18 months in Iraq, I asked my interpreters [very educated men] if they had ever heard of the Holocaust/Shoah. None of them had. We got on the internet & looked at a few films/articles. they were speechless
Maybe because of your brutal sanctions for 12 years iraqi young generation did not get a proper education. Isolated from all the world not even russia and iran had this kind of sanctions
That is a decent point to raise, and I do not know the context of why you were living in Iraq for an 18 month period, but it sounds like you were there long enough to understand context, and you should really explain the context that information may have been suppressed because of what America and Britain had done installing and propping up a government comprised of ethnically Jewish people. It does not mean it is right, but gives background as to what has happened in that region by colonial powers thousands and thousands of miles away.
@@ragoosh No the people are kept ignorant, I'm South African and I know about the Holocaust because it was a great evil perpetrated on humanity and it was a part of a World War. If that is not taught then your education is deficient and people from that region speak out of ignorance.
The Ancient Regime. 1. The First Republic (1792-1804) Following the aftermaths of the Revolution of 1789 and the abolishment of the monarchy, the First Republic of France is established on September 22 of 1792.
in my opinion, I have no problem with living with jews if u don't know Muslim can marry jews yes as long as the person is cool and good with me but not saying like I will kill him cause he said a bad thing to me it's like crossing the line like the Israel govt I have Hindu friends I have Christian friends talking to each other for months years with no problem but it doesn't mean I will throw out the jews from the country but it will be a hard thing for them cause the jews will start the same thing as Muslim people to claim the situation it might take YEARS
Idk why he did the interview if he’s just gonna be biased and say no all the time. He even said it doesn’t matter to the guy when he talked about the whole family being killed.
Because your religion is so idiotic and un eductaional, most of you don't even know basic english, you just so fucking brainwashed, people there is like "yea lets throw every jew to the sea 😃" but after 3 minuts they will be like "those zionist are so bad and racist 😡".
@@lironcohen2938 “un eductaional”? but “our religion” doesn’t teach English? WHAT RELIGION IS MEANT FOR TEACHING A LANGUAGE? it be the dumb ones like you..
Gus was making some extremely good points and it seemed like whoever was recording was trying to dismiss a lot of his information. He was literally giving examples that happened in recent times (like the family being burnt alive). I noticed when some other people were starting to make some good points too and the videographer kind of either says "doesnt matter" or cuts the video off.
@@gcanada3005yeah that’s a long long time ago. How many generations of other cultures lived there and developed a functioning society which Zionists felt some HOLY RIGHT to destroy. Just because Jews were prosecuted doesn’t mean they are so holy that they can claim a land for spritual purposes. Imagine if the whole world started making claims to their ancestral lands!?!? Yeah… look out Texas, New Mexico, every other state and Canadá….
@@gcanada3005 The Palestinians will say that they are descendants of the Canaanites. They will never admit the facts because they would lose the "original natives" argument.
I think he did a good job in identifying a common perspective among Palestinians, in showing that many do not want Jews living in their ancestral homeland Israel. Archaeological evidence would point to the fact that Jerusalem was Jewish long before it was Muslim or Palestinian.
pahari Dewan my point is Jewish people have the right to live in their ancestral homeland. I didn’t say anything about sending anyone back to Europe. What exactly is the point your trying to prove?
@SafeSpace Post "France has always been French" Before the overthrow of the monarchy in 1793, the Kingdom of France was simply defined as whatever the ruling monarch of the Frankish aristocracy owned ...common ethnicity, language, or culture need not apply. E.g. when the First Republic was founded, probably only half (or so) of the population even spoke the erstwhile King's French ...instead, it was a myriad hodgepodge of different people without much in the way of a shared tradition other than being ruled by the same jackass and his relatives in Versailles. The history of Europe, even up to relatively modern times, has been one of intense tribalism and regionally distinct cultures that don't at all correspond to modern national borders.
@SafeSpace Post Since you are apparently quite stupid, I'll repeat what I wrote earlier: The history of Europe, even up to relatively modern times, has been one of intense tribalism and regionally distinct cultures that don't at all correspond to modern national borders. ...now, here's the parallel to be made, pay close attention: replace "Europe" with the Levant and the point should be quite clear: Whether stating "France has always been French" or "Palestine/Israel has always been Jewish" ...it's all folly. *Ethno-states are folly in regions with no history of ethnic homogeneity* So you can take your ethno-state bullshit and choke on it ...the Palestinians and Israelis sure have, to their mutual detriment. "Frankish, Gauls, Celts, you know, the ones who have been there for thousands of years." More bullshit from you: Franks, a culturally Germanic tribe, established themselves in the migration era (in roughly 5th century), and various "Celtic" tribes had been migrating in and out of Gaul prior to it being conquered by the Romans who, of course, left their own enduring linguistic and cultural influence there. Hellenic settlers had also been living in Gaul for many centuries by then, as had Basque and Iberians in the South and South West. And that's really just the tip of the iceberg, e.g. in the late 18th century, just over 1000 years after the founding of the Kingdom of France under Charles II, only half (or so) of the population even spoke "French." ...so what part of *heterogeneous* has you fucking confused?
That Californian is obviously travelled and knowledgeable of cohabiting with different people's. He is more balanced. The others sound like extremists in their thinking. Interviewer isn't interviewing though. He is trying to make the palestinians seem racist or stupid but it's backfired.
Did you hear the interviewer on the family being burned? The Palestinian said they caught the people , the guy behind the camera said no they didn’t then said whatever and moved to another question like the family being burnt means nothing to him. Wow
No offense; That is what happens when they see you as like a wild animal. What happens to someone who kills a group of wild animals? They show up in the news and pass away.
@@tuub1281 Corey is unbiased in one video he will be questioning jews with Talmud verses in another video he will be questioning Palestinians about 1947 Israel
@@silossilos1927 He isn't askimg tough questions, he's literally being a biased prick who doesn't even seem to be interested in the answers. He should find himself a new job as this isn't what journalism is about.
@@tuub1281 Havent seen much of the channel yet, but I have seen him in some other vids to ask difficult questions to Israelis and they also stumble on their own answers So how does that make you biased? Who is he favoring?
@Maizer Effendi Sure, i agree but this is their land. It always was. The guy there didn't end anyone's career by saying that that land belongs to palestinians. he couldvé said something else like idf brutality but saying that it was always palestinian land made no sense. It was the land of jews for thousands of years. mohammed came 1400 years ago and invented his own religion
@@snan9402 he tried to manipulate the guy to say something to gain views and failed, the guy is a instigator but regardless YOU are the idiot for not seeing that.
Dude your previous video was about asking people where their grandparents were from and over 95% of them said latin american countries or europe. And now you dispute this kid with braces when he says the same? You're a hypocrite bro.
+TechnocraticBushman There is no occupation. The PA runs the Arab areas of the West Bank and Hamas runs Gaza. King Hussein runs Jordan which is 70% of the area known as palestine. The vast majority of palestinian Arabs roots in Israel go back no further than the Jews do.
+DarkBungleX As it is mentionned in the Video, Jews were in palestine before Israel was created, and it was all fine, so the past tells us you are wrong. the current people says you are right (certainly out of animosity) , we can take the example of Iran's jews (omg jewish's devil), whom, as I m writting this comment, are living all fine among iranese, but hey why spread a good news about a country we want to despise?
What really shocks me is that according to Israeli laws, I, a person who grew up in Russia, who has never practiced Judaism, barely knows what it’s about and has never even been to Israel, but has a Jewish grandma, and my completely non-Jewish boyfriend, if he becomes my spouse, both potentially have more rights to Israeli land than Palestinian people who have lived there for generations. This bit of realization makes me understand Palestinians who don’t want settlers to stay. Why would I be more entitled than they are? How fucked up is that?
This is not there land. And not yours either. Self made Palestine live in Gaza and West Bank. Israel land never belong to them . And yes all of Russian who is most none Jew have to return back to there home land. You made Israel like Russia . I’m originally born in Russia but all of my family Jew. No mix. And my grandmother mama from Jerusalem born . They came to kavkaz and stay because couldn’t back to Palestine in 1930-1937 time . Only we back when Gorbachev came. Some my family use to live in Israel and some in ussr
No.....if you are Jewish and you want to live in Palestinian land like Ramallah, Jenin, Beit Lehem, East Jerusalem or other, you only have the right to chose what cemetery you'll be buried. Israel is a deferent place and we don't take clueless ppl with all respect to your grandmother. Read more......and stay safe.
@@fantasticfoodcanada9373 I recommend you go hit the books, how is the land of Palestine, not the Palestinians? you say they live in Gaza and the West Bank but have you seen the map of change in which illegal settlers have slowly taken over, and they still are. Tell me if somebody came to your home and told you to get out it's theirs now would you not fight back, would you not feel animosity, would you not feel oppressed? I recommend you go to Google or any search engine and search up images showing how the Jewish camps slowly took over the lands of the Palestinians not to mention go research how many genocides occurred, it wasn't only displacements and abuse there were countless genocides brought upon the Palestinians. And you're referring to your family being Jewish all right I understand that but the argument that the Israeli State makes is that they are all descendants of the Old Kingdom of Israel and the tribes of Judah, thus that gives them the right to take this land which the Romans took over 2,000 years ago. This is an extremely weak argument considering the majority of those who inhabit the modern state of Israel have no biological ancestor to the Old Kingdom of Israel and the tribes of Judah and are usually Ashkenazi or Sephardim Jews. Contrary to that argument many Palestinians are direct descendants of Jews from the Old Kingdom of Israel and the tribes of Judah. Being of the same religion doesn't make you the descendant of that group. And if we were also to work on the same argument that the Israeli state uses, which is "this was our land 2,000 years ago and we deserve to have it back", you can easily Uno reverse card this argument by saying, so why not give the land back to the Canaanites or the descendants of the Canaanites, and last on my checked majority of those who possess The Descent of the Canaanites are also Arab. So it works both ways. Not to mention I have not denied that there are indeed descendants of the tribes of Judah, but they are a small minority. Finally, an argument that zionists like to make is that God has given this land to the children of Abraham, when you think of the children of Abraham you have to think of The Descendants of Abraham, who are the two major Semitic groups of Abraham's descent? Arabs and Jews, not just any Jews and not just any Arabs those who have the Descent of Isaac or Ishmael. This also goes as being called anti-Semitic, it's a pathetic thing to be hating on Jews because they practice their religion but when somebody starts throwing around the word anti-Semitic it loses everything. Considering Arabs and Jews are Semitic ethnicities. And I'm talking about the Jews who descend from Isaac.
The reason why Palestinians in so-called Palestinian territories don't have an Israeli citizenship is because their parents or their parent's parents fleed (or were pushed out, but those were a minority) during the Arab revolt of 1948, or came with the land Israel conquered during the 1967 war.
"Shocking". When you hear these people what do you expect from Israel? To let in people that will do 10/7 again and again? Would you let in people that live close to you and threatens to butcher and rape your entire community? Why it's not a big deal when Jews can't live in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Yemen?
To the interviewer: In light of your saying at 14:27 that there were 600,000 Jews present before 1948, I'd say the Palestinian boy's guess of half a million descendants of those Israelis at 1:10 deserved less of a dismissive attitude from an unbiased interviewer no?
The Palestinian guy was correct, but to be accurate, the interviewer was saying *descendants of* people born before 48 are "most Israelis" (I don't have the numbers for this). But in any case, it's not actually an easy clear cut thing of "pre-1948" - that's adopted by a lot of people here out of pragmatism. But the reality was that a huge number of Jews who had migrated to Palestine before 48 did so under conditions of British military occupation (i.e. post-1918) and a denial of Palestinian self-determination. In other words, the Palestinians didn't have a say in the mass migration that happened, and in fact, the mass migration was facilitated in part to set up a British-allied polity in the region that counterbalanced against the Arabs - it wasn't a matter of pure humanitarian impulse (Balfour for instance was a huge anti-Semite). Conversely though, that is complicated by the fact that I generally favour free movement of people, especially that Jews were suffering heavy persecution at the time (and indeed, Muslim lands had been historically open to such Jewish refugees). In short, you had a situation of a coloniser (Britain) facilitating the mass migration of a persecuted people (Jews) in part to facilitate the persecution of another people (Palestinians). And all that, in turn, is made even more complicated by the fact that a large number of the migrants would have been ideological migrants affiliated with the Zionist movement; i.e. their plan was to create a state there at the expense of the Palestinians, and they would have supported Israel in 1948. Then you have another large number who would have been refugees fleeing the horrors of the Holocaust etc. (and of course, a lot of those would have supported Israel too). Then you have later Jewish refugees who came into Israel *after* 1948 because they were kicked out of Arab countries (Egypt, Iraq, Yemen) after the Nakba. So this idea that "all Jews" who were in Palestine before 1948 were living lovey dovey with the Palestinians or "weren't Zionists" - as if Zionism began in 1948 - is false. For sure, a lot of Jews did have historically positive relations with the Palestinians, but these tended to be the older, Arabised settled ones - rather than the newer European migrants. On the other hand, the notion that all Jews who migrated to Palestine were all fanatical Zionists etc. is also false - a lot were refugees. A further complexity is where these two overlap - i.e. you're a Zionist because you're a persecuted refugee, and the solution to your problem is to come at the cost of creating another problem. The complexity with Zionism is that it was both a) an exclusionary, racialist settler-colonial movement (from the very start) that looked down upon Palestinians, long before 1948 - its project was structurally exclusionary of the people who would become its neighbours from its 19th century beginnings (even during the Ottoman Empire, Zionist Jewish migrants would buy lands from absentee landowners and expel Palestinian tenant farmers, and refuse to hire them); and b) that it was nonetheless rooted in a very real and undeniable context that Jews weren't safe in most places they lived in. Nonetheless, it was actually a fringe movement within European Jewry up until the Holocaust - until then most Jews belonged to left-wing, anti-Zionist groups.
@@os17312 and I acknowledge he was talking about the descendants specifically, for which the exact numbers are more difficult to tally or find. But exactly for that reason, the boy’s uneducated guess FWIW should not be dismissed so summarily.
@Durv Teixeira La France existe au moins depuis Clovis! France has been around since before King Saint Louis! 300 years ago? That was the time of d'Artagnan and the Three Musketeers. Much later than Emperor Charlemagne! At that time, France had already been around for many centuries. Il y a des gens qui racontent n'importe quoi. L'Histoire n'est pas bien enseignée dans les pays anglophones. Ils ne s'intéressent qu'au commerce, au business. English speakers are taught very little about History, culture, and humankind as a whole. Their curriculae put too much emphasis on trade and business, hence their disregard of universal civilisation. Pity that the US and the UK are major powers today, because they are making a mess of the world!
@@norben1162 I am well aware of what we are speaking about. I was merely positing a reason why someone might think France wasn't around 300 years ago. And the truth is because modern day France WASN'T around 300 years ago! Like 2 sentences before he says that, the guy asks "When was Israel established?" and if you Google "france established" you get the date July 14, 1789. So 300 years ago modern day France didn't exist just like Gaul doesn't exist today and the Kingdom of France no longer exists today! Plus, he then says "but there were still French people" but no one in Gaul called themselves a French person. And Francia means land of the Franks, so I'm not even sure if people there referred to each other as anything other than Franks until modern times!
@@HellYeah223 travelling, including the USA has given him many examples of indigenous peoples been kicked off their land and/or made into 2nd degree citizens. In there own land! If only the Israelis had been fair and equal with the Palestinians. Israelis had the opportunity to build a peaceful union with the Palestinians. But as shown all over the word. If men can dominate they will.
It is not. I used to believe in the 2 state solution but palestinians have ALWAYS rejected it so only WAR can settle this. NOW hamas is getting their war. I feel ZERO sympathy for the palestinians as so many on here advocate the murder of all Jews.
@@WhoReallyCares917 not true, check his video "how much do you hate the Palestinians" and the video "how much do you hate the Israeli's" it will become very clear the hate is only on 1 side.
@ss-xy2im I guess when you are the occupier, you have the luxury to have that view.... I will use the last 50 years of history to form mine! We are watching!
@Canadian Gintleman I certainly don't need eudcation from you because you have a very biased approach and you are ALL OVER THE PLACE!!! Your comment is pure hatred towards muslims. Enlighten yourself!!! Especially someone who lives in Canada shouldn't have such narrative.
The jews are working on getting all criticism of "Zionism" or the Israeli state labelled as "anti-Semitism" or racism. The whole Zionist=Jew thing is something which the special interest lobbies are working on here in the U.S.
Of course Judaism and Israel are intricately tied. Just crack open a Bible for crying out loud. Even in the Quran it says that Israel was meant for a state of the Jews. If you consider yourself religious, but advocate otherwise you’re a heretic IMO. You have a stronger argument if you’re a secularist and argue that there should be no religious affiliated states at all. However, there too, I think you should start with the Muslim and Christian nations that vastly outnumber Israel before targeting the 1 tiny Jewish state.
The producer sounded like a kid, like tucker carlson of fox news. Losing his shit with his heart beating fast even though he was the one asking the questions.
You man he can speak a perfect California 'merican english? They all seem well mannered to me. This is a problem born out of Zionism, Rothschild money and ignorance fed into the ears of Brits who knew nothing of history. Now it's perpetrated by American Christian Zionists and settlers from the US who are well taken care of. the Natufians were the original inhabitants. The Amazigh. The Bedouin and Mizrahi never left and find out how they've been treated since 1948.
I don’t understand people who were expecting palestinians to not hate Israelis? Of course colonised people tend to hate their colonisers, what’s surprising about that?
Well, unless my glasses need cleaning, they are clearly not the brightest! A low quotient of the stuff that matters comes with a laundry list of negative traits it inflicts on society, and right at the top of the list, in terms of its negative impact, is an increased propensity for violence and predatory aggression. Watch those ferals parading Shani Louk (legs broken, her father said) through the streets of Gaza in the back of a pickup truck, or listen to a son brag to his *proud* parents how he killed Jews with his own hands, or listen to a soldier describing the moment he found a baby that had been put in an oven and its parents shot (after they were forced to watch?), to understand what the civilised world is dealing with.
@@macclift9956why are you repeating lie over another lie? Problem with you “civilised” people, your racism runs so deep that you convince yourself that your violence is good because it is against savages and their violence is terrorism.
I don't agree with that. Redemption is something that can always be obtain but it requires a cold hard look at reality. There's a song called Amazing Grace. Listen to it sometime.
That is unfortunately Islamic mentality! Growing up at the mercy of United States, but faithful to enemies of Christians and Jews. Isnt the other guy ashamed to say he is an American citizen yet support terrorists?
@@viv4060 A terrorist to you could be very much a freedom fighter to him. Its a matter of which side you're on. Its all in the grey man (speaking very specifically for the Palestinians. FUCK ISIS THO lol), You can't pick which side is wrong exactly reality dont work in the black and white no more.
2:07 "they tortured him for six months" I hope everyone can see _why_ a lot of these Palestinians are unwilling to share a country with Israelis. Of course it's not morally right to ethnically cleanse the Israelis, but I think we have to see the interviewees' views in the context of what they've been subjected to on a massive scale for many years. Peace will not happen as long as Israel continues its gross injustices against Palestinians.
actually I'm watching this to confirm my bias that palestinians are never going to be alright with a two state solution, they want to either kill or expunge the jews to canada@@user-je7gf5uc3c How ignorant you must be to think everyone is on your side.
though i understand where you are coming from, most israeli (and we all lost ppl to terrorist attacks done by palestinians and had to endure missle threats) say that if palestinians will want peace there will be no problem living with them or having their own country or whatever they would prefer. if both side - all they see is agression yet the majority of one side still wants peace with them then i dont think you can excuse a behavior like that.
@@scud100 France as a country did not exist before 300 years ago. It was, like many modern European countries, made up of tribes with different languages, Basque, Occitan etc
@@AmitB France didn't always existed, but it's not a made up country with less than a hundred years who killed the autochthonous populataion and spoiled their rights, pushed them to live in suburbs and slowing are taking over the rest.
The kid telling the Jew that they have no history, no culture in that area is unbelievable. No history and culture? One of the oldest and richest but the Palestinian completely denies its existence.
@@seacampal1425 Where is it ??? they sreached and never founed secound i say you don't have culuture and you raelly don't have culuture that sad but true you all are just occupiers with small propaganda
@@jordanlavalley the palestinians aren't like native americans. jews are indigenous to the levant, and "palestinian" as a national identity didn't exist until the 20th century. prior to that, the levant had been colonized by romans, then arabs, then ottomans. the situation is in no way analgous.
@@eclecticEntrepreneur he said zionists not Jews. There was peace before, like the treaties between the Jews, Christians and Muslims. But to completely claim a country you’re a guest to causes tension between the people.
He clearly knows nothing about jews or judaism, and he believes in forcing jews to migrate out of their land, which is immoral. At least he didn't believe in killing us :/
@@White-rb5ey haha nice one. The editor saw that the interviewer was a complete dogshit asshole when uploading the video so he added a subtitle to make the interviewer less of a heartless asshole
@@White-rb5ey It really does matter because it shows how Palestinians are being treated as 2nd class citizens and Israel, quite frankly, doesn't care. Now, if Palestinians take back their homeland, won't there be some mixed feelings towards the Zionists who allowed this treatment of Palestinians to be held.
@@yungalmond2529 It has nothing to do with the topic of the video, also Zionists don't "allow" this treatment, how can they stop military personnel from doing something.
Indeed. The Israeli state matter makes me think of the abortion isssues in law. Can I appeal in a case before a judge at the same time to canonik rulings and to local state rulings? That is getting hard to get a legal coherent discours that leads to a solution by a judge. Wish Moshe and Golda and Kisinger anew sat around the table. This leads really to nothing.
one day in Brussels I shortly met a palestinian from Gaza. He had been besieged by Hamaz and was litterally shot in pieces. He showed me were the bullits entered and came out back again on his belly and his legs. Luckilly he found a job at Duchatelet's armored vehicles in Liège. Still he lived under a bridge. I gave him money and food for the coming days. That was his and also my story. I don't hate jews and I don't hate alestinians. Far from that. The thing is, anyone who visited the holy land in my circle told me theIsreali's are the most unwelcoming nation on earth. Rude to anyone who is not a zionist. My mom happened to had white hair and blue eyes, she was picked out at BenHurion airport and checked out over and over again. That is how things go in Israel. I swore to myself I will never set foot on Israeli soil never ever I would rather die.
I stayed with a Muslim Palestinian family in Jericho during my last visit to the area and when I asked the father if he was better off now that they were under Palestinian governance instead of Jewish/Israeli administration he said that there was a lot of corruption now and he was better off before. I also knew an Israeli Arab girl in her 20s who I asked would she not be better off in an Arab country rather than in Nazareth under Israeli rule, she said as a female she would not get a bank card with credit so easily as she could in Israel. Not all Arabs want Muslim Arab rule.
An anecdote, although interesting, can’t be taken as the general fact. I lived in the Middle East, came from a western culture, and found the low crime very good for me but that’s just my anecdote. I don’t agree with lots of what they do but you can’t imply one race or culture is better than the other. We should be better than that.
+ColonelCrow Sure. Judaism is, as we know, a monotheistic religion that forms a massively similar theology to both Christianity and Islam, but it preceded both. Zionism is a political movement that started in the 19th century, that claims that Palestine was promised to Jews by God (many orthodox Jews completely oppose this) and they are therefore entitled to claim the land at any cost. So if you believe Jews have a right to some land, like ISIS believe to be able to steal land and oppress/expel the people within, you're a Zionist.
+ColonelCrow Saying that they're fundamentalist presumes that their political ideology is an amplification of Jewish ideology. Which it isn't, as I explained. Hence, I would argue to the contrary, namely that their injustice and oppression towards the Palestinian people makes them external to Judaism, just like ISIS is contradictory to Islam.
+Abraham ElMasih Evidently, from your vulgar language and uneducated statistic (you're not accounting for the large Kurdish, Turkish and Persian population of the Middle East), you are not to be taken seriously. May God guide you out of the dark side.
That guy at 4:43 has spoken truth to the core and exposed interviewer neutrality too. But I will praise interviewer too for honestly uploading his views.
He said the Jews will be the guests in “Palestine” like “they’re (Palestinians) now “ and then say the “Palestinians “ are like the native Americans , well who are the leaders now in America ? Natives or immigrants ? And also obviously Israel is a much much different situation but still.
That guy that 'spoke the truth' legit said Jews will not be equal to Palestinians. What did the Israeli Jews do to these people? Wasn't it the Israeli government and the PA and Hamas that caused all of this? How dare you insinuate that this is what should happen it's deplorable.
He can't afford those radical and inhumane opinions, by some people who didn't even think about the Question properly, tho just threw their fantasies and shit to the air.... And BTW people who don't understand shit about the conflict or what happened after 1948... All they belive is that they had a country here before 1948 and then Israel took It and nothing has happened since.
@@lordwolfking1537 It doesn't contradict that they have no knowledge about the conflict nor intelligence. I agree that Palestinians and Israelis should work together and control the land in an agreement and not by forces... and terror, like Hamas does
@Jim Vento And you think Israel does??? Ofcourse Israel takes actions while thinking about civil lifes, but despite all of this, there are always deaths. IDF soliders can't shot people according to their own minds. There are clear rules. First they need to shot at the air in order to threat, and only after that they are allowed to kill, because they won't take the risk of it being a suiciding terrorist... Hamas fires on civilian inhabitants on everyday bases, and when they kill children, it is a success, unlike it, when Israel does, then that's a mistake which was trying to be prevented.
Lol this is all silly to me. King David ruled over a Jewish nation 3000 years ago. Then 1400 years ago, the Ottoman Empire OCCUPIED our land... then in the 17th century Jews started coming back to their promised land, purchasing land at fair market value, made it beautiful, and now Palestinians want it beck because they became jealous that for 1400 years they did nothing to beautify the land, and in 300 years the Jews beautified it again. There is no “reclaiming what’s ours” for Palestinians. Abraham purchased the land of Canaan, and gave it to the Jewish people. Just because the Quran says Ishmael received the blessing of the land doesn’t make it true. Do your research in Jewish history before you make ignorant comments. All of you...
I like the guy from California. Everything he says makes sense. Though he is way smarter than that aggressive interviewer, he is being very considerate and polite.
You lefties are a trip. “I don’t like the aggressive interviewer because he sounds mean” Palestinians want to push out and kill Judaism “I like the guy from California, he sounds nice” You digging that $3.50 a gallon for gas as long as trumps mean tweets are gone 😂 love y’all’s childish mentality.
Palestinian revisionist history thinking the Jews are not indigenous to the land is disregarding historical and archaeological fact. Therefore, the comparison to the Native Americans is inaccurate. If you disregard the historical claim to the land argument, you’re left with a situation in which the Arab leaders rejected the UN Partition Plan of 1947 (pretty much 60/40 split where Jewish people had 40%). The Jewish people then won the first stage of the 47-48 war against the Palestinians and then the second stage against the neighboring Arab countries. They then defended themselves in subsequent wars and all peace plans were rejected. Fact is they conquered the land and defended it thus far. Palestinians have every right to keep fighting to reclaim what they think is their land and Israelis have every right to defend. This is just how nations work and unfortunately it doesn’t seem like Palestinian leadership, especially Hamas has its peoples best interest in mind.
@@polmenakos no he's racist because when israelites said the same words he didn't close the camera and go away if you lived in country ruled by nazi who killed you in your homes and streets would kiss him I don't think so I don't say anyone has the right to do this hitler isn't justified but put yourself in their shoes
I like this interview and the answers. For the best part it explains why there isn't a Palestinian state. Apart from the fact that the PLO did state in an interview to a Dutch newspaper that the Palestinian identity exists for political reasons to defeat Zionism.
Mmm. I disagree. There was never a Palestine before. And for many Israelis that is their ancestral land, just as it is for Palestinian people. Zionism I agree is a little racist. Just like the Koran. My race is better and gets better privileges. NO..My race is better and we should get better privileges.
@@jensmith4411 palestine existed for more than a thousand years now. What you said about ‘israelis ancestral land’ you are referring to the land of jews before Christ. How do you know they are rooted of jews from that time? Many of the jews that live in israel today have immigrated from different parts of the world. For god sake they have Law of Return. Look it up. While Palestinians on the other hand have lived there before the jews decided to move back. It’s like you buy a property today, then you leave for several generations. Others have settled in and all of a sudden your descendants find out you owned the land therefore claims it when someone else was living on it. Make it make sense.
@@ketn0o416 Palestine as a country has not existed for more than a thousand years. Palestine is simply a word given originally by the Greeks (philistine) and the romans (Syria palaestina) for a group of people that settled roughly around modern Palestine, Israel, and jordan, but they never owned the land, they lived alongside many other groups of settlers...such as Israelites. They are not native like many of the people in this video think, they are of Aegean origin and arrived in the region at roughly the same time as the Israelites and other settlers. Both sides of this conflict are simply nationalists trying to claw at whatever they can get in order to justify their actions, Israel-using nativity and their religion, Palestine-using nativity and (essentially) anti-immigration
@@jensmith4411 Koran racist? Bruhhh don’t even. Go read it from start to finish then speak There is no division in Islam and no racist can enter heaven in Islamic belief. Clearly, you don’t know what you're talking about when it comes to the Quran** so please read it before putting such a statement or claim of a holy book that’s cherished by over a billion people. So speak for yourself and your own faith but don’t go putting another religion faith/holy book into it without reading it whole and knowing what it’s truly about and also spell it right.
Corey i sincerely appreciate you being somewhat unbiased this time, and for the most part actually letting the Palestinians speak and give their opinion
+b6makavelithugz Who knows, let's not assume things that cannot be proven, but he's only one doing this. I have learned so much watching these videos. Damn i can even speak few words hebrew because of these videos lol
@Bolshevik Breaker Can someone please tell me why people are using zionist as a bad thing in this era? I mean being a zionist is a great honor, you just don't want to be called anti semetic so you are "anti zionist" and that almost the same thing.
@@lironcohen2938 so your justifying racism? Zionism is racism because zionists stand by Israel not Palestine. Israel shouldn’t even be a thing. You guys are colonizers and think you are right for stealing someone else’s land.
It's a little bit much to take to just leave this demands for Genocide uncommented. I'm more surprised that he keeps himself that civilized. Many of the interviewees are completly fine with him personally getting "spread" (aka killed)... The Palestinians in this video demonstrate very good why they keep losing und don't get any step forward
@@pushboy1802 lol. Nice way to twist their words. None of them ever mentioned or killing any Israelis nor did they even imply genocide once. They just want their land back and them gone. Simple. Even if they did want to kill some of them, with what they have gone through can you even blame them for having these feelings? If my parents were burned alive or tortured and my land was taken from me....I would think about more than just expelling. They are pretty patient for wanting just that honestly.
It seems a little disingenuous of the person filming to continue insisting that most of the Jewish people were there previously, the region was about 20-30% Jewish people prior to 1948 and is 70-80% now. There has always been a Jewish presence in the region, but to deny or deflect that there was massive European immigration (along with the creation of a country specifically for the newly increased population), is just... lack of understanding of perspective for the other side. Then when the man is talking about the family being burned and the perpetrator not being punished the response of the person filming ultimately is "it doesn't matter", not ideal. Getting the two sides to come together.... going to be real rough.
I suspect you are pretty ignorant, I feel sorry for your children. If you were to do even a modicum of research you under understand there will never be a two state solution when it comes to Palestinians.
Well said @lisa therein lies the problem. These inflated numbers of how many Jews were there in 1948 seems to be growing by the minute. I wonder why ancestory tests are banned in Israel except by court order…🤔
@@Lin-js3vx DNA testing is not banned in Israel. The Genetic Information Law, passed in 2000 amid privacy concerns, conditions domestic testing on a doctor's prescription or court order, & that testing be done by accredited labs. Commercial ancestry tests can be purchased from abroad.
Interviewer is biased and completely unsympathetic to the Palestinians he interviews. When one commented that Zionism and Judaism are not the same, the POS interviewer argued with the point even though it is unequivocally correct. I know because I am a Jew and absolutely not a Zionist. The amazing thing to me is how polite and reasonable most of these Palestinians are. The frequently voiced opinion that an independent Palestine would mean that Jews would have to leave is the inverse of the actual deeds that Israeli militancy has inflicted upon the Palestinians. It is a strawman point that the interviewer frames as a justification for continued repression. Since when is policy enacted by the man in the street?
@@philwilson609I think If he was really biased he would cut out the interviews he didn't like and only use whatever fit his agenda. Seems to me he's only sticking to the facts as he knows them. What do you think is the solution for the conflict?
@@idohadad3039 from the interviewer's point of view everything he said was right. His view towards their comments is that we will look at them as being wrong and crazy the way he does.
+sem r the difference is, the jews in Israel only settled empty land, which palestinians didn't occupy, therefore palestinians do not own those lands. It's like saying Native Americans own all of america just because they settled in a few locations, and that is simply not true.
www.uwyo.edu/sward/articles/ward-quranonisrael-boullatavol.htm Most people in the world support Jews/ Israel aganist arabs. Because they see whats is happing in the arab world. They gain more and more supporters. Thats the fact. Peace :D
+MALEK KHIEREDDINE you were protecting old jew before 48? explain ► 1834: 2nd Hebron Pogrom, Ottoman Palestine. 1834: Safed Pogrom, Ottoman Palestine. 1847: ethnic cleansing of the Jews in Jerusalem, Ottoman Palestine. 1920: Irbid Massacres: British mandate Palestine. 1920 - 1930: Arab riots, British mandate Palestine. 1921: 1st Jaffa riots, British mandate Palestine. 1928: Ikhwan Massacres, Egypt, and british mandate Palestine. 1929: 3rd Hebron Pogrom British mandate Palestine. 1929: 3rd Safed Pogrom, British mandate Palestine. 1933: 2nd Jaffa riots, British mandate Palestine. 1936: 3rd Jaffa riots, British mandate Palestine.
יגאל גורביץ I will explain sir First, since the establishment of the Islamic religion and Mohammed urges tolerance among religions proof of this: "Treaty City," which was one of its articles without prejudice to any individual Jew in the city and freedom of religious belief. Read the history of the city and you'll find that the Jews have lived with Muhammad and his followers and where they lived in peace. And most religions were protected in the era of the Prophet Muhammad, a lot of people wrong, in ordered Muhammad as a prophet, he did not urge violence and killings, but there have been military movements against those they want to do a betrayal or murder, or support for the enemies, like any state at that time or at the present time. It is important, you know, my dear sir, that the Apostle were neighbors Jews, and most famous story to tell our elders, Messenger was his friend and neighbor Jew, always thrown on him greeting, and one day, the Jewish neighbor did not appear because he was sick, he went Mohammed the prophet who Zbunha to visit Sheikh Jew in his house, and did you know that when this old man died, sadness Prophet Muhammad Tayeb underway. Sir, did you know that in Spain, in 1492 AD, the reign of Ferdinand and Isabella, battles so-called Reconquista, the Muslims saving Jews from the massacres "inquisition", which was to kill all Muslim or Jew, in Spain, and months of the rescued these is "Rais Hamidou" and is a sea captain from Algeria, and other sailors Muslims, and who rescued thousands of Jews, and were transferred to Algeria, Tunisia and Morocco, evidence that Jews were to live with us in peace and safety, until France came and colonized Those countries, in 1830 AD, and then France treated the Jews as enemies to them. Other information, in the global war, the Nazis to kill Jews, and in France they were killed in a brutal manner, Did you know that Muslims, Baa Jews in mosques, to protect them from being killed, by the Nazis, and you know that they risked, also issued official documents of the Jewish states They are Muslims, so as not to kill them Nazis, and most famous mosque in France protected the Jews, it is the great mosque in the French city of Paris, and who rescued thousands of Jews from inevitable death at the hands of the Nazis. France and even today recognize thanks to the Muslims in the protection of the Jews of France. Information Muslims did not hate Jews or any other religion, evidence that the Prophet Muhammad said in an interview, "there is no difference between black or white, and there is no difference between an Arab or non-Arab," and did you know that Mohammed call for the protection of the people of the book and they are Christians and Jews, and not allowed to kill them or attack them, in the case of self-defense and the nation. Did you know that many centuries and Jews live in countries which were under the rule of Islam safely, evidence that since the establishment of the Islamic nation in 610 AD until the fall of the Ottoman Empire, and Jews living in the midst of all Muslims and Arabs safely and even so there is a lot of married Jews . Evidence that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah married in a Jewish period of his life. And also he married a Christian. If only question really, it was the Muslims, the Jews are being killed like what he was doing Christians, because they killed Christ according to Christian, Christian Europe Imagine kill, kill Jews and Muslims also, is there a single Jew today ???? Of course not, because there is no place where I was hiding Jews. However, since the Jews were living in peace with Muslims, they Ngo of extinction due to the Christian killing them. Sir, as a human being cultured Atkhalt rabble between these murderers who kill people and religions, they are not a Valasraileon Jews, terrorism is not Islam. The last question to you, what do you think in America ?? Of course, it will say the state of freedom, and Msawh. But the land question in fact come on American Indian land. The europians kill all Indians peaceful, why do you let these freedom? If America was really believes in freedom today, he left for America and bring it back to the Indians. Imagine if you are living in a country where ancestors lived since ancient times, been Allarrobion come and occupy your country, and kill your people, do you accept that? Of course, that the earth was the king of football since you really? Today the problem that most of the intellectuals silent, for fear of telling the truth, the fact of the terrible some countries that lie history, if true history books, rejoice too much. The idea there are many common traits between Jews and Muslims, and even their habit. Search and you'll find it. search tuth and open your eyes
יגאל גורביץ no sir please it's not dream okey ? me like muslim i respect מֹשֶׁה please dont TSB does not have anything sacred And you know I am a Muslim, Mohammed does not allow me to WASP Jesus Christ or Moses, and you know I respect and like Moses, so please do not insult the Prophet. And Mohammed does not have day war against the Jews do not distort history, but only from Kano fight Mahm, everyone knew that he fought against the Jews allied themselves with the Quraish and wanted to kill Muhammad and his followers, you are in place Do you remain static, or defend yourself, then why when defending Prophet Muhammad himself becomes a criminal, but when you defend or America itself become a hero ?? First she is not abused but that he should defend himself. And please tell you anything Do not listen to the myth fabricated by Politicians best for you and for your people, the guide does not forget that he was your introduction to the Nazi Holocaust. Do not lie and also did not defend the day and not the day Christians for Jews even today. War not for Jews, but for gold and technology, evidence that many of the heads of US companies and Brtanih, Kano have slaves of the Jews Alnazin camps, search, Bush and other Kano have Jews use them as slaves in the industry without paying money for them. There is a contract between Hitler and these Americans did and Britanin, where Hitler gives them Jewish labor, as slaves.
+MALEK KHIEREDDINE it was a dream that dreamt in the tent, that abu bakr volunteered to lie for him that it was real. cause he is a prophet and prophets don't lie. what a hoax. Muhammad never being in Jerusalem he failed to describe it. far mosque which referring to Beit al-Maqdis corresponding to jewish bet a Hamikdash the holy temple was no longer present at the time of Muhammad. nor any mosque existed. meeting jesus, abraham and moses, arguing over 50 times of prayer with allah lol what a funny story. resembles to the argument conducted by abraham with god in the bible. islam cannot be independent from jewish narratives it has to borrow. it was but a dream. another points to consider the al aqsa mosque present day is the fifth structure after previously four were destroyed by earth quacks none including the fifth were present at time of Muhammad. they were built years later one. the first of five was actually known Ayliya Mosque changed to al aqsa mosque for political purposes. so much complications. I don't insult Muhammad, I tell the truth about him. truth is not an insult. you the one insults him, by attributing him a false characteristic and a false historical narratives. islam is vile, evil and you should be a shamed for aligning to it. you truly a traitor to humanity.
The interviewer is so bias he asks loaded questions whenever someone comes with valid answer he denies them or changes subject he tries to pretend to be neutral but clearly has a bias against Palestinians I would recommend they educate interviewer on better interviewing techniques or get another guy
Joe Roberts I’m not American and this nothing to do with comment I was talking about interview being bias and using leading questions, good journalism requires one to be neutral and not push agenda he should be asking question to seek truth not to push an agenda or confirm his own bias’s
@@joeroberts2156 Yes but now the US has equal rights for everyone and the police don't beat or kill (frequently). The point is that palestinians have no rights and no help under the israelis
@@TH-camMadeMePickHandle you troll 😀 The fact is despite the obvious attempt by the interviewer to bait them most of them were clear about a solution of peaceful coexistence with those who were traditionally from the land ( and not from later immigration) under equal laws. And bear in mind they could hold on tremendous grudges after what these civilians have indure.
@@samphyllobates4765 Yes, they are quite humane given the oppression. Obviously not the "animals" that Zionists would have the world believe they are in order to gain support for their corrupt cause.
@@TH-camMadeMePickHandle if we could’ve interviewed native Americans in the 1700’s and they said Americans should all go back where they came from, would they have been bigots? How much inhumane treatment are people supposed to endure before they’re allowed to hate you?
Why would their opinion change? Because they decided to murder 1,000 Jews in Israel? Do you think their opinion changed after they murdered people and those people retaliated? Seems like they were already willing to murder babies so I wouldn't be worried about what they think now.
@@lovescent46 Gee, what made them have genocides against the Jews even during the time of Mohammed, i wonder?could it be that Mohammed himself taught then to be genocidal maniacs towards the jews?
@@lovescent46 Did Israel occupy Iran? The Jews were thrown out of Iran. Did Israel occupy Iraq? They were thrown out of Iraq. It seems that maybe it isn't a Palestinian "oppression" thing but a Muslim thing. By the way, weren't the Jews from that area, somewhere around Palestine? Where should the Jews live? What is a homeland they can call their own without Muslims attacking them?
4:42 man is so calm and he knows what’s he speaking about. The man who’s recording pushed so hard so he might sound racist or anything but he’s really knowledgeable. It backfired good
no it did not, saying that people have no tradition is as objectively racist as you can be, he didn´t have to push to make him seem racist, he was racist already
@@d.p.mlsgnrqtrsratm5793 the guy from 4:42 and onwards didn’t need any translations. You are thinking of the younger kids before him. And I think they are referring to the state of Israel and the idea of Israelis, that they have culture as Jews, the same as Arabs as a whole, but doesn’t have as much national/non religious tradition as Israelis, which Palestinians do. It’s debatable but I don’t think that’s racist.
Most of them are portraying it as if Arabs are the natives of the region (5:37), even though Jews have been there for over 1000 years before the arabs. Just because they were displaced to Europe or North America doesn’t mean they’re not originally from Israel
@@sventorgersen7545 It exist since Clovis baptism somewhere between 490-500, so yeah, more than 300 years. And you can't even say that modern France is from the Revolution because there as been multiple Empires, restoration and Republics since (we are at the 5th one right now)
@shmuck stealyourgoldberg Texas and the other insurrectionist, traitor, confederate states are not considered America. California is the heart and soul of America.
@@johnrobinson4445 I'm willing to bet the Confederate constitution is probably more American than whatever laws imposed on the people of California today
This is literally the most stupid question I ever heard in an interview. According to this guy's logic, if someone kicked you out of your home by force, then you can't get your home back because the occupier doesn't have a place to go now, and now it's your problem. I'm amazed how you are considering this as an argument really.
@@danielhorn4113 palestine he s saying that if someone takes your house per example, should we feel bad for him if you take it back and kick him out because he has nowhere to stay even tho hes the instigator
And this is literally one of the most stupid comments I have ever read and I'm amazed that you are considering this an argument. You can't compare countries to homes. You can't compare taking someones home to the complexity of what happened historically in Palestine / Israel. You can't compare people who were born in a country, living there for their whole live and having to leave to a burglar sitting in your home for a few days and getting kicked out. I can find more examples of how ridiculous your comparison is but I leave it for now. Btw. I have a lot to criticize about Israel, historical and political. But I prefer having arguments for that, not ridiculous comparisons...
@@nomissimo Thanks for the reply. Please take it easy on yourself, I'm sure you know what "analogy" is, what I said is clearly an EXAMPLE to show the shallowness of what the interviewer is going around asking people about, I'm not denying that on the higher scale the situation is far complex, but it's just an analogy to show how flawed the approach from the interviewer is, focusing on where should the Israelis go if Palestinians get their land back, and if they can't think of a good solution on the spot for such complex situation then they are in the wrong and taking back their land and home back is not an option until you give a solution, that's what I'm criticizing! basically the interviewer's logic, I'm not sure why you got so offended. But since you did, funny enough my comparison isn't far from what's really happened on a personal level, isn't it? Palestinians did get kicked out of their homes in the end, make it as complex and as historical as you want, this is what happened exactly, saying that this is complex and historical doesn't take away the fact that actual people are now living in refugee camps. Have a nice day.
How come Palestinians STILL are living in ”refugee camps”, aka (almost) ordinary suburbs in Jordan, Libanon and also in the West Bank (!!), without getting citizenship in Jordan, Libanon...🤔??? So They can go on with their lives...🤷🏻♂️ I was 2 years Old when my family fled Hungary in 1956 because of the civil war...we stayed in a refugee camp in Austria for two years When We got granted a quota asylum in 1958 to Sweden. My parents a little reluctantly accepten it... We got help with an appartement, mother with a job and father was hospitalised a lot. My older brother and sister started School and I went to the kindergarten. In 1966 We were permitted a Swedish citizenship. We were now FREE people being able to travel almost everywhere in the world.
@@morp904 who called for genocide? all i heard was that they can leave or stay just under Palestinian's law, you just make up stories and do you just convince yourself that people who lost families, children and friends want to see more death? if it was that case with the Israelis too they would've reached a middle solution! the problem is not the Palestinians nor the Jewish people... the real problem is governments and politicians who care about none of the sides.
Such a sad situation, my grandmother was Jewish and fled Ukraine during the war, I feel the two people should live in peace but I know it will never come to pass
No he is no biased he just hates to hear lies, like every normal person. For example, that Arab guy in the beginning said the Jews have no tradition nor history in Israel which is a straight up blatant lie since there are countless pieces of evidence proving Jews lived there long before any Arab or Muslim even set foot in this land. The name Jews came from Judea which was later renamed by the Roman empire to Palestine. As a matter of fact, there is no tradition or history of so called Palestinians, simply because there is no such thing as "Palestinian". They are a mix of Arabs from Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Saudi Arabia etc who moved to Israel during the centuries.
@@d3struction61 So I have a few questions here: Where were you as ethnicity before Judaism was born ? Was judaism found before the kingdom (Land of Palestine or Israel or whatever) or after ? Your father and the father of Arabs Abraham were was he ? Where did he live ? Where was he born ? Where was his Clan ? When your people moved to This Land cause I know they moved to it from another place and you should too, was it empty or was there people living in The Land, and what was the name of it, cause names can change but people can be in the same place? Such as Italy, Spain, Korea. Are all Palestinians now living there have only Arabic blood or other Ethnicity mixed with it cause I saw a video on Arabs showing that the Levant have all kinds of ethnicities as well duo to their neighboring people ? Are you denying that some Arabs lived in the Levant region (including the Land of Palestine or Israel or whatever) as well as other groups of different Semitic and Hamitic people before the three religions even existed? Were not Moses and Israelites in Egypt when he received the Torah ? I also have watched a video on this very channel where the interviewer asked the Israelis: Are you white? and most of them where Arab jews from Iraq, Moroccan, Yemen, Syria, Tunisia and a minority from Europe (mostly Poland i think) called the Ashkenazi Jews. Therefore does that mean they are not original Israelites and only Arab jews, and I quote from you the following describing Palestinians: (They are a mix of Arabs from Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Saudi Arabia etc who moved to Israel during the centuries.). Now I understand that the Ashkenazi Jews are the only group of jews that are not Eastern as they do not identify themselves or their ancestor as that, so are Ashkenazi Jews Semitic, cause they look white? and who are the original Israelites today (Please give me a name of a group of people identified among your people as The Israelites lineage today) by DNA Not Jews by religion ? What is the prove that the Israelites were living there alone and why are you so sure that the Palestinians right there today are not The real Israelites lineage mixed with others, some are converted to Christianity, Islam and some remained jews in faith, cause there are jew Palestinians before the state of Israel existed as mentioned in the video ? Are you saying that Canaan people were not there before Israel ? Canaanites are included in a list of nations to exterminate among other nations, and later described as a group which the Israelites had annihilated (Source: Joshua 1-12, (2015): A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary). If you read more in this book, it says that ancient Israelites moved to the Land ruled at the time by Canaanites, destroyed them and then took over the land to establish a kingdom for themselves (meaning it is not originally The Land of Israelites) , In addition there was no prove if only Israelites remain in the land or the original people lived with them (which maybe they are the Palestinians today). When exactly did the Israelites spread all over the world (year) ? Thank you.
+James Parker thank you James. The only one with sense. Why do people forget this. When you say that though they say La yani Sham. Cause it was part of greater Syria at one point also.
James Parker haha, what did I tell you, this guy b6makavelithugz is like "no like Sham". :D fucking predictable. Yeah south would be part of Egypt and north would be Syria (bilad al sham). So you want a dictatorship disguised as a muslim caliphate? why didn't you just say that? There is one being started in Sinai and a bigger one in Iraq and Syria. lol
MALEK KHIEREDDINE You are sooo full of shit. Britain built infrastructure, developed its colonies. Listen, every group of people had slaves at one point, its not all Europeans. Africans did it, Asians etc etc. You are so racist and naïve with your comment. its pathetic and illogical. You would be lucky to live in UK, France or Germany. Instead of blaming others because life didn't turn out how you wanted take a look at yourself and improve your situation and adapt
At the end of World War I, the Allies and the League of Nations took 1.2 million square miles of land from the Turks. They divided that land up to create several homelands for various non-Turkish peoples: Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Jordan and Palestine. The official boundaries of these areas also solidified the formation of other distinct and sovereign homelands such as Iran, Saudi Arabia and Egypt. Of the 1.2 million square miles, more than 44,000 square miles were designated as The British Mandate for Palestine. It was in this region that the British had agreed to the creation of a Jewish homeland. This was slightly more than 3% of the total land taken from the Turks. Opponents of Israel usually claim that the Jews received most of the land - 3% is hardly most of the land. The British agreement, which was set forth in the 1917 Balfour Doctrine, stipulated "...that nothing should be done which might prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine..." There was no mention of specific land rights to be granted or guaranteed to the non-Jewish communities within the Jewish homeland. If it was the intention of the British for the Jewish homeland to be merely a religious community within a much larger muslim State it would not have been necessary to stipulate Jewish protection of muslim civil and religious rights. However, of the 44,000 square miles of The British Mandate for Palestine, 33,000 was then chopped off and given to the muslim arabs under the governorship of Abdullah, a Hashemite family leader from Arabia. This land was re-named "Trans-Jordan" (now called Jordan), and placed off-limits to Jews. The League of Nations formalized this division in their Mandate For Palestine of July 1922. The League of Nations' Mandate included the same stipulation made in the Balfour Doctrine "...that nothing should be done which might prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine..." Again, there was no mention of specific land rights to be granted or guaranteed to the non-Jewish communities within the Jewish homeland, and no indication that the Jewish homeland was to exist within a dominant muslim State. At this point just 11,000 square miles was left for a Jewish homeland; less than 1% of the total land taken from the Turks. If 3% of the land is hardly "most of the land" as some ignoramuses state in their remarks on the subject, then how little is less than 1%? In 1938, the British convened the Peel Commission, which recommended that the 11,000 square miles be further divided to about 3,500 square miles to the Jews and 6,500 square miles to the muslims. The Jews said "okay," but the muslims refused and rioted. Nothing was done. In 1947, the British surrendered its Mandate of Palestine to the United Nations. A UN commission suggested splitting the 11,000 square miles into three zones: Jewish, muslim, and an international Jerusalem. Minus the land to be set aside for an international Jerusalem, 61% of the land was designated for the Jews. About half of the Jewish land consisted of the virtually uninhabited Negev Desert (not at all "most of the best land" as claimed by anti-Israel people). The Jews agreed to the Partition Plan, but the muslims rejected it. However, non-acceptance of the UN Partition Plan by either or both of the parties did not invalidate the UN's Partition Plan, nor did it prevent the British from following through on their decision to remove all military personnel and disengage their oversight by May14, 1948. Had the British decided not to disengage and remove their military, Israel Declaration of Independence might not have occurred or it might have been delayed. In any event, the muslim leadership in Palestine chose to place their future in the hands of the surrounding muslim nations who had promised to conquer all of the land and annihilate all the Jews. The muslim armies attacked en masse on May 15, 1948. Although Israel won the war, some land that was designated for a muslim state was seized by Jordan and Egypt (the west bank and Gaza; respectively). Jordan also seized Jerusalem. These areas were annexed to Jordan and Egypt without any interest of giving the land to the non-aligned muslims to create an independent muslim state. This situation existed for 19 years. After two additional wars in which the muslims, and Jew-haters, hoped to eradicate the Jews and Israel, the current nation of Israel is about 8,500 square miles. So Israel represents about 0.7% of the land taken from the Turks. Considering that the Jewish population of Israel represents approximately 2% of the population living on the land taken from the Turks, it could be said that the Jews have less than half of the land they should have’ on a proportionate basis. Coincidentally, the size of Israel today corresponds very closely to the population division of un-divided Palestine just prior to 1922. Muslim population was 80%, non-muslim 20%. Adding together Jordan, Gaza and west bank cities under muslim control, the muslims have about 81% of the land. Jordan has no Jewish citizens. There are about 1.6 million muslim citizens of Israel, all of whom enjoy full civil and religious rights as hoped for in the Balfour Doctrine. Jordan is about 4 times the size of Israel with 25% fewer people. So, other than how insane, ignorant Jew-haters interpret history, and wish to portray current conditions, the truth is quite different.
You left out the part where from 1890s to 1948, the Zionist bought lands from Arabs holders to build settlements. The first Kibbutz (communities) were estblished by 1910. By the time the British arrived in 1917, there were already jewish settlements up and down the coastline, and a thriving economy. All that happened was that both Jewish and Arab migration increased under the British. When you say that the British gave 3% of the land to the Zionists, people get confused and think wrong. They think that the British took land property away from the Arabs and gave it to the Jews. That's not what happened. What the British and UN did was divide the region into sovereign statehoods so countries could be formed. Arabs, Christians or any other non-Jew who wanted to be part of Israel still retained their land holdings and became Israeli citizens. There has never been a Palestinian people, culture, nation state, kingdom, or tribe until Arafat started using the term in 1962. Before that you were either Jordanian Arab, Egyptian Arab or Israeli Arab, at least post 1948. I've literally known Palestinians who were alive back in 1967 and even said, "One moment, I am Jordanian. Then, all of a sudden, I was now Palestinian." The idea of an Arab statehood was a European introduction post WW1. Before that, Arabs only identified themselves in the following order. Tribe! Village! Religion (Village can also be town or city)! There was no Palestinian recognition as a people. As an area in the Middle east named by the Romans, yes. But not as a people. Palestinian was more of a Western outsider term to describe the area and people before the 1960s. The entire area has always been under occupational control as its been one of the most repeatedly conquered regions in all of human history. Each empire has brought settlers to Palestine, which is how Arabs got there (being a culture from Arabia). But what most people don't realize, and I am just stating facts, is that the Zionists are the only settlers who didn't take the land by conquest of war. They purchase their way in, buying land from other Arabs, and then used their numbers and political influences to build a nation state.
@@mollysmeow3455 Even if some land was designated for Jews in Europe, the land of Israel would still be our homeland. For over 2000 years we have faced Jerusalem 3 times a day and prayed to return there. Anywhere else, even if under Jewish self-governance, would still be foreign land that we were exiled to. I don’t consider myself a Zionist politically speaking, as my goal is not necessarily a Jewish-run government. My connection with the land and the people is a religious and spiritual one. What I insist upon is for all Jewish people to be welcome to LIVE and PRAY in PEACE in the land of our forefathers. I don’t mind at all if others were also there doing the same thing. If the Arab governments could guarantee me that right I wouldn’t have such a problem with them. My political support for the modern state of Israel is pragmatic in nature. The current Israeli government is welcoming to the Jewish people and a potential Palestinian government would not be.
@@mollysmeow3455all the important archeological sites for Jews are in Israel. Their Holy ground is there. Likewise for Christians. Jews and Christians mostly get aling very well now. They can coexist. But muslims can not coexist well with anyone.
As a completely non-biased Romanian, I find this guy that is doing the interview or however you call it, really really ignorant. He keeps pressuring them into answering what he wants to hear, and when he doesn't get the answer he wanted he leaves lol... Those people outclassed you big time.
You do know that you are only seeing clips from a larger recording right? I'm sure there were much broader discussions taking place. I'm sure most of it wasn't interesting. It didn't seem like he pressured anyone. He did throw some opinion in there, but I don't think the interviews were poorly done.
Considering how brutal Romania was to the Jews prior to WW2 I can’t take your opinion seriously especially since my family was killed there and now live in US and Israel.
You have to look back to WW1 when the Arabs allied with Britain in 1915 to fight the Ottomans on the condition that the Arabs would have their lands and independence after the war, including Palestine. Britain agreed but went back on their word when they issued the Balfour Declaration in 1917 and encouraged European Jews to move into Palestine instead. So for over 30 years the Arabs have tried diplomacy and protests for the land that was promised to them. And instead the UN gave 56% of Palestine to the Jews who made up only 32% of the population and owned less than 6% of the land. The only logic is to reject such a proposal because it forced so many Palestinians from their homes, but even after rejecting, it did not matter and the UN went through with the partition anyway. Look up the letter to the NYTimes in 1948 that Albert Einstein signed, where he makes comparisons of an Israeli political party to that of Nazism and Fascism. He knew it was wrong to take someone else's land and displace them.
Because Jews want a state based on their religion, so based in their beliefs of a God. Palestinians are mixed group of people of many religions who lived on their land until the Zionists arrived because the UK decided that would be a great idea. Why should Palestinians be like "ooh you want some land because Churchill promised it to you? Sure take it! You Buddhists also want some? Sure, come, we don't care!" This is colonization, a project of the British and the Zionist Jews coming from Europe and the US.
At the end of the day the two state solution was an excuse to steal a land by using religion. If Zionists really wanted two states, they would never start illegal settlements. They would stop using violent laws against Palestinians. They would stop bombing Gaza. They would stop killing to gain more land and cancel Palestinians from their country. But this is not happening, so now we know they have never entered to be guests: they wanted all the land to themselves from the beginning.
@@madjames1134 No it isn't. The Hijaz is Arabia. Israel is in the Levant, not in Arabia. Notice how you have to make up stuff out of whole cloth to defend the Palestinian narrative. Why do you think that is?
when they were speaking about the family that were burned did u see how he tried to brush it off and make his idea of what happened seme like the reality
If it's the case I'm thinking of, the Jewish settler that did the fire bombing admitted doing it, and laughed about it. I saw him on an interview, after he served his 3 months in jail.
@@MrKT410 Well Arabic is entirely Semitic. Somehow your comment made it seem like you were saying Arabic isn't Semitic, which would be a total falsehood. "Hebrews" likely were some form of Canaanite themselves since there is no evidence of a widespread invasion or devastating conflict in the region during that time period. Likely they were native Canaanites themselves that just splintered religiously.
@@navotshiener4503 Exposing what? Even the jew who is asking questions asks what about the jews around the world who came here after 1948. Look what jews are doing to immigrants in USA and u can't just because your tora tells you that this is the promised land and u are the chosen people and above all just justify it. But if a person is not ashamed of this fact then they won't understand anything especially when they think that they are the chose people who are the best humans.
no hes not, muslims dont belong on that land. the muslims have history going back their 1000 years, but the hebrews have history going back their 4000 years. GOD gave the hebrews that land. that is only the facts. I am a Roman catholic and we will support isreal jews no matter what
@@ramboyman1010 my great grandfather was from Iraq but that doesn't mean he owns the entire country of Iraq nor does that makes me Iraqi you know Jacob wasn't living there all by himself they were other people too so the jew's can't claim the entire contry just because their ancestors lived there once
Congratulations to the interviewer for having the courage to ask such a thorny question in a land of conflict. Not only that, he uploaded it for all of us with Internet access to watch it for free of charge.
All the people here who are critical of Palestinians for not forgiving Israelis- has Israel ever apologised for what they've done? Have they asked for forgiveness? Have they acknowledged any culpability at all, ever?
if there was a country called palestine before then thats fair. but there wasnt. there was just repeated history of arabs attacking jews, even wayyyy before 1948 (including with literaly arab leaders meeting h*tler). the land was a mandate, before just empire after another. and with 7 peace offers all being refused by the palestinians and replied by more terrorism (which is the reason for the israeli checkpoints), i dont know what else do you expect from israel. ofc its not an easy life for the palestinians but israels priority should always be its own citizens (since the palestinians in the palastinian areas have their own leadership with their own laws)
Perhaps that is a good pont. But have the arabs ever apologised for prosecuting and not allowing freedom of religion (not by law but in practise) for Christians in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Saudi, Nigeria etc? No, instead there is virtually no church or temple in Saudi Arabia while muslims demanding full rights in western countries. How can this freedom of religion only go one way? That is not a way to live together in peace.
@@sapiruwu3799 lol. well take this: At a 1956 funeral for an Israeli soldier killed by Palestinians in Gaza, Gen. Moshe Dayan, one of Israel’s most famed military leaders, advised the following: _Let us not cast the blame on the murderers today. Why should we deplore their burning hatred for us? For eight years they have been sitting in the refugee camps in Gaza, and before their eyes we have been transforming the lands and villages, where they and their fathers dwelt, into our estate._
@UmaU-pg1mx first source? Second quotes from random ppl don't mean too much. Ppl here have a lot of empathy, sometimes too much. Look up how the 'refugee camps' of gaza looked like before this war. Not to even mention that in 1956 gaza belonged to Egypt so if gazan suffered there is because Egypt didn't give a shit about them. It's also funny you mention that cuz in gaza before 1948 war you had jewish villages that were there for thousands of years and they got kicked out of them too, but instead of trying to get revenge they built a new life. Another point I want to mention is that when you start a war, youight lose, and the arabs started a war and lost. Hundreds of millions of ppl got displaced through out the 40s yet only 'Palestinians ' (I say that considering they started to call themselves that only in the 60s) never moved on, started war after war, and kept losing.
The person who asks questions always seems to load his questions and find faults in palestinian videos but claims he is trying to be neutral when same happens in isreli videos.
Big Mofo i just learnt that he was israeli. Initially I just saw his videos and noticed this trend. But then i found out that he was israeli when he was asking swedish people if they thought that sweden generally supported israel. He started each question with "so, i am from israel". That was the wrong way to start such a question. He might as well have held a gun to their heads.
Big Mofo coincidences do not occur so many times. Logically and scientifically, there is no such thing. Learn to spot patterns, it could save YOUR life. Learning to call everything that isn't a coincidence a coincidence won't save my life, it would further endanger it. Better safe than sorry. And this isn't even a life or death situation so stop the drama.
![BOWKYLION - วิงวอน (ex-change) [Official MV]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/cLdnZWDaO-w/mqdefault.jpg)
Don't make it personal when you're asking questions. You're not getting honest answers like that
it was off topic
But it really makes people think of the implications of their opinions.
Donald Trump Jr. Jr. IF TALKING ABAUT POLITIC EVER STOP ABAUT THIS PROBLEM BETWEEN ISRAEL AND PALESTINIAN.
I am not sure but Trump may fulfill the prophecies of Bible, Quran and Torah and may help Israel to shift its capital to the Holy city of Jerusalem .
@@saketmishra4332 lol fairy tales
18 months in Iraq, I asked my interpreters [very educated men] if they had ever heard of the Holocaust/Shoah. None of them had. We got on the internet & looked at a few films/articles. they were speechless
Non holocaust
Maybe because of your brutal sanctions for 12 years iraqi young generation did not get a proper education.
Isolated from all the world not even russia and iran had this kind of sanctions
Ironic. I was born in Iraq, and my cousins who range between the ages of 13-20, all have at least some understanding regarding the holocaust.
That is a decent point to raise, and I do not know the context of why you were living in Iraq for an 18 month period, but it sounds like you were there long enough to understand context, and you should really explain the context that information may have been suppressed because of what America and Britain had done installing and propping up a government comprised of ethnically Jewish people. It does not mean it is right, but gives background as to what has happened in that region by colonial powers thousands and thousands of miles away.
@@ragoosh No the people are kept ignorant, I'm South African and I know about the Holocaust because it was a great evil perpetrated on humanity and it was a part of a World War. If that is not taught then your education is deficient and people from that region speak out of ignorance.
He casually said "doesn't matter" to a Palestinian family being burned alive...?
There's a reason why he said that....
@@taaha4532 which is??
Might sound stupid but it's true! Arabs have been getting killed this way for years and years so people are "kind of" getting used to it :/
@@taaha4532 OK now I get what you mean. Sad but true.
Any evidences?
After watching many of your videos, peace still has a long way to go
Interviewer: there was no France 300 years ago
England: *so who tf was I at war with*
Old Regime :)
Frankia
Well depends what you mean. French revolution was 200 years ago.
The Ancient Regime.
1. The First Republic (1792-1804) Following the aftermaths of the Revolution of 1789 and the abolishment of the monarchy, the First Republic of France is established on September 22 of 1792.
in my opinion, I have no problem with living with jews if u don't know Muslim can marry jews yes
as long as the person is cool and good with me but not saying like I will kill him cause he said a bad thing to me
it's like crossing the line like the Israel govt I have Hindu friends I have Christian friends talking to each other for months years with no problem
but it doesn't mean I will throw out the jews from the country but it will be a hard thing for them cause the jews will start the same thing as Muslim people to claim the situation it might take YEARS
Idk why he did the interview if he’s just gonna be biased and say no all the time. He even said it doesn’t matter to the guy when he talked about the whole family being killed.
The people who murdered the family should be punished. But saying you're gonna generalize a whole group, race etc because of that is crazy
he said "that's not what happened" then said it doesn't matter, meaning they were going on a tangent and he wanted to recenter the discussion
You really just hear what you want to hear.
Because your religion is so idiotic and un eductaional, most of you don't even know basic english, you just so fucking brainwashed, people there is like "yea lets throw every jew to the sea 😃" but after 3 minuts they will be like "those zionist are so bad and racist 😡".
@@lironcohen2938 “un eductaional”? but “our religion” doesn’t teach English? WHAT RELIGION IS MEANT FOR TEACHING A LANGUAGE? it be the dumb ones like you..
"France didn't exist 300 years ago"
French history: 😀
Yeah like what the fuck??😂
There are French in Canada
Which make them france citizens
@@zubairrahman3679 stop saying shit, its because you speak french that your are a citizen of France. They are canadian (québécois precisely)
I’d consider the Monarchy and the Republic to be two different entities
@@TrueStoriesTH-cam Taking about that jewish guy logic. Merci
Gus was making some extremely good points and it seemed like whoever was recording was trying to dismiss a lot of his information. He was literally giving examples that happened in recent times (like the family being burnt alive). I noticed when some other people were starting to make some good points too and the videographer kind of either says "doesnt matter" or cuts the video off.
Like the fact Israel was established as the Jewish home country 3200 years ago
Yeah because he has an agenda. He is Zionist 🙄
@@gcanada3005yeah that’s a long long time ago. How many generations of other cultures lived there and developed a functioning society which Zionists felt some HOLY RIGHT to destroy. Just because Jews were prosecuted doesn’t mean they are so holy that they can claim a land for spritual purposes. Imagine if the whole world started making claims to their ancestral lands!?!? Yeah… look out Texas, New Mexico, every other state and Canadá….
@@gcanada3005 The Palestinians will say that they are descendants of the Canaanites. They will never admit the facts because they would lose the "original natives" argument.
@@r.c.4119 They are as a group as uneducated as they are violent
The interviewer is himself biased and has no sense of how to conduct an interview.
Yes bro , he is trying to promote hatred among these youth .
yeah this was absolutely stupid, extreme bias and he wasn't even making valid points
I think he did a good job in identifying a common perspective among Palestinians, in showing that many do not want Jews living in their ancestral homeland Israel. Archaeological evidence would point to the fact that Jerusalem was Jewish long before it was Muslim or Palestinian.
@@timfrench9545 Then let's ship back all the white people back in Europe from the USA, South America and Australia by that logic.
pahari Dewan my point is Jewish people have the right to live in their ancestral homeland. I didn’t say anything about sending anyone back to Europe. What exactly is the point your trying to prove?
"'There was no France 300 years ago..'' The interviewer is flailing a bit.
glenemma1 Jesus loves you
@@jairchavira8212 okay...thanks for that.
@أحمد المنصور
Yes, I agree.
@SafeSpace Post "France has always been French"
Before the overthrow of the monarchy in 1793, the Kingdom of France was simply defined as whatever the ruling monarch of the Frankish aristocracy owned ...common ethnicity, language, or culture need not apply.
E.g. when the First Republic was founded, probably only half (or so) of the population even spoke the erstwhile King's French ...instead, it was a myriad hodgepodge of different people without much in the way of a shared tradition other than being ruled by the same jackass and his relatives in Versailles.
The history of Europe, even up to relatively modern times, has been one of intense tribalism and regionally distinct cultures that don't at all correspond to modern national borders.
@SafeSpace Post Since you are apparently quite stupid, I'll repeat what I wrote earlier:
The history of Europe, even up to relatively modern times, has been one of intense tribalism and regionally distinct cultures that don't at all correspond to modern national borders.
...now, here's the parallel to be made, pay close attention: replace "Europe" with the Levant and the point should be quite clear:
Whether stating "France has always been French" or "Palestine/Israel has always been Jewish" ...it's all folly. *Ethno-states are folly in regions with no history of ethnic homogeneity*
So you can take your ethno-state bullshit and choke on it ...the Palestinians and Israelis sure have, to their mutual detriment.
"Frankish, Gauls, Celts, you know, the ones who have been there for thousands of years."
More bullshit from you:
Franks, a culturally Germanic tribe, established themselves in the migration era (in roughly 5th century), and various "Celtic" tribes had been migrating in and out of Gaul prior to it being conquered by the Romans who, of course, left their own enduring linguistic and cultural influence there.
Hellenic settlers had also been living in Gaul for many centuries by then, as had Basque and Iberians in the South and South West. And that's really just the tip of the iceberg,
e.g. in the late 18th century, just over 1000 years after the founding of the Kingdom of France under Charles II, only half (or so) of the population even spoke "French."
...so what part of *heterogeneous* has you fucking confused?
Everybody gangsta until the Palestinian from California starts talking. 😎
Indeed 🤣🤣🤣 the only sane person with sane ideas
That Californian is obviously travelled and knowledgeable of cohabiting with different people's. He is more balanced. The others sound like extremists in their thinking. Interviewer isn't interviewing though. He is trying to make the palestinians seem racist or stupid but it's backfired.
@Kason Joziah No we don't now stop spamming.
He said Jews have no tradition and culture...
@@ayoubkaboul3548 its true u just take other countries where u where culture dont forget jews were nomads
Did you hear the interviewer on the family being burned? The Palestinian said they caught the people , the guy behind the camera said no they didn’t then said whatever and moved to another question like the family being burnt means nothing to him. Wow
the power of state run propaganda
yeah I noticed that but the guy he was speaking to (The Palestinian) was calm and spoke with confidence.
Israeli are only happy when it benefit their agenda. They don't want to hear the truth when lies are benefiting them.
no he didn't, he let him talk, he just said he was in custody for 6 months and it hadn't been proven yet!
No offense; That is what happens when they see you as like a wild animal. What happens to someone who kills a group of wild animals? They show up in the news and pass away.
Interviewer is way too confrontational, argumentative, and aggressive. The guy from California made him look like a chump.
Interviewer is just terribly biased.
@@tuub1281 Corey is unbiased in one video he will be questioning jews with Talmud verses in another video he will be questioning Palestinians about 1947 Israel
@@Alexander-vm2ox What?
@@silossilos1927 He isn't askimg tough questions, he's literally being a biased prick who doesn't even seem to be interested in the answers. He should find himself a new job as this isn't what journalism is about.
@@tuub1281 Havent seen much of the channel yet, but I have seen him in some other vids to ask difficult questions to Israelis and they also stumble on their own answers
So how does that make you biased? Who is he favoring?
4:43 That guy just ended your whole career. This channel is a joke
@@snan9402 The questions were a bit one-sided though he may have wanted to throw light on views from both sides.
i don't see him ending his whole career. doesn't seem like it. Jews have stayed in israel for thousands of years.
@Maizer Effendi Sure, i agree but this is their land. It always was. The guy there didn't end anyone's career by saying that that land belongs to palestinians. he couldvé said something else like idf brutality but saying that it was always palestinian land made no sense. It was the land of jews for thousands of years. mohammed came 1400 years ago and invented his own religion
No France 🇫🇷 300 years ago 🤭
@@snan9402 he tried to manipulate the guy to say something to gain views and failed, the guy is a instigator but regardless YOU are the idiot for not seeing that.
Dude your previous video was about asking people where their grandparents were from and over 95% of them said latin american countries or europe. And now you dispute this kid with braces when he says the same? You're a hypocrite bro.
DarkBungleX I agree completely. (I'm serious)
+TechnocraticBushman There is no occupation. The PA runs the Arab areas of the West Bank and Hamas runs Gaza. King Hussein runs Jordan which is 70% of the area known as palestine. The vast majority of palestinian Arabs roots in Israel go back no further than the Jews do.
+DarkBungleX As it is mentionned in the Video, Jews were in palestine before Israel was created, and it was all fine, so the past tells us you are wrong. the current people says you are right (certainly out of animosity) , we can take the example of Iran's jews (omg jewish's devil), whom, as I m writting this comment, are living all fine among iranese, but hey why spread a good news about a country we want to despise?
exactly pretty he was hipocrite
David Cummings Then how come there can be no humanitarian aid sent there? Why all attempts to reach Gaza by sea were stopped by Israel?
What really shocks me is that according to Israeli laws, I, a person who grew up in Russia, who has never practiced Judaism, barely knows what it’s about and has never even been to Israel, but has a Jewish grandma, and my completely non-Jewish boyfriend, if he becomes my spouse, both potentially have more rights to Israeli land than Palestinian people who have lived there for generations. This bit of realization makes me understand Palestinians who don’t want settlers to stay. Why would I be more entitled than they are? How fucked up is that?
This is not there land. And not yours either. Self made Palestine live in Gaza and West Bank. Israel land never belong to them . And yes all of Russian who is most none Jew have to return back to there home land. You made Israel like Russia . I’m originally born in Russia but all of my family Jew. No mix. And my grandmother mama from Jerusalem born . They came to kavkaz and stay because couldn’t back to Palestine in 1930-1937 time . Only we back when Gorbachev came. Some my family use to live in Israel and some in ussr
No.....if you are Jewish and you want to live in Palestinian land like Ramallah, Jenin, Beit Lehem, East Jerusalem or other, you only have the right to chose what cemetery you'll be buried.
Israel is a deferent place and we don't take clueless ppl with all respect to your grandmother.
Read more......and stay safe.
@@fantasticfoodcanada9373 I recommend you go hit the books, how is the land of Palestine, not the Palestinians? you say they live in Gaza and the West Bank but have you seen the map of change in which illegal settlers have slowly taken over, and they still are. Tell me if somebody came to your home and told you to get out it's theirs now would you not fight back, would you not feel animosity, would you not feel oppressed? I recommend you go to Google or any search engine and search up images showing how the Jewish camps slowly took over the lands of the Palestinians not to mention go research how many genocides occurred, it wasn't only displacements and abuse there were countless genocides brought upon the Palestinians. And you're referring to your family being Jewish all right I understand that but the argument that the Israeli State makes is that they are all descendants of the Old Kingdom of Israel and the tribes of Judah, thus that gives them the right to take this land which the Romans took over 2,000 years ago. This is an extremely weak argument considering the majority of those who inhabit the modern state of Israel have no biological ancestor to the Old Kingdom of Israel and the tribes of Judah and are usually Ashkenazi or Sephardim Jews. Contrary to that argument many Palestinians are direct descendants of Jews from the Old Kingdom of Israel and the tribes of Judah. Being of the same religion doesn't make you the descendant of that group. And if we were also to work on the same argument that the Israeli state uses, which is "this was our land 2,000 years ago and we deserve to have it back", you can easily Uno reverse card this argument by saying, so why not give the land back to the Canaanites or the descendants of the Canaanites, and last on my checked majority of those who possess The Descent of the Canaanites are also Arab. So it works both ways. Not to mention I have not denied that there are indeed descendants of the tribes of Judah, but they are a small minority. Finally, an argument that zionists like to make is that God has given this land to the children of Abraham, when you think of the children of Abraham you have to think of The Descendants of Abraham, who are the two major Semitic groups of Abraham's descent? Arabs and Jews, not just any Jews and not just any Arabs those who have the Descent of Isaac or Ishmael. This also goes as being called anti-Semitic, it's a pathetic thing to be hating on Jews because they practice their religion but when somebody starts throwing around the word anti-Semitic it loses everything. Considering Arabs and Jews are Semitic ethnicities. And I'm talking about the Jews who descend from Isaac.
The reason why Palestinians in so-called Palestinian territories don't have an Israeli citizenship is because their parents or their parent's parents fleed (or were pushed out, but those were a minority) during the Arab revolt of 1948, or came with the land Israel conquered during the 1967 war.
"Shocking". When you hear these people what do you expect from Israel? To let in people that will do 10/7 again and again? Would you let in people that live close to you and threatens to butcher and rape your entire community? Why it's not a big deal when Jews can't live in Iraq, Syria, Lebanon, Yemen?
This interviewer just embarrassed himself 💀
th-cam.com/video/jbWGm-ARaSk/w-d-xo.html
hes not trying to "get them " hes just asking and listening.
its the same questions every time its not an interview its a poll.. the amount of idiots on here is astounding.
@@gorash100 thats exactly what he is not doing,he shows his bias everytime he is not “listening”to them hes kinda looking to have arguments with them
@@maher.itorer I don’t think so, he has videos asking similar questions to Israelis this is just what he does on his channel
To the interviewer:
In light of your saying at 14:27 that there were 600,000 Jews present before 1948, I'd say the Palestinian boy's guess of half a million descendants of those Israelis at 1:10 deserved less of a dismissive attitude from an unbiased interviewer no?
That's actually true!
Damm I didn’t notice that. Good call out 👍🏼
The Palestinian guy was correct, but to be accurate, the interviewer was saying *descendants of* people born before 48 are "most Israelis" (I don't have the numbers for this). But in any case, it's not actually an easy clear cut thing of "pre-1948" - that's adopted by a lot of people here out of pragmatism. But the reality was that a huge number of Jews who had migrated to Palestine before 48 did so under conditions of British military occupation (i.e. post-1918) and a denial of Palestinian self-determination. In other words, the Palestinians didn't have a say in the mass migration that happened, and in fact, the mass migration was facilitated in part to set up a British-allied polity in the region that counterbalanced against the Arabs - it wasn't a matter of pure humanitarian impulse (Balfour for instance was a huge anti-Semite). Conversely though, that is complicated by the fact that I generally favour free movement of people, especially that Jews were suffering heavy persecution at the time (and indeed, Muslim lands had been historically open to such Jewish refugees). In short, you had a situation of a coloniser (Britain) facilitating the mass migration of a persecuted people (Jews) in part to facilitate the persecution of another people (Palestinians).
And all that, in turn, is made even more complicated by the fact that a large number of the migrants would have been ideological migrants affiliated with the Zionist movement; i.e. their plan was to create a state there at the expense of the Palestinians, and they would have supported Israel in 1948. Then you have another large number who would have been refugees fleeing the horrors of the Holocaust etc. (and of course, a lot of those would have supported Israel too). Then you have later Jewish refugees who came into Israel *after* 1948 because they were kicked out of Arab countries (Egypt, Iraq, Yemen) after the Nakba.
So this idea that "all Jews" who were in Palestine before 1948 were living lovey dovey with the Palestinians or "weren't Zionists" - as if Zionism began in 1948 - is false. For sure, a lot of Jews did have historically positive relations with the Palestinians, but these tended to be the older, Arabised settled ones - rather than the newer European migrants. On the other hand, the notion that all Jews who migrated to Palestine were all fanatical Zionists etc. is also false - a lot were refugees. A further complexity is where these two overlap - i.e. you're a Zionist because you're a persecuted refugee, and the solution to your problem is to come at the cost of creating another problem.
The complexity with Zionism is that it was both a) an exclusionary, racialist settler-colonial movement (from the very start) that looked down upon Palestinians, long before 1948 - its project was structurally exclusionary of the people who would become its neighbours from its 19th century beginnings (even during the Ottoman Empire, Zionist Jewish migrants would buy lands from absentee landowners and expel Palestinian tenant farmers, and refuse to hire them); and b) that it was nonetheless rooted in a very real and undeniable context that Jews weren't safe in most places they lived in. Nonetheless, it was actually a fringe movement within European Jewry up until the Holocaust - until then most Jews belonged to left-wing, anti-Zionist groups.
@@os17312 yo thanks for that answer, gives me a lot to research for myself! :)
@@os17312 and I acknowledge he was talking about the descendants specifically, for which the exact numbers are more difficult to tally or find. But exactly for that reason, the boy’s uneducated guess FWIW should not be dismissed so summarily.
"...300 yrs ago there was no France in Europe." Really? Are you sure of that...?
When he said that it really threw me off. Especially when he said there was no france but still french people. I was like wtf?
Late 18th century was when the Republic of France was first founded. Prior to that it was a Kingdom. At least I think that's what he's talking about.
@Durv Teixeira
La France existe au moins depuis Clovis! France has been around since before King Saint Louis! 300 years ago? That was the time of d'Artagnan and the Three Musketeers. Much later than Emperor Charlemagne! At that time, France had already been around for many centuries. Il y a des gens qui racontent n'importe quoi. L'Histoire n'est pas bien enseignée dans les pays anglophones. Ils ne s'intéressent qu'au commerce, au business. English speakers are taught very little about History, culture, and humankind as a whole. Their curriculae put too much emphasis on trade and business, hence their disregard of universal civilisation. Pity that the US and the UK are major powers today, because they are making a mess of the world!
@@norben1162 I am well aware of what we are speaking about. I was merely positing a reason why someone might think France wasn't around 300 years ago. And the truth is because modern day France WASN'T around 300 years ago!
Like 2 sentences before he says that, the guy asks "When was Israel established?" and if you Google "france established" you get the date July 14, 1789. So 300 years ago modern day France didn't exist just like Gaul doesn't exist today and the Kingdom of France no longer exists today!
Plus, he then says "but there were still French people" but no one in Gaul called themselves a French person. And Francia means land of the Franks, so I'm not even sure if people there referred to each other as anything other than Franks until modern times!
France like most European countries was a viking/pagan colony at one point
Thank you for exposing yourself as a Zionist, it really saved me from accepting your portrayal of Palestinians as unbiased.
Imagine only hearing waht you wanted to hear, must be a new for of selective deaf.
I like the guy from 5:00 to 10:00. He is simply coolly discussing and didn't put personal emotion into it.
"A guy killed him, didn't matter"
💯💯
He lives in US, maybe he has less stakes in the century old conflict... somehow
Agree. Interviewer trying to pick a fight
@@HellYeah223 travelling, including the USA has given him many examples of indigenous peoples been kicked off their land and/or made into 2nd degree citizens. In there own land! If only the Israelis had been fair and equal with the Palestinians. Israelis had the opportunity to build a peaceful union with the Palestinians. But as shown all over the word. If men can dominate they will.
Until this moment I believed peace was possible, when people are brought up on hate and lies ... I fail to see how peace is possible 😢
It is not. I used to believe in the 2 state solution but palestinians have ALWAYS rejected it so only WAR can settle this. NOW hamas is getting their war. I feel ZERO sympathy for the palestinians as so many on here advocate the murder of all Jews.
Unfortunately, the hate is on both sides...
@@WhoReallyCares917 not true, check his video "how much do you hate the Palestinians" and the video "how much do you hate the Israeli's" it will become very clear the hate is only on 1 side.
@@WhoReallyCares917Shut up. Sick of misinformed people like you and your false equivalencies.
@ss-xy2im
I guess when you are the occupier, you have the luxury to have that view....
I will use the last 50 years of history to form mine!
We are watching!
“It doesn’t matter”
Just showed your true colors
do you know how to read subtitles
Do you know how to understand the context ?
@@regularman3153
The context is what sucks
Yeah I heard doesn’t matter Oop
Im talking about the second one
Not the first “It doesn’t matter”
Looks like this will never end. 😢
bro theres a palestinian guy who has an israeli girlfriend so dont generalize
@@ruinsfnbr776yes there are many, are you new to the world or what? say your point already
The amazing Lack of knowledge comes from the amazing Submission of quaran.
They just told you how to end this.
as long as there is occupation there will be resistance!
There’s definitely a difference between Zionism and Judaism, the interviewer isn’t right on that
Perhaps he's a Zionist who is insecure about other's opinion about his ideology therefore not accepting it.
@Canadian Gintleman I certainly don't need eudcation from you because you have a very biased approach and you are ALL OVER THE PLACE!!! Your comment is pure hatred towards muslims. Enlighten yourself!!! Especially someone who lives in Canada shouldn't have such narrative.
Joey Blow thanks for pointing that out. Zionism is a secular movement and ideology, has nothing to do with judaism.
The jews are working on getting all criticism of "Zionism" or the Israeli state labelled as "anti-Semitism" or racism. The whole Zionist=Jew thing is something which the special interest lobbies are working on here in the U.S.
Of course Judaism and Israel are intricately tied. Just crack open a Bible for crying out loud. Even in the Quran it says that Israel was meant for a state of the Jews. If you consider yourself religious, but advocate otherwise you’re a heretic IMO. You have a stronger argument if you’re a secularist and argue that there should be no religious affiliated states at all. However, there too, I think you should start with the Muslim and Christian nations that vastly outnumber Israel before targeting the 1 tiny Jewish state.
The guy at 4:43 is actually really intelligent and well mannered
He said the complete truth and nothing but the truth and I admire him for it.
The producer sounded like a kid, like tucker carlson of fox news. Losing his shit with his heart beating fast even though he was the one asking the questions.
You man he can speak a perfect California 'merican english? They all seem well mannered to me. This is a problem born out of Zionism, Rothschild money and ignorance fed into the ears of Brits who knew nothing of history. Now it's perpetrated by American Christian Zionists and settlers from the US who are well taken care of. the Natufians were the original inhabitants. The Amazigh. The Bedouin and Mizrahi never left and find out how they've been treated since 1948.
Az Plasma so smart he doesn't know what zionism is...
Az Plasma so smart he doesn't understand who started the atrocities.
The guy at 4:50 completely destroyed him with facts and logic
nah
@@Pk_1911 nAh
@@interestingcommentbut....7378 he's good but not completely destroyed.
@AV Mendenhall Yes, the ebony skin and curly hair jews not blue-eyed and blonde "jews" who don't have a drop of blood from the first ones.
Yeah the interviewer had literally no comeback
Guys, it looks like these people were made for war. It will never end, unfortunately. Peace ✌️🕊️
No peace with that kind of shallow thinking
Yep, it's ingrained in their religion
@@Jayladeit’s ingrained in all Abrahamic religions.
If they had the native Americans mentality, they wouldn’t exist today, israel only understands the language of force
funny how the interviewer couldn't handle a westernized Palestinian's prospective
Abu Obaid Alshamrani funny how a WESTERNIZED Palestinian says Jews have no traditions- racism much?
@@CryptocurrencyInsider whats your culture if you take your religious practices and not count it? Flafel? Hummus? come on
@@CryptocurrencyInsider no matter how "westernized" you might think palis are.... racism and naz ism are the basis of their culture.
@@abuobaidalshamrani7810 Falafel and Hummus? Wow - such progress. Have some Nobel prizes on us.
@@CryptocurrencyInsider no one denies that, i was just pointing out the consequences of people being born in Diaspora, don't feel insulted.
Once someone is conditioned with hate, it's difficult for them to change. Same as conditioned with racism.
I don’t understand people who were expecting palestinians to not hate Israelis? Of course colonised people tend to hate their colonisers, what’s surprising about that?
Well, unless my glasses need cleaning, they are clearly not the brightest! A low quotient of the stuff that matters comes with a laundry list of negative traits it inflicts on society, and right at the top of the list, in terms of its negative impact, is an increased propensity for violence and predatory aggression. Watch those ferals parading Shani Louk (legs broken, her father said) through the streets of Gaza in the back of a pickup truck, or listen to a son brag to his *proud* parents how he killed Jews with his own hands, or listen to a soldier describing the moment he found a baby that had been put in an oven and its parents shot (after they were forced to watch?), to understand what the civilised world is dealing with.
@@macclift9956why are you repeating lie over another lie? Problem with you “civilised” people, your racism runs so deep that you convince yourself that your violence is good because it is against savages and their violence is terrorism.
I don't agree with that. Redemption is something that can always be obtain but it requires a cold hard look at reality. There's a song called Amazing Grace. Listen to it sometime.
Well said. Israel needs to stop being racist.
This Palestinian guy who is from California said it all!..👍🏻
That is unfortunately Islamic mentality! Growing up at the mercy of United States, but faithful to enemies of Christians and Jews. Isnt the other guy ashamed to say he is an American citizen yet support terrorists?
@@viv4060 A terrorist to you could be very much a freedom fighter to him. Its a matter of which side you're on. Its all in the grey man (speaking very specifically for the Palestinians. FUCK ISIS THO lol), You can't pick which side is wrong exactly reality dont work in the black and white no more.
@@viv4060 Zionists are terrorist
@@viv4060 zionists are terrorists
@@viv4060 no.. mentality is not islamic or cathotholic or jewish....
2:07 "they tortured him for six months"
I hope everyone can see _why_ a lot of these Palestinians are unwilling to share a country with Israelis. Of course it's not morally right to ethnically cleanse the Israelis, but I think we have to see the interviewees' views in the context of what they've been subjected to on a massive scale for many years. Peace will not happen as long as Israel continues its gross injustices against Palestinians.
actually I'm watching this to confirm my bias that palestinians are never going to be alright with a two state solution, they want to either kill or expunge the jews to canada@@user-je7gf5uc3c How ignorant you must be to think everyone is on your side.
@@Dworblackwhat you mean do what the Israelis have done and continue to do to the Palestinians every single day?
though i understand where you are coming from, most israeli (and we all lost ppl to terrorist attacks done by palestinians and had to endure missle threats) say that if palestinians will want peace there will be no problem living with them or having their own country or whatever they would prefer. if both side - all they see is agression yet the majority of one side still wants peace with them then i dont think you can excuse a behavior like that.
Since America likes them so much. Move Israel to a state and give that away.
😂
As a french dude, i am glad to learn that france did not exist 300 years ago 😂
He meant the republic of France
France the country did not exist but the french people existed... 😂😂😂
what about the Franks and Frankish empire you idiot.... that’s the origins on france and the french dating back over a millennia....
mdrr
@@scud100
France as a country did not exist before 300 years ago.
It was, like many modern European countries, made up of tribes with different languages, Basque, Occitan etc
France did exist 300 years ago
Yes.i think your history is weak
And before also
True, but the idea was correct - France didn't always exist
Yeah and now france belongs to one of the many islam countrys
@@AmitB France didn't always existed, but it's not a made up country with less than a hundred years who killed the autochthonous populataion and spoiled their rights, pushed them to live in suburbs and slowing are taking over the rest.
Interviewer needs more practice comes across like he wants to get a negative reaction
He speaks like Charlie Kirk and a lot of right wingers.
Because he does
wrong
@@RedMcc Do you mind elaborating?
The kid telling the Jew that they have no history, no culture in that area is unbelievable.
No history and culture? One of the oldest and richest but the Palestinian completely denies its existence.
About 3% of Israelis are Semitic Jews. The rest are European Jews who have no genetic link to the region
you litrlay don't have culuture
The Salomon temple.
@@seacampal1425 Where is it ??? they sreached and never founed secound i say you don't have culuture and you raelly don't have culuture that sad but true you all are just occupiers with small propaganda
😂. Ig you have. And "European" culture
That California Guy impressed me. I liked his point of view his story and how he told it
@@jordanlavalley the palestinians aren't like native americans. jews are indigenous to the levant, and "palestinian" as a national identity didn't exist until the 20th century. prior to that, the levant had been colonized by romans, then arabs, then ottomans. the situation is in no way analgous.
the california guy clearly doesn't know what he's talking about. jews have no culture? it is literally an ethnoreligious culture.
@@eclecticEntrepreneur he said zionists not Jews. There was peace before, like the treaties between the Jews, Christians and Muslims. But to completely claim a country you’re a guest to causes tension between the people.
@@Visible-jb2ew there is no functional difference between "zionist" and "jew" in this context. the term "zionist" here refers to israeli jews.
He clearly knows nothing about jews or judaism, and he believes in forcing jews to migrate out of their land, which is immoral. At least he didn't believe in killing us :/
08:05 he was telling him about a family burned alive, and he said it doesn't matter!!
Notice how the subtitles said "not for this video"
@@White-rb5ey haha nice one. The editor saw that the interviewer was a complete dogshit asshole when uploading the video so he added a subtitle to make the interviewer less of a heartless asshole
@@yousseftarek5226 But it... really doesn't matter for the sake of the video, it has nothing to do with it.
@@White-rb5ey It really does matter because it shows how Palestinians are being treated as 2nd class citizens and Israel, quite frankly, doesn't care. Now, if Palestinians take back their homeland, won't there be some mixed feelings towards the Zionists who allowed this treatment of Palestinians to be held.
@@yungalmond2529 It has nothing to do with the topic of the video, also Zionists don't "allow" this treatment, how can they stop military personnel from doing something.
CALIFORNIA GUY WAS THE BEST!
Haha he was just vibin. "Really? All of them? Alright man, I'll tell em', but I'm starting to feel bad for this guy."
The interviewer met his match with this guy..very chilled but knew his history..
I love how he was one of the only people that didn't want to kill them or kick them out lmfao
@@ah9034 Dude, can you relax a bit? Jesus Christ. Is it exhausting being so tense all the time? Are you having a bad day?
yeah.. He knows what he's talking about.. there's no prejudice in his words.. just facts... hard facts.
The level of idiocy is astounding
Indeed. The Israeli state matter makes me think of the abortion isssues in law. Can I appeal in a case before a judge at the same time to canonik rulings and to local state rulings? That is getting hard to get a legal coherent discours that leads to a solution by a judge. Wish Moshe and Golda and Kisinger anew sat around the table. This leads really to nothing.
one day in Brussels I shortly met a palestinian from Gaza. He had been besieged by Hamaz and was litterally shot in pieces. He showed me were the bullits entered and came out back again on his belly and his legs. Luckilly he found a job at Duchatelet's armored vehicles in Liège. Still he lived under a bridge. I gave him money and food for the coming days. That was his and also my story. I don't hate jews and I don't hate alestinians. Far from that. The thing is, anyone who visited the holy land in my circle told me theIsreali's are the most unwelcoming nation on earth. Rude to anyone who is not a zionist. My mom happened to had white hair and blue eyes, she was picked out at BenHurion airport and checked out over and over again. That is how things go in Israel. I swore to myself I will never set foot on Israeli soil never ever I would rather die.
the guy in 4:43 : if you see my comment , i love you man
He kept his composure the whole time. Amazing.
A great guy
13
I stayed with a Muslim Palestinian family in Jericho during my last visit to the area and when I asked the father if he was better off now that they were under Palestinian governance instead of Jewish/Israeli administration he said that there was a lot of corruption now and he was better off before. I also knew an Israeli Arab girl in her 20s who I asked would she not be better off in an Arab country rather than in Nazareth under Israeli rule, she said as a female she would not get a bank card with credit so easily as she could in Israel. Not all Arabs want Muslim Arab rule.
Those are minorities
@@mathew1812 Those are suppressed minorities without a voice.
@@scented-leafpelargonium3366 and, these useful idiots make a huge problem. They are not loyal to justice
An anecdote, although interesting, can’t be taken as the general fact. I lived in the Middle East, came from a western culture, and found the low crime very good for me but that’s just my anecdote. I don’t agree with lots of what they do but you can’t imply one race or culture is better than the other. We should be better than that.
There are absolutely some races/cultures that are better than others. What an ignorant comment.
50 seconds in and I’m annoyed of the interviewer. I think he should’ve kept it professional and make it not personal.
Perhaps you could keep your cool when people call for your elimination. And everyone you know. Good luck.
@Maizer Effendi But he has a point here, right?
@@dogbert52 how much is the IDF paying you?
@@Flex2212 howdy, Mr IDF
Trust me, things will always feel personal when you interact with haters no matter how professionally it's dealt (Islamic mentality)
The Moslem gentleman is well spoken and logical in his thought process. He supports his points of contention with examples.
What's a Moslem ?
@@magiclionthe original English word of Muslim before it was changed.
I like how the Palestinian American guy inserted some critical thinking to this thought provoking topic and his points were fair.
He probably did not go to a Palestinian school and it shows.
I really loved his thinking, made me question the zionist jews.
@@emmanuelm8036 jews are good people but Zions aren't
@@Flex2212 your argument is unrelated and thus unimportant
dude read some history this guy was making up shit
"There's no difference between Zionism and Judaism"
wow
I'm not actually sure what the difference is, can u pls explain it to me?
+ColonelCrow Sure. Judaism is, as we know, a monotheistic religion that forms a massively similar theology to both Christianity and Islam, but it preceded both.
Zionism is a political movement that started in the 19th century, that claims that Palestine was promised to Jews by God (many orthodox Jews completely oppose this) and they are therefore entitled to claim the land at any cost. So if you believe Jews have a right to some land, like ISIS believe to be able to steal land and oppress/expel the people within, you're a Zionist.
+Mohamed Ali alright thx. so could you say that Zionism is a fundamentalist/fanatical group of jews?
+ColonelCrow Saying that they're fundamentalist presumes that their political ideology is an amplification of Jewish ideology. Which it isn't, as I explained. Hence, I would argue to the contrary, namely that their injustice and oppression towards the Palestinian people makes them external to Judaism, just like ISIS is contradictory to Islam.
+Abraham ElMasih Evidently, from your vulgar language and uneducated statistic (you're not accounting for the large Kurdish, Turkish and Persian population of the Middle East), you are not to be taken seriously. May God guide you out of the dark side.
That guy at 4:43 has spoken truth to the core and exposed interviewer neutrality too. But I will praise interviewer too for honestly uploading his views.
That's wat I thought too. he completely destroyed the interviewer bias but still this piece was uploaded.
A history of Arab Israel conflict since 1917 th-cam.com/video/G2YqSycDWZ0/w-d-xo.html
He said the Jews will be the guests in “Palestine” like “they’re (Palestinians) now “ and then say the “Palestinians “ are like the native Americans , well who are the leaders now in America ? Natives or immigrants ? And also obviously Israel is a much much different situation but still.
That guy that 'spoke the truth' legit said Jews will not be equal to Palestinians. What did the Israeli Jews do to these people? Wasn't it the Israeli government and the PA and Hamas that caused all of this? How dare you insinuate that this is what should happen it's deplorable.
Secret Circle how can you invade your own home?
You are biased....as an interview you should just get their opinion and cross question them, not force your ideology .
He can't afford those radical and inhumane opinions, by some people who didn't even think about the Question properly, tho just threw their fantasies and shit to the air....
And BTW people who don't understand shit about the conflict or what happened after 1948...
All they belive is that they had a country here before 1948 and then Israel took It and nothing has happened since.
@@lior995 Actually Israelis are just a Family from Palestine so yeah its isrealis land but it Palestinians as well
@@lordwolfking1537
It doesn't contradict that they have no knowledge about the conflict nor intelligence.
I agree that Palestinians and Israelis should work together and control the land in an agreement and not by forces... and terror, like Hamas does
@Jim Vento
And you think Israel does???
Ofcourse Israel takes actions while thinking about civil lifes, but despite all of this, there are always deaths.
IDF soliders can't shot people according to their own minds.
There are clear rules.
First they need to shot at the air in order to threat, and only after that they are allowed to kill, because they won't take the risk of it being a suiciding terrorist...
Hamas fires on civilian inhabitants on everyday bases, and when they kill children, it is a success, unlike it, when Israel does, then that's a mistake which was trying to be prevented.
Lol this is all silly to me. King David ruled over a Jewish nation 3000 years ago. Then 1400 years ago, the Ottoman Empire OCCUPIED our land... then in the 17th century Jews started coming back to their promised land, purchasing land at fair market value, made it beautiful, and now Palestinians want it beck because they became jealous that for 1400 years they did nothing to beautify the land, and in 300 years the Jews beautified it again. There is no “reclaiming what’s ours” for Palestinians. Abraham purchased the land of Canaan, and gave it to the Jewish people. Just because the Quran says Ishmael received the blessing of the land doesn’t make it true. Do your research in Jewish history before you make ignorant comments. All of you...
I like the guy from California. Everything he says makes sense. Though he is way smarter than that aggressive interviewer, he is being very considerate and polite.
exactly he was discrete and honest with his answers, I respect him for his sincerity
He actually said we do not have any traditions.. and rightfully it made the interviewer to stop filming because it was just crazy
@@tomswanable teh california guy stats at 4:41 not before.
You lefties are a trip. “I don’t like the aggressive interviewer because he sounds mean”
Palestinians want to push out and kill Judaism “I like the guy from California, he sounds nice”
You digging that $3.50 a gallon for gas as long as trumps mean tweets are gone 😂 love y’all’s childish mentality.
Palestinian revisionist history thinking the Jews are not indigenous to the land is disregarding historical and archaeological fact. Therefore, the comparison to the Native Americans is inaccurate.
If you disregard the historical claim to the land argument, you’re left with a situation in which the Arab leaders rejected the UN Partition Plan of 1947 (pretty much 60/40 split where Jewish people had 40%). The Jewish people then won the first stage of the 47-48 war against the Palestinians and then the second stage against the neighboring Arab countries. They then defended themselves in subsequent wars and all peace plans were rejected.
Fact is they conquered the land and defended it thus far. Palestinians have every right to keep fighting to reclaim what they think is their land and Israelis have every right to defend. This is just how nations work and unfortunately it doesn’t seem like Palestinian leadership, especially Hamas has its peoples best interest in mind.
The interviewer is so arrogant
Al Quds i would love to shred him with argumentshe states so many wrong facts about both sides
@@polmenakos no he's racist because when israelites said the same words he didn't close the camera and go away
if you lived in country ruled by nazi who killed you in your homes and streets would kiss him I don't think so
I don't say anyone has the right to do this hitler isn't justified
but put yourself in their shoes
I wouldn't expect nothing more from an arab
@Truth Seeker you need to go even more back in time my friend
I like this interview and the answers. For the best part it explains why there isn't a Palestinian state. Apart from the fact that the PLO did state in an interview to a Dutch newspaper that the Palestinian identity exists for political reasons to defeat Zionism.
The young woman was the most cruel one. She is teaching her kids all this hate, they become terrorists and the cycle of violence goes on and on.
It's the war and this culture is all world spread
And Jews are chosen race- can't change it!
it's hard not to feel cruel toward your captors even if it develops into collective rage
Can you blame her? There's not a single Palestinian who lives in Palestine that didn't lose their loved ones
@@4CelciusDegree Israelie shills will blame her all day and acknowledge 0 short-comings from their side.
All you need to see is start at 4:50 truly a man who know what happened.
Mmm. I disagree. There was never a Palestine before. And for many Israelis that is their ancestral land, just as it is for Palestinian people.
Zionism I agree is a little racist. Just like the Koran. My race is better and gets better privileges. NO..My race is better and we should get better privileges.
@@jensmith4411 palestine existed for more than a thousand years now. What you said about ‘israelis ancestral land’ you are referring to the land of jews before Christ. How do you know they are rooted of jews from that time? Many of the jews that live in israel today have immigrated from different parts of the world. For god sake they have Law of Return. Look it up. While Palestinians on the other hand have lived there before the jews decided to move back. It’s like you buy a property today, then you leave for several generations. Others have settled in and all of a sudden your descendants find out you owned the land therefore claims it when someone else was living on it. Make it make sense.
@@ketn0o416 Palestine as a country has not existed for more than a thousand years. Palestine is simply a word given originally by the Greeks (philistine) and the romans (Syria palaestina) for a group of people that settled roughly around modern Palestine, Israel, and jordan, but they never owned the land, they lived alongside many other groups of settlers...such as Israelites. They are not native like many of the people in this video think, they are of Aegean origin and arrived in the region at roughly the same time as the Israelites and other settlers. Both sides of this conflict are simply nationalists trying to claw at whatever they can get in order to justify their actions, Israel-using nativity and their religion, Palestine-using nativity and (essentially) anti-immigration
@@jensmith4411
Where does the Quran teach anything racist??
@@jensmith4411 Koran racist? Bruhhh don’t even.
Go read it from start to finish then speak
There is no division in Islam and no racist can enter heaven in Islamic belief.
Clearly, you don’t know what you're talking about when it comes to the Quran** so please read it before putting such a statement or claim of a holy book that’s cherished by over a billion people.
So speak for yourself and your own faith but don’t go putting another religion faith/holy book into it without reading it whole and knowing what it’s truly about and also spell it right.
Corey i sincerely appreciate you being somewhat unbiased this time, and for the most part actually letting the Palestinians speak and give their opinion
Yes its good, but does sometimes. He is pro-israel
+b6makavelithugz Who knows, let's not assume things that cannot be proven, but he's only one doing this. I have learned so much watching these videos. Damn i can even speak few words hebrew because of these videos lol
+denig Oh, please. It's good for people to have someone who disagrees with them from time to time - keeps them on their toes.
Aarchione i think the Palestinians have enough people disagreeing with them.. and why doesn't he do it with the Israelis then?
+denig Because Israelis tend to make sense.
Palestinian : “The Zionists aren’t the same as the Jews” .
The interviewer was emphatically refusing to recognise that fact (?)
Is this a debate or interview? And why the dude always makes it personal lmao.
He just wants to ask provocative questions to get the worst out of them and paint them like they are the aggressors being kept tame by Israel.
@@govegan6682 he was honest collected and spoke the truth. May Allah protect him ❤️🤲🏻
@Bolshevik Breaker Can someone please tell me why people are using zionist as a bad thing in this era? I mean being a zionist is a great honor, you just don't want to be called anti semetic so you are "anti zionist" and that almost the same thing.
@@lironcohen2938 so your justifying racism? Zionism is racism because zionists stand by Israel not Palestine. Israel shouldn’t even be a thing. You guys are colonizers and think you are right for stealing someone else’s land.
@@salmaaa8776 Haha you can't colonize what is already yours, Israel was always and will be always a jewish land.
ARE YOU SERIOUS?! There’s no difference between Zionists & Jews? This guy represents our community horribly!
the guy is stupid
Hard core Zionists believe that only they are the real Jews.
He is typical
He sounds obese
@@Karim-ik5ij he is
The interviewer looks like he’s arguing with the people not just discussing or simply listening to their opinions
@Roman - this is kinda stupid in both way
It's a little bit much to take to just leave this demands for Genocide uncommented. I'm more surprised that he keeps himself that civilized. Many of the interviewees are completly fine with him personally getting "spread" (aka killed)... The Palestinians in this video demonstrate very good why they keep losing und don't get any step forward
@Roman - No - You want stupid people around you? or smart people that being asked the hard questions? forced to debate and protect their opinions?
@@pushboy1802 lol. Nice way to twist their words. None of them ever mentioned or killing any Israelis nor did they even imply genocide once. They just want their land back and them gone. Simple. Even if they did want to kill some of them, with what they have gone through can you even blame them for having these feelings? If my parents were burned alive or tortured and my land was taken from me....I would think about more than just expelling. They are pretty patient for wanting just that honestly.
because they are saying clearly immoral and anti-Semitic things
It seems a little disingenuous of the person filming to continue insisting that most of the Jewish people were there previously, the region was about 20-30% Jewish people prior to 1948 and is 70-80% now. There has always been a Jewish presence in the region, but to deny or deflect that there was massive European immigration (along with the creation of a country specifically for the newly increased population), is just... lack of understanding of perspective for the other side.
Then when the man is talking about the family being burned and the perpetrator not being punished the response of the person filming ultimately is "it doesn't matter", not ideal. Getting the two sides to come together.... going to be real rough.
I suspect you are pretty ignorant, I feel sorry for your children.
If you were to do even a modicum of research you under understand there will never be a two state solution when it comes to Palestinians.
Well said @lisa therein lies the problem. These inflated numbers of how many Jews were there in 1948 seems to be growing by the minute. I wonder why ancestory tests are banned in Israel except by court order…🤔
@@Lin-js3vx DNA testing is not banned in Israel. The Genetic Information Law, passed in 2000 amid privacy concerns, conditions domestic testing on a doctor's prescription or court order, & that testing be done by accredited labs. Commercial ancestry tests can be purchased from abroad.
Good point. But you also forget something: Both populations grew a lot (immigration versus child birth).
Denying mass Jewish immigration from Europe isn't technically denying holocaust?
"the israeli burned a family alive and the israeli court gave him a 30 day probation"
interviewer: "it doesnt matter"
he didnt want to start an argument on whether it was 6 months or 30 days so he said 'doesnt matter'.
how can so many people get that wrong amazes me
Interviewer is biased and completely unsympathetic to the Palestinians he interviews. When one commented that Zionism and Judaism are not the same, the POS interviewer argued with the point even though it is unequivocally correct. I know because I am a Jew and absolutely not a Zionist. The amazing thing to me is how polite and reasonable most of these Palestinians are. The frequently voiced opinion that an independent Palestine would mean that Jews would have to leave is the inverse of the actual deeds that Israeli militancy has inflicted upon the Palestinians. It is a strawman point that the interviewer frames as a justification for continued repression. Since when is policy enacted by the man in the street?
@@philwilson609 As a Palestinian I want to tell u - YOU the Man Phil!
@@philwilson609I think If he was really biased he would cut out the interviews he didn't like and only use whatever fit his agenda. Seems to me he's only sticking to the facts as he knows them.
What do you think is the solution for the conflict?
@@idohadad3039 from the interviewer's point of view everything he said was right. His view towards their comments is that we will look at them as being wrong and crazy the way he does.
just skip to 4:48 guy literally annihilate the ignorant interviewer.
th-cam.com/video/jbWGm-ARaSk/w-d-xo.html
Yeah that guy is the only one I agree wit has an arab myself
"annihilate" are you the ben shapiro title guy? the dude thinks the israeli/palestine conflict is the same as native americans in the USA.
@@overkill1025 what is wrong with that?
@@overkill1025 it is white people came and took their country. Sounds similar to me .
Love for the Californian guy.
Me too
Yep. He makes one comment, and the camera gets turned off.
Just because he's from California doesn't mean he's right on this matter. He called Palestinians native in Israel, ridiculous
@@mirjanabosnjak8064 where did I write "he's from California so he's cool"?
@@mirjanabosnjak8064 but they are. Palestinians are native to the land that’s now Israel
In the end God will deal with ALL those who curse His chosen people !!!!
His chosen people aren't European!!!!!
from 4:46 till 10:05 i underestimated his intelligence when i saw him but hes really smart and makes good points
With his points every single "arab" country should give back their lands. Meaning all north Africa.
But i am here to see the pretty girl in thumbnail and smarty dude put that video in last ahahhahaha
@@ciprianpopa1503 With your slippery slope fallacy, why not just go straight to be a single cell?
The smart boy should be in the thumbnail. The way he spokes and eye contact towards his friends are just everything. His parent must be proud of him.
+sem r the difference is, the jews in Israel only settled empty land, which palestinians didn't occupy, therefore palestinians do not own those lands.
It's like saying Native Americans own all of america just because they settled in a few locations, and that is simply not true.
If the interviewer wants to ask such questions the least they can do is stay neutral.
the media stay neutral? what are you 5 yrs old?
300 years ago, there was a France....
The video seemed interesting but they interviewer is too close minded
We don't want them means "Send them to Canada"... What does that say about all the people who immigrate from Palestine to Canada?
This is the true face of palestinians and most of the arabs.
www.uwyo.edu/sward/articles/ward-quranonisrael-boullatavol.htm
Most people in the world support Jews/ Israel aganist arabs. Because they see whats is happing in the arab world. They gain more and more supporters.
Thats the fact.
Peace :D
+MALEK KHIEREDDINE you were protecting old jew before 48? explain ► 1834: 2nd Hebron Pogrom, Ottoman Palestine. 1834: Safed Pogrom, Ottoman Palestine. 1847: ethnic cleansing of the Jews in Jerusalem, Ottoman Palestine. 1920: Irbid Massacres: British mandate Palestine. 1920 - 1930: Arab riots, British mandate Palestine.
1921: 1st Jaffa riots, British mandate Palestine. 1928: Ikhwan Massacres, Egypt, and british mandate Palestine.
1929: 3rd Hebron Pogrom British mandate Palestine. 1929: 3rd Safed Pogrom, British mandate Palestine.
1933: 2nd Jaffa riots, British mandate Palestine. 1936: 3rd Jaffa riots, British mandate Palestine.
יגאל גורביץ
I will explain sir
First, since the establishment of the Islamic religion and Mohammed urges tolerance among religions proof of this:
"Treaty City," which was one of its articles without prejudice to any individual Jew in the city and freedom of religious belief.
Read the history of the city and you'll find that the Jews have lived with Muhammad and his followers and where they lived in peace.
And most religions were protected in the era of the Prophet Muhammad, a lot of people wrong, in ordered Muhammad as a prophet, he did not urge violence and killings, but there have been military movements against those they want to do a betrayal or murder, or support for the enemies, like any state at that time or at the present time.
It is important, you know, my dear sir, that the Apostle were neighbors Jews, and most famous story to tell our elders, Messenger was his friend and neighbor Jew, always thrown on him greeting, and one day, the Jewish neighbor did not appear because he was sick, he went Mohammed the prophet who Zbunha to visit Sheikh Jew in his house, and did you know that when this old man died, sadness Prophet Muhammad Tayeb underway.
Sir, did you know that in Spain, in 1492 AD, the reign of Ferdinand and Isabella, battles so-called Reconquista, the Muslims saving Jews from the massacres "inquisition", which was to kill all Muslim or Jew, in Spain, and months of the rescued these is "Rais Hamidou" and is a sea captain from Algeria, and other sailors Muslims, and who rescued thousands of Jews, and were transferred to Algeria, Tunisia and Morocco, evidence that Jews were to live with us in peace and safety, until France came and colonized Those countries, in 1830 AD, and then France treated the Jews as enemies to them.
Other information, in the global war, the Nazis to kill Jews, and in France they were killed in a brutal manner, Did you know that Muslims, Baa Jews in mosques, to protect them from being killed, by the Nazis, and you know that they risked, also issued official documents of the Jewish states They are Muslims, so as not to kill them Nazis, and most famous mosque in France protected the Jews, it is the great mosque in the French city of Paris, and who rescued thousands of Jews from inevitable death at the hands of the Nazis. France and even today recognize thanks to the Muslims in the protection of the Jews of France.
Information Muslims did not hate Jews or any other religion, evidence that the Prophet Muhammad said in an interview, "there is no difference between black or white, and there is no difference between an Arab or non-Arab," and did you know that Mohammed call for the protection of the people of the book and they are Christians and Jews, and not allowed to kill them or attack them, in the case of self-defense and the nation.
Did you know that many centuries and Jews live in countries which were under the rule of Islam safely, evidence that since the establishment of the Islamic nation in 610 AD until the fall of the Ottoman Empire, and Jews living in the midst of all Muslims and Arabs safely and even so there is a lot of married Jews . Evidence that Muhammad is the Messenger of Allah married in a Jewish period of his life.
And also he married a Christian.
If only question really, it was the Muslims, the Jews are being killed like what he was doing Christians, because they killed Christ according to Christian, Christian Europe Imagine kill, kill Jews and Muslims also, is there a single Jew today ????
Of course not, because there is no place where I was hiding Jews.
However, since the Jews were living in peace with Muslims, they Ngo of extinction due to the Christian killing them.
Sir, as a human being cultured Atkhalt rabble between these murderers who kill people and religions, they are not a Valasraileon Jews, terrorism is not Islam.
The last question to you, what do you think in America ??
Of course, it will say the state of freedom, and Msawh.
But the land question in fact come on American Indian land. The europians kill all Indians peaceful, why do you let these freedom?
If America was really believes in freedom today, he left for America and bring it back to the Indians.
Imagine if you are living in a country where ancestors lived since ancient times, been Allarrobion come and occupy your country, and kill your people, do you accept that? Of course, that the earth was the king of football since you really?
Today the problem that most of the intellectuals silent, for fear of telling the truth, the fact of the terrible some countries that lie history, if true history books, rejoice too much.
The idea there are many common traits between Jews and Muslims, and even their habit. Search and you'll find it. search tuth and open your eyes
יגאל גורביץ
no sir please it's not dream okey ? me like muslim i respect מֹשֶׁה please dont TSB does not have anything sacred
And you know I am a Muslim, Mohammed does not allow me to WASP Jesus Christ or Moses, and you know I respect and like Moses, so please do not insult the Prophet. And Mohammed does not have day war against the Jews do not distort history, but only from Kano fight Mahm, everyone knew that he fought against the Jews allied themselves with the Quraish and wanted to kill Muhammad and his followers, you are in place Do you remain static, or defend yourself, then why when defending Prophet Muhammad himself becomes a criminal, but when you defend or America itself become a hero ??
First she is not abused but that he should defend himself. And please tell you anything Do not listen to the myth fabricated by Politicians best for you and for your people, the guide does not forget that he was your introduction to the Nazi Holocaust.
Do not lie and also did not defend the day and not the day Christians for Jews even today.
War not for Jews, but for gold and technology, evidence that many of the heads of US companies and Brtanih, Kano have slaves of the Jews Alnazin camps, search, Bush and other Kano have Jews use them as slaves in the industry without paying money for them.
There is a contract between Hitler and these Americans did and Britanin, where Hitler gives them Jewish labor, as slaves.
+MALEK KHIEREDDINE it was a dream that dreamt in the tent, that abu bakr volunteered to lie for him that it was real. cause he is a prophet and prophets don't lie. what a hoax. Muhammad never being in Jerusalem he failed to describe it. far mosque which referring to Beit al-Maqdis corresponding to jewish bet a Hamikdash the holy temple was no longer present at the time of Muhammad. nor any mosque existed. meeting jesus, abraham and moses, arguing over 50 times of prayer with allah lol what a funny story. resembles to the argument conducted by abraham with god in the bible. islam cannot be independent from jewish narratives it has to borrow. it was but a dream. another points to consider the al aqsa mosque present day is the fifth structure after previously four were destroyed by earth quacks none including the fifth were present at time of Muhammad. they were built years later one. the first of five was actually known Ayliya Mosque changed to al aqsa mosque for political purposes. so much complications.
I don't insult Muhammad, I tell the truth about him. truth is not an insult. you the one insults him, by attributing him a false characteristic and a false historical narratives.
islam is vile, evil and you should be a shamed for aligning to it. you truly a traitor to humanity.
The interviewer is so bias he asks loaded questions whenever someone comes with valid answer he denies them or changes subject he tries to pretend to be neutral but clearly has a bias against Palestinians I would recommend they educate interviewer on better interviewing techniques or get another guy
If native americans wanted to throw you out your country you'd be cool with it?
Joe Roberts I’m not American and this nothing to do with comment I was talking about interview being bias and using leading questions, good journalism requires one to be neutral and not push agenda he should be asking question to seek truth not to push an agenda or confirm his own bias’s
@@k-way232 that's true, but the idea that any territory has original inhabitants is childish , that's not how the world evolved
Joe Roberts again that has nothing to do with my original comment
@@joeroberts2156 Yes but now the US has equal rights for everyone and the police don't beat or kill (frequently). The point is that palestinians have no rights and no help under the israelis
This is basically a case of "keep asking them questions until they say something wrong"
Most of them got it wrong from the first question. Shows they’re as bigoted as zionists. Both sides are genocidal toward each other.
@@TH-camMadeMePickHandle you troll 😀
The fact is despite the obvious attempt by the interviewer to bait them most of them were clear about a solution of peaceful coexistence with those who were traditionally from the land ( and not from later immigration) under equal laws.
And bear in mind they could hold on tremendous grudges after what these civilians have indure.
@@samphyllobates4765 Yes, they are quite humane given the oppression. Obviously not the "animals" that Zionists would have the world believe they are in order to gain support for their corrupt cause.
@Ben David What caused the second intifada?
@@TH-camMadeMePickHandle if we could’ve interviewed native Americans in the 1700’s and they said Americans should all go back where they came from, would they have been bigots? How much inhumane treatment are people supposed to endure before they’re allowed to hate you?
The third guy in the black t-shirt was balanced and not full of hate.
Absolutely. He not only had the most moral view point, but also the most realistic.
Remember that this video was taken 8 years ago. So you can imagine what the Palestinians think of Jews now.
they have hated jews for a very long time
Why would their opinion change? Because they decided to murder 1,000 Jews in Israel? Do you think their opinion changed after they murdered people and those people retaliated? Seems like they were already willing to murder babies so I wouldn't be worried about what they think now.
gee what could possibly make them hate jews i wonder? cant be the israeli occupation and thier use of judaism as a scapegoat
could it?
@@lovescent46 Gee, what made them have genocides against the Jews even during the time of Mohammed, i wonder?could it be that Mohammed himself taught then to be genocidal maniacs towards the jews?
@@lovescent46 Did Israel occupy Iran? The Jews were thrown out of Iran. Did Israel occupy Iraq? They were thrown out of Iraq. It seems that maybe it isn't a Palestinian "oppression" thing but a Muslim thing.
By the way, weren't the Jews from that area, somewhere around Palestine? Where should the Jews live? What is a homeland they can call their own without Muslims attacking them?
The guy asking questions is so biased, it’s sad how he doesn’t see where he is in the wrong
@ཏྦཱལ་ག་པོ། not when he gets defensive over facts
He also asks Jews in Israel the same questions and pushes them to answer uncomfortable questions. Its you that is biased not the interviewer.
The woman’s literally saying he and his family should and will be killed, and you want him to be unbiased. You’re clearly anti Semite.
4:42 man is so calm and he knows what’s he speaking about. The man who’s recording pushed so hard so he might sound racist or anything but he’s really knowledgeable. It backfired good
no it did not, saying that people have no tradition is as objectively racist as you can be, he didn´t have to push to make him seem racist, he was racist already
@@d.p.mlsgnrqtrsratm5793 wrong person, the guy from 4:42 didn’t say any of that. And the interviewer is quite condescending.
@@fanzhang5568 so did he translate it wrongly? what did he say there?
@@d.p.mlsgnrqtrsratm5793 the guy from 4:42 and onwards didn’t need any translations. You are thinking of the younger kids before him. And I think they are referring to the state of Israel and the idea of Israelis, that they have culture as Jews, the same as Arabs as a whole, but doesn’t have as much national/non religious tradition as Israelis, which Palestinians do. It’s debatable but I don’t think that’s racist.
@@fanzhang5568 interesting, it may not be racist but still seems quite wrong, thanks for the insight though
Most of them are portraying it as if Arabs are the natives of the region (5:37), even though Jews have been there for over 1000 years before the arabs. Just because they were displaced to Europe or North America doesn’t mean they’re not originally from Israel
"there was no France 300 years ago" well... I have bad news for you
The French Revolution was 232 years ago.
@@wesjones6370 So France did not exist before then? That's like saying that the USA started in 1865.
@@jackoclubs8845 As a republic
@@wesjones6370 But France did exist as a monarchy, its also France. It exist since 843 I would say
@@sventorgersen7545 It exist since Clovis baptism somewhere between 490-500, so yeah, more than 300 years. And you can't even say that modern France is from the Revolution because there as been multiple Empires, restoration and Republics since (we are at the 5th one right now)
That guy slapped you very hard from 4:45 , clears every doubt popping up in people's mind 😏
The guy from California said everything on point. Very smart 🤓 Thanks.
he knew clearly what he was talking about
He has the privilege of perspective and most likely education.
But yeah, he had the most realist and fair solution: Stop Apartheid, lol!
@shmuck stealyourgoldberg Texas and the other insurrectionist, traitor, confederate states are not considered America. California is the heart and soul of America.
I’m not a Jew or Palestine but I agree with him . Specifically on the natives= Palestine
@@johnrobinson4445 I'm willing to bet the Confederate constitution is probably more American than whatever laws imposed on the people of California today
So sad to say, I don't understand how the righteous Mosiach will bring peace to the world? I pray for peace every day. Peace
7:01 The guy answering was NOT gonna have the interviewer gaslight him and we love to see it.
@Tyler Evans to make someone question their own reality, it’s a form of manipulation to make someone doubt their own perception
@Tyler Evans it literal a term used by psychologists. I’m also not a liberal 🤢
@Tyler Evans leftie /=/ liberal x
@shmuck stealyourgoldberg you're quite the dumbass arent ya
@@eternalM0TH report him. He's anti Semetic.
This is literally the most stupid question I ever heard in an interview.
According to this guy's logic, if someone kicked you out of your home by force, then you can't get your home back because the occupier doesn't have a place to go now, and now it's your problem. I'm amazed how you are considering this as an argument really.
im confused, are you supporting Israel or palestine,
@@danielhorn4113 palestine
he s saying that if someone takes your house per example, should we feel bad for him if you take it back and kick him out because he has nowhere to stay even tho hes the instigator
And this is literally one of the most stupid comments I have ever read and I'm amazed that you are considering this an argument. You can't compare countries to homes. You can't compare taking someones home to the complexity of what happened historically in Palestine / Israel. You can't compare people who were born in a country, living there for their whole live and having to leave to a burglar sitting in your home for a few days and getting kicked out. I can find more examples of how ridiculous your comparison is but I leave it for now. Btw. I have a lot to criticize about Israel, historical and political. But I prefer having arguments for that, not ridiculous comparisons...
@@nomissimo Thanks for the reply. Please take it easy on yourself, I'm sure you know what "analogy" is, what I said is clearly an EXAMPLE to show the shallowness of what the interviewer is going around asking people about, I'm not denying that on the higher scale the situation is far complex, but it's just an analogy to show how flawed the approach from the interviewer is, focusing on where should the Israelis go if Palestinians get their land back, and if they can't think of a good solution on the spot for such complex situation then they are in the wrong and taking back their land and home back is not an option until you give a solution, that's what I'm criticizing! basically the interviewer's logic, I'm not sure why you got so offended.
But since you did, funny enough my comparison isn't far from what's really happened on a personal level, isn't it? Palestinians did get kicked out of their homes in the end, make it as complex and as historical as you want, this is what happened exactly, saying that this is complex and historical doesn't take away the fact that actual people are now living in refugee camps.
Have a nice day.
How come Palestinians STILL are living in ”refugee camps”, aka (almost) ordinary suburbs in Jordan, Libanon and also in the West Bank (!!), without getting citizenship in Jordan, Libanon...🤔???
So They can go on with their lives...🤷🏻♂️
I was 2 years Old when my family fled Hungary in 1956 because of the civil war...we stayed in a refugee camp in Austria for two years When We got granted a quota asylum in 1958 to Sweden. My parents a little reluctantly accepten it... We got help with an appartement, mother with a job and father was hospitalised a lot. My older brother and sister started School and I went to the kindergarten. In 1966 We were permitted a Swedish citizenship. We were now FREE people being able to travel almost everywhere in the world.
You won't listen to any of his answers unbiasedly, just get emotional.
lmao he's a human too
lo l but it’s supposed to be an interview and to be an interviewer getting emotional is no choice
yeah i agree, hes whining and having quite a rude tone actually
@@fountainofyouth000 They're literally calling for genocide. How can he remain normal
@@morp904 who called for genocide? all i heard was that they can leave or stay just under Palestinian's law, you just make up stories and do you just convince yourself that people who lost families, children and friends want to see more death? if it was that case with the Israelis too they would've reached a middle solution! the problem is not the Palestinians nor the Jewish people... the real problem is governments and politicians who care about none of the sides.
Such a sad situation, my grandmother was Jewish and fled Ukraine during the war, I feel the two people should live in peace but I know it will never come to pass
Hes very biased and he gets pissed when he questions people and hears what he doesnt want to hear which is very unprofessional
No he is no biased he just hates to hear lies, like every normal person.
For example, that Arab guy in the beginning said the Jews have no tradition nor history in Israel which is a straight up blatant lie
since there are countless pieces of evidence proving Jews lived there long before any Arab or Muslim even set foot in this land.
The name Jews came from Judea which was later renamed by the Roman empire to Palestine.
As a matter of fact, there is no tradition or history of so called Palestinians, simply because there is no such thing as "Palestinian".
They are a mix of Arabs from Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Saudi Arabia etc who moved to Israel during the centuries.
He’s like that on both sides tho... he’s hostile towards both Jews and Muslims.
@@d3struction61 So I have a few questions here:
Where were you as ethnicity before Judaism was born ?
Was judaism found before the kingdom (Land of Palestine or Israel or whatever) or after ? Your father and the father of Arabs Abraham were was he ? Where did he live ? Where was he born ? Where was his Clan ?
When your people moved to This Land cause I know they moved to it from another place and you should too, was it empty or was there people living in The Land, and what was the name of it, cause names can change but people can be in the same place? Such as Italy, Spain, Korea.
Are all Palestinians now living there have only Arabic blood or other Ethnicity mixed with it cause I saw a video on Arabs showing that the Levant have all kinds of ethnicities as well duo to their neighboring people ?
Are you denying that some Arabs lived in the Levant region (including the Land of Palestine or Israel or whatever) as well as other groups of different Semitic and Hamitic people before the three religions even existed?
Were not Moses and Israelites in Egypt when he received the Torah ?
I also have watched a video on this very channel where the interviewer asked the Israelis: Are you white? and most of them where Arab jews from Iraq, Moroccan, Yemen, Syria, Tunisia and a minority from Europe (mostly Poland i think) called the Ashkenazi Jews. Therefore does that mean they are not original Israelites and only Arab jews, and I quote from you the following describing Palestinians: (They are a mix of Arabs from Egypt, Lebanon, Jordan, Saudi Arabia etc who moved to Israel during the centuries.). Now I understand that the Ashkenazi Jews are the only group of jews that are not Eastern as they do not identify themselves or their ancestor as that, so are Ashkenazi Jews Semitic, cause they look white? and who are the original Israelites today (Please give me a name of a group of people identified among your people as The Israelites lineage today) by DNA Not Jews by religion ?
What is the prove that the Israelites were living there alone and why are you so sure that the Palestinians right there today are not The real Israelites lineage mixed with others, some are converted to Christianity, Islam and some remained jews in faith, cause there are jew Palestinians before the state of Israel existed as mentioned in the video ?
Are you saying that Canaan people were not there before Israel ?
Canaanites are included in a list of nations to exterminate among other nations, and later described as a group which the Israelites had annihilated (Source: Joshua 1-12, (2015): A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary). If you read more in this book, it says that ancient Israelites moved to the Land ruled at the time by Canaanites, destroyed them and then took over the land to establish a kingdom for themselves (meaning it is not originally The Land of Israelites) , In addition there was no prove if only Israelites remain in the land or the original people lived with them (which maybe they are the Palestinians today).
When exactly did the Israelites spread all over the world (year) ?
Thank you.
@@sanag7632 Sana are u on 🇵🇸 or 🇮🇱 side
@@jjcapo3426 Do you have answers to my Questions? Or is it more important what side am I on?
"Palestine of 1948"
So a British colony?
+James Parker thank you James. The only one with sense. Why do people forget this. When you say that though they say La yani Sham. Cause it was part of greater Syria at one point also.
No pre-ottoman empire
b6makavelithugz So it would be part of Egypt?
James Parker haha, what did I tell you, this guy b6makavelithugz is like "no like Sham". :D fucking predictable. Yeah south would be part of Egypt and north would be Syria (bilad al sham). So you want a dictatorship disguised as a muslim caliphate? why didn't you just say that? There is one being started in Sinai and a bigger one in Iraq and Syria. lol
MALEK KHIEREDDINE You are sooo full of shit. Britain built infrastructure, developed its colonies. Listen, every group of people had slaves at one point, its not all Europeans. Africans did it, Asians etc etc. You are so racist and naïve with your comment. its pathetic and illogical. You would be lucky to live in UK, France or Germany. Instead of blaming others because life didn't turn out how you wanted take a look at yourself and improve your situation and adapt
At the end of World War I, the Allies and the League of Nations took 1.2 million square miles of land from the Turks. They divided that land up to create several homelands for various non-Turkish peoples: Lebanon, Syria, Iraq, Jordan and Palestine. The official boundaries of these areas also solidified the formation of other distinct and sovereign homelands such as Iran, Saudi Arabia and Egypt.
Of the 1.2 million square miles, more than 44,000 square miles were designated as The British Mandate for Palestine. It was in this region that the British had agreed to the creation of a Jewish homeland. This was slightly more than 3% of the total land taken from the Turks. Opponents of Israel usually claim that the Jews received most of the land - 3% is hardly most of the land.
The British agreement, which was set forth in the 1917 Balfour Doctrine, stipulated "...that nothing should be done which might prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine..." There was no mention of specific land rights to be granted or guaranteed to the non-Jewish communities within the Jewish homeland. If it was the intention of the British for the Jewish homeland to be merely a religious community within a much larger muslim State it would not have been necessary to stipulate Jewish protection of muslim civil and religious rights.
However, of the 44,000 square miles of The British Mandate for Palestine, 33,000 was then chopped off and given to the muslim arabs under the governorship of Abdullah, a Hashemite family leader from Arabia. This land was re-named "Trans-Jordan" (now called Jordan), and placed off-limits to Jews. The League of Nations formalized this division in their Mandate For Palestine of July 1922. The League of Nations' Mandate included the same stipulation made in the Balfour Doctrine "...that nothing should be done which might prejudice the civil and religious rights of existing non-Jewish communities in Palestine..." Again, there was no mention of specific land rights to be granted or guaranteed to the non-Jewish communities within the Jewish homeland, and no indication that the Jewish homeland was to exist within a dominant muslim State.
At this point just 11,000 square miles was left for a Jewish homeland; less than 1% of the total land taken from the Turks. If 3% of the land is hardly "most of the land" as some ignoramuses state in their remarks on the subject, then how little is less than 1%?
In 1938, the British convened the Peel Commission, which recommended that the 11,000 square miles be further divided to about 3,500 square miles to the Jews and 6,500 square miles to the muslims. The Jews said "okay," but the muslims refused and rioted. Nothing was done.
In 1947, the British surrendered its Mandate of Palestine to the United Nations. A UN commission suggested splitting the 11,000 square miles into three zones: Jewish, muslim, and an international Jerusalem. Minus the land to be set aside for an international Jerusalem, 61% of the land was designated for the Jews. About half of the Jewish land consisted of the virtually uninhabited Negev Desert (not at all "most of the best land" as claimed by anti-Israel people). The Jews agreed to the Partition Plan, but the muslims rejected it.
However, non-acceptance of the UN Partition Plan by either or both of the parties did not invalidate the UN's Partition Plan, nor did it prevent the British from following through on their decision to remove all military personnel and disengage their oversight by May14, 1948. Had the British decided not to disengage and remove their military, Israel Declaration of Independence might not have occurred or it might have been delayed. In any event, the muslim leadership in Palestine chose to place their future in the hands of the surrounding muslim nations who had promised to conquer all of the land and annihilate all the Jews. The muslim armies attacked en masse on May 15, 1948.
Although Israel won the war, some land that was designated for a muslim state was seized by Jordan and Egypt (the west bank and Gaza; respectively). Jordan also seized Jerusalem. These areas were annexed to Jordan and Egypt without any interest of giving the land to the non-aligned muslims to create an independent muslim state. This situation existed for 19 years.
After two additional wars in which the muslims, and Jew-haters, hoped to eradicate the Jews and Israel, the current nation of Israel is about 8,500 square miles. So Israel represents about 0.7% of the land taken from the Turks. Considering that the Jewish population of Israel represents approximately 2% of the population living on the land taken from the Turks, it could be said that the Jews have less than half of the land they should have’ on a proportionate basis.
Coincidentally, the size of Israel today corresponds very closely to the population division of un-divided Palestine just prior to 1922. Muslim population was 80%, non-muslim 20%. Adding together Jordan, Gaza and west bank cities under muslim control, the muslims have about 81% of the land. Jordan has no Jewish citizens. There are about 1.6 million muslim citizens of Israel, all of whom enjoy full civil and religious rights as hoped for in the Balfour Doctrine.
Jordan is about 4 times the size of Israel with 25% fewer people.
So, other than how insane, ignorant Jew-haters interpret history, and wish to portray current conditions, the truth is quite different.
Thank you for taking the time to summarize this
You left out the part where from 1890s to 1948, the Zionist bought lands from Arabs holders to build settlements. The first Kibbutz (communities) were estblished by 1910. By the time the British arrived in 1917, there were already jewish settlements up and down the coastline, and a thriving economy. All that happened was that both Jewish and Arab migration increased under the British. When you say that the British gave 3% of the land to the Zionists, people get confused and think wrong. They think that the British took land property away from the Arabs and gave it to the Jews. That's not what happened. What the British and UN did was divide the region into sovereign statehoods so countries could be formed. Arabs, Christians or any other non-Jew who wanted to be part of Israel still retained their land holdings and became Israeli citizens. There has never been a Palestinian people, culture, nation state, kingdom, or tribe until Arafat started using the term in 1962. Before that you were either Jordanian Arab, Egyptian Arab or Israeli Arab, at least post 1948. I've literally known Palestinians who were alive back in 1967 and even said, "One moment, I am Jordanian. Then, all of a sudden, I was now Palestinian." The idea of an Arab statehood was a European introduction post WW1. Before that, Arabs only identified themselves in the following order. Tribe! Village! Religion (Village can also be town or city)! There was no Palestinian recognition as a people. As an area in the Middle east named by the Romans, yes. But not as a people. Palestinian was more of a Western outsider term to describe the area and people before the 1960s.
The entire area has always been under occupational control as its been one of the most repeatedly conquered regions in all of human history. Each empire has brought settlers to Palestine, which is how Arabs got there (being a culture from Arabia). But what most people don't realize, and I am just stating facts, is that the Zionists are the only settlers who didn't take the land by conquest of war. They purchase their way in, buying land from other Arabs, and then used their numbers and political influences to build a nation state.
@@mollysmeow3455 Even if some land was designated for Jews in Europe, the land of Israel would still be our homeland. For over 2000 years we have faced Jerusalem 3 times a day and prayed to return there. Anywhere else, even if under Jewish self-governance, would still be foreign land that we were exiled to.
I don’t consider myself a Zionist politically speaking, as my goal is not necessarily a Jewish-run government. My connection with the land and the people is a religious and spiritual one. What I insist upon is for all Jewish people to be welcome to LIVE and PRAY in PEACE in the land of our forefathers. I don’t mind at all if others were also there doing the same thing. If the Arab governments could guarantee me that right I wouldn’t have such a problem with them. My political support for the modern state of Israel is pragmatic in nature. The current Israeli government is welcoming to the Jewish people and a potential Palestinian government would not be.
@@mollysmeow3455all the important archeological sites for Jews are in Israel. Their Holy ground is there. Likewise for Christians. Jews and Christians mostly get aling very well now. They can coexist. But muslims can not coexist well with anyone.
Commenting here so I can save it later. Puts the whole "free palestine" vernacular into perspective
The 3rd man makes the most sense and is the most reasonable
As a completely non-biased Romanian, I find this guy that is doing the interview or however you call it, really really ignorant. He keeps pressuring them into answering what he wants to hear, and when he doesn't get the answer he wanted he leaves lol... Those people outclassed you big time.
He asks tough questions to prove a point.
You do know that you are only seeing clips from a larger recording right? I'm sure there were much broader discussions taking place. I'm sure most of it wasn't interesting. It didn't seem like he pressured anyone. He did throw some opinion in there, but I don't think the interviews were poorly done.
He does esp w the france 300 years ago lol
Considering how brutal Romania was to the Jews prior to WW2 I can’t take your opinion seriously especially since my family was killed there and now live in US and Israel.
@@cleveland3357 yeah an antisemite word means nothing
If they did not have any problems with the 1948 Jews, why did every Arab state declare war when the two state solution was proposed in 1948?
You have to look back to WW1 when the Arabs allied with Britain in 1915 to fight the Ottomans on the condition that the Arabs would have their lands and independence after the war, including Palestine. Britain agreed but went back on their word when they issued the Balfour Declaration in 1917 and encouraged European Jews to move into Palestine instead. So for over 30 years the Arabs have tried diplomacy and protests for the land that was promised to them. And instead the UN gave 56% of Palestine to the Jews who made up only 32% of the population and owned less than 6% of the land. The only logic is to reject such a proposal because it forced so many Palestinians from their homes, but even after rejecting, it did not matter and the UN went through with the partition anyway.
Look up the letter to the NYTimes in 1948 that Albert Einstein signed, where he makes comparisons of an Israeli political party to that of Nazism and Fascism. He knew it was wrong to take someone else's land and displace them.
Stop lying
THIS
Because Jews want a state based on their religion, so based in their beliefs of a God. Palestinians are mixed group of people of many religions who lived on their land until the Zionists arrived because the UK decided that would be a great idea.
Why should Palestinians be like "ooh you want some land because Churchill promised it to you? Sure take it! You Buddhists also want some? Sure, come, we don't care!"
This is colonization, a project of the British and the Zionist Jews coming from Europe and the US.
At the end of the day the two state solution was an excuse to steal a land by using religion. If Zionists really wanted two states, they would never start illegal settlements. They would stop using violent laws against Palestinians. They would stop bombing Gaza. They would stop killing to gain more land and cancel Palestinians from their country. But this is not happening, so now we know they have never entered to be guests: they wanted all the land to themselves from the beginning.
"where are they gonna go?"
The zionists weren't asking that when they were "displacing" palestinians were they.
Arabs to arabia. Simple.
@@dogbert52 And Palestine is part of Arabia. Simple.
@@madjames1134 sure. Its also part of australia.
@@madjames1134 No it isn't. The Hijaz is Arabia. Israel is in the Levant, not in Arabia. Notice how you have to make up stuff out of whole cloth to defend the Palestinian narrative. Why do you think that is?
@Stormwind No, they refused to accept Australia until all the Aussies are driven out. Maybe just Tasmania?
The guy from California has the right mentality
when they were speaking about the family that were burned did u see how he tried to brush it off and make his idea of what happened seme like the reality
That's the privilege of the oppressor. I'm NA and concur that the modern "Israelis" are like those who arrived in the Mayflower.
If it's the case I'm thinking of, the Jewish settler that did the fire bombing admitted doing it, and laughed about it. I saw him on an interview, after he served his 3 months in jail.
4:43 guy just shut down a hypocrite
So HARD
Palestinians aren't native you racist
@@MrKT410 The Canaans are native, right?
@@MrKT410 Well Arabic is entirely Semitic. Somehow your comment made it seem like you were saying Arabic isn't Semitic, which would be a total falsehood.
"Hebrews" likely were some form of Canaanite themselves since there is no evidence of a widespread invasion or devastating conflict in the region during that time period. Likely they were native Canaanites themselves that just splintered religiously.
No he didnt.
Jews are native to the land of israel.
You often were neutral or didnt comment on opinions but this video was very biased.
I love how when ever he exposes the Palestinians then the video is "biased"
@@navotshiener4503 How he is exposing them? Can u explain?
@@zwedenish exposing, as in showong the true face of the Palestinians and their goals
@@navotshiener4503 Exposing what? Even the jew who is asking questions asks what about the jews around the world who came here after 1948. Look what jews are doing to immigrants in USA and u can't just because your tora tells you that this is the promised land and u are the chosen people and above all just justify it. But if a person is not ashamed of this fact then they won't understand anything especially when they think that they are the chose people who are the best humans.
Radjes Idrees can you give some proof?
Peace means everyone getting on together.
Unless you are Muslim, then it means join or die.
The interviewer is a joke 😂
no hes not, muslims dont belong on that land. the muslims have history going back their 1000 years, but the hebrews have history going back their 4000 years. GOD gave the hebrews that land. that is only the facts. I am a Roman catholic and we will support isreal jews no matter what
@Alex Rostov and jesus was jewish...
@@danielhorn4113 God did not give the hebrews that land in fact it Israel existing goes againts God's will.
@@ramboyman1010 my great grandfather was from Iraq but that doesn't mean he owns the entire country of Iraq nor does that makes me Iraqi
you know Jacob wasn't living there all by himself they were other people too so the jew's can't claim the entire contry just because their ancestors lived there once
@Alex Rostov nice explanation 👍
The guy behind the camera made an absolute mug of himself to be honest.
Congratulations to the interviewer for having the courage to ask such a thorny question in a land of conflict. Not only that, he uploaded it for all of us with Internet access to watch it for free of charge.
All the people here who are critical of Palestinians for not forgiving Israelis- has Israel ever apologised for what they've done? Have they asked for forgiveness? Have they acknowledged any culpability at all, ever?
if there was a country called palestine before then thats fair. but there wasnt. there was just repeated history of arabs attacking jews, even wayyyy before 1948 (including with literaly arab leaders meeting h*tler). the land was a mandate, before just empire after another. and with 7 peace offers all being refused by the palestinians and replied by more terrorism (which is the reason for the israeli checkpoints), i dont know what else do you expect from israel. ofc its not an easy life for the palestinians but israels priority should always be its own citizens (since the palestinians in the palastinian areas have their own leadership with their own laws)
then why should God forgive them? if you dont forgive , dont expect to be forgiven, youre not higher than God, eat your breakfast
Perhaps that is a good pont. But have the arabs ever apologised for prosecuting and not allowing freedom of religion (not by law but in practise) for Christians in Pakistan, Bangladesh, Saudi, Nigeria etc? No, instead there is virtually no church or temple in Saudi Arabia while muslims demanding full rights in western countries. How can this freedom of religion only go one way? That is not a way to live together in peace.
@@sapiruwu3799 lol. well take this:
At a 1956 funeral for an Israeli soldier killed by Palestinians in Gaza, Gen. Moshe Dayan, one of Israel’s most famed military leaders, advised the following:
_Let us not cast the blame on the murderers today. Why should we deplore their burning hatred for us? For eight years they have been sitting in the refugee camps in Gaza, and before their eyes we have been transforming the lands and villages, where they and their fathers dwelt, into our estate._
@UmaU-pg1mx first source? Second quotes from random ppl don't mean too much. Ppl here have a lot of empathy, sometimes too much.
Look up how the 'refugee camps' of gaza looked like before this war.
Not to even mention that in 1956 gaza belonged to Egypt so if gazan suffered there is because Egypt didn't give a shit about them.
It's also funny you mention that cuz in gaza before 1948 war you had jewish villages that were there for thousands of years and they got kicked out of them too, but instead of trying to get revenge they built a new life.
Another point I want to mention is that when you start a war, youight lose, and the arabs started a war and lost. Hundreds of millions of ppl got displaced through out the 40s yet only 'Palestinians ' (I say that considering they started to call themselves that only in the 60s) never moved on, started war after war, and kept losing.
The person who asks questions always seems to load his questions and find faults in palestinian videos but claims he is trying to be neutral when same happens in isreli videos.
So what you are saying is that the interviewer is a Jews?
Color me triggered!
Big Mofo i just learnt that he was israeli. Initially I just saw his videos and noticed this trend. But then i found out that he was israeli when he was asking swedish people if they thought that sweden generally supported israel. He started each question with "so, i am from israel". That was the wrong way to start such a question. He might as well have held a gun to their heads.
Big Mofo coincidences do not occur so many times. Logically and scientifically, there is no such thing. Learn to spot patterns, it could save YOUR life.
Learning to call everything that isn't a coincidence a coincidence won't save my life, it would further endanger it. Better safe than sorry. And this isn't even a life or death situation so stop the drama.
Oh.so it's the fault. Of who asked th3 questions and not the people who gave the answers ?!
Look, peace is better than neutrality.
the issue is complicated they should think critically not emotionally.