A mother asking a total stranger to translate for her son who has been deaf for three years so she could understand is one of the saddest thing I've ever seen on screen. And liming taking time to learn sign language so he could communicate with Heart is beautiful. It shows how much he cares and admire Heart. Everyone out there needs that one person that can go an extra mile for them. A person that can be there, care and love the beautiful and unique you. I can't wait to see the next episode. ❤
I rarely cry in real life and when watching movies. The last time I cried was probably years ago, can't even remember. That scene made me cry my eyes out 😭 Very well directed and acted by the actors!
I was going to write the same thing. My heart hurt as i saw this. It shows his mom doesn't really care about her son but more about how other people might think of them. I believe that's probably the reason she never lets him leave the house. It's not that I think she doesn't care about heart at all but she does it in a very fucked up way
I literally cried when heart's parent didn't understand him and never tried to learn sign language and the way li ming treats him and comforts him. Gemini and fourth acting is so great and their chemistry
Especially when Heart said it’s been so long since he felt like a normal person then Liming answered there’re no different between Heart and others 😭😭😭
"I haven't felt this way in a long time" "What way" "Like a normal person" Li Ming is literally Hearts comfort zone he makes him feel like he exist he took all the loneliness away from Heart, I like how Li Ming educated Heart's Mum with their confrontation he even made her realize how she actually doesn't know anything about her own Son and she had to depend on Li Ming to tell her what her Son was actually saying, Heart was really broken, seeing how Heart leaned on Li Ming's shoulder and hugging him tight and the tears flowing that was really heart wrenching.
@@bethconley exactly 💯 and that what hurts, Heart the most because his Mom has been with him ever since he became deaf for 3yrs and she couldn't even make the efforts of learning how to communicate with him instead she just forbid him from going out no wonder Heart told her if she is ashamed of him, it's really hurts he was crying with so much pain 😣.
as a person who knows sign language i was actually shocked when i discovered gemini didn't know tsl before this. you can see he puts his heart into. sign language is not only about how you sign, expressions are a big part of it, and he doesn't lack on it, like some other hearing actors playing deaf characters. he learned well!
@@deanasnyder3774 more like if they know thai Sign language, I know my country sign language and i don't see he flows this well like they said, but it could be because I don't know thai xd. Just a little stretch on the topic: just because someone knows sign language doesn't mean they are experts or know every countries mannerisms and flow with it.
I have been signing for over 6 years now and I am so impressed and shocked with Gemini's performance. Like, I don't even care if a Deaf person is played by a Hearing person as long as it is done properly, and Gemini had me actually looking up if he was Deaf or not.
Honestly I feel like GeminiFourth play the biggest roles in this series as they communicate without actually talking but with actions. They have to take on a role that they would struggle to fully understand as they haven't experienced it and they pull it off so well. I'm so proud of them honestly their roles in this series tell the biggest story in a language that if we took a little time of our day to learn everyone could understand with no problems and it shows the harsh reality of someone people who are deaf. I can't wait to see more of this couple 🤭
I agree as well. Talented people, and they probably also have good instructors too... Which says even more about how the production team is giving these things the attention they deserve.
This is why I want a bl with a deaf male lead, I understand communication is important but bl’s tend to put too much emphasis onto audible communication which gets boring, and they end up putting less focus on physical communication.
Gemini's acting is extremely commendable. He was able to convey his acting literally through mere actions. I was sobbing in the scene where he confronted his mother. The actor playing his mother also deserves credit. It was such a heartbreaking scene.
it was very heartbreaking when Heart tried to speak to her mother using sign language but what Heart got, nothing.Gemini's acting is extraordinary, it needs to be appreciated. the pain that Heart feels, can be channeled to everyone who sees it
The scene where heart is confronting his parents and only Li Ming can understand and translate is so powerful, gemini and fourth acting skills aren't joke
Yeah, it broke my heart and made me furious on Heart's behalf. Imagine how how felt when his parents couldn't be bothered to learn how to communicate with him on even a basic level... And then to have them isolate him further by not allowing him to leave the house would have been another blow. As a parent, I can't comprehend their reasoning for their actions.
@@Arador76 I don't understand too how this is even possible for parents to do this to their child. To my mind this is somehow child abuse to keep him trapped in this house for 3 years and be left out by his family, not trying to understand and communicate with him 🤷🏻♀️😔
@@blushing-alpaca2679If you had a deaf son, you would learn sign language for him, but the mom is only accusatory, and wants to keep her son trap, and unable to communicate and live independently. He may be deaf, but he has a lot life in him and wants to live and treated normally.
Man. I thought Wen and Alan's fights were the most real thing I'd ever seen on TV. But then we get this scene with Heart and his mom and I'm actually sobbing. I'm so grateful for P'Aof. Everything he touches is beautiful, magical, and so true it aches.
@@saburrrna P'Aof has many famous works. 1000 stars, together, bad buddy, our skyy, dark blue kiss among many others. You can search his name 'Aof Noppharnach Chaiyahwimhon'
I replay Wen and Alan's fight so many times just to see their expression. It was so real. And man, I feel so tired for Jim. So many things happen in this episode and it's never ending for Jim xD But all in all, this episode is beautiful in so many level. This drama is spot on.
12:48 - So nobody noticed how Heart’s room/mirror is decorated with all the sticky notes that his mom used to communicate with him?!? This just goes to show how even despite everything Heart had so much love for his mother
Was looking for this comment. Glad someone noticed it too. Where all those notes couldn't bring an understanding between the parents and the son. The hug shown in the mirror tells how simple and enough it can be to communicate everything. Loved this frame. ❤
'i don't have a place to stay anymore'... well bby boy, i feel like you've finally hit the perfect sweet spot for uncle jim who has a cat that used to be a stray, a nephew he takes care of like a son, a diner that barely makes profits because he's always giving out (practically) free food, & a friend whose surprise pregnancy he's helping with... all of which means that he physically CANNOT seem to ignore people like you in need of his help 🥺🥺
geminifourth's acting is so beautiful... seriously can't believe this is the first roles they filmed for gmmtv... they did so well, i literally cried with them
Omg is it just me? I really really really want a spin-off series for Heart and Li Ming. The story, Gemini and Fourth's acting, their chemistry, everything is just so good. I was smiling like crazy at their first few scenes but then I almost cried.
As someone who is deaf and has been since I was born 36 years ago, this episode REALLY hit me! The portrayal of Hearts pain at the lonely, silent world we feel and experience is all too real! To be seen and treated as normal is all we deaf people want. So when we find that person who sees us as such, well, we just want to hold onto them tight. So I understand Hearts pain and anger at Heart towards his parents for essentially trapping him in the house for 3 years, like a bird in a gilded cage. All he wants to be is free and Li Ming gives him that. Well done to the production and writing team for, in my opinion, an accurate portrayal of a deaf person.
I’m not part of the deaf community but is it normal for people who lose their hearing after a years of hearing ie gemini 10+ yrs to not speak despite knowing how to vocalise? Cos I thought that was kinda weird
@Shaemus🫣 Yes. He might have developed a speech impediment (like i did), so he may not be confident in speaking. Also his parents didn't communicate with him other than pass notes under the door, so he may have lost the ability to speak properly, plus remember before Le Ming, Heart didn't go out or really communicate with ANYONE at all, which further exacerbates the loss in speaking properly.
@@kellykuk thanks for the reply. Yeah that all makes sense. Ig I was only thinking about ppl without speech impediments and his parents choices would obviously negatively effect his communication abilities/style
I don’t know why but there is something like magic in Heart and Li Ming scenes. Be it My school president or Moonlight chicken those 2 rookies nailed the scenes and they set the bar so high for finding solace in each other ❤
I do agree with you when they appear it’s something like magical in them that we can’t take our eyes away from them the chemistry is so amazing too I really obsessed with them 😢❤
Heart feeling a normal person is such a beautiful scene. Finally LiMing's efforts paid off. It makes me sad that Heart's parents never made any effort for their son, they just leave him alone at home. Heart and LiMing are the cutest couple ❤️😌 It was so heart wrenching scene when Heart's parents couldn't understand his signs and LiMing has to explain them. As a parent they failed him 😞 Hat's off to Gemini. Heart was made for him to play, he did an amazing job
I felt Heart's pain knowing that his parents did not make any effort to learn sign language. I would feel the same way. And Li Ming delivering what Heart wants to tell her mom? Amazing. This on screen couple is my favorite. For rookies, they truly have done an amazing job. These 2 are precious gems.
I never knew that Heart's parents don't understand the sign language till this eps.. how can u ask someone to translate your own child language, Heart deserve to be happy and the only person that can make him happy is Liming
@@addictedbtskpop1876 this tells us that in Ep1 when Heart broke that liquor bottle, he was signing something during the argument with Jim and Liming and his mother pretended to understand him. When in fact she did not, she just wanted to Liming to take responsibility
No one's gonna talk about how solid Leng's lines are? "A baby girl or baby boy, we raise them the same" "We let them choose their gender identity when they grow up"
100% agree! But couldn’t help but cringe at him saying no ultrasounds… fetal development is very important to keep track of 😬😬 they’re not just used to find out the gender
The way how Li Ming is always carefully watching Heart even if others around, care about him and love him shows a true deep connection what is really rare. I think I can say that Fourth and Gemini so far the best actors. They showing characters perfectly, they truly make them alive and their chemistry is on a way higher level then the other pairs. They play difficult characters perfectly. I deeply hope they will have a lot of series together because they really deserve it and can tell they will be successful for sure in every character what will play in the future as well.
”what did he say?” Li Ming having to translate sign language for Heart’s mom even though her *_son_* has been deaf for three *_years_* was the saddest thing i’ve seen today
…i’m still so fully jusT SO TOTALLY BLOWN AWAY BY GEMINI’S ACTING 🤯🤯🤯 it’s SO good and so real that this is what it is, the hardships, the pain and anger heart is feeling and expressing through his gestures, the signing, his eyes. i completely felt it.
Ugh this show makes me so happy. I absolutely love how they have a deaf character and are spreading deaf awareness. Deaf people are the exact same as hearing people, the ONLY difference is that they can’t hear. There’s no reason to coddle a deaf person or treat them like a child. I’m so happy they’re addressing this in the show. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
When Li Ming said, "You're normal to me", it's really heartwarming. Just because he can't do some activities others can do, doesn't mean he is anything less. The confrontation scene with Heart's mom was wonderfully executed. Hats off to the rookie actors...they truly are gem! And I always love the scenes between Uncle Jim and Li Ming. Teenagers think they have grown up, they want control of their life. While raising teens is really difficult if the guardian doesn't try to think being in their shoes. Both must find the middle ground. The emotion First portrays are super powerful. He was trying so hard not to break down during the dinner time. Jim didn't want complicated relation, but life has never been fair to anyone, we get what we don't want.
This series just keeps getting better and better every episode, I’m not ready for it to be over next week😭😭. Also the scene where Li Ming was translating what Heart was saying to his mother was absolutely heart wrenching, all the actors did absolutely fantastic conveying their characters feelings during that scene❤❤.
you could really see the hurt in gemini's eyes and the awkwerdness with fourth and eventually the hurt in the mother's eyes when she realised that li ming actually understood her son when she couldn't.
Esta serie es un claro ejemplo de que una serie bl puede tener un buen guión, buenas actuaciones, una trama interesante , el tema de inclusión bien manejado sin forzarlo, mantiene las expectativas, evoluciona, muchas gracias por su trabajo.
This story is so well done, the way in which Li Ming had to translate what Heart said to her own mother shows how little she knows her son,she literally dont know how comunicate with him, Li Ming with only a short time opened up to understand Heart and treat him as a normal person, adorable.
It hurts seeing the mom or the dad never made efforts to learn how to sign… it clearly shows how they treat their son’s situation as something not to be concerned of.😔
my heart goes to Heart!!!! Gemini did so well expressing his emotions. I cried so hard knowing what he had been through like him being at his house locked like a cage for 3 years and finally felt like a normal person when he is out with Li Ming. It's so hard to see him cry like that😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 GeminiFourth's chemistry really shines and I can't wait for tomorrow's episode🤧🤧
I have to commend the whole team for this wonderful drama. The cinematography , script writing, lighting, and acting are top-notch. Earth and mix conveying so many different emotions with just their eyes. First's acting in the apartment after the confrontation last episode and the conversation he had with Mix in the restaurant just felt so real. The characters they portrayed felt like real people with all their flaws , mistakes, and complications.
Sabes que siiii, es una de las mejores que están saliendo hasta ahora, seguida de My School President.. la otra a la que le tengo una GRAN expectativa es a Last Twilight de JimmySea, es algo como la historia de Li Ming y Heart aquí,, el trailer se ve bonito, lo estoy esperando mucho
Usually Im amazed by Fourth's acting skills but in this episode Gemini killed it! The way he is very fluent in the sign language shows how much effort he has put! Geminifourth has a long way to go! Excellent actors with great chemistry! ❤
The notes on the wall in Heart’s room KILLED ME. He learned SL all by himself to communicate with his parents firstly and his parents couldn’t even make a single effort. He must have felt so alone and trapped 😢
the worst part for me is you can see that Heart has some sign language posters up on the wall near the window, probably of the most basic signs like "hello", "thank you" etc. His parents' don't even have the excuse of not having the materials to learn bcs they're right there on Heart's wall.
Just a hug...just a hug but it meant so muchhhh..The deep sigh what heart took after hugging ming was something that can't b expressed by words..I cried a lot in this episode in the begging when Jim acted like stranger..when Alan was hoping for some chances..when hearts mother felt completely helpless ..The fact being under the same roof still she was not able to understand her child...Apart from all this Jims life is a hell ..can't stand for his own love ...business..his teenage nephew...all a puddle
Me too, though I watched MSP too but their acting in Moonlight Chicken are right at the top, with their age & their experience in acting & they are able to convey all the complicated emotions that the character/scene needs, I'm impressed
"Let's stop hurting each other's." It takes so much courage to finally accept that the love once made us so happy has coming to an end. The honest conversation of Alan and Wen about there relationship is so heartbreaking yet much needed. They both did excellent job on that scene especially ALAN, PS. FIRST make me a fan of his from this😊
I watch him in all of that but that genre seems don't fit in him. It's the first time I feel him. Thu his chemistry with khao is great. But I can fairly say that I admire him here.
8:54 this scene was soo heart breaking when heart was talking with his parents about how it feels to live alone and his mom was soo lost bcuz she can't understand what heart was saying she was so lost and that time he nedeed liming to understand what his own is saying to him.
8:28 start from this minute it shows Heart’s frustration, and it’s hurt. Gemini played Heart really really well, like pls this boy deserved award for this role
HeartLiming coversation is so simple yet so emotional “I haven’t felt this way in a long time” “What way” “Like a normal person” “You’re normal to me” Li Ming is the reason Heart feel that he exists again and Li Ming literally took away all 3 years of loneliness. The sadness,frustration,loneliness is all on Heart expression and body language when he confronts his mum through Li Ming. It’s was so heart wrenching when he broke down in Li Ming arms, holding so tightly and crying so hard. I cried when the camera span across the notes sticked across his bedroom. It’s must be such a lonely journey he has been going through without having someone there for him. Not gonna lie, GeminiFourth gonna be the next big thing for GMMTV. Gemini acting is so admirable. Fourth is so natural at acting but Gemini acting is not praised enough. Both of them are so young yet their characters are so deep and they deliver it so well. Heart and Li Ming storyline is the one that carry the show for me.
Interesting choice of lighting. In Heart's house the blue tones show everything is cold, except for his own bed and the stairs that lead to his bedroom. Even in his bedroom, the blue lighting show his parents notes. While in Li Ming's house the colors are warmer, showing he has a trusting family in Uncle Jim.
Yes, the cinematography and lighting in this is spectacular. The details they incorporate even with the script writing like the pen and reigniting the flame is so soo good.
that's a good point. it's all these background details in the show that really adds more depth to the story imho, you can tell the production team took that as another layer of storytelling without additional dialogue. I'm used to seeing this kind of detail in independent films but rarely in a series, let alone a bl series.
Wen and Alan were a pretty cute couple back then. I loved Heart and Li Ming moments together when they were with Wen at the mall, it was so adorable. The business meeting between Jim and Alan was tensed, wow. And the metaphor about their relationship, they did with the pen, omg. Alan is not here to joke. Love the constant support LiMing give to Heart and how he encourages him to do new things. Finally, Alan and Wen had an honest talk about their relationship, it was needed. It's hurt for both of them, but it's time to let go. I like the type of metaphor, like here, they're ending their relationship for good and the waiter came to "reanimate" the fire for the beef but Wen said its not necessary, because they're done, they're done eating, and with their couple, so they don't need to reanimate the flames between them. The mom telling he taught him to ride a motorcycle but he's deaf so it's a problem??? What? I loved so much how Li Ming told straight to Heart mom that Deaf people are normal people and that she knows nothing about them and that she needs to stop acting like she's doing right now. I'm glad that Heart talked to her to and said he was tired of this. I wish they would put subtitles for when Heart is using sign language, it's so needed. It's too bad that Jim didn't support Li Ming at this moment or understood him a little more, but I think he has a lot on his plate with his own life and just want to protect Li Ming. He just need to treat him like a grown up and back him up when it's needed. It will be a weight out of his shoulders. He raised him well since all these years, it's time to think for himself and make decisions, until now, he's doing pretty fine. With Heart, he's growing up so well. I liked the end with Wen and Jim.
I think them not putting subtitles when heart does sign language is a great choice, it shows that even us the audience do not understand what he is going through. It emphasizes the value of Li Ming learning sign language and how he is the only one who really understands him during that scene.
Agree with what has been explained about the sign language subtitles by other commenters. I just wanna add that even without the sub, we can still get a very good idea of what Heart says afterward since Li Ming always repeats and asks for clarification to make sure he understands Heart correctly. This is such a great way to show how considerate Li Ming is and also to help us viewers follow their conversations.
12:15 Heart realmente siente que li ming es su lugar seguro 🥺 miren cómo cada vez se apoya más en él, se acerca y lo abraza más con todo su cuerpo. se adoran 🥺💖
I'm not exaggerating when I say that Li Ming's and Heart's story is one of the most beautiful, heartwarming and impactful love stories that I've ever seen, not least because it's as much about friendship, coming-of-age and disability rights as it is about romantic love. Forth and Gemini are also outstanding in their roles. we're not even halfway into the season, and I'm not sure that my heart will be able to take it.
I cried a lot in this episode between Alan and Wen's confrontations and Li Ming and Heart's scenes, my emotions are leveling up! Oh I'm so in love with this series...
The whole scene of LiMing and Heart here is the best scene’s I’ve ever seen in any BL series ever. Kudos to the screenwriter, the director and the actors. This was a top notch performance here
Even though First doesn’t have such a leading role in this series, his performances here are a cut above the other series, competent as those were. In fact, all of the cast are doing so wonderfully. Powerful yet subtle performances, every one.
I love how innocent and pure they built li ming and heart's relationship it's not built on looks or sex, li ming is that company heart's been searching for..
those little steps of LiMing towards Heart at 4:04 is so beautiful how they nudged eo looked so beautiful into eo's eyes its all soo warmm P'Aof how long should i praise you for giving us thse wonderful dramas 🥺🥺
so you're telling me next episode features wen & uncle jim living together, heart & liming's first kiss, jim finding out about the cuties being together, AND gaipa finally confessing to the old man?! tomorrow can't come sooner 😭😭
No es fácil intentar madurar sin que tus tutores no piensen que eres un crío todavía. Jim y Li Ming tienen que llegar a entenderse y no pelearse constantemente. Los ojitos de Jim y Wen cuando Wen aparece con las maletas y dice que no tiene un lugar al que volver, me parte el corazón 😭.
The best thing is seeing deaf people saying such positive things about this show and the portrayal of them. It’s so important to have accurate representation and I’m so happy to see the positive responses:) congrats to the writers of the show!
I'm so happy my man Gem is receiving the praises he deserves🥺🥺 it's his first work even before MySchoolPresident but look at how beautifully he conveyed his emotions thru his eyes and actions my boi deserves all the love🥺🥺
Li Ming and heart,A complete opposite side of Gunn and tinn! Like these two are so talented!! Li Ming is such a heart warming character ☺️ They just touched everyone's soul I guess! GMMTV you have like the best actors, seriously the best❤️
Gemini and fourth even though they're rookie their acting is SO AMAZING. They alwasy play their character perfectly, from tinn and gun to heart and li ming. Their range of acting is just beyond amazing
Bravo to all the actors in this episode. Mix and First did an excellent job trying to bring their relationship to an end with some dignity intact. Wen's sadness at not being able to fix things for Alan and Alan's quiet devastation was so touching. Also, Jim's problems all coming to a head at the same time, Earth makes you feel how stressed and worried he is, so he's made some mistakes especially with Li Ming. That boy could use some unconditional support from his only relative right now, but Jim's worries are taking over. And Gemini and Fourth are just stealing the show with their characters gentle and fragile, but getting stronger every episode love story. Li Ming finding someone finally who is laser focused on him and Heart getting a best friend who loves him truly and will bend over backwards for him. This series is one of the best I have ever seen in Thai BL. All the characters are real and relatable - fantastic work from all who worked to bring this to the screen.
I like that these characters are super flawed and going about things in all the wrong ways. It gets boring sometimes when the mains are just these perfect like people with no problems other then things that don't matter in real life. With this series we are getting real feelings and emotions, finally getting to see that relationships aren't just cookie cutters, they have flaws and sometimes they work and sometimes they won't. Bravo to everyone involved in this...thank you
Kudos for Gemini for conveying Heart's frustration and emotional scene, very real, he even groaned like he really wanted to scream it out if he could talk.
I'm on my knees, this show, especially FourthGemini made me cry ocean of tears. Li Ming and Heart's story is so powerful, I'm so in love. This is the best pure love that was shown on TV, seriously.
Heart's parents really can't convince me that they tried to understand Heart. Imagine your son being deaf for 3 years and you're still unable to know what he thinks, what he feels, what he wants to convey and what he is going through. You can't just leave him locked inside your house so that he doesn't get into trouble outside. This is not how you help him. The more time he spends with Li Ming, the more he feels comfortable and free. This is why he finds comfort in him rather than his parents who do not even treat him like a normal person.
Las actuaciones de Gemini y Fourt son muy buenas, cuando veo My School President siento que estoy viendo a personas completamente diferentes, eso habla de lo buenos actores que son.
Heart and Li Ming's story is genuinely one of the sweetest and most beautiful that I've ever seen. I want nothing but happiness for the both of them. But seriously, this entire scene was so beautiful and heartbreaking at the same time. I'm glad Heart was able to finally express the hurt his mother was inflicting upon him, and it's made even more sad that someone who has just met him not long ago is able to understand him when even his own mother hasn't tried to learn to. Gemini and Fourth have done a fantastic job with this story and these characters and like I said, I want nothing but happiness for these two :((
Seriously, I'm so impressed by Gemini's performance especially. I really appreciate the respect that this show has given Heart's character and you can tell a lot of care went into the role.
12:08 Esa lágrima de Corazón me llegó a mi corazón me parte en mil verlo así pero que hermoso el abrazo con Li Ming. Los adoro siempre juntos. 😍😍🥰🥰❤❤💖💖
0:33 they really put 2 people eating lovey dovey at the back🤭that’s so cute. Also seeing Li Ming & Heart getting closer and understand each other is just amazing & adorable.
This series is so amazing. Every casts doing their amazing job with their character, feelings and emotions. Like everyone. They completes the storyline that flows with right pace and everything makes sense. They are so real. They understands everything and delivers it to us so that we can feel it too. Kudos to everyone! Its a great job!
12:55 Three years is such a long time when you are young, but passes so quickly when life takes your youth from you and smothers it with responsibilities. Heart’s parents love him. Li Ming understands that. They have tried to find a way to manage, although they have very nearly failed. Li Ming may be the one to save them as well as their child.
Lo sabía. Tendríamos un "beso" entre Gemini y Fourth antes del último episodio de My School President.... y Jim los ve. Me parece perfecto que Jim diga que son amigos, luego con calma se conocen sinceramente y pueden comenzar una relación saludable.
Gemini is doing an amazing job i am in awe!!! his ability to convey his feelings so clearly through mere actions is just wow.. both he and fourth are so talented
"he said that ur ashamed of him being deaf." - um..I was moved to tears when I heard Li interpret Heart's body language. I deeply admire Heart for bravely expressing his desire for a normal childhood, despite years of suffering and his mother's shame towards others. Li's courage in standing up to protect Heart, learning sign language to communicate with him and being the first person to hug and comfort him after the incident is truly admirable. Gemini and Fourth acting are so excellent.
this series is a bliss for me. my heart is screaming happiness seeing heart and ming enjoying each others comfort. we can tell how comfortable they are and legit, ming adores heart so much and likewise. I am glad heart was able to finally made his mom realise how she/they treated him since he became deaf. for 3 years, mom, you never tried to learn even basic SL so you can communicate with him. it breaks my heart yet relieved at some point that heart was able to voice out what he has been keeping inside. And that hug with liming is so comforting. 😭
8:28 el climax de está escena es simplemente algo bien ejecutado los sentimientos en escena están tan expuestos que llore y simpatizo con ambos Li Ming-Hearth, como veníamos diciendo Hearth ve a Ming más que un amigo por el hecho de que desde que se conocieron el ha hecho más que sus padres, todos los actores hicieron un maravilloso trabajo y FourthGemini como siempre han demostrado que son los actores más jóvenes y maravillosos al momento de actuar ❤️
This series is sophisticated and mature. It gives characters time to develop, and their minds are complex. Uncle Jim does for Wen what he couldn't do for Li Ming during their conversation. He has been so protective of his comfort zone, which ideally is a life of simplicity, hence no tolerance for complications, yet now, Li Ming and Wen, Praew's pregnancy, and the looming buy-out of the restaurant make his life soooo complicated. He lashes out at Li Ming because he feels responsible for him but also because Li Ming is so chaotic for him. Wen introduces the chaos that is his relationship with Alan. He's adapting now, though, letting go of his fear of complication. JMO.
Li ming and Heart's story is so well written and executed. Gem and Forth's actings were so powerful it broke my heart. i officially love this side couple more than the main couple now. Li ming and Heart's relationship is just so sweet, pure and precious! 😭
![[Eng Sub] Moonlight Chicken พระจันทร์มันไก่ | EP.6 [1/4]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/1Q4LzjraPnw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[Eng Sub] Moonlight Chicken พระจันทร์มันไก่ | EP.6 [1/4]](/img/tr.png)
A mother asking a total stranger to translate for her son who has been deaf for three years so she could understand is one of the saddest thing I've ever seen on screen. And liming taking time to learn sign language so he could communicate with Heart is beautiful. It shows how much he cares and admire Heart. Everyone out there needs that one person that can go an extra mile for them. A person that can be there, care and love the beautiful and unique you. I can't wait to see the next episode. ❤
And that is why Heart says his mom is ashamed of him because he is deaf
It’s unbelieveable to see that Liming and Heart is the star of this series
Their story really stands out ❤
I rarely cry in real life and when watching movies. The last time I cried was probably years ago, can't even remember. That scene made me cry my eyes out 😭
Very well directed and acted by the actors!
I was going to write the same thing. My heart hurt as i saw this. It shows his mom doesn't really care about her son but more about how other people might think of them. I believe that's probably the reason she never lets him leave the house. It's not that I think she doesn't care about heart at all but she does it in a very fucked up way
@@_exotress_4593 absolutely, and the dad is just furniture at this point.
I literally cried when heart's parent didn't understand him and never tried to learn sign language and the way li ming treats him and comforts him. Gemini and fourth acting is so great and their chemistry
istg i love them so much
Especially when Heart said it’s been so long since he felt like a normal person then Liming answered there’re no different between Heart and others 😭😭😭
@@ayeshaaamer6861 samee
@@PAS835 yes 😭
I am cying😢😢😢
"I haven't felt this way in a long time"
"What way"
"Like a normal person"
Li Ming is literally Hearts comfort zone he makes him feel like he exist he took all the loneliness away from Heart, I like how Li Ming educated Heart's Mum with their confrontation he even made her realize how she actually doesn't know anything about her own Son and she had to depend on Li Ming to tell her what her Son was actually saying, Heart was really broken, seeing how Heart leaned on Li Ming's shoulder and hugging him tight and the tears flowing that was really heart wrenching.
Ugh their storyline is so good, watching Li Ming translate for Heart when he’s only known him a little while really got to me. ❤❤❤
heart wrenching you better write this comment.
Seriously this series is is really interesting because of this two
@@bethconley exactly 💯 and that what hurts, Heart the most because his Mom has been with him ever since he became deaf for 3yrs and she couldn't even make the efforts of learning how to communicate with him instead she just forbid him from going out no wonder Heart told her if she is ashamed of him, it's really hurts he was crying with so much pain 😣.
Agree Gemini and Fourth are the gem of this series
as a person who knows sign language i was actually shocked when i discovered gemini didn't know tsl before this. you can see he puts his heart into. sign language is not only about how you sign, expressions are a big part of it, and he doesn't lack on it, like some other hearing actors playing deaf characters. he learned well!
I am so glad to hear this from someone that knows sign language.
@@deanasnyder3774 more like if they know thai Sign language, I know my country sign language and i don't see he flows this well like they said, but it could be because I don't know thai xd.
Just a little stretch on the topic: just because someone knows sign language doesn't mean they are experts or know every countries mannerisms and flow with it.
@@ezequielmondada6427 Gemini did so well both sign language and expression.
@@dekbrisbane7294 so it is just the flow of the language?
Idk Thai sign language, it seems really strong how he signs.
I have been signing for over 6 years now and I am so impressed and shocked with Gemini's performance. Like, I don't even care if a Deaf person is played by a Hearing person as long as it is done properly, and Gemini had me actually looking up if he was Deaf or not.
Honestly I feel like GeminiFourth play the biggest roles in this series as they communicate without actually talking but with actions. They have to take on a role that they would struggle to fully understand as they haven't experienced it and they pull it off so well. I'm so proud of them honestly their roles in this series tell the biggest story in a language that if we took a little time of our day to learn everyone could understand with no problems and it shows the harsh reality of someone people who are deaf. I can't wait to see more of this couple 🤭
Honestly I agree with you
I agree as well.
Talented people, and they probably also have good instructors too... Which says even more about how the production team is giving these things the attention they deserve.
UR WORDS DEEP, LOVE IT
@@BJCMXY Couldn't agree more!
This is why I want a bl with a deaf male lead, I understand communication is important but bl’s tend to put too much emphasis onto audible communication which gets boring, and they end up putting less focus on physical communication.
Gemini's acting is extremely commendable. He was able to convey his acting literally through mere actions. I was sobbing in the scene where he confronted his mother. The actor playing his mother also deserves credit. It was such a heartbreaking scene.
it was very heartbreaking when Heart tried to speak to her mother using sign language but what Heart got, nothing.Gemini's acting is extraordinary, it needs to be appreciated. the pain that Heart feels, can be channeled to everyone who sees it
I am crying too…😢
You can just tell that Heart means so much more to Li Ming than just a friend!! Their chemistry is so strong that it's overflowing!!!🥺🥺🥺🥺
that preview!!! I screamed!!
@@pusakuching Not HeartMing having a kiss before TinnGun🤣🤣
Frr
@@annakendra1365 exactly 😭✋
I’m cried 🥹🥹🥹
The scene where heart is confronting his parents and only Li Ming can understand and translate is so powerful, gemini and fourth acting skills aren't joke
Seeing Heart's mom not understanding him so he has to speak through Li Ming broke me on a different level
Same 😢
Same... 💔
Yeah, it broke my heart and made me furious on Heart's behalf. Imagine how how felt when his parents couldn't be bothered to learn how to communicate with him on even a basic level... And then to have them isolate him further by not allowing him to leave the house would have been another blow. As a parent, I can't comprehend their reasoning for their actions.
@@Arador76 I don't understand too how this is even possible for parents to do this to their child. To my mind this is somehow child abuse to keep him trapped in this house for 3 years and be left out by his family, not trying to understand and communicate with him 🤷🏻♀️😔
@@blushing-alpaca2679If you had a deaf son, you would learn sign language for him, but the mom is only accusatory, and wants to keep her son trap, and unable to communicate and live independently. He may be deaf, but he has a lot life in him and wants to live and treated normally.
Man. I thought Wen and Alan's fights were the most real thing I'd ever seen on TV. But then we get this scene with Heart and his mom and I'm actually sobbing.
I'm so grateful for P'Aof. Everything he touches is beautiful, magical, and so true it aches.
What else has P’Aof worked on?? The writing/storylines on this show are amazing and I would love to watch more of his stuff
@@saburrrna P'Aof has many famous works. 1000 stars, together, bad buddy, our skyy, dark blue kiss among many others. You can search his name 'Aof Noppharnach Chaiyahwimhon'
I replay Wen and Alan's fight so many times just to see their expression. It was so real. And man, I feel so tired for Jim. So many things happen in this episode and it's never ending for Jim xD But all in all, this episode is beautiful in so many level. This drama is spot on.
12:48 - So nobody noticed how Heart’s room/mirror is decorated with all the sticky notes that his mom used to communicate with him?!? This just goes to show how even despite everything Heart had so much love for his mother
I was wondering what are those notes , now I got it. Thank you.
my heart shattered when I saw that💔🙁
Was looking for this comment.
Glad someone noticed it too.
Where all those notes couldn't bring an understanding between the parents and the son.
The hug shown in the mirror tells how simple and enough it can be to communicate everything.
Loved this frame. ❤
'i don't have a place to stay anymore'... well bby boy, i feel like you've finally hit the perfect sweet spot for uncle jim who has a cat that used to be a stray, a nephew he takes care of like a son, a diner that barely makes profits because he's always giving out (practically) free food, & a friend whose surprise pregnancy he's helping with... all of which means that he physically CANNOT seem to ignore people like you in need of his help 🥺🥺
Yes, in a nutshell!!!
This is so true!
I'm sorry but I'm laughing reading ur comment but you summed it up perfectly
🤣🤣🤣 eiiih,,, bestie you nailed it
best thing that i read today
geminifourth's acting is so beautiful... seriously can't believe this is the first roles they filmed for gmmtv... they did so well, i literally cried with them
It’s so warm and so smooth ever seen
Yeaaaah agree, they were born to be an actor!
Nope it's the second show...they are already in another drama that is my school president.. In which they are playing the lead role...
@@zehrasayed9122 moonlight chicken was filmed first before msp
@@saturn_djsu ohh 😯
Omg is it just me? I really really really want a spin-off series for Heart and Li Ming. The story, Gemini and Fourth's acting, their chemistry, everything is just so good. I was smiling like crazy at their first few scenes but then I almost cried.
Me too P re watch this Ep for 10 times just to watch Gemini's acting, He killed it. I was crying badly.
Yes i agree
As someone who is deaf and has been since I was born 36 years ago, this episode REALLY hit me! The portrayal of Hearts pain at the lonely, silent world we feel and experience is all too real! To be seen and treated as normal is all we deaf people want. So when we find that person who sees us as such, well, we just want to hold onto them tight. So I understand Hearts pain and anger at Heart towards his parents for essentially trapping him in the house for 3 years, like a bird in a gilded cage. All he wants to be is free and Li Ming gives him that.
Well done to the production and writing team for, in my opinion, an accurate portrayal of a deaf person.
Its okay. You are normal like everyone. If someone ever treated you bad like heart's mom. They dont deserve you. You are precious
I’m not part of the deaf community but is it normal for people who lose their hearing after a years of hearing ie gemini 10+ yrs to not speak despite knowing how to vocalise? Cos I thought that was kinda weird
@Shaemus🫣 Yes. He might have developed a speech impediment (like i did), so he may not be confident in speaking. Also his parents didn't communicate with him other than pass notes under the door, so he may have lost the ability to speak properly, plus remember before Le Ming, Heart didn't go out or really communicate with ANYONE at all, which further exacerbates the loss in speaking properly.
@I am really bad at names... 🙃 Thank you so much. You don't realise how much I needed to hear that.
@@kellykuk thanks for the reply. Yeah that all makes sense. Ig I was only thinking about ppl without speech impediments and his parents choices would obviously negatively effect his communication abilities/style
I don’t know why but there is something like magic in Heart and Li Ming scenes. Be it My school president or Moonlight chicken those 2 rookies nailed the scenes and they set the bar so high for finding solace in each other ❤
I do agree with you when they appear it’s something like magical in them that we can’t take our eyes away from them the chemistry is so amazing too I really obsessed with them 😢❤
Agreee my biased sorry if I skipped if without them
I'm watching only their parts in the series...
Strongly agree with you...gemini and fourth, these two are so amazing together ❤️....
Totally agreed with u...they have something special ❤️🤌
Heart feeling a normal person is such a beautiful scene. Finally LiMing's efforts paid off. It makes me sad that Heart's parents never made any effort for their son, they just leave him alone at home. Heart and LiMing are the cutest couple ❤️😌
It was so heart wrenching scene when Heart's parents couldn't understand his signs and LiMing has to explain them. As a parent they failed him 😞
Hat's off to Gemini. Heart was made for him to play, he did an amazing job
He just went to feel normal
Exactly
Hoping that on the next epsiode Heart's parent would understand him more. :)
I got so emotional seeing people appreciating Gemini❤
I felt Heart's pain knowing that his parents did not make any effort to learn sign language. I would feel the same way. And Li Ming delivering what Heart wants to tell her mom? Amazing. This on screen couple is my favorite. For rookies, they truly have done an amazing job. These 2 are precious gems.
Seriously they are so good for being so young!! ❤❤
I never knew that Heart's parents don't understand the sign language till this eps.. how can u ask someone to translate your own child language, Heart deserve to be happy and the only person that can make him happy is Liming
It's a testament to their acting that they've even upstaged the main couple a bit who are also a fantastic pair of experienced performers!
@@addictedbtskpop1876 this tells us that in Ep1 when Heart broke that liquor bottle, he was signing something during the argument with Jim and Liming and his mother pretended to understand him. When in fact she did not, she just wanted to Liming to take responsibility
No one's gonna talk about how solid Leng's lines are?
"A baby girl or baby boy, we raise them the same"
"We let them choose their gender identity when they grow up"
Exactly 💯
And then be like
Who care whatever you are if you earn money you are winner
I’ve been looking for this comment !!
i was searching for this comment only
100% agree!
But couldn’t help but cringe at him saying no ultrasounds… fetal development is very important to keep track of 😬😬 they’re not just used to find out the gender
Gemini's acting is so amazing I can't even begin, he plays the character so well the frustrations and Fourth too and the hug was so comforting
The way how Li Ming is always carefully watching Heart even if others around, care about him and love him shows a true deep connection what is really rare. I think I can say that Fourth and Gemini so far the best actors. They showing characters perfectly, they truly make them alive and their chemistry is on a way higher level then the other pairs. They play difficult characters perfectly. I deeply hope they will have a lot of series together because they really deserve it and can tell they will be successful for sure in every character what will play in the future as well.
”what did he say?”
Li Ming having to translate sign language for Heart’s mom even though her *_son_* has been deaf for three *_years_* was the saddest thing i’ve seen today
Yh.. they always leave him in the house alone so they don't know the sign language, that's why they are always writing on paper
Yaa thats totally broken 😭😭
Yes 🥺
😭😭😭😭😭
…i’m still so fully jusT SO TOTALLY BLOWN AWAY BY GEMINI’S ACTING 🤯🤯🤯 it’s SO good and so real that this is what it is, the hardships, the pain and anger heart is feeling and expressing through his gestures, the signing, his eyes. i completely felt it.
The huge work him and Forth did for their roles is insane. These actors are truly gems.
Ugh this show makes me so happy. I absolutely love how they have a deaf character and are spreading deaf awareness. Deaf people are the exact same as hearing people, the ONLY difference is that they can’t hear. There’s no reason to coddle a deaf person or treat them like a child. I’m so happy they’re addressing this in the show. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
12:35 Gemini never seizes to amaze me. And Foooourth... conveying Heart's message to the parents is really HEARTFELT. (Full of emotion and content)
When Li Ming said, "You're normal to me", it's really heartwarming. Just because he can't do some activities others can do, doesn't mean he is anything less.
The confrontation scene with Heart's mom was wonderfully executed. Hats off to the rookie actors...they truly are gem!
And I always love the scenes between Uncle Jim and Li Ming. Teenagers think they have grown up, they want control of their life. While raising teens is really difficult if the guardian doesn't try to think being in their shoes. Both must find the middle ground.
The emotion First portrays are super powerful. He was trying so hard not to break down during the dinner time.
Jim didn't want complicated relation, but life has never been fair to anyone, we get what we don't want.
This series just keeps getting better and better every episode, I’m not ready for it to be over next week😭😭. Also the scene where Li Ming was translating what Heart was saying to his mother was absolutely heart wrenching, all the actors did absolutely fantastic conveying their characters feelings during that scene❤❤.
you could really see the hurt in gemini's eyes and the awkwerdness with fourth and eventually the hurt in the mother's eyes when she realised that li ming actually understood her son when she couldn't.
is it already over in 3 episodes... :'( ? Then NLMG, MSP and Moonlight Chicken will end at the same time, what will I watch :/...? :'((
Esta serie es un claro ejemplo de que una serie bl puede tener un buen guión, buenas actuaciones, una trama interesante , el tema de inclusión bien manejado sin forzarlo, mantiene las expectativas, evoluciona, muchas gracias por su trabajo.
This story is so well done, the way in which Li Ming had to translate what Heart said to her own mother shows how little she knows her son,she literally dont know how comunicate with him, Li Ming with only a short time opened up to understand Heart and treat him as a normal person, adorable.
ชอบความสัมพันธ์ของฮาร์ทกับลี่หมิง น่ารักมาก ลี่หมิงรักฮาร์ทมาก ดูแลเอาใจใส่ฮาร์ทมากจริงๆ
11:52 Liming and Heart are the reason I'm watching this show I just love their pure non-toxic relationship
YES 👏🏻👏🏻
Fr it's so CUTE
Yes and earth mix my good wen and Alan I just wait to see the interaction between Alan and gaipa hope they will be together
I'll say yess
Same it's so Cute
It hurts seeing the mom or the dad never made efforts to learn how to sign… it clearly shows how they treat their son’s situation as something not to be concerned of.😔
In real life there are parent like Heart’s parent so sad
Exactly 😭 i felt so sad i am glad heart has li ming
Right. I was mad that the mom was trying to act all sad. Like ma'am you were acting like your son annoyed you or you didn't care episodes before.
True. The saddest part of this eps is about Heart and his parents😢
Three years. Tres anos. 3 sets of 365. Not one bit of sign learned. Li Ming just land and translating for Heart's parents. Smh. An entire 3 years!
my heart goes to Heart!!!! Gemini did so well expressing his emotions. I cried so hard knowing what he had been through like him being at his house locked like a cage for 3 years and finally felt like a normal person when he is out with Li Ming. It's so hard to see him cry like that😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 GeminiFourth's chemistry really shines and I can't wait for tomorrow's episode🤧🤧
sama :"(
Omg I feel like he's been holding his breath for three years and finally released it at 12:25😭
ตกใจตอนหลี่หมิงแปลภาษาว่าฮาร์ทหูหนวกมาสามปีแล้ว แต่แม่ฮ่าร์ทไม่ยอมเรียนภาษามือเลย เพราะตอนที่พ่อแม่ฮาร์ทเรียกหลี่หมิงมาเค้นเรื่องเหล้า เห็นฮาร์ททำภาษามืออธิบาย แล้วแม่ฮาร์ทพยักหน้า แสดงว่าจริงๆแม่ฮาร์ทไม่เข้าใจภาษามือ แต่รู้เรื่องจากที่ฮาร์ทเขียนใส่กระดาษให้แน่ๆ ฮาร์ทคงเหงามาก มันเหมือนพ่อแม่ไม่ใส่ใจด้วย แต่กับหลี่หมิงคือพอรู้ว่าฮาร์ทหูหนวกก็หัดเรียนภาษามือมาคุยกับฮาร์ทเลย หลี่หมิงพยายามมากกว่าพ่อแม่ฮาร์ทอีก
แม่ยังเข้าใจฮาร์ทได้ไม่เท่าหลี่หมิงด้วยซ้ำ สงสารน้อง😭
สงสารฮาร์ท ลูกหูหนวกมา3ปี พ่อแม่ไม่เคยสนใจใส่ใจลูกเลย😭😭😭
อ่ยสงสารลูกๆ
จริงค่ะแถมพ่อแม่ฮาร์ทชอบปล่อยให้ฮาร์ทอยู่คนเดียวอยู่บ่อยๆพอมีหลี่หมิงมาอยู่ด้วยฮาร์ทดูมีความสุขมากๆและดูไม่เหงาเลยย
สงสารฮาร์ท😢😢😢
I have to commend the whole team for this wonderful drama. The cinematography , script writing, lighting, and acting are top-notch. Earth and mix conveying so many different emotions with just their eyes.
First's acting in the apartment after the confrontation last episode and the conversation he had with Mix in the restaurant just felt so real.
The characters they portrayed felt like real people with all their flaws , mistakes, and complications.
The scene with Li Ming, Heart and his mother made me cry so much and seeing all his mother's notes he kept broke my heart even more... Awesome acting
El director hizo tan buen trabajo ,y los actores Armán tan bien sus personajes
Sin miedo a decir que será la mejor serie del 2023 😫🤌🏻💕
with MSP ;)
Siiiii
Sabes que siiii, es una de las mejores que están saliendo hasta ahora, seguida de My School President.. la otra a la que le tengo una GRAN expectativa es a Last Twilight de JimmySea, es algo como la historia de Li Ming y Heart aquí,, el trailer se ve bonito, lo estoy esperando mucho
Coincido, no por demeritar a otras, pero me parece un buen guión y actuaciones muy realistas, es de lo mejor que he visto
@@Ocean8soul ESA TAMBIEN ME ENCANTA
Usually Im amazed by Fourth's acting skills but in this episode Gemini killed it! The way he is very fluent in the sign language shows how much effort he has put! Geminifourth has a long way to go! Excellent actors with great chemistry! ❤
The notes on the wall in Heart’s room KILLED ME. He learned SL all by himself to communicate with his parents firstly and his parents couldn’t even make a single effort. He must have felt so alone and trapped 😢
the worst part for me is you can see that Heart has some sign language posters up on the wall near the window, probably of the most basic signs like "hello", "thank you" etc. His parents' don't even have the excuse of not having the materials to learn bcs they're right there on Heart's wall.
Just a hug...just a hug but it meant so muchhhh..The deep sigh what heart took after hugging ming was something that can't b expressed by words..I cried a lot in this episode in the begging when Jim acted like stranger..when Alan was hoping for some chances..when hearts mother felt completely helpless ..The fact being under the same roof still she was not able to understand her child...Apart from all this Jims life is a hell ..can't stand for his own love ...business..his teenage nephew...all a puddle
A wonderful summary of how this episode made all of us feel. Well said.
😂😂😂😂😂All a puddle bestie
@@gaemlinsidoharthi 💖💖💖
Atleast someone sees jim wen undoubtedly mesmerizing acting thanks yaar
@@sosin3064 true this man can act and its not because I am his loyal dying fan but anything he is in it I will watch it
I am shocked I did not expect this level of acting for GeminiFourth, their chemistry
Me too, though I watched MSP too but their acting in Moonlight Chicken are right at the top, with their age & their experience in acting & they are able to convey all the complicated emotions that the character/scene needs, I'm impressed
@@kcyoong2391 exactly, me too
"Let's stop hurting each other's."
It takes so much courage to finally accept that the love once made us so happy has coming to an end. The honest conversation of Alan and Wen about there relationship is so heartbreaking yet much needed. They both did excellent job on that scene especially ALAN,
PS.
FIRST make me a fan of his from this😊
You should watch Not Me if you haven’t yet, First is so good in that as well!!
Try not me, the eclipse too 🤍
@@cheyloveskhaothe shipper as well🏃🏃🏃
I watch him in all of that but that genre seems don't fit in him. It's the first time I feel him. Thu his chemistry with khao is great. But I can fairly say that I admire him here.
8:54 this scene was soo heart breaking when heart was talking with his parents about how it feels to live alone and his mom was soo lost bcuz she can't understand what heart was saying she was so lost and that time he nedeed liming to understand what his own is saying to him.
Oh my ! Fourth and Gemini’s performance stood out in this episode … amazing !!! Let’s give them a big round of applause guys .
that scene with li ming being a translator between heart and his mother was painful yet beautiful ❤😭
เจมีไนน์โฟร์ทคือแสดงได้ดีมาก สีหน้าแววตาคือดีสุด สื่ออารมณ์ได้ดี เก่งมากนี่คือร้องไห้ตามแล้วนะ
Me alegra de que Wen porfin haya dejado todo claro con Alan, espero que pronto Alan conozca a Gaipa
yessss
no me importa que no terminen juntos, con que se hagan amigos me es suficiente 😞
หลี่หมิงทำไมหนูน่ารักขนาดนี้ลูกก ฮาร์ทก็น่ารักอะ🤏🏻💓😭
หูหนวกทำไมพูดไม่ได้อะคะ
EPนี้ เราร้องไห้หนักมากตอนหลี่หมิงกับฮาร์ทเกิดอุบัติเหตุแล้วโดนแม่ฮาร์ทดุ ทุกคนแสดงดีมากจริงๆ โดยเฉพาะน้องทั้งคู่
Heart and Li Ming are so pure. You can really tell that they found comfort from each other. 🥺
8:28 start from this minute it shows Heart’s frustration, and it’s hurt. Gemini played Heart really really well, like pls this boy deserved award for this role
The moment he throwed the notepad I was stunned
@@sangamvishwakarma1569 agree😢
I agree. He is a natural actor. 👍
Fr !!!
@@sangamvishwakarma1569 IKR
Liming's character is my favorite of all time, I've never seen a character so relatable who embodies the struggles and passion of youth like he does
I guess it's because Fourth is under him, he's so full of life and energy!
ไม่ไหวแล้ว มันเกินจริงไปหน่อย ตอนนี้งง ว่าจะหัวเราะก่อนหรือร้องไห้ ตอนแรก 6 ก็โหดแล้ว
HeartLiming coversation is so simple yet so emotional
“I haven’t felt this way in a long time”
“What way”
“Like a normal person”
“You’re normal to me”
Li Ming is the reason Heart feel that he exists again and Li Ming literally took away all 3 years of loneliness.
The sadness,frustration,loneliness is all on Heart expression and body language when he confronts his mum through Li Ming. It’s was so heart wrenching when he broke down in Li Ming arms, holding so tightly and crying so hard. I cried when the camera span across the notes sticked across his bedroom. It’s must be such a lonely journey he has been going through without having someone there for him.
Not gonna lie, GeminiFourth gonna be the next big thing for GMMTV. Gemini acting is so admirable. Fourth is so natural at acting but Gemini acting is not praised enough. Both of them are so young yet their characters are so deep and they deliver it so well.
Heart and Li Ming storyline is the one that carry the show for me.
I WILL NOT GET TIRED THAT GEMINIFOURTH'S PERFORMANCE IS SO INCREDIBLE,I LOVE THEM 💘
Interesting choice of lighting. In Heart's house the blue tones show everything is cold, except for his own bed and the stairs that lead to his bedroom. Even in his bedroom, the blue lighting show his parents notes. While in Li Ming's house the colors are warmer, showing he has a trusting family in Uncle Jim.
Yes, and it’s always super dark in Alan and Wen’s place! I noticed the lighting there too. ❤
Yes, the cinematography and lighting in this is spectacular. The details they incorporate even with the script writing like the pen and reigniting the flame is so soo good.
that's a good point. it's all these background details in the show that really adds more depth to the story imho, you can tell the production team took that as another layer of storytelling without additional dialogue.
I'm used to seeing this kind of detail in independent films but rarely in a series, let alone a bl series.
there was blue lightning in Moonlight Chicken too, it reflected in Earth mouth, tongue and teeth it was very awkward to watch x'D
Wen and Alan were a pretty cute couple back then.
I loved Heart and Li Ming moments together when they were with Wen at the mall, it was so adorable.
The business meeting between Jim and Alan was tensed, wow. And the metaphor about their relationship, they did with the pen, omg. Alan is not here to joke.
Love the constant support LiMing give to Heart and how he encourages him to do new things.
Finally, Alan and Wen had an honest talk about their relationship, it was needed.
It's hurt for both of them, but it's time to let go.
I like the type of metaphor, like here, they're ending their relationship for good and the waiter came to "reanimate" the fire for the beef but Wen said its not necessary, because they're done, they're done eating, and with their couple, so they don't need to reanimate the flames between them.
The mom telling he taught him to ride a motorcycle but he's deaf so it's a problem??? What?
I loved so much how Li Ming told straight to Heart mom that Deaf people are normal people and that she knows nothing about them and that she needs to stop acting like she's doing right now.
I'm glad that Heart talked to her to and said he was tired of this.
I wish they would put subtitles for when Heart is using sign language, it's so needed.
It's too bad that Jim didn't support Li Ming at this moment or understood him a little more, but I think he has a lot on his plate with his own life and just want to protect Li Ming.
He just need to treat him like a grown up and back him up when it's needed. It will be a weight out of his shoulders. He raised him well since all these years, it's time to think for himself and make decisions, until now, he's doing pretty fine. With Heart, he's growing up so well.
I liked the end with Wen and Jim.
I think them not putting subtitles when heart does sign language is a great choice, it shows that even us the audience do not understand what he is going through. It emphasizes the value of Li Ming learning sign language and how he is the only one who really understands him during that scene.
they don't put the subtitles so we can feel the frustration too and understand the struggle of Heart trying to communicate but not being able to.
@Abbie Nibini ohh, haven't thought like this, indeed it's a good choice.
@@junseonghofr16 haven't thought of that. It's a good way to show us all that, indeed!
Agree with what has been explained about the sign language subtitles by other commenters. I just wanna add that even without the sub, we can still get a very good idea of what Heart says afterward since Li Ming always repeats and asks for clarification to make sure he understands Heart correctly. This is such a great way to show how considerate Li Ming is and also to help us viewers follow their conversations.
12:15 Heart realmente siente que li ming es su lugar seguro 🥺 miren cómo cada vez se apoya más en él, se acerca y lo abraza más con todo su cuerpo. se adoran 🥺💖
I'm not exaggerating when I say that Li Ming's and Heart's story is one of the most beautiful, heartwarming and impactful love stories that I've ever seen, not least because it's as much about friendship, coming-of-age and disability rights as it is about romantic love. Forth and Gemini are also outstanding in their roles. we're not even halfway into the season, and I'm not sure that my heart will be able to take it.
I cried a lot in this episode between Alan and Wen's confrontations and Li Ming and Heart's scenes, my emotions are leveling up! Oh I'm so in love with this series...
The whole scene of LiMing and Heart here is the best scene’s I’ve ever seen in any BL series ever. Kudos to the screenwriter, the director and the actors. This was a top notch performance here
Even though First doesn’t have such a leading role in this series, his performances here are a cut above the other series, competent as those were.
In fact, all of the cast are doing so wonderfully. Powerful yet subtle performances, every one.
I love how innocent and pure they built li ming and heart's relationship it's not built on looks or sex, li ming is that company heart's been searching for..
those little steps of LiMing towards Heart at 4:04 is so beautiful how they nudged eo looked so beautiful into eo's eyes its all soo warmm P'Aof how long should i praise you for giving us thse wonderful dramas 🥺🥺
i don't know what gem and fourth are doing to me but every time i look at them i feel like i'm in love with the chemistry between them it's unique
so you're telling me next episode features wen & uncle jim living together, heart & liming's first kiss, jim finding out about the cuties being together, AND gaipa finally confessing to the old man?! tomorrow can't come sooner 😭😭
@@babyrubyjane right, no need for us to wait until next week😭🤩🤩
I wonder if the kiss scene was just a position or they actually kissed. this is because in MSP, we didn't get one bit HAHA
@@minatoandyori i think just angle kiss😂
@@sabrina08080 i think so HAHA it's because very impossible to get it
SO much happening tomo
No es fácil intentar madurar sin que tus tutores no piensen que eres un crío todavía. Jim y Li Ming tienen que llegar a entenderse y no pelearse constantemente.
Los ojitos de Jim y Wen cuando Wen aparece con las maletas y dice que no tiene un lugar al que volver, me parte el corazón 😭.
x2
The best thing is seeing deaf people saying such positive things about this show and the portrayal of them. It’s so important to have accurate representation and I’m so happy to see the positive responses:) congrats to the writers of the show!
I'm so happy my man Gem is receiving the praises he deserves🥺🥺 it's his first work even before MySchoolPresident but look at how beautifully he conveyed his emotions thru his eyes and actions my boi deserves all the love🥺🥺
Li Ming and heart,A complete opposite side of Gunn and tinn! Like these two are so talented!! Li Ming is such a heart warming character ☺️ They just touched everyone's soul I guess! GMMTV you have like the best actors, seriously the best❤️
Gemini and fourth even though they're rookie their acting is SO AMAZING. They alwasy play their character perfectly, from tinn and gun to heart and li ming. Their range of acting is just beyond amazing
100000% agree, they are so talented~
Riiiiiggghhttt???!!! they are rookies but they do outstanding acting than most of the bl actors.
this whole episode was VERY emotional, very very beautiful, all actors are doing such an AMAZING job
la relación entre heart y li ming es de las historias más bonitas, mañana se viene otro capitulazo♡
Bravo to all the actors in this episode. Mix and First did an excellent job trying to bring their relationship to an end with some dignity intact. Wen's sadness at not being able to fix things for Alan and Alan's quiet devastation was so touching. Also, Jim's problems all coming to a head at the same time, Earth makes you feel how stressed and worried he is, so he's made some mistakes especially with Li Ming. That boy could use some unconditional support from his only relative right now, but Jim's worries are taking over. And Gemini and Fourth are just stealing the show with their characters gentle and fragile, but getting stronger every episode love story. Li Ming finding someone finally who is laser focused on him and Heart getting a best friend who loves him truly and will bend over backwards for him. This series is one of the best I have ever seen in Thai BL. All the characters are real and relatable - fantastic work from all who worked to bring this to the screen.
I like that these characters are super flawed and going about things in all the wrong ways. It gets boring sometimes when the mains are just these perfect like people with no problems other then things that don't matter in real life. With this series we are getting real feelings and emotions, finally getting to see that relationships aren't just cookie cutters, they have flaws and sometimes they work and sometimes they won't. Bravo to everyone involved in this...thank you
Kudos for Gemini for conveying Heart's frustration and emotional scene, very real, he even groaned like he really wanted to scream it out if he could talk.
NOT HEARTLIMING HAVING THEIR FIRST KISS BEFORE TINNGUN 😭😭😭
Literally 😂😂
Brooooo samee 😭😭😭😭... They made us wait till the last episode for their kiss and here we are getting kiss before last episode of MSP
Nah for real, I literally choked when I saw and had to rewatch to make sure I wasn’t seeing things🤣🤣.
@@Riley_Loewen lol I thought I was the only one who rewind to make sure, did they really kissed 🤣
I was gonna write the same thing 😂
ใจเจ่บไปหมดเห็นเจมิไนน์ร้องห้าย
Lo bonito que es ver a Li ming entendiendo y comprendiendo a Heart es genial 😿💗
I'm on my knees, this show, especially FourthGemini made me cry ocean of tears. Li Ming and Heart's story is so powerful, I'm so in love. This is the best pure love that was shown on TV, seriously.
Heart's parents really can't convince me that they tried to understand Heart. Imagine your son being deaf for 3 years and you're still unable to know what he thinks, what he feels, what he wants to convey and what he is going through. You can't just leave him locked inside your house so that he doesn't get into trouble outside. This is not how you help him. The more time he spends with Li Ming, the more he feels comfortable and free. This is why he finds comfort in him rather than his parents who do not even treat him like a normal person.
Que lindos son Li Ming y Heart, es un amor tan puro y real
Las actuaciones de Gemini y Fourt son muy buenas, cuando veo My School President siento que estoy viendo a personas completamente diferentes, eso habla de lo buenos actores que son.
Heart and Li Ming's story is genuinely one of the sweetest and most beautiful that I've ever seen. I want nothing but happiness for the both of them.
But seriously, this entire scene was so beautiful and heartbreaking at the same time. I'm glad Heart was able to finally express the hurt his mother was inflicting upon him, and it's made even more sad that someone who has just met him not long ago is able to understand him when even his own mother hasn't tried to learn to.
Gemini and Fourth have done a fantastic job with this story and these characters and like I said, I want nothing but happiness for these two :((
Seriously, I'm so impressed by Gemini's performance especially. I really appreciate the respect that this show has given Heart's character and you can tell a lot of care went into the role.
12:08 Esa lágrima de Corazón me llegó a mi corazón me parte en mil verlo así pero que hermoso el abrazo con Li Ming. Los adoro siempre juntos. 😍😍🥰🥰❤❤💖💖
Heart es mi corazon❤y verlo asi me parte el corazon😢.
Ese abrazo es lo que restaura
i love how even tho gemini can't speak his expressions are so clear when he plays heart, especially during the scene with his mom.
Earth's sigh is iconic. He delivers every sigh very well. and those powerful eyes that can talk even if he doesnt utter any words.
0:33 they really put 2 people eating lovey dovey at the back🤭that’s so cute. Also seeing Li Ming & Heart getting closer and understand each other is just amazing & adorable.
I cried with him as deaf person had that experience, and it really hit me so hard like finally exactly everyone can recognize this
This series is so amazing. Every casts doing their amazing job with their character, feelings and emotions. Like everyone. They completes the storyline that flows with right pace and everything makes sense. They are so real. They understands everything and delivers it to us so that we can feel it too. Kudos to everyone! Its a great job!
12:55 Three years is such a long time when you are young, but passes so quickly when life takes your youth from you and smothers it with responsibilities.
Heart’s parents love him. Li Ming understands that. They have tried to find a way to manage, although they have very nearly failed.
Li Ming may be the one to save them as well as their child.
Lo sabía. Tendríamos un "beso" entre Gemini y Fourth antes del último episodio de My School President.... y Jim los ve.
Me parece perfecto que Jim diga que son amigos, luego con calma se conocen sinceramente y pueden comenzar una relación saludable.
Gemini is doing an amazing job i am in awe!!! his ability to convey his feelings so clearly through mere actions is just wow.. both he and fourth are so talented
"he said that ur ashamed of him being deaf." - um..I was moved to tears when I heard Li interpret Heart's body language. I deeply admire Heart for bravely expressing his desire for a normal childhood, despite years of suffering and his mother's shame towards others. Li's courage in standing up to protect Heart, learning sign language to communicate with him and being the first person to hug and comfort him after the incident is truly admirable. Gemini and Fourth acting are so excellent.
this series is a bliss for me. my heart is screaming happiness seeing heart and ming enjoying each others comfort. we can tell how comfortable they are and legit, ming adores heart so much and likewise.
I am glad heart was able to finally made his mom realise how she/they treated him since he became deaf. for 3 years, mom, you never tried to learn even basic SL so you can communicate with him. it breaks my heart yet relieved at some point that heart was able to voice out what he has been keeping inside. And that hug with liming is so comforting. 😭
8:28 el climax de está escena es simplemente algo bien ejecutado los sentimientos en escena están tan expuestos que llore y simpatizo con ambos Li Ming-Hearth, como veníamos diciendo Hearth ve a Ming más que un amigo por el hecho de que desde que se conocieron el ha hecho más que sus padres, todos los actores hicieron un maravilloso trabajo y FourthGemini como siempre han demostrado que son los actores más jóvenes y maravillosos al momento de actuar ❤️
This series is sophisticated and mature. It gives characters time to develop, and their minds are complex. Uncle Jim does for Wen what he couldn't do for Li Ming during their conversation. He has been so protective of his comfort zone, which ideally is a life of simplicity, hence no tolerance for complications, yet now, Li Ming and Wen, Praew's pregnancy, and the looming buy-out of the restaurant make his life soooo complicated. He lashes out at Li Ming because he feels responsible for him but also because Li Ming is so chaotic for him. Wen introduces the chaos that is his relationship with Alan. He's adapting now, though, letting go of his fear of complication. JMO.
Fourth y Gemini son unos actores tan increibles, dios la escena me hizo llorar
Li ming and Heart's story is so well written and executed. Gem and Forth's actings were so powerful it broke my heart. i officially love this side couple more than the main couple now. Li ming and Heart's relationship is just so sweet, pure and precious! 😭