This is so true, each singer has different talents and they can be better in different areas of singer's but this doesn't mean we can compare singer's to others.
Don't thrown yourself down because: Tom and Jerry represent only true cartoon. (Everybody 0-1000 can watch real tom and jerry) Not those cartoons only age restricted to 0-3 year old only.
bella and birdy they both has delivered an absolutely amazing performance but i personally think that birdy,s performance was way like the next level....wow !
Omg!!!!! I can't stand it,. She is just unbelievable!!! Seriously, listen to Bella Ferraro's x factor vid, then come back to this,and tell me Birdy doesn't do it better!?! Bella has nothing on this girl.This young women is amazing, she is not just a singer she is a musicians, no fancy riffs and runs needed. This girl can sing, haunting beautiful an amazing. AND she looks like a star sitting at that piano!!! I'm dying right now
Don't forget Bella doesn't know she was that good...and she is actually in a competition and is very nervous, there is a huge difference between competing and just a performance. The fact that her mum cried already proves that there is so much on the line..and she definitely didn't receive any vocal training or whatever..it is what i called raw talent...Try giving her a few years of training and practice...Bella would be just as good or even better.
I dont agree, Bellas version is sooo much better. I went to school for music and even my professor will tell you Bellas is soooooo much better!!!! The only reason Bellas may not add up quite as much is bc she doesnt have the experience in performing in front of ppl. Give her a cpl years, and she would be sooooo much better than Birdy!!!
Birdy set the standard to all these girls singing "Skinny Love". The first time I listened, I thought she pulled a bit over in the high notes. Most of those girls at the contests lacks some emotion. This song is hard to sing, and some girls go too plain, others go too high. This is a sad song and Birdy is the one who got closer to its meaning.
honestly i think Bella is WAY better, seeing she had no vocolization training or anything like that. I think Bella has raw talent inside her, i love Birdy but i dont think she can match all the potential that Bella has!
Bon Iver's version was the original... simply put. Birdy's is absolutely brilliant. Bella's was also very very well done. All three have a different approach to it and all three are great... The arguing is pointless.
@@searchingforchrist7792 nah lol Bon Iver’s will always be the original but birdy was the 1st to sing it in this style everyone else is a bad copy cat 🐱 and birdy’s version will forever be known as the greatest so you can can smack your head on a table and suck it
You inspired Bella Ferraro to cover this song in her audition. When I heard her version it inspired me to tryout. In 2013 I got my Golden Ticket with two original songs. Your music continues to inspire us. I am going to try again. Music is love. Music is hope. Music is peace. We have to share it.
@@benparkin6448 She was never mainstream lmao. She became famous for not making mainstream music at the time, she was a breath of fresh air amongst all the mainstream music. She hasn´t fallen off she is just not a fame hungry artist, she has stayed true to herself ever since she became famous but that also has made her boring to the masses because she isn´t changing her hairstyle or color or style all over the place like people expect from female artists. Taylor Swift said it best, if you´re not changing or doing something crazy every album you release then people will most likely lose interest, this mostly goes for female artists. People don´t expect as much from male artists and they usually don´t even have to do much on stage either to be loved. Sad but true.
In my opinion, lol. Birdy released SKINNY LOVE at the age of 14. She transformed a deeply heartfelt song into a hauntingly beautiful hit. Before anybody says that Bella Ferraro or Bon Ivor are better it must be noted that at 14 years Birdy could not have an emotional range that would have caused her to create anything different than the song she sings because she liked it and did it her way. She is talented and is getting the experience as she matures. The world will definitely be hearing more of her.
I have severe insomnia and at 10:48 at night I was trying to fall asleep so I started listening to this and started falling asleep because her voice was so angelic
Guys, you are better than this. Stop comparing Bella to Birdy then CRITICIZING people for their opinions. I personally think that Birdy is better, but that is MY opinion. And I, and everyone else, is entitled to one. So before you call me deaf or an idiot or something just think. :)
I agree :) Just because We dont have the same ideas, It doesnt mean we have to be enemies :) But for me, I like Bella more, Hahaha Sorry, But i respect your opinion :) Birdy also sounds great! :)
Would you people stop complaining about who's version better or write her own music, she's talented and if you can't accept it don't watch it and take your sorry ass comment with you and leave.
Birdy is the best. Such a talent from a 14 year old and make other's songs her own with a new arrangement. Tha makes her unique.. Some people made covers but just usually did what the original does and it takes a lot of skills and talent to make cover as if it was originally written by you. That makes Birdy one of a kind.
Yes, some may say Bella Ferraro is the better singer, but Birdy's voice is more unique and significantly more memorable than Bella's. As for the debate on whether or not Bon Iver's original was better than Birdy's, I would say there is no right answer as both versions invoke different emotions when listened to; so it boils down to a matter of opinion and how you interpret the song.
most people only heard of this song because of her and assumed it was her who originally did it which it wasnt, happens all the time with covers that are wide world famous
It is hilarious reading these comments...geesh. To each their own....stop arguing about who's version is better and just enjoy the song. If you don't think Birdy's is the best, leave this page and go enjoy Bon Iver's or Bella's...why even come here in the first place? No one cares about your opinions. Besides...this page is for people who think Birdy's version is the best, LOL
I don't agree I feel like we should all be allowed to post our opinions on whatever youtube video we watch, it's just the way people express themselves that start mini arguments and such
Excellent cover and I do not like Covers normally. But her second album which she wrote/composed herself at just 15yo shows that this a huge talent. 2015 on the verge of world wide success and still a teenager !
It's insane how much Bella sounded like her when she auditioned, holy shit?! I didn't realize she mimmicked her voice so perfectly?! Wow! They are both amazing!
Nothing will ever top the original by Bon Iver, whom is a master in my eyes, but her unique approach on Skinny Love is beautiful, and she makes the song melancholy and the creates an entirely different vibe that I don't think anyone can bash her on covering a song. Plus, damn the girl can sing.
I love how the audience is just so quiet it shows how much her voice is so unique and beautiful you just want to listen to it
Yea i kn right
Yeah...but Bella's cover is better.
Check any live concert with a Japanese audience.
@@Dreamweaverl r u tone deaf
Like hearing one of them go Shsh.
I really don't think that anyone's voice will ever hit me like Birdy's does. Love her so so much! Such a talented girl!
birdy version is unique, her voice is so special and magical
The judge on the far right pushing out his chair at 3:49 when Birdy holds that amazing note.
That's Ronan Keating
That voice, beautiful ...
It was
She's so talented!! Also she has such a delicate voice, which makes the effect of the song more personally effective.
Bella was great singing Skinny Love, but Birdy, OMG! I just... LOVE HER.
Stop comparing singers and just admire their talents :)
I didn't expect to find you here LOL
So true..
Fan ka din pala ni birdy idol doof ❣
Amazing i was just checking out your game records on MLBB a moment ago hahahh
This is so true, each singer has different talents and they can be better in different areas of singer's but this doesn't mean we can compare singer's to others.
At 14 she was already busy in studio
I was all day stuck on Tom and Jerry
Lol😂
Birdy 24 1996
Don't thrown yourself down because:
Tom and Jerry represent only true cartoon. (Everybody 0-1000 can watch real tom and jerry)
Not those cartoons only age restricted to 0-3 year old only.
Because if adult watching it, they will catch mental illness.
Perfect. I love everything about Birdy, her voice, her songs, her style, her personality, she's just perfect. Bless her.
bella and birdy they both has delivered an absolutely amazing performance but i personally think that birdy,s performance was way like the next level....wow !
Bellas is better
This is one of the most beautiful performances I have ever listened to.
Omg!!!!! I can't stand it,. She is just unbelievable!!! Seriously, listen to Bella Ferraro's x factor vid, then come back to this,and tell me Birdy doesn't do it better!?! Bella has nothing on this girl.This young women is amazing, she is not just a singer she is a musicians, no fancy riffs and runs needed. This girl can sing, haunting beautiful an amazing. AND she looks like a star sitting at that piano!!! I'm dying right now
Don't forget Bella doesn't know she was that good...and she is actually in a competition and is very nervous, there is a huge difference between competing and just a performance. The fact that her mum cried already proves that there is so much on the line..and she definitely didn't receive any vocal training or whatever..it is what i called raw talent...Try giving her a few years of training and practice...Bella would be just as good or even better.
I dont agree, Bellas version is sooo much better. I went to school for music and even my professor will tell you Bellas is soooooo much better!!!! The only reason Bellas may not add up quite as much is bc she doesnt have the experience in performing in front of ppl. Give her a cpl years, and she would be sooooo much better than Birdy!!!
God you're so absolutely right... sorry but Birdy is a million times better
Birdy set the standard to all these girls singing "Skinny Love". The first time I listened, I thought she pulled a bit over in the high notes. Most of those girls at the contests lacks some emotion. This song is hard to sing, and some girls go too plain, others go too high. This is a sad song and Birdy is the one who got closer to its meaning.
honestly i think Bella is WAY better, seeing she had no vocolization training or anything like that. I think Bella has raw talent inside her, i love Birdy but i dont think she can match all the potential that Bella has!
What a talent! Just perfect in every way and playing piano whilst singing like that is just pure talent!
She is incredibly talented, and I love this song! :)
Wether the song is hers or not (I know it isnt) I believe she performs it outstandingly gorgeous, she is a very talented person so my respects to her
Someone said it thank you
I love this song
Cow MOOx No doubt she is talented. However, i personally think that Ferraro's version was far better! Just my opinion.
+Cow MOOx What song isn't hers?
But it is?
+Stephanie Gonzales Bon Iver!
Goosebumps 😱 her voice is amazing 💜
BRINGS TEARS TO MY EYES... : 0 )
Bon Iver's version was the original... simply put. Birdy's is absolutely brilliant. Bella's was also very very well done. All three have a different approach to it and all three are great... The arguing is pointless.
Bryce Wendler I agree the arguing is pointless
Bellas version is definitely the best by far I’m not sure how it’s even comparable with the other 2 tbh, they aren’t bad but bellas is just insane
Bella is really just copying Birdy's arrangement, as incredible as her singing is.
@@searchingforchrist7792 nah lol Bon Iver’s will always be the original but birdy was the 1st to sing it in this style everyone else is a bad copy cat 🐱 and birdy’s version will forever be known as the greatest so you can can smack your head on a table and suck it
She has the voice of an angel😇
You inspired Bella Ferraro to cover this song in her audition. When I heard her version it inspired me to tryout. In 2013 I got my Golden Ticket with two original songs. Your music continues to inspire us. I am going to try again. Music is love. Music is hope. Music is peace. We have to share it.
Amazing. The only sounds I made when I was 16 were the ones trying to get out of bed the morning.
ihatecountry very good👍
Such a shame we dont hear anything from her nowadays..
Check her Instagram. It is very obvious that she is working on new materials right now.
Muhammad Tantowi Jauhari he means she’s not mainstream anymore, she fell off
she's still young, and not in a hurry for fame and money. im anxiously waiting for her new album as well.
@@benparkin6448 She was never mainstream lmao. She became famous for not making mainstream music at the time, she was a breath of fresh air amongst all the mainstream music. She hasn´t fallen off she is just not a fame hungry artist, she has stayed true to herself ever since she became famous but that also has made her boring to the masses because she isn´t changing her hairstyle or color or style all over the place like people expect from female artists. Taylor Swift said it best, if you´re not changing or doing something crazy every album you release then people will most likely lose interest, this mostly goes for female artists. People don´t expect as much from male artists and they usually don´t even have to do much on stage either to be loved.
Sad but true.
@@xanderbrink5167 I kind of dont want her to be too mainstream. like can I keep her my secret favorite? haha but I do wish her success.
i still dont know how people can have such vocal control and focus on piano at the same time. i dont get it
Muscle memory .. if you play a song enough. Your fingers will just go with the flow...
In my opinion, lol. Birdy released SKINNY LOVE at the age of 14. She transformed a deeply heartfelt song into a hauntingly beautiful hit. Before anybody says that Bella Ferraro or Bon Ivor are better it must be noted that at 14 years Birdy could not have an emotional range that would have caused her to create anything different than the song she sings because she liked it and did it her way. She is talented and is getting the experience as she matures. The world will definitely be hearing more of her.
She is perfection
Just a lovely song. It is so chilling that it is amazing by itself in the dark. You dont need to see the beautiful Birdy to love this song.
am I the only one that knows that "Birdy" is royalty???? British royalty that is...love love love her voice such a talented young lady!!!!
Her voice is so sweet ♡♡
love her voice so much! she has so much talent!
She’s literally amazing and I love this songgg
Never get tired of this! ❤
I have severe insomnia and at 10:48 at night I was trying to fall asleep so I started listening to this and started falling asleep because her voice was so angelic
She is so lovely and really beautiful...........
its so cute how shy she is
Lol a girl yelled "BIRDY I LOVE YOU" in the crowd.
Princess Poké Aw.
Guys, you are better than this. Stop comparing Bella to Birdy then CRITICIZING people for their opinions. I personally think that Birdy is better, but that is MY opinion. And I, and everyone else, is entitled to one. So before you call me deaf or an idiot or something just think. :)
I agree :) Just because We dont have the same ideas, It doesnt mean we have to be enemies :) But for me, I like Bella more, Hahaha Sorry, But i respect your opinion :) Birdy also sounds great! :)
Birdy is much more better
Toda vez que escuto me arrepia,simplesmente fecho os olhos e sinto a voz,o instrumental,é tudo muito lindo,Birdy tem muito talento
Her voice wen she talk is so beautiful.
Voice of an angel 😇🙌🙏♥️
Birdy, God has really blessed you. Thank you, for letting it shine!!!
She sounds just as good if not better live! You go girl!
Her voice it so pure golddddd
I love her voice!! She sings like an angel
She is so amazing. Such strong and powerful voice, she is my singing role model... i love her very much. She should be heard about even more.
I love her voice. Its so pure and humble. Hope my dreams come true like hers.
Would you people stop complaining about who's version better or write her own music, she's talented and if you can't accept it don't watch it and take your sorry ass comment with you and leave.
She is SO pretty!!
Damn I cant tell the difference between the studio version and the live version..
Birdy is so good!
Hard to think this was 8 years ago when you first came into our studio...
This kid is incredible. Holy shit
Goosebumps,goosebumps everywhere :) :)
Birdy is beautiful, beautiful voice and a beautiful girl. This really takes me back.
Still gives me goosebumps
Don't care who sang what better, to me her voice is perfect.
her voice is so high. It's great
Anyone wanting to impress me with the perfect first date , just simply bring me to theater.
Birdy ❤
Birdy is the best. Such a talent from a 14 year old and make other's songs her own with a new arrangement. Tha makes her unique.. Some people made covers but just usually did what the original does and it takes a lot of skills and talent to make cover as if it was originally written by you. That makes Birdy one of a kind.
Shes AMAZING
Today , someone won't allow me to forget them if I tried. This song means a lot and she sings it so beautiful.
Incredible voice for such a young girl. So pure and beautiful.
shes so amazing live!! AND SHES SO CUTE OMG
Her voice is amazing!
Yes, some may say Bella Ferraro is the better singer, but Birdy's voice is more unique and significantly more memorable than Bella's. As for the debate on whether or not Bon Iver's original was better than Birdy's, I would say there is no right answer as both versions invoke different emotions when listened to; so it boils down to a matter of opinion and how you interpret the song.
If their voices were combined... just imagine
Bellas voice is better, just better overall
Both singers are Perfect!
most people only heard of this song because of her and assumed it was her who originally did it which it wasnt, happens all the time with covers that are wide world famous
Huh?
+hartright3397 what do you mean huh?
What you wrote does not make any sense.
+hartright3397 How? It makes perfect sense apart from my mix up of the the words "wide world"
Mostly good, just some punctuation and capital letters would help clarify your opinion. Best wishes.
It is hilarious reading these comments...geesh. To each their own....stop arguing about who's version is better and just enjoy the song. If you don't think Birdy's is the best, leave this page and go enjoy Bon Iver's or Bella's...why even come here in the first place? No one cares about your opinions. Besides...this page is for people who think Birdy's version is the best, LOL
I totally agree
I don't agree
I feel like we should all be allowed to post our opinions on whatever youtube video we watch, it's just the way people express themselves that start mini arguments and such
rmbeavers no need to be hostile people can have there opinons
It’s great to see Australians cheering a British person,I didn’t even think they liked us!!!!
Only song to make my soul itself cry....
Flawless, what a performance.
i'm sweating through my eyes rn. such a beautiful song
what a voice!!
Bella's version is AMAZING
Birdy's version is MAGICAL
I like both of their versions....
i'm so glad I found this song, her voice is magic
shows respect to listen :)
Makes me sad that most of this planet won't even hear the original, beautiful version of this song by one of the most talented artists there is.
Personally, I liked Bella's version the best, then Bon Iver, then Birdy. I fell in love with Bella's voice.
Excellent cover and I do not like Covers normally. But her second album which she wrote/composed herself at just 15yo shows that this a huge talent.
2015 on the verge of world wide success and still a teenager !
You know you're amazing when the whole audience is completely silent because they are in awe of Birdy's beautiful voice.
2019 love
yeea i know... i listen to him since back in 2009
It's insane how much Bella sounded like her when she auditioned, holy shit?! I didn't realize she mimmicked her voice so perfectly?! Wow! They are both amazing!
Bellas voice was better
@@searchingforchrist7792 From this performance, I think I agree.
Best version still.
This song instantly makes me tear up wtf ppl be cutting onions
Love Bon Iver's version more, simply because it explodes with raw passion
Wow, beautiful, Love the whole set up with the twinkling trees
I cried after watching her sing wtf
Nope Birdy wins, she is playing piano for herself and singing the song beautifully, this beats put Bella LOL
Bella is better by far
aaahhhh i cant choose between her and bella! theyre both just so incredible!!
she is very talented
I really can't believe people like this cover over bon iver, fuck
BON IVER OG MAN
i like bon iver, but this cover is diffirent.
two diffrent voices
Who is Bon Yver xD
Beautiful voice....
Birdy is the best
So beautiful this song the words her voice perfection ❤️
Nothing will ever top the original by Bon Iver, whom is a master in my eyes, but her unique approach on Skinny Love is beautiful, and she makes the song melancholy and the creates an entirely different vibe that I don't think anyone can bash her on covering a song. Plus, damn the girl can sing.
Just superb. Cherish talent like this. Stunning.
She is sooo talented, I completely lost word
i love you birdy
Beautiful voice, she's amazing!
I like his cover but Bon Iver will always have that special connection with the song and put emotion into his songs. I love them both tho (: