She is saying that she didn't approve the members participating in Permission to dance MV but when they were marketed as BTS 's sister group she was silent.
these are both different situations not gonna lie and participating in mv is something more for me than being marketed as someone's sister group. tho it's interesting why she didn't want them in the mv
I mean I thought we been knew this, She have an article from billboard when Newjeans debuted quite literally saying hybe didn’t know the date on Newjeans debut
i think it's strange that they talk about it now and not when min heejin accused them of debuting le sserafim before newjeans because they just wanted to, the timing is really weird
@@twojogoreczek1966 In HYBE's response to MHJ press conference, it was said that she is lying, and the things were different from what MHJ stated. Source Music didn't come up with anything because they knew that they will sue MHJ, for lying and dragging LS in this mess.
@@twojogoreczek1966that's bcos this was information that dispatch got from evidences that Source music submitted for MHJ's defamation case in court recently. Dispatch is very tenacious and how they got it.. they may have some contacts inside the legal offices. They not only expose kpop artist, but actors and actresses, politicians.. at least now you know who really cares for their talents. HYBE was professional enough not to reply and said they will settle it legally. Why do companies do this? It's to protect their employees and talents from further speculation. That's a protocol.. on the other hand, MHJ made a presscon complete with oily face and imawreckrightnow get up and said her life is being threatened. Dragging her talents NJ and their parents, ILLIT, Le Serafim and even aespa. 🤣 This is all to cover the news that she is being audited by HYBE. She dragged a lot of people when she could have just let them audit, surrender her laptop and have them check it since she claims innocence. If your innocent, then why create drama and refuse to return your work equipment? However, she returned the laptop after completely erasing the drive. Her lawyers admitted to this. If she really cared for NJs career, all her petty accusations can be settled over a meeting with board of directors.
You literally twisted the situation. Hybe (specially the chairman) promised Mhj and Nj members' parents that they would be Hybe first girl group (this is confirmed in a video footage of a share holder meeting). Mhj delayed the debut because she wants everything to be perfect. But instead of delaying LSF to keep their promise, Hybe debuted LSF first and told Mhj to say nothing so the public thought this would be Mhj group. If you think it was her fault for delaying and they cant wait to debut LSF, that is totally fine. But a broken promise is still a broken promise.
I love how her excuse is always “it was taken out of context,” when it doesn’t matter if it was. Min Hee Jin is talking about people in a way she shouldn’t, with or without context.
She lost me forever when it came out about how she talked about NJ. Then when members and their parents backed her I was done with them too. I hope the whole lot of them go away. You’re so great? Ok. Go do it. They all are desperately hanging on to HYBE. They can’t do it that’s evident.
Like Calling the members brats, lazy, fat and etc. and also the way she handled that one female employee who reported SA from one of the executives, and misogynistic remarks to other employees. I really want to see her explain the context needed to make those remarks acceptable
1. The only person I feel bad for in the whole mhj mess is Youngseo. The poor girl was so talented. 2. Didn't MHJ say that she wanted newjeans to be seperate from hybe. But now she wants them to defend her for the plagiarism accusations? 3. People are allowed to not stan fifty fifty 2.0 if they don't want to. But why hate on the members. Also i saw some people saying " we should not stan" and "we are not stanning. Hello? Who is this we here? Some people really want to pretend that they are morally superior.
exactly...she was on verge of debuting in two groups...and she couldn't cause mhj literally destroyed her chance in both of them. and nearly ruined illit too. and in process of ruining nj (I wish it wont happen. They are very talented and young)
I know mhj had somthing to with youngseo leaving illit i mean she made her leave the original new jeans line up what was stoping her from making youngseo leave illit i am very sad that she left she was my bias 😢
@@isha0616that song proly has a double meaning that mhj denied but idk about that bcz I didn't listen to that song often anyway so I can't really tell u if it is a wierd song or not
All mhj did from the starting to till this date is to play victim card. Dragging all the other hybe group illit ,Lee serefem bts . And new jeans parents are equally bad
She though she could divide the labels under HYBE so they wouldn't all work together to fight her oh how stupid of her they other labels under HYBE are far more united then she thought now she's poked them it's like poking the sleeping Dragon it's now awake, annoyed and hungry
MHJ - professional liar. All her claims look childish. The plagiarism accuations? She's spinning stories rather than stating actual facts about the similarity. IT IS PLAGIARISM. None of her statements is to the point or direct answer. Everything is a pity story and disconnected from reality.
Yes, mhj lied SO MUCH in that 1st conference. The lies are just PILING UP.. I remember her saying minji was the only ok trainee and she handpicked the other members while fake crying. Smdh
1- The fact that Source Music made the concept and they made Attention is so funny for me, because the originality claims when she did even do half of the stuff and the ones she did have bland copies
have you seen earlier style and pre debut choreography to attention? it was um... more mature and not appropriate for them in my opinion and let's remember that producing isn't everything, she is more as a manager and concept creator than music producer so even tho it was made under source music, i can see changes and well of course the biggest is that there are five members not seven. she did things that can count as half i think but it depends on how we look, if half she ments as only song or song and mv concept
@@twojogoreczek1966 dance choreo was probably demo for all we know. We can't conclude that thats the final version. It takes a lot of changes to finalise anything anyway. And yea she finalised on 5 members coz her shaman said the other 2 looked possessed loll 💀
NewJeans’ parents are just as shady as mhj and they got these girls in their web to where I feel NewJeans members are gonna come out the same way as them with them openly supporting mhj too despite all the lying and trash talking she has done to them…shame.
like i understand wanting to support your children, but if you see that they are living in poor conditions and you don't approve, then take them out of that situation. When you let your child go through and then complain, it looks bad on you(parents) for not protecting your child
@@AUGHHHHHBBG you know what's the solution for being quiet? of course money and i wouldn't be surprised if she ever paid to newjean's parents to stay quiet and even when no, cookie is a song that is kind of known from newjeans so i dont think that parents would complain if it has big numbers
@@jada.177 I am a parent of a daughter, at the first sign of inappropriate behavior from MHJ pictures on walls, shady dealings my kiddo would have been out of there. I would have approached HYBE for her to stay somewhere away from MHJ but if they said no. My child would be out. That’s my job as a parent. Parents are culpable for not even trying to protect their children. Disgusting.
Also let's not forget how everyone was blaming Source Music for the dance cover heels due to the inappropriate choreography (which is true, I completely agree with that, it was inappropriate). But when proof came out about Min Hee Jin being IN Charge of the performance, bunnies said nothing. They defend her as if she was part of the group, the 6th member the gp never knew they had.
This is so right??? Its crazy how they suddenly care about whats appropriate and not when it came to that..when they never cared or said anything about cookie or the creepy behaviors of hers since their debut. I believe that witch has put a spell on them and knets
Bilo je lepo objavljeno pred časom, kako je Min Heejin preko GSM govorila, da so dekleta debela, lena, da ni nič od njih itd.... Glede trenutne situacije, predvidevam, da bo ta posnetek ponovno prikazan kot dokaz proti Min Heejin. Ne razumem, kako lahko še naprej tako slepo verjamete vsem, kar reče ali stori Min Heejin. Ja temni oblaki se zgrinjajo nad Min Heejin. Kdor visoko leti, nizko pade in to zelo hitro.
They try to make up a rumor that Bang stop Newjeans album name and gave it to illit because they didn't know how to read. They saw real me and Ador's claim and ran with it.
tbh I can’t anymore with mhj, just put her in jail alr or something; also I see nothing wrong with adding new members to fifty fifty, im actually excited the ru next members may be joining
But they were still under SOMU and MHJ was *JUST* in charge of branding etc 😂💀. Who is she to say that they were not allowed to be apart of the MV? This woman needs to sit herself down. ✋🏻😂
No cus bunny to bunny, any of y’all who still defending min heejin u are not a bunny cus this women do not care about our girls 😭😭 Also min heejin is so funny to me but kpop Stan’s are even more funny cus like… how do you stare at a bear trap as big as the bear trap in kill this love by blackpink and you STILL step in it 😭😭 like y’all are we joking how y’all proven wrong and STILL spreading lies.
Couldn’t their parents take them out of the training system if they was mortified by how they was trained and how they was treated? Didn’t they not research in to SOURCE’s training system? Where were these parents when NEWJEANS were dancing too COOKIE?
@@2ndMostUnoriginalUsernameEver somewhere else it was said that minjin allegedly cried on phone to her parents while she was living in those alleged conditions
Guys and what do y'all think of SM x Kakao mess lol cus it's somehow linked to HYBE as well, kpop companies and CEOs obsession with hybe and BTS is actually crazy
Like you? Stop attacking the girls who worked hard for their positions while your here sitting commenting saying that their clowns when clearly you are bc you like to hate on hardworking girls who were taken advantage of and just wanted to be kpop idols.
I am glad the dispute is finally between Hybe & mhj and she is not dragging illit & lesserafim through the mud again. I mean this two groups has become the punching bags of kpop now. It's not even about critiquing their vocals anymore it's about a game of shitting on them in the harshest way possible to completely destroy them mentally cuz I guess that's the new cool trend in the kpop scene right now
she literally destroyed so many groups. illit and lesfim is a known thing she destroyed svt, NJ, bts, txt, enha by saying hybe pays for brands and albumsales and then after she won she said she was joking. At the same time svt albums were thrown on streets making it look like her statement was true. And bts is getting hate(when they are already hated for even breathing) and exols dragged 2016 matter into it and made a fuss. She even had influence on other company groups especially sm.
The possession part just made me realize just how crazy and mentally ill min hee jin is Like i know she's a evil but ewww wtf is wrong her She should go, nobody will hire in vine
Honestly embarrassing how the parents obviously care more about the money than protecting their own children. They complain about certain things but where were they when the girls were singing and performing cookie??
So nj and their parents knew mhj was lying when she said source music wanted to debut lesserafim first and delay new jeans debut when in reality SHE was the one to who delayed new jeans debut. Mhj and nj parents made a big a deal about the girls not being first hybe group to debut Mind you all this sserra girls were getting dragged because they chose to lie I can excuse the nj girls for not telling the truth because they were probabky manipulated by mhj but their parents are grown adults they should know better
Not sure if we can say that the current Hybe CEO actually "FAILED" to acquire SM when reports are coming out that SM and Kakao used unethical and illegal means to block Hybe from the purchase. I mean, you can't say you failed to win when the winners cheated, right?
@@vivid_blossoms Reports say that when Hybe was trying to purchase SM, Kakao used stock manipulations schemes to inflate the stock prices of SM. It came to the point that Hybe basically backed out bec the made up value was no longer worth it to them. If you google "kakao stock manipulation" you will get more details.
Lbh, NJs members aren't that special or talented in reality. They can easily be replaced, but after all this drama, I don't think that 'BTS' little sisters' trope will be as popular for marketing because this stain will always be brought up...
Agreed! NJ is overrated, nothing about them is original like MHJ made them out to be. An overrated group of girls that openly support a liar and a thief. The parents are wrong to supported MHJ. They must be after the $ too.
its just crazy what money can do to parents. i find it odd how njs parents can still defend her, and how bunnies can still defend her. shes a huge problem and kind of creepy imo
I think in May, was shown messages where MHJ said different not so good things about NJ girls, and that, if the girls are not thanking her or prise her at the awards shows she will kill them. Of course after the messages went public, MHJ said that everyone knows that's the way, that she is normally talking, and that she joked about killing them, as we all thought, that she wants to become a criminal. But MHJ words didn't sound good, and she definitely may have her own ways to punish the girls.
they should do neither? if it turns out later they and their parents both were being manipulated by that evil narcissistic b*tch I'd still have some pity for them when shit goes down but now it's looks far from manipulation, as if they've joined their hand knowing everything...as the lies comes out more, it'd be very likely that odds would be agInsthrir favour then...unless they're affected by MHJ's voodoo rituals, just like you
We all knew, except the aggressive rabbits, that MHJ was lying about this, about the "originality" and more things and they try to to turn it around because they are exposing the girls, well, if MHJ had not lied I doubt very much for this to be exposed, since it would have no value. The parents seem to only want money, a shame for the girls, but I must say that I am sooo tired of the NJ and their issue....
Karma is a b*tch. In her press conference she left no stone unturned to destroy the image and ruin Hybe, BSH and several new grps including Illit, LSF and TWS. Now all are coming back to bite her. With three lawsuits on her and maybe more to come, she and NJ both are so going to be out of entertainment scene. Since she started this media play and drama, Ig now she must be enjoying all the drama and accusations pouring in.
Park Ji-won, did a lot for HYBE as a CEO. He was the one that managed HYBE to become the biggest entertainment company in Korea, and one of the biggest in the world. So, saying that he did all wrong in HYBE isn't only untrue, but it's with bad intention. His job was to expand HYBE and to create the a solid base for the future. Since last year he said that he will leave the CEO position, I am assuming that he ended his contract. Your comment is putting the former and actual CEO of HYBE in a bad positions, and that isn't fair, nor for them, or for HYBE. It isn't our position as outsiders to say what they (HYBE), did wrong, or how they needed to do things about the company and the issues with MHJ. People need to be well informed, so they can know what is happening with the label that owns BTS. They need that, because of BTS, otherwise there are millions of troubles between companies around the world and we don't care, it isn't our problem. MHJ created a problem with HYBE since BTS members were in military, and the label is fighting back, in the justice system. Hope everything will be settled, or in the way to be settle down, before BTS members will finish their military next summer.
The textes didn't leak it was placed into cloud and because Min He Jin didn't turn in the laptop to HYBE they went into the cloud and found all the test messages.
MHJ doesn’t seem very smart to me. We have a Shaman coaching her every step. You have to wonder what other backers she has, the other players in this criminal activity.
MHJ spoiled the girls so hard, that's why parents take her side because they think MHJ really cares about the girls. She did everything to get their trust. and they fell for it. Parents claims are stupid. of course trainees training until 2 am is no new thing. LSF does that too. and every other kpop trainee work their asses off. These girls and parents are so manipulated and its scary. HYBE need to let them go. They don't need them. they have ILLIT, KASTSEYE and LSF. they don't need these women who bites the hands that fed them.
That's why we don't want minors debuting. As much as it seems that the conditions were horrible, unfortunately that's what happens with most of the trainees in the kpop industry. The parents were worried if their child would debut and they accused source music that they had a contract that guaranteed their debut but I'm reality there's no guarantee in kpop. You can train for years and be in the final lineup but you can be dropped off at the last minute. The parents were worried about the living conditions but that's what happens with most of the kpop companies unless they are from big 3. And when Minji had joined source music then they only had gfriend and they were not even under hybe so obviously they didn't have a budget like they have now. I also blame parents, if they think the conditions were horrible enough for their child then they should have pulled their child off from source music. Why to blame hybe when they could have protected their child way better. Them praising ador for providing better conditions but forgetting ador is a subsidiary of hybe and they only got the budget because of hybe. I can understand why they would side with mhj here but why would they turn a blind eye towards all the bad deeds mhj has been doing. They are openly criticising Sakura and Chaewon for interrupting their child's debut and again lesserafim is getting dragged into this mess for no reason. They have already debuted and your child has debuted too, why to bring this up now when they already have a hate train behind them. And when source music would sue ador then everyone will say it was lsfm's vocals which got them hate. As if they are not getting hate because of this drama. BS.
1.Believe it or not all the drama is for BTS all the company's have kinda connection with whatever is going on cause they only have one year to take down BTS they tried to did the same thing in 2018
@@belaytriksno they weren’t lol? They had their food thrown out in front of them and weren’t adjusting well to Aran’s surgery schedule, ( she was on a ton of pain meds ) then another member had a mental breakdown and they even proved this with medical reports on instagram.
@@parasol3561That's the kpop industry...its fast paced and everyone is replaceable because they are manufactured products...there rarely is any longevity for GGs because they age out as soon as they stop acting/looking like kids...
@@parasol3561 It was stablished that it was not their agency the one that did that. Their agency gave them more freedom than most, that is what I mean.
It’s so ironic to me when the parents & MHJ is so attached or making such a fuss about NJ not being the first hybe gg to debut. When in time & time again they always publicly stated they are independent & NJ has anything to do with hybe. But still they want the title as a first gg of hybe ? 🤣. As you can see they just want the privilage & publicity.
If their parents couldn’t bare to see their beloved children like that, they why send them to train at HYBE in the first place? Why did they not bring their own daughters back and save them? I don’t understand their reasoning. Why have they decided to break the silence now? They should’ve done this long ago. It’s partially their fault too if the claims about HYBE neglecting them is true. 💀😂
Important to note that the neglectgul living condition happened way before hybes involvement in source music. So the poor living condition was provided by source music, not hybe. From the new statement from parents the only complaint that we can relate to hybe is the constant push back of the girls debut, which cause lsf to debut first which again mhj is the one who kept pushing back the debut. And the emotional distress the girls went through when celebrity idols joined hybe and feared that they would be replace by them,(obviously refering to sakura and chaewon the never ending obsession from this two istg)
@@_JustArandomMultistan_yup unfortunately people misunderstood again, according to thr timeline even on the official statement the parents only were mentioning source not hybe while talking about the training neglect
And after yesterday's new scandal (minji living conditions as a trainee) now the fans are watching (evenmore) MHJ as a saviour of the girls 🙃 and they don't even want to blame the parents 😃
Yeah I’ve always been on the side of fuck MHJ specifically for how she fucked up ILLIT’s debut with hate, sent more unnecessary hate to LSF, and a bunch of other inconsistencies within her narratives. But when I heard about that stuff with Minji I was like my god how could source music do that to Minji? But then I took a second to think. Two things can be true at once. Source Music shouldn’t have pressured Minji into stopping school, they shouldn’t have had her working till 2AM, and they shouldn’t have had her living in that fuck ass dorm. But we also gotta give partial blame to Minji’s mom. Yes I get that you wanted to support your daughters dreams (not a lot of parents do that) and I understand that no other company was taking female trainees at the time, but let’s look at the facts. You wasn’t allowed to see your daughter for a year or wasn’t allowed to visit, that’s the first red flag. She called you at 2AM because she was worried about walking back home at 13 years old at night, another red flag. And then when you finally saw the dorm and saw the mold and cockroaches, that should’ve been the third and final red flag. Your job as a parent is to protect your kids. She should’ve pulled Minji out after seeing and knowing that your daughter was enduring all of that in silence or at the very least, raised these problems to Source Music.
@@kayziofficial right?? Like people likes to speak sh1t about Latin America, but here if your kid is doing something for their future and one of the first things that they tell is that you can't visit your kid... everyone is taking the kid out of there... like... is common sense. And one of the things about parenting is that, sometimes in order to protect your kids you have to take them out of dangerous situations that for them might be like a betrayal, but in the future they will understand that is for a better good I don't care what anyone says, for me the parents are the first ones to be blame, they're greedy and now they're using all those difficult situations that the kids had to endure, for their own benefit... despicable
@@Arizzu_98 highly agree. It also raises the question of where was the concern when they released Cookie and also, if you didn’t speak up about this before, why do it when MHJ is on the chopping block and Source Music is the one throwing the punches? It makes her look like she’s only doing this for sympathy. I love NewJeans I truly do. But this shit is fucking ridiculous. If anything, that Minji situation should open the door to the conversation about how companies treat their idols and their trainees.
@@kayziofficial partial? I'll say Most blame should go to the parents. This is unfortunately a common occurrence for idol trainees alot even went through so much worse, and I'm not a fan of that so I'll understand if minjis Mom didn't knew beforehand, but minjis mom fully knows what's going on and even saw for herself but didn't do anything and didn't say anything, it almost seems like it wasn't such a big deal to her at that time, because I know i would've done something. Some trainees and even idols live with their parents or their parents rent them a separate dorm for a better living condition. Or idk any good parent seeing what their young daughter is going through would've pulled them out of the situation, I know I would. But they didn't, mind you minjis Mom had alot to yap but these are the same parents who send an 8 year old minji who can't speak English in Canada BY HERSELF. These are stage parents and they are rarely good parents. And I read somewhere on Reddit that "source is the only agency accepting female trainees at that time" was complete cap, first I think it was hyein or hearin who had that problem not minji, but either way someone aligned the timeline of the girls being accepted in source is the same time Chiquita (or other BM member) got accepted in YG
Also it was revealed that while the new jeans members were under source music they made Haerin Hyein and hanni (minors) dance sexy and suggestive dance moves. Some people were saying that they’re glad that they are in ador because see how much eunchae is being made to do these types of dances. Others were saying that it was fine that it was just dance practice videos but to me it’s not cause they were minors dancing suggestively infront of God knows who (men!! Could be women tho) and were also being recorded too
Mhj didnt join at the time they were minors it was 2 years before i dont think hybe even ahd source as a label yet this was still around the late times of gfriend@@april2782
@@luvvs.tillaniemhj joined in 2019 and half of new jeans were minors into their debut majority of them just turned 18 THIS year, what do you mean she wasn't there when they were minors do y'all just make up you lies to defend without doing research
@@powbobs ok let s not act like hybe isnt trash no matter what they shouldnt be posting the girls private information it s just not ok but yeah the parent are being brainwashed by that woman
now i just wonder what will nj be like if it was a 7 member group under source music that wouldve been cool, and mhj just needs to leave hybe cause nothing is getting better for her cause watch her staff start and close workers start leaving her. Nj parent's need to stop being babies and defend their kids from mhj cause the way she has been putting a bad image on these girls is ew.
I’m not supporting the new fifty fifty but some of y’all gotta chill with the hate. I hope the girls in the group have a good career I just don’t wanna give money to that company. STOP HATING THE ALLEGED MEMBERS
That company did nothing , The givers are to be blamed here and those girl betrayed attrakt because of their greed over the sucess of Cupid even when attrakt gave them a chance to drop the lawsuit and reconcile those girls still refused , The givers manipulated and gaslighted them , so don't blame the company
Yeah like not supporting and hating are two different things, why the hate just move on😭...I'd love it for them if they rebrand themselves like Blackswan did, tho
As a bunny, I don’t know what to think about this shit anymore. Like genuinely. I can understand if nobody wants to interact with NewJeans after this. All of the adults failed these girls. Every single last one.
New Jeans really had nothing to do with this it was all Min He Jin Plus she more or less brain washed New Jeans members and their parents into believing her.
@@Disneylover024 I know they have nothing to do with it, but with the way MHJ, their parents, and Bunnies are attacking everyone, it makes sense why nobody wants to interact. Also agree with the brain washing. Been helping MHJ cover up lies
Everyone talking about the MHJ situation. Im just excited for the new Fifty Fifty debut if its true that Chanelle is going to be a member than way better I also like Yewon too. Oh, and MHJ? She's just a hypocritical liar
am I the only one who's just realizing that people didn't realize she was lying this entire time I figured out she was lying when she said BTS copied NewJeans how they haven't made any music since NewJeans debuted like everything that she says get exposed and no one has anything to argue with I'm kind of happy because at this point the girls need a better CEO what are their parents doing like what type of parents are these people
I think everyone, even tokkis, know and have known that she lies but everyone is so deep in the hybe hate that they think they have to choose a side instead of admitting both sides suck.
Ko sem to slišala na prvi konferenci sem se stresla, kako podla je ta ženska. In nihče od prisotnih novinarjev jo ni vprašal od kje je dobila namig, da je BTS kopiral njo. In ves čas se dela nedolžno. Vsa umazanija prihaja na dan. Res ta ženska je zrela za psihiatrijo.
The only thing I have a problem with with the dispatch article is the vid of the girls dancing inappropriately. Other than that, the article is just stating and giving info/evidence on all the things Min Hee Jin lied about. Mind you, feels like everything at this point. It is so hard to even think that MHJN is even half of a good person. We all know that a lot of idol companies don't treat their trainees and idols right sometimes. But with MHJN, she seems like ARKATT CEO and how in pic and articles they seem to love their artists and treat them like family. but behind the scenes, they're mistreating them and calling them offensive words.
It’s already been revealed that the Attrakt CEO is not the one who mistreated the girls but instead The Givers (the company who the girls sided with in this whole ordeal). There was no evidence provided by anybody that legally declared Attrakt to be responsible for their “supposed” mistreatment
Keena was the longtime Attrakt trainee, while the other three were brought in later by Siahn. It seems to me that none of the members are victims and everyones doing what they want to do. Chanelle makes it interesting. I like her a lot. Sio, Aran and Saena will come back someday too. I'm kind of happy for everybody.
Not a potential, but a spiral downfall. They and their parents have done everything wrong. All for what? They think they can win against HYBE? Especially when they don't have a strong case and only just supporting a liar? Hopefully they at least have some investments from the money they've received so far
1- Never thought company can release trainees practice videos 2- i think hybe don't like NJ either. Their Plagiarism was shown in national tv while they deleted every article for tws plagiarism accusations
1- I mean, companies have all right to release trainees' videos cus the copyright is theirs. Those trainees signed a contract before becoming trainees. It's not new to see companies releasing/using trainees practice videos 2- Idk about tws plagiarism accusations but I don't think they hate NJ particularly, they probably just HATE Mhj to the core after all the shit she made them go through. TWS and NJ case aren't exactly the same thing if you see what I mean
That's Min Hee Jin's strategy for everything when in doubt just blame HYBE. The woman literally had power over everything from the styling to the music😂😂😂😂
because the truth of the plagiarism she committed was revealed and it was true, then she covered it up by suing hybe. NJ's fans are very disgusting, they are very fanatical in attacking bands from the UK, isn't the plagiarism very visible and should the plagiarism they do not only this from the beginning until now all the plagiarism results are disgusting when I see NJ and his parents are still defending, and is NJ so greedy that leaving their friend who was supposed to debut together at sourcemusic?
Who cares about debut dates, etc. You have PROOF that an employee (MHJ) was plotting to bring down the value and reputation of their boss (Hybe) in order to buy out their own sub-label at a cheaper price. You have PROOF that this employee had people snooping into the finances of the bosses biggest asset (BTS) and was waiting for them to 'leave' before enacting their plan. And apparently, you can't fire this person or at least get a quick decision by the courts? Frankly, I am embarrassed for the Korean police and legal system. What a joke. MHJ has a severe superiority complex. She had a high paying job with a reputable company and was given a massive budget, excellent working conditions, and full autonomy in her role. But that wasn't enough for her. Whether she is fired or works to the end of her contract, no one in the Kpop industry will ever trust her again.
Please boycott who?...they said the same about illit but look at illit today. Previous fans can boycott all they want , new fans will Stan them as long as they've good music and concept lol
@@RekhaSharma-hh1sv by their company it's so disrespectful to compare a hate train to the serious health and physical abuse that happened to fifty fifty please get grip
Nah cuz i thought it was over but wtf😭😭im stayin neutral, dont even know what side to believe. Im pretty sure we'll be seeing documentaries about this whole drama some years later...might be a plot twist too in it
For FIFTY-FIFTY, I wonder if they will rebranded EVERYTHING, including the group name because what are people gonna view them as? What are they gonna call them? “The new fifty-fifty”? “fifty-fifty2.0”? It’s gonna make the hate train even worse especially for the new members in the group. Also, what if people don’t find the new members “not talented enough” like the other 3 members who left?
not to bring hate to anyone or their beliefs but why are there so many stories of shamans and other religious leaders telling people to make terrible choices in their life and business? Not all of course but it's getting concerning...
I feel like for FIFTY FIFTY, people shouldn’t boycott the group. the CEO worked hard for them, he sold his car (i saw that in some article) and idk if the members were actually mistreated. think of it in this way. if a member of the group you manage was sneaking about a box full of junk food into their dorm, wouldn’t you be upset? idols have to maintain a specific diet, it’s their job. i’m not saying that idols should eat less, it’s just that they should have a balance.
The CEO selling his car is false and it wasn’t just regular dieting the members faced severe issues due to dieting (one lost her period for months, another had kidney issues, and another had issues with her gallbladder)
She is saying that she didn't approve the members participating in Permission to dance MV but when they were marketed as BTS 's sister group she was silent.
Everything she's said is coming back to bite her like how do ppl still defend her??
All she cares about is money and publicity, being marketed as "BTS sister group" will definitely get nwjns more publicity.
the crazy thing is they didn't need permission for nwjns members to participate in ptd video since the girls wasn't under ador yet
She is crazy asf.
She wanted hybe popularity to get Newjeans started then she wanna try to leave. Like what the fuck
these are both different situations not gonna lie and participating in mv is something more for me than being marketed as someone's sister group. tho it's interesting why she didn't want them in the mv
So min heejin was complaining that le sserafim debuted before NewJeans when SHE was the reason thaf le sserafim debuted before NewJeans 💀
I mean I thought we been knew this,
She have an article from billboard when Newjeans debuted quite literally saying hybe didn’t know the date on Newjeans debut
i think it's strange that they talk about it now and not when min heejin accused them of debuting le sserafim before newjeans because they just wanted to, the timing is really weird
@@twojogoreczek1966
In HYBE's response to MHJ press conference, it was said that she is lying, and the things were different from what MHJ stated.
Source Music didn't come up with anything because they knew that they will sue MHJ, for lying and dragging LS in this mess.
@@twojogoreczek1966that's bcos this was information that dispatch got from evidences that Source music submitted for MHJ's defamation case in court recently. Dispatch is very tenacious and how they got it.. they may have some contacts inside the legal offices. They not only expose kpop artist, but actors and actresses, politicians.. at least now you know who really cares for their talents. HYBE was professional enough not to reply and said they will settle it legally. Why do companies do this? It's to protect their employees and talents from further speculation. That's a protocol.. on the other hand, MHJ made a presscon complete with oily face and imawreckrightnow get up and said her life is being threatened. Dragging her talents NJ and their parents, ILLIT, Le Serafim and even aespa. 🤣 This is all to cover the news that she is being audited by HYBE. She dragged a lot of people when she could have just let them audit, surrender her laptop and have them check it since she claims innocence. If your innocent, then why create drama and refuse to return your work equipment? However, she returned the laptop after completely erasing the drive. Her lawyers admitted to this. If she really cared for NJs career, all her petty accusations can be settled over a meeting with board of directors.
You literally twisted the situation. Hybe (specially the chairman) promised Mhj and Nj members' parents that they would be Hybe first girl group (this is confirmed in a video footage of a share holder meeting). Mhj delayed the debut because she wants everything to be perfect. But instead of delaying LSF to keep their promise, Hybe debuted LSF first and told Mhj to say nothing so the public thought this would be Mhj group. If you think it was her fault for delaying and they cant wait to debut LSF, that is totally fine. But a broken promise is still a broken promise.
I love how her excuse is always “it was taken out of context,” when it doesn’t matter if it was. Min Hee Jin is talking about people in a way she shouldn’t, with or without context.
She lost me forever when it came out about how she talked about NJ. Then when members and their parents backed her I was done with them too. I hope the whole lot of them go away. You’re so great? Ok. Go do it. They all are desperately hanging on to HYBE. They can’t do it that’s evident.
Like Calling the members brats, lazy, fat and etc. and also the way she handled that one female employee who reported SA from one of the executives, and misogynistic remarks to other employees. I really want to see her explain the context needed to make those remarks acceptable
@@Spiderpunkrocks Exactly
Whenever her texts leaked, the parents will come forward and play victim card .
It just make them seem like irresponsible parents who only care about money.
exactly
Ikr that is whats sp suspicious about it..
they want some money money money
I feel like both the members and parents were manipulated by her 🤷
Min heejin be giving me ideas of how to write a manipulative and pathological liar💀.
😂😂😂
Y’all comments make me fly😭😭😭
1. The only person I feel bad for in the whole mhj mess is Youngseo. The poor girl was so talented.
2. Didn't MHJ say that she wanted newjeans to be seperate from hybe. But now she wants them to defend her for the plagiarism accusations?
3. People are allowed to not stan fifty fifty 2.0 if they don't want to. But why hate on the members. Also i saw some people saying " we should not stan" and "we are not stanning. Hello? Who is this we here? Some people really want to pretend that they are morally superior.
I remembered when people was saying the same thing after are u next lol
exactly...she was on verge of debuting in two groups...and she couldn't cause mhj literally destroyed her chance in both of them. and nearly ruined illit too. and in process of ruining nj (I wish it wont happen. They are very talented and young)
I know mhj had somthing to with youngseo leaving illit i mean she made her leave the original new jeans line up what was stoping her from making youngseo leave illit i am very sad that she left she was my bias 😢
The fact that New Jeans’ parents are siding with MHJ is very embarrassing. It’s clear that they only care for money and stardom…
It was arguably clear from Cookie
What happened during cookie @@vivid_blossoms
@@isha0616that song proly has a double meaning that mhj denied but idk about that bcz I didn't listen to that song often anyway so I can't really tell u if it is a wierd song or not
@@isha0616 they sang a song that had very suggestive lyrics
@@vivid_blossoms true. Even some TH-cam who reacted to cookies said so
Mhj is a professional liar 😆😆😆😆😆😆
My goodness I'm so happy ,thank u so much for the likes ,love u guys 🥰🥰
LMAOO I love this 💀💀
FR
@@chrisprettychu4 I was gonna like yur comment but you have 143 likes I can't ruin that 😭😭
@@Staniel_Protect-NewJeans 😘
@@Staniel_Protect-NewJeansStraykids mentions!!!
All mhj did from the starting to till this date is to play victim card. Dragging all the other hybe group illit ,Lee serefem bts . And new jeans parents are equally bad
She though she could divide the labels under HYBE so they wouldn't all work together to fight her oh how stupid of her they other labels under HYBE are far more united then she thought now she's poked them it's like poking the sleeping Dragon it's now awake, annoyed and hungry
MHJ - professional liar. All her claims look childish. The plagiarism accuations? She's spinning stories rather than stating actual facts about the similarity. IT IS PLAGIARISM.
None of her statements is to the point or direct answer. Everything is a pity story and disconnected from reality.
She didn't even give proof for the plagiarism accusations. I don't even know how people sided with her when she never gave the receipts.
I feel so bad for the girls they dont deserve this 😭😭
Yes, mhj lied SO MUCH in that 1st conference. The lies are just PILING UP.. I remember her saying minji was the only ok trainee and she handpicked the other members while fake crying. Smdh
1- The fact that Source Music made the concept and they made Attention is so funny for me, because the originality claims when she did even do half of the stuff and the ones she did have bland copies
Are we surprised. Originality isn’t something u can spell in the name Min heejin for a reason
have you seen earlier style and pre debut choreography to attention? it was um... more mature and not appropriate for them in my opinion and let's remember that producing isn't everything, she is more as a manager and concept creator than music producer so even tho it was made under source music, i can see changes and well of course the biggest is that there are five members not seven. she did things that can count as half i think but it depends on how we look, if half she ments as only song or song and mv concept
@@twojogoreczek1966 all demos are like that because the HUGE majority are made by wester artists
@@twojogoreczek1966 dance choreo was probably demo for all we know. We can't conclude that thats the final version. It takes a lot of changes to finalise anything anyway. And yea she finalised on 5 members coz her shaman said the other 2 looked possessed loll 💀
then why tf aren’t their names in the credits?? god let’s use thinking skills people
NewJeans’ parents are just as shady as mhj and they got these girls in their web to where I feel NewJeans members are gonna come out the same way as them with them openly supporting mhj too despite all the lying and trash talking she has done to them…shame.
No cus I’m glad more Stan’s realize how messy the parents are. Litterally during cookie I was shocked nobody was saying where are the parents
like i understand wanting to support your children, but if you see that they are living in poor conditions and you don't approve, then take them out of that situation. When you let your child go through and then complain, it looks bad on you(parents) for not protecting your child
Den company is not iven beter if der hold minor kids in dat condticions...
@@AUGHHHHHBBG you know what's the solution for being quiet? of course money and i wouldn't be surprised if she ever paid to newjean's parents to stay quiet and even when no, cookie is a song that is kind of known from newjeans so i dont think that parents would complain if it has big numbers
@@jada.177 I am a parent of a daughter, at the first sign of inappropriate behavior from MHJ pictures on walls, shady dealings my kiddo would have been out of there. I would have approached HYBE for her to stay somewhere away from MHJ but if they said no. My child would be out. That’s my job as a parent. Parents are culpable for not even trying to protect their children. Disgusting.
I personally dont care for either side but damn why do i kinda feel bad for hybe
No cus right. Hybe is a mess but dayum they going through it with this women
Fr I feel bad for hybe and NewJeans
And you also have SM and Kakao messing with them. Everyone is teaming up against them lol
@@meilichankan9282 Res je.
@@meilichankan9282i mean yeah hybe has grown to be bigger than the big 3 so of course other labels will try to take them out
Also let's not forget how everyone was blaming Source Music for the dance cover heels due to the inappropriate choreography (which is true, I completely agree with that, it was inappropriate). But when proof came out about Min Hee Jin being IN Charge of the performance, bunnies said nothing. They defend her as if she was part of the group, the 6th member the gp never knew they had.
Oh really, didn't know MHJ was in charge of that. I'm just glad she'd be out of HYBE sooner or later.
Ker jih Min Heejin drži v šahu zato ne govorijo. Prav tako tudi starši. Min Heejin igra zelo umazano igro.
This is so right??? Its crazy how they suddenly care about whats appropriate and not when it came to that..when they never cared or said anything about cookie or the creepy behaviors of hers since their debut. I believe that witch has put a spell on them and knets
This proves bunnies are 10 year olds. They do nothing but yap
bro as a dancer....i found nthg wrong with somu chreograoghy...it was basic to basic kpop steps.
1- I never saw those medical reports, that was just a big fat bunnies lie to defend MHJS.
Me neither, not that i want to see them, but it is weird that everyone is talking about that and yet is nowhere to be seen...??
Bilo je lepo objavljeno pred časom, kako je Min Heejin preko GSM govorila, da so dekleta debela, lena, da ni nič od njih itd.... Glede trenutne situacije, predvidevam, da bo ta posnetek ponovno prikazan kot dokaz proti Min Heejin. Ne razumem, kako lahko še naprej tako slepo verjamete vsem, kar reče ali stori Min Heejin. Ja temni oblaki se zgrinjajo nad Min Heejin. Kdor visoko leti, nizko pade in to zelo hitro.
@@Arizzu_98 Don't mind them. It's just reports talking about trainees who missed a dance practice because of one injury or the other. Just basic info.
They try to make up a rumor that Bang stop Newjeans album name and gave it to illit because they didn't know how to read. They saw real me and Ador's claim and ran with it.
Yall there on the video of dispatch
tbh I can’t anymore with mhj, just put her in jail alr or something; also I see nothing wrong with adding new members to fifty fifty, im actually excited the ru next members may be joining
But they were still under SOMU and MHJ was *JUST* in charge of branding etc 😂💀. Who is she to say that they were not allowed to be apart of the MV? This woman needs to sit herself down. ✋🏻😂
No cus bunny to bunny, any of y’all who still defending min heejin u are not a bunny cus this women do not care about our girls 😭😭
Also min heejin is so funny to me but kpop Stan’s are even more funny cus like… how do you stare at a bear trap as big as the bear trap in kill this love by blackpink and you STILL step in it 😭😭 like y’all are we joking how y’all proven wrong and STILL spreading lies.
Frr I can't with bunnies who support min heejin. Im not saying hybe is right because they aren't but min heejin is any better
@@Staniel_Protect-NewJeansexactlyyy. Also girl I keep seeing you around 😭😭😭
Like Hybe care 😂😂😂..pls ..
@@ZareSamo-cn8pr Like min heejin cares? Please-
Hybe no cares / MHJ iven less care...same shit ...der only care about MONEEYYYY😊
ay wrile file sory for dat kids..
Couldn’t their parents take them out of the training system if they was mortified by how they was trained and how they was treated? Didn’t they not research in to SOURCE’s training system? Where were these parents when NEWJEANS were dancing too COOKIE?
@@2ndMostUnoriginalUsernameEver somewhere else it was said that minjin allegedly cried on phone to her parents while she was living in those alleged conditions
Y'all this was before hybe acquired source, so this was source training system especially when they were broke at that time and only had gfriend
@@Spiderpunkrocksdoesn’t every subsidiary company under HYBE not have the same training system though?
They don't have the same training system as far as i know. Some parts can be the same, but not the entirety of process. @@_JustArandomMultistan_
@@_JustArandomMultistan_ it was later acquired by hybe ,
Guys and what do y'all think of SM x Kakao mess lol cus it's somehow linked to HYBE as well, kpop companies and CEOs obsession with hybe and BTS is actually crazy
SM is living up to its name as always
Justice for BTS tbh 😭
Like it must be crazy being it boys like that cus those companies are on their MEATTTTT 💀💀💀
Literally in every situation BTS is always mentioned even when they are not even connected to the situation
@@AUGHHHHHBBG anyone who mess up with BTS will lead to their downfall like MHJ who will also lead NJ to their downfall too
Mhj, bunnies, newjeans, and parents are a bunch of clowns😂
Like you? Stop attacking the girls who worked hard for their positions while your here sitting commenting saying that their clowns when clearly you are bc you like to hate on hardworking girls who were taken advantage of and just wanted to be kpop idols.
I am glad the dispute is finally between Hybe & mhj and she is not dragging illit & lesserafim through the mud again. I mean this two groups has become the punching bags of kpop now. It's not even about critiquing their vocals anymore it's about a game of shitting on them in the harshest way possible to completely destroy them mentally cuz I guess that's the new cool trend in the kpop scene right now
Literally!!! I don't fw this anymore tbh cos I tried defending and trying to make people understand not to hate but then yea they don't seem to stop
she literally destroyed so many groups.
illit and lesfim is a known thing
she destroyed svt, NJ, bts, txt, enha by saying hybe pays for brands and albumsales and then after she won she said she was joking.
At the same time svt albums were thrown on streets making it look like her statement was true.
And bts is getting hate(when they are already hated for even breathing) and exols dragged 2016 matter into it and made a fuss.
She even had influence on other company groups especially sm.
The possession part just made me realize just how crazy and mentally ill min hee jin is
Like i know she's a evil but ewww wtf is wrong her
She should go, nobody will hire in vine
Honestly embarrassing how the parents obviously care more about the money than protecting their own children. They complain about certain things but where were they when the girls were singing and performing cookie??
So nj and their parents knew mhj was lying when she said source music wanted to debut lesserafim first and delay new jeans debut when in reality SHE was the one to who delayed new jeans debut.
Mhj and nj parents made a big a deal about the girls not being first hybe group to debut
Mind you all this sserra girls were getting dragged because they chose to lie
I can excuse the nj girls for not telling the truth because they were probabky manipulated by mhj but their parents are grown adults they should know better
Mhj - did anything to fix the situation
Also, Mhj: OH BUT HYBE THO-
Samo Min Heejin.
Lol
i knew this was going to happen after she decided to sue dispatch'
dispatch ain't going down without a fight 😂
Not sure if we can say that the current Hybe CEO actually "FAILED" to acquire SM when reports are coming out that SM and Kakao used unethical and illegal means to block Hybe from the purchase. I mean, you can't say you failed to win when the winners cheated, right?
How did they block HYBE?
@@vivid_blossoms Reports say that when Hybe was trying to purchase SM, Kakao used stock manipulations schemes to inflate the stock prices of SM. It came to the point that Hybe basically backed out bec the made up value was no longer worth it to them. If you google "kakao stock manipulation" you will get more details.
@@vivid_blossoms they bought illegal shares to compete with hybe and used media outlets to write negative articles about hybe and its artists
Lbh, NJs members aren't that special or talented in reality. They can easily be replaced, but after all this drama, I don't think that 'BTS' little sisters' trope will be as popular for marketing because this stain will always be brought up...
Yea
Agreed! NJ is overrated, nothing about them is original like MHJ made them out to be. An overrated group of girls that openly support a liar and a thief. The parents are wrong to supported MHJ. They must be after the $ too.
its just crazy what money can do to parents. i find it odd how njs parents can still defend her, and how bunnies can still defend her. shes a huge problem and kind of creepy imo
She just want a company for FREE. Real evil
This crazy woman must fall and must be out of this industry. ✊
Za vedno.
Also, I wonder what Nj's parents and the members themselves were thinking tbh.
Nič. Še vedno so na strani Min Heejin.
I kinda have a feeling min heejin managed to manipulate them.....
The members have no power.
They have to do what they’re told.
Do you know nothing about K-pop?
Ador Min Hee-jin = the Givers Ahn Sung-il. New Jean's drama is literally a Fifty Fifty Season 2. even the gaslighted parents are the same.
i can't understand why nj can still supprt her on national tv
Wtf der need to suport Hybe ??? Source ...
Mehhh
@@ZareSamo-cn8prno they should stay neutral bcz if mhj goes down they will go down with her because of their support for her😂😂
I think in May, was shown messages where MHJ said different not so good things about NJ girls, and that, if the girls are not thanking her or prise her at the awards shows she will kill them. Of course after the messages went public, MHJ said that everyone knows that's the way, that she is normally talking, and that she joked about killing them, as we all thought, that she wants to become a criminal. But MHJ words didn't sound good, and she definitely may have her own ways to punish the girls.
they should do neither? if it turns out later they and their parents both were being manipulated by that evil narcissistic b*tch I'd still have some pity for them when shit goes down but now it's looks far from manipulation, as if they've joined their hand knowing everything...as the lies comes out more, it'd be very likely that odds would be agInsthrir favour then...unless they're affected by MHJ's voodoo rituals, just like you
We all knew, except the aggressive rabbits, that MHJ was lying about this, about the "originality" and more things and they try to to turn it around because they are exposing the girls, well, if MHJ had not lied I doubt very much for this to be exposed, since it would have no value. The parents seem to only want money, a shame for the girls, but I must say that I am sooo tired of the NJ and their issue....
Karma is a b*tch. In her press conference she left no stone unturned to destroy the image and ruin Hybe, BSH and several new grps including Illit, LSF and TWS.
Now all are coming back to bite her. With three lawsuits on her and maybe more to come, she and NJ both are so going to be out of entertainment scene. Since she started this media play and drama, Ig now she must be enjoying all the drama and accusations pouring in.
Where are the hell are newjeans parents doing
Checking their bank accounts
Defending the groomer
Like, how can they jeopardize their children's career to this extent?
@@royal_bee4534 do you know anything about child stars? Unfortunately, this happens all the time
looking for another to excuse
Park Ji-won, did a lot for HYBE as a CEO. He was the one that managed HYBE to become the biggest entertainment company in Korea, and one of the biggest in the world.
So, saying that he did all wrong in HYBE isn't only untrue, but it's with bad intention.
His job was to expand HYBE and to create the a solid base for the future. Since last year he said that he will leave the CEO position, I am assuming that he ended his contract.
Your comment is putting the former and actual CEO of HYBE in a bad positions, and that isn't fair, nor for them, or for HYBE.
It isn't our position as outsiders to say what they (HYBE), did wrong, or how they needed to do things about the company and the issues with MHJ.
People need to be well informed, so they can know what is happening with the label that owns BTS. They need that, because of BTS, otherwise there are millions of troubles between companies around the world and we don't care, it isn't our problem.
MHJ created a problem with HYBE since BTS members were in military, and the label is fighting back, in the justice system.
Hope everything will be settled, or in the way to be settle down, before BTS members will finish their military next summer.
didn't MHJ also leak her text with the BSH and the ceo of source? But you do it back and its defamation? That's crazy
The textes didn't leak it was placed into cloud and because Min He Jin didn't turn in the laptop to HYBE they went into the cloud and found all the test messages.
@@Disneylover024 either way shes hypocritical
I am convinced that min hee-jin has newjeans parents under her shaman spell😂💀
Lol yes 😂😂
MHJ doesn’t seem very smart to me. We have a Shaman coaching her every step. You have to wonder what other backers she has, the other players in this criminal activity.
It takes a certain level of smartness to look really stupid
MHJ spoiled the girls so hard, that's why parents take her side because they think MHJ really cares about the girls. She did everything to get their trust. and they fell for it. Parents claims are stupid. of course trainees training until 2 am is no new thing. LSF does that too. and every other kpop trainee work their asses off. These girls and parents are so manipulated and its scary. HYBE need to let them go. They don't need them. they have ILLIT, KASTSEYE and LSF. they don't need these women who bites the hands that fed them.
2- The two songs are so alike that is actually crazy, everything from the melody to the beat/instrumental are the same.
The level of Snake-kery is astounding
That's why we don't want minors debuting. As much as it seems that the conditions were horrible, unfortunately that's what happens with most of the trainees in the kpop industry. The parents were worried if their child would debut and they accused source music that they had a contract that guaranteed their debut but I'm reality there's no guarantee in kpop. You can train for years and be in the final lineup but you can be dropped off at the last minute. The parents were worried about the living conditions but that's what happens with most of the kpop companies unless they are from big 3. And when Minji had joined source music then they only had gfriend and they were not even under hybe so obviously they didn't have a budget like they have now.
I also blame parents, if they think the conditions were horrible enough for their child then they should have pulled their child off from source music. Why to blame hybe when they could have protected their child way better. Them praising ador for providing better conditions but forgetting ador is a subsidiary of hybe and they only got the budget because of hybe. I can understand why they would side with mhj here but why would they turn a blind eye towards all the bad deeds mhj has been doing. They are openly criticising Sakura and Chaewon for interrupting their child's debut and again lesserafim is getting dragged into this mess for no reason. They have already debuted and your child has debuted too, why to bring this up now when they already have a hate train behind them. And when source music would sue ador then everyone will say it was lsfm's vocals which got them hate. As if they are not getting hate because of this drama. BS.
1.Believe it or not all the drama is for BTS all the company's have kinda connection with whatever is going on cause they only have one year to take down BTS they tried to did the same thing in 2018
Finger crossed for new fifty fifty members. Old members voices are unique in kpop. Let's see what new members offers
I feel so bad. They were treated amazing and still complained.
@@belaytriksno they weren’t lol? They had their food thrown out in front of them and weren’t adjusting well to Aran’s surgery schedule, ( she was on a ton of pain meds ) then another member had a mental breakdown and they even proved this with medical reports on instagram.
@@parasol3561That's the kpop industry...its fast paced and everyone is replaceable because they are manufactured products...there rarely is any longevity for GGs because they age out as soon as they stop acting/looking like kids...
@@parasol3561 It was stablished that it was not their agency the one that did that. Their agency gave them more freedom than most, that is what I mean.
It’s so ironic to me when the parents & MHJ is so attached or making such a fuss about NJ not being the first hybe gg to debut. When in time & time again they always publicly stated they are independent & NJ has anything to do with hybe. But still they want the title as a first gg of hybe ? 🤣. As you can see they just want the privilage & publicity.
Looks like hybe has become a necessary evil for them, want to destroy them but can't exist without their payola support, lol
If their parents couldn’t bare to see their beloved children like that, they why send them to train at HYBE in the first place? Why did they not bring their own daughters back and save them? I don’t understand their reasoning. Why have they decided to break the silence now? They should’ve done this long ago. It’s partially their fault too if the claims about HYBE neglecting them is true. 💀😂
Vse zaradi denarja.
Important to note that the neglectgul living condition happened way before hybes involvement in source music. So the poor living condition was provided by source music, not hybe. From the new statement from parents the only complaint that we can relate to hybe is the constant push back of the girls debut, which cause lsf to debut first which again mhj is the one who kept pushing back the debut. And the emotional distress the girls went through when celebrity idols joined hybe and feared that they would be replace by them,(obviously refering to sakura and chaewon the never ending obsession from this two istg)
@@Spiderpunkrocks So people are blaming the wrong company?
Some person attacked me online for saying that!
@@_JustArandomMultistan_yup unfortunately people misunderstood again, according to thr timeline even on the official statement the parents only were mentioning source not hybe while talking about the training neglect
We can just say that she didn’t give them
🎵”PERMISSION TO DANCE”🎵😳
i'm sorry but this is the funniest thing I've seen in a long time 💀💀💀
hahahaha. But they didn't need her "permission to dance"
@@BlessingOgunleye-n7mI see what you did there 🫵🏻😏😂
And after yesterday's new scandal (minji living conditions as a trainee) now the fans are watching (evenmore) MHJ as a saviour of the girls 🙃 and they don't even want to blame the parents 😃
Ne najdem pravih besed za te ljudi.
Yeah I’ve always been on the side of fuck MHJ specifically for how she fucked up ILLIT’s debut with hate, sent more unnecessary hate to LSF, and a bunch of other inconsistencies within her narratives. But when I heard about that stuff with Minji I was like my god how could source music do that to Minji? But then I took a second to think. Two things can be true at once. Source Music shouldn’t have pressured Minji into stopping school, they shouldn’t have had her working till 2AM, and they shouldn’t have had her living in that fuck ass dorm. But we also gotta give partial blame to Minji’s mom. Yes I get that you wanted to support your daughters dreams (not a lot of parents do that) and I understand that no other company was taking female trainees at the time, but let’s look at the facts. You wasn’t allowed to see your daughter for a year or wasn’t allowed to visit, that’s the first red flag. She called you at 2AM because she was worried about walking back home at 13 years old at night, another red flag. And then when you finally saw the dorm and saw the mold and cockroaches, that should’ve been the third and final red flag. Your job as a parent is to protect your kids. She should’ve pulled Minji out after seeing and knowing that your daughter was enduring all of that in silence or at the very least, raised these problems to Source Music.
@@kayziofficial right?? Like people likes to speak sh1t about Latin America, but here if your kid is doing something for their future and one of the first things that they tell is that you can't visit your kid... everyone is taking the kid out of there... like... is common sense. And one of the things about parenting is that, sometimes in order to protect your kids you have to take them out of dangerous situations that for them might be like a betrayal, but in the future they will understand that is for a better good
I don't care what anyone says, for me the parents are the first ones to be blame, they're greedy and now they're using all those difficult situations that the kids had to endure, for their own benefit... despicable
@@Arizzu_98 highly agree. It also raises the question of where was the concern when they released Cookie and also, if you didn’t speak up about this before, why do it when MHJ is on the chopping block and Source Music is the one throwing the punches? It makes her look like she’s only doing this for sympathy. I love NewJeans I truly do. But this shit is fucking ridiculous. If anything, that Minji situation should open the door to the conversation about how companies treat their idols and their trainees.
@@kayziofficial partial? I'll say Most blame should go to the parents. This is unfortunately a common occurrence for idol trainees alot even went through so much worse, and I'm not a fan of that so
I'll understand if minjis Mom didn't knew beforehand, but minjis mom fully knows what's going on and even saw for herself but didn't do anything and didn't say anything, it almost seems like it wasn't such a big deal to her at that time, because I know i would've done something. Some trainees and even idols live with their parents or their parents rent them a separate dorm for a better living condition. Or idk any good parent seeing what their young daughter is going through would've pulled them out of the situation, I know I would. But they didn't, mind you minjis Mom had alot to yap but these are the same parents who send an 8 year old minji who can't speak English in Canada BY HERSELF. These are stage parents and they are rarely good parents. And I read somewhere on Reddit that "source is the only agency accepting female trainees at that time" was complete cap, first I think it was hyein or hearin who had that problem not minji, but either way someone aligned the timeline of the girls being accepted in source is the same time Chiquita (or other BM member) got accepted in YG
Also it was revealed that while the new jeans members were under source music they made Haerin Hyein and hanni (minors) dance sexy and suggestive dance moves. Some people were saying that they’re glad that they are in ador because see how much eunchae is being made to do these types of dances. Others were saying that it was fine that it was just dance practice videos but to me it’s not cause they were minors dancing suggestively infront of God knows who (men!! Could be women tho) and were also being recorded too
And it later revealed that it was mhj who was performance director not their ceo
Mhj didnt join at the time they were minors it was 2 years before i dont think hybe even ahd source as a label yet this was still around the late times of gfriend@@april2782
@@luvvs.tillaniemhj joined in 2019 and half of new jeans were minors into their debut majority of them just turned 18 THIS year, what do you mean she wasn't there when they were minors do y'all just make up you lies to defend without doing research
and later revealed that was MHJ doing and recorded as performance director LOL
they hide this until now i m telling u now hybe is really dropping nj
Most likely. They have 4 GGs already; I'llit, Lesserafim, Fromis 9 and Katseye. They won't miss NJ. It'll just be a pity for the girls
After what the parents did I don’t know what else they can do.
The parents ended the girls careers.
@@powbobs ok let s not act like hybe isnt trash no matter what they shouldnt be posting the girls private information it s just not ok but yeah the parent are being brainwashed by that woman
@@royal_bee4534 nj deserve better parent and every single adult in their life failed them only for some cash
@@sarahjyun2044 what private information? they gave them months but they still sided with pedo
now i just wonder what will nj be like if it was a 7 member group under source music that wouldve been cool, and mhj just needs to leave hybe cause nothing is getting better for her cause watch her staff start and close workers start leaving her. Nj parent's need to stop being babies and defend their kids from mhj cause the way she has been putting a bad image on these girls is ew.
I’m not supporting the new fifty fifty but some of y’all gotta chill with the hate. I hope the girls in the group have a good career I just don’t wanna give money to that company. STOP HATING THE ALLEGED MEMBERS
That company did nothing , The givers are to be blamed here and those girl betrayed attrakt because of their greed over the sucess of Cupid even when attrakt gave them a chance to drop the lawsuit and reconcile those girls still refused , The givers manipulated and gaslighted them , so don't blame the company
@@Kitty_missss that's your opinion on this conflict which I respect
It's the Givers not Attrakt, they didn't do anything
Also it’s so weird to me how everyone is like “we can’t support them yet.”
Yet? We don’t even know who they are!
Yeah like not supporting and hating are two different things, why the hate just move on😭...I'd love it for them if they rebrand themselves like Blackswan did, tho
Awesome waiting for the next episode of this drama
As a bunny, I don’t know what to think about this shit anymore. Like genuinely. I can understand if nobody wants to interact with NewJeans after this. All of the adults failed these girls. Every single last one.
New Jeans really had nothing to do with this it was all Min He Jin
Plus she more or less brain washed New Jeans members and their parents into believing her.
@@Disneylover024 I know they have nothing to do with it, but with the way MHJ, their parents, and Bunnies are attacking everyone, it makes sense why nobody wants to interact. Also agree with the brain washing. Been helping MHJ cover up lies
including their parents.
Mhj mentioning riize for copying newjeans, i cant accept it. As much as i hate hybe, but mhj ADOR is way worst
So MHJ shaman has vodoo new jeans the parents korean public...this shaman is very good.
The ones suffering the most from this will be the girls. I feel sorry for them.
Temni oblaki se zgrinjajo nad Min Heejin. Kaj bo še umazanega prišlo na dan. Vedno je dejala, da je to samo "šala". Ta šala jo bo dokončno uničila.
Toxic narcissist and greedy 😏
Everyone talking about the MHJ situation. Im just excited for the new Fifty Fifty debut if its true that Chanelle is going to be a member than way better I also like Yewon too. Oh, and MHJ? She's just a hypocritical liar
😭wtf I am tired of their conflict, I hope newjeans gonna get freedom to this conflict,whyyyyy newjeans parents just siding min hee Jin????
Mhj is laughable parents of new jeans are just as bad
am I the only one who's just realizing that people didn't realize she was lying this entire time I figured out she was lying when she said BTS copied NewJeans how they haven't made any music since NewJeans debuted like everything that she says get exposed and no one has anything to argue with I'm kind of happy because at this point the girls need a better CEO what are their parents doing like what type of parents are these people
I think everyone, even tokkis, know and have known that she lies but everyone is so deep in the hybe hate that they think they have to choose a side instead of admitting both sides suck.
Ko sem to slišala na prvi konferenci sem se stresla, kako podla je ta ženska. In nihče od prisotnih novinarjev jo ni vprašal od kje je dobila namig, da je BTS kopiral njo. In ves čas se dela nedolžno. Vsa umazanija prihaja na dan. Res ta ženska je zrela za psihiatrijo.
Watch the press conference
the conclusion is...they need to and must hate hybe...and the only way is to support mhj
@@luvvs.tillanie you go watch dispatch report .
The only thing I have a problem with with the dispatch article is the vid of the girls dancing inappropriately. Other than that, the article is just stating and giving info/evidence on all the things Min Hee Jin lied about. Mind you, feels like everything at this point.
It is so hard to even think that MHJN is even half of a good person. We all know that a lot of idol companies don't treat their trainees and idols right sometimes. But with MHJN, she seems like ARKATT CEO and how in pic and articles they seem to love their artists and treat them like family. but behind the scenes, they're mistreating them and calling them offensive words.
OMG those videos were beyond disgusting
It’s already been revealed that the Attrakt CEO is not the one who mistreated the girls but instead The Givers (the company who the girls sided with in this whole ordeal). There was no evidence provided by anybody that legally declared Attrakt to be responsible for their “supposed” mistreatment
and new info MHJ was the performance director of it.
Keena was the longtime Attrakt trainee, while the other three were brought in later by Siahn. It seems to me that none of the members are victims and everyones doing what they want to do. Chanelle makes it interesting. I like her a lot. Sio, Aran and Saena will come back someday too. I'm kind of happy for everybody.
I’m supporting Fifty Fifty 🤍
And your supporting and enabling abuse 🎉✨ congratulations 🎉✨
I hate mhj and her supporters for dragging le sserafim, illit, BTS into this matter 🙄🙄🙄🙄🙄
thank you for being so clear.
Yesss Dispatch...I always love you....just take the evil far away from Hybe ...love you dispatch
Poor new jeans, they were good...this could really be a potential downfall for the group
Not a potential, but a spiral downfall. They and their parents have done everything wrong. All for what? They think they can win against HYBE? Especially when they don't have a strong case and only just supporting a liar?
Hopefully they at least have some investments from the money they've received so far
"they were leaked without her knowledge"
I think thats what "leaked" really supposed to be
The test messages were in cloud and when Min He Jin wouldn't turn in the laptop HYBE went into cloud and found everything that Min He Jin said.
민씨의 말은 거의 대부분이 거짓말인 것 같다.
Shame of MHJ & NJ parents.
I think MHJ is preparing NJ for doom without she knowing it because, you can't win everytime.
that's the curse of believing to witchcraft.
The hybe drama will never end
Calling Bang clueless is rather rich for a nobody using an AI
Remember how be lift lab and illit got hate got hate
yeah but idk if source music would debut a 13 year old-
Despatch are paid by Hybe. Need I say anymore how trustworthy they are
MIN HEE JIN BUSTED...MIN HEE JIN BUSTED
Now still some peoples are defending her..
Nj deserve better,,nj are talented
1- Never thought company can release trainees practice videos
2- i think hybe don't like NJ either. Their Plagiarism was shown in national tv while they deleted every article for tws plagiarism accusations
1- They can, they have a contract
1- I mean, companies have all right to release trainees' videos cus the copyright is theirs. Those trainees signed a contract before becoming trainees. It's not new to see companies releasing/using trainees practice videos
2- Idk about tws plagiarism accusations but I don't think they hate NJ particularly, they probably just HATE Mhj to the core after all the shit she made them go through. TWS and NJ case aren't exactly the same thing if you see what I mean
@@meilichankan9282 trainee has contract??
Both tws and nj got copying accusations.
@@user-cj5tm3te7c yes trainees get contracts they signed a contract to be a trainee then they signed another contract when they debut
@@user-cj5tm3te7ctes are from fans while nj is from the group themselves
That's Min Hee Jin's strategy for everything when in doubt just blame HYBE. The woman literally had power over everything from the styling to the music😂😂😂😂
because the truth of the plagiarism she committed was revealed and it was true, then she covered it up by suing hybe. NJ's fans are very disgusting, they are very fanatical in attacking bands from the UK, isn't the plagiarism very visible and should the plagiarism they do not only this from the beginning until now all the plagiarism results are disgusting when I see NJ and his parents are still defending, and is NJ so greedy that leaving their friend who was supposed to debut together at sourcemusic?
Who cares about debut dates, etc. You have PROOF that an employee (MHJ) was plotting to bring down the value and reputation of their boss (Hybe) in order to buy out their own sub-label at a cheaper price. You have PROOF that this employee had people snooping into the finances of the bosses biggest asset (BTS) and was waiting for them to 'leave' before enacting their plan. And apparently, you can't fire this person or at least get a quick decision by the courts? Frankly, I am embarrassed for the Korean police and legal system. What a joke.
MHJ has a severe superiority complex. She had a high paying job with a reputable company and was given a massive budget, excellent working conditions, and full autonomy in her role. But that wasn't enough for her. Whether she is fired or works to the end of her contract, no one in the Kpop industry will ever trust her again.
Please boycott who?...they said the same about illit but look at illit today. Previous fans can boycott all they want , new fans will Stan them as long as they've good music and concept lol
Illit wasn't being abused mentally or physically. . Nor were any health conditions they had worsened so why do y'all think Ill it is a good example?
@@NilynneAdeyemi they were ? they were tormented by everyone
@@RekhaSharma-hh1sv by their company it's so disrespectful to compare a hate train to the serious health and physical abuse that happened to fifty fifty please get grip
This robot voice is a troll.
Nah cuz i thought it was over but wtf😭😭im stayin neutral, dont even know what side to believe. Im pretty sure we'll be seeing documentaries about this whole drama some years later...might be a plot twist too in it
For FIFTY-FIFTY, I wonder if they will
rebranded EVERYTHING, including the group name because what are people gonna view them as? What are they gonna call them? “The new fifty-fifty”? “fifty-fifty2.0”? It’s gonna make the hate train even worse especially for the new members in the group. Also, what if people don’t find the new members “not talented enough” like the other 3 members who left?
BTS BTS AND ARMY BTS BTS 💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜💜OT7👑
Thank you Dispatch
not to bring hate to anyone or their beliefs but why are there so many stories of shamans and other religious leaders telling people to make terrible choices in their life and business? Not all of course but it's getting concerning...
I feel like for FIFTY FIFTY, people shouldn’t boycott the group. the CEO worked hard for them, he sold his car (i saw that in some article) and idk if the members were actually mistreated. think of it in this way. if a member of the group you manage was sneaking about a box full of junk food into their dorm, wouldn’t you be upset? idols have to maintain a specific diet, it’s their job. i’m not saying that idols should eat less, it’s just that they should have a balance.
The CEO selling his car is false and it wasn’t just regular dieting the members faced severe issues due to dieting (one lost her period for months, another had kidney issues, and another had issues with her gallbladder)
If ador keeps this up hybe gonna let newjeans go and min hee jin wont have anybody to steal money from and nj will disband
Meanwhile Dreamcather are like. What is all that drama BS