What a great knowledgeable scholar... We have been very unfortunate to not learn from him since our child hood. 7 generation have passed out with zero knowledge of all this knowledge. Romila Thapar and Irfan Habib have overtaken our educational institutions.
Sir Tamizh person here. I speak five languages including Samskrutam. I will certainly support any government that declares Samskrutam as the National Language of Bharatam. Tamizh people will not accept Hindi + Urdu because they see it as alien to their culture. No Tamizh person other than Dravidian sympathisers opposes Samskrutam. In fact, Tamil Nadu has the highest number of Samskrutam speakers in Bharatam. There are more similarities between Tamizh and Samskrutam than between Hindi and Samskrutam. Tamizh people do not consider Samskrutam as a threat to Tamizh culture at all since all the great Tamizh kings right from the Kalabhras to the Pandyas knew Samskrutam and Tamizh and actively promoted Samskrutam in Tamizh Nadu. Jayatu Samskrutam. Vettrivel veeravel.
Glad to see someone recognising tamil from someone from north. Could you also recommend BA tamil in BHU. You could include nationalistic works in syllabus, true history, this could counter false narrative of McCauley putras from TN.
Bro people's like us always praised our Regional (not only yours) languages - Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada , Marathi, Konkani . It's also our mother language
@@JoJo-mq6jt the step has to be taken from people who are not from south. Many come to work in bangalore , chennai and do not bother learning the language. They show contempt when asked to learn the language. 2 hands need to come together for clapping, 1 is sufficient for slapping.
I admire you prof kapoirji for clearly mentioning that hinduism is a misnomer and sanatan dharm is more appropriate for dharma in Bharatvarsh. The linguistic conflict is quite prevailing in Bharatvarsh and it has become a tragedy for the country. I think sanskrit can be an unifying force to bridge the gap. Vande Bharat Mataram.
Let us talk now and ask him questions regarding the improvements need to be done on state and on the national level after all this raita spread by white Britishers and black Indian britishers on our nation and make things easier and subjects easier and make education useful and productive. I am pointing towards something like Gurukul method, in that era one subjects is taught for one year and not this 50 minute period when actual teaching time is 30-40 mins which changes in few mins. And the worse thing is learning different subjects in english and even those subjects which have no use in our later life. So need to rewrite our books also which teach TRUE indian history and culture input mother tongue
Art 15(1) and Art 16(2) as well as Art29(2) prohibited the state from discriminating on grounds of language among other markers like religion, caste, sex, place of birth or descent prohibited for their experienced social divisiveness . Art 29(1) alone gives a group right to citizens to conserve their distinct language as it has a human right dimension in giving a group identity as analysed by Prof. Nayef Al Rodhan. The only tinge of linguistic chauvinism in the original Constitution is in picking Hindi as the national language. The Congress gave it a political platform by the Linguistic reorganisation of states which Rajiv Gandhi later lamented as a blunder. I cannot agree with the learned Professor.
with all due respect kapil ji your understanding of brahman is wrong no traditional vedantin considers it as energy brahman cannot be defined in words it has no beginning and no end its of the nature of consciousness all words used for brahman in the shastras are only indicative not definitive, urja or prana(though not the same) might be the closest correlate to energy, also unlike brahman energy is not constant. Energy is not a sakshi to anything, ur understanding of Brahman reduces it to materialism
Some shit coming for this person who is a supposed scholar or should I call scammer. Just because you get a forum, speak confidently and pacify Tamils by speaking about the greatest of a bygone era don’t think your misinformation will be ignored. The Prof was referring to Taxila and how common Sanskrit was before Islamic invasion. If Sanskrit was so common why are all Mauryan era Buddhist texts in Pali? Go to Thailand, Srilanka, Cambodia and Vietnam. They teach Pali and conduct exams in Buddhist schools for Pali so that future generations can learn Pali to understand the original Buddhist scriptures. If Sanskrit replaced a commonly spoken language did the Sanskrit speakers destroy a glorious Buddhist civilisation?
What a great knowledgeable scholar... We have been very unfortunate to not learn from him since our child hood. 7 generation have passed out with zero knowledge of all this knowledge. Romila Thapar and Irfan Habib have overtaken our educational institutions.
Sir Tamizh person here. I speak five languages including Samskrutam. I will certainly support any government that declares Samskrutam as the National Language of Bharatam. Tamizh people will not accept Hindi + Urdu because they see it as alien to their culture. No Tamizh person other than Dravidian sympathisers opposes Samskrutam. In fact, Tamil Nadu has the highest number of Samskrutam speakers in Bharatam. There are more similarities between Tamizh and Samskrutam than between Hindi and Samskrutam. Tamizh people do not consider Samskrutam as a threat to Tamizh culture at all since all the great Tamizh kings right from the Kalabhras to the Pandyas knew Samskrutam and Tamizh and actively promoted Samskrutam in Tamizh Nadu. Jayatu Samskrutam. Vettrivel veeravel.
Thanks for the time stamps. 🧡
Glad to see someone recognising tamil from someone from north. Could you also recommend BA tamil in BHU. You could include nationalistic works in syllabus, true history, this could counter false narrative of McCauley putras from TN.
Bro people's like us always praised our Regional (not only yours) languages - Tamil, Telugu, Malayalam, Kannada , Marathi, Konkani .
It's also our mother language
I wish people's like you come out in public and stand together
B'coz it's our Language Our Pride🎉
@@JoJo-mq6jt the step has to be taken from people who are not from south. Many come to work in bangalore , chennai and do not bother learning the language. They show contempt when asked to learn the language. 2 hands need to come together for clapping, 1 is sufficient for slapping.
आप भारतीय संस्कृति और सनतन दर्शन की सही विवेक प्रदान करते हो । पाणिनीजीका शब्दानुशासनम् और संस्कृत भाषा का लौकिक च वैदिकम् च अच्छा समझाया ।
Marvellous
We need more teachers like you in America. We are really falling behind our education in. a high schools and even elementary schools.
I admire you prof kapoirji for clearly mentioning that hinduism is a misnomer and sanatan dharm is more appropriate for dharma in Bharatvarsh. The linguistic conflict is quite prevailing in Bharatvarsh and it has become a tragedy for the country. I think sanskrit can be an unifying force to bridge the gap. Vande Bharat Mataram.
How can Sanskrit be an unifying factor when south indian languages have completely different language family and only has loan words from Sanksrit
charan sparsh Sir
Thnq !
🤔🙏
Pandurang Shashtri Athavale is great Rishi of 20th century 🙇♂️🙇♂️🙇♂️
Let us talk now and ask him questions regarding the improvements need to be done on state and on the national level
after all this raita spread by white Britishers and black Indian britishers on our nation and make things easier and subjects easier and make education useful and productive.
I am pointing towards something like Gurukul method, in that era one subjects is taught for one year and not this 50 minute period when actual teaching time is 30-40 mins which changes in few mins.
And the worse thing is learning different subjects in english and even those subjects which have no use in our later life.
So need to rewrite our books also which teach TRUE indian history and culture input mother tongue
rss and shah shoud listen to this and stop hindi nonsense . Hindi is not our national language and it should never be.
Vijayanagara also Spoke Urdu and Hindi Like Mumbai.
Very true
Yes Hindi chavunism in particular
Rajaji had warned Nehru not to divide our country in linguistic State which will be a disaster....
Sir Thyagaraja wrote in Telugu
Art 15(1) and Art 16(2) as well as Art29(2) prohibited the state from discriminating on grounds of language among other markers like religion, caste, sex, place of birth or descent prohibited for their experienced social divisiveness . Art 29(1) alone gives a group right to citizens to conserve their distinct language as it has a human right dimension in giving a group identity as analysed by Prof. Nayef Al Rodhan. The only tinge of linguistic chauvinism in the original Constitution is in picking Hindi as the national language. The Congress gave it a political platform by the Linguistic reorganisation of states which Rajiv Gandhi later lamented as a blunder. I cannot agree with the learned Professor.
with all due respect kapil ji your understanding of brahman is wrong no traditional vedantin considers it as energy
brahman cannot be defined in words it has no beginning and no end its of the nature of consciousness all words used for brahman in the shastras are only indicative not definitive, urja or prana(though not the same) might be the closest correlate to energy, also unlike brahman energy is not constant. Energy is not a sakshi to anything, ur understanding of Brahman reduces it to materialism
What does Tanya sister do?
Who are you man?
Some shit coming for this person who is a supposed scholar or should I call scammer. Just because you get a forum, speak confidently and pacify Tamils by speaking about the greatest of a bygone era don’t think your misinformation will be ignored. The Prof was referring to Taxila and how common Sanskrit was before Islamic invasion. If Sanskrit was so common why are all Mauryan era Buddhist texts in Pali? Go to Thailand, Srilanka, Cambodia and Vietnam. They teach Pali and conduct exams in Buddhist schools for Pali so that future generations can learn Pali to understand the original Buddhist scriptures. If Sanskrit replaced a commonly spoken language did the Sanskrit speakers destroy a glorious Buddhist civilisation?