ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 11 ก.ย. 2024
- For nearly two weeks, Ukrainian forces have been seizing and occupying Russian territory in the Kursk region.
It marks the first time since World War Two that a foreign army has been fighting inside Russia - and for many Russian people, it is cause for alarm.
Repeating the official messaging of the state media, some Russians call for “peace on Russia’s terms”, while others expressed hope that Moscow and Kyiv will sit down at the negotiating table and work out a way to end the conflict.
But, while the Kremlin is still calling what its troops are doing in Ukraine a “special military operation”, ordinary Russians use one simple word to describe all of this: "war".
Subscribe here: bit.ly/1rbfUog
For more news, analysis and features visit: www.bbc.com/news
#Russia #Ukraine #BBCNews
Lady “why is this happening with us?”
WOW, she really doesn’t know. Don’t take the free press for granted.
The
She literally knows exactly what's happening she even admitted it
When you've been lied to for so,so long you've no clue what's going on?
@@ronlacker326do ruski bots work for free?
@@Lenser Bots, yes. Trolls get borscht.
0:36 "I am not a political person." - This seems like a common refrain among Russians. Six seconds later she asks, "Why is this happening to us?" The answer is because you and millions of your countrymen chose not to be political.
Lesson to be learned for all of us I think. Don't take what we have for granted.
THIS IS HAPPENING BECAUSE OF WESTERN COLONIALISM
ENOUGH OF 1000+ YEARS OF WESTERN COLONIAL GLOBAL ATROCITIES. LIES. EXPLOITATIONS. SCANDALS. CENTURIES OF RACISM. CENTURIES OF HATEFUL PROPAGANDA. HYPOCRISY. ENOUGH OF GLENCORE BLACKROCK.
ENOUGH OF WESTERN COLONIAL CORRUPT EXPLOTIVE ENERGY FIRMS.
WAR CRIMES. CORRUPTION. MERCENARY AND FAR RIGHT TERROIST ORGANISATIONS.
ENOUGH IS ENOUGH!
"ITS THEIR GOVERNMENT. ITS THE GOVERNMENT OF THE RICH. ITS THE GOVERNMENT OF WALLSTREET OF THE OIL GIANTS OF THE DEFENCE CONTRACTORS.
NOT ONE MORE BOMB DROPPED NOT ONE MORE BULLET FIRED NOT ONE MORE SOLDIER COMING HOME IN A WHEELCHAIR NOT ONE MORE FAMILY SLAUGHTERED.
NOT ONE MORE DAY OF US IMPERIALISM". - MIKE PRYSNER
In EVERY invaded/conflict/war torn location there are always 1000+ years of Western Colonial Exploitive Corrupt Energy Companies drilling and mining that nation by the back door. GLENCORE. BLACKROCK
Those who are always 'not political persons' is the set up for the pro propaganda pro Kremlin position that follows.
@@angelic8632002 "fight for your right" i believe your looking for.
Funny how only thing russians seem to remember from WW2 is fighting against germans. Conveniently forgetting what they did in Poland, Baltic countries and Finland.
They live in a authoritarian and totalitarian state. They remember alternative version of history because that’s result of 80 years of propaganda. They live in the dark.
@@bezceljudzelzceljsh5799 I don't know what you mean exactly. Nazis look down on the finnish race. Not so much as slavic people, but finns we're considered less than other Nordic people by nazis.
That's because history revisionism is a thing in Ruzzia. They glorify themselves and simply remove bad and inconvenient truths from their history books. Their children never read or learn about it and are instead taught fiction.
It's like with WW2, when the reason the Soviets ultimately managed to beat back the Germans were largely thanks to the Americans supplying the Soviets with weapons, but that is a fact that is since long deleted from their history books.
and more recently..Bucha.
@@bezceljudzelzceljsh5799probably some russian bots wish we believe that.
🇺🇦🇺🇦🇺🇦✌️✌️✌️
“Someone let this happen.”
Hmmmmmmm who could’ve possibly sparked this whole kerfuffle
Its a long and convoluted story but both sides have contributed vastly
@@Ryan_the_dawg nope. Russia invaded in 2014 and then again in 2022 completely unprovoked. And before you say “NATO expansionism”, Ukraine wasn’t going to join NATO anytime soon.
Putin invaded because Ukraine continued moving towards EU (not NATO) membership, which was popular with Ukrainians. With his grasp of Ukraine slipping away, Putin invaded Crimea and the Donbas.
Eight years later, Putin invaded with the goal of annexing all of Ukraine. To everyone’s surprise, Ukraine fended off Russia’s attack.
Now, both sides have dug in, and Putin is stuck trying to win a fruitless war against a nation who know what they are fighting for and will never back down. Russia’s only hope is for “The West” to stop supporting Ukraine. That’s why they use disinformation bots to muddy the waters and weaken support for Ukraine. But we will win. 🇺🇸🇺🇦
@@Ryan_the_dawg ha ha. You are smart as stone
@@Ryan_the_dawg well the one levelling whole cities in Ukraine is 90% responsible. Ukrainians are guilty for the desire to not exist at the pleasure of imperialist ruzzia
You explain what you think started it. I'd love to hear what you come up with.
Never a moment's thought for the suffering they have cause to innocent Ukrainians. No insight, no remorse.
They don't know
I think most of them genuinely don't know what's going on.
@@billthepay5990 they definitely know, just being resistant to truth. When you lie to yourself for a very long time, your start believing in your own lies
@@billthepay5990 In Kursk? They do.
The same goes to Europeans and americans too. And they invaded more countries that Russia will ever have.
If someone asked Germans in late 1944, they would get the same answers... "we are lucky to have our Fuhrer, we believe in our soldiers, we want peace", same story.
The sad part is that the people of the video will probably think like that for the rest of their life, it's the next generation that will be terrified by the ideas of their parents
@@aquilesca5tr0 The entire generation of young Russians was born and raised under the reign of Fuhrer Putin, so they can't imagine life w/o him.
You is an stupido
I mean if the fuhrer can get Unemployment reduced by 60% in 6 months, starting infra projects across the country, turning germany into technological powerhouse with a strong economic boom along with #1 army in the world then yeah people are right.
It just proves that most people are not bad but sometimes they get confused and misled. And to be honest I heard the same answers before from many people when the was had started. Events in Kursk changed people minds a little bit (some realized that the war isn't there but it is here... among us) but there wasn't much to change. Most of russians don't want this war and even those who support it believe that it happens for the greater good (for the future peace).
If you want peace , then get the hell out of Ukraine .
aight jackfishcampbell boss them lady gonna get out of ukraine now since you said it🤣
@fennecrvrs8370 probably you're from a thirld world country or a westerner with a double digit IQ. Either way it's not good for you😂
Nah
I mean are russian citizens currently rushing into Ukraine? No. It is soldiers ordered by putin.
tell that to USA
"I'm not a political person, why is this happening to us"
That's why, lady.
So you expect her to sacrifice herself for your motives?
Educate yourself. "In March 2023, criminal case was opened against Moscow resident Yury Kokhovets, a participant in the RFE/RL's street poll. He faced up to 10 years in prison under Russia's 2022 war censorship laws".
@@somestuff7876 that's correct, but doing the right thing has consequences as well.
@@frishter No but you expect her to teach her kids and grand kids good values and understanding of the world -you know, the things that would normally come with a long life lived. But since they're all so hellbent on being apolitical, they let their kids get brainwashed by media and feed the war.
Also yes she could do a lot of things to go against Putin that doesn't involve "self sacrifice". Something as simple as banding together as communities, then those communities grouping and forming resistance, then that resistance leading to political change, etc. Like, many countries have been able to accomplish what Russians refuse to even try. Cowardice is the core of their society.
Have you ever thought about the fact that you will never be shown the truth, because there is censorship in these media? They will never show a person who can clearly answer why Russia is fighting with Ukraine. Who can say that Russians have many relatives and parts of their families in Ukraine, because it was a united country for centuries. And in 2014, pro-American forces seized power in Ukraine, who began bombing cities where there are relatives of these people. And 8 years later, Russia dared to force Kyiv to stop this war, which the Ukrainians themselves and especially people in Europe hypocritically tried not to notice. Why doesn't the BBC show people who answer like that, but only shows old grandmothers who think only about their garden and grandchildren?
Started the war and now whining 🤦♂️
There are videos from Kursk border region of people cheering russian military columns going into Ukraine back in 2022. They wanted it. They got it
they kind of have no option. Many interviewed here are genuine, but others are just afraid. Russian surveillance has tightened in light of the invasion of Ukraine in 2022. And it has been seriously tightening since the 2018 elections
@@shubhnamdeo2865did you even read what I said? No one was forcing them to cheer military columns. This is just one example. People in THIS particular segment could have just kept walking without answering questions to BBC... you know, the "enemy". Instead they spoke their minds. Don't tell me they were forced to.
@@sergeybebenin alright whatever.
The Russian psyche believes that they are owed a Russian empire and that these other countries should be part of their sphere of influence. The Russians can't wrap their heads around the fact that the Russians are hated by everyone in Eastern Europe. They want the old Soviet Union and the Eastern Bloc back. The Russians and the Chinese are now the only countries behaving like imperialists.
You're right. I saw this too.
The bullies don’t like it when their victim fights back.
One more Russo-phobic westerner. Your one-sidedness prevents you from realizing that the Kiev regime had been massacring Russian-speaking Ukrainians for a decade, who is victim of whom? Statuses of victimhood only for those the West endorses?
Victims donbass 2014
@@pablitoemilio614 You mean when Russia attacked and invaded Donbass in 2014, after forcefully invading Crimea? Yeah we remember those crimes too. Thanks for listing even more crimes of the Kremlin.
@@pablitoemilio614 Russia started the mess in Donbas, 'pablito'.
nah, I see that you have learned the lies from your Western media. I invite you to consult the letter from the little girl of Donbass Faina Savenkova youtube letter
This reminds me of videos from North Korea where people can only ever repeat: "i am convinced we are doing better than them, we are winning" when they are standing in a building with no access to electricity.
They are doing better than Ukraine and are winning🤔
@@saviola5194they are not winning. They entered another country and have lost over 100,000 young soldiers. Ukraine is in Russia occupying their land. How is that winning. NATO will never let Russia end this with a victory. No land will be exchanged for either side and a new Russian leader will prevail.
Only difference is that the Russians are actually doing better .Ukraine is a shithole 😂
@@dukerblanchfield2489 how many soldiers have Ukraine lost to lower the conscription age to 25?
Doesn’t Russia occupy a quarter of Ukraine ?
Are you living in a dream world?
Don’t worry it’s ok to be wrong
@@saviola5194 this is the same as the afghan-soviet war situation
neither side can win, the only question is how much will they both lose
So it's OK to invade neighbors, but it is not OK for those neighbors retaliate? The hypocrites.
Russia never installed missiles in Canada and Mexico , surrounding USA.
@@rubenacevedo2484 ummm does Cuba sounds like anything to you at all?
UPAine is a nazi country. See red-black flags? See totenkopf and wolfsangel? See white cross? All those things you will find when nazis attacked Poland September 1939.
I am from Poland. i speak with many people running away from that nazi state of UPAine. They are not running away from Russians. They are running away from UPAinian nazis as soon as they can.
If you want to call someone hypocryte... dont be one. Nazi hero... the T-shirt man, never shaved actor, in January 2022 wanted to enter NATO and place nuclear weapons in UPAine. From the very beiginning it was all about neutrality of Ukraine, which was dead in 2012 and UPAine have started.
People know that. dont be hypocryte or nazi scum.
@@waregraph Cuba is a response to the deployment of US missiles in Turkey.
Peace enforcement of war criminals of Ukraine. Ukraine used the army against its people , this is a war crime. Criminals have no right to self-defense.From 2014 to February 24, 2022, there was a civil war in Ukraine.To force peace, on February 21, 2022, the recognition of the independence of the DPR and LPR was announced, and a treaty on friendship, cooperation and Mutual assistance was signed.After continuing the shelling of the LPR and DPR preparing for the offensive of the Nazi criminal troops of Ukraine ,it was decided to launch a preemptive, preemptive strike on the criminal Armed Forces of Ukraine. A military operation was carried out, as a result of which Zelensky was ready to sign a peace treaty,but then the Anglo-Saxons intervened and disrupted the peace talks.You're a hypocrite, but you're not ashamed, are you?
I am from a country that was a Soviet Union satellite and we were hearing about peace and peace again from Moscow during the Cold War all the time when I was a child. In the end, who started this war were the Russians and their imperialistic president and also dictator.
👏👏👏
I know the feeling. We are saying for 30 years to our friends in the West: "stop trusting Russia! Stop your business with Russia! You will regret it! Stop being dependent on Russia!"
Their answer?
"You are living in the past. Russia is changed, they are on a democratic and peaceful path!"
@@leonardgrant6876
Are you quite positive about that?
Reminds me of children in preschool.
Billy kicks Tommy under the table, Tommy hits Billy. Everyone but Billy and Tommy believe that Tommy is the bully. Billy is the one who loudly blames Tommy.
And there is also Sammy who had promised Billy a chocolate bar and protection for kicking Tommy.
Sammy wanted the seat near a window that was Tommy's.
The sad fact is that there is no chocolate bar, just bruises for both Billy and Tommy.
And Sammy is going to be the teacher's pet because he shouted that fighting is bad.
@ekaterinalokshina2043 good point. Could have happened in 2022, 2014, 1992, 1980, 1968, 1956, 1939...
@@ekaterinalokshina2043 -- Are you saying Ukraine invaded Russia in 2022?
“We’re so lucky to have Putin.”
“What do you like about him?”
Long pause, followed by a pre-canned response she probably got from state owned media. Propaganda is a helluva drug.
You've defeated a normie woman in a political argument. Good job.
she is one sick woman.
@@hulking_presence What are you on about? You just made zero sense.
It really feels like she spoke that by rote.
From the look on her face, I think that was more, "Why did you put me on the spot like that? Now I have to give an answer that won't get me in trouble."
Lady “why is this happening with us?”
Why tf do you think?
They really don’t know what’s going on outside their borders. In this day and age, it is still possible to drip feed propaganda as it was done in olden times. This is the Great America Donald Trump would like for USA…
I'm sure they all are the ones who made the call for invasion, of course cuz we all know how much the russian government respects the people's views.
Because of americans of course
@@Nat_creates_IT Dumb. Russia started a war, they invaded a country and started MURDERING men, women, and children. f Russian troll, you want peace? Then leave Ukraine.
She has been consistently lied to by the talking heads of RT and is genuinely clueless.
"Foreign soldiers on Russian territory and that's a shock."
And it wasn't a shock to Ukrainians when THEY had "Foreign soldiers on UKRAINIAN LAND"?
Maybe if Russia hadn't invaded Ukraine, they wouldn't have Ukraine returning the favor!
Dohledejte si proč byla napadena Ukrajina !!!
Najděte souvislosti a potom suďte !
It was not a shock. The population of the territory of the so-called Ukraine had been pumped up with hatred towards Russians and Russia as a whole for decades. At the end of 2013, Victoria Nulad reported that 5 billion dollars had been successfully spent on this. Zlensky refused to implement the completed peace treaty regulating the end of the civil war in the east and the reintegration of the two new republics that had broken away during the coup d'etat in 2014 in Kyiv, mainly consisting of ethnic Russians, back into Ukraine. Then Russia was forced to recognize their independence. At that moment, I saw a video from some location of the Ukrainian Armed Forces and remembered this video well, in which one of the soldiers shouted "kill everyone, take everything!", finally what they were preparing for will happen: "Muscovites on knives" (c). After which Russia signed agreements with the republics on cooperation and mutual assistance (including military assistance) and what the "honest and independent" media call "an unprovoked full-scale war" began, despite the fact that Kyiv has still not been wiped off the face of the earth like Gaza.
I read the comments and am surprised at how many people blame Russia and compare Russia to Nazi Germany, completely ignoring the fact that Russia and Ukraine were one country for hundreds of years, and many Russians have relatives there. Just a few years ago, it was their common home. And in 2014, pro-American forces seized power in Ukraine and Washington ordered Kyiv to bomb cities where Russians lived. The genocide of the Russian population lasted 8 years, after which Russia began a military operation in 2022. And for some reason you ignore the fact that the new government of Ukraine, which seized power in 2014 as a result of a bloody coup, began to tear down monuments to those people who fought against Hitler, began to rehabilitate fascism and revive it, to name streets and stadiums after fascists. Doesn't anything bother you about this?
@arturincloud9892 because USSR TOOK all those countries by force! They all fought for independence and your KGB dicktater Putin wants the "glory" of the USSR back and all the countries that gained independence. If there are Russians in Ukraine that don't consider themselves Ukrainians, then they should move to the "motherland" Russia... it's the largest country in the world and has PLENTY of room for them!
@arturincloud9892 and Russia was allies with Nazis until they didn't agree on certain things and broke it off... so don't act like they were anti Nazi!
‘We only want peace.’
‘We are surely going to win.’
🙄 So duplicitous
Another version of 'you remove the man, you remove the problem'.
Duplicitous, and what about the West's leaders, are they the paramount of sincerity and non-cynicism?
They are so complicit.
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq Did the West invade Ukraine? Did the West invade Russia?
Stick to the issue of the video.
Foreign fighters on Russian soil and how the population is responding to those attacks.
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq🤡
Really proud for people who signed Molotov-Ribbentrop act… The only reason Russia fought the real Nazis is because they were betrayed by them. The west did not forget what you did to Poland.
Baltic states too 😔
What about Czechia? Did you forget about it?
@@inet222u Did what ? developed you , built nuclear plant, roads, hospitals and cities ?. You were governed by dictators and there were no democracy there
Following the Anschluss of Austria in March 1938 and the Munich Agreement in September of that same year, Adolf Hitler annexed the Sudetenland from Czechoslovakia. The loss of the Sudetenland was detrimental to the defense of Czechoslovakia, as the extensive Czechoslovak border fortifications were also located in the same area. As a consequence, the incorporation of the Sudetenland into Germany that began on 1 October 1938 left the rest of Czechoslovakia weak. Moreover, a small northeastern part of the borderland region known as Trans-Olza was occupied and annexed to Poland, ostensibly to "protect" the local ethnic Polish community and as a result of previous territorial claims. Furthermore, by the First Vienna Award, Hungary received the southern territories of Slovakia and Carpathian Ruthenia, which were largely inhabited by Hungarians.
So, the Germany and Poland started the 2nd world war.
Any time idiots say freedom of the press doesn't exist in America, they should watch this. Just cause people choose to watch biased sources, doesn't mean our press isn't free. These people genuinely sound like they have no idea why they're being invaded
The "free" press that said biden was competent, until it said he wasn't? There is no free press in the the West either. You are just as brainwashed as any russian.
True. Even though here in the US 90% of the mainstream media outlets are owned by leftist corporations and couldn't tell the truth if their life depended on it, we do still have access to many independent media sources to be able to hear something other than the woke drivel that most of the mainstream media parrots. Thank God for that!!
Russia has no press at all. Every single “journalist” in Russia is working as a propagandist for Russian imperialism. Any deviation from the kremlin message is punishable by hard prison time or worse.
Western countries don’t generally lock up journalists for reporting or independent editorial commentary.
It’s silliness on stilts to both sides this and claim that media in the west is the “same” as in Russia or any other totalitarian dictatorship.
They know why, they just can’t say publicly. The “someone is in charge” line proves it. They know better than anyone that ‘political’ people in Russia accidentally fall out of windows when they say the wrong thing.
Pathetic idiot!
What exactly is the point of street interviews where identities aren't protected at all in a country where criticizing the government can get you arrested?
What led them to this point? And who has to change the situation - Ukraininan soldiers sacrificing their lives, or these `not political persons` who support war? Have you noticed the fisherman saying `I would go to war but I`m too old`?
In April 2023, a very interesting interview took place, which was given by the British satirical writer with Russian roots, and part-time popular stand-up comedian Konstantin Kisin, to the former Deputy Prime Minister of Australia John Anderson. During the conversation, Kisin compared the numbers of arrests for publications on social networks over the past year in Russia and in the West. The announced figures, to put it mildly, shocked, and not the Russians, but the Europeans. As it turned out, in Russia there were 400 such arrests, and in Britain "a little" more - 3,300. And these are not unfounded statements by Konstantin Kisin, but official data published in the renowned publication "The Times". The population of Russia is about 150 million, and in Britain 67 million people. That is, by simple arithmetic calculations, we find that in "free and democratic" Britain the number of arrests per capita is 20 times greater than in "totalitarian" Russia. P.S.: Freedom for political prisoner Pavel Durov !
У нас свободы больше чем у вас! Ассанж...😅😅😅😅😅
Yeah, like the UK.
@@arturincloud9892you sound so brainwashed
That`s normal attitude of bullies. They attack, is alright, but when they are contra- attacked , the others are criminals and terrorists.
speaking of bullies do you ever look into the mirror lol
@@briant5685 So ,you are a bully. I understand ! A suggestion : try a treatment, before you are punished...
@@briant5685 that’s a very week argument! Haven’t you got anything better to do?
Like IDF
@@JamesMurphy-ry2mx have you got anything Better to do or just being like the rest of us boring people and comment on TH-cam lol we’re all the same here. It’s just the matter of who’s learn more about the war. I bet you $1M you don’t even know why Russia invaded Ukraine in the first place.. if you say Putin than “propaganda is a helluva drug” we’re literally watching two siblings fight each other and we’re being forced to pick sides.. as far as I’m concerned half the world population didn’t even know what Ukraine is, what, where. In the end Afghans suffered way more than Ukrainians have for decades, but because WE DID IT, we expect others to forget. If you watch the invasion of Iraq compared to Ukraine invasion.. it’s like comparing Saving private Ryan to Conkas bad fur day.
Russia brought this upon them selves and are now paying the price.
what price? Ukraine seize a tiny percent of Russian land and soon to be evicted!
Half a million amd counting. All they died for was further embarrassment. At least ukraine has a noble cause of defending their home @johnpaul252003
What did the lady do to deserve that
@@johnpaul252003we shall see
Putin.
They want peace yet their leader invaded an independent, free nation. Cognitive dissonance.
Two thoughts don't contradict each other if they don't exist in the mind at the same instance.
Yes the cognitive dissonance eats you I can see that. 😂😂😂
Actually, people wanting one thing and supporting people who does just the opposite is not just a russian thing. If people in democratic countries voted according to their beliefs instead of blindly trusting this or that political party, things would be very different.
A "free country" turned into a PUPPET of NATO, led by nazi militias, comparable to Argentina led by Videla, after the military coup by C.I. A.
The US government and NATO and the CIA started this war back in 2014 long before Putin had to invade you might want to go look up some real history about this war Putin gave them every chance for peace the west kept telling Ukraine not to take it you think Putin just willy nilly and up and invaded for no reason.
Happy Independencr Day, Ukraine. 🇺🇦 🇺🇦 🇺🇦 Slava Ukraine!
Fašistický Banderovský pozdrav ...?
Ukrajina je prolezlá fašisty !
Co jste dokázali?
Okrádat celou Evropu , lidé s tím nesouhlasí vy bando špinavců!
There is no independence in Ukraine since 2014 when USA seized the power in this country and forced Kivev to bomb Ukrainian cities.
"You are not interested in war... but the war is interested in you"
"Why is this happening to us?" They ask, as they move into year 3 of their invasion of ukraine. Its so absurd.
I can't think of another group of people that has less self awareness than Russians.
What an awful country filled with awful people. Fuck these people, they'll get a hole of their own.
that not what she said, what she said was "why is this war happening", she never said " to us"...ask any russian speaking person
no we wont because youre brainwashed. @katyasilentium
@@katyasilentium I speak Russian and the direct translation to English is literally "Why does this happen to us?" so I don't know what you're smoking, she didn't even say the word "war". Because of it it's actually not even clear of she meant the Kursk invasion or the war in general, although the sentence after implies it's the recent events in Kursk.
Do they really not know that they invaded Ukraine…? Or they know but all pretend like they did not…? It’s amazing….
IYOU don't know what is going on there! The war started in 2014. The signed Minsk peace agreement has not been implemented by Kiew. Putin's army started to fight the Ukrainian Army that had been killing people for 8 years only after all other possibilities to finish the crisis were exhausted. In January 2022 Zelenski announced that he wants nucs back and that Crimea is Ukrainian territory. And the leaders of NATO countries applauded him.
Don't allow BBC to fool you!
They occupied the areas where Russians lived and who had been killed by Ukrainians since 2014.
I think they know, but don't care much. It is very hard to think about one's own nation as being the most guilty, not many people can do that - no matter the country.
Russian people think ukraine is "theirs" because of what was written in their 8th grade history textbooks. Kievan Rus, yadda yadda.
maybe they do now that their own people were slaughtered in Donetsk/Luhansk.
No matter your politics , this is whats called an echo chamber
Yes, too bad they didn't let the lady who was saying what she liked about Putin finish her thought. Why aren't we allowed to hear what they think? It would help the cause of peace for everyone to understand each other better. Our echo chamber is very loud .
Have you ever thought about the fact that you will never be shown the truth, because there is censorship in these media? They will never show a person who can clearly answer why Russia is fighting with Ukraine. Who can say that Russians have many relatives and parts of their families in Ukraine, because it was a united country for centuries. And in 2014, pro-American forces seized power in Ukraine, who began bombing cities where there are relatives of these people. And 8 years later, Russia dared to force Kyiv to stop this war, which the Ukrainians themselves and especially people in Europe hypocritically tried not to notice. Why doesn't the BBC show people who answer like that, but only shows old grandmothers who think only about their garden and grandchildren?
@@krisniznik3953 She said putin was "rational." Nobody needs to hear more from a clueless sheep.
Oh the irony.
“I’m not a political person” well you’re going to have to decide now that it’s affecting you. Thousands of Ukrainians have been dying for the past couple of years. Disgusting.
I imagine, a lot of Russian men too. Like it or not, Russia and Ukraine are going to be socially disrupted over the next 2 decades.
She says that so she does not have to fear repressions after the video is published. I know personally Russians who did phrase their real opinion about the war in Ukraine and I have not heard from them in two years now. 😞
@@AlexanderBlumenauMoscovits are often apolitical because if you are political you need to go the whole way in. It was common in Ukraine before too. And almost everything was the war's fault.
Putin is very bad person and uses the same tactics as the Nazis used on his own people what are by nature religious and hard working people. Often it's the leaders who start wars.
My Opa was born in Germany in 1920, though he died when I was very young in 2002. When I'd ask family members what it was like for him to live through the 1930s and 1940s, I had always heard it described that he didn't support the regime, that he was an apolitical person, and I can only assume because he described himself as such. He was obviously too young to affect the rise of H, but now I think the assertion that he was apolitical actually is telling about how an authoritarian regime like in 1930s-40s Germany or modern Russia makes its citizens think. Either they are diehard supporters of the regime and party, or they say to themselves that there's nothing they can do, that they shouldn't think about politics, that politics is the domain of the party and their great leader.
Gorbachev , was not a terrible leader . He had a ❤️ heart
He brought Pizza Hut to Russia
russia is still an empire with a heck of a lot of people who have an empire building/subjugating mindset. Gorbachev is widely viewed as a very weak leader who is blamed for the collapse of the USSR - and that is one of their greatest travesties (in their minds!). In fact some even go so far as to believe that he must have been an American asset - not a true russian.
Gorbachev's loving heart didn't extend to his people, many of whom died due to poverty, crime, drug addiction and suicide back in the 90s. I've witnessed all these and don't want that time to come back.
@@mazitovaliliya1408 Okay to wich russian leader does that not account? That's how russia got ruled since forever.
@@mazitovaliliya1408 Gorbachev inherited collapsing empire, his reforms came too late, but also broke the control the empire had on people and subjugated nations. You're also mixing up pre and post Soviet Russia, Gorbachev time on helm ended in 1991. I think he was the only leader of Russia/Russian empire who genuinely had the people in his mind, not the power of state or themselves.
Also also, all of post-USSR states were in chaos in 90s. Those who had the least "strong men" in lead, did best to recover from it. Three Baltic states quickly overtook Russia, despite having no natural resources to sell, no geopolitical power, no inherited Soviet reserves in gold and foreign currencies. P.S. I'm talking of period before EU, and thus also before any EU development funds
00:57. Look at this poor woman. She sells vegetables while Putin wastes billions of dollars on his war.
So do our countries
@@AlbertYork-db8ihPutin acts like it’s not his issue though.
@@DzNuttz_710 is it?
@@AlbertYork-db8ih unlike Russians, we're allowed to critisize our leaders and fire them, if they don't do their job properly. As for Putin, Russians "like" him, but don't even know what they like him for.
She didn't cared about war when roosia invaded Ukraine, but when Ukraine striked back now she's interested
Do people know these facts; Ukrain/Kiev is older than Russia/Moscow, Russia of course is largest country in Europe with Ukraine 2nd , of course Ukrainians are not power hungry or don't invade anybody except in very extreme situations, they are a naturally peaceful people, the sooner peace happens in this region the better, ❤cheers 🍻 from Australia 😊
Did you know the fact that Kiev is motherland of Russia? And Kiev and Ukraine and the rest of Russia was union country for the centuries until 1991?
I read the comments and am surprised at how many people blame Russia and compare Russia to Nazi Germany, completely ignoring the fact that Russia and Ukraine were one country for hundreds of years, and many Russians have relatives there. Just a few years ago, it was their common home. And in 2014, pro-American forces seized power in Ukraine and Washington ordered Kyiv to bomb cities where Russians lived. The genocide of the Russian population lasted 8 years, after which Russia began a military operation in 2022. And for some reason you ignore the fact that the new government of Ukraine, which seized power in 2014 as a result of a bloody coup, began to tear down monuments to those people who fought against Hitler, began to rehabilitate fascism and revive it, to name streets and stadiums after fascists. Doesn't anything bother you about this?
@@arturincloud9892 kremlin bot, Kiev is older than moscow, the kievan rus is a unique political and cultural identity, and the rus people are a wide spawn of slavic peoples. The russian empire invented the russian identity as one that envelops all slavs for the purposes of expansionism. Im not typing to answer your comment because youre clearly a kgbot, its just for anyone reading the responses to show some perspective. Stop spreading false info to justify the slaying of innocent lives for the benefit of gazprom oligarchs
"Naturally peaceful people" if we conveniently forget the fact that they massacred tens of thousands of Poles during WW2
@@paulschofield2630
Chronicles first mentioned Ukraine in the 12th century. The world was used to describe the border territories of Volyn, Galich, and Pereyaslavl princedoms of Russia.
Only their border territories, not the princedoms themselves.
Kiev used to be the capital of Rus or Russia after Oleg united large territories and basically created a state of Russia and moved it's capital from Novgorod to Kiev in the 9th century. Thus the Rurikids dynasty of Russia started.
Oleg was the regent for Rurik's son Igor. Most probably he was a Rurik's kinsman.
They were vikings apparently invited to Novgorod to rule (Novgorod was a democracy that used to invite princes as war leaders).
Kiev indeed is way older than Moscow.
Due to a complicated system of inheritance among Rurikids (so called ladder system) different lines of Rurikids for a long time moved from princedom to princedom. So within a few years a city (or the princedom around it) could see several different princes. It was a bit of a mess. Rurikids fought each other, had unions, etc, but all of them were relatives.
However in a while the country kind of had three regions with different traditions.
Novgorod was a typical democracy that could sent princes away and invite them back. Vladimir and Suzdal had a strong united power of princes. Galich and Volyn had weak princes and strong aristocracy that was fighting among themselves.
So pretty quickly the Great Duchy of Lithuania captured Gaich and Volyn's territories. Later there were lots of fights for those lands.
Moscow line of Rurikids got to prominence due to their long and persistent resistance against the Mongols.
It took them many generations to collect power, but eventually they managed to defeat the Mongols and get independence.
Do you ever read books? Ukrain didn't exist before. It appeared as a country after Soviet Union))) Kiyv Rus' existed but not Ukraine.. omg people are so silly...
Russians really has a stereotypical mind. It's always the same few reactions in every street interview:
"What have we done to deserve this? Russia has never attacked anyone" "I don't care what happens as long as the enemy don't come here" "Our leader is smarter and wiser than us and we will support him to the end, no matter what he does" "It's awful, I would go to fight myself, but I'm too old" "It is inevitable that we win" and "We want peace, by annihilating the enemy" Not to mention that they think they fight NATO who are after their sweet, sweet resources, and that the outside world is ammoral and hostile.
Ditto!
Propaganda is one of the most evil forces on this planet
That's what happens when you get lied for 20 years straight on TV getting brainwashed all these years makes you believe they're right that Pootin is a hero who will save them, crazy.
This is what happens when critical thinking is systematically wiped out of the citizenry. I’d argue that the average Russian has a “serf” and middle-ages type of mentality where they bow to “the state”. Russian society is not evolving but actually going back in time and “de-evolving”. It’s sad as Russia had a chance at becoming something great, but the odds of that happening now are slim to none.
I couldn't express it better. We say that Russia is a state of mind and here is the proof!
I hear the people of Russia are also asking to be liberated from Russia.
я вижу ты давно освобождён от мозгов
Heard the same about USA
Yes, that should have been done in 1991.
Kursk independence referendum is coming😂
@@Whataboutism-o8j
кто проводить будет ? 🐽🐽🐖🐷🐷🐖🐖🤣🤣🤣😂
"We want peace" -- gee, if your soldiers would just all go home maybe there would be peace..
Imagine being grateful that your president is dictator 🤦♂️
😊
Dictators are the only ones that get things done. When my family was in Italy in the 20’s we were thankful as can be for our dictator.
Have you read Terry Pratchett?
Путин не диктатор
@@22--_.-_.-._-279 Oh yeah sure and Navalny is not dead
no hope for these people if they think Putin is rational
They are stupid.
Americans voted for Trump, then Biden, and probably Trump again so we shouldn’t speak on world leaders
@@ainWorldCoGodlyin America there is at least a whole democratic government so the president itself isn't too important, in Russia it's one man with a government full of people whose only wish is to get his favor to be promoted
@ainWorldCoGodly It ain't all about America, you're < 5% of the world's population, and they are far better models of democracy to look at.
But yeah, at least it's a democracy of sorts, even if it's an in-built 2 party state democracy.
@@ainWorldCoGodlyIn USA they have power divided unlike Russia that is modern authocratic dictatorship.
It's sad that they call their invader army "defenders" 😢
You don't know what is going on there! This war started in 2014. The signed Minsk peace agreement has not been implemented by Kiew. Putin's army started to fight the Ukrainian Army that had been killing people for 8 years only after all other possibilities to finish the crisis were exhausted. In January 2022 Zelenski announced that he wants nucs back and that Crimea is Ukrainian territory. And the leaders of NATO countries applauded him.
Don't allow BBC to fool you!
Russian Army defend DNR and LNR who officially asked for help!
Очень грустно,(((( отсутствие критического мышления), очень грустно... Источников информации достаточно для анализа текущей ситуации в МИРЕ. ЗАЦИКЛЕННОСТЬ НА ИНФОРМАЦИИ "не предоплаченные массмедиа" и дает такую оценку происходящего.
In every war there is an invader. What did the germans, the americans... Nobody cares anymore and admit they lead the world.
It is sad for you but for Russians they love and fully support their leader and their soldiers
@@honoresangwa1000
До скончанья времени, свысока,
золотым дождём, поливая рожь, -
постоянно следуя на закат,
за собою манит нас солнце-вождь!!!
Doubt anyone outside of Kursk cares
They didn't give a flying fuck about Georgia, Crimea, Chechnya, full invasion of Ukraine. Hard to believe they give a fuck about "some region next to Ukraine that I've never heard of".
You're right if course
yeah, it's truth, but the cuz of it is government, they're doing everything so that russians don't notice the war
From this video it is clear most of them don't care until invasion reach their territories.
Most of us Americans do not care about Ukraine, either. Only Biden and the Uniparty in Congress care.
I'll explain it to the foreign viewer. In Russia, you can go to prison for 6-20 years for criticizing the war, Putin, for an anti-war position. What answers do these journalists hope to hear when filming everything on camera?
When have you been in Russia last time?
@@claus-not-santa all my life I live in Russia. And I live here write now)
@@mozhest
Where in Russis?
@@claus-not-santa Ivan, you don't have to visit the Moon to know that it exists.
@@claus-not-santa зачем тебе?
You can't expect Russians to speak out against their dictator even if they wanted to, the personal risk of speaking out is astronomical.
then don't speak
it's a problem of Russia. All those problems they have because milions people afraid to speek agains dictator
@@mike_oeI see reading is not your strong suit. Do it again, then post useless comments
the ones who dont believe the propaganda did not respond to the news crew. these people believe what theyre saying.
As russian, fully agree
Interviewer: "What do you like about Putin?"
Interviewee: {visible panic attack at the thought of what happens if she gives the wrong answer}
I know she didn't "cheat" there but it looked funnily enough as if she was reading the note from her hand lmao
Чел, разве не видно что ее взгляд падает в разные направления? Если у вас так деот не значит что и в России так же😂
@@Felixxxx555In our countries, we’re actually allowed to criticise the government without being thrown out of a window or poisoned.
@@Neutralino пиздешь, у американских политиков забрали паспорта в аэропорту когда хотели вылететь в Россию. В Украине и Европе арестовывают тех кто поддерживает Россию или те кто осквернил политику их страны. Путин и Россия не о чем не жалеет, Путин подписал закон о том что иностранцы могут проживать временно без визы если в их стране предстрастено ЛГБТ или ненависть к России. Уже множество иностранцев переселено добровольно из недружественных стран России
how about comedian zelenskiy?
2:48 25 years of brainwashing 😂🇷🇺🤡
Sad..
It looked like she lied through her teeth to avoid a visit from the police
It's been a lot longer than that.
It'll be like in Germany after ww2, only the following generation will be freed from propaganda
and you've been brainwashed by your western media and govt your entire life. You've been brainwashed to think that your w4r mongering western nations are fighting a good fight when all they do is des troy every nation that doesn't agree with them and want to live in peace without their influence
That woman said why is this happening to us, FFS.
I read the comments and am surprised at how many people blame Russia and compare Russia to Nazi Germany, completely ignoring the fact that Russia and Ukraine were one country for hundreds of years, and many Russians have relatives there. Just a few years ago, it was their common home. And in 2014, pro-American forces seized power in Ukraine and Washington ordered Kyiv to bomb cities where Russians lived. The genocide of the Russian population lasted 8 years, after which Russia began a military operation in 2022. And for some reason you ignore the fact that the new government of Ukraine, which seized power in 2014 as a result of a bloody coup, began to tear down monuments to those people who fought against Hitler, began to rehabilitate fascism and revive it, to name streets and stadiums after fascists. Doesn't anything bother you about this?
What is happening? USA want allways something that is not for USA.
Man those Russians are so freaking depressing, their own Leader started all of this madness and they’re still kissing his shoes so yeah i don’t feel bad for them at all and i hope for the sake of all Ukrainians that have lost their lives to protect their homeland that those Orcs will lose this war so even their people will finally know how it feels like when you take an L.
Post in your native tongue Ukrainian next time, we can use Google Translate.
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq Screw off
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq Says the Russian troll.
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq Ukrainian would call you a ruzzian and wouldn't capitalize the word "leader" when talking about your shitlord. Definitely wouldn't capitalize the word "orcs".
Oni nemaju trunku zala i za svoje koji ginu?
Suddenly they want peace.
u confuse a democracy with a dictatorship, only few want war there
Мы с самого начала хотели мира и сечас хотим. Путин постояно говорит что давайте сейчас сядем за стол переговоров но вам не показывают этого . политики западные знают что мы хотим мира но они специально вас обманывают что мы здесь злые и хотим войны. У кого зотите спросите на улицах России хотят ли они войны, каждый ответит "нет, хотим мира". С самого начала сво все взрослые не вмешивались в политику но сейчас когда все возненавидели русских на западе из за западных пропаганды стала тяжело на душе когда ты не желал людям зла а они тебя ненавидят. Политики руководят страной а не народ, политики слушают народ и сейчас все очень хорошо в России кроме границы в курской области. Украина специально все свое последнее туда направила чтобы создать впечатление что они побеждают пока они несут огромные потери в ДНР. Давайте будем честны, СВО началось из-за массовой гибели людей в гражданской войне. Когда Украина захотела отказаться от всего русского хотя большая часть населения Украины говорила только на русском , училась и ценила русский и воспринимала Россия как свое родное так оно и было. Были переговоры но последние переговоры отменила Украина. И когда перед нападением на Курск Россия планировала с Украиной тайные переговоры о небольшом прекращение ударов по границам. Но после такого явно не будет переговоров пока Россия не ответит, а ога ещё не ответила но за день пол тысячи украинцев и сотни вашей техники наши солдаты уничтожают. Наши солдаты приезжают на выход домой и все рассказывают как там и что там, конечно страшно но еще с давних времен нас учили сражаться за свою родину до конца. Если сейчас Украина отправит заявку на переговоры Россия ее обязательно примет. Мы такие же люди как и вы у которых семьи причем многодетные и в нашей стране много ценностей и праздников. Русские всегда помогут пусть вы будете даже украинцем суравно помогут. Все что вам рассказывают о нас ложь. Такер Карлсон говорит правду, те кто в вашей стране говорит правду о России устраняют как Такера с телевидения, теперь он сам ведет видео блоги. Вы не тех слушаете. Нам не внушают о политике как вам и впрочем не врут. Пусть настанет мир на земле, все люди хотят жить счастливо для этого не нужно войн
They always did! go back two years and the Russian public were saying exactly the same thing, go ahead look those videos up. Clearly some of us have a better memory.
@@XavierAway что делали?
@@Felixxxx555ти диви в дурку інтернет провели 😂😂 ти пиши пише ще такого, нехай всі у світі бачать, які ви там всі намахані. "Гражданская вайна в деенер", ну так зараз гражданская война в курской области, а ми просто миротворці.
“If you're not interested in politics, you'll be governed by those who are.” Platon
Ah, the famous Greek philosopher Platon.....He was from Krypton where everything ends in n.
His name was not Plato. Platon is the correct greek terminology. Latin language countries call him Platon or Platão. @@misterbum1
Big words for a slave owner 😂
This nation is probably one of the most evil that I have ever seen.
Let me tell you about this place called USA...
@@cerebrophage7709 yeah, tell me about it. Tell me how they sent billions and billion of free aid, including 3 times to Soviets and Russia. NO OTHER nation helped the world more than United States. Simple facts. Get your facts straight or get lost.
@@cerebrophage7709 or UK
@@cerebrophage7709 And yet, the USA supports Ukraine against Russia. Funny thing, that.
Злых людей много. Их феномен в том, что они не только злые и бессильные, а ещё и подлые и агрессивные. Просто они похожи на нормальных людей, потому что используют человеческую одежду, украшения и используют современные технологии для коммуникации с остальным миром.
It is quite stupid to ask such question, if wrong answer is a few years in jail….
The wrong question will also get the reporter a few years in jail...
this
Agreed. That lady at 2:00 seems terrified when talking about Putin, she was really careful about her answers
Фантазеры!
This is not China dude, speaking out against the government will most likely not lead to anything at all unless you are openly and systematically opposing the status quo.
These people are completely oblivious. What comes around goes around.
They really don’t know what’s going on outside their borders. In this day and age, it is still possible to drip feed propaganda as it was done in olden times. This is the Great America Donald Trump would like for USA…
You’re talking like the old grandma bombed ukraine, wake up autist
like cuba, vietnam, right?
I would say it is applies to you too with media propaganda of yours 😂😂😂😂
@hannapapaioannou3928 unlike these buffoons (and probably you too) I don't believe what my government tells me. I research it from as many sources as possible and draw my own conclusions. These people are only allowed one source and they believe it.
im sure you had deluded people like this in nazi germany asking as the world fell apart around them "why is this happening to us"
You don't know what is going on there! This war started in 2014. The signed Minsk peace agreement has not been implemented by Kiew. Putin's army started to fight the Ukrainian Army that had been killing people for 8 years only after all other possibilities to finish the crisis were exhausted. In January 2022 Zelenski announced that he wants nucs back and that Crimea is Ukrainian territory. And the leaders of NATO countries applauded him.
Don't allow BBC to fool you!
Nazis is on the other side. And your UK government is collaborating with them.
Seems the average person doesn't watch mainstream media there, likely a rural town where they sell their labours on the street. How would they be deluded if that's the case? Similar to farmers here in the UK who don't know who the Prime Minister is because they don't have the time nor patience to give a shit about our politics.
💯
Did she just say putin is logical and rational??? 😂😂😂 while threatening nukes and invading the country next to it.
I read the comments and am surprised at how many people blame Russia and compare Russia to Nazi Germany, completely ignoring the fact that Russia and Ukraine were one country for hundreds of years, and many Russians have relatives there. Just a few years ago, it was their common home. And in 2014, pro-American forces seized power in Ukraine and Washington ordered Kyiv to bomb cities where Russians lived. The genocide of the Russian population lasted 8 years, after which Russia began a military operation in 2022. And for some reason you ignore the fact that the new government of Ukraine, which seized power in 2014 as a result of a bloody coup, began to tear down monuments to those people who fought against Hitler, began to rehabilitate fascism and revive it, to name streets and stadiums after fascists. Doesn't anything bother you about this?
@arturincloud9892 I do my own research! I know the truth russian bot!
@@arturincloud9892 Ukrainians want their own country. Whatever problems Ukraine has within itself, is for Ukraine to solve. Russia needs to get the fuck out of there.
@@KingFishdom
And why did he do that?
@@ekaterinalokshina2043 for fake reasons
Let them feel what people in Ukraine have been through.
Yes!
There more war crimes there merrier? You know like shelling, occupation, civilian deaths etc?
I will never understand why it so hard to condemn wrong doing regardless of who is committing it. What's going on inside your brain?
Who am I kidding, you're probably religious to boot.
Yes definetely, what their people were feeling when their government started killing them in 2014?
@@frankt5987nazi
Do these people know that they INVADED Ukraine two years ago without provocation?
10 years ago - 2014, Crimea
They know it was WITH provocation.
@@TheBobVova It was Putin that started it in 2014. Classic KGB method. Supply insurgents with weapon and training. Escelate the situation. Wait. Send in the troops to "stabilizise the situation".
"without provocation".... 😆😆😂😂🤣🤣🤣.
Classic Mickey-Mouse joke.
That right there tells really ALL.
You're oblivious and know absolutely nothing on this subject.
Crazy insane to me there are still people who seem to be able to type comments online with an IQ of 55.
No, they think they were provoked into saving Russians from the oppresive Ukrainian regime.
we never heard that Gorbachev&Yelstin invaded neighbouring peace loving country. Let us not be brainwashed.
Peace-lovong country? Ukraine? They bombed their own cities with jets, like NO OTHER COUNTRY IN HISTORY! CLueless dicks u are all. Braindead scam.
Hitler admired the british because they invaded other countries for centuries
calling Ukraine a peace-loving country after it destroyed the Donbass is the height of hypocrisy.
Gorbachev and Yeltsin destroyed their country.
Gorbachev was the last USSR president before it collapsed so of course there still will be people who blame the man. That's why she said that THEY were unfortunate for having the Soviet Union collapse in 1991 (by pointing out Gorbachev for that). However, I don't know anything much about Yelstin yet, all I know is that he had something to do with economy changes
yeltsin commited genocide in chechnya. read about the first chechen war
Russia has become an awful country ....or might be it always was ...
Haha you are one of the bullies here... No the worst country is yours, who created those monsters that are hating people all over the world
"The most important thing is that the war doesnt come here." because I am a self-absorbed piece of garbage.
"it's not my problem as long as it doesn't effect me" behavior
@@smereka04Exactly!
She said “I wish there was no war”, everywhere, not just in her town. You've been misled by a mistranslation.
@@ivanraevsky Then she said, "that they don't come through here." ....but there was a cut in-between... I am undecided.
“The most important thing is that war doesn’t come here” Really!!!!? What about it being that countries respect the territorial integrity of another nation and do no harm, onto others!? Slava Ukraine 🇺🇦
хахахаххахаха пиздец ты дебил, ещё наверное в бред по типу "в россии кончилась еда" или "у русских нету стиральных машин" мда, тебе конкретно мозги промыли🇺🇦🤡
Sad, these people don't even know the reality in their own backyard.
We do. No need to doubt about it. We just can't believe that you can be so naive to trust this media outlet to portray us unbiasedly in their opinion. You all are just at whole new level of unmatched ignorance.
@@shelupaykoaccount already detected as chatgpt?
@@aquilesca5tr0 tell me straight or say nothing
@@shelupaykoWhy does Putin think he can just invade a sovereign nation? He’s killed so many innocent people because of his nonsense invasion.
Wow. Some of those poor Russian people support Putin the same way MAGA people support Trump. Trump/Putin basically the same.
Interviewing people like this in public and in the open won't get you a genuine answer. They're either saying what the state expects them to say (anything that won't get them in trouble) or they've actually been brainwashed to say good-to-neutral statements about the state. You'd have to read through the non-verbal cues to actually know what they want to say.
They're not gonna disclose any incriminating opinions especially to a stranger.
The citizens of Russia have a very bad experience with fascists and know that it is better to pretend that you know nothing. A lot can happen when the NATO propaganda cameras are turned off.
I lived 20 years among russians. In public they will say only naratives of government. Some fanatics of some political pupet party will tell narative of party. In general russians are quick to lie for anything. Only truth you will hear "is in kichen said near fridge". Who knows this meaning those agree with me.
If they say the wrong thing in an interview then Russians can be sent to prison for 10 years.
You should stop watching stupid Western propaganda. And only in America if You want to express Your point of view like in "Occupt Wall street" movement or Capital Hill resurection You'll be arrested and thrown in jail. Do You want to say it didn't happen? LOL
And already did. "In March 2023, criminal case was opened against Moscow resident Yury Kokhovets, a participant in the RFE/RL's street poll. He faced up to 10 years in prison under Russia's 2022 war censorship laws". Good thing, they only gave him 5 years...
Maybe Radio Liberty can ask BBC why the hell journalists keep showing people faces after that incident?
Crap….they are brain washed or brain dead.
Ни разу, у нас устроено вот как: есть известные люди, пару сотен посадили, предварительно предупредив процентов 80 из них, что их ожидает орест, а остальным обозначили границы допустимого.
A woman recently was sentenced to 12 years in a russian prison for making a financial contribution to Ukraine. Treason was the charge. There is no name given, only a picture, but I didn't delve into it as it's old news now.
IGNORANCE.....is not justification , a very poor country mentally .....
The average Russian reads literature. In my country the United States you need detective work to find people who read but cheap romance novels.
You don't know what is going on there but they do! This war started in 2014. The signed Minsk peace agreement has not been implemented by Kiew. Putin's army started to fight the Ukrainian Army that had been killing people for 8 years only after all other possibilities to finish the crisis were exhausted. In January 2022 Zelenski announced that he wants nucs back and that Crimea is Ukrainian territory. And the leaders of NATO countries applauded him.
Don't allow BBC to fool you!
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq literature? ahmm..... porn....
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq You are trying to educate someone who does not read, it is impossible
@@RicardoMartinez-oh9sq Fairytales about Ivan the Fool are not the literature that improves cognitive abilities.
Call them whatever you want, but you cant deny they back their leader.
Just like Germans backed their Fuhrer in 1944...
Does anyone has realised that the boundary between Russia and Ukraine has becomr shorter and better defendeble by natural obstacles
Why does the boundary need to be defended in the first place? Instead of being respected.
He means blowing up bridges
@@geothon Ideally it'd be respected, but that failed when Russia invaded.
@@monkemode8128it failed when USA didn't remove their troops from Europe and Japan when ww2 ended and when the cold war ended.
@@hulking_presencecringe
How have Russian reacted: Hypocritically, dishonestly, and ignorantly.
Ignorant of the war they find themselves in and why.
You don't know what is going on there but Russians do! This war started in 2014. The signed Minsk peace agreement has not been implemented by Kiew. Putin's army started to fight the Ukrainian Army that had been killing people for 8 years only after all other possibilities to finish the crisis were exhausted. In January 2022 Zelenski announced that he wants nucs back and that Crimea is Ukrainian territory. And the leaders of NATO countries applauded him.
Don't allow BBC to fool you!
Educate yourself. "In March 2023, criminal case was opened against Moscow resident Yury Kokhovets, a participant in the RFE/RL's street poll. He faced up to 10 years in prison under Russia's 2022 war censorship laws".
@@somestuff7876 - Most admirable. But is he representative of ALL Russians? I think not, or Russia would not have the "government" it currently does.
Я это лично не делал, так что это меня не касается, + ответственность должна нести армия, а не простые граждане. По твоей логике, если родители кого-то убили, значит их дети - убийцы
@@raymondg7565 you do realise that what you're saying is that antiwar movement in any country is bs, because if majority of citizens would actually be against war there would be no war or government that would want to start a war in the first place.
Moreover, if we have democratic and authoritarian regimes starting wars, which population is more to blame for failing to stop their countries?
idk, its quickly becoming catch-22 problem, don't your think.
I pray peace will return for everybody soon. War is so senseless. 😥
Can you do something else instead of praying? It clearly isn't working.
@@moravianlion3108what a fucked up way to respond to a nice comment
@@Glebatron It's honest feedback. Action counts, not thoughts and prayers. World might be significantly better place, if more people would understand and/or accept this.
And it would also result in less people being into centralised religions preying on people's insecurities.
@@moravianlion3108 lead by example then, objectively your comments here do nothing more than “thoughts and prayers”
@@moravianlion3108 God works in mysterious ways, mind you.
I hope these people are safe!
people? get real
these puppetkooks are just lame ant-WORLD N-BRED BOTS! period!
Saying the last great leader of your country before Putin was Alexander III says everything you need to know. His most enduring legacy, apart from there being peace during his reign, is one of Russification, closing of institutions in languages other than Russian, very significant hostility to Jews (it was during his reign that the first modern-era pogroms against Jews started in Europe), unlimited autocracy and a general fanatical opposition to the liberalising reforms of his predecessor. If she was a general monarchist, she could have said Nicholas II (the last emperor), but no, she chose Alexander, very deliberately I'm sure.
Alexander III also reversed all of the liberal reforms introduced before him. Most people in Russia know and love him because he said that Russia got no friends but its army and its navy
I think the reason she brought him up is because Putin really likes Alexander III
Nicolas 2 is a shame to the nation. Weak in mind and lost in reality. No wonder that he was the last one.
Alexander 3 was a true patriot which invested a lot into the country. Liberalism is not equal to development, it's just a bla-bla practice of nothing. The same as what's going on ibln Europe now - emptiness and stagnation though absolutely liberal.
Alexander was killed by the people sent from european and american nazi
Now they know how it feels to get invaded
I read the comments and am surprised at how many people blame Russia and compare Russia to Nazi Germany, completely ignoring the fact that Russia and Ukraine were one country for hundreds of years, and many Russians have relatives there. Just a few years ago, it was their common home. And in 2014, pro-American forces seized power in Ukraine and Washington ordered Kyiv to bomb cities where Russians lived. The genocide of the Russian population lasted 8 years, after which Russia began a military operation in 2022. And for some reason you ignore the fact that the new government of Ukraine, which seized power in 2014 as a result of a bloody coup, began to tear down monuments to those people who fought against Hitler, began to rehabilitate fascism and revive it, to name streets and stadiums after fascists. Doesn't anything bother you about this?
They felt it in 2014 in Dombas as well
Well, at the end of the day, a person named Bertrand Russell said "War does not determine who is right, only who is left"
War has determined the borders of Russia for centuries.
These people all seem to be stuck in the 80s
“I don’t involve myself in politics”
Your politics involve themselves in all wars in the World. You don't have the right to judge Russians. Your polititians are the most cruel in the World, bloody invaders! Killed so many Scottish people, native americans, destroyed so many countries, but you are judging Russians, really?
"It is just sheer misery; so silence is the best".
Alexander Pushkin.
"1984" light version.
Everything is 1984. Try reading another book.
And if you ask them they say the west is in state of “1984”, while obviously in the same shape if not worse.
@@hulking_presence It is, all over.
4:00 this sh*t is straight from a Borat movie
I just wish the war and all the other shit would end so no more people would die or get hurt
Thats humanity for you!
"I stand for everything good and against everything bad"
It's like wishing there was no suffering in the world. Get real!
It will stop, I promise. But there are still some ukrainians. 🙏
What kind of agreement does BBC have with Russia to work there?
It's a superpower it takes care of its people and the journalist is brave. Also the journalist is controlled for sure. Just you cannot see it. Have you seen those lame questions?
The journo is carefull not to incriminate himself just like the people he interviewing.
Questions are not statements.
March 2022 'The BBC is temporarily suspending its journalists' work in Russia, in response to a new law which threatens to jail anyone Russia deems to have spread "fake" news on the armed forces.' May 2024 'Following the invasion of Ukraine, BBC News Russian journalists and their families were moved out of Moscow to the Latvian capital of Riga. Now, 39 BBC staff remain in Riga, continuing the work of reporting independent and impartial news to audiences around the world in Russian. They also play an active part in countering disinformation about the war.'
I think if you toe the Russian government line (and are not Russian) you would be allowed to work in Russia. Extremely dangerous as you could be arrested at any time.
@@ThePomidor000 anything else would get him expelled. I love how you think the UK is a superpower though 🤣
So much for claims press is not free ;)
That Lady doesn’t wish to end up in Siberia…
Siberia is a good place. We like to spend vacations in Altai mountains or on Baikal
@@arturincloud9892 A vacation means you can leave…
Soft piano music. Create a mood of foreboding. Well done, the BBC drama department.
Well, more appropriate than Benny Hill music.
We shall see who wins
Son you've already lost on every metric, fool.
To be fair.. the US has a history of invading other countries, and we become completely outraged if somebody comes into our country
Exactly, but you are one of the few posting here who can side both sides of a problem. All others are Manichean thinkers.
Answer me then: will it legitimize this then Russia's actions?
Whataboutism! 😂
@@robertgyiran дело в том, что сша строят из себя такую хорошую, миролюбивую страну, помогая устроить в украине гос.переворот. А на самом деле сша делала намного худшие вещи чем россия
@@Wasdasda I think you are not bothered with facts, like Ukraine had multiple elections since then and they never voted back your russki friends.
Why is this happening??? Did they not hear their contry INVADED Ukraine?!
That's a level of stupidity that's hard to comprehend.
You will never get them to say anything bad about Putin on camera. They know that is a death sentence for them
Anybody can say bad about Putin.
The citizens of Russia have a very bad experience with fascists and know that it is better to pretend that you know nothing. A lot can happen when the NATO propaganda cameras are turned off.
@@TheBobVova You seem to be lost. Sure anybody can talk bad about Pootin, but most Russians talking bad about him seem to fall out of windows and planes.
@@lamarw7757 I don't care this "seem".
The fact is that most Russians talking bad about him are alive and free.
Are you crazy?!! There is more freedom of speech in Russia as in UK!!!
The citizens in the occupied territories in Kursk are now being taught kindness and the value of human life as we speak.
The citizens of Russia have a very bad experience with fascists and know that it is better to pretend that you know nothing. A lot can happen when the NATO propaganda cameras are turned off.
It's war, kindness has nothing to do with it.
The citizens in the -occupied- liberated territories in Kursk are now being taught kindness and the value of human life as we speak.
Fixed that for you.
@@SirAntoniousBlock word "occupation" doesn't sit well with you? Why?
"Russian-occupied territories of Ukraine" and "Ukraine-occupied territories of Russia" both statements are true, now.
@@somestuff7876 No, Ukraine is being defended from and a part of Russia is being liberated from the fascist heel, do you see?
She said, Putin is, “Logical and rational?” He’s a loose cannon! 🤯🤯
Like it or not, Putin, not the West, is the one who has prevented this proxy war from becoming a nuclear war. He is the adult in the room, whether or not the invasion of Ukraine was justified.
VIVA Ukraine!
2:15 Mikhail Gorbachev was a good leader. what does she mean?
He ended the Soviet Union and helped East and west Germany unite.
This Dame is out of her mind.
Bad leader, ZSRR should have never collapsed. It needed reforms.
She said last decent leader was Tsar Alexander III.
@@BruhV52 Your opinion.
The Soviets put innocent people in gulags.
And responsible for 20 millions deaths from its beginning in the 1920s.
The true good Russia was the Russian empire.
Then communism came in Russia and made it rotten.
Putin won cause he lied to his people
He said he was going to make Russia a
Democracy and to make it like how it was during the Russian empire.
USSR OR CCCP is almost the same thing as the Germans in world war 2.
Matter of fact Russia helped Hitler invade
Poland which ended in with over 2 million polish men and women killed in 1940.
Stalin was drooling for Poland and other small countries to come to his reign.
A lot of those countries wanted to escape
The reds but couldn’t cause they were trapped in a communist cage made by the Soviets.
You have every right to believe what you want.
But I am not changing my beliefs on how bad the USSR/CCCP were.
@@BruhV52 The USSR is not good.
They killed over 20 million people.
Helped the Germans invade Poland.
Lied to people
Made innocent people to slaves
In gulags.
Killed and raped people
And many more reasons.
@@BruhV52 USSR was a "country" made from occupied countries Russia invaded. It had to collapse as these countries never wanted to be part of it. Nobody asked them.
No reforms would change that. Countries and people wanted freedom.
BBC was not banned in Russia?
Apparently just to broadcast, yet RT and I think one or two others are banned in the UK, period. The irony of it!
@@Tina-gm4uf UK lets Ruzzians launder their money in London and possibly this is one of the returned favours.
@@Tina-gm4uf The conclusion is that someone here is using their money more cleverly, i.e. it is easier to corrupt Russians than similar people in the UK.
@@Tina-gm4ufthat’s because RT and other such tv is propaganda for Putin, owned by Putin. Whatever criticisms you you have of the BBC it’s journalists aren’t killed or jailed by the UK governments. Putin wants the veneer of legitimacy he gets from having the BBC report, but you can bet they aren’t letting them report everything, and will jail them if the fancy takes Putin. He is a dictator, there is no equivalence or magnanimity in his actions
Notice the BBC reporter carefully did not say anything against Russia, like 'What do you think of the Russian invasion of Ukraine?'
Due to this video I noticed one significant change - people want to know more about war. Before Ukraine invasion in Kursk they said aren't interested in it. Maybe they become read more about war
She said they are lucky to have Putin. They need to feel what the Ukrainians feel.
Hmmm, would you say the same usa or China
what you feel about war 2014-2022? y just don't know about it?) west started it. they loved do revolutions-/
"SOMEONE LET THIS HAPPEN." Hm..I wonder who?
@@alexkoz34 Perhaps they should pack up and leave for Russia proper if Ukraine is not to their liking. Do a web search for "Heim ins Reich".
It's so laughable not too long ago they all agreed with the invasion of Ukrane . Now they are starting to get scared and wish for peace 😂 ireland
The citizens of Russia have a very bad experience with fascists and know that it is better to pretend that you know nothing. A lot can happen when the NATO propaganda cameras are turned off.
The guy dancing a jig, while using his cane as an air machine gun wishes he could be on the front lines.
that probably could be arranged
@@brianharper8304 LOL, sad though.
Reminds of the movie depicting WW1 "All quiet on the Western Front".
On leave the soldiers get welcomed home with all this nationalistic furor by the old people.
One day at the front would quickly change there minds. Perhaps a tour in a militairy hospital would too.
The residents of Russia Kursk offer interviews, Ukranians residents of Bucha could not do this because there were raped and killed...the differences between the soldiers of 2 nations
The irony is that except for Stalin and Putin, Russia. was not invaded under Kruschev, Breshnev, Gorbachev, Yieltsin, Andropov and Chernenko,
Are you implying that Hitler wouldn't have invaded Russia if there was any other leader than Stalin?? 😆😂🤣🤣
@@Fuse7000well Stain was an ally of Nazi Germany and happy to be so. Hitler went mad when Stalin started entertaining calls from Churchill and so invaded. If Stalin hadn’t talked to Churchill , trying to play both sides , Hitler probably would never have invaded.
So if any other leader had been in power Hitler may never have invaded Russia 😊
@@dianeshelton9592 Thanks for educating people. Yes, Churchill reaching out, was the psychological Chess move that toppled Hitler. I think the Allies could have done it without Russia, but it would have been a lot longer, deadlier conflict, with a few more Big Boys and Little Boys.
I was blessed to have a Grandpa that served in WWII. Unbelievable, the size of the balls on that Generation.
After that invasion there will be a pause as well.
Don't need any invasions when your country is already was torn appart by those god's perfect morons.
My other man: playing air guitar on his cane.
That's your typical drunk Russian.
OMG that was so cringe trash
1M rubbles isn’t even £9k. A man’s life has to be worth more than that!😢
meh, about $11k. Not a bad signing bonus.
In Yakutsk a small room (20 sq.meters) would cost you 7M rubles. So this money is nothing.
@@vissarion3505 fuuuuuuuck! Really? I thought maybe it was a paltry sum when converted into Sterling, but at least it would get you some thing nice in Russia. How depressing.
@@LivingroomTV-me9oz у моих родителей двухэтажный дом за 9 миллионов рублей. Так что он врëт
@@Wasdasda in English?
Lady saying Putin is good, with fear in her voice and eyes.
Innocent civilians suffer the most.
When will we get to see a world without conflicts and turmoil?
#peaceandprosperity
PUTIN YOU ARE A PAPER TIGER
Never why would you think it would be otherwise?
They are not innocent. They support the war in Ukraine.
@@pythondre brother all of us including you long for such a world. Maybe the commenter got frustrated enough to express his desire.
As long as we are physically vulnerable mortal beings it won't go away, so it will never go away. Someone will always take advantage of our biggest weakness. Nuclear weapons are the strongest guard against a large war , I believe the thing that has stopped us descending into ww3 in recent decades. We should and can stop violence when it happens and strive for peace, but to believe there will be a time without it is naive, it's obvious that things are heating up in the world, literally. At its heart life is brutal but also beautiful.