ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 22 ส.ค. 2024
- #starwars #rogueone #andor #mandalorian #maythe4thbewithyou
Stam Fine Reviews looks at the first of the planned standalone Star War side-stories: Rogue One, A Star Wars Story. Director Gareth Edwards (and partly at least Tony Gilroy) have given us the best Star Wars film in decades. Stars Felicity Jones as Jyn Erso, Diego Luna as Cassian Andor, Alan Tudyk as K2SO, Ben Mendelsohn as Krennic, Forest Whitaker as Saw, and Mads Mikkelsen as Galen. Also: Riz Ahmed, Donnie Yen, Wen Jiang, Genevieve O'Reilly, and Jimmy Smits.
Rogue One was what the sequels should have been.
But it's not, it's a prequel.
@@miketran4289 He just means they should have respected SW instead of trying to rewrite everything and be good instead of sucking
@@miketran4289 I'd say it's a midquel since the prequels have been released🤣
@@donkeysaurusrex7881 lol What do you mean "rewrite"?
Rogue One did that. It ruined A New Hope.
Every Star Wars film or show by Disney that has storm troopers and rebels falls flat for me.
Season one of the mandalorian is their only good product.
@@FriendlyCroockwithout imperials or rebels you can hardly call it STAR WARS. ....
I love Rogue One and still watch it a few times a year. I'm not sure how such an enjoyable film slipped past Disney and got released!
Same with Andor. IMO it's the best piece of SW media since ESB
I'm sure Disney are absolutely FURIOUS that people love RO so much and not the horrible Rey movies.
@@Foebane72 guarantee you they don’t care because those movies made money
@@farwoodfarm9296 Agreed, but not just Starwars, it's the best thing I've watched in 2022.
lol I do not like this film one bit.
Except for some of the action scenes maybe.
Preaching the truth. Rogue One is a damn fine Star Wars film.
YUP...Love it....I own it...great flick!
Rogue One is hands down my favorite Disney Star Wars movie. I remember having hope for the future of the franchise after watching it. Unfortunately it's been one disappointment after another since then. Disney has no plan and no vision. They just produce uninspired content.
Rogue 1 had “the feels” of the original Star Wars trilogy. Nothing else has. The original ‘trilogy’ is now four movies long. 👍🏼
I enjoyed Rogue One a lot more than the Skywalker sequels. It had a great aesthetic. Not perfect but there was a lot to like.
I feel like the imperfections make it perfect but I 100% agree with you
This is the best Star Wars movie since the Return of the Jedi
Comes cloose to some of the novels and Star Wars Comics
I’d say Revenge of the Sith
Slight correction, he simply made the reactor highly unstable, but the exhaust port was a normal design choice, which the Rebels had to find with the plans a way to get to it
I watched Andor with my dad who never saw Rogue One. We watched it after and that series DID give a ton of depth to the film.
The only Star Wars good movie under disney.
100% this.
I would argue solo is 100% better then this. Its a absolutely gorgeous looking movie, but it still has a lot of flaws, with the chief problem being underdeveloped characters. Post andor has corrected this to a point, but judged on its own merits it has trouble standing.
I thought solo was good not amazing but still a good movie
@@jonaswhitt4322 - I think Solo was a bit too intent on explaining everything. Like how he got his name, how he met Chewbacca, how he obtained his blaster pistol, how the Kessel Run happened, why C3PO accused the Millenium Falcon of having a "peculiar dialect". It was a bit of an overload of coincidental explanations, all condensed into a brief segment of Han Solo's history.
Rogue One stepped over the line a few times (like having Jyn run into Evazan and Ponda Baba just days before they showed up at the Mos Eisley cantina) but it wasn't as much of an overload.
@@jonaswhitt4322 nah bro solo is a great film but this was a master piece.
Great retrospective. 100% agree with everything you said. Until Andor, Rogue One was probably my favourite 'new' Star Wars. There have been good entries on the streaming and animated sides, but the thing about Rogue One was it gave me a different feel for this universe. It gave peril, trudgery, oppression and for the first time made me feel like I understood what people were fighting for in A New Hope (rather than being told it). It's a rare prequel that adds colour to the previously release film. Do I want all Star Wars to be like this? No. Do I want some to be like this? Definitely. Rogue One showed you could branch out and tell different types of stories in this setting and make it work, and that's what I really hoped for and this film gave, variety.
Rogue One is also one of my favorites of the entire Star Wars collection. Man did we have it good before the sequel trilogy
I worked at a movie theater as an usher when this was out and every day I would go in a few minutes early to watch the Darth Vader hallway scene, it was great and so much fun
I was in my late Thirty's sitting in a theater watching this film. When the Rebel Fleet comes out of hyperspace and you see Gold Leader and Red Leader I turned into a 12 year old boy. Thank you Mr. Edwards and to your team this film is Star Wars Gold. If your a Star Wars fan and most of what Disney is disappointing you Rouge One and now Andor is our hope, our Luke Skywalker.
As someone who is the right age to remember the rebel heroics of the original trilogy at the time I came to the disturbing realisation while watching Rogue One that the rebels were depicted as terrorists from a certain point of view 🤔
No, just more realistic. War is a dirty business and nobody is entirely good.
This was the only Star Wars movie I'd seen since TESB that gave me _that_ feeling, the one Star Wars movies are supposed to give you. If the original had come out in 2016 instead of 1977, I think it would've been very much like Rogue One.
No it wouldn't. ESB is the least Star Warsy Star Wars movie. No dog fighting. Barely any alien life. No grand set pieces and action scenes. The opening battle was the equivalent of tying an elephant's shoe laces together, the saber fight was good though. Lucas likes Star Wars to have more than one tone. And ESB has one tone. Dire, and Dark. And the SW universe is more diverse than that. The best representation of what Star Wars "is" is Return of the Jedi.
@@treborkroy5280 Pfft. ROTJ might as well have been called The Muppets in Space.
@@valmarsiglia because of one species? The Ewoks? Planet Earth has species that look cuter and sillier than them and are actual real animals. Please..
@Trebor Kroy The Ewoks (I didn't know the Earth had anthropomorphic teddy bears), Jabba's Muppet palace and those godawful musicians, just the overall tone was incredibly silly, more like a kids' show than a SW movie.
PS: And Hamill's haircut, lol.
First: I love Rogue One. The only Disney contribution to Star Wars that was Star Wars. Second: I freaked out laughing when the little sequence was inserted where classic actors had over 10 terabytes of data for their digital selves and Steven Seagals was 19 kilobytes. Good shot.
I enjoyed Rogue One so much that I made the prescient decision to no longer watch any more Star Wars films. I felt that it was so good that nothing made subsequent to it would match it. Such a great film to end the Star Wars universe for me (I was 8 when I saw the original back in 1977)
Tell me you watched Andor?
You haven't missed anything
@@farwoodfarm9296 Andor is even better than Rogue One IMO. The rumor is that season 2 is going to end right at the beginning of where Rogue One starts. That would be quite cool.
Make sure you watch ANDOR...ABSOLUTE stellar.
It would be great to see the Gareth Edwards's directors cut.
or at the very least the deleted scenes!
I love how Donnie Yen reprised his Zatoichi role in John Wick. With a Chris Walken flair.
I loved this movie. Beautifully shot.
This movie is so good that it is almost impossible to believe Kathleen Kennedy green-lit it. I own it on DVD and I've been re-watching it every few months.
I'm sending Steven Seagal a gallon of ointment. That was a savage nerd-burn. 🤣
Got a genuine laugh out of me.
Loved Rouge One!
And that scene with Dark Vader!
Rouge One? A new make up line by Maybelline!
This is the only Star Wars movie I wish I could watch in the theater. It is way better than what some claim
Yes it was good in the theater. My favorite modern Star Wars film.
And I saw it in 3D!
Seeing the Darth Vader scene in theaters was insane lol.
The main thing that bothered me about the CGI Peter Cushing was the fact that we were denied the chance to see Wayne Pygram as Tarkin for a whole film.
Disney needs to bite the bullet and recast any roles of old characters that pop up from time to time instead of covering up their faces and voices.
I love this movie and it sits right on the shelf next to the original six...unlike 3 other movies that shall not be named. I wish Andor would get released in a physical medium.
Same here....boy do I want Andor in a physical medium.....pleassssssseeeee yes, I hope they do.
Thank you for giving the actors each their own nod cause that’s why this movie is so good they made it so. And you see it cross over to Andor ands it even better because of it
Great summary. Rogue One is the only Disney Star Wars movie that respects and adheres to George Lucas’s legacy. And the only one I own on 4K Blu-ray.
One part I always enjoy watching is when Jin steps up to lead the crew to get the plans. She says "Saw Gerrera used to say ..." , and if there was ever any doubt in the men following her, it was gone with that line.
Rogue One proves that if Disney wanted to, they could make good Star Wars movies. Sure it's not flawless but overall, I really love this movie.
I wish every Disney film had its level of execution.
Its a great movie for sure. I really wanna see the sequences that were cut, they need to bring out all the deleted scenes
Great review Stam. Once i saw that Donnie Yen was cast in this film i just knew it was gonna be a winner. and i had proven right
It has spy games like the cold war, role playing like D&D, mission briefings like SW1, a beach assault like apocalypse now!.
Is a suicide mission that you know how it ends and were it goes from there. I LOVE IT.
After the prequels and sequels I was done with SW, they were films where you were looking at your watch to guess when they'd end, something you should never find yourself doing in a theatre. Then came R1, when it ended I looked along the seat rows as the lights came up and the collective gasps of joy from the audience was highly palpable.
I'm old enough to have watched all the SW films, at launch, since 1977 and after the initial trilogy I always left the cinema thinking of how I would get my own personal copy; R1 is only the 4th to make me think that way.
At 54 yrs old I eventually got a tattoo...'' and I fear nothing, for all is as the force wills it..'' That's what Rogue One means to me.
If I remember correctly, Galen Erso did spell out the weakness he had created. That the reactor could be caused to detonate the entire station if the Rebellion could set off an explosion in it or near it. The reason they needed the plans to the Death Star was so they could find a way to introduce the explosive... which they ended up doing by exploiting the exhaust port.
Yeah, I guess mounting a starfighter attack to hit a nearly impossible target had a higher percentage of success than planning an infiltration and sabotage mission into the bowels of the reactor…oh wait…
This has become my favorite SW movie, but ESB is still almost tied.
Andor made me appreciate this movie even more.
As far as I'm concerned, Rogue One was the final good Star Wars movie after ROTS.
It's so quick, but the Steven Seagal 19Kb gag _destroyed_ me, rofl 🤣🤣🤣
The Stephen Seagal dig is GOLD 😂
Yup, my favorite disney star wars movie
Great movie. One of my absolute favorites 💓
Yes, agree. This was my favorite modern Star Wars films. I like the smart ass robot and how it dovetailed into a new hope.
Apparently in the next Disney Star Wars movie the main baddie is called Rom De Slantis!
This video "was a surprise, but a welcome one to be sure." Entertaining, it was. New sub!
I've lost it at Steven Seagal floppy disk. Awesome review, you got a subscriber.
My third favorite Star Wars movie, beating Return of the Jedi. It was the one that got my hopes up, Disney might have a clue what to do with Star Wars… what a fail! Even the Mandalorian turned into a boring watch. But surprisingly, Andor is really good. Maybe they should try an Urso show…
Absolutely, the best. Thanks for the fantastic research and presentation
THE PREQUEL WITH No EQUAL - I like the phrase here very fitting!
Rember when I saw it in theaters it was the Star Wars movie I’ve been waiting decades for
My love for this film cant be describe
I wholeheartedly agree that K2SO is the best comedic touch of this movie. He and the blind dude were my favorites when I watched this
Tudyk is a gem.
The only truly great Disney Star Wars film. Solo comes second, but a long way back from this.
It was an early one, before all the "progressive" messaging started to infect the company.
I read the book.
Galen Urso was working on a cheap power generation tech using kyber crystals. He didn't know he was working on a weapon until Saw Guerrera told him he was which is when he fled.
The flaw in the Death Star was placed there because the radiation risk when they weapon fired to the people onboard was extreme. Krenic didn't see a problem with that until he realised that senior imps could be killed. The solution given was exhaust ports to vent excess hard radiation into space. A retro-fit. The exhaust ports lead to the weapon's kyber reactor and not the Death Star's main reactor.
Rogue One is a real movie. It can stand alone on its own. An Art masterpiece with so many subtle layers that makes you want to watch it on and on...
Rogue One is great. One of those films that you just put on every now and then.
The ultimate tease by Disney. A really, really good Star Wars film.
Two things:
1. The Imperials nuked Scarif because their repository of secrets and plans (like the Death Star) had been breached, and so decided to annihilate it to prevent further breaches and thefts of information. It's not like that place contained the only copies, after all.
2. Darth Vader was so tired and out of breath by ANH's opening simply because of his murderous rampage just before in RO's climax, which makes perfect sense. Don't forget, Vader is also not as young as he used to be.
One of the best Star Wars fan fiction movies! We all know of course that it really was Kyle Katarn and Jan Ors, who stole the death Star plans, but whatever.. great and epic fun!
🤣🤣🤣
Yeah it’s just a coincidence that Jyn and Casian bear more than a passing resemblance to Kyle and Jan.
The reality, let's be honest, the best original Star Wars scenes, such as the attack on either Death Stars, the battles on Hoth and Endor's Moon, the capture of Tantive IV, anything with Han Solo, were all Rebel scenes. Rogue One is a culmination of what was really the most fun elements of the original trilogy.
spot-on review. My only issue with Rogue One is the clumsy insertion of R2D2 and C3PO who are meant to be on Leia's ship.
I didn't have a problem with that, figuring they must have been herded aboard the ship when they left Yavin. I'm more bothered by Jyn running into Evazan and Ponda Baba just days before they were at the Mos Eisley cantina.
@@RictusHolloweye ‘member berries, as far as the eye can see
Doctor Krenick- "The man that thought he got Matthew Quigley."
Best of the new Star Wars films
Rogue One is by far the greatest "Star Wars Feeling" movie since E6 ❤️
I was told that Alan Tudek was actually on Set the whole time. Apparently he was wearing electrician, stilts and stomping around. I heard him joking about it one time. He said that an unforeseen complication of him being on the stilts is that his crotch was right at everybody’s eye level
My third favourite of all Star Wars films, only behind A New Hope and The. Empire Strikes Back.
Easily my second dav film of the franchise. This movie was so close to perfect. Such a tragic tale, but one of arguably the most important event for the rebellion. Without those plans, the rebellion would surely be lost.
Chirrut Îmwe is best boi.
I'm so glad "Rogue One" gets such acclaim. There is nothing to fault in it.
Three planets in the first 15 minutes?
I said this the day I saw it, R1 was excellent but there were still people who said it was terrible. Now, everyone praised how good it was. It doesn’t take genius to see the story was good, the characters were likable and flawed, the comedy was on point and not silly or over done, and the action was really well done. No it’s not perfect, but it’s damn good.
Here here!
imo R1 is the best of the universe since Empire.
"Look ma, no Jedi"
Chirrut Îmwe: "Am I a joke to you?"
The irony that Cassian dies by the tech he helped build.
Funny story I dropped my car at a shop and walked by a theater. Opening day they sneaked in an 1130 showing that wasn't sold-out, so I thought what the heck! I had chills leaving the theater. Thought it was the best thing since Empire. The next show was packed!! People in line could see I liked it.
great movie- great commentary.
Was very impressed with Rogue One. Honestly I rank it #4 out of all the star wars movies, right after the original trilogy (in order).
Rouge noun is the StarWars/Holby City crossover we didn't no we needed.
I'm not a big Star Wars fan, but I really enjoyed this movie.
Best Star Wars film by a country mile
Yes Stam, Starboard is down. (In Space) lol
13:00 😂 Segal’s floppy disk
I loved it, R1 was such an interesting view and take on the SW Galaxy
Thanks for reviewing Rogue One 👍🏻
Better for having no Skywalkers in it. 😂
This movie was by far the best and most creative sw movie under disney. And if you like the darker more adult tones of the tv shows you have this to thank. I know some people think the characters are a little shallow and the pacing is a little off. But this movie is the first actual war movie in star wars. Most people dont like the saving private ryan because of the character's. The people in a war movie should seem like realistic grounded characters that could be anyone. And in war tons of people just die and essentially forgotten. So im fine with them being less defined and all dying.
Hang on a moment. Are you saying this film is a prequel to Star Wars? I thought this was a prequel to 'Moulin Rouge'.
I saw the originals as a kid but RO is in my top three now great pic
Tony Gilroy 🏆
And we also got a themed SW BF 2 Scarif map and skins.
Great vid and great opinions
Best Star Wars movie EVER.
Definitely in the top 4 star wars movies - with episodes 3,4&5
Andor was a great prequel to this prequel
Rogue One and Andor are the best products of Disney's StarWars, Period.
Rogue One became my favorite Star Wars movie
Fantastic as always... I've not always been the biggest Star Wars fan, but you're right this is a good one... so how come no "Doctor Who actor" bingo? Surely that's a thing?
There are a few but Felicity Jones is the only one with more than a few lines of dialogue.
The best Star Wars movie
Great movie, my favorite
best star wars movie fact
I love this movie, possibly better than The Skywalker Saga films.