@@dalynlebronwilliamshis hands move different in RDR1 like he’s an agent in the military but in RDR2 he moves his hand behind him sorry for the bad grammar but It’s different
@Garland846For some reason RDR2 John walks like a catwalk model with one foot directly in front of the other. It's not necessarily a bad thing, there aint nothing wrong with a little bit of zest, but it doesnt suit a cowboy who spend the better half of his life robbing trains and killing folk.
Something about that rdr1 soundtrack always makes me feel not just nostalgia but like, gives me a nice feeling of wonder and mystery and makes the world 100 times better. RDR2 did it well too but just something about rdr1 makes me feel more happy
RDR1's soundtrack worked so perfectly because it sounded correct for the time period. Most of the main instruments used were actually of that era of the late 19th/early 20th century, which gave this haunting realism to the sound. RDR2's soundtrack was almost like a "new age" modern western score, utilizing more MIDI sound effects and less period-correct instruments, and while it was great in its own way, it lacked the authenticity that RDR1's score had.
@@justajad2809 I agree. It worked well for RDR2, but would not have fit RDR1 at all. The latter is still the better soundtrack in my opinion because it actually works in both games, as proven by this video.
@@gabrielmartines3510 I disagree. The RDR1 soundtrack is more authentic to the time period overall, therefore to me it is more versatile across both games than RDR2's soundtrack is.
Man if we got this john (and rdr1 music) in rdr2 epilogue people wouldnt hate him as much. Hearing Macfarlanes ranch and the West Elizabeth wanted music brings so much time
Exactly. With his unique look, outfits, and the first game's music, new fans would've seen how badass and distinctive John is instead of finding him lame and wanting to go back to Arthur.
@@themadtitan7603is Rockstar fault, they made john very dirty in RDR2, i completely agree, red dead redemption 2 is a good game, but is a terrible prequel, that completely created new lore and contradictions for RDR1, and created out of nowhere 20 useless gang members that don't exist and were never mentioned in RDR1 by any characters, that you barely do 2 missions with then to actually know them in RDR2, RDR2 to RDR1 feels very disconnect for a lot of reasons, and only connect itself in a very superficial level, bringing back characters from RDR1 but the only one that had screentime and importance was dutch, john that was very charismatic and likeable in RDR1 his personality is completely different in RDR2 and completely dumber and useless needing rescue from others, Abigail and jack too they are very annoying in the game and epilogue, in comparison to their personalities in RDR1, and rockstar pretty much put John personality being sarcastic, threatening people, making jokes into Arthur in RDR2, even the backstory for arthur that Rockstar made growing up in the gang comes from John from what he say about his own past to others characters in RDR1. You learn much more about John in RDR1 than you ever do about Arthur in RDR2, If RDR2 is a prequel why not play as Dutch or John or at least make you change characters like GTA 5 to actually see john and Dutch perspective, and Rockstar repeated the same ending killing a main character again, the difference is that in RDR1 the story was completely new impredictable and that ending even more, in RDR2 is very obvious that most of those made up new characters for the gang are going to die or flee including Arthur. RDR1 in writing, story, characters, OST soundtracks, are still far better than RDR2. More than 95% of the people that played RDR2 never played RDR1 so of course that they would like RDR2 since they never played the original one first to begin with.
@gabszz Agreed. RDR2 felt like they created a whole new story and then tagged on RDR1 characters and lore for the series familiarity. So all the prequel bits are incorporated half-assedly because they were much more interested in the new characters and story. If RDR2 was a consistent prequel and the OG characters (John especially) retained their same personality traits; I bet both RDR1 and John as a character would've been as popular and beloved in the community now as they were in 2010. The new players would've seen how consistent RDR2 and RDR are thematically and continuity wise and been much more enthusastic to play the first game and admire it on its own value.
This is excellent work. You included free roaming and combat themes. Good shooting too. I've been editing in RDR1 lines into RDR2's gameplay but i'm on console. It would be really cool to get the whole package of RDR1 ambient music, John's classic appearance and his witty RDR1 banter/ shootout lines.
@@Bithe_Get True. It's because RDR2 has a very limited number of ambient tracks compared to the first game in general. So even the other states loop the others' music. Roanoke Ridge is the only place with unique theme tracks.
I don’t understand why they didn’t use the RDR1 soundtrack when you play as John especially in West Elizabeth and New Austin. Btw West Elizabeth soundtrack in the first game is something else
I love how you also tried to replicate the feeling of those through modding John's appearance, walking animation, straight modding places to match as closely to RDR1 and putting them similar lighting conditions that would exist in RDR1. That's some crazy effort.
John was soo badass in rd1...rockstar should put that original outfit the way it was and others to buy in the stores, THx for this video. This game was my favorite in ps3 age.
They forgot to add fame in rdr2 that would be cool npcs recognizing you as the man who killed Emmet granger, flaco hernandez and those other gunslingers
Still holding out hope the game is released on current gen with the og music added in west elizabeth and new austin, the wanted music at least would be a nice touch.
The world seems too vibrant for some of the pieces. Blackwater's gray and metallic OST does not match the vibrant street lights or beaming sun, glowing sidewalks and theatre lights. New austin sort of fits, but it still feels far too colorful for it's sad and lonely atmosphere.
Dude you have got to tell me what mod you're using for the camera angle position. The game looks so good! Tbh everything about your game looks perfect, John looks like OG john, and the world and lighting looks better, and the weapon wheel too! Seriously if you can list what you're using I'd be so grateful! Edit: You've got them in the description! Legend! Could you tell me if one specific mod is responsible for the on foot camera placement though? I swear it is not the same as the shoulder mounted camera in Vanilla RDR2.
it's the second zoom option after the shoulder one, so before the last far zoom. not much was changed to lighting except using dark nights by alsharad. it removes vignette and makes nights realistically dark. and the rdr1 wheel should just be called rdr1 weapon wheel and icons!
The soundtrack for RDR 1 is infinitely better. If you can check out “horseplay” in the soundtrack. It genuinely feels like a western chase and has a lot of feel to it
The soundtrack for Red Dead Redemption 1 is amazing and unfortunately Rockstar didn't put these songs on the rdr1 map unfortunately John is very poorly done I honestly wish I had a PC To play with these and other mods.
Blackwater looks cooler with that giant town hall building, it really emphasizes how the government has just taken over the place. Same with the sadder music.
I think it would have been pretty easy to implement as well, seeing as GP, NA, and TT just reuse base game tracks and already have unique area triggers.
could you please give us the mod that allows you to use the rifle while still having the rifle holster on the back? as In every time you take out the rifle with the regular rifle holster mod it makes the rifle holster itself dissappear from your back, you have a version that doesint do that but keeps it on after drawing your rifle, could you release that to the public? or know where we can get that?
@@pastaa_7 it's not. That mod shows it on your back if your weapon is slinged but if you draw it, it dissappears, he has a mod where it doesint dissappear after drawing
@@pastaa_7 not the fucking one I'm talking about he does not have in the description because it's not a mod on nexus or rdr mods it's a server mod u can only get from discord.
Rdr 2 is my favorite game, but the epiloque is so weird, jonh model, all map of new austin, soundtrack, but mods save this part, og Jonh, classic rdr musics, rdr1 menu style, rdr 1 outffits, this is so beauty in comunitty
This video makes me feel so bad that we didn't get a full remake of RDR1😢 Not to say that in RDR2 we didn't get the real John Marston in the epilogue💀 But I knee in face of modders, they're the true lovers and heroes of this game
![Restoring John Marston To His True Self [REUPLOAD WITH COMPARISON]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Jo9NAE_Uk14/mqdefault.jpg)
The real john marston we deserved and a remasted what we need
Beta john RDR2 was an actual remaster but nah rockstar had different plans for no reason
@@Tunova Rockstar have a plan my boah just is not good for the another
@@oskarurielperez2926 yeah their plan is creating Gta 6 so they can milk that for 20 years. I mean Gta games are good but after a mf decade nah bro
I played the port
Oh.......
John’s walk in RDR was sooo cool
Isn't it the same walk animation from rdr2 tho?
@@dalynlebronwilliamshis hands move different in RDR1 like he’s an agent in the military but in RDR2 he moves his hand behind him sorry for the bad grammar but It’s different
@@dalynlebronwilliamsI meant to say a special forces agent
@@hamoudial-daghri9093you know what a like besides the walking animation the fully built black water that's awesome
@Garland846For some reason RDR2 John walks like a catwalk model with one foot directly in front of the other. It's not necessarily a bad thing, there aint nothing wrong with a little bit of zest, but it doesnt suit a cowboy who spend the better half of his life robbing trains and killing folk.
Something about that rdr1 soundtrack always makes me feel not just nostalgia but like, gives me a nice feeling of wonder and mystery and makes the world 100 times better. RDR2 did it well too but just something about rdr1 makes me feel more happy
It truly tickles
Me too Man it's so good the RDR1 soundtrack unfortunaly we don't have the México in RDR2 :(
@@dog3401 undead nightmare 2 could have utilized Mexico, imagine all the content rockstar could have added to online too
@@deadset15-hrvavik17 yea this could be the GOAT
It's the combination of Rdr1's more cartoony spaghetti-western art-style with rdr1's short but more overall soundtrack that makes it more memorable.
RDR1's soundtrack worked so perfectly because it sounded correct for the time period. Most of the main instruments used were actually of that era of the late 19th/early 20th century, which gave this haunting realism to the sound. RDR2's soundtrack was almost like a "new age" modern western score, utilizing more MIDI sound effects and less period-correct instruments, and while it was great in its own way, it lacked the authenticity that RDR1's score had.
Nailed it. But the RD2 soundtrack is also top tier.
@@justajad2809 I agree. It worked well for RDR2, but would not have fit RDR1 at all. The latter is still the better soundtrack in my opinion because it actually works in both games, as proven by this video.
@@Dagger_323 It works better on the areas that actually were in RDR1, this score wouldn't work on the areas exclusive to RDR2.
@@gabrielmartines3510 I disagree. The RDR1 soundtrack is more authentic to the time period overall, therefore to me it is more versatile across both games than RDR2's soundtrack is.
Yeah rdr2's soundtrack is like 7/10 at best but rdr1 strikes a nice 10 on music terms
16:43 "run away and say i escaped!" John out there giving those lawman the best advices ever
wassup bro
Is that voice line also a mod? I never hear John or Arthur yell in combat
@@Red_1911 yes
Man if we got this john (and rdr1 music) in rdr2 epilogue people wouldnt hate him as much.
Hearing Macfarlanes ranch and the West Elizabeth wanted music brings so much time
Exactly. With his unique look, outfits, and the first game's music, new fans would've seen how badass and distinctive John is instead of finding him lame and wanting to go back to Arthur.
@@themadtitan7603 there you are. I was wondering when will you comment
@@Luka2000_ I was expecting for that type of comment, as a RDR1 player (No OP PC for RDR2 lol)
@@themadtitan7603is Rockstar fault, they made john very dirty in RDR2, i completely agree, red dead redemption 2 is a good game, but is a terrible prequel, that completely created new lore and contradictions for RDR1, and created out of nowhere 20 useless gang members that don't exist and were never mentioned in RDR1 by any characters, that you barely do 2 missions with then to actually know them in RDR2, RDR2 to RDR1 feels very disconnect for a lot of reasons, and only connect itself in a very superficial level, bringing back characters from RDR1 but the only one that had screentime and importance was dutch, john that was very charismatic and likeable in RDR1 his personality is completely different in RDR2 and completely dumber and useless needing rescue from others, Abigail and jack too they are very annoying in the game and epilogue, in comparison to their personalities in RDR1, and rockstar pretty much put John personality being sarcastic, threatening people, making jokes into Arthur in RDR2, even the backstory for arthur that Rockstar made growing up in the gang comes from John from what he say about his own past to others characters in RDR1. You learn much more about John in RDR1 than you ever do about Arthur in RDR2, If RDR2 is a prequel why not play as Dutch or John or at least make you change characters like GTA 5 to actually see john and Dutch perspective, and Rockstar repeated the same ending killing a main character again, the difference is that in RDR1 the story was completely new impredictable and that ending even more, in RDR2 is very obvious that most of those made up new characters for the gang are going to die or flee including Arthur. RDR1 in writing, story, characters, OST soundtracks, are still far better than RDR2. More than 95% of the people that played RDR2 never played RDR1 so of course that they would like RDR2 since they never played the original one first to begin with.
@gabszz Agreed. RDR2 felt like they created a whole new story and then tagged on RDR1 characters and lore for the series familiarity. So all the prequel bits are incorporated half-assedly because they were much more interested in the new characters and story. If RDR2 was a consistent prequel and the OG characters (John especially) retained their same personality traits; I bet both RDR1 and John as a character would've been as popular and beloved in the community now as they were in 2010. The new players would've seen how consistent RDR2 and RDR are thematically and continuity wise and been much more enthusastic to play the first game and admire it on its own value.
4:02 is all I ever need in life.
Boggles my mind they didn’t use the original score in RDR2, it was literally one of the best things about RDR1
Rockstars must've not realized how important that OST was RDR1's world and how alive that makes it.
@@lakshaykochhar6799or they could have remade it like they remade American venom
@@lakshaykochhar6799maybe because they have no time left and in rushed to fully make the game
How did he get the rifle holster to stay on his back? Mine just disintegrates
@@goldengaming5506you downloaded the mod wrong
John in 1911 was a SAVAGE.
so Pinkertons were right in a way
10:00 everytime i hear that while wondering around tumble weed or Benedict point sends shivers down my spine i always get a sense of dread
Rdr1 is so much more atmospheric compared to rdr2
This is excellent work. You included free roaming and combat themes. Good shooting too.
I've been editing in RDR1 lines into RDR2's gameplay but i'm on console. It would be really cool to get the whole package of RDR1 ambient music, John's classic appearance and his witty RDR1 banter/ shootout lines.
this video has 2 of those things, i was working on a voice line comparison video between rdr2 john and arthur, and rdr1 john but i never finished it
@@praiseaidan sounds interesting.
They should've reused RDR1's themes for West Elizabeth and New Austin instead of just looping New Hanover music.
They looop music from all states there actually
@@Bithe_Get True. It's because RDR2 has a very limited number of ambient tracks compared to the first game in general. So even the other states loop the others' music. Roanoke Ridge is the only place with unique theme tracks.
@@themadtitan7603 i meant they loop musics from others states to new austin
@@Bithe_Get Yeah, I know, I'm just saying even other states loop tracks that aren't their own like New Austin in RDR2.
mad titan agreed bro rdr1 was a true western man. rdr2's music wasnt nearly as cold
During the armadillo one all i could hear in my head was "Hey you chicken head guy!"
8:21 hits different
Blackwater, tall trees ambience still haunts me
Mister you have a kind face
My favorites 🤠
If they won’t give us the OG look, they could’ve at least given us the OG music.
This is sick bro 🔥
.
I don’t understand why they didn’t use the RDR1 soundtrack when you play as John especially in West Elizabeth and New Austin.
Btw West Elizabeth soundtrack in the first game is something else
the rdr2 modding community makes me wanna bash my head in as a console player. it’s so cool. extremely jealous!!
Nice video bro its legendary deserves more attention
11:06 we need more of this
you want more rdr1 music videos?
@@praiseaidan more wanted music vids
@@rdclips3647 I can do that
This mod is so perfect, awesome!!
Only the OGs will understand this
How did you get OG Marston hair from rdr1?
@@OutlawRedMoose it's a mod on the rdrmc discord server
@@praiseaidan can i join?
@@OutlawRedMoose i don't know if i can invite you but if you look around on nexus and find their public mods they should have invite links there.
@@praiseaidan thanks
Rockstar screwed up the epilogue badly.
Bro the OST of Red Dead Redemption 1 is for me one of , if not the best ost ever.
I wonder if there's a way you can use both the original game's soundtrack modded in and 2's standard ambient soundtrack together. Best of both worlds.
damn someone should make a mod of it, after we get john's control all ambient music would be replaced from rdr 1 :)
Already kind of one. But the flood gates are open, the tools for it are now available
I love how you also tried to replicate the feeling of those through modding John's appearance, walking animation, straight modding places to match as closely to RDR1 and putting them similar lighting conditions that would exist in RDR1. That's some crazy effort.
Usually put on headphones to listen to the old games soundtrack when alone.
If the RDR remaster is even half as good as this, I’ll be ecstatic.
This aged well
RDR1 still has one of the best if not the best soundtrack in video game history.
I love how there’s more people in armadillo makes the place pop
Quality content
Shootout in New Austin with OGs Wanted Theme is so cool. Love it❤
I like both RDR1's and RDR2's soundtrack the same but it would be way better if RDR1 locations had RDR1 music
John was soo badass in rd1...rockstar should put that original outfit the way it was and others to buy in the stores, THx for this video. This game was my favorite in ps3 age.
Looks and sounds fantastic! I hope RDR1 remastered would look as great as this video.
Love this video! This is exactly what the rdr1 remaster should look like!
If RDR1 came out on PC as a remastered version i would pay full price for it!
I desperately need a PC
Rdr 1 soundtrack was so much western and awesome and Rdr 2 soundtrack
I could see this RDR1 style as John happening, maybe if RDR2 released back in 2019 instead of early 18's
10:50 how did the policeman survive a headshot from a shotgun?
Red Dead Redemption 1 on steroids.
They forgot to add fame in rdr2 that would be cool npcs recognizing you as the man who killed Emmet granger, flaco hernandez and those other gunslingers
Blackwaters theme is by far my favourite, there’s an eerie somber feeling to it, civilisation is expanding and the old west is dying
So you’re saying me that there’s not a mod that brings this banger? 12:02 😢
Now there is, I made it.
This ain’t just music it’s art 💯
Still holding out hope the game is released on current gen with the og music added in west elizabeth and new austin, the wanted music at least would be a nice touch.
I wish I was in the alternate timeline where the remake was made lol
The wanted music really sells the dread that you’ve pushed your luck for the last time, there’s no coming back
The world seems too vibrant for some of the pieces. Blackwater's gray and metallic OST does not match the vibrant street lights or beaming sun, glowing sidewalks and theatre lights. New austin sort of fits, but it still feels far too colorful for it's sad and lonely atmosphere.
Dude you have got to tell me what mod you're using for the camera angle position. The game looks so good!
Tbh everything about your game looks perfect, John looks like OG john, and the world and lighting looks better, and the weapon wheel too! Seriously if you can list what you're using I'd be so grateful!
Edit: You've got them in the description! Legend! Could you tell me if one specific mod is responsible for the on foot camera placement though? I swear it is not the same as the shoulder mounted camera in Vanilla RDR2.
it's the second zoom option after the shoulder one, so before the last far zoom. not much was changed to lighting except using dark nights by alsharad. it removes vignette and makes nights realistically dark. and the rdr1 wheel should just be called rdr1 weapon wheel and icons!
@@praiseaidan It really all works together so perfectly to make it look and feel like RDR1. Amazing showcase! 😊
The soundtrack for RDR 1 is infinitely better. If you can check out “horseplay” in the soundtrack. It genuinely feels like a western chase and has a lot of feel to it
You have the barn, sheriffs and store at McFarlands ranch 🤔
Mexico in RDR had the best soundtrack for all situations, especially for shootouts.
It was also my favorite location/arc in the entire game
The soundtrack for Red Dead Redemption 1 is amazing and unfortunately Rockstar didn't put these songs on the rdr1 map unfortunately John is very poorly done I honestly wish I had a PC To play with these and other mods.
Please Remastered this whole game rockstar come on guys !
I was expecting John to get gunned down by high power pistols in Blackwater once you got a wanted level
Blackwater looks cooler with that giant town hall building, it really emphasizes how the government has just taken over the place. Same with the sadder music.
If only my pc could run this game 😢 this is amazing
6:48 undead nightmare
The song playing in the beginning you can hear it in a little house near rosses house and the fort
That policeman at 10:52 survived a shotgun shot to the face 😅
unfortunately for him he didn't survive the second one
@@praiseaidan yep
You made john look normal!!!
Arthur dies for John so he can have a peaceful life
10:51 John
I think it would have been pretty easy to implement as well, seeing as GP, NA, and TT just reuse base game tracks and already have unique area triggers.
By any chance, what mod was it called for the Blackwater sidewalks between Blackwater bank and police department in the video
rdr1 has the best soundtrack. These tracks should be on 2
I heard that if you do the Mexico glitch there you can hear the rdr1 songs,I dont know if thats true
You can hear the Mexico music in new Austin if you go as southwest as possible, or cross the river to Mexico
could you please give us the mod that allows you to use the rifle while still having the rifle holster on the back? as In every time you take out the rifle with the regular rifle holster mod it makes the rifle holster itself dissappear from your back, you have a version that doesint do that but keeps it on after drawing your rifle, could you release that to the public? or know where we can get that?
Is on the description
@@pastaa_7 it's not. That mod shows it on your back if your weapon is slinged but if you draw it, it dissappears, he has a mod where it doesint dissappear after drawing
@@billymays__2839 the mods are on the description
@@pastaa_7 not the fucking one I'm talking about he does not have in the description because it's not a mod on nexus or rdr mods it's a server mod u can only get from discord.
@@billymays__2839 drive.google.com/file/d/1S4TQoiOlp-S6xfDdSZms5igQj3qtZIsO/view?usp=sharing
Mann I wish they at least added RDR1 content as an DLC in RDR2
We need a mod for this
Ridgewood farm sounds like pronghorn ranch
With this mod who needs remake 😂
Is there a mod that actually adds RDR1 music to RDR2 or is that impossible?
I need these outfit in rdr2 ps4 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭
Why are the graphics for RDR 1 in this so good!?
Edit: I figured out why😂
Revolutionary new mod called Red Dead Redemption 2 lol
All i do is use SoundCloud and Spotify and then choose how i want it to sound.
They should make the graphics more melancholic, west elizabeth ost doesnt match too much with the current graphics
The real John Marston 💯🦾🦾🤠
It saddens me Rockstar didnt use the og soundtracks for John 😭
Rdr 2 is my favorite game, but the epiloque is so weird, jonh model, all map of new austin, soundtrack, but mods save this part, og Jonh, classic rdr musics, rdr1 menu style, rdr 1 outffits, this is so beauty in comunitty
Hey how do you keep the rifle holster on your back with your weapon drawn?
Hi i was wondering what mod you used to get Blackwater looking the way it did
What mods did you used to get McFarlane's ranch and manzanita post to look like they did in rdr 1 ?
quick question, i see that your rifle holster doesnt dissapear when you draw your rifle, how did you do that?
Now in reverse what if rdr1 used rdr 2 instead
🔥
Rockstar que te cuesta parchear el sombrero 😭
how do you keep the (empty) holster attached to John's back when the longarm is equipped/being used?
This video makes me feel so bad that we didn't get a full remake of RDR1😢 Not to say that in RDR2 we didn't get the real John Marston in the epilogue💀 But I knee in face of modders, they're the true lovers and heroes of this game
What mod are you using for the high power pistol
Need an rde1 remake
What mod do you use for the gunbelt bro its so cool?
Can anybody tell me where the dry grass mod came from in macfarlanes ranch i really want it badly!
After installing Xenia I don't bother to play RDR2 anymore, RDR1, Jack Marston, and chill
RDR1 is more western spaghetti and RDR2 is more default western
hey how did you get the slick back hair for john mine does not work
It’s not slicked back hair it’s his rdr1 hair and if you can find an invite to the rdrmc discord you can get it
@@praiseaidan where do i find it in the server i've been in there for a few months and haven't seen it.