é muito bom ver a Fernanda falando inglês mas não falando para os gringos, ela continua falando para nós, acho que no fundo ela tem uma consciência de que pros gringos é só um momento exótico o que esse filme tá causando, mas pra nós é outra coisa, é outro patamar
@@jonasguerizoli7857 She is THE GOAT! You nailed ... it bring me tears on seeing her respect and the bless that she has on having her mother still alive and acting ... what a honor. Loved when she said: You do not cut "my mom's" scene ...lol
Possibly a major global power, maybe close to what China is today, which would go against US hegemony in the americas. And to think some brazilians still support the coup.
Estaria bem melhor, com toda certeza, pq apesar da ditadura ter tentado trazer avanços industriais, eles fizeram tudo isso da forma mais porca possível e com emprestimos estrangeiros, oq lançou o país em uma terrível crise econômico nos anos seguintes após a redemocratização. A ditadura trouxe mais atrasos econômicos e culturais, do que avanços
Minha família naquela época era muito pobre e despolitizada, como a maioria dos manipulados velhos e que eram adolescentes cegos naquela época. O que fez minha família perceber que algo estava TOTALMENTE ERRADO foi quando meu bisavô, trabalhador de obra e chão de fábrica também, simplesmente SUMIU do dia para a noite. Ninguém soube onde ele foi, o que ocorreu, se ele tinha sido assassinado, roubado, enfim... duas/três semanas depois ele reaparece, não queria falar muito sobre o que tinha acontecido com ele nessas semanas, mas ele contou porquê tinha sido pego pelos militares, ele cometeu o grande crime de: Ficar parado na esquina depois do serviço de 10h dele para conversar com os colegas. Esse foi o crime e a razão na qual meu bisavô sumiu por 2 semanas, e sabe-se lá o que fizeram com ele nesse período, mas ele voltou BEM abalado. E o mais nojento na minha opinião, é a galera do "Deus Pátria Família e LIBERDADE" terem a pachorra de se dizerem tão a favor da ""liberdade"" enquanto querem a volta de um tempo vil, nojento e cruel da nossa história. Imagina dizer que é da "liberdade" enquanto somem e te torturam por coisas tão banais quanto ficar no meio da rua. Eu estudei, entedo nossa história e digo: NUNCA. MAIS.
Esse povo que defende a ditadura é imbecil, não sabem o que foi aquele tempo... não sabem o absurdo que defendem. Ficam na rua pedindo intervenção e quando a polícia apreende gritam por liberdade de expressão. Não fazem o menor sentido. Burros, ignorantes, que se acham inteligentes... o pior tipo. É o boi comemorando o churrasco.
Bandido é isso.. fala a merda que for pra se manter.. RESTA A GNT FAZER JUSTICA PQ A POLICIA É BANDIDO TB. Confia e vai!! Independente do imbecil que aparecer
This is relevant to the cold war but the people who had their family members kidnapped and killed couldn’t care less about who were backing their authoritarian government. This is about Brazil, and not the US. It feels like Americans somehow have to make everything about them first.
@matheusp572 That is not my point. My point is that, first and formost, they did and still do pay for corruption and violance in foreign governments worldwide. And this is very relevant to everybody, not only for us to be able to understand History, but also for us to undersand the present, as their foreign politics is still a problem right now, specialy to the global south, 'cause their ways of doing foreign politics by financing corruption and war worldwide has not changed. Other than that it is a very relevant information to add, as the title of the video seem to use a very common tone when talking about the countries in the global south, that is that they (we) lack something, either it be the capacity to rule and organize themselves as a society or moral principles to do it. Either way, it is akin to biological racism, that treat other cultures and peoples as "the strangers", the strange other, in the same line of thought that thinks "the savages" or the "unfathomable east". In other words, it implies prejudice.
@@matheusp572no my dear friend,we brazilians know in fact,that the participation of yoyr govenement in this horrofing moment in our history is above the mere finacial support ,your fellas not just train the "interrogators" but also pratice in our country some "experimental metods" of "getting the true out of peapol"...the us involvement is clear to everyone that is down here in south america,not just in brazil but in every country in this continent
@@matheusp572 The US was the one responsible for the coup, they organized and payed for the entire military dictorship. That's the most important part of the coup, it's history
@ it’s wasn’t, the Brazilian military and economic elites also wanted the coup, you can see photos of people on demonstration with signs asking for “military intervention”. Of course the US had a significant part on it, and it likely wouldn’t have happened without their support, but don’t act like Brazil had no agency whatsoever. You need a confluence of factors for that kind of thing to happen, not just the wishes of a foreign power. And to be clear, I’m not defending any of the people who were pro coup or are trying to whitewash the dictatorship crimes. I just think this kind of thinking is simplistic and leads to complacency. A country don’t need foreign influence to destroy it’s democracy, just look at could’ve happened in 2022, the military was even plotting to kill the elected president and supreme court minister, and they did all of that by themselves.
Let’s take the opportunity now that “I’m Still Here” is gaining attention to inform people outside Brazil about the connection between the former president Jair Bolsonaro and this story. Bolsonaro harbored deep hatred for the real-life Rubens Paiva, a congressman who was brutally tortured and killed during the military dictatorship-a fact Bolsonaro has consistently denied, falsely claiming Paiva wasn’t murdered by the regime. In the film, Fernanda Torres portrays the real-life wife of Rubens Paiva, whose tragic story is intertwined with the horrors of the dictatorship Bolsonaro openly admires. Bolsonaro’s hostility toward Paiva and his family reflects his broader admiration for the military regime that ruled Brazil from 1964 to 1985. He is a staunch defender of that era and has repeatedly praised its legacy. During a vote to impeach former president Dilma Rousseff-a survivor of the dictatorship's brutal practices-Bolsonaro paid tribute to Alberto Ustra, a military officer notorious for orchestrating torture and deaths during that time. Ustra was directly involved in Rousseff’s torture. Bolsonaro genuinely believes the dictatorship was a “revolution” rather than a dictatorship, aligning himself with its legacy in both rhetoric and ideology.
Bia, I want to share this youtube video on my facebook page and I thought your words are so accurate and meaningful. Can I copy your text and post it, giving credts of course? I’m a Japanese descendent who grew up in São Paulo, and I have too many (in a very negative way) family members and Japanese descendant friends that sitll say that the dictatoship was the best thing that happened in Brazil, and they voted (and will vote again) to Bolsonaro. It is disheartening to see the huge support Boslsonaro has from the Brazilian-Japanese community.
@@yokoemy Hi Emy, I’m so glad my comment resonated with you! Feel free to use it however you’d like. What you shared about your family and the community is so complex and heartbreaking. It’s a reflection of how history shapes perspectives, but it’s also sad to see how some people only empathize with danger and pain when it directly affects them. Wishing you all the best!
My uncle passed the tests and became a federal police during the dictatorship (is the Brazilian equivalent of F.B.I.) My family is from rural northeast, they grew up poor. He was an attorney when he passed. These tests are really really hard, it was, and still is, a prestigious job, and pays really well. He was in his early twenties when he started the job, and he was forced to work in the "burning archives", back then, people went missing from nothing, some people went to work, or buy groceries, and never came back. If someone was suspect of anything, from protesting to just criticize the dictatorship, the government would kidnap, torture, and most of the times even murder. The bodies, documents, all the traces where completely erased by the government, even after the dictatorship, and to this day, no one know what happened to most of the victims. Families never had a chance to known what happened to their loved ones, or even make a proper burial, some of then still hopes do find the ones they lost. After the dictatorship ended, my uncle came back completely destroyed physically, mentally, and addicted to drinking. He never worked again, and since then, he spent all day, everyday, locked in his room, drinking, playing guitar, and crying. He drinks until colapse, most of the time on the floor, just to wake the next day and repeat the process. He never told anyone what he was forced to do, even his siblings, wife and kids.
Meu Deus, que história horrenda! Me faltam palavras de consolo para seu tio e sua família. Talvez o único consolo que resta é que seu tio ficou assim por não perder a humanidade e não ter se tornado o monstro que alguns foram.
@@crisferraz25 que ele se arrependa do que fez eu consigo entender. Agora vc eximir a culpa que ele carrega pelos crimes que cometeu, aí só Deus na causa mesmo.
@@xotroxa2718, não eximi a pessoa de culpa. Inclusive, acho que um dos grandes erros históricos que o Brasil cometeu foi anistiar os ditadores e aqueles que trabalharam para ele, e espero que não cometamos o mesmo erro agora com os que tentaram outro golpe. Mas a pessoa se autodestruiu totalmente e disso eu tenho compaixão. Alguns que certamente fizeram coisa pior que esse homem voltavam pra casa no final do dia pra jantar com a família e dormir como se tivessem passado o dia trabalhando num escritório. Não parece ser o caso da pessoa citada.
@@xotroxa2718 pela história que o rapaz contou, o tio dele era um funcionário concursado apenas. Provavelmente muito do que ele teve que fazer era sob ordens. Era isso ou ele mesmo sumir também, bem como a familia. Como julgar uma pessoa assim? Eu não me atrevo porque nem imagino o que sentiria no lugar dele. No lugar de milhares de pessoas que eram simplesmente funcionárias, subordinadas, trabalhando pra ganhar seu pão e tentar chegar viva em casa no final do dia.
in fact it was not just a government, but a military dictatorship established in the '64 coup with the support of the USA. More than 20,000 people were murdered by the military and more than 200, including Rubens Paiva (the father of the family represented in this film) never had their bodies found and buried, Rubens' death certificate, in fact, is only symbolic, we never knew what the military did to him during his arrest or after his death. They are still here.
@@thifany_exe parece que nunca foram embora pq quem instaurou a ditadura militar no Brasil não autorizou dar um golpe nela mesma quando o salnorabo não se reelegeu
Acho que você misturou os números. De acordo com o relatório realizado pela Comissão da Verdade e a Corte Interamericana de Direitos Humanos, cerca de 20 mil pessoas foram torturadas. O número de mortos pelo Estado reconhecidas foi de em torno de 500 pessoas. Há um pesquisador da CNV que também entende que camponeses que foram desaparecidos ou morreram por conta do coronelismo latifundiário no período também são da conta da ditadura. Aí é difícil estimar o exato, mas pelo menos mais de 1200 pessoas.
is crazy to see that even in now days with all the evidences and cases, there is still a bunch of brasilians that chose to not belive that all this history moment happend, is insane
É assustador que tem gente que acha que é tudo mentira. A ditadura acabou faz menos de 40 anos. MUITA gente que sofreu nessa época ainda esta viva e mesmo assim tem gente que insiste que é tudo mentira. Imagina daqui a 50 anos.
@@yuriteixeira11 It was stolen from her mother - Fernanda Montenegro in 1999 by Gwyneth Paltrow. Not exactly by GP, but by Harvey Weinstein with all the power he had who made sure Shakespeare in Love will get as much Oscars as possible. If you didn't see the film for which Fernanda Montenegro was nominated its called Central do Brasil. In English it's called Central Station.
It was stolen from her mother - Fernanda Montenegro in 1999 by Gwyneth Paltrow. Not exactly by GP, but by Harvey Weinstein with all the power he had who made sure Shakespeare in Love will get as much Oscars as possible. If you didn't see the film for which Fernanda Montenegro was nominated its called Central do Brasil. In English it's called Central Station.
Fernanda Torres (whom I know as Fernandinha, or 'Little Fernanda'; her mother is 'The Fernanda,' or Dona Fernanda-for few Fernandona) is ready to conquer and slay the talk show circuit. She's intellectual, witty, and articulate. She will take America by storm.
that was awesome to watch! this film deserves to be recognized all over the world. congrats to walter salles, fernanda torres, selton mello, fernanda montenegro and all the crew! a real piece of art
I am notchi brazilian, but I thinky Fernanda Torres deserves an Oscar for this movie. No, but for real tho, I think Americans in particular would benefit SO much from watching this movie. Especially Liberals, ironically.
@@miooj not sure, but maybe because the dictatorships that were imposed thoughout Latin America were supported, planned and financed by the American government, even through Democrat leadership I believe. Just the effects of American imperialism I guess
@miooj It’s a movie about the right-wing military dictatorship in Brazil, which was installed (with the help of the US as part of their regime change Cold War foreign policy) in the context of a “Red Scare” that wasn’t real.
@@miooj Well the political ideology known as "Liberalism" (which is defended by the democratic party and it's supporters in the USA) is a right wing ideology. It is in it's essence an extremely capitalist economical and social school of thought. The military coup and dictatorship in Brazil (and in many other latin american countries during that time) were directly supported and funded by the US government - this isn't a conspiracy or a secret, it's a widely available information. In fact the US president at the time it all started was Lyndon Johnson, a democrat. I am not from the US (I'm brazilian), but - at least from a far - it seems that a lot of US Americans have a very shallow understanding of certain political concepts. From what I have seen and consumed from the country I feel like a lot of people "confuse" leftist and liberal ideas (which is ironic, because they are, in their core, completely opposing). It kinda boils down to the fact that the US has no concrete (or at least "mainstream") leftist movements or parties. Probably do to the many government efforts of repressing them, especially during the cold war. I mean, do remember that I am a foreigner who is not involved in the US social moviment scene - so the left may be stronger than I think idk. But as a brazilian, the only left leaning US american references I have are Malcolm X and the Black Panthers. To foreigners the majority of the US seems to be quite alienated, even the ones who do try to engage with politics (but are not envolved directly or scholars of it) seem to lack awearness of the meaning and history of political ideologies; movements and of most of the US's foreing actions and policies, to an almost funny (if it wasn't sad) degree. I think it´s kind of what the first comment meant or at least what I interpreted from it :) Idk if you are from the US and I don't mean any of it as an "attack" hahah it's not exactly a criticism either, I do belive that US Americans are purposefully "kept in the dark" and/or not incentivated to be and think politically for a reason. In Brazil it's seen as very bad and selfish to say things like "I'm apolitical" or "I don't do politics", but that seems to be the general attitude in the US and that is, more than anything, terrifying.
Agora precisamos de um filme ou série contando a história de José Jobim... essa história acaba com toda argumentação q diz não ter havido corrupção durante a ditadura militar.
@@fabricioazevedo2361o José Jobim foi um diplomata brasileiro que foi torturado e morto pela ditadura. É uma história bem complexa - tem um podcast muito bom sobre chamado Cálice que ainda está rolando e muitas outras coisas-, mas tipo o resumo é que ele foi morto por queima de arquivo, ele conhecia muitas coisas por detrás da ditadura e como o governo Figueiredo prometia suavizar as coisas ele decidiu escrever um livro denunciando (com provas) a corrupção por trás da construção da Usina de Itaipu.
@@fabricioazevedo2361ele não chegou a escrever o livro, mas a notícia chegou na ditadura porque um amigo dele era parte do serviço secreto dos militares. Embora tenhamos informações sobre o suoerfaturamente o quão foi suoerfaturado e os detalhes morreram com ele. Quando ele foi morto ele tinha 69 anos e a família foi aterrorizada com um falso sequestro e desmoralizada com uma história ridícula de suicídio e fraude. Eles tiveram que lutar por anos para ter a causa da morte dele reconhecida. Principalmente a filha dele.
It's like Fernanda Torres said, we were living a phase full of energy and creativity in Brazil, in culture, art, education with innovative pedagogical projects and, suddenly, everything was truncated in a frightening way, from which we never recovered, but it is under this reality, and knowing that effervescence is part of us, that we will rebuild ourselves. As it has been said since then, 'down with the dictatorship, torture never again'. We recently went through events that reminded us of those times, when part of the population, the military and politicians did not accept the electoral defeat in 2022. The past is more present than we would like, but 'não passarão'.
The film is already a winner, the Oscar award would be just protocol. In fact, the Oscar is not a parameter of film quality, it is an industry and not art.
Nossa Fernandinha brilhando em cena e fora dela..entrevistas maravilhosas, num inglês fluente. No filme, o nosso talentosíssimo Selton Mello assim como o personagem Rubens Paiva passam à Eunice o protagonismo. Aplausos para esses grandes atores e o diretor.
24 วันที่ผ่านมา +6
Telling our history with great quality as usual with the Torres girls. Incredible work, I can not wait for O Auto da Compadecida 2 with Selton Melo this December 🤩🤩
Doida para ver esse filme com o Selton e a Fernanda. Cresci com Selton Mello dublando Nova onda do Imperador ( Meu filme favorito da vida!!! E dublagem mais epica de todos os tempos. 😂) e no MAGNÍFICO CLÁSSICO adaptado O Auto da Compadecida que ele inclusive interpreta com a grande diva do teatro Brasileiro Fernanda Montenegro que foi indicada para o Óscar por outro grande clássico do cinema Brasileiro: Central do Brasil. ❤ E Fernanda Torres eu lembro desde Os Normais... Um papel Muuuuuuito diferente do que agora, mas que na minha opinião e um dos muitos modos que ela tem de brilhas nas câmeras❤️🎥🎞️🎬🎭❤ Boa sorte Fernanda Torres!!!!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
About voices, I guess Selton is in the top 3 most recognizable voices of Brasil. And accents... 😂😂😂 Among everything he does, he is a famous voice actor too. He is our Daniel San, he and his brother, and he is our Kusco. Just to name some of his work. So... Selton is a staple here in Brasil. I don't know a person who don't love him... So, at least for me, when I heard he was on the movie, I knew I wouldn't see Rubens Paiva. And that's fine. What we get from Selton when he is on is rich, full of life and detail... And he sells any idea... He does it all, comedy and drama, with the same care. That said... Fernanda... We're used to seeing her with witty funny and intelligent scripts. She has this fast thinking and a way of reacting to stuff on scene that is amusing, cool and soooo relatable. Seeing her in drama reminds us she can be subtle and smooth and still makes us feel something. Amazong actress. This movie is a treat...
I was born in Brazil during those tough, oppressive times-so yeah, I’m older than the democratic Statehood of my country, which is just crazy to think about. Without a doubt, I wish my fellow Americans would find a theater showing this movie. It’s a hard and cruel portrait of our childhoods, giving a stark and real illustration of what it was like to live in a country gripped by the 'enemy within' rhetoric. It hits close to home.
Some acting works are in another level, and the language barrier can be overlaped if you are considering just the acting, and that's why Fernanda Torres deseves all awards this year, but are the voters open to consider this and overlap the language barrier?
15:20 that is just what I thought when I watched the movie, the acting in this film doesn't feel like acting at all, it's really almost a documentary and I love that. Something that really pisses me is that culture of cinema point of view (kinda like mexico beeing yellow) and expositive dialogues (those dialogues that are useless for the people in the movie, that serves just to explain things to the spectators like a child) which this film had none
![[UNCUT] เก็บ "สจ.โต้ง" เอี่ยวมาเฟีย รู้ตัวคนบงการ ก่อนสั่งลั่นไก I คนดังนั่งเคลียร์ I 13 ธ.ค.67](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/o-J_p62D40w/mqdefault.jpg)
Fernanda: “my parents are actors” as if her mother isn’t the grand dame of Brazilian acting, Fernanda Montenegro 😂
é muito bom ver a Fernanda falando inglês mas não falando para os gringos, ela continua falando para nós, acho que no fundo ela tem uma consciência de que pros gringos é só um momento exótico o que esse filme tá causando, mas pra nós é outra coisa, é outro patamar
@@BrunoCaruso-wz7pgsim. Eu amo a consciência dela em saber que esse filme é de brasileiros, para brasileiros. Ansioso pra ir assistir ❤
Fernanda Montenegro is the Brazilian Meryl Streep, a total acting GOAT!
@@ohmyjak Pois vá, é pesado, forte, angustiante, ao mesmo tempo é de um primor, de uma sensibilidade imensa. Obra prima do cinema nacional.
@@jonasguerizoli7857 She is THE GOAT! You nailed ... it bring me tears on seeing her respect and the bless that she has on having her mother still alive and acting ... what a honor. Loved when she said: You do not cut "my mom's" scene ...lol
Fernanda is still being goofy even when speaking another language, I love her so much 😭
sim! o humor é internacional! ♥
Luíz melodiiiiia 🥴
Eu sinto saudades da Vani como se ela tivesse sido real...
Imagine how Brazil could have been now if this coup had never happened?
we would be bigger than USA and china
Imagine what all of Latin America would be like today if there were no USA
Way better for sure
Possibly a major global power, maybe close to what China is today, which would go against US hegemony in the americas. And to think some brazilians still support the coup.
Estaria bem melhor, com toda certeza, pq apesar da ditadura ter tentado trazer avanços industriais, eles fizeram tudo isso da forma mais porca possível e com emprestimos estrangeiros, oq lançou o país em uma terrível crise econômico nos anos seguintes após a redemocratização. A ditadura trouxe mais atrasos econômicos e culturais, do que avanços
Minha família naquela época era muito pobre e despolitizada, como a maioria dos manipulados velhos e que eram adolescentes cegos naquela época. O que fez minha família perceber que algo estava TOTALMENTE ERRADO foi quando meu bisavô, trabalhador de obra e chão de fábrica também, simplesmente SUMIU do dia para a noite.
Ninguém soube onde ele foi, o que ocorreu, se ele tinha sido assassinado, roubado, enfim... duas/três semanas depois ele reaparece, não queria falar muito sobre o que tinha acontecido com ele nessas semanas, mas ele contou porquê tinha sido pego pelos militares, ele cometeu o grande crime de: Ficar parado na esquina depois do serviço de 10h dele para conversar com os colegas. Esse foi o crime e a razão na qual meu bisavô sumiu por 2 semanas, e sabe-se lá o que fizeram com ele nesse período, mas ele voltou BEM abalado.
E o mais nojento na minha opinião, é a galera do "Deus Pátria Família e LIBERDADE" terem a pachorra de se dizerem tão a favor da ""liberdade"" enquanto querem a volta de um tempo vil, nojento e cruel da nossa história. Imagina dizer que é da "liberdade" enquanto somem e te torturam por coisas tão banais quanto ficar no meio da rua.
Eu estudei, entedo nossa história e digo: NUNCA. MAIS.
Esse povo que defende a ditadura é imbecil, não sabem o que foi aquele tempo... não sabem o absurdo que defendem. Ficam na rua pedindo intervenção e quando a polícia apreende gritam por liberdade de expressão. Não fazem o menor sentido.
Burros, ignorantes, que se acham inteligentes... o pior tipo.
É o boi comemorando o churrasco.
Bandido é isso.. fala a merda que for pra se manter.. RESTA A GNT FAZER JUSTICA PQ A POLICIA É BANDIDO TB. Confia e vai!! Independente do imbecil que aparecer
sinto muito pelo seu biso, deve ter sido extremamente traumatizante pra ele e pra todo mundo da família :(
Muito grato pelo seu depoimento! Todo solidariedade do mundo pro seu bisavô e aos seus familiares. NUNCA MAIS
Que isso nunca mais se repita!
"When the Brazilian Government Kidnaped Its Own People backed up by the US government", would be a better title for the video...
This is relevant to the cold war but the people who had their family members kidnapped and killed couldn’t care less about who were backing their authoritarian government.
This is about Brazil, and not the US. It feels like Americans somehow have to make everything about them first.
@matheusp572 That is not my point. My point is that, first and formost, they did and still do pay for corruption and violance in foreign governments worldwide. And this is very relevant to everybody, not only for us to be able to understand History, but also for us to undersand the present, as their foreign politics is still a problem right now, specialy to the global south, 'cause their ways of doing foreign politics by financing corruption and war worldwide has not changed. Other than that it is a very relevant information to add, as the title of the video seem to use a very common tone when talking about the countries in the global south, that is that they (we) lack something, either it be the capacity to rule and organize themselves as a society or moral principles to do it. Either way, it is akin to biological racism, that treat other cultures and peoples as "the strangers", the strange other, in the same line of thought that thinks "the savages" or the "unfathomable east". In other words, it implies prejudice.
@@matheusp572no my dear friend,we brazilians know in fact,that the participation of yoyr govenement in this horrofing moment in our history is above the mere finacial support ,your fellas not just train the "interrogators" but also pratice in our country some "experimental metods" of "getting the true out of peapol"...the us involvement is clear to everyone that is down here in south america,not just in brazil but in every country in this continent
@@matheusp572 The US was the one responsible for the coup, they organized and payed for the entire military dictorship. That's the most important part of the coup, it's history
@ it’s wasn’t, the Brazilian military and economic elites also wanted the coup, you can see photos of people on demonstration with signs asking for “military intervention”. Of course the US had a significant part on it, and it likely wouldn’t have happened without their support, but don’t act like Brazil had no agency whatsoever. You need a confluence of factors for that kind of thing to happen, not just the wishes of a foreign power.
And to be clear, I’m not defending any of the people who were pro coup or are trying to whitewash the dictatorship crimes. I just think this kind of thinking is simplistic and leads to complacency. A country don’t need foreign influence to destroy it’s democracy, just look at could’ve happened in 2022, the military was even plotting to kill the elected president and supreme court minister, and they did all of that by themselves.
Let’s take the opportunity now that “I’m Still Here” is gaining attention to inform people outside Brazil about the connection between the former president Jair Bolsonaro and this story. Bolsonaro harbored deep hatred for the real-life Rubens Paiva, a congressman who was brutally tortured and killed during the military dictatorship-a fact Bolsonaro has consistently denied, falsely claiming Paiva wasn’t murdered by the regime. In the film, Fernanda Torres portrays the real-life wife of Rubens Paiva, whose tragic story is intertwined with the horrors of the dictatorship Bolsonaro openly admires.
Bolsonaro’s hostility toward Paiva and his family reflects his broader admiration for the military regime that ruled Brazil from 1964 to 1985. He is a staunch defender of that era and has repeatedly praised its legacy. During a vote to impeach former president Dilma Rousseff-a survivor of the dictatorship's brutal practices-Bolsonaro paid tribute to Alberto Ustra, a military officer notorious for orchestrating torture and deaths during that time. Ustra was directly involved in Rousseff’s torture. Bolsonaro genuinely believes the dictatorship was a “revolution” rather than a dictatorship, aligning himself with its legacy in both rhetoric and ideology.
Bia, I want to share this youtube video on my facebook page and I thought your words are so accurate and meaningful. Can I copy your text and post it, giving credts of course? I’m a Japanese descendent who grew up in São Paulo, and I have too many (in a very negative way) family members and Japanese descendant friends that sitll say that the dictatoship was the best thing that happened in Brazil, and they voted (and will vote again) to Bolsonaro. It is disheartening to see the huge support Boslsonaro has from the Brazilian-Japanese community.
@@yokoemy Hi Emy, I’m so glad my comment resonated with you! Feel free to use it however you’d like.
What you shared about your family and the community is so complex and heartbreaking. It’s a reflection of how history shapes perspectives, but it’s also sad to see how some people only empathize with danger and pain when it directly affects them.
Wishing you all the best!
Thank you so much !👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
@@biagionim thank you!
My uncle passed the tests and became a federal police during the dictatorship (is the Brazilian equivalent of F.B.I.) My family is from rural northeast, they grew up poor. He was an attorney when he passed. These tests are really really hard, it was, and still is, a prestigious job, and pays really well. He was in his early twenties when he started the job, and he was forced to work in the "burning archives", back then, people went missing from nothing, some people went to work, or buy groceries, and never came back. If someone was suspect of anything, from protesting to just criticize the dictatorship, the government would kidnap, torture, and most of the times even murder. The bodies, documents, all the traces where completely erased by the government, even after the dictatorship, and to this day, no one know what happened to most of the victims. Families never had a chance to known what happened to their loved ones, or even make a proper burial, some of then still hopes do find the ones they lost. After the dictatorship ended, my uncle came back completely destroyed physically, mentally, and addicted to drinking. He never worked again, and since then, he spent all day, everyday, locked in his room, drinking, playing guitar, and crying. He drinks until colapse, most of the time on the floor, just to wake the next day and repeat the process. He never told anyone what he was forced to do, even his siblings, wife and kids.
Meu Deus, que história horrenda! Me faltam palavras de consolo para seu tio e sua família. Talvez o único consolo que resta é que seu tio ficou assim por não perder a humanidade e não ter se tornado o monstro que alguns foram.
@@crisferraz25 que ele se arrependa do que fez eu consigo entender. Agora vc eximir a culpa que ele carrega pelos crimes que cometeu, aí só Deus na causa mesmo.
@@xotroxa2718, não eximi a pessoa de culpa. Inclusive, acho que um dos grandes erros históricos que o Brasil cometeu foi anistiar os ditadores e aqueles que trabalharam para ele, e espero que não cometamos o mesmo erro agora com os que tentaram outro golpe. Mas a pessoa se autodestruiu totalmente e disso eu tenho compaixão. Alguns que certamente fizeram coisa pior que esse homem voltavam pra casa no final do dia pra jantar com a família e dormir como se tivessem passado o dia trabalhando num escritório. Não parece ser o caso da pessoa citada.
@@xotroxa2718 pela história que o rapaz contou, o tio dele era um funcionário concursado apenas. Provavelmente muito do que ele teve que fazer era sob ordens. Era isso ou ele mesmo sumir também, bem como a familia. Como julgar uma pessoa assim? Eu não me atrevo porque nem imagino o que sentiria no lugar dele. No lugar de milhares de pessoas que eram simplesmente funcionárias, subordinadas, trabalhando pra ganhar seu pão e tentar chegar viva em casa no final do dia.
in fact it was not just a government, but a military dictatorship established in the '64 coup with the support of the USA. More than 20,000 people were murdered by the military and more than 200, including Rubens Paiva (the father of the family represented in this film) never had their bodies found and buried, Rubens' death certificate, in fact, is only symbolic, we never knew what the military did to him during his arrest or after his death. They are still here.
Inacreditavelmente sim, eles ainda estão aqui todos impunes.
@@xotroxa2718 eles tentam voltar sempre
@@thifany_exe parece que nunca foram embora pq quem instaurou a ditadura militar no Brasil não autorizou dar um golpe nela mesma quando o salnorabo não se reelegeu
Acho que você misturou os números. De acordo com o relatório realizado pela Comissão da Verdade e a Corte Interamericana de Direitos Humanos, cerca de 20 mil pessoas foram torturadas. O número de mortos pelo Estado reconhecidas foi de em torno de 500 pessoas. Há um pesquisador da CNV que também entende que camponeses que foram desaparecidos ou morreram por conta do coronelismo latifundiário no período também são da conta da ditadura. Aí é difícil estimar o exato, mas pelo menos mais de 1200 pessoas.
@@LucasRodmo acho que vc perdeu o contexto, quais indígenas constam nessas relações?
Loved how they switched Fernanda Torres and Selton Mello name tags.
Obrigade "da Costa"
Sim! 😂😂😂😂
Fernanda Torres delivered probably one of the best performances I've seen in the last decade
Masterpiece of Brazilian cinema
Masterpiece of film history
is crazy to see that even in now days with all the evidences and cases, there is still a bunch of brasilians that chose to not belive that all this history moment happend, is insane
É assustador que tem gente que acha que é tudo mentira. A ditadura acabou faz menos de 40 anos. MUITA gente que sofreu nessa época ainda esta viva e mesmo assim tem gente que insiste que é tudo mentira. Imagina daqui a 50 anos.
No, my guy. The illusion is that it only happened to deserving criminals. It's not that it didn't happen, but that it worked.
@@pedroeubgwhich somehow makes it even worse
brilliant film, Fernanda Torres KILLS it in a contained performance
Great movie! Fernanda deserves an oscar nomination for that movie
Not just the nomination, she'll take that statue
@@yuriteixeira11 It was stolen from her mother - Fernanda Montenegro in 1999 by Gwyneth Paltrow. Not exactly by GP, but by Harvey Weinstein with all the power he had who made sure Shakespeare in Love will get as much Oscars as possible. If you didn't see the film for which Fernanda Montenegro was nominated its called Central do Brasil. In English it's called Central Station.
It was stolen from her mother - Fernanda Montenegro in 1999 by Gwyneth Paltrow. Not exactly by GP, but by Harvey Weinstein with all the power he had who made sure Shakespeare in Love will get as much Oscars as possible. If you didn't see the film for which Fernanda Montenegro was nominated its called Central do Brasil. In English it's called Central Station.
@@jurema1646 já vi, pô, sou brasileiro kkkkk
Fernanda is greater than Oscar... And the Oscar not deserve Fernanda.
Oscar not deserve Fernanda... She is greater than a trophy.
Fernanda Torres (whom I know as Fernandinha, or 'Little Fernanda'; her mother is 'The Fernanda,' or Dona Fernanda-for few Fernandona) is ready to conquer and slay the talk show circuit. She's intellectual, witty, and articulate. She will take America by storm.
we need an extended version of this movie. i need to watch all the cut scenes.
Me too!
A rede globo vai lançar a versão estendida no globo play
Se tem o livro, já ajuda a ver a história um pouco mais. Os livros sempre são mais completos que os filmes.
What a sense of humor from Fernanda Torres.
Fernanda Torres is so intelligent, funny, and charismatic! I'm glad her sense of humor isn't getting lost in translation.
The two Fernandas and Selton are beloved actors in Brasil, we are so proud of them
This film and the whole team are remarkable. They are amazing. Fernanda is talented and fun
Fernanda's hilarious . Great actress , she deserves the Oscars for her performance in this film.
that was awesome to watch! this film deserves to be recognized all over the world. congrats to walter salles, fernanda torres, selton mello, fernanda montenegro and all the crew! a real piece of art
This movie is a piece of art
20:45 Smart move... não se corta Fernanda Montenegro 🤣🤣🤣
I watched it with my girlfriend at the cinema, it was emotional.
You mean, it was touching - indeed
Assisti com minha ex no cinema também, 1 dia depois de terminarmos, it was VERY emotional.
@andrevictorgomes se loco, pedrada ein? Se cuida e forças mano
@@lpcsm1973 valeu, meu mano! A vida segue...
Amei a entrevista. Tomara que essa cena que a Nanda falou que foi cortada do filme esteja na versão de 3h20 do Globo play quando sair
One of the best interviewer. Great questions!
Best Actress for Fernanda Torres
Best Supporting Actor for Selton Mello
We are so proud of this important and inspiring movie!! 🇧🇷
Great interview by Janelle Riley. Didn't know her, now I'm going to follow her work.
An incredible performance by Fernanda Torres! Brilliant movie!
I am notchi brazilian, but I thinky Fernanda Torres deserves an Oscar for this movie.
No, but for real tho, I think Americans in particular would benefit SO much from watching this movie. Especially Liberals, ironically.
can you explain the last part? why would they benefit? i havent watched it yet
@@miooj not sure, but maybe because the dictatorships that were imposed thoughout Latin America were supported, planned and financed by the American government, even through Democrat leadership I believe. Just the effects of American imperialism I guess
@miooj It’s a movie about the right-wing military dictatorship in Brazil, which was installed (with the help of the US as part of their regime change Cold War foreign policy) in the context of a “Red Scare” that wasn’t real.
I think your keyboard might be Brazilian 😂
@@miooj Well the political ideology known as "Liberalism" (which is defended by the democratic party and it's supporters in the USA) is a right wing ideology. It is in it's essence an extremely capitalist economical and social school of thought. The military coup and dictatorship in Brazil (and in many other latin american countries during that time) were directly supported and funded by the US government - this isn't a conspiracy or a secret, it's a widely available information. In fact the US president at the time it all started was Lyndon Johnson, a democrat.
I am not from the US (I'm brazilian), but - at least from a far - it seems that a lot of US Americans have a very shallow understanding of certain political concepts. From what I have seen and consumed from the country I feel like a lot of people "confuse" leftist and liberal ideas (which is ironic, because they are, in their core, completely opposing). It kinda boils down to the fact that the US has no concrete (or at least "mainstream") leftist movements or parties. Probably do to the many government efforts of repressing them, especially during the cold war.
I mean, do remember that I am a foreigner who is not involved in the US social moviment scene - so the left may be stronger than I think idk. But as a brazilian, the only left leaning US american references I have are Malcolm X and the Black Panthers.
To foreigners the majority of the US seems to be quite alienated, even the ones who do try to engage with politics (but are not envolved directly or scholars of it) seem to lack awearness of the meaning and history of political ideologies; movements and of most of the US's foreing actions and policies, to an almost funny (if it wasn't sad) degree.
I think it´s kind of what the first comment meant or at least what I interpreted from it :)
Idk if you are from the US and I don't mean any of it as an "attack" hahah it's not exactly a criticism either, I do belive that US Americans are purposefully "kept in the dark" and/or not incentivated to be and think politically for a reason. In Brazil it's seen as very bad and selfish to say things like "I'm apolitical" or "I don't do politics", but that seems to be the general attitude in the US and that is, more than anything, terrifying.
Fernanda is the most funny person, even in english.
Agora precisamos de um filme ou série contando a história de José Jobim... essa história acaba com toda argumentação q diz não ter havido corrupção durante a ditadura militar.
S2
Eu não sei dessa. Me dá contexto por favor.
Mano o que me quebra é como os militares mal tentaram esconderam o que fizeram com ele
@@fabricioazevedo2361o José Jobim foi um diplomata brasileiro que foi torturado e morto pela ditadura. É uma história bem complexa - tem um podcast muito bom sobre chamado Cálice que ainda está rolando e muitas outras coisas-, mas tipo o resumo é que ele foi morto por queima de arquivo, ele conhecia muitas coisas por detrás da ditadura e como o governo Figueiredo prometia suavizar as coisas ele decidiu escrever um livro denunciando (com provas) a corrupção por trás da construção da Usina de Itaipu.
@@fabricioazevedo2361ele não chegou a escrever o livro, mas a notícia chegou na ditadura porque um amigo dele era parte do serviço secreto dos militares. Embora tenhamos informações sobre o suoerfaturamente o quão foi suoerfaturado e os detalhes morreram com ele. Quando ele foi morto ele tinha 69 anos e a família foi aterrorizada com um falso sequestro e desmoralizada com uma história ridícula de suicídio e fraude. Eles tiveram que lutar por anos para ter a causa da morte dele reconhecida. Principalmente a filha dele.
Adoro a Jenelle Riley, ela já fez entrevistas históricas. Foi a escolha perfeita pra conversar com Fernanda e Selton.
I absolutely adore the amount of international recognition this movie is getting.
It's like Fernanda Torres said, we were living a phase full of energy and creativity in Brazil, in culture, art, education with innovative pedagogical projects and, suddenly, everything was truncated in a frightening way, from which we never recovered, but it is under this reality, and knowing that effervescence is part of us, that we will rebuild ourselves. As it has been said since then, 'down with the dictatorship, torture never again'. We recently went through events that reminded us of those times, when part of the population, the military and politicians did not accept the electoral defeat in 2022. The past is more present than we would like, but 'não passarão'.
só os brasileiro escrevendo em inglês, ai tu vai ler os nome "sebastião, joão, pedro" kkkkkkkkkkk
Uai, o canal é em inglês
somos caliban
HAHAHA
jahahahahahahaha socorro sim
acabei ler um Lucas Nogueira KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK ATILA MACHADO
A Fernanda Torres é muito carismática até em inglês
Watching this after the announcement that Fernanda Torres received an Golden Globe nom
I'm a brazilian cinema student and this fills my sudacan heart with pride
The film is already a winner, the Oscar award would be just protocol. In fact, the Oscar is not a parameter of film quality, it is an industry and not art.
Fernanda is outstanding, everybody in this movie is great
Best Actress in Leading Role ❤
Watch I'm Still Here!! The film has the ability to show in a sensible and delicate way a dark period of the dictatorial regime imposed at the time.
Fernanda and her mother are Brazilian Royalty! She is also so funny, lover her!! 🥰
Xique-Xique Bahia📍: masterpiece of Brazilian cinema
hahahaahah amo
"I'm not brazilian but I loved this movie!" - @joaonascimento234
que legal que a galera de xique-xique possui mais cultura e patriotismo do que vc, enzo leite com pêra criado pelo tio-avô despolitizado e imbecil
Fernanda i love how your portrayed the movie's massage, this is a great statement, lookin at what is ahead, though unpleasant is a big need
Tão bom, ver Brasileiros brilhando no mundo❤❤❤❤
Selton is so 🥺🤏
This is a marvelous piece of art.
When the names of the actors are swapped and you think about the person who had that one job 😂
But seriously, Fernanda and Selton are amazing!
Nossa Fernandinha brilhando em cena e fora dela..entrevistas maravilhosas, num inglês fluente. No filme, o nosso talentosíssimo Selton Mello assim como o personagem Rubens Paiva passam à Eunice o protagonismo. Aplausos para esses grandes atores e o diretor.
Telling our history with great quality as usual with the Torres girls. Incredible work, I can not wait for O Auto da Compadecida 2 with Selton Melo this December 🤩🤩
The movie is truly amazing!!
Masterpiece!!!
I havent seen the movie yet, but can't wait to watch !
Venezuela North Korea is doing the same thing right now
@@dorismaricoraviana5089 cry more, bomberman fangirl
Best movie of the whole year, love em so much
Love them so much! Fernanda is so spontaneous, funny, even in english…great actors!
Doida para ver esse filme com o Selton e a Fernanda. Cresci com Selton Mello dublando Nova onda do Imperador ( Meu filme favorito da vida!!! E dublagem mais epica de todos os tempos. 😂) e no MAGNÍFICO CLÁSSICO adaptado O Auto da Compadecida que ele inclusive interpreta com a grande diva do teatro Brasileiro Fernanda Montenegro que foi indicada para o Óscar por outro grande clássico do cinema Brasileiro: Central do Brasil. ❤
E Fernanda Torres eu lembro desde Os Normais... Um papel Muuuuuuito diferente do que agora, mas que na minha opinião e um dos muitos modos que ela tem de brilhas nas câmeras❤️🎥🎞️🎬🎭❤
Boa sorte Fernanda Torres!!!!!!!❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️
This film is amazing, probabily the best drama of 2024.the performance of Fernanda Torres is just incredible!!
especialmente por ser baseado em histórias reais.
Looking forward to watching it
O senso de humor da Fernanda
Great interview and amazing movie!
About voices, I guess Selton is in the top 3 most recognizable voices of Brasil. And accents... 😂😂😂 Among everything he does, he is a famous voice actor too. He is our Daniel San, he and his brother, and he is our Kusco. Just to name some of his work. So... Selton is a staple here in Brasil. I don't know a person who don't love him... So, at least for me, when I heard he was on the movie, I knew I wouldn't see Rubens Paiva. And that's fine. What we get from Selton when he is on is rich, full of life and detail... And he sells any idea... He does it all, comedy and drama, with the same care. That said... Fernanda... We're used to seeing her with witty funny and intelligent scripts. She has this fast thinking and a way of reacting to stuff on scene that is amusing, cool and soooo relatable. Seeing her in drama reminds us she can be subtle and smooth and still makes us feel something. Amazong actress. This movie is a treat...
this is such a masterpiece!
Its really nice to see the amount of recognition Fernanda and Selton are having.. Well done!
What an amazing interview! Thank you, guys. ❤
Fernanda will revenge her mom, because the Academy stoled her mom's Oscar.
👏👏👏 great interview, great film
Iconics performances
this movie is just beautifully spectacular!
ABSOLUT CINEMA!!!!!!
OBRIGADO FERNADA TORRES
She's incredible! Love her!
she's amazing !!!!!!
Fernanda e Selton, nossos orgulhos
I was born in Brazil during those tough, oppressive times-so yeah, I’m older than the democratic Statehood of my country, which is just crazy to think about. Without a doubt, I wish my fellow Americans would find a theater showing this movie. It’s a hard and cruel portrait of our childhoods, giving a stark and real illustration of what it was like to live in a country gripped by the 'enemy within' rhetoric. It hits close to home.
Gostei do ingles do Selton. Aguardando esse filme.
Fantastic movie!!
We love Fernanda Montenegro And Fernanda Torres
That situation still kind of happens in a way. Only not with rich white people anymore. But I believe not just in Brazil, other places too.
são incontáveis os golpes planejados, financiados, suportados e realizados pelos imperialismo estadunidense.
please, love yourselves and watch this film!
❤❤❤ I love Fernanda and Celton
Oscar for this !!!
Fernanda is amazing ❤
Muito divertidos eles juntos. A Fernanda Torres tão preciosa 🤏🥰
Fernanda and Selton ❤❤ I love them
IncrEdible acting!
Aii que delicinha ver a Nanda e o Seltinho. Sempre é uma delicinha ver eles
Great movie! ❤❤❤
Love them ❤
tão bom ver estas joias brasileiras ganhando o mundo...
Linda!!!🎉🎉🎉
Amazing
Some acting works are in another level, and the language barrier can be overlaped if you are considering just the acting, and that's why Fernanda Torres deseves all awards this year, but are the voters open to consider this and overlap the language barrier?
15:20 that is just what I thought when I watched the movie, the acting in this film doesn't feel like acting at all, it's really almost a documentary and I love that. Something that really pisses me is that culture of cinema point of view (kinda like mexico beeing yellow) and expositive dialogues (those dialogues that are useless for the people in the movie, that serves just to explain things to the spectators like a child) which this film had none
The best film of 2024’ ❤😊
Porque não fazem um filme sobre o Clesão? Quero ver.
Os atores brasileiros dando showww no inglês.