If you haven't already make sure to subscribe and chuck my album, Evil That Lurks Within a listen: th-cam.com/video/Us5jRtkXVyk/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=ThomKenobi open.spotify.com/artist/4AjcN1AunoPa6nK8PK4tsl
This version would make a great visual aid, since everyone for some reason thinks that Rey defeated Palpatine alone, when she actually had every single Jedi in existence to boost her
Precisely, it would have done a wonderful job of showing this in a way that leaves no room for doubt. While I would be skeptical of of her defeating Palpatine on her own, she is not fighting alone. She has the support of essentially the entire light side of the force against a being who has essentially become the physical representative of the dark side. That is a fitting way to end this conflict.
This simple addition would have really enhanced the conclusion of The Skywalker Saga. Goosebumps from a fan edit. Well done. I always understood the premise of “I am all the Jedi”, but seeing all the force ghosts behind her would have been a welcomed addition. I’m wondering if maybe one day, we’ll get some content that concurs during this scene (like how Clone Wars 7 happened alongside ROTS)…or give it “from a certain point of view” twist…with Filoni bringing Anakin back in Ahsoka and reaffirming and strengthening his role as the Chosen One, who knows?…
Kinda got me teary-eyed seeing Yoda, Obi-Wan, Anakin, and Luke. I heard this was the original idea, including others supporting Rey, but Kathleen Kennedy just wanted it to be Rey defeating Palpatine.
Exactly right! It was great how they brought back and involved the Jedi from the past and yet the present, but surely you could have had some of them materialised in spirit form as we know and have seen some of them in previous movies in this form. Anyway great scene!
they could but understanding that Disney absolutely sucks, they likely wouldn't as it would mean recognizing work they didn't do. Disney is the Dark side now.
Why oh why was this not the actual scene … so powerful that Yoda,Obi Wan, Anakin and Luke are there all helping finally defeat the sith…. Bravo to whoever made this
depends how you look at it. My personal headcanon is that Anakin started a cycle of chosen ones for every generation, so every time darkness rises, light will meet it and keep it from growing
I just realised: that's the SECOND time Palps has been fried by his own lightning. All he had to do was just stop sending bloody LIGHTNING and he'd have been fine!
aside from this not being the default version that we got in theatres, my biggest gripe of this scene is...why would palps just not...stop shooting the lighting the second Rey starts deflecting it? i know, i know...plot armor....etc. still. erks me to this day.
“The heart of a Jedi lies her strength”. True. Emotional Intelligence is equally important as physical prowess and IQ. There are many genius humans who get isolated because their bosses and colleagues felt threatened by their intelligence, and obnoxious attitudes. EQ is necessary to survive in society. 1 genius cannot defeat an entire of society.
I always wondered why, when he realized that he was screwed, that he didn't just stop firing the force lightning at her. She couldn't kill him without pushing his own power back at him.
@@StReEtReApEr12R Unless the force lightning is different than what he used in Return of the Jedi against Luke there was no indication that I'm aware of that he couldn't control it. In Return of the Jedi he took pleasure in toying with Luke by stopping to give him time to realize what was happening and how strong the Dark side is. His final assault was preceded by the great line of "now you will die!" accompanied by a big smile. So did I miss something that indicated that he couldn't control the power once he activated it?
@@danwills9981 I'm not talking about the lightning itself but the fact that he was so consumed and it was already in process. Once it started coming back same story as with windu
In the name of the Jedi; Obi-Wan Kenobi, Anakin Skywalker, Ahsoka Tano, Kanan Jarrus, Luminara Unduli, Mace Windu, Yoda, Qui-Gon Jinn, Aayla Secura, Adi Gallia, Luke Skywalker & all the others…YOU SHALL FALL!
Rey not death , and her grandfather kidnapped Ben Solo ; She won battle but Palpatine learned about immortality from Darth Plagueis and , like Sauron in The Lords of The Rings, Palpatine not yet deactivated forever.
unpopular Theroy, palpatine wanted ey to kill him he won. Also the jedi are evil they were never about balance. Anaikin did balance the force by killing the jedi
Palpatine works decades perfecting the force, learning its secrets and creating a machine to help him channel all of the Sith. Mary Sue held a lightsaber about a month and wins with two lightsabers.
Be real. It's metaphorical that they were actually being helped by the dead. Rey had moral support only. They each had their own strength separately. Rey was more powerful than her father.
Either people have severe comprehension issues or they really just hate Rey because she's a girl...As she literally says she's "all the Jedi" with numerous Jedi there with her...Yet people continue to say she beat Sidious alone..🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Why couldn't anyone call on dead Jedi to help them in battle before Ray? And why wouldn't the force ghosts appear to help Luke? Why didn't Qui Gon ever appear to help Obi Wan? It just seems a bit cheap. I would have preferred an ending where Kylo and her take out the emperor together. But we can't have that now can we?
To be fair it’s topping what Disney did is a really really low bar. If you want to do this properly scrap the whole thing. Don’t make Sidious the biggest moron ever instead show him to actually be the strongest sith ever instead of making massive plot holes and nonsense like loosing to his Mary Sue granddaughter with barely any training or experience.
Should have been the Sith and Jedi both die. Then balance would really be restored to the Force. You could still have Rey survive, she could forge her own path not as a Jedi or a Sith (or a Skywalker)
Worst scene ever, I would prefer if she said " And I'm a Skywalker" to make more sense with the title of the movie The Rise of Skywalker but that's just me.
If you haven't already make sure to subscribe and chuck my album, Evil That Lurks Within a listen: th-cam.com/video/Us5jRtkXVyk/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=ThomKenobi open.spotify.com/artist/4AjcN1AunoPa6nK8PK4tsl
Kinda funny that you stole this from that huge channel that spent they're time making this but whatever
Remember, this was because of Ryan Johnson who was listening to Kathleen Kennedy
No, because Kathleen Kennedy doesn't want anything to make star wars movie look good 😮
This version would make a great visual aid, since everyone for some reason thinks that Rey defeated Palpatine alone, when she actually had every single Jedi in existence to boost her
Yeah, exactly! That's what everyone's got wrong.
Precisely, it would have done a wonderful job of showing this in a way that leaves no room for doubt. While I would be skeptical of of her defeating Palpatine on her own, she is not fighting alone. She has the support of essentially the entire light side of the force against a being who has essentially become the physical representative of the dark side. That is a fitting way to end this conflict.
Actually, they were indeed going to showcase the Force Ghosts, but a superstition in China disallowed then from doing so.
@@lordofcreativity9637 Awesome Analogy!
@@iam4026 C'mon China! Let us down again. Well, really Disney. Money hungry dogs. They should accommodate for everyone, not just China.
This simple addition would have really enhanced the conclusion of The Skywalker Saga. Goosebumps from a fan edit. Well done. I always understood the premise of “I am all the Jedi”, but seeing all the force ghosts behind her would have been a welcomed addition. I’m wondering if maybe one day, we’ll get some content that concurs during this scene (like how Clone Wars 7 happened alongside ROTS)…or give it “from a certain point of view” twist…with Filoni bringing Anakin back in Ahsoka and reaffirming and strengthening his role as the Chosen One, who knows?…
Alone never have you been✊
I exploded when I heard Kanan and Ahsoka too. I love this scene.
Same here!
We have the same mind
When I heard Alex Guinness I was crying he is my OG
So Ahsoka is dead
Kinda got me teary-eyed seeing Yoda, Obi-Wan, Anakin, and Luke. I heard this was the original idea, including others supporting Rey, but Kathleen Kennedy just wanted it to be Rey defeating Palpatine.
Of course...
Of course...😅
Put a chick in it
Make it lame
"MAKE IT GAY! AND MAKE HER A LESBIAN!"
That woman ruins a lot of things. Especially good ideas.
Can Disney just make this the official version? It’s perfect, so powerful
Exactly right! It was great how they brought back and involved the Jedi from the past and yet the present, but surely you could have had some of them materialised in spirit form as we know and have seen some of them in previous movies in this form. Anyway great scene!
Agreed.
they could but understanding that Disney absolutely sucks, they likely wouldn't as it would mean recognizing work they didn't do. Disney is the Dark side now.
@@mikeholton3914Kathleen Kennedy didn't want this to happen
56 yrs old, seeing this perfection with tears in my eyes. Thank you!! Great job!!
I thought she would snap her fingers with that line delivery but that's a different movie.
Anakin has stopped the Sith before and he can help did it again even in death.
you see you see for there to be balance in the force the jedi have to win just as the Sith win in equal measure for there to be balance✊✊
The force is with you, and so are the Jedi!
This SHOULD have been in the movie.. the audience would have literally SHIT themselves with excitement!!! WOW!! Excellent job friend! DAMN!!
Why oh why was this not the actual scene … so powerful that Yoda,Obi Wan, Anakin and Luke are there all helping finally defeat the sith…. Bravo to whoever made this
This was amazing! Disney should make this change to the movie. AMAZING
I was waiting for old classic Voiceover in the background:
Excellent!
Impressive!
Well done!
Oh my god why didn't they do this - such a missed opportunity. This was great by the way well done.
That was such an easy "lay up". I cannot believe no one over there thought of that.
"Every Jedi who ever lived, lives in you" DUDE CHILLS
Let's just admit that selling to disney is the worst thing that any company, writer, musician, franchise, or person can do.
1:03 wow i wonder why they didnt do this in the movie ... would have been epic ...
Chills. Literally chills
This is a great scene. Rey is the culmination of all the Jedi before and the start of a new order that will last millennia
Unfortunately , she still alive, that was a good death and this movie it would have been better
My life is waiting for this all Jedi masters version, I can die now😂.
That would be MOVIE HEAVAN.
Un fan no puede hacer un mejor final a una saga.
Un fan...
Trekkie here... But THIS was dope!
i didnt like palpatines return it ruins vaders sacrifice but you just have to admit this is a badass scene.
100% EXACTLY
depends how you look at it. My personal headcanon is that Anakin started a cycle of chosen ones for every generation, so every time darkness rises, light will meet it and keep it from growing
Palpatine returned in Legends as well. Much sooner too.
@@MCSPARTAN501 a few times if I remember correctly...
I just realised: that's the SECOND time Palps has been fried by his own lightning. All he had to do was just stop sending bloody LIGHTNING and he'd have been fine!
😂
Almost perfect, needed Leia
I didn’t like the sequels (mainly because of how they treated the OT characters)
But this is an AWESOME scene. 🎬.
aside from this not being the default version that we got in theatres, my biggest gripe of this scene is...why would palps just not...stop shooting the lighting the second Rey starts deflecting it?
i know, i know...plot armor....etc. still. erks me to this day.
This was better than the original
Rey: I'M ALL OF THE JEDI!
It should say "And I am The Force"
Well no. There is the light side and the dark side and some in between but none of them are all of the Force.
It really is better than the original
Thankyou!
truly.... so much better with this
Definitely agree!
It'd be great if they also added Leia, Mara Jade, Kyle Katarn, Revan, Bastila, Cal Kestis, Jaden Korr etc.
Lol if anyone actually knew who any of these names were outside of Leia. Never heard of a single one!
“The heart of a Jedi lies her strength”. True. Emotional Intelligence is equally important as physical prowess and IQ. There are many genius humans who get isolated because their bosses and colleagues felt threatened by their intelligence, and obnoxious attitudes. EQ is necessary to survive in society. 1 genius cannot defeat an entire of society.
The last clip (Rey's death) didn't save for some reason and accidentally zoomed itself in. Whoops. It looks really bad.
Does she have to die?
What is the name of the force theme when Rey first gets back up? I know it’s a certain versions does anyone know?
"The Force Is With You" by John Williams! Beautiful! th-cam.com/video/kIr-3GYLZMM/w-d-xo.html&ab_channel=DisneyMusicVEVO
This is how it should have been done!
Wow palpatines face goes from conceited i am invincible to "i am so fucked".
I always wondered why, when he realized that he was screwed, that he didn't just stop firing the force lightning at her. She couldn't kill him without pushing his own power back at him.
@@danwills9981 he can't it's already started.
@@StReEtReApEr12R Unless the force lightning is different than what he used in Return of the Jedi against Luke there was no indication that I'm aware of that he couldn't control it. In Return of the Jedi he took pleasure in toying with Luke by stopping to give him time to realize what was happening and how strong the Dark side is. His final assault was preceded by the great line of "now you will die!" accompanied by a big smile. So did I miss something that indicated that he couldn't control the power once he activated it?
@@danwills9981 I'm not talking about the lightning itself but the fact that he was so consumed and it was already in process. Once it started coming back same story as with windu
@@danwills9981 him using his own lightning and him having it channeled back on him are 2 different things
Best scene in the new era of Starwars
all the force ghosts behind Rey would have been so much better
got a pretty good team assembled
Rey just learned the same lesson Luke Skywalker did in episode 4.
In the name of the Jedi; Obi-Wan Kenobi, Anakin Skywalker, Ahsoka Tano, Kanan Jarrus, Luminara Unduli, Mace Windu, Yoda, Qui-Gon Jinn, Aayla Secura, Adi Gallia, Luke Skywalker & all the others…YOU SHALL FALL!
Once again, the fans prove superior to the corporate juggernaut.
Deadpool and Fire fist show up
Fire Fist: Hey, you stole that from Endgame
Deadpool: Yeah, you stole that from Endgame
Should do a make over, and add this like they did in RETURN OF THE JEDI.
All I know is that Exegol is a junkyard now
Haha. Yeah, jesus. I wonder what's going on there?
If the scrappers that lived where Kal hid at were still alive, hoo boy.
They would be getting paid especially well for salvaging parts from there!
so good.
Rey not death , and her grandfather kidnapped Ben Solo ; She won battle but Palpatine learned about immortality from Darth Plagueis and , like Sauron in The Lords of The Rings, Palpatine not yet deactivated forever.
That was cool. Can you do an edit so the last 3 films were entertaining?
they definitely with me
Oh I have to say pelboutine was the most evil.Most cunning and most powerful sith lord in all of star wars but still was no match for all the jedi
So does this mean Ahsoka is dead by this time too?
thom indeed ;)
Wow!
In an overall terrible movie this was a really good scene
mark hamil has gotten so kookie.
Boss babe needed an all men ensemble to help her😂😂😂😂😂
Looks like Goku's spirit bomb😂
Rey went to the Sith Home World to stop the Sith once and for all.
so be it...
Bravo!
unpopular Theroy, palpatine wanted ey to kill him he won. Also the jedi are evil they were never about balance. Anaikin did balance the force by killing the jedi
Rey is the most hated Jedi ever. She serves the dark lord Kennedy who is destroying Star Wars. Come on Disney fire both of them.
Rest in (not) Peace
Palpatine works decades perfecting the force, learning its secrets and creating a machine to help him channel all of the Sith.
Mary Sue held a lightsaber about a month and wins with two lightsabers.
Somehow , palpatine has returned..........😅
Be real. It's metaphorical that they were actually being helped by the dead. Rey had moral support only. They each had their own strength separately. Rey was more powerful than her father.
It's the Force. You know? The thing that has ACTUAL POWER?! And I'd imagine a Force spirit manifesting itself would be perfect fucking powerful.
"and I.... Am Iron Man."
They could've maybe not stolen their own ending. Feels cheap.
not true starkiller by himself would have slaughtered Palpatine.
Luke had to deal with his father Darth Vader, Rey had to deal with her family as well.
Either people have severe comprehension issues or they really just hate Rey because she's a girl...As she literally says she's "all the Jedi" with numerous Jedi there with her...Yet people continue to say she beat Sidious alone..🤦♂️🤦♂️🤦♂️
Agreed.
No she’s just poorly written throughout the whole trilogy as is the trilogy a a whole
Why couldn't anyone call on dead Jedi to help them in battle before Ray? And why wouldn't the force ghosts appear to help Luke? Why didn't Qui Gon ever appear to help Obi Wan? It just seems a bit cheap. I would have preferred an ending where Kylo and her take out the emperor together. But we can't have that now can we?
It isn't because she's a girl...so are Ahsoka and Jyn, great characters.
Rey is just an archetype.
And i… I am iron man 😂
After Ahsoka, Rey is the worst
Eu sunt CAAMRAC!❤❤JEDAY SUPREM..😂😂😂
I am all the Jedi, except for the ones in the Acolyte. They were all gay.
But it was Rey's sheer will!
Mary Sue Rey: I am all the jedi.
Yoda: A jedi, you are not. A mistake, for sure you are.
So.... Palpatine is dead right.....? right?
👍 👍 👍 ❤️
Disney would never do this. The cringe will be with them, always.
Rip Star Wars. we'll remember you for the story you were, not the abused brain hemorrhage you were made into.
If your a starwars fan. At this point. Are you like me saying really?
rise
Why can't the bad guys ever win?
To be fair it’s topping what Disney did is a really really low bar. If you want to do this properly scrap the whole thing. Don’t make Sidious the biggest moron ever instead show him to actually be the strongest sith ever instead of making massive plot holes and nonsense like loosing to his Mary Sue granddaughter with barely any training or experience.
I like the addition of the force ghosts but "BEST FORCE SPIRIT EDIT!"??? I think not. The cuts between scenes were sloppy.
Is she dead? Will she join the Jedi Masters?
Great edit up until you kill off Rey, kinda misses the whole point of the Jedi living on and all that.
I get your point. I just wanted to show the scene in whole.
Should have been the Sith and Jedi both die. Then balance would really be restored to the Force. You could still have Rey survive, she could forge her own path not as a Jedi or a Sith (or a Skywalker)
Why does watching this give me the urge to go buy useless toys?
This alone would have made this wack movie the best
There was a best line in that movie?
Exactly.
Kathleen Kennedy, are you reading this?
Still didnt like the movie but this ending would have at least made a little more sense to it
Fair enough.
Worst scene ever, I would prefer if she said " And I'm a Skywalker" to make more sense with the title of the movie The Rise of Skywalker but that's just me.
So ur tryin to make perfect by addin jedi force ghosts 😂
Nothin will change.
Bluetooth battery charging.
She's no Jedi.
This was the scene that made me quit Star Wars altogether