I like how john says he isn’t after fame. Because he ends up sort of getting it. Because rockstar said that in RDR 1 John was supposed to get famous. (You have a fame meter, but you were meant to get it high) due to single handily turning the tides to a Mexican revolution, hunting and killing bill Williamson, Javier, and Dutch. Not to mention all the people and places you save, like McFarlanes ranch, ect.
This is great because it means that when Landon Ricketts tells John about his fellow gunslingers being dead, he doesn't realize that he's talking to the man who killed them.
@@rdr.erased John can do it for gameplay purposes solely, Arthur is the guy who did it, John has arthurs copied dialogue for a lot of stranger missions that you meet the character once (these) but he only goes like ''oh i knew a fella'' for missions that reaccur - hamish
To give props to granger, he fought the duel with a knife, it seems stupid until you realise that he must’ve fought gun duels in the past eight a knife…. And WON, he brought a knife to a gun fight and won, which means not every thing he said must’ve been lies.
@Deadx2172 fr, in rdr1 we were even told how was john when he was in dutch's gang. It's an incoherence, and not "character development". I mean, it's not just like 1911 was a badass, stoic and smart man, but it also is that we know since rdr1 how he was in the past Talking about rdr2 stupid choices rockstar took : after 5 years it still annoys me that they made john many times unable to talk properly, making stupid decisions, etc... with few good moments during 1899 where we see his wisdom, smartness, and we see his skills like in two missions. Even in rdr2, we see that john is cleary on top about making plans, wise quotes and all, but they couls have done better, especially about 1907 john
@@nightmarepegasus4141i like to just try and think that john was dutchs favorite and more involved before the blackwater massacre. Then in rdr2 hes mostly checked out and getting ready to leave again. I always john thought did alot better on his own rather than riding with a few people
@@jessebailey5962 yeah true In rdr2, john is in a depressive mood, it also can be the reason why he's like this, with also him doubting dutch ( the first to doubt and being hated for that, from what we're told in rdr1) , not feeling ready to be a father ( probably mostly because the bio father of john was a violent drunk gambler, so john being scared to be an aweful father maybe) and that jack probably wasn't john's son ( abigail could have cheated on john Yeah, john have been dutch's favorite, probably cause of john's skills, smartness, way to see the world... Arthur was also jealous of john cause of it, john being the asset of the gang I'd like a rdr3 about the golden age of the gang, with a john that really was like we're told he was from rdr1, as a badass and clever, well speaker outlaw
@@nightmarepegasus4141 yep Arthur even says John always learned faster than he did. He was the 4th guy in the gang at 12, so I'd imagine 15 year old to 26 year old John was a different monster then life happened like his kid and the kids mom, he left, then the blackwater stuff so by the time rdr2 started he was checked out. I mean he thought about leaving again in the first scene in the mountains
The i shoot ppl in the back doesnt fit john to he has some gunslinging honor when he isnt outnumbered like when he duels the mexican official during that mission
Awesome video! I don't know why, but for me the 1.00 Fitment not working. (I putted it in to the JMRP Streaming files.)In the video it looks like you are using John's npc body. Where did you get John's beta Wheel outfit with the beta cassimere shirt? Please, can you help me out?
There is the JMRP V3.57 folder, just copy and paste it to the lml folder. There is the bonus files folder, open the Outfit Files folder, then open the All Optional Outfit files folder copy everything and paste the files to the JMRP V3.57 folder. There is the JMRP_Streaming_Files folder, copy and paste that to the JMRP V3.57 folder as well. There is a folder called Changed Pronghorn Outfits, open the folder, copy the file in the folder and paste it in to the JMRP V3.57 folder. Start the game and go to the Fence. Was this so hard to do?!
John’s attitude and personality fit rather well. Though, since most people never played RDR1 they think that Arthur is superior. Arthur’s whole tough guy attitude was originally John’s back in the first game.
@silentsangheili4895 Arthur personality a lot different from John , only a fool would say Arthur is copied from John lol , I love both protagonists , but Arthur is more flashed out , funny compared to stoic serious John Marston, he has more sense of humor , emotions , I love Johnny boy but it's time to admit that Arthur feels more humane compared to John , and don't say I didn't played rdr 1 , because I did couple times , I like John as a badass dangerous person , but I love Arthur more as a human
@@labelnineArthur felt more real to you because he got girly emotional about half the stuff he thought about. John went around being being himself and killing when it was needed. And it showed because through rdr1 and rdr2 john makes alot more friends just being real than Arthur ever did.
I like how john says he isn’t after fame. Because he ends up sort of getting it. Because rockstar said that in RDR 1 John was supposed to get famous. (You have a fame meter, but you were meant to get it high) due to single handily turning the tides to a Mexican revolution, hunting and killing bill Williamson, Javier, and Dutch. Not to mention all the people and places you save, like McFarlanes ranch, ect.
Got all of this.. When he only wanted his family back :(
Exactly, steadily creating a mess (just like the far away song)
This is great because it means that when Landon Ricketts tells John about his fellow gunslingers being dead, he doesn't realize that he's talking to the man who killed them.
It was Arthur wo killed them
@@MacGyver122 In this video it's John
@@MacGyver122 if you can do it as john it wasnt arthur
@@rdr.erased John can do it for gameplay purposes solely, Arthur is the guy who did it, John has arthurs copied dialogue for a lot of stranger missions that you meet the character once (these) but he only goes like ''oh i knew a fella'' for missions that reaccur - hamish
@@MacGyver122it’s clearly John doing it lmao
That’s some attention to detail.. to add the RDR1 stranger* mission complete theme at 18:00
Thank you fazcock
@@praiseaidan no problem praisekaleb
LOVE the music from RDR1 being used.
To give props to granger, he fought the duel with a knife, it seems stupid until you realise that he must’ve fought gun duels in the past eight a knife…. And WON, he brought a knife to a gun fight and won, which means not every thing he said must’ve been lies.
this is not how john would phrase things, that is why I more prefer to do these with morgan
rdr1 john would though some things he wouldnt say though
@Deadx2172 fr, in rdr1 we were even told how was john when he was in dutch's gang. It's an incoherence, and not "character development". I mean, it's not just like 1911 was a badass, stoic and smart man, but it also is that we know since rdr1 how he was in the past
Talking about rdr2 stupid choices rockstar took : after 5 years it still annoys me that they made john many times unable to talk properly, making stupid decisions, etc... with few good moments during 1899 where we see his wisdom, smartness, and we see his skills like in two missions.
Even in rdr2, we see that john is cleary on top about making plans, wise quotes and all, but they couls have done better, especially about 1907 john
@@nightmarepegasus4141i like to just try and think that john was dutchs favorite and more involved before the blackwater massacre. Then in rdr2 hes mostly checked out and getting ready to leave again. I always john thought did alot better on his own rather than riding with a few people
@@jessebailey5962 yeah true
In rdr2, john is in a depressive mood, it also can be the reason why he's like this, with also him doubting dutch ( the first to doubt and being hated for that, from what we're told in rdr1) , not feeling ready to be a father ( probably mostly because the bio father of john was a violent drunk gambler, so john being scared to be an aweful father maybe) and that jack probably wasn't john's son ( abigail could have cheated on john
Yeah, john have been dutch's favorite, probably cause of john's skills, smartness, way to see the world... Arthur was also jealous of john cause of it, john being the asset of the gang
I'd like a rdr3 about the golden age of the gang, with a john that really was like we're told he was from rdr1, as a badass and clever, well speaker outlaw
@@nightmarepegasus4141 yep Arthur even says John always learned faster than he did. He was the 4th guy in the gang at 12, so I'd imagine 15 year old to 26 year old John was a different monster then life happened like his kid and the kids mom, he left, then the blackwater stuff so by the time rdr2 started he was checked out. I mean he thought about leaving again in the first scene in the mountains
The dislouge is exactly the same it seemed a bit of doesnt feel like john would suggest to kill him in his sleep or say the word BUNK
Yeah it fits arthur more
Did anyone say the mod changed voice lines? Did anyone say it's possible to pull custom dialogue straight from the voice actors out of thin air?
@@galactigod no but soon as dialogue modding is possible all ppl gotta do is get an cameo of rob saying the stuff they need
The i shoot ppl in the back doesnt fit john to he has some gunslinging honor when he isnt outnumbered like when he duels the mexican official during that mission
@@Bithe_GetI'm sorry but these things are NOT as easy as yall think. Otherwise you'd be doing it yourself.
again another masterpiece!
Shit john's wearing the black winter coat in lemoyne you should have gone with rip van winkle or another less warm outfit loo
He’s RDR1 accurate, immune to weather and temperature
@@praiseaidan lmao now thats dedication to the recreation
The black winter coat looks cool, i always use it, even in new austin, sadly you can't close it
@@pastaa_7 i totally agree, closed i find it really good looking
I wish we could open vests and close coats
what can I say amazing video once again
15:22 the new varnish for lancasters
Black belle is hot
is the cashmere shirt texture from JMRP as well?
no, it's his beta cassimere texture jmrp doesn't use it
Awesome video! I don't know why, but for me the 1.00 Fitment not working. (I putted it in to the JMRP Streaming files.)In the video it looks like you are using John's npc body. Where did you get John's beta Wheel outfit with the beta cassimere shirt? Please, can you help me out?
You put 1.00 fitment in the lml stream folder not jmrps
@@RainGunslinger I tryed that already and still not worked. I will use JMRE instead of JMRP, I just wait for a bigger update.
can play these side quests even as jhon marston
My John Marston!
When do you add The Mods Freeroam or in the beginning of epilog one?
Please tutorial on how to install modi
There is the JMRP V3.57 folder, just copy and paste it to the lml folder. There is the bonus files folder, open the Outfit Files folder, then open the All Optional Outfit files folder copy everything and paste the files to the JMRP V3.57 folder. There is the JMRP_Streaming_Files folder, copy and paste that to the JMRP V3.57 folder as well. There is a folder called Changed Pronghorn Outfits, open the folder, copy the file in the folder and paste it in to the JMRP V3.57 folder. Start the game and go to the Fence. Was this so hard to do?!
Hey how did you switch the weapons sounds please ?
Mods
those dialogues cringe af as john
Arthur’s same exact lines are uncanny when it’s a different protagonist whose personality is different than arthurs
cringe? alot of arthurs lines in the game is literally copy pasted from john in rdr1.
John’s attitude and personality fit rather well. Though, since most people never played RDR1 they think that Arthur is superior. Arthur’s whole tough guy attitude was originally John’s back in the first game.
@silentsangheili4895 Arthur personality a lot different from John , only a fool would say Arthur is copied from John lol , I love both protagonists , but Arthur is more flashed out , funny compared to stoic serious John Marston, he has more sense of humor , emotions , I love Johnny boy but it's time to admit that Arthur feels more humane compared to John , and don't say I didn't played rdr 1 , because I did couple times , I like John as a badass dangerous person , but I love Arthur more as a human
@@labelnineArthur felt more real to you because he got girly emotional about half the stuff he thought about. John went around being being himself and killing when it was needed. And it showed because through rdr1 and rdr2 john makes alot more friends just being real than Arthur ever did.
first
second
Third
Fourth idiots
Fourth
Fifth