Hahhaha English bhi compulsory q hai wo bhi ni hona chahye waha q ni bolty .... bkwas Islam py a k ruk jati hai inki .. inko Talban hi thk kr skty hain ... Talban ny librel aur in jaisy kutto ko inki auqat yad dila di hai boht jldi tm jaisy logo ko bhi auqat yad dilai jay gi time any wala hai hahahah
Far and wide I have read Pakistani scholars, listened to them for hours and months and years. You are head and shoulders above ALL. In 73 years of misery of this hell hole, I have found only 2 - who are most effective at crispy clear vision That’s you & H. Haqqani🙏👏👏
Our prayers are in Sanskrit, however, Sanskrit is introduced only in 6-7th class and 9th and 10th it is optional and we don’t study it after 10th. Still we respect Sanskrit and acknowledge its importance in our culture. Sanskrit is one of the oldest language and still going strong
But if Sanskrit is made compulsory from 1st standard it won't be wrong as it's not a foreign language .it's language of this land .it's not foreign language like Arabic Even Pakistan should adopt Sanskrit as it's language of our ancestors. Language is language, many countries follow Islam still have their own language
We Bangladeshis know and respect the importance of mother tongue very well. So it would not be right to use foreign language in the curriculum by force. The best initiative would be to learn through the native language. Otherwise it can bring extreme dark for the nation.
@Humanity Insaniyat no actually i have embraced my indus valley culture. This name Lawrence of Arabia is just a reference to the film. (I made this acc long ago)
Rare word is not enough to use , i m atleast short of words , india havebeen going through same problems now a days , a secular country is more like a heaven to live but these religious stupid clerics want something stupid according tp their cheap mentality . bhai jan bacha lo india ko otherwise india ka bhi pakistan wala hal hone wala hai kuch years k andar andar
We proudly say that we are sanatani Hindus the oldest civilisation in the world Unlike Pakistans who changed their religion under force of Sword and taxes..🙏
@@amnahaque9058 exactly Kids have to learn English as it is the international language then they added regional languages too now they are making Arabic compulsory Height of idiocy
Indian subcontinent is multi lingual ..india doesnt have national langauge ..all states languages are official languages of indian union by consititution of india....Unity in Diversity..
Even after 50 yrs of B'desh independence, Pakistan didn't change they imposed a random language (urdu) which was born in New Delhi on us bengalis who don't speak it, Pakistanis should promote/speak their own native languages like punjabi or Pashtun not urdu or arabic
Wow... I'm surprised, That it is True, actually know the History, URDU was Orginated in LUCKNOW by Upper Class Clerks, Of Muslim and HINDU working in AWADH Sultanate Courts, Only Few used it, And then got it Replaced by MUGHAL Court from Turkish to URDU in 18th Century.
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 Turkish was never a court language in any muslim dynasty in India.. And the urdu was made by itself no one had created it... Urdu itself means army.. The invaders army used to speak Arabic and Persian and turkic chagatai and many more so.. The hindi was mixed with these foreign languages and this is now known as urdu.. But after 15 century the muslim intelectual class wanted to remove hindi and sanskrit from india. So they started Arabization and turkification and of hindi.. They remove every possible exist sanskrit word from urdu then added Persian the most and some Arabic and turkic chagatai... It becomes rekhta then now urdu..
@@sasmalprasanjit2764wtf dude urdu you don't know anything urdu famous in Mughals time it was by Muslims urdu is mix turki farsi and Egyptian language
I'm a Indian and I really don't know why I watch Pakistan related videos. But I guess root of that too come from my being Indian, where we always care more about our neighbours. I have hurd this term Pakistan's Indenity Crisis so many times, and it looks like it's the real issue here. Pakistan should not be ashamed of her origin and her Indian past, it may be happened because of artificial environments created by dictators for consolidating power. I still believe Pakistan should identify herself as non religious democratic country and proudly preserve her Indian identity and get over land disputes. Then rest be assured India will try her best to normalise relations. Look how close we are with Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Nepal, Pakistan could be there too. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇵🇰
We are having same culture and different religions , religion is about choice but culture is not choice , its natural lekin koi bhi mulla pandit priest nai smjhe ga
@@thelogicalaspect1323 bhai culture Hazaar saalo me banta hai isliye culture hamesha permanent rahega tum chahe maano ya na maano pakistan ka problem hai wo apni roots dhudhte hai arab Turk me just because unka religion islam hai how stupid 😆🤣😁😁🤗🥰 Egypt ke log aaj bhi apne culture or cultural gods ki ijjat karte hai bhale hi unhone islam apna liya ho unke hero aaj bhi egyptian civilization waale hi honge
জনাব, আমি বাংলাদেশের একজন গর্বিত নাগরিক। গত কিছু দিন আপনার ভিডিও দেখে আপনাকে একজন শিক্ষিত আধুনিক পাকিস্তানি বলে মনে করছি। আপনার কথা যদি পাকিস্তানের শিক্ষিত সম্প্রদায়ের ২% ও হয়ে থাকে, তবে আগামী ৫০ বছরে পাকিস্তান হয়তো নিজের অস্তিত্ব স্থাপন করতে পারবে। শুভকামনা। Mr. I am a proud citizen of Bangladesh. I have been watching your videos for last few days & judging by your words i think you are an educated current generation Pakistani. If your words represents even 2% of educated Pakistani, then it's possible that Pakistan might find & establish it's origin. Regards.
Same thing jinnah did by imposing urdu too bengalis..which they objected..and conflict started ..ended with newly Bangladesh state..with bengali their langauge
I am from India. In my country all state languages are our national languages. In states of Bihar, Jharkhand, Delhi, West Bengal Urdu has the status of 2nd official language. No language should be imposed. Arabic is a beautiful language , the language of Holy Quran and the language of our beloved Prophet Sallallahu Alaihivasallam. But it is not the mother tongue of the people of Indo Pak Subcontinent. We are not the followers of Arab culture. Our civilization is Indus valley civilization which is common to India and Pakistan. Pakistan should learn from the imposition of Urdu on East Pakistan and its subsequent effects.
@@vinamrasinghai2339 Two Nation theory has still validity. It is still valid.It is true that the people of east Bengal had detached their political affiliation with Pakistan. But they have never rejected the 2 Nation theory. If they have rejected the 2 Nation theory genuinely certainly they would have merged with West Bengal and would have come under the sovereignty of our country.
@@kassimka123 bro the two nation theory basically was that the hindus and the muslims cant live together so they created a separate nation. But it turned out that even the muslims cant live together as well. So the point is, only religion can not ever be a force to bind a country together.
@@kassimka123 Easy pakistan when become Bangladesh declared itself as secular .Bangladesh is a secular state as per their constitution...Two nation theory is dumbed in 1971
Dear mozammel Bhai I am an Urdu speaking bangladeshi.i have been following you for quite some time and truly speaking have become a fan of you.you are presenting the true history and mindset of the people of pakistan. Rather than teaching the real history of this region and portraying the real heroes a completely distorted history is being taught to the children.presenting the Invaders plunderers looters and murderers as our heroes.people like you are trying to produce sanity in the thinking process of people but so much damage has already been done that any hope looks to be a distant thing.the only way to improve the things is to liberate the country from the hands of molvis and depoliticise the Pak army.it needs a long long time.and nothing is going to happen without a bloody revelution. پھر بھی امید رکھنی چاہیے کہ پاکستانی شاعر فیض نے کہا ھے"لمبی ھے غم کی شام مگر شام ھی تو ھے" I salute you
Bhai India se Salaam, u r genius, Pakistan do have identity crisis, first they thought they are Arab, then ottomans(turk) now they think they are Chinese 😂😂🤔🤣
Language is not bound to any religion. Arabic, persian, Turkish, existed before Islam came. Bangladesh did not give up Bengali. The language of Sindhi and Punjabi are languages of Indian subcontinent and derived from sanskrit. Urdu is also the language of this subcontinent and a mixed of Indian, persian and Arabic language. Unfortunately Urdu has been associated with language of Muslims. No, it is a language belong to Indian subcontinent, and people of all religion just like Bengali, hindi, tamil, marathi.
Urdu is an artificial language that was made by incorporating Persian Arabic words into Indian khadi bol. Now that we are promoting indigenous languages, there's no need for Urdu.
The problem is much bigger than what you said. Problem is minimizing the effort and time it takes to learn one language and scientific subjects . They think one can learn useless languages and still learn the important subjects to the same extent , to be able to compete with the world
💯% agree with you , there is no need to teach Arabic to students because its difficult to understand for them. In primary school of kpk 4 languages taught to them (English, urdu, hidko/pashto, and Arabic) its really challenging for students to even differentiate the Alphabet of urdu, hindko and Arabic. They always confused between these languages and student can't understand it. Its just wastage to time (both students and teachers), wastage of money to print books and barden on students
@@Sp-le4oy Our Ancestors were pagans just like Europeans africans asians Now we are all muslims and christians . Hindu is a persian word And Buddhists are kinda of atheist people. And We belong to Aryan civilisation which destroyed your indus valley ✌️
@Balochi boy Not all Arabs were pagans some were Abrahamic from beginning they are decandants of Ishmael son of Hazrat Abraham or ibrahim . If you were a muslim you would know 😜
Love your thinking bro we friends often talk about you that you represent us,you bring up the same issues which we talk about...we need people like you
For Record the real struggle of Bangladesh begun when west Pakistan try to impose Urdu on East Pakistan . This mistake was done by our own founder of Pakistan .He might have not known the consequence of his decision but we know .we should abolish urdu as a national language and term it as a regional language.Nations stay together when their economic interests are together not when they speak the same language.Go ahead and look at India how they abolished their national language.As far as more languages are concerned one should learn as many as he/she can.
I would like to correct you that we have more than 20 official national languages in India and none among them has been abolished till date. Our education system or institution is framed in such a way that we get to learn three languages: first language as English, 2nd language as Our mother tongue which in my case is Bengali, and 3rd language as Hindi. Some students also interchange the 2nd and 3rd languages according to their preferences, like hindi can be 2nd lang and bengali can be 3rd language. In Universities, we are taught a foreign language of our choice like spanish, French or German. In my case it was French. So we can learn as many languages we want to as our curriculum gives much scope. There are also singular separate courses of other different languages which we can learn if we wish to.
Thing is, nobody claims to be British descent when they speak English. You have to accept who you really are. You can change religion but you can't change your DNA and ancestors.
Hello bro .I am from India maharashtra Mumbai. I would like to put just 1 point that :- Pakistanis don't take religious message seriously. They take serious to book cover only , not book
اپ کی بات درست ہے ہمیں اپنی زبان اور اپنے کلچر پر فخر ہونا چاہے کسی دوسری زبان کو نصاب میں لازمی مت قرار دیں بلکہ آپشنل رکھیں ہماری عوام پر جو یہ ظلم کیا گیا ہے کہ انگریزی کو لازمی قرار دیا گیا ہے اپ کو اس کے بارے میں بھی اسی طرح زور و شور سے بات کرنی چاہے یہاں تک کہ مختلف مضامین بھی انگریزی میں پڑھائے جاتے ہیں ویسٹ کا کلچر بھی ہمارا کلچر نہیں ہے آج تک جو انگریزی نہیں ختم کر سکے وہ عربی کے خلاف اب کس منہ سے بولیں گے جیسے یہاں انگریزوں کے غلاموں کی کمی نہیں ایسے عربوں کے غلاموں کی بھی کوئی کمی نہیں
Dear syed mozammill you have spoken well ,regarding divine guidance God has never left any comunity unguided.Quran was revealed in arabic for arabs. true seeker will find what he deserves.
Very soon.. Mandarin language will become the official language of Pakistan and Chinese personalities will become hazrats of Pakistani Muslims. Which will be adopted by Pakistani Indians also soon after.
Agr ap impartial hn to plz esa hi ek prgrm English Language pr bhi kr den jnab rural areas k bache kb se English smjhne ki koshish kr rhe hn lekin smjh hi ni ati jb k Quran e Pak asani se hifz bhi kr lete hn
Mustafa Ata Turk also changed the writing script of the Turki language. It used to be Arabic script which he changed and banned the use of Arabic script.
You nailed it. I'm an Indian and have heard Indian muslims recount how horribly they get treated in the middle east when they go there for work. They are treated like slaves. 🌺 🌿
Bahut behtrin soch hai aapki. Agar sab aap jaise ho jaye to koi madla hi na rahe. Main Bharat Indore se hu. Bharat aaye aap to mere ghar pe aapka swagat hai. 😊
Really you are right sir, India is elder brother and Pakistan is second are not separate by root our root is one accept it, for your progress love from gujrat India
Dont worry for thousands of years indian cultured absorved turkish, persian and arabic culture none of them was able to absorve indian culture turks came to this land , persians came came to this land arabs came to this land but all become indians and forgetten their languages and culture have you seen any mughal speaking turkish , have you seen any ansari syed etc speaking arabic all speak india
I am a pushtun a proud Afghan but my area falls under the jurisdiction of Pakistan so I call myself Pakistani as well ..if you speak and represent a language of India that is called Urdu you are far from my Pakistan .For me learning Urdu and imposing Urdu is same as imposing Arabic or English
@@childrenofadam4 I call myself Pakistani Because my area comes underjurisdiction of Pakistan so in nationalistic meaning I am Pakistani...There is no race called Pakistani .. Afghan is a race ..
@@bilalraziq9641 so just like that, pakistan was and is part of indian subcontinent. urdu is the language associated with the muslims of indian subcontinent, so if pakistan imposes urdu, what is the problem with it? I agree with you about arabic and english, they should be optional if someone wants to learn, but not urdu.
@@childrenofadam4 well the problem is when you call it state of Indian Muslim .There were ppl living in the areas that constituted Pakistan pushing an Indian language on the indigenous population is just another form of colonialism
@@childrenofadam4 ofcourse you are welcome but thinking like a camel which just wanted it head first ...but now wants the whole tent to itself ..and between you and me.Urdu was the main reason we pushed Bengalis away.
Great video and thank you for introducing Raza Rabani, to me, I only know a handful of people in Pakistan who has brain to think, rest all are wagging tail puppies, who don’t know which direction they come from and which direction they should go.
Wonder why they don't bother about our regional languages. Punjabi, Saraiki are taught in no schools in Pakistan. Our children can't read them. Well, let's enforce Arabic, all right.
What Javed Abbassi smoking these days? Compulsory subject should be Computer, Medical Sciences etc. We need to start teaching our kids skills from the early age. AI, ML, Robotics. etc. This is the future. Arabic language will lead us to dead end.
@Usman Ansari Lets make it clear here. This video is NOT about "Islam or religion". This video is about "Arabic Language". So those who are using "Religion" to impose their Arabic language "Agenda" and collect "Chanda" for Pakistani people are also number 1 Munafiqq.
all the subjects are important and the Arabic language will not let it to our dead but inshallah will reunite as a ummah,, remember Imam Mahdi whom will be unter his banners ?
@@fakhraamin667 love doesn't have a language, remember that.. there is nothing wrong with learning arabic, since it is the language of our religion, but it shouldn't be a must to learn it.... arab is the language of arabs, and our roots are NOT arab
@@zunairali1492 i use it because it is easier to type here in english... do not worry about my roots and what my amma abba speak, that is none of your goddamn business. i understand 6 different languages, 3 from east and 3 from west, and i use english more because i live in an english speaking country(not UK) and i have to use it more than other languages. any problem with that?
Pakistan is very intelligent nation. It chose Urdu as official language to represent its history of Arabs, Iranics, Sanskrit, Turks....which is very neutral. Love Paks from Algeria 🇩🇿 Punjabis, Sindhis, Pashtuns, Balochis......
@@DrStrange234 but u r muslim ...how r u from dravid land.....koi sense h iss baat h.....😆😂...by the way..ivc dravidian h ye proved nhi h bs theory h.....
@@DrStrange234 it is just a theory Aur agar uski bhi maano toh only upper caste Hindus are real Aryan specially Brahmins Jo ki aisi hi glt hai cause ethnicity se nhi Lena dena caste ka ( i am from Brahmin community too but i don't believe in caste system)
Although it's useless to advise u people. Language is the vehicle of culture, don't kill your culture which is thousands year old otherwise coming generations will find it more difficult to assimilate with the motherland.
Dont worry for thousands of years indian cultured absorved turkish, persian and arabic culture none of them was able to absorve indian culture turks came to this land , persians came came to this land arabs came to this land but all become indians and forgetten their languages and culture have you seen any mughal speaking turkish , have you seen any ansari syed etc speaking arabic all speak indian languages
Wrong, Pakistan shares cultural heritage with neighbouring states if India such as Punjab and possibly Rajestan. Other parts of Pak have nothing to do with India.
![[TH] 2024 PMGC League | Survival Stage วันที่ 1 | PUBG MOBILE Global Championship](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/FVFT-PFwU80/mqdefault.jpg)
Love you beta. Bless you with all my heart. Pakistan needs youth like you. Wish pakistani youth brings pakistan to its glory. Love from India 💖
Hahhaha English bhi compulsory q hai wo bhi ni hona chahye waha q ni bolty .... bkwas Islam py a k ruk jati hai inki .. inko Talban hi thk kr skty hain ... Talban ny librel aur in jaisy kutto ko inki auqat yad dila di hai boht jldi tm jaisy logo ko bhi auqat yad dilai jay gi time any wala hai hahahah
I cant believe he is a Pakistani and he is saying these things... May god keep you safe
So many people in Pakistan like him but cannot speak infront of media which he has guts to do
@@packerslife175 true
Far and wide I have read Pakistani scholars, listened to them for hours and months and years.
You are head and shoulders above ALL. In 73 years of misery of this hell hole, I have found only 2 - who are most effective at crispy clear vision
That’s you & H. Haqqani🙏👏👏
Our prayers are in Sanskrit, however, Sanskrit is introduced only in 6-7th class and 9th and 10th it is optional and we don’t study it after 10th. Still we respect Sanskrit and acknowledge its importance in our culture. Sanskrit is one of the oldest language and still going strong
Not "one of the"
It is The Oldest Language
It's the oldest
But if Sanskrit is made compulsory from 1st standard it won't be wrong as it's not a foreign language .it's language of this land .it's not foreign language like Arabic
Even Pakistan should adopt Sanskrit as it's language of our ancestors. Language is language, many countries follow Islam still have their own language
@@fida80 Sanskrit has been already an optional language. Just like languages other than mother tongue.
@@VimdhayakJiOP sanskrit is the "oldest surviving" language. not oldest
We Bangladeshis know and respect the importance of mother tongue very well. So it would not be right to use foreign language in the curriculum by force. The best initiative would be to learn through the native language. Otherwise it can bring extreme dark for the nation.
Please f off and eat your fish. Dont lecture us about your fishy language you bongoli
@@t.elawrence273 It's the same attitude you shown in 1971. And you know what happened next 😌.
Respect every one.
@@harshit3980 you gangu pajeet has no right to lecture a Pakistani. Go and f"ck off to bihar and shit on railways.
@@harshit3980 you over obsessed indian who thinks nothing other than Pakistan. Go and fix your own country. Your country is a worse shit hole than us
@Humanity Insaniyat no actually i have embraced my indus valley culture. This name Lawrence of Arabia is just a reference to the film. (I made this acc long ago)
Syed muzammil,
You seem an intellectual and logical person in Pakistan, rare in Pakistan.
Rare word is not enough to use , i m atleast short of words , india havebeen going through same problems now a days , a secular country is more like a heaven to live but these religious stupid clerics want something stupid according tp their cheap mentality . bhai jan bacha lo india ko otherwise india ka bhi pakistan wala hal hone wala hai kuch years k andar andar
Lmao it's considered rare in India too
@@AsifAli-yq2bv islamization radicalism is also is on peak in india
@@AsifAli-yq2bv Hindutva is a positive response to Islamism.
@@thelogicalaspect1323 Islamisation is rapidly growing in India. The only solution is Hindutva
Excellent book. Reimagining Pakistan. Why don’t you invite the author for an interview? I know you don’t do interviews but it will be excellent.
We proudly say that we are sanatani Hindus the oldest civilisation in the world
Unlike Pakistans who changed their religion under force of Sword and taxes..🙏
Goodness I didn't know that there are sensible humans in Pakistan as well. !!!
@XRP SNIPER teaching and learning Arabic should be optional, not enforced.
This is just extra pressure on children.
Not all can cope with it.
@@amnahaque9058 exactly
Kids have to learn English as it is the international language then they added regional languages too now they are making Arabic compulsory
Height of idiocy
You are absolutely right beta, may Allah give you more success Ameen
Indian subcontinent is multi lingual ..india doesnt have national langauge ..all states languages are official languages of indian union by consititution of india....Unity in Diversity..
"unity"
Exactly my point is we are multi langual / multi cultural people. If we go back to our Indus Valley roots we don't even know which language they spoke
Indus valley civilization spoke dravidion, it is proven from the scripts and art found
@@austin201984 lmao it didn't speak tamilian stop larping. They spoke their own languages
@@t.elawrence273
th-cam.com/video/k1knEjrxKgo/w-d-xo.html
Great to hear a rational view from a young and bright pakistani.
Even after 50 yrs of B'desh independence, Pakistan didn't change they imposed a random language (urdu) which was born in New Delhi on us bengalis who don't speak it, Pakistanis should promote/speak their own native languages like punjabi or Pashtun not urdu or arabic
Wow... I'm surprised, That it is True, actually know the History, URDU was Orginated in LUCKNOW by Upper Class Clerks, Of Muslim and HINDU working in AWADH Sultanate Courts, Only Few used it, And then got it Replaced by MUGHAL Court from Turkish to URDU in 18th Century.
@@sasmalprasanjit2764 Turkish was never a court language in any muslim dynasty in India..
And the urdu was made by itself no one had created it...
Urdu itself means army..
The invaders army used to speak Arabic and Persian and turkic chagatai and many more so.. The hindi was mixed with these foreign languages and this is now known as urdu..
But after 15 century the muslim intelectual class wanted to remove hindi and sanskrit from india.
So they started Arabization and turkification and of hindi..
They remove every possible exist sanskrit word from urdu then added Persian the most and some Arabic and turkic chagatai... It becomes rekhta then now urdu..
@@ompaik2863yeah even Turkish invaders wanted persian to be their court language.
@@sasmalprasanjit2764wtf dude urdu you don't know anything urdu famous in Mughals time it was by Muslims urdu is mix turki farsi and Egyptian language
@@sherazali9815are you paki ?
Farsi was the official language of the Mughal empire
Get some knowledge dude
Come out from madarsa plz
Another gem of a talk. The clarity which you bring to the talks reminds me of E J Dionne and Rachel Maddow. Keep going bro!
آپ کی گفتگو میں اکثر مختلف کتابوں کا ذکر ھوتا ھے جن حصول ناممکن ھے،یہ بھی کرم ھے کہ آ گہی حاصل ھو جاتی ھے۔ سلامت رھو آمین
You can get this book on ocean pdf website in pdf form. I hope this will help
I'm a Indian and I really don't know why I watch Pakistan related videos. But I guess root of that too come from my being Indian, where we always care more about our neighbours. I have hurd this term Pakistan's Indenity Crisis so many times, and it looks like it's the real issue here. Pakistan should not be ashamed of her origin and her Indian past, it may be happened because of artificial environments created by dictators for consolidating power. I still believe Pakistan should identify herself as non religious democratic country and proudly preserve her Indian identity and get over land disputes. Then rest be assured India will try her best to normalise relations. Look how close we are with Bangladesh, Sri Lanka and Nepal, Pakistan could be there too. Jai Hind 🇮🇳🇵🇰
Bhai aap neh mera Dil jeeth liya.. culture and religion are always different..
We are having same culture and different religions , religion is about choice but culture is not choice , its natural lekin koi bhi mulla pandit priest nai smjhe ga
I love my culture that is hindustani culture and i m in deep love with it
@Racist white Koshur oh yes Muslim fundamentalist too
@@thelogicalaspect1323 bhai culture Hazaar saalo me banta hai isliye culture hamesha permanent rahega tum chahe maano ya na maano pakistan ka problem hai wo apni roots dhudhte hai arab Turk me just because unka religion islam hai how stupid 😆🤣😁😁🤗🥰 Egypt ke log aaj bhi apne culture or cultural gods ki ijjat karte hai bhale hi unhone islam apna liya ho unke hero aaj bhi egyptian civilization waale hi honge
Pakistan ko itni fiker nhi jitni tom logo ko fiker ha
Proud of you brother. Now you're in the list of my favorite people. ☺️🥳
জনাব, আমি বাংলাদেশের একজন গর্বিত নাগরিক। গত কিছু দিন আপনার ভিডিও দেখে আপনাকে একজন শিক্ষিত আধুনিক পাকিস্তানি বলে মনে করছি। আপনার কথা যদি পাকিস্তানের শিক্ষিত সম্প্রদায়ের ২% ও হয়ে থাকে, তবে আগামী ৫০ বছরে পাকিস্তান হয়তো নিজের অস্তিত্ব স্থাপন করতে পারবে। শুভকামনা।
Mr. I am a proud citizen of Bangladesh. I have been watching your videos for last few days & judging by your words i think you are an educated current generation Pakistani. If your words represents even 2% of educated Pakistani, then it's possible that Pakistan might find & establish it's origin. Regards.
Truly, visionary person you are. You deserve highest post in Pakistan who can remind Pakistanis their root.
Rarely we find such educated person in pakistan. Allah bhagwan aapko sehatmand rakhe taki aap apni knowledge se enlight karte rhe
Same thing jinnah did by imposing urdu too bengalis..which they objected..and conflict started ..ended with newly Bangladesh state..with bengali their langauge
Great analysis as always keep it up man !!!
I am from India. In my country all state languages are our national languages. In states of Bihar, Jharkhand, Delhi, West Bengal Urdu has the status of 2nd official language. No language should be imposed. Arabic is a beautiful language , the language of Holy Quran and the language of our beloved Prophet Sallallahu Alaihivasallam. But it is not the mother tongue of the people of Indo Pak Subcontinent. We are not the followers of Arab culture. Our civilization is Indus valley civilization which is common to India and Pakistan. Pakistan should learn from the imposition of Urdu on East Pakistan and its subsequent effects.
That is against Two Nation Theory.
@@vinamrasinghai2339 Two Nation theory has still validity. It is still valid.It is true that the people of east Bengal had detached their political affiliation with Pakistan. But they have never rejected the 2 Nation theory. If they have rejected the 2 Nation theory genuinely certainly they would have merged with West Bengal and would have come under the sovereignty of our country.
@@kassimka123 bengalis rejected two nation theory because both were Muslims and both can't live together. Are all right my boy??
@@kassimka123 bro the two nation theory basically was that the hindus and the muslims cant live together so they created a separate nation. But it turned out that even the muslims cant live together as well. So the point is, only religion can not ever be a force to bind a country together.
@@kassimka123 Easy pakistan when become Bangladesh declared itself as secular .Bangladesh is a secular state as per their constitution...Two nation theory is dumbed in 1971
Wow... what a talk! Logical fact bases and to the point. It is a pleasure listening to you.
Dear mozammel Bhai I am an Urdu speaking bangladeshi.i have been following you for quite some time and truly speaking have become a fan of you.you are presenting the true history and mindset of the people of pakistan. Rather than teaching the real history of this region and portraying the real heroes a completely distorted history is being taught to the children.presenting the Invaders plunderers looters and murderers as our heroes.people like you are trying to produce sanity in the thinking process of people but so much damage has already been done that any hope looks to be a distant thing.the only way to improve the things is to liberate the country from the hands of molvis and depoliticise the Pak army.it needs a long long time.and nothing is going to happen without a bloody revelution.
پھر بھی امید رکھنی چاہیے کہ پاکستانی شاعر فیض نے کہا ھے"لمبی ھے غم کی شام مگر شام ھی تو ھے"
I salute you
sir you are a brave Pakistani. congratulations.
Yr mn sochdaaa h Kash Punjab divide naaah hondaaa ah bc mughllaaan d zubaaan Urdu kuin parhiaaa meraa Dada waghera nu eik lafaz nhi onda urduu d
What a person, you are a true intellectual muzammil, love from 🇮🇳
Sach kaha ap ny .
Shaid hamain islye Arabic sikha rhy han k wo hamain apna chota samjain
Bhai India se Salaam, u r genius, Pakistan do have identity crisis, first they thought they are Arab, then ottomans(turk) now they think they are Chinese 😂😂🤔🤣
true af but the correct ans is Indian 😁
Couldn't stop laughing 🤣🤣🤣🤣
@@shubhangi709INSHA'ALLAH we're proud but the people who spread Islam in Pakistan caused it
😂😂
Doing a great job sir I m a big fan of u
Really appreciable👍👍
Brilliant 👏👏
#respect from India 🇮🇳🇮🇳
It is already compulsory in schools,i read Arabic till grade 8th.Thanx to education ministry , I'm able to understand arabic
Encouraging learning Arabic would help strengthening the fight against Islamic Extremism. Especially in Bangladesh, India and Pakistan.
Your perfect Mr sayad..... Great point.... When Pakistan understand this believe sir all problem will solve 👍
Zabardast. Fully agree.
Jabardast 👏❤️
Language is not bound to any religion. Arabic, persian, Turkish, existed before Islam came. Bangladesh did not give up Bengali. The language of Sindhi and Punjabi are languages of Indian subcontinent and derived from sanskrit. Urdu is also the language of this subcontinent and a mixed of Indian, persian and Arabic language. Unfortunately Urdu has been associated with language of Muslims. No, it is a language belong to Indian subcontinent, and people of all religion just like Bengali, hindi, tamil, marathi.
Baloch and Pashto
@@AliAhmed-ve5xl Balachi and Pashto languages are of Iranian root, like Persian language.
@@hsd4526 85 million Pakistanis are from those roots
@@AliAhmed-ve5xl That is why Baloch and pakhtuns are demanding separate nations.
Urdu is an artificial language that was made by incorporating Persian Arabic words into Indian khadi bol. Now that we are promoting indigenous languages, there's no need for Urdu.
Syed Sir aap sahi hai Pakistan 1947 sey abhi tak apni identity hi dhund raha hai
Im an indian but Hats off to u bro..
The problem is much bigger than what you said. Problem is minimizing the effort and time it takes to learn one language and scientific subjects . They think one can learn useless languages and still learn the important subjects to the same extent , to be able to compete with the world
You are so good in teaching
💯% agree with you , there is no need to teach Arabic to students because its difficult to understand for them.
In primary school of kpk 4 languages taught to them (English, urdu, hidko/pashto, and Arabic) its really challenging for students to even differentiate the Alphabet of urdu, hindko and Arabic. They always confused between these languages and student can't understand it.
Its just wastage to time (both students and teachers), wastage of money to print books and barden on students
identity crises is the biggest problem in Pakistan as we don't know who we are.
You all were hindus and buddhist before conversion
And belong to indus civilization
Its you who suffer from identity crisis and inferiority complex .
Liberal people like you have doomed pakistan and muslims.
@@Sp-le4oy
Our Ancestors were pagans just like Europeans africans asians
Now we are all muslims and christians .
Hindu is a persian word
And Buddhists are kinda of atheist people.
And We belong to Aryan civilisation which destroyed your indus valley ✌️
@@DrStrange234 lol apni history ko hi accept nahi kr pa rahe ho...
@Balochi boy
Not all Arabs were pagans some were Abrahamic from beginning they are decandants of Ishmael son of Hazrat Abraham or ibrahim .
If you were a muslim you would know 😜
Well explained Syed muzammil...👍
Respect from India
Love your thinking bro we friends often talk about you that you represent us,you bring up the same issues which we talk about...we need people like you
Only sensible person in Pakistan
well explained
Panjabiyon ka "karty hoty hain" bht acha lgta hai..😊😂
Which ethnicity are you? Native urdu speaker? Just wondering
Nice brother.
For Record the real struggle of Bangladesh begun when west Pakistan try to impose Urdu on East Pakistan . This mistake was done by our own founder of Pakistan .He might have not known the consequence of his decision but we know .we should abolish urdu as a national language and term it as a regional language.Nations stay together when their economic interests are together not when they speak the same language.Go ahead and look at India how they abolished their national language.As far as more languages are concerned one should learn as many as he/she can.
I would like to correct you that we have more than 20 official national languages in India and none among them has been abolished till date. Our education system or institution is framed in such a way that we get to learn three languages: first language as English, 2nd language as Our mother tongue which in my case is Bengali, and 3rd language as Hindi. Some students also interchange the 2nd and 3rd languages according to their preferences, like hindi can be 2nd lang and bengali can be 3rd language. In Universities, we are taught a foreign language of our choice like spanish, French or German. In my case it was French. So we can learn as many languages we want to as our curriculum gives much scope. There are also singular separate courses of other different languages which we can learn if we wish to.
It's treat to hear you...
I really appreciate your views 🙏🏼❤
I am a graduate student, and I would love to learn and speak Arabic.
I agree with you ,but English is also compulsory subject in our country. We feel proud in English speaking, and it becomes the sign of periority .
What would you say about this?
Bhai english se job opportunity milti h, India ka 200 billion dollar ka IT export h, english language uska bada reason h
English is time ki need h
That is related to economic prosperity, as it is the language of almost every country it is an international language...
Thing is, nobody claims to be British descent when they speak English. You have to accept who you really are. You can change religion but you can't change your DNA and ancestors.
bhai poori ad dekhi hai.videos rukni nahi chahiye 👍
Nice analysis
Totally agreed muzammil Bhai. Say no to Arabic❌️
You are always speaking true I'm agree with you. Pakistani people root's from 🇮🇳 India you should take indian culture.
Afsos Pakistani bot kam hain apko sun nay waly you're great
Love you from India bahut achha se explain karte ho i am your fan
Arabic is way forward good step....
Hello bro .I am from India maharashtra Mumbai.
I would like to put just 1 point that :- Pakistanis don't take religious message seriously. They take serious to book cover only , not book
Solute to you sir 🙏 😇👍
All religions should be avoided by masses
Dr Carl Sagan videos and wickepedia
Thank you sir
اپ کی بات درست ہے ہمیں اپنی زبان اور اپنے کلچر پر فخر ہونا چاہے کسی دوسری زبان کو نصاب میں لازمی مت قرار دیں بلکہ آپشنل رکھیں ہماری عوام پر جو یہ ظلم کیا گیا ہے کہ انگریزی کو لازمی قرار دیا گیا ہے اپ کو اس کے بارے میں بھی اسی طرح زور و شور سے بات کرنی چاہے یہاں تک کہ مختلف مضامین بھی انگریزی میں پڑھائے جاتے ہیں ویسٹ کا کلچر بھی ہمارا کلچر نہیں ہے آج تک جو انگریزی نہیں ختم کر سکے وہ عربی کے خلاف اب کس منہ سے بولیں گے جیسے یہاں انگریزوں کے غلاموں کی کمی نہیں ایسے عربوں کے غلاموں کی بھی کوئی کمی نہیں
آپ نے سب درست لکھا صرف یہ واضح کرنا چاہتا ہوں کے کلچر اور زبان پر فخر کرنا بے معنی ہے لیکن فروغ ضرور دینا چاہئیے۔
Arabs and pakistanis will remain friends forever...
Pakistan is introducing Arabic language in schools and Saudi Arabia is introducing Mahabharat and Ramayan in schools.
Ganga ulti bah rahi hai
InshAllah one Arabic and Urdu will be national language of pakistan . Arabic language is soul of pakistan and urdu is heart
Pakistan language is only Urdu and local provincial languages
Pakistan has only urdu and provincial languages Arabic is foreign language if you love it most go to arabia
hell nah only Urdu arabs ki gulami na manzoor.
زبردست بیانیہ تجزیہ👋👋
Dear syed mozammill you have spoken well ,regarding divine guidance God has never left any comunity unguided.Quran was revealed in arabic for arabs. true seeker will find what he deserves.
Very soon.. Mandarin language will become the official language of Pakistan and Chinese personalities will become hazrats of Pakistani Muslims. Which will be adopted by Pakistani Indians also soon after.
Pakistan UAE friendship zindabad..
Great analysis Muzamil Bhai ❤️❤️
Arab will rule the world inshallha
Why arabic is for arabs
Very good podcast ,You have a great analytical mind ❤❤
We are proud to be Arab!
I admire ur thought
Agr ap impartial hn to plz esa hi ek prgrm English Language pr bhi kr den jnab rural areas k bache kb se English smjhne ki koshish kr rhe hn lekin smjh hi ni ati jb k Quran e Pak asani se hifz bhi kr lete hn
Mustafa Ata Turk also changed the writing script of the Turki language. It used to be Arabic script which he changed and banned the use of Arabic script.
Good stuff!
You nailed it. I'm an Indian and have heard Indian muslims recount how horribly they get treated in the middle east when they go there for work. They are treated like slaves. 🌺 🌿
You are exceptionally excellent Pakistani.
Bahut behtrin soch hai aapki. Agar sab aap jaise ho jaye to koi madla hi na rahe. Main Bharat Indore se hu. Bharat aaye aap to mere ghar pe aapka swagat hai. 😊
Really you are right sir, India is elder brother and Pakistan is second are not separate by root our root is one accept it, for your progress love from gujrat India
Dont worry for thousands of years indian cultured absorved turkish, persian and arabic culture none of them was able to absorve indian culture turks came to this land , persians came came to this land arabs came to this land but all become indians and forgetten their languages and culture have you seen any mughal speaking turkish , have you seen any ansari syed etc speaking arabic all speak india
I am a pushtun a proud Afghan but my area falls under the jurisdiction of Pakistan so I call myself Pakistani as well ..if you speak and represent a language of India that is called Urdu you are far from my Pakistan .For me learning Urdu and imposing Urdu is same as imposing Arabic or English
with your logic, you shouldn't call yourself pakistani, but afghan, right? 🤔
@@childrenofadam4 I call myself Pakistani Because my area comes underjurisdiction of Pakistan so in nationalistic meaning I am Pakistani...There is no race called Pakistani .. Afghan is a race ..
@@bilalraziq9641 so just like that, pakistan was and is part of indian subcontinent. urdu is the language associated with the muslims of indian subcontinent, so if pakistan imposes urdu, what is the problem with it? I agree with you about arabic and english, they should be optional if someone wants to learn, but not urdu.
@@childrenofadam4 well the problem is when you call it state of Indian Muslim .There were ppl living in the areas that constituted Pakistan pushing an Indian language on the indigenous population is just another form of colonialism
@@childrenofadam4 ofcourse you are welcome but thinking like a camel which just wanted it head first ...but now wants the whole tent to itself ..and between you and me.Urdu was the main reason we pushed Bengalis away.
Great video and thank you for introducing Raza Rabani, to me, I only know a handful of people in Pakistan who has brain to think, rest all are wagging tail puppies, who don’t know which direction they come from and which direction they should go.
Wonder why they don't bother about our regional languages. Punjabi, Saraiki are taught in no schools in Pakistan. Our children can't read them. Well, let's enforce Arabic, all right.
What Javed Abbassi smoking these days? Compulsory subject should be Computer, Medical Sciences etc. We need to start teaching our kids skills from the early age. AI, ML, Robotics. etc. This is the future. Arabic language will lead us to dead end.
@Usman Ansari Lets make it clear here. This video is NOT about "Islam or religion". This video is about "Arabic Language". So those who are using "Religion" to impose their Arabic language "Agenda" and collect "Chanda" for Pakistani people are also number 1 Munafiqq.
all the subjects are important and the Arabic language will not let it to our dead but inshallah will reunite as a ummah,, remember Imam Mahdi whom will be unter his banners ?
@@fakhraamin667 love doesn't have a language, remember that.. there is nothing wrong with learning arabic, since it is the language of our religion, but it shouldn't be a must to learn it.... arab is the language of arabs, and our roots are NOT arab
@@childrenofadam4 so our roots go back to England isn't it. That's why you are using English because our Abba & Amma spoke in this language
@@zunairali1492 i use it because it is easier to type here in english... do not worry about my roots and what my amma abba speak, that is none of your goddamn business. i understand 6 different languages, 3 from east and 3 from west, and i use english more because i live in an english speaking country(not UK) and i have to use it more than other languages. any problem with that?
Pakistan is very intelligent nation. It chose Urdu as official language to represent its history of Arabs, Iranics, Sanskrit, Turks....which is very neutral.
Love Paks from Algeria 🇩🇿 Punjabis, Sindhis, Pashtuns, Balochis......
Every country should preserve their culture by making Mother tongue as compulsory language.
Bro ❤️❤️❤️
THANKYOU for this
İ want to learn Indus valley civilization.
Read Indian school books (Social sciences class 8,9,10).
They're available online. You can search that on NCERT's official site.
Learn about Aryan civilisation
Its our own
Indus valley is dravidian thing
@@DrStrange234 😂lol there is not aryan invesion,its fake theory already debunked
@@DrStrange234 but u r muslim ...how r u from dravid land.....koi sense h iss baat h.....😆😂...by the way..ivc dravidian h ye proved nhi h bs theory h.....
@@DrStrange234 it is just a theory
Aur agar uski bhi maano toh only upper caste Hindus are real Aryan specially Brahmins
Jo ki aisi hi glt hai cause ethnicity se nhi Lena dena caste ka ( i am from Brahmin community too but i don't believe in caste system)
Although it's useless to advise u people.
Language is the vehicle of culture, don't kill your culture which is thousands year old otherwise coming generations will find it more difficult to assimilate with the motherland.
Dont worry for thousands of years indian cultured absorved turkish, persian and arabic culture none of them was able to absorve indian culture turks came to this land , persians came came to this land arabs came to this land but all become indians and forgetten their languages and culture have you seen any mughal speaking turkish , have you seen any ansari syed etc speaking arabic all speak indian languages
@@fahadnazir945 As long as u follow a foreign religion, you'll remain a cultural slave of Arabia - with or without Arabic language.
@@mlg1279 true....religion thing suppose to be a spiritual thing not a devil cult that controls u
Very true.
What a wise man.
Pakistan and India 🇮🇳 🇵🇰 culture are one one and same
how?
Wrong, Pakistan shares cultural heritage with neighbouring states if India such as Punjab and possibly Rajestan. Other parts of Pak have nothing to do with India.
@Vajasrava Nachiketa hindustan ka matlab? Modi = bagvan
@@slazengerrodeo8829 Lol, Your Logic is Too Flawed To Take it Correct.
@@slazengerrodeo8829 and Punjab is completely different from rest of india?😂
Literally a flawed statement bro
No God. No religion. This is TRUTH ❤️👍🌞