@Jonny Reed wasnt an argument or reasoning, he just admitting that he has such a strong bias that he couldnt give an objective answer, which is fair enough. ive played in semi-pro back in the day, I would never back the opponents over my own teammates
The chemistry Keane, carragher, neville and Richards have is brilliant. You can't create that chemistry that comes through your tv. Who would have believed those 4 men would provide us with so much entertainment and knowledge of the game. I respect everyone of those men and like to hear their opinions and debates and you can tell they are good mates off camera. There is still only 1 ROY KEANE though haha.
Neville puts himself down too. The actual truth that people forget, Neville was up there with the best right backs on the planet when he played - and was renowned as so around the planet. Neville is too humble and let's the narrative play out (which is banter) but I lived through those years. He was very, very good.
@@manchesterfellow He was good but not "very very good". I watched most of the games in the 90's and early 00's. Remember how many times Fowler absolutely embarrassed him? He couldn't guard world class strikers and they were not even the fastest.
@@duttyburger6528 i agree, but to embarass neville you only need a good forward, not a world class one. Nev was good and solid, but when he met proper good players he wasn't upto the mark
Keane has sort of been rebranded in hindsight as this no nonsense, hard man midfielder. I mean he was that but he was an excellent technical football player. People forget just how good he was. An excellent passer of the ball. Always forward, always quick. Brilliant football brain. In his prime he was one of the best midfield players in the world.
I think because Scholsey was the better passer, Keane was sort of relegated to being the defensive midfielder. He still made runs forward and could finish as well.
I love how some pundits on Sky Sports like, micah, neville and carragher have relaxed Roy and made him open up and enjoy himself when it comes to punditry and help people see the other side of Roy. So happy he is more comfortable in front of the camera and being able to smile.
@@shush4018 not won the league for 10 years yet still the biggest club in the world, they are shite don’t get me wrong but as a club they just defeat everyone
Roy Keane should be viewed as the standard by ALL players. Passion, honesty and humility. There’s a reason he is called the best captain. Not just because of what he accomplished but how he accomplished it. Without a doubt my favourite player to ever exist. His character shines through as a pundit as well. Incredible talent and a gift to the game
As a United fan it's heartbreaking to know how badly things ended between them. If any player epitomised SAF on the pitch, it was Keano. Maybe that's part of the reason they clash because they're so similar. It also shows me that there must've been a strong bond there, for things to be so bad now. You wouldn't hold grudges like this, if you never had genuine love for eachother. We all hoped when Fergie nearly died, it would bring them together. But sadly, looks like it won't ever happen.
@@wehatethemancs7075 JFT 39 Victim FC got us all banned from Europe for 5 years never see Heysel remembered. But Hillsborough where your own scum ticketless fans caused the crush is everyone elses fault but your own? Always the victims never take no responsibility for what happened. Everyone is meant remember it yet you's go and murder 39 Juventus fans and it's forgotten and never your fault. Offended by everything ashamed of nothing. Those poor fans died because of your own scum fans and the blame got passed onto Duckenfield? They were getting in no matter what but nope, not your fault. No one deserves to go to a game and not come home but you's always play the victims it's anyone else's fault just not the scum.
Agree, it is such a shame they have not patched things up - mind you, SAF did kick him out in an awful way, considering what an outstanding player and captain he had been for Utd (from a Liverpool fan).
For being one of the most ruthless and ferocious player on the field, Keane does seem really humble and down to earth off the pitch. What a real professional, and a great man.
It's also part of being Irish. We are raised not to boast, have a big head or think we are better than everyone else. You will lose home support quicker if you are like that. A perfect example is Conor McGregor who is generally hated in Ireland especially in martial art circles. It's one thing being the "big man" in press conferences in Las Vegas. But to act like that at home will lose any support you have. Conor is like the anti Keane.
Die hard Liverpool fan as well. Sane here. I have nothing but respect for the likes of Keane, Neville, SAF. Hated them, but I respected them. It's their passion for the game and the club. Same for Mourinho, Terry, Lampard etc. Something lacking in today's game
Keane was the best captain in PL history for me too, Stevie was massive for us, and will go down as a legend of the English game... But Keane was such a driving force in that United team. Looking at Hendo now, you can see why Roy gave him that chance at Sunderland.
Henderson is a better captain then Gerrard but not a better player Keane is the best captain in premier league history and the league has had some quality captains Jt Sol Campbell Tony Adams Kompany Gerrard Viera but some of them weren’t as good as Keane
This makes you realise that a "Keane and Carragher" duo make an even better partnership than "Neville and Carragher". Sky need to try out this pairing more often, they have a great natural chemistry with one another.
Carra's like the son Keane never wanted but ended up caring for anyway. Probably helps too that Jamie's physically-tough and aggressive and knowledgeable, something Roy can respect.
11:20-12:45 - Carragher is spot on and this why Sir Alex will always go down as the GOAT. Won the European Cup winners cup with Aberdeen. Re-built United as a club from scratch, then went on to build 4 different trophy winning United teams. If he got beat by a new style of play by Wenger or Mourinho - Sir Alex adapted his tactics and won the war overall. If Pep had come to the PL earlier and let’s say won the first couple of league titles like Jose/Wenger did - Sir Alex would have adapted his team and beaten Pep just like he did against Jose. And this is proved in the fact that he did it vs Wenger Mourinho Benitez Ancelotti Mancini. This is what makes him the GOAT.
@@theherogothamneeds1014 Pep's style of play was new at the time in 2009. Same way Jose's was in 2004. Sir Alex adapted every single time. I'm sure if he got the chance to play Pep again in the Premier League he would have adapted and beaten Pep. Ole beat Pep 4 times.
Rangers are in a final to win same as Aberdeen, it's not that busy g a deal as to be evidence of the greatest of all time, he won nothing in his first 5 years which is frankly awful when he moved to the richest club in the world who are already a top team in the top division and only won 2 CL in 30 years of management, these things instantly take him out of the running as the greatest. Good but not greatest, many managers would do what he did at Utd with the money and time he was given.
"A new manager's coming in; for how a great a professional he is and how great a player he is, he could be a problem." Jamie didn't know how right he was...
The one thing I don’t like about Keane’s hindsight is people mainly just remember him as a no nonsense captain, which of course he was and I believe the best there was, but he was also a very good footballer and doesn’t get the credit for that he deserves
@@Chronicles_Of_WA Having one or two of him in midfield would work wonders just to give a bit of foundation and confidence to control the pace of the game
Gerrard always dragged Liverpool by the scruff of the neck over the finish line. The match that comes to mind was in the 07/08 season when Liverpool were struggling against Derby County of all people, Gerrard managed to get a goal in the 90th minute to snatch the win. If it wasn't for his input then Liverpool would've been bouncing about 6th-8th place for years on end.
The fact he needed to shows his lack of tactical awarenes. When your best midfielder is just legging it around the pitch chasing the ball like a 10 year old and listening to the fans yelling 'shooooot', whacking the ball as hard as he can you will need to be dragged to victory Watching Gerrard trying to to reinvent himself as some scouse scholes / pirlo was hilarious. Like a doberman trying to learn how to play chess His slip against Chelsea is Gerrard all over: if it didn't involve putting his foot either through the ball or an opponent he was out of his depth
Actually dislike just how often Roy puts Gary down as a player. She she wasn't a true great. But Roy bangs on about loyalty with the team yet feel how shit it makes Gary feel every time roy underlay his role in uniteds dominant period.
@@mcbc4 I didn't expect this as well, I thought he would be dumb and too loyal to the club (A bit like Neville), but so far he's been doing a good job and not afraid to speak his mind even regarding to liverpool.
I literally live for off the cuff, informal setting type Roy Keane interviews/conversations. I've always adored him as a player but Christ the man is humble, reflective and insightful (almost shy if you've seen him and Neville on their walk!!!) and you'd never marry that to the snarling hard man he was on the pitch. Absolutely TOP man. . .
Well like Rio says he’d be really quiet in the dressing room reading a book relaxed but then when they got out there he became a different person and Rio couldn’t understand it ! Greatest player
To say City and Liverpool have the best rivalry in premier league history is ridiculous. They’re the best 2 teams yes but as an actual rivalry there’s not much there. Like Roy said, they’re nice and hugging after the game. Best rivalry is United/Arsenal easily
Why does hatred have to be such a pre requisite to constitute a rivalry? Just because the players aren’t breaking eachothers legs and the fans aren’t fighting in the stands doesn’t mean it’s not a great rivalry, for me it’s respect and the quality of football and these two teams are beginning to show that perfectly
Keanes words on him being the best captain in premier league history, for me shows why he is the best captain in premier league history. Never let trophies and titles get to his head, never saw himself as better then his team, setting examples for veterans and youngsters alike
Jeez I love these when two people can actually have conversations and one of them not yelling back at the other one trying to prove their point, this was awesome!
What a fantastic episode! Calm and sensible discussions, acknowledging the skill and impact of other Legends and just an overall friendly vibe between two people who were at each other’s throat 20 years ago. Well done Jamie Carragher and Roy Keane 👏.
Man I could listen to these 2 for hours, It's amazing listening to how much the culture of English football has changed. It's almost become very refined and civilised from quite a barbaric/rough around the edges beggining and listening to the stories of very old very real rivalries and attitudes is so intriguing.
Completely agree with Roy here, City vs Liverpool is the greatest competition for the Premier League trophy we've ever seen but they are far from rivals. United vs Arsenal and United vs Liverpool are still the biggest blockbuster rivalries that ever happened in the Prem.
That's genuinely the first time I've seen/heard Keano laugh! He's so serious on Super Sunday and was as a player. But the banter between these pundits is pure gold. Just hope Sky don't mess it up like they did with Soccer Saturday.
I think this is from Keane's changing room POV. From comments made by the class of 92 lot, Eric Harrison and Fergie - "Uncle Gary" was always this sort of busy body, tackling grievances, 'can talk for England' type character
This was brilliant got to agree with Keane on the rivalry thing would definitely like to see a bit more aggression between Liverpool & Man City but I guess the game has changed
@@lfcgero35 Still a very very good team he put out. The top of the pitch should have still been immense. Liverpool just blew them out of the water for most of the game
It’s disgusting seeing two teams that good fighting for honours and being all lovey lovey with each other, even the fans are all over the internet “ohhh I love you”.. They’re both brilliant teams but it’s so boring and soppy, someone slap someone or something, get angry, show passion, not all this dick sucking shit
Yeh defo, i also think that sentiment is mutual as they both have a similar fierce mentality towards the game which is why Roy picked Carra in the "who would you pick in the dugout" question, also Carra's football knowledge is second to none, proper footy anorack.
Roy shows more humility and balance in his answers than so many of the fans who do this sort of thing. People look over him being quite a principled and intelligent person.
Very well said,i like his attitude and must say as a liverpool fan over 30 years if he would in that utd dressing room now they would all be very scared lol
Stevie G would take a smaller team and drag them through. Scholes was like the cherry on top of an already top team and make them elite. Part of a team that controlled games. Scholes would play I'm this City team whereas Gerrard would play in this Liverpool team based on how both teams play.
Different types of players mainly due to their physical attributes. Scholes should be compared to players like modric and xavi as he was that type of cm. Gerrard played rm cm and am in his career. Diff types of players.
@@Keysersoze786 but I think Gerrard could easily play in Scholes role. Of the three, he's probably the more well rounded. I remember him playing playing almost like a regista when the almost won the title with Rodgers and would say he was quite good at it. Distributing the bal and controlling the pace while Henderson took on the midfield runner role
Part of the reason he is the best captain in PL history is his humbleness as displayed perfectly here. No cockiness or over confidence even now when he’s long retired.
@Glinch Carra might not have been one of the greats playing wise but we always loved him. And of course he's one of the greatest analysts in modern football. So take your sanctimonious bullshit somewhere else
I love the fact these two get along. Always thought Keane would have a dislike for Carra because he was a liverpool legend but you can tell Keane has a lot of respect for him. Legends
Gotta love how loyal but honest Keane is. When he realised he was supposed to argue his point of view, he just went yeah I gotta back my boy. Carra doesn’t back his boy for captain😢
what roy said bout “not wanting to let the managers down” is the United DNA that the current united players rn aside from players who thrived under fergie does not possess. and that’s why we’re so embarrassing for the past decade
Had a smile on my face all the way through watching this 😄 , it's just mad but really good watching Carragher and Keano proper getting on and you xan see the respect, and dead funny when they talk the old school stuff. YNWA
@@ds.3577 he's saying that as he doesn't want to appear as biased. He used to do the same thing with fergie v Clough. As Keane if he had to play with one of them who would it be.. you'd know the answer. In fact the thing that Liverpool fans say was Gerrards greatest strength (scoring goals) lampard was better at! Scholes could dictate the game (the flow , the pace) Gerrard couldn't. Gerrard was the best player in an average Liverpool team (or a shit team if you compared them to United the way people compare United to Liverpool now.. ) scholes was for 4/5 years the best player in the best team in England and one of the 1-3 best teams in Europe .
@@monrush i feel like scholes and lamps had more specific skills but gerrard was the better all round player and leader but end of the day its all preferences they’re all legends of the premier league either way.
@@monrush Scholes was never the best player at united ever. From the Keane days to the Rooney Ronaldo ones, he never even won a united player of the year ffs you spew so much waffle, he was a legend just not as good as Stevie and there's nothing wrong with that just accept it and move on.
I would take the Manchester United/Arsenal rivalry of the early 2000's because of the beautiful football both teams played. There was such a high intensity and pace to some of those games that seems to be lacking in the more recent rivalries.
Clicked as fast as i could when i saw Roy Keane's face and name on the thumbnail. This is already one of the best videos ever done in the agree to disagree series
@@MrKAKARONALDOMESSI you my friend need to get a life, who feels the need to make a petty comment because an e was left out of another man’s surname who would walk past you on the street 🤣
Roy Keane was the greatest captain in Premier League history because he had a huge impact on the players. He had to be listened to by Nistelroy and Beckham and Giggs and all the other big names at the time.Who else can achieve something like that in his career..Keans was the last after Ferguson
Liverpool v United...Who wins, and by how many? 👀
Liverpool 3-1 from United fan
Liverpool will hammer us cuz we are fucking shocking 🤣
4-1 Liverpool
Will we get a pizza story?! 🍕
As a Real Madrid fan
Man U will give a tough game against Liverpool cuz they’re trying to be in 4th position and it goes to Liverpool too let’s see
Keane: The few games I played with Scholes
318 games.
I feel that once Klopp retires Wayne ROONEY would replace him
@@SerioussoccerfanYT what lol
Sarcasm
The few [hundred] lol typical Irish
@@SerioussoccerfanYT lol
"Just cause they ran past Gary in training his thinking you've got to sign him up" lmao
lololololo I was rolling on the floor when he said that.
I am choking 😂
Hahahaha
Neville gets no respect🤣
@Jonny Reed wasnt an argument or reasoning, he just admitting that he has such a strong bias that he couldnt give an objective answer, which is fair enough. ive played in semi-pro back in the day, I would never back the opponents over my own teammates
The chemistry Keane, carragher, neville and Richards have is brilliant. You can't create that chemistry that comes through your tv. Who would have believed those 4 men would provide us with so much entertainment and knowledge of the game. I respect everyone of those men and like to hear their opinions and debates and you can tell they are good mates off camera. There is still only 1 ROY KEANE though haha.
@Liverpool FC what
@Liverpool FC what? Lmao
@Liverpool FC what you on about you pleb
@Liverpool FC carragher should be no where near a TV when Liverpool play , the sheer biasm is nauseating, ban him
@@flawlessviiictory that's part of the reason they have him, the massive Liverpool fan base is appeased and improves TV rating
Love Carragher and Keane pitying Neville together 😂😂😂
Neville puts himself down too. The actual truth that people forget, Neville was up there with the best right backs on the planet when he played - and was renowned as so around the planet.
Neville is too humble and let's the narrative play out (which is banter) but I lived through those years. He was very, very good.
@@manchesterfellow He was good but not "very very good". I watched most of the games in the 90's and early 00's. Remember how many times Fowler absolutely embarrassed him? He couldn't guard world class strikers and they were not even the fastest.
@@Legenda20SLO to be fair, fowler would embarrass anyone
He was solid
@@duttyburger6528 i agree, but to embarass neville you only need a good forward, not a world class one. Nev was good and solid, but when he met proper good players he wasn't upto the mark
For such a no nonsense legend like Roy to humbly acknowledge StevieG's impact - this is true sportsmanship
Gerrard was unreal if you put him in Chelsea or United he hands down would of won titles after titles
@@jonlacey316 And I think Roy respects him more because he didn't desert his club
@@jonlacey316 The countless times he carried Liverpool.
Wasn't better than Scholes tho not a chance although he was great.
Better all round player.
Keane has sort of been rebranded in hindsight as this no nonsense, hard man midfielder. I mean he was that but he was an excellent technical football player. People forget just how good he was. An excellent passer of the ball. Always forward, always quick. Brilliant football brain. In his prime he was one of the best midfield players in the world.
he was a complete player. could do a bit of everything really.
I think because Scholsey was the better passer, Keane was sort of relegated to being the defensive midfielder. He still made runs forward and could finish as well.
Speak on itttt
@@ForzaBlucerchiati yes he could... but keane was pretty decent too
@@happychimp1077 the comment I replied to was about Keane 🙄
Love the way Keane says ‘Paaatrick’…makes him sound like a rival from Cork or something!😂😂 Great days with the Keane/Vieira rivalry.
pietrick
😂😂😂
Paaartrick
agree the best era of my life
Golden era
His humility about speaking about his captaincy is testament of his character
He was the guy I always wanted at Liverpool. A no nonsense midfielder and leader. Our team in the 90s would have been very different with him in it.
Wasn't he the manager who bought through Jordan Henderson at Sunderland?
He's an Old hag living off past days.
''don't look at my name'''
th-cam.com/video/BRPTnAu8yYo/w-d-xo.html
As an Irish person, I feel like Roy is one of the best things to ever come out of this country. Love him so much, from a liverpool fan ❤
As a Cork man I agree 😄
@@100ah3 😐
Apart from, of course, him walking out on Ireland in the World Cup then absolutely
@@jm-np4mu he was right to walk out
@@grlfcgombeenhunter2897 agreed
This is the most down to earth content I've seen of Roy 😂 love both of them, great pundits
You'd probably enjoy his first autobiography Keano. It's similar in content / his views
THIS should be the duo. Get rid of Neville
Check out The Overlap on TH-cam.
Neville does a great interview with Keane that goes for about an hour.
Anything of Roy on the Overlap is like this as is the stuff on here with Micah. Carra and him are class together.
Yeh when he first started he was a lot more serious
as a liverpool fan, i absolutely love keane, he’s very honest with himself and united
Yes, so honest about his lacklustre managerial career.
@@CJ0101 not quite as lacklustre as Neville’s
I hated him so mutch in that red shirt, but i love his no bullshit attitude, a great pundit, and sounds like the perfect team player
@@CJ0101 Yeah he should have won the league with sunderland? you are thick arent you?
@@ahmaranwar1488 His managerial record is diabolical and his personal reputation isn't much better. Well done numb nuts.
As a lifelong Liverpool fan, my love for Roy Keane is a peculiar and inexplicable thing
He's just a loveable grouchy fossil.
yeh same it feels so wrong but i just cant hate him atall and sky acquiring micha turned out to be a great move him and roy together are hilarious.
Carra: You're the greatest captain in PL history
Keane: That's slightly over the top
''don't look at my name'''
@@chizo2611 DM me xx
@@DIFFIEH beg
He knows a lot about going over the top.
Yes Gerard slipped on his arse for you.lets be honest Scousers think they are the best at everything Myth
Keane has more loyalty to his former team mates than Giggs had to his own brother
😂😂
Lol giggs loves a bit of minge
😂😂
i feel bad for giggsy, people are gonna dig that up for years lol
@@jmckeev765 How can you feel bad for the piece of garbage, he deserves everything he gets.
Nothing beats hearing two legends reminiscing
Carragher is vile, he spits at people
I see one legend and one wannabe 😉
Can you provide a link
@@zanussidish8144 ?
@@LoneWolfOfHouseStark1989 I've asked the OP a question
I love how some pundits on Sky Sports like, micah, neville and carragher have relaxed Roy and made him open up and enjoy himself when it comes to punditry and help people see the other side of Roy. So happy he is more comfortable in front of the camera and being able to smile.
They are turning our Roy into weak and soyman. We need our old stoic Roy KEANE who wanted nothing standing on his was to acheiving success.
It might be Roy that's changed, I belive it's all of us that have changed.
@@paddyt4043 well I mean everyone changes as they age Roy is no different
I think he's done it off of his own back, had he not softened, he wouldn't have a job within the media.
Love to see this comment
As a Liverpool fan I use to absolutely hate Roy Keane, but since he’s gone into punditry he’s really grew on me
yeah this vid made e warm to him i never iked him i expected fully big arguments and instead keane was agreeing with jamie
I think that’s because you had too watch him win title after title after title whilst Liverpool fans are over the moon cause they’ve seen 1🤦♂️
I had a wart grow on me.
@@fatmenroundme8958 look at united now tho joke of a team
@@shush4018 not won the league for 10 years yet still the biggest club in the world, they are shite don’t get me wrong but as a club they just defeat everyone
Roy Keane should be viewed as the standard by ALL players. Passion, honesty and humility. There’s a reason he is called the best captain. Not just because of what he accomplished but how he accomplished it. Without a doubt my favourite player to ever exist. His character shines through as a pundit as well. Incredible talent and a gift to the game
humility !?
Ask Fergie
Too hothead
As a United fan it's heartbreaking to know how badly things ended between them. If any player epitomised SAF on the pitch, it was Keano. Maybe that's part of the reason they clash because they're so similar. It also shows me that there must've been a strong bond there, for things to be so bad now. You wouldn't hold grudges like this, if you never had genuine love for eachother. We all hoped when Fergie nearly died, it would bring them together. But sadly, looks like it won't ever happen.
Keanoe holds grudges against the world so not surprising 🤣 these are just the same old stories.. Without them we would have nothing to watch 😂
As a Liverpool fan
Nobody cares if your heartbroken you crying Manc.🤣
@@wehatethemancs7075 JFT 39 Victim FC got us all banned from Europe for 5 years never see Heysel remembered. But Hillsborough where your own scum ticketless fans caused the crush is everyone elses fault but your own? Always the victims never take no responsibility for what happened. Everyone is meant remember it yet you's go and murder 39 Juventus fans and it's forgotten and never your fault.
Offended by everything ashamed of nothing.
Those poor fans died because of your own scum fans and the blame got passed onto Duckenfield? They were getting in no matter what but nope, not your fault. No one deserves to go to a game and not come home but you's always play the victims it's anyone else's fault just not the scum.
Agree, it is such a shame they have not patched things up - mind you, SAF did kick him out in an awful way, considering what an outstanding player and captain he had been for Utd (from a Liverpool fan).
Any context for the whole saf n keane past that happened between them??
Keane having a chat with anyone is the stuff dreams are made of
''don't look at my name'''
I wpuld like roy and keane have a chat honestly
Just don't get him talking about United or SAF. It's clear that he holds a HUGE grudge over how he left.
hearing these two talk about football 😍
Ratio
C'mon TH-cam we know you don't watch football
So random for TH-cam to just be chilling
bring back dislikes you nonces
nah no way it's real
For being one of the most ruthless and ferocious player on the field, Keane does seem really humble and down to earth off the pitch.
What a real professional, and a great man.
It's also part of being Irish. We are raised not to boast, have a big head or think we are better than everyone else. You will lose home support quicker if you are like that.
A perfect example is Conor McGregor who is generally hated in Ireland especially in martial art circles. It's one thing being the "big man" in press conferences in Las Vegas. But to act like that at home will lose any support you have. Conor is like the anti Keane.
@@marcmccomiskey summed it up well. I want to see mcgregor pummelled every fight now.
''don't look at my name'''
th-cam.com/video/BRPTnAu8yYo/w-d-xo.html
@@SolidusSnapes I used to be a fan of McGregor, now I love it when he gets his ass beat. Talks too much and he definitely doesn't have it anymore.
Jamie nailed it. Knew exactly what was going to happen with Ronaldo
But at least he scores hat-tricks against semi-professionals in Saudi Arabia!
Die hard Liverpool fan here. I have nothing, but the utmost respect for Roy Keane. Top player both on and off the pitch.
Bet u have connections to Liverpool though
Die hard Liverpool fan as well. Sane here. I have nothing but respect for the likes of Keane, Neville, SAF. Hated them, but I respected them. It's their passion for the game and the club. Same for Mourinho, Terry, Lampard etc. Something lacking in today's game
Keane was so humble in this....respect from a rival fan
As a utd fan I can’t stand it when people justify their opinions by opening the sentence stating what team they support
🤣
As a Liverpool fan I almost missed what you did there.
🤣🤣
@@johnohare992 don't milk it
😂😂😂
There will never be another Roy Keane, favourite player growing up. How much do Man United need a Roy Keane right now.
Casemiro
Keane was the best captain in PL history for me too, Stevie was massive for us, and will go down as a legend of the English game... But Keane was such a driving force in that United team. Looking at Hendo now, you can see why Roy gave him that chance at Sunderland.
Henderson is a better captain then Gerrard but not a better player Keane is the best captain in premier league history and the league has had some quality captains Jt Sol Campbell Tony Adams Kompany Gerrard Viera but some of them weren’t as good as Keane
@@josephcarlsson9063 You know what's make a good captain? Good mental and technical ability. Hendo is not even close to Gerrard .
StevieG was a superhero captain. Roy made his team mates shine more.
Roy keane was like having a modern box to box on the pitch who was also a mini fergie he embodied what SAF wanted in his team he was the heart
@@josephcarlsson9063 did you genuinely just say Henderson is a better captain than Gerrard? Lmao
This makes you realise that a "Keane and Carragher" duo make an even better partnership than "Neville and Carragher". Sky need to try out this pairing more often, they have a great natural chemistry with one another.
Carra's like the son Keane never wanted but ended up caring for anyway. Probably helps too that Jamie's physically-tough and aggressive and knowledgeable, something Roy can respect.
Nah it will be echo chamber, these two got to many similiarities, their banter gonna grow old fast
11:20-12:45 - Carragher is spot on and this why Sir Alex will always go down as the GOAT. Won the European Cup winners cup with Aberdeen. Re-built United as a club from scratch, then went on to build 4 different trophy winning United teams. If he got beat by a new style of play by Wenger or Mourinho - Sir Alex adapted his tactics and won the war overall. If Pep had come to the PL earlier and let’s say won the first couple of league titles like Jose/Wenger did - Sir Alex would have adapted his team and beaten Pep just like he did against Jose. And this is proved in the fact that he did it vs Wenger Mourinho Benitez Ancelotti Mancini. This is what makes him the GOAT.
Keane still holding grudges on fergie that’s the only reason he disagreed
Ferguson lost twice to pep in 2 champions League finals....So I don't agree on adapting and beating him
@@theherogothamneeds1014 Pep's style of play was new at the time in 2009. Same way Jose's was in 2004. Sir Alex adapted every single time. I'm sure if he got the chance to play Pep again in the Premier League he would have adapted and beaten Pep. Ole beat Pep 4 times.
@@shahzadirani and in 2011 his players are not as good as they used to be
Rangers are in a final to win same as Aberdeen, it's not that busy g a deal as to be evidence of the greatest of all time, he won nothing in his first 5 years which is frankly awful when he moved to the richest club in the world who are already a top team in the top division and only won 2 CL in 30 years of management, these things instantly take him out of the running as the greatest. Good but not greatest, many managers would do what he did at Utd with the money and time he was given.
Love this duo. They've a good chemistry on and off the pitch
Have we seen Roy Keane and Micah Richards yet because that would be a good chem as well
When did they have good chemistry on the pitch, having never played together???
@@reck8402 maybe they had the chemistry of potassium and oxygen whilst playing against each other ……
@@reck8402 odd guy
On the pitch ????
"We kick them harder" both of them emphasising that at the same time was hilarious.
"A new manager's coming in; for how a great a professional he is and how great a player he is, he could be a problem." Jamie didn't know how right he was...
Keep these up LadBible they’re Amazing!
When carra and keane meet its more of bantering Neville than the actual chat 😂
u'll be slaughtered by ur owns for saying this
The one thing I don’t like about Keane’s hindsight is people mainly just remember him as a no nonsense captain, which of course he was and I believe the best there was, but he was also a very good footballer and doesn’t get the credit for that he deserves
Unbelievable point… what a passer absolute zingers going into feet and ideal for attacking forward thinking play.. unreal
He's not a flashy footballer, but he never had a bad game.
@@gold9994 what i’d do to have 11 of those at United now
@@Chronicles_Of_WA It'd be really bad because Man city is a well rounded team and Liverpool has 2 great players in Mane and Salah.
@@Chronicles_Of_WA Having one or two of him in midfield would work wonders just to give a bit of foundation and confidence to control the pace of the game
Gerrard always dragged Liverpool by the scruff of the neck over the finish line. The match that comes to mind was in the 07/08 season when Liverpool were struggling against Derby County of all people, Gerrard managed to get a goal in the 90th minute to snatch the win.
If it wasn't for his input then Liverpool would've been bouncing about 6th-8th place for years on end.
Scholes and Gerrard had diff roles though so not sure why anyone compare them
@@Keysersoze786 Talking about an all round midfielder.
The fact he needed to shows his lack of tactical awarenes.
When your best midfielder is just legging it around the pitch chasing the ball like a 10 year old and listening to the fans yelling 'shooooot', whacking the ball as hard as he can you will need to be dragged to victory
Watching Gerrard trying to to reinvent himself as some scouse scholes / pirlo was hilarious. Like a doberman trying to learn how to play chess
His slip against Chelsea is Gerrard all over: if it didn't involve putting his foot either through the ball or an opponent he was out of his depth
Another that comes to mind was the match against crystal palace
@@alansouthall8221 who hurt you?
It's not old school. It's good school. Well said Roy.
This is their best episode so far, in my opinion, to be honest.
"How many times can we milk the same questions in different settings".
Gerrard vs Scholes zzzzzzzz
Interesting that Keane agrees that Stevie is way better though 🤣🤣.
@@eazyollie9370 Keane was never Scholes’ biggest fan. He always rated Ince higher and Butt on a similar level
@@stevendonovan7564 That's because Scholes was shit, he could pass and shoot that's it 🤷🤷
@@eazyollie9370 pretending scholes is shit is just cringe not even pool fans think that lad
@@eazyollie9370 Scholes' peak was after Keane when he got a bit older and came further back from the pitch
Last question about Gary Neville😂😂😂😂
“he’s lacking something obviously”
“Sleep”
“Your a fullback stay in your lane” made me crack up a bit
Actually dislike just how often Roy puts Gary down as a player. She she wasn't a true great. But Roy bangs on about loyalty with the team yet feel how shit it makes Gary feel every time roy underlay his role in uniteds dominant period.
I love how Jamie always brings the best out of his fellow pundits and even makes Roy crack and laugh
It's just Liverpool thing.. he's good at cracking jokes.
Jamie has been a breathe of fresh air, adds value and is a thoughtful pundit. Coming from a United fan I'd never every think I'd say that about him.
@@rianadhitana9508 if its a Liverpool thing he should be good at cracking front doors
@@mcbc4 I didn't expect this as well, I thought he would be dumb and too loyal to the club (A bit like Neville), but so far he's been doing a good job and not afraid to speak his mind even regarding to liverpool.
I literally live for off the cuff, informal setting type Roy Keane interviews/conversations.
I've always adored him as a player but Christ the man is humble, reflective and insightful (almost shy if you've seen him and Neville on their walk!!!) and you'd never marry that to the snarling hard man he was on the pitch.
Absolutely TOP man. . .
Literally?
Well like Rio says he’d be really quiet in the dressing room reading a book relaxed but then when they got out there he became a different person and Rio couldn’t understand it ! Greatest player
To say City and Liverpool have the best rivalry in premier league history is ridiculous. They’re the best 2 teams yes but as an actual rivalry there’s not much there. Like Roy said, they’re nice and hugging after the game. Best rivalry is United/Arsenal easily
Why does hatred have to be such a pre requisite to constitute a rivalry? Just because the players aren’t breaking eachothers legs and the fans aren’t fighting in the stands doesn’t mean it’s not a great rivalry, for me it’s respect and the quality of football and these two teams are beginning to show that perfectly
i have to agree utd and arsenal easliy wins in rivalry terms. Even utd v liverpool has more rivalry especially over a much longer period of time too.
Biggest rivalry in the prem is Man United vs Liverpool easily. It runs deeper than football. Arsenal don't even come close
Who gives a fuckkkk
Even United/MourinhoChelsea rivalry is bigger than this lol. They were passing the titles between them each 1/2 years it’s mad.
Keanes words on him being the best captain in premier league history, for me shows why he is the best captain in premier league history. Never let trophies and titles get to his head, never saw himself as better then his team, setting examples for veterans and youngsters alike
One of the most honest interpretations on the game so many of us love. I’d like to thank you both.
💯
Jeez I love these when two people can actually have conversations and one of them not yelling back at the other one trying to prove their point, this was awesome!
What a fantastic episode! Calm and sensible discussions, acknowledging the skill and impact of other Legends and just an overall friendly vibe between two people who were at each other’s throat 20 years ago.
Well done Jamie Carragher and Roy Keane 👏.
''don't look at my name'''
Man I could listen to these 2 for hours, It's amazing listening to how much the culture of English football has changed. It's almost become very refined and civilised from quite a barbaric/rough around the edges beggining and listening to the stories of very old very real rivalries and attitudes is so intriguing.
Roy clearly in a grand mood for this:)) he’s smiling from the beginning:))
Completely agree with Roy here, City vs Liverpool is the greatest competition for the Premier League trophy we've ever seen but they are far from rivals. United vs Arsenal and United vs Liverpool are still the biggest blockbuster rivalries that ever happened in the Prem.
That's genuinely the first time I've seen/heard Keano laugh! He's so serious on Super Sunday and was as a player. But the banter between these pundits is pure gold. Just hope Sky don't mess it up like they did with Soccer Saturday.
Damn Gary from being a quiet boy at Utd to doing so many things, travelling and knowledge about so many things. What a transformation
I think this is from Keane's changing room POV. From comments made by the class of 92 lot, Eric Harrison and Fergie - "Uncle Gary" was always this sort of busy body, tackling grievances, 'can talk for England' type character
I love seeing Keane in this relaxed tone where he’s not argumentative and the opinions are shared freely and accepted by both parties.
Yeah no Micah Richard laughing his ass off like a muppet
They both approached this with maturity, going past team loyalties and speaking honestly, but showing respect for the others opinions
This was brilliant got to agree with Keane on the rivalry thing would definitely like to see a bit more aggression between Liverpool & Man City but I guess the game has changed
Felt alot more like an old fashioned rivalry in the fa cup, alot more aggression there and dont think I've ever seen city play as scrappy as that
@@darthsidious1959 the player changes pep made was the difference unfortunately.
@@lfcgero35 Still a very very good team he put out. The top of the pitch should have still been immense.
Liverpool just blew them out of the water for most of the game
It’s disgusting seeing two teams that good fighting for honours and being all lovey lovey with each other, even the fans are all over the internet “ohhh I love you”.. They’re both brilliant teams but it’s so boring and soppy, someone slap someone or something, get angry, show passion, not all this dick sucking shit
yeah but i must say, the athletico vs city game brought back that old feel
You can see the respect in Carragher eyes still to this day. A fear/respect for his rival.
Yeh defo, i also think that sentiment is mutual as they both have a similar fierce mentality towards the game which is why Roy picked Carra in the "who would you pick in the dugout" question, also Carra's football knowledge is second to none, proper footy anorack.
"Just because they ran past Gary in training he wanted to sign em up". Hahaha
I'm a Liverpool fan all my life but you can't help but love keano he's a character 🤣
"Your a fullback,stay in your lane" ffs lmao
I don't
Roy shows more humility and balance in his answers than so many of the fans who do this sort of thing. People look over him being quite a principled and intelligent person.
Very well said,i like his attitude and must say as a liverpool fan over 30 years if he would in that utd dressing room now they would all be very scared lol
Stevie G would take a smaller team and drag them through.
Scholes was like the cherry on top of an already top team and make them elite. Part of a team that controlled games.
Scholes would play I'm this City team whereas Gerrard would play in this Liverpool team based on how both teams play.
Different types of players mainly due to their physical attributes. Scholes should be compared to players like modric and xavi as he was that type of cm. Gerrard played rm cm and am in his career. Diff types of players.
@@Keysersoze786 Comparing Scholes and gerrard with Xavi and Modric is like comparing Rooney and Kane with R9 and Gerd muller .
Scholes would play in both Rijkaard & Pep's Barcelona sides while Gerrard would more likely to play in Lucho's
@@Keysersoze786 nope you got destroyed man utd said gerrad can't get out now
@@Keysersoze786 but I think Gerrard could easily play in Scholes role. Of the three, he's probably the more well rounded. I remember him playing playing almost like a regista when the almost won the title with Rodgers and would say he was quite good at it. Distributing the bal and controlling the pace while Henderson took on the midfield runner role
Part of the reason he is the best captain in PL history is his humbleness as displayed perfectly here. No cockiness or over confidence even now when he’s long retired.
7:08 Roy Keane's unbelievable passion for the game is unmatched and I absolutely love it.
roy keane looks in a good mood. never seen him laugh that much.
That interaction at 9:20 is brilliant 🤣
What a discussion. Would love to hear these legends non stop.
i could watch more of this for hours. great fun and genuine insights not useless blather. great stuff
Best one yet! "your a full back, stay in your lane" 😂😂
Boss these clips along with the Overlap, Carra, Keane & Nev are great pundits & characters with great knowlege & humour thrown in the mix.
Both Legends of the game 🔥
carragher? 💀💀💀
@Glinch also put in a world class display against Ac Milan one of the greatest sides ever
@Glinch wouldn’t say he’s a legend of the game but certainly a top player don’t put him on the same bracket as Micheal Keane that’s disrespectful
@Glinch Carra might not have been one of the greats playing wise but we always loved him. And of course he's one of the greatest analysts in modern football. So take your sanctimonious bullshit somewhere else
Definitely, those calling Carra, must have only started watching football a couple years ago.
Never get bored when these two face to face 😂
That was so good. Well done boys. Two greats and a great chat. Simple and totally enjoyable.
Seen Keane like this, so relax, makes smile so much during the whole segment. Jamie admires him a lot..it shows.
Carragher, Keane, Micah and Neville - new hosts for Top Gear = GOLD
I love the fact these two get along. Always thought Keane would have a dislike for Carra because he was a liverpool legend but you can tell Keane has a lot of respect for him. Legends
In their playing days, Roy and Vieira had such a drive that will be very difficult to replicate in modern day football.
When I saw Carragher say Keane was the best captain in PL history I just loudly said “What a sweetheart!”
I’m a Liverpool fan but Arsenal united was a proper rivalry breaking each other up 🔥
Gotta love how loyal but honest Keane is.
When he realised he was supposed to argue his point of view, he just went yeah I gotta back my boy. Carra doesn’t back his boy for captain😢
what roy said bout “not wanting to let the managers down” is the United DNA that the current united players rn aside from players who thrived under fergie does not possess. and that’s why we’re so embarrassing for the past decade
As a Liverpool fan, I have to agree Keane the greatest captain in PL
These two are soo much more similar... 😂😂 hell it's almost poetic they both are good friends with Gary 😂
"You're a fullback, stay in your lane."
LOL
9:17 is so wholesome and cute how Roy complements and finishes Jamie's argument, great chemistry
Love to see Carra being reasonable here tbh. I'm a United but seeing him respect Keane and talks about his leadership and even respect SAF. Respect 👏👌
Carra generally gives non bias opinions, he respects quality players & football over club & teammates
We need a Gerrard, lampard and scholes episode. That would be elite
Your forgetting that Gascoigne was better than them all
@@purpledragons1146 talent wise yeah
Gerrard and Lampard only. Scholes is the most boring person in human history.
Or john terry and Wayne bridge 😂
@@mattyreynolds4243 Agreed, talent wise, not longevity by a long shot!
Had a smile on my face all the way through watching this 😄 , it's just mad but really good watching Carragher and Keano proper getting on and you xan see the respect, and dead funny when they talk the old school stuff. YNWA
This one’s gunna be good haha
Even Roy Keane knew Gerrard was different class.
Yep only picked scholes because of ‘loyalty’ respect to roy says it how it is
@@ds.3577 he's saying that as he doesn't want to appear as biased. He used to do the same thing with fergie v Clough. As Keane if he had to play with one of them who would it be.. you'd know the answer. In fact the thing that Liverpool fans say was Gerrards greatest strength (scoring goals) lampard was better at! Scholes could dictate the game (the flow , the pace) Gerrard couldn't. Gerrard was the best player in an average Liverpool team (or a shit team if you compared them to United the way people compare United to Liverpool now.. ) scholes was for 4/5 years the best player in the best team in England and one of the 1-3 best teams in Europe .
@@ds.3577 they played diff positions tbh Scholes is more comparable to modric or xavi and Gerrard to lampard for eg.
@@monrush i feel like scholes and lamps had more specific skills but gerrard was the better all round player and leader but end of the day its all preferences they’re all legends of the premier league either way.
@@monrush Scholes was never the best player at united ever. From the Keane days to the Rooney Ronaldo ones, he never even won a united player of the year ffs you spew so much waffle, he was a legend just not as good as Stevie and there's nothing wrong with that just accept it and move on.
Roy is an inspiration...the memories will live forever....the best captain in Premier League history, no doubt
I would take the Manchester United/Arsenal rivalry of the early 2000's because of the beautiful football both teams played. There was such a high intensity and pace to some of those games that seems to be lacking in the more recent rivalries.
Not to mention OG Old Trafford and Highbury.
Roy Keane smiling and being chill is somewhat funny. I`ve never seen the man have a good time before.
The amount of respect on that table is insane 💯 ..
11:26 Sir Alex and Roy Keane the greatest heartbreak story of all time. And Roy still haven't forgiven Sir Alex!
As a Man Utd fan I just hope that both of them patch up before Sir Alex is gone. Both were a big part of each other's success.
Clicked as fast as i could when i saw Roy Keane's face and name on the thumbnail. This is already one of the best videos ever done in the agree to disagree series
“He never said a word” 😂😂😂 Roy kean is a bloody character mate
It's Roy Keane at least get the name right 🤣
@@MrKAKARONALDOMESSI you my friend need to get a life, who feels the need to make a petty comment because an e was left out of another man’s surname who would walk past you on the street 🤣
Carragher’s insights are always spot on, club loyalties aside
His football knowledge is also huge.
8:49: “y’alright Neymar yeah sunny innit”
Roy Keane was the greatest captain in Premier League history because he had a huge impact on the players. He had to be listened to by Nistelroy and Beckham and Giggs and all the other big names at the time.Who else can achieve something like that in his career..Keans was the last after Ferguson
Weird seeing Keane like this! Love it