Brazil: a nation divided | FT Film
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 23 ก.ย. 2024
- Latin America’s largest nation is facing its most important election in decades as Jair Bolsonaro and Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva square off amid deep political and cultural polarisation. FT Brazil bureau chief Bryan Harris travels the nation to look at the enormous economic and social challenges facing the next president. He meets wealthy farmers, truckers, evangelicals and those facing food insecurity. Read more at on.ft.com/3Cjrg5T
#Brazil #jairbolsonaro #luladasilva #latinamerica #politics #foodsecurity #economy #latinamerica
See if you get the FT for free as a student (ft.com/schoolsa...) or start a £1 trial: subs.ft.com/sp....
► Check out our Community tab for more stories on the economy.
► Listen to our podcasts: www.ft.com/pod...
► Follow us on Instagram: / financialtimes'
4:18 That's a bit historically incorrect. Brazil's traditional political elite come from agriculture since before the Empire years. São Paolo was a coffe production powerhouse state while Minas Gerais was one for cattle. They were most powerful states getting the most privilleged power postions once Brazil became it's own country as well.
"Costal States" such as Rio and Penanbuco had their power too but not as much as Minas and São Paulo and even Rio Grande do Sul who are powerful specifically for their agro power.
Agro was always were power laid in Brazil.
Mas é diferente. A elite de hoje tá mais pra um aristocracia burocrática do que latinfudiaria.
Agro Brasil 2024 facista
@@MatheusHenrique-gg7pjoxi, quer dizer que minha Nona é fascista? (Sim Fascista não facista), ela tem um terreno e produz batata, vende pro mercado local.
I'm a foreigner living in Brazil and I can tell you for a fact that most of the news you see on foreign media does not reflect the realities of the ground.
I am a Brazilian born in Brazil and I don't know which foreign media you're having access to , but the ones i see are pretty accurate to reality.
:) Italy just elected a conservative (They are terming her a fascist) :) Is Balsenaro going to win in BR?
Lol and whats the reality ??
@@simmingflgiht3722 She is called a fascist because she walks and talks like a fascist. No innocent "conservative" goes around and acts like a Mussolini apologist. If another "conservative" were to do the same in Germany (spoilers, daft knobs from AfD do sometimes) and said Hitler wasn't a bad man, they would be called a Nazi too, and rightfully so. You lot aren't special and certainly aren't righteous. You are delusional.
Bolsonarooooooo🤟🤟🤟🤟
Tabata Amaral, posing with João Campos the young guy 20:13 that is a descendant of one of the richest families in Brazil's northeast (Campos / Arraes) an oligarchy where cousins fight each other for power in their home state. As you can see, brazilian politics are not for amateurs.
Tabata, it's good to remember, voted in favor of projects that harm poor population, although herself comes from a poor family.
안녕하세요!! 투표 한번 잘 못하면은 나라 망가진 나라 됩니다!? 투표 하실때 신중히 한번더 잘 생각 하시고 선택하시길 바랍니다!?🙏🙏🙏🇰🇷
That's our main problem!
🇧🇷🤝🇰🇷
Pois bem, eu votarei no Bolsonaro!
Se votar no Ladraot. LARÁPIO CACHACEIRO lula roubou TRILHÕES do Brasil e doou aos diradores da América Latina e África e depois volta para o bolso dele e do partido comunista, pt,porque não passa pela fiscalização de o COAF e outros .. ou votamos em JB ou o Brasil já era!
나는 더 이상 해결책이 있다고 생각하지 않는다. 둘 다 끔찍한 대통령입니다.
WE ARE UNITED AGAINST CORRUPTION FIGHTING FOR OUR FREEDOM.
waka waka waka
We will not let this man be president!
Juntos com os estadunidenses nossos grandes irmãos 😂
Tabata Amaral is in no way akin to Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez. Alexandria is a textbook left-wing populist while Tabata has serious concerns about fiscal responsability, so much that she voted for pensions reform, which was so unique amongst representatives of the left in Brazil that many still accuse her of being a right winger despite all her other progressive stances on most subjects. She thinks we need to worry about indicriminate spending while also focusing investments on social areas which are lacking. We need more like her.
Besides that, excellent report from FT.
If Tabata is hated by the far right and far left, we know that she´s a great politician hahahahaha
Tabata Amaral sell your country in name of money ops equality, Bolsonaro don't is perfect but what she represent in my country is lie. All your poverty pass Where won by own strength is just an excuse of propaganda already all media have side and lefth side .
I was looking for this comment, thank you for that. I just disagree with the fact that we need more representatives like her, I'd rather have AOC here.
Tabata IS a exemple of people who sell in name of Power, don't show nothing of plain of governm only do fake news.
@@rodrigobarroso6075 No, don´t even say that as a joke!, we don´t need puppets of a woke ideology as she is!
This is the lowest point we have reached with our Democracy. Choosing between two corrupt populists is an insane thing, voting for the null option and desperately seeking out a democratic opposition group is the only option left to preserve our democracy for the next four years. Not all Brazilians participate in this circus between an almost autocrat and one who is inspired by Latin American dictators for their respective power projects. The first man who appeared in the video, Felipe D'Ávila, was one of the best candidates we had along with a social democrat, Ciro Gomes, but polarization forced us to the two worst candidates.The two current corrupts who compete in the second round will never be an option. Deus tenha Misericórdia dessa Nação
I second that!
Facts!!! 👏👏👏👏
Inflation is a Leftist problem though.
Felipe D'Ávila has a promissing future! 🇧🇷
I’ll always go with the guy who isn’t a far right wing evangelical
Brazil is being censored, help 🇧🇷🙏
q mané help mulher
kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk
@@GabrielVelasco1908.Estão felizes com as abóboras kkkkk
.... 17:41 "Orlando Silva is an influential lawmaker and close ally of Lula"..... just forgot to mention that he is from the Comunist Party! To describe him simply as a "Federal Lawmaker" is ridiculous. Let people know who support the "return of the criminal ex-president to the crime scene" - words from his current vice president two years ago. Yeah, they are allies now.
Bolsonaro is envolved with different crimes as well. Every day has a new scandal. Are you not shy?
Times have changed and now crypto market is all about pump and dump leaving retailers as bag holders. Bag holders turned to long term investors will still bag hold and bitcoin might go to zero. There is too much news, too many analysts, too many factors, too many firms, insiders influencing it's price. Retailer money is being sucked. I've made $550k combined net this year and paid no Federal taxes. Thanks to George Stewart's trading services.
I'm surprised you know him too! I've been making a lot of profits investing with him for a few months now.
@@eleazerhart1214 Mr George is really best when it comes to crypto trading. Was very happy when I received my first huge profit
You invest with George Stewart too? wow that man has been a blessing to me and my family.
How do I reach out to him to trade for me too please? I'm new to cryptocurrency trading.
@@peytoncohen3541 I make 20k USD weekly trading profit with him 😃
It is very interesting to see how people have sold the Catholic faith of their ancestors for an imported evangelical one for a handful of dollars...
Agree. This rising religious fanatism is disastruous for Brazil.
It's disgusting. And they continue to sell it. So many catholics (it really hurts to call them that) are defending this heretic, protestant apologist, liberal farce. They prevent us from opening a real catholic alternative to the garbage we currently have in politics.
I’m an eastern Catholic from the South Indian state of Kerala, and we see a lot of this in our community too. I blame the Catholic church itself for this. Up to the 80s the church was very much focused on both social and spiritual well-being, but ever since it adopted a deadly combination of Liberation Theology and Charismatic worship and stopped caring about social aspects of life. When the Evangelical churches came along in the 90s offering their flashy worship services and no nonsense conservatism, a lot of the Catholic faithful just defected there.
@@arunjkz same as in Brazil. But I'd say, I don't blame the Church. I blame those usurpers who took her over.
What ancestors are you talking about? The ones who worshiped the thunder god? Or the ones who developed the faith in the orixas? Christian faith, no matter the flavor you choose, is "imported" everywhere.
Bolsonaro is the Brazilian Duterte. Vote him out before it's too late because there is such a thing as too late, as no matter how hopeful tomorrow can be, some people don't make it to tomorrow.
If you vote him out then lula will rise to power and transform Brasil in a Venezuela. I stand with Bolsonaro
Lula is like brazilian Maduro.
Lula is NOT brazilian maduro, if u think that lula is a 100% per cent a communist president, you didnt live during 2002-2010
@@d.monari of course, PT was from 2002 to 2014 on presidency and Brazil has never been close to be like Venezuela. Stop your political panic, be reasonable.
@@MatheusDC9 No, just one scandal after another. Overpriced works and support for socialist dictatorships. Lula should be in jail!
As a brazilian this video is ridiculous and totally biased.
When that lady was saying that Bolsonaro calls on his supporters to shoot the opposition, there wasn't the slightest attempt to factcheck her. Nor did they provide any actual statement from Bolsonaro to this effect (because such statements don't exist).
@@davidmontoute2074 Yea
Muita grana meu caro! Sou do Piauí e sei que Bolsonaro irá ganhar! O povo nordestino acordou! A maioria da grande mídia do Brasil e do mundo está vendendo suas almas para o dinheiro sujo do comunismo chinês! Rumo pra frente! O bem sempre vencerá! Continue participando!
@@aloisiocorreia5007 seu sonho não vai concretizar meu caro, Bolsonaro representa o que há de pior no país, principalmente no Rio de Janeiro (Estado este onde eu nasci), ele é um miliciano e aos poucos essa corja vai se expandindo para todo país para favorecer mais as elites e deixar o pobre cada vez mais pobre e escravizado. Eles usam da retórica para engajar o debate e captar pessoas como você que ainda acredita em comunismo.
@@davidmontoute2074 th-cam.com/video/p0eMLhCcbyQ/w-d-xo.html
Hope you get it. Portuguese, of course
"Lula was embroyled in the car wash corruption scandal and served time in prison... Legal history aside"
I would consider that to be a little more than legal history, more like a discrediting factor for someone seeking public office.
The legal process was completely bogus, proven after a hacker invaded the judge´s Telegram account, then with tents of stories published on The Intercept. That´s why all the accusations were dropped and he was acquitted.
@@specialiseesi6746 Got it, thanks for clarifying.
@@specialiseesi6746 The accusations weren't dropped, today most of the supreme court was appointed during the 14 years of the workers party and they freed Lula in a 6x4 vote (barely majority), only the sentence was dismissed because supposedly Lula should've been judged in the capital, Brasilia, instead of Curitiba city were Moro condemned Lula and other 30 judges in multiple instances also condemned Lula, Lula used more than 400 legal resources and still lost. I see by your name that you're french, so, instead of trying to clarify things that you only know by international media, you should let a brazilian explain the things.
Car wash corruption scandall = Lawfare
@@oole0111 Oh you´re right. They were nullified, not dropped, since accusers were commiting crimes anyway. Never a proof was found and he´s legally innocent. And you failed to mention the same Supreme Court was responsible for the overthrowing of Dilma´s government (from the Workers Party), and also for sending to jail many leaders of the Workers Party. So, NO, his party did not appoint friendly judges, and it´s past time you stop this nonsense.
Brazil ☀️
As a citizen, i have no words to describe how shame is to my country pursuit such instability and also immaturity in politics.
hope one day this country get back on the line of respect and prosperity, despite all ideology war that is occurring nowadays.
Vai acontecer, a próxima eleição será Moro, Zema e Tarcisio. Não entre o falastrão e ladrão.
Bring back your monarchy if you want stability and to end this farce and cult of personality.
Financial Times forgot to mention Bolsonaro is a dictatorship nostalgic and said on TV he wanted to start a civil war in Brazil, shut down the congress and Supreme Court 🤡
Voltar para a linha de respeito e prosperidade implica que o Brasil já teve qualquer um dos dois, o que nunca ocorreu
I don’t have any shame at all. We have problems to solve as all the others countries have. And we don’t need a charismatic chatty president but one who can prove good results. And this one nowadays is Bolsonaro with any doubt.
As a brazilian I'm ashamed about what have been going on here since 2019, the hatred, political violence and threats to the democracy are leading this nation to caos.
As a Brazilian, I was born in Brazil
Sounds like you've been watching TV too much
People of the world: what was shown in this documentary is the real face of Brazil. Not beaches, football and carnaval.
Facts and I'm even Brazilian 💯💯
Nem o carnaval é a verdadeira "face" do Brazil, a nossa cultura provêm do norte, sul e nordeste do país.
@@Álvaro_Ávila-021 Sim. Foi o que falei. Carnaval não representa o Brasil todo.
@@joaoaugustolandim Só o Rio, e nem surgiu lá, surgiu pela europa
2:57 A divided country interests many. If the decade had not been lost, Brazil would be among the most influential today. Bolsonaro was elected with corporate support.
Very frustrating to see how the press isn’t honest with the information.
@Trump HatesAmericans it's not about loving or hating Bolsonaro but giving a fair reportage.
👻
They want us to stay poor, so they can export food and oil. But you, from the north of the world, will not stop our development. The freedom already won the elections, even If Bolsonaro loses, we elected right wing senators and governors.
How so? What's wrong exactly
@Trump HatesAmericans hahahahah you nailed it. Im Brazilian and im used to this narrative. In the Bolsonaro bubble they only believe information delivered through whatsapp. The press is always biased and lying in their view
Government coruption should be a death sentence.
"If you look back to all presidential candidates (...) the only two that created movements around their personas were Lula and Bolsonaro" WHAT?!?!?!?! And what about Vargas, you Einstein?
"candidates"
@@leogama3422 vargas se reelegeu como candidato.
Tb tem o collor e o janio quadros.
E o Vargas é candidato esse ano?! kkkkkk
Lula was literally in Jail
You mean during the military dictatorship that Bolsonaro served or after?
BRAZIL is a nice country and BOLSONARO is the best president of the last 4 Years. He is not perfect but everyone will agree that he is a patriot. 🇧🇷 Our economy now is much better.
He was the president of the last 4 years. And he is another fiasco. Neither Lula or Bolsonaro deserve being president. Brasil as today, is in a verge to become a military government and the next step is DICTATOR SHIP. ANOTHER VENEZUELA. 😢😢
Poor Brazil. The crazies cheated and want the people to shut up😢.
"He says to shoot the opposition!" clip follows "Hey, you should buy guns. An armed populace will never be enslaved". I'm not seeing the connection here.
There was a situation where he stated something like that. Maybe he didn't mean literally(at least that is what he always says,but he said something like"vamos fuzilar a petralhada" in a public event.
They didn't play the relevant clip. He literally said "vamos fuzilar a petralhada aqui do Acre" (let's gun down the opposition here in Acre). The clip can be easily found on YT by searching the relevant keywords.
I hope you see the connection now.
@@thaigo972 he obviously didn't mean it literally, people who do that are lula's friends like fidel castro and Ortega.
@@guilhermevieira6010 Yeah, he only literally mimicked shooting people with a tripod while he said it. But he obviously didn't mean it literally...
And not to ruin your whataboutism, but don't forget JB praising Pinochet and defending the use of torture by his own country's military. Praising violent dictatorships isn't exclusive to either side.
@@thaigo972 but it's only one side that has actually funded dictatorships and speaks openly about implementing censorship.
The bottom line for Brazil 🇧🇷:
If Lula wins the election and Bolsonaro does not accept defeat then we will social upheavals.
If Bolsonaro wins the election and Lula does not accept defeat then will see social upheavals.
Brazil in a very fragile situation for now. This situation in Brazil depends on the actions and narrative of two men: Lula and Bolsonaro.
Greetings from Germany...🍺🖐
lula has no followers to cause social upheavals. If the election is not rigged the majority of people will accept .
True!!!
We cannot allow communism take over Brasil. Lula has Chaves, Maduro, and Ortega as his friends.
He also wants to destroy our kids with the gender ideology, drugs liberation, and pornographic education to our little kids in the schools.
We must defend our kids.
I am brazilian and I vote for bolsonaro I pray and hope than bolsonaro win 🇧🇷
Yeah, but just Bolsonaro have threatened to not accept, over and over and over again. He's a REAL threat to out democracy.
BIASED, R.I.P real journalism!
There is a misinterpretation at the end of the documentary that the interior is thriving and the coast is impoverished. The poor girl in the video is from São Paulo, the richest state in the country. And in the less developed and more agriculture-dependent parts, poverty also predominates. The only people getting rich there are the owners of large lands.
única coisa que falta é taxação das grandes fortunas, e não pense você que será a nossa centro esquerda que o fará. O nosso estado é baseado numa máfia política e do crime organizado muito mais bem distribuída e infiltrada do que a gente imagina. Mas ao poucos eu espero que a gente vá colocando pessoas melhores no congreso, que é de fato quem toma as decisões aqui.
Taxar grqndes fortunas, piada,
Taxam os ricos > sao donos/investidores dos meios de producao > repassam o valor sob o produto > pequenos empreendedores quebram pois compram um produto pra produzir outro/pessoas pagam mais caro e salario n acompanha > reduz producao/vendas/ economia recolhe > investidores vendem suas acoes e seguram o dinheiro/levam pra fora > menos empregos > menos poder de compra, ciclo se repete
Se o governo congelar os precos, os ricos n abrem suas empresas, o governo forca a abertura das empresas=ditadura (trabalho forcado)
Qual sua resposta para isso?
6:51 he looks really comfortable riding that horse 🤣🤣😂🤣🤣
Anyone equating Lula to Bolsonaro is acting in bad faith. Lula never antagonized the republican institutions and never argued for civil war. Bolsonaro did. And keeps doing so.
Lier
Bolsonaro can’t ended the democratic process in Brazil. In the other hand delivery the country to Lula it’s like agree, that corruption and bad politicians are okay to drive the country for the XXI century, and to become a banana republic forever.
Just type in Portuguese. You make no sense
we brazilians dont want a convicted man as a president. he is a criminal. stop with this trash fake news
@@cesarjlisboa7586
If you cannot read, or listen to the publication, stop commenting on it.
You are making a fool of yourself.
God bless the people of Brazil.
God will bless those who bless Israel.
And will curse those who curse Israel.,..,
Poor countries : cult of personality instead of consensual pragmatism.
Nobody in Brazil seems to be looking at their southern neighbour, Uruguay, which seems to have embraced consensual pragmatism and is actually on its way to becoming if not a rich country ... at least a manageable country.
When it comes to Brazil .... it's been a mess for a long time and it doesn't seem like it's going to become any less messy.
Well, The USA is by no means a poor country and also has a very clear cult of personality. Brazil is not poor, it is extremely unequal, and there's a difference in both terms. In regards to Uruguay, you are correct to mention the fact that they are a stable country. However, it only has 3.5 million inhabitants with much less diversity, be it economic, social, racial, etc; compared to Brazil. Therefore, both realities are just too different to be placed into the same "box". The way a country is formed DOES imply in different policies outcomes.
@@mendesleiteyuri Good points. The US is actually pretty messy and I don't even know if it's still a rich country : apparently they have to deal with massive amounts of foreign debt. When it comes to rich countries I would rather mention Canada, which is a lot more stable, or places like Sweden or the Netherlands. Yet you do have a point when you claim that smaller countries might be a lot more manageable than big countries (and I know, Canada is big yet has a very small population - so, yes, I might have cheated on that one).
Yet I stick to my belief that consensual pragmatism might be the best (perhaps the only) way to deal with complex problems. Achieving that consensus ... well, that's the big (huge) challenge.
@@mottahead6464 I understand your point. The big issue in Brazil is how to achieve consensus when 'everyone here is different from anyone else'. Brazil is 44% white with the majority of them living in the south; 8% Black mostly living in the slums and the rest being mixed race and asian (especially japanese). I know the country needs to reach consensus, but it is too young, diverse and unequal to find the so called consensus in a country like Uruguay which has a fraction of its population and isn't as diverse.
@NEKO Nowadays one can be considered rich if one is not deep in debt.
Poor civilization! BTW, what’s Trump and French Le Pen are? So; only poor countries? 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
In bolsonaro’s brazil the rich are getting richer and the poor are getting poorer. It’s a tragedy and you can clearly see why his electorates are mostly white rich farmers and enterpreneurs while lula's are the poor mostly who are currently back living in precarious conditions, as mentioned in the video, there's over 33 million people facing hunger while in 2021 alone, brazil got 40 new billionaires.
So many liers being interviewed.
Brazil is no longer a democracy. It's important to the world to know.
Misinformation!
How so?
2:00 Calling bolsonaro a right wing politician and lula a social democrat show the vastly disproportional way in which the media treats those candidates is why people sitting on the fence move in favour of bolsonaro. You have to acknowledge lulas position.
Superb and detailed. The FT should set up a TV channel. It will be one of the best in the world with the calibre of your journalists.
Lies, lies. They manipulate the interviews. The make me vomit. Tabata lies. Bolsonaro never told anyone to shoot others
Leftist International agenda, full of lies.
Lula does not represent the poorest as a whole. Bolsonaro has good policy proposals for this issue. I see his effort and also his team's effort as a different way of helping both sides. There is no racism because we are a nation.
Lucid and realistic analysis of the current Brazilian political situation, especially with regard to the development of regions linked to agribusiness compared to the economic decline of coastal industrial regions. In Brazil we tend to only look at our own belly button as we are a very large and very complex nation. However, obviously what happens in the world also has internal repercussions in Brazil. The development of agribusiness in the Cerrado began in the 70's, during the Military Dictatorship, but certainly the rise of China and the Asian Tigers, great demanders of food commodities, generated an economic power, and consequently political, unparalleled in the rural regions of the Brazil. The Brazilian industry has been slowly dying since the consolidation of the globalization process. It was an industry built facing inwards, for the quasi-monopolistic exploitation of the internal market, little open to competition. With the globalization of markets and the technological revolution, it has become an obsolete and unproductive industry, which is languishing, despite all the protection, subsidies and lobbying power. Agribusiness, in turn, little protected, little subsidized and exposed to the global market, became increasingly productive and dynamic.
You managed to capture the essence of this division, which is not only political, but also economic and cultural between coastal and industrial Brazil and the Brazil of agribusiness. And this clash between these two Brazils coincides with a time of cultural wars and an identity agenda in the western world.
Solid synopsis Tattiana, yet there can be some pushback though on the economic divide described between coastal and interior regions, because a significant part of GDP in fact comes from productivity in coastal states- Rio, São Paulo, Paraná, and Santa Catarina. It seems the economic divide is more accurately defined between north and south, the latter being much more productive and therefore wealthier. Interestingly, the northern states is where socialist government is and has been dominant.
22 🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Nah, completely ignored corporate role in polarization. Ignored that Dilma was impeached unfairly. That's when polarization really began. The current situation is manufactured.
@@shindousan Unfair is the amount of money stolen in the largest corruption case in the history of the country.
Financial Times forgot to mention Bolsonaro is a dictatorship nostalgic and said on TV he wanted to start a civil war in Brazil, shut down the congress and Supreme Court 🤡
Good morning, good afternoon or even good night. I don't know what time you will read what I write, but... as a Brazilian citizen I will point out some reasons why I want to see Lula da Silva and his collaborators arrested.
I'll start with the simple ones:
In my belief, Christianity. We believe there is repentance. When you make a mistake like this gentleman made a mistake, the least that can be admitted is the mistakes, which in this case are countless.
This gentleman should have at least made a Mea Culpa in relation to his mistakes, unfortunately the lack of scruples makes him simply divert from subjects when the responsibility is conferred on him ("I don't know anything").
The PT is Lula and Lula is the PT.
I am against the deification of any personality, the end of it is: the ruin of that personality.
I'm Anti-PT. I consider this party a faction, I had the displeasure of working on various campaigns in the state of Rio and outside it making jingles and working with the people of marketing agencies.
I was able to meet some leaders from Rio, and when I went to São Paulo I was in the ABC, I saw that unfortunately the same system of shady negotiations and political patronage to which they so discriminate, was an official practice.
It is the party that had the best conditions to provide improvements in the quality of life of our population, but instead, preferred to shield itself in a summit and ignore all those who did not agree with its attitudes, aiming only at power.
Lula changed his convictions as it suited him electorally. His often contradictory actions cast doubt on whether he had any country projects. But wouldn't the former president have been right in adapting to different situations, giving them different answers and almost always ensuring high growth?
Not. As we have seen, none of the fundamentals for lasting growth were a priority under his administration. Many strategic mistakes were made, mistakes that would only be felt in the medium term, during the troubled (to say the least) management of Dilma.
When “Nine Fingers” took over, Brazil was in full condition to expand its potential. The president did nothing, but sold as if he had. He was underhanded. He handed over the country essentially as he found it, if not worse. It was careless. He entered the government as a champion of honesty. But according to the understanding of justice, in reality he was corrupt.
Regardless of what one thinks of Lula's character, it is necessary to recognize that his management was, at the very least, silent and inefficient. There is, on the part of many, the belief that the Lula government was apotheotic, a sudden change towards success, and that “never in the history of this country” has the country been so prosperous. None of this is true. The ex-president was able to construct this narrative, drawing on his base of loyal voters, who had bet on him since 1989. He is a thief
I'm a Brazilian citizen. Bolsonaro in his propraganda emphasizes the ideological subjects because his economical agenda is extremely harmful to poor people. The most of population that votes for him is composed by middle classs, people who is harmed by government actions also, but thinks they are not dependet on governamental policies. In general, Paulo Guedes, Economy Minister has great affection for bankers, bussinessmen and finacial investors.
How is his free market economical agenda harmful to poor people?
@@lrn_news9171 The economy minister, Paulo Guedes, took several measures that harm the poor, such as a pension reform that will make it impossible for many old people to retire, a labor reform that reduces salary and makes working conditions precarious in a country where salary of large part of the population is already low.
Not to mention other specific measures such as the reduction of a program that could lead to the extinction of delivery of medicines for those who need them, the end of the regulatory stock of food that allowed for a more affordable price of food in times of crisis, in addition to benefiting the small farmer, etc.
It is not by chance most of voters who elected the new president, Lula, are from the poor population.
At the same time, almost all economic measures were aimed to favoring large businessmen and the financial market.
I am going conclude with an example to illustrate: in 2020 in the pandemic, the Bolsonaro government refused to provide clean water and hygiene products to indigenous peoples alleging specific lack of money in the budget but released more than a trillion reais to the banking system.
@@psdapsda3601 Sounds like he was pro free market and making brazil more attractive for business and foreign investment. In the long term that would probably pull Brazil out of the middle income trap. Perhaps you like other leftoids don't understand how economic development process works. A lot of this seems like propaganda, there's probably counter-arguments for all of this from the Bolsonaro supporters.
Bolsonaro 22 🇧🇷
Bolsonaro 💛💚💖
situation in Brazil is complicated.
leftist government has 19 people convicted of curruption talking on ministries.
I visited brazil last year , todays brazil is far more developed than 5 year before brazil i visited. More people are educated and ore business is growing i think jair did something good which his predecessor never did
Where did you go? For sure a wealth neighborhood or touristic place... The Brazil that doesn't see the real Brazil
@@MatheusDC9 ipanema, copacabanaa, cidada alté .
@@MatheusDC9 o Brasil é um país continental, dependendo de onde você ir, pode encontrar uma área que pode ser considerada como desenvolvida
You dont know nothing about Brazil
Unfortunately the new ruling Jair "Messiah", took away a lot of our freedom. Our northeast regions have no voice, only southerners and a small minority are in favor of bolsonaro. We want Lula, because since he left we have been orphaned children
meus amigos, vocês estão muito errados em sua análise, a divergência de pensamento é a fortaleza da democracia, quando um país deixa de conviver com essa divergência é que a democracia morre, foi assim na Alemanha Nazista, foi assim na Venezuela atual.
divergencia de mais é ruim, divergencia de menos tambem.
wow !!! very good Leftist content !!! as usual lacking reality , any comments on why LULA was absolved from his friends on the supreme court? I invite anyone to go for some holidays in Venezuela or Cuba to see what the future Lulas brazil will look like .
Those are sanctioned countries, any country that is under sanction won't do well. So please make a better example.
Hrrr dar "go to Venezuela or Cuba to see your future" typical argument of Bolsonaro support who has a lown QI
Like in the middle age, politics related church.... Oh boy
Fake news.
O Brazil. Surfando. Na. "Comodities. "E. Enriquecendo. O. Agro. E. O. Povo. Passando. Fome🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
lula so é atribuido como bom por causa das comodites sendo que os outros paise cresceram absurdamente em relação ao brasil naqulea epoca
Mentira!
Engraçado é que fazem um vídeo sobre o Brasil, mas não colocam legendas em português.
Ue, mas a gente ja sabe o que ta acontecendo no Brasil kkkkk
Bolsonaro the best of Brazil
Avante Presidente Bolsonaro!!
🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷🇧🇷
Avante para dentro da cela
@@shindousan , e por acaso ele é Lula ou do PT?
@@marcosjose6441 Pede pra liberar os sigilos covardes de 100 anos e daí eu te respondo
@@shindousan , ele já respondeu a respeito disso. Inclusive disse na cara do Luladrã0 num debate. Procura aí no TH-cam.
Aliás, LuladrãO já disse que não vai mais a debates. Por que será? Kkklllll
@@marcosjose6441 Mentiras, como é típico dos bolsonaristas.
No, definitely Tabata Amaral is not our version of AOC
Congratulations on the unbiased view of the reality brazil is going through! Unbiased news sources are getting harder and harder to find..
Para de pagar pau de gringo, todo mundo falando em português no vídeo e vc aqui comentando em inglês como se os gringos fossem ler oq vc escreve, 90% de quem ta vendo isso é BR se liga
The whole process is unfair, from the release of the PT party candidate by a judge appointed by the candidate himself to the rest of the events until the elections. The national mainstream media strangely manipulates the news in such a way that it always seemed to favor the PT party candidate, manipulating popular opinion, a series of judicial decisions were always overwhelmingly in favor of the PT party, there were many censorships, always against whoever was on the side of Bolsonaro. The selections themselves showed strange behavior on their chart. An Argentine boy made two lives from Argentina about an audit that shows anomalies in the elections. There are millions of people on the street in protest and the national media does not show or say that there are ten troublemakers and calls the people imbeciles, universities with ideological bias lie about the COVID wave to discourage demonstrations. It's the simple people who don't accept a big thief in the presidency. In the investigative operation "Lava Jato", from years ago, corruptions were found that reached the values of R$ 8000000000000.
@@ordiv12345 Mais um falando em inglês respondendo outro brasileiro que comentou em inglês, que esquizofrenia é essa?
@@LeoestreladouniversoGladiador o canal é americano, logo eles fazem isso pra não confundir o público comum do canal. the channel is American, so they do this so as not to confuse the channel's common audience.
@@rafasynox Só tem brasileiro comentando, os americanos nem assistem isso.
Brazil's problems is much bigger. only as an example we work 6 months per year to pay taxes, the Brazilian state turn from servant to master.
But brazil doesn't have public service
Great documentary with a fair and unbiased view.
14:27 "Lula's history aside" ? LOL
The history of Lula and his party is one of the main reasons for this polarization that we live here.This video lack information about things that have occourd recently in Brazil, essential things to understand a bit more what is happening here.
If Bolsonaro's government is an disaster, if he is threat to democracy, an homofobic, an misogynistic, etc...why the elections are so polarized? why so many people still thinks that he is the best candidate when compared to Lula?
These are some of the questions that maybe a foreigner may ask themselves while watching this video.
Neymar supports Bolsonaro🇧🇷
Both are crap.
This was a non-biased documentary. I wish more of them wereas such.
In short: we plant tons of food for you to eat and we get hungry
Jair Bolsonaro is the best choice at this point...
Goiás eo Texas do Brasil
Realmente
Lula os a convict. In addition, one cannot talk about the current situation in Brazil without taking into account the fact that the Supreme Court no longer respects the constitution, the division and independence of the Three Powers, the Public Prosecutor's Office, the legal due process, and acts as a political agent. Alexandre de Moraes ignored the constitutional right of parliamentary immunity of deputies and started to arrest, suspend out of office and blocked their accounts on social networks. He ignored the popular vote and ousted mayors and governors he considers opposition under the allegation of anti-democratic actions. He also ignored the legal due process by acting as a victim, whistleblower, investigator, prosecutor and judge of ordinary citizens. As President of the Electoral Court, he was partial to Lula to the detriment of the opposition candidate.- This being the reason for the population's revolt.- He implemented prior censorship. All these actions are expressly prohibited by the constitution. Who is attacking Brazil’s democracy? The only possible comparison with current events is with what happened in VENEZUELA. Comparing them to the US is a fallacy, misinformation and an act of bad faith. Brazil has become a judiciary dictatorship. Not to mention that Lula is still a convict condemned in ALL criminal instances and was NOT supposed to be eligible to run for presidency. That was only made “possible” through a conning maneuver done by the Supreme Court. Thus, Lula is an ILLEGIMATE President. PLEASE GET THE FACTS FIRST.
I think one reason for the economic problems is that its virtually impossible to immigrate to Brazil. Many people for example from America would want to move to Brazil, and they would bring billions of dollars in spending, businesses, real estate, etc. Brazil needs to open up and let foreigners bring their talent and money. "Protecting the job market" is really protecting poverty.
No man. If you come with billions, the doors are wide open.
Perhaps not. The economic politic is directed to the financial market; one can profit very much just buying Brazilian public debt bonds, no risk. Why someone would like to invest in other activity?
Propaganda! No matter, the poor people's hopes are for a Lula win! But there is only one thing that can change anything and that is a revolution! All power to the working class and the poor of Brazil.
Ave Império do Brasil
I'll never lose my faith in my country get united again
Think, and vote.
For those who don't know Brazil and don't live here, I'll update you on our current context. We are disputing an election between two extremes, on the one hand is Jair Bolsonaro who is extreme right, defends freedom of expression, family, religious freedom, believes in God, is against criminals, against abortion, and in favor of carrying guns. . On the other hand, we have Lula, a former president who was imprisoned for two years for involvement in one of the biggest corruption schemes in the world, which is in favor of abortion, in favor of drug liberation, wants to implant gender ideology in schools (teaching about sex since kindergarten), which wants to reduce the severity of petty crimes such as cell phone theft and house theft, is against churches, Christian religions, is against the family, and of course wants to regulate the media, so that in this way no one else can take him out of power. I hope I have been able to clarify the reason for the war we are living. And feminists who walk naked on the street vote for Lula, part of the LGBT is also in favor of Lula because the leftist media created, in an attempt to demoralize President Jair Bolsonaro, a narrative that he does not like gays, because in fact he said that would not like to have a gay son, but he has gay friends and for him they are normal people like any other and which person's sexual option does not matter to him. Another group that is also in favor of Lula are civil servants, as one of Jair Bolsonaro's previous promises was to privatize several state companies in order to reduce expenses and thus be able to make better investments, because here in Brazil in the public sector, the Employees end up having a great security that they "can't" be dictated after being hired, so to do the job of one person, sometimes we need 5 people. For example, street sweepers sometimes have 6 on a street, there are 2 on the street and 4 on the wheel chatting, and our money being thrown in the trash, and this extends to health, education and other public departments. Anyway, the summary is this, on one side conservatism on the other socialism mixed with communism. May God bless us and keep us.
100% great comment. Thank you. Hello from Canada. I wouldn't say Bolsonaro is extreme right however.
it's very hard to watch this as a Brazilian. So sad.
Bolsonaro 22 defends the family, is against abortion and against gender ideology.
Therefore, I will vote for Bolsonaro 22.
A realidade no Brasil é outra. Bolsonaro 22 defende a família, é contra o aborto e contra a ideologia de gênero.
Portanto, votarei em Bolsonaro 22.
Gender ideolog? Damn you're so funny. You have been so creative on inventing fantasy stories, you should write a book, would be a sucess like an GOT ou Harry Potter.
Ideologia de gênero? Cara, vocês são muito engraçados. São tão criativos intentando histórias de fantasia, deveriam escrever um livro, seria um sucesso tipo GOT ou Harry Potter.
As a Brazilian I can say that Tabata Amaral is a very intelligent woman. People like her are our hope for a better Brazil in the future. I hope she may running for president in the coming years. For the time being, at least till 2026 we are gonna have a horrible government, no matter who is gonna win the elections this year. But, for sure, Bolsonaro is way worse than Lula.. Even Lula being a Corrupt. (Bolsonaro is also a Corrupt).
No he's not, learn the difference between currency and cash first
@@KazumaSatouStellYourPants Not everything sums up into money.
Thank you for the content!
This is so ridiculous!!! It is an ocean of lies!! Haha you dont know how Brazil works.
Deus, Familia e Brasil! #Bolsonaro2022
In my opinion, in a democracy the race or gender of a politician is irrelevant. Want more female politicians? Vote female. Want more pardo politicians? Vote according to skin color. This is a non issue and to pretend otherwise is the same as calling the electorate stupid.
Why do you defend a criminal (Lula)? He was not acquitted. His lawyers maneuvered to nullify the procedure that had already gone through court of appeals where he was convicted by unanimous vote of a college of five independent justices in the federal circuit. He's still answering criminal lawsuits. The main process stemming out of the car wash operation just went back to first circuit. A loophole in Brazilian electoral law and the support of the justices he and Dilma appointed to the Supreme Court while he was in power are the reason he's been allowed to run for president. Bolsonaro, despite of his "macho" speech, has not been accused of any crime, not by official entities not even his opposition. The accusations against him are based on things he says taken out of context, not his concrete measures as president, the things he actually implemented. He implemented no measures against LGBT or minorities. Quite the opposite. The average voter is warranted to not investigate into what is speech and what is fact. I didn't expect that financial times would lack the resources, expertise and independent journalism to go beyond the Instagram memes and fake news. Do you want to see what Bolsonaro has actually implented? Please read below in Portuguese (Google translate it) and by all means fact check everything. More facts, less speculation and innuendos without grounds please.
Voto 13. Faz o L
The only criminal is the terrorist Bolsonaro who literally threw a bomb in an army barrack and was arrested accordingly
A brasil um país tão rico e tão pobre ao mesmo tempo😢
Frustrating to see how FT didn't do their diligent investigation about what those interviewed said, instead just presenting it as "facts" - FT failed with the journalism as it was supposed to be.
For instance, one say that bolsonaro instructs his followers to shoot others: what ridiculous accusation - yes, he said something that can be transformed into that, but taken completely out of context as it is here, it becomes nonsense, and FT failed to assess such strong statement and act accordingly (either explain it, or give the decades of context behind it, or remove it, or...)
That was presented as a politicians opinion "she thinks - she fears"
@@Langworthy13. What she thinks is not relevant under this circumstance. People like her are places in a higher pedestal in the international community hence she should state facts instead of opinions. Nothing good is reported about Brazil in the international press due to people like her. They never say anything good about their own country unfortunately.
Bolsonaro never said to shoot his opponents but Lula thanked a supporter who pushed a man onto a truck "to save him" (the man was only shouting "Lula is a thief")
Actually they didn't say that
They interviewed a politician who stated that opinion.
@@dalusifa the president has given fact free political opinions all the time.
Wtf type of standard do you want from her.
He said a few weeks ago anything other than a 60 percent round 1 win for him was fraud
He insinuated the vaccine can make you a crocodile
He accused Leonardo DiCaprio of causing fires in the Amazon to make him look bad.
^^ does this seem like a fact based statement that makes Brazilian leaders look serious
He also claimed it's good and evil in this election. Is thata fact based statement...or political rhetoric
Hold the feet to the fire for both sides please
Also she does love her country. All of politics is essentially identifying problems within your country...bringing them to the forefront in a an effort to change your country for the better.
Bolosnaro did this when he ran...running against the corruption in his country and the violence. He focused on these negatives as they were harming the country ...and he believes he had the solutions
She's doing that from a different angle.
Nelson Mandela , Martin Luther King, Ghandi etc etc all were critical about ills in their country and were rather public about it. Were they not Patriots or were they trying to improve their nations?
Lessen the scale and that's what political activists on both sides do.
Hell in the u.s "make America great again" implies it's not great now, but they are striving
Hello, I am Brazilian, and I am experiencing everything that was reported in this short documentary about the political situation in my beloved Brazil, I disagree with some parts, Lula is not a Social Democrat he is totally focused on Communism, the hunger situation we are in living today reflects the 8-year term of Lula's government and 6 years of Dilma Russef's successor. Brazil was handed over to President Jair Bolsonaro bankrupt, so much so that Lula was sentenced in three stays and imprisoned, why? Because it was, he and his party who plundered Brazil, the state-owned companies went bankrupt and started thousands of infrastructures works in the country and did not finish any. At no point did the documentary report that a maneuver by the federal supreme court invalidated the conviction to release and make Lula eligible again in a trumped-up judicial maneuver. They used the covid-19 pandemic to, through the rotten Brazilian media, all of which were financed with public money, and which suffered huge cuts in their revenues after the inauguration of Jair Bolsonaro, whoever pays the media in Brazil has the people under control, as a way of building a bad image of President Jair Bolsonaro.
There was never polarization in Brazil because the parties that existed were two sides of the same coin. Today we have a clearer division of ideological conflicts because there is really a differentiation in the management of the country. Brazil needs infrastructure works, so that it can grow again and improve economically, the medicine for the cure of the Brazilian economy is unfortunately bitter, but 4 years to undo all the evil that was done after 14 years of the workers' party in power It's little, it's impossible.
The game is the corruption, aganist the strong man.
Cesar de Lisboa but they are both corrupt buyt the latter incites civil war. he is a war monger
i am brazilian, and i live here. i lived here all my life, thank God. We are not divided. you exagerate. There has been political poles here since 1994. why ypu didn't noticed? because that's how we disagree; peacefully and orderly. i understand you make money by selling blood. a sad burden, though.
This is by far the best reporting of the current situation I've seen so far. And I love the unbiased view that shows both candidates for what they are, without demonizing one side over the other. Both of them are terrible choices to lead the country, and whatever happens the situation will only get worse.
Não amigo, vai melhorar! como brasileiro, digo que nesses últimos 4 anos a nossa economia melhorou, o preço dos produtos cairam, e o salário mínimo subiu.
Mano, Bolsonaro é a melhor escolha.
Lula is connected with corruption cases, leftists such as Hugo Chavez and Maduro (Venezuela), and Castro's family (Cuba). Don't believe in Tabata Amaral, she also is leftist.
@@erickvinicius7861 KKKKKKK PRECO DE QUE CAIU????? Do jetski??? Kkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkkk tu nao tem nem vergonha de tentar mentir pra gringo ne KKKKKKKKKKKKK
wonderful documentary，better than reading articles on Economist
A qualidade do conteúdo e da produção desse vídeo é incrível! Me surpreendeu demais.
What?
Isso E Mentira！Vcs Os Odeiam Pq Ele Nos Mostrou A Verdade Ok ，Ele E Amado Pela Maioria Do Povo Brasileiro，Inclusive Mulheres 🙄😤
Bolsonaro Always be the best choose to us of brazil i am from brazil and i know the true 🇧🇷 22🤝👏👏
Bolsonaro 💛💚💖
@@___vz___ always be the best chooose kkkkkkkkkkkkk. tinha que ser bolsominion ne
BOLSONARO PRESIDENTE 💒🇧🇷
Bolsonaro 22 from Bulgaria ( Europa )🇧🇷🇧🇬
thank yuo from Brazil
Love from Brazil🇧🇷
Say no to fascism!! ❤Lula
BOLSONARO 2022...
@@___vz___ LULA IS CORRUPT JUST LIKE CORRUPT BIDEN BOTH SELLING THEIR COUNTRIES TO THE CHINESE COMMIES.
What about indigenous rights and the violence that they are subject to by miners and loggers approved and spurred on by bolsónaro. Not that lula is a good guy but glaring over this fact is a bit weird 🤔
I'm an active subscriber of the Financial Times for many years, but I'm saddened to see such bias in what used to be more independent journalism
So unsuscribe lol
Where is the bias? They showed every side.
Bolsonaro o melhor presidente do Brasil 🇧🇷
GOD BLESS PRESIDENT BOLSONARO AND BRAZILLIAN PEOPLE. 1 MILLION PEOPLE ON THE PAULIST AVENUE.
WE WILL NOT BE VENEZUELA! #Bolsonaro2022
13:38 this guy call himself a christian, but all he cares about is money. He is not concerned about the millions Brazilian starving right now, he is concerned about the "people in agribusiness". What about that, Jesus! #forabolsonaro
One thing I'm sure, I would never vote for a guy who has been convicted by all instances of justice and by more than 20 judges, and even cases where he hasn't been convicted yet.
Dude was talking about hunger at 1:13 and the boy got apple. *confused*