Johannesburg's Shack City | Carte Blanche | M-Net
ฝัง
- เผยแพร่เมื่อ 1 เม.ย. 2024
- 𝗧𝗵𝗶𝘀 𝘀𝘁𝗼𝗿𝘆 𝗼𝗿𝗶𝗴𝗶𝗻𝗮𝗹𝗹𝘆 𝗮𝗶𝗿𝗲𝗱 𝗼𝗻 𝟯𝟭 𝗠𝗮𝗿𝗰𝗵 𝟮𝟬𝟮𝟰.
The City of Johannesburg (COJ) is building an informal settlement for displaced residents. With a 500 000 housing backlog, the city has repeatedly failed to deliver on its housing projects, leaving thousands of residents without adequate homes. Last year, when 77 people died in a massive blaze at the Usindiso building downtown, the city’s skewed priorities and lack of preparedness were exposed. Every municipality is required to provide temporary shelters for residents caught in a major disaster - but the COJ hadn’t made any arrangements. So, it built 300 one-room, paper-thin tin shacks at an eye-watering R4.2 million. But should shacks cost ratepayers millions of rands? Carte Blanche investigates.
Find more exclusive content on Carte Blanche: The Podcast: linktr.ee/carteblanchetv
---
Visit the Carte Blanche official site: mnet.dstv.com/show/carte-blanche
Find us on Catch Up: bit.ly/32VvbU5
Stream the show live on the DStv Stream app: bit.ly/3l92LhH
Watch more series and movies on Showmax, start your 14-day free trial here: bit.ly/36PFSr0
Get DStv: bit.ly/3edx58V
Like Carte Blanche on Facebook: / carteblanchetv
Follow Carte Blanche on Twitter: / carteblanchetv
Be a fan on Instagram: / carteblanchetv
#carteblanche #southafrica #news #investigation #housing #house #disaster #humanrights
*NB: Please read our rules before commenting.
Please alert us by emailing report@carteblanche.co.za should you see any comments or threads that contain the below:
Racist and/or homophobic comments will not be tolerated and users will be banned immediately.
1. Hate speech, defamation & hostility inciting comments.
2. Harassing (incl. sexual), threatening, embarrassing, swearing at, or abusing of another participant.
3. Acting as employees of Carte Blanche.
4. Spam links or comments.
5. Crude or offensive language.
Your privacy is important to us. Please do not share personal details in the comments as they will be removed for your safety.
Might be worth taking a look at Vienna social housing when talking about the topic of handling lower and middle income housing.
The city owns most of the land, builds it all up, and rent is pretty low.
@@Masterrunescapeer Yes, but that's with population decline.
L
I do not understand the logic behind building shacks instead of fixing existing buildings. It is clear the contempt the government has for citizens.
Those existing buildings are for the comrades once EWC kicks in... they've got to eat, you know!
remember my friend if they fix or build proper housing that means they wont be chowing the state money on those
Heres the logic. The person in charge of building those shacks probably charged them R200k per unit
As soon as any building is renovated for people to live in, you'll have various groups demanding that they are given that accommodation for free, or they'll just hijack the building before any else is allowed to move in.
my Jaw is on the floor thinking the same thing. common sense has left our government. wow!! i'm in disbelief
4.2M for informal settlements 😮... ANC is slapping us with no shame at all.
That's is corruption.Everyone must earn in this procedure...
@@adrianolszewski231 ITS EXTORTION
@@adrianolszewski231😂
Is it just me or are the financial figures provided by this guy reminiscent of... that R24-million+ FLAG situation??😮😮
3.2M it's gone because each zozo cost R3 500 x 300 zozos =R 1,050,000 😢
R68k for a shack that size?? With the building material of that quality?? This government is a disgrace
😂
Is it just me or are the financial figures provided by this guy reminiscent of... that R24-million+ FLAG situation??😮😮
The Apartheid Govt did more for these people than the “ great” ANC
of Mandela and his cohorts have ever done. Communism cannot prevail. What has the vote given these scavengers? Nil Nothing
Money laundering by the NGO companies they own. Pure theft of our VAT money.
That's the rain bow nation for you
One more reason not to vote for ANC
Those people will say viva anc
Joburg is run by the DA
@RAMAJACO02072 ok comrade 😂
@ramajaco02072 They don’t wanna hear the truth. Not do they want to do their homework.
You just hate ANC, or you forgot that Joburg is under coalition? What all the parties that are in that coalition because they were all there when people moved to that place. DA, EFF, PA, ANC and other small parties
For half that budget they could've bought 300 container homes properly converted to suit the needs of the people - at R7000 per container with proper safe structure. What they have given and what we have paid for is clear tender corruption.
How will the comrades eat if they build proper housing?
Wow, that's WAY above the brain capacity of those city employees.
But you are 100% correct.
until you get the tender, all of this is just pep talk.
I'm against what they anc government is doing. But then again I have never seen a container costing R7 000. I have been looking for one for the passed 2years to use for business and the cheapest quote I got for a normal container is R20 000. So please refer me where I can buy that 7k container without being scammed. Thank you
@@tendamudzimugoza5402 I also know containers to range from R25k
Instead of complaining about ANC, vote them out.
If only was as sensible as you brother we would have a different S.A. unfortunately these very people will vote and campaign for the cANCer
@@mohsinjoe8617 Low self-esteem on a national scale
Remember this on the 29th of May.
😂 Sure they will
Carte Blanche is doing the lords work with these latest episodes. They all serve as a reminder to vote wisely. The ANC must fall!
Noo man arrest this people
It hurts so badly to witness unbridled corruption what a disgrace!
It's sad!!! These tin foil boxes is what the ANC Government personnel should have to live in while their home are given to these poor people. While they wait in for permanent housing 🤷🏼♀️
So...what do you suggest ??? Stop criticising and come up with practical selutions
@truth-Hurts375 subsidize family Planning instead of promoting child grants alone so that children are not born into destitution and deprivation to start their lives. To promote the family unit and parenting. To Educate people to understand basic numeracy and financial literacy. Hold thieving politicians to scrutiny and account for taking what should go to the people. Educate people so they grasp what things really cost the taxpaying populace. To stop telling people to expect free things. Nothing is Free! Everyone who is able should contribute something! Like keeping ones environment clean, keeping an eye out for another, being responsible for oneself instead of making welfare an ideal.
That's correct ! Yet the saddest part is that portable water or recycled water is the one killer in Johannesburg ! The city will never have fresh water flowing through the infrastructure every again without turning Johannesburg Metropolitan City back into agriculture sector with greenhouse oasis rooftops and windmills
We all deserve to live in dignity, whether rich or poor. There is no dignity in forcing poor people to live like this. Especially when you consider the money used to make all this happen comes from our salaries. LOL 5 star, what is this guy talking about.
"An evil man, will burn his own nation to the ground….to rule over the ashes. “
100%
ANC can’t even build shacks right 😭
😂😅😂
It just shows their incompetence
Joburg is run be the DA
They are that incomplete
Worldclass journalism
The fact that ppl are still voting ANC into power puzzles me every time.
It crazy. People must blame themselves after 29th May. No one must feel sorry for them from that point.
More than 68000 for shack😮!!! Then how come there are so many shacks in this country when they are so expensive 😅
Inflated prices to later collect their cut from whoever got the "tender ". But God's not sleeping...
😂
136k for double storey 😂
Am sensing that this spokesperson is one of the beneficiaries of the tender, not comprehending anything that Claire was telling him about what she witnessed on that site. Truly upsetting.
No ways man!!! These folks are wasting taxpayers money, the grin on this COJ person is just appalling, this makes me SICK!!! No man 😢 this is a sad reality for our country.
😂
Is it just me or are the financial figures provided by this guy reminiscent of... that R24-million+ FLAG situation??😮😮
This is infuriating when I think of how much I’m being taxed every month 😡 😤
Stop taking a lotto and get a job in the anc,you will definitely have more chance of becoming a millionaire.
The lack of long term planning. The lack of consideration to uphold human dignity. Don’t these people want to be proud of the work that they do? This is crazy.
These ANC people have completely lost their minds
😂😂😂... ANC never fails to Dissapoint.
ANC is failing. They must go
I worked on a project in 2017 where we earmarked state-owned buildings in the inner city that would be used for affordable rental, gentrification and emergency relief but here we ae 7 years later and still nothing has been done
This ANC government is a true disgrace!!🚮🚮this deputy director is beyond tone deaf, if not deliberately dismissive of his own people' s suffering- what sane human finds these conditions in habitable? Claire should've asked him if he'd be comfortable living there.
Yrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrrr!!!! This is what our leaders think of people.
The contractor is smiling all the way to bank.
😂
Brooo😭
For someone who is showing case the beauty of Africa on our TH-cam channel, this is heartbreaking.
And the tax payer must keep on coughing up money.
My husband just told me that he spend around R15 000 in taxes each month, ie income tax and value added tax on fuel and groceries.
It is one person's monthly income we lose to this sod of a government.....
@@t-worx4458oh so his gross salary is around 60k per month. But who's calculating the VAT, that's just depressing and time consuming, you pay on everything VAT, to the exception of some things that no one buys😂
As the people shall govern so shall the people pay for it
Let's be honest most who vote for ruling party..dont pay tax or never have in there lives ...
To help illegals.
Great that you involved Heather Dodd. She has the know-how and experience and is a voice to listen to, to take this in the right direction!
My goodness I am dissapointed at the City of Johannesburg's planning, is this really the best they could do with all the resources they have at their disposal 😢.. That spokesperson is also delusional there has never been a 'temporary' shelter in Jozi, it's only a matter of time before it becomes a permanent fixture to Joburgs inner city living standards.. very poor job for the self proclaimed world class African city...
what do you expect in a country run by greedy pensioners,
This ANC is really chowing peoples money right in front of us while watching.
Yet we still vote fir them! We only have ourselves to blame. They must go out this year!
Anc and the tenders are really stealing from us 😢😢😢
Is it just me or are the financial figures provided by this guy reminiscent of... that R24-million+ FLAG situation??😮😮
@@thamim7935 I guess the rest want into his pockets
The cheek in Modingwane's responses. Amazing. He really represents his Master glaringly.
I gasped!
I need carte blanche to broadcast everything as we're going to elections next month
As a young south african, I appeal to you as Carte Blanche to flies a lawsuit against the Johannesburg Municipality and follow through to ensure that doesn't happen to others. As a young south african, there is nothing that I can do to combat this, but as Carte Blanc you can. I beg, let those in need not continue to suffer in the hands of this cripled state. Fight for the rights of the people, I believe that you will prosper!
Carte Blanche and the rest of DSTV is owned by Nasionale Pers (press) which own all the news publications...so they wont do/say anything the Broederbond I mean FF+ dont want done or said ..
Of course you, young South African, have the power to change this country!! By participating in the elections to get these greedy b@$736@$ off their high rotten pedistal.
You go vote for any party except the ANC, EFF and MK(just as sod as ANC). As none of them are for their own people, but their pockets.
You have the power to change, but YOU have to vote for it. That is the ONLY way, other than bloodshed in war.
I beg to disagree! As young people, *you have the power to effect immediate change and demand accountability* by taking to the streets on sustained monthly (at the very least), respectfully orchestrated protests. It is so disappointing to see our young people sitting back, waiting for the change to come. It's never going to happen. Worse, is the young people who celebrate the thieves in government as they flaunt their ill gotten gains - the bling brigades!
As a Black person myself, who struggled to raise funding through government programmes to start my own business simply because I am not politically connected, then securing the investment privately (yes, from white people!), and then making a success of my business, but needing to take painstaking measures to live as simply as possible because others unjustly assume that I am where I am because of BEE or political connections, it's doubly infuriating. I don't want to be associated with that bunch but because of the colour of my skin, I am.
If young people were/are actively working to change the exploitation of the poorest of the poor, we wouldn't be having the problems we have. I speak to my staff repeatedly, they agree but just don't have the incentive to work to bring about the change we need. I can assure you, that investors are eager to invest in SA, but they cannot do so with the criminals running the country (Please don't get me wrong, I am against the DA and it's pro-West stance. Many Europeans I know are themselves sick of living under the yoke of the US with their weak complaisant governments!).
Our problems are not insurmountable, but again, it's you young people that must drive the change!
Sad part of it is that the same poor victims who are subjected to these living conditions will vote for ANC with not hesitation. Poor people and ANC isinkwa ne butter
Margerine 😂
Now this is gut wrenching 💔
Thanx - I no longer live in Johannesburg - talk about a scam city - this is it
It's really sad 😭💔 and heartbreaking with what is happening with a black child 😢😢
All these people find themselves in this situation because they have no regard for the rule of law. If they have not occupied the building illegally they will not be in this position.
The building was not hijacked by them. They were renting from the hijacker.
@@amukelaninkuna8180 They were still there illegally.
@@amukelaninkuna8180 An accomplice is a cooperator or participator, commonly in criminal acts.
Thank you for mentioning this. We must just be comfortable with lawlessness. And the makeup of those people are usually illegal immigrants also.
The level of callouse you have to be to blame poor people for a lack of affordable housing.
The ANC government built 300 flimsy Spaza shops for people to live in and what looks like 15 toilets 😢😢😢
No chance of anything solid happening under the ANC…
Time to vote em out
These crooks have found a new money making scheme.
A very fast one. How to steal 50 thousand in 5 MINUTES ?
Earmarking buildings that are suitable for accommodation is the ANC speak for "we first need to figure out how to maximise the project budget so that the income of various cadre's can be ensured"
Nice job ANC..tidy profit mark up..line you're own pockets..So much faith in you're party..NOT..shame on you.
Is it just me or are the financial figures provided by this guy reminiscent of... that R24-million+ FLAG situation??😮😮
Why are we not using old shipping containers for housing for the poor?
They cost more.
Do the math.
Someone please compare the affordable housing built by the ANC vs the DA. I want to see something
The DA is no better. Come see what they're up to in Cape Town 🚮. They are a huge contributor to uprooting people from homes, to make way for those who are looking for investments, instead of homes. This country had failed it's citizens- in Canada is wasn't frowned upon when a moratorium was placed on foreign home ownership to allow for locals to be sheltered and own homes. Here every foreign owner have free reigns, in the name of boosting the economy. 🚮
That's would the private sector in the western cape, and employing people. The ANC find another way to loot😂
What about the solid brick built buildings of the apartheid era?. Still fit for purpose 50 to 70 years or more down the line.
As a "Native South African Citizen" 47yrs old... I strongly can't argue nor question that statement!!😢 Mkhonto weSizwe clearly means... Putting a spear into the heart and soul of The SA Nation!😢
Even a 2nd year student would tell you that they would love working for companies working and getting these tenders
For that price a suitable 3 room concrete house can be built with proper running water and sanitary 🚻 for the people yes this can be done
Getting rid of shacks is just one big fat lie of the ANC
What's going on here? 4 million South African Rands down the toilet.
😂😂 You mean... "down the Zink"!!😂😂
@@thamim7935good one😅
This is so heart-wrenching. Do we have no compassion for our people?
Why are these particular people given *any* free housing? 'coz they invaded a property that then burnt down? What about those who live in even worse conditions & didn't invade any buildings?
The ANC will really regret this. The youth ?? Yoh
The reason why government cannot convert existing inner city buildings into habitable living spaces is the amount of bureaucracy building policies and regulations they have to deal with to get planning approval to convert these buildings. The money is there, the empty buildings are there but the planning approvals are not.
It’s easier to build a shack because there’s no planning or building rules to deal with.
R14,000 per shack How is this even possible? These tin cans are a Lesufi disgrace. What about all the existing buildings?
Is it just me or are the financial figures provided by this guy reminiscent of... that R24-million+ FLAG situation??😮😮
After he mentioned R14000 I just dropped my Jaws straight..Clear tender corruption at play.Always creating "Sustainable" channels to Loot 💔
DAS LIKE 4 SHACKS😭
Unfortunately these people have got exactly what they voted for… 😢
Exactly this! They voted all while, ignoring the government's early on signs of blatant corruption, self enrichment and stealing of state funds. Yet here we are.
😂
Most people didn't vote😢
@@WalterWhite-bc8ck That's even worse
Beggars can't be choosers 😂😂
This is some in your face type of corruption 😳😧
This is embarrassing 😮. A municipality should never resort to housing people in a formal settlement
Well at least it's not informal 😂 you get what you vote for I guess
ANC failed us.
Dumping people in inadequate shelters far away from their jobs and communities, with no services, no local shops or schools or clinics. Straight out of the Apartheid urban planning manual. Shame on you Gauteng.
At this rate, the thieves are on the verge of carrying the ANC away...
Know what is ironic...come May 29th they vote for same people who put them there...brilliant 🇿🇦
The contractor made approx 2.7 million in his pocket if each shack cost R5000.00. WOW
Bless him shame 😂
Everything that is happening in South Africa Its Like a Movie😂😂
😂
On repeat
Mind boggling....Wow...ANC at it as always....ANC voteshedding!!!
The hefty expenditure on temporary shacks that will later on get demolished does not sit right with me. The disrespect tax payers are subjected to in this country is disgusting.
Who really believes there is any money in the disaster fund definitely not me
R68 mil for 1000 shacks and to buy councilors and ministers the latest S-Class or 7 series
G wagon 😂
This is disgusting you hear mee absolutely disgusting! I am so angry to see this. How pathetic of the so called provincial government. I can assure that corruption is involved. I don't stand behind this. I'm disgusted!!
This is also an indication, apart from how much money has been spent questionably, that the money has run dry for corruption. The money has been stolen and lost and none is left.
So true bcoz a mere R4 million was Parking Lot change to these Tender Looters 2years ago!!😮
Shameless . I cannot stand the ANC . I mean how money hungry can you be 😭😭😭. Lord help our country
About what I am living in, mine cost 20K 9 years ago, not one penny from the state
Wow this how they treat poor people 😢😢😢
Kwenzakalani eMzansi 🙏🙆🙆🙆, this guy!!!! Why esasebenza?
Bru! and he even has a smirk on his face naye uyabona ukuthi ayikho lento ayichazayo there's nothing to defend. I just wish he could go and live there for at least two weeks and experience first hand what people are going through.
These shacks will blow away just by mere wind
Im proudly 🇿🇼Zimbabwean, the rest is history.
I really am disgusted by my country
Wow, this must certainly be the final straw 😔
Nkosinathi doesn't know the price of a 1 room shack. A 1room shack is sold at R3000-3500. 1 and half room is sold at R3500-R4000. 2room is sold at R4000-R4500.
Denver out of all places... Flip that shack is R4000
South Africa is a shadow of its former self. I mean who would come up with such a scheme?
Yhaaa...this is what we belong on this shacks but politicians keep saying vote for me
Theres something wrong with the tap water East of the JHB cbd. I was sick along with my household and neighbors in the street. Water in the Yeoville resovoir needs to be tested.
Dead body
And this has to do with what exactly 😂 is it related to the shack honorable member 😂
What do you think 🤔 the test would cost 😂
@@Matlin1 Clean water isn't important.
World Class Journalism
These shacks are too close to each other a fire can easily ravage this area.
corruption everywhere, sickening
What kind of **t is this?
Amandla Born Free! AMANDLA!
Some things will never change
That's just the way it is 😂
This is how the anc blesses their supporters.
And... tada!! They will yet again vote for the ANC.....😂😂
They've really stepped up, from free t-shirt to free shack 😂
People in jail got better accommodation.our can the government let people stay in something like that we really going backwards in South Africa.
Yooooo our country is going down the drain💔
Consequences of chasing wealthy people out of SA?
Anyone who swallows the contractor's SPIN is an unadulterated FOOL or COMPLICIT in the FRAUD.
the only way to fix this country and get rid of the ANC is to have people use their TAX Income number to register to vote and not their ID numbers. We have a total of 27 Million people living off grants in this country, but only 7 million people pay tax..... that alone explains the whole situation
Ok so implement this then
I struggle to understand born frees who live in shacks. As a young person with freedom there is so much opportunity. You just have to take it
spoken from privilege
You're a deluded individual.
@exposeANCFraudNOW Oh I love me a buzzword....privilege
@exposeAfrikanerFraudNOW I am a black man born in the late 90s. I grew up in one of the most dangerous townships in Cape Town. I had childhood friends who didn't make it to adulthood. Unlike most of my peers I took the opportunities given to me. People will blame everyone but themselves.
@@caven7056just shut up
Please send this to SCOPA strictly Corruption R14 000 for dis 2by2 square metre its a fugazi
It's disappointing to see some ppl living in such situations but that what we voted for as our democracy