It is truly astonishing how little honest research and analysis of primary sources is present in this video. First and foremost, Imam Ibn Kathir, in his Tafsir, did not explain the verse the way you claimed he did. He merely mentioned that others have explained the ayah in such a way while simultaneously casting doubt on these interpretations. You may ask why the Imam included that explanation while disagreeing with it. The simple answer is that the purpose of his work is to gather all the various interpretations of the Quranic verses by different people-scholars and otherwise-while providing the source of each interpretation. Some of the explanations of the verses referenced in his Tafsir were attributed to the Messenger of God himself-peace be upon him-others to his companions, those after them, and even the Jewish and Christian communities. His referencing of these explanations does not imply his agreement, nor does it mean they represent mainstream Islamic beliefs or acceptable interpretations of the verses. His work is simply an archive of reports. The story about the whale, as noted by scholars of Quranic Exegesis, originates from the Jewish and Christian traditions. Notice that Ibn Abbas-may Allah be pleased with him-did not say that this story was from the Messenger of God himself-peace be upon him-he simply mentioned it. Among scholars of Quranic Exegesis and Hadith, it is well known that some Companions would share stories they heard from Jewish and Christian scholars. The fact that the story of the whale comes from Jewish and Christian traditions is mentioned by countless scholars. For example, Shaykh Muhammad Abu Shahba in his book 'Isra'iliyyat and Fabrications in the Books of Tafsir' and Ibn al-Qayyim in his work 'al-Manar' (pg 252) reference this story as an example of fabricated reports. Secondly, you seem to have overlooked the science of textual criticism in the context of Hadith. No narrator, not even the Companions, is above textual criticism. There are numerous instances where Companions disagreed with the reports of other Companions, and there are even examples of the students of the Companions critically examining the accuracy of the Companions’ reports. No one accepted the words of the Companions at face value without first assessing the authenticity of their reports. Once a report was deemed accurate, scholars would then discuss how the report should be understood. Should it be interpreted literally or metaphorically? Should it be applied universally without exceptions, or are there exceptions? Was the report abrogated, or does it remain applicable? These are just some of the questions that scholars address when dealing with any text. Thirdly , even if, for the sake of argument, this was a mainstream belief among Muslims and the Muslim scholarly class (which it wasn't), what is the connection between that belief and scientific progress? Can you provide any evidence that Muslims halted scientific progress because they believed the world existed on a sea creature? Some of the greatest achievements of Muslim scholars occurred from the 7th century onwards, including the codification of the sciences of algebra, logic, and medicine, philosophy and countless others. Some of the finest architecture and engineering projects-which still stand today-were completed during and after the 7th century. Clearly, your claim that beliefs like this led to the collapse of Muslim scholarly and scientific progress is completely baseless. I urge you to reconsider your stance in the video and further explore primary sources instead of regurgitating outdated orientalist tropes. You should review an article written by Turkish Scholar Recep Senturk titled "The decline of the decline paradigm: Revisiting the periodisation of Islamic history". For an interesting discussion on the idea of an 'islamic golden age'. I am happy to further discuss these points further should you care to do so.
So why is there hardith that a re influenced by Jewish and Christian traditions? Why ia there weak hadith. Why did they have to make hadith science? Because there is so many fakes!! Do you know those scholars?? No! You know what some priests did with children right? Why should you trust some scholar you don't even know😅
This is true, i have been asking where did we go wrong. Then I kept picking up how ideal sunni world is and how realistic quran is. It should be both realistic, not the opposite. You do not need to be rocket scientist to see the flaw of sects and hadith. Quran is the way to go if you are a proper Muslim.
Why are people calling him Shia? Dont the Shia have their own hadith? You dont need to label everyone. Allah simply called us Muslims, just say you're Muslim.
Allah Almighty Creator called the believers in the Qur'an, Muslims. The Qur'an explicitly and preemptively rejected the ahadith. And states that those who believe in any scripture out side of the Qur'an as being outside the fold of Islam. Ahadith is outside of the Qur'an. Further, Ahadith divides the Muslim Ummah into various sects, thus places the followers of the hadith outside of Islam.
@MariamKhan-oj6zb I agree, that we don't need the ahadith. I wouldn't say people who follow it are outside of Islam, just further from the center and clear path.
@@zaidmuhammad6343 You need nt say. The Qur'an says it. That's enough if you are Muslim. If you include ahadith along with the Qur'an then according to the Qur'an you are outside of the fold of Islam. Read it for yourself.
@@zaidmuhammad6343 It is not in one place as Allah repeatedly warns against the ahadith in very many ways in very many verses. If you are Muslim and have read the Qur'an it is indeed strange that you know not of it. However if you are really unaware of these warnings in the Qur'an then I can take the time to arrange them in a manner for you and others to check them out. So let me know if I need to find time and make this effort. BTW to clarify a few things: "ahadith" means statements. For example when it comes to Divine authority, the Quran endorses no other hadith(statement) but only the Quran. Qur'an is the ‘the best hadith’ ("Ahsanal Hadeeth", (Surah 39:23), as it calls itself. So the sole emphasis of the Quran is on Quran only, not on any other hadith, "lahwal hadeeth", (Surah 31:6), as it calls them. As a revelation the Qur'an describes itself as self-explaining, fully detailed, complete, easy-to-learn. The Quran is, according to the Quran itself, the only authority of Islam and the only Divine source of law. Thus no other hadith is acceptable in Islam. This should tell you why accepting ahadith, Sunnah and other so-called secondary authorities outside of the Quran to define Divine system is considered by the Quran as idolatry or polytheism. Thus ahadith is Shirk.
Islam was completed in March 632 CE (Maida / Chapter 5 verse 3). Hadith collection was a profitable business. Later, shorter the isnād (chain of narration) the more valuable it would be in the market. There is even Hadith whose narrator is a jinn. Interestingly, in the 7th and 8th century, typical chain would be 28 narrators, and then in the 9th century, suddenly we find the chain shortens to 5 narrators. People who point this out are polemicized as Hadith Denier (منکر حدیث). Well, truth is, everyone is a Hadith Denier. There is no one who believes in every Hadith. Even Bukhari collected 600,000 narrations, but compiled around 4,500, hence rejecting 595,000. Here is a simple rule: any Hadith that Quran validates is potentially true, and otherwise false.
Profitable business?? Can you elaborate please. Al bukhari for instances spend his entire life collecting the Hadiths and lived on people's generosity and ended up in prison because he wouldn't take hadiths from suspicious source. At least dare to read the history of the hadiths collectors and the tremendous suffering they went trough.
@@DistortedEmpath Out of approximately 600,000 Hadith he is said to have collected, he included around 7,275 Hadith in "Sahih al-Bukhari" (including repetitions). Without repetitions, the number of distinct Hadith is about 2,600. He gave a long list of reasons for rejection: poor insad, ittisal, inconsistencies, adalat, lacking corroboration, lacking content and context consistency, failure in verification in direct travel, reputation and peer review (fist-cut of Ilm Rajaal)
@AbidNasim so you listed valid reasons to he used to eliminate hadith. Now we have 7000 which don't have these issues your best course of action is to reject all 7000?
Questionable Hadith tells women to bow down to their husband, Aisha RA age when proof shows she was way older, yet people take bhukari or sahi Muslim to be 100% authentic and that’s dangerous.
Here’s a popular traditional scholar of Hadith debunking the child marriage claim: th-cam.com/video/03b97GUacpM/w-d-xo.html Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater…
You are so ignorant of your faith I almost feel sorry for Islam and I’m not even Muslim. First the Quran clearly instructs women to obey their husbands even to let them have sex with them when they wish unless the wife has a legitimate religious excuse. That unequivocal. Second point: Their is no Proof that Aisha was way older when she married the prophet. All you have as your “proof” is speculation and conjecture. Meanwhile there are multiple Hadiths from different sources that state Mohammed married when she was a child and plus her own Hadiths written by Aisha herself. I mean come on when are u gonna stop making excuses for your faith? Either accept it or reject but don’t try to artificially moderate your faith to make it look more acceptable. You might as well be a Christian at that point if that is the approach u have. Good luck. Read more. May I ask are u a Muslim? And what kind? I’m just surprised by your comment. Thanks
You're literally attempting to make the Age of `Ā'ishah (May Allah be pleased with thrm), in the Name of Islāmophobic "Political-Correctness"...you're a Coward.
Very simple: whomever rejects the Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition rejects The Qur'ān by default: a. Both The Qur'ān & the Sunnah are at-Tanzīl/Revrlation. b. The Same-Persond whom humanly documented The Sunnah also documented The Qur'ān. c. Both The Qur'ān & the Sunnah were documented during the Lifetime of Muhammad (Peace be upon them).
Akbar is not a name of Allah. Not sure who they think there invoking. Its insulting. Akbar is not a name of Allah in the quran. Check in the quran where akbar is. Astafirallah! I say Allahu Al kabeer now!!
@@CraftyFoxx al khabeer means Allah is the master great. Akbar means greater. Its grammatically incorrect and its not one of his attributes or names. I say Allahu al khabeer. Its better then Allahu Akbar. Akbar in the quran is never used to describe Allah. Check it and see for yourself.
Yes, Hadith is the real cause of ruination of Islam and Muslims. Every sect has been been a victim of Hadith. Islam is being driven in reverse gear over the last 700 years. If one looks at some of the stories narrated in Qur'aan, one finds that Allah narrated the best Hadith and said in 45:6 "After this Hadith (Qur'aan), which Hadith will they believe?" Our Prophet was given Qur'aan and when he recited out, all people understood the message and embraced Islam. He spoke only through Qur'aan and never referred to any tale. Hadith collections were made by tale-collectors and story-tellers like Bukhari, Muslim, Dawood and others who came from Central Asia. Note that none of them was an Arab. Imam Malik wrote some when the Baghdad Caliph forced him to write some because he was a scholar of Islam and specialised in Islamic jurisprudence. Our Prophet had forbidden to write anything about him. And the tale-collectors did. Qur'aan is Islam's only Scripture. It is obligatory on eveery Muslim. Hadith is neither Islam's scripture nor it is obligatory. Each and every Hadith from anyone is subject to Qur'aan's scrutiny. Hadith does not taech anything. The tale collectors heard tales, narrations and saying from various people and lumped them in their collections. Hadith tales were told in Caliphs' Courts and people became more interested in tales and that is how it was sold. A thousand years ago, the fast car of Islam started slowing down and stopped moving 600 years ago, because various Imams plied their opinions and interpretation of Qur'aan through Hadith tales. Reading and understanding Qur'aan was ignored. Coimng to the word saheeh, it means true, right, correct, genuine and authentic in Arabic. Saheeh Bukhari means the genuine collection by Bukhari or Hadith according to Bukhari just like 'The Gospel, according to Matthew and others. But Saheeh Bukhari does not mean that everything in it is saheeh. Scholars scrutinise all ahaadith under Qur'aan and classify them as Good, authentic, true, and also as poor, defective and not reliable. It is not that the tale-collectors lied. They wrote what they heard from Muslims, the Jewish and Christian converts and others. There are lots of ridiculous and absurd ahaadith which came into Islam through early Jewish and Christian converts. Those are known as Israeliyaat. That is one should not rely on Hadith at all. Some Muslims do believe in the subject of Hadith but they should know that Qur'aan stands Supreme because Qur'aan is the only Scripture of Islam. That is what a Muslim follows. The current Ummah is not that Ummah which Qur'aan talked about. Every Muslim state has its own Ummah. Saudi Ummah, UAE Ummah, Kuwaiti Ummah, Egyptian Ummah, Kuwaiti Ummah, Bahraini Ummah, Omani Ummah, Pakistani Ummah, Turkish Ummah and so on. Yet they are not one united Ummah. Some Arab Ummahs follow Qur'aan Qur'aan based on their Hadithi scholars. All that has resulted in the degradtion of Muslims Ummahs. The real cause is Hadith.
Qur'ānism by default/definition is a Hizb/Religio-Sect: Muhammad (Peace be upon them) wasn't a "Qur'ānist" & none amongst as-Salaf (as-Sahābah/the Companions & Generations-1&2 of at-Tābi`īn/the Followers) were "Qur'ānists". So, you've literally proven how much of a Hizbī (Religio-Heretic) & Mubtadi` (Religio-Innovator) you & all those like you actuallg are.
@GarethBryant15 assalamu alyaikum. It really surprising me how you and many others call people 'Quranist' with such an aggression and hatred, abhorrence.. A man says he is following the Quran and you saying he is wrong!! Doesn't that strange to you? Don't you hear yourself? Allah only decides who is on the right path or not. HE will show everyone on the Judgment day who was following what. So stick each of you to your path and wait. May Allah guide all of us to the right path. Amin
You are 100% correct it's unfortunate so many have fallen slaves to these fake texts of Hadith! These jerks had no fear of Allah unfortunately but now I'm sure they're paying the price. How dare them take the Quran and alter it for their benefits in Hadith. I have removed every single Hadith from my home never ever will it be allowed inside again. My kids are being raised on Quran only no Hadith
O Allah, I ask you to guide me to the right and true, straight path forever and forever, quickly and urgently in the best way forever and forever! Amin
Then don't say O Allah, it's not quranic. Only it applies to the creation like O Prophet, O Mankind, O fire... But not for the creator O Allah (Ya Allah)
Fun fact: second righteous sunni caliph Umar ibn Al Khattab was Quranist. He punished Abu Hurayra for spreading hadith, he prevented prophet from writing his will by saying: we have Quran and it is enough.
..... Prevented Prophet ....and following his religion; what a nonsense. Omer didn't believe in his prophethood ? His living instruction vis a vis narration about his instructions can't be the same.
Ummar and Abu Bakar had been defiant against the Prophets commands when the Prophet had started becoming very ill, with Ummar denying the Prophets request for a pen and paper so that he could leave them one last command " so that Muslims dont go astray " being the last. Not only did Ummar disobey the Prophets command but he admoniahed the prophet by saying " we have the Quran and that is enough for us ". That one statement of defiance to the Prophets command isnt proof that Ummar was a Quranist. The fact both Abu Bakr and Ummar refusing the Prophets order to go battle as the Prophet was ill but chose to hang around etc Abu Bakr and Ummar were ensuring their accension to the throne of leadership was not challenged or contested.
How do you know? We're uou there? See how people made up hadith. Case and point this comment. There is evidence whatsoever that this happend. Like most of hadith.
I agree, I think Hadith should not be rejected entirely as lots of Hadith matches with Quran and history but it not be treated divine or 100% authentic rather good tool but also put question marks and red line on questionable Hadiths, any questionable sayings should be rejected, like stoning of adultery should be rejected.
The very few that agree with the Quran are completely redundant, they just regurgitate what the Quran says without any change. Completely unnecessary to ascribe man made books to Allahs deen
@@homer1273history is nonfiction literary critique. Once it passes into the realm of religious dogma it cannot be critiqued and is no longer historical.
Salaamun Alaikum. Sunnism and Hadith sounds like a Religion out of Harry Potter. I am certain it will make a very entertaining reading and good stories for kids.
Ironically, your Statement literally proves that you don't even believe in The Qur'ān: Number-1...Allah affirms/confirms that everything Muhammad (Peace be upon them) stated, did, etc. regarding al-Islām was at-Tanzīl/Revelation. (Noble-Qur'ān: Chpt.53, V.1-5) Number-2...Muhammad stated: "Beware, verily, I was granted The Qur'ān & something just like it as Revelation. And there'll be Persons from my Natiin whom'll recline on Couches claiming "The Qur'ān aline is enough for me.". Beware of them.". (Abū-Dāwud) Number-3...Allah affirms/confirms that whomever mocks Muhammad and/or whatever they were sent with as per at-Tanzīl are Cursed-Persons. (Noble-Qur'ān: Chpt.108) There's 0-Doubt that mocking the Concept of "Hadīth" literally (by default/defibition) is Mockery of anything/everything which Allah revealed to Muhammad via at-Tanzīl.
The only thing that made me an apostate at 15 years old were the Hadith and Muslims themselves. Now, I am relearning Islam again and would consider myself a Hadith sceptic and non sectarian. Alhamdullilah
Ahadith if taken to heart would make any thinking truth seeking person a non-Muslim. In fact it appears as if that was the very purpose for fabricating the ahadith.
@@Itzyasir2absolutely not. Quran is from Allah swt. Just the structure , the miracles, the number of répétitions of certain words shows us it is preserved as God promised to do. Hadiths are not infaillible, god never promised to préserve them. The quran itself says its complète. The quran says there is no compulsion in religion. Yet some countries use hadiths to kill apostates. At this point this is shirk as you are litterally putting hadiths over quran. If the hadith goes in the same direction than quran then okay why not but if it goes against then no.
I'm glad this has a lot of views, and I hope a lot of those viewers who agree. I'm a revert from the Netherlands and every muslim I know is a sunni and I not only feel alone in my faith (bc I have no family member who's muslim), but even among muslims.... I hope people will rise up to hadiths, as they are very dangerous...
Average muslims don't study hadith themselves and neither it is necessary to study hadith . Just follow 5 pillars of Islam and know the difference between halal and haraam and u are good to go . Rejecting hadith will led to the formation of many sects .
I say to Sunni and Shia and any other sect upholding hadith: Eat the dates then consume the poison if you are truthful about your beliefs... no ifs and buts, very straightforward!
“He who has a morning meal of seven ‘ajwa dates will not suffer harm that day through toxins or magic.” (Bukhari, Hadith 5327 and Muslim, Hadith 3814).@@dgenxali
We are truthfull about our beliefs...your explaination of hadith is wrong. Hadith simply says , “Whoever eats seven ‘ajwah dates in the morning, will not be harmed by any poison or witchcraft that day.” (May or may not) The way doctor ask you to eat multivitamins tablets you will not get harm with lot of diseases. (May or may not)
Majority of Muslims likes stories, one wear white turban, the others will wear green, black, yellow etc. They will look at each others beards and say mashala yours is longer than mine and lifts their pants up showing their heals some will have long hair that's the religion they follow.
I don’t get your point. So they follow a religion of stories? Is that what Islam is basically. Because the Quran is a very short book. If u take out the Hadith you almost have nothing in Islam. How do u know how many times to pray? Yup it’s not in the Quran.
@@Crazy88277 you call that a short book with 114 suras so has Allah made a mistake when it says in the quran this revaltion is complete and fully detailed and it says in the quran how to pray prostate and bow and worship me alone nothing else matters.
Amongst all the Muslims, I've most respect for those Quranists, not only because rejecting the terrible Hadith allows them to be more rational or scientific, and they're at least trying to prove their Quran as a self-sufficient or complete holy book, but also their scepticism is most reasonable, since the Hadith have been authorized without approval of Muhammad, or even his companions, centuries after canonization of the Quran. Unfortunately, the Quran itself remains a disorganized and incomplete book, either because people who supposed to transmit its data have died before the canonization, or because Muhammad himself have died before the book was fully revealed and organized, so the Quran is absolutely dependent on other books like the Hadith, which makes up for those loses, including the missing context for the Quran, vast majority of practical guidance, and all data about Muhammad, or the founding history of Islam.
The Koran seems disorganised because: 1) It came down as revelation at various points and times usually in response and relation to something that was happening or something that was asked. One could argue that this is a better way to reveal the message since it responds to various everyday experiences encountered over the lifetime of Mohamed rather than him being revealed the message in one session or sitting as he is informed about random things without direct experience. 2) We are used to information being delivered in thematic groupings which the Koran does not follow. That is because it is not a 'story' per se with chapters in a chronological order as is often found in the Bible, but a response to living that is to be used as a guide to respond to varied experiences of human life especially social life. One could rearrange the order of information in the Koran into thematic chapters and it would then be easier to follow. The story like elements it does include are there to connect to the preious traditions of Judaism and Christianity to connect the speaker of the Koran to the preious revelations and address the followers of those faiths directly. It acts to remind them of those stories to establish a familiar voice to them and to also make corrections to any stories miscinstrued in preious revelations. That's why it states it is a final message because it is touching upon what ithas already revealed in the form of stories. Did the Bible come down thematically in stories as found in the Bible, or was it compiled and written in ways organised by men to make more sense, clarity and ease of read? Perhaps in the raw form of the Gospel it read like the Koran. The Gospels of Mark etc. are not that coherent. They also follow a pattern of documenting information that happened over the course of Jesus' lifetime in response to cases or people he encountered and his responses to them. 3) A Koran only reading provides much more clarity to topics, issues and responses which becomes only more clear the more one focuses on it as a sole source. The hadith cloud one's ability to notice what the Koran actually is saying loud and clear. And when you realise that much of the hadith counter what the Koran is saying, that's when the game changes for you and your understanding of Islam. I highly doubt if hadith were the doorway into Islam there would be a singke conert. Most converts come to Islam through the door of the Koran. And there is a reason for that. I highly suspect it is the hadith and Muslims' application of them that becomes the source of any doubts that arise.
@@TheExplorer-e1j Not only seems disorganized, but the Quran actually lacks any logical order, while including only some stories, which are based on chronological order, and so far as I'm concerned, the Quran is not even ordered by date of revelation.
I am so glad I found this channel. It’s this kind of intellectual pursuit that strengthens my Iman and keeps me committed to the deen. Thank you. Please keep it going brother
Your nafs finds excuses for rejecting Hadith. Unless you submit to Quran and Sunnah completely, your iman can't be complete. Listen to mainstream scholars on the dangers of rejecting Hadith
@@sophosalpha “some people will never learn anything…because they understand everything too soon.” I will worry about my Iman, which is stronger than it has ever been and growing. You should worry about yours.
@@sophosalphabrother you are just like the Christian’s and Jews who just follow what others around them follow. Allah completed our religion in the Quran. Anything additional is innovation. Allah knows best
I don't care if hadith collection was fully verified videos of Mohammed saying a bunch of stuff that made complete logical/scientific sense. It would still be a source outside of Quran and therefore nothing to do with God or Islam.
As a Byzantine Catholic I never met with a Sola Quran before. Would you be interested in debating Muhammad Hijab or other popular Sunni apologists? Very interesting.
A valid argument in general. However, I couldn’t understand why you have singled out sunnism for this. Are you a shia and therefore blaming only sunnis. The shia hadith in Kafi, Alibtibsar, NahjulBalagha, etc. is equally rather more unreliable, damaging and fraudulent. The sunni hadith made the Quran subservient to the Prophet but the shia hadith made it subservient to their so-called imams for their theological-political exigencies. So be fair bro and don’t sound sectarian because that makes your entire, rather good, narrative dubious and will be seen as motivated by sectarian bias.
You are right But there are things that you can't ignore. Such as this verse from Quran Surah Al-Ahzab (33:21) There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often." Or In his Farewell Sermon, Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said: O people, I am leaving among you two precious things, the Book of Allah and my family (Ahlul Bayt). If you adhere to both of them, you will never go astray. You can't turn a blind eye on this and ignore these statements.
All Glory and praise exclusively belong to the Creator alone. Everything outside Quran is dirty/impure including minds, hadith, other books,, language, etc.. If the Creator compels the soul to dwell in Quran, the purification process begins. The reader will impute their impure thoughts on it's verses, yes. However, by Allah's will alone, the sincere will gain understanding as one continue's to dwell in it without interference or interruption. The Quran represents the 'chamber of converse' between the reader and Allah. The only door to this chamber must remain shut (never to be opened) to root out any interference (Satan). Following Hadith, sin, or other associates or authorities other than Allah's supreme authority of Quran, sent as a mercy, will keep a screen over the hearts, eyes and ears and minds and it will be as if they were donkeys unable to read the Holy Quran which they carry on their backs. Allah watches as one is distracted or engrossed. The Holy Quran is a two way communication screen. As Allah sees (may the All-knowing, the Omnipresent, and the Compeller forgive my imperfect speech) one coming into His chamber ( May Allah alone be praised for His gifts), He will know who, among the sincere will close the door behind him (never to open it again) or not and , by His grace, bounty, compassion and mercy, will guide, misguide, or leave in their places whomever He wills.
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often. You need to know How Muhammad was, and follow his patterns. This is the direct order of Allah. You will follow his pattern if you fear the Judgement day and have hope in the mercy of Allah on the Judgement day
@@mazm4860 You obviously have not studied the verse (they do not ponder the Quran as it should be pondered). Is this how you patiently ponder Allah's revelation? The verse you cite: Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often. Analysis 1: 'There has certainly been...' refers to the Messengers pattern in the past ('has'=past tense) , not present or future. For the present and future, we now have the 'completed, perfected , preserved, clear, elaborated, and preserved explanation of all things (In Allah's own words) in the Quran. Muhammad had to be obeyed by his contemporaries (As Allah instructed in the Quran) since the Quran was not fully revealed (Quran: 'was revealed in stages', 'do not rush Allah's message, it is for Allah to reveal it and collect it'). Analysis 2: 'for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern....' Here we read that the Messenger's pattern was one of several optional patterns to be followed. Otherwise, Allah would state in the Quran that Muhammad's pattern was the only pattern for believers to follow and not just 'a' (an) pattern. However, Allah states 'an excellent pattern', directly implying a pattern among several. Also the term 'excellent' while a superlative noun, is not a noun of exclusivity. For example, a classroom full of A+ students, demonstrates that more than one can be excellent! I know the above to be true because of Quran. Allah also say (in Quran) to follow the cult (pattern) of Abraham; we are not to make distinctions between His messengers (Quran): a believer is one who believes in all of his messengers and books (cleared by Quran as, being the perfection of religion to all mankind, the criterion to determine what is true or false (Quran). With dirty hands you have used this verse to condemn or avoid. the complete reliance on the same Book that you cite this verse from! Why did you not carefully read the verse (as I did) before drawing your conclusion, which you did not support with other verses of Quran ( as I did support)? It is because you do not reverence Allah alone. Allah in the Quran states that Muhammad was only a messenger and his job was to only deliver the message which is Quran. Allah, therefore, has not sent down authority to harvest from the person of the Messenger, more than Allah's preserved and manifestly true Quran (such as hearsay accounts of what the messenger said and did, from self -appointed authorities besides Allah's clear authority in Quran). You are caught in the filter with others who do not truly reverence the unseen Lord of all being, and, therefore, you are barred from developing a Quranic brain which is the most excellent and exclusive pattern: 39:23. 'God has sent down the best of narrations: A Scripture consistent and paired. The skins of those who reverence their Lord shiver from it, then their skins and their hearts soften up to the remembrance of God. Such is God’s guidance; He guides with it whomever He wills. But whomever God leaves astray, for him there is no guide.'
A very bogus caption: Islam was not destroyed. Islam can’t be destroyed. To claim that Hadith destroyed Islam shows a little knowledge of Islam and of Hadith.
@Qurantalk, I agree wholeheartedly with everything you have put forth here. However, I still don't understand why no other Muslim (other than myself) cares about the fact that "Prophet" is a mistranslation of the word "Nabi". In the 12th century, Europeans translated the Hebrew Bible to several languages and used the very word to translate "Nevi", but the primary function of all of these Messengers (pbut) wasn't to foretell the future but to (summon, publicly orate, warn, deliver message, etc)--> all fittingly translate the verb of what a Nevi/Nabi does.
Google says that the word “prophet” goes back to the Greek word “phenai”, which means to speak, and gives rise to “phetes” - speaker. Thus, we have: pro (before) + phetes (speaker) = prophetes. Sounds like the same/similar root word as in Arabic, like you said?
You literally don't even care how Pathologically-Ignorant you actually are. The Word "Nabī" literally means "Prophetic-Individual", from the Word "Nubuwwah" which means "Prophecy/Prophethood", which comes from the Word "Naba'" which means "Event", "News", etc. (Lisān-ul-`Arab: Lexicon of the Arabic-Language, ibn-Manzhūr) Allah literally calls Muhammad (Peace be upon them) "Nabī", Several-Times via The Qur'ān itself. You've literally proven that you & those like you don't even know The Qur'ān, which you & those like you claim to exclusively follow.
Sunnis reject the Quran. When God alone is mentioned, the hearts of those who do not believe in the Hereafter are filled with aversion, but when others are mentioned besides Him, they rejoice. 39:45
@@Sufia-k1p you clearly reject verses of the Quran to uphold you Hadith. This verse specifically talks about you guys. I know so many Muslims who call me kaffir when I say Allah, Allah, Allah, but the second I say Allah and his rasool their faces light up and say yes that is correct. You’re telling me the Quran says one who believes in Allah alone is a kaffir? There’s so many other verses you guys reject too. What about the verse that says “ these are Gods verses recited to you in truth, so in what other Hadith after Allah and his verses will they believe in”? Clearly you reject this as you uphold thousands of other Hadith and then you make Judgement using something that was not sent by God, and the Quran clearly states that anyone who judges using sources that have not sent down by God he is a kaffir. You want me to keep going?
Quran is the word of Allah and the way for humans to live by. Hadith and sunnah is the sayings and doings of the Prophet saw to know how to follow the Quran. But the Hadith and sunnah must coincide with Quran. Otherwise it is not authentic. Some hadith could just be metaphorical, not literal.
Can you provide the reference for the first Hadith you mentioned collected by At-Tabari? Also why did you quote al-kaafi? That’s not even a Sunni source, it’s a Rafidhi book… only 5 minutes in and deceit is creeping up from this himaar
@@GarethBryant15 Al-kafi isnt a person. its arabic for 'the sufficent'. It is the sahih bukhari of the rafidhi world and the compilier was a ithna ashari hadithen. Also, the quranic model of cosomolgy describes a firmament, undeniably.
@@GoPrayDontDelay For the Record: the Concept/Term "Sunni" is a Misnomer. "Sunni" is literally nothing more than a Religio-Political Euphemism describing Muslims whom're Non-Shi'is. garethbryant.wordpress.com/2024/04/16/sunnimonopoly/
@@GoPrayDontDelay As per what you mentioned about "Firmament": a. What's your Point?!!! b. How's that even relevant as per the Fallacy of al-Qur'aniyyah/Qur'anism?!!! #IllWait
Quran is the word of God . whoever tries to get information rather than Quran makes fool of himself.. Quran Surah Ali Imran _7 It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific.1 As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord.
Jews Got torah added talmud, muslism Got Quran added manmade hadith , Christians Got injel added athor books this tells you that all religions are manmade
God is real and his existence is a reality and islam is the truth. It is not humanly possible for the Quran to have been man made. Your accusation is based on ignorance.
Has anyone been to website of the Podcast? It has a part about how to pray, the positions of prayer? How did know how to pray? Someone tell me? I can't find it in the Quran.
All prophets from Moses Jesus Abraham etc .. prostrated and bowed down to Allah. We Muslims we are asked by Allah to bow down to him That's the most important gesture in all prayers all prophets did. Muslims are ordered to prostrate and bow done to Allah in the Quran.
Not sure if this is sarcasm, but it brings a good point that the hadiths are what tought Muslims how to pray, the quran is very general and not super specific on the prayer
I reject anything written by men that does not match the Quran. However the Quran does state very plainly that the earth is flat as like a carpet and that the sky is a fixed construction.....
@@justfootball7998 ahh. Well my friend I certainly don't have the Quranic verses memorized. the flat earth is a touchy subject with a lot of believers. However since I don't have proof one way or another I just go with God.....
but Quran doesnt say about flat earth...u need to understand arabic too with it like most people say Allah prays for Muhammad but in arabic it say sending blessings.....@@chrislyman6946
Allah never states that the Earth is "Flat". You've literally just proven how much of The Qur'ān you've 0-Knowledge of. garethbryant.wordpress.com/2022/11/10/muslimflatearther/
He is saying the glorious time happened because they put Koran first not hadith first as other times did. And that's why they were successful. They were using the Koran which encourages thinking and analysis and study and obseration - all which develop creativity, experimentation, experience and discovery - unlike the Hadith which encourage the opposite - stagnation and regression.
There's few from Allah teaching for human in Qur'an. It support art, human wear jewellery, fighting against corruption stealer of wealth, oppressors of the weak, freedom of religion, questioning others religions, questions the authority, questions religious conveyor, can eat everything except pork etc, This alone will transform Muslim society and Muslim never do this today. Are you against Allah guidance for humankind?
"so accept whatever the Messenger gives you, and abstain from whatever he forbids you. Be mindful of God" surat Al hashr 7. The above is the command from Allah to Muslims. Question : how do you know what the Prophet (PBUH) forbade and what he commanded since you were not there to hear from him during his 23 years of prophethood? Answer: follow the sunna... As simple as that Mr deception.
The verse from Surah Al-Hashr (59:7) is often cited out of context to justify following the Sunna in a general sense. However, reading the surrounding verses reveals that it specifically addresses the distribution of war booty among different groups, particularly highlighting the rich who contest this distribution. For instance, Surah Al-Hashr, Verse 6 states, "Whatever Allah has bestowed on His Messenger from the people of the towns belongs to Allah, to the Messenger, and to the relatives, orphans, the poor, and [stranded] travelers-so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you. Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it, and whatever he forbids you, abstain from it. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty." This context shows that the verse emphasizes accepting the Prophet's decisions on material wealth distribution to prevent wealth concentration among the rich and ensure fair distribution to those in need. The rich were contesting the distribution of the booty made by the Prophet, who had favored the most disadvantaged. The verse clearly addresses them: they must accept the share given to them and not seek to obtain more through illegitimate means, such as exerting pressure. This is confirmed by the continuation of the verse: "so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you." It is, therefore, about the distribution of material wealth delivered to the Prophet. Additionally, Surah Al-Hashr, Verse 8 further clarifies, "It is for the poor emigrants who were expelled from their homes and their properties, seeking bounty from Allah and [His] approval and supporting Allah and His Messenger. Those are the truthful." This underscores the focus on supporting the needy and marginalized. Misinterpreting this verse to justify following the Sunna generally overlooks its actual context. Similar instructions on wealth distribution are found in Surah Al-Baqara, Verse 215: "They ask you, [O Muhammad], what they should spend. Say, 'Whatever you spend of good is [to be] for parents and relatives and orphans and the needy and the traveler. And whatever you do of good-indeed, Allah is Knowing of it.'" And in Surah Al-Isra, Verse 26: "And give the relative his right, and [also] the poor and the traveler, and do not spend wastefully." It is essential to read the preceding and following verses to understand the exact meaning. In this case, it clearly deals with wealth distribution, not the general concept of the Sunna. Talking about Sunna here is completely out of context and shows a manipulation of the Quran's meaning to give it an erroneous interpretation. And Allah knows best.
@@eliaslebrun4181 The prophethood of Muhammad (PBUH) is not just limited to transmitting Allah (swt) revelation as you are labouriously trying to prove. Far from that, he allowed him to legistale and to translate the Quran's commands into practice which the Sunna captured. Question for you who is posing as Muslim (an Egyptian coptic probably belonging to the tanwir group posing as a Muslim ): Salat (prayer) is prescribed upon Muslims in the Quran, how do you perform the prayer? The Quran did not give the details but Muhammad (PBUH) did. Zakat is prescribed upon Muslims in the Quran, how do you perform that obligation knowing that all kinds of wealth (which are numerous) fall into that obligation? The Quran does not give the details but Muhammad (PBUH) did. Hajj is an obligation in the Quran (for those who can afford it). How do you perform hajj and what are the rituals? The Quran did not give the details but Muhammad (PBUH) did. All in all, Allah (swt) allows his messenger not to be just a transmitter of the revelation but also made him a role model for all Muslims to follow and without Sunna that model dissappears which you guys are working hardly to achieve.... to no avail.
@@eliaslebrun4181 I don't know why my answer to your comment disappeared! Probably those in charge don't want other people to see it. In a nutshell, those who attacks on the hadiths and the sunna know very well that Muhammad (PBUH) has been given to the Muslims as a role model to follow, something which kept Islam strong, they want to take Muhammad (PBUH) out of the picture and hence weaken Islam. I am quit sure the same people elsewhere also attack the Quran (which they say is true here) . These tricks do not work. For those who want Allah (swt) and the last day : " The Messenger of God is an excellent model for those of you who put your hope in God and the Last Day and remember Him often" 33:21. Muhammad (PBUH) is a model for all Muslims in all their affairs through his sunna, period.
@@josephalison12is incest child marriage slavery bedroom slavery lying lying on Gods name stealing breaking oaths ending innocent lives conquer innocent n whatever u steal 1/5 for prophet
@@Gs9sk Apparently people like you does not understand historical context and now blasphemy against the Prophet, and you consider yourself as a Muslim yeah?
Muhammad is not identified in the Koran , Muhammad means praiseworthy. Yet in the hadiths supposed to identify his character. Strangly jesus is mentioned and praised more than the unknown personage of Muhammad.
lol. this is ridiculous. the quran asks us to follow hadeeth! it would seem that a lot of this is not being able to submit to the prophet's example and wanting your own actions to be permissible.
@@AsgarAli-w1j lol when the quran wasn't even written yet there was already the quran! its th same memorisation n recitation process for both th Quran n hadeeth. both are, in their true forms, recited n memorised . not written hadeeth rejectors seem to be blind go to this
@@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman Allah never said follow the prophet. Allah said follow the messenger You follow the messenger by following the message that he brings i.e. the Qur'an. Qur'an Al Nur verse 54:"Say, “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger. But if you turn away, then he is only responsible for his duty and you are responsible for yours. And if you obey him, you will be ˹rightly˺ guided. The Messenger’s duty is only to deliver ˹the message˺ clearly.” ( PLEASE READ THE LAST LINE OF THE ABOVE VERSE)
No its not. Allah promised to preserve the Holy Quran. The rest is man made. If it was such a vast science how come you have weak and or sort of hadiths? Its history with wisedom but not a rule book like Quran @@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman
@@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman If it is the same memorisation process then why were some hadith found to be inauthentic and rejected but not surah's from the Koran?
A lot of ancient texts and Native Tribes speak of this Matrix as illusionary a copy of the real world so to say many religious books points to this too! In many Native American tribes the world was carried on the back of an ancient 🐢! Fascinating subjects which I love to talk about. Also in Native American belief life is a dream and when we die we truly awaken..sooo very interesting! I appreciate this video very much Thank You🪶🐳🦚🦠🔎
The Native American tribal belief as just described IS Quran wherein God describes this world as the nether world or nether life; and that the props that made us feel secure will all wash away on the day of Judgement when eyes will see clearly and all will be exposed as the skies and the earth will disintegrate as a stage that is dis-assembled after the play wherein the test period of it's protagonists has been completed. God says in the Quran that no community or city will be deprived of His message. (for He is all- just all-reaching). All praise be to the the Holy One.
Native Americans are also a people of wisdom and also have a oral tradition i find them very interesting, do you have any YT channels you can recommend ?
Any of you geniuses know the verse that shows how many rakah there is in fajr prayer? Dhuhr? The verse for the Hajj rituals? The sequence and manner of wudu’u, ablution? There’s always a joke that’s not funny that keeps going round and coming back. Obey Allah and His Messenger for YOUR benefit. If you don’t it is YOUR loss.
This are man made creations, Salat is a spiritual connection to Allah and the Quran mentions about how to do it and also mentions how the prophets over the ages have done it. And you are not following the messenger by following the hadith, you are following Bukhari.
Who wrote the hadiths? The people who wrote the Qur'an, i.e. the people who narrated the Qur'an, also narrated the Ahadith.According to you, if the hadiths are made by people, then the Qur'an is also made by people, because this Qur'an was also written during the time of Hazrat Uthman, who has seen the Qur'anAccording to you, if the hadiths are made by people, then the Qur'an is also made by people, because this Qur'an was also written during the time of Hazrat Uthman, who has seen the Qur'an before that? The point is that you people run away from hadiths so that you can make people interpret the Holy Qur'an according to your wishes, and distort the meaning of the Qur'an whenever you want. Indeed, you people are a great and most dangerous temptation, you people are not people of the Qur'an, but wishful thinking
Yet Koran is the divine of God and most hadith are outright against Koran. It's better to focus on Qur'an and take hadith as historical source not as guidances.
@@NikMirza take also quran as a historical assest, who narrated quran narrated hadees, you don't understanding this basic if only quran is important so why Allah send prophet ? Wallahi it's great fitnah, interpretating quran own wishes not what prophet interpretate quran.
You are missing the forest for the trees. Uthman was a second cousin, son in law and companion of Mohamed and died in 656 in the same century as Mohamed revealed his message, and died only two decades after him. Hadith on the other hand were written and gathered into large collections during the 8th and 9th centuries. That's at least two centuries apart from Mohamed and Uthman's times. Furthermore, Mohamed commanded the companions memorise word for word the revelations. No such mention was made for the Hadiths which were only orally remembered and passed on for generations for at least two to three centuries before they were recorded and had travelled over 1, 000 km from where Mohamed lived which is where they were collected from. That's a lot of interaction between time and space full of various people, culture and religion that influnced the Hadiths before they were recorded. Given especially that the Hadith were not under any specific obligation to be memorised word for word like the Koran, they were open to all sorts of influence.
you are making this too much about sunni. as if the good guys were shia and the bad guys were sunni . fact is they were all sunni. you are also licking and smacking in the micro which is annoying
We call out Sunnis because Sunnis are the majority who enforce the ideology of the "sunnah" and dictate Islam to the rest of the world. If the Shia had all the power like Sunnis do we would address them.
I’m Sunni but I don’t think even Shia call their Hadith 100% authentic when I spoke to Shia rather use it as alternative source to understand Islam, but Sunnis use sword to call people kaffir for not believing the Hadith as absolute truth, that’s dangerous because most of problems like what Taliban force people to follow a certain brand of Islam is from Hadith, that only leads to apostasy as they will see violent and controlling for of Islam, yes punishment should for serious crimes but not controlling every aspect of people’s lives, forcing women to cover their face and hair takes away their free will, this is not healthy and will make them deslike Islam
Prophet Salah's detailed information is only found in the hadith. I look through all the hadiths, but I cannot find any that mention the world resting on a whale. Why did this man demean the Prophet's companions? all Sahabah رضي الله عنهم.
Quran explain in detail on how to salat...Connect/comunicate with Allah through quran seeking guidance, humbly rukuk (accepting), humbly sajda(submit). When u have understood connect/communicate to others...may Allah guide us...
The semen does determine the sex of the offspring, the woman can only contribute an "X;' chromosome, the sperm can contribute either an "X" chromosome, or a "Y" chromosome.
...the way i heard it explained is that if the father ejaculates first the child whether male or female will Look more like the father & not that if the father ejaculates 1st the child will be Born as a male .
Assalamu alyaikum. Please do not answer me here because I won't reply, don't to want to fall into dispute that has no sence since everyone will stick to his path anyway. AlhamduliLlyah I'm a believer and muslim. I read the Quran everyday, I pray like Muhammad did (s.a.s) but some words I see here in comments surprising me. I just want you to read ayas from 67 to 71 of sura' Baqara'(2). Just read them and think doesn't that seem like an argument about words 'Quran is not enough '?)) Allah just ordered people to slaughter a cow, but they started to ask a details and were close to not to execute the order of God. )) SubhanaLlah. AstaghfiruLlah. And this is only one point from the Quran. There is sura' about Ant)) You just think about that. Ant is in the Quran, and you say that it is not detailed and need something more... AstaghfiruLlah. May Allah guide all of us to the right path. Amin.
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often. Yes you are right Quran tells you everything, it tells you whose patterns you need to follow if you fear the day of Judgement
@mazm4860 Then you don't need The Quran at all. Read those 'patterns' every day and live your life. Follow those patterns, not Quran. Leave The Quran behind your back. There is no sense in reading and following The Quran once you got those 'patterns'.
@@AuthorReviews No Bro Quran says Follow Allah and his messenger So first Quran then Muhammad My dear it's the direct order of Allah to follow Muhammad along with the Quran, you can't ignore this fact or else you be lying to yourself
It's interesting tho, because i remember a hadith people linked with the Mongols and how it was accurate. Allahu 3alam, what i'm quite sure is that hadiths are in no way able to abrogate the Quran or be a firm ruling source. May Allah guide us all...
Hadith and reliance on the Sunna have a tradition in every school of Islamic thought predating any of the information you include. You are speaking on what is called "the closing of the doors of Textual Interpretation". As a follower of fiqh that predates the Sunni/Shia schism I can personally attest to this fact. This fossilization of interpretation on unsettled matters (scholarly consensus that is rare, not by abundant gov, sect or school decree). While the doors were never closed according to the talking points of the Shia in response to the Sunni, they can only do this in jest, as their "doors" are only open in batches of years an Imam ruled (or today in Iran depending on the judges who board the country by the approval of the Ayatollah) and not according to fiqh'u'sunnah but according to the innate knowledge of the hereditary leader. The corollary in Christianity many may be familiar with is the canonization of certain book (into THE book) and making others apocryphal, as all writings considered for the bible were post-prophetic narrations of an Abrahamic prophet's teachings and sayings. Historically this can not be the Injil, but a derivative. This must be understood about Hadith and thus Quranic Authority is always above it in veracity of accuracy... Some scholars, especially further towards modernity (as the Hanbali and Shafi instances you mention) have almost reversed this verification flow... opposing their own dogmatic "freezing" of previous rulings as forever authoritative... showing this 'hukm's" flaw. Shafi's insistence (and late Hanbal's one upping) on textual literalness, even in metaphorical matters led to an accusation of anthropomorphism by Hanbal... Thank Allah my school never went through this as it was already rationally decided and textually confirmed in 1st CH with clear distinction between metaphor and objective and rules about crosswalking them. Al Hukm' Allah. The Quran is created. Leaders are not Hereditary, neither by tribe nor lineage, but by faith and performance. Abraham was neither Jew or Christian but was Muslim... Mohammad was neither Sunni nor Shia but was Muslim. That does not mean your only choice is to throw out the baby with the bathwater and reject all written tradition that can elucidate Tafsir and Sirat. Leaving the doors open, there are things like isnad cum matn that you ignore by reducing all hadith scholarship to one sect, select schools and conflating Abbasid empire success with hadith interpretations... there are a myriad of reasons for this. The early Shia of Iran also made the Sunni's follow Shiism or suffer. This was especially hard in the face of forcing people "to curse the caliphs" in religious service as required liturgy... not everything came down to honest theological differences. The "claim of pre-validated power" in those that ruled or wished to, as in all growing societies IMHO had a much more corroding effect on Muslim culture and practice than the intellectual figh formations. Galileo had a hard time of it for the same reasons... more church vs state than religious co-option of either... power plays. Greek and Arab! writing on the round Earth were prevalent at the time. His persecution was political.
It's interesting how the evolution of Islamic jurisprudence reflects broader human tendencies toward institutionalization and control, where power dynamics often shape theological stances more than the foundational texts themselves. In this context, the tension between preserving the purity of early teachings and adapting to new realities becomes a crucial balancing act, especially when authority is both decentralized and contested across different interpretations.
@@crazy_afghan It is also often overlooked, especially in the West, that for almost 1000 years, Islamic jurisprudence on the applied level had codified inference sources, but the rulings themselves were local to the event. The idea that each and every legal decision must be put into a precedential framework that binds the next ruling was absolutely unheard of before well after most of the major historical scholarly figures had any say in a case more than approving a government marriage license.
Hadiths are source of knowledge you can take those who make sense and used it as a literature this is how classical Muslims used they didn’t accept them as true
2:12 I mean to be fair, in Baghdad they had contact with Indian scientists and whatnot, and they have in their books the Elephants and Earthqackes idea... so that might have also been due to cultural exchange...
A lot of cultural exchange could have happened over the time between Mohamed's death and when Hadiths were recorded. The Muslims expanded from where Mohamed lived and died in the 7thC to places of rich various religious traditions and cultures. Almost three centuries of time and religious and cultural interaction took place by the point Hadiths were gathered.
Still you need to find and look for How Muhammad lived his life and practiced the Quran. Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
@@mazm4860 And we have his example in the Qur'an, alongside the other prophets like Abraham, who is told to be an "excellent pattern" for us twice as much (two more verses use this expression and it's about Abraham) If a Christian/Jew now called us Bible rejectors and used these verses to justify them following the "sunnat of Abraham" since it has more "details" than the Qur'an... what would you answer them? The same answer you would give them, then that's my answer. Personally, it's not that i don't like what those sources say, i just see too much contradiction therein and therefore it can't be from God. It's logic. Also they are hearsay, rumors, and often slanders and some are written to make us doubt our faith and to doubt the Qur'an, i have 0 doubt much of that is written by enemies of Islam to make people apostate or to make them become hypocrites also... And i'm not buying that.
@@servantofGodGabriel Allah has designed the system in a way that logic alone can never get you to Allah, put your faith in Allah as we are here to test our faith. Secondly Yes All the Prophets have an excellent pattern no doubt, but you must follow what Allah has appointed for you.
@@mazm4860 I agree, that's why i follow the Qur'an that the messenger of God gave us. The issue with the sects is i believe mainly when they promote shirk like the kissing of the black stone and other idolatrous acts, and the fact that no scholar seems to care to denounce it it a big red flag to me. I wish it was not the case, it would be super easy to just follow the majority. But if this life was about it being easy, then God would have made us a single community, but for the sake of the test he decreed otherwise, and there is wisdom in that, even if we don't see it now. Peace and may God guide us all to his straight path he mentions on the Qur'an by the mouth of Prophet Muhammad alaihi salam.
And then your mom had you, “They seek to deceive Allah and the believers, yet they only deceive themselves, but they fail to perceive it.” Al-Baqarah, Ayah 9
@@MariamKhan-oj6zb one can't follow the sunnah of Allah, he is the creator. I am not. I can follow only his instructions. Not his way of life. What does Sunnah mean to you? لقد کان لکم فی رسول اللہ اسوۃ حسنہ ۔ Please provide the source of اسوۃ حسنہ. If you can't, then again Allah the Almighty is asking to follow something that doesn't exist. I used to be one lone you, but then when i read Quran i came to know that Quran itself is referring me to follow sunnah, that is Sahi hadith. I can give you other verses that instructs to follow sunnah.
وَ اَنْزَلْنَاۤ اِلَیْكَ الذِّكْرَ لِتُبَیِّنَ لِلنَّاسِ مَا نُزِّلَ اِلَیْهِمْ وَ لَعَلَّهُمْ یَتَفَكَّرُوْنَ(44) سورۃ النحل لتبین کا معنی ہے elaborate or explain. Where can i get the explanation made by our beloved prophet SAW? بہن! آخری گزارش آپ سے یہ ہے کہ حدیث کوئی شے ہی نہیں تھی تو لوگوں نے گڑھی ہی کیوں؟ من گھڑت حدیث کی ضرورت لوگوں کو کیوں پیش آئی؟ یہ خود اتنی بڑی دلیل ہے کہ لوگ شروع سے ہی اس کو حجت مانتے تھے اسی لئے انھوں نے وضع کی۔ ورنہ موضوع حدیث کا وجود ہی نہ ہوتا۔ اللہ ہم سب کو فھم دے۔
If The Hadith Is Gone Then Islam Isn't In Its Original Form, Qala Allah Subhana Wattaghallah: AtighuAllaha Wa Attigharrasul. So There Is Now Nothing To Say And If You Are Mulhid Then It's Your Choice
Follow the Hadiths that tell you about the direct orders of the Quran only. 99% of Hadith are marked as weak by Hadith collectors themselves. The remaining ones are Just tribal stories not the Deen of Allah. Just prepare yourself of What Allah will Ask you.
Your religion is the most important thing in your life. You should not learn it from TH-cam , did you see a doctor who graduated from the Internet. Many comments, without any insult, reveal how much they are ignorant about thier religion.
There are no hadiths that contradict the Quran. Hadith narrations were also a factor of Sunni and Shii schism, Shia Muslims collect and adhere to hadith narrations from the Ahlul Bayt (PBUT) in addition to hadith narrations from the Prophet (PBUH), whereas Sunni Muslims only rely on hadith narrations from the Prophet (PBUH). The Prophet (PBUH) told his companions not to document/write anything about him that is not the Quran, in other words, no hadith narrations were to be written down. However, Allah says in the Quran that “He [the Prophet] does not speak out of his own desire, everything that he says is a revelation revealed to him by Allah” (Surat An Najm:3). Therefore, it would be very understandable that his companions would consider the Prophet’s speech and habits to also be “revelation” that has to be written down and transmitted. The Prophet (PBUH) also said: “inform people about me, even if it is done through a single verse of the Quran.”, telling people about Islam is done through the narration of Quran as well as hadith.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah Yes, sir. That's true, that's what I believe. Quran is the Word of God and it is applicable everywhere and at everytime. You can't disprove this fact. Humanity is created based on the Quran. It even explains the first sin of Adam, what are you talking about? Of course everything is based on the Quran, it is the Words of Him Who had created the world as you know it. There is no narration against the Quran.
"Whatever he says" in this Allah is talking to Kuffar specifically about Quranic verses only cause they were critiquing that Quran is the word of Muhammad. "Warn them about me" Yes tell them about the messenger of Allah. As is written in the Quran that's it. The only verse that clearly says to follow Muhammad and the one that can't be challenged is this one Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
@@TheLasthourAAMohammed hijab has a video on TH-cam where he says People who follow Quran alone is a pedophile because Quran doesn't explain when is the right time to marry a girl without the hadith. Pissed me off because I know it's outright lie.
@@TheLasthourAAI don’t think not all should be rejected, that’s vast amount of info that matches with Quran being chucked away rather the term sahi should be removed, questionable sayings should not be followed, like stoning not from Quran should be not followed.
People always go the wrong way how do you pray without hadith, many things you cant know without hadit People just dont like the rules and say oh i onley koran fear allah stop playing
Quran only islam. Where is eating human meat haram in islam? No limitation of how many men a woman can marry. Quran allows you to have sex with wife and what your right hand posses. Ignoring the sunnah, if you posses animals is sex with them halal on quran only? When does you wuzu break? How do you pray? Can you refute the objections of answering islam based on Quran alone? including the inheritance example?
Allah Almighty says in the Glorious Quran Surah Ale Imran chapter 3 verse 31: 1- "Say: "If ye do love Allah follow me(Muhammad(Pbuh): Allah will love you and forgive you your sins for Allah is Oft-Forgiving Most Merciful."(3:31) Explanation: So the question is that how to attain Allah's love? The answer is given by Allah Almighty Himself. His love is attained by following His messenger. So this shows the importance of following the Holy Prophet(pbuh) in all eras and ages and obeying him. 2- "But no, by your Lord, they can have no Faith, until they make you (O Muhammad SAW) judge in all disputes between them, and find in themselves no resistance against your decisions, and accept (them) with full submission."(Surah Nisa chapter 4 verse 65) Explanation: This is the importance of following the beloved Prophet Muhammad(pbuh). Allah Almighty says that no one can be a Momin until they make Muhammad(pbuh) their judge in all disputes. So the question is how to make him the judge in our disputes? How will we know about Muhammad(pbuh) until we dont know what he says? And what are his sayings? The Hadith of course! 3- "He who obeys the Messenger (Muhammad SAW), has indeed obeyed Allâh, but he who turns away, then we have not sent you (O Muhammad SAW) as a watcher over them."(Surah Nisa chapter 4 verse 80) Explanation: Allah Almighty guarantees that one who follows His Prophet(pbuh) has obeyed Allah. And He also warns that who so ever turns away will be punished. 4- "The answer of the Believers when summoned to Allah and His Apostle in order that He may judge between them is no other than this: they say "We hear and we obey": it is such as these that will attain felicity.It is such as obey Allah and His Apostle and fear Allah and do right that will win (in the end)."(Surah Noor chapter 24 verse 51-52) Explanation: Allah Almighty tells the signs of the Momin believers that what the Prophet(pbuh) tells them they just obey without doubting. 5- "Do not make [your] calling of the Messenger among yourselves as the call of one of you to another. Already Allah knows those of you who slip away, concealed by others. So let those beware who dissent from the Prophet's order, lest fitnah strike them or a painful punishment."(Surah Noor chapter 24 verse 63) 6- "Indeed in the Messenger of Allâh (Muhammad SAW) you have a excellent example to follow for him who hopes in (the Meeting with) Allâh and the Last Day and remembers Allah much."(Surah Ahzab chapter 33 verse 21) Explanation: Again Allah Almighty guarantees that in the Messenger of Allah we have an excellent example to follow. So the question is how will we follow him unless we don’t know about his sayings and his orders and his Sunnah? If we reject all the ahadith and say that they were written 200 years after the Quran then we will be neglecting this verse of the Holy Quran. 7- "It is not for a believer, man or woman, when Allah and His Messenger have decreed a matter that they should have any option in their decision. And whoever disobeys Allah and His Messenger, he has indeed strayed in a plain error."(Surah Ahzaab chapter 33 verse 36) 8- "..And they say, "We hear, and we obey."(Surah Baqarah chapter 2 verse 285) Explanation: True Muslims are those that when they are told something from Holy Prophet(pbuh) they just hear and obey. They dont question that. What Holy Prophet(pbuh) ordered they just follow it and don’t give their own opinions. 9- "O ye who believe! put not yourselves forward before Allah and His Apostle: But fear Allah: for Allah is He who hears and knows all things. O ye who believe! raise not your voices above the voice of the Prophet nor speak aloud to him in talk as ye may speak aloud to one another lest your deeds become vain and ye perceive not. Those that lower their voice in the presence of Allah's Apostle their hearts has Allah tested for piety: for them is Forgiveness and a great Reward."(Surah Al-Hujraat chapter 49 verse 1- 3)Explanation: Allah Almighty says that Muslims shouldnt step forward from the Holy Prophet(pbuh).For example whatever Holy Prophet(pbuh) has taught Muslims,they should consider it enough and the best. As the Holy Prophet(pbuh) himself said that he has taught us muslims all the things which will bring them closer to Allah. So anyone who thinks that by doing new things in religion for the sake of reward will yield nothing if not proven from the Sunnah of Holy Prophet(pbuh). Secondly there is another lesson in this verse. Those who say that we will understand Quran from our own thinking. So if everyone starts understanding Quran from his own thinking then there will be a fight. Some will derive something,others will derive something else. So the best way is to see the tafseer of the Holy Quran. And the tafseer of the Holy Quran is they sayings of our Beloved Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) and his life. So those who dont accept the ahadith. How will they come to understand the Quran's best meaning? And Also Allah Almighty says that don’t put yourselves forward before Allah's Messenger and do not raise voice above the voice of Holy Prophet(pbuh). How does this verse applies today as Holy Prophet(pbuh) is not amongst us? Don’t raise your voices above the voice of Holy Prophet(pbuh) means that when we hear some hadith then we should keep quite in respect and not speak that i dont accept this hadith and i don’t believe in it. This is raising our voices above the voice of Holy Prophet(pbuh). What if that hadith is authentic and that really is the saying of our beloved Prophet Muhammad(pbuh)? Will Allah Almighty leave us on the Day of Judgment if we reject His messenger's sayings? 10- "And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad SAW) gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain (from it), and fear Allâh. Verily, Allâh is Severe in punishment."(Surah Hashr chapter 59 verse 7) Explanation: This verse is self explanatory.Allah Almighty orders us to take whatever Holy Prophet(pbuh) gives us and abstain from whatever he orders us to abstain from. This is the way to success. All others who think that they can follow Islam without Holy Prophet's(pbuh) sayings are living in fools paradise. 11- "Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only an Inspiration that is inspired. "(Surah Najm chapter 53 verse 3-4) Explanation: Allah Almighty says that whatever the Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) tells the Muslims is not from his own desire but it is an inspiration that is inspired. So those who say that only following the Quran is Islam,they are wrong. Without following the Prophet's(pbuh) sunnah one cannot follow Islam because Prophet(pbuh) also told the Muslims what Allah wanted him to tell. He never said anything from himself regarding Islam.
Brother/ sister in Islam, I see you’re upon correctness, please don’t come to TH-cam and expose yourself to doubts by watching stuff like this, your religion and the guidance Allāh has given you is much more precious okay? بارك الله فيكم May Allāh protect us. Rasūlullāh ﷺ used to ask the turner of hearts (Allāh) to keep his heart firm. Allāhumma ya muqallibal quloob thabbit qalbi ala deenik
Assalamu alyaikum. Brother, why are you providing only one or two sentences from the Quran and interpret it as you or scholar wants/thinks correct?)) I think you know that Allah says in the Quran that it interpret itself.(Sorry for my English if it's hard to understand). Please don't lose the context of the ayas and it's real sence. I'm not the so called "Quranist" or blind sunni/Shia or any other. I'm a believer and Muslim AlhamduliLlyah. I just want you or any other stop trying to take several words from th Quran and say that "this means exactly this or that" in attempting to prove your own belief. The Quran is full of wisdom and hukm, and Allah says us '... use your mind'. And Allah says many times to the prophet '...remind by the Quran'.
Stone running away after Moses put his clothes on it 😂 making grown men drink breastmilk to make them mahram 😂 checking if lizards are jews camouflaged 🤣🤣
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 the word of Allah ﷻ is greater than our intelect. We can only perceive things through our limited senses what is thag compared to Allah ﷻ’s power
@@goshbaby8531 Good job einstein, but the things that we can perceive God made it clear for us otherwise why on earth would He reveal it to people. Take care dude Peace
سلام عليكم For anyone, it is a must to learn the Quran and the Sunnah (Sahih Bukhari, Muslim...). Unfortunately, most prefer to follow an understanding based on whims and desires. There is an explanation for everything in Islam, but you can't just listen to some people with distorted hearts or who may have misconceptions and then claim that an era of failure for the muslims approached with the uprising of this and that. This is a great propaganda and evil. May Allah the Almighty guide you.
But if it were rlly a MUST then the prophet muhammad pbuh with have definitely compiled it while he was still alive. While I do believe hadiths are helpful as a tool in understanding the quran and adding historical context it makes absolutely no sense to say that it is a requirement. Hadiths are essentially all hearsay since the the prophet nor any of his companions were alive to verify it. They could have easily been tampered with and as yk there are a lot of contradicting hadiths out there. There's nothing more evil than mankind so I wouldn't be too quick to trust it
Only the hadith mentions the black stone. The Torah says sacred stones NOT just idols are forbidden. "Do not make idols or set up an image or a sacred stone for yourselves, and do not place a carved stone in your land to bow down before it. I am the LORD your God" - Lev. 26:1 I would recommend facing the old temple in Jerusalem rather than the ka'aba to do your salah.
Read quran 4.59. Didn't Allah order us to obey Allah and obey the messenger .We cannot reject the maqbool (accepted) hadiths i.e hadiths which are classified as hasan or sahih.
There is a popular theory now that the early part of the Koran originates from a Syriac Aramaic speaking group of Christians who resemble Ebionites, but also have a lot of Gnostic connections, the early passages might have originated in Merv ,.. if coins and other religious influences are anything to go by. Muhammad is the title they used for Christ, and the text makes more sense in some passages if read in Syriac Aramaic...but it seems the later guy also called Muhammed has got confused with him? So some of the more peculiar Hadith might be from weird Gnostic texts about other versions of Jesus. ..and some of the cosmology and scientific speculations might also originate from Gnostic sources? Is this also a view taken by Islamic groups , or just the opinion of Europeans studying the subject?
Are you referring to Christof Luxenberg's work? I don't know about that idea but I have heard of the idea that the Arabic used at the time of the Koran was a different kind of Arabic with more Syro - Aramaic influences in its language which has influenced misunderstandings of Koranic verses through misinterpretation of its language. Semitic languages relate to each other but still hold important differences. A good example of this is the work of Luxenberg who gave a different interpretation through this Syro-Aramaic Arabic language paradigm of a controversial verse in the Koran which desrcibes paradise and refers to it being a place of wine drinking and buxom beauties. Luxemberg translated this instead as 'raisins' rather than buxom beauties which actually makes more sense since the sentences around this talk specifically about grapes and wine. On the other hand, a video on TH-cam by Quran Centric called "Protrusions of Grapes or Breasts? (Sura 78:33)" is an excellent commentary and analysis of this topic and though he does not describe raisins, he does continue the theme of them being grapes rather than 'breasts' and he shows this by actually breaking down Arabic language. It makes much more sense that the Koran is talking about ripe round grapes rather than breasts because the surrounding sentences are about this theme. His explanation makes perfect linguistic and thematic sense leaving no doubt that particular basal mindsets asserted onto this verse their own personal desires or imaginations of what paradise would be. Most likely the same people behind the 72 virgins awaiting martyrs. As for 'some of the more peculiar Hadith being from weird Gnostic texts about other versions of Jesus. ..and some of the cosmology and scientific speculations might also originate from Gnostic sources', some Hadith do seem to touch upon ideas that are echoes of Jewish and Christian texts, and perhaps also from other sources, however none of these are mentioned in the Koran which supports the idea of Hadith as fabrications.
@@TheExplorer-e1j Some of the numbers are also interesting, in the Ugarit texts they seem to have 72 important Gods, and in the last supper Jesus saying 'this is my blood' referring to the wine sounds more appropriate to Dionysus, so perhaps various Christian groups are adopting some pagan ceremonies. Dionysus is also occasionally represented on a cross as this relates to one of the myths about Him...And in a Canaanite myth Baal dies and is reborn on the 3rd day. Perhaps in participating in this sacrament the spirit of the person merges with the Gods or something similar? There is a fresco somewhere of spirits being handed large white grapes... and they do come in different shapes, sizes and colours. I'd like to think that is what those rounded shapes on the statue of Diana of the Ephesians represent ( rather than bulls testicles or whatever).
@@traceyolsen308 I am at the moment researching Chritianity and Islam. Many old non Abrahamic religions tended to have a 'three in one' God figure where they were usually related but separate beings. Look up Triad (Religion) in Wikipedia for an outline. Plus, according to my understanding everything about the Trinity concept came from not Jesus directly but from Paul, and The Nicene Creed. In other words, the latter was men discussing their theories about what and who God is and coming to their own conclusions which have more parallels to pre-existing religions of Greece and Rome than the Old Testament. Many of the areas that had pre-existing religions that involed a triad of some sort were part of the Council of Nicaea - Roman, Greek, Persian etc. According to Persian Zoroastrianism, there was Ahura Mazdā, the supreme deity as well as Spenta Mainyu who was believed to be a holy spirit aspect of Ahura Mazdā. Through the holy spirit, Ahura Mazdā creates life and maintains and protects it. Interestingly, many of these pre-existing faiths had elements of characters of sun gods and early paintings of Jesus as a trinity feature some sun like feature behind him. Wine is a feature of pre-existing non Abrahamic faiths and is presented positiely in the Old Testament, symbolising joy, blessings, life but the Koran takes issue with its potential for harm in excess due to immoral and antisocial ramifications of drunkeness and the barrier its intoxication creates to conscious connection to God through prayer. However there is an implication that the wine of paradise does not have this intoxication effect. Since Islam focuses on aspects of self discipline, perhaps wine is something that is given as a test on earth but is given in paradise as a reward. Some have stated that the deity Mohamed refers to is the pagan moon god of the pre-Islmic Arabs, especially because of the close association of the names, however it is possible that Mohamed attempted to restrict the belief of deity down to one supreme deity since pagan Arabs had hundreds of additional tribal deities, and reform the definition and perspective of that deity as Islamcally correct. The word Allah is the generic term for God and is used by Christian Arabs too to refer to the Father. The Arabic 'Allahu' or 'Ilahi' sound not that far off from the Hewbrew 'Yahuwa' or 'Elohi'. In the Koran the Arabic 'Huwa' also refers to Him or His when it says 'He is (Huwa) The Merciful,' for example.
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
Good work brother and team, but some hadith are authentic. Nabi s.a said i am leaving behind two things one quran and another Aal e Mohammad my family if you follow them both you will not go astray. All authentic hadith are available from Imam Jaffar al sadiq in fiqe jaffaria. It has not seen the light of day in sunni islam. And also the book Nahjul balaga by Imam Ali a.s. don't get biased because it the shia books moulvi don't want you to read it they are hidden from us.
That could be true amd i believe that is due to the mixed nature of islamic societies. Such mixed communities will always become source of problems if they decide to tread the myopic path. Case in point, hinduism, it is most fruitful as a multicultural global idea and becomes self deafeating once it starts identifying with something or someone tangible.
It is truly astonishing how little honest research and analysis of primary sources is present in this video.
First and foremost, Imam Ibn Kathir, in his Tafsir, did not explain the verse the way you claimed he did. He merely mentioned that others have explained the ayah in such a way while simultaneously casting doubt on these interpretations.
You may ask why the Imam included that explanation while disagreeing with it. The simple answer is that the purpose of his work is to gather all the various interpretations of the Quranic verses by different people-scholars and otherwise-while providing the source of each interpretation.
Some of the explanations of the verses referenced in his Tafsir were attributed to the Messenger of God himself-peace be upon him-others to his companions, those after them, and even the Jewish and Christian communities. His referencing of these explanations does not imply his agreement, nor does it mean they represent mainstream Islamic beliefs or acceptable interpretations of the verses. His work is simply an archive of reports.
The story about the whale, as noted by scholars of Quranic Exegesis, originates from the Jewish and Christian traditions. Notice that Ibn Abbas-may Allah be pleased with him-did not say that this story was from the Messenger of God himself-peace be upon him-he simply mentioned it. Among scholars of Quranic Exegesis and Hadith, it is well known that some Companions would share stories they heard from Jewish and Christian scholars.
The fact that the story of the whale comes from Jewish and Christian traditions is mentioned by countless scholars. For example, Shaykh Muhammad Abu Shahba in his book 'Isra'iliyyat and Fabrications in the Books of Tafsir' and Ibn al-Qayyim in his work 'al-Manar' (pg 252) reference this story as an example of fabricated reports.
Secondly, you seem to have overlooked the science of textual criticism in the context of Hadith. No narrator, not even the Companions, is above textual criticism. There are numerous instances where Companions disagreed with the reports of other Companions, and there are even examples of the students of the Companions critically examining the accuracy of the Companions’ reports. No one accepted the words of the Companions at face value without first assessing the authenticity of their reports.
Once a report was deemed accurate, scholars would then discuss how the report should be understood. Should it be interpreted literally or metaphorically? Should it be applied universally without exceptions, or are there exceptions? Was the report abrogated, or does it remain applicable? These are just some of the questions that scholars address when dealing with any text.
Thirdly , even if, for the sake of argument, this was a mainstream belief among Muslims and the Muslim scholarly class (which it wasn't), what is the connection between that belief and scientific progress? Can you provide any evidence that Muslims halted scientific progress because they believed the world existed on a sea creature?
Some of the greatest achievements of Muslim scholars occurred from the 7th century onwards, including the codification of the sciences of algebra, logic, and medicine, philosophy and countless others. Some of the finest architecture and engineering projects-which still stand today-were completed during and after the 7th century. Clearly, your claim that beliefs like this led to the collapse of Muslim scholarly and scientific progress is completely baseless.
I urge you to reconsider your stance in the video and further explore primary sources instead of regurgitating outdated orientalist tropes.
You should review an article written by Turkish Scholar Recep Senturk titled "The decline of the decline paradigm: Revisiting the periodisation of Islamic history". For an interesting discussion on the idea of an 'islamic golden age'.
I am happy to further discuss these points further should you care to do so.
So why is there hardith that a re influenced by Jewish and Christian traditions? Why ia there weak hadith. Why did they have to make hadith science? Because there is so many fakes!! Do you know those scholars?? No! You know what some priests did with children right? Why should you trust some scholar you don't even know😅
This is true, i have been asking where did we go wrong. Then I kept picking up how ideal sunni world is and how realistic quran is. It should be both realistic, not the opposite. You do not need to be rocket scientist to see the flaw of sects and hadith. Quran is the way to go if you are a proper Muslim.
Why are people calling him Shia? Dont the Shia have their own hadith? You dont need to label everyone. Allah simply called us Muslims, just say you're Muslim.
Allah Almighty Creator called the believers in the Qur'an, Muslims. The Qur'an explicitly and preemptively rejected the ahadith. And states that those who believe in any scripture out side of the Qur'an as being outside the fold of Islam.
Ahadith is outside of the Qur'an. Further, Ahadith divides the Muslim Ummah into various sects, thus places the followers of the hadith outside of Islam.
@MariamKhan-oj6zb I agree, that we don't need the ahadith. I wouldn't say people who follow it are outside of Islam, just further from the center and clear path.
@@zaidmuhammad6343 You need nt say. The Qur'an says it. That's enough if you are Muslim. If you include ahadith along with the Qur'an then according to the Qur'an you are outside of the fold of Islam. Read it for yourself.
@@MariamKhan-oj6zb can you show me where it says that in the Qur'an?
@@zaidmuhammad6343 It is not in one place as Allah repeatedly warns against the ahadith in very many ways in very many verses. If you are Muslim and have read the Qur'an it is indeed strange that you know not of it.
However if you are really unaware of these warnings in the Qur'an then I can take the time to arrange them in a manner for you and others to check them out. So let me know if I need to find time and make this effort.
BTW to clarify a few things: "ahadith" means statements. For example when it comes to Divine authority, the Quran endorses no other hadith(statement) but only the Quran. Qur'an is the ‘the best hadith’ ("Ahsanal Hadeeth", (Surah 39:23), as it calls itself. So the sole emphasis of the Quran is on Quran only, not on any other hadith, "lahwal hadeeth", (Surah 31:6), as it calls them.
As a revelation the Qur'an describes itself as self-explaining, fully detailed, complete, easy-to-learn. The Quran is, according to the Quran itself, the only authority of Islam and the only Divine source of law. Thus no other hadith is acceptable in Islam.
This should tell you why accepting ahadith, Sunnah and other so-called secondary authorities outside of the Quran to define Divine system is considered by the Quran as idolatry or polytheism. Thus ahadith is Shirk.
Islam was completed in March 632 CE (Maida / Chapter 5 verse 3). Hadith collection was a profitable business. Later, shorter the isnād (chain of narration) the more valuable it would be in the market. There is even Hadith whose narrator is a jinn. Interestingly, in the 7th and 8th century, typical chain would be 28 narrators, and then in the 9th century, suddenly we find the chain shortens to 5 narrators. People who point this out are polemicized as Hadith Denier (منکر حدیث). Well, truth is, everyone is a Hadith Denier. There is no one who believes in every Hadith. Even Bukhari collected 600,000 narrations, but compiled around 4,500, hence rejecting 595,000. Here is a simple rule: any Hadith that Quran validates is potentially true, and otherwise false.
Profitable business?? Can you elaborate please.
Al bukhari for instances spend his entire life collecting the Hadiths and lived on people's generosity and ended up in prison because he wouldn't take hadiths from suspicious source.
At least dare to read the history of the hadiths collectors and the tremendous suffering they went trough.
True. However, Bukhari selected only 2761 hadith out of 600,000 for his ghair sahih غیر صحیح, if you don’t count the repetitions.
He didn't reject 500,000 most were repetitions from different with fallible chains
@@DistortedEmpath Out of approximately 600,000 Hadith he is said to have collected, he included around 7,275 Hadith in "Sahih al-Bukhari" (including repetitions). Without repetitions, the number of distinct Hadith is about 2,600. He gave a long list of reasons for rejection: poor insad, ittisal, inconsistencies, adalat, lacking corroboration, lacking content and context consistency, failure in verification in direct travel, reputation and peer review (fist-cut of Ilm Rajaal)
@AbidNasim so you listed valid reasons to he used to eliminate hadith. Now we have 7000 which don't have these issues your best course of action is to reject all 7000?
Questionable Hadith tells women to bow down to their husband, Aisha RA age when proof shows she was way older, yet people take bhukari or sahi Muslim to be 100% authentic and that’s dangerous.
Here’s a popular traditional scholar of Hadith debunking the child marriage claim: th-cam.com/video/03b97GUacpM/w-d-xo.html
Don’t throw the baby out with the bathwater…
You are so ignorant of your faith I almost feel sorry for Islam and I’m not even Muslim. First the Quran clearly instructs women to obey their husbands even to let them have sex with them when they wish unless the wife has a legitimate religious excuse. That unequivocal.
Second point: Their is no Proof that Aisha was way older when she married the prophet. All you have as your “proof” is speculation and conjecture. Meanwhile there are multiple Hadiths from different sources that state Mohammed married when she was a child and plus her own Hadiths written by Aisha herself. I mean come on when are u gonna stop making excuses for your faith? Either accept it or reject but don’t try to artificially moderate your faith to make it look more acceptable. You might as well be a Christian at that point if that is the approach u have. Good luck. Read more.
May I ask are u a Muslim? And what kind? I’m just surprised by your comment. Thanks
There's 0-Ahādīth/Narrations via the Sunnah which commands Women to bow to their Husbands. You literally don't know what you're talking about.
You're literally attempting to make the Age of `Ā'ishah (May Allah be pleased with thrm), in the Name of Islāmophobic "Political-Correctness"...you're a Coward.
Very simple: whomever rejects the Sunnah/Prophetic-Tradition rejects The Qur'ān by default:
a. Both The Qur'ān & the Sunnah are at-Tanzīl/Revrlation.
b. The Same-Persond whom humanly documented The Sunnah also documented The Qur'ān.
c. Both The Qur'ān & the Sunnah were documented during the Lifetime of Muhammad (Peace be upon them).
Praise God!
I thank Allah for guiding me here. May he bless you Allahu AKBAR!
Akbar is not a name of Allah. Not sure who they think there invoking. Its insulting. Akbar is not a name of Allah in the quran. Check in the quran where akbar is. Astafirallah! I say Allahu Al kabeer now!!
@@ElizabethCooke-c9d Akbar means greatest and we say Allah hu Akbar means God is the greatest, nothing wrong in it
don't get misguided by the Quranists propaganda. They are Kufars
@@CraftyFoxx al khabeer means Allah is the master great. Akbar means greater. Its grammatically incorrect and its not one of his attributes or names. I say Allahu al khabeer. Its better then Allahu Akbar. Akbar in the quran is never used to describe Allah. Check it and see for yourself.
Allahu Al Kabeer** al kabeer means most great.**** akbar means greater.
Yes, Hadith is the real cause of ruination of Islam and Muslims. Every sect has been been a victim of Hadith. Islam is being driven in reverse gear over the last 700 years.
If one looks at some of the stories narrated in Qur'aan, one finds that Allah narrated the best Hadith and said in 45:6 "After this Hadith (Qur'aan), which Hadith will they believe?"
Our Prophet was given Qur'aan and when he recited out, all people understood the message and embraced Islam. He spoke only through Qur'aan and never referred to any tale.
Hadith collections were made by tale-collectors and story-tellers like Bukhari, Muslim, Dawood and others who came from Central Asia. Note that none of them was an Arab. Imam Malik wrote some when the Baghdad Caliph forced him to write some because he was a scholar of Islam and specialised in Islamic jurisprudence. Our Prophet had forbidden to write anything about him. And the tale-collectors did.
Qur'aan is Islam's only Scripture. It is obligatory on eveery Muslim. Hadith is neither Islam's scripture nor it is obligatory. Each and every Hadith from anyone is subject to Qur'aan's scrutiny. Hadith does not taech anything.
The tale collectors heard tales, narrations and saying from various people and lumped them in their collections.
Hadith tales were told in Caliphs' Courts and people became more interested in tales and that is how it was sold. A thousand years ago, the fast car of Islam started slowing down and stopped moving 600 years ago, because various Imams plied their opinions and interpretation of Qur'aan through Hadith tales. Reading and understanding Qur'aan was ignored.
Coimng to the word saheeh, it means true, right, correct, genuine and authentic in Arabic.
Saheeh Bukhari means the genuine collection by Bukhari or Hadith according to Bukhari just like 'The Gospel, according to Matthew and others.
But Saheeh Bukhari does not mean that everything in it is saheeh.
Scholars scrutinise all ahaadith under Qur'aan and classify them as Good, authentic, true, and also as poor, defective and not reliable.
It is not that the tale-collectors lied. They wrote what they heard from Muslims, the Jewish and Christian converts and others. There are lots of ridiculous and absurd ahaadith which came into Islam through early Jewish and Christian converts. Those are known as Israeliyaat.
That is one should not rely on Hadith at all.
Some Muslims do believe in the subject of Hadith but they should know that Qur'aan stands Supreme because Qur'aan is the only Scripture of Islam. That is what a Muslim follows.
The current Ummah is not that Ummah which Qur'aan talked about. Every Muslim state has its own Ummah. Saudi Ummah, UAE Ummah, Kuwaiti Ummah, Egyptian Ummah, Kuwaiti Ummah, Bahraini Ummah, Omani Ummah, Pakistani Ummah, Turkish Ummah and so on.
Yet they are not one united Ummah. Some Arab Ummahs follow Qur'aan Qur'aan based on their Hadithi scholars.
All that has resulted in the degradtion of Muslims Ummahs. The real cause is Hadith.
yo 🤡 azz Zindeeq al Jahell Poosillanimous
You were so right and I 100% agree with you! You worded it very very well
Qur'ānism by default/definition is a Hizb/Religio-Sect:
Muhammad (Peace be upon them) wasn't a "Qur'ānist" & none amongst as-Salaf (as-Sahābah/the Companions & Generations-1&2 of at-Tābi`īn/the Followers) were "Qur'ānists". So, you've literally proven how much of a Hizbī (Religio-Heretic) & Mubtadi` (Religio-Innovator) you & all those like you actuallg are.
@GarethBryant15 assalamu alyaikum. It really surprising me how you and many others call people 'Quranist' with such an aggression and hatred, abhorrence.. A man says he is following the Quran and you saying he is wrong!! Doesn't that strange to you? Don't you hear yourself?
Allah only decides who is on the right path or not. HE will show everyone on the Judgment day who was following what. So stick each of you to your path and wait.
May Allah guide all of us to the right path. Amin
You are 100% correct it's unfortunate so many have fallen slaves to these fake texts of Hadith! These jerks had no fear of Allah unfortunately but now I'm sure they're paying the price. How dare them take the Quran and alter it for their benefits in Hadith. I have removed every single Hadith from my home never ever will it be allowed inside again. My kids are being raised on Quran only no Hadith
O Allah, I ask you to guide me to the right and true, straight path forever and forever, quickly and urgently in the best way forever and forever! Amin
"Also we dont change our heart after you guided me to straight path and have mercy and forgive me"
Allah, yes please
Then don't say O Allah, it's not quranic. Only it applies to the creation like O Prophet, O Mankind, O fire... But not for the creator O Allah (Ya Allah)
@@KORAN-ALONE why can't you say o Allah
@@rehanrassi9410 Because He is the Creator
Fun fact: second righteous sunni caliph Umar ibn Al Khattab was Quranist. He punished Abu Hurayra for spreading hadith, he prevented prophet from writing his will by saying: we have Quran and it is enough.
..... Prevented Prophet ....and following his religion; what a nonsense. Omer didn't believe in his prophethood ? His living instruction vis a vis narration about his instructions can't be the same.
Ummar and Abu Bakar had been defiant against the Prophets commands when the Prophet had started becoming very ill, with Ummar denying the Prophets request for a pen and paper so that he could leave them one last command " so that Muslims dont go astray " being the last.
Not only did Ummar disobey the Prophets command but he admoniahed the prophet by saying " we have the Quran and that is enough for us ".
That one statement of defiance to the Prophets command isnt proof that Ummar was a Quranist.
The fact both Abu Bakr and Ummar refusing the Prophets order to go battle as the Prophet was ill but chose to hang around etc
Abu Bakr and Ummar were ensuring their accension to the throne of leadership was not challenged or contested.
How do you know? We're uou there? See how people made up hadith. Case and point this comment. There is evidence whatsoever that this happend. Like most of hadith.
I agree, I think Hadith should not be rejected entirely as lots of Hadith matches with Quran and history but it not be treated divine or 100% authentic rather good tool but also put question marks and red line on questionable Hadiths, any questionable sayings should be rejected, like stoning of adultery should be rejected.
The very few that agree with the Quran are completely redundant, they just regurgitate what the Quran says without any change. Completely unnecessary to ascribe man made books to Allahs deen
Why do u need them u still dont have iman In ur soul What is The reason for u to need them if u have Quran there is No Logic
@@AsadAli-hm2vx Hadith are not redundant. Hadith are historical accounts that can add information to what we understand from Quran
@@homer1273history is nonfiction literary critique. Once it passes into the realm of religious dogma it cannot be critiqued and is no longer historical.
Just dont get any religious rulings from hadiths.
Beautiful to see Muslims upon the Haqq and leaving behind the hadeeth which corrupts our belief system Alhamdulillah
You literally don't even care how Pathologically-Ignorant you are.
Quran is the only book of guidance
Salaamun Alaikum. Sunnism and Hadith sounds like a Religion out of Harry Potter. I am certain it will make a very entertaining reading and good stories for kids.
Ironically, your Statement literally proves that you don't even believe in The Qur'ān:
Number-1...Allah affirms/confirms that everything Muhammad (Peace be upon them) stated, did, etc. regarding al-Islām was at-Tanzīl/Revelation.
(Noble-Qur'ān: Chpt.53, V.1-5)
Number-2...Muhammad stated: "Beware, verily, I was granted The Qur'ān & something just like it as Revelation. And there'll be Persons from my Natiin whom'll recline on Couches claiming "The Qur'ān aline is enough for me.". Beware of them.".
(Abū-Dāwud)
Number-3...Allah affirms/confirms that whomever mocks Muhammad and/or whatever they were sent with as per at-Tanzīl are Cursed-Persons.
(Noble-Qur'ān: Chpt.108)
There's 0-Doubt that mocking the Concept of "Hadīth" literally (by default/defibition) is Mockery of anything/everything which Allah revealed to Muhammad via at-Tanzīl.
Ig he suck Damn Manṭiqi sick Shi'a denomination Waahiyat Chi'a Chews seeds
he *sucks
@@ridzbey2080 What's your Point?!!!
The only thing that made me an apostate at 15 years old were the Hadith and Muslims themselves.
Now, I am relearning Islam again and would consider myself a Hadith sceptic and non sectarian. Alhamdullilah
Ahadith if taken to heart would make any thinking truth seeking person a non-Muslim. In fact it appears as if that was the very purpose for fabricating the ahadith.
Alhamdulilah you're back ❤ I recommend you this channel: Let the Quran speak, it talks about quran and problematic hadith that contradicts Quran
if you reject hadith you are rejecting quran, always remember that
@@Itzyasir2absolutely not. Quran is from Allah swt. Just the structure , the miracles, the number of répétitions of certain words shows us it is preserved as God promised to do. Hadiths are not infaillible, god never promised to préserve them. The quran itself says its complète. The quran says there is no compulsion in religion. Yet some countries use hadiths to kill apostates. At this point this is shirk as you are litterally putting hadiths over quran.
If the hadith goes in the same direction than quran then okay why not but if it goes against then no.
@Itzyasir2 they aren't all equal tho
I'm glad this has a lot of views, and I hope a lot of those viewers who agree. I'm a revert from the Netherlands and every muslim I know is a sunni and I not only feel alone in my faith (bc I have no family member who's muslim), but even among muslims.... I hope people will rise up to hadiths, as they are very dangerous...
Average muslims don't study hadith themselves and neither it is necessary to study hadith . Just follow 5 pillars of Islam and know the difference between halal and haraam and u are good to go . Rejecting hadith will led to the formation of many sects .
@@rahmanibrothers1017 brother all of the sects existing today rely on Hadith. Only Hadith reliance caused this much of sects
There is nothing wrong with learning from Hadith; it’s just not LAW.
Islam don't need Hadithbooks.
It just needs the hadiths in the qur'an
I say to Sunni and Shia and any other sect upholding hadith:
Eat the dates then consume the poison if you are truthful about your beliefs... no ifs and buts, very straightforward!
Which Hadith is that?
“He who has a morning meal of seven ‘ajwa dates will not suffer harm that day through toxins or magic.” (Bukhari, Hadith 5327 and Muslim, Hadith 3814).@@dgenxali
🤣👍
@@user-mw3tg9pl6bthx bro 😅 they are fucked up The worst hipocrites ignorant Whatever bad words there is they own them
We are truthfull about our beliefs...your explaination of hadith is wrong.
Hadith simply says , “Whoever eats seven ‘ajwah dates in the morning, will not be harmed by any poison or witchcraft that day.” (May or may not)
The way doctor ask you to eat multivitamins tablets you will not get harm with lot of diseases. (May or may not)
MashAllah!! I needed this
Majority of Muslims likes stories, one wear white turban, the others will wear green, black, yellow etc. They will look at each others beards and say mashala yours is longer than mine and lifts their pants up showing their heals some will have long hair that's the religion they follow.
Lol😂😂
True especially here in Pakistan
It’s like taekwondo red belt or green belt or black belt
I don’t get your point. So they follow a religion of stories? Is that what Islam is basically. Because the Quran is a very short book. If u take out the Hadith you almost have nothing in Islam. How do u know how many times to pray? Yup it’s not in the Quran.
@@Crazy88277 you call that a short book with 114 suras so has Allah made a mistake when it says in the quran this revaltion is complete and fully detailed and it says in the quran how to pray prostate and bow and worship me alone nothing else matters.
Amongst all the Muslims, I've most respect for those Quranists, not only because rejecting the terrible Hadith allows them to be more rational or scientific, and they're at least trying to prove their Quran as a self-sufficient or complete holy book, but also their scepticism is most reasonable, since the Hadith have been authorized without approval of Muhammad, or even his companions, centuries after canonization of the Quran. Unfortunately, the Quran itself remains a disorganized and incomplete book, either because people who supposed to transmit its data have died before the canonization, or because Muhammad himself have died before the book was fully revealed and organized, so the Quran is absolutely dependent on other books like the Hadith, which makes up for those loses, including the missing context for the Quran, vast majority of practical guidance, and all data about Muhammad, or the founding history of Islam.
The Koran seems disorganised because:
1) It came down as revelation at various points and times usually in response and relation to something that was happening or something that was asked. One could argue that this is a better way to reveal the message since it responds to various everyday experiences encountered over the lifetime of Mohamed rather than him being revealed the message in one session or sitting as he is informed about random things without direct experience.
2) We are used to information being delivered in thematic groupings which the Koran does not follow. That is because it is not a 'story' per se with chapters in a chronological order as is often found in the Bible, but a response to living that is to be used as a guide to respond to varied experiences of human life especially social life. One could rearrange the order of information in the Koran into thematic chapters and it would then be easier to follow.
The story like elements it does include are there to connect to the preious traditions of Judaism and Christianity to connect the speaker of the Koran to the preious revelations and address the followers of those faiths directly. It acts to remind them of those stories to establish a familiar voice to them and to also make corrections to any stories miscinstrued in preious revelations. That's why it states it is a final message because it is touching upon what ithas already revealed in the form of stories.
Did the Bible come down thematically in stories as found in the Bible, or was it compiled and written in ways organised by men to make more sense, clarity and ease of read? Perhaps in the raw form of the Gospel it read like the Koran. The Gospels of Mark etc. are not that coherent. They also follow a pattern of documenting information that happened over the course of Jesus' lifetime in response to cases or people he encountered and his responses to them.
3) A Koran only reading provides much more clarity to topics, issues and responses which becomes only more clear the more one focuses on it as a sole source. The hadith cloud one's ability to notice what the Koran actually is saying loud and clear. And when you realise that much of the hadith counter what the Koran is saying, that's when the game changes for you and your understanding of Islam. I highly doubt if hadith were the doorway into Islam there would be a singke conert. Most converts come to Islam through the door of the Koran. And there is a reason for that. I highly suspect it is the hadith and Muslims' application of them that becomes the source of any doubts that arise.
@@TheExplorer-e1j Not only seems disorganized, but the Quran actually lacks any logical order, while including only some stories, which are based on chronological order, and so far as I'm concerned, the Quran is not even ordered by date of revelation.
@@TheExplorer-e1j Your response is wonderful 👍
I am so glad I found this channel. It’s this kind of intellectual pursuit that strengthens my Iman and keeps me committed to the deen. Thank you. Please keep it going brother
Your nafs finds excuses for rejecting Hadith. Unless you submit to Quran and Sunnah completely, your iman can't be complete. Listen to mainstream scholars on the dangers of rejecting Hadith
@@sophosalpha “some people will never learn anything…because they understand everything too soon.”
I will worry about my Iman, which is stronger than it has ever been and growing. You should worry about yours.
@@sophosalphabrother you are just like the Christian’s and Jews who just follow what others around them follow. Allah completed our religion in the Quran. Anything additional is innovation. Allah knows best
@@Biblyshiply You are in total error. Without Hadith, you can't even know how many rakah to pray let alone the detailed law given in Shariah
Great title..
Just awoke to this reality recently..
And the Quranic Revolution declaration 2021 clarified it..
I don't care if hadith collection was fully verified videos of Mohammed saying a bunch of stuff that made complete logical/scientific sense. It would still be a source outside of Quran and therefore nothing to do with God or Islam.
May Allah Azza wa jallah bless this brother, and may the actual incorruptible light of Quran shine again. Ameen
As a Byzantine Catholic I never met with a Sola Quran before. Would you be interested in debating Muhammad Hijab or other popular Sunni apologists? Very interesting.
Yea they lie a lot
I say that as a muslim
It wouldn't be much of a debate since a person who adheres to scripture will beat the guy who loves to use Chinese whispers
@@yahia1000Mohammed hijab says Muslim who follows Quran only is a severe pedophile
Mohamed Hijab will never debate a Quranist.
A valid argument in general. However, I couldn’t understand why you have singled out sunnism for this. Are you a shia and therefore blaming only sunnis. The shia hadith in Kafi, Alibtibsar, NahjulBalagha, etc. is equally rather more unreliable, damaging and fraudulent. The sunni hadith made the Quran subservient to the Prophet but the shia hadith made it subservient to their so-called imams for their theological-political exigencies. So be fair bro and don’t sound sectarian because that makes your entire, rather good, narrative dubious and will be seen as motivated by sectarian bias.
You are right But there are things that you can't ignore. Such as this verse from Quran
Surah Al-Ahzab (33:21)
There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often."
Or
In his Farewell Sermon, Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) said:
O people, I am leaving among you two precious things, the Book of Allah and my family (Ahlul Bayt). If you adhere to both of them, you will never go astray.
You can't turn a blind eye on this and ignore these statements.
@@mazm4860by following quran you are following the prophet.he also followed Quran.
MashAllah! Very informative video and on TARGET! Praise God!
All Glory and praise exclusively belong to the Creator alone. Everything outside Quran is dirty/impure including minds, hadith, other books,, language, etc.. If the Creator compels the soul to dwell in Quran, the purification process begins. The reader will impute their impure thoughts on it's verses, yes. However, by Allah's will alone, the sincere will gain understanding as one continue's to dwell in it without interference or interruption. The Quran represents the 'chamber of converse' between the reader and Allah. The only door to this chamber must remain shut (never to be opened) to root out any interference (Satan). Following Hadith, sin, or other associates or authorities other than Allah's supreme authority of Quran, sent as a mercy, will keep a screen over the hearts, eyes and ears and minds and it will be as if they were donkeys unable to read the Holy Quran which they carry on their backs. Allah watches as one is distracted or engrossed. The Holy Quran is a two way communication screen. As Allah sees (may the All-knowing, the Omnipresent, and the Compeller forgive my imperfect speech) one coming into His chamber ( May Allah alone be praised for His gifts), He will know who, among the sincere will close the door behind him (never to open it again) or not and , by His grace, bounty, compassion and mercy, will guide, misguide, or leave in their places whomever He wills.
May Allah SWT bless you brother
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
You need to know How Muhammad was, and follow his patterns. This is the direct order of Allah. You will follow his pattern if you fear the Judgement day and have hope in the mercy of Allah on the Judgement day
@@mazm4860 You obviously have not studied the verse (they do not ponder the Quran as it should be pondered). Is this how you patiently ponder Allah's revelation?
The verse you cite:
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
Analysis 1:
'There has certainly been...' refers to the Messengers pattern in the past ('has'=past tense) , not present or future. For the present and future, we now have the 'completed, perfected , preserved, clear, elaborated, and preserved explanation of all things (In Allah's own words) in the Quran. Muhammad had to be obeyed by his contemporaries (As Allah instructed in the Quran) since the Quran was not fully revealed (Quran: 'was revealed in stages', 'do not rush Allah's message, it is for Allah to reveal it and collect it').
Analysis 2:
'for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern....' Here we read that the Messenger's pattern was one of several optional patterns to be followed. Otherwise, Allah would state in the Quran that Muhammad's pattern was the only pattern for believers to follow and not just 'a' (an) pattern. However, Allah states 'an excellent pattern', directly implying a pattern among several. Also the term 'excellent' while a superlative noun, is not a noun of exclusivity. For example, a classroom full of A+ students, demonstrates that more than one can be excellent!
I know the above to be true because of Quran. Allah also say (in Quran) to follow the cult (pattern) of Abraham; we are not to make distinctions between His messengers (Quran): a believer is one who believes in all of his messengers and books (cleared by Quran as, being the perfection of religion to all mankind, the criterion to determine what is true or false (Quran).
With dirty hands you have used this verse to condemn or avoid. the complete reliance on the same Book that you cite this verse from! Why did you not carefully read the verse (as I did) before drawing your conclusion, which you did not support with other verses of Quran ( as I did support)? It is because you do not reverence Allah alone. Allah in the Quran states that Muhammad was only a messenger and his job was to only deliver the message which is Quran. Allah, therefore, has not sent down authority to harvest from the person of the Messenger, more than Allah's preserved and manifestly true Quran (such as hearsay accounts of what the messenger said and did, from self -appointed authorities besides Allah's clear authority in Quran). You are caught in the filter with others who do not truly reverence the unseen Lord of all being, and, therefore, you are barred from developing a Quranic brain which is the most excellent and exclusive pattern:
39:23. 'God has sent down the best of narrations: A Scripture consistent and paired. The skins of those who reverence their Lord shiver from it, then
their skins and their hearts soften up to the remembrance of God. Such is God’s guidance; He guides with it whomever He wills. But whomever God leaves astray, for him there is no guide.'
A very bogus caption: Islam was not destroyed. Islam can’t be destroyed. To claim that Hadith destroyed Islam shows a little knowledge of Islam and of Hadith.
@Qurantalk, I agree wholeheartedly with everything you have put forth here. However, I still don't understand why no other Muslim (other than myself) cares about the fact that "Prophet" is a mistranslation of the word "Nabi". In the 12th century, Europeans translated the Hebrew Bible to several languages and used the very word to translate "Nevi", but the primary function of all of these Messengers (pbut) wasn't to foretell the future but to (summon, publicly orate, warn, deliver message, etc)--> all fittingly translate the verb of what a Nevi/Nabi does.
He literally prophesied judgement day and warned about it.
And which calendar date would that judgment day be on?
It's referred in islam as "the hour" and only god has knowledge of the exact time of this event
Google says that the word “prophet” goes back to the Greek word “phenai”, which means to speak, and gives rise to “phetes” - speaker. Thus, we have: pro (before) + phetes (speaker) = prophetes.
Sounds like the same/similar root word as in Arabic, like you said?
You literally don't even care how Pathologically-Ignorant you actually are. The Word "Nabī" literally means "Prophetic-Individual", from the Word "Nubuwwah" which means "Prophecy/Prophethood", which comes from the Word "Naba'" which means "Event", "News", etc.
(Lisān-ul-`Arab: Lexicon of the Arabic-Language, ibn-Manzhūr)
Allah literally calls Muhammad (Peace be upon them) "Nabī", Several-Times via The Qur'ān itself. You've literally proven that you & those like you don't even know The Qur'ān, which you & those like you claim to exclusively follow.
Mashaallsh Brother you are a Sound of Quran that exists may you thrive in this world and in here after.🤞🏻
Sunnis reject the Quran.
When God alone is mentioned, the hearts of those who do not believe
in the Hereafter are filled with aversion, but when others are mentioned
besides Him, they rejoice.
39:45
Realize how it says God Alone not God and his messenger.
What?how did you come into that ridiculous and lying conclusion?
@@Sufia-k1p what do you mean? This is a verse from surah 39:45 it literally says the word wahdaho which means ALONE.
@@prodbysuli5080 I asked how did you come into the conclusion that we reject the Quran?
@@Sufia-k1p you clearly reject verses of the Quran to uphold you Hadith. This verse specifically talks about you guys. I know so many Muslims who call me kaffir when I say Allah, Allah, Allah, but the second I say Allah and his rasool their faces light up and say yes that is correct. You’re telling me the Quran says one who believes in Allah alone is a kaffir? There’s so many other verses you guys reject too. What about the verse that says “ these are Gods verses recited to you in truth, so in what other Hadith after Allah and his verses will they believe in”? Clearly you reject this as you uphold thousands of other Hadith and then you make Judgement using something that was not sent by God, and the Quran clearly states that anyone who judges using sources that have not sent down by God he is a kaffir. You want me to keep going?
Quran is the word of Allah and the way for humans to live by. Hadith and sunnah is the sayings and doings of the Prophet saw to know how to follow the Quran. But the Hadith and sunnah must coincide with Quran. Otherwise it is not authentic. Some hadith could just be metaphorical, not literal.
Many have no way of being metaphorical and are outright abominable and ridiculous.
Can you provide the reference for the first Hadith you mentioned collected by At-Tabari? Also why did you quote al-kaafi? That’s not even a Sunni source, it’s a Rafidhi book… only 5 minutes in and deceit is creeping up from this himaar
False...al-Kāfī wasn't a "Rāfidhī". Slander isn't a "Flex".
@@GarethBryant15 Al-kafi isnt a person. its arabic for 'the sufficent'. It is the sahih bukhari of the rafidhi world and the compilier was a ithna ashari hadithen. Also, the quranic model of cosomolgy describes a firmament, undeniably.
@@GoPrayDontDelay al-Kafi isn't a so-called "Rafidhi-Source", that's actually the Point.
@@GoPrayDontDelay For the Record: the Concept/Term "Sunni" is a Misnomer. "Sunni" is literally nothing more than a Religio-Political Euphemism describing Muslims whom're Non-Shi'is.
garethbryant.wordpress.com/2024/04/16/sunnimonopoly/
@@GoPrayDontDelay
As per what you mentioned
about "Firmament":
a. What's your Point?!!!
b. How's that even relevant as per the Fallacy of al-Qur'aniyyah/Qur'anism?!!!
#IllWait
I listened to this things while i sleep at night and sometimes i can't control myself laughing 🤣😂
That's because you don't have any brain cells left so all you can do is laugh c
Quran is the word of God . whoever tries to get information rather than Quran makes fool of himself..
Quran Surah Ali Imran _7 It is He who has sent down to you, [O Muḥammad], the Book; in it are verses [that are] precise - they are the foundation of the Book - and others unspecific.1 As for those in whose hearts is deviation [from truth], they will follow that of it which is unspecific, seeking discord and seeking an interpretation [suitable to them]. And no one knows its [true] interpretation except Allāh. But those firm in knowledge say, "We believe in it. All [of it] is from our Lord.
Fear Allāh and stop misguiding the people, may Allah guide you or give you what you deserve
Jews Got torah added talmud, muslism Got Quran added manmade hadith , Christians Got injel added athor books this tells you that all religions are manmade
Unlike other religions, Quran is still in its original form.
God is real and his existence is a reality and islam is the truth.
It is not humanly possible for the Quran to have been man made. Your accusation is based on ignorance.
Awesome thanks from South Africa
Has anyone been to website of the Podcast? It has a part about how to pray, the positions of prayer? How did know how to pray? Someone tell me? I can't find it in the Quran.
All prophets from Moses Jesus Abraham etc .. prostrated and bowed down to Allah.
We Muslims we are asked by Allah to bow down to him
That's the most important gesture in all prayers all prophets did.
Muslims are ordered to prostrate and bow done to Allah in the Quran.
Not sure if this is sarcasm, but it brings a good point that the hadiths are what tought Muslims how to pray, the quran is very general and not super specific on the prayer
Go to your nearest majeed.. And ask 10 years old muslim boy he will teach you.. How to pray...
😊
#Precisely
It surprises people, that God made it actually simple, but as usual it's made complex by the scholars.
i had to pause and laugh it out the way you delivered some parts.
😂😂😂
I reject anything written by men that does not match the Quran. However the Quran does state very plainly that the earth is flat as like a carpet and that the sky is a fixed construction.....
verse pls
@@justfootball7998 ahh. Well my friend I certainly don't have the Quranic verses memorized. the flat earth is a touchy subject with a lot of believers. However since I don't have proof one way or another I just go with God.....
but Quran doesnt say about flat earth...u need to understand arabic too with it like most people say Allah prays for Muhammad but in arabic it say sending blessings.....@@chrislyman6946
The Quran is bearing witness to the firmament that the Israelites wrote about thousands of years earlier
Allah never states that the Earth is "Flat". You've literally just proven how much of The Qur'ān you've 0-Knowledge of.
garethbryant.wordpress.com/2022/11/10/muslimflatearther/
Qu’anis has long been debunked. If you are sincere look it up.
The Quran has been debunked? How? Do you understand what you are saying?
Amazing video. From a Sunni Muslim. Al-Jahiz means "bug-eyed", btw, they were making fun of his appearance.
Crap. If what this guy saying is true then even the glorious time of Muslims would not have happened in the first place…
He is saying the glorious time happened because they put Koran first not hadith first as other times did. And that's why they were successful. They were using the Koran which encourages thinking and analysis and study and obseration - all which develop creativity, experimentation, experience and discovery - unlike the Hadith which encourage the opposite - stagnation and regression.
There's few from Allah teaching for human in Qur'an. It support art, human wear jewellery, fighting against corruption stealer of wealth, oppressors of the weak, freedom of religion, questioning others religions, questions the authority, questions religious conveyor, can eat everything except pork etc,
This alone will transform Muslim society and Muslim never do this today. Are you against Allah guidance for humankind?
No app for andriod user? 😔
But how would we pray?
Clicked like just because of the title of the video
This guy is super biased and he’s not being 💯 forthright
You have a respectful voice,i have not listened,i find value in many hadiths
"so accept whatever the Messenger gives you, and abstain from whatever he forbids you. Be mindful of God" surat Al hashr 7.
The above is the command from Allah to Muslims.
Question : how do you know what the Prophet (PBUH) forbade and what he commanded since you were not there to hear from him during his 23 years of prophethood? Answer: follow the sunna... As simple as that Mr deception.
The verse from Surah Al-Hashr (59:7) is often cited out of context to justify following the Sunna in a general sense. However, reading the surrounding verses reveals that it specifically addresses the distribution of war booty among different groups, particularly highlighting the rich who contest this distribution. For instance, Surah Al-Hashr, Verse 6 states, "Whatever Allah has bestowed on His Messenger from the people of the towns belongs to Allah, to the Messenger, and to the relatives, orphans, the poor, and [stranded] travelers-so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you. Whatever the Messenger gives you, take it, and whatever he forbids you, abstain from it. And fear Allah; indeed, Allah is severe in penalty." This context shows that the verse emphasizes accepting the Prophet's decisions on material wealth distribution to prevent wealth concentration among the rich and ensure fair distribution to those in need.
The rich were contesting the distribution of the booty made by the Prophet, who had favored the most disadvantaged. The verse clearly addresses them: they must accept the share given to them and not seek to obtain more through illegitimate means, such as exerting pressure. This is confirmed by the continuation of the verse: "so that it will not be a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you." It is, therefore, about the distribution of material wealth delivered to the Prophet.
Additionally, Surah Al-Hashr, Verse 8 further clarifies, "It is for the poor emigrants who were expelled from their homes and their properties, seeking bounty from Allah and [His] approval and supporting Allah and His Messenger. Those are the truthful." This underscores the focus on supporting the needy and marginalized.
Misinterpreting this verse to justify following the Sunna generally overlooks its actual context. Similar instructions on wealth distribution are found in Surah Al-Baqara, Verse 215: "They ask you, [O Muhammad], what they should spend. Say, 'Whatever you spend of good is [to be] for parents and relatives and orphans and the needy and the traveler. And whatever you do of good-indeed, Allah is Knowing of it.'" And in Surah Al-Isra, Verse 26: "And give the relative his right, and [also] the poor and the traveler, and do not spend wastefully."
It is essential to read the preceding and following verses to understand the exact meaning. In this case, it clearly deals with wealth distribution, not the general concept of the Sunna. Talking about Sunna here is completely out of context and shows a manipulation of the Quran's meaning to give it an erroneous interpretation. And Allah knows best.
@@eliaslebrun4181
The prophethood of Muhammad (PBUH) is not just limited to transmitting Allah (swt) revelation as you are labouriously trying to prove. Far from that, he allowed him to legistale and to translate the Quran's commands into practice which the Sunna captured.
Question for you who is posing as Muslim (an Egyptian coptic probably belonging to the tanwir group posing as a Muslim ): Salat (prayer) is prescribed upon Muslims in the Quran, how do you perform the prayer? The Quran did not give the details but Muhammad (PBUH) did.
Zakat is prescribed upon Muslims in the Quran, how do you perform that obligation knowing that all kinds of wealth (which are numerous) fall into that obligation? The Quran does not give the details but Muhammad (PBUH) did.
Hajj is an obligation in the Quran (for those who can afford it). How do you perform hajj and what are the rituals? The Quran did not give the details but Muhammad (PBUH) did.
All in all, Allah (swt) allows his messenger not to be just a transmitter of the revelation but also made him a role model for all Muslims to follow and without Sunna that model dissappears which you guys are working hardly to achieve.... to no avail.
@@eliaslebrun4181
I don't know why my answer to your comment disappeared! Probably those in charge don't want other people to see it.
In a nutshell, those who attacks on the hadiths and the sunna know very well that Muhammad (PBUH) has been given to the Muslims as a role model to follow, something which kept Islam strong, they want to take Muhammad (PBUH) out of the picture and hence weaken Islam. I am quit sure the same people elsewhere also attack the Quran (which they say is true here) . These tricks do not work.
For those who want Allah (swt) and the last day : " The Messenger of God is an excellent model for those of you who put your hope in God and the Last Day and remember Him often" 33:21. Muhammad (PBUH) is a model for all Muslims in all their affairs through his sunna, period.
@@josephalison12is incest child marriage slavery bedroom slavery lying lying on Gods name stealing breaking oaths ending innocent lives conquer innocent n whatever u steal 1/5 for prophet
@@Gs9sk Apparently people like you does not understand historical context and now blasphemy against the Prophet, and you consider yourself as a Muslim yeah?
Muhammad is not identified in the Koran , Muhammad means praiseworthy. Yet in the hadiths supposed to identify his character. Strangly jesus is mentioned and praised more than the unknown personage of Muhammad.
lol. this is ridiculous. the quran asks us to follow hadeeth! it would seem that a lot of this is not being able to submit to the prophet's example and wanting your own actions to be permissible.
When the Qur'an was finalised your Hadith books weren't even compiled .
@@AsgarAli-w1j lol when the quran wasn't even written yet there was already the quran!
its th same memorisation n recitation process for both th Quran n hadeeth.
both are, in their true forms, recited n memorised . not written
hadeeth rejectors seem to be blind go to this
@@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman Allah never said follow the prophet.
Allah said follow the messenger
You follow the messenger by following the message that he brings i.e. the Qur'an.
Qur'an Al Nur verse 54:"Say, “Obey Allah and obey the Messenger. But if you turn away, then he is only responsible for his duty and you are responsible for yours. And if you obey him, you will be ˹rightly˺ guided. The Messenger’s duty is only to deliver ˹the message˺ clearly.”
( PLEASE READ THE LAST LINE OF THE ABOVE VERSE)
No its not. Allah promised to preserve the Holy Quran. The rest is man made. If it was such a vast science how come you have weak and or sort of hadiths? Its history with wisedom but not a rule book like Quran @@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman
@@AbdulKareemAbdulRahman If it is the same memorisation process then why were some hadith found to be inauthentic and rejected but not surah's from the Koran?
A lot of ancient texts and Native Tribes speak of this Matrix as illusionary a copy of the real world so to say many religious books points to this too! In many Native American tribes the world was carried on the back of an ancient 🐢! Fascinating subjects which I love to talk about. Also in Native American belief life is a dream and when we die we truly awaken..sooo very interesting! I appreciate this video very much Thank You🪶🐳🦚🦠🔎
Then you should follow what you like and let other people be free to do the same .
Peace .
@@adrianabonitaaziz I do exactly that so it's sound advice💐
The wind is when the turtle 🐢 farts. You've opened me up to such wisdom here.
The Native American tribal belief as just described IS Quran wherein God describes this world as the nether world or nether life; and that the props that made us feel secure will all wash away on the day of Judgement when eyes will see clearly and all will be exposed as the skies and the earth will disintegrate as a stage that is dis-assembled after the play wherein the test period of it's protagonists has been completed. God says in the Quran that no community or city will be deprived of His message. (for He is all- just all-reaching). All praise be to the the Holy One.
Native Americans are also a people of wisdom and also have a oral tradition i find them very interesting, do you have any YT channels you can recommend ?
Any of you geniuses know the verse that shows how many rakah there is in fajr prayer?
Dhuhr?
The verse for the Hajj rituals?
The sequence and manner of wudu’u, ablution?
There’s always a joke that’s not funny that keeps going round and coming back.
Obey Allah and His Messenger for YOUR benefit.
If you don’t it is YOUR loss.
This are man made creations, Salat is a spiritual connection to Allah and the Quran mentions about how to do it and also mentions how the prophets over the ages have done it.
And you are not following the messenger by following the hadith, you are following Bukhari.
I found a monafiq channel 😢😢
@WaqasAfzali-ls5yi my answer got deleted by your Satanist, friends.😅😅
You've literally proven their Entire-Point.
Basically...everything you've stated is All-Facts.
@WaqasAfzali-ls5yi You've literally proven how Pathologically-Ignorant you actually are.
garethbryant.wordpress.com/2019/11/13/quranism/
So how do you pray without Hadith?
This is the stupidest question hadith sectarian asking every time. Go read the Qur'an and find out and stop asking silly questions!
@@monoteismul that is not a response.
Do it by searching verses of salat in the Quran@@FoxtrotbravoSierra
Read the Quran and figure it out
@@user-oz5yk9bm5c Good answer brother. But most people do not know...
We do not live on a spinning wet ball. FACT.
Not alla muslims scholars stated that the earth was a ball, there are others who measures the earth saying that the earth was static
You mean an spherical planet? Yes we do. FACT.
@@tapir.lepirodaeshow one fact that proves your theory we live on a ball.
@@sreno66 How about the fact that both Americans and Russians agree on it? 😋😋
How’s that a fact we live on a spinning ball? Try again.
If anything the Quran points towards us living on a fixed, stationary Earth, not a round Earth.
Hadiths are interesting,have you read the 12 letters of the apostles?
We are Just Muslim AL Zamaat
We are NOT Sunni NOT Shia NOT Wahabi
We rejects many Hadiths
God bless you for your hard work which is so logical 😊
Who wrote the hadiths? The people who wrote the Qur'an, i.e. the people who narrated the Qur'an, also narrated the Ahadith.According to you, if the hadiths are made by people, then the Qur'an is also made by people, because this Qur'an was also written during the time of Hazrat Uthman, who has seen the Qur'anAccording to you, if the hadiths are made by people, then the Qur'an is also made by people, because this Qur'an was also written during the time of Hazrat Uthman, who has seen the Qur'an before that? The point is that you people run away from hadiths so that you can make people interpret the Holy Qur'an according to your wishes, and distort the meaning of the Qur'an whenever you want. Indeed, you people are a great and most dangerous temptation, you people are not people of the Qur'an, but wishful thinking
Yet Koran is the divine of God and most hadith are outright against Koran. It's better to focus on Qur'an and take hadith as historical source not as guidances.
@@NikMirza take also quran as a historical assest, who narrated quran narrated hadees, you don't understanding this basic if only quran is important so why Allah send prophet ? Wallahi it's great fitnah, interpretating quran own wishes not what prophet interpretate quran.
@@HappyForestTrees-si8lx
If the hadith isn't against Koran then it should be no problems.
@@NikMirza Hadith contradicts the Qur'an??
You are missing the forest for the trees. Uthman was a second cousin, son in law and companion of Mohamed and died in 656 in the same century as Mohamed revealed his message, and died only two decades after him. Hadith on the other hand were written and gathered into large collections during the 8th and 9th centuries. That's at least two centuries apart from Mohamed and Uthman's times. Furthermore, Mohamed commanded the companions memorise word for word the revelations. No such mention was made for the Hadiths which were only orally remembered and passed on for generations for at least two to three centuries before they were recorded and had travelled over 1, 000 km from where Mohamed lived which is where they were collected from. That's a lot of interaction between time and space full of various people, culture and religion that influnced the Hadiths before they were recorded. Given especially that the Hadith were not under any specific obligation to be memorised word for word like the Koran, they were open to all sorts of influence.
you are making this too much about sunni. as if the good guys were shia and the bad guys were sunni . fact is they were all sunni. you are also licking and smacking in the micro which is annoying
We call out Sunnis because Sunnis are the majority who enforce the ideology of the "sunnah" and dictate Islam to the rest of the world.
If the Shia had all the power like Sunnis do we would address them.
I’m Sunni but I don’t think even Shia call their Hadith 100% authentic when I spoke to Shia rather use it as alternative source to understand Islam, but Sunnis use sword to call people kaffir for not believing the Hadith as absolute truth, that’s dangerous because most of problems like what Taliban force people to follow a certain brand of Islam is from Hadith, that only leads to apostasy as they will see violent and controlling for of Islam, yes punishment should for serious crimes but not controlling every aspect of people’s lives, forcing women to cover their face and hair takes away their free will, this is not healthy and will make them deslike Islam
This is amazing.
How you make the Salat withaut Hadith?
Prophet Salah's detailed information is only found in the hadith. I look through all the hadiths, but I cannot find any that mention the world resting on a whale. Why did this man demean the Prophet's companions? all Sahabah رضي الله عنهم.
Salat is not robotic exercise, salat means spiritual connection between you and God
Quran explain in detail on how to salat...Connect/comunicate with Allah through quran seeking guidance, humbly rukuk (accepting), humbly sajda(submit). When u have understood connect/communicate to others...may Allah guide us...
The semen does determine the sex of the offspring, the woman can only contribute an "X;' chromosome, the sperm can contribute either an "X" chromosome, or a "Y" chromosome.
...the way i heard it explained is that if the father ejaculates first the child whether male or female will Look more like the father & not that if the father ejaculates 1st the child will be Born as a male .
Assalamu alyaikum. Please do not answer me here because I won't reply, don't to want to fall into dispute that has no sence since everyone will stick to his path anyway. AlhamduliLlyah I'm a believer and muslim. I read the Quran everyday, I pray like Muhammad did (s.a.s) but some words I see here in comments surprising me. I just want you to read ayas from 67 to 71 of sura' Baqara'(2). Just read them and think doesn't that seem like an argument about words 'Quran is not enough '?))
Allah just ordered people to slaughter a cow, but they started to ask a details and were close to not to execute the order of God. )) SubhanaLlah. AstaghfiruLlah. And this is only one point from the Quran. There is sura' about Ant)) You just think about that. Ant is in the Quran, and you say that it is not detailed and need something more... AstaghfiruLlah.
May Allah guide all of us to the right path. Amin.
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
Yes you are right Quran tells you everything, it tells you whose patterns you need to follow if you fear the day of Judgement
@mazm4860 Then you don't need The Quran at all. Read those 'patterns' every day and live your life. Follow those patterns, not Quran. Leave The Quran behind your back. There is no sense in reading and following The Quran once you got those 'patterns'.
@@AuthorReviews No Bro
Quran says
Follow Allah and his messenger
So first Quran then Muhammad
My dear it's the direct order of Allah to follow Muhammad along with the Quran, you can't ignore this fact or else you be lying to yourself
Thanks so much Allah bless you
It's interesting tho, because i remember a hadith people linked with the Mongols and how it was accurate.
Allahu 3alam, what i'm quite sure is that hadiths are in no way able to abrogate the Quran or be a firm ruling source.
May Allah guide us all...
Hadith and reliance on the Sunna have a tradition in every school of Islamic thought predating any of the information you include. You are speaking on what is called "the closing of the doors of Textual Interpretation". As a follower of fiqh that predates the Sunni/Shia schism I can personally attest to this fact. This fossilization of interpretation on unsettled matters (scholarly consensus that is rare, not by abundant gov, sect or school decree).
While the doors were never closed according to the talking points of the Shia in response to the Sunni, they can only do this in jest, as their "doors" are only open in batches of years an Imam ruled (or today in Iran depending on the judges who board the country by the approval of the Ayatollah) and not according to fiqh'u'sunnah but according to the innate knowledge of the hereditary leader.
The corollary in Christianity many may be familiar with is the canonization of certain book (into THE book) and making others apocryphal, as all writings considered for the bible were post-prophetic narrations of an Abrahamic prophet's teachings and sayings. Historically this can not be the Injil, but a derivative. This must be understood about Hadith and thus Quranic Authority is always above it in veracity of accuracy...
Some scholars, especially further towards modernity (as the Hanbali and Shafi instances you mention) have almost reversed this verification flow... opposing their own dogmatic "freezing" of previous rulings as forever authoritative... showing this 'hukm's" flaw.
Shafi's insistence (and late Hanbal's one upping) on textual literalness, even in metaphorical matters led to an accusation of anthropomorphism by Hanbal...
Thank Allah my school never went through this as it was already rationally decided and textually confirmed in 1st CH with clear distinction between metaphor and objective and rules about crosswalking them.
Al Hukm' Allah.
The Quran is created.
Leaders are not Hereditary, neither by tribe nor lineage, but by faith and performance.
Abraham was neither Jew or Christian but was Muslim... Mohammad was neither Sunni nor Shia but was Muslim.
That does not mean your only choice is to throw out the baby with the bathwater and reject all written tradition that can elucidate Tafsir and Sirat.
Leaving the doors open, there are things like isnad cum matn that you ignore by reducing all hadith scholarship to one sect, select schools and conflating Abbasid empire success with hadith interpretations... there are a myriad of reasons for this. The early Shia of Iran also made the Sunni's follow Shiism or suffer. This was especially hard in the face of forcing people "to curse the caliphs" in religious service as required liturgy... not everything came down to honest theological differences. The "claim of pre-validated power" in those that ruled or wished to, as in all growing societies IMHO had a much more corroding effect on Muslim culture and practice than the intellectual figh formations. Galileo had a hard time of it for the same reasons... more church vs state than religious co-option of either... power plays. Greek and Arab! writing on the round Earth were prevalent at the time. His persecution was political.
It's interesting how the evolution of Islamic jurisprudence reflects broader human tendencies toward institutionalization and control, where power dynamics often shape theological stances more than the foundational texts themselves. In this context, the tension between preserving the purity of early teachings and adapting to new realities becomes a crucial balancing act, especially when authority is both decentralized and contested across different interpretations.
@@crazy_afghan It is also often overlooked, especially in the West, that for almost 1000 years, Islamic jurisprudence on the applied level had codified inference sources, but the rulings themselves were local to the event. The idea that each and every legal decision must be put into a precedential framework that binds the next ruling was absolutely unheard of before well after most of the major historical scholarly figures had any say in a case more than approving a government marriage license.
U real muslim? 9:39 9:41 9:68 9:73 9:23? U muslim?
Hadiths are source of knowledge you can take those who make sense and used it as a literature this is how classical Muslims used they didn’t accept them as true
2:12 I mean to be fair, in Baghdad they had contact with Indian scientists and whatnot, and they have in their books the Elephants and Earthqackes idea... so that might have also been due to cultural exchange...
A lot of cultural exchange could have happened over the time between Mohamed's death and when Hadiths were recorded. The Muslims expanded from where Mohamed lived and died in the 7thC to places of rich various religious traditions and cultures. Almost three centuries of time and religious and cultural interaction took place by the point Hadiths were gathered.
Still you need to find and look for How Muhammad lived his life and practiced the Quran.
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
@@mazm4860 And we have his example in the Qur'an, alongside the other prophets like Abraham, who is told to be an "excellent pattern" for us twice as much (two more verses use this expression and it's about Abraham)
If a Christian/Jew now called us Bible rejectors and used these verses to justify them following the "sunnat of Abraham" since it has more "details" than the Qur'an... what would you answer them?
The same answer you would give them, then that's my answer.
Personally, it's not that i don't like what those sources say, i just see too much contradiction therein and therefore it can't be from God.
It's logic.
Also they are hearsay, rumors, and often slanders and some are written to make us doubt our faith and to doubt the Qur'an, i have 0 doubt much of that is written by enemies of Islam to make people apostate or to make them become hypocrites also...
And i'm not buying that.
@@servantofGodGabriel Allah has designed the system in a way that logic alone can never get you to Allah, put your faith in Allah as we are here to test our faith.
Secondly Yes All the Prophets have an excellent pattern no doubt, but you must follow what Allah has appointed for you.
@@mazm4860 I agree, that's why i follow the Qur'an that the messenger of God gave us.
The issue with the sects is i believe mainly when they promote shirk like the kissing of the black stone and other idolatrous acts, and the fact that no scholar seems to care to denounce it it a big red flag to me.
I wish it was not the case, it would be super easy to just follow the majority.
But if this life was about it being easy, then God would have made us a single community, but for the sake of the test he decreed otherwise, and there is wisdom in that, even if we don't see it now.
Peace and may God guide us all to his straight path he mentions on the Qur'an by the mouth of Prophet Muhammad alaihi salam.
And then your mom had you, “They seek to deceive Allah and the believers, yet they only deceive themselves, but they fail to perceive it.”
Al-Baqarah, Ayah 9
و اطیعواللہ و اطیعوالرسول
I can't follow prophet saw without hadis.
Can U?
Ahadith is not from ProphetMuhammadPBUH. It is from Bukhari etal. You follow the Qur'an: The Sunnah of Allah.
@@MariamKhan-oj6zb so Quran is asking me to follow something that doesn't exist?
@@MariamKhan-oj6zb one can't follow the sunnah of Allah, he is the creator. I am not. I can follow only his instructions. Not his way of life. What does Sunnah mean to you?
لقد کان لکم فی رسول اللہ اسوۃ حسنہ ۔
Please provide the source of اسوۃ حسنہ. If you can't, then again Allah the Almighty is asking to follow something that doesn't exist. I used to be one lone you, but then when i read Quran i came to know that Quran itself is referring me to follow sunnah, that is Sahi hadith.
I can give you other verses that instructs to follow sunnah.
وَ اَنْزَلْنَاۤ اِلَیْكَ الذِّكْرَ لِتُبَیِّنَ لِلنَّاسِ مَا نُزِّلَ اِلَیْهِمْ وَ لَعَلَّهُمْ یَتَفَكَّرُوْنَ(44) سورۃ النحل
لتبین کا معنی ہے elaborate or explain.
Where can i get the explanation made by our beloved prophet SAW?
بہن! آخری گزارش آپ سے یہ ہے کہ حدیث کوئی شے ہی نہیں تھی تو لوگوں نے گڑھی ہی کیوں؟ من گھڑت حدیث کی ضرورت لوگوں کو کیوں پیش آئی؟
یہ خود اتنی بڑی دلیل ہے کہ لوگ شروع سے ہی اس کو حجت مانتے تھے اسی لئے انھوں نے وضع کی۔ ورنہ موضوع حدیث کا وجود ہی نہ ہوتا۔
اللہ ہم سب کو فھم دے۔
If The Hadith Is Gone Then Islam Isn't In Its Original Form, Qala Allah Subhana Wattaghallah: AtighuAllaha Wa Attigharrasul. So There Is Now Nothing To Say And If You Are Mulhid Then It's Your Choice
Follow the Hadiths that tell you about the direct orders of the Quran only.
99% of Hadith are marked as weak by Hadith collectors themselves.
The remaining ones are Just tribal stories not the Deen of Allah.
Just prepare yourself of What Allah will Ask you.
Your religion is the most important thing in your life. You should not learn it from TH-cam , did you see a doctor who graduated from the Internet. Many comments, without any insult, reveal how much they are ignorant about thier religion.
Thank God that i live in this time of
Earth and when you also live ❤❤😅😢
There are no hadiths that contradict the Quran.
Hadith narrations were also a factor of Sunni and Shii schism, Shia Muslims collect and adhere to hadith narrations from the Ahlul Bayt (PBUT) in addition to hadith narrations from the Prophet (PBUH), whereas Sunni Muslims only rely on hadith narrations from the Prophet (PBUH).
The Prophet (PBUH) told his companions not to document/write anything about him that is not the Quran, in other words, no hadith narrations were to be written down. However, Allah says in the Quran that “He [the Prophet] does not speak out of his own desire, everything that he says is a revelation revealed to him by Allah” (Surat An Najm:3). Therefore, it would be very understandable that his companions would consider the Prophet’s speech and habits to also be “revelation” that has to be written down and transmitted.
The Prophet (PBUH) also said: “inform people about me, even if it is done through a single verse of the Quran.”, telling people about Islam is done through the narration of Quran as well as hadith.
"there are no hadiths that contradict the Quran"
I stopped reading after that.
@user-oz5yk9bm5c Yes apparently he thinks no narration exists in all humanity against Qur'an
@@user-oz5yk9bm5c Well, you don't need to comment if that's where you stopped.
@@Quran_Alone_Dawah Yes, sir. That's true, that's what I believe.
Quran is the Word of God and it is applicable everywhere and at everytime.
You can't disprove this fact.
Humanity is created based on the Quran. It even explains the first sin of Adam, what are you talking about? Of course everything is based on the Quran, it is the Words of Him Who had created the world as you know it.
There is no narration against the Quran.
"Whatever he says" in this Allah is talking to Kuffar specifically about Quranic verses only cause they were critiquing that Quran is the word of Muhammad.
"Warn them about me" Yes tell them about the messenger of Allah. As is written in the Quran that's it.
The only verse that clearly says to follow Muhammad and the one that can't be challenged is this one
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
Would have been better if references from Hadith could be given
Like Sahih Bukhari Hadith number …
😎😎😎 I didn't know if you are shia but i suspected before that something is not right with you. Please fear Allah and don't mislead the people.
He's not Shia. He's follower of Quran Alone. What he said is right. Hadiths should be in dustbin and should never be a source of religion
@@TheLasthourAA this is too controversial for the cultists. They fear their scholars too much.
Shut up
@@TheLasthourAAMohammed hijab has a video on TH-cam where he says People who follow Quran alone is a pedophile because Quran doesn't explain when is the right time to marry a girl without the hadith. Pissed me off because I know it's outright lie.
@@TheLasthourAAI don’t think not all should be rejected, that’s vast amount of info that matches with Quran being chucked away rather the term sahi should be removed, questionable sayings should not be followed, like stoning not from Quran should be not followed.
People always go the wrong way how do you pray without hadith, many things you cant know without hadit People just dont like the rules and say oh i onley koran fear allah stop playing
Quran only islam. Where is eating human meat haram in islam? No limitation of how many men a woman can marry. Quran allows you to have sex with wife and what your right hand posses. Ignoring the sunnah, if you posses animals is sex with them halal on quran only? When does you wuzu break? How do you pray? Can you refute the objections of answering islam based on Quran alone? including the inheritance example?
Allah Almighty says in the Glorious Quran Surah Ale Imran
chapter 3 verse 31:
1- "Say: "If ye do love Allah follow me(Muhammad(Pbuh):
Allah will love you and forgive you your sins for Allah is
Oft-Forgiving Most Merciful."(3:31)
Explanation: So the question is that how to attain Allah's love?
The answer is given by Allah Almighty Himself. His love is
attained by following His messenger. So this shows the
importance of following the Holy Prophet(pbuh) in all eras and
ages and obeying him.
2- "But no, by your Lord, they can have no Faith, until they
make you (O Muhammad SAW) judge in all disputes
between them, and find in themselves no resistance against
your decisions, and accept (them) with full
submission."(Surah Nisa chapter 4 verse 65)
Explanation: This is the importance of following the beloved
Prophet Muhammad(pbuh). Allah Almighty says that no one can
be a Momin until they make Muhammad(pbuh) their judge in all
disputes. So the question is how to make him the judge in our
disputes? How will we know about Muhammad(pbuh) until we
dont know what he says? And what are his sayings? The Hadith of
course!
3- "He who obeys the Messenger (Muhammad SAW), has
indeed obeyed Allâh, but he who turns away, then we have
not sent you (O Muhammad SAW) as a watcher over
them."(Surah Nisa chapter 4 verse 80)
Explanation: Allah Almighty guarantees that one who follows
His Prophet(pbuh) has obeyed Allah. And He also warns that who
so ever turns away will be punished.
4- "The answer of the Believers when summoned to Allah
and His Apostle in order that He may judge between them
is no other than this: they say "We hear and we obey": it is
such as these that will attain felicity.It is such as obey Allah
and His Apostle and fear Allah and do right that will win
(in the end)."(Surah Noor chapter 24 verse 51-52)
Explanation: Allah Almighty tells the signs of the Momin
believers that what the Prophet(pbuh) tells them they just obey
without doubting.
5- "Do not make [your] calling of the Messenger among
yourselves as the call of one of you to another. Already
Allah knows those of you who slip away, concealed by
others. So let those beware who dissent from the Prophet's
order, lest fitnah strike them or a painful
punishment."(Surah Noor chapter 24 verse 63)
6- "Indeed in the Messenger of Allâh (Muhammad SAW)
you have a excellent example to follow for him who hopes
in (the Meeting with) Allâh and the Last Day and
remembers Allah much."(Surah Ahzab chapter 33 verse 21)
Explanation: Again Allah Almighty guarantees that in the
Messenger of Allah we have an excellent example to follow. So
the question is how will we follow him unless we don’t know
about his sayings and his orders and his Sunnah? If we reject all
the ahadith and say that they were written 200 years after the
Quran then we will be neglecting this verse of the Holy Quran.
7- "It is not for a believer, man or woman, when Allah and
His Messenger have decreed a matter that they should have
any option in their decision. And whoever disobeys Allah
and His Messenger, he has indeed strayed in a plain
error."(Surah Ahzaab chapter 33 verse 36)
8- "..And they say, "We hear, and we obey."(Surah Baqarah
chapter 2 verse 285)
Explanation: True Muslims are those that when they are told
something from Holy Prophet(pbuh) they just hear and obey.
They dont question that. What Holy Prophet(pbuh) ordered they
just follow it and don’t give their own opinions.
9- "O ye who believe! put not yourselves forward before
Allah and His Apostle: But fear Allah: for Allah is He who
hears and knows all things. O ye who believe! raise not
your voices above the voice of the Prophet nor speak aloud
to him in talk as ye may speak aloud to one another lest
your deeds become vain and ye perceive not. Those that
lower their voice in the presence of Allah's Apostle their
hearts has Allah tested for piety: for them is Forgiveness
and a great Reward."(Surah Al-Hujraat chapter 49 verse 1-
3)Explanation: Allah Almighty says that Muslims shouldnt step
forward from the Holy Prophet(pbuh).For example whatever
Holy Prophet(pbuh) has taught Muslims,they should consider it
enough and the best. As the Holy Prophet(pbuh) himself said that
he has taught us muslims all the things which will bring them
closer to Allah. So anyone who thinks that by doing new things in
religion for the sake of reward will yield nothing if not proven
from the Sunnah of Holy Prophet(pbuh). Secondly there is
another lesson in this verse. Those who say that we will
understand Quran from our own thinking. So if everyone starts
understanding Quran from his own thinking then there will be a
fight. Some will derive something,others will derive something
else. So the best way is to see the tafseer of the Holy Quran. And
the tafseer of the Holy Quran is they sayings of our Beloved
Prophet Muhammad(pbuh) and his life. So those who dont accept
the ahadith. How will they come to understand the Quran's best
meaning? And Also Allah Almighty says that don’t put yourselves
forward before Allah's Messenger and do not raise voice above the
voice of Holy Prophet(pbuh). How does this verse applies today
as Holy Prophet(pbuh) is not amongst us? Don’t raise your voices
above the voice of Holy Prophet(pbuh) means that when we hear
some hadith then we should keep quite in respect and not speak
that i dont accept this hadith and i don’t believe in it. This is
raising our voices above the voice of Holy Prophet(pbuh). What
if that hadith is authentic and that really is the saying of our
beloved Prophet Muhammad(pbuh)? Will Allah Almighty leave
us on the Day of Judgment if we reject His messenger's sayings?
10- "And whatsoever the Messenger (Muhammad SAW)
gives you, take it, and whatsoever he forbids you, abstain
(from it), and fear Allâh. Verily, Allâh is Severe in
punishment."(Surah Hashr chapter 59 verse 7)
Explanation: This verse is self explanatory.Allah Almighty orders
us to take whatever Holy Prophet(pbuh) gives us and abstain from
whatever he orders us to abstain from. This is the way to success.
All others who think that they can follow Islam without Holy
Prophet's(pbuh) sayings are living in fools paradise.
11- "Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only an
Inspiration that is inspired.
"(Surah Najm chapter 53 verse 3-4)
Explanation: Allah Almighty says that whatever the Prophet
Muhammad(pbuh) tells the Muslims is not from his own desire
but it is an inspiration that is inspired. So those who say that only
following the Quran is Islam,they are wrong. Without following
the Prophet's(pbuh) sunnah one cannot follow Islam because
Prophet(pbuh) also told the Muslims what Allah wanted him to
tell. He never said anything from himself regarding Islam.
Brother/ sister in Islam, I see you’re upon correctness, please don’t come to TH-cam and expose yourself to doubts by watching stuff like this, your religion and the guidance Allāh has given you is much more precious okay?
بارك الله فيكم
May Allāh protect us. Rasūlullāh ﷺ used to ask the turner of hearts (Allāh) to keep his heart firm.
Allāhumma ya muqallibal quloob thabbit qalbi ala deenik
Assalamu alyaikum. Brother, why are you providing only one or two sentences from the Quran and interpret it as you or scholar wants/thinks correct?)) I think you know that Allah says in the Quran that it interpret itself.(Sorry for my English if it's hard to understand).
Please don't lose the context of the ayas and it's real sence.
I'm not the so called "Quranist" or blind sunni/Shia or any other. I'm a believer and Muslim AlhamduliLlyah. I just want you or any other stop trying to take several words from th Quran and say that "this means exactly this or that" in attempting to prove your own belief.
The Quran is full of wisdom and hukm, and Allah says us '... use your mind'. And Allah says many times to the prophet '...remind by the Quran'.
Can i ask for a debate Peter ?
According to the Quran, the bealivers are not engaging in debates, but just inform and warn people arround about Allah's will.
Hadith is the way to Islam
Stone running away after Moses put his clothes on it 😂 making grown men drink breastmilk to make them mahram 😂 checking if lizards are jews camouflaged 🤣🤣
Bro what?
When you hear reality for the first time on a given subject
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 the word of Allah ﷻ is greater than our intelect. We can only perceive things through our limited senses what is thag compared to Allah ﷻ’s power
@@goshbaby8531
Good job einstein, but the things that we can perceive God made it clear for us otherwise why on earth would He reveal it to people.
Take care dude
Peace
@@thesignsofgodareamongyou8306 😂
He is either shia or non-muslim. Don't listen to him.
سلام عليكم
For anyone, it is a must to learn the Quran and the Sunnah (Sahih Bukhari, Muslim...). Unfortunately, most prefer to follow an understanding based on whims and desires. There is an explanation for everything in Islam, but you can't just listen to some people with distorted hearts or who may have misconceptions and then claim that an era of failure for the muslims approached with the uprising of this and that. This is a great propaganda and evil.
May Allah the Almighty guide you.
So you tell us to put our faith into humans and follow blindly?
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
But if it were rlly a MUST then the prophet muhammad pbuh with have definitely compiled it while he was still alive. While I do believe hadiths are helpful as a tool in understanding the quran and adding historical context it makes absolutely no sense to say that it is a requirement. Hadiths are essentially all hearsay since the the prophet nor any of his companions were alive to verify it. They could have easily been tampered with and as yk there are a lot of contradicting hadiths out there. There's nothing more evil than mankind so I wouldn't be too quick to trust it
See shamsi speakers corner vs hadith rejector for a better insight into this topic
Only the hadith mentions the black stone. The Torah says sacred stones NOT just idols are forbidden.
"Do not make idols or set up an image or a sacred stone for yourselves, and do not place a carved stone in your land to bow down before it. I am the LORD your God" - Lev. 26:1
I would recommend facing the old temple in Jerusalem rather than the ka'aba to do your salah.
Petra?
😂😂😂 it's not your fault though
Read quran 4.59. Didn't Allah order us to obey Allah and obey the messenger .We cannot reject the maqbool (accepted) hadiths i.e hadiths which are classified as hasan or sahih.
Learn what it means to obey the messanger first, and learn why allah only used "obey mesanger" and never "obey prophet" or "obey muhammed" 😉
Obeying a human being is timely action, not universal.
@@Jamie-l6e ???
Right, to remind that you he is a messenger from him and when you obey him, you're obeying Allah. @@theskg1495
There is a popular theory now that the early part of the Koran originates from a Syriac Aramaic speaking group of Christians who resemble Ebionites, but also have a lot of Gnostic connections, the early passages might have originated in Merv ,.. if coins and other religious influences are anything to go by. Muhammad is the title they used for Christ, and the text makes more sense in some passages if read in Syriac Aramaic...but it seems the later guy also called Muhammed has got confused with him? So some of the more peculiar Hadith might be from weird Gnostic texts about other versions of Jesus. ..and some of the cosmology and scientific speculations might also originate from Gnostic sources? Is this also a view taken by Islamic groups , or just the opinion of Europeans studying the subject?
Are you referring to Christof Luxenberg's work? I don't know about that idea but I have heard of the idea that the Arabic used at the time of the Koran was a different kind of Arabic with more Syro - Aramaic influences in its language which has influenced misunderstandings of Koranic verses through misinterpretation of its language. Semitic languages relate to each other but still hold important differences. A good example of this is the work of Luxenberg who gave a different interpretation through this Syro-Aramaic Arabic language paradigm of a controversial verse in the Koran which desrcibes paradise and refers to it being a place of wine drinking and buxom beauties. Luxemberg translated this instead as 'raisins' rather than buxom beauties which actually makes more sense since the sentences around this talk specifically about grapes and wine.
On the other hand, a video on TH-cam by Quran Centric called "Protrusions of Grapes or Breasts? (Sura 78:33)" is an excellent commentary and analysis of this topic and though he does not describe raisins, he does continue the theme of them being grapes rather than 'breasts' and he shows this by actually breaking down Arabic language. It makes much more sense that the Koran is talking about ripe round grapes rather than breasts because the surrounding sentences are about this theme. His explanation makes perfect linguistic and thematic sense leaving no doubt that particular basal mindsets asserted onto this verse their own personal desires or imaginations of what paradise would be. Most likely the same people behind the 72 virgins awaiting martyrs.
As for 'some of the more peculiar Hadith being from weird Gnostic texts about other versions of Jesus. ..and some of the cosmology and scientific speculations might also originate from Gnostic sources', some Hadith do seem to touch upon ideas that are echoes of Jewish and Christian texts, and perhaps also from other sources, however none of these are mentioned in the Koran which supports the idea of Hadith as fabrications.
@@TheExplorer-e1j Some of the numbers are also interesting, in the Ugarit texts they seem to have 72 important Gods, and in the last supper Jesus saying 'this is my blood' referring to the wine sounds more appropriate to Dionysus, so perhaps various Christian groups are adopting some pagan ceremonies. Dionysus is also occasionally represented on a cross as this relates to one of the myths about Him...And in a Canaanite myth Baal dies and is reborn on the 3rd day. Perhaps in participating in this sacrament the spirit of the person merges with the Gods or something similar? There is a fresco somewhere of spirits being handed large white grapes... and they do come in different shapes, sizes and colours. I'd like to think that is what those rounded shapes on the statue of Diana of the Ephesians represent ( rather than bulls testicles or whatever).
@@traceyolsen308 I am at the moment researching Chritianity and Islam. Many old non Abrahamic religions tended to have a 'three in one' God figure where they were usually related but separate beings. Look up Triad (Religion) in Wikipedia for an outline. Plus, according to my understanding everything about the Trinity concept came from not Jesus directly but from Paul, and The Nicene Creed. In other words, the latter was men discussing their theories about what and who God is and coming to their own conclusions which have more parallels to pre-existing religions of Greece and Rome than the Old Testament. Many of the areas that had pre-existing religions that involed a triad of some sort were part of the Council of Nicaea - Roman, Greek, Persian etc. According to Persian Zoroastrianism, there was Ahura Mazdā, the supreme deity as well as Spenta Mainyu who was believed to be a holy spirit aspect of Ahura Mazdā. Through the holy spirit, Ahura Mazdā creates life and maintains and protects it. Interestingly, many of these pre-existing faiths had elements of characters of sun gods and early paintings of Jesus as a trinity feature some sun like feature behind him.
Wine is a feature of pre-existing non Abrahamic faiths and is presented positiely in the Old Testament, symbolising joy, blessings, life but the Koran takes issue with its potential for harm in excess due to immoral and antisocial ramifications of drunkeness and the barrier its intoxication creates to conscious connection to God through prayer. However there is an implication that the wine of paradise does not have this intoxication effect. Since Islam focuses on aspects of self discipline, perhaps wine is something that is given as a test on earth but is given in paradise as a reward.
Some have stated that the deity Mohamed refers to is the pagan moon god of the pre-Islmic Arabs, especially because of the close association of the names, however it is possible that Mohamed attempted to restrict the belief of deity down to one supreme deity since pagan Arabs had hundreds of additional tribal deities, and reform the definition and perspective of that deity as Islamcally correct. The word Allah is the generic term for God and is used by Christian Arabs too to refer to the Father. The Arabic 'Allahu' or 'Ilahi' sound not that far off from the Hewbrew 'Yahuwa' or 'Elohi'. In the Koran the Arabic 'Huwa' also refers to Him or His when it says 'He is (Huwa) The Merciful,' for example.
Only Quran is to be taken guidance from
Al-Ahzab (33:21):"There has certainly been for you in the Messenger of Allah an excellent pattern for anyone whose hope is in Allah and the Last Day and who remembers Allah often.
I agree to a greater extent.
Good work brother and team, but some hadith are authentic. Nabi s.a said i am leaving behind two things one quran and another Aal e Mohammad my family if you follow them both you will not go astray. All authentic hadith are available from Imam Jaffar al sadiq in fiqe jaffaria. It has not seen the light of day in sunni islam. And also the book Nahjul balaga by Imam Ali a.s. don't get biased because it the shia books moulvi don't want you to read it they are hidden from us.
That could be true amd i believe that is due to the mixed nature of islamic societies.
Such mixed communities will always become source of problems if they decide to tread the myopic path.
Case in point, hinduism, it is most fruitful as a multicultural global idea and becomes self deafeating once it starts identifying with something or someone tangible.