The reason why this scene still strikes me as one of the most thrilling and moving scenes I have ever seen in a film (even after 30 years) is not at all the politics of the October Revolution, but the fact that one has the sense of the excitement of actually being a participant in a major historical event, even as one's own life path and one's own close relationships are being transformed. This is brilliant film making.
Just noticed your comment on this Saturday night perusing music and stuff. This scene still moves me too after all these years. I'm a lifelong socialist, a republican socialist and a dedicated student of Marxism. I experienced the struggle for freedom in my country, Ireland, against British imperialism, and like many others I paid a price, but I was always inspired and guided by my core beliefs. The Internationale forever.
Plus you got sexy warren getting all Moody and sexy with sexy Diane... Seriouslyp, the next time I have sex I'm going to put on the internationale. Maybe Billy braggs version
@Bombastic Very nice to hear from you in America. I always wanted to go there and see that country, but I can never do that now because I wouldn't be allowed enter. People like myself are automatically barred from entering the US and Canada, you know what I mean, the legacy of the northern conflict and legal matters. But I often thought in the spirit of that great October event, I could go to Mexico instead, pay homage to the San Patricio Battalion and then take my chances running across the Rio Grande, or maybe climb over that damn wall, or whatever. Well, not really but it's a nice thought though. I wish you well.
@Bombastic Yes I think I know what you mean, things have changed in the past couple of decades. People here in Ireland are surprised at how little is paid in the US to those who are unemployed due to the pandemic. I hear it is a once off payment of fourteen hundred dollars, whereas here in Ireland everyone affected in that way are paid 350 euros a week, which is a little over 1684 dollars per month. Then most people qualify for free healthcare also, or subsidised private healthcare because there are no charges for hospitalisation. But don't get me wrong, there are still a lot of inequalities and issues, and anger. Let's hope we live to see the mighty US working class rise again and remove those responsible for creating the vast gulf of inequality in the US and the world.
@@americancommunist6076 Marx would consider transgenderism/lgbtq fantasy as the equivalent of the opium of the masses, also workers don't support gayness
The Leftist elite in Hollywood played _the Internationale_ 24/7 anyway. (many still do) They never needed to wait til the academy awards to do it. It was their great love and raison d'être. The only thing they would've absolutely never done is abandon their massively entitled lives and actually go live in Russia. Much easier to keep their precious hands clean and love it from their nice comfy chateaux in the hills above LA.
You know that communsim is an world wide thing wen all your friends (Russian Spanisch italian turk french im german) start singing the internationale in their mothers languge
In China and Vietnam today, to being a feminist, socialist, speak against capitalism, billionaires, autocratic ruling class or singing the Internationale outside are considered crimes. Down with that two fake communist parties! Free the workers!
I eat playdoh, what does this prove, exactly? They sung the Internationale. Just because they sung the Internationale doesn’t make them Communist. North Korea says that they are democratic, but they are clearly not democratic, for example.
@@theasianboy315 the Trump cultists had no democratic mandate, the October revolution was carried out upon the basis of mass democratic action - so strong was the mandate of the Petrograd working class that it was almost a mere formality
Well, yes, quite in the beginning, when I was still able to walk outside and sing... I gave birth at home and it was a great summer morning. The Finnish lyrics is very suitable for giving birth, because it says something like: "This is the last push!" :D
I watched this movie for the first time today and it was amazing. Every school should show this movie! It’s so brilliant and just exciting! They really don’t make um like they use to
An inspiring and moving moment from one of my favourite films. The ideas expressed in the song have been around a very long time , and always will be, as long as one man is exploited by another. The Soviet Union failed for many reasons, but the events portrayed in the film show that we can win and learn from the experience of the first attempt of common people to rule and govern themselves.
This is a great movie and the Internationale is a very stirring song! I just listened to another version done by an Irish folk singer that was amazing!
Don't just wait for the revolution to come, it doesn't happen on its own. The people cause a revolution. Educate people, de-program the fascists and conservatives by debate, help those in need. The Western population is lead to belive this is the only alternative, unbridled, corrupt and immoral capitalism. Tell them there is another way, and show to other the better way by helping others. Kinda like the black panthers. Educate the uneducated, women, children and men, set up pantries to feed the hungry. You grow a movement via compassion, not only words. Stay strong comrades!
@@shabdikacharyya2516 we have experienced crisis after crisis as the living standards earned by the workers and peasants through the threat of revolution are being chipped away. Yes, it has been happening, it is happening and it will keep happening until the rotten structure of capitalism collapses under the weight of Proletarian Revolution
Shabdik Acharyya, hundreds of millions have died as a result of capitalism. The same is true of Communism. The only difference between the two ideologies is that one of them is harder to eradicate than the other. The real solution is democratic socialism, of which this song advocates.
Down with oligarchy governments... Down with capitalist exploiters... Down with tyrannical oppressors... Down with hate prejuctures... Down with religious opiums... With the International uniting, humanity will rise up!
Emanuel Rascol i agree these globalist scum destroy nations And not to mention the shit they did to your country taking the states of north barbarosa and destorying the economy in eastern europe
Arise ye pris’ners of starvation Arise ye wretched of the earth For justice thunders condemnation A better world’s in birth! No more tradition’s chains shall bind us Arise, ye slaves, no more in thrall; The earth shall rise on new foundations We have been naught we shall be all. Refrain: ’Tis the final conflict Let each stand in his place The International Union Shall be the human race. We want no condescending saviors To rule us from their judgement hall We workers ask not for their favors Let us consult for all. To make the theif disgorge his booty To free the spirit from its cell We must ourselves decide our duty We must decide and do it well. Refrain: ’Tis the final conflict Let each stand in his place The International Union Shall be the human race. We toilers from all fields united Join hand in hand with all who work; The earth belongs to us, the workers, No room here for the shirk. How many on our flesh have fattened! But if the norsome birds of prey Shall vanish from the sky some morning The blessed sunlight then will stay Refrain: ’Tis the final conflict Let each stand in his place The International Union Shall be the human race.☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭ Long live the Internationale ...let's all border be destroyed and let peoples United republic of Earth be formed
It was never communist. It was and still is socialist. Socialism with Chinese Characteristics. President Xi is upholding Marxism. Communism has never been achieved because it requires a socialist period. Socialism first, then communism. If you read and understand Marx's view of historical materialism you will understand. China never achieved bourgeois capitalism; the Western colonial powers prevented China from doing so. It was artificially held back into feudalism between warlords. Today, China has elements of capitalism because it never achieved capitalism. Capitalism, markets under control of the Communist Party allows China to advance through a "capitalist" period without the chaotic and exploitative effects.
I saw this movie in the theaters when it came out, and I barely remember it, except that it was so long it needed an intermission, which, by that time, was quite rare. I need to see it again.
This scene was filmed in Finland's capitol Helsinki where I live, so to me it looks very ridicilous to see Lenin and communists marching almost in front of my doorstep:P
Eikös se olisi mahtavaa. Kommunistit ottaisivat suomessa hallinan ja kaataisivat riistäjä Sipilän hallituksen ja vapauttaisi Suomen kansan kurjuudesta! Kommunismi on ikuista! Eläköön Lenin ja kommunismi!
+bernardobiritiki actually my friend have try it and the cops came to him and tell him to turn it down, but he didn't get arrest though, the cops probally didn't know what it is. I guess if the cop knows the meaning then I think he would get his ass arrested
@@mariusebeling6329 and what is proof British still worship Churchill whobis responsible for genocide of Indians,Taiwan worship Chiang shek,PRC worship Mao ,Us worship Washington and you say Lenin a mass murderers yes he suppressed his opponents but he never kill Soviet citizens he was many times better than today's British, European heroes.
@@RedWanderer26 Speaking as an American, we do not have a better chance! Even most of the so called leftist youth are convinced that communism is akin to reaction and that dreaded “authoritarianism”.
Yeah that certain "cyka bylat" (What a funny Russian stereotype :^) ) just industrialized the country and made it able to defeat one of the most advanced capitalist countries of the time. Not to mention the enormous increase in living standards, GDP, life expectancy, etc
Saw that movie again tonight on DVD. I will always be impressed. To me one of the best movie with Warren Beaty and Diane Keaton. John Reed was a great man...!!! Sure : "THE INTERNATIONALE UNITES THE HUMAN RACE...!!!"
A great film, attempting to identify and to illustrate, like the French Revolution, the birth of a new idea that would benefit ordinary people, the masses. Rather over-passionate in places - but so is the continued capitalist pursuit of money, wealth and profit, which many people support, though they themselves will never be rich enough to become capitalists. Whatever the Soviet Union ultimately became, its birth was colossally important, its results stupendous and, like the French Revolution it gave a new impetus to the lives, the aspirations of working people, and how they viewed themselves under the heel of the money-men, the Tsarist autocrats, and the burden of serfdom. Those heels still exist, and they are no less oppressive to working people of all countries. Perhaps even more oppressive now, with a corrupt, evil self-serving banking system, than it was then. Long Live Socialism!
One of the BEST portrayals of both sides, positive and negative, of at least 2 stages of the Russian Revolution (for those of your who've actually read about it). Sadly, much of John Reed's work was shortened by the film and Louise Bryant's is almost nonexistent, but their observations are no less stunning or relevant.
Wait! I saw you on Communist videos and now! You're a nazi?! And '' I posted this when i was a stupid commie. ''... What the?! Execute him now! *chk-chk* *aims* *TRATATATATATATATATATA!*. No but seriously, how did you change to a Nazi so fast?
One day, the people will come out in droves to sing this song in Washington D.C., London, Paris, and the great capitals of the world. The people have had enough of this broken and corrupt system!
The system works for anyone that tries, its called meritocracy. American's live in nice homes and own many nice things. Even the American poor are well fed, have big screen televisions, smartphones, internet access and nice vehicles as a general rule. You are living in a fantasy world Zach.
@@vanillaexplosion99 Just because Americans "live in nice homes and own many nice things" does not mean they live in a just and democratic system. You could use exactly the same argument for China: "Chinese people live in nice homes and own many nice things, therefore there is absolutely nothing wrong with the government". Of course, you and I both know that the Chinese government is a repressive, undemocratic regime which spies on its citizens and commits genocide against minorities. But hey, they have big screen televisions, so everything's alright! I am not a communist. But what I am is a realist. And it is entirely unrealistic to say that everything's alright because a lot of people have nice televisions and fancy phones. That kind of thinking breeds ignorance and leads to large swathes of the populace becoming complacent with a system that is driving hundreds of thousands of people into debt every year because they had the misfortune of getting sick. We can push for better than that, and we will.
As a Londoner; watching this in 82 was very profound for me. The Cold War was still VERY real...Populace Indoctrination Against the communists was SO Strong...but after seeing this picture all thought that Snowy winter; it changed my perception of the prolatereate...why shouldn't we ALL have something...that concept is STILL with me Today and l do what I can for the people, when l can...
The nod to Trotsky (Proletarian Internationalist) is correct. He is the FOUNDER of the Soviet Red Army. Stalin (a Nationalist, would come into power seven years later) had him removed from Russian history via pictures and literature. And, he had Trotsky assassinated as he was living in exile in Mexico. It was because of Lenin’s death and Trotsky’s failing as a politician that led to Stalin’s position. The arts and sciences flourished for those seven years of Lenin and Trotsky.
Fun fact all the scenes showing petrograd or moscow were shot in helsinki. In some of the shots you can see the old senate house. You can also see the senate marketplace (previosly known as the Nikolai's marketplace)
The stairway here actually has huge historical signifigance in itself. It was the actual place of the assassination of General Governor Bobrikov in 1904, which is considered the one of the first events which led into Finnish independence in 1917.
I love this video! I do! The only thing that bugs me about it is that the footage and sounds aren't in sync with each other. But other than that, I love it!
Joe Torres Anarchist communism is a theory of anarchism which advocates the abolition of the state, capitalism, wages and private property (while retaining respect for personal property), and in favor of common ownership of the means of production, direct democracy, and a horizontal network of voluntary associations and workers' councils with production and consumption based on the guiding principle: "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need". en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_communism Communism (from Latin communis - common, universal) is a socioeconomic system structured upon common ownership of the means of production and characterized by the absence of social classes, money, and the state; as well as a social, political and economic ideology and movement that aims to establish this social order. en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communism
mystuff123 already sounds like it is set to fail. just like every other political ideology. its all the same. I used to be a communist until I seen what bullshit it is. just more liars and propaganda. no difference at all. no matter how you try to twist it. politics is poison plain and simple.
Other than Finland (including the rural scenes, when Reed is captured by Finnish soldiers), it was filmed in Spain (for the Middle East and Mexico) and in London, for the city scenes in Portland, Ore., and Greenwich Village, NY.
The street scenes in this clip were all filmed in Helsinki, in the main square (Senaatintori) right by the government house and very close to the harbor.
una muy buena pelicula!!! cuando tenga si dios quiera mi hijo su cancion de cuna va ser ni mas ni menos q el himno del obrero en el mundo q es LA INTERNACIONAL. Saludos desde Perú
Prekrasan film. Gledala sam ga s velikim uživanjem dva puta. Nisam prvi put ni shvatila sasvim neke događaje. Potrebno je znati i malo povijesti iz tog perioda da bi doživljaj bio potpun.
I am not at all the same opinion sa the user "legendsxdie123". Not at all !!! I think because of the worldwide capitalism there is so much poverty, starvation, wars and other kinds of misery in this world ...
you might wanna think about it then......the working class can bring Communism, the party took power away from the Soviets (workers councils), so what happened after the revolution was not Communism, you like the movie probably because you actually dont like Capitalism lol just saying and the International's a beautiful working class song...and I am a Hip-Hop head lol
![[TH] 2024 PMSL SEA W2D5 | Fall | พลาดวันนี้ จะต้องเสียใจ](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/A5-Cuo12p6A/mqdefault.jpg)
The reason why this scene still strikes me as one of the most thrilling and moving scenes I have ever seen in a film (even after 30 years) is not at all the politics of the October Revolution, but the fact that one has the sense of the excitement of actually being a participant in a major historical event, even as one's own life path and one's own close relationships are being transformed. This is brilliant film making.
Just noticed your comment on this Saturday night perusing music and stuff. This scene still moves me too after all these years. I'm a lifelong socialist, a republican socialist and a dedicated student of Marxism. I experienced the struggle for freedom in my country, Ireland, against British imperialism, and like many others I paid a price, but I was always inspired and guided by my core beliefs. The Internationale forever.
Plus you got sexy warren getting all Moody and sexy with sexy Diane...
Seriouslyp, the next time I have sex I'm going to put on the internationale.
Maybe Billy braggs version
@@frankpeter6851 Nah, I prefer the sweeping orchestral versions to Billy Brags.
@Bombastic Very nice to hear from you in America. I always wanted to go there and see that country, but I can never do that now because I wouldn't be allowed enter. People like myself are automatically barred from entering the US and Canada, you know what I mean, the legacy of the northern conflict and legal matters. But I often thought in the spirit of that great October event, I could go to Mexico instead, pay homage to the San Patricio Battalion and then take my chances running across the Rio Grande, or maybe climb over that damn wall, or whatever. Well, not really but it's a nice thought though. I wish you well.
@Bombastic Yes I think I know what you mean, things have changed in the past couple of decades. People here in Ireland are surprised at how little is paid in the US to those who are unemployed due to the pandemic. I hear it is a once off payment of fourteen hundred dollars, whereas here in Ireland everyone affected in that way are paid 350 euros a week, which is a little over 1684 dollars per month. Then most people qualify for free healthcare also, or subsidised private healthcare because there are no charges for hospitalisation. But don't get me wrong, there are still a lot of inequalities and issues, and anger. Let's hope we live to see the mighty US working class rise again and remove those responsible for creating the vast gulf of inequality in the US and the world.
No matter how large a choir sings the internationale, it always sounds best when a large group of workers and farmers sing it
Get rid of that flag.
@@velcranoxofficials9970 there's three flags and I don't see a reason to get rid of any of them
@@monika.alt197 yes the trans "workers" and farmers will lead the revolution
keep that flag, comrade
@@americancommunist6076 Marx would consider transgenderism/lgbtq fantasy as the equivalent of the opium of the masses, also workers don't support gayness
I saw this movie when it came out in the 1980s. I was still a student suffering through the Reagan years, and I loved the music of "Internationale".
I think I was the only North Carolinian to go watch Reds; I know I was the only one who loved it.
@@deanwhite7970 Did your neighbors regard you as an oddball, maybe even a "commie"?
Regean was an amazing president anything you “suffered” through was merely caused by yourself you pouting socialist.
@RockabillyFox Caused a mountain of debt to pile up too
@@professionalspaceenthusias3024 oh and also supporting the Taliban mujahids in Afghanistan which after some years came back to bite USA only
I remember the Oscars when Reds was nominated for maybe ten different things, and the orchestra played The Internationale every time.
Me, too!
The Leftist elite in Hollywood played _the Internationale_ 24/7 anyway. (many still do) They never needed to wait til the academy awards to do it.
It was their great love and raison d'être. The only thing they would've absolutely never done is abandon their massively entitled lives and actually go live in Russia.
Much easier to keep their precious hands clean and love it from their nice comfy chateaux in the hills above LA.
If your blood doesn't rage even after seeing injustice, then it's water which flows in ur veins
~Chandra Shekhar Azad
Me sober: "I won't get political*
Me drunk: 0:01
You know that communsim is an world wide thing wen all your friends (Russian Spanisch italian turk french im german) start singing the internationale in their mothers languge
In China and Vietnam today, to being a feminist, socialist, speak against capitalism, billionaires, autocratic ruling class or singing the Internationale outside are considered crimes. Down with that two fake communist parties! Free the workers!
Long Nguyen You can also hearing Internationale國際歌 in any Chinese Music App
th-cam.com/video/mHSN6kNyg6k/w-d-xo.html
I eat playdoh, what does this prove, exactly? They sung the Internationale. Just because they sung the Internationale doesn’t make them Communist. North Korea says that they are democratic, but they are clearly not democratic, for example.
Really, A language that cannot sing the Internationale is very unlucky.. She has missed the magical melody
Even to this day, I feel very emotional when I hear this. Red's is a movie but Jack Reed was truly real and so very passionate
It's been 99 years. We have only gone backwards.
Sad but one one day
keep beliving comrades
Shilong Yang not really. Think about Cuba. We didn't have that kind of success to hang on in 1917.
Reagan,Bush, the GOP Senate
One day, comrades. One day our International Soviet will arise.
regardless of the lanuage, the words remain the same, we have, "nothing to lose, but",,our chains. long live karle marx!!
karle
What about the life?
Greatest song EVER!
yea
yea
Hoping that one day, this scene will play out in Washington DC. :)
th-cam.com/video/mWsxkzSzKRo/w-d-xo.html
It happen, but the one who did it was the Trump Cultists
@@theasianboy315 But thank God Trump had none of Lenins mental capacities....or we would have been truly effed,
Give it a decade or two might happen
@@theasianboy315 the Trump cultists had no democratic mandate, the October revolution was carried out upon the basis of mass democratic action - so strong was the mandate of the Petrograd working class that it was almost a mere formality
So comrades, come rally, and the last fight let us face. The internationale unites the human race!
The most beautiful version of the Internationale to ever grace my ears
I nearly freaked out when I saw Lenin...
Did you know that our loved leader Lenin was in Finland more than half year.
I nearly threw up. If only it had been someone better, like Kropotkin
+New East I hope that was a joke
Lenin is the best!
Comrade Lenin*
I confess it: every time I see again this extract from red I cry so much, it's stronger than me! =D
having sex + The Internationale plays in the background = Epic
I have even given birth singing the Internationale! :D
Taina Hollo Did you really?
Well, yes, quite in the beginning, when I was still able to walk outside and sing... I gave birth at home and it was a great summer morning. The Finnish lyrics is very suitable for giving birth, because it says something like: "This is the last push!" :D
Taina Hollo Nice little tune for your child to hear in his/her first seconds of life.
Славься товарищ
I watched this movie for the first time today and it was amazing. Every school should show this movie! It’s so brilliant and just exciting! They really don’t make um like they use to
Perhaps, there is another movie you should see also. Doctor Zhivago.
This is has to be one of the best movie scenes ever
An inspiring and moving moment from one of my favourite films. The ideas expressed in the song have been around a very long time , and always will be, as long as one man is exploited by another. The Soviet Union failed for many reasons, but the events portrayed in the film show that we can win and learn from the experience of the first attempt of common people to rule and govern themselves.
The Internationale is the GREATEST Anthem ever heard
This is a great movie and the Internationale is a very stirring song! I just listened to another version done by an Irish folk singer that was amazing!
One day, this scene will be in Washington D.C.!
That it will comrade, that it will
Don't just wait for the revolution to come, it doesn't happen on its own. The people cause a revolution.
Educate people, de-program the fascists and conservatives by debate, help those in need.
The Western population is lead to belive this is the only alternative, unbridled, corrupt and immoral capitalism.
Tell them there is another way, and show to other the better way by helping others.
Kinda like the black panthers. Educate the uneducated, women, children and men, set up pantries to feed the hungry.
You grow a movement via compassion, not only words.
Stay strong comrades!
Capitalism.exe has stopped working
No actually the reverse has happened
@@shabdikacharyya2516 we have experienced crisis after crisis as the living standards earned by the workers and peasants through the threat of revolution are being chipped away.
Yes, it has been happening, it is happening and it will keep happening until the rotten structure of capitalism collapses under the weight of Proletarian Revolution
Shabdik Acharyya, hundreds of millions have died as a result of capitalism. The same is true of Communism. The only difference between the two ideologies is that one of them is harder to eradicate than the other. The real solution is democratic socialism, of which this song advocates.
Yeah keep telling yourself that.
Zachary Wilson here we see succdems at their finest. Comparing Socialism to Capitalism
the Internationale unite the human race!
L'internationale sera le genre humain..!!!!
....and then kill them if they begin to commit thoughtcrime!
Down with oligarchy governments...
Down with capitalist exploiters...
Down with tyrannical oppressors...
Down with hate prejuctures...
Down with religious opiums...
With the International uniting, humanity will rise up!
BULSHIT , SOCIALISM IS DEVIL WORSHIPING. I LIVE 23 YEARS IN COMMUNIST ROMANIA.
Emanuel Rascol i agree these globalist scum destroy nations
And not to mention the shit they did to your country taking the states of north barbarosa and destorying the economy in eastern europe
Workers of the world unite
《閘北樓C 座》(曹哲1958--? )
港府一直不清楚黑社會的實力, 2016 年暴動, 梁振英隱忍不發, 三合會終於暴露出他們有多少人, 因此, 梁振英獲委政協副主席, 亦係事所必至, 理有固然, 跟著, 下一任特首林鄭月娥和鄧炳強就開始部署反黑工作, 暗中行事, 希望把香港的黑社會一網打盡,
@@Mike.Salimi
中山先生認為, 知之固能行, 不知亦能行, 行易知難, 以鼓舞國人實行三民主義主張, 辛亥革命, 興漢排滿, 奮鬥, 救中國, 君主立憲是一個騙局, 到了今天, 吾爾開希, 柴玲, 封從德, 王丹都移玉台灣, 民主抗共,
Love to all of my communist brothers.....
Kill a commie for mommie.
Laal salam bhai!
@@SureshBalajiDN Laal Salam Comrade
Arise ye pris’ners of starvation
Arise ye wretched of the earth
For justice thunders condemnation
A better world’s in birth!
No more tradition’s chains shall bind us
Arise, ye slaves, no more in thrall;
The earth shall rise on new foundations
We have been naught we shall be all.
Refrain:
’Tis the final conflict
Let each stand in his place
The International Union
Shall be the human race.
We want no condescending saviors
To rule us from their judgement hall
We workers ask not for their favors
Let us consult for all.
To make the theif disgorge his booty
To free the spirit from its cell
We must ourselves decide our duty
We must decide and do it well.
Refrain:
’Tis the final conflict
Let each stand in his place
The International Union
Shall be the human race.
We toilers from all fields united
Join hand in hand with all who work;
The earth belongs to us, the workers,
No room here for the shirk.
How many on our flesh have fattened!
But if the norsome birds of prey
Shall vanish from the sky some morning
The blessed sunlight then will stay
Refrain:
’Tis the final conflict
Let each stand in his place
The International Union
Shall be the human race.☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭☭ Long live the Internationale ...let's all border be destroyed and let peoples United republic of Earth be formed
... And sisters!
Very moving
LONG LIVE TO WORKER'S INTERNATIONALISM-from italy!!!
proletari di tutti i paesi unitevi!
Hail Imperium!
Compagni!!!
Grande compagno
Oh Oh hai seriamente ragione
As a Chinese,I have to say that the country itself is not communism country any more.The revolution has failed,but we communists shall never give up
juchuan niu china is communist country
Dmytry B it has changed far away from original communist
It was never communist. It was and still is socialist. Socialism with Chinese Characteristics. President Xi is upholding Marxism. Communism has never been achieved because it requires a socialist period. Socialism first, then communism. If you read and understand Marx's view of historical materialism you will understand. China never achieved bourgeois capitalism; the Western colonial powers prevented China from doing so. It was artificially held back into feudalism between warlords. Today, China has elements of capitalism because it never achieved capitalism. Capitalism, markets under control of the Communist Party allows China to advance through a "capitalist" period without the chaotic and exploitative effects.
It has never been communism! And most of you dont even believe it!
We had betrayed communist ideology since 1989.In fact,China is a Confucian country or national capitalism county
Best scene from a fantastic film.
Honestly, I'm not even a Communist, but the redness in me freaked out when I saw Lenin.
Not Lenin, but marx and engels
@@stevenleung9532 All three of them + Trotsky
I saw this movie in the theaters when it came out, and I barely remember it, except that it was so long it needed an intermission, which, by that time, was quite rare. I need to see it again.
This was Petrograd in 1917. One day, the same scene will replay in Washington DC.
It did
This scene was filmed in Finland's capitol Helsinki where I live, so to me it looks very ridicilous to see Lenin and communists marching almost in front of my doorstep:P
+Matias Holm Good for you Fins had Mannerheim back then :P
+Matias Holm Hollywood couldn't exactly film in Moscow during the Cold War and we were the closest one this side of the curtain.
Eikös se olisi mahtavaa. Kommunistit ottaisivat suomessa hallinan ja kaataisivat riistäjä Sipilän hallituksen ja vapauttaisi Suomen kansan kurjuudesta!
Kommunismi on ikuista! Eläköön Lenin ja kommunismi!
Kensei Takesi Joo ei kiitos
kansanvihollinen!!
I wanna see somebody go in frount of the wite house an play this and see how long until cops come to arrest him for using his freedom of expression
+bernardobiritiki actually my friend have try it and the cops came to him and tell him to turn it down, but he didn't get arrest though, the cops probally didn't know what it is. I guess if the cop knows the meaning then I think he would get his ass arrested
+Tanawatt Siriwattanagul yeah they are american cop the no nothing about socialism.
but still hate it
not just cop alot of them as well
+bernardobiritiki wow, I thought US was a lot different from my country. from S.Korea.
+bernardobiritiki freedom of expression... How many People in Russia and China have died while speaking out against their government...
COMRADE LENINNNNNN !!!!! I love Lenin !!
lenin can burn in hell.
BoogalooBoy1776 plz go be a virgin incel somewhere else lmao
Hopefully you don't mean the paranoid mass murderer Lenin.
@@mariusebeling6329 and what is proof British still worship Churchill whobis responsible for genocide of Indians,Taiwan worship Chiang shek,PRC worship Mao ,Us worship Washington and you say Lenin a mass murderers yes he suppressed his opponents but he never kill Soviet citizens he was many times better than today's British, European heroes.
@@BoogalooBoy your Nazi trump can burn in hell
comrade brother comunisme .
love from 🇮🇩 ✊
dari film apa ni bg
@@comradeUglyy REDS gan judulnya ..
This is such a good movie, wish more have seen it.
Временное поражение.Мы зализываем раны,делаем выводы и готовимся к новой битве.
Это вряд-ли. Современная молодежь слишком либеральна. У американцев шансы больше.
@@RedWanderer26 on verra : pour le moment on se réarme
@@Mauve2 Excuse me?
@@RedWanderer26 Speaking as an American, we do not have a better chance! Even most of the so called leftist youth are convinced that communism is akin to reaction and that dreaded “authoritarianism”.
I do say your "revolution" will end terribly if you bring weapons into the mix. That's a bloody civil war on your hands.
Minneapolis when the 3rd Precinct burned down, 2020, colorized
No....
god i wish
based
100% based
I wish but no.
101 years later and back where we started...
102...
The USSR started out with such promise....
Yeah, and just became the world's 2nd largest economy and became a nuclear superpower. Such shortcomings :c
Lord Meowric
Didn't end well, though.
***** Good point -- a lot of what they wanted to do could be done better now.
Definetely didn't end well, where are we now? we are in shit.
Yeah that certain "cyka bylat" (What a funny Russian stereotype :^) ) just industrialized the country and made it able to defeat one of the most advanced capitalist countries of the time. Not to mention the enormous increase in living standards, GDP, life expectancy, etc
2:51 The statue of Alexander II, still standing in the centre of the Senate Square.
What a heart-warming footage... n_n
Ora e sempre RESISTENZA! From Italy
I wonder what this October is gonna be like after a hundred years.
Long live communism.... I wanna see the whole Asia applying communism... Love from India
How about a 'no' on that one
@@hermannthefisherman2960 You don't have a choice
Lal selam comrade
@@saumalya1203 Lal Selam
bro i wanna see the whole world apply communism
Saw that movie again tonight on DVD. I will always be impressed. To me one of the best movie with Warren Beaty and Diane Keaton. John Reed was a great man...!!! Sure : "THE INTERNATIONALE UNITES THE HUMAN RACE...!!!"
A great film, attempting to identify and to illustrate, like the French Revolution, the birth of a new idea that would benefit ordinary people, the masses. Rather over-passionate in places - but so is the continued capitalist pursuit of money, wealth and profit, which many people support, though they themselves will never be rich enough to become capitalists. Whatever the Soviet Union ultimately became, its birth was colossally important, its results stupendous and, like the French Revolution it gave a new impetus to the lives, the aspirations of working people, and how they viewed themselves under the heel of the money-men, the Tsarist autocrats, and the burden of serfdom. Those heels still exist, and they are no less oppressive to working people of all countries. Perhaps even more oppressive now, with a corrupt, evil self-serving banking system, than it was then. Long Live Socialism!
One of the BEST portrayals of both sides, positive and negative, of at least 2 stages of the Russian Revolution (for those of your who've actually read about it).
Sadly, much of John Reed's work was shortened by the film and Louise Bryant's is almost nonexistent, but their observations are no less stunning or relevant.
All power to the People! All Power to the Soviets! 🇷🇺✊
Use either of this flags.. 🇧🇾🇨🇳🇰🇵🇻🇳. Atleast there is red .
@@cijoykjose Nvm but Chin* is capitalist
@@everythingisheresahil2283 f no . Don't be jealous ..
@@cijoykjose what's there to be jealous...I am saying facts for your kind knowledge!
@@everythingisheresahil2283 want some bing chilling to brainwash u
long live workers, long live socialism, long live communism !
proletaries of all countries unite!
D Kelly,Jr And YOUR god didn't!?
@FireWithFire you're right, its even worse..
Augusto Pinochet, Fulgencio Batista, François Duvalier, Manuel Odria, Tiburcio Carías, *Saddam Hussein*
FireWithFire Not all communists are atheists
Workers of the world unite!
Wait what arent you the guy that told me a fucking communist in the horst wessel lied and you have a swastika as your channel background
Zukas Mapping I posted this when I was a stupid commie.
So you change from nazism to communism 2 months? Hah and then you call me a 7th grader.
Zukas Mapping Thanks for assuming shit about me. It's really appreciated.
Wait! I saw you on Communist videos and now! You're a nazi?! And '' I posted this when i was a stupid commie. ''... What the?! Execute him now! *chk-chk* *aims* *TRATATATATATATATATATA!*.
No but seriously, how did you change to a Nazi so fast?
Happy May Day to the International Proletariat & others around the world! ✊
The people united shall never be divided. Let's see if they can do it again.
Best moment in human history.
A las barricadas!! The Internationale unites us all!
glory to Great october revolution .
I saw Reds more than two decades ago!
holy shit he actually looks like lenin
Ads on the Red Internationale, what are you a capitalist roader?
Воспрянет род людской, товарищи!
I almost lost my shit when Lenin got on to the stage
One day, the people will come out in droves to sing this song in Washington D.C., London, Paris, and the great capitals of the world. The people have had enough of this broken and corrupt system!
The system works for anyone that tries, its called meritocracy. American's live in nice homes and own many nice things. Even the American poor are well fed, have big screen televisions, smartphones, internet access and nice vehicles as a general rule. You are living in a fantasy world Zach.
@@vanillaexplosion99 if by 'tries' you mean 'is rich', you are correct.
@@vanillaexplosion99 Just because Americans "live in nice homes and own many nice things" does not mean they live in a just and democratic system.
You could use exactly the same argument for China: "Chinese people live in nice homes and own many nice things, therefore there is absolutely nothing wrong with the government". Of course, you and I both know that the Chinese government is a repressive, undemocratic regime which spies on its citizens and commits genocide against minorities. But hey, they have big screen televisions, so everything's alright!
I am not a communist. But what I am is a realist. And it is entirely unrealistic to say that everything's alright because a lot of people have nice televisions and fancy phones. That kind of thinking breeds ignorance and leads to large swathes of the populace becoming complacent with a system that is driving hundreds of thousands of people into debt every year because they had the misfortune of getting sick.
We can push for better than that, and we will.
One of the best scenes ever
Sing it louder comrades!!!
Communism Hasn’t worked
Skywind r lol okay.
Ignoring Cuba, the USSR and China lol
The ussr fell apart so that one didn't work
As a Londoner; watching this in 82 was very profound for me. The Cold War was still VERY real...Populace
Indoctrination Against the communists was SO Strong...but after seeing this picture all thought that Snowy winter; it changed my perception of the prolatereate...why shouldn't we ALL have something...that concept is STILL with me Today and l do what I can for the people, when l can...
More and more people see this event as a step forward for humanity. Truly is beautiful.
Russian and French revolution were a mistake
The nod to Trotsky (Proletarian Internationalist) is correct. He is the FOUNDER of the Soviet Red Army. Stalin (a Nationalist, would come into power seven years later) had him removed from Russian history via pictures and literature. And, he had Trotsky assassinated as he was living in exile in Mexico. It was because of Lenin’s death and Trotsky’s failing as a politician that led to Stalin’s position. The arts and sciences flourished for those seven years of Lenin and Trotsky.
Nah, Glory to comrade Stalin
@@Charles-by9gmRead a book
@@iillililillliliilliiililil5066 U are the one who needs to read a book brother
Fun fact all the scenes showing petrograd or moscow were shot in helsinki. In some of the shots you can see the old senate house.
You can also see the senate marketplace (previosly known as the Nikolai's marketplace)
The stairway here actually has huge historical signifigance in itself. It was the actual place of the assassination of General Governor Bobrikov in 1904, which is considered the one of the first events which led into Finnish independence in 1917.
@@froloffantonno studio scenes
@@lexkanyima2195 no shit
@@froloffanton yes
Great film liverpool
proud to be communist ,
Same
+Zachary Jaenish where u from
yo leav me alone
French Touch Get out of here we never commented your so called democracy
Why would you be proud of a mental illness?
I love this video! I do! The only thing that bugs me about it is that the footage and sounds aren't in sync with each other. But other than that, I love it!
100 years ago! The Internationale unites the human race!
This song just purely great!
I saw this movie when it came out in 1981.
Happy 7th Nov comrades
The future is Red!
Long live marxism-leninism!
Long live October!
***** what the hell is an anarcho communist? such a thing does not exist.
Joe Torres
...You obviously have much to learn about Communism. :3
Joe Torres Anarchist communism is a theory of anarchism which advocates the abolition of the state, capitalism, wages and private property (while retaining respect for personal property), and in favor of common ownership of the means of production, direct democracy, and a horizontal network of voluntary associations and workers' councils with production and consumption based on the guiding principle: "from each according to his ability, to each according to his need".
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anarchist_communism
Communism (from Latin communis - common, universal) is a socioeconomic system structured upon common ownership of the means of production and characterized by the absence of social classes, money, and the state; as well as a social, political and economic ideology and movement that aims to establish this social order.
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Communism
mystuff123 already sounds like it is set to fail. just like every other political ideology. its all the same. I used to be a communist until I seen what bullshit it is. just more liars and propaganda. no difference at all. no matter how you try to twist it. politics is poison plain and simple.
Joe Torres And thus you've exposed your ignorance about everything said thus far.
This past November 7 was the 105th anniversary of the storming of the Winter Palace
That moment when you're really angry at your employer and you feel a song coming on. 🤣🤣🤣
Little did they know the monster they were going to create.
Nope
Long live the October Revolution! It is time to restore the USSR we miss and love!
Other than Finland (including the rural scenes, when Reed is captured by Finnish soldiers), it was filmed in Spain (for the Middle East and Mexico) and in London, for the city scenes in Portland, Ore., and Greenwich Village, NY.
The street scenes in this clip were all filmed in Helsinki, in the main square (Senaatintori) right by the government house and very close to the harbor.
Was it no studio or sets are filmed ? That was so well done
Beautiful!
una muy buena pelicula!!! cuando tenga si dios quiera mi hijo su cancion de cuna va ser ni mas ni menos q el himno del obrero en el mundo q es LA INTERNACIONAL. Saludos desde Perú
Some scene of Reds had shot at Helsinki Finland. Because those days was not possibly go to Soviet and film there. So Helsinki was "Peterburg".
It's a movie about the October Revolution!
"The personal life is dead in Russia for a man with any manhood."
reds will rise again . specially in turkey
The proletariat has nothing to lose but their chains, but they have a world to win!
Great detail at 2:58, a Red Guard seemingly preventing a soldier to sack an expensive chandelier
2.51 that's filmed in Helsinki. LOL
HASTA LA VICTORIA SIEMPRE!!!!!
Prekrasan film. Gledala sam ga s velikim uživanjem dva puta. Nisam prvi put ni shvatila sasvim neke događaje. Potrebno je znati i malo povijesti iz tog perioda da bi doživljaj bio potpun.
What a wonderful film !
Das ist so ein schöner Film. Er macht Mut in den finsteren kapitalistischen Zeiten heute....
I am not at all the same opinion sa the user "legendsxdie123". Not at all !!!
I think because of the worldwide capitalism there is so much poverty, starvation, wars and other kinds of misery in this world ...
/watch?v=PcsLTm6zvl8 .Fackel des Antimarxismus. Derzeitig Nr.1 Hit.
@@xxwzaebd leider...
I may not agree with Communism, but I do like the Internationale and this movie.
What is the name of the movie pls ?
YoeThit Aung Reds
Thanks
YoeThit Aung It's a very well made Movie.
you might wanna think about it then......the working class can bring Communism, the party took power away from the Soviets (workers councils), so what happened after the revolution was not Communism, you like the movie probably because you actually dont like Capitalism lol just saying and the International's a beautiful working class song...and I am a Hip-Hop head lol
Red Salute! Long Live The Revolution! ✊🏾
Red salute comrade! Are you from Bengal?
Filmed in Helsinki, Finland. Aleksanterinkatu, in the downtown, that street-scene.
One of the most historical event in human history.
Вставай, поднимайся, рабочий народ!