, you probably have no rational definition of "evil".
Once they redefined definition to a fluid concept that changes with political pressure they were able to redefine anything Smart move, scary consequences
I dont even think thats true, i think words expand on their meaning but i dont think they change. Some words may dissapear from common use but some things will always be constant, because language must have an attachment to something empirical. There will always be words for individuals, man and woman. Strangely enough, gender is more likely to dissapear than sex. Victorians invented gender as a word because sex was so taboo that even saying the word was socially unacceptable. The greatest weapon against gender ideology is to just remove the word from use and let it die off like so many words before
I doubt that, given how they are being educated at this moment. Many schools nowadays forbid kids to use terms like girls or boys to describe other kids, let alone woman and man... They are forced to learn to use more "inclusive terms".
Feminists do. There are a lot of feminists who support the M to F transgender ideology and support men pretending to be women over protecting the rights of women.
@@babotond since Eve was created in the Garden of Eden. Since conception of every female child. there are instincts inherent to female chromosomes that are stereotypically female. Not that men wouldn't have any of these traits, but Men most definitely do NOT have XX chromosomes that identify females as a female from conception. I'm not a Doctor, but we all learned this immutable truth when I was in school.
@@amark9775do you think a Spirit being like Almighty God microwaves food and eats it? Why would He cause His word to become flesh born of woman if He, Himself, is flesh? God is Spirit and existed outside time and space in order to create it. I don't think he stopped at a taco truck on the way.
It’s the exact opposite. A lie is simple, but no matter what the truth will always be complicated. The fact you believe the opposite is evidence of an oversimplified worldview.
normaly I would say it is the other way around. There is only one reality, one truth but there can be unlimmited many lies, so finding the truth is often harder. But in this case it is easy as the word and meaning of women was defined by humans themself. If they would just say "women is a female human but we want to chanhe that" than at least they would be correct but it would still be extremly stupid because then we would need a new word for something that already has a word just to describe something that already has a word. A person who changers their apperance to look like the other gender is trans. And if you just "feel" different without trying look like the other gender, thats just a whole nother level of metal illnes. I mean do what ever you want, I don't care, as long as you don't affect other peoples lifes its okay. But disabling the language (especially the german one gehts completly f'd right now) and the official places to go like trans women in women sports or something like women of the year is so stupid. In my sports club they now don't have male and femal toilets. They now have toilets with or without piss standig area. So now anyone can go to any toilet. No privacy anymore 🤷♂️
actually the dude was right, definitions chances over time. And it doesn't always have to be a lie for it to change. Heck, you're seeing it with your own eyes if you paid attention. Simply due to how those words are used. There was a time when gay used to simply mean joyful and happy, as taken from the French language. There was a time when the rainbow was associated with the end of rain and with god via the end of the flood. There was a time where a "h.o.e." used to refer to very promiscous girls or even sex works. Now girls call this all the time and they aren't all that 30+ boy count by the age of 25. This happens because language changes over time. However, we shouldn't change... the basis of our language and society. A cat was a cat 2000 years ago and its a cat now. Same word, same definition. But english didn't exist 2000 years ago. Still, a man is a man and a woman is a woman. I miss the times where we made fun of prof Oak asking you "are you a boy or a girl" in pokemon games. As in "can't you just tell by looking at my character? let me pick the gender don't make it a question". Honestly, its sad the degradation that takes place :(
@@serikazero128 just because people use words in different context doesn't mean the definition changes. A hoe is still a promiscuous woman, it's just that they don't care anymore because they have no shame.
Why? Because it boxes women into a stereo type. Men and women both have masculine and feminine traits. Masculine and feminine is not the same as men and women
It is not supposed to be.....self righteous, mindless person. Women have nothing too do with this. It's PURELY sexual. Their minds have been haltered. Pornography must be the reason. Biologically Speaking.....they know their not women. Mentally Speaking.....they can be anything they want. I can believe that!!!! Every action.....there is a reaction. We are now seeing the effects of pornography. Deal with it!!! Cause porn; is here to stay!!! Unless????????
He's tired of getting dunked on. Right before this clip he melted over a simple question about religion, then told the guest to leave and pivoted to "What is a woman" on his way out just to get this clip
You should have seen Walsh clawing the podium like a scared kitten just moments before this clip when he refused to answer the most basic question from this kid
That’s true, but the truth doesn’t have to change for a society to use words in a misleading manner. so society’s descriptive, definition of the word, woman is not mutually exclusive, or inclusive of what it should be and/or its prescriptive definition. A lot of people refer to Pocahontas as American Indian, but that doesn’t make her trans racial; it doesn’t even make trans-racialism a thing. so the question succeeds at raising awareness about the fact that the technicalities of an etymological paradigm have not been clearly decided upon. but the question fails to address what those technicalities should be.
I literally does. When we discover new things, we change our view of the world and then the “truth” is updated. That’s just how basic science and human understanding works.
The closing statement...." I hope you understand that " ...... should've been followed by the Russell Westbrook meme.......the dude saying it didn't understand that 😂😂😂😂😂
To be honest, I wouldn't trust Matt Walsh in it, as he himself is a proponent of catholocism. We know that catholics indoctrinate their believers into pedophilia. I live in a predominantly muslim nation ahd what we did to solve this issue is, that when a christian man comes near a muslim children, the men of the community will take this man and have their way with him. If he orgasms, which can be easily proven with man, he is proven to be wicked and often is given to the authorities or has his penis cut off.
but rock can also be used to refer to a music genre, and moving something side to side or forward and back like a rocking chair. people act like a woman is only defined by sex but the idea that gender and sex are two different things is not new, is a woman a person who is born with a vagina, sure, but it can also be someone who identifies with and presents themselves in a way a woman would, words do change
@@TomYeeha that men are women. In the simple fact that they can’t define what a woman is, but yet 5000 years according to evolution, knows what a woman is until the socialist ideology of mental illness pops up
@@TomYeeha He was asked a simple question: “What is a woman?” His response was the same regurgitated nonsense about anyone that align with feminine values and spectrums can be a woman BS that is taught in gender studies classes across the country, of course he didn’t even say his own nonsense right. Hope that clarify for you.
A woman is a woman who doesn’t have to continue telling everyone she is a woman
... especially if she doesn't have an Adam's Apple.
@@davidlafleche1142Some biological women actually have adams apples
@@xienela Okay, but maybe you should refer to them as "real" women.
@@davidlafleche1142 or that
@@xienela minority isn’t the majority
A woman is a person who doesn't have to pay to have a vagina.
Or have to use a dialator to keep the fake vagina from closing
I see no plot holes in this statement
I screwed so many women when I was in my 20s I never paid for a vagina. Am I a woman ??
Great answer Laura! Now if I can only find a girl that thinks like this.
"Fine, I'll do it myself"
-Thanos
Asking a Woke that question is like throwing holy water on a vampire lol
More like throwing the orb of confusion at them lol
Ha ha!!
🤣🤣🤣🧛♀️🦇💨💨💨
Hahahaha brilliant and vampires are as fictional as men that can bare children I see what you did there 😂
Basically
His answer sounds like what I used to write on my English papers to increase the word count.
😂
Underrated comment 🎉
I feel bad for him he was probably nervous and getting even more so by the crowd’s jeering…. He probably would’ve had a better time talking in person one on one
But that comment contradicts the idea that the average American would refer to Kaitlynn Jenner and Blaire White as, "Woman." What a society is able to do (even if doing so is morally unsound) is have an etymological paradigm that is based not on true but on mental gymnastics. And the leftist definition is not the most widely used definition but I would argue that specifically it is: "someone who wants the NORMALCY OF the way that they look, dress and act to be judged by the standards that the society that they live in has set for people with XX chromosomes." So someone could be a woman by leftist standards and have physical features and a personality that is usually found in people with XY chromosomes if: that leftist wants the people around him/her to think it's weird that he/she expresses him/herself that way. And someone could be a woman by leftist standards and have physical features and a personality that is usually found in people with XX chromosomes if: that leftist wants the people around him/her to think it's NORMAL that he/she expresses him/herself that way.
😂😂
This is what 200 grand in student loans gets you.
Yeah and that will end up having to pay for if Biden the Dems get control
Yep. In retarded government funded indoctrination camps.
In America maybe 😂
Facts can change. Truth never changes. It's a fact you cut off your penis. It's true that you're still a man
Some snowflakes need to melt.
You can call yourself a feminine man, but not a woman. Two different things
Yes an effeminate man is still a man not a woman.
To be a man you have to be a male (XY)
To be a woman you have to be a female (XX)
As society, we do associate some traits with men or women, and that of course may be slightly wrong, but that's what we are, humans, and make mistakes.
That does not mean that the term "man" and "woman" are wrong, from which their main traits are described above.
A feminine man would still be conceived as a mam, the vast majority of trans women you wouldn't even know that they're not born as a women, the vast majority of social issues and interactions that they would have would be that of a cis women (female )
So there's a pretty good reason to separate sex from gender and not have them mean the same thing.a
very true God bless you if you believe in him.
@@idenree5949 lol a feminine man is still a man and its very obvious when u see trans women they still look like men cuz they are men :)
"Boys have a penis, girls have a vagina"! Kindergarten cop.
Basic biology duh!
Why would they it's another load of rubbish to distract you from the truth is so obvious when you get it..
Always enjoyed that movie. "IT'S NAHT A TOOMAH!"
Funny story. This film was supposed to be shown in northern Colorado (I lived there at the time), I can't remember if it was a film festival by Colorado State University or if it was by an independent group in the town.... it was removed from the list for being transphobic. This was a couple of years ago. It must have been because of your quote lmao.
Don’t say the name of the movie now the left are gonna go try cancel it
A rock is still a rock, either after 6,000 years or 4 billion years. The 'definition' doesn't change.
His mother should smack him for disrespecting her.
You can call what he said dumb, but disrespectful to his mother is just you being bad faith.
@@spikemurphy5054Utter rubbish, these idiots are disrespecting all women.
Russia, China, North Korea etc are laughing at this insanity....
And we will pay a heavy price in the future for being so weak...
@@spikemurphy5054 idk man, my beloved mother wouldn't be really happy getting compared to some man with mental illness
@@spikemurphy5054 When is he disrespectful to his mom?
@@laughinglaufey4704for talking like a moron
He looked so normal until he opened his mouth.
@Steve C
Look at his eyes, they give it away
I'm sure that's what I'll say if I meet you too... But then again, hopefully I don't have to have the pleasure lol
@@hemek I doubt anyone like you would be anywhere in my orbit.
@@hemek people like you who agree with this should be put in mental hospital
That's why we don't have to buy into people's looks until they start talking...
Abnormal people also look normal most times.
My two cents...
Oxford dictionary definition of a woman: “an adult human female”.
Yes, but that’s logical and sane. We are talking to the crazy and those that live in a fantasy world
what is a female?
@@narvdogg8671 a great question that not one of them can or will answer
@@ratsrude of or denoting the sex that can bear offspring or produce eggs, distinguished biologically by the production of female gametes (ova) that can be fertilized by male gametes.
There are females who aren’t able to bare children, but this only further affirms their womanhood. Why? Because a doctor can run tests on a female to find out exactly why she cannot bare children, whereas not a single doctor on earth is going to run a test on a male if he were to report that he cannot have children. In other words, there are *distinguishable biological attributes* between both sexes (not just on the basis of sexual function either). 👍
@@leahmay1506 problem is, you can’t tell these crazies this. In their fantasy world the impossible, is possible. The saddest part of all of this is, as a society, we are allowing this to become normal, instead of standing up and saying “ No!! What you are saying is not possible. Unfortunately, it’s vulnerable children that are getting this shoved down their throats and made to believe it and normalising it. Society won’t stand up and say something all because they don’t want to hurt some poor irrational snowflakes feelings. We are doing more harm than good by allowing this to continue. The same goes for this “ pronoun “ rubbish. If they don’t know what they are, how is anyone else ? I saw a video by some irrational moron, they said “ if I have a blue scrunchie on my wrist , my pronouns are he /him, if I have a red one , then it’s them/they … this went on for a bit. How is anyone meant to know what colour is what pronoun ?? Then they get their panties in a twist if we get it wrong. The world has gone to shit
I've never seen anyone struggle so hard to put a word salad together. Thank you higher education😂
Kamala 😂
Except Biden or Kamala
I disagree with the kid’s model, but I wouldn’t call it ‘word salad’.
His idea is that ‘woman’ is a ‘gender’, and gender is which of the traditional ‘gender roles’ you act out/typify.
I think his model is bad, but it is not nonsensical like ‘whoever identifies as one’.
“Great answer, now can you define delusional?”
Yes, I can - just give me 5 minutes & a mirror.
He just did.
and the lightning strikes😂✌🏻
Kinda like religion right lol
Alas, that definition has also changed.
Well he’s just disrespected his mother in a huge way.
His mother may have done things to get him this way
@@strongbrave most people don’t think about it that way
Right he just described a woman as a gender stereotype lol.
@@SeymoreButtss he comes across as very soft and feminine. Is he a woman
@@gamingstoneham You need to define most people!
Can we just go back to calling these people idiots and ignoring them?
Bring back bullying!
Yes
Ignoring no thats how we got in this mess in the first place, we have to address and educated them on the facts nlt fiction or feelings
@@kabir93sardar If you haven't noticed, they don't care about facts. Informing people who willingly disregard facts because they have already made the choice to hold their position is a waste of breath. No one, including "transgender" advocates, believe men can become women and vice versa. It's simply nonsense and they know it.
Agree
The longer I live in this planet the more I understand why rooster start their day screaming.
😂😂
😂😂😂
Ask him to define those “stereotypical female traits” and take a shot for every openly misogynistic thing that comes out his mouth. Be careful, don’t get blood poisoning.
I was thinking the same. "Stereotypical female traits"? Doesn't that reject their ideology? They have probably had meetings to try and prove Matt's definition wrong. Since nothing even somewhat coherent comes out I would say the meetings didn't go well.
This is why I love woke "logic" - give it enough time and they will surely find a way to contradict their previous position.
@@NewYorkCityGritty5
He couldn’t even answer the kids question on religion. They cut it out because Walsh had no comeback.
And why does it bother you how people identify themselves? It’s so creepy honestly 😂
Then ask him what feminine is . The definition is “having qualities that are like women or girls “ He would have to define women to claim a thing is feminine.
@@kangaroo3708 "Why does it bother you how people identify?"
Because I don't want a man in a dress in the ladies' room with my mum, my sister, or my nieces.
CLAIMING TO BE WISE THEY BECAME FOOLS-HOLY BIBLE
Exactly !
You’re looking at the wrong person when you’re interpreting that
Just a few years ago everyone knew what a woman is. WTF
Sheep's
Just following the agenda. See how easy it is to brainwash ppl
Before Obama came into office
@@johnbills3056 literally
Everybody still knows, but a lot of people are just afraid to say it.
I give him credit for giving the best, most objective and complete answer possible given the worldview he has, and saying it very respectfully without name-calling, with the single exception of the insinuation that "I hope you understand that." Some wouldn't interpret it this way, but it could be interpreted as a passive dig at him rather than a plea for understanding and common ground.
I wanted this response to include Matt asking, what constitutes traditional feminine traits, then? What degree, type, or number of feminine traits does someone have to have to be considered a woman? At some point the subjectivity breaks down into either total subjectivity, at which point woman cannot be defined at all, or some attempted objective standard besides "an adult human female." And one can't get more objective than that, regardless of whether one believes that definition is accurate.
I like Piers Morgan’s statement. He said “ if a person is able to identify as to what they are, with no need to explain, then i identify as a black lesbian “. Perfect response.
Charlie Kirk said something similar and they lost their minds.
I saw that and there was a beautiful black woman on the panel and when Piers Morgan said that she absolutely lost it it was hilarious and the white chick was incredulous that what Piers Morgan said was absurd. Oh the irony of it all
A woman is the mature adult of the female of the human species.
And there's only 1 woman. One born as one. And the argument that some are born with both is irrelevant. Less than .005% of people are born with both, and when they are they still have an obvious indication of the sex that they were meant to be, whether that's physically, hormonally or both
You are smarter than all of the college students pits together.
What does "be a man" mean?
@@nowandrew4442 now THAT'S a question mark!
@@nowandrew4442 you die protecting women and children.
He needs to apologize to his mother cause clearly he doesn't know his mother is a woman. Aligns with feminine side? GTFOH
He needs to apologize to his mother? Are you that unhinged? Is being unhinged a feature of womanhood to you?
@@noahb.3279 Yes he needs to apologize to his mother. This kid is offensive. The thing of what humans can really be... WTF.
@@annettegerage4478 You need to apologize to your pastor for using that kind of language, even in abbreviation. See? I can do it too!
@@noahb.3279 Yes he needs to apologize to his mother, father, grandmother, grandfather and whomever else is alive in his family for such ignorance.
@@noahb.3279 Ps Annette doesn't need you to tell her to apologize to a pastor when God will forgive her. You are not righteous & stop being a simp, riding with this Woke garbage.
If you are a man, grow a pair & do some manual labor instead of playing keyboard 🖥 warrior. You probably was raised by a single mom who celebrates both mother's & father's day, you'll probably never understand women or truly become a man.
A woman is an adult female human.[a][1][2] Prior to adulthood, a female human is referred to as a girl (a female child or adolescent).[3]
A woman in Selangor, Malaysia
Typically, women inherit a pair of X chromosomes, one from each parent, and are capable of pregnancy and giving birth from puberty until menopause. More generally, sex differentiation of the female fetus is governed by the lack of a present, or functioning, SRY-gene on either one of the respective sex chromosomes.[4] Female anatomy is distinguished from male anatomy by the female reproductive system, which includes the ovaries, fallopian tubes, uterus, vagina, and vulva. An adult woman generally has a wider pelvis, broader hips, and larger breasts than an adult man. Women typically have less facial and other body hair, have a higher body fat composition, and are on average shorter and less muscular than men.
A Wikipedia definition ladies and gentlemen ___
As my teacher said "if you don't have a Y, you ain't a guy"
Ask your teacher how people could differentiate between men and women before the XX century then. He will be surprised they could. Spoiler alert: they didn't have to touch each other genitals either
@@don_goku They would see men that looked like men and women that looked like women. By defining characteristics. That’s what’s new. Visually, you can tell between the genders because men and women wore certain outfits and fit their gender identities. Now, you can’t tell what a teen is, and your yelled at like a child for assuming. Good try though.
@@anitatapiocah You can't tell what a teen is? Haha, ok
"Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity."
sure but Mat Walsh makes alot of money so he probably doesn't care about being ignorant.
Yellowstone national park?
Love that statement. My pet-peeves have always been rudeness and incompetence. But again, love your statement.
As a soccer playing woman that used to wrestle her brother when she was little, I am 100% a woman and not a man in any way. His answer is just hurtful and will f*ck up a lot of girls that don't know that being a tomboy is OK and that they will allways be female, no matter their traits.
Brilliantly Said! THANK You
This!
Blows my mind we are debating this STILL.!!
The Definition of STUPIDITY never changes
Agreed
Yeah. Stupid like all the d-bags in the crowd and Matt Walsh. How pathetic.. a thousand people picking on one individual. Wow.
😂😂
Or the definition of cowardice. Matt Walsh spends his time debating 18 year olds. 🙄
@@Thaco69 Shut up.
When you tell the truth, you don’t have to remember anything. The true definition of a woman doesn’t change over time.
As Micheal Jordan says: Stop it, get some help
I have meth. I'm assuming that works.
"Things change over time." = "If science is old, you can ignore it."
My Mom worked at a factory full time, drove a forklift, repaired machinery. She also worked as a cocktail waitress part time, dressed in dress and high heels. She raised 3 daughters on her own. She was a woman. I love and miss her.
That's awesome! She obviously played the role of a father in a way too but still in all respects is a woman. What an amazing woman to juggle all that at once, you my friend are a lucky individual ❤️
Peace!
She was a hella woman!!
She sounds like a badass
Ok but what *is* a woman
Definitions don’t change because you want them too. Man, these people need help!
@@sterlingfallsproductions3930 Depending on how much dope you're on.
@@sterlingfallsproductions3930 right over your head. Lol
@@sterlingfallsproductions3930 look them up in the dictionary to see the definition. I’m not your teacher. You’re talking about a drug or slang for cool, then a flying rat or something used to hit a baseball with, then someone people worship or look up to. Troll elsewhere bub.
@@sterlingfallsproductions3930what is a woman?
@@sterlingfallsproductions3930 what is a women?
They've indoctrinated him very well. He actually believes what he says. 😂😂😂
And he said basically nothing. If the definition of "everything" changes over time, how are we going to communicate about anything? Opinions can change over time, but "definitions?" Half the reason for the existence of a dictionary is to standardize the meaning of words for the sake of clear communication. Does the term "empty - headed" still mean what it used to - this guy?
every person born on the planet came from a woman . not some guy who pretends to be one
No, I don’t think he believes a word he said.
no, he's just scared of saying the wrong thing. dont have wrongthink
And here he comes again with the pathetic circular argument
This guy represents the struggle many are going through. A watering down of original creative nature He should be counselled / supported
This is what happens when you let a phone raise your child..
BINGO!
More precisely, this is what happens when your child is never expected or required to think for themselves, and is rewarded for regurgitating naive beliefs that are rooted in contempt for life’s realities.
You guys nailed it. It's terrifying
Lol.
When a SIMP is trying to impress woke women😂
I hope that guy's not going to medical school.
No shit! 😂👍🏻
He will
They already are. DO NOT trust any doctor under 50.
I hope he’s not looking for a job other than flipping burgers.
Should be fine if he does. Wasn’t like he was defining biological female.
He is the reason to just say NO!! To a student loan!
I wish they had run that campaign in my High School
“the definition of things changes over time.”
What gives you the right to change it?
@@ArctecGemini You must have never used a single word in the English vocabulary, or any vocabulary for that matter, if you think definitions never change. The word “girl” was once gender-neutral, but that is undoubtedly no longer the case.
@@devoid-of-life I didn’t say words don’t change. I said what gives him the right to change it. Imo for words to change, all, if not an overwhelming majority of society has to agree to go by the new definition. I doubt that much of society will agree to address a woman as anything other than an adult human female. I certainly won’t.
Despite his confusion, you have to admit that he’s very brave for speaking up amongst a room full of people who disagree with him.
I think the perfect question to these people would be who gave birth to you
Similar to asking pro-abortion activists, “Aren’t you glad that your mother didn’t abort you?” 👍🏽
@@ronsamborski6230they’re all so edgy they’d just say no
my mother 😇
Yes ask them all if they were born to a man or a woman lmbo
They would just say birthing person. Which would be incredibly offensive to my mother who is a woman.
But that's their right to say it and believe it. Doesn't make them right. But being offended is strictly on the person offended. If any of this offends someone they are wholly too attached to politics.
Imagine having to pay more tax to fund their college education.
Mal-education.
We don't pay more tax here in Sweden, yet our schools are free... Imagine that!
On the other hand; we don't give our taxes to a private cooperation, and we don't let our politicians get fat and rich on our tax money, so you might have a problem with "holes" that steals the tax dollars... 🤷🏻♂️
@@SgtMclupus you do pay more tax though. Your income tax rate is 52% and you pay 25% sales tax 😂😂😂😂 imagine giving 75% of your money to the government 😂😂😂😂
Wow, I never considered that piece of logic 😯
In which case I'm bloody glad to be a Brit 😊
@@davidgraham8739 You're trying to educate me on how much I pay in tax??!
Okey; if we're gonna see it the way you see it, a waitress in Sweden earn the equivalent of $35/ hour before taxes, plus tips..
The thing is; 25% of what you pay in tax of your salery you never see; it's not in your contract that states your monthly income before taxes!
You clearly don't have a clue what you're talking about!
Try educating yourself before you open your mouth
Imagine 10 years ago your biology teacher asks you „define a woman.“ and you say „the definition changes over time so I can’t answer that.“ 😂 would def get an F and get checked if I’m mentally good or not
It's all based on evolution theory. Once people accepted that big lie they were ready to accept anything.
@@sketchartist1964 if people dont evolve why do you have an appendix?
@@johnv6806 Same reason we all have noses, we're human.
@@sketchartist1964 your appendix isn't used anymore dummy
@@sketchartist1964 if "god" made everyone why do we still have left over parts?
They have so much strength for managing to articulate their thoughts while being heckled by the crowd, lots of respect
This generation that can not define who woman is, is going to be a disgrace to the human existence.
It's a scary time, these young people are going to be our future leaders!
Well he gave a definition. Maybe you didn’t hear him over the triggered brainlets screaming at nothing.
Hassan, it is the generation that will disintegrate. All degenerate groups of people in history have collapsed.
@ILL LOGIK thats epic because genz has more people working several jobs at once than any generation before, most will probably work harder than you or anyone you know and still never make enough to get by
So sad, its like saying some one who swims alot is a fish or if i wear a superman costume i can fly Grow up people if i stand on a garage it doesnt make me a car
Woman vs feminine are 2 different distinct things
WOMAN is a noun
FEMININE is an adjective
Feminine traits, traits is also a noun and it is being described with feminine
@@SIEGESLAYER69whatever the case, a woman is a human Adult female of the nature to get pregnant and has never been, of the nature to impregnate.
If a "trans person" could impregnate at some point in the person's life before the "change", the person is not a woman . He is a man. Not any other option! (Because there are only two options. If not we would be born in all shapes and forms)
I don't need to explain this.
I know, you know and they know as well.
An adjective that directly relates to woman
@@crystallogan4675No, not directly. Feminine can refer to anything that is generally associated with girls or women, but it doesn't need to be directly related to women.
We consider things like pink, baby dolls, long hair, dresses, heels, etc as typically feminine because they are more often used/displayed by girls and women, but there is no direct relationship between those things and women.
For example someone can be a feminine man, or a pattern can be considered feminine because it is pink, but that is different than something directly linked to female biology.
@rachelmarie2228 you said it yourself. Feminine relates to a woman. A feminine man is womanly. Pink is feminine because it's a "womanly" color. So, I stand by my statement and you only reinforced it.
It infuriates me that they can’t define what a women is! I’m a women and a mother of four daughters and I’m scared shitless for their future.
Don't take offense to this, but this kid actually shows very good critical thinking skills. I see very few people who are thoughtful enough to realize this is a question of language NOT science, and as a language teacher, this makes me very happy, and actually gives me hope for our future!
Its largely women who are responsible for this stuff so.....
@@eddiehauser6661 No.
@@eddiehauser6661 lmao this kid is showing no signs of critical thinking 😅
Keep them grounded, mom. ❤
The truth NEVER changes!
Not all women are feminine according to the traditional traits associated with femininity. It’s actually so much more sexist to say this
And rare exceptions don't prove rules wrong.
@@bigguy7353 true. But I don’t think the “traditional traits associated with femininity” are what make women women. There are women who lean more masculine or androgynous but are still biologically women, and they are no less so.
Women are mothers; mothers nurture. I think being nurturing is the most feminine thing you can be.
You're absolutely right. By his logic, any girl who is a "tomboy" is actually just a boy.
i was just thinking "wow that was an incredibly sexist response". me choosing to wear pants instead of a skirt or cutting my hair shorter makes me a man i guess😂
That’s the left. They constantly patronise. A bunch of whites, complaining about minorities problems 😂 What would they know about that?
That guy should go into politics. He's good at non-answering.
This kid’s parents have to know they grew a nut job, maybe they have a nut farm and the kid identifies as a nut plant, anyway why does he get time on this discussion
I agree, Matt Walsh completely walked around the question on ignoring science in favor of the supernatural.
@@jake8286 science says women have a pussy and tits, while dudes have a dick n balls. Also guys cant give birth.
😂
He literally answered the question
New question to add to the first:
"What are females?"
Nah, the next question is, “what is feminine?”
Nah because most of them still can admit that sex is biological and that "gender is a social construct". So they will admit that females produce the egg (or ova) and carry and birth children and have xx chromosomes.... whereas the male produces sperm (or gamies) and has XY chromosomes.
Do women have a prostate ??? Do men have a prostate????
As someone who has consistently found myself aligning with the Matt Walsh’s on all this… I don’t hate this student’s answer. At least he tried to offer a legitimate response that he feels keeps his ideology within the boundaries of the question. Per the click-baity title I was expecting someone more ridiculous, and as a result I’m kinda bummed the crowd reacted over his comments.
That’s What I was thinking
The definition of a woman never changes. It will be the same forever!
These people compete in the Paralympics of mental gymnastics.
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣💀💀💀💀
This is what happens when you’re so open minded that you’re brain falls out…
It has nothing to do with being open-minded. It is just plain foolishness. They know the definition but they just pretend not to know.
To be quite honest, that's not even open mindedness. That's allowing your mind to get programmed to a point where the room for common sense is completely depleted and replaced with garbage.
Hahaha good one the open mind thing,haha creative 🤣
Hope you don’t mind I use this …
Haven’t laughed out load like that for a while
🤣🤣🤣
HA! I get it! 😂
Every time you ask a question like that. They end up like SpongeBob and Patrick holding the orb of confusion.
Almost like the people Walsh speaks to are either very carefully hand-selected or massively edited.
Why bother having a decent argument when you can rig the venue.
@@Capybarrrraaaa you’re free to tell us what a woman is here in this chat since this venue was rigged. Now’s your chance to share the most compelling answer you have or even an answer you heard from someone else. I haven’t heard anything yet, so I’m genuinely curious.
@@Capybarrrraaaa biology 101 can give the most simple answer.
@@elmergloo3259 Why do we have to define a concept that we don't use?
We reject the gender-binary, 'woman' is not our word to define because we're not the ones proposing it as a concept.
@@moaidalmutairi3188 Yeah, you could sex a person based on their sex-traits, and that's useful in many different contexts.
The issue is that 1. society doesn't do that, generally because 2. those definitions don't hold any utility in most usages.
Like, how do you discuss 'women's clothes' or 'makeup' or 'masculine jobs' or 'the bread-earning gender' or 'sexism' using biology? You just don't, biology tells you jack about those things. Sure, you could get *an* answer, but you'd have to do tonnes of digging to discuss even simple concepts. Hence why nobody uses gender in the same way they do sex-traits.
It's like living in "Idiocracy."
Well... I "align" with billionaire traits, but I'm broke AF and I don't see the government appeasing me by sending me boatloads of cash.
Bring back mental institutions!! And fill them with all of these crazies!!
Sir. This is the thought IRS. Now since you identify as a billionaire. We’re going to have to tax you as such. Though you may not physically have the funds, we support your thoughts equally. The following amount needs to be paid by the end of June. $12,147,947.03. Thank you
@@Bearded_Drone LOL!!! 😂🤣
You don’t align with their traits at all.
You, as well?! I, myself "identify as" a millionaire! I tried explaining this to the bank teller, but she tried to say that I was just a "thousandaire" (or a hundredaire on a rough week), but she refused to accept my "pronouns," which are "millionaire" and "his wealthyness!" I'm suing them for "miswealthasizing" me! Just because I only have a few Gs in the bank doesn't give them the right to "assume my savings account."
Obviously, I'm being facetious, but in 2023, I feel the need to clarify this -not to *you,* personally, but to random people who may read my comment and not catch the satirical nature of what I'm saying.
Cheers and kind regards.
He’s wishing his professor was there to help him. Unfortunately they’re all hiding behind their degrees in campus classrooms waiting to predate the next generation.
Or hiding in their safe spaces
“I think definitions change over time”
“Ah yes, floor is a planet.”
Oh boy if u think thats not true ive got a real shit sandwich for ya.. the word "literally" now also means "not literally"
Weve been redefining words to their exact opposite meaning for some time now, even outside of weird trans stuff. Were actively ruining our own language
What is a man?
@@Ch1lton_A a man is a person who was born with masculine features, a greater mass for muscle than women. a man is also born with a penis, and a man is not a woman. a man can't get pregnant and a man does not have a uterus. men are different than women, and instead of transitioning, it's better if we accept the great that we can do with our bodies instead of quitting and switching - both men and women are unique and that should be what's accepted.
@@Ch1lton_A A human being born with XY chromosomes.
@@tylerbailey835and men also have XY chromosomes
WE ARE DOOMED!!!!
This student is clearly confused. Borderline mental, not quite, but close.
He doesn’t look confused, he just looks like he’s trying to get laid. Thinks being an sjw will get him some tail.
Def mental. This kid will get worse. "The definition of everything changes over time"? Um.. no it doesn't. If it did, then you wouldn't be standing in a theater room in a university. We would still be breaking rocks with other rocks and dying of our teeth.
he was intimidated because if the large crowd but also brainwashed AF by leftist ideology.
he is basically a zombie with zero ideas of his own.
mat walsh didnt answer his question
@ARyzen Oh he did.
10 years ago that guy would have been laughed out of the room for that answer.
What do you think was happening? He literally couldnt speak in this echo chamber
10 years ago none of this needed to said.
He was literally being laughed and heckled out of the room are you blind? 😂
@@WeinerDefender his definition was wrong though, under his definition masculine women are not women...
@@caesarstrings “Everything changes over time.” NO. Not everything. A WOMAN IS AN ADULT BIOLOGICALLY BORN FEMALE, PERIOD. I’m so damn tired of this crap, and the way so many are feeding the delusional thinking of the obviously mentally ill.
When you run out problems, you create ones.
True😂
Best answer Mohammad
Exactly
That’s human nature.😂
I like how he was respectful and didn’t react to the crowd and start cursing at him like we’ve seen so many other people do. One thing I do sort of agree with him on is that the definition of a word and or concept can change over time but there are also words and concepts that will never change, for example what a man or a women is
"I hope you understand that"
Son, NOBODY understood that.
HE didn't even understand his words😂
He seemed like a very respectful young guy
@Naosch He does. It doesn't change the fact that he spewed an illogical word salad attempting to dance around what he knows is the truth. He's a respectful, and clueless, young man.
"Respectful", my ass. Denying my fucking gender is anything but respectful.
Stupidity is a bigger plague than COVID ever could be.
I’d say you haven’t seen the whole clip where the student asks Matt Walsh a question and he freezes and refuses to answer
@@conortroper4225 does not matter he is still right.
@@akaroamale475 what? Have a you watched the whole vid or just this snippet of it that right wingers want you to see not what actually happened
Did you watch the documentary "what is a woman ?" Let live and let live, just don't push the ideology on others especially children. I realize many don't want anyone to disagree with them.
@@pennylan6466 no I didn’t and I’ll admit I didn’t. They constantly push ‘it’s for the kids’, while guns are allowed that kill more kids than a trans person would. But because it falls into their religious beliefs they think the government should step in there instead but not with guns. As the student said in the actual full video they don’t care about science when it comes to religion but when it comes the gender it’s some big issue
They try to define what humans can be while we define what humans are.
Yes 👌
We all just going to ignore the fact that Matt Walsh had literally no response to his question from earlier?
This guy deserves to become a meme. He literally made a fool of himself giving bad answer.
With bad hair as well.
Every single leftist gives this exact same answer, you can predict it everytime
Actually one of the few who was able to give an answer. Not correct sure but still an answer of sorts.
@@bsfr2500 it wasn’t an answer at all!
@@spartarome8807 how was it not an answer? It was an answer. It was just a wrong answer.
Imagine having to explain a simple word by using hundreds of sentences for half an hour
And still not narrowing it down much.
I think the foundation that "everything changes over time . . ." simply needs to be destroyed. Death is Death. Food is Food. Breathing is Breathing. The most obvious essential realities need to be hammered into the morons who want to live in Meta's Un-verse.
Please, give a simple definition for “black person.” Because surely any suitable definition of something so easily noticeable should also be simple.
@@Texas75023 no, he said definitions change over time… which they do. Words are tools that describe ideas. It would be silly if we were using the same words we started with for everything instead of changing them to suit our needs. You could make the argument that the inclusion of trans women in the “woman” category is not useful, but that’s not the same as saying it’s ontologically incorrect.
@@phillapple8260 Go listen again. He said *EVERYTHING.* Change for the sake of change, or worse, deception and destruction, is evil. But then, you probably have no rational definition of "evil".
"The definition of everything changes over time"
Bro is living in 1984
Once they redefined definition to a fluid concept that changes with political pressure they were able to redefine anything
Smart move, scary consequences
What is etymology?
His haircut certainly is.
@@TheGamer-nj9if the study of how words have fixed definitions and never change or evolve?
I dont even think thats true, i think words expand on their meaning but i dont think they change.
Some words may dissapear from common use but some things will always be constant, because language must have an attachment to something empirical.
There will always be words for individuals, man and woman.
Strangely enough, gender is more likely to dissapear than sex.
Victorians invented gender as a word because sex was so taboo that even saying the word was socially unacceptable.
The greatest weapon against gender ideology is to just remove the word from use and let it die off like so many words before
This whole clip is like a remake of the scene in Joker where he's doing his standup routine and the crowd is just roasting him
Legend says he is still trying to answer that question to this day 😂🤣😅
😂😂😂😂
Ha Haaaaa!
He sounds like a beauty pageant contestant trying to get through the On - stage question portion of the show.
He seems to believe in Darwin's evolution except time is replaced with his own ass.
🤣🤣🤣
Only a real man can answer that question.
👏👏👏
go on...
🤣
❤❤❤ Indeed.
FACTS! 😂
Ask a 5 year old. Theyll say " it's a grown girl, NOT a man "
I doubt that, given how they are being educated at this moment. Many schools nowadays forbid kids to use terms like girls or boys to describe other kids, let alone woman and man... They are forced to learn to use more "inclusive terms".
@@mst2937 . That's sick
The emperor truly has no clothes
@@mst2937 - What terms are they telling them to use instead of boy and girl?
You get your answers from 5-year olds? Lmao
"A woman is a stereotype of females"... the people that want to tell you everyone is different
Brilliant
Adult biological female, thats it, anyone who thinks otherwise is clinically insane
I don't even think he followed that load of bs. He is the definition of the 404 error code on a computer 😂
And who set the standard for feminine traits? Real, actual women.
Feminists do. There are a lot of feminists who support the M to F transgender ideology and support men pretending to be women over protecting the rights of women.
Nice!
Women are born with those traits too
since when?
@@babotond since Eve was created in the Garden of Eden. Since conception of every female child. there are instincts inherent to female chromosomes that are stereotypically female. Not that men wouldn't have any of these traits, but Men most definitely do NOT have XX chromosomes that identify females as a female from conception. I'm not a Doctor, but we all learned this immutable truth when I was in school.
“The definition of everything changes over time”.
Incorrect sir. I award you no points, and may God have mercy on your soul.
And people wonder why the world is laughing at us. He asked a simple question and this fool can’t answer it
it's funny you should say that considering this channel edited out the clip where matt walsh refused to anser the students question.
@@SinheadXOthey didnt cut out shit link it
This man was fighting for his life.
No that was Map Walsh, that Fuckin pussy struggle to answer the chad in the yellow shirts questions xD
What is a man? 😂
@@DareusTyn a man is a man
True, one could see the woke blather of one of ze’s college professor’s trying to load.
He died .
He’s gunna watch this video after he gets into the real world and feel really stupid.
Especially when he cannot get is transgender woman pregnant
We've been saying that for years. Unfortunately, the real world isn't the one we knew. The real world will now coddle and encourage his behavior.
Let's hope!
He's being groomed so may never happen
No, he won't
“The definition of everything changes overtime. “ 😖😖😖
The truth is simple. A lie is complicated. That’s why they have these never-ending, run on sentences that don’t make sense
Can God microwave a burrito SO HOT that even HE can't eat it?
Like every “answer” that every single Biden judge appointee has given to every question.
@@amark9775do you think a Spirit being like Almighty God microwaves food and eats it?
Why would He cause His word to become flesh born of woman if He, Himself, is flesh?
God is Spirit and existed outside time and space in order to create it.
I don't think he stopped at a taco truck on the way.
It’s the exact opposite. A lie is simple, but no matter what the truth will always be complicated. The fact you believe the opposite is evidence of an oversimplified worldview.
normaly I would say it is the other way around. There is only one reality, one truth but there can be unlimmited many lies, so finding the truth is often harder. But in this case it is easy as the word and meaning of women was defined by humans themself. If they would just say "women is a female human but we want to chanhe that" than at least they would be correct but it would still be extremly stupid because then we would need a new word for something that already has a word just to describe something that already has a word. A person who changers their apperance to look like the other gender is trans. And if you just "feel" different without trying look like the other gender, thats just a whole nother level of metal illnes. I mean do what ever you want, I don't care, as long as you don't affect other peoples lifes its okay. But disabling the language (especially the german one gehts completly f'd right now) and the official places to go like trans women in women sports or something like women of the year is so stupid. In my sports club they now don't have male and femal toilets. They now have toilets with or without piss standig area. So now anyone can go to any toilet. No privacy anymore 🤷♂️
Definition changes when people lie. That's all.
actually the dude was right, definitions chances over time. And it doesn't always have to be a lie for it to change.
Heck, you're seeing it with your own eyes if you paid attention.
Simply due to how those words are used. There was a time when gay used to simply mean joyful and happy, as taken from the French language.
There was a time when the rainbow was associated with the end of rain and with god via the end of the flood.
There was a time where a "h.o.e." used to refer to very promiscous girls or even sex works. Now girls call this all the time and they aren't all that 30+ boy count by the age of 25.
This happens because language changes over time.
However, we shouldn't change... the basis of our language and society. A cat was a cat 2000 years ago and its a cat now. Same word, same definition. But english didn't exist 2000 years ago.
Still, a man is a man and a woman is a woman.
I miss the times where we made fun of prof Oak asking you "are you a boy or a girl" in pokemon games.
As in "can't you just tell by looking at my character? let me pick the gender don't make it a question".
Honestly, its sad the degradation that takes place :(
@@serikazero128 just because people use words in different context doesn't mean the definition changes. A hoe is still a promiscuous woman, it's just that they don't care anymore because they have no shame.
@@serikazero128 Yes, it's sad, but worse it's destructive.
One big reason people are fighting to stop it.
What a massive insult to all REAL BIOLOGICAL Women.
True
why?
Why? Because it boxes women into a stereo type. Men and women both have masculine and feminine traits.
Masculine and feminine is not the same as men and women
I hate what is happening now with those trying to dictate their so-called views on what is a woman they can't even tell us?
It is not supposed to be.....self righteous, mindless person.
Women have nothing too do with this.
It's PURELY sexual. Their minds have been haltered. Pornography must be the reason.
Biologically Speaking.....they know their not women.
Mentally Speaking.....they can be anything they want. I can believe that!!!!
Every action.....there is a reaction.
We are now seeing the effects of pornography.
Deal with it!!! Cause porn; is here to stay!!!
Unless????????
Woman is firstly Mother so we all are on this planet called 😊mother Earth. ❤ respect every every woman❤🎉
Matt doesn’t even look irritated at this point, he just looks tired and sorry for them.
That kid got dragged to the dark side by an ex girlfriend and has no clue what his real thoughts are. 😂
He's tired of getting dunked on. Right before this clip he melted over a simple question about religion, then told the guest to leave and pivoted to "What is a woman" on his way out just to get this clip
@@southernparadise9896nice fanfiction
You should have seen Walsh clawing the podium like a scared kitten just moments before this clip when he refused to answer the most basic question from this kid
@@suicidallysosome4651 way to deflect lol. I wasn’t talking about Matt. I was reading the kids body language. But hey, you do you.
See the tuition department at your Uni and ask for your money back; they've failed you.
His answer was correct. Sorry you didn't get enough education to understand how things work.
@@jfitz369 what? So you agree that anyone with feminine traits is a woman? What?
@@jfitz369 I don't need to be a veterinarian to know what a dog is😅 it's simple there's only two genders
@@jfitz369 His answer was utter gibberish ….you cannot just align with something to be it.
@@robotsonmars1989 He never said that. Why are you putting words in his mouth? Also, can YOU define what a woman is?
The Truth does Not change.
That’s true, but the truth doesn’t have to change for a society to use words in a misleading manner. so society’s descriptive, definition of the word, woman is not mutually exclusive, or inclusive of what it should be and/or its prescriptive definition. A lot of people refer to Pocahontas as American Indian, but that doesn’t make her trans racial; it doesn’t even make trans-racialism a thing. so the question succeeds at raising awareness about the fact that the technicalities of an etymological paradigm have not been clearly decided upon. but the question fails to address what those technicalities should be.
@@XaxtonRevolution2 aint no one reading allat
I literally does. When we discover new things, we change our view of the world and then the “truth” is updated. That’s just how basic science and human understanding works.
The closing statement...." I hope you understand that " ...... should've been followed by the Russell Westbrook meme.......the dude saying it didn't understand that 😂😂😂😂😂
Boy, he’s just pulling that answer out of his ass little by little…!!😂😂😂
Turtle poke!
For sure...
Lmfaooo😂
No, he prepared the response. See how he's getting ready to recite his nonsense?
Just like the beads he already has in him😂😂
We learn what humans can be. Yeah apparently we learn over the years how unbelievably stupid they can get
😄 You're right on there!
The devil is having a field day in America at this moment
Not only in Amri a, in Germany gets crazy too like this. Sick world
Yep
To be honest, I wouldn't trust Matt Walsh in it, as he himself is a proponent of catholocism. We know that catholics indoctrinate their believers into pedophilia. I live in a predominantly muslim nation ahd what we did to solve this issue is, that when a christian man comes near a muslim children, the men of the community will take this man and have their way with him. If he orgasms, which can be easily proven with man, he is proven to be wicked and often is given to the authorities or has his penis cut off.
He is everywhere but I 💯 % agree
Also in the UK..
Definitions change😂😂😂a rock is a rock 1000 years ago and now
but rock can also be used to refer to a music genre, and moving something side to side or forward and back like a rocking chair. people act like a woman is only defined by sex but the idea that gender and sex are two different things is not new, is a woman a person who is born with a vagina, sure, but it can also be someone who identifies with and presents themselves in a way a woman would, words do change
The universities should absolutely be at least partly held accountable for this insanity
I believe the percentage would best be described as...💯💯💯💯🤳
And social media. This trend wouldn't have caught on like wildfire if it wasn't for tik tok and Instagram
@@jimhughes1070 BINGO!
@@roseparade_ I'm trying to imagine seeing him afraid... Not working for me 🤣🙏🤳
He tried so hard to remember what those professors told him to say, those last two braincells were smoking
what did he say that was wrong out of interest?
@@TomYeeha that men are women. In the simple fact that they can’t define what a woman is, but yet 5000 years according to evolution, knows what a woman is until the socialist ideology of mental illness pops up
Plus buckled under to peer pressure. Another follower.. 👎
@@TomYeeha He was asked a simple question: “What is a woman?” His response was the same regurgitated nonsense about anyone that align with feminine values and spectrums can be a woman BS that is taught in gender studies classes across the country, of course he didn’t even say his own nonsense right. Hope that clarify for you.
@@The1Monty Where do you get your answer for what is a woman?
The definition of truth hasn't changed
Nice one.
No, but its content has
No ,definitions don't change over time😅😅😂😂😂
Looks like the lights were on but no one was home .
😂😂😂❤❤❤❤
I agree, but Matt Walsh has always been that way
@@TheGamer-nj9if I think you have a typo in your reply , you misspelled audience member .