Quality preschool child care, Universal pre-K, free school lunches for ALL children, and a move away from 'for profit' private schools would all improve education. Other western democracies know this, and invest in their children, why not us?
Because it takes more than preschool. Without parents who support kids all the way through to graduation, with stable finances and homes, the benefits of enriched preschool makes no difference.
@@Cathy-xi8cbit makes a difference. It's not going to fix everything, but can reduce our avoid a lot of childhood trauma and reduce the reading skills gap for kids beginning elementary
@@growtocycle6992 There is some fairly good recent research that tells us that the "bump" disappears by grade 3. Just as reading becomes more about interpreting instead of decoding simple messages. Putting parents into good jobs with benefits does far more. Stable housing, stable meals, stable transportation, etc. THOSE things help kids learn.
@@growtocycle6992 Education doesn't solve childhood trama. Nor do schools solve kids arriving hungry, or exhausted from up in the night coming home from babysitters after their parents' 2nd job. Or nightly chaos left home with their 12 year old sibling baby sitting. Changing who's at the bottom, their education proposal, solves nothing. Teachers aren't social workers. Min Living Wage - for all.
I’m a true conservative with a background in economics. Tim Walz has a great economic policy record. He is a sane veteran who simply fights for the working class. Is that radical? I think we need to keep the country fair to keep what we have. USA innovation comes from fair laws, so Walz’s ideas can help us stay competitive. Hopefully Harris & Walz KEEP LINA KAHN @ FTC and fight hard for fairer class dynamics.
Some very compelling ideas here. Providing the conditions for nurturing families and communities to thrive should be society’s number one priority. There is no substitute for mentorship, leadership, and tailored solutions. It is hard and requires engaging with complex issues, but the children are worth it.
Basic income programs like this *also* need what Chetty is talking about - hands-on system navigation. It can be a capacity challenge or an executive function challenge, that, when overcome, will lead to a snowball of gains throughout their lives! Fantastic segment, Hari, thank you!
Providing counseling and other social supports to families is something I wrote about in 2007 in a short report called, Healthy Families & Neighborhoods for all kids. Having grown up in a family with domestic violence and a 3x incarcerated dad resulted in me growing up inside a dry cleaning shop so commonsense to me as to what is needed.
The comprehensive examination of this research is very compelling. It offers valuable insight that could potentially guide our political and social objectives for enhancing America and the world.
For starters, the GOP has kept cutting the EEOC budget. Let's reverse that so corporations have to promote fair hiring and promotion by law. I have zero confidence that corporations can self-regulate and be fair.
Both parties promote importing a labor glut. Rs' visa indentured white collar, Ds' blue collar Everyone Here Illegally Should Stay Here. Both parties, regardless of being in control of both white house and congress, have left min tipped wage at $2.13 an hour. Washington is anti-economic household stability for the public.
Don't let the weird uncle touch them. Feed them from the produce and fresh mest aisle. Ask where they are going. Ask where they have been. Don't put your selfish adult wants and greeds on their tiny shoulders. Embarrass them in front of their friends. Hug them when they aren't expecting it. Commute their sentence from time to time. Tell them where to get help if they can't come to you with a problem. Don't make everything about you.
Poor white young adults could have told you this w/o a study; they see that they are struggling in ways their poor aunts and uncles did not. Those white kids in the 70s had access to union jobs because racist policies favored them and unions protected them. That is now gone. Rich people have always done well. And always will.
Rich people favor having a labor glut, for rock bottom wages, regardless of race. "And always will." The very basis of globalism. Shop for and exploit the cheapest workers on the planet. Sell high, in the west/westward. Flaw in their plan, impending implosion: no discretionary income in the west, means no discretionary market there either.
I'm almost tempted to watch and listen just to learn how the discussion defines/the scholars define "...is closing..." ["...racial gap is closing..."🤔🕵🏿♀️🦉🕵🏿♀️☹️🤞🏿😵💫🤢🦉🕵🏿♀️
The Clintons kicked off "Centrist" democrats - and tipped min wage has been at $2.13 ever since. It shouldn't take a village, to feed a child. Living Min Wage. Nationally.
I think social media now, TH-camr and tik toker, there are people/kids make tons of money now by making videos... so by that being said, I think we definitely moving on to the new era. But I totally agree that income plays an very important role. And attentive parent too, of course!
You could probably attribute most of the losses in all groups to increases single parent household and any gains to unfathomable government spending to try to make progress against the tide. A cultural change to value intact families and education would be a cost effective and more productive way forward.
It’s just not happening fast enough (social-economic upward mobility) to combat inflation and ‘COLA’ sharp changes. Even as a resident of the Southeast US region cited within segment, recruit from out of state and contract professionals (especially in technology, finance, mid-management) from overseas fill positions on a rotation while not impacting policy enhancement as engaged voter population. Those with highest stake in realized social-economic change continue to be circumvented by appealing incentive employers. The ‘race specific’ determining factor for opportunity to sustain rise in quality of life conditions remains a reality here. Please continue speaking more on topic to hold policymakers accountably aware via media coverage. PS: Per Scholas required enrollees to be available full time during daytime working hours, lack of flexibility disqualifies the working adult population unable to remove effectively unemployed, not obliged to meet living expenses to benefit from sponsored ‘upskill’ training program being offered (inquired about 1 year ago).
Industry is making record profits from imported labor glut. They aren't going to hire an American engineer when they can get a visa indentured worker from India at $8.10 an hour, or an American blue collar worker when they can get an illegal immigrant at wage theft rates of less than min wage. 35 years of this, and it's only gotten worse.
The best way to put a child on the path to success as adults is for that child to be reared in two parent, stable home. The family is the foundation of our social structure.
He me tinned economically stable families but never expanded on it. You are spot on- two parents in a stable relationship raising kids with stability and love. That's a kids ticket to success. Why they won't state the importance of stable marriages for children is beyond me.
@ideaWorld403 he is a professor of public economics. There's no public policy intervention that can make two parents love, respect and support each other so he doesn't mention that. When are we going to move on from the idea that it's OK to write tens of millions of kids off just because they grew up in the "wrong" kind of family?
There's something about the "years of birth" range that is a bit *meh* for me; the demographic for this specific dataset is those between the ages of 32-46 years old. What about these factors in younger demographics? The data is not giving the whole picture but it is SOUNDING as if it is the whole picture. That's the problem.
with respect, aren't these the same old programs that have been in place forever? None of this sounds new or different. Throwing $ at problems of course isn't enough but positioning these ideas as great new suggestions sounds insane to me
I was one of three students in 3rd grade that excelled. The teacher said that only one of us will be successful because it's a bad world. I did not survive. I got bullied in 5th grade.
Fortunately, I had a father who started assertiveness training on us when we were small. As for the bullies, your opinion of you is far more important than that of others. Particularly opinions of bullies who can't control their own abusers, so forward their hostilities to others. Best wishes, and take care of your 3rd grader aspirations - he's still there, waiting for you, to pick him up.
@@imperialmotoring3789 Transgender are born that way. They're changing their physical gender to match their brain's gender. The two are from two different hormone spikes during pregnancy, which occurs two weeks apart. For most of us, that hormone spike is the same gender, but not for all of us.
@@buzoff4642 I do see your point. Why did everyone get mad at Rachel Dolezal when she changed her physical race to match her brain's race? Rachel is a gorgeous and intelligent African-American woman and was mistreated for being who she is.
Better odd: Economically stable family, which any Harvard affiliate will avoid including in evaluation. Thus, they propose play the odds - with education. My Asian coworkers move to locales with "schools reputed for easy As".
Quality preschool child care, Universal pre-K, free school lunches for ALL children, and a move away from 'for profit' private schools would all improve education. Other western democracies know this, and invest in their children, why not us?
Because it takes more than preschool. Without parents who support kids all the way through to graduation, with stable finances and homes, the benefits of enriched preschool makes no difference.
@@Cathy-xi8cbit makes a difference. It's not going to fix everything, but can reduce our avoid a lot of childhood trauma and reduce the reading skills gap for kids beginning elementary
@@growtocycle6992 There is some fairly good recent research that tells us that the "bump" disappears by grade 3. Just as reading becomes more about interpreting instead of decoding simple messages. Putting parents into good jobs with benefits does far more. Stable housing, stable meals, stable transportation, etc. THOSE things help kids learn.
@@growtocycle6992 Education doesn't solve childhood trama. Nor do schools solve kids arriving hungry, or exhausted from up in the night coming home from babysitters after their parents' 2nd job. Or nightly chaos left home with their 12 year old sibling baby sitting.
Changing who's at the bottom, their education proposal, solves nothing. Teachers aren't social workers.
Min Living Wage - for all.
@@Cathy-xi8cb Which is why we need to support those things too.
This is real news.. I appreciate how the interviewer asked about how this can be applied and that Raj actually had an answer…
❤ WE NEED MORE PEOPLE LIKE RAJ CHETTY 🎉 PLEASE KEEP COVERING
I’m a true conservative with a background in economics. Tim Walz has a great economic policy record. He is a sane veteran who simply fights for the working class. Is that radical? I think we need to keep the country fair to keep what we have. USA innovation comes from fair laws, so Walz’s ideas can help us stay competitive. Hopefully Harris & Walz KEEP LINA KAHN @ FTC and fight hard for fairer class dynamics.
Some very compelling ideas here. Providing the conditions for nurturing families and communities to thrive should be society’s number one priority. There is no substitute for mentorship, leadership, and tailored solutions. It is hard and requires engaging with complex issues, but the children are worth it.
It's no substitute for Living Min Wage.
Basic income programs like this *also* need what Chetty is talking about - hands-on system navigation. It can be a capacity challenge or an executive function challenge, that, when overcome, will lead to a snowball of gains throughout their lives! Fantastic segment, Hari, thank you!
Providing counseling and other social supports to families is something I wrote about in 2007 in a short report called, Healthy Families & Neighborhoods for all kids. Having grown up in a family with domestic violence and a 3x incarcerated dad resulted in me growing up inside a dry cleaning shop so commonsense to me as to what is needed.
Amazing to hear. Shoutout to our amazing ancestors & boomer parents for helping to shrink our insidious race gaps. ❤🎉
The comprehensive examination of this research is very compelling. It offers valuable insight that could potentially guide our political and social objectives for enhancing America and the world.
For starters, the GOP has kept cutting the EEOC budget. Let's reverse that so corporations have to promote fair hiring and promotion by law. I have zero confidence that corporations can self-regulate and be fair.
Both parties promote importing a labor glut. Rs' visa indentured white collar, Ds' blue collar Everyone Here Illegally Should Stay Here.
Both parties, regardless of being in control of both white house and congress, have left min tipped wage at $2.13 an hour.
Washington is anti-economic household stability for the public.
Don't let the weird uncle touch them. Feed them from the produce and fresh mest aisle. Ask where they are going. Ask where they have been. Don't put your selfish adult wants and greeds on their tiny shoulders. Embarrass them in front of their friends. Hug them when they aren't expecting it. Commute their sentence from time to time. Tell them where to get help if they can't come to you with a problem. Don't make everything about you.
Im a psychotherapist serving older teens and young adults. Great advice.
Don't give boys tampons.
Eddie Murphy & Dan Akroyd's movie back in the day was just about this same thing.
The Duke Brothers/Koch Brothers whatever.
Trading Places! I watch it every Christmas.
Poor white young adults could have told you this w/o a study; they see that they are struggling in ways their poor aunts and uncles did not. Those white kids in the 70s had access to union jobs because racist policies favored them and unions protected them. That is now gone. Rich people have always done well. And always will.
Rich people favor having a labor glut, for rock bottom wages, regardless of race.
"And always will."
The very basis of globalism. Shop for and exploit the cheapest workers on the planet. Sell high, in the west/westward.
Flaw in their plan, impending implosion: no discretionary income in the west, means no discretionary market there either.
I'm almost tempted to watch and listen just to learn how the discussion defines/the scholars define "...is closing..." ["...racial gap is closing..."🤔🕵🏿♀️🦉🕵🏿♀️☹️🤞🏿😵💫🤢🦉🕵🏿♀️
Hillary wrote It Takes A Village decades ago. Sounds like he's basically saying something very similar.
The Clintons kicked off "Centrist" democrats - and tipped min wage has been at $2.13 ever since.
It shouldn't take a village, to feed a child.
Living Min Wage. Nationally.
Excellent research to help us continue to find ways to address entrenched issues
I think social media now, TH-camr and tik toker, there are people/kids make tons of money now by making videos... so by that being said, I think we definitely moving on to the new era. But I totally agree that income plays an very important role. And attentive parent too, of course!
1:45 misleading visual. If the chart has axis crossing at $0 it won’t appear to be such a dramatic change.
Great segment
You could probably attribute most of the losses in all groups to increases single parent household and any gains to unfathomable government spending to try to make progress against the tide. A cultural change to value intact families and education would be a cost effective and more productive way forward.
Opportunities Insight @ Harvard😊
It all comes down to family.
Which is a wild card.
Worse, "success" means moving away for college and again for work, leaving family behind. "Fly In For The Funeral" population.
The data is from 1978 to 1992?
Those are the years of birth of the people tracked today
No shit, don't send them to law school, we don't need more lawyers. Teach them to make things, not manipulate things.
"make things"
Etsy isn't a plan. The rest of consumables has been offshored, to ultra cheap labor locations.
Clearly class plays the largest role.
The City of Atlanta is not doing well, but Metro Atlanta is striving
That's how it is in Manila, Philippines also. The wealth gap is quite visible.
Metro [any city] "is striving" due to walling off of the cheap labor, to city centers.
It's called Snob Zoning.
It’s just not happening fast enough (social-economic upward mobility) to combat inflation and ‘COLA’ sharp changes. Even as a resident of the Southeast US region cited within segment, recruit from out of state and contract professionals (especially in technology, finance, mid-management) from overseas fill positions on a rotation while not impacting policy enhancement as engaged voter population. Those with highest stake in realized social-economic change continue to be circumvented by appealing incentive employers. The ‘race specific’ determining factor for opportunity to sustain rise in quality of life conditions remains a reality here. Please continue speaking more on topic to hold policymakers accountably aware via media coverage. PS: Per Scholas required enrollees to be available full time during daytime working hours, lack of flexibility disqualifies the working adult population unable to remove effectively unemployed, not obliged to meet living expenses to benefit from sponsored ‘upskill’ training program being offered (inquired about 1 year ago).
Industry is making record profits from imported labor glut.
They aren't going to hire an American engineer when they can get a visa indentured worker from India at $8.10 an hour, or an American blue collar worker when they can get an illegal immigrant at wage theft rates of less than min wage.
35 years of this, and it's only gotten worse.
The best way to put a child on the path to success as adults is for that child to be reared in two parent, stable home. The family is the foundation of our social structure.
He me tinned economically stable families but never expanded on it. You are spot on- two parents in a stable relationship raising kids with stability and love. That's a kids ticket to success. Why they won't state the importance of stable marriages for children is beyond me.
@ideaWorld403 he is a professor of public economics. There's no public policy intervention that can make two parents love, respect and support each other so he doesn't mention that.
When are we going to move on from the idea that it's OK to write tens of millions of kids off just because they grew up in the "wrong" kind of family?
There's something about the "years of birth" range that is a bit *meh* for me; the demographic for this specific dataset is those between the ages of 32-46 years old. What about these factors in younger demographics? The data is not giving the whole picture but it is SOUNDING as if it is the whole picture. That's the problem.
A simple solution for parents - move to better zip codes
with respect, aren't these the same old programs that have been in place forever? None of this sounds new or different. Throwing $ at problems of course isn't enough but positioning these ideas as great new suggestions sounds insane to me
I was one of three students in 3rd grade that excelled. The teacher said that only one of us will be successful because it's a bad world. I did not survive. I got bullied in 5th grade.
Fortunately, I had a father who started assertiveness training on us when we were small.
As for the bullies, your opinion of you is far more important than that of others. Particularly opinions of bullies who can't control their own abusers, so forward their hostilities to others.
Best wishes, and take care of your 3rd grader aspirations - he's still there, waiting for you, to pick him up.
How about starting with, not telling children there where are black jobs, and white jobs.
And stop telling them that they can choose and change gender.
@@imperialmotoring3789 Transgender are born that way. They're changing their physical gender to match their brain's gender. The two are from two different hormone spikes during pregnancy, which occurs two weeks apart. For most of us, that hormone spike is the same gender, but not for all of us.
@@buzoff4642 Serial killers are born that way too.
@@buzoff4642 Is it transphobic to abort a trans baby?
@@buzoff4642 I do see your point. Why did everyone get mad at Rachel Dolezal when she changed her physical race to match her brain's race? Rachel is a gorgeous and intelligent African-American woman and was mistreated for being who she is.
Trump:- my time black kids did good 😁…. Biden:- my time black white together went war..😎🥤
We don't believe you, you need more people.
Oh yeah, let's solve the problem by just moving everyone out of the poor communities, and get them to move into the rich communities... 🤦
Living Min Wage.
habitus = reproduction of cultural capital.
What are the factors which helped them to perform better, please explain
Better odd: Economically stable family, which any Harvard affiliate will avoid including in evaluation.
Thus, they propose play the odds - with education. My Asian coworkers move to locales with "schools reputed for easy As".